Nagorno-Karabakh: Armenia vs. Azerbaijan explained
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 มิ.ย. 2024
- The Nagorno-Karabakh-conflict involving Armenia, the unrecognised Republic of Artsakh and Azerbaijan has been described as one of many frozen conflicts worldwide. However, the latest developments of 2020 have demonstrated that the ice seems to have melted. In truth, the conflict was heading into the direction of escalation since at least 2016, as the ongoing peace process has yielded little to no results.
This video is a simplified summary and analysis of what is going on in this conflict: How did the conflict about Karabakh start? What is it about? And which countries are involved? We are taking a look at the conflict's historic development since 1918, explore the value of Karabakh to the Armenian and Azerbaijani people and also touch upon the involvement of the most prominent regional powers in this conflict: Turkey, Russia and Iran.
Thanks for watching, consider subscribing for more content like this in the future!
____________________
Consider supporting this channel on Patreon:
Link to my Patreon: / politicswithpaint
____________________
Music:
No.1 A Minor Waltz (by Esther Abrami)
____________________
Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
1:28 History 1918-1994
5:34 Developments after 1994
6:22 Unsuccessful peace process
7:23 Status quo until 2020
8:08 Why is Karabakh important?
8:35 Armenian historic claim
9:30 Azerbaijani historic claim
10:37 Legal claims of both nations
11:40 Karabakh's importance in internal affairs
12:19 Turkey's interests in Karabakh
13:05 Russia's interests in Karabakh
13:40 Iran's interests in Karabakh
14:17 Conclusion and Outro
____________________
Sources:
Baddeley, John F. (1999) The Russian Conquest of the Caucasus. Curzon Press: Surrey.
Baev, Pavel K. (2017) Russia: A Declining Counter-Change Force. In: Cornell, Svante (2017) The International Politics of the Armenian-Azerbaijani Conflict: The Original “Frozen Conflict’’ and European Security. Palgrave MacMillan: New York.
Bebler, Anton (2015) “Frozen conflicts” in Europe. Barbara Budrich Publishers: Opladen.
Cornell, Svante (2017) The International Politics of the Armenian-Azerbaijani Conflict: The Original “Frozen Conflict’’ and European Security. Palgrave MacMillan: New York.
Kuburas, Melita (2011) Ethnic Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh. In: Review of European and Russian Affairs (2011), Vol. 6, No. 1, 43-54.
Pokalova, Elena (2015) Conflict Resolution in Frozen Conflicts: Timing in Nagorno-Karabakh. In: Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies (2015), Vol. 17, No. 1, 68-85.
Rasizade, Alec (2011) Azerbaijan’s prospects in Nagorno-Karabakh. In: Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies (2011), Vol. 13, No. 2, 215-231.
____________________
#armenia #azerbaijan #karabakh
UPDATE (10th November 2020): The Armenian government and the de-facto authorities of the Republic of Artsakh have announced an end of the 2020 Karabakh war, as they can no longer support the war effort. They and Azerbaijan have agreed to start implementing a peace plan brokered by Russia. Not all details are public yet, but we know that it is similar to the Madrid principles shown in the video:
- Armenian forces will withdraw from all of Karabakh
- Armenia will return certain regions in the Karabakh lowlands to Azerbaijani control
- Azerbaijani forces will remain in control of all the recently captured territory in Karabakh
- Russian peacekeepers will be stationed in the parts of Nagorno-Karabakh still under Armenian control, based in Stepanakert/Xankəndi to enforce the ceasefire for 5 years
- Armenia will retain a temporary corridor with Nagorno-Karabakh protected by Russian peacekeeping forces
- Internally displaced people and refugees will be returning to Karabakh
- An exchange of prisoners of war, detained persons and the dead will be conducted.
- Armenia agreed to allow the construction of infrastructure linking Azerbaijan's autonomous Nakhichevan exclave with the rest of the country
The Azerbaijani government has also announced that Turkey will be part of the peacekeeping force, however no details have been released yet on that. It is also not yet clear what will happen to the Armenian populated regions of Karabakh (will they be reintegrated into Azerbaijan with autonomy or without?).
Still a really good and informative video
TURKEY AZERBAİJAN WİN
@@BMW-vs6iq russia wins
Russia and the USA are sending PKK and DAS terro terrorist organization militants to Armenia, why don't you talk about this?
@@tanit5997 you are right Russia won without dropping a pinch of blood. I hope Azeri and Armenian people will built a long lasting peace based on acknowledgment of each other’s legitimacy claim on the land , pain and suffering. Otherwise pain and suffering will switch sides from time to time
They are not 15 million Azerbaijanies in Iran, they are more than 30 million
Iran itself confirms the figure of 15 million Azerbaijanis. But they are all citizens of Iran, not Azerbaijan.
The Azerbaijani side, as usual, doubles the figures.
It's between 27--29 mio
%45 of Tahran, %40 of Iran population is originally South Azerbaijan , East Turkey Turks.
@@erikart2526 CIA estimates a conservative 24 million. So yeah Iran's official numbers are obviously bullshit. And if you're so sure they like Iran and Persians (Who think of themselves as the supreme race and belittle Azerbaijanis on a daily basis), hold a referendum. I'm sure they will vote to remain inside Iran, you seem very sure. For some reason though, I feel like what you're showing here is wishful thinking, because why would a Persian that thinks Azerbaijanis are his friends and Iranian citizens try to distort figures?
@@postyoda1623 Who is the Persian here?)
When you realise world history is more Interesting than any movie
Lol no
@@OkaySoShit Ok
@CalmMarioBros no
@CalmMarioBros no
@CalmMarioBros no
Interestingly enough, this war is a good case study of propaganda and disinformation tactics coming from both sides, some include to encourage conscription and to influence international support for either side. As a PR practitioner, it was a great look at geopolitics.
Also a great warning, don't start to believe your own propaganda and disinformation. In the words of a russian analyst I read, the armenian army was trained for parades not fighting...
@@MrJChristianz of please! Armenians won the first war with no official military. Azerbaijan was the loser for over 30 years.
Secondly, you should know the mafia style regime of Azerbaijan by Aliyev. Azerbaijan is known for propaganda, lack of democracy. Compare the ratings, Armenia is more free! Azerbaijan used thousands of mercenaries from Syria 🇸🇾, had nato Turkey who supplied troops, and powerful drones. Azerbaijan has a much bigger death toll of its soldiers. The 3000 death toll is a lie! You should know better.
@@MrJChristianz exactly and the woman who commented above me is a great example of propaganda🤡
@@mg-sp5ou look at this stupid propoganda.We fucked you up with modern tech.No need for Syrians
@@mg-sp5ou You are Projecting
Nooooldu Pasinyan
What Happened Pashinyan
Go get your milk kid, the conflict does not include you.
@@georgimkryan9965 If you are still alive it means the conflict also does not include you too
@@omarmusazade9174 :)
@@georgimkryan9965 The true facts are so hard right? ❤🇦🇿
@@dinoturtle7454 you must answer that question, your exactly in that possession right now. Guess Aliyev has brainwashed all of you already 🥱🥱
🇦🇿❤️🏳️🌈
Apologies for the late release of this video. It got delayed several times and making it took also longer than expected. Please also keep in mind that many events and issues I mention in this video are of course simplified for time’s sake. Anyways, I hope you like it and thanks for your support!
@zoki kostadinov funny how both armenians and azeris just start reeeeeeeeeing without watching the full video
@Mike Hunte nagornyy literally means highland in russian?? karabakh is not a russian word but thats not what he said
@Mike Hunte brother i had been both country also armenia also azerbaijan and i am neutral but i must say that karabak art and culture is azerbaijanian and in karabagh they have old azeri mosques have thousands age,but armenian church is almost new (200-250 year).it means karabag is azeri areas
3:27 is wrong. Stalin did not grant that land to Azerbaijan. Stalin ordered to RETAIN it with Azerbaijan. RETAIN and GRANT are two different things. If you retain something, that means it is already belonging to you. It is a key moment. Please correct it.
Here is what Stalin ordered:
"(1) proceeding from the need to maintain national peace between the Muslims and the Armenians, the economic ties between Upper and Lower Karabakh, and its constant contacts with Azerbaijan, Nagorno-Karabakh SHOULD BE LEFT WITHIN THE AZERBAIJAN S.S.R. with broad regional autonomy and its administrative center in the town of Shusha, which belongs to the autonomous region;"
Here is the link to the original document:
karabakh.org/karabakh-history/karabakh-during-the-1920-1988/how-the-caucasian-bureau-of-the-c-c-r-c-p-b-discussed-the-karabakh-issue-in-1920-1923-3/4/
5:22 is wrong. Turkey or any other muslim country did not support Azerbaijan in that war (Karabakh War I).
And here is what Abulfaz Elchibey (the president of Azerbaijan at that time) says:
He says he requested four helicopters from Turkey, Iran and Russia to save the civilians from the Armenian combatants and he was rejected.
Here is the link to that interview: th-cam.com/video/5G7qRrekx-k/w-d-xo.html
So, what kind of support it was at that time if you could not get four helicopters to save civilians?! Please correct the info you share.
I’m not going to judge since I know how difficult politics are up close even if they seem easier from the outside but your explanations by themselves never give off a vibe that this is oversimplified. Great job !
I'm very new to this whole international relations field, and I find it all fascinating, but I'm starting to realize how MESSY everything is. IR seems like a never-ending web of alliances and rivalries. It feels rewarding to learn about this stuff, but I feel like the more I learn, the less I feel I know. Either way, PLEASE keep making these videos, they are excellent.
Lmao same
But never forget that you have no history
Strongly agreed.
@@tunarismayilov4565 Wow u got offended? 😂
Oh boy this didn't age well
never had anything so complicated explained in such a easy to understand way, thanks.
10:06
-oğlum,sucuk,ayran?
-amk
Shghvkkc 😂
HARBİ
xd
This guy has no idea what those things are...having those things around 18-19th century? Emmm...you’re missing something there my friend...🤣🤣🤣
çok saçma ya qweweqwqwewqqw
Ne alaka
So glad I found this channel, this is great
Я азербайджанец и хочу мира между нашими странами. Я не ненавижу армян. Как может человек ненавидеть того, кого он не видел в своей жизни? проклятые войны. Армяне очень похожи на нас, мир и любовь
❤🇦🇿🤝🏻🇦🇲❤😊🙂😇
People like you should be leaders
You have made a mistake in 9:34. Azerbaijanis don't consider themselves to be the descendants of ancient locals of the region. Azerbaijanis consider themselves as descendants of those Seljuq Turks who migrated to the region starting from the 11th century. What is Azerbaijan is saying about Albanians is that Armenians were not the initial inhabitants of Qarabagh, as they claim, but it was Albanians who lived in Qarabagh in the ancient times. Azerbaijanis don't claim to be descendants of those Albanians, "who somehow started to speak Turkish". You mixed up two things
Ancestry is a very tricky thing, especially when we talk about ancestry of peoples who lived 2000 years ago or more. People of course intermixed a lot and cultures changed also a lot over time, and genetic and linguistic research does indicate that Azerbaijanis have Turkic heritage from various Oghuz Turkic tribes which arrived in the area between the 11th and 16th century, as well local non-turkic peoples - which is what happened everywhere on earth: intermixing. Of course, Azerbaijanis today are a Turkic ethnicity.
@@PoliticswithPaint Of course. There was intermixing, like all the people in the world. But while you did not emphasize the intermixing of Armenians with other groups, you did emphasize it for Azerbaijani Turks, and you said "Azerbaijanis CONSIDER THEMSELVES to be descendants of local Albanians who adopted Turkish language". What I am trying to say is that Azerbaijani Turks don't consider themselves like that, they just consider themselves to be Turkish, as Armenians just consider themselves to be Armenians, as Russians just consider themselves to be Russian, as the English just consider themselves to be English, despite the fact that all of them have intermingled with numerous other groups
@John So was half of actual turkey, syria and the whole of lebanon, would you give them back to armenia as well ? Also if we're playing this game can you please leave the fuck out USA/Australia/NZ/GB and leave it to locals ? In advance ty bro. Also its more legitimate since its not 2000 years old issues LOL.
Btw you also seems like quite indo-european to me, please go back to mongolia as well cause your ancestor migrate to europa in the past. If mongolia doesnt suits you go back to ethiopia where all humans came from, nice place, harsh life tho.
Albanians (there are a lot of small ethnic nations) were locals however they created an Albanian country after migration of 3 turkish groups named Kimmers, Iskits and Saks (the name of Arsak came from Sak which means in turkish Ar (Ər) brave man and Sak the name of crew). They are together created Caucasus Albania which existed around 16 century. As Azerbaijani Turk consider themselves as descendants of migrated turks ( Kimmer, Iskit and Sak in bc. 9 / Hun turks in 3 century and Seljuk turks in 11 century) we are saying that most of the local countries established by local turks are predecessors of Azerbaijani republic.
@Elshad Aliyev No. I am aware of the difference between Turkic and Turkish. "Turkic" is a language family, like Germanic, Romanic, Slavic, Semitic, which includes multiple ethnic groups. "Turkish" on the other hand, is a specific ethnic group within the Turkic language family, that live in the geographical regions of Azerbaijan and Anatolia. Although, I understand that in English the word "Turkish" is mostly used as "related to Turkey", which is not wrong. "Turkish" can mean ethnicity (in which case, ethnic Turks living in Turkey, Azerbaijan and Iran are encompassed) and citizenship (in which case it only refers to Turkey). It is a similar story with "German". It can be used as citizen of Germany, but also at the same time can be used to refer ethnic Germans of Switzerland. Or "Arab", which can refer to citizen of Saudi Arabia, as well as, any ethnic Arab living in Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Oman, Yemen and etc.
Thank you for this unbiased video. I would really like to wish peace, but it happened... Love from Azerbaijan.
Anlama probleminiz var sizin? Bizdə nə vaxt suriyalılar türkiyəlilər vuruşub? Əllərində heç bir dəlil yoxdur sadəcə saxtakar ermənilərin yalanlarına inanıb video hazırlayıb bu ağılsız. Bu videonun harası unbiased oldu?? Yoxsa ermənisiniz biz Azərbaycanlıların adından yazırsınız?
I come from Armenia. I want peace too. I want have strong relationship to you and i want the war over and do not be war between our countries anymore. Peace my and your countries friend🤝
@@anunazganun7873 thank you my friend for your beautiful wishes :)
@@ittihadi_islam Qardaş,bu deyəsən bizim içimizdə yaşayan ermənilərdəndir
@@ittihadi_islam BBC and the Guardian did provide proof. Are you yet another government propaganda brainwashed person who will believe that the Earth is flat as long as your president tells you it's so?
People want peace, and to do that you need to accept that your country did commit crimes.
I hope to put subtitles on the video, because my English is not good, so I hope it will be more convenient to watch. The video is great.
This was the best and well documented video I watched and learned about this conflict. Thank you.
12:37 Syrians cannot defend their country. Will they protect Azerbaijan?🤦Do you know about the terror in Ganja and Barda?I think you know that. But you don't want to say.
Stop playing victim.
@@dylanshumian8730 We are not playing Vicitim we are telling Truth
@@azerbaijandemocraticrepubl9624 👍👍👍
@@dylanshumian8730.How are the toilets you took from Kalbajar? Are they broken? 😂😂😂
@@rvanhmidov4796 you needed the toilets, common, aren't you rich. See I don't get it if you are soo rich, why you should soo poor. Rich people would not even mention toilets.
Not 15 mln. 30-35 mln Azerbaijani live in the İran (South Azerbaijan)
That figure seems to be bloated.
The figures that I have seen range from 10 mln and up to 20 mln. In that regard, saying 15mln seems reasonable.
It's also important to remember that only roughly half of those people see themselves as "South Azerbaijan", the other half sees Azerbaijan as "North Iran".
South Azerbaijan is not iran topraghon ❤🇦🇿😎
@@user-ms6bq9dv5p I don't think you understood what I said
@@gilgamesh_9119 he is speaking in azeri language
@@agasfcfrov3752 ?
You've better started from 1828. This all started since that year as Russian project in cuacuas
Than you greatly for the video
PWP: finally upload a video about nagorno-karabakh conflict
me : impossible
KARABAKKKK😂🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿✌🔥🔥🔥
Karabakh🇦🇿♥️💪🏼
🇦🇿
10:04 like a Real Turk
amk ne lan XNJSNDNSJSNSNSNZNSNANAMA
Sucuk ayran yemiyorlar vatan hainleri
@@Trakyal yiyorlar sucuk herkes yiyor ve ayran da var onlar da ee nasıl oluyorda yemiyor
-Olum sucuk ayran? ( Bro, sausage ayran? )
-Amk. ( ### #### ##### )
@@arthurmorgan3822 Sausage=sosis
Thanks for the video!
"Middle Eastern politics are easy" said nobody ever.
What about european colonial empires?
“This is Middle East.”
said by you and nobody else ever.
@Corn Pop who are you talking to
@@mossfen583 who are you talking to
@Brother Coa, except this region in question isn't in the middle east.
some impotant things were omitted but I can live with it. thanks for the work you've put in!
I mean, it was a summary
A summary does not omit important points to appeal to all the stakeholders or whatever the reason was. To be frank, I can't remember clearly after three months.
So I'm not sure what you mean by your comment. Have a nice day buddy.
@@denizzz08 hold on, who is he appealing to? Because he doesnt mention your pet points? Its a summary, its not supposed to be extensive and write down every single thing.
@@complexaltruist Why do you think a summary can't be critiqued for its arguably poor choice of starting point, while still going back for millennia briefly but failing to also briefly mention important power and population shifts. Why can't a summary be criticized for the normalization of those so called pet-points of either side to appeal to more people while still keeping the dress of a objective summary of the conflict and the historical events that led to it?
I know the definition of a summary, but thanks for reminding me every time you reply to me. You must be thinking that a summary is an infallible work by god that can not be critiqued; nothing to take, nothing to add, mine will be just as perfect as yours would be... or you're just out for blood on a comment I made three months ago, stating my opinion about this piece and thanking the author for it. smh
@@denizzz08 a summary can be criticized but you are criticizing. You just said he missed points and didn't elaborate. Criticism should be constrictive. He did mention population change. A summary on a specific debated topic will get people complaining from many sides, but is work is good. What annoys me is people always complain about summaries, he didnt butcher anything, he didnt mislead anyone. There is no objective summary, history is subjective, very few things in this world are actually objective.
40 millon nüfüs iranda
Onların hepsi Azerbaycan Türk'ü değil ki
Azerbaycan Türkleri sadece 25 milyon
@@zhongli6724 hayır 35 mln Azerbaycan türkü var orda 1 mln Türkmenistan türkleri geriye kalanıda karışık türk halkları
@@zhongli6724 sən nə danışırsan? Güney Azərbaycan'da ən azı 35 million TÜRK yaşayır
@@turkdifai936
Azerbaycan Türkü yox ümumi türk
Türkmen Türkleri Uyğur Türkləri de var
🇹🇷🇦🇿♥️🤲Küzey ♥️Güney Azərbaycan
That was the best explanation! Thank you ❤ I like that you present viewpoints from both sides.
Georgia *silently eating popcorn*
More like silently eating turkish cucumbers 🥒💦
I have to say that your video is so informative and makes people understand easily to this complex conflix. As an international relations graduate, I found your video helpful. (Also, I liked your sense of humor, it is hard to do this especially on such a topic like political) Thanks.
Really nice and detailed!
"Armenia is Russia's closest ally". If this conflict didn't exist, Armenia wouldn't want anything to do with Russia, how ironic...
What is today Armenia is only so firmly Armenian because of settlement policies by the Russian empire after the area was conquered from Iran
Lmao Armenia is litterially nothing without Russia, Armenia can get clapped in two days if Russia wont support and help them
Exactly why I said "if this conflict never existed" in the first place. The Armenian nation likes Russia, the Armenian people don't.
@@theone_who_knocks You guys are nothing without Pakistan and Turkey
@@prodbykomrebi lol we destroyed Armenia. Wdym. And its a fact that Azerbaijan is much much stronger than Armenia : Azerbaijan's military is placed 60th is the table while Armenia's military is placed somewhere in 100s
Very informative video. 👏👏💯
As a Azerbaijani thanks for unbiased video it was pretty well-crafted.Although it seems like you really worked hard on this video it would be very nice for you to mention UNSC resolutions about this war.But thanks very much overall.Good job
They mostly ask for cessation of hostilities as a whole
@Mellivora Capensis only in one of the regions, not all. And UN also recognized it as contested land. Check the document again
@Mellivora Capensis yeah thats the right document. so where is the part you mentioned? it only talks about certain regions. Not even mentioning NK which legal right to independence was rejected in the first place. Check artcle 3 of 1990 soviet law on cessation.
@Mellivora Capensis well i did an error when i relooked the doc i searched for nagorno not nagorny. But regardless, no word was mentioned about withdrawal from NK, just arbirtary nonsense. Azerbaijan violated the resolutions aswell because the ceasefire was only made in 1994 and azer also violated 1990 soviet law on cessation in the first plce. They could have left the historically and demographically armenian lands for the armenians and that would have been it. It’s only 5% of the land area and doesnt even have any major natural recources
Why the fuck are you so hostile anyway?
@Mellivora Capensis
Oh please dont act like get off your high horse, don’t act like you haven’t said anything true on the internet lmfao. Besides I didn’t lie, I misremembered what i read about it before. I’ll take the L on that, I should have rechecked it before making a claim, but i didnt knowingly lie to you.
No i didnt. Clearly the Main message was to stop the fighting, thats the kind of an approach international community has. Negotiate, don’t fight.
Yeah well the resolutions were pretty arbirtary when discussing the NK and the status of troops there.
The areas around it are understandable, those ones can actually be classified as occupied but even then there should be an asterisk. NK was attacked and Stepanekert was sieged and shelled so it was kind of necessary to take land for the sake of security. This war would have been over much quicker if NK was just an enclave with enemy all around and no supply line to armenia.
It was a war, do you think only armenia was being hostile before the 1994 ceasefire? I didnt talk about the skirmishes after it, most of which azerbaijan was the aggresor of per most sources. I was talking about the time period between the resolutions and the ceasefire. And it makes sense when you think about it. Armenia was content with status quo, why would it attack a much stronger opponent?
3:30 not to be granted but remain as a part of Azerbaijan. Read the agreement correctly
No no, granted... stalin stole from us and gave it to you as a gift.
@@BitsEUismynamelilbish I think you have a problem with reading. As I said read the agreement.
@@BitsEUismynamelilbish Search about Kharabakh Khaganate before make a comment with your ass.
At 13:51, what map is used or did you make it yourself? If your using it and there's a website for it, can you give the link as I'm using it to make the world with it.
Perfectly explained. Thank you. You earned a new sub. Greetings from Switzerland! May all these conflicts in the world stop and the people find peace and happiness. I can't help but be shocked of people in our western countries who complain for the smallest things whilst not too far away, some have suffered during their entire lives...
We are very happy the war in the Caucasus didnt grow to Middle Eastern scales though. These 40 days were hard for both sides, now the active war finished.
բերանդիր
@@Baghirov. would this mark the first time an Azerbaijani and an Armenian agreed on something?
Edmond Babakhanyan its not the first time, during USSR we were fine, but on this we can agree even now.
@@Baghirov. during the USSR we were just under the control of the Union, that is why right after collapse there was war.
While I know this comments section is gonna be filled with Azeris and Armenians screeching at one another, I'd just like to say this is one of the most informative and unbiased videos on this subject that I've ever seen.
Its biased actually
@@mamedmamedli5847 if you make such a claim you have to substantiate it with some form of evidence.
@@mamedmamedli5847 May you please explain how?
@@mamedmamedli5847 not sure biased but definitely has holes. Probably not as deeply researched as topic and nuances of the issue requires
@@alekxs2k551 see my comment to Mamed.
5:37 has reinforced my deeply held belief that the words "Autonomous Region" are a clear sign that something severely wrong is going on. Excellent job, and I look forward to the next one!
Please elaborate
@@Mythbusters2021 Those words are always used to mark areas where something bad is going down. Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone, so on and so forth.
@@BrotherPo are you saying it is usually a cover up. You gave me an idea to read up where the concept of autonomous legal framework come from.
There is also the Åland autonomous region and there is nothing wrong going on there.
@@yusufs1878 Well there used to be scuffles after ww1
Well explained, thanks.
You gave all the information in an unbiased way, thank you
I agree
This is probably most unique situation in the world by the fact that the land that wanted to join armenia is completely within territory of Azerbaijan.
yeah because of the cleansed azerbaijanis from the land 30 years ago.
Actually they wanted to be independent they didn't want to joint armenia, wanted to be another Republic
Abduel Tio Azerbaijan was trying hard to cleanse Armenians for 70 years, still didn’t succeed as it only went from 6% to 17. Go sit down your country is 168th in the world for freedom of speech. You have only been taught propaganda
rhymalishis mitchell one nation cannot get the independence twice when they already have a country. So in that case for the armenians living in Karabakh have no right for self determination, cause Azerbaijan is a multicultural country where live many nations like - Lezgins (lezgic people), Talysh people, Mountain Jews, Tats and Russians. So armenians are just one of those. They were living in peace all the time...
@@nihalhasanov162 I know, my father and his are from fuzuli, and now that this is over I will go there and build a house 🏠
wonderful video, thanks for clearing up this war! the newspapers in my country do not pay much attention to this war!
It's an Armenian land for which the turkish are fighting now. They want all our lands. The lands in which Armenians lived and live for more than 2000 years.)
@Khadija Samadova you have nothing. Everything is proved to be Armenian. 🇦🇲 and don't tell me what to do....I know it all how 1918 azerbaijan was created. Even azerbaijan the name is from Persia. Cuz as I said you have nothing. That's why you always shout that everything is yours.
@Khadija Samadova we are not peacemakers but we are.the PEACE. Everyone knows that its ours. So dont be blind and fool you have nothing jan. And dont write Im neither reading nor answering. Ciao. 👋
@@mariamalexanyan2526 You have been deleted from Azerbaijani lands in couple weeks... If there wouldn't be any cease fire it would only take 3-4 days to wipe your occupying asses from those lands. You will obey to Turks. And always remain royal to your owner. Much love from Turkey 😘
@@atacanturgut316 and what if you become the obey? Iti kovan Kimi.😉 much love from Eastern Armenia to Western Armenia.😘😘😘
Thank you for this video
Who's here after this conflict is over
me
This was beautiful and was just the video I was looking for, do you have a discord server, or a patreon?
Great video (commenting for algorithm points)
Я хочу, чтобы не было войн во всем мире. В каждой стране веками шли войны, и теперь они живут в мире и спокойствии. Я верю, что Армения и Азербайджан, как и прежде, будут жить на Кавказе в мире и согласии. если мы этого не увидим, это увидят будущие поколения. Мир миру и Южному Кавказу ....
❤🇦🇿✌🏻🇦🇲
Хоть 1 чел так думает
give them artsakh then
@@normal7877 ok bro
This channel has been a great help for my IP studies, well done and carry on!
You've won a subscriber with this video, well done!
Amk.
Olum Sucuk ayran?
@@arthurmorgan3822 ne alaka la
Azerbaycan'dan selamlar :D
🇹🇷❤️🇦🇿
wrong and misleading, very inaccurate video
@@ilahamamedova1676 what is wrong about it
5:20 it isnt about them being muslim, turkey helped them because they were turkish
@Razif Al-Ikhlas ???
yeah but Pakistan seems to support cause of muslim
@@preacher3958 kinda make sense
@@drum4416 Pakistan and Azerbaijan has good relations because:
In 20th century, there were diseases and poverty in Pakistan. Oil Millionaire Haji Zeynalabdin Tagiev sent Pakistan a lot of vaccines, medicines and money. Since this event Pakistan love Azerbaijan and Azerbaijan too. There are a lot of topics about H.Zeynalabdin in history books of Pakistan
@@kalamandrovka5828 ok thanks for the information! I respect to both of those countries
Glad I found this channel!
great video, good info/analysis no politics 👍👍👍👍👍
Great vid, as an armenian I dont see why It got dislike bombed though, It remains very unbiased and informative.
I agree, a very balanced presentation of the conflict. And I hope our two countries can reach some form of agreement, where both people can live peacefully side by side. It has to be possible to do so. Co-habitation is already the norm in so many other parts of the world.
But the language we use against each other has to change - we can’t keep assigning attributes to a whole people based on ethnicity.
Do you have relatives in the region?
Also Armenian also agree. One thing that bothers me though:
I don't like that the overarching issue of nationalism isn't quite addressed imo and are taken for granted, which makes sense for a summary, but is an important factor.
It's semi addressed in the beginning where he talks about diverse makeup of the region, which is important imo. He also does mention it as a nationalist conflict which I feel is accurate. But I worry that it is taken for granted, don't know if that fact will stay with viewers as he goes through the rest of the history unfortunately...he accurately mentioned some of the internal pressures, but again, doesn't quite explore how those pressures were cultivated by narrow minded nationalist rhetoric on all sides. This was going to be hard to do in a summary, so I hope this comment might at least help someone understand that...
Especially sad given the diverse landscape and shared history of the people who call that region home.
you are right but Armenia killed 200 000 Azerbaijanis In The World If they will say sorry we will okay
Ask your fellow Armenians
Armenia had the land first and the Muslims took it with their false god.
Dude, this is an awesome educational video.
awfully misleading, wrong, false-facts video
4:03 lmao
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That's the unfairness in this world
fax
Kahabagh had never changed jusrisdiction within sovient union. And stalin decided took zangezur from azerbaijan, grant zangezur to armenia but don't change karabagh jusrisdiction. It is clearly stipulated in the document :left karabagh as it is within Azerbaijan
No!🤦🏻♂️
Azerbajcan Never existed before 1918!🇦🇲🔪🔪🇦🇿⚰️
@@heyellada-ball3929 History of Azerbaijan
the eldiguzids-> Kara Qoyunlu-> Ak qoyunlu-> Safavid Empire ->Afshar empire->Qajar state(Half Azerbaijan, half Iran)->Republic of Azerbaijan
You were kicked in the Karabakh war.🇦🇿🤜🇦🇲
Zangezur was always in Armenia man,Stalin didn't gave it to azeris
Nagorno-Karabakh and Zangezur were controlled by Armenia during the 1918 war, Stalin didn't give Zangezur to Armenia he gave Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijan.
Very well done, definitely among the best explanation videos I've seen regarding this conflict.
very misleading and wrong, lying, in fact.
I didn’t know this was a conflict, probably due to me living in North America, and me not focusing too much on the news, so I’m glad I was informed about it.
Actually no much people care about this conflict, everyone glued theirs eyes on Trump and covid lockdown.
It is definitely good video but has holes. Probably if the author had more time it would have researched a bit more and peeled the onion a bit more
I find it really sad that so many stupid things are getting so much more news than this. It is an important issue. I'm not saying that covid etc isn't important but all the drama isn't.
you got information from the wrong informer. this video has distorted all facts and the history. it is false and misleading.
@@ilahamamedova1676 What are some better sources of information about this conflict?
15 m azeri at south azerbaijan??? more like 30m bro :D
35 million
Always more it looks like a auction sale
It's not correct explanation conflict , it is not complicated history , Armenians are displaced to this region by Russian empire from Iran and Syria created Region ,, Armenia, 19 century,
Can you prove via international strong source!? Waiting for it or you are just imbicile
@@ObserverEffect-xp4dk Read about "Treaty of Turkmenchay" & "Treaty of Gulistan" and tell me where you see Armenians in that period of time prior to these above-mentioned treaties. The were moved by Russians to today's so-called Armenia from the modern-day Turkey and Iran, so there would be no land connection between Ottoman Empire and Azerbaijanis, both Turkic ethnicity nationalities. Armenians historical legacy do not go farther than 1828 in Caucasus region, and that's a fact.
@Bits海 that twat can't be my bro
@Bits海 They have lived in eastern part of todays Turkey, not in Caucasus. To Caucasus they've been moved after 1828 from Ottoman Empire, Persia and Middle East. They were living close, in Ottoman Empire, but absolutely not in Caucasus region.
@Bits海 That's a fake history right there. Just because Armenians were living there, doesn't make Ottoman territories Armenian. They never had their own governance, ever. It's a proven fact. Even an Oxford scholar in Georgian history confirmed that, not to mention Armenian scholars in US universities. Armenia was always a geographical territory, not a country. Why do you think they're calling themselves hays, not Armenians? They're calling the country Hayastan, not Armenia. They just chose this historical name for themselves to make some solid historical back up to their claim. They're not Armenians. Armenia was like todays Caucasus, Balkans, Baltic regions. It was not affiliated to any minorities or nations, rather than just a region name. So, go back to school and read the real history, not the one that you've been brainwashed with.
Relatively Fair Explanation. You basically covered fair historical points for both nations. I did not notice any allusions to propaganda. Well done to the author!
you didn't look well. Many facts are false or distorted. Lying a lot
@@ilahamamedova1676 Yea but for someone not from the region content is still pretty good. Much better than many fancy "bla bla bla explained" bullshit youtubers.
@@ilahamamedova1676 We have real history books out here, only two countries disagree with the events you seemingly refer to. Your attitude only escalates the conflict, that is still ongoing, and claims more lives unnecessarily in both your side and the Armenian side (that has some hotheads too). A peaceful solution can be reached that benefit both sides, only if a little humanity enters you guys' souls.
несправедливость в том что он забыл указать переселение туда армян из ирана в 1828 после туркменчайского договора
Can't wait for the next video
Karabakh was part of the Seljuk empire, the ancestors of the Azerbaijani Turks (and Turkey,Turkish and Turkmen) (1037-1194) : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seljuk_Empire
Karabakh was a part of the Azerbaijani Turkic (Turkoman) state of Qara Qoyunlu state. (1374-1468) : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qara_Qoyunlu
Karabakh was a part of the Azerbaijani Turkic (Turkoman) state of Aq Qoyunlu state. (1378-1503) : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aq_Qoyunlu
Karabakh khanate, one of the khanates of Azerbaijan, ruled between 1747-1822. : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karabakh_Khanate
Karabakh was a part of the Azerbaijan People's Republic (1918-1920) : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azerbaijan_Democratic_Republic
Karabakh was a part of the Azerbaijan Socialist Republic (1920-1991) : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azerbaijan_Soviet_Socialist_Republic
Based on the United Nations resolution. Karabakh is a part of Azerbaijan.
I am from South Azerbaijan
Tehran and viva Azerbaijan 🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿✌
پس "آذربایجان جنوبی" تون شامل تهران هم میشه ها؟ اصفهان شیراز چی؟؟ یا یزد و کرمان؟؟؟ به نظرم کیش و قشم هم باید باشن قبل از اینکه فارسا اشغالشون کنن سرزمین ترکا بود. کلا ایرانو فارسای اشغالگر از مالکان اصلیش ترک ها تصرف کردن نه؟
Siktir
بگو کجای تبریز خایه هاتو ببرم وطن فروش
🇦🇿❤️🇦🇿
Great video
Very interesting video, easy to follow, easy to understand, good sources, I'll recommend that to some friends!
and very misleading and wrong
@@ilahamamedova1676 explain?
I hope one day this wars would end once and for all, Rest In Peace to Armenian and Azerbaijan soldiers. By the way im Armenian
Sadly as long as hate and greed exists war is inevitable
I hope so :( R.I.P to all soldiers and Im from Azerbaijan☺
@Roni Shirinian, as long as these nations respect the internationally recognized borders of their neighbors and don't go on insane military campaigns with massive ethnic cleansing like Armenia did in the 1990s.
I'd imagine peace will be achieved.
@Shah Ümit I'm all for peace dude but I'm not from Armenia or Azerbaijan.
I just found this conflict and it's history to be fascinating.
Thank you Roni, I hope here will be peace between us.
i absolutely love the graphic you have used in your videos for world war 1
Granted to " ? Please, don't give false information. THE document says " stay within the borders of " not " granted to " Azerbaijan.
@@nigarologhy2154 Ən birinci yazdığımı diqqətlə oxu . Başa düşməyə calış ki , nə yazmışam .
@@hajazizov5008 nəzərə alaram adına baxdım linç etmək istədim 😅😄😄
He is just another "unbiased" youtuber repeating armenian version of history.
Ignored 1988 deportation of azerbaijanis from Armenia. Ignored 1950 deportation.
Ignored the fact how armenians were originally imported from everywhere and azerbaijanis were deported from their home lands.
Ignored too many facts, but didn't forget to insert "syrian fighters" who allegedly were involved in 2020 war. No prove of that of course.
@@uncle_fword Qağaş öpürəm
@@hajazizov5008 nə yazmışdı ki
Good explanation for a conflict I could not make any sense of. But, I have 2 questions...1st of what real value is this region; is it a fertile farming region, an easily defensible land barrier to invasion, is it mineral rich or does it have religious/cultural value? What makes it so special that these 2 countries are and have been fighting over it for more than 100 years?
And 2. Why is Israel represented by a box and not a ball like everyone else? I notice Kraut does the same thing.
For your first question, the region doesn’t have many resources, but there are theories that Azeris want to use it as an oil pipeline land. Azerbaijan and Turkey want to create a pan turkic state, which would involve getting rid of Armenia as a whole. getting rid of Karabakh is the first step of that. Armenians defend the land because they have lived there for thousands of years before Azerbaijan even existed. If Azerbaijan is allowed to keep the region, they will slaughter the Armenians there. their soldiers have recorded themselves torturing, skinning, beheading, mutilating, and executing Armenian soldiers AND civilians (these videos can be found quite easily online, so this isn’t just be spouting propaganda). So Armenia needs to keep the land in order to keep its people and country alive. Long story short, Azerbaijan sees the land as a means to an end for Armenia, and Armenia is fighting to stay alive at the hands of Turkey and Azerbaijan. And as for tour second question, i’m afraid i’m not of much help :(
@@yeranmkrtchian5875 Panturkic state idea died with Enver Pasha. Any Turkic official would like the idea but they wouldn't act on it since it's impossible. Do you think Armenians just started existing there? They also took that land with force. No one can claim any piece of land as "historically theirs" since there isn't any way one can claim land based on history. Azerbaijani soldiers who recorded themselves torturing people were arrested and imprisoned by the Azeri Government. Also, there are as many videos of Armenian soldiers killing Azerbaijani soldiers/citizens as well so what's your point? "The next step" of Turkey is not getting rid of Armenia as some made you believe, since that would create problems near Turkey which Turkey would never want.
For Israel being a cube, I think it's a coutryball joke, but you'll have to ask someone else for details
@@yeranmkrtchian5875 why u lying, first of all, those lands belong to Azerbaijan, russia gave u land and moved u from Anatolia to the place where u live now, and u guys started occupations land of Azerbaijan
@@hidebehind3565 explain why Azerbaijan has laid claim to Syunik and Yerevan. And yes, Armenians have always lived there throughout all of recorded history so they can claim the land was historically theirs. We do not know anything concrete about the time before recorded history. Any claim that Armenians conquered the region is baseless speculation, it is unknowable. Armenians have always been the dominant ethnic and cultural group in Artsakh and they still are today. That is as strong of a claim as any nation could ever make.
8:27 kim Kardashian 😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
leyla alieva. Da,😁da,😁да да
@@artyomkaramyan8927 Лейла Алиева - культурная женщина Азербайджана. Не путайте с Ким Кардашьян..
@Jano Belal7 Leyla Əliyeva kültürlü bir Azərbaycan kadını ve onu Kardaşyanla kıyaslamayın diyor
Your voice is heaven brother. Keep it up!
🇦🇿🖓
💛💛💛💛🇦🇲
Great video! I was so confused
Loved the video!
Guys there was another history/politics channel which used the same animation style with the circle flag faces. What was the name of that channel I can’t remember?
brainforbreakfast
I just noticed that u said iran fears azerbaijan because of southern azerbaijan then if they go to armenian side the fear goes up right?
It's bad if Iran joins either side. If it supports Armenia, the Azerbaijanis in Iran will not support them and might rebel. If they support Azerbaijan, the Azerbaijanis in Iran would want to join a victorious Azerbaijan or would increase nationalistic fervor and cause issues in the future.
One day for sure, Azerbaijani people of Iran will get their freedom from their despotic, fake-Islamic rulers.
Thanks to you, for showing whole conflicts.
showing in a very misleading way distorting facts, this is a biased video, false facts
@@ilahamamedova1676 Get lost punk!
This video is amazing! Congratulations for the content, it is always a pleasure to watch it. Greetings from Brazil
not being able to get an interlocutor is not harmful. even if you eat such a serious insult, it means you get in touch and can have an effect that will cause such a huge reaction.
but no interlocutor is taken, a conversation is made above the level, and no interlocutor is taken, which causes a person to hate both the opposite side and believing in it, which drives them crazy.
the biggest insults are in behavior, not words. Russia's cold shower on Armenians...
Good project you say truth thanks
Great video man
Are you sure? 50k Armenians forcibly replaced 700k Azerbaijanis. Who is minority now?
Second of all,Stalin didn't grant Karabakh to Azerbaijan. He said it must remain within Azerbaijan.
The war isn't between 50k armenians and 700k azerbaijanis. I just want to say one word to describe the situation - "Russia"
Mən bu videoda ancaq dezinformasiya gördüm bunun nəyini bəyənirsinz ya sevinirsiniz. Şikayət etmək lazımdır.
Məncə də şikayət etmək lazımdı mən edəcəm indi bunu
Qarabağ həmişə Azərbaycanın olubdu qaqaş (tfu qaqaş didim)
seyx izleyicisen delsen
@@Abbasov.7 nə ?
@@frruxshekiliyeff6206 tfu dedin onu pubg oynayan şeyx kanalı deyir
@@Abbasov.7 yoxe ne şeyxdı sən o sözü şeyxdən eşitmisən
Jsjsjsjjsnnsn😆😆😆🤘🇹🇷🇦🇿 İnsanığda arada çaşrığ. Paşik kimi 😆🇹🇷🇦🇿 (tfü paşikə insan dedim)
Mostly unbiased video. Good job 👍.
Very informative, and very fair!
Perhaps needed to do more research as they are holes
it is very biased.. lots of wrong info indeed. Armenians mainly living around Van lake ( today's Turkey ), they have moved there by the middle of 19th century from Iran and Ottoman as part of Russian strategy.
@@azeturkmen Not true, while Van and surrounding regions were hardcore Armenian center, Armenians did also inhabit the Karabakh region long before the Ottomans or Russians even existed. Armenia’s long ancient history itself is more than enough to prove the claim to the land, they have inhabited the region long before and Turks migrated there. Azerbaijani history can’t even precede the existence of Islam, which by historical standards is a pretty new religion despite how large it’s become.
Sucuk ayran diyor amk ne güldüm sismskcjshdjd
Hangi sahne? 😀
Hangi sahne videoyu hızlı atlamak istiyom
@@orkhanhaji2105 unuttum
@@furkanytne7956 unuttum özür dileriz
@@orkhanhaji2105 10:04 😂
it was pretty cool how different eras had new weapons
During the "Treaty of Turkmenchay" in 1828 Karabakh was already confirmed as part of Azerbaijan. You can check it up. When Azerbaijan became part of USSR, document says "stays within the borders of" not "granted to" Azerbaijan.
That's not true because in sovet the president of Russia handed naxigevan and karabakh to Azerbaijan and then Armenians got it back a few years late
@Nihad Memmedli YOU ARE SO MEAN AND RUDE DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH PEOPLE LOST THEIR LIVES AND HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE CRIED THAT THEY LOST THEIR SON YOU STUPID FUCKING BITCH
@@nanenanor Did they not know the consequences of living in land that did not belong to them ?
@@Luna-fz2tb no
@@nanenanor Do you know Russian? I think you should check out that 1921 document)
Just stumbled across this channel over the channel of Kraut and after watching your last few videos, I'm very glad to have found this channel. You seem to make amazing content. I hope you'll grow even more soon and wish you the best
One thing to notice, in the first war which finished 1994, we were alone, noone backed Azerbaijan except some volunteers
Armenia at that time was also alone. And now too.
@@a.s.a.l.a.4827 yes, but we were alone too
The thing is the powerful and who has the truth won,
We showed you that to shell the blood is not right way, I hope all these wars will be good example for the people of not our country but all Caucasus to improve
There are much valuable things in this universe than hatred we spread among ourselves
I hope one day our rulers, politicians and most importantly people who suffered more, will understand and do not go to fire by the hand of third factors )))
You know these factors as me
@@a.s.a.l.a.4827 Armenia was maybe alone but all the equipments and motivation from Russia was enough to win battle and war
Most important and decicive factor in war is the capability of the army to sacrifice for their belives and what is holy for them
And this is what you had,
Ps I try to put logic and racianalism here
If you ask me that Azerbaijan Enclave is so ass like what was Russia on while making those boarders
I have heard that the Soviet Union purposely fragmented ethnic states like that in order to decrease unity so they wouldn't be able to unite and have independence movements and stuff like that, no idea if it's true or not but seems like an explanation. Keep them too disunified to stand against you.
@@jamesdulak3108 I won't be suprised since they genocided and deported ethnic minorities too replace them with russian settlers. If they did do what you say It's probably because "let them do the dirty work"
this is the best impartial video about this countries and karabakh! congratulation ✨✌️
Maybe, but there are some mistakes. During the days of russian empire (1897 census) it was azeri who is the majority of population in karabakh. It does have significant armenian minority tho
Kharabak not country .Kharabak is Azerbaijan's❤
oh, it is veeery partial. very misleading. false facts. distorted truth
@@ilahamamedova1676 but Kharabak ain't country İlaha Mamedova only Kharabak Azerbaijan 's land , half ❤
Oh yeah Mit ra we wait u i the Kharabak , love from AZERBAIJAN ❤AND YOU COME THIS LAND FOR TRAVEL HAVE NICE NATURE , TASTE MEAL
and if you wanna you can research about our Dolma , Shah plov , Dovga , Qutab , Dushbere ❤❤❤and we have the rich history and for this at the Azerbaijan have so much monument Kilse , Mescid or differend
Thank you for this amazing video...it takes an artist to explain simply a very complicated situation. I hope to keep learning more about this beautiful country and its challenges
He is done good job but probably hasn’t done deeper research as there are holes. For example Stalin didn’t give Karabag to Azerbaijan. The official document states Azerbaijan RETAINS. Maybe he has read an English translated version of the document
it takes a historian to explain this situation. this is a very misleading and wrong video, very false
@@ilahamamedova1676, then what exactly is actually going on? Please, enlighten us.
I see no significant mistakes or obvious bias, just like the other videos on this channel. But why does this particular video have such an unusually high number of dislikes?
Sort comments by newest and you know why. armenians and azeri peoples both dont like it when he doesnt just repeat their propaganda
How did you see the Like:Dislike ratio
@@crayngo2844 Browser plugins, the one I use is called Return TH-cam Dislike.
Да будет мир между нашими странами. Давайте вместе сделаем Кавказ раем, война не радует мир Давай жить в мире Привет из Азербайджана в Армению ...
🕊❤🇦🇿🇦🇲❤🕊
impossible
🙏🇦🇲🇦🇿🙏 j'espère
наконец нормальный человек
Никогда не прошу армян
Что они делали с детьми, беременными женщинами
Вспомните Ходжалинский геноцид
@@user-wz1il1bv6d еще один шизик
Ай шизик, это ваши сделали! И убыли того, кто говорил правду
А именно убыли Чингиза Мустафаева
Wars does not end with a ceasefire , they end with peace.
Something azerbaijan doesnt understand.
@@BitsEUismynamelilbish the only thing that Azerbaijan cannot understand is terrorism and creating 13 terrorist groups within 3 mln population which Is the only thing Armenia good at
@@shabnama3796 theyre just feeding lies to you, you rlly dont get it?
@@BitsEUismynamelilbish During 44 days we were able to see who spreads lie, thanks God 🙏🏻
The most important thing is that no one gets murdered or hurt anymore, then I don't care what happens.
Well there has been huge casualties....
well unfortunately azerbaijan has kept bombing nagorno karabakh's peaceful civilian areas and cities, including the capital Stepanakert during the entire war. more than 50 civilians died
@@edouardsahakyan4636 it’s just terrible and over 5000 armenian men have been killed in the war may god be with them all. absolutely heartbreaking .
Oh boy you can bring the tissue then
I love the objectivity. Good job.
Oh, by the way is the background music trying to play Chopin's waltz, but can't entirely? 😂
Love Both Armenia and Azerbaijan from Brazil 🇧🇷♡🇦🇲🇦🇿
Bruh! Please run the world!! You have my vote ❤❤