And at the time I actually thought Jeanette Mcurdy had a twin sister but then I found out the trick of how they do that on tv and movies it takes 3 people and they can’t cross the line in between them to pull it off
I honestly can't blame Freddie in this episode. Sam has done a lot of strange and unforgiving things to him at this point. Plus, if you had someone trick you so many times, would you really believe they have a twin sibling?
Yes I wouldn’t believe her either I don’t blame Freddie Sam is too much for me when she’s around Creddie I do like her with Spencer though she seems more happy and herself around Spencer
@@alishashay17 Again, if you had someone deceive you multiple times, you begin to not trust them anymore. Freddie isn't stupid, and it makes sense that he wouldn't believe Sam had a twin sister.
You’re doing some of the lords work, I’ve been trying to find the iTwins episode ending for a goooood minute now without spending money on streaming services 🖤🔥
@@kallmemikey1701 unfortunately when I looked it up, they said I had to have paramount+ but I already have a Disney+ & Hulu bundle, Amazon prime, and Netflix subscriptions and those already are expensive enough 😭 gotta love how everything is split up on different stuff, Netflix only has seasons 3-5
They should've had an episode where crazy ponnie(from victorious) teamed up with nora and they kidnapped melanie thinking it was sam, and sam had to go save her.
Man, Freddie and Melanie would've been perfect. If only he wasn't so delusional. Not that I blame him, he's been tricked so many times, and eventually the truth will sound like a lie.
If you where born in 1994 and meet jennette mccurdy in 2008 get her to dress like this and go to club with you that wouldve been great but fuck it we cant have everything right?
Melanie is always messing with someone every time she appeared. First she confused Freddie into thinking she's Sam switching back and forth. And now she pretended to be Sam's evil twin (ironically, Sam is the evil one in reality) to scare Cat. It makes you wonder what if Freddie and Cat met and shared their mutuals stories about Melanie (minus the part where Cat learned the truth, of course)
Kinda wish you didn't cut out Goomer asking Cat about what kind of juice and tree she was attacked with, since that was the only good moment in that episode. I know that's not the main purpose of this video, but still.
What's funny is how Freddie just can't seem to accept that the disconnect between Sam and Melanie would be TOO drastic and great for her to be faking it. Sam is just too aggressive to ever "tone it down" for any reason. That's why she was still like that even when she did date Freddie. Also, having a twin isn't exactly unique or special to the point it's impossible. If anything, Sam having a nice twin only makes sense even more. Twins are usually the opposite of each other (not all the time of course) in terms of attitude and personality. Hence, the trope "evil twin". Poor Freddie simply missed out having a great and nice girlfriend, even if she looked like Sam.
To be fair, it's Sam and Carly's fault for tricking him multiple times as shown in the beginning of this episode. If they hadn't done that, Freddie would have trusted them and believed Sam when she said she had a twin sister.
@@JaxNovoa509 I don't think they were trying to trick him. Carly explicitly pointed out that Melanie is Sam's twin sister. And Melanie herself admitted as much. Sam didn't give a fuck for Freddy's opinion, which is just Sam being pure Sam. Freddy was only suspicious cause he thinks Sam would have played the long con that long just to fool him. But she's too aggressive and short tempered to ever tone down her aggression, even if only to mess with Freddy. That's why everyone thought it odd when she was being "nice" the next time, and that's cause she actually started to like him.
@@igorpolyakov4113 Even if one was explicit about the existence of someone, you still wouldn't believe them until it is proven otherwise which did not happen in this episode. Freddie isn't stupid, and he has every right to defend himself from his friends' supposed lie.
@@JaxNovoa509 Sure, but doesn't Melanie get a say here? I think it'd be unfair to be accused of being someone else or not being truthful just because someone else is paranoid or skeptical. He's just lucky Melanie was such a nice and kind girl, the complete opposite of Sam essentially, that she took it in stride and simply corrected him every time. She also agreed to date him, which if he had believed she was Sam's twin sister, would mean that he essentially scored with a girl without even trying, and completely threw that away because of his own paranoia.
@@matthewedwards4622 Melanie technically kissed him just to try to show him that she isn't her sister & no one knows that Sam/Freddie did kiss just to get the whole 1st Kiss thing over with
@ShaneWasTaken because of the way both Carly and Sam were tricking him a lot during the beginning of the episode that's why he kept claiming that Sam never had a twin sister
The fact that thats how Jeanette Mcurdy is in real life and not like Sam.
And at the time I actually thought Jeanette Mcurdy had a twin sister but then I found out the trick of how they do that on tv and movies it takes 3 people and they can’t cross the line in between them to pull it off
She kinda was a tomboy because she was raised around brothers
I really wish they'd revealed Melanie to Freddie at the end
Same
same
Same.
I agree so Freddie can see that Sam wasn’t playing with him. I know that Sam play alot but this is true
Ik same
I honestly can't blame Freddie in this episode. Sam has done a lot of strange and unforgiving things to him at this point. Plus, if you had someone trick you so many times, would you really believe they have a twin sibling?
Like I said it was sams sister.She wasn’t messing with him.
Well Sam was telling the truth about having a twin
Yes I wouldn’t believe her either I don’t blame Freddie Sam is too much for me when she’s around Creddie I do like her with Spencer though she seems more happy and herself around Spencer
@@alishashay17 Again, if you had someone deceive you multiple times, you begin to not trust them anymore. Freddie isn't stupid, and it makes sense that he wouldn't believe Sam had a twin sister.
plus one of them always had different plans every time freddie wanted to hang out
Man it wouldn't of been nice if Melanie appeared more in the series like for real
Exactly. She’s the only one in the family who doesn’t get in trouble
I love the character Melanie might be my fave, I love her personality
@@xomenace999 I know the exact opposite of Sam makes it totally funny
@@kallmemikey1701 facts
@xomenace999 easy Sam is Super Aggressive, and Melanie is Super Perky & Girly
You’re doing some of the lords work, I’ve been trying to find the iTwins episode ending for a goooood minute now without spending money on streaming services 🖤🔥
Season 2 episode 20
@@kallmemikey1701 unfortunately when I looked it up, they said I had to have paramount+ but I already have a Disney+ & Hulu bundle, Amazon prime, and Netflix subscriptions and those already are expensive enough 😭 gotta love how everything is split up on different stuff, Netflix only has seasons 3-5
You're pretty much out of luck at this point.
The fact that Melanie is the only good member in a family of criminals and juvenile delinquents is a real blast 😂😂😂
One thing that Carly and Sam could've done to prove to Freddie that Sam has a twin sister was to show him a picture of Sam and Melanie together.
They should've had an episode where crazy ponnie(from victorious) teamed up with nora and they kidnapped melanie thinking it was sam, and sam had to go save her.
Man, Freddie and Melanie would've been perfect. If only he wasn't so delusional. Not that I blame him, he's been tricked so many times, and eventually the truth will sound like a lie.
yes melanie and freddie would've been perfect for each other
I mean… one way or another; he found his way with a Puckett lol
yes that is true 👍
2:12. 3:00. The way Freddie says Melanie’s name. 😂
Nathan Kress' deliveries on those lines is pure perfection.
Cat: What are they doing here?
Sam: I don’t know!
Also Melanie was killing that dance at the end
I used to have a big crush on Carly and I mean a HUGE crush but after this episode Sam/ Jennette Mccurdy was my big crush and still is years later.
I also used to have a Ginormous Crush on Carly
If you where born in 1994 and meet jennette mccurdy in 2008 get her to dress like this and go to club with you that wouldve been great but fuck it we cant have everything right?
@@Dr.Johnny.10 That's true, unfortunately.
I still do Miranda is just that Gorgeous and kind ❤
Can we take a moment to appreciate how well the actress plays two opposite characters?
Jennet Mccurdy did a great job pulling off the twins roles
1:34 "Nice meeting you! :)"
"Uh okay 🤪"
💀💀💀💀
I ain't gonna lie if Freddie would've just swallowed his pride he could've had a great time 😂
He would've if Sam and Carly didn't fool him more than once.
@@JaxNovoa509I mean that kiss should’ve changed his mind for real 😂😂
The whole episode was lowkey a twist 😅
This is one of the best romantic kisses I have seen!
Melanie+freddie=meddie❤
Or Meladie
3:57. We’ll have to dance together… 3:58 pressed against against each other. 😂
Melanie going to the lengths of kissing Cat for this plan. That’s dedication- 🤣🩷💜💙
That scene is cringe.
I like how Carly was kind a jealous when Freddie kissed Melanie. She wanted Freddie so bad but never confessed unitl many years later 😂
8:29 YOU HAVE A TWIN SISTER!?!?! 🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
I wish they had shown them both together
By both, do you mean Sam and Melanie with Freddie
They were shown together twice in this episode.
I wished she appeared more often but since after Jeannette retired it’s not just the same anymore
You should be glad she doesn't do this anymore. A real person's life is more important than them starring in fictional media.
Melanie is always messing with someone every time she appeared. First she confused Freddie into thinking she's Sam switching back and forth. And now she pretended to be Sam's evil twin (ironically, Sam is the evil one in reality) to scare Cat. It makes you wonder what if Freddie and Cat met and shared their mutuals stories about Melanie (minus the part where Cat learned the truth, of course)
we need more melanie scene and also "meddie" even if "creddie" is the end game.
5:05 Well Freddie will feel like 🔩⚾️
I can't even tell them apart or which is which
@isiahanderson2409 Melanie is the most Cheerful of the two as well as the favorite according to their mom
Good enough 🫤
Kinda wish you didn't cut out Goomer asking Cat about what kind of juice and tree she was attacked with, since that was the only good moment in that episode. I know that's not the main purpose of this video, but still.
Everyone’s afraid of Sam except Carly
@@Joseph-i9o5q yup since they became best friends over a tuna sandwich LOL
Can you imagine Melanie being a giant?
In your imagination what Melanie being a giant?
That'd be terrifying.
😅
0:30 “Melanie Puckett?” Wait, “MEL PUCKETT?” 🤷🏻♂️
@@Yont2013 yup and Jennette mccurdy played both of them
What's funny is how Freddie just can't seem to accept that the disconnect between Sam and Melanie would be TOO drastic and great for her to be faking it. Sam is just too aggressive to ever "tone it down" for any reason. That's why she was still like that even when she did date Freddie. Also, having a twin isn't exactly unique or special to the point it's impossible. If anything, Sam having a nice twin only makes sense even more. Twins are usually the opposite of each other (not all the time of course) in terms of attitude and personality. Hence, the trope "evil twin". Poor Freddie simply missed out having a great and nice girlfriend, even if she looked like Sam.
To be fair, it's Sam and Carly's fault for tricking him multiple times as shown in the beginning of this episode. If they hadn't done that, Freddie would have trusted them and believed Sam when she said she had a twin sister.
@@JaxNovoa509 I don't think they were trying to trick him. Carly explicitly pointed out that Melanie is Sam's twin sister. And Melanie herself admitted as much. Sam didn't give a fuck for Freddy's opinion, which is just Sam being pure Sam.
Freddy was only suspicious cause he thinks Sam would have played the long con that long just to fool him. But she's too aggressive and short tempered to ever tone down her aggression, even if only to mess with Freddy. That's why everyone thought it odd when she was being "nice" the next time, and that's cause she actually started to like him.
@@igorpolyakov4113 Even if one was explicit about the existence of someone, you still wouldn't believe them until it is proven otherwise which did not happen in this episode. Freddie isn't stupid, and he has every right to defend himself from his friends' supposed lie.
@@JaxNovoa509 Sure, but doesn't Melanie get a say here? I think it'd be unfair to be accused of being someone else or not being truthful just because someone else is paranoid or skeptical. He's just lucky Melanie was such a nice and kind girl, the complete opposite of Sam essentially, that she took it in stride and simply corrected him every time. She also agreed to date him, which if he had believed she was Sam's twin sister, would mean that he essentially scored with a girl without even trying, and completely threw that away because of his own paranoia.
@@igorpolyakov4113 These are good points and I agree. But still, in his perspective, I can understand why he had trust issues and I don't blame him.
Ariana was brave enough 😅😅😅😅😢😮😢
@cecilyngoka9677 agreed. to have to suffer from all the torture from Melanie's antics, I feel so bad for her
ICARLY SAM AND CAT FRIENDS
NICKEIODEON EPISODES LOVE
Question what are you a seddie or a Creddie and why
My favorite number is derf (or 5.5)
4:27 there opposite but you can tell that there is some Sam in her
@@dellosayshello5405 how so
Why did they wait until this episode to tell Freddie abot Melanie
@@Ben_levine no one knows except the makers of the show
@@kallmemikey1701 obviously. But Carly and Sam knew Freddie for years you'd think would come up before this
She never showed any fear to same
Melanie puckett is samantha.s twin sister on icarly. 😅
OMG that's true!!!
In other news, water is wet.
ASHLEY
I wish sam and Melanie were together more in iCarly and Sam and cat
Agreed
I think it has something to do with the fact that Jennette McCurdy portrays both characters.
@@JaxNovoa509Yeah
FREDDIE AND MELANIE KISS
BOYFRIEND NEW GIRLFRIEND
@@matthewedwards4622 Melanie technically kissed him just to try to show him that she isn't her sister & no one knows that Sam/Freddie did kiss just to get the whole 1st Kiss thing over with
Maelna friends halim Ahmad
kim. sam
Huh?
@@Yoongi-Marry-Me109
kim
@@IakDiwnw What do you mean by Kim? Is it a ship name or what do you mean by kim?
Kaley. Kim. Ga
@@Yoongi-Marry-Me109 Don't waste your time with this. It's clearly a lousy parent allowing their 4-year-old child to write these comments.
😂😂😂
Idk why freddie kept pissing me off with this 😭😭
@ShaneWasTaken because of the way both Carly and Sam were tricking him a lot during the beginning of the episode that's why he kept claiming that Sam never had a twin sister
@ 😭😭😭
Crying wolf
Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
Fede is not cool
who is Fede
“Fede” 💀
Freddie *