Elsa Is A Goddess [Frozen Theory]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- Head to to expressvpn.com... and find out how you can get 3 months of VPN coverage for free!
Today J dives into the Disneyverse to determine if Elsa’s role as the 5th spirit makes her a true blue goddess just like Te Fiti in Moana!
Popcorn Culture ::
podcasts.apple...
open.spotify.c...
#SuperCarlinBrothers #Frozen #Disney
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrot...
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlin...
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![How FAST Is Elsa's Horse? [Frozen Theory]](/img/n.gif)
Elsa is a Goddess Agree or SUPER AGREE?
SUPER AGREE
Super super agree
SUPER AGREE FOR ME
omg y’all like my comment i’m shook💛💛💛 one million percent agree
I don't agree. Elsa is a spirit in name only. Yes she has fantastical, elemental powers. But I don't think she's on the same wavelength as Tefiti. Also. If Elsa were a goddess, it would have been revealed in Frozen 2.
The first minute of jay’s confusion basically represents my whole life 😂
It def warrants some explanation!
@SuperCarlinBrothers
lol cuz I’m always the one in the group who has no idea what’s going on
SuperCarlinBrothers I wonder why normal people can walk around Elsa’s castle in basically no protection, they also have higher elevation
Eeman Saud I have never related to someone so similar in my entire life
@@SuperCarlinBrothers Have you guys considered that Iduna was also the Fifth Spirit before Elsa? I'd love to see you explore this possibility ^.^
Some of my reasons Why Iduna Was The Fifth Spirit Before Elsa
1. The Fifth Spirit is a bridge between two different sides (Iduna, a Northuldran, saved Agnarr who’s an Arendellian; Elsa, their offspring, bridges the people and the magic of nature and also unifies Arendelle and Northuldra just like their parents)
2. Both Iduna and Elsa have a good relationship with nature (Iduna has a special connection with Gale, the other elemental spirits and reindeers, just like Elsa)
3. In order to find the truth, both Iduna and Elsa are drawn to go to Ahtohallan (Iduna went there accompanied by Agnarr)
4. This is one of the most convincing evidence: Honeymaren said "They heard it (The Fifth Spirit) call out the day the forest fell."
We all now know the Fifth Spirit call is actually young Iduna when she’s saving Agnarr, potentially meaning that she is also the Fifth Spirit before Elsa was born
5. Iduna sang "Show Yourself" together with Elsa, a duet between two Fifth Spirits or it could also mean Iduna passing on the Fifth Spirit mantle to Elsa
6. In “Show Yourself”, Iduna has a solo part mixed with “All Is Found”; The part “You are the one you’ve been waiting for” was added by her and not Elsa, not to mention it is not a part of “All Is Found”, meaning she’s improvising and her ability to sing along at that very moment could mean that her spirit is alive in a way (because I don’t think a memory can improvise in the middle of a song)
7. Relating to Iduna's spirit is still alive, why didn't Iduna (or Ahtohallan) called Elsa during the events of Frozen I? Because Iduna, some way or another, could probably watching over Elsa grow and understand her true self, and to gain some personal experiences in leadership; only after seeing Elsa understanding her powers and being a capable queen, Iduna finally called her to face/overcome the dangers she will encounter on the way to Ahtohallan, to unify the Arendellian and the Northuldran like a true queen or leader, and to also lead the elemental spirits in harmony
Thanks SCB!
#Theory
But, going back to that "fire monster" bit.. Maybe they're coming at this wrong, it's not that fire monsters are their similarity (lol Gandalf). Te fFti is earth and fire, Else is air and ice(water). Perhaps they are the spiritual poles of the earth. Does anyone else think this could be a thing?? I love it! Like the two goddesses of the elements, like zodiac signs being under one of four elements.
ok but what does Elsa have of air?
There are times when she generates cold winds, if I recall correctly. Basically, she represents cold in all its forms, and cold in general is often viewed as being a mix of air and water when it comes to classical elements.
@@Talonidas7403 Cold air plus water= Ice and snow
@@Talonidas7403 I am one with the winds and sky
So basically te fiti and Elsa are two halfs of the 5th spirit ( or te fiti is the 6th spirit)
Me before every SCB video: There is no way you can convince me THIS is true!
After the video: I HAVE BEEN BLIND!! HOW COULD I NOT SEE THE TRUTH!?!?
I feel the same way!!!
Yes no kidding 😃
Ronin 28 SAME
Life tip: You will always be convinced by SCB
First thing I thought is we don't need a white woman as a Polynesian goddess
Sokka: My first girlfriend was an ice goddess...
Zuko: That's rough, buddy...
i understand this is a reference and a joke
but like if your first girlfriend was elsa, then you are above us all
@@ArcherWillows very fair point, haha
I think we are soulmates.... 😂😂😂
XD
I just... I just love this coment 🤣🤣🤣🤣
“The answer comes all the way on the other side of the world in Moana.”
Me: Yes. The answer is always Lin Manuel-Miranda
To quote Hamilton: that's true
Mhmm
When I read this it was at the exact moment when he said that😵
*Always*
The world turned upside down...
Those diamonds point inwardly to Elsa, and outwardly into the unknown!
wow that makes sense!
Last time I was this early the “These Socks are Amazing” segment still existed! 😂
Dont open the door
I miss that segment 😿
Do you know why they stopped it?
Ivy Garcia I wish I knew. I miss it to!
@@ivygarcia6878 Same!
J: I guess if you stole her heart she'd you know die.
Me: You clearly haven't watched Once Upon a Time
I think he said in a livestream he did with his wife a while back that he hasn't watched it but that Ben has, or something like that.
Yes! A fellow OUAT fan!
Rumplestiltskins just laughing in the corner
"steal her heart u say? I can manage that dearie!" (insert impish laugh here)
The Unown Ditto Girl “for a price.”
haven't heard someone mention that show in a long time
Because her mom was human and her father was saved by the spirit wouldn’t Elsa technically be a demigod?
*GASP*
I'd say it's debatable. Traditionally, when someone is classified as a demigod they are usually the result of one divine parent and one human parent (think characters like Percy Jackson), whereas the way this theory is worded, it sounds more or less like he's trying to say that Elsa is the goddess or Spirit of the goddess taken physical form (think characters like Zelda from Skyward Sword), though I have heard of some cases where divinity "becomes human" and is classified as demigod, though those circumstances are few and far between and usually tend to involve a loss of powers and/or divinity, neither of which seem to apply to Elsa.
Of the third generation
That would mean Anna too!
I think that since the fifth spirit saw that someone of Arendelle and someone of Northuldra would one day fall in love, it selected them to be the parents of the fifth spirit that will one day untite the two waring peoples, and bring balance to everything.
considering that there are four elements, what if we meet the "fire" goddess in raya and the last dragon?? that would be so cool!
Oooooooooo
Or maybe Rapunzel do to the sun magic
An important character from Anna and the Snow Queen that was omitted from Frozen was the queen of summer who naturally had powers of life and warmth in contrast to Elsa's cold and death -- although interestingly the main theme surrounding her wasn't actually ice but bees; she was a queen bee who presided over a hive. This carries a kind of femme fatal subtext to it given that the queen is one of the few and most dominant female bees in a given hive, or perhaps the cruel cannibalistic aspect of nature; the mother who eats her own children.
This contrasts very sharply with the themes of Frozen given that both Anna and Elsa's parents die early in the story so they are never coddled by them, although their isolation is allegorical more than anything.
This would lead us to assume that the role of the summer queen would be the positive aspect of the mother image that supports children in their efforts to find independence, which brings us a little closer to Frozens themes concerning the individual spirit.
I can't think off the top of my head how best to incorporate her into the story, but she's already semi-cannon, having cameod and been mentioned in sumo supplementary material, if I recall.
@@amanofnoreputation2164 That makes sense since they were originally going to make Elsa the villain before they redid the whole thing. It would have been interesting to see that iteration
Maybe tefiti and elsa are both two elements
Tefiti is earth and fire
Then elsa would be water and air since I'm pretty sure she's made cold winds before and ice is just water on a chill pill
J: One is soft and curvy
Scott: like me
J: the other rigid and sharp
Scott: like J's hair
I'M DYING
IKR?? Scott’s comments r so funny!!
@@eemu252 yeah it's my favorite thing to keep an eye out for in every video lol
I just wish they were on the screen longer so I can read them
@@sweetmissirish oh yeah, sometimes I spend a full minute just pausing and unpausing so that I can read them lol
Isn't Elsa's "bad version" her as a child? Her being locked away in her room? Just like Te Fiti, once she has her heart back she is her true self, once Elsa has her freedom back she is her best self. I feel as though Elsa's childhood is her worse side, the time in which she could not express herself and not be able to show who she is? But after Let it go and Show yourself she becomes her true form.
Though to herself that was not the worst. In the second movie she didn't want Anna in harm's way which means she probably feels that when she hurt her sister is her worst because can you imagine being the reason your sister died
I mean you are probably right so....
@@sappyice and considering that Anna is literally the only family member that Elsa has left it’s quite possible she wants to be a 5th spirit
Personally I think of her as something akin to the Avatar
The Avatar of Winter.
Vance The Weeb she’s just boring
Screw you all!!!!!!!!!
I don’t like that they froze water and said hey look new element why? Well it makes sense. She has ice powers ice spirit.
@@rowanw1312 chill kid
“The other ridged and sharp”
“ *like J’s hair* ” 😂
Well, I haven’t even watched the video, but I’m 150% sure that they will convince me.
Love the username (not sarcastic)
Alpaca Suitcase thanks.
How the heck did this get a heart and over 100 likes?
@Ylfa Karen Guðbjörnsdóttir Well there is 1%
Can you guys please make a video talking about the Disney earth? Like where everything takes place and like geography and stuff?
I think they did or at least made like a pixar theory for disney
I wasn't confused about who was calling to her. The first time I saw it, I assumed Elsa's mom called to the four spirits when she was young (i.e. specifically the wind spirit, Gale) and in that moment she actually became the "fifth spirit"...kinda. she stepped into that role bc she was intervening between man and nature with her action, but she didn't have innate magic and didn't know enough to fulfill the role until too late, but she passed that destiny on to Elsa (and Anna, the other half of the bridge) and that's why the spirit of Iduna calls to her (with the same voice as when she was young and stepped into the role, creating this destiny) to help Elsa take on the mantle of her powers and her role.
Yeah, I am totally not confused either. Just so we're on the same page, who is actually calling to her?
@@dudetheman3 I think Elsa's mom is calling to her. She believed it's the fifth spirit calling to her, but it's Elsa who is the fifth spirit and her mom was just calling her to her destiny. It seems to be technically the voice of her when she was young, but its definitely still her, or rather her spirit. At least that's what I always thought.
@@friend_trilobot Ok, that makes sense, thanks!
It’d be fitting if Te Fiti is an ancient, ageless spirit while Elsa is one who is always reborn
Unless Moana IS Tifiti, because then it would be equal.
When Tifiti was without her heart, she covered everything with heat. Love is represented by a heart, and love thaws. Elsa covered everything with ice when she didn’t feel love the love to thaw. So when she and Elsa didn’t feel love, bad things happened.
Why can people walk on Elsa’s ice castle in no coats?(or at least in little coat covering)
It’s driving me nuts
They can also walk around it tho, higher elevation must not help either
Maybe because...”the cold doesn’t bother them”? lol sorry I couldn’t help myself
If you're talking about the first movie then i think i can help
Anna and kristoff were wearing coats. The soldiers who came to get her were wearing military uniforms and presumably had to climb to get to the castle so they were already warm when they got there
@@kennethrapp1379 There's actually such a thing as hotels made entirely of ice. As it would happen, they can be found in Scandinavia. One of them even made a replica room based on Arendelle castle.
static01.nyt.com/images/2014/03/17/travel/17frozen/17frozen-blog480.jpg
ice is actually an insulator! so while still cold, being *inside* and ice structure is much warmer than outside it! thats why people in the ice age made igloos
11:05 She doesn't create magical items but I feel like her creating life (Olaf, Marshmallow, tiny snowmen) is a close enough parallel!! She can also make permafrost which seems like a magical 'item'
But she does create her dress in let it go. So I guess she can create things just doesn’t know how
omg yes i’ve been saying she’s a goddess for forever😂💛💛 love this
Kyla Campbell same!
Lol same!
I LOVE ELSA YES GODES
Idk if this means anything but Elsa also doesn't fall in love with anyone. She's very independent. Even with her family she's distant. I mean obviously the whole thing in the beginning of Frozen 1 was her keeping her powers a secret from everyone including her sister. Of course she still loves her sister and cares for her friends and her kingdon, but like notice how she can keep her "heart" distanced from others.
You're voice is so soothing
True dat
Aw thanks so much what a nice compliment!
Yeah, it’s true
Can I just point out, Maui is the demigod of the “wind and sea” and Te Ka was the goddess of “fire and earth”. See, water, air, fire and Earth. All 5 spirits
That is only 4 - water, air, fire, and earth. 🤔
I think the 5th Spirit would only exist in the north because of Atohollan (I probably spelt it wrong)
@@radcircles9865 While I think you're on to something, the sea is a body of water, so that would probably be...one spirit?
Blab Generic-Tee I didn’t say ‘sea’, I said ‘see’. Also, I meant 4 spirits
Blab Generic-Tee sea=water
What do you mean theory? Elsa IS a goddess! No question. Beauty, power, Idina Menzel's voice, water spirit steed = goddess for sure
J: Elsa creates life; like Olaf and Marshmallow
Snowgies: Are we a joke to you?
*vídeo* : "Elsa is a Goddess"
*Me (a wlw)* : heck yeah she is! That girl is ho-
*Me* : oh you mean like, she's a literal Goddess
*Me* : okay convince me
He always does lol
Marina M IKR
Gladly!
What’s a wlw?
^
Wait. A king and queen using an ancient magic to save one of themselves, then go on to have a blonde girl who is the living embodiment of said ancient magic. Who then went north of her kingdom, to fulfil her destiny, and bring balance to other ancient magic. Why does that sound familiar? Because it's Rapunzel.
Queen Ariana got sick. King Fredrick used the Sun Drop to save her. She then gave birth to Rapunzel, a blonde girl who is the living embodiment of the Sun Drop if you watch Tangled: the Series. Rapunzel was then later called to the Dark Kingdom north of her kingdom (I know what it's called I'm just not saying it) where she was meant to fulfil her destiny by bringing balance between the ancient magic of the Sun Drop and the Moon Stone.
King Agnarr got knocked out. Queen Iduna summoned the fifth spirit. She then gave birth to Elsa, a blonde girl who is the living embodiment of the fifth spirit. Elsa was then later called to Ahtohollen, north of Arendelle, where she was meant to fulfil her destiny by bringing balance to the spirits.
Just saying sounds pretty parallel. Also SCB if you guys haven't watch Tangled: The Series, you *MUST*!
Is anyone still low key obsessed with the soundtrack of this movie
Yes! The sequel's musical numbers are vastly superior to the first movie
My son is, so I am too. But really the music is awesome!
Show yourself
Tia Hammad yesss definitely. I like to belt this one when I get the chance
Alissa Mai, yeah me too, but it’s a bit painful when you can’t sing
I don’t know if anyone else has pointed it out, but in the lullaby All Is Found, it calls Ahtohollan a “mother full of memory” and Te Fiti seems like a mother goddess. Seems to fit.
"She is human, she is nature, she is a goddess."
So she's not a Disney Princess then??? 😂
She’s a Disney Goddess
Uh, no. She is not. She is a Queen.
@@SANSd20 nope, She is a Goddess Queen.
@@LordEmperorHyperion I was closer than Princess. Why would anyone want to demote her?
Its NOT a demotion it's a promotion, one day she'll rule the Spirits, the Northuldra and the people of Arendelle this what a Goddess Queen is, look like it up on google..
i just reliesed that in frozen 1. anna says. why couldn't elsa have tropical powers that cover the fyords with white sand and warm fire.
Ong i forgot about that but then that scene played on my head
1234567890
Was looking for something to watch, thanks for providing some quality entertainment!
"Could Elsa have some evil side that is released if her heart is stolen?"
Look into Kingdom Hearts 3, and the rumored original plans for her stage
The explanation for why Elas is the heart is similar to why Repanzel in Tangled is the flower after it heals her mother.
I feel like y'all just been trying to explain all the plot holes in Disney movies recently (especially frozen 2)! They should put you on the payroll as writers cuz they be messin up with these stories lol
Disney would be in a far better place right now if SCB wrote all of their movies.
After watching the making of Frozen 2, I think many of these theories are pointless. The writers had no clue how to finish the story and the whole writing process was a clusterf#@$.
@@clarebo exactly!
This is so crazy! I was literally re-watching Moana last night, and when they said the bit about Te Fiti being able to create life my mind went straight to Elsa creating Olaf! Of course, that's where you see the difference between me and the Super Carlin Brothers, because that's as far as the thought went with me, whereas they went and found supporting arguments!
Chudley Cannons, Chudley Cannons, Boom Boom Boom, We are not Pirates
ok but really i can't stop laughing how they zoomed up when he said die was so extra and funny
"Does Elsa have some angry creature inside her that will come out if someone steals her heart?"
Me: So what I'm hearing is, when Anna dies... we get The Snow Queen? Is this just her origin story???
I mean, the original Frozen movie was supposed to be based off of The Snow Queen by Hans Christian Andersen, so you might actually be not too far from the source...
I got Express VPN because of you guys and I love it! I read the title and expected Hercules because of gods and goddesses but I LOVE the Moana connection! I think the Moana koru is designed that way to also look like a wave (like the Water Nation symbol in ATLA).
That was fast
BIG PLOT TWIST: Todays sponsor ISN'T Candid! :O
11:55 Can’t wait for all the people to come back after Frozen 3 and be like *gasp* YOU WERE RIGHT
Hey they were right about the rock giants in Frozen II, and even got their message as far as Disney who put it in the next trailer, so I think we should listen.
Matpat and SCB: EVERYONE IS A GODDESS
for sure she is a Divine Being, I have hopes that the future Frozen films deal with the reality of that and what it means to her being and mortality, she could literally have evolved into an immortal - I mean, it could be AMAZING, but really sad, but AMAZING
I think Elsa's heart is her love. Kinda the point of the whole first movie. Her fear makes her lose control and become a monster (deadly, like te ka), while her love is what frees her.
I've never clicked so fast in my life
Ikr lol
Ha
same tho
Same tho!
You should get an auto-clicker. Auto-clickers can crush that time!
This video made me think about how Moana and Frozen’s magic system fit together in their shared universe, and by extension how all of the magic systems in all Disney animated films fit together. To me, a lot of them seem both very similar and very different, albeit very soft (undefined). I’d be interested in you guys pulling together all that we know about magic from the Disney Animated movies to try to understand and define rules for the Disney magic system.
Technically, Elsa was already a Goddess, but I guess you’re talking about a different kind, like Greek and Roman mythology
Just after I finished Frozen 2, I was super confused as to why or how does Ice relate to the "fifth" spirit stuff, but then it occurred to me that, she is the spirit of ice because that is the predominant element where she is located and in there, it is almost always winter, so I started to theorize that maybe in Frozen 3 we will get to see the other 3 Gods or spirits or wardens or something, why 3? well, since Elsa has ice powers, she would be a perfect fit for the Winter role, and as such, there would be more people to represent the other 3 elements! and thanks to this theory, Moana or Te fiti (which I believe are the same) can be the Summer aspect.
also, I believe that Frozen 3 will tackle Global warming themes somehow, in the second movie, there are some references to the rapid development of technology and some consequences; very minor stuff but it felt very out of place. I believe Olaf makes those references
It was only winter in Arendelle because of Elsa. She cast the eternal winter herself when she left.
@@imaginefun13 Arendelle's still in a cold climate, though. The winters shown in the movies may be unseasonal, but you can probably expect there to be plenty of snow in the region when it is properly winter.
Personally, I think that's probably the main distinction here, if the connection between Elsa and Te Fiti is an actual thing. They're both essentially spirits of the land, but Elsa is the spirit of a near-arctic region and therefore her powers mostly manifest as cold. Te Fiti, on the other hand, is the spirit of a region of tropical or subtropical islands, many of which are probably volcanic, and her powers manifest accordingly.
That said, for this reason, I don't think the outward-pointing diamonds are pointing towards Te Fiti. Instead, if anything is present where those lines converge, it'd be a southern cold spirit... or perhaps Elsa is also linked to the antarctic regions as well. Another possibility is that there are three other Te Fitis spread across the world - perhaps the fire diamond (her ability to rejuvenate plant life could be linked to the Avatar theme of fire representing "energy and life" - noting that, like fire, life is primarily fueled by oxidation reactions) or earth diamond points to Te Fiti, and the other diamonds all point to similar deities.
I thought this was more or less explicitly canon in the second movie.
"If someone steals her heart..."
*Sighs in Kingdom Hearts 3 Frozen datamining*
This could also open up the possibility of having other elemental princesses. Maybe in villains or even in even suddle ways, but I bet that in the next Disney princess movies we're going to be having a few new elemental princess movies, leading up to a elemental princess get together! WHICH could support the theory on having the disney crossover which could make Rapunzual somehow involved in all this princess stuff. Maybe she is one of the elements! But magical healing hair doesn't seem very likely. So she'll probablly have some even more important role when they have a big crossover, (Because seriously, how could they NOT do that.) Unless of course the crossover was supposed to be reck-it-ralph... Defintally not it. But they still probablly are going to have a movie dedicated to some sort of elemental crossover.
I do also believe that Moana is going to have some sort of descendant. (Ah descendants, looks like that's what's up.) Which will have some similar powers to Elsa. Because I think that Elsa is a descendant of an ICE GOD and Moana IS the WATER GOD, and sense Moana takes place a whole lot before Frozen, there's sometime for her and some person to get married have kids, and after a few generations, one of them has slightly less god like water powers and so on so on till the times of Frozen.
Oh and this generation is defintally going to be called the magical era.
And this is a whole lot isn't this? x>
But I truley do think this is some what gonna happen.
I’ve been rewatching year one videos and it’s crazy the Chanal has evolved. So glad for your guy’s success.
I thought I knew everything I needed to know about Elsa, then this popped up. I’m ready to be mind blown
Thank you for teaching me the term "antipodal."
I've been interested in this specific geographic science for as long as I can remember but I never knew the terminology.
👍
She's a goddess, and J and Ben are gods
I love your guys videos. You both put in a ton of research & then creatively come up with theories I love! Big fan of your channel. Keep up the good work! Best luck guys.
It’s like Yue from ATLA. She has part of the Moon spirit within her when she was born, and then she later becomes one with the Moon spirit. Elsa has part of the fifth spirit in her because of her father being saved by the fifth spirit, and the rest of the spirit is left at Ahtohallan, which eventually calls to her so that Elsa can become one with the spirit.
They’re also similar because both of those “returning the heart” songs make me cry THANKS JAY!!!! 😭😭😭
I already knew she was a goddess but I’m so ready to be SCB convinced she is.
Yeah “SCB Convinced” is a whole other level
I love the idea of Anna being Elsa's heart 😂, from the Frozen movies it seems like Anna is the only person who is able to command Elsa around lol
Else died in Frozen 2. The only reason we are seeing her at the end is because water remembers.
elsa immortal confirmed
I am in New Zealand and I was so happy when they were talking about it.
The line " You are the one you've been waiting for all of MY life" implies that she was calling herself and she was the voice... At least in her perspective. This is confusing... grammatically and "PLOTically"
Wow imagine Elsa being immortal/living a super duper long time like Tafiti and outliving Anna and all her family except Olaf. Also I def want to see her create a magical item-that sounds epic lol
Wasn't Elsa's mom calling out to Gale, though? 🤔 After all, we see she seems to be close to the wind spirit when we see her play with it, and Gale's the one to ultimately help Elsa's parents.
Aside from that, I totally agree with the rest of the theory!
I was actually thinking more along the lines of Iduna's (Elsa's mom) song being a call to all spirits, not just one. The wind spirit is the one that responds and helps them (I think the wind spirit is quite friendly to Iduna since she was playing with it when she met Elsa's dad). The reason the voice of the one calling to Elsa is her mom is because her mom is the last person to call on the spirits with the song (the Northaldra (sp?) people either don't know the song (it was prob taught to Iduna by the wind spirit) or they didn't have a need to (they didn't realize they've been trapped for years)) The one who sent out the spirit call to Elsa is Atohallan itself either because Elsa has finally learned to control her powers and has come to her magical maturity (thus making her powerful enough to take her proper place as the fifth spirit) or because it has been nearly fifty years since the forest was closed off (Iduna and her husband were kids, teenagers at best when it happened and their kids were in their late teens when they left/died) and there had been a fifty year deadline for the Arendelle people to come and appease the spirits (it would explain why their parents left when they did, they could've gone before Elsa was born or after Elsa was old enough to take over as queen in their absence)
I always saw it as Ahtohallan being the place where you find the truth out, and because water holds memories (something they mention loads) it kept the memories of her mother? And that was what was calling her? The memory of her mother? But then how was her mother singing to her? That can’t be a memory surely... now I’m confused again lol
Jay: we havn't seen Elsa make any thing magical.
Olaf: Am I not magical enough for you?
Thats what I was thinking! I was like "she literally just made a living being appear....like from thin air....is that not magical
Omg! all New Zealander's freaking out when someone 'famous' says our name hahaha
Also... roll the R on Koru
I was looking for this comment! 😂😂👌👍
Heloise Phillips-Smith haha same
THE TROLLS IN FROZEN ALSO HAVE SPIRALS ON THE BACK OF THEM !!!!!!
THIS WAS AMAZING. I really am interested in how this turns out. Also, water holds memory and so, if Elsa can freeze water, she can freeze memories and effectively time.
Go NEW ZEALAND 🇳🇿!
This was really a running videos love J's sense of humor
Wait didn't elsa re-dress herself in let it go (made with her- powers?)
And that's a- a object- right-?
You guys are the only youtubers that don't make me forward the ads parts lol I think its something about your voices.
Alternate title:
Gandalf Is a Disney Princess
Its amazing how much these brothers and co respond to comments
This is more of a fact than a theory if you catch my drift ;)
Based on this theory, I want to propose that Elsa and Tefiti are yin-yang and I have proof:
The yin yang balance often refers to heaven and earth, like having the power to make space ice vs the power to create land masses with plant life.
The two also embody the ideas of being passive vs active, such as passively standing by as your heart is returned vs actively going out to restore your heart.
Also there’s the idea of heat and cold, which can be seen not only by the island locations but also plants need sunlight (heat) to thrive whereas ice needs to be cold.
There’s the idea of hard vs soft which is seen in the “heart logo” of both.
There’s big and small, which can be interpreted through the physical size of the two.
I’m sure there’s plenty more I can come up with but this is good enough for now
You guys should sort Star Wars characters into hogwarts houses
YES PLS
Yeh for example dooku, it can be raven claw or maybe slytheryn, he fights for the jistice as he says
Sequel characters are one sided
And atla
Elsa is a level 20 divine soul sorcerer with an ice theme
Ok what if Elsa hasn’t unlocked her full “potential” and in frozen 3 it would e like she creates something other than ice and then she like merges with the other four spirits and she had to master her powers to defeat the “big bad” and then in frozen 4 Elsa and moana team up somehow
TigerJack 177 so she becomes the Avatar....that would be awesome 😎
@@alicechristopher204 I know right
I. Love. This.
I love this sort of thing with parallels and stuff. Thank you so much for seeing this and sharing it.
Ok being a witch i can see where ja is comeing from with this theory.
Elsa->element = ice->spirit
Tifitie->element = earth -> goddess Gaia
? ->element = fire ->god Hephaestus/goddess Hestia
? ->element = air -> goddess HERA
? ->element = water -> goddess Amphitrite/god Poseidon
Now we need to find out what disney princess will take the form of water,air,and fire. Or is elsa consider a water goddess sense she is ice?
Perhaps Moana is water
@@thedragonwarrior5861 the only thing i am questioning is elsa is ice which is made from water so is she is spirit or is she goddess of water?
Ariel for water. She is a mermaid after all! (And presumably Poseidon's granddaughter)
Fire: The spark-- in her hair: Tangled.
Air: Someone with wings. Tinkerbell?
Please let there be a frozen three. I love the idea described in this video! Very much enjoyed it😊
me just sitting in the back already knowing the stuff about New Zealand ...
cuz i live there
J: Sounds like the plot of Frozen 3 if you ask me.
Me: Sounds like the plot of Frozen 1 if you ask me.
Our bodies are “safe” ... I’m getting fatter😭😭😭
Which means you are harder to kidnap. Hence, safe. (Yes this is a joke. Please don't hate me)
Esther Meyerhoff 😂💀
SCB: "We don't actually see Elsa create any... Magical Objects herself, but..."
Olaf: "Hi, I'm a talking snowman."
Lol
So Moana and Frozen 2 form the actual song of ice and fire ??
Ooh. And then we get Jon Snow who is a descendant of Moana and Elsa. 🤣
Kia Ora from New Zealand! One of my favorite videos by far! Love the research you clearly did into the culture and the references to lotr!
Actual theory: Moana copied frozen so that they could have more merch from the *same* story.
jk
SP Magic But are you joking though?
We know Frozen debuted in 2013, however this is based on the second Frozen film, Moana came out almost 4 years ago, so your theory is redundant.
@@taniavankemp4394 'Jk' is an abbreviation of the word 'just kidding' :)
Or ... the other way round
@@anwenm But Frozen came out first.
@@spmagic9083 But Frozen 2 came out second (or third, depending how you look at it)
I love the channel so much 😍
Ben and J are the best.
So I don't know if Goddess is the right word since we are dealing with spirits and such instead, I point you to Celtic Mythology (I believe this where they originate correct me if I'm wrong) with Faeries/Fae. So for those who don't know Fae are split into three main groups Winter Court, Summer Court, and Wild-Fae. Focusing on just the first two, I believe that Elsa is the Winter Lady (youngest queen of the Winter Court) and Te Fiti is the Summer Queen (Leader of the Summer Court). Let me know if you agree or disagree and why. Also, I would love to know what the brothers think about this if someone could post it in their discord or something.
I only know the lore of the Fae from an amazing book series called the Dresden Files by Jim Butcher, so I may have gotten some of the Mythology about them wrong, but I think this really fits well with both this theory and the movies.
I think it would be Norse mythology rather than Celtic, since Frozen seems to be based on Scandinavia, and Norway in particular. Different mythologies but similar.
@@bradiedean7466 I don't believe Norse mythology has Fae. And this isn't our world so there mythology will be different. I'm just saying that she's Fae which is from Celtic Mythology. If you were to go with Nordic mythology she would actually I believe have to be a Frost giant, which doesn't make much sense.
@@peterbroussard915 Frozen is set near the Saami. The Saami traditionally have gods and goddesses that pertain to weather, so Elsa would likely be a goddess seeing as she's part Saami and her mother is Saami. (edit: And plus, Ahtohallan is based on the Saami too, they're called the "Northuldra" in the movies bc it's a made up tribe).
@@StarrySeal Fair enough then. How does Moana fit in though? I think your explanation for Elsa is honestly pretty good, but how can it relate back to Moana as well.
@@peterbroussard915 so Moana is based on Polynesian cultures, which many do have concepts of gods and goddesses. In Māori tradition they’re referred to as atua. So Te fiti would generally represent the earth mother being the source of life, growth and death (represented as Te Ka).
I always get really excited when youtubers talk about New Zealand, love this theory!
Considering Elsa is a Christ figure in this story, I've always believed she became a goddess after her "resurrection". She was human with otherworldly powers blessed by some sort of celestial being, died, then was brought back as someone more celestial with greater powers. So not her entire life, but by the end, definitely a goddess.
Good job team! That animation was amazing!