When Key is crying and Onew is hugging him you can tell how hard Onew is trying to keep strong and not break down as well. As leader of SHINee and the big brother of the rest of them he had to put aside his own grief in that moment to support them.
Onew was a rock. But he suffered trying to be strong. In the Japan concert when they sang “from now on” with Jonghyun’s vocal playing during his parts, Onew was crying his eyes out at the end. I felt terrible for him.
SHINee have their comeback now, and I'm here watching this. For sure, Jonghyun is happy for his brother's. We miss the angel. Damn! I can't stop crying.
Key can't hold his sadness. Minho trying so hard to not cry . Onew , the leader , use bangs to cover his eyes, I know he tried so hard to hold back tears. And the maknae , Taemin , almost lost his soul.
00:44 The first one with black hair is Taemin, behind him Key, and behind Key, its Onew with his hairs who cover his eyes. And 00:50 its Minho with the thing in his hands.
And Onew, with his heart broken into pieces, held Key's hand, offered him a shoulder to cry on, and whispered reassurances into his ear. Then went on to comfort the older lady, who I presume was Jonghyun's mother, before ushering the other members into the limousine. Minho tried so hard to hold back his tears, and put his arm around Jonghyun's sister when she was overcome by emotion. They were family to each other. They were chief mourners, because they were important to Jonghyun. He was reported to have a distant relationship with his own father. Blood may be thicker than water, but that doesn't mean sh*t. I am glad they were there, and were able to offer some comfort to Jonghyun's family.
@@MC-ko2mx they were like a family to their members family, honestly u can see it. Shiit I can't stop crying I not a shawol , but damn his father story makes it even more sad. Poor jonghyunie Hope the angel is happy , his one smile is an instant serotonin boost and the way Key couldn't hold his tears , broke my heart . Bro I only saw their don't call me few weeks ago , and now I m ugly crying. And I read jonghyun's story. Your favourites or not , nobody deserves to be felt like that .
Imagine being his mother. You barely get to see your son as he is always busy and the next thing you know you get a phone call thinking its your son but its actually someone telling you that your son has passed away That would absolutely shatter me
True , I ain't a showal but I wanna see jonghyunie come back . This angle's smile made me smile and this made me cry. Hope he is happy for-ever Edit- Now I m a shawol
@@augustaprasanna2185 hi malayali here.. They are members of a Korean pop music band.. One of their fellow music band shots singer committed suicide.. 😭
Yeah, its first time I am watching this clips and I am choked.. filled with emotions and sadness. I know seeing this clips remind me again of junghyun and also sulli, and Bora.. all the others K-pop idols who are suffering and can't show Thier emotions to others. I feel sad. I wish we were there for him during the last day. I wish we have able to comforts him and change his mind. I wish we can turn back the time and understand him better. 😭
i feel so sad for yeri she will miss her bestfriend and everyone calling her dramatic for crying like wth peopld she cried because she just lost a brother-bestfriend!
This is the worst part about being a leader :( when he needs to be comforted, when he actualy lost his soul, when he actualy shatter into pieces, but he is there being strong for his member.
He also explained that he felt like he wasnt allowed to cry. Bc Onew was in the midst of a scandal when Jonghyun passed. So basically he felt like he had to self reflect on his actions instead of grieving his member. Its sounds awful but knetz were abusive towards him when his scandal broke out
@@layloo5244 i know i shouldnt say this but sometimes i hope knetz should feel or be in his shoes sometimes so they wont judge and pointed their finger so easily. It was just so crazy and unbeliveable they were abusive him to the point he cant even cry for his own member.
@@layloo5244 I feel so sorry for Onew. Being caught up in a scandal, doesn't mean he isn't allowed to grieve. They aren't mutually exclusive, regardless of what netizens say, or expect.
Razel Hollero hey. Yes the scandal was basically he was at some club, he was very drunk, fell down, grabbed a womans leg to stabilise himself. Then he fell down again and grabbed the womans leg again. His friends explained he thought it was a pole. But that woman went on to report him to the police for sexual harassment. Police booked him for sexual harassment in Aug 2017 and S.M. Entertainment had defended Onew at the time, saying, “Onew had visited the club to congratulate a friend who was debuting as a DJ. While dancing in his drunken state, Onew unintentionally came into physical contact with the woman.” Police tried to question Onew at the time of the incident but he was too intoxicated to answer questions. Nor could he later remember even touching her. Due to the scandal, Onew dropped out of the second season of the JTBC TV drama “Hello, My Twenties!” Due to netizens request of course. He was tormented by netizens. In December, Onew apologized through a handwritten letter to us Shawols. Only a few days later however Jonghyun took his life. Police later cleared him of sexual harassment charges the next year.
I’m not a fan of SHINEE but when I heard about his death I was sad like imagine how bad his family and friends were and still are hurt. I wouldn’t wish this on no one 🥺
I came here again because today was Moonbin of Astro's funeral. To me, Kpop companies need to make immediate changes. Regular days off, not the seven days a week schedule of practices, rehearsals, promotions, fan signs and events, appearances, photoshoots, concerts, and tours. Groups should start getting 30 vacation days off per year. Hire mental health therapists to be on staff from now on. If staff report that an artist is having difficulties, whether physical, emotional, or mental? See that the artist gets help right away, put them first, not the profit line on budget reports.
When he passed I was in so much pain that I had to distance myself from all of Kpop. His death affected me so much I had never cried for an idol so much. He is special to me. Shinee was one of the few bands that introduced me to kpop back in 2011.
My story is exactly similar to yours. Shinee and IU brought me to love Kpop in 2011. I cut off after his passing in December, I couldn't just take the shock and it felt unreal, my gosh it was exactly a week after my birthday and I was so excited trying to catch up on clips of what turned out to be his last concert. It took an entire year for me to ease back into the Kpop community and even since then, I just got the courage for the first time to watch this video. I hope you're holding in fine?
same here...when i heard the news that he passed away, i was heartbroken..it was hard that you cannot see your inspiration anymore..it took me two years to start listening to kpop again though...until now, it still hurts but knowing that he is in a better place, it lessen the pain a little
This is exactly how I reacted. I couldn't listen to kpop for a long time. Jonghyun is the only idol I have ever cried over. Shinee is my ultimate bias group.
It’s his birthday today....it’s been 3 years RIP I miss u sm and I hope ur doing good up there than being here.😭❤️ Edit: im back again but this time it’s his death anniversary,I hope ur doing well up their,just so u know we all miss u😭😭-12/17/20 Edit: I’m back again, I miss him a lot and I still hope he’s doing good up there, we will continue to remember him every year♥️😭-12/17/21 Edit: I’m back…again, this time it’s his birthday. I will continue on coming back every year.This man deserved the world burg the world didn’t. He is really missed but I know he’s doing good up there. -4/7/22♥️
Karin Hanna my favorite Kpop group why does my baby have to pass away please stay we love you it hurts me to see you gone comeback I love you I miss you 💜🥰🥺💋😭😍😘😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺 the members are crying it hurts me to see them cry of there love one I love you
Let me just say this Onew is such a brave individual I'm speechless he was in great pain as well but he still comforted his members I really respect him for that
Alice Night He comforted his members because he knows they needed him, but I’m also breaking cause after this, he had his psychiatrist. He didn’t cry the whole wake, he just comforted his members that’s why he needed a psychiatrist back then. He’s traumatized... and that’s heartbreaking...
Onew was under a cloud, and caught up in a scandal a few months before Jonghyun passed. Because of this, he said he felt he couldn't cry, as he was supposed to be "self reflecting". He did what he does best, and comforted his members. But it came at a cost, and he wasn't allowed to grieve publicly, or show outward emotion. My heart broke.
@@Ray-kc6wf uh, they don't know the other people you were talking abt? U want someone to tell you "sounds like this person's death is more important than other people" when someone you love dies?
I didn't not know the guy so at first I thought this was a kdrama but I looked it up and it's sad to see someone died because of depression I hope in his next life he will get the life he had always wanted
@@Nishattfatimaa. 00:34 it's Minho with the thing in his hands 00:44 in the left side is Taemin, Key and Onew And the other side is Super junior members (Leeteuk, Eunhyuk, and Donghae)
It really breaks my heart. I'm not their fan but I can't imagine the pain they are going through. And the hardships jonghyun has experienced must be beyond words. I hope he can finally rest well in peace. It's been years but my heart still aches for his family and friends' loss.💔💔
Yeah you can't imagine how hard it was for me and for the others he was my bias I'm still heartbroken and I can't believe is gone how why why why I miss him so much my heart is in so much pain
@@alessiacinca6608 Even though we can't share the pain with you, don't worry fans like you did great loving him with all your heart....the angel is in a better place now, remember him as the person who made you happy, he wouldn't want to see his fans cry....sending warm hugs♡
it’s disgusting how there were cameras flashing the entire time.. I would be so furious if people were flashing cameras at the funeral of a loved one. R.I.P Jonghyun.
i wish the cameras weren’t there his friends and family are mourning for the lost of him and there are flashing lights everywhere not the time nor place
Unfortunately its because they chose to do a public funeral. Notice that in privately held funerals there are no cameras and journalists are not allowed to enter or be anywhere around.
Sm and family agreed to do it public, but the cameras only allow till the entrance / lobby. I also feel the cameras and flashes is disturbing and not appropriate to be there.
@@saskya8391 this is so true . Why tf ppl hate K-pop so much or the fans are so obsessed. It's life of the most of the K-pop idols like jonghyun here. Many make it through , but imagine what they are going through
Thats sad the photographers couldnt even let Jonghyun's mother send her son off on his final ride without the flashing cameras. Very disrespectful to his mother.
@Flower Twice they had personal funeral and family allowed. Btw you are watching it because of them. The family understand he is a public figure, his fans were already down with sudden news. Please understand it last meeting with him for fans also
I hope SM noticed the condition of the fellow Shinee members, especially Onew. He is walking as if his very will to live has left his body. I see the pain of the others but his body looks as if it could collapse at any moment. These guys need grief counselors to help them manage the next few days. Onew especially shouldn't be alone. I hope Kpop fans stop attacking idols for every little mistake. Some words hurt some more than others. I see a lifeless Onew and that worries me. Please stop attacking people. We were not born perfect and never can be. Give people a chance to learn from their mistakes.
a pesar de que ya pasaron 5 años, aún sigo llorando por la pérdida de Jonghyun, cómo fan de ellos desde sus inicios es muy doloroso todavía el asimilar este trágico suceso de mi querido Jonghyun. :(
@@celiagarcia4437 en abril 2023 murió Moonbim de astro, tremenda perdida 😭 yo lo conocí hasta ahora que ya no está y me duele aún sin conocerlo era excelente artista.
I've been a fan of SHINee since 2008, they got me into kpop. If you don't know them, that's okay. They were really huge and were able to get a spotlight amongst bands like BIGBANG, Super Junior, and even TVXQ! SHINee's songs got me through many difficult times, and I am forever grateful. But even so, fans weren't able to do anything to stop Jonghyun committing suicide. In the end, we were completely powerless, no matter how much we could have wanted to help. This is not the only tragedy. I'm thinking about Sulli and GoHara amongst others. The Kpop industry is terrible. The attacks idols receive everyday, especially online, are terrible. The more spotlight they get, the more hate they receive. Mental health issues are kind of a taboo in S. Korea and that's a shame. What I really want to say, is that it can happen to anyone. I'm sure some ARMY will read this. I am and ARMY too. This could happen to anyone. No matter your fandom, how big, how small. Don't hate on artist. Even if their fans insult your bias. Don't attack artists. Their life, especially in the debuts, is already hell. They make too many sacrifices as it is, don't make them sacrifice their own life. Music, entertainment, its not worth their life. If I could give back everything I received from Jonghyun and SHINee for a chance of him being alive, I would. If it kills them, it's not worth it.
@@srinidhi.n9556 I am sure ARMY will read this because there are a lot of ARMY. Not necessarily to them, but BTS are getting a lot of attention, and I wanted to talk about how the more spotlight idols get, the harder it gets.
I find myself thinking about Eunwoo (Astro) and how the army’s said that his third place in the "male idol brand reputation ranking" doesn’t belong to him because the first 7 should be for BTS. It's not fair, I love Astro, they were the ones who introduced me to k-pop, and it was because of them that I met BTS (I'm also an army) and I'm happy with the success Eunwoo is having with his kdrama. But it must be really horrible because he has to deal with the acting and with the group, he must feel a lot of pressure and guilt for representing them on charts and still he has to read those kinds of comments. DO NOT DO THAT! he's getting so much on his back, why do they have to be so mean? Eunwoo can be there and face bts on charts (and hopefully one day with Astro too) and that doesn't take away the legend that is already bts, nor love, success and nothing. They are also friends! I do not understand the rivalries and the hate that is created towards other groups, idols do not deserve it, it is not fair.
@@Inopia7 Ahh I didn't know that, sorry tho on behave of ARMY. Hope all the " only BTS should be first" kinda toxic fans realise and stop creating fan wars tbh
I still think about Jonghyun everyday. He was my first kpop bias when I was 13 in 2012. I loved him so much. I grew out of kpop but I always made sure to follow SHINee when they brought out new songs. It still hits me hard and I'm 23 now
The Super Junior members are trying so hard to not break down, you can tell they’re holding back their tears. They know that they need to be strong to support their juniors
They didn't have to bring in the reporters. I wish they had let them grieve in private. This is so heart breaking. As someone who has lost a loved one too, the grief never really goes away, but I hope they can learn to deal with it.
i think the family of jonghyun gave consent to have them there because it was a public funeral, so fans and others came. and then they had a private funeral the next day without reporters. it's still sad that they cant have a break from the paparazzi :(
Jonghyun has been away from his sister for so long and having Yeri there who didn't even had the chance to enjoy her childhood freely. he really treated her as a real sister and same towards Yeri. I'm sorry i know I'm late
When i first saw this video it was just 1 day ago and at that time i didnt know about rv so naturally i didnt know who yeri was. Seeing her like this at that time i thought she was his sister or girlfriend to be crying so hard. Then when i started to stan rv i got to know the deep sis and bro bond they shared. And seeing this video again now i feel so sad for yeri😞😞🙁🙁😖😖😖
The fact this was 6 years ago I was a kpop fan after I heard his I cried my eyes out it's so hard seeing someone dead if you know them or not rest in peace moonbin jonghyun sulli goohara you will be never forgotten ❤
this is why i hate kpop. companies don't paying attention for health and mental health of their artists. idols just smiling, while dying inside. companies need to take care about their artists. idols don't deserve hating, internet bullying etc. let's love and be always cheerful for our idols. show them your love, because they are need it. and jonghyun/sulli/goo hara now in the best place...❤
@@iliketiddies462 i know, it's fans fault too, but companies really need to help them with...for example hating comments, right? it's make me sad, some entertainments ignoring haters and their bad comments🥺 I'm sorry for my english👉🏻👈🏻
The thing is they cant just sue every hate comment if theres too much its not the fault of the companies theres not that many thing they can do ive heard heechul talk about that the company do have people who talk with idols when its a bit too much in sm but you know no matter how much support they get it only take 1 more comment to make them break We should blame the antis not anybody else
@@sarafnawar2134 this is an old video. Jonghyun was one of the members of shinee. Shinee are a second gen group but they are still active and famous. Jonghyun died in 2017 by suicide, he suffered of depression. His death really impacted a lot kpop world. He was really loved by everyone, a gentle and caring soul. And he was such an incredible artist. He wrote lots of shinee songs and had the voice of an angel. You should check shinee discography, it's considered one of the best in kpop. And also jonghyun solo albums.
2023 and this still hits so hard seeing them carry him in anguish it's so painful to see them hurting 💔😢 my heart breaks everytime and don't get me started on his poor families pain that's another level of hurt
No one mentioned it but the fact Super Junior Leeteuk, Eunhyuk and Donghae are also next to SHINee members tells so much about everything. SHINee members are like little brothers to Suju and they lost a little brother who saw growing up. Hope Jonghyun is in a good place now
Even Yeri looks broken We miss you Jonghyun I wish we supported you more, We never knew that this would happen We’re so sorry We hope you’re happy What hurts more is that it’s all in the past and we can’t change it *We love you* *_Rest in peace_*
I... don't know how I ended up here again so many years later. I held his Sydney memorial, cried for days, couldn't sleep and watched this over and over. Now I can think of him with joy, think of all the smiles and songs he gifted us without pain, but there will always be a hole. My shinee is 5, they always will be.
same, i was just singing happily some songs then searched for shinee ones, and somehow ended up here, crying like it was that year. i couldn't attend the memorial in my country but i too cried for days, weeks even, i didn't imagine that his loss would affect me that much. and i too can now think about him with a smile, remembering his voice, the funny videos and all that, and lastly, yes, there will always be a void
When this happened years ago, I was really devastated. I wasn't even a fan of SHINee before but it broke my heart too much. Now that I started stanning them, it hurts more. Seeing how the members finally opening up and talking about him, which they couldn't do before bcs it could create issues. The continuous mourn for him even after years of him since he has gone to heaven is really huge. I'm always hoping that you're doing well there Jonghyun, you're the purest angel that we have. I love you always.
Some netizens were critical of Yeri, saying she should have controlled herself better. She is even having the way she grieves a close friend's passing dictated to her. People are vile.
I discovered SHINEee in 2018. But I can't imagine how Onew felt. That must have been so hard being the leader, grieving and supporting the other members. I hope people didn't pile hate on top of him to.
As I saw them looking to the ground the amount of lights flashing, I immediately started to cry and then I saw his mother clearly in pain. I cannot believe people turned up to a funeral uninvited to take pictures of this just to plaster it all over social media. RIP my love, I miss you
@Lynnie Vivi (slight trigger warning) "Depressed people don't want to die. They want to feel alive but deperately can't". Did you ever hear that quote? I think there's a lot of truth in it. Depression doesn't work like that, it's terrible and suicide is never something "happy", neither for the person commiting it nor for those who knew them. Suicide is not also not "choice", it's more like the only way out in the minds of people who are severly depressed (although there are always other ways!). But hopefully he's in a better place now. However I appreciate your effort to comfort others ❤️
@@ivaaggarwal122 gosh how disrespectful of you. This is a video to honor jonghyun but you're just spamming about a bts video? I really hate people sometimes
i recently just knew about him and i already feel so attached to him,but here i am crying really hard,i have never cried this hard in my whole life. you did so well jonghyun we are so proud of you! i hope you are happy now wherever you are ❤️
Idk Why I'm crying I don't even know him😭😭😭😭..so hard It would've for his be loved ones.It's really painful. May his soul rest in peace and no other has to face it.
It still hurts..and knowing that in the casket is his body.. his body that was once filled with so much life. So much love. So many memories.. is now gone. In a box. All those beautiful memories. All those sad memories.. everything is just in a box. I can’t get my mind around that. And I won’t try because I’m already crying. Rip Jonghyun. We haven’t forgotten about you. We never will..
I cried as much reading your comment as I did watching the video. It's hard enough losing the physical person, but I think the final ending of all those things you mention when someone dies is the hardest part to cope with. All those unique memories, experiences, knowledge, gone forever from the world.
Can't believe it's been three years already. He still comes to my mind suddenly every once in a while and I always take a moment to cherish his memory in the hopes that he knows he'll never be forgotten.
The last time they were together as 5.... Man.. imagine being new to a place.. make 4 new Friends.. with whom u have spent everyday for ten years together.. worked together.. lived together..and..one day... One of those 5 people is not there..and still..you just have to go on without him\her...
2022...I got to know about him in 2019...Saw this video a few times since then but still I can't help but cry...Am sure am not the only one...Every single person cried for him...We can't forget him we never can
I still remember when Shinee first shine out with their "Replay". Can't believe it's 2021 already and one their member is no more. A heartfelt condolences from my side 😭
They are the strongest group out there. The way they handled themselves and how they got through this tragedy and stayed a group. Most would not have been able to achieve that. It’s a testimony to their bond. When you see SHINee together you know that bond is stronger than ever and the love is real.
That whole comeback was about jonghyun. The symbolism behind it is incredible. That album takes a special place in my heart. Shinee is one of the strongest groups i have ever seen. They have been through hell but they never gave up. Most groups would have broken after something like this....but they kept going on also for jonghyun, to carry on his legacy. I respect them so much. I can't even imagine how terrible it was for them. They share a beautiful bond.
Dear Jonghyun. Today is my birthday, I just turned 18 and the first voice I listened to was yours. I just felt like writing to you on this day that's very special to me. I've never got the chance to discover SHINee at an early age, and up until last year had never heard of you. But I was introduced to Taemin, then to SHINee and then got to know more about you. And somehow, even if I didn't know you, it hurt my feelings a lot to know I'll never be able to. I still feel so bad for your loss today. But you're not just that - all the content I found about you just proved that you're way more than your depression or your passing. You seem to be a very soft, caring person, your songs and astonishing lyrics are so comforting to me. You had a great voice, charisma, stage presence, multiple other skills including being a talented lyricist, author and reader and a handsome, cute, smart, kind, flirty and sexy, brave, and obviously inspiring human being. For real, I don't know if I could've kept on with my studies (which are really tough and stressful) if you weren't there. And I'm pretty sure you did the same for many people. So you may have thought this wasn't your personality, and that we wouldn't want to know the real you, and I'm not bold enough to say I know what you were like. But, you know, I'm convinced your behavior wasn't just all an act. You may not have shown us all sides of yourself, but I'm sure the qualities from what we got to see were real, and that I would've supported you anyways. Well, that's just my belief. By the way, you didn't believe in God so I'm not gonna assume you're in heaven or whatsoever, but somehow it feels like you're still there. You've brought so many good things to my life that it's like, even if there is no God, your soul is somewhere watching over me, over Shawols, over SHINee, and it's so reassuring to think this. It may be some kind of denial, but I truly believe you're not completely gone. In the end, I respect your choice - I used to be a bit angry and I'm truly sorry for that. I still don't understand everything but there's no need to, if you think you've fought enough then I guess all we can do is to overcome the sadness and be grateful you were born, and honor the memories and legacy you left behind. So congratulations Jonghyun, you've worked and fought so hard and you've done more than well. You'll always be remembered and have a special place in our hearts. Thank you so much, for everything. You are and will always be an awesome person and a true poet, a true artist. I love you, may you rest in peace. 💎 김종현, 수고했어. 사랑해. ❤️
As like you i also belive this ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️ spirit or innocent Soul still alive. Still his Soul can see and can understand everything. Your saying is so good. Thank you for your this kind love for dear ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️.
Like you I met Taemin first then Shinee, only got to know jonghyun 6 years after his passing. The more content of him I see, evrytime I see this clip its painful.....I really wish he had held on a little longer and didn't give up....😢 I hope the rest of the guys and other K-pop idols are taking care of their mental health coz it looks like they are very good at faking to be ok when they not.....I really wish they knew that real fans don't have an Idol imagine for them, we accept them just as they are flaws and all. No one is perfect.....
Onew... poor Onew. The stupid knetz making it more unbearable for him. They are crazy, bashing him and boycotting him then now feeling sorry?? Uhmmm just to let you know, IT'S BECAUSE OF YOU KNETZ that these idols are geting depressed, shaping their lives to your likings. How about people trying to meddle yours, would you like that? smh. My heart hurts so much watching Onew and the other members.
Miro B yes. both jonghyun and onew were cyber bullied for the past few years. both has a history of depression. just a week before this tragedy SM partnered with a law firm to protect all their idols from gossip sites and anti fans. but it was too late.... one is gone.. I hope atleast now they will leave idols alone..
Really? Both were cyber bullied? Crazy fans/netizens, they have nothing else to do with their lives. Thing is, fans tend to think of their idols as perfect individual were in fact, they are humans too. I hope they would let them make mistake and be imperfect. That's where the idols think that they are lacking becoz of how people view them as someone who shouldn't make any mistake. Poor idols.
yeahhhhh trueeeeeeee...always they are poking idols lives,,,,,either idols are human being they need their freedom as well...what shitty rumors ...makes their lives as a hell grrrrr :/
shawol4ever so true bullying hurts I was bully in school it hurts . so I teach my daughter not to pick on people and to protect herself from bullying, and to tell someone in charge and most importantly come tell me first because I have 0 tolerance for bullying,I tell her she can talk to me about anything even though I might not like everything but I rather she talk to me first 😭😩😩
2022 and Im still crying...Jonhyun was my favourite, I loved him as if he was my child...my heart broke into pieces when I found out...I was depressed for a very long time..but...I'm okay now I still miss him tho...he's the most beautiful flower I saw in my whole entire life. ❤❤❤
3 years and I still can't fathom that he's gone. You are my bias Jonghyun, my guardian angel now, I love you and miss you. Whenever I feel like giving up it's like your voice is their telling me to keep going I love you beautiful angel.
Every once and a while I still cry for you. I'm sorry this earth did not give you the happiness you needed. I'm sorry that you suffered. You truly deserved better. But even still, even though it's been years and I'll still cry to this day, I'm so grateful that you touched my life. Thank you. Thank you so much. You did so well. More than I can say, more than anyone can say, you did so well. As always, I hope you're resting peacefully. Thank you, Kim Jonghyun.
It’s 2024 and Onew has getting back to work after a long hiatus. I feel relieved seeing him doing fine now, as we can tell clearly how much this event (and other things) hurt him. I just hope they are physically and mentally healthy. You are doing very well guys 🖤🖤🖤
![[C.C] Key and Taeyeon think of the beautiful memory with Jonghyun #SHINEE #KEY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vad27IQEVYo/mqdefault.jpg)
Its 2022...and this still brings tears to my eyes... This is real pain and real love
True,so sad.
True
Same :(
Im here too
True😭
imagine carrying the lifeless body of your friend. This is so heartbreaking..
When you put it that way it feels unbelievable
I was shocked when I saw it. It's just so heartbreaking. Why would they let them do it 😭
Duty of a family member, it shows just how deep Shinee's bond is.
@@travelkitty8659 I feel the same way, it's shocking.
@@016fantasy when you word it like that it sounds more like an honor, as it should be, I suppose.
Who is here to remember him 2020 am crying so bad
Raxmo Ali im so sad i love shinee but🥺
Me😭
God i miss him so much
I kant hold my tears
Me 😭😭😭
When Key is crying and Onew is hugging him you can tell how hard Onew is trying to keep strong and not break down as well. As leader of SHINee and the big brother of the rest of them he had to put aside his own grief in that moment to support them.
😢
So horrible, heartbreaking😢
You can see onew whispering comforting words in key’s ear
Onew was a rock. But he suffered trying to be strong. In the Japan concert when they sang “from now on” with Jonghyun’s vocal playing during his parts, Onew was crying his eyes out at the end. I felt terrible for him.
So true. It must be so hard for onew to do that. But he did as a love to jonghyun n the rest of shinee member
SHINee have their comeback now, and I'm here watching this. For sure, Jonghyun is happy for his brother's. We miss the angel. Damn! I can't stop crying.
SHINee forever 5♥️
This
We all miss Jonghyun... He is proud of them, he is proud of his boys. Rest in peace, Jonghyun😭❤️
:")
Yesss. It really hurts whenever they have a comeback cause we are always reminded of this.
Key can't hold his sadness. Minho trying so hard to not cry . Onew , the leader , use bangs to cover his eyes, I know he tried so hard to hold back tears. And the maknae , Taemin , almost lost his soul.
who is who?(by hair color) i'm not a shawol
00:44 The first one with black hair is Taemin, behind him Key, and behind Key, its Onew with his hairs who cover his eyes.
And 00:50 its Minho with the thing in his hands.
And Onew, with his heart broken into pieces, held Key's hand, offered him a shoulder to cry on, and whispered reassurances into his ear.
Then went on to comfort the older lady, who I presume was Jonghyun's mother, before ushering the other members into the limousine.
Minho tried so hard to hold back his tears, and put his arm around Jonghyun's sister when she was overcome by emotion.
They were family to each other.
They were chief mourners, because they were important to Jonghyun.
He was reported to have a distant relationship with his own father.
Blood may be thicker than water, but that doesn't mean sh*t.
I am glad they were there, and were able to offer some comfort to Jonghyun's family.
@@MC-ko2mx they were like a family to their members family, honestly u can see it. Shiit I can't stop crying
I not a shawol , but damn his father story makes it even more sad. Poor jonghyunie
Hope the angel is happy , his one smile is an instant serotonin boost and the way Key couldn't hold his tears , broke my heart . Bro I only saw their don't call me few weeks ago , and now I m ugly crying. And I read jonghyun's story.
Your favourites or not , nobody deserves to be felt like that .
LETS ALL LAUGH AT HIS DEAD BODY🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍
Imagine being his mother.
You barely get to see your son as he is always busy and the next thing you know you get a phone call thinking its your son but its actually someone telling you that your son has passed away
That would absolutely shatter me
i would paralyze 😭
From what I understand, he was very close to his family. A sweet and sensitive man, he was.
BBANGGG SII HYYUKKK?! hehe
I would die..
I would be crying and screaming jonghyuns name
It's 13 March 2024. This still brings tears to my eyes .
Gone but never forgotten. He's part of many 2nd generation kpop fans teenage years and one of the best 2nd gen kpop lead vocalist
I'm crying as well 😢😢😢
I came again after two year 😢😢😢
😢😢😢❤❤❤❤
To all the people thinking why they are crying and they are not even a fan.its because to be a human,u don't have to be a fan
Truth.
that s right
True 🥺😢
Yes, u r right
True , I ain't a showal but I wanna see jonghyunie come back . This angle's smile made me smile and this made me cry.
Hope he is happy for-ever
Edit-
Now I m a shawol
Shinee Still have 5 members.. 4 members is Human and 1 member is Angel 😔
Its 2024 already...miss you Angel 🤍
True same to meee
In don't call me choreo you can see the spot for a 5th member
he doesn’t like being called an angel
@@mookiiggtg1923 how would you know that-
@@vantebey724 he said it himself
Onew being hurt as much as anyone else, but he managed to comfort his members and assist them. This is what being a strong leader is.
i am here after the news of moonbin passing and i cant believe we lost a beautiful soul again. i am very sad.i hope he will be truely happy now.
When Key cried at Onew's shoulder then hugged him. This is so heartbreaking.
Who is the mother death? I am tamilnadu pls tell me
@@augustaprasanna2185 what do you mean to ask?
@@augustaprasanna2185 hi malayali here.. They are members of a Korean pop music band.. One of their fellow music band shots singer committed suicide.. 😭
i cried sm when i saw taht :((((
This made me cried harder 😭
Today is December 18, 2020. It's been three years today...
Same here😭😭😭😭😭
😭😭😭
Wait, october or december?
Wait.. 225 likes? Wow...
3 years felt like it was just yesterday.. I miss Jonghyun so much..
SHINee is forever ot5
4 humans
1 angel
Forever shawol❤
This makes me cry even more😭😭😭😭😭😭
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Your comment made me cry 😢
Yeah sure just make me cry more 😭
@@TheNerdSpot17 yes me too I really miss him very muth 💔😭😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔
It's 2023...and this still brings tears to my eyes.😭😭
Eu caí do nada aqui em 2024 MT triste
When he died, i never had the guts to watch this video. After almost 4 years, I did. Still crying as hard as back then
Same... This is actually the first time i watched it after years..
I'm bawling cause I avoided this video like the plague.
May i know why leeteuk, donghae and hyukjae is there?
@@JuanGomez-uh1st they're label mates
Yeah, its first time I am watching this clips and I am choked.. filled with emotions and sadness. I know seeing this clips remind me again of junghyun and also sulli, and Bora.. all the others K-pop idols who are suffering and can't show Thier emotions to others. I feel sad. I wish we were there for him during the last day. I wish we have able to comforts him and change his mind. I wish we can turn back the time and understand him better. 😭
Honestly , I didn't even know them ...but when I see their attachment and their sadness literally made me cry..🥺💜
Me too 🥺💜
Yah.. Me too
حتى انا،،،الحمد لله على كل حال💔
Same
Yeah😭😭😭
I feel sad for IU, she lost her three bestfriends. But i know she’s strong and happy now
@@elyssaxx3368 sulli and goo hara
3years later and it still Painful hopes all my babies are ok and happy in some manner of life you are loved....💋💋❤❤🌷*
Im still worried for her tho cuz of the promise they made to each other...
@@ches6824 May I ask what the promise was?
@@ches6824 what promise ?
Es 2023,aun trae lagrimas a mis ojos. Lo extraño tanto ,nos hace mucha falta
i feel so sad for yeri she will miss her bestfriend and everyone calling her dramatic for crying like wth peopld she cried because she just lost a brother-bestfriend!
is yeri the one with his photo? sorry i haven't really looked back at these videos in a while since i started stanning shinee
@@emilia1515 no i think she is the girl at 3:04
@@emilia1515 the one with photo is his family member maybe sister or something i don't really know
@@emilia1515 yeri is the one from 2:40, the girl holding the photo is his sister
This is the worst part about being a leader :( when he needs to be comforted, when he actualy lost his soul, when he actualy shatter into pieces, but he is there being strong for his member.
He also explained that he felt like he wasnt allowed to cry. Bc Onew was in the midst of a scandal when Jonghyun passed. So basically he felt like he had to self reflect on his actions instead of grieving his member. Its sounds awful but knetz were abusive towards him when his scandal broke out
@@layloo5244 i know i shouldnt say this but sometimes i hope knetz should feel or be in his shoes sometimes so they wont judge and pointed their finger so easily. It was just so crazy and unbeliveable they were abusive him to the point he cant even cry for his own member.
@@layloo5244 I feel so sorry for Onew.
Being caught up in a scandal, doesn't mean he isn't allowed to grieve.
They aren't mutually exclusive, regardless of what netizens say, or expect.
@@layloo5244 im sorry but what scandal was onew that time? i feel so sad for them up until now 😿😿
Razel Hollero hey. Yes the scandal was basically he was at some club, he was very drunk, fell down, grabbed a womans leg to stabilise himself. Then he fell down again and grabbed the womans leg again. His friends explained he thought it was a pole. But that woman went on to report him to the police for sexual harassment. Police booked him for sexual harassment in Aug 2017 and S.M. Entertainment had defended Onew at the time, saying, “Onew had visited the club to congratulate a friend who was debuting as a DJ. While dancing in his drunken state, Onew unintentionally came into physical contact with the woman.” Police tried to question Onew at the time of the incident but he was too intoxicated to answer questions. Nor could he later remember even touching her. Due to the scandal, Onew dropped out of the second season of the JTBC TV drama “Hello, My Twenties!” Due to netizens request of course. He was tormented by netizens.
In December, Onew apologized through a handwritten letter to us Shawols. Only a few days later however Jonghyun took his life. Police later cleared him of sexual harassment charges the next year.
I’m not a fan of SHINEE but when I heard about his death I was sad like imagine how bad his family and friends were and still are hurt. I wouldn’t wish this on no one 🥺
Who is crying at minute 2:04? I can't recognize it
@@CECYGAMESS key/kibum
Me too
Me too
His family didn't support him so only he killed himself
I came here again because today was Moonbin of Astro's funeral. To me, Kpop companies need to make immediate changes. Regular days off, not the seven days a week schedule of practices, rehearsals, promotions, fan signs and events, appearances, photoshoots, concerts, and tours. Groups should start getting 30 vacation days off per year. Hire mental health therapists to be on staff from now on. If staff report that an artist is having difficulties, whether physical, emotional, or mental? See that the artist gets help right away, put them first, not the profit line on budget reports.
I'm.confused .... who died there ?
Moon bin?
@@celiagarcia4437 no in this video SHINee's member Jonghyun died
Descanse em paz
I hope Jonghyun is happy wherever he is...i still can't believe it's been years....
I'm still mourning
Str
Me too
My tears is coming non Stop
Its 3
Same I've not healed yet I'm still sad
It is 2019 already and im still crying--
Jonghyun-ah ~
Me too 😭😭
I can't take it😭 I still can't accept the fact that his already dead😭
It's still hard to believe that's he's gone he's no more with us 😭😭😭
Here too
I miss kim jong hyun ❤😢
When he passed I was in so much pain that I had to distance myself from all of Kpop. His death affected me so much I had never cried for an idol so much. He is special to me. Shinee was one of the few bands that introduced me to kpop back in 2011.
My story is exactly similar to yours. Shinee and IU brought me to love Kpop in 2011. I cut off after his passing in December, I couldn't just take the shock and it felt unreal, my gosh it was exactly a week after my birthday and I was so excited trying to catch up on clips of what turned out to be his last concert. It took an entire year for me to ease back into the Kpop community and even since then, I just got the courage for the first time to watch this video. I hope you're holding in fine?
Until now 💔😭
same here...when i heard the news that he passed away, i was heartbroken..it was hard that you cannot see your inspiration anymore..it took me two years to start listening to kpop again though...until now, it still hurts but knowing that he is in a better place, it lessen the pain a little
Are you okay now? I have group that I admire too and I can't even think how will I cope if things like this happened. I hope you are okay now.
This is exactly how I reacted. I couldn't listen to kpop for a long time. Jonghyun is the only idol I have ever cried over. Shinee is my ultimate bias group.
and now Moonbin is gone.🥀💔
It’s his birthday today....it’s been 3 years RIP I miss u sm and I hope ur doing good up there than being here.😭❤️
Edit: im back again but this time it’s his death anniversary,I hope ur doing well up their,just so u know we all miss u😭😭-12/17/20
Edit: I’m back again, I miss him a lot and I still hope he’s doing good up there, we will continue to remember him every year♥️😭-12/17/21
Edit: I’m back…again, this time it’s his birthday. I will continue on coming back every year.This man deserved the world burg the world didn’t. He is really missed but I know he’s doing good up there. -4/7/22♥️
Karin Hanna my favorite Kpop group why does my baby have to pass away please stay we love you it hurts me to see you gone comeback I love you I miss you 💜🥰🥺💋😭😍😘😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺 the members are crying it hurts me to see them cry of there love one I love you
He should have turned 30 years old.
😔😭😞
I MISS HIM TOO😭
I hope his be good there
Let me just say this Onew is such a brave individual I'm speechless he was in great pain as well but he still comforted his members I really respect him for that
Alice Night He comforted his members because he knows they needed him, but I’m also breaking cause after this, he had his psychiatrist. He didn’t cry the whole wake, he just comforted his members that’s why he needed a psychiatrist back then. He’s traumatized... and that’s heartbreaking...
He is such a great leader 💗
Alice Night , I agree with you.
Onew was under a cloud, and caught up in a scandal a few months before Jonghyun passed.
Because of this, he said he felt he couldn't cry, as he was supposed to be "self reflecting".
He did what he does best, and comforted his members.
But it came at a cost, and he wasn't allowed to grieve publicly, or show outward emotion.
My heart broke.
2 years and 4 months...
When I watch his funeral I feel like it's a scene from a Kdrama not a reality.
Why Jonghyun..? Why..?
aouichaoui ghada
I promise it will be ok he is in our heart and will forever be with us💚
maybe it's for the best. he suffered so much... I never know what it feels to experience a lot of pain. I hope he's happy now that he is free.
@@kyuala1907 Sounds like their death is more important then the Death of other people lol
@@Ray-kc6wf uh, they don't know the other people you were talking abt? U want someone to tell you "sounds like this person's death is more important than other people" when someone you love dies?
I didn't not know the guy so at first I thought this was a kdrama but I looked it up and it's sad to see someone died because of depression I hope in his next life he will get the life he had always wanted
its 2024 and im still crying, we miss you jonghyun. always.
I can't imagine they attend sulli's funeral😭. I.JUST.CANT
Clestina Ajueuddbx Sulli’s attendee his funeral and now 😢😢😢😢😢😢
I think the same and that is the reason im here. This is so heartbreaking
Clestina Ajueuddbx same it’s just so sad 😔
Jonghyun death happened when i came home from school
@@tereasdownes9793 I learned about it during school...I literally was in denial until I came home and basically broke down
the way Onew hardly walk and how Key cries on his shoulder is heartbroken.
And how he gently hugs Key
Can you please tell me who is who. Like i guess shinee have 4 members and who are others
@@Nishattfatimaa. 00:34 it's Minho with the thing in his hands
00:44 in the left side is Taemin, Key and Onew
And the other side is Super junior members (Leeteuk, Eunhyuk, and Donghae)
@Nishat The right side ( which looks left, in the front holding the name plaque is Minho, behind him is Taemin,then Key and Onew( SHINee Members) :'(💔
@@击击-b2y Can you tell me who is the blond hair girl at the end please?
It really breaks my heart. I'm not their fan but I can't imagine the pain they are going through. And the hardships jonghyun has experienced must be beyond words. I hope he can finally rest well in peace. It's been years but my heart still aches for his family and friends' loss.💔💔
Yeah you can't imagine how hard it was for me and for the others he was my bias I'm still heartbroken and I can't believe is gone how why why why I miss him so much my heart is in so much pain
I am also not their fan , but i still feel very sad about him , cuz i know that he was a good and pure person....
@@alessiacinca6608 Even though we can't share the pain with you, don't worry fans like you did great loving him with all your heart....the angel is in a better place now, remember him as the person who made you happy, he wouldn't want to see his fans cry....sending warm hugs♡
it’s disgusting how there were cameras flashing the entire time.. I would be so furious if people were flashing cameras at the funeral of a loved one.
R.I.P Jonghyun.
i wish the cameras weren’t there his friends and family are mourning for the lost of him and there are flashing lights everywhere not the time nor place
Unfortunately its because they chose to do a public funeral. Notice that in privately held funerals there are no cameras and journalists are not allowed to enter or be anywhere around.
Sm and family agreed to do it public, but the cameras only allow till the entrance / lobby. I also feel the cameras and flashes is disturbing and not appropriate to be there.
that's Korea, and the life of the kpop.
@@saskya8391 this is so true .
Why tf ppl hate K-pop so much or the fans are so obsessed. It's life of the most of the K-pop idols like jonghyun here. Many make it through , but imagine what they are going through
@clow _ - Family invited the press .
The other service was private as is his burial site .
Thats sad the photographers couldnt even let Jonghyun's mother send her son off on his final ride without the flashing cameras. Very disrespectful to his mother.
Stacie Reynolds that's korean for ya
the family gave consent for a public funeral, the next day they had a private one
Stacie Reynolds
the family allowed it anyway
Nothing disrespectful. The family allowed it because they understand he is a public figure. This is also a way for his global fans to say good bye.
@Flower Twice they had personal funeral and family allowed. Btw you are watching it because of them. The family understand he is a public figure, his fans were already down with sudden news. Please understand it last meeting with him for fans also
I hope SM noticed the condition of the fellow Shinee members, especially Onew. He is walking as if his very will to live has left his body. I see the pain of the others but his body looks as if it could collapse at any moment. These guys need grief counselors to help them manage the next few days. Onew especially shouldn't be alone. I hope Kpop fans stop attacking idols for every little mistake. Some words hurt some more than others. I see a lifeless Onew and that worries me. Please stop attacking people. We were not born perfect and never can be. Give people a chance to learn from their mistakes.
Mi W it's really painful for him, I wish god give them enough strength to embrace this pain
👍👍
👍👍👍now we can pray for their strength
I wish everyone think the way you do
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
a pesar de que ya pasaron 5 años, aún sigo llorando por la pérdida de Jonghyun, cómo fan de ellos desde sus inicios es muy doloroso todavía el asimilar este trágico suceso de mi querido Jonghyun. :(
5 años ? No fue ahora en abril 2023?
@@celiagarcia4437 no, Jonghyun falleció el 18 de diciembre del 2017.
@@titiwhat5214 ok thanks I didn't know the date
Creo que no lo asimilare jamas
@@celiagarcia4437 en abril 2023 murió Moonbim de astro, tremenda perdida 😭 yo lo conocí hasta ahora que ya no está y me duele aún sin conocerlo era excelente artista.
CRYING AND CRYING AGAIN EVERYTIME I WATCHED IT NOW IS AUGUST 2019 STILL CRYING, WE NEVER FORGET YOU HUHUHU
Handsome
X2 😭🙏 REST IN THE PEACE 1990 2017
Same 😭😭
😭😭😭😭
I've been a fan of SHINee since 2008, they got me into kpop. If you don't know them, that's okay. They were really huge and were able to get a spotlight amongst bands like BIGBANG, Super Junior, and even TVXQ!
SHINee's songs got me through many difficult times, and I am forever grateful. But even so, fans weren't able to do anything to stop Jonghyun committing suicide. In the end, we were completely powerless, no matter how much we could have wanted to help.
This is not the only tragedy. I'm thinking about Sulli and GoHara amongst others. The Kpop industry is terrible. The attacks idols receive everyday, especially online, are terrible.
The more spotlight they get, the more hate they receive. Mental health issues are kind of a taboo in S. Korea and that's a shame.
What I really want to say, is that it can happen to anyone. I'm sure some ARMY will read this. I am and ARMY too. This could happen to anyone. No matter your fandom, how big, how small.
Don't hate on artist. Even if their fans insult your bias. Don't attack artists. Their life, especially in the debuts, is already hell. They make too many sacrifices as it is, don't make them sacrifice their own life. Music, entertainment, its not worth their life.
If I could give back everything I received from Jonghyun and SHINee for a chance of him being alive, I would.
If it kills them, it's not worth it.
@@srinidhi.n9556 I am sure ARMY will read this because there are a lot of ARMY. Not necessarily to them, but BTS are getting a lot of attention, and I wanted to talk about how the more spotlight idols get, the harder it gets.
True😭
Non SHAWOL please dont hate coment too our boys please🙏😭
I find myself thinking about Eunwoo (Astro) and how the army’s said that his third place in the "male idol brand reputation ranking" doesn’t belong to him because the first 7 should be for BTS. It's not fair, I love Astro, they were the ones who introduced me to k-pop, and it was because of them that I met BTS (I'm also an army) and I'm happy with the success Eunwoo is having with his kdrama. But it must be really horrible because he has to deal with the acting and with the group, he must feel a lot of pressure and guilt for representing them on charts and still he has to read those kinds of comments. DO NOT DO THAT! he's getting so much on his back, why do they have to be so mean? Eunwoo can be there and face bts on charts (and hopefully one day with Astro too) and that doesn't take away the legend that is already bts, nor love, success and nothing. They are also friends! I do not understand the rivalries and the hate that is created towards other groups, idols do not deserve it, it is not fair.
@@Inopia7 Ahh I didn't know that, sorry tho on behave of ARMY. Hope all the " only BTS should be first" kinda toxic fans realise and stop creating fan wars tbh
Thank you so very much for explaining what happened. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
It's 2021 already and this still breaks my heart!💔
I still think about Jonghyun everyday. He was my first kpop bias when I was 13 in 2012. I loved him so much. I grew out of kpop but I always made sure to follow SHINee when they brought out new songs. It still hits me hard and I'm 23 now
that's beautiful!
SHINee is *forever* ot5
5 angels
4 on land
1 on heaven
isint this copied??
Marrabelle Skits SO WHATTTTT??!!
He didn’t say I made this phrase.We are here sad for Jonghyun .Its not time to say these things
Nensi Arapi yes x
The thing is jonghyun is actually watching over them because in a photo with the remaining four there is the four plus another shadow
Its July 2021 and I still cry . He never left us he just went to a safer and peaceful place .
Kada alae 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
@@kadaalae7897 😭😭
Now 2023 ;)
He will always be in our heart no matter how many years have passed since his death 🤍🌼
Always.... True 🙏
@@ivaaggarwal122 stfu...stop promoting your channel here
The Super Junior members are trying so hard to not break down, you can tell they’re holding back their tears. They know that they need to be strong to support their juniors
We have been at this dark place too with Leeteuk’s family
@@sfb3665 yeah😭and it's still painful until now.
They didn't have to bring in the reporters. I wish they had let them grieve in private. This is so heart breaking. As someone who has lost a loved one too, the grief never really goes away, but I hope they can learn to deal with it.
i think the family of jonghyun gave consent to have them there because it was a public funeral, so fans and others came. and then they had a private funeral the next day without reporters. it's still sad that they cant have a break from the paparazzi :(
I came back on his birthday like I do every year, I hope he realizes he isn’t alone anymore...
KOI케올 he knows🙏🏻💘
Where is he buried ?
yeri must be really close to jonghyun. its so heartbreaking to see her like that
Jonghyun has been away from his sister for so long and having Yeri there who didn't even had the chance to enjoy her childhood freely. he really treated her as a real sister and same towards Yeri. I'm sorry i know I'm late
When i first saw this video it was just 1 day ago and at that time i didnt know about rv so naturally i didnt know who yeri was. Seeing her like this at that time i thought she was his sister or girlfriend to be crying so hard. Then when i started to stan rv i got to know the deep sis and bro bond they shared. And seeing this video again now i feel so sad for yeri😞😞🙁🙁😖😖😖
The fact this was 6 years ago I was a kpop fan after I heard his I cried my eyes out it's so hard seeing someone dead if you know them or not rest in peace moonbin jonghyun sulli goohara you will be never forgotten ❤
this is why i hate kpop. companies don't paying attention for health and mental health of their artists. idols just smiling, while dying inside. companies need to take care about their artists.
idols don't deserve hating, internet bullying etc.
let's love and be always cheerful for our idols. show them your love, because they are need it.
and jonghyun/sulli/goo hara now in the best place...❤
why do you think its their fault we are the ones that didnt give him enough love and attention when he was still with us stop blaiming the companies
@@iliketiddies462 i know, it's fans fault too, but companies really need to help them with...for example hating comments, right? it's make me sad, some entertainments ignoring haters and their bad comments🥺 I'm sorry for my english👉🏻👈🏻
The thing is they cant just sue every hate comment if theres too much its not the fault of the companies theres not that many thing they can do ive heard heechul talk about that the company do have people who talk with idols when its a bit too much in sm but you know no matter how much support they get it only take 1 more comment to make them break
We should blame the antis not anybody else
Kpop is a genre of music*** hate the companies.
Ikr
He died on my Birthday..he was my biggest inspiration. Because of him i started singing. Thank You jonghyun..you’re my childhood Hero.
Someday I’ll be able to accept that he’s gone. Today is not that day.
Same
Who died ?? I am new I don't know
@@sarafnawar2134 this is an old video. Jonghyun was one of the members of shinee. Shinee are a second gen group but they are still active and famous. Jonghyun died in 2017 by suicide, he suffered of depression. His death really impacted a lot kpop world. He was really loved by everyone, a gentle and caring soul. And he was such an incredible artist. He wrote lots of shinee songs and had the voice of an angel. You should check shinee discography, it's considered one of the best in kpop. And also jonghyun solo albums.
2023 and this still hits so hard seeing them carry him in anguish it's so painful to see them hurting 💔😢 my heart breaks everytime and don't get me started on his poor families pain that's another level of hurt
October 1, 2019.😭💔
We miss you Jonghyunie💔
Still hurts a lot💔💔💔💔💔
I feel like crying
It's so sad
forever missed
me too ..
The way key leaned on onew's back and how he embraced him made me cry💔🤧 we really do miss him... 🤧
That very part got me crying as well.
Misty Waters Same, and I don’t even know who they are. But this was just sad and I didn’t think it would get me this emotional.
@@Sakiko23 me too.
onew is the best leader he ws there to console his members when he was hurt himself the best leader in kpop
No one mentioned it but the fact Super Junior Leeteuk, Eunhyuk and Donghae are also next to SHINee members tells so much about everything. SHINee members are like little brothers to Suju and they lost a little brother who saw growing up.
Hope Jonghyun is in a good place now
Watching yeri coming there with her heart broken mades me feel so sad
İs Yeri blonde girl? İn 2:38
Dzczjeib
@@kimnana579 yep
@@youdonknowshiig Is she his sister?
@@Princess-xq8ks nope
Even Yeri looks broken
We miss you Jonghyun
I wish we supported you more,
We never knew that this would happen
We’re so sorry
We hope you’re happy
What hurts more is that it’s all in the past and we can’t change it
*We love you*
*_Rest in peace_*
It's so hard to see the SM artists hold a casket with his body inside. Imagine being them... R.I.P. Jonghyun ❤
I... don't know how I ended up here again so many years later. I held his Sydney memorial, cried for days, couldn't sleep and watched this over and over. Now I can think of him with joy, think of all the smiles and songs he gifted us without pain, but there will always be a hole. My shinee is 5, they always will be.
same, i was just singing happily some songs then searched for shinee ones, and somehow ended up here, crying like it was that year. i couldn't attend the memorial in my country but i too cried for days, weeks even, i didn't imagine that his loss would affect me that much. and i too can now think about him with a smile, remembering his voice, the funny videos and all that, and lastly, yes, there will always be a void
When this happened years ago, I was really devastated. I wasn't even a fan of SHINee before but it broke my heart too much. Now that I started stanning them, it hurts more. Seeing how the members finally opening up and talking about him, which they couldn't do before bcs it could create issues. The continuous mourn for him even after years of him since he has gone to heaven is really huge. I'm always hoping that you're doing well there Jonghyun, you're the purest angel that we have. I love you always.
I started stanning after his death. I didn't even know he was not alive anymore at first....when i realized it broke my heart to pieces.
I'm still crying and I don't know how to stop.
I still feel hurt seeing Yeri and the members cry :(
Same, i lost it when Yeri show up.
Whats up with yeri? Im sorry i dont really know much bout them. whats the connection?
@@bloobadooba4600 oh, rip
@@cactusamber1703 Jonghyun treats Yeri as his little sister. And Yeri does the same. Yeri and Irene were really close with him...
Some netizens were critical of Yeri, saying she should have controlled herself better.
She is even having the way she grieves a close friend's passing dictated to her.
People are vile.
Aun dueles mucho Jonghyun aunque andes de gira por las estrellas en la tierra se te extraña.
I discovered SHINEee in 2018. But I can't imagine how Onew felt. That must have been so hard being the leader, grieving and supporting the other members. I hope people didn't pile hate on top of him to.
I just discovered them 2020 but could real how they loved each other.
I know how u feel
JONGHYUN WE LOVE U 💔💔💔
As I saw them looking to the ground the amount of lights flashing, I immediately started to cry and then I saw his mother clearly in pain.
I cannot believe people turned up to a funeral uninvited to take pictures of this just to plaster it all over social media.
RIP my love, I miss you
Actually his family allowed it but had a seperate private funeral for close friends and family only
I cry everytime I watch this, i wish jonghyun was here, i wish he didn't suffer from depression, i wish he was not in pain. Ah so many wishes!
It's 2022 and still we can feel the pain
We don't know how our idols are suffering.
But Jong-Hyun you are in our hearts forever and forever
June 22, 2019
What am i doing here? Its been already a year, and it's still hurt. I miss him💔
@Lynnie Vivi (slight trigger warning)
"Depressed people don't want to die. They want to feel alive but deperately can't".
Did you ever hear that quote? I think there's a lot of truth in it. Depression doesn't work like that, it's terrible and suicide is never something "happy", neither for the person commiting it nor for those who knew them. Suicide is not also not "choice", it's more like the only way out in the minds of people who are severly depressed (although there are always other ways!). But hopefully he's in a better place now. However I appreciate your effort to comfort others ❤️
NCAA
now our shinee and yeri, and all sm family is happy! we should live and be happy.
@@ivaaggarwal122 gosh how disrespectful of you. This is a video to honor jonghyun but you're just spamming about a bts video?
I really hate people sometimes
@@sophli3663 I’m really sorry it was done by mistake
@@ivaaggarwal122 disrespectful!!
jonghyun and yeri's relationship is like they are siblings and as a reveluv and shawol seing yeri cries make me so sad:(
i recently just knew about him and i already feel so attached to him,but here i am crying really hard,i have never cried this hard in my whole life. you did so well jonghyun we are so proud of you! i hope you are happy now wherever you are ❤️
Wat happend to him how did he die?
@@charithanaidu9343 suicide
Idk Why I'm crying I don't even know him😭😭😭😭..so hard It would've for his be loved ones.It's really painful. May his soul rest in peace and no other has to face it.
Same😥 2021 now Everytime I watch this I'm crying
It still hurts..and knowing that in the casket is his body.. his body that was once filled with so much life. So much love. So many memories.. is now gone. In a box. All those beautiful memories. All those sad memories.. everything is just in a box. I can’t get my mind around that. And I won’t try because I’m already crying.
Rip Jonghyun. We haven’t forgotten about you. We never will..
I cried as much reading your comment as I did watching the video. It's hard enough losing the physical person, but I think the final ending of all those things you mention when someone dies is the hardest part to cope with. All those unique memories, experiences, knowledge, gone forever from the world.
1年経った今見ても泣けます…
本当にメンバーの悲しみが伝わってくる
Here again today after moonbins news...I can't stop crying...
Jonghyun literally saved my life with his music
Same here during Pandemic beginning his music calmed me
Can't believe it's been three years already. He still comes to my mind suddenly every once in a while and I always take a moment to cherish his memory in the hopes that he knows he'll never be forgotten.
When Key put his head on Onew's shoulder..it still makes me cry. Wow Sept 2019 and its still so hard to watch.
Here in November 2022 and still crying over losing one of the best voices in k-pop history.
It 2020 and Im still crying watching this
Shinee was one of my first boy groups.....they were so precious
The last time they were together as 5....
Man.. imagine being new to a place.. make 4 new Friends.. with whom u have spent everyday for ten years together.. worked together.. lived together..and..one day... One of those 5 people is not there..and still..you just have to go on without him\her...
2020 and i'm still cry when i'm watching this.
Deaneliciana Me too 😭💔
Same here 💔
2022...I got to know about him in 2019...Saw this video a few times since then but still I can't help but cry...Am sure am not the only one...Every single person cried for him...We can't forget him we never can
I still remember when Shinee first shine out with their "Replay". Can't believe it's 2021 already and one their member is no more. A heartfelt condolences from my side 😭
still shocked that they ended up having a comeback months later. The strength that must have took.
They are the strongest group out there. The way they handled themselves and how they got through this tragedy and stayed a group. Most would not have been able to achieve that. It’s a testimony to their bond. When you see SHINee together you know that bond is stronger than ever and the love is real.
That whole comeback was about jonghyun. The symbolism behind it is incredible. That album takes a special place in my heart. Shinee is one of the strongest groups i have ever seen. They have been through hell but they never gave up. Most groups would have broken after something like this....but they kept going on also for jonghyun, to carry on his legacy. I respect them so much. I can't even imagine how terrible it was for them. They share a beautiful bond.
May 30, 2019 and still coming back here. I miss you so much Jonghyun😭💔
June 06, and me too 😭💔💔💔
Yielsha Alburo is jhong hyun in we got married rigth
Dear Jonghyun. Today is my birthday, I just turned 18 and the first voice I listened to was yours. I just felt like writing to you on this day that's very special to me.
I've never got the chance to discover SHINee at an early age, and up until last year had never heard of you. But I was introduced to Taemin, then to SHINee and then got to know more about you. And somehow, even if I didn't know you, it hurt my feelings a lot to know I'll never be able to. I still feel so bad for your loss today.
But you're not just that - all the content I found about you just proved that you're way more than your depression or your passing. You seem to be a very soft, caring person, your songs and astonishing lyrics are so comforting to me. You had a great voice, charisma, stage presence, multiple other skills including being a talented lyricist, author and reader and a handsome, cute, smart, kind, flirty and sexy, brave, and obviously inspiring human being. For real, I don't know if I could've kept on with my studies (which are really tough and stressful) if you weren't there. And I'm pretty sure you did the same for many people.
So you may have thought this wasn't your personality, and that we wouldn't want to know the real you, and I'm not bold enough to say I know what you were like. But, you know, I'm convinced your behavior wasn't just all an act. You may not have shown us all sides of yourself, but I'm sure the qualities from what we got to see were real, and that I would've supported you anyways. Well, that's just my belief.
By the way, you didn't believe in God so I'm not gonna assume you're in heaven or whatsoever, but somehow it feels like you're still there. You've brought so many good things to my life that it's like, even if there is no God, your soul is somewhere watching over me, over Shawols, over SHINee, and it's so reassuring to think this. It may be some kind of denial, but I truly believe you're not completely gone.
In the end, I respect your choice - I used to be a bit angry and I'm truly sorry for that. I still don't understand everything but there's no need to, if you think you've fought enough then I guess all we can do is to overcome the sadness and be grateful you were born, and honor the memories and legacy you left behind.
So congratulations Jonghyun, you've worked and fought so hard and you've done more than well. You'll always be remembered and have a special place in our hearts. Thank you so much, for everything. You are and will always be an awesome person and a true poet, a true artist. I love you, may you rest in peace. 💎
김종현, 수고했어. 사랑해. ❤️
Beautiful words. You expressed yourself so well.
BTW, Happy Birthday.
@@annatoscano9775 thanks
As like you i also belive this ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️ spirit or innocent Soul still alive. Still his Soul can see and can understand everything. Your saying is so good. Thank you for your this kind love for dear ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️.
Like you I met Taemin first then Shinee, only got to know jonghyun 6 years after his passing. The more content of him I see, evrytime I see this clip its painful.....I really wish he had held on a little longer and didn't give up....😢 I hope the rest of the guys and other K-pop idols are taking care of their mental health coz it looks like they are very good at faking to be ok when they not.....I really wish they knew that real fans don't have an Idol imagine for them, we accept them just as they are flaws and all. No one is perfect.....
Onew... poor Onew. The stupid knetz making it more unbearable for him. They are crazy, bashing him and boycotting him then now feeling sorry?? Uhmmm just to let you know, IT'S BECAUSE OF YOU KNETZ that these idols are geting depressed, shaping their lives to your likings. How about people trying to meddle yours, would you like that? smh. My heart hurts so much watching Onew and the other members.
Miro B yes. both jonghyun and onew were cyber bullied for the past few years. both has a history of depression. just a week before this tragedy SM partnered with a law firm to protect all their idols from gossip sites and anti fans. but it was too late.... one is gone.. I hope atleast now they will leave idols alone..
Really? Both were cyber bullied? Crazy fans/netizens, they have nothing else to do with their lives. Thing is, fans tend to think of their idols as perfect individual were in fact, they are humans too. I hope they would let them make mistake and be imperfect. That's where the idols think that they are lacking becoz of how people view them as someone who shouldn't make any mistake. Poor idols.
Miro B
yeahhhhh trueeeeeeee...always they are poking idols lives,,,,,either idols are human being they need their freedom as well...what shitty rumors ...makes their lives as a hell grrrrr :/
shawol4ever so true bullying hurts I was bully in school it hurts . so I teach my daughter not to pick on people and to protect herself from bullying, and to tell someone in charge and most importantly come tell me first because I have 0 tolerance for bullying,I tell her she can talk to me about anything even though I might not like everything but I rather she talk to me first 😭😩😩
It’s been three years and I still miss him so badly
Onew comforting key while being in so much pain gets me everytime...what an outstanding human being.
2022 and Im still crying...Jonhyun was my favourite, I loved him as if he was my child...my heart broke into pieces when I found out...I was depressed for a very long time..but...I'm okay now I still miss him tho...he's the most beautiful flower I saw in my whole entire life.
❤❤❤
3 years and I still can't fathom that he's gone. You are my bias Jonghyun, my guardian angel now, I love you and miss you. Whenever I feel like giving up it's like your voice is their telling me to keep going I love you beautiful angel.
And now, we lost sulli to because of the same thing. We people really need to change :'
Every once and a while I still cry for you. I'm sorry this earth did not give you the happiness you needed. I'm sorry that you suffered. You truly deserved better. But even still, even though it's been years and I'll still cry to this day, I'm so grateful that you touched my life. Thank you. Thank you so much. You did so well. More than I can say, more than anyone can say, you did so well. As always, I hope you're resting peacefully. Thank you, Kim Jonghyun.
It’s 2024 and Onew has getting back to work after a long hiatus. I feel relieved seeing him doing fine now, as we can tell clearly how much this event (and other things) hurt him. I just hope they are physically and mentally healthy. You are doing very well guys 🖤🖤🖤
yes i hope they are all okay, they have been so strong this whole time and i'm so proud of everything they've done 💎🖤