Who Exactly is a “Caucasian?”
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 มิ.ย. 2019
- Who exactly is a Caucasian? And what does this label even mean anyways? Although the term "Caucasoid" or "Caucasian" is largely considered to be outdated and inaccurate, today we'll be discussing whether the people historically described as such actually have any sort of genealogical or socio-political/cultural similarities in their origins whatsoever.
This video is NOT intended to be controversial or spark arguments over the usage of the word “race,” only to show a common genetic contribution to various populations spread out over a large chunk of the Earth's surface and the historical reasoning and analysis behind the term “Caucasoid.” It's just a stupid term that someone made up over a hundred years ago, so relax. Thanks for watching!
Masamap: / masamap_4_groups_histo...
Sources:
(Split between Eastern and Western Eurasians and genetic distinctions between modern populations) phys.org/news/2018-01-ancient...
(Mitochondrial differences between Eastern, Western and Southern Eurasians) www.researchgate.net/figure/T...
(Eastern Eurasian impact on Western and Southern Eurasian populations) eurasiandna.com/detailed-look...
(Western Eurasian impact on the Indian Subcontinent before Indo-Aryan migration measured in mtDNA haplogroups) www.cell.com/current-biology/...
(Western Eurasian vs Sub-Saharan African ancestry among Horn Africans) anthromadness.blogspot.com/201...
![[UNCUT] ฝันรักห้วงนิทรา | EP.8 (4/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RDYJYiDwsj0/mqdefault.jpg)
4:57 CLARIFICATION: I meant to say that most Middle Easterners are genetically closer to Sub-Saharan Africans than Europeans are, but messed up with the phrasing on that one.
Let me know which of the colloquial “races” you'd like me to break down next. Thanks for watching
Masaman perhaps do a re-upload with a correction
American Indian. Too many people don't understand that we are as diverse as any other race and are as distinct a group as Asians or Europeans.
Also great video masa, very informative.
Middle Easterners are closer to Sub-Saharan Africans right? Yet that treat most Africans like shit in their countries 🤔🤔🤔
@Imperial Thought It's skin colour even the darker skinned Arabs are treated like shit.
As a spaniard, that US census map makes me cringe every time.
*OTHER HISPANIC ANCESTRY*
It was designed to always seem as if there is a "white majority" to further black- white divide.
-MEXICAN
-PUERTO RICAN
-SPANISH
-SOME OTHER HISPANIC IDENTITY IDK FUCK OFF
-BRAZIL
honestly whoever made the census should be fired.
+belstar I wonder who is "us", are you Odin or something?
@@belstar1128 It depends on which Spanish speaking people you are referring to.
Caucasian is not a skin colour...it's a shape of skull...
@ZEL DRIS that's bullshit they used Europeans as a base so we are not part African part Eurasian Africa is not an ethnicity nor is Eurasia we are different we are not related to west or South Africans or majority of Europeans we are afroasiatic we share haplogroup with berbers Egyptians oromos beja afar and Arabian population mainly Yemen and hejaz furthermorr we used to be related to some extinct ethnicities
In reality its the native people of caucasus
@@tsduali7516 That's rich. What group do you identify with then?
@@Myreactionwhen_80085 lol - i used word ' word ' 2 times in one sentence with obvious reference - and connective context - but ok ... i'm Caucasian - actual Caucasian - my ancestors lived here for very very long time - my name . which is also a clan name , and name of tribe that no longer exists , comes from over 2800 years ago - and before that it was part of even older tribe that came from middle east ... and probably before that from north Africa ... i don't know exactly , but considering my DNA - that is partially European as well as Asian , i would say ... hmm - Eurasian ... i'm Eurasian ... is this fine for you ... or i need something more to IDENTIFY myself
@@tsduali7516 So can you explain your process in coming to the conclusion that Europeans are "dumb". Are you unaware that many other people groups throughout history have adopted inaccurate racial terms?
Exactly so many people are ignorant and presume Caucasian means "white skinned" European.
adjective
1.
NORTH AMERICAN
white-skinned; of European origin.
it's the same..
source: google
@@kylawhyte6557 I believe its US context, who loves stereotypes.
The genetics of whites go back to the steppe people of that area so thats why Caucasian means white. Linguistics too of aryan langages.
@@kylawhyte6557 well dumbass don't you think maybe its because that's an american interpretation (which no one outside of america cares about btw)
@@insertname_1708 Caucasian was used before America even existed. Americans have like 350 year history, but people living in the Afro-Eurasia have +8Million year history. Caucasian is used now because Other than Africa (the land of black skinned peope), First Man And Woman were found in Georgia(Sakartvelo) So they called it (White Skinned peope), so first Caucasians (eurasians) are Georgians, but others living in the Caucasus they immigrated here from Asia, india, africa, that's why European languages are Indo-European even Latin. So all Caucasians aren't whites, cuz of immigrants from other countries. But only Georgians are.
Spaniard : White Caucasian european
USA : wait, I though spain was in the south of mexico
XD
US education system lol😂
Ignorance still exist in 2020... Its knowledgeable the same as arrogance as ignorance is to humility?🕵
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
You ain’t lien😂
Glad to see you supporting the idea of race and ethnicity being far more complex than most people think.
Both are tools for the rich to divide poor people.
you wish
You wish
I think I prefer calling them “variations” rather than separate races/species.
@@CoreyStudios2000 Race and Variation are the same thing. Race is the variation of a species.
I'm caucasian. Because I live in Caucasus !
finally someone who understands!!!!! i am caucasian because i am from caucasus, and born in caucasus.
😂😂😂..i am Indian bcoz i live in India
Wich country?
Maybe you are a refugee😂
Easy!
I hope that people one day will stop using the word “Caucasian” to describe race
no probably not, its not really that important, so the terminology will probably be eternal or go extinct but only because one day everyone is most likely going to be mixed
Look up Ghullam
There are two races:
Those wo have money and those who don't.
White is not the same as rich
Black is not the same as poor
Truth
Tim you must add to your comment. Those who have an education and those who don't. 9-5-2021
Fact
@@timothyball7502 Gotta disagree with you there Tim.
There are plenty of rich people out there with no education and even more very well educated ones who are poor.
Some humor: th-cam.com/video/gMu2xFxpGmQ/w-d-xo.html
Caucasian. Just another misused, misunderstood, confusing and outdated term used to classify human beings.
The word carries with it so many problems. For starters, it was analogous to "Negro" for a long time, which should give some idea of how long the word has been in use. And it is so often used to describe Europeans only, when in fact the Caucasus Mountains are barely in Europe! Whenever I hear someone mention that Middle Easterners are not Caucasian, I ask, "Well, then - what are they?" People will usually say "brown," even though that is the most imprecise of all the "color" terms for race and can refer to any of various races. Occasionally someone will say "Semites," but then the Jews are Semites and most of them are considered white. Frankly, I think "brown" (at least when used in a Middle Eastern context) is pretty much a code word for "Muslim," because I've noticed that Christian Arabs are usually able to pass for "white"; in fact, many Christian Arabs have "melted" into white America entirely, while most Muslim Arabs apparently have not.
HazelKraft
Aryans are only used for Indians and Iranians.
@Sharon Cato did you not hear this man talk about phenotype?
@John Bold How is it not? We can talk about breeds from different areas, (like different horses and dogs) but we are all still humans!
@Sharon Cato No it is not a artificial construct. There are 4 main racial groups. Australoid Caucasoid mongoloid and negroid. There are distinct physical differences between each race. For example just by looking at a scull. A trained anthropologist can tell you what race that person was. Each racial group also has been found to have a certain admixture of archaic human relative DNA. Caucasoid = Neanderthal, Mongoloid= mostly neanderthal with some Denosovan, Australoid= mostly Denosovan with some Neanderthal, Negroid= heidelbergensis and Paleo Africanis. Each of the admixes of arcane DNA results in the regional physical and internal differences among the races. All modern humans are hybrid sub species of Homo sapiens. That does not mean that one race is any better than the others. The facts point out that race is in fact real. Each race is suited best for the part of the world they are fund in because of there individual genetic admixture.
Your analysis are quick, succinct and challenging the old assumptions about race.
It's fascinating material you offer to your audience. Thank you very much for contributing. A heartfelt thanks!
According to the US supreme court Spanish, not white. North African, white.
confusedjackychan.jpg
Have you ever heard of the Berbers. They were the original inhabitants of north Africa. They have been there for over 12k years.
@@factsbeforefeellings6115 I am not saying they are dark like proper Africans, but North Africans are undoubtedly darker and had more African influence than Spaniards. And as others have pointed out Sudan is on that "caucasion nations" US list, enough said.
@@darthmortus5702 dark? What a vague term
The U.S. is retarted
@@darthmortus5702 Original North Africans from Morroco to Libya are Amazigh-Berbers. Spaniards & Arabs just invaded the land.
We Americans live on a different plane of existence compared to world. It truly is a mindset.
Oh say can you see, by the dawns early light...
And what is that being WHITE which theres no such theng just like black its only colors and iam not to kin on taking history listen from ANY Caucasian European person cause i know they tend to change history to benefit there needs this been going on every sense the invasion of Africa
@@jeneromilton True Americans Love Freedom and Democracy. Socialists Need to Leave!
@@john_smithchiropractor3931 true americans are you talking about native Americans to whom this country belongs too and if you have an issue wont you leave being that you are an immigrant yourself last i check youll did arrive here by boat
@@jeneromilton get a life troll.
Is this why Somalis move to cold cities in the US like Minnesota of all places? LOL
Iga dawa geey
They are sent there to displace the white populations.
Nitro Dubs who are they sent by exactly
@Derrick Jensen They are not, they're partially mixed with arab caucasoid genes but they're mostly subsaharan african
This is actually hilarious
We Somalis are not Caucasian. We are Cushitic.
We Carry the E1B1B Haplogroup that means we are off Cushitic race. We are way older than the Caucasian race.
@Jgean Accounts We are not Caucasian. We Somalis are proud of our Ancient Cushitic culture. We never want to be White
@@havilahkuush7110 Cushitics are also Caucasians. Melanated Caucasians. Ethiopians, Eritreans, Somalis and Sudanese, all of these belong to the Cushitic race.
@@havilahkuush7110 walaalo reer badiyo nimo fan maha,
ee naga daa, nomadict ka aa naga dawa dadid 🤭🤭🤭
@@beproud5447 kkkkkkk dowlo
@@havilahkuush7110 Right, this video just stated that not all Caucasoids are white; in fact, not even a third are pale-skinned. Look at Indians for reference, many of whom are incredibly dark. What all Caucasoids share in common with eachother is hair structure, bone structure (which can especially be seen in the face). Looking at Ethiopians and some Somali you can absolutely see more similarities in their faces with other Caucasoids than the typical sub-Saharan African.
To reiterate Caucasoid =/= White, at least not the majority
Caucasian is a term used on the people of the Caucasia region
Caucasoid is a term used on human appearance form
And lesbian is a term used on the people of the Lesbos island
Lesboid is a term used on human appearance form
Caucas-a-void hohohoo..
And none of them are scientific terms. Caucasian isnt a thing.
Elias
: "Caucasian is a term used on the people of the Caucasia region. Caucasoid is a term used on human appearance form"
This is true. There are three human races: caucasoid, negroid and mongoloid. 😉
"As you know people of the same race always get along all the time."-Masaman
Good one. Lol.
The Omnissiah's Chosen
Because Europeans and Arabs love each other SO MUCH right?
True. And that extends to ethnic groups, too. Slavs don't get along with other Slavs and Hispanics don't get along with other hispanics. I don't really understand why, they came from the same people.
@The Omnissiah's Chosen Individualism is probably the best way to overcome the WEAKNESS of diversity.
@The Omnissiah's Chosen
Om Sai Ram!🙏🙏🙏
Did he really say that?
There goes WW1.
Thanks Masaman as a Somali I appreciate the work you put into your videos. I hope you are not discouraged by some of the ignorant comments in the comment section.
This video is large correct but he was wrong that the traditional 4 races have any scientific basis. There is really only 2 origins for the features seen across the human species that being of Sub Saharan African (any part of Africa below the Equator) and those form outside it's territory. But going back far enough we share our origins as human beings and even living beings from Eastern Africa, so dividing based on origins of such phenotype traits and exact Genotype is all a moot point.
In just three years time, the science has already changed.
Though you desperately want to believe it, Somalis(?) are not caucasian..
Those people came from you not the other way around like he’s explaining. Your ancestors have never been to the mountains of death ( caucuses Mountain). Those people are a fixed race that can only have kids their own paleness or whiter … the melanin is dominant why would you identify ur self as white when you are genetically superior
@@douche8980 so are Arabs caucasian?
@@douche8980 Correct. Just because each of these has some Caucasian substratum, doesn't make them the same so-called "race." The Levant, northeastern Africa, and the Caucasus itself have the highest admixtures of Caucasian, but it's extremely low in the rest of Europe and South Asia. So this would apply to the Syrians, much less to the Somalis, but not to the Sri Lankans or Swedes. This is outdated colonial era pseudo-science for a reason, and it baffles me why, rightly, saying "Black race/negroid, "yellow race/Mongoloid," and "red race" are rightly seen as offensive and inaccurate, and somehow in the US "Caucasian" is somehow seen as polite and valid. Yes, it would be interesting to find out why this is the case, probably either because there was an existing Caucasian substratum before Afro-Asiatic and Ino-European peoples began to dominate in the area, or because e.g. the Hyksos were originally a Caucasian people before spreading into the Middle East and then Egypt, even though they're simply assumed to be Semitic (Afroasiatic).
Having family from the actual Caucasus region, we have Indo-European Languages in Iranic and Armenian, Altaic languages in Turkic, and Caucasian languages such as Georgian and Chechen. Although we are genetically related having lived next to each other for several centuries, calling us all "Caucasian" culturally or ethnically instead of simply geographically, is something we find outdated and ignorant, just FWIW.
Masaman has another video where he covers what Caucasian actually is or isn't, rather than this outdated European colonial era version.
yo why is this so intense sounding, like the music and the intense talking makes this whole thing insane
8:05 American logic: sudanes people are caucasiens but spaniards obviously aren't.
Bruh Spaniards are White on the census. Most Puerto Ricans are even white on the census, what are you on about
@@milesbairely-ujueta4785 why is race a topic on the us census??
@@milesbairely-ujueta4785
Puerto Ricans are mix from europe, africa and a small portion of natives that's why they can be white or black or something between, the same goes for Spainards
Africa is to close and they came to Spain to often in the history that they wouldn't left black DNA in Spain
@@altergreenhorn I feel like you might be confused at what I'm saying. Spaniards are White on the us census. That is not a position, it is a fact. That is how they are classified by the us government if it were up to me I would have a much more complex system of classification but it's not, I have been aware of all the things you just said for some time, and they are mentioned in this very video. The Puerto Rican point that I am making is that the majority of Puerto Ricans should not be classified as White on the census because they occupy a very different societal position than White people, and most of the ones who are told to write White are just light skinned mixed people for whom another option of mestizo, mulatto, mixed latino, or Afro-Latino should be available.
@@SimKivi Because it is a useful data point given the fact that we live in a racially stratified society..
Caucasian is a completely outdated and inaccurate term.
sam hinchee I don’t think labels in taxonomy can really become inaccurate, they aren’t strict in the first place.
@@silence6605 Generally the terms we used to divide people into ethnic categories are not considered taxonomic. Taxonomically, all modern humans are monotypic, largely because we managed to absorb any significantly divergent human subspecies or species as we colonized the world.
Eh, there is some value in it. Certainly genetics and morphology seems to suggest Caucasians are a distinct group. Although the people who think it means Europeans alone are dead wrong.
Yea i think its just silly.
@@threerabbit2227 but even if that was the case the term race itself is still pretty bad. The way I see it, all of the modern day humans belong to the same race since we all descend from Africans who left that continent and you can breed with any other human. Race realistically would only be a factor if you compared yourself to an extinct species of human like the Neanderthals or denisovans
I'm half white and half Indian, I'm considered Caucasian because the majority of South Asians belong to the same race as Middle Eastern and Europeans.
South Asian were arguably considered a fifth group dubbed 'Veddoid' or Dravidian. They are counted under the US census as "white" or Caucasian but most of society would disagree.
@@douche8980 they're mixed between Caucasoid and australoid north Indians r closer to Caucasoid then south Indian Dravidians (who got australoid look the further south u go) and in some parts of east India and near Nepal there's even an admix of mongoloid
@@christopherguy9591 u could probably pass as Armenian, Persian, Italian, Spaniard, Greek or southern French
@@sean1139 we are all mixed to a certain degree and there is no Caucasoid this or Australoid that. Genetics doesn't recognize made up colonial nonsense used to divide those of the working and poor class people.
@@douche8980 they r indo european north indians r thats about as close to "white" or european as they would ever get
As a Somali being called 'caucasian' has to be the worst insult of 2023 lol fk/ hell! we don't want any part of it. We're just Somali.
Ok Caucasian
Talk about, the common ancestor between the caucasoid and mongoloid peoples, who probably lived in central Eurasia. Or maybe, the paleo Siberians
Did you read my comment or my mind?
@d puski Nah, they all share a common ancestor. Just one that exists at an even earlier date.
The ancient north Eurasians contributed to the genomes of central Asian proto indo European ppl as well as paleoindians
@d puski No, idiot. The ancestor of Eurasians and modern day Africans (who continued to evolve) split around 80,000 to 100,000 years ago. The common ancestor of all modern humans lived hundreds of thousands of years earlier.
Vtron, are you referring to Basal Eurasians?
7:58
Spain: Am I a joke to you?
Sudan is white and Spain is not
Especially considering how Portugal is white and Brazil is not
I mean at least it explains why the country seems to confuse many Americans or why they sometimes claim "Spaniards aren't white", something a European wouldn't even say after taking all drugs in existence at the same time.
probably for political reasons to keep the southern border easier to control.
@- Invictus - if u google sudan people you see the Sudanese race, which is south sudan, north sudan is Sudanese arab, still not white for shit tho lol
🙏🏻 masman for your effort. we all human stop fighting who is who
Mate, this was very good. Thanks. This entire area has really captured me since the Denisovans turned up.
On the map at 7:54 I'm surprised that Spain is not considered white.
theyre "Hispanic" according to americans hahahahah
xXxSkyViperxXx so stupid
@@EK-kw7tr Hola chula😍😘
Kim jon un. Did you really kill your own uncle?
El Pachuco Loco 😂
I was literally searching this a couple of days ago. Masaman knows what I want 🙌
The word "race" is not scientific. There are haplotypes with somewhat similar and homogeneous external traits.
The word "race" is typically anglosaxon and victorian, and colonial by definition.
cope
Caucasoid theory seems valid to me, seems allot of people think Caucasoid and White (in the American sense) is the same thing which an uneducated statement.
Caucasoid isnt based on skin colour
It is based on cranial structure, the typical Caucasoids are the Middle East, North Africa and Europe, then their descendants throughout the world, within the non-typical Caucasoids we can find the Ethiopians and Somalis who are a mixture of Ancient Africans with Natufians ( Ancient Caucasoids), South Indian (a mix of Caucasoid and Australoid), Hispanic (a mix of Amerindian with Caucasoid)
👍👍@@user-yt3xd2jl6d
@@user-yt3xd2jl6dAfter analyzing the genetic average of the Yemeni samples (including the genes of African minorities resulting from immigration and slavery), it was found that the genetic average of the Yemenis is much closer to the genetic average of Iceland, which is 700 kilometers away from Yemen, rather than the Horn of Africa, which is 20 kilometers away from Yemen. However, the genetic average of the population The Horn of Africa is enormously closer to the Yemeni genetic average than the genetic average of the Bantu countries or China.
There are only two races: Gingers and normal
Gigers are not a race they are soulless demons. I know I am one.
Yeah I hate gingers too,
@@thisguysgaming7246 I could tell by your pfp
what you say boi?
Why? What's wrong with Gingers?
I like how most people are in war with their own race lol😂
Most people of specific races you mean.
@RockSkater99.
Sudan: say that to my face, if you can reach.
@R the Sudanese are taller
@@gugi4477 It's a hand full of people in South Sudan, unlike the Netherlands, where the average is 185 cm...
@R The tallest ppl in the word are from west Balkan (Dinaric alps) not N. Europe. This includes Croatia, Bosnia, Serbia and Montenegro.
Masaman, you are the MAN! Woman & supreme educator. Race, perhaps complicated & how you explain that is absorbing. Thanks for being alive & sharing your head.
Thank you for your work!
Sudan is not Caucasian period!
Some Sudanease Arabs are up to 70% West Eurasian.
@Hare Krishna most are 40-60% Caucasian
Warsame Jibriil Yuusuf lol are you Sudanese. Mostly rich people are very light skinned and likely to be more Arab and they are the minority.
@@PK-ex6nf No I'm Somali from Djibouti/Somalia
@Hare Krishna then they should. The one drop rule is retarded
Humans are weird
Humans are garbage
@thegigadykid1 hey don't insult me like that racist im proud of my human heritage
“Humanity is a virus” - The Matrix
Ross Whitlock shut up alien.
ahhh bro 🚬🚬
I would love to hear you speak about the link between The oceanic peoples and South Americans as well as the links between the indigenous Japanese New Zealanders and Australians
8:00 Sudan was considered white/Caucasian? And Spain wasn’t? Lol
@Devine Truth The exclusion of Spain from that map is because the US Census distinguishes Hispanic (of any race) from whites, blacks, etc. who aren't of Hispanic or Latino ancestry. Spain is counted alongside Latin America (except Brazil) as Hispanic, with Brazil being counted as Latino but not Hispanic. Thus, all the other European countries are counted as non-Hispanic white while Spain is counted as Hispanic. So yes, the map is somewhat arbitrary, especially when it comes to Spain.
@@yodorob This is why Portugal is marked as Caucasian, since Brazil is the largest Latin state. It is not logical
SUDAN MEANS BLACK AND THE WESTERN AND EASTERN LANDS INSO-CALLED AFRICA WAS CALLED NEGRO LAND BY W.E.B. DUBOIS IN HIS WORLD AND AFRICA. OF COURSE THE EUROPEANS BACK TO BLUMENBACH DID NOT CONSULT ARABIC SOURCES. THE KINGDOMS OF CASTILE, LEON, AND ASTURIAS IN NORTHERN SPAIN AND ANDALUSIA (LAND OF THE VANDALS) WERE JUST AS EUROPEAN AS THE LAND OF THE FRANKS (FRANCE) OR THE SAXONS/NORMANS OF ENGLAND WHO WERE TEUTONIC AND VIKING. SOUTHERN SPAIN WAS MOORISH.
The people from the Caucasus mountains are not white... Iran,Turkey,Dagestan,Armenia and Georgia look different.. they're the real Caucasian.... we're all mislead bullshit story and stolen history
Spain or Sudan ain't white
Have you done a video on the Khoisan yet?
Perhaps soon.
@@Masaman Can you also do a video on Karen people. They're an ethnolinguistic group that live in Myanmar [Burma].
Cushite Karen? Lol
@@Masaman you are so racist
@@Masaman dude... I can help on this one. There is a gentleman from my country who has done extensive research on this. His name is Patric Tariq Mellet. A lot of it goes over my head but he is very dedicated. His site is camissapeople.wordpress.com/about-2/
I am from Dagestan, Caucasia. I am a real caucasian, I always get angry, when some white person being european claims that he is a caucasian 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Europeans are Caucasians aswel 😂
@@LoL-mu4oe europeans are more African than Caucasians 😂
Thank you for helping find myself!
your race has nothing to do whit who are you, is your values and actions. What you learn by where you live by your parents and what you think and do basing in that. I think
I like how you used "Self Esteem Fund" by Kelly Bailey in the middle of the video. It's my all times fav music piece :)
2:01 that map is missing many islands, New Zealand, Indonesia, Cuba, Taiwan, Sri Lanka, Madagascar, Jamaica, Puerto Rico and I’m sure others that I didn’t notice.
wow, thank you for the in-depth explanation, I may not understand all the genetics but It was very enlightening!
Very interesting, I'd like to learn more. Thanks.
Oh man, people are really getting triggered that he said Somalis are Caucasian lol.
If you payed attention he said Caucasian doesn’t mean white, just like how Asian doesn’t mean Chinese.
@Loki Animations African is someone that's from the continent of Africa. Don't make it seem like all Africans have one look because they don't, just like other continents. Africa is diverse.
@Loki Animations one thing people don't appriciate enough is how long Africa has been inhabited by humans.
Because of that length of habitation there is more genetic variation in Africa than any other contient, or similar region. Then you add into the mix isolation, immigration, and phenotipic mixing. Africa's genetic diversity is incredible.
You sound triggered
@Fidus Achates they aren't mixed, they are cushitic. Actually some of the least mixed people in the region
@Fidus Achates Somalis aren't mixed for the last time. Somalis are E1b1b DNA Haplogroup. This haplogroup originated in the Horn Of Africa specifically Somalia. Somalis are a very ancient people, not mixed with anything.
Masaman adding light and truth to a time where people capitalize on ignorance, especially around race. Showing how strange and inaccurate our classifications are and how interconnected different groups of people are is the surest way to diffuse the groups trying to capitalize on ignorance by appealing to constructed racial group identity. Thanks for that.
I completely agree with you. Masaman is fucking based.
Jake Pflasterer
Masaman’s a benevolent and intelligent “race realist”, and for this he is based especially in the “West”.
This is important but it's also important to realize that the identities of "Black" and "Brown" were forced on the slaves and Latin Americans in the US due to the culture around them, e.g. Anglo culture, who saw them as all the same. So to combat their oppression, they turned their identity into something positive for them, something to feel proud of, to negate the inferiority they were meant to feel when being discriminated against.
Ignorance is taking people of different races and cultures and throwing them into the same country expecting it to not end in bloodshed.... But yeah, pretend that it's going to work even though the evidence to the contrary is so blatantly obvious.
@Stirgid Lanathiel So..... You're going to pretend that Culture A (one that is very patriarchal to the point where women must cover their entire body and where the genitalia of women is mutilated at birth) can absolutely coexist and flourish with Culture B which is the exact opposite of it?
I know you're trying to come off all philosophical n what not... But THAT, what you just said is PURE ignorance.
You are ignore everything that's happening for this vision that YOU want humanity to be, it's not that nor will it become that in the near future and you need to accept that.
Very Nice Video, thank you
I always thought that Somalis and Ethiopians did look quite distinct from people from other sub Saharan African countries. It makes sense that genetics would be quite different too.
Search up e-m78
People from the Horn (Somalis, Ethiopians, Djiboutians, and Eritreans) are some of the oldest Africans which is why you find the oldest archeological evidence of humans in this region. We are the original depiction of phenotypes incorrectly referred to as "Eurocentric". We led the mass migrations movement out of Africa, just look at the "Cheddar Man" and you'll clearly see that he resembles a native person from the Horn of Africa
Somalis surely arent caucasian. I understand it was inferred from skull shape categorisation but I think we can all agree that is outdated. They have a very unique skull shape and facial features, you can almost always identify a somalian when you see them. it's very interesting
We are the oldest race on earth, the oldest human fossil "Lucy" was found in Hadar, Ethiopia, where the somali people inhabit. it used to be part of somalia but after the ogaden war, it was given to ethiopia.
@@CloseThatBackdoor Somalis aren't the oldest race, and they've also changed in the past 500,000 years.
@@CloseThatBackdoor it was Afar not Ogaden
That’s so true, or maybe it’s because I can easily spot my own people. Even non somalis can automatically tell who’s somali and who isn’t
@@CloseThatBackdoor Ethiopians aren't a race, and you didn't belong to the same race as Lucy. Unless you're an Australopithicus of some sort. And you're not. Your ancestors have been changing and evolving just like everyone else's.
Us Somalis are unique and it’s actually an insult to call us mixed because mixed people in Somalia are looked down upon, and there are a lot of mixed race tribes like the barwani,shansi , reer xamar and rexanwayn.
Somalis are a Cline population, meaning they are in-between two groups, now forming their own distinct group.
Somalis can still look down on people? Aren't you guys last on the totem pole?
Fadiel Benjamin then you haven’t met any Somali person, they are very prideful.
@@sahraali4760 without reason
Somali women are often very attractive and pretty w a narrow nose though and a more euro type of face structure or so I’ve noticed.
As a Georgian, this word always confuses me... Describing the whole race with this word overshadows our culture and it's not nice. It's kind of annyoing hearing Western Europeans or Americans call themselves Caucasian. The word that describes a culture shouldn't be used to describe a race.
You have mistaken
It isn't the Latins who needs validation
It's the Angloid, they will travel from Egypt to Persian to India to Caucasus to claim their history
Every second is 10/10 interesting.
I'm somali and I don't think I have anything in common with a Dutch person other than being human and living on earth lol.
I'm somali too
Somalis we out here 👍👍👍
@Bakar Hussein
Not really...
@@Laascaanood614
My dad was a proud African somali man.
@Bakar Hussein
What ethnicity are you
Love the research you put into these man, thumbs up!
When he said lastly for the different types and still hadn’t scene which group the part of Mexico my parents are from... I felt that
Ethiopian and Somalis have partial Caucasian ancestry and they do look different from other sub saharan africans but they are still mostly like the rest of sub saharans
@DANGOTE Mazinge I didn't know that, which tribes?
@@aezyadkine158 thts bullshit the dir and darood have white features
@DANGOTE Mazinge why you mentioning barwani tribes those mufukers are not Somali. Only 30 percent the rest they are dutch arab indian etc
Based on archeology alone, it is the Europeans and others who inherited the Somali facial features than the other way around because of human origins like Lucy.
Super-super informative. Thank you for all the detail. I often had to stop the video in order to digest the many charts. At one point you used a word that sounded to me like "desidgination" ( at about 7:10). I can't find the definition for this word. Of course I am most probably misspelling it. Could you clarify please. Thanks.
The word is miscegenation
I would be interested in a genetic analyse of the french people. They are pretty much the halfway point of Europe, surrounded by the Iberian peninsula, the British isles and more. I always wondered what is there genetic make-up. I really like your videos!
Genghis Khan
😂😂😂
@@adityanawani8134 Genghis khan descendants are everywhere lol!
@@kentajin7860 no only in Asia not Europe
@@Jaylio Mongol Empire even had European territories for decades, and wherever they colonized they spread their genes!
French in province mongrels in cities
Never knew about the truth of the word, thank you so much for explaining, very cool
Hello from Chechenya ✨
Привет из арабия 😴🤚🏻
@@dsno9576 пока арабия🖐
Что са Китайский картинка профиля?
@@franza2109 это не китайский это моя любовь
@@miiiii1926 любовь made in China*
You always have the answers to things I’ve always wondered about and didn’t know who to ask. Thanks for the informative content
He wannabe historian
Like what? Lmao am scared of your answer
Except when he's wrong.
@@themobileentrepreneur you are.
Masaman: Somalis; Caucasian
Everyone in the Horn: *Hey man, are you okay?*
Somalia are Caucasoid by skull shape race categorisation.
I’m Somali and I know this we are different
Soomaali Cushitic Somalis are Cushitic
@@vwqp.1947 Cushitic is a subrace of Caucasoid.
@@zibongo6720MANY 19TH CENTURY WHITE THEOLOGIANS STATED THAT CUSH ALONG WITH CAANAN, THE SONS OF HAM WERE ACCURSED IN THE BIBLICAL ACCOUNT BY NOAH AND BEFORE THE AMERICAN CIVIL WAR THIS EXCUSE WAS USED TO SANCTION SLAVERY OF AFRICAN AMERICANS. AFTER THE CIVIL WAR THE EUROPEANS WITNESSING THE GREAT CIVILIZATIONS OF THE NILE AND THE HORN CALLED THE REGION THE LAND OF THE CAUCASIAN HAM. IN FACT SO MUCH OF AFRICA WAS CALLED HAMITIC FROM BANTU TO FULANI THAT ONE WONDERED WHERE SO-CALLED BLACK AFRICA BEGAN. I GUESS I COULD BE CALLED CAUCASIAN UNDER THESE RUBRICS,BUT I KNOW BETTER. DON'T BELIEVE THE HYPE. SAY IT LOUD BE CUSHITIC, BLACK, AND PROUD.
When I was in college many years ago, one of my required humanities classes brought in the county coroner to talk about "race". He said that coroners could generally come up with a general description of a person from bones alone, assuming there was enough material to examine, and said that there were three races, broadly speaking: Indo-European, Asian and African, and this was based on bone structure, not skin color. Obviously, because there is so much "mixing" of DNA in the US and much of the world, this can sometimes create issues for coroners using bones alone to come up with a description of the deceased.
Anytime I’m curious about the world’s population and roots of it, I know I can count on Masaman. Extremely educated and articulate in all videos!! Truly a privilege to listen.
Somalis are not Caucasian..
Ik these white people have lost their mind, talking about us as if they know what we are.
They are Caucasoid by skull shape race categorisation.
@@zibongo6720 Bullshit .. Somalis look nothing like a European..even the skull shape. THEY HAVE A UNIQUE FEATURE LOOK AT THEIR FOREHEAD TOO. YOU SHOULD KNOW IF YOU'RE REALLY A SOMALI.
@@Kermatrix smdh.... wannabe from the Caucasus mountains
@@Kermatrix that's all pseudo science.
I’m just tryna know what to put on the questionnaire about my race for my new school enrollment😭😭😂
so what are we to call the persons who originated in the mountains of Caucus?
Hi there your lectures are just great I love them and can’t get enough hear you on the next one Salam bro
Could you make a video about the Mongoloid Races ?
Aryan countries, Afghanistan, Tajikistan, Iran, India, 🇦🇫🇩🇪🇮🇷🇮🇳🇭🇺
Pita sri is R1a or R1a z93 different than the rest of R?
shut up u idiot
India?
@anonymous D
Germans do not have R1A in significant quantities.
@anonymous D
Are you talking about Brahmins?
Not all north Indians are brahmins.
Infact,even in the north,the average would likely be somewhere around 10%.
The map shows Turkey as Asian.Do Turkish people considered Asian or cauasian or middle Eastern or European?
There is nothing called Turkish people when it comes to what is now called Turkey , they are a mixture of Middle East and European with a small percentage of Turkic and Mongolian blood.
this is kinda a weird question, but can more races or ethnicities be "created" in the future?
Yes like mix of different races can create new race
Love how consistent the uploads have been keep it up dude
I feel as though people are confused by Caucasian thinking it means Europeans due to the US census. Demographics on the census should be more specific and luckily it is turning out that way
US census is bullshit. Confuses everyone with race & ethnicity.
After all, anyone can be American.
@The Omnissiah's Chosen >doesn't say what's wrong
10:46 why does south africa has green spots
Is it a different group
Pls respond masama
It’s not different
What is that beautiful music specifically at 5:06
One thing i want to add since my other comment became controversial
We have thin noses not because of mixture because for people in the highlands it evolves that way
Masaman, you are already more professional than 90% of American cultural anthropologists.
Absolutely my go to source on this subject, resubscribing.
I talk about this all the time for decades.
You really put this video together really well.
God bless you 🙏
Caucasian people are ancestors of first indo-european people :) thats why white race is called caucasian.
@@borisgodunov6 ok so what does that mean exactly. Maybe I am missing something. Ty for sharing
@@DCJNewsMedia First Indo-European people were people called Yamnaya. you can search that name. this was the first people who had blonde hair(they had first mutation). they lived in the north of the Caucasus in the territory of modern Russia. they were physically strongest people at that time because they were first people who consumed milk. they also were eating meat and honey so their diet contained 40% more calories than other people's diet. Yamnaya's people also had strong bone structure (because Milk=Vitamin D). they also used horses. one more thing to mention is that they had very advanced metallurgy. their weapons were too good for that time. all these were the reasons why they conquered whole Europe.
now the question: did they have any connection to real caucasian people?
answer: yes :) yamnaya's people created by mixing 2 people of that time.
1)caucasian hunter/gatherer
2)eastern european hunter/gatherer
so we see that 40-50% of Yamnaya's peoples genetics comes from Caucasian people but its not only genetics, its culture too. As I said Yamnaya's people were eating honey and gathered it in pots. do you know how they knew it? because their ancestors Caucasians(Georgia) were first beekeepers in the world
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beekeeping
Yamnaya's people were herders so they couldn't beekeeping but they gathered it.
I also said that they had advanced metallurgy. science says that first advanced metallurgy was in Asian countries and Yamnaya's people took it from them but Holy Bible says that first advanced metallurgy in the world was invented by Tubals(Georgian tribes) 5000 years ago. Georgia is Caucasian country. Yamnaya's people may took it from them or from Asian countries. no one knows that.
Caucasian Hunter/Gatherer people mixed with other peoples too
Yamnaya's people were herders they took their genetics in whole Eurasia too.
Now there are genetical maps where we find Caucasian hunter/gatherer gene in Europe, Asia and north Africa too.
there are plenty researches of Yamnaya's peoples genetics. You can search it. If you want I can send few genetical researches about them.
@@borisgodunov6 your pretty smart. Looks like you are a world history guy. Very interesting. I will look into this further. Thank you so very much for sharing this with me.
Have a fantastic day
@@DCJNewsMedia thank you very much. It was nice to talk with you.
have a nice day Sir.
You did a great job explaining an archaic terminology that the U.S. can't seem to part with. Doing the Census gave me firsthand experience with this fun. ✌️😎
Hi Masaman, this week my Dad got is Ancestry DNA results. We got surprised! My Dad and his Family have always said to be Sephardic Jews with some Moorish descent. My Dad had some Middle eastern descent but 51% of his DNA is Native Mexican-American Indian! 😀
Then you are Indigenous-American because that is your predominance
As an somali person I have never felt so insulted like this before this is worst than being call arab 😡
@ hmm did Arabs invent the internet? What about Russians? East Asians? 😫
@@hodonhibo6889bro I love Somalis as a European
@masaman @9:23 You made a mistake grouping horn Africans as Eurasian. Your chart on the right groups them based on Eurasian and African locality. The horn of Africa is located in Africa. The other Eurasian groups are correctly grouped 9:23
Masaman-I am an instant fan and subscriber. I have been enlightened, informed and educated. Thank you for simplifying, condensing, and placing in order the information that you have shared. God bless you and all of your future endeavors.
Could you break down the ethnic/racial groups that make up Assyrians?
Semitic people. There you go. No need to thank.
Likeitornot Assyrians have very close or should I say totally similar genes with the rest of Northern Iraqis and western Syrians , all of these regions share the same genes in both Parental YDNA haplogroup and they only speak different languages . Christian Assyrians are not special and they just sustained their culture from ancient Assyria unlike the rest .
African Hunter-Gathers. There are two separate races of Pygmy or maybe three and the Hadza are unrelated to the Khoisan, and some Khoisan are tall with black skin, possibly from Bantoid admixture? Lots of genetic variation and confusion around African Hunter-Gatherers and it pains me to see them lumped together so often.
Of course there is some variety there.
@masaman We know White skin evolved about 8k to 9k years ago. Blue eyes a few millenia older but what about the Caucasoid skull shape? (And for that matter the Mongolia skull type) I've found it hard to find a definitive point when this skull type developed. 35k year old skulls 💀 I saw that were formerly called Caucasoid now have reconstructions that look very similar to modern Khoisan tribesmen & mentioning that I'm searching for the oldest Caucasoid skull type post OAA because with such a diverse phenotype I'm sure skulls that fall in the Caucasoid range could be found amongst Black Africans (I use this term for all aboriginal African groups -pre North African back migration with no admixture)
I'm sure we are talking older than 15k bce but I'm wondering had you ever looked into this question
classifications and observations are very interesting study of cultures and their evolution throughout history .
admixtures and various haplotypes spread across Africa are very interesting as well
You should make a video where you make it clear that Somalis are not mixed
He already made a video on that, & the Horn Of Africa countries you should check it out. 🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
Not *recently mixed but I agree
Lua Gita I wouldn’t trust this guy. He made a video about the Nilotic people and someone commented the shit historically inaccurate phrase ‘we wuz kangz n shiet’ and he liked the comment. I would recommend you guys to watch hometeamhistory and everybody hates angel. Their better channels if you want to know about the history of the horn. As a half Kenyan myself I don’t agree on the fact Sudanese and the people of the horn are Caucasian (which in itself is an outdated and offensive term for other races) I hope this helps✌🏽
@@je8479 why you mad we are Caucasian
Somali Vlogs yeah maybe ages ago but definitely not now. The term ‘Caucasian’ is an old term. The only real Caucasian people are the ones who live in the Caucas regions but since the word ‘Caucasian’ is actually offensive and used to down-grade other races. I think the best way to describe them is ‘white Eurasian’. As for Somalis, most Somalis I’ve come across refer themselves as Cushitic black Africans and are proud to be black Africans. Let’s admit most people who are deemed as ‘Caucasian’ in this video probably don’t have any ‘white privilege’ anyway. But if you want to call yourself Caucasian that’s fine I’m just saying it shouldn’t be a word to describe people anymore
Here is a topic. Similarities between turkic and "hispanic" mestizos of amerindian and european ancestry. After all it said the Natives originated from central asian region. It can also explain why some "Hapas" are sometimes confused with being latino. Hapas being Asian and European. Its so interesting yet so confusing.
Similarities only to people not familiar with either group.
Hapa is a Hawaiian term that meant half Asian or Pacific Islander it could be anyone who's half asn or P islander even a blasian person I think a better term would be Eurasian I agree native north Americans were Eurasian in origin and that's y Eurasians would look like Latinos sometimes
Watch this at 50% to 75% speed to digest as much as possible, especially the charts, though some are unfortunately lacking units on the axes.
These are originally German terms adopted later by some other Western countries. In other countries, they do not use this term. Something else is used and other maps exist.
Sri Lankans are not Caucasian or Caucasoid in any way... Common sense would tell..
Caucasoid not Caucasian two different thing
@Ryan Kiddo THAT IS WHY THE GREEKS INCLUDING HERODOTUS CALLED INDIA , EASTERN ETHIOPIA (ETHIOPIA DRIENTALIS)?
South Asians are Australoid. Some have Caucasoid DNA admixture.
It is , but because your lack of understanding / education
Sinhalese are consider as Caucasoids
humanphenotypes.net/Sinhalesid.html
I would love to see your take on the Māori, since there are no pure blooded Māori left in the world, since all are part European, but have remained a united culture and race, and still remain a central place in New Zealand culture and society.
Maori used to be Austronesian/Polynesian, that's kinda scary because mixed race is like destroying civilization. A lot of Māori nowadays are mixed and even already identify as Caucasian, the same with Aboriginals. Understand if people are obsessed with Caucasian features but kinda not good tho. Filipinas, Indonesia, and Malaysian are in this tho obsessed with Caucasian half ppl
@@KimAhrina11Mixed race is what gives birth to civilization, Egypt, Mesopotamia, Indus valley, Mesoamerica, China, all mixed race
@@KimAhrina11mixing is both inevitable and what humans have been doing for millions of years, non of us would look how we do if not for humans mixing
Hey i was wondering can you do Pharoah Rameses haplogroup L1b1a3 . And How in the world can someone look like peoole in the past
I need to get my DNA tested I’m mixed race more tanned. With jet black hair. But I think I’ve got more European descent as mum is more Dark skinned but European features and my dad is white Irish. So would I be classed as Caucasian then?