What time signature was THAT?? | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - Geoff Castellucci | Reaction/Analysis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ธ.ค. 2021
- Geoff absolutely rocked this incredibly creative rendition of a classic song, and I can't wait to see what he does next.
As always, make sure you:
Support the original video! • God Rest Ye Merry Gent...
Support me on Patreon! / mortius
Join the discord community! / discord
Aaaand support this video you just watched by liking, commenting, and subscribing. See y'all next time! - เพลง
Hey guys I know it’s 6/8 now 😋
The lyrics are in iambic pentameter, so it’s cool that Geoff chose to match the time signature to the natural cadence of the lyrics.
You’re honestly one of my top three reactors, Man. You’re so awesome! 👏🏼
You can also count it as 4/4 on the drum kick haha
Let the comments flow, helps the algorithm 😁 I still reckon 12/8 though 😜
I always think that if it sounds like skipping, not the rope kind, the child kind, then it's 6/8, also think Viennese Waltz, which is 6/8, if that helps. I fully appeciate why the pauses happen to allow you to comment but, personally, having listened to it without pauses to start with, I like to share that experience with others if you see what I mean. As a whole thing he always builds and builds to make it a particular experience which is spoiled for me, and doubtless you too, by continually pausing. I hope that makes sense. I especially felt that with VoicePlays Hoist the Colours. it just loses so much by pausing it for comment. However, althoughI do understand why some feel it necessary, listening to it straight through is so much more of an emotional experience. Though seeing how excited you get this way perhaps you couldn't cope with more :)
Eli set up the lighting for Geoff in this one, but Geoff... That man is reaching absolutely new heights with every arrangement he does. I absolutely enjoy watching your reactions to him and VoicePlay. Your enthusiasm and insights are wonderful!
Homefree have out did everyone with their cover of brothers in arms and their original Christmas ain't for the lonely and then Tim Foust released his first acopela single come go with me
"I'll get one or two who'll comment that I pause too much - And I'll delete them." - Hell yes king! I love your reactions and analysis, and I feel like I learn to notice new things about arrangements that I wouldn't otherwise have thought of thanks to you. Plus, your passion and enthusiasm is infectious!
You didn’t say anything but I’m guessing by your expressions that you realized that Geoff is now TEASING us a bit by giving a lead-up that makes us expect one of his super bass notes, only to just go on with the song. He’s freaking playing with us now! LOL
Yes I completely agree. With a lot of his songs, it makes you feel like he’s teasing you for that bass note.
Geoff made it his own. He started out traditionally then kicked up so wonderfully. Love it.
One of the things I most love about Geoff's solo work is that he builds in moments where he LOOKS AT HIS OTHER SELVES. I mean, we all know he isn't really there four times at once, but we just accept that he can nod approvingly at a good bit performed by one of his loops. It's actually funny as hell and no one EVER remarks on it.
As a complete aside, I need to say that Geoff's decision to grow his hair long was one of the best choices he ever made. The videos of him with short hair ... I barely notice him. He's a clean-cut, nice-looking young man, but bland, bland, bland... Tony's eyebrows catches more of my attention in those older videos. Or Earl's whiney tenor (which is fabulous in some songs, and fingernails on a blackboard in others, to my ears). Layne ... just ... I could listen to him all day but watching his mouth move when he's beatboxing just confuses the heck out of me. J None has a voice that ranks right up there, but I'm really glad they brought in Caesar as a permanent member - he's just an amazing fit. Yeah, I know I'm six months late to this video but I'm just cycling through some of your VP content and needed to say something.
Strongly agree on both Geoff interacting with the "Geoffettes" (Folsom Prison Blues and Way Down are *brilliant* examples of editing genius in this), and on Geoff growing his hair long! Can't believe he jokes about getting "old" when he literally looks better with long hair now than he did like 10 years ago with short hair (not that he ever looked bad, but you really nailed it in that had I known about Voiceplay in their early days, I probably would have glanced right over Geoff. But now? Hoo boy, hard to take my eyes off him honestly!)
you know Geoff did awesome when Mortius giggles like a schoolgirl seeing her crush.
Lol, i love your energy towards people who just want straight up reactions with minimal pauses. While I'm in that camp most of the time i completely understand that you're not here for that so i don't complain. Also there's plenty of other channels that don't pause very much.
I appreciate that even though you have a different style you prefer, you still enjoy (and more importantly, respect) the style that I choose to put out. Thanks!
OMG I love it when you absolutely geek out about Geoff. Especially for this because I think it's epic. I've watched this so many times I think I'm definitely obsessed. My favourite part is the a cappella in the middle. It's great that he uses all his range and of course his harmonies are to die for. His arrangements just get better & better. Shout out to Eli for the atmospheric lighting.
I love listening to other people freak out about how much range Geoff has. I only stumbled onto his stuff near end of August but it is fantastic. He truly does have a mad reach as a bass.
And just finished it, great reaction, as always. Don't worry about the pauses -- we'll go to Geoff's channel for the uninterrupted experience, as you say (as well we should, give him due respect for a great product). I mean, only other way you could get in your analysis is to 'save up' and talk longer when you do, which could get boring. Or maybe add visual text on the screen for some of the observations? I've seen that done to great effect, but it looks like a bear to edit. Whatever, your way is great, and it's what I keep coming back for! (Well, that, and to see if Mortimis might put in an appearance! When's she coming back here? Love hearing her take on things, too!) :)
Geoff does an amazing job with this one. With the timing change, octave catches, the Picardy 3rds he throws in there, the staccato steps, etc., he blows my mind! Love your reactions and your explanations. Don't apologize for pausing your own viewing for your analysis[how else are you to comment on all his surprises?]. Thank you.
You make me laugh all the way. Ignore people who make snide remarks. I love hearing your take on a song and you make me notice the nuances. Thank you so much. ❤️☺️
As soon as I saw your video pop up for this I went right to it. I KNEW you were gonna lose your sh*t! (In the best way possible, of course.) This is such an awesome arrangement, Geoff just keeps raising the bar he prevously sets, either in his solo work or in what he arranges for VP. I thoroughly enjoyed your R&A and always look forward to giggling at your giggling when you get to certain parts! I may listen to this all year through, like I already do with his and VP's Halloween offerings, it's just that perfect. All the best to you and yours this holiday season!
I'm new here, but i *love* the way you do reactions! As a non-music person, hearing you talk about all of the different things is _amazing_
Thank you! This is my favorite type of comment, I love bringing music to people who don’t necessarily get to enjoy the details normally
Thank you for your analysis, comments and reactions to this amazing arrangement by Geoff Castelluchi. I have just discovered him and am enthralled with his renditions of music I know and love. You have helped me to appreciate Geoff's music more, and to understand what makes his pieces so creative and unique.
One of the reasons I love your reactions to Geoff is that you really appreciate all of the technique and, frankly, the beauty of his overall work. So many reactors get so locked into wowing over the incredibly deep bass notes that I feel like they miss a lot in the harmonies. Thanks for giving some love to what a fantastic overall singer and arranger this man is!
I've known *nothing* about music other than I've known what I like. Geoff the Secret Dragon snagged me into the Voiceplay rabbit hole. Between your reactions and those of the Charismatic Voice, I am finally learning why I like what I do. The greater understanding of the music and its structure has really added to my love of the songs. And your reactions absolutely make my day. Thank you!
I love watching your reactions and how giddy you get when you get to nerd out about music stuff. I am in the same boat, although have forgotten a lot of my music technical knowledge over the years, it's so much fun to watch someone get to break down and really talk about what makes it so cool. Geoff's song arrangements are always very fun to 'break apart' too! I do love what he did with this one for sure and it was fun to hear your break down of what was happening
Your pauses and resultant enthusing are amusing and add to the reaction.
Geoff knocked it out of the theater on this one. Arrangement was stunning. Loved your fanguy reaction.
Long time watcher, first time Subscriber. Wanna know what did it for me
"It's 11pm, I'm tired and passive aggressive but shut up😁" that right there!!!! That wittiness and just pure joy from saying it accompanied with that adorable smile made me Smile from ear to ear 😁🥰 great job well done Sir 👔👍
I know I’ve said this before but I so enjoy your reactions! I love your energy, excitement and passion and I always learn something new from you :)
Absol-freaking lutely
I think, as others have commented, when the drums come in, it's 6/8 ( *ONE* , two, three, FOUR, five six...).
Most likely this. But if I had to throw an oddball guess out there I'd actually say it was written in 3/4 and played in 1. Just a guess on the way the accents fall.
I’m pretty new to your channel so I’ll go ahead and say there are several pauses but watching your joy/analysis at such a greatly talented singer is so fun! Don’t let haters get to you.
I've really been enjoying Peter Barber lately, too! But I still enjoy your stuff ;) Just your unrestrained enthusiasm is... so much fun. You always bring a smile to my face ^_^
I love your reactions as you’re so open and expressive, and I love you pausing often to share what you find cool about an arrangement. It gives me better insight into what I’m enjoying and highlights moments that I might not otherwise have appreciated fully. And I find your reactions refreshing when it comes to Geoff’s work, because it isn’t just the low notes that you’re reacting to and appreciating. They’re great, but so is a lot of the other things Geoff does too, so I appreciate you melting at them (as we all do) but then giving equal weight to the other great stuff. 💚
I always love & look forward to your reactions, as soon as I see a new Geoff, Voice play, Home free or PTX song, I always wait for my notification that you've reacted. you always add so much fun to the reaction too, tired or not. thank you
I love your reactions and your analysis- pause as much as you like! :) This is a fabulous arrangement, and we love to hear what you have to say- you always notice some things that I missed, and I have a pretty solid vocal music background. For what it's worth, I'm pretty sure it switches to 6/8 when the drums come in.
Definitely 6/8. Although all the sheet music I can find is 3/4. The accenting gives it away.
I love your reactions so much! You're so expressive! As if I didn't love these songs already, you make me appreciate them even more! Thank you!!
The major chord at the end....YES! Love your reactions.
Fantastic reaction to a wonderful video! Geoff has made me love a Christmas Carol I used to just consider one of the bunch! You don’t pause too much, your videos are very well balanced! And your unbridled enthusiasm makes them so much fun!
I love your reactions, because they make me appreciate the details of the performance. You'll always call out things I missed (like the bass descending while the upper harmony ascends) or that I just don't have the training to articulate. Combine that with your animated reactions, and your reactions are just (chef's kiss)!
Enjoyed all your observations of those little things that make it so enjoyable. I usually listen to music very casually - sort of in the background- but I find myself rewinding from time to time to try to dissect a part. It is all your fault! Ever since you did your analysis (blinded by textbooks) of Oogie Boogie I listen for little things like Eli’s plaintive notes there.
Peter was blown away too. So nice to know that uninformed me listens with the same enjoyment as you experts!
In a TOTALLY different way I recently enjoyed Home Free’s “Full of Good Cheer”. Lots and lots of fun.
Really love all of your reactions. This arrangement is just astonishing. I don't like christmas carols and I've listened dozens of times. It's such a joy!
Another outstanding review! You are one of the best and informative reviewers!
OH MY GOD! xD
I don't know if you're familiar with the musical theater commentary channel "Sideways", but he discussed that technique where the accompaniment drops out for a moment to emphasize the vocals in, I think, his Cats video? And he used the exact same moment from Danny Don't You Know as an example! So when you started talking about that technique and your favorite example of it, I was like "Is it gonna be...? No, there's no way, but wouldn't that be crazy--" AND THEN IT WAS!
And I mean it makes sense!! It's a pretty damn good example!
Love when a song makes you giddy.
You break down the songs really well! Thank you for this reaction!
Love your reaction!! yes stop all you want!! Geoff has us all in awe!
So I've been having a blast wandering through all of Mortius' videos, and I've already subscribed, but if I hadn't - the inclusion of NSP in this video would have clinched it for me. You are an absolute gift to watch, my dude. :)
The most in-depth analysis and enthusiasm is here on this channel. :)
Love your reactions. Analysis is what I watch your channel for and the delight on your face (which is just like mine). If I want to see it without interruptions I go to Geoff's channel as you said. Am enjoying the extra reactions and all the Christmas music. Merry Christmas to you & family
Adore this! It's a permanent fixture on my playlist now.
I love your heart! You're a breath of fresh air
Your reaction is a fab start to holiday music listening.
Ah Mortius! Watching your reactions brightens my day every time ☺️ Seeing your facial expressions and excitement just makes me giggle 😁
Don't mean to make you blush, but I love it when you are moved to giggle by the music. And you keep stopping the video and analyzing and gushing enthusiastically -- that's why we're here!
There are plenty of folks I watch for their minimal-pause ractions... you I watch for your enthusiastic analyses and multiple pauses to geek out
Before I went to sleep tonight I made sure to watch your reaction cause I saw you updated with this ealier today when I was busy and was excited. You always help me notice things I missed the first dozen times watching, which I appreciate, but I absolutely love how much delight you take in your enjoyment of music. It never fails to bring me joy, every time, just by you being yourself. Also, lookin dapper as always!
Keep deleting those silly "stop pausing" comments! Analyses are pause ridden and that's fine, I agree! Ya don't them anyways
We very much appreciate the double content gift ❤️
Love your reactions. I am an extremely amateur musician and singer. When I heard Geoff do the vocal scoop my first thought was it was a grace note. At least if I was playing it on an instrument that's how I would do it. Don't let the haters get you down. If they don't don't like the way you do this then find another channel. Personally I hate when people wait and then talk about something because I don't remember what it sounded like or just plain missed it. I want to hear about it as soon as it happens. I am used to taking music for granted and I love hearing about all the background nuances. ❤❤
I was so excited to see this reaction! Geoff really outdid himself on this one! I would love to see you do snow globe by home free if you haven’t already! It’s an amazing original co-written by Tim. And it is in fact a Christmas song!
The fact that I came to this reaction for Geoff and Mortius, and I got a surprise NSP in the middle with Danny Don't You Know...perfection.
Awesome reaction as always, Mortius! Don’t worry about the pausing, your input is always fun or interesting or both. The NSP reference though… maybe you can give us a reaction/analysis to them soon?👀 Keep up the good work! :)
Thank you! Home Free Christmas original musts: Warmest Winter (co written by Austin), Christmas Ain’t For the Lonely (co-written by Tim), Cold Hard Cash (co witten by Austin) Full of Cheer, a personal favorite written by Tim. Merry Christmas to you and Mortimiss! I saw Home Free online concert and hearing Adam Rupp’s Do You Hear What I Hear live was phenomenal! 😱🙌
You're a beautiful soul Mortius!
Tim Foust just dropped his first all Tim, all a cappella doo wop video Come Go With Me, and as I understand it there’s more on the way! He has a whole album!
I hate Christmas carols but this was so intense and good I can't stop listening. Your fun reactions just make it even better
Geoff has a video on how he does arrangements. Might give you an insight on his thought process.
It’s an old one, but I’d love to see your reaction to VoicePlay’s Mission Jingle Bells. It wouldn’t take a lot of analyzing, but it’s so much fun!
Yeah my reaction was ... how. How?! H O W they made those WORK??? 😁 it was so much fun
The more I listen, the more I think this is in 12/8 when the drums kick in. Phrasing still points to 4 lots of 3 instead of 2 lots of 3. Happy to be corrected 😁
I think he scrambled your brain! Mine too, definitely mine too!
I loved what Geoff did with this it’s very different
The downbeat is felt on 1 and 4 which is why it's 6/8. In 3/8 the downbeat would be only on the 1.
you always look amazing. where do you get you amazing ties?
This is 12/8 btw :) Great reaction as always
Well, I was actually going to say you beat the time in two groups of three so 1, 2, 1, 2, with 3 notes for each beat not 6 beats separately But it amounts to the same thing. There is a name for this key signature [maybe 3/2] The emphasis Geoff made seemed to me a striking of the beats counted as 1, 2 in 3 note groups. (Which is why I mention it) BTW Waltz time - 3/4 is popular in music , too. Love your reactions. And each reaction brings something new to the appreciation of the music. Great comment about pausing. I like it. Thanks
This man sings higher and lower than I can.
Hey, Mortius. I love this reaction. I don't like traditional Christmas music generally, but I can't stop listening to this one!
On a personal note, I would like to ask a favor from you. My wife of 23 1/2 years died on November 26, and her favorite Christmas song was "White Wine in the Sun" by Tim Minchin. I would absolutely love to hear your reaction to this original and quite unusual Christmas song.
Love your work!
I’m sorry for your loss. If you haven’t already seen it, Home Free has a new original song called “Christmas Ain’t For The Lonely” which you might relate to.
I’m so sorry for your loss. Best Holiday wishes and hugs to you!
I lost my husband to Covid this year, how wonderful you have a special carol that you shared with your wife. I hope he does this for you, I am not familiar with it.
@@DennisKovacich thank you, Dennis. I listened to this song this morning. I cried quite a bit, but I think it's gonna be a big holiday favorite going forward.
Fastest pause on the internet! I'm not surprised -- not when it's Geoff singing. (Please know this is NOT a criticism 🥰 I love your reactions!)
Does anyone know if there's an audible difference between 6/8 and 12/8? Because I can see it written in 12/8 to keep the 4 beats per measure like the original version in 4/4, but I don't know if there's any difference between 6/8 and 12/8 when performing. Same way with 2/4 and 4/4
The Picardy third at the very end works so very well here.
It's like "How dare you sir have so much talent, that is not allowed."
please react to queen in 5 minutes! or the little mermaid medley they’re both amazing and once again shows geoff’s amazing range
So I wanted to make one comment at the end, but you keep making me think of other things -- the mark of a good reactor! I wonder if there's a word for this: When Geoff harmonizes in those higher registers, he seems to prefer a certain set of notes, as here, with his Headless Horseman, Monster Mash, Sixteen Tons, etc. There's a similarity of harmonic intervals there, the note progressions of the parts he's singing. Is there a name for those notes he's choosing, as opposed to other notes in the chord he could have chosen? It's been years since I looked at any kind of musical theory, and I've forgotten more than I probably knew (if that's possible), but it feels like that's some category of 'shape'? Is that right?
10 months behind on the view, but I generally only like 3-5 pauses in a reaction for most reactors as they tend not to add anything. While you aren't as in-depth as Charismatic Voice, you do have something legitimate to add when you do pause to geek out about a facet of the work in general. We've probably already heard it, so it is nice to get a deeper understanding and thus gain a deeper appreciation of the work. Anyway, I hope you read old comments and know that you add value and not just mindless entertainment.
I do read old comments, so thank you! I appreciate your words
It feels kind of like 6/8 time. Takes a 2/2 and gives it rolling feel.
"It's 11PM and I'm tired and passive aggressive.' funnily enough, I'm watching this just after 11PM!
I wasn't sure you'd get through this one :) Santa was heading out the door when you were done :P Picardy third too!! And when low Geoff comes in on Joy is sounds like a THX surround system on.
The upbeat part reminds me of Trans-Siberian Orchestra Carol of the Bells. It's not exact but similar.
9:28 its actualy not a subharmonic, but the ending low note was
I didn't see you in the comments of Peter's reaction of this video. His reaction is already up. Still looking forward to a joint reaction between you two!
i cant think about a better explonation than that geoff sounds like a church organ at the end when the drums drop out the second time XD
Mr. @mortius, I really like your "Late Night" reactions.
Btw my vote is for 12/8 - it feels like four main beats to the bar, rather than two (6/8) although it might have changed during the bell-like echoing middle section
LOL...I totally smile when you get all giddy like a schoolgirl listening to Geoff. I do the same thing! I get it! lol
Trans-Siberian Orchestra type beat and he's wearing what looks like a modified Cossack style top blended with Star Trek.
Video REACTIONS usually include pauses and analysis , those that bitch and moan about it only do it to have something to be mad about.
Keep up the good work mortius.
Can't believe you showed Danny Sexbang , and Ninja Brian. They Rock!!!! Geoff is pretty impressive as well.
Its a triplet fill so its fast 6/8 where i believe the 8th note gets the beat either that or the quarter note but as far as i know its the 8th note
If you love this, PTX has a fantastic version you'll probably love too
IF THEY DON'T LIKE THAT YOU PAUSE SO MUCH THEY CAN JUST NOT WATCH YOUR VIDEOS!!! There, I took care of the haters...as you were...🥰🥰
Hello again just thought i would let you know that when instruments and vocals are together and the music drops out leaving a true acapella that is a "tacit",just thought I would help you there. My directors years at Harvard were not wasted.
I think the second section is in 6/8.
Same. The background drums give it away.
Have you reacted to Sabaton - Christmas Truce - or any Dan Vasc, including his brand new Christmas release, Angels we Have Heard On High? If not, please🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 do! Haven't listened to many of your reactions yet, but I like what I've seen.
Dude your quite a cool person
15:56 that sound was actually hilarious
The music resembles a lot to Trans-Siberian Orchestra's "Christmas Eve Sarajevo 12/24" which you should check out
What you are saying is a scoop is called a slur. I also think the time signature is 6/8. Geoff teases us by begging us to follow him down the path of a super subharmonic note, but he doesn’t. When he did go low was perfect timing.