Editorial With Sujit Nair | Does South India Feel Left Out?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2024
- In this editorial segment, Mr. Sujit Nair addresses the imbalanced allocation of funds between northern and southern Indian states, along with the upcoming delimitation and seat redistribution in Parliament. Tamil Nadu, for every rupee it contributes to the Centre receives only 29 paise in return, while Uttar Pradesh gets ₹2.73 and Bihar receives ₹7.06. The current formula used by the Fifteenth Finance Commission (XVFC) for distributing funds from the pooled-in tax collections favors certain states, leading to significant disparities. The higher weightage given to population in the formula disproportionately benefits some northern states, causing contention between the affected states and the Centre. Tamil Nadu's Finance Minister, P.T.R. Palanivel Thiagarajan, criticizes the allocation based on population, stating that it rewards states that have not effectively controlled their population.
#northsouthdivide #northindia #southindia #tamilnadu #kerala #andhrapradesh #karnataka #telangana #uttarpradesh #bihar #madhyapradesh #jharkhand #rajasthan #mkstalin #pinarayivijiyan #narendramodi #nirmalasitharaman #delimitation #gst #taxdevolution
#HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
South will be called India in future and North will be called Bharat. I 100% support India.
Well said and seems to be logical too.
Well, just because the north is not contributing in monetary terms , doesn’t mean that the north is enjoying free lunches . Lets not forget, when the entire nation was facing famines and acute food shortage, it was the north that turned the tables. And that entire ‘burden’ of making this nation food surplus was put on just 3 states - Punjab, Haryana and UP(west). The side-effects of which are haunting these states now. But do you see us blaming the south Indians for it ?
@@ravi-it3vj - South India is more corrupt. In fact the state Tamilnadu can be called the corruption capital of india. Insipte of this South India beats North in every aspect of development index
There are only three reasons.
The working class here is Hardworking, Sincere and displined.
Extraordinary focus on education studies particularly engineering and medicine and a constant endeavour to learn more.
The young are very ambitious and don't expect anything from government. Most of them aim to move out of the country for jobs.
@@ravi-it3vj - Everyone saw the wonderful development when Chennai airport was flooded and no basic disaster management was in place 🤣🤣 Same happened with Kerala in 2018
So remember, if you point a finger towards others many would be pointing towards you
@@TechWizardGinu you will never understand. that's why you will remain poorer for ever.
We want Union of South India🎉
In simple sense, South India needs
Independence with autonomous power for each and every states.
I am from Kerala, and I don't feel part of the concept of a larger nation. The votes of South Indians don't count. The taxes are not only misused, but we in the South have to bear the punishment through extreme discriminatory fiscal policies. Just take Railways for example and compare the allocations. Cooperative federalism has died. The centre has stopped GST Compensation to the states but still collects GST Compensation Cess. They have even extended the levy of the GST compensation cess till 2026, ffs!?!
For North Indians, the picture may all be rosy and saffrony. But, as a South Indian, I seriously wonder why should we continue to believe in the concept of India?
Absolutely well said and I am a Maharashtrarian from Mumbai. I can totally empathise with you!
@@kunalmore5212 it was Mumbai now it's bangaluru
Most of Keralites work outside of Kerala
@@srikudoris91 Your sentence is a random word list that floats around in a vacuum without affecting even the myru particles in the comment I made.
First create enough jobs in Kerala, Kerala people migrate to others State for unskilled jobs
Separate South India is the only solution ❤
South was always ignored whether it was UPA or BJP. If this continues it's better that the south boycott the election until a better system is in place
It is better if SOUTH INDIA becomes a separate country or some guarantees in the Constitution that will keep SOUTH INDIA and SOUTH INDIANS safe and secure from the onslaughts of hindi dominated peoples and hindi domination
@@lakshmananrajjk1989shameful
@@sameer-fk8oy
What is shameful to remain as bonded slaves pimps and impotents to hindi north or to surrender the real freedom of SOUTH INDIANS to hindi north or to simply watch the Cheatings Stealings Lootings of SOUTH INDIAN taxes earnings and revenues by hindi north or to accept all the shit filth dirt and stink of hindi north that they impose and FORCE on SOUTH
What is shameful
@@sameer-fk8oy
What is shameful
Do you want to accept all the shit dirt stink and filth of hindi north by SOUTH will that be OK
@@sameer-fk8oy
SHAME on you fellows for cheating stealing snatching swindling and Looting SOUTH INDIA & SOUTH INDIANS
Justice for South India 🇮🇳❤️
Yes, we south feel left out.. our entire representation in parliament is less than just UP+Bihar+Gujarat together.
This is a planned move by North to keep south out of power in India.
Not a plan by the north, but by the parties that can only ensure victory easily in the North.
As far as I know, every state gets equal share. When it comes to Karnataka, the state government is not using those funds on development. Instead it is using it for the populist schemes like free rice, free underwear, free gutka etc.,
Investments are done by the companies and the state has to ensure proper business environment. Infrastructure is one among them. If the state government invests on infrastructure instead of freebies, I’m sure investors will definitely come.
During SM Krishna Government, Karnataka was a business hub, why? answer is the infrastructure.
@@TechWizardGinuhe is telling about lok sabha seat numbers and here u BJP cowdung spokesperson copy pasting random shit about funding😂😂😂😂
@@TechWizardGinu You feel? Numbers, boss! That tells the story. Not your imagination and interpretation.
@@BM-cz5uz - You mean the numbers which are manipulated so that people can play victim card. We all know how these so called numbers can be manipulated. Blindfolded bigots like you won't be able to know this
We Kerala people agreed 💯
SOUTH WANTS JUSTICE. we can’t be punished for being better.
South India should boycott elections and elect their own ministries and start collecting taxes, and start build our own military
Then stop getting FDI in the name of whole India 🤡 just burning investors and high valuation dream going to collapse of all south states
Build own military 😂😂😂
True
South has to import everything, including labourers.. best of luck
I am from Bangalore and i attribute all the traffic woes in Bangalore to lack of funds. Bangalore though generates a lot of money, doesn't get back much.
Lack of funds? Do you know how much SGST state collect directly in Karnataka? Why did we need mindless freebies for everyone like Bhagyalakshmi scheme and free electricity? If the guy does not know how to utlize money, no amount of funding is going to help.
Great point. It takes in people from all over the country. There should be a national grant for improving infrastructure to accommodate the growing numbers.
Even people from neighbouring states are settling in large numbers in Bangalore as its perceived to be the happening destination
@@juPi05tEr the infrastructure issue is there since 10-15 years. Not just because of the free schemes from the recent government. Any project, be it flyover, roads, Metro, Underpass, etc takes 3X the normal time required to complete, in Bangalore. The only reason can be, lack of funds.
@@nirmalnak yeah stop crying and go get some lollypop. Politicians make money by delaying work not by making it fast. which lala land do you live in?
@@juPi05tErFreebies to the locals are more important, than the money being retained by the Crntral government and sent to States where corrupt politicians line up their own pockets with our money.
Why does every programme be named in Hindi and also required carry the photograph of 56 inch even if he has nothing to do with it like state sponsored schemes. Naming programmes in Hindi doesn’t mean anything to common citizens and villagers in the south. Even shah can’t pronounce some of the catchy labels given to the programmes.
Brutally spot on comment 😅
Shah doesn't know English that's why he want south Indians to learn hindi 😂😂
@@sinpiedad1503 not only shah , it's the majority of the north ...
A north Indian passport officer refused to speak in english and made my young daughter 19yrs old had to sweat by not only being rude but insulting young minds. She called me from inside where I was not allowed in and almost in tears. This guy was talking fast Hindi. Forcing one to talk in Hindi only in Bengaluru? This was unwarranted prejudiced terrorizing a young helpless girl.
Better to use english and dump himdi as it's not acceptable in south
Why South should feed North
Because they are made owners of the country by constitution
TN, Kerala, Karnataka, Telangana & Andhra Pradesh has contributed 22,26,983 crores to Union govt as Direct and indirect tax. 6,42,295 crores had come back to these states as devolution (which is just 1/4th of the amount sent).
On the other hand BJP governed states like (MP/UP/Rajasthan)
MP as GST for the last 5 years 3,41,817 crore, but got back 6,91,375 Crores as devolution.
WHEN COMPARED AGAINST A RUPEE PAID TO UNION GOVT. MONEY EACH STATE HAS GOT BACK.
TN : 26 paisa
Karnataka: 14 paisa
Telangana: 40 Paisa
Kerala : 62 paisa
AP : 50 Paisa
MP : 1 Rupee 70 Paisa
UP : 2 rupees 2 paisa
Rajasthan : 1 rupee 14 paisa
@@jansobieski1641 Govt employees and Neta's are there to serve the public not to dictate them !!
@@Peoplevoice09 yes you forgot Bihar
@@Peoplevoice09 do you forget that racist Arun Jaitley who was behind 15th Finance commission ?
India should NEVER have been ONE nation since it never was. It was called a sub-continant of India. Moreover the south is more cultured and educated than anything the North has to offer. Time for a re-order of " nation " or the state power.
I fully agree with you. The North Indians are boorish, vulgar, loud and aggressive. The only pity is that Modi has succeeded in vitiating the atmosphere in the South too by injecting the saffron poison. After using 'Hindu Khatre Mein Hai' and successfully building the Ram Mandir he is now aiming to poison the South. You can be very sure that if he wins this time he will focus on the South. BJP is like a weed. They have to spread for the damage to be felt. For democracy to die the BJP weed has to choke and poison the Hindus of the South.
Right 👍
❤😂🎉😢😮😅😊
😂😂😂😂.
North also bore the brunt of the attacks and invasions from foreign invaders, women raped, mass conversions, temples destroyed and south remain safe because of the resistance in North. Why don't you mention that? Adi Shankaracharya spread his words to north, south and east and west. So dont say who is more cultured and who is less cultured. and mind you, i am not a North Indian
There is already authoritarianism of North Indians in some of the Central Government departments. If the delimitation happens then nobody will ask South India and South Indians. You are absolutely right Mr Nair. It's a wake up call.
First PM kashmiri not even a freedom fighter. Many hanged like vakkom Abdul khader veluthambi dalva etc in south. Nethaji was thrown out. After 75 years no kerala or tamil PM😮😮😢😢😢
If they do this, we will fight for a separate country South India 🇮🇳
Exactly 💯 I will happen
U guys always have 5-8 Children, shut up.
Just day dream
showing true colour, is it enough that once its done
Name checks out
South India need to be a separate country.
Why do you feel leftout
@@patriots9993tum log ka dominance he central Power me
🐈⬛✨🛳️
@@patriots9993 we want
..we show u how develop nation
Not cow nation
Well said bro. There is no other solution for us, they think we are idiots and slaves
If south form their own union country, we are sure to become one of the top super power nation in next 20 years.
Nope you will be further divided by bigger powers and become a shit hole much like paxxtan or any other such trashy states
Yes South India is left out & not required in seat counts to form a Government & choose the PM, this is the reason ND MODI cared less to visit Manipur despite all the atrocities there.
NDA is in power only one state, in so called five big state in southern region of India, there they already building new capital (Amaravati), so you can rest assured it would be most beautiful capital in India.
In Tamil nadu, BJP is no where.
In Kerala, BJP is struggling for 3rd spot right now, they won their first seat in state election this time. So onus of development is on either UPA or Left alliance.
In Karnataka, their are chances BJP forming government this time., Till then for all development need people of karnataka dependent on UPA government.
@@TechWizardGinu Modi govt. failed utterly in giving what he assured to residual AP though they elected NDA2 in 2014.
Absolutely true. He can go Odissa for train accident but no time for Manipur
South India ensured that population in kept in control but north Indians producing babies like a sheep who will be brain washed into communal politics to keep BJP in power for next 100 years😢
Moreover north Indian states and sucking money from economy like a bedbug and rich south India economy has to provide poor from UP BIHAR free food through BJP government!!
Yes as a South Indian we do feel disconnected from India
Most south indians proud to the nation but injustice like no aiims in entire south but giving two aaiims to J&K is real injustice......
I'm an Indian living in Southern part and it's not disconnected
Stop imagining things
strike started today , now it will spread every corner of the nation , coz of discrimination by the ruling party , in the future may come slogans for south India.
effectively south India is funding BJP's surge in North
South will be developed very fast when divided.
@@Jesssconorth is only increasing population
All problem one solution separate south indian country.
No, 28 states should have independent country.
No matter Congress or BJP in Union Government, South especially Tamil Nadu is always left out. The idea of India is really not working.
Don't worry.
In Tamil Nadu, Annamalai is in ground from BJP.
@@shrin210 Annamalai is a North Indian Slave. He needs to suck up to Amit Shah for every decision.. Tamil should govern Tamil Nadu. We flipped bird to even Asoka. :)
@@shrin210no use
@@shrin210Haahaa..😂😂
SOUTH INDIA should be independent and will be independent soon.❤❤
Soon means within how many years??
I support it
@mdjaffarhussyou are muslim 😂😂😂ainn6266
Capital of south india ?
Dravidian nation
United Dravidian nation 👍
I Noticed the Discrimination when the
Previous Finance Commission chose
Population as the Basis of Allocation
of the Net Proceeds of Taxes. 😓
Well, just because the north is not contributing in monetary terms , doesn’t mean that the north is enjoying free lunches . Lets not forget, when the entire nation was facing famines and acute food shortage, it was the north that turned the tables. And that entire ‘burden’ of making this nation food surplus was put on just 3 states - Punjab, Haryana and UP(west). The side-effects of which are haunting these states now. But do you see us blaming the south Indians for it ?
Yes off course
TN, Kerala, Karnataka, Telangana & Andhra Pradesh has contributed 22,26,983 crores to Union govt as Direct and indirect tax. 6,42,295 crores had come back to these states as devolution (which is just 1/4th of the amount sent).
On the other hand BJP governed states like (MP/UP/Rajasthan)
MP as GST for the last 5 years 3,41,817 crore, but got back 6,91,375 Crores as devolution.
WHEN COMPARED AGAINST A RUPEE PAID TO UNION GOVT. MONEY EACH STATE HAS GOT BACK.
TN : 26 paisa
Karnataka: 14 paisa
Telangana: 40 Paisa
Kerala : 62 paisa
AP : 50 Paisa
MP : 1 Rupee 70 Paisa
UP : 2 rupees 2 paisa
Rajasthan : 1 rupee 14 paisa
PLEASE click Like and share this video so that more people from the South see this. It is VERY IMPORTANT!!! PLEASE make this video go viral in the South PLEASE!! We need to start the discussion!!
THIS IS AN EXCELLENT VIDEO!!!
THE WHOLE SOUTH NEEDS TO SEE IT!
PLEASE TELL YOUR FRIENDS AND FAMILY!!
Yes indeed education is important and population control is much more important. South achieved almost both. North nothing. 😡🤦
Only one solution. Divide india and south will be developed so fast.
Well said
Jessco I am from central government I will put you in jail for this comment NIA remember that
@@antojose6902😂
The lecture is very useful for the South Indians. We need to think of it . Every state has the same seats.
Data speaks louder than words. Well presented sir. Hope someone in the finance commission alters and do justice to all. Thank you sir.
Even culturally, the Dravidians feel dominated by Aryans.
😂😂😂😂aryans
True in the name of Sai Baba and new gods they are destroying local tamil gods🥲
Union of Southern States
Why
maybe it is time! I sick of only hearing about the North and they are so proud, they talk down to the South on social media.
@@patriots9993nortg no use
If South India separates from North, Srilanka will join.
English will be the only National/Official Language.
It will be a fantastic country.
2026 Delimitation is going to make or break of India's unity. Congress will never dare to do delimitation. But, BJP might try & withdraw eventually
@@soundar4270 no not a separate country but only little more say in matter of administration and finance
Here is a simple thumb rule to follow for Tax Distribution:
No state to receive back less than 50% of their tax paid, No state to receive more than 200% their tax paid.
This will ensure performing state are rewarded, at the same time, the backward states or disadvantaged states or the war-torn states are also helped.
Then there will be no incentive to work; people will look for loop holes on how to evade paying taxes. The right numbers should be 70% and 110% (not including special assitances)
@@janami-dharmam This is not about personal income tax. This is about distribution of tax collected from states.
Good thinking.
Well said.....
agreed
Look at the way funds are allocated in proportion to tax collection. The discrimination is clear
Have two Prime Ministers, one for the North and one for the South.
Why not 4 prime minister?
Divide North East as well.
@@shrin210yes why not if prime Minister not listening to our needs then why not
@@shrin210 s, offcourse.
Y we don’t have any prime minister or deputy prime minister from south . Power is controlled by north and funds r provided by south
The north-east feel left out since India got independence.
Thank you BJP for increasing the divide. Just cant help it, the cause to not remain as a country goes stronger each day unless people take a hard look at itself about how we conduct our affairs.
PLEASE click Like and share this video so that more people from the South see this. It is VERY IMPORTANT!!! PLEASE make this video go viral in the South PLEASE!! We need to start the discussion!!
THIS IS AN EXCELLENT VIDEO!!!
THE WHOLE SOUTH NEEDS TO SEE IT!
PLEASE TELL YOUR FRIENDS AND FAMILY!!
Annamalai is on ground from BJP.
Thank you Sujit for throwing light on this heart burning 🔥 issue - hope the whole of North is listening as Brotheren 🎉
Matter of the fact is not only south is loosing their hard earned money, south has become the livelihood for entire north indians right from Rajasthan to Orissa
😂😂😂
Yes very well said
S,true offcourse,in TN, Coimbatore has sizeable number of Gujarati people with voter ID,which will become the deciding factor in state poll.
@@ThamizhiAaseevagar in every non hindi states this is happening in Maharashtra also north indians gujju marwadi increased population and they vote for bjp
I want separate nation for south indian states which is economically free from the north india
No, 28 states should have their independent country.
@@shrin210 Do not care about cheaters.
@@tamilenusuruda7038 Same here
I think this is actually a point where people from South should think of a separate country... The United states of south india.. Hail South India
USSI? Or USSB?
Definitely we South people should know the dangerous situations.
TN minister Mr. PTR has been voicing out this GST issue for the past three years, good that this disparity is gaining momentum. The GST collection of southern states if not sent to the centre and utilized among the southern states, the southern economy would be par with developed nations in a few years.
If this has to happen, you all can easily guess what needs to be done...
South Indians are Dravidians , and should use a South Indian language for communication . All the states of south should unite together and stand against this.
Even the northeast states are suffering.
@@user-op9jx3co9c well of course genius the past few thousand years saw a lot of Intermixing but culturally we are still dravidian
Dravidian concept is a nauseating political construct that apart from a minor political class in tamil nadu, no one else in Southern india matters it... There is a means to settle things amicably... Hope northern political lobby wouldnt be that stupid to continue to be so inconsiderate to the Concerns of vast majority of south Indians...
@@Barbaric-dumilanlike you people are mixe and also migrants
This channel is openly supporting people who are against SOUTH INDIANS 👍👍
Keep it up 👆
Next republic day you can expect an award
Karnataka gets only.15p for every 1 rupee from central government, UP and Bihar gets 7 rupee for 1 rupee given. Being Bangalorean that hurts a lot 😢
Most south indians proud to the nation like me but injustice as no aiims in entire south but giving two aaiims to J&K is real injustice......
South India should be a separate Country if delimitation happens
Well said ❤
South India will protest sooner or later but need dialogue with Centre and say facts
Protest for what??
Protest for what??
@@Swarajya123
For your lack of knowledge
@@sunnybhai6161 lack of knowledge about what??😹
@@Swarajya123
Visit South India will know the facts 😅
Soon to separate countries ,south india will be called India and north india will be bharath,when highest contributing south indian states leaving,bharat will start facing consequences,sooner or later it will be collpased like pakisthan bcs of financial crisis after south indian contribution stops,we all are heading that era
Will this happen soon
Isn't it high time we woke up , faced the reality and stated a fact that the so called unity in diversity is nothing but an invalid cliche? It just doesn't exist in india. It is a fleeting mirage that appears during few minutes on certain days of the year, differently in different part of the nation. In ordinary times while traveling one often encounters experiences exemplifying how fragile the unity actually is. While you say it, it sounds kinda nice that the color, sounds, smell and tast of india is mesmerizing. In actuality Color is garish , Sound is too loud and uncomfortable, Smell is actually stench and Taste is monotonous and unbearably spicy. We bear it with conviction that everything is fine just to cover up our discomfort. 99.9 percent of the tourist would scream that india was a fantastic experience citing the onslaught on the senses. Ask them in private if they would want to come back and the answer would be " actually no ". High time we called a spade a spade. Nothing is alright in india currently.
your inner bias will never understand the concept of a nation.
@@ravi-it3vjhe is talking about the current situation of our nation. If u can't see that, may be u r biased.
Only thing I don't agree with is him telling about the food being too spicy everywhere.
For the distribution of resources, India is essentially built on the model of a welfare state. So the govt. is bound to put its resources in the areas where they are needed the most
@@TechWizardGinu but not at the cost of other state's interest. cess is meant for emergency purposes. This is the first time cess is used to increase centre share thus depriving other states share.
TN, Kerala, Karnataka, Telangana & Andhra Pradesh has contributed 22,26,983 crores to Union govt as Direct and indirect tax. 6,42,295 crores had come back to these states as devolution (which is just 1/4th of the amount sent).
On the other hand BJP governed states like (MP/UP/Rajasthan)
MP as GST for the last 5 years 3,41,817 crore, but got back 6,91,375 Crores as devolution.
WHEN COMPARED AGAINST A RUPEE PAID TO UNION GOVT. MONEY EACH STATE HAS GOT BACK.
TN : 26 paisa
Karnataka: 14 paisa
Telangana: 40 Paisa
Kerala : 62 paisa
AP : 50 Paisa
MP : 1 Rupee 70 Paisa
UP : 2 rupees 2 paisa
Rajasthan : 1 rupee 14 paisa
It is high time that South takes action. Not accepted at all. Also PM post most of the time from North.
Problem is not just TN, Kerala, Karnataka and Telangana getting less. Problem is also how Bihar, UP and Rajasthan are utilising the money and how are they ensured to deliver for what they are over utilising today. We see nothing on this line - “Absolutely Nothing “. The way things are running looks like irresponsible kids of the family. If the financial ‘delivery’ part is not owned by Finance commission and south is not appraised of this ‘delivery’ status and explained why Gujarat and Maharashtra are not on par to south in contributors, then we can naturally expect a revolution to happen from south and they getting branded as usually as “AntyIndian”.
💯
Excellence observation and clear presentation. It’s a fact that the South feel left out for reasons rightly pointed out by you. Expect more success such works from you.
In the past its was british colonialism, now it's north indian colonialism. Wake up south india. Let's fight for our identity and freedom
Excellent and well researched article by Sujit. South India is taken for granted 😢
The biggest plunder what our ancestors did was they failed to have a seperate partition during 1947 time ...two ethnic communities living together is a big problem North India always undermined South India....even today its good to seperate south India for the betterment of south.otherwise it will fall victim to constant attempt from North to destroy sothern culture and language.....how peacefully it can be done without violance some UN monitored Annexatiion .....look TN contributes a lot to the GDP of India but they got nothing as a relief for a recent storm damages...our resources are drainning....recent North governors revolt against state anthem all shows how hatred thwy are towards south
Not only South , sir we Bengalis from West Bengal have also started feeling disconnected from India.
Yes. Defence huge supplies they got
This will ensure worthwhile candidates from South to become ministers who can develop everyone to prosper.
Thank you for understanding our feelings ❤
THIS IS AN EXCELLENT VIDEO!!!
THE WHOLE SOUTH NEEDS TO SEE IT!
PLEASE TELL YOUR FRIENDS AND FAMILY!!
South already know these things. Ask northerners see and understand the issue.
Yes
North East needs to make their own country as well.
Even today the Cow belt loots the Taxes of South India. This loot will increase after 2026.
Hindi states are burden on Maharashtra south india bengal punjab
maharashtra inner feeling: please add us in part of south india 😅❤
U guys raise out your voice think about it spread it bcz u r the first richest state in India
If the south becomes a separate country, it will be Europe. UP will be Somalia.
Voted for Modi twice not going to vote this time ..coz I travelled north India and I can see the developmental work going on their and in the south we r completely ignored
It is fault of State Govt for not building infrastructure.
Modi can't force infrastructure.
We the people of the South as part of this whole union are ready and responsible to provide for those who need the most. But the problem is we have been providing the needy states for the last 75 years, yet they are not improving and my question is what have they been doing with these funds for all these years? I am not saying that Southern states doing perfectly but they are doing way better than Northern states with limited funds they have. We have improved socially, and we have control over our population, but what happening now is we are being penalized for those achievements we made down here.
Most south indians proud to the nation like me but injustice as no aiims in entire south but giving two aaiims to J&K is real injustice......
Only thing left is to ask for a separate country
Major points/issues/concerns highlighted by Sujit ji which every south indian echoes.
As long as the south stands strong India will stay balanced. We in NE know wat is to be truly left out and our existence ignored. South bros stay strong 💪. Peace
If this continues like this one day North and South will form seperate country. How north and south korea operates. North will rule by Dictator Modi similar to North Korea Kim jong un, south will rule by some educated and secular leader... Please note down this....
😂modi Kim jong😂
Number of MPs must be decided on the basis of states collective IQ.
you mean UP and Bihar will have no seats😂
@@amjadkhan474we mean muslim will have zero representations after 2026😂😂😂😂
says a muslim lol @@amjadkhan474
The bigger states like UP, etc., should be made into smaller units.
All advanced states are working for UP,Bihar and north .
Are we fools like…,, we South should wake up and it is better if we are detached from North India We can develop our South States and progress better. Why should we work hard and pay for those who don’t even try to work hard and earn their living in North itself.
Sujith Sir …. You have really Awakened the South but for no use with this adament Govt.😩😩😩😩
TN, Kerala, Karnataka, Telangana & Andhra Pradesh has contributed 22,26,983 crores to Union govt as Direct and indirect tax. 6,42,295 crores had come back to these states as devolution (which is just 1/4th of the amount sent).
On the other hand BJP governed states like (MP/UP/Rajasthan)
MP as GST for the last 5 years 3,41,817 crore, but got back 6,91,375 Crores as devolution.
WHEN COMPARED AGAINST A RUPEE PAID TO UNION GOVT. MONEY EACH STATE HAS GOT BACK.
TN : 26 paisa
Karnataka: 14 paisa
Telangana: 40 Paisa
Kerala : 62 paisa
AP : 50 Paisa
MP : 1 Rupee 70 Paisa
UP : 2 rupees 2 paisa
Rajasthan : 1 rupee 14 paisa
We Maharashtrian are with South we want our atleast 50% tax back for our own development.
@GIGADEV690 irrespective of the state, we are asking the ROI for the tax money contributed to Union govt.
It's the state government that can use this money to build projects that directly benefit the people of that state.
As an Indian from the south, i think the burning need of the hour, is a drastic change to the political system to ensure that all states are treated fairly. It should be done by a constituted panel of experts who have a deep understanding and far reaching vision.
The tone of south versus north is dangerous to the unity of Bharath, which has been very similar culturally since ancient times, though we were united as India politically much later.
Jai Hind
Sujit saab ..something is happening/being done with purpose in India which her own people are not realizing...its so unfortunate for this beautiful country's prospect
The South should take a step before the 2024 election...
The North South divide existed yesterday, today and it will always exist. There is diversity, but there is no unity. The unity is done with the baton, by force. It is by force that the territory is safeguarded. South has always been left out, in all the aspects. And thanks to your permutations and combinations
North East should be divided as well from India.
TN, Kerala, Karnataka, Telangana & Andhra Pradesh has contributed 22,26,983 crores to Union govt as Direct and indirect tax. 6,42,295 crores had come back to these states as devolution (which is just 1/4th of the amount sent).
On the other hand BJP governed states like (MP/UP/Rajasthan)
MP as GST for the last 5 years 3,41,817 crore, but got back 6,91,375 Crores as devolution.
WHEN COMPARED AGAINST A RUPEE PAID TO UNION GOVT. MONEY EACH STATE HAS GOT BACK.
TN : 26 paisa
Karnataka: 14 paisa
Telangana: 40 Paisa
Kerala : 62 paisa
AP : 50 Paisa
MP : 1 Rupee 70 Paisa
UP : 2 rupees 2 paisa
Rajasthan : 1 rupee 14 paisa
Do north really thinking hindi is a national language? Im repeating again there is no national language in india..Every Languages are regional languages
One more point needs to be added, the extra money being pumped into UP and Bihar is not being reflected in terms of development of the two states. If there was proportional development, then it could be justifiable and there could be some satisfaction with a hope that sooner or later there shall be an equitable position between the states. But that is not happening! Where is that money being drained!?
Well analysts excellent brother an eye opener and fantastic whistleblower
Salute man 🫡🫡🫡🫡🏴👍
Very interesting! Thank you!
Loot South and feed cow belt
We keralaits became fools by decreasing population
we used to have 12 brothers in my dads generation, now we have one or two child in each house, its because not that we cannot, it because we respected the decision, this is inhuman
Absolutely South is left out. Checking the facts and figures. If this persists South might form a separate country.
I don’t know who you are but your analysis it’s mind blowing and thundering keep doing will support democracy which is mother india 🇮🇳 😍😘🥳🥳🥳🏴🙏🏽💪🏾
In response to southern states allegations FM said bjp gave more than UPA,but she didn't menrion how much central received from these states,what is % of received amount given to states. What a half statement.also there is no gst on that time states collected sales tax which directly gone to State.
Wonderful analysis much appreciated 🙏
South India is like a colony for central government. They collect taxes in big amount, but doesn't allocate the fair share to the region.
Already south is better than north in many social indicators. I can only imagine how better it would have been if south was treated right. I believe in individual freedom. You don't feel Nationalism when you feel left out of of the nation. In my opinion Pakistan and Bangladesh should have been part of India ,And
Provinces like Hyderabad,Madras,Travacore etc should have been a independent entity. What good federalism when some states are ignored. I don't know how to solve this, but south deserve far better than this. I don't know maybe in future there will be another country.
More federalism and devolution of powers is the answer. Except defence and external affairs, all other aspects should be under state government control.
100% right
Defence all jobs north getting. So all air bases must be in deccan.
Centre -10% power
States -90% power
You made Southern state point beautifully❤
South india must get #Independence from 🐄 💩 north before ModiXi enforces
One language
One clothing
One food
One bank
One industrialist duo
One telephone
One syllabus
One university (whatsapp)
One religion
One caste
&
Zero representation of south india
Minimal budget to south india.
I dare andh bhakts to comment without using religion
Fantastic editorial thanks
As a person from South India, there are sentiments and aspirations within certain segments of the population regarding regional autonomy or greater decentralization within the Indian federal structure. These sentiments stem from a desire to address perceived socio-economic disparities and to ensure effective governance tailored to the unique cultural and linguistic characteristics of the region.
South India would be on par with developed countries like US and EU if they got back all the tax collected from them, it's North India that's pulling down South India and that's a fact.
We Indians are diversed in many ways it doesn't mean Take from My Pocket to give Others kept me Empty.
Even a family system distribution of funds is a challenge by equally. So assume a country co existing of cultural diversity, languages, religious beliefs etc.
So the power Equality and divident shares of Fund allocation should be transparent as well as integrity.
Here the divisive policy raises allocation of funds amongst states based on performance. South Indian states are performed in all development aspects comparatively other regions.
That doesn't mean using our growth and insisting us to feed always North. There is a time limit for every growth. Due to uncertain political agenda of North people are moving backwards and it gets impact on overall growth of our country. It directly hits our funds goes in waste warehouse. Otherwise we are getting struggle to receive that funds for our natural calamity and rebuild us .
Howmany times we requested Union Government to provide us immediate cause. But nothing happened in Ground on allocating any fund.
This raises natural tension amongst People who knows the system how functions it.
Union Government runs basically from state funds. There is no any direct sources for developing finance by Union Government. They are having only resources from state government bodies. If uniform growth from states in all financial aspects Union Government will get taxes from them to run a County.
Tamilnadu one of the people welfare and socio economics builds in nature by people's and covering all the investment complying industrial infrastructure development. This causes mainly to attract investors to investment.
But deliberately collapsing the system by Finance Minister taking into power head saying all the complaints against state bodies. She never even talk politely by nature and insisting ruling power on us.
She doesn't know how the system functions in South compare to North. She has only eligibility a community background which always thinks that.
Many projects has been kept hold due to insufficient of funds. People welfare fund and social care will get struggle by this People's. We are naturally bonding by welfare schemes which promotes indirectly spending economics to run the industrial sector. There is no need for Union Government to rule us.
Please leave us as we wish to run the government by the effective process You guys take defensive fund from us and protect borders.
That's it. Enough is Enough.
Hi Sujt thanks for time on ur saloon .
Brilliant work . 👏👏👏 . Hope south india wakes up .
thanks for discussing this topic.
We should dismantle the MPs ratio based on Population and define the percentage of difference between the Top voted MP and Lowest Voted MP candidate.