I'm sure there are some good parts, but I'm 4 minutes in and already there is one bit I disagree with, although it is a bit of nuance. A true faithful service, though, would not skip this important part of the story. It is quite relevant and has echoes into today. One of the key incidents that led up to the revolution was the Boston Tea party, which lends its name to the modern branch of the Republican Party, however its interesting that the goal of the two are not similar. The Boston Tea party was not a protest against the Tea tax. The tea tax was used to pay for the French and Indian war, which the colonists largely appreciated. Colonists at the time mostly considered themselves English citizens and enjoyed the safety the crown offered. What they objected to was not the actual tax, but the tax exemptions given to the largest international company of its time, the British East India Trading Company. They object to the tax breaks given ti the ultra rich, not the tax itself. This is well documented, but not spoken about in today's corporate sponsored education system. The modern Tea Party movement has it backwards.
It can’t be understated how incredibly difficult it was for Knox to move the cannons from north of Saratoga to Boston. Crossing two of the major rivers of the northeast, countless smaller rivers, around or over mountains, hills and long ridges. He had to take an extraordinarily long route to avoid the green mountains and the mountains of southern NH and northern Massachusetts. If you know the ground, you can’t help but marvel at the effort and success. An absolutely pivotal operation.
Wish I knew more about this incredible effort. I've been to Lake Champlain and down through VT/ Massachusetts Berkshires. My sense is that he was aided by frozen rivers/lakes. But those mountains, the biting cold, the general terrain. Questions I wonder about: did he have an Indian guides, anybody succumb to the cold, how many people brought cannons down, how did they get food to sustain themselves, etc. It turned the tide. Boston was the first city to become free.
I'm from and live in New Zealand but I've always had massive passion for history of the American Revolution. It is superb to see such a faithful account of the political landscape and field battles that shaped the war Well done sir!
Perfect treat just shy of July 4th. Thanks for the balanced analysis; it was a hard-fought campaign on both sides, and both sides had exceptional displays of tactical and strategic excellence marred by very understandable blunders. Those who ridicule either side heavy-handedly underestimate the difficulties of traversing the east coast's terrain and gathering sufficient intelligence for sound decision-making. As someone who lived and grew up near Boston, it's a wonder that the Brits managed to fend off the colonial militias at all when they had been so forewarned and organized. Superb training and the valour of relief forces kept Lexington and Concord from turning into a small-scale disaster. In any modern conflict (God forbid), an attacking force would suffer appalling casualties against determined resistance (a few machineguns and short-range anti-armor teams would wreak havoc in the interior of Massachusetts), whereas these crazy SOBs were fighting uphill in wool uniforms and in the face of concentrated fire.
Thanks! Completely agree, both sides showed tremendous bravery. The entire conflict is fascinating and harrowing. Next episode will cover the Invasion of Canada, another story with incredible feats from both armies
@@HistoryRebelshey man, I know this is out of left field, but can you find any in depth information about the battle of Munda point? It happened in WW2 on Bougainville, Solomon Islands. My great grandma’s first husband died there. Without this battle, I don’t exist. Food for thought. Either way, thank you for your content.
Fantastic! This just might be the best Bunker Hill video I’ve ever seen! Excellent job! 🇺🇸 🇬🇧 John Stark’s New Hampshire militia displayed an incredible level of discipline during Bunker Hill. While many of the New England militiamen would have been veterans of the French and Indian War, many were younger men who had never tasted battle before. It’s not at all easy for an untrained man to stand firm against experienced, trained soldiers - men who are well drilled, trained and paid to kill, have done so, and are much better at it than you. Stark, his officers and NCO’s had enough control and trust over their men where the Royal Welch (a top of the line grenadier unit with quite the reputation, mind you) were practically on top of them, and none of them tried to flee or fire preemptively. The end result was that, when the order to fire was given, they routed the Royal Welch in a single volley. That wasn’t a very common occurrence in 18th Century warfare. Bravo, gentlemen!
Absolutely love this. Cant wait for the next episode. As an American i really appreciate how accurate this history is . Keep it up looking forward to this channel to grow .
This is absolutley amazing. More please. Love how you manage to switch between an explaination of the international politics driving the conflict & a detailed tatical view of the individual battles themselves so seamlessly. Cant wait for the next ep!
Another well done. I look forward to the entire series. I'm near a key point of Knox' Trail [and Washington's Springfield Armory] and am well versed in the New England history of the revolution but you're including some details that I yet hadn't known.
I love these History Marche and Epic History inspired channels, its awesome to see. All the best to you man I'm enjoying this video right now. Good luck!
I see you draw a lot of your inspiration from Epic History TV, which is my favorite documentary channel from the Napoleonic Era as a Frenchman living in Boston. I have always wanted that channel to do something with the Revolutionary War... then I came across your channel a few moment ago - I am so glad! You earned a new subscriber!
Having been raised in a decidedly American and New York tradition, it’s great to hear a more considered assessment. Surprisingly then as now it seems politicians screwed things beyond redemption. Your research is nicely detailed.
These are just superbly done. Great narration, excellent use of details and numbers. Demonstrating the basics of warfare at that time is an excellent touch to instruct those unfamiliar with the concepts and thus begins to teach new generations unfamiliar with this historical period. It’s my understanding that these subjects are (or already have) becoming less and less areas of teaching in schools. It is truly sad to see college level students not being able to answer even the most basic questions on their own country’s history which has led to the veery way of how they live compared to other areas of the world. But back to my main point, these are excellent historical videos and done superbly. I can’t wait to see more. Thank you
I have to say this might be the best analysis of the Battle of Bunker Hill I have seen. I know many things about The Revolutionary War it intrigues me so, but I think I have such a better understanding of the Battle from your video WELL DONE. This was done in such high quality.
This is the best video and most detailed Ive seen on one of my favorite battles of the American Revolution! You are amazing, and in a few months youll have hundreds of thousands of subscribers! Thank you and never stop!
Proud to say that my 5th great grandfather served in Washington's colonial army. Sadly, he didn't survive the winter at Valley Forge and succumbed to disease...likely dysentery. Jacob Eckman. Haven't officially done it yet but, I am a Son of the Revolution and...I think thats really cool!
Subscribed. A channel finally does a Epic History/Historymarche style series on the American Revolution! Can't wait to see what the future of the channel will look like when this is complete.
Just finished watching the second episode the visuals are great the narration is interesting, detailed and keeps you engaged throughout the episode overall incredibly well made looking forward to seeing the next episode
Well done. Few videos on this even make the distinction between Breed's & Bunker Hill. It really should be referred to as the Battle of Breed's Hill, in all honesty.
Never stop making content, no one has really done such amazing documentaries on the Revolutionary war. You just started but your videos are amazing! Keep up the good work mate and here’s another subscriber for you!
Well done, authors. Your historical research has paid off. All Americans need to understand the history of the Revolutionary War. Thanks, LTC Rick Keilig Jr. MS USAR (R)
Just wanted to leave a comment before your channel explodes! All tho the American revolution gets talk about a lot it very rarely get covered in such detail great work so far can’t wait for more so glad I have a new history channel to look forward too!
Just a note: The Marines were not granted the title "Royal" until 1802. To that year they were titled His Majesty's Marine Forces and wore white uniform facings (rather than the blue of "Royal" regiments).
This is very good. The only thing I might add to it is that the defenses of Dorchester Heights were largely created out of sight and then moved there and set up at night, rather quietly. They were probably fairly thin and, indeed, more apparent than real, but after Bunker Hill, Howe was never again willing to conduct a bloody frontal assault on the colonials.
I always wished there was a Video in detail about the American Revolution, Like how there are so Many for Napoleon and Other European wars. And Finally theres a Wonderful Video on The Revolution! I hope you make this into a series!
Very well done. One tiny flaw - When Howe evacuated Boston, he did not sail to New York City as you show. He went to Halifax, Nova Scotia. It was Washington who took his forces to New York City.
I can’t think of any way this video could have been better. The best explanation/visualisation I’ve seen on the subject. Some interesting comments too.
Interesting contrast in the hunting culture of the colonials given the edge in marksmanship, and the direct action of hand to hand with the British regulars.
Very good video. The one bit of advice I would offer is to either cut down on the number of quotes you use between segments or atleast space them out a bit more.
This is an excellent brief with excellent video graphics demonstrating the manuaver portions of the battle. The post battle analysis is a great footnote.
Morbid fact: two of the senior most British officers on the field at Bunker Hill (Pitcairn & Abercrombie), were both killed by former slaves (Peter Salem & Salem Poor).
Finally someone does a faithful series on the revolution. Well done sir!
He did very well woth hunker hill.
Are you British?
@@becnvhmarker3964 American
Very well done. Excellent graphics!!!
I'm sure there are some good parts, but I'm 4 minutes in and already there is one bit I disagree with, although it is a bit of nuance. A true faithful service, though, would not skip this important part of the story. It is quite relevant and has echoes into today.
One of the key incidents that led up to the revolution was the Boston Tea party, which lends its name to the modern branch of the Republican Party, however its interesting that the goal of the two are not similar.
The Boston Tea party was not a protest against the Tea tax. The tea tax was used to pay for the French and Indian war, which the colonists largely appreciated. Colonists at the time mostly considered themselves English citizens and enjoyed the safety the crown offered. What they objected to was not the actual tax, but the tax exemptions given to the largest international company of its time, the British East India Trading Company. They object to the tax breaks given ti the ultra rich, not the tax itself. This is well documented, but not spoken about in today's corporate sponsored education system. The modern Tea Party movement has it backwards.
It can’t be understated how incredibly difficult it was for Knox to move the cannons from north of Saratoga to Boston. Crossing two of the major rivers of the northeast, countless smaller rivers, around or over mountains, hills and long ridges. He had to take an extraordinarily long route to avoid the green mountains and the mountains of southern NH and northern Massachusetts. If you know the ground, you can’t help but marvel at the effort and success. An absolutely pivotal operation.
"Where a goat can go a man can go, and where a man can go, he can drag a gun"
Have often thought that driving up and down 87N
Wish I knew more about this incredible effort. I've been to Lake Champlain and down through VT/ Massachusetts Berkshires. My sense is that he was aided by frozen rivers/lakes. But those mountains, the biting cold, the general terrain.
Questions I wonder about: did he have an Indian guides, anybody succumb to the cold, how many people brought cannons down, how did they get food to sustain themselves, etc.
It turned the tide. Boston was the first city to become free.
Very good point! In the snow with poor roads, rivers, mountains, poor food, and cold, it is a miracle they did it.
I'm from and live in New Zealand but I've always had massive passion for history of the American Revolution. It is superb to see such a faithful account of the political landscape and field battles that shaped the war
Well done sir!
Perfect treat just shy of July 4th. Thanks for the balanced analysis; it was a hard-fought campaign on both sides, and both sides had exceptional displays of tactical and strategic excellence marred by very understandable blunders. Those who ridicule either side heavy-handedly underestimate the difficulties of traversing the east coast's terrain and gathering sufficient intelligence for sound decision-making. As someone who lived and grew up near Boston, it's a wonder that the Brits managed to fend off the colonial militias at all when they had been so forewarned and organized. Superb training and the valour of relief forces kept Lexington and Concord from turning into a small-scale disaster.
In any modern conflict (God forbid), an attacking force would suffer appalling casualties against determined resistance (a few machineguns and short-range anti-armor teams would wreak havoc in the interior of Massachusetts), whereas these crazy SOBs were fighting uphill in wool uniforms and in the face of concentrated fire.
Thanks! Completely agree, both sides showed tremendous bravery. The entire conflict is fascinating and harrowing. Next episode will cover the Invasion of Canada, another story with incredible feats from both armies
@@HistoryRebelshey man, I know this is out of left field, but can you find any in depth information about the battle of Munda point? It happened in WW2 on Bougainville, Solomon Islands. My great grandma’s first husband died there. Without this battle, I don’t exist. Food for thought. Either way, thank you for your content.
@@VespasianJudeakings and generals has a series on the ENTIRE Pacific war
@@ethansmith8813
You’s a series bih
@@ethansmith8813
I’ll check it out. Ty
Fantastic! This just might be the best Bunker Hill video I’ve ever seen! Excellent job! 🇺🇸 🇬🇧
John Stark’s New Hampshire militia displayed an incredible level of discipline during Bunker Hill. While many of the New England militiamen would have been veterans of the French and Indian War, many were younger men who had never tasted battle before. It’s not at all easy for an untrained man to stand firm against experienced, trained soldiers - men who are well drilled, trained and paid to kill, have done so, and are much better at it than you.
Stark, his officers and NCO’s had enough control and trust over their men where the Royal Welch (a top of the line grenadier unit with quite the reputation, mind you) were practically on top of them, and none of them tried to flee or fire preemptively. The end result was that, when the order to fire was given, they routed the Royal Welch in a single volley. That wasn’t a very common occurrence in 18th Century warfare.
Bravo, gentlemen!
Absolutely love this. Cant wait for the next episode. As an American i really appreciate how accurate this history is . Keep it up looking forward to this channel to grow .
Thank you Mark, that's really appreciated. Next video should be out next week!
This is absolutley amazing. More please.
Love how you manage to switch between an explaination of the international politics driving the conflict & a detailed tatical view of the individual battles themselves so seamlessly.
Cant wait for the next ep!
Thanks you for the feedback! Really appreciated. Next episode out in 4 weeks time 💪🏻
How does this only have 3K subs? This is as good or better than the HistoryMarche I just watched.
The Chanel was only started a month ago so that's probably why
Have Vlogging Through History do a reaction to it. He helped Decades reach over 10k subs in a few days!
Awesome work! I love how you give a non-sensationalized version of the war which, ironically, misses out on so much of it. You've earned a subscriber.
Thanks FieldMarshal, that's what we were going for! And as a fan of your channel, that's really appreciated
Another well done. I look forward to the entire series. I'm near a key point of Knox' Trail [and Washington's Springfield Armory] and am well versed in the New England history of the revolution but you're including some details that I yet hadn't known.
Great Job Bro.
This was truly exceptional.. well done.. and I learned much. Thank You and Keep Up The Awesome Work. James C.
I love these History Marche and Epic History inspired channels, its awesome to see.
All the best to you man I'm enjoying this video right now.
Good luck!
Excellent lesson on this pivotal battle!
I’ve been waiting for someone to cover the American Revolution, keep it up!
I see you draw a lot of your inspiration from Epic History TV, which is my favorite documentary channel from the Napoleonic Era as a Frenchman living in Boston. I have always wanted that channel to do something with the Revolutionary War... then I came across your channel a few moment ago - I am so glad! You earned a new subscriber!
Having been raised in a decidedly American and New York tradition, it’s great to hear a more considered assessment. Surprisingly then as now it seems politicians screwed things beyond redemption. Your research is nicely detailed.
Bro this is so well done. Keep up the good work
Absolutely fantastic! I've done a revolutionary war video on my own channel, but this one goes above and beyond!
Thanks Snave - I just checked out your video too, it's great!
This is superb quality for such a new channel. Congratulations on the success.
These are just superbly done. Great narration, excellent use of details and numbers. Demonstrating the basics of warfare at that time is an excellent touch to instruct those unfamiliar with the concepts and thus begins to teach new generations unfamiliar with this historical period. It’s my understanding that these subjects are (or already have) becoming less and less areas of teaching in schools. It is truly sad to see college level students not being able to answer even the most basic questions on their own country’s history which has led to the veery way of how they live compared to other areas of the world. But back to my main point, these are excellent historical videos and done superbly. I can’t wait to see more. Thank you
I have to say this might be the best analysis of the Battle of Bunker Hill I have seen. I know many things about The Revolutionary War it intrigues me so, but I think I have such a better understanding of the Battle from your video WELL DONE. This was done in such high quality.
This is the best video and most detailed Ive seen on one of my favorite battles of the American Revolution! You are amazing, and in a few months youll have hundreds of thousands of subscribers! Thank you and never stop!
I dont find a single movie were i could see this battle even in english,now is detailed here tank you só much for this
Proud to say that my 5th great grandfather served in Washington's colonial army. Sadly, he didn't survive the winter at Valley Forge and succumbed to disease...likely dysentery. Jacob Eckman. Haven't officially done it yet but, I am a Son of the Revolution and...I think thats really cool!
Yes, but he left his seed, his legacy.... Job's a good'un, we now get to hear his story from his descendant.
One if my family did too. He was at the same place but didn't stay throughout winter. His name 1Sgt Robert lemon Sr
Descendent of Ensign Bradley Richards here - officer under Washington
@@henryrichards1556 Nice! My ancestor was just a rank and file soldier. Likely died of dysentery at Valley Forge. Proud...none the less!
I too have ancestors who bled and died in the Revolution.
This is very Good!
The gun model shown at 11:00 is a percussion cap btw
So what.
Because percussion locks didn't exist until sometime around 1810. This is either a converted flintlock or a much later gun.
And again our founding fathers put out well with 2 to 1 against Britain! Thank you for the great history lessons
fantastic video and channel. Very well made and entertaining. Lots of details that I have not heard before. Looking forward to seeing more!
LOVE THE VIDEO! Absolutely crushed it! Keep them coming!
Keep it up bro. And also remember me when you get famous ❤
Thanks for the encouragement, means a lot!
This is awesome, I’ve been trying to find a series on the American Revolution, I’m hyped 👀
Subscribed. A channel finally does a Epic History/Historymarche style series on the American Revolution! Can't wait to see what the future of the channel will look like when this is complete.
Great video, I drive a concrete mixer in Boston just did a condo on Bunker Hill, my how times hav changed!
Newport R.I. is one word. Great video !!
Thanks! Updated for the latest video
commenting for the algorithm. good stuff, makes me interested where I was previously uninterested
The algorithm brought me here , I am glad it did 👍🏻
Keep up the good work
Just finished watching the second episode the visuals are great the narration is interesting, detailed and keeps you engaged throughout the episode overall incredibly well made looking forward to seeing the next episode
Very well done! Looking forward to the rest of the series. Subscribed.
Watched both vids, love the series. Subscribed and shared to friends, please continue to grow and release videos!
Well done. Few videos on this even make the distinction between Breed's & Bunker Hill.
It really should be referred to as the Battle of Breed's Hill, in all honesty.
Very well done! Looking forward to the rest of the series. Subscribed.. Very well done! Looking forward to the rest of the series. Subscribed..
I sure do hope that you are able to continue making episodes. The format of your videos is quite informative and interesting. LIKED AND SUBSCRIBED!!
Thanks for the feedback! Next episode out in about one week 💪🏻
very good
We need a video about the Battle of Fort Ticonderoga.
Animation quality of the battles is very good
Appreciated!
@@HistoryRebelswhen does the next episode drop. This is the best revolutionary series thus far. And these types of channels are all I watch
@@ethansmith8813 thank you! It should be in about 3 weeks or less, with an early release on Patreon. Animating it as we speak!
@@HistoryRebels niceee. I'll be watching every one of them
Never stop making content, no one has really done such amazing documentaries on the Revolutionary war. You just started but your videos are amazing! Keep up the good work mate and here’s another subscriber for you!
Well done
You are killing it bro. Just saw your chanell from the post of Historymarche. By the way are you planning on doing videos on medevial history?
The best documentaries on the American War of Independence I’ve seen , thank you and well done! 🇬🇧🇺🇸
Brilliantly done! I was captivated throughout.
Well done, authors. Your historical research has paid off. All Americans need to understand the history of the Revolutionary War. Thanks, LTC Rick Keilig Jr. MS USAR (R)
I hope one day this channel gets the recognition that It needs. .
Just wanted to leave a comment before your channel explodes! All tho the American revolution gets talk about a lot it very rarely get covered in such detail great work so far can’t wait for more so glad I have a new history channel to look forward too!
Just a note: The Marines were not granted the title "Royal" until 1802. To that year they were titled His Majesty's Marine Forces and wore white uniform facings (rather than the blue of "Royal" regiments).
Well spotted, and noted for future videos. Thanks!
Amazing quality another amazing channel on history can’t wait for more videos.
This is very good. The only thing I might add to it is that the defenses of Dorchester Heights were largely created out of sight and then moved there and set up at night, rather quietly. They were probably fairly thin and, indeed, more apparent than real, but after Bunker Hill, Howe was never again willing to conduct a bloody frontal assault on the colonials.
Great job I hope you keep up the series!!!
I always wished there was a Video in detail about the American Revolution, Like how there are so Many for Napoleon and Other European wars. And Finally theres a Wonderful Video on The Revolution! I hope you make this into a series!
Thank you! I'm planning on approximately 15 episodes - the next one should be released next week (ish)
Really great. Thank you
Very good made , very good analyses.......please more of this style.....
Brilliant! Absolutely bloody brilliant!!! Every video in this series is outstanding. Cheers from Tennessee
I watch a ton of these type of videos. Let me tell you, these are excellent I am proud to be a new subscriber
Love it - keep up the great work!
Subbed at video title. Great channel
Good video. In the future please do one on the king Phillips war
Terrific job guy! Looking forward to more of these videos
Well done. I much enjoyed it.
Very well done.
One tiny flaw - When Howe evacuated Boston, he did not sail to New York City as you show. He went to Halifax, Nova Scotia. It was Washington who took his forces to New York City.
Well spotted! This was to help the flow of the story - but we get it right at the end of the next episode and show them moving from Halifax :)
Really enjoyed the video.
thank you for sharing! amazing.
Incredible work. Subbed so I can catch the next one!
Splendid!
Love your videos. Please keep them coming. Hopefully can see one on Brandywine and Yorktown.
Wonderful job on this
This was great, just found the channel. Thank you, it was well researched and a non stop watch!
Just stumbled across this and I'm very happy I did, Subscribed and looking forward to the series!
Edit: If possible please cover the battle of Cowpens
Awesome work!! 🇺🇲
Loved the presentation. I watched your video about Lexington and Concord over on the VTH channel and was directed to here. Great job!
Keep up the good work
Subscribed! Cant wait for more content!
Love the details. Keep them coming
I can’t think of any way this video could have been better. The best explanation/visualisation I’ve seen on the subject.
Some interesting comments too.
I can see the influences from Epic History TV here. This is very well done, subbed.
Interesting contrast in the hunting culture of the colonials given the edge in marksmanship, and the direct action of hand to hand with the British regulars.
This is sick bro, keep it up, I love the animation and quality of the videos
Thank you! Next episode coming soon
You guys have yourselves another subscriber 👍
Can't believe I haven't found this channel before. Subbed!
These are excellent videos!
New sub man i like your content
Good work
Loved it.
This really was excellently done.
im just glad that we all agree that tea belongs in the harbor.
Very good video. The one bit of advice I would offer is to either cut down on the number of quotes you use between segments or atleast space them out a bit more.
Thanks, taken on board for the next episode!
For the algorithm
No, for ME!
no.
This is an excellent brief with excellent video graphics demonstrating the manuaver portions of the battle. The post battle analysis is a great footnote.
Need more of this cuz i won't have enou' 🦅🇺🇲
outstanding video
By god man fantastic work
Morbid fact: two of the senior most British officers on the field at Bunker Hill (Pitcairn & Abercrombie), were both killed by former slaves (Peter Salem & Salem Poor).