DJI vs RODE vs Comica vs Hollyland - Which Wireless Mic is Best for You?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ก.ค. 2024
- DJI vs RODE vs Comica vs Hollyland - Which Wireless Mic is Best for You?
In this video, we compare the new Comica Vimo C3 to the DJI Mic to the Rode Wireless Go II and the Hollyland Lark M1 microphones. I did not adjust the audio in post - so you can hear the exact way each mic sounds.
All the systems come with two mics, removable windscreens, and charging cables. The DJI, Comica and Hollyland come with a nice case that also charges the mics. Though the wind muffs and cables do not fit into either case (would be great if they did!)
The DJI, Comica and Rode have easy-to-read screens, so you know the audio levels. The Hollyland does not, though you can adjust the audio level.
Which system sounds best to you? What system makes the most sense for your use? Let us know in the comments!
Bonus - battery life (keep in mind the Rode and DJI have been used over 100 times)
DJI - 4.5 hours
Rode - 6 hours
Hollyland - 6 hours
Comica -
Comica Vimo C3 $129 - amzn.to/3V355Hg
DJI mic $329 - amzn.to/3FQ1nfP
Rode Wireless Go II $299 - amzn.to/3W1kjxN
Hollyland Lark M1 $149 - amzn.to/3Pt4e1q
@DJI
@HollylandTechnology
#dji #rodewirelessgo #hollyland #comica
0:00 intro
2:57 Comica Vimeo C3
4:18 Rode Wireless Go II
6:58 Hollyland Lark M1
8:43 DJI Mic - กีฬา
I have had Comica and have tried several Comica's. They sound great, especially the high-end ones, but all of them have more signal clipping than the competition. The DJI's are very good but heavy, with rode sound and bigger size. The Hollyland's don't sound as amazing, but they have a rock-stable signal, which I value very much. Especially when you are not recording static interviews where the subject is moving and facing Wi-Fi interference and other elements. At those times, you realize why Hollyland is known for their wireless transmitters. They may not sound like the DJI's, but you don't have a single micro signal dropout that ruins your recording.
This is solid gold insight! I have been looking into the Hollyland wireless video transmission systems. Any insight on them as well? I am hopping for low latency for streaming seminars.
@@Engearment If you consider low cost hollyland performance is the way to go, if you are not willing to spend thousands of dollars on something that is barely going to offer 10% more performance for 10 times the cost.
@@frecuenzi that’s good to hear!
Thank you for your comparative analysis of wireless mics🌺
Happy to help! Lots of good choices here.
Thanks for the video, exactly what I was looking for.
Thank you for the nice note!
This was so helpful! Thank you!
Thank you so much for the nice note! Glad it was helpful 🙌
I've seen some people recently talk about the Comica but not many comparisons with all of the others, interesting review! Was looking for what to get for myself, nice one 👍
Thank you! Glad you appreciate the comparison review approach.That was the goal, so that others can hear how they all sound. They pack quite a punch for the money! Take care
One of the best comparison videos I have watched - on any subject. A wonderfully relaxed manner whch gave all the information I needed. Thank you. One question - just how many guitars do you own?!
Thank you so much!! Really appreciate that! 🙌
5 guitars. Two here in this room (Martin acoustic and Gibson SG) the others are not as nice, but are a joy to play.
Thanks for the nice note and fun question!
Just what I was looking for 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻 i love DJI and Rhode, the only thing I hear noise with the dji, but the extra features definitely make it up 💪🏼💪🏼
Heck yes! Good insight.
I just shot a new comparison with two other companies too. They also come with lav mics that sound decent. But still, Rode aha DJI are my two go-to choices.
Take care!
Great video. Well done. Thx for sharing.
Thank you too!
Fantastic review!
Thank you kindly!
Great video! Thank you!
Great job! I'm wanting to compare them with the Boya XM6...so many models!
that looks interesting as it is close to the price of the Hollyland but lets you use external lav mics.
Glad your Comica worked. Mine doesn't. Tried it on my IPhone 13 Max Pro and my Samsung S22 Ultra. I used the suggested trs cables and absolutely nothing has worked. I was extremely excited to use this unit so now I'm equally disappointed. Going to DJI now.
So beautiful. No one is doing a video on the Comica vs the others. I love the Hollyland but I will chose the Comica because it has the screen
You get it!! you have chosen wisely :)
I've Got the Comica for the iPhone and just ordered the one for the the Nikon. Why dump so much money for audio when you cant even tell the difference?
For the price i will go for the comica 100%, and they sound good
That is a really good call. Hard to argue on the value. 🙌
I'm leaning towards the Holliland lark C1 for use with the phone and gimbal
Good call on that!
Hollyland w the wind m on it. excellent
Good call on that. Thanks for the vote!
The Comica looks like a good fit for low-cost DSLR type filming where a standard stereo cable is in play. I didn't see a lightning port or USB C port, so the DJI would be much better in my opinion for its adaptability. I have used the DJI mic kit without issue for all of my video needs.
Agreed! It does have USB C port for charging, but no lighting port adapter (at least not the kit we tested). DJI is pretty hard to beat for adaptability out of the box!
The issue is that's their budget option, their RODE competitor is their "BOOM" line. Boom X-U and Boom X-D. One nice thing about the BOOM X-D they offer a $60 receiver for iPhone and Android (Lightning or USB C respectively), if you use your phone for quick blogs or want to record an interview/podcast on the go in a minimalist fashion.
Nice video, hollyland has a firmware update, which isn’t easy to install.
Dji for sure..having a backup recording internally is worth the price. Just in case any wireless interference
Great call on that!
Great Video- $329 for DJI- ouch!!!!
Tell me about it LOL. It is pricey, especially compared to the Comica and Lark
0:52 - Dji mic
2:57 - Comica vimo c3
4:18 - Rode wireless go2
6:58 - Hollyland lark m1
8:43 - Dji mic
Thank you for putting this together! I eill get it updated.
@@Engearment Glad you noticed my comment. Please add timecodes to the description. It is much more convenient to interact with the video
It was very helpful. I have this updated now thanks to you.
Agreed, the chapters do help a lot. We put them in about 20% of the time. TH-cam seems to automatically do it on some videos too. It can be tricky when we are doing 7 videos a week, keeping up with the comments and links. Thanks for your help with this!
Good comparison, but they video could really use time stamps or at least keep the titles up for the current mic in use. That way I could quickly compare each mic without searching for them
Great idea! I will get the time stamps going. TH-cam often does this for our videos and I was hoping they would for this one too. But, I can just set that up. Thanks for the tip!
for price and quality, i will go with holyland
I am having trouble making a decision between RODE and DJI. I currently own the Rodecaster/Podmics and the DJI Osmo Pocket, and I enjoy both brands.
If you like the quality and sound of the RODE, then I think go with the RODE. Do you have the Rodecaster pro or pro 2? They just released an update for the pro 2 that really takes advantage of the RODE wireless go II mics.
The DJI is very nice as well. I like the connivence of them. But I feel like the sound is a bit more accurate with the RODE. Either one is going to treat you very well.
@@Engearment That's a fantastic feature! I ended up getting Hollyland's Lark 150. I have tested it out on a few audios and sounds good. Thanks for your feedback!
@@janaecarlee Excellent! So glad you are enjoying the Hollyland!
The DJI sounds great but I prefer the price of the Hollyland 🤷🏼♂️👍🏻, still undecided
Fair enough! The Hollyland packs a punch for the price. The only downsides is no screen, no ability to record internally and no lav mic inout. Most people wont even miss those features though. Take care!
Well, I'm probably wrong, but Comica sounded the best. Thank you.
That is great! Whatever sounds best to you is correct. That is why I do these kind of comparisons. Take care!
Pourquoi tu n'as pas tester le comica avec l'anti vent dessus ? C'est dommage
Dang, I've been looking at these, but since I don't really get a lot of views on my videos I'm not at all monetized, so it doesn't make sense for me to spend $300+ for the DJI. I was looking at the Hollyland but it seems without a gain control it's kind of useless since sometimes I want to record myself at the range, and for that I would like to lower the gain down so that the gunshots don't overblow the audio too badly. The Comica seems promising with the gain control but it seems like it just starts off too loud if that audio sample was at 2/4, I could imagine setting it to 1/4 won't be low enough for my use case...
DJI HANDS DOWN!!! It seems to have like a limiter or noise cancellation on the DJI. If you're doing TH-cam videos AND podcasts.... DJI all day!! thanks for this comparison bro! Great job!
Heck yes! Good call on that. Thank you for the nice note!! Take care :)
The DJI you can get now for about $/€220 with one RX and one TX. Same quality! might be something for talk to camera video's. The big thing with the Comica is that you can't plug in a external mic. Which means you need to upgrade for that. with a DJI you are all set. Best sounding is DJI for me, low budget Comica option is great bang for your bucks or euro's.
Great insight! Thanks for sharing. Your handle is spot on too - this was helpful :)
The single transmitter version lacks the charging case though right? That's definitely one of the selling points of the DJI system.
Is the mic on the top of the Comica and DJl mic or on the front? Which would be less likely to get that clothes rubbing on the mic hissing noise when you are wearing the mic (and/or trying to hide the mic)?
Good question. The DJI is on top. I sometimes get my chest hair or clothing rubbing on it (if I am not using the windscreen) The Hollyland is also on the top. But it is lighter and I find that it does not move around as much (and therefore has less clothing interference. Hope that helps!
Hello, I am searching a better budget mic, I have been using Rode camera mic with cable . Hard to use when you are on distance from Iphone. I am comparing between comica and hollyland Lark M1. Which you prefer I go for .. Because in this video I am missing out doors noise tests featuring noise cancellation in both of them?
Hello! I did not use any of the cameras noise cancellation settings. I find that it sounds artificial. But, the Comica I think has an edge as you can see the levels on the mic.
the RODE just sounds so crisp
Heck yes. Agreed.
For audio on my dji 3 mini drin and iPhone would all of these be compatible and reasonably seemless to use with the devices and video editor software? Thanks to anyone who responds, its my first microphone.
Yours is the second review I have watched trying to decide between the Comica and DJI, and so far, no one has covered how easy the Comica is to set up compared to others to start using, or the battery life of the Comica. I have learned that the DJI is easier to use than the Rode, but not the Comica. I would assume that the Comica is pretty much plug and play, just haven't heard anyone say it. (Being 77, neither my brain nor body work as fast as they once did...)
Hey Von! Good question. The Comica is very easy to use. It is already synced up when it arrives. Battery life has been as good, if not better than the DJI. It is very easy to use. Pull the mic and receiver out of the charging case and it is ready to use. Hope that helps!
@@Engearment Danke...
The only thing missing from Comica is the jack for the lavalier mic. In my case I cannot fit the Comica inside my motorbike Nolan Xlite helmet
@@KonstantinGabriel1978 That is very helpful. Having a lav input is a great feature!
Curious to hear how they sound as far as picking up background noise
They all do a good job of focusing on the person speaking. I did not notice as much background pic up
If you were going to do this justice, the BOOM X-D or BOOM X-U from Comica are more in line quality wise with the RODE and DJI. Comica is a great company, but after playing with the DJI Mic (even though like 100 more than the X-D Pro from COMICA) is my favorite. Didn't like the experience with RODE. Also the build quality on the DJI is easily the best. THOUGH that said, haven't played with the Hollyland one. So can't speak to it. But, Comica has some really interesting and unique mics out there for cameras, like a wireless boom. Their Two armed transforming boom mic.
We reviewed the Boom last year as well. Nice unit. Comica does make some good stuff! We will have two more mics we are reviewing. One from Samatac and a new one from Hollyland.
@@Engearment Hollyland looks interesting. I was going to pick that up. Since you know, having literally 15 different wireless systems like that is not excessive or anything. Was not a fan of the Boom X-U the arm felt cheap and could only swing in one direction.
It sounds like the Hollyland might be fine when run through a de-esser? The sibilants would be tough on the ear in a 2 or 3 hour class.
That is good insight. I had not thought of running it though that kind of processing. I would imagine that the average person would not do that for a seminar in real time. More than likely just run and gun with some post work at most. Just my experience. Thanks for the great insight!
RODE OU COMICA ? Parece que o COMICA a Altura do Áudio e também a Voz fica mais Encorpado e Bonita!
For me the Hollyland is the best.
tHANKS FROM CHICAGO
Thanks for the nice note!
@@Engearment You are welcome. After seeing your reviews, I will go with Holland. I like item that are easy to use
@@bradleyc79 Thank you so much! I think that will work well for you! Have fun with them!
Just to be fair with all the mics. I have tested the hollyland, and it sounds way better than in this video. Seems that all the devices are clipping ( using monitor headphones make the problem worse for sure)
Hmm. Not really sure what to say here. They were not clipping when we recorded this. Thanks for the note.
Hi, In my opinion, DJI filters the sound, meaning you don't hear the sound around you, but it also makes your voice lower. Don't you think?
It seems to filter the sound a bit. I like the Rode for accurate sound.
Can you connect a wired lav to the Comica or the Hollyland? I think the answer is no as far as I can tell. The DJI and the Rode you can correct?
You can monitor sound externally tho via headphones which is a good feature to hear what it actually sounds like
@@prophetamo yeah but I’m thinking more along a more hidden approach of the mic itself. Once people started wearing rode mics on their shirts collar I thought that looked goofy as hell. A small lav wired into the rode is the way to go IMO. So I’m looking for a system that allows that, and was hoping something other than the DJI/Rode could do that. Thanks for the reply.
Which mic u prefer for outdoor vlogs
Usually the DJI with a windscreen
maybe there can be another choic for new creator like LAMSCAT.
Is the comica mountable to insta360 X3 so it is invisible (like the rode)? Appreciate your work!
I will give that a try and let you know. Thanks for the idea and nice note!
@@Engearment That would be cool, thank you in advance!
@@Engearment please do! I’m really interested in hearing the comica with the X3 and if it fits securely on the rode mount.
I have the video up on this. The Comica did really good on the Rode mount! th-cam.com/video/IQ_zw06JDrQ/w-d-xo.html
@@Engearment Nice!!
The Hollyland is very good and complete with wind screen, i love it.
1. dji 2.hollyland 3.rode. 4 comica because is too loud
Thanks for the input (puny! LOL) l think you are spot on. Though I might put the Rode at 2 in the right situations.
Which sound quality do you prefer, DJI or Rode?
I like the Rode sound quality. I feel that it is more accurate.
Do you think the filter on dji is caused by the internal mic or transmitter? I really like dji, wondering if external lav mic will help
Hi Engearment! I want to start a new youtube channel and i want to buy a wireless microphone under 200$. Can you recommend to me which one is the best in your opinion? I was thinking something between the comica or hollyland... Which one do you suggest is the better microphone? I want something reliable. Thank you.
Fantastic!! I love it. You will have fun doing this. I like the Hollyland for its size but I like the Comica for the screen to see the levels. Either way you will be good to go. Much success to you and your channel 🙌
@@Engearment Thank you, Wish you the best.
Comica might be better for all the features. I just really like seeing levels so I dont wast time recording bad audio.
TH-cam has hidden your subscribe button
what i dont want is the breathing, the sounds of tongue hitting the roof of the mouth etc. this isnt it
I think mic location is going to help out in this situations