Mike. Thanks so much for the video. After your first video on the Vulcan 205 I rolled the dice and bought one. Couldn’t be happier. My father has been a welder at nuclear plants and a welder instructor for years. Always has used Lincoln and Hobart and miller at the fab shop he is at now. I told him about my 205 and he just kinda laughed. Then he came over and used the 205 and said Wow. !!! I can not believe how this machine performs. He kept thinking like most people it was from harbor freight and would be a joke. And to my disbelief….. said his next aluminum welder will be a Vulcan. Again he has used them all. I told him about your Chanel and showed your video. But seeing it wasn’t doing it for him. Using it. That proved it to him. Thanks for such a well done tutorial as always. He also likes my 170 titanium. But liked the Vulcan much better with all the functions like you mentioned 😊👍
Thanks Mike! I like all the Leonard Nimoy pics (and all the other ones) "hidden" in the video. It was fun. Great editing. The last few videos, I have noticed all the little extras you have been doing in the past few videos.
I dig it. Great comparison and recommendations. What I really appreciate about your content is the no-BS, straight forward info that most of the common DIY garager’s want to know. Quick suggestion- I’ve worked in manufacturing maintenance for a long time and one of the biggest problems for most machinery is clean airflow. Over time dust and debris from shop use and the environment in general will build up and can cause issues. I use a high flow universal filter media on all my machines that have an open intake like the back of those welders. Just place a few strips of Velcro tape around the welder intakes and the filter media clings to it. Easy to maintain and replace and it keeps those internal components clean for a long life of use.
Mike, I'm behind on watching like seven of your video's I have to catch up on them. I'm still alive and well. I'll be watching and commenting tonight. Thanks again for producing down to earth AWESOME material!
Mike, I bought the Hynade welder after watching one of your videos. My experience is no reflection on you. I just wanted you to know about my experience. I had my most experienced welder help get this welder tuned in, however it would not keep the high frequency on. It would start the torch but then go off and destroy the tungsten. Hynade eliminated their phone number and do not respond to emails. The 3 year warranty is not valid if you can not reach anybody. I’ll probably switched to the Vulcan for my home use. I owned a company with over 50 tig welding personnel so I have been around the process. I had all Miller dynasty welders and 95% was aluminum tig. I sold the business after 20 years and two locations. I do a lot of mig but never mastered tig. I do appreciate your videos. Thanks for all your videos.
Huh. I've had issues with my Vulcan for a bit with erratic arc, but they went away when I went to a buddy's house to weld something with it and used his regulator. Didn't even connect the dots until this video. Thanks!
Hey Mike, how about doing a comparison on the yeswelder ds250p ac/dc tag like you said you were going to do a couple months ago. With the current deals on the yeswelder you can buy an AC DC tig with all the adjustments for 600 bucks. it'd be nice to know (since you have one) how durable, how long-lasting and how good the welder is. It would also be nice to have your opinion on how well it really works and is it something you would buy again since you've had it for a while.
Probably just going to go with the Titanium when I end up getting one of these. I don’t think I really need the extra features, I just want to mess around with Tig some more and do some basic repairs. Also the Vulcan has went up in price and I don’t think another three or four hundred is worth it for me.
I have a Titanium 200 multi process welder. Bought it about a year ago and so far everything has worked great. Although I haven’t tig welded with it yet, mainly because I haven’t needed to weld any aluminum. But I have used the hell out of the mig function and I can’t complain. Never had an issue with regulators or over heating etc… My only real complaint is mine didn’t come with a pedal. I haven’t really looked into getting one for it cause I wasn’t sure that it was an option until seeing this video. Oh, great video by the way! And thanks for the review.
I also own the Titanium unlimited 200 it been working great for over 3 years now. The TIG is a DC only TIG so aluminum is out for that machine unless you buy a spool gun. These welders are AC/DC welders and both are high frequency start.
@@Mikefestiva thanks a lot. I didn’t know that about my welder. Saved me a bunch of headaches down the road. Obviously I don’t know as much as I probably should but, I know a little more now so thanks again.
Mike, on first using the Titanium, we had the spread out flame. We blamed it on the 2 tungsten rods they gave you; however, you experiences are more than mine. So I’m going to follow your advice and get an argon flow regulator. Thanks 😊 so much for your excellent videos
Bless Great video. Just bought the Titanium about a month ago. I’m not going to be Tigging a lot. So for now I’m happy. Love comparison videos. Thanks 😊
Thanks 😊 for checking out my new video John 👍 How was your regulator that came with your Titanium? Mine was flowing a lot of gas and reading wrong. Just curious is I just got a bad one or if there’s a bad run of regulators?
I've had the Vulcan 220 mig welder for about 5 years now. I bought it to fabricate my ornamental handrailing at home. I've ran maybe 100 lbs of wire thru it in that 5 yrs so it's used only occasionally but just built two entrance gates and it runs like it did the day I got it. Been thinking of buying a tig machine and for hobby use, knowing how well the Vulcan mig rig has done, it's hard not to consider buying another Vulcan.
Nice review Mike, I was wondering how those two welders stacked up against each other. I'm a welder and metal fabricator by trade, used the old Miller Dialarc for tig for years then the Syncrowave. Welding thin aluminum as in 35 to 80 thou the added adjustments are very handy and help do a better job. I know I'll be building some homebuilt aircraft fuel tanks in the future so I may look at getting the Vulcan over the Titanium. As for the size of the foot peddle... it's the same size as the one Miller has used for some 50 years now. I should know I've worn a couple of them out. Simple design means simple to fix. Have a good week.
The smaller pedal for the Vulcan is a direct copy of the Tweco/ESAB pedal I have on my ESAB. I can’t speak to what’s inside, but it the gold standard design. A few companies make copies.
I bought the Pro TIG 205 for my gunsmithing/gun engraving business and I absolutely love it. I use it for other things also. Looking at the Titanium 45 Plasma cutter for my next purchase.
If you talked about duty cycle, I missed it. Like if you're welding 1/2" steel on max amps, how long can you weld a bead, and then how long does it have to cool down before you can weld again on each model, and at each input voltage?
Thanks. I was playing w my buddy’s titanium yesterday. He got an open box unit and it for a great price and it was doing that same arc blowing thing until we turned the regulator way down.
Thanks for the video. I've welded over the years in the body shop and at home with a mig but I've never used a tig. I need to do some frame rail repairs to my truck but I think the mig is probably better for that kind of work. A Lincoln Handy Mig isn't the best welder, and it has almost no adjustments for the settings, but it does alright for how I use it. It looks like the Titanium 200 tig will be better for my needs. Not sure if it's the best for doing tiny welds on gun parts though.
Nano Nano - oops wrong tv show 😜 Thanks for taking the time to show comparison. I read an earlier comment about the Yes machine and would look forward to your review.
Thanks for making the video you helped out a lot. There's not a big enough price difference to justify the Titanium. For a couple hundred extra bucks may as well just get the Vulcan. You helped me make up my mind. Thanks again!
I was wandering if my titanium was using to much gas,seamed like it went through the last bottle quick. It's my first time using gas so i don't have anything to compare too. Thanks for the insight Mike. 👍
Very good overview Mike. There are many different manufacturers and importers of welders. Many of which aren’t “real” companies, but guys importing the minimum number from a larger Chinese exporter. You find these on eBay, and sometimes Amazon. I tell people to stay away from them. Even if they work at first, there is absolutely no support. Harbor Freight makes good welders these days, at the price they sell them at, very competitive with other brands. They aren’t industrial quality, but neither is the price, and HF does generally have good support.
Great review and information Mike. Thanks for your time and effort. Being an ordinary Muggle, my first reaction would be to lean towards the Titanium and I wonder if there would be a way to adapt the foot control from the Vulcan to the Titanium. Seems that having the foot control from the vulcan and a flow meter would make the Titanium an excellent choice for the neophyte, even though it may be "good enough" as delivered.
Thanks for checking out my video Mark! Honestly the amp pedal that comes with it works completely fine, it’s just big and looks clunky and cheap, but it varies the amps just fine. I would buy a $40 Argon flow meter though, the stock regulator was not good. The Titanium TIG welds aluminum and steel really well, the auto set was spot on 👍
I'm curious how they can sell the titanium tig200 at $899 and the Vulcan protig205 at $1299 with the limited features and amps when the Primeweld 225 is only $869. Am I missing something of did Harbor Freight price themselves out of the hobby grade welding market? When these machines first came out they were hundreds cheaper and seemed to be priced appropriately...
I think the biggest difference would be these welders especially the Vulcan has memory and the interface is a lot different with the digital settings then the Primeweld with all manual settings.
@@Mikefestiva an atlas 10f th 54 the power feed and the cross feed had bad parts no steady rest underpowered motor but nice original stand for 400.00 at an estate sale couple other problems that kind of make me wish I’d of waited but the wife said I could so !
@@brandenpatterson2776 you will get them worked out 👍 I have a few things I need to address on mine as well, lots of slop in the cross slide, so I think I need to make a new brass nut to fix the loose parts.
Hey Mike! Thanks for going over these two great welders for those of us venturing outside of mig welding. Have you done a video on a budget fab table? That is what my next project will need to be. Thanks!
Thanks for checking out my new video 👍 I haven’t done a video on Fab tables yet, I basically went from a small home made welding/cutting table for years to the Langmuir system table and as nice as it is, it’s definitely not a budget table. There’s a lot of tables out there in the $100 range like Harbor freight sells, I will do some research and try to put together a video 🙂 Thanks for the suggestion!
@@Mikefestiva I like that it comes with the CK worldwide torch and hoses. It also seems it'd be easier to play with the settings when you can just turn the specific dial you want for pre-post, etc. while you're welding. Thanks for these great videos! Keep up the good work.
Hey Mike, I bought the Vulcan ProTIG 200 when it came out and I love it. I can't remember if you had one or not. I also bought an Everlast MTS211Si multi-process because it was on sale, lol. Got it in 1 day since Everlast is only about 40mi from me in South SanFran, CA I like 'em both. I like your edit showing Mr. Spock on the display and the 'Live Long and Prosper' over the VULCAN name. Thanks for this vid, Cheers.
I bought the ProTig 200 and also really liked it, really easy to set up, good machine, I thought the Titanium would have had similar features to the original ProTig 200 but they really simplified the new Titanium almost to a point where the operator has zero input in any settings. The Vulcan 200 just had about everything you want, only lacking pre and post flow. Take care 👍🙂
Mike thanks for the Titanium tig machine video. Been wondering about that machine I have the Titanium unlimited 200 and love it but want to do aluminum too. Looks like I'm saving for another machine it's just what I need keep up the great videos they are appreciated.
Thanks for checking out my new video Michael! The auto set works really well on the Titanium TIG, just plan on buying a $40 Argon flow meter like the one I showed in the video 🙂👍
Hey Mike, a few years ago, I bought a Vulcan omnipro 220, because I thought I could do Tig/mig/stick with just one welder. I haven't gottent a Tig torch or pedal yet because upon more research, I found out it would not do aluminum. Then there are some who say it can do aluminum, but it's just more difficult due to AC/DC lack of being able to change. I also didn't want to buy a whole other tank pure argon, and different regulator if I wouldn't be able to Tig aluminum anyway. I really like how it mig welds, and I got to try stick welding with it, and it did well with that. Is there any point to getting a Tig torch and pedal for this? Or should I just get a purpose built Tig machine? I don't see much need for Tig other than occasional for what I do. Lower investment might be torch and pedal, but if it isn't going to work well, might be better to just use mig. What do you think?
Thanks for checking out my new video! I like the Yeswelder helmet, I think it’s really comparable to the Vulcan helmet I own but the Yeswelder helmet cost me $100 compared to the Vulcan for $150. I can’t remember the model number of the Yeswelder helmet? They make a wide range of models.
Thank You Mike. That was a Great job on these 2 TIG / STICK machines. Ive been thinking about one for a long time. For as much as I will use it. I think the cheaper one is going to fit for me. Again Thank You Sir...Great Video...
Thanks for checking out my new video Thomas 👍 I’m actually testing out a new AC/DC TIG with good options and features, and it sells for a little less then the More affordable Titanium I reviewed in this video, I hope to make a video in the next few months once I get more time in on it, I don’t want to recommend any new welders till I get more hours in on it.
The ProTig was just on sale with the insider card for under $1000, so keep an eye out for the insider sales also I keep seeing 20% off coupons for welders on HF ads. That could save you a bit 👍🙂
On the titanium tig, is your torch still connected to Negative? Just getting started with aluminum & I know most AC torch is on Positive but SOME machine still use Negative
How is the duty cycle on the titanium? Do you think I could install a finger toggle in place of the foot pedal? I really need a mig and tig at home . Kinda disappointed that the titanium unlimited 200 isn’t a ac/dc machine with a foot pedal option . Foot pedal is great at the work bench but a finger toggle is nice for in the floor .great video Mike .
How long can you weld aluminum like 3 inches and stop then you have to wait before restart it won't restart right away is this how it's supposed to a t at 140 amps
So I could buy 7 of the AHP 201XD welders like I have (just 1) for the price of one Miller. I do wonder what the massive profit margin is for Miller, as there is no way it costs them like $4 or 5k to build them. My AHP came with the 'sewing machine' foot pedal and I ended up getting the Vulcan pedal from HF and adapting it to the AHP, piece of cake. Works great.
Haha I Have used my friends Miller Dynasties and it didn’t work 7 times better then my Vulcan 😂 it welded basically the same. Thanks for checking out my new video 👍
I have the Vulcan 220 and its a great machine but I need a ac/dc tig machine I do like the 205 but when you get to the 1200.00 range there are some options out there what welder would you recommend for a good ac/dc tig
I wonder if you could modify the Titanium pedal to a lower profile? It seems possible with a cnc plasma table, Just a thought. Also do you think the harbor freight flow meter is a good purchase?
I am doing a large repair job on a old aluminum boat. Lots of corroded spots and bolt holes. All the plate is 3/16. Is the 205 enough of a machine to tackle the 3-16 plate? Or is a 220 a better choice?
I will do a comparison video soon, I’m actually testing another AC/DC TIG that sell for about $650, it’s got about the same features as the Yeswelder 250P but is easier to set up. Once I get more welding time on that welder I will do a review of all 3 units 🙂👍
@@Mikefestiva awesome! i just got my Firstess MP200 and getting the hang of it but already itching for an AC TIG welder and can't decide which one lol.
Mike, I don't understand using AC power, VS DC power. I hear you have to use DC for this and that, and I hear someone else the opposite. Could you do a video and explain this so a beginner can understand where to use which, please?
Mike, love the video’s, they have been super helpful. I am currently in welding school, and am wondering how people get HF to send them these welders to test out for free? Obviously my funds are super tight.. I spend a ton of money at HF.. just wondering if there is a program people can sign up for?
These Harbor Freight welders are tempting but what kind of support does one expect? Are their extended warranties useful? Even simple things like battery replacement for their power tools and replacement bowl for their tumblers, was either not possible, or got the run around.
I cant wait to see how that new yes machine works. I'm likely going to pull the trigger on one in the next few months. Any estimate on when the YesWelder review might come out?
Can you put a different ft pedal on the titanium? And does it have the option to weld without the foot pedal? I am also looking for a basic machine for using every couple months but would like the option to use the ft pedal when needed it to use the machine without .scratch / lift arc style . Great video
This might be a little off topic but can you make a mig lead longer? If so how do you go about doing it. I have the omnipro 220 and hate how short the mig gun lead is. And the ground clamp lead, i have a grip on extending the ground clamp lead but the mig gun i have no clue if its even possible, anyways back to the video, great as usual, ive been wondering how the new titanium tig was since it came out so was pretty excited when i saw this, thanks!!
Hey I haven’t ever ran any Primeweld products before. The company reached out to me a few years back and asked if I wanted to try there welders. At the time I was testing out a new welder ( from a different company ) and didn’t want to switch brands because I really like to test one machine for a year or so in my shop so I can test it and others can see how it holds up in my videos. So I turned down there offer. I have heard other subscribers mention over the years they like the Primeweld stuff. I just looked it up and I really like the CK torch and super flexible lead. I run that on my other TIG welders 👍 the price is good. Looks like it comes with everything you will need. I would suggest looking at many reviews and even check there older TIG models to see if anyone has had any problems with them. I doubt you will need it but it’s nice it comes with a 3 year warranty 👍 For the price I’m sure it’s a good machine. I would say go for it and get TIG welding 😊
In his other TIG video he is using the 205 welding 1/8th inch aluminum with a 115v 15 amp or 20 amp plug i think and said he doesnt have a problem and MAYBE could push it to 3/16
Great video! You have never shared a video related to welding helmets. That I know of. Can you share your thoughts on the best for a reasonable price. I do not weld every day, so cannot justify buying an expensive helmet. Or do I even need too. Thx Mike “Live long and prosper”😂
Seems like the Vulcan is the clear winner. With the Titanium, you save $220 or so, but get a junk regulator (you aren’t the first to mention this), a clunky foot pedal, less features, goofy plug adapter and an overall less confidence inspiring machine. If there was $400-$500 between machines, I’d have to think about it, but for $220, the Vulcan is a CLEAR winner.
I just got one of the titanium for $400 barely used still in the box. I know nothing of tig or the machines, and I could tell immediately it was lacking features.
Maybe I missed it, but can the Vulcan ProTig 205 run Lift Tig? I know it is High Freq capable, but being able to run Lift Tig around sensitive electronics is a must.
Unfortunately both of these welders offer a lift start setting, only high frequency start. That also means they always need a pedal to operate as well.
How much amps does the titanium actually run I wanna buy one and wanna plug into house or generator what do you recommend and can a 240 outlet hold the titanium 200
Got the Titanium and no gas is coming out. Checked the torch and bottle. Nothing. Guess I will have to return it. Checked everything all the way to the back. Then check the torch with bare. Nothing.
Mike. Thanks so much for the video. After your first video on the Vulcan 205 I rolled the dice and bought one. Couldn’t be happier. My father has been a welder at nuclear plants and a welder instructor for years. Always has used Lincoln and Hobart and miller at the fab shop he is at now. I told him about my 205 and he just kinda laughed. Then he came over and used the 205 and said Wow. !!! I can not believe how this machine performs. He kept thinking like most people it was from harbor freight and would be a joke. And to my disbelief….. said his next aluminum welder will be a Vulcan. Again he has used them all. I told him about your Chanel and showed your video. But seeing it wasn’t doing it for him. Using it. That proved it to him. Thanks for such a well done tutorial as always. He also likes my 170 titanium. But liked the Vulcan much better with all the functions like you mentioned 😊👍
Mike!!! When you insert those pictures in your videos (easter eggs) it takes the video to 11!!! BRAVO SIR BRAVO!!!!!
Haha 😂 thanks Jon! 🙂👍
Thanks Mike! I like all the Leonard Nimoy pics (and all the other ones) "hidden" in the video. It was fun. Great editing. The last few videos, I have noticed all the little extras you have been doing in the past few videos.
Ha ha thanks for catching those and thanks for watching 👍
I dig it. Great comparison and recommendations. What I really appreciate about your content is the no-BS, straight forward info that most of the common DIY garager’s want to know.
Quick suggestion- I’ve worked in manufacturing maintenance for a long time and one of the biggest problems for most machinery is clean airflow. Over time dust and debris from shop use and the environment in general will build up and can cause issues. I use a high flow universal filter media on all my machines that have an open intake like the back of those welders. Just place a few strips of Velcro tape around the welder intakes and the filter media clings to it. Easy to maintain and replace and it keeps those internal components clean for a long life of use.
Thanks for checking out my new video! Man that’s a great idea! Thanks for the suggestion 👍🙂
Mike, I'm behind on watching like seven of your video's I have to catch up on them. I'm still alive and well. I'll be watching and commenting tonight. Thanks again for producing down to earth AWESOME material!
It’s really good to hear from you Joe! I had been wondering how you have been. 🙂👍
Great reviews, Mike. Thanks for taking your time to make the video. Got a laugh from Spock and He-Man as well. 👍
Thanks Greg! I really appreciate it man 🙂 Haha Spock and He-Man are classics 😂
Mike, I bought the Hynade welder after watching one of your videos. My experience is no reflection on you. I just wanted you to know about my experience. I had my most experienced welder help get this welder tuned in, however it would not keep the high frequency on. It would start the torch but then go off and destroy the tungsten. Hynade eliminated their phone number and do not respond to emails. The 3 year warranty is not valid if you can not reach anybody. I’ll probably switched to the Vulcan for my home use. I owned a company with over 50 tig welding personnel so I have been around the process. I had all Miller dynasty welders and 95% was aluminum tig. I sold the business after 20 years and two locations. I do a lot of mig but never mastered tig. I do appreciate your videos. Thanks for all your videos.
So many TIG welder reviews omit whether or not it has high frequency start. The most important factor in my mind.
I definitely think High frequency start and amp pedals are worth mentioning 👍
Thanks for checking out my new video 🙂
I literally had that He-Man lunch box and thermos as a kid lol. Great review as always.
You put so much work into your videos and they are both fun and enlightening. Thanks!
Thanks! I really appreciate it 👍🙂
Great video Mike, really informative. Thanks buddy for the update. Take care and stay safe!
Thanks for checking out my new video Ants 🙂👍
Huh. I've had issues with my Vulcan for a bit with erratic arc, but they went away when I went to a buddy's house to weld something with it and used his regulator. Didn't even connect the dots until this video. Thanks!
Hi Mike! Watching now as I didn't get the notification, but saw your community post. Thank you. Ross
I watched it a few days ago, but didn't have time to cruise the comments. Keep up the good work!
Thank you for the picture of Spock. It's exactly what l think of when l hear Vulcan. Lol.
Haha 😂 me too!
Hey Mike, how about doing a comparison on the yeswelder ds250p ac/dc tag like you said you were going to do a couple months ago. With the current deals on the yeswelder you can buy an AC DC tig with all the adjustments for 600 bucks. it'd be nice to know (since you have one) how durable, how long-lasting and how good the welder is. It would also be nice to have your opinion on how well it really works and is it something you would buy again since you've had it for a while.
Hi! Yes I will get one out soon I want to have a little more time on the machine before i complete the review. Thanks for watching!
Yeah, then compare the yeswelder with the vulcan protig
On this subject, you should do a comparison on the yeswelder ac/dc tig. vs. the primeweld tig 225
I would also like to see this comparison ASAP while some of the deals are in places. Thanks. Cheers, Tom
Probably just going to go with the Titanium when I end up getting one of these. I don’t think I really need the extra features, I just want to mess around with Tig some more and do some basic repairs. Also the Vulcan has went up in price and I don’t think another three or four hundred is worth it for me.
Just purchased the titanium 200 gunna start with this as i am new to tig welding aluminum then as i get better i will upgrade to a quality machine !!
I have a Titanium 200 multi process welder. Bought it about a year ago and so far everything has worked great. Although I haven’t tig welded with it yet, mainly because I haven’t needed to weld any aluminum. But I have used the hell out of the mig function and I can’t complain. Never had an issue with regulators or over heating etc… My only real complaint is mine didn’t come with a pedal. I haven’t really looked into getting one for it cause I wasn’t sure that it was an option until seeing this video. Oh, great video by the way! And thanks for the review.
I also own the Titanium unlimited 200 it been working great for over 3 years now. The TIG is a DC only TIG so aluminum is out for that machine unless you buy a spool gun.
These welders are AC/DC welders and both are high frequency start.
@@Mikefestiva thanks a lot. I didn’t know that about my welder. Saved me a bunch of headaches down the road. Obviously I don’t know as much as I probably should but, I know a little more now so thanks again.
Mike, on first using the Titanium, we had the spread out flame. We blamed it on the 2 tungsten rods they gave you; however, you experiences are more than mine. So I’m going to follow your advice and get an argon flow regulator. Thanks 😊 so much for your excellent videos
Bless Great video. Just bought the Titanium about a month ago. I’m not going to be Tigging a lot. So for now I’m happy. Love comparison videos. Thanks 😊
Thanks John
Thanks 😊 for checking out my new video John 👍 How was your regulator that came with your Titanium? Mine was flowing a lot of gas and reading wrong. Just curious is I just got a bad one or if there’s a bad run of regulators?
Great comparison, my first tig was the 205 and I've beat it up on thin and thick aluminum. For me its worth the extra $ for sure.
I've had the Vulcan 220 mig welder for about 5 years now. I bought it to fabricate my ornamental handrailing at home.
I've ran maybe 100 lbs of wire thru it in that 5 yrs so it's used only occasionally but just built two entrance gates and it runs like it did the day I got it.
Been thinking of buying a tig machine and for hobby use, knowing how well the Vulcan mig rig has done, it's hard not to consider buying another Vulcan.
Did you? What's the verdict?
Nice review Mike, I was wondering how those two welders stacked up against each other.
I'm a welder and metal fabricator by trade, used the old Miller Dialarc for tig for years then the Syncrowave. Welding thin aluminum as in 35 to 80 thou the added adjustments are very handy and help do a better job.
I know I'll be building some homebuilt aircraft fuel tanks in the future so I may look at getting the Vulcan over the Titanium.
As for the size of the foot peddle... it's the same size as the one Miller has used for some 50 years now. I should know I've worn a couple of them out. Simple design means simple to fix.
Have a good week.
Thanks for watching Kriss 👍
The smaller pedal for the Vulcan is a direct copy of the Tweco/ESAB pedal I have on my ESAB. I can’t speak to what’s inside, but it the gold standard design. A few companies make copies.
I bought the Pro TIG 205 for my gunsmithing/gun engraving business and I absolutely love it. I use it for other things also. Looking at the Titanium 45 Plasma cutter for my next purchase.
I have the plasma 45 and its incredible. I love it.
I had that exact master's of the universe lunch box as a kid 💪
Haha Right on! Those lunchboxes had some good style 😂
Sure do appreciate your comparison! Thank you.
Thanks Glenn
If you talked about duty cycle, I missed it. Like if you're welding 1/2" steel on max amps, how long can you weld a bead, and then how long does it have to cool down before you can weld again on each model, and at each input voltage?
I’d love a how to run a metal lathe video just the basics!
Thanks. I was playing w my buddy’s titanium yesterday. He got an open box unit and it for a great price and it was doing that same arc blowing thing until we turned the regulator way down.
TiG Welding, I'm not quite there - yet. Still a lot to learn. Thank you for your honest review. Big point these days...Budget.
Thanks for the video. I've welded over the years in the body shop and at home with a mig but I've never used a tig. I need to do some frame rail repairs to my truck but I think the mig is probably better for that kind of work. A Lincoln Handy Mig isn't the best welder, and it has almost no adjustments for the settings, but it does alright for how I use it. It looks like the Titanium 200 tig will be better for my needs. Not sure if it's the best for doing tiny welds on gun parts though.
Nano Nano - oops wrong tv show 😜 Thanks for taking the time to show comparison. I read an earlier comment about the Yes machine and would look forward to your review.
Haha Mork and Mindy 😂
Thanks for checking out my new video 👍
thanks for sharing this video, you covered both of these machines very well
Thanks for watching 👍
Thanks for making the video you helped out a lot. There's not a big enough price difference to justify the Titanium. For a couple hundred extra bucks may as well just get the Vulcan. You helped me make up my mind. Thanks again!
I was wandering if my titanium was using to much gas,seamed like it went through the last bottle quick. It's my first time using gas so i don't have anything to compare too.
Thanks for the insight Mike. 👍
Great review and thanks for touching on the tig pulse.
Mike,
That big foot pedal is the same as my old Miller 330 ABP welder. Had it for 25 years. It is industrial grade. :)
Very good overview Mike. There are many different manufacturers and importers of welders. Many of which aren’t “real” companies, but guys importing the minimum number from a larger Chinese exporter. You find these on eBay, and sometimes Amazon. I tell people to stay away from them. Even if they work at first, there is absolutely no support.
Harbor Freight makes good welders these days, at the price they sell them at, very competitive with other brands. They aren’t industrial quality, but neither is the price, and HF does generally have good support.
Great review and information Mike. Thanks for your time and effort. Being an ordinary Muggle, my first reaction would be to lean towards the Titanium and I wonder if there would be a way to adapt the foot control from the Vulcan to the Titanium. Seems that having the foot control from the vulcan and a flow meter would make the Titanium an excellent choice for the neophyte, even though it may be "good enough" as delivered.
Thanks for checking out my video Mark!
Honestly the amp pedal that comes with it works completely fine, it’s just big and looks clunky and cheap, but it varies the amps just fine.
I would buy a $40 Argon flow meter though, the stock regulator was not good.
The Titanium TIG welds aluminum and steel really well, the auto set was spot on 👍
i mig weld a lot havent tig welded yet maybe time to learn, great info thankyou
Thanks Chris
Well after watching this video you have convinced me to go out and get the vulcan. Now I just need to wait till they have a good deal on it.
another radical video Mike :) getting ready to learn to weld :) thanks for these amazing videos and all the energy you put into creating them :)
Thanks for the support Dave!
Next time you make it out this way I would be happy to hang out and show you how to weld 👍🙂
@@Mikefestiva RADICAL!!!!! THANKS MIKE!!! this will be life changing!!!
Great video Mike, Thank you. I’m going to get a 205 next time they go on sale.
I like the size and simplicity of the titanium.
As a professional welder I'll agree it's nice not to have to set up all settings... just turn it on and go to work.
Vulcan. I like this video.
thanks for the video! good and informative as always!
Thanks Marcus
I'm curious how they can sell the titanium tig200 at $899 and the Vulcan protig205 at $1299 with the limited features and amps when the Primeweld 225 is only $869. Am I missing something of did Harbor Freight price themselves out of the hobby grade welding market? When these machines first came out they were hundreds cheaper and seemed to be priced appropriately...
I think the biggest difference would be these welders especially the Vulcan has memory and the interface is a lot different with the digital settings then the Primeweld with all manual settings.
I have had 6 205 in last 2 years. If you doing and grinding around it the metal gets in it and it pops the board I have keep returning them
Thanks for the informative tutorial. That huge fan choked me up, I guess the duty cycle is better on the Vulcan.
Great video Mike sorry I was late to view busy ordering parts for my new to me metal lathe! Finally got one
Awesome! What kind of lathe did you get?
@@Mikefestiva an atlas 10f th 54 the power feed and the cross feed had bad parts no steady rest underpowered motor but nice original stand for 400.00 at an estate sale couple other problems that kind of make me wish I’d of waited but the wife said I could so !
@@brandenpatterson2776 you will get them worked out 👍 I have a few things I need to address on mine as well, lots of slop in the cross slide, so I think I need to make a new brass nut to fix the loose parts.
@@Mikefestiva it would be a great video just saying!
Hey Mike! Thanks for going over these two great welders for those of us venturing outside of mig welding. Have you done a video on a budget fab table? That is what my next project will need to be. Thanks!
Thanks for checking out my new video 👍 I haven’t done a video on Fab tables yet, I basically went from a small home made welding/cutting table for years to the Langmuir system table and as nice as it is, it’s definitely not a budget table.
There’s a lot of tables out there in the $100 range like Harbor freight sells, I will do some research and try to put together a video 🙂 Thanks for the suggestion!
Nice. I was unaware the Vulcan had pulse. I'm happy with my vulcan215. But I ended up getting primeweld 225 for tig.
I would like to see a comparison between the vulcan, primeweld, and AHP
I hear a lot of people like there Priweweld TIG machines 👍
@@Mikefestiva I like that it comes with the CK worldwide torch and hoses. It also seems it'd be easier to play with the settings when you can just turn the specific dial you want for pre-post, etc. while you're welding. Thanks for these great videos! Keep up the good work.
Hey Mike,
I bought the Vulcan ProTIG 200 when it came out and I love it. I can't remember if you had one or not. I also bought an Everlast MTS211Si multi-process because it was on sale, lol.
Got it in 1 day since Everlast is only about 40mi from me in South SanFran, CA I like 'em both. I like your edit showing Mr. Spock on the display and the 'Live Long and Prosper' over the VULCAN name. Thanks for this vid,
Cheers.
I bought the ProTig 200 and also really liked it, really easy to set up, good machine, I thought the Titanium would have had similar features to the original ProTig 200 but they really simplified the new Titanium almost to a point where the operator has zero input in any settings. The Vulcan 200 just had about everything you want, only lacking pre and post flow.
Take care 👍🙂
Mike thanks for the Titanium tig machine video. Been wondering about that machine I have the Titanium unlimited 200 and love it but want to do aluminum too. Looks like I'm saving for another machine it's just what I need keep up the great videos they are appreciated.
Thanks for checking out my new video Michael! The auto set works really well on the Titanium TIG, just plan on buying a $40 Argon flow meter like the one I showed in the video 🙂👍
Hey Mike, a few years ago, I bought a Vulcan omnipro 220, because I thought I could do Tig/mig/stick with just one welder. I haven't gottent a Tig torch or pedal yet because upon more research, I found out it would not do aluminum. Then there are some who say it can do aluminum, but it's just more difficult due to AC/DC lack of being able to change. I also didn't want to buy a whole other tank pure argon, and different regulator if I wouldn't be able to Tig aluminum anyway. I really like how it mig welds, and I got to try stick welding with it, and it did well with that. Is there any point to getting a Tig torch and pedal for this? Or should I just get a purpose built Tig machine? I don't see much need for Tig other than occasional for what I do. Lower investment might be torch and pedal, but if it isn't going to work well, might be better to just use mig. What do you think?
Good info Mike! Would really like to get into TIG but I don't think I would use it that much. How do you like the YES helmet ?
Thanks for checking out my new video!
I like the Yeswelder helmet, I think it’s really comparable to the Vulcan helmet I own but the Yeswelder helmet cost me $100 compared to the Vulcan for $150. I can’t remember the model number of the Yeswelder helmet? They make a wide range of models.
@@Mikefestiva Thanks I may check it out!
For the slight price difference and a 20% off coupon I would say the Vulcan is the one I would get
I definitely agree 👍🙂
What 20% off coupon are you referring to?
@@brianholbrook4393 once and while hf sends out a 20% coupon
Thanks Mechanic lyfe
Thank You Mike. That was a Great job on these 2 TIG / STICK machines. Ive been thinking about one for a long time. For as much as I will use it. I think the cheaper one is going to fit for me. Again Thank You Sir...Great Video...
Thanks for checking out my new video Thomas 👍 I’m actually testing out a new AC/DC TIG with good options and features, and it sells for a little less then the More affordable Titanium I reviewed in this video, I hope to make a video in the next few months once I get more time in on it, I don’t want to recommend any new welders till I get more hours in on it.
@@Mikefestiva oh Cool. Thank You. I cant wait to see it. You always have Great Videos.. Looking forward to the Video Sir...
Thank Mike for this tutorial i appreciate your review..
Thanks for watching Fred
Very informative, I have been looking at the Vulcan for a while now, I think it's time I go spend some money.
Thank you Randy
The ProTig was just on sale with the insider card for under $1000, so keep an eye out for the insider sales also I keep seeing 20% off coupons for welders on HF ads. That could save you a bit 👍🙂
This answers some questions I had thanks
can either of them run 6010's? i have been looking for 1 welder that can stick and tig.
Would you possibly do a comparison between the vulcan migmax 250 and the yeswelder mig pro 250? That would be awesome.
Another great video. Thanks Mike!
Spock on the screen. Nice touch.
Another top notch review Mike
Thanks Jesse
On the titanium tig, is your torch still connected to Negative? Just getting started with aluminum & I know most AC torch is on Positive but SOME machine still use Negative
My question is What’s the lightest gauge you can weld aluminum with the titanium welder ? And is 110 the max it puts out ?
I was looking at the Omni Pro, but I think it'd be best to get the separate Vulcan Tig and Mig units separate, for a few bucks more.
I reached the same conclusion. If the Omni pro offered AC I would have probably went that route.
How is the duty cycle on the titanium? Do you think I could install a finger toggle in place of the foot pedal? I really need a mig and tig at home . Kinda disappointed that the titanium unlimited 200 isn’t a ac/dc machine with a foot pedal option . Foot pedal is great at the work bench but a finger toggle is nice for in the floor .great video Mike .
How long can you weld aluminum like 3 inches and stop then you have to wait before restart it won't restart right away is this how it's supposed to a t at 140 amps
Can you connect and use a different pedal on the titanium if you wanted?
So I could buy 7 of the AHP 201XD welders like I have (just 1) for the price of one Miller. I do wonder what the massive profit margin is for Miller, as there is no way it costs them like $4 or 5k to build them. My AHP came with the 'sewing machine' foot pedal and I ended up getting the Vulcan pedal from HF and adapting it to the AHP, piece of cake. Works great.
Haha I Have used my friends Miller Dynasties and it didn’t work 7 times better then my Vulcan 😂 it welded basically the same.
Thanks for checking out my new video 👍
@@Mikefestiva Yes, exactly!
Really helpful review! Thanks
I have the Vulcan 220 and its a great machine but I need a ac/dc tig machine
I do like the 205 but when you get to the 1200.00 range there are some options out there
what welder would you recommend for a good ac/dc tig
I wonder if you could modify the Titanium pedal to a lower profile? It seems possible with a cnc plasma table, Just a thought. Also do you think the harbor freight flow meter is a good purchase?
I am doing a large repair job on a old aluminum boat. Lots of corroded spots and bolt holes. All the plate is 3/16.
Is the 205 enough of a machine to tackle the 3-16 plate?
Or is a 220 a better choice?
Great information Mike, thanks for posting.
Thanks for checking out my new video Doug 👍🙂
He-man approves this message
In Canuck land we have Princess Auto (PA), same idea as HF. I’m curious how the PA tig/stick machines would compare.
can you compare these two to the Yes Welder TIG-250P ACDC since they're about the same price?
I will do a comparison video soon, I’m actually testing another AC/DC TIG that sell for about $650, it’s got about the same features as the Yeswelder 250P but is easier to set up. Once I get more welding time on that welder I will do a review of all 3 units 🙂👍
@@Mikefestiva awesome! i just got my Firstess MP200 and getting the hang of it but already itching for an AC TIG welder and can't decide which one lol.
Mike, I don't understand using AC power, VS DC power. I hear you have to use DC for this and that, and I hear someone else the opposite. Could you do a video and explain this so a beginner can understand where to use which, please?
It’s fairly simple, DC for Steel and Stainless steel, AC for aluminum. 😊👍
Mike, love the video’s, they have been super helpful. I am currently in welding school, and am wondering how people get HF to send them these welders to test out for free? Obviously my funds are super tight.. I spend a ton of money at HF.. just wondering if there is a program people can sign up for?
These Harbor Freight welders are tempting but what kind of support does one expect? Are their extended warranties useful? Even simple things like battery replacement for their power tools and replacement bowl for their tumblers, was either not possible, or got the run around.
I cant wait to see how that new yes machine works. I'm likely going to pull the trigger on one in the next few months. Any estimate on when the YesWelder review might come out?
I like to have at least a few months running a machine before I do a review. I’ll try to get one out soon 👍
@@Mikefestiva I wouldn't want you to rush. My mig is getting me by just fine for now. Just curious
Can you put a different ft pedal on the titanium? And does it have the option to weld without the foot pedal? I am also looking for a basic machine for using every couple months but would like the option to use the ft pedal when needed it to use the machine without .scratch / lift arc style . Great video
I'm here for the foot pedal question too
@@MichaelRoachWVsame
Hey a little off the topic do you have a good flex head 15’ replacement for the Omni pro 220? Some say the Lincoln 250 fits.
This might be a little off topic but can you make a mig lead longer? If so how do you go about doing it. I have the omnipro 220 and hate how short the mig gun lead is. And the ground clamp lead, i have a grip on extending the ground clamp lead but the mig gun i have no clue if its even possible, anyways back to the video, great as usual, ive been wondering how the new titanium tig was since it came out so was pretty excited when i saw this, thanks!!
check with USA weld, HTP welders
do you know if the titanium can be upgraded with a better foot pedal?
now can I ask did you add the picture in onto the front of that screen or did you program it to have the picture on the front display?
I want to see you playing with titanium
Great vid Mike🍻
Thanks Joe
Hey Mike I'd like to hear your opinion on the prime weld 225 I'm on the fence about it and I'd value your thoughts
Hey I haven’t ever ran any Primeweld products before.
The company reached out to me a few years back and asked if I wanted to try there welders. At the time I was testing out a new welder ( from a different company ) and didn’t want to switch brands because I really like to test one machine for a year or so in my shop so I can test it and others can see how it holds up in my videos.
So I turned down there offer. I have heard other subscribers mention over the years they like the Primeweld stuff.
I just looked it up and I really like the CK torch and super flexible lead. I run that on my other TIG welders 👍 the price is good. Looks like it comes with everything you will need.
I would suggest looking at many reviews and even check there older TIG models to see if anyone has had any problems with them.
I doubt you will need it but it’s nice it comes with a 3 year warranty 👍 For the price I’m sure it’s a good machine.
I would say go for it and get TIG welding 😊
My work shop has a 30amp breaker, would the titanium 200 work with my 110, 30amp setup? I’m only welding 1/8 aluminum
In his other TIG video he is using the 205 welding 1/8th inch aluminum with a 115v 15 amp or 20 amp plug i think and said he doesnt have a problem and MAYBE could push it to 3/16
Great video! You have never shared a video related to welding helmets. That I know of. Can you share your thoughts on the best for a reasonable price. I do not weld every day, so cannot justify buying an expensive helmet. Or do I even need too. Thx Mike “Live long and prosper”😂
Seems like the Vulcan is the clear winner. With the Titanium, you save $220 or so, but get a junk regulator (you aren’t the first to mention this), a clunky foot pedal, less features, goofy plug adapter and an overall less confidence inspiring machine. If there was $400-$500 between machines, I’d have to think about it, but for $220, the Vulcan is a CLEAR winner.
I just got one of the titanium for $400 barely used still in the box. I know nothing of tig or the machines, and I could tell immediately it was lacking features.
Maybe I missed it, but can the Vulcan ProTig 205 run Lift Tig? I know it is High Freq capable, but being able to run Lift Tig around sensitive electronics is a must.
Unfortunately both of these welders offer a lift start setting, only high frequency start. That also means they always need a pedal to operate as well.
Mr. Spock approved!
Thanks Mike.
So. how does it stack up against the Yes Welder?
Are you asking how the Vulcan stacks up against the Yeswelder 250P or the Titanium?
@@Mikefestiva both of them.
How much amps does the titanium actually run I wanna buy one and wanna plug into house or generator what do you recommend and can a 240 outlet hold the titanium 200
Got the Titanium and no gas is coming out. Checked the torch and bottle. Nothing. Guess I will have to return it. Checked everything all the way to the back. Then check the torch with bare. Nothing.