@@wolfieisacat13 She was Rumpleteazer on the 2018 world tour, in which she does the cockney accent. She can do it, she was just for some reason directed not to for this.
I donno, as someone who listens to the songs mostly on Spotify, from the original London recording, I genuinely think it's just a matter of which version you're more used to.
I love the London version, it just flows so smoothly. Dunno why Mistoffollees sings it in the Broadway version. The third version is nicer, the chaos suits the characters. it's a shame they cut half the song in the 98 movie.
This is the original 80s version of the song, albeit a teensy bit more sinister. The upbeat 90s version of the song is the best in my opinion, if that’s the one u were referring to
I've only gotten myself to watch this scene in full exactly one time. Funny enough, I watched this scene to try and give the movie a chance because this is my favorite number. You can imagine how that went.
I really wanted to hate this version of the song because I'm so accustomed to the one we all know (from Cats 1998, used in most modern productions now), but, honestly... I actually like this version quite a bit. Hate Cats 2019, but I like the tempo to this version, and the sort of "old-timey London criminal" vibe this gives off. I think it suits the characters well. Makes sense that this isn't objectively terrible, since I guess this was the original version of the song.
I had no predisposition I only know that I saw an exemplary performance by a youth theatre which triumphed over this. And most definitely, this particular Victoria never says "'orrible' quite correctly
To everyone bashing the song's tune, it's actually the very first version of it from the London productions...I found including it to be a neat callback, though it WAS jarring, admittedly, being used to the version everyone uses now.
I still like the 98 version better but after hearing this a few times it’s grown on me. At least it’s not on the level of gumbie cat or bustopher jokes
For anybody wondering (of for anybody who doesn't want to scroll through the comments/lh), this version of the song is from the original version back in 1981 or smthn, I forgot the timeline. But yea, I was upset for, like, 2 minutes, but then realized "ohhhhh, it's the original version! That makes more sense"
I think the weirdest thing about this scene is that they decided to make the pair calico cats instead of tiger striped cats. Given how rare male calicos are, it doesn't make sense. Not to mention they were tiger striped cats purposely because the song talks about how the owners sometimes couldn't tell them apart. It's easy to tell calicos apart. Just one, in a sea, of weird changes this movie decided to make.
before you dismiss this version completely, just listen to the original 1981 version its the same tune pretty much but its fun and jazzy instead of the worst thing ever
I watched this movie first and i enjoyed it, but then i went to watch the original and this song was one of my favorites of the original, so i came back after a year or so of not seeing it and they absolutely ruined it. 😭
People on Broadway are able to jump sing and fight while singing and it sounds stable and well defined. All through this dumpster fire it sounds like they are all out of breath, and like they missed the last 20 years of vocal lessons. This is bad.
"Let's take all the good parts out of the version of this song people are most familiar with make it flat as Poland aaaaaand.... yes that it. A master peice for sure"
I hadn't seen or listened to anything from 'Cats' until today; I've watched 4 numbers from the 1998 stage film, and this is the 2nd I've watched from the movie. This will probably get me yelled at, but I prefer this version of this song, I like the vibe better. And from what I've read in YT comments, this is how the song originally was anyway. The complaints I've read about this movie sound very valid to me even without knowing much about 'Cats', but I have to disagree with this 1 common complaint I'm seeing.
yesss XD i love the movies songs and i feel like everyone is hating on it bc its not like the original even tho it wasnt made or ment to be like the original
Yeah, this version of the song is actually not bad, I enjoy it as much as the more playful one. I just dont like the movies version because of the interuptions, which is probably a me problem because I dont see anybody talking about it.
What I love most about this version of Cats are Andrew Lloyd Webber finally finding the actress who is both a Classical Prima Ballerina, like Victoria and a Lyrical Prima Donna, like Jemima, aka Syllabub and Victoria's very own song to go with her backstory.
God this song sounds so meaningless and dumb, In the 1998 version you can see how much fun there having, here it feels more like a 5th grade poem reading
The musical is fantastic, easily one of my all time favorites. This movie, well ... To be fair, I haven't watched the whole thing, just the songs and some reviews/critiques. Some of the songs are decent and the CGI for the most part isn't nearly as eye-meltingly horrendous in my opinion as people make it out to be, but eh, I'll stick with the 1998 film myself.
tbh the only thing I loved was the skimbleshanks song in the movie, the tap dancing addition was great although the sudden pause ruined the vibe a bit but either way I loved it.
@@Schuyler2614 I cannot and will not watch the film. This is a musical masterpiece. Meant for stage and for natural movement . As a crasy old cat woman, I attest that no cat should ever be "CUT"
Worst part it the actor playing Rumpleteazer CAN do the accent, she played Rumpleteazer in the stage show before the movie and did the accent just fine 🙄
@@maltesers1238Then it was clearly a direction from the production team for her to use her native accent, not an actors choice. I’ve worked with Naoimh Morgan (Rumpleteazer) and trust me, the woman can do anything and any accent, she’s amazing.
Wait a minute, New Dream Cats Collection; Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats Book, 1 Cats 1981 Broadway Musical in Music-CD, 1 Cats 1998 Movie in VHS, 1 Cats 2019 Movie in DVD-Video, and Deleted Cats Broadway Musical Songs and Dances in Music and Lyric Videos on I-Tunes.
Not bad, but it could use more charisma. At least unlike certain songs, I can bear to listen to it. I'm surprised the vase didn't fall, does that happen later in the scene?
Why why do you do this to my heart their voices and personalities don't match the real Mungojerrie Rumpteazer from 1998 and I'm not trying to judge the actors I'm just saying they could have been more playful and childish😭 Geez you could have casted two twins that you see on the street and they would have done a a better job I feel like they did not study these characters they did not learn the personality these two twin cats that you see in the 2019 movie they are strangers to me
I greatly prefer the 98 version of course but I’m in the minority of preferring this version of the song! I like the slower jazzy tempo, and how it builds with time
Holy Christ this is bad. From the singing to the pacing to the beat. Not to mention changing the song. They even say the others name? Lord above save me from this travesty.
Do you realize we almost got to see a horrible CGI human-dog? Like, if Mice and Cockroaches are humanoid, why not dogs? Why doesnt't it speak? I'm glad they didn't attempt it, but like, it also just makes no sence.
![เปิดใจ "อาจารย์เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม" อดีตเคยสุดทุกทาง ถ้าใช้หนี้หมดไปบวชแน่ l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IxeE0xVhy08/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m having an aneurysm over her saying “teazer” and not “teazeah”
Same TwT
Yes
No cat would ever say such barstewerdness
The actress is Northern Irish, so that’s just her natural accent. It was a direction from the production team for her to speak with her own accent.
@@Anonymous-qm7qf then don't get an actress who's northern irish? that's not how the song is supposed to be sung
@@wolfieisacat13 She was Rumpleteazer on the 2018 world tour, in which she does the cockney accent. She can do it, she was just for some reason directed not to for this.
My favourite song and characters of the whole musical and they murdered it
This rhythm is just SO wrong…
AND WHAT DID THEY DO TO THE WORDS
This set my teeth on edge so bad
Respect the opinion, but disagree. I really like how it sounds, the humor is pretty funny too.
And Rumpleteazer is so so pretty!
@@pinky0558 This is the only song that is better than Cats 1998
@@MisterVest really? And how about that stunning-adorable-absolutely-WOW! Skimbleshanks on a click track? Steven McRae is the best.
"I bought these for her myself."
"Did what?"
"Wait-"
Best lines in the whole movie.
I know that it's supposed to be the original london cast version of the song but the version we're used to is way more iconic
I donno, as someone who listens to the songs mostly on Spotify, from the original London recording, I genuinely think it's just a matter of which version you're more used to.
Even then, this version is also way worse than the original version, it sounds so stilted here
I love the London version, it just flows so smoothly. Dunno why Mistoffollees sings it in the Broadway version. The third version is nicer, the chaos suits the characters. it's a shame they cut half the song in the 98 movie.
@@OllieV__nlWe need a definitive revival that takes all the best parts of all past productions that’ll also be shot like the ‘98 film was
Bruh they literally changed this whole song and the way it goes omg
This is the original 80s version of the song, albeit a teensy bit more sinister. The upbeat 90s version of the song is the best in my opinion, if that’s the one u were referring to
It’s the original. The one you have in mind is the broadway version.
I've only gotten myself to watch this scene in full exactly one time. Funny enough, I watched this scene to try and give the movie a chance because this is my favorite number. You can imagine how that went.
The scale of the cats is wrong in this scene. On the dining table they're the size of mice.
The scale of the cats is wrong in the entire movie. One thing I think that made this film so visually unpleasant and uncomfortable.
The thing with this is that you can hear the movements in their voice, if that makes sense I don’t know how to word it.
No, I get it, the 1998 play was better cuz their voices don't tremble as much when they move
I really wanted to hate this version of the song because I'm so accustomed to the one we all know (from Cats 1998, used in most modern productions now), but, honestly... I actually like this version quite a bit. Hate Cats 2019, but I like the tempo to this version, and the sort of "old-timey London criminal" vibe this gives off. I think it suits the characters well. Makes sense that this isn't objectively terrible, since I guess this was the original version of the song.
This.
I had no predisposition
I only know that I saw an exemplary performance by a youth theatre which triumphed over this.
And most definitely, this particular Victoria never says "'orrible' quite correctly
What have they done to such this song and it's lovable duo?
Its fine...
@@rokzila Pardon, good sir?
@@rokzila the trailers were the first sign that it was not going to fine
@@isabellae.532 The human noses 🤢
😭😭😭
To everyone bashing the song's tune, it's actually the very first version of it from the London productions...I found including it to be a neat callback, though it WAS jarring, admittedly, being used to the version everyone uses now.
Well then maybe there was a reason this was the “first version” and never used
The other version is better
Never saw the one everyone hints was so great. I effing love this movie. Who cares?
@@davidp3196 Cats 1998. Look it up
@@personifiedsmol3168Haha, it’s amusing how far all you haters will go out of your own way to nitpick and find faults with something just to fit in.
I still like the 98 version better but after hearing this a few times it’s grown on me. At least it’s not on the level of gumbie cat or bustopher jokes
For anybody wondering (of for anybody who doesn't want to scroll through the comments/lh), this version of the song is from the original version back in 1981 or smthn, I forgot the timeline.
But yea, I was upset for, like, 2 minutes, but then realized "ohhhhh, it's the original version! That makes more sense"
These actors did the best they could and their vocals are great it’s just they didn’t pick the better version of the song and the cgi is uncanny
The way Victoria says “it’s that horrible cat” at 2:58 is so cute!
No
You mean, 2:56
would be cuter if the film was done correctly
I think the weirdest thing about this scene is that they decided to make the pair calico cats instead of tiger striped cats. Given how rare male calicos are, it doesn't make sense. Not to mention they were tiger striped cats purposely because the song talks about how the owners sometimes couldn't tell them apart. It's easy to tell calicos apart. Just one, in a sea, of weird changes this movie decided to make.
before you dismiss this version completely, just listen to the original 1981 version its the same tune pretty much but its fun and jazzy instead of the worst thing ever
Yup, my thoughts exactly
I watched this movie first and i enjoyed it, but then i went to watch the original and this song was one of my favorites of the original, so i came back after a year or so of not seeing it and they absolutely ruined it. 😭
Beyond Victoria’s 4 minute long Bisexual panic
I actually prefer this version to this to the original
I know, gives off a sense of criminality that the original lacked
Same, the vocals are also just way more fun
This version is closer to the original than the 98 one
Evictificent work of art so extravagant I applaud this movie greatly.
No no no no no i made a mistake, i was looking for the good version 😭😭😭😭 what is this what is this what is thisssss no no
This song is NOT the same song.
"I'M COMING VICTORIAAA!"
0:36 Yikes! they didn't think to re-record that in the studio. Whose bright idea was it to have us hear them sing while jumping around?
Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer seems two villains from the 1966 Batman TV show.
I mean I like the 1998 version better because the tempo gives off more of a playful energy like they’re just curious mischievous little kittens.
Wow...
Was this rated R for disturbing images and violence (murdered a great song and characters)?
Believe it or not, this keeps to a beat!
Not a good one
People can like what they want
❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊
It's like the original song, but stripped of all of its charm.
Idk how you feel about the movie yah the cgi is terrible but the dancing and singing, that takes talent, good on the actors fr
Dancing* ffs
No the “singing” is not even that most of the time they are talk singing at best. But this is just god awful
watch original musical and you'll change your mind when you will see how it should be done
People on Broadway are able to jump sing and fight while singing and it sounds stable and well defined. All through this dumpster fire it sounds like they are all out of breath, and like they missed the last 20 years of vocal lessons. This is bad.
1:33 this kills me in so many ways
"Let's take all the good parts out of the version of this song people are most familiar with make it flat as Poland aaaaaand.... yes that it. A master peice for sure"
This version is better than the original
2:08
She literally held her hand.
Smooth Rumple. Smooth
Idc what people think
I love this one, well at least this scene. Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer are my favorites
all of the whimsy, and silly tones from the original have been left to burn in the trash. This movie really did the musical dirty.
Trop cool la chanson 😊victoria cats so cute ❤❤
I hadn't seen or listened to anything from 'Cats' until today; I've watched 4 numbers from the 1998 stage film, and this is the 2nd I've watched from the movie. This will probably get me yelled at, but I prefer this version of this song, I like the vibe better. And from what I've read in YT comments, this is how the song originally was anyway. The complaints I've read about this movie sound very valid to me even without knowing much about 'Cats', but I have to disagree with this 1 common complaint I'm seeing.
yesss XD i love the movies songs and i feel like everyone is hating on it bc its not like the original even tho it wasnt made or ment to be like the original
Yeah, this version of the song is actually not bad, I enjoy it as much as the more playful one. I just dont like the movies version because of the interuptions, which is probably a me problem because I dont see anybody talking about it.
My favorite song and characters and they dismembered it
Edit: to the shelter
So this song is about cats being assholes
I loved this song
It's like they hired two people who couldn't sing.
Trust me, Naoimh Morgan (Rumpleteazer) can sing. That woman is a goddess.
@@Anonymous-qm7qfwell it doesn't show does it.
I hate this whole thing but no one has mentioned how dumb the color of them is. They’re cats that are burglers now why don’t they have striped coats??
Where's the sense of playful mischief and morbid curiosity that this poem is literally about? This arrangement frames them as _malicious_
They need to be the chaos that kittens are. It's too measured.
What I love most about this version of Cats are Andrew Lloyd Webber finally finding the actress who is both a Classical Prima Ballerina, like Victoria and a Lyrical Prima Donna, like Jemima, aka Syllabub and Victoria's very own song to go with her backstory.
God this song sounds so meaningless and dumb,
In the 1998 version you can see how much fun there having, here it feels more like a 5th grade poem reading
What a disappointment 😞
To Rohhh ohh ohhhh muh lmao 😂
The rest of the of theater had left by this time
Well that was a choice.
No matter what people say this will always be a good movie/musical in my opinion💖
The musical is fantastic, easily one of my all time favorites.
This movie, well ... To be fair, I haven't watched the whole thing, just the songs and some reviews/critiques. Some of the songs are decent and the CGI for the most part isn't nearly as eye-meltingly horrendous in my opinion as people make it out to be, but eh, I'll stick with the 1998 film myself.
tbh the only thing I loved was the skimbleshanks song in the movie, the tap dancing addition was great although the sudden pause ruined the vibe a bit but either way I loved it.
@@Schuyler2614 I cannot and will not watch the film.
This is a musical masterpiece. Meant for stage and for natural movement .
As a crasy old cat woman, I attest that no cat should ever be "CUT"
Apparently Tom Hooper grew up with the original Cats cast recording and this based off that… but I much prefer the 1998 video version
I equally love Victoria, Jemima, and Syllabub in this Musical!
K les hicieron a mis favs aaaaaAaaa
The complete lack of accent cohesion between them...🙄
Worst part it the actor playing Rumpleteazer CAN do the accent, she played Rumpleteazer in the stage show before the movie and did the accent just fine 🙄
@@maltesers1238Then it was clearly a direction from the production team for her to use her native accent, not an actors choice. I’ve worked with Naoimh Morgan (Rumpleteazer) and trust me, the woman can do anything and any accent, she’s amazing.
@@Anonymous-qm7qf yeah that's what I'm saying. Bad direction. Tom Hooper sucks
I personally like the new version.
Technically, calico cats are all female. But whatever...
Male calico cats are just impotent and exist… but whatever
Not all. Male calicos are very rare, and are sterile. But they do exist
This was the best part of the movie. They kept to the original version. If you dont like it then you dont know cats
Yup
Original does not equate better
@@MrrpDrrp but in this case, specifically, it is also better
I've always wondered what the relationship between these two is?
Wait a minute, New Dream Cats Collection; Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats Book, 1 Cats 1981 Broadway Musical in Music-CD, 1 Cats 1998 Movie in VHS, 1 Cats 2019 Movie in DVD-Video, and Deleted Cats Broadway Musical Songs and Dances in Music and Lyric Videos on I-Tunes.
The thing is it doesn't fit them. Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer are kittens. Kittens who are being loud and obnoxious
they butchered the candace of this awesome song
Gawd aful
Aren't male tortoiseshell cats impossible?? (I may be wrong though, I just read it somewhere)
Mangojerrie And Rumpleteazer By Andrew Lloyd Webber/Tim Rice
Cool
Why don't the Actors and Actresses in the Cats Broadway Musical wear some cat suits?
look how they massacred my boy :(
Please just go and find clips from the filmed stage show from 1998…this is horrible
Thanks, I hate it. 🙃
Not bad, but it could use more charisma. At least unlike certain songs, I can bear to listen to it.
I'm surprised the vase didn't fall, does that happen later in the scene?
Ewe, what did they do to this song, and why? Different melody, and it loses all of the lyrical zings of the original
The huntsville high-school was amazing
Why why whyyyyy. They killed this song. Sucked the joy out of it all 😩
映画ではこっちの曲だったんだ…。
Seriously what happened to the two children that are so called adults😭
totally killed the spirit of the song.
Im trying to give these songs a chance but so far, the original version of this song was better. Alot more character
This whole movie is just so WRONG.
как... плоско, скучно и уныло.
🥺😥
Why why do you do this to my heart their voices and personalities don't match the real Mungojerrie Rumpteazer from 1998 and I'm not trying to judge the actors I'm just saying they could have been more playful and childish😭
Geez you could have casted two twins that you see on the street and they would have done a a better job I feel like they did not study these characters they did not learn the personality these two twin cats that you see in the 2019 movie they are strangers to me
You clearly don’t know about ‘Cats’. This is a rendition of the original 1981 London version of the song.
These two are supposed to be troublemakers.
this is NOT mungojerrie and rumpleteazer
Today I'm gonna have some strange dreams 👌 after watching this horror video
I greatly prefer the 98 version of course but I’m in the minority of preferring this version of the song! I like the slower jazzy tempo, and how it builds with time
Holy Christ this is bad. From the singing to the pacing to the beat. Not to mention changing the song. They even say the others name? Lord above save me from this travesty.
This is how the original 1981 sounds. Cry about it.
Love the movie ❤❤❤❤❤❤ all heaters are idiots
I still don’t understand why they are so small?!
Do you realize we almost got to see a horrible CGI human-dog? Like, if Mice and Cockroaches are humanoid, why not dogs? Why doesnt't it speak? I'm glad they didn't attempt it, but like, it also just makes no sence.
this is my first time seeing anything from the cats movie……… i don’t wish to see more
Skimbleshanks is amazing my daughter's 3rd grade friends and teachers catch her sing it
1:19
Jesus loves you ❤️
It’s not the same song … and they aren’t singing at all …
Terrible
Чц1ау❤ф
Oh f*ck they ruined my favorite song
What is this.....
Honestly, this musical should have not been remade.
The original cats musical was the best !
They killed this song :(
Please stop remaking musicals !
Oh this is dreadful! Theyve literally ruined this amazing song.