Mine: 30 - The Four Horsemen 29 - Moth Into Flame 28 - Halo on Fire 27 - Too Far Gone? 26 - Enter Sandman 25 - Master of Puppets 24 - Sweet Amber 23 - The Call of Ktulu 22 - Battery 21 - No Remorse 20 - Fight Fire with Fire 19 - Fuel 18 - Trapped Under Ice 17 - For Whom the Bell Tolls 16 - Fixxxer 15 - Bleeding Me 14 - Cyanide 13 - Sanitarium 12 - My Friend of Misery 11 - Blackened 10 - Spit Out the Bone 9 - Creeping Death 8 - Wherever I May Roam 7 - Until It Sleeps 6 - The Unforgiven II 5 - Fade to Black 4 - All Nightmare Long 3 - Disposable Heroes 2 - Ride the Lightning 1 - The Outlaw Torn (especially S&M2)
@FullMetalEverything I agree that’s bs JITF is actually good, and is in my favorite songs list, it’s hard to believe that people will actually ‘hate it’
Fade to Black as a ballad is great as well but imo not as good as the unforgiven, plus its very overrated. I love every song on Rtl but i've never understood why ppl consider that one top 3 material. I think it's bcs Unforgiven is shorter and less repetitive. Sanitarium is great as well but it's a bit repetitive and long as well
@@vinceyrankings Glad you ask. It's really emotional, the lyrics are really relatable, love the shift from soft to heavy and the outro solo is insane. 😁
@@gabrielpaiva9070 All the shifts are insanely great, specially the ending, it's intense and full of meaning. That intro was also unexpected if you think about prime Metallica. As i said i love all of Rtl. It's my favorite album tied with MOP. When i first got into the band. MOP, unforgiven and Jump where my favorites since the very beginning.
Disposable Heroes is pretty neat, here’s my list 30. The Day That Never Comes 29. Invisible Kid 28. Sad But True 27. The Struggle Within 26. Through The Never 25. Just A Bullet Away 24. Battery 23. Chasing Light 22. Metal Militia 21. Hardwired 20. Atlas, Rise! 19. The Call Of Ktulu 18. Some Kind Of Monster 17. Frantic 16. St. Anger 15. For Whom The Bells Tolls 14. To Live Is To Die 13. One 12. Blackened 11. Nothing Else Matters 10. Enter Sandman 9. Master Of Puppets 8. Orion 7. [Anesthesia] -Pulling Teeth 6. Room Of Mirrors 5. All Within My Hands 4. Ride The Lightning 3. Inamorata. 2. Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 1. Fade To Black
Good list! Appreciate the time you took to type all of this! It actually surprises me to see Anesthesia, St Anger, Invisible Kid and Some kind of monster since i've never liked those songs but hey, it's your taste and it's good to be different
@@vinceyrankings Thanks, I feel like people just say St. Anger is bad, but they’re comparing it to albums like Master Of Puppets and Ride The Lightning. So yeah, when you compare it to albums like those, yes St. Anger sucks. But without comparing St. Anger to anything, it’s a solid album in my opinion. And I’ve just grown to love Anesthesia ‘cause my friend is a bass player and he always plays Anesthesia lol.
Great effort to put a list like this together, but so many great songs should be in there. Phantom Lord, Ride the lightning, Lepar Messiah, To live is to die, Sad but true, Fuel, St Anger, All Nightmare long.
@@nickozetti952 It's in my personal top 40's. It didn't impact me as hard as the others on this list plus pretty overrated (more than sandman imo) Agree on your ideas except for St. Anger which is one of my least favorite songs of theirs. Thank you for appreciating my effort!
I'm just having fun with you. I know everyone's opinions vary. St Anger is a terrible album, but I like the song. After the change of Metallica sound of the load and reload albums (I call them hard rock albums, not metal albums) it was good to hear them get back to that metal sound.
great list! i share a lot of parallels so here is mine: 30. lux aeterna 29. call of ktulu 28. the memory remains 27. dream no more 26. the thing that should not be 25. phantom lord 24. unforgiven 3 23. frantic 22. unforgiven 21. ride the lightning 20. some kind of monster 19. all nightmare long 18. ajfa 17. atlas rise 16. king nothing 15. outlaw torn 14. spit out the bone 13. 2x4 12. hit the lights 11. low mans lyric 10. four horseman 9. sanitarium 8. one 7. wherever i may roam 6. sad but true 5. damage inc 4. battery 3. 72 seasons 2. creeping death 1. dyers eve some that you call very underrated i have just outside the top 30… for instance Wild Things is my #42, inamorata is #39, heroes is #32, etc
mine: 30-The unamed feeling 29-Spit out the bone 28-Broken beat and scarred 27-Phantom Lord 26-All within my hand 25-Here comes revenge 24-The Shortest straw 23-Where ever I may roam 22-Confusion 21-My apocalypse 20-Metal militia 19-72 seasons 18-whiplash 17-King noting 16-Master of puppets 15-Fade to black 14-The day that Never comes 13-The unforgiven II 12-The Unforgiven 11-The unforgiven 10-Suicide and redemption 9-All Nightmare long 8-...and justice for all 7-Damage Inc. 6-Nothing else Matters 5-Ride the lighting 4-To live is to die 3-Call of Ktulu 2-Disposable heroes 1-One No One is not my top spot for the memes, genuinely my favourite metallic song and maybe even my favourite song of all time Rock On Metallica
My top favorite 30 best songs in my opinion 1- Battery 2- Master of Puppets 3- Enter Sandman 4- Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 5- Fight Fire with Fire 6- Fade to Black 7- Seek and Destroy 8- Creeping Death 9- Leper Messiah 10- Nothing Else Matters 11- The 4 Horsemen 12- Wherever I May Roam 13- King Nothing 14- Mama Said (This song is special for me, it helped me during the pandemic in 2020) 15- Fuel 16- Inamorata 17- The God That Failed 18- My Friend of Misery 19- Of Wolf and Man 20- 72 Seasons 21- Spit Out The Bone 22- Ride The Lightning 23- Trapped Under Ice 24- The Unforgiven 2 25- Disponsables Heroes 26- And Justice For All 27- Eye of the Beholder 28- One 29- You Must Burn! 30- The Outlaw Torn 5 extra: - Damage Inc. - The Frayed Ends of Sanity - The Memory Remains - The Day That Never Comes - All Nightmare Long
Woooahhh! Lots of incredibly BASED hot takes in here. Inamorata and Spit out the bone absolutely deserve to be on here, as well as Unf 3. Unforgiven. 3 is straight up my favorite metallic song period. I also heavily agree that holier than thou is super underrated, that's one of my favorite main riffs ever. Its definitely not top ten though. Same thing with jump in the fire and escape. Motorbreath, Trapped under ice, and shortest straw are cheeks. I just don't enjoy listening to them that much. I wanna point out sad but true and title track for 72s, those are some of my favorites.
I’ll do my top 20 planning on doing all of them 20: Nothing Else Matters 19: Ain’t My Bitch 18: Hardwired 17: Leper Messiah 16: Blackened 15: St. Anger 14: All Nightmare Long 13: The Thing That Should Not Be 12: Spit out The Bone 11: Ride The Lightning 10: Welcome Home Sanatarium 9: Enter Sandman 8: Where The Wild Things Are (Underrated as hell) 7: Fade To Black 6: Damage Inc 5: For Whom The Bell Tolls 4: Master of Puppets 3: One 2: Suicide & Redemption (Yeah, love this song. Best solo to any song ever only things holding it back from being number 1 is the main riff is annoying as hell should’ve been like 15 minutes long thought it’s already like 10 minutes long.) 1: Disposable Heroes
Here's mine: 30 - Escape 29 - Fuel 28 - Ride the Lightning 27 - ...And Justice for All 26 - Metal Militia 25 - The Unforgiven II 24 - 2 X 4 23 - Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth) 22 - Until it Sleeps 21 - The Unforgiven III 20 - The God that Failed 19 - Disposable Heroes 18 - Confusion 17 - Welcome Home, Sanitarium 16 - The Thing That Should Not Be 15 - Sweet Amber 14 - The Outlaw Torn 13 - Bad Seed 12 - Moth Into Flame 11 - Battery 10 - For Whom the Bell Tolls 9 - Creeping Death 8 - Enter Sandman 7 - Harvester of Sorrow 6 - Seek And Destroy 5 - The Unforgiven 4 - One 3 - Inamorata 2 - Fade to Black 1 - Blackened
Here's the reason that they didn't play Dyers Eve that much: 5 words: It's way too damn fast. Might not seem like it but try to play it for 5 minutes straight and you'll understand
I listem them from like 2013-14 and I totally agree with Your ranking, but there's more awesome songs like Metal Militria, No remose from Kill' Em All; Next is Black Album because songs from RTL to Justice are on perfect place. I love Wherever I May Roam and Of Wolf and Man, these songs are masterpieces. From Load very underrated is Wasting My Hate. St. Anger is very hated album but I listen to this album many times and I like it, my fav is Sweet Amber; this riff is soo good. DM song are very underrated like The Judas Kiss and My Apocalypse, I recomend listen to costum version of My Apocalypse in Seattle 89' cuz this is killer. From Hardwierd album my heart goes to Moth Into Flame, Halo On Fire and Split Out the Bone. And closing we have 72 Seasons album: Instantly I loved Screeming Suicide, Lux Æterna with 80' vibe, Chasing Light, Too far Gone?, Room of Mirrors where drums are killer and Inamorata
Hard to give only 30. I’ll give you the whole discog. The best of the best. Isolated from the others. Just perfect: 1 Creeping Death 2 One 3 Fight Fire With Fire 4 Master of Puppets 5 Blackened 6 Ride The Lightning 7 Battery Absolute classics, though not as good as the top 7: 8 Seek and Destroy 9 Eye of the Beholder 10 Don’t Tread on Me 11 For Whom The Bell Tolls 12 Fade To Black 13 Disposable Heroes 14 And Justice For All 15 Damage Inc 16 The Four Horsemen 17 Broken Beat And Scarred 18 The Frayed Ends of Sanity 19 The Thing That Should Not Be 20 Escape These ones aren’t S tier but still legendary: 21 Enter Sandman 22 Spit Out The Bone 23 My Friend of Misery 24 Nothing Else Matters 25 Whiplash 26 The Unforgiven III 27 Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 28 Inamorata 29 Harvester of Sorrow 30 Dyers Eve 31 Hardwired 32 Cyanide 33 Fuel 34 Now That We’re Dead They’re bangers, but not enough to be called legendary: 35 The Call of Ktulu 36 Cure 37 No Remorse 38 The Day That Never Comes 39 The End of the Line 40 The Unforgiven 41 2x4 42 Frantic 43 Metal Militia 44 Bad Seed 45 My Apocalypse 46 72 Seasons 47 Where The Wild Things Are 48 Lux Aeterna 49 Hit The Lights 50 Trapped Under Ice These songs are still very good, like Metallica usually are: 51 Orion 52 The Struggle Within 53 Shoot Me Again 54 Sad But True 55 All Nightmare Long 56 Shadows Follow 57 Suicide And Redemption 58 To Live Is To Die 59 Moth Into Flame 60 Room of Mirrors 61 Sleepwalk My Life Away 62 Murder One 63 Attitude 64 That Was Just Your Life 65 Motorbreath 66 The Shortest Straw 67 If Darkness Had A Son 68 You Must Burn 69 Fixxxer 70 Leper Messiah 71 The Unnamed Feeling I definitely like them, but most others surpass them: 72 Phantom Lord 73 ManUNkind 74 The Outlaw Torn 75 Holier Than Thou 76 Am I Savage 77 Atlas Rise 78 The Unforgiven II 79 St Anger 80 Here Comes Revenge 81 Prince Charming These songs I can still call them good songs but I don’t feel they match the rest: 82 Halo On Fire 83 Wherever I May Roam 84 Purify 85 Devil’s Dance 86 Chasing Light 87 My World 88 All Within My Hands 89 Until It Sleeps 90 Through The Never 91 Some Kind of Monster 92 King Nothing They’re decent, but I can’t quite call them good.: 93 Bleeding Me 94 Better Than You 95 The God That Failed 96 Poor Twisted Me 97 Dream No More 98 Too Far Gone 99 Screaming Suicide They’re OK. I can still enjoy them for the most part but there are a few things that aren’t my taste: 100 Carpe Diem Baby 101 Wasting My Hate 102 The Judas Kiss 103 Sweet Amber 104 Thorn Within 105 Ain’t My B***h 106 Confusion 107 Crown of Barbed Wire I don’t really enjoy these ones. I don’t dislike them enough for me to say that I hate them, though. Just not easy for me to listen to: 108 Anaesthesia (Pulling Teeth) 109 Mama Said 110 Hero of the Day 111 Low Man’s Lyric 112 Dirty Window These are the songs that I HATE: 113 Of Wolf And Man 114 Slither 115 Ronnie 116 The Memory Remains 117 Jump In The Fire 118 Invisible Kid 119 The House Jack Built
Wow!! That must have taken a lot of time!! I made a list ranking all of their songs and you should make your own as well, it doesn't have to be a super editing masterpiece tho.. I love Jump In The Fire and like The House Jack Built but I perfectly see why you don't like them.. Maybe Jump sounds like an old annoying ACDC song and the talkbox solo is self-explainatory. Also making this lists is about being different and sharing different opinions, otherwise it would be boring if everyone had the same opinion or taste
Mine: 30: Frantic 29: The Four Horsemen 28: The End of the Line 27: Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 26: The Frayed Ends Of Sanity 25: 72 Seasons 24: Shadows Follow 23: Screaming Suicide 22: The Unforgiven 21: Fade to Black 20: Moth Into Flame 19: Cyanide 18: Jump In The Fire 17: Seek & Destroy (especially from their 1990-1994 concerts with the song) 16: Fight Fire With Fire 15: Until It Sleeps 14: Lux Æterna 13: If Darkness Had A Son 12: Spit Out The Bone 11: Sad But True 10: Wherever I May Roam 9: Disposable Heroes 8: Creeping Death 7: Master of Puppets 6: All Nightmare Long 5: For Whom The Bell Tolls 4: Harvester Of Sorrow 3: Inamorata 2: Enter Sandman 1: One
1-To Live Is To Die 2-Fade to black 3-My friend of misery 4-Dyers Eve 5-The day that never comes 6-The Call of Ktulu 7-Eye of the beholder 8-Orion 9-Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 10-Blackened 11-The unforgiven 12-Harvester of Sorrow 13-Creeping Death 14-That was just your life 15-Nothing else matters 16-The four horsemen 17-One 18-And Justice For All... 19-For whom the bell tolls 20-Master of puppets 21-Damage, Inc. 22-Fight fire with fire 23-Wherever i may roam 24-Just A Bullet Away 25-Suicid & Redemption 26-The unforgiven II 27-Moth Into Flame 28-Halo On Fire 29-The unforgiven III 30-Battery
Buen video, buenas elecciones, trapped under oce y until it sleeps casi nunca aparecen en los tops de la gente. Totalmente de acuerdo en que es la mejor del RTL Tienes pensado en hacer videos de top de las canciones mas difíciles de tocar?
No se nada de teoría musical y solo hago estos videos para compartir mi opinión e interés sobre la banda. Tienes otra idea quizas? Aun tengo q hacer el top de las infravaloradas
Here's my top favorite Met songs (i'll go with one per album because i know i'm gonna include the whole Justice album if i don't make it like that): 12) 72 Seasons 11) Moth Into Flame 10) Iced Honey (yes, some Lulu, this is one of their best song ever in my opinion) 9) The Unforgiven III 8) Frantic 7) Carpe Diem Baby 6) Wasting My Hate 5) Wherever I May Roam ? 4) ...And Justice For All 3) Leper Messiah 2) Ride The Lightning 1) No Remorse
I'll offer just a Top 10. 1. Creeping Death. 2. Master of Puppets. 3. One. 4. That Was Just Your Life. 5. Fade to Black. 6. For Whom The Bell Tolls. 7. The Four Horsemen. 8. Moth Into Flame. 9. Blackened. 10. Seek & Destroy. Honorable mention (cover song): Remember Tomorrow.
My top 20 is: 1- Orion 2- Master of puppets 3- One 4- For whom the bell tolls 5- Nothing else matters 6- Fade to black 7- Creeping death 8- Sanitarium 9- Blackened 10- Call of ktulu 11- Seek and destroy 12- The four horsemen 13- Disposable heroes 14- The things that should not be 15- Battery 16- The shortest straw 17- To live is to die 18- Ride the lightning 19- Anesthesia 20- And justice for all
My list would be totally different than yours. Let me give it a try: 1. One 2. Fade to Black 3. The Unforgiven 4. Blackened 5. Master of puppets 6. For whom the bell tolls 7. Hero of the day 8. Wherever I may roam 9. Unforgiven 2 10. Turn the page 11. Low man's lyric 12. And Justice for all 13. Battery 14. Until it sleeps 15. Whiskey in the Jar 16. Bleeding me 17. Mama said 18. Outlaw torn 19. Unforgiven 3 20. Creeping death
Whiskey in the jar???!!😱 Sorry, I just got surprised since I seriously cannot stand that song but hey, it's ur taste. Appreciate the time u took to type all of this
@vinceyrankings that's because I always liked the original one and when Metallica sang that, I found their version even better than the original. Never expected that.
I definitely have one of the most unusual tops in terms of a set of songs... Let's go! 30) No Leaf Clover 29) Orion 28) Rebel of Babylon 27) Hardwired 26) Frantic 25) Bleeding Me 24) Phantom Lord 23) Hit the Lights 22) Fade to Black 21) The Call of Ktulu 20) Shoot Me Again (yes, I like this song) 19) The Unforgiven III 18) Until it Sleeps 17) Mama Said 16) The Judas Kiss 15) The Shortest Straw 14) The Struggle Within (does anyone even remember about her?) 13) The Unforgiven II 12) Fight Fire with Fire 11) St. Anger 10) Leper Messiah 9) Fuel 8) The Unforgiven 7) Damage Inc. 6) For Whom the Bell Tolls 5) One 4) Jump in The Fire (SO COME ON!) 3) No Remorse 2) Some Kind of Monster (SURPRISE!) 1) The Four Horsemen I love a huge number of Metallica songs, but I got tired of some, but I still listen to these and enjoy them. All the songs that are in the top - I still listen to them often. YEAH!
master of puppets should have been put further. Even if it is overrated it still belongs further up, especialy since it introduced you (and me) to the band.
It still holds up tho. FTB and FWTBT kind of lost its touch for me but this, RTL, Unforgiven were too strong to still be a few of my favorites. What's your top 30?
This list is tentative so I may change things around, but here’s my top 30: 30. Sweet Amber 29. The Four Horsemen 28. Halo on Fire 27. Moth Into Flame 26. All Nightmare Long 25. Too Far Gone? 24. Creeping Death 23. To Live is to Die 22. Master of Puppets 21. Dyers Eve 20. Inamorata 19. The Unforgiven II 18. The Unforgiven III 17. Bleeding Me 16. Ride the Lightning 15. Spit Out the Bone 14. Whiplash 13. The Unforgiven 12. Damage, Inc. 11. Blackened 10. The Outlaw Torn 9. Orion 8. Suicide & Redemption 7. Fight Fire With Fire 6. Fixxxer 5. No Leaf Clover 4. Fade to Black 3. Disposable Heroes 2. One 1. Nothing Else Matters
My top not in order would be: one, sanitarium, wherever i may roam, the unforgiven, creeping death, fade to Black, moth into flame, orion, master of puppets, and justice for all, the frayed ends of sanity, inamorata, dyers eve, the outlaw torn
I personally love Escape cos it's full of angst and i love the bridge riff. I like FTB as well but it kind of depresses me depending on my mood. It's not top 10 worth, top 20 at the very most, i honestly put it in in the top 40
I personally have it somewhere my top 50 bcs it didn't hit me as hard as the other songs even tho it is still a really good song. There's like only 20 songs in their discography I dislike, so..
Always too polarized opinions towards Escape, this song have come a long way from being underrated to be considered one the very best of the band. But seriously guys, it wasnt that bad back in the day (actually I liked it) but it's still a filler song that pales within the formidable discography of Metallica.
Mine:
30 - The Four Horsemen
29 - Moth Into Flame
28 - Halo on Fire
27 - Too Far Gone?
26 - Enter Sandman
25 - Master of Puppets
24 - Sweet Amber
23 - The Call of Ktulu
22 - Battery
21 - No Remorse
20 - Fight Fire with Fire
19 - Fuel
18 - Trapped Under Ice
17 - For Whom the Bell Tolls
16 - Fixxxer
15 - Bleeding Me
14 - Cyanide
13 - Sanitarium
12 - My Friend of Misery
11 - Blackened
10 - Spit Out the Bone
9 - Creeping Death
8 - Wherever I May Roam
7 - Until It Sleeps
6 - The Unforgiven II
5 - Fade to Black
4 - All Nightmare Long
3 - Disposable Heroes
2 - Ride the Lightning
1 - The Outlaw Torn (especially S&M2)
Accurate ranking homie.
It’s a cardinal sun that Ride the lightning was dead last and not top 5
Finally someone who likes Jump In The Fire
Ym people think it sucks? Bs that is
This horrible jump in the fire bro
@FullMetalEverything I agree that’s bs JITF is actually good, and is in my favorite songs list, it’s hard to believe that people will actually ‘hate it’
Much respect for putting Motorbreath, Bleeding me and Jump in the Fire, underrated songs indeed
Very nice choices! Motorbreath and Trapped Under Ice are SOOOOOO underrated.
Also, finally someone agrees that The Unforgiven is their best ballad.
Fade to Black as a ballad is great as well but imo not as good as the unforgiven, plus its very overrated. I love every song on Rtl but i've never understood why ppl consider that one top 3 material. I think it's bcs Unforgiven is shorter and less repetitive. Sanitarium is great as well but it's a bit repetitive and long as well
@@vinceyrankings Honestly, Fade To Black is my favourite off RTL (Trapped Under Ice is really close) but to each their own.
@@gabrielpaiva9070 Oh ok then. What do u like about it? 😀
@@vinceyrankings Glad you ask. It's really emotional, the lyrics are really relatable, love the shift from soft to heavy and the outro solo is insane. 😁
@@gabrielpaiva9070 All the shifts are insanely great, specially the ending, it's intense and full of meaning. That intro was also unexpected if you think about prime Metallica. As i said i love all of Rtl. It's my favorite album tied with MOP.
When i first got into the band. MOP, unforgiven and Jump where my favorites since the very beginning.
Finally some love for the unforgiven 3!!!
That vocal into the solo 😫😫😫
Thanks for adding my favourite concert in the background!
Disposable Heroes is pretty neat, here’s my list
30. The Day That Never Comes
29. Invisible Kid
28. Sad But True
27. The Struggle Within
26. Through The Never
25. Just A Bullet Away
24. Battery
23. Chasing Light
22. Metal Militia
21. Hardwired
20. Atlas, Rise!
19. The Call Of Ktulu
18. Some Kind Of Monster
17. Frantic
16. St. Anger
15. For Whom The Bells Tolls
14. To Live Is To Die
13. One
12. Blackened
11. Nothing Else Matters
10. Enter Sandman
9. Master Of Puppets
8. Orion
7. [Anesthesia] -Pulling Teeth
6. Room Of Mirrors
5. All Within My Hands
4. Ride The Lightning
3. Inamorata.
2. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
1. Fade To Black
Good list! Appreciate the time you took to type all of this! It actually surprises me to see Anesthesia, St Anger, Invisible Kid and Some kind of monster since i've never liked those songs but hey, it's your taste and it's good to be different
@@vinceyrankings Thanks, I feel like people just say St. Anger is bad, but they’re comparing it to albums like Master Of Puppets and Ride The Lightning. So yeah, when you compare it to albums like those, yes St. Anger sucks. But without comparing St. Anger to anything, it’s a solid album in my opinion. And I’ve just grown to love Anesthesia ‘cause my friend is a bass player and he always plays Anesthesia lol.
Finally someone who mentioned Orion!!!
Its the most unerrated Metallica song
Glad you have Blackened on here, best one ever IMO
my man had the balls to put escape third , you have my total respect
I had The Thing That Should Not Be as my fav because I mostly like the heavier sh*t. And this song might be their heaviest.
excuse me, where is fade to black?
Overrated
@@Narcissist808cap
Four Horseman? Sanitarium? Sad but True? For whom the bell tolls? Whiplash? Sandman?, FADE TO BLACK?
Sad but true and whiplash are in my top 60
Bellz is in my top 50
FTB top 40
Four Horsemen, Sandman and Sanitarium in the top 35-30
exactly I was so sad sanitarium and fade to black wasn't on there
Whatever someone says, Metallica is the greatest metal band ever.
First four albums are iconic.
Great effort to put a list like this together, but so many great songs should be in there. Phantom Lord, Ride the lightning, Lepar Messiah, To live is to die, Sad but true, Fuel, St Anger, All Nightmare long.
Oh and why isn't fade to black in there?
@@nickozetti952 It's in my personal top 40's. It didn't impact me as hard as the others on this list plus pretty overrated (more than sandman imo) Agree on your ideas except for St. Anger which is one of my least favorite songs of theirs. Thank you for appreciating my effort!
I'm just having fun with you. I know everyone's opinions vary. St Anger is a terrible album, but I like the song. After the change of Metallica sound of the load and reload albums (I call them hard rock albums, not metal albums) it was good to hear them get back to that metal sound.
great list! i share a lot of parallels so here is mine:
30. lux aeterna
29. call of ktulu
28. the memory remains
27. dream no more
26. the thing that should not be
25. phantom lord
24. unforgiven 3
23. frantic
22. unforgiven
21. ride the lightning
20. some kind of monster
19. all nightmare long
18. ajfa
17. atlas rise
16. king nothing
15. outlaw torn
14. spit out the bone
13. 2x4
12. hit the lights
11. low mans lyric
10. four horseman
9. sanitarium
8. one
7. wherever i may roam
6. sad but true
5. damage inc
4. battery
3. 72 seasons
2. creeping death
1. dyers eve
some that you call very underrated i have just outside the top 30… for instance Wild Things is my #42, inamorata is #39, heroes is #32, etc
mine:
30-The unamed feeling
29-Spit out the bone
28-Broken beat and scarred
27-Phantom Lord
26-All within my hand
25-Here comes revenge
24-The Shortest straw
23-Where ever I may roam
22-Confusion
21-My apocalypse
20-Metal militia
19-72 seasons
18-whiplash
17-King noting
16-Master of puppets
15-Fade to black
14-The day that Never comes
13-The unforgiven II
12-The Unforgiven
11-The unforgiven
10-Suicide and redemption
9-All Nightmare long
8-...and justice for all
7-Damage Inc.
6-Nothing else Matters
5-Ride the lighting
4-To live is to die
3-Call of Ktulu
2-Disposable heroes
1-One
No One is not my top spot for the memes, genuinely my favourite metallic song and maybe even my favourite song of all time
Rock On Metallica
My top favorite 30 best songs in my opinion
1- Battery
2- Master of Puppets
3- Enter Sandman
4- Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
5- Fight Fire with Fire
6- Fade to Black
7- Seek and Destroy
8- Creeping Death
9- Leper Messiah
10- Nothing Else Matters
11- The 4 Horsemen
12- Wherever I May Roam
13- King Nothing
14- Mama Said (This song is special for me, it helped me during the pandemic in 2020)
15- Fuel
16- Inamorata
17- The God That Failed
18- My Friend of Misery
19- Of Wolf and Man
20- 72 Seasons
21- Spit Out The Bone
22- Ride The Lightning
23- Trapped Under Ice
24- The Unforgiven 2
25- Disponsables Heroes
26- And Justice For All
27- Eye of the Beholder
28- One
29- You Must Burn!
30- The Outlaw Torn
5 extra:
- Damage Inc.
- The Frayed Ends of Sanity
- The Memory Remains
- The Day That Never Comes
- All Nightmare Long
Woooahhh! Lots of incredibly BASED hot takes in here. Inamorata and Spit out the bone absolutely deserve to be on here, as well as Unf 3. Unforgiven. 3 is straight up my favorite metallic song period. I also heavily agree that holier than thou is super underrated, that's one of my favorite main riffs ever. Its definitely not top ten though. Same thing with jump in the fire and escape. Motorbreath, Trapped under ice, and shortest straw are cheeks. I just don't enjoy listening to them that much. I wanna point out sad but true and title track for 72s, those are some of my favorites.
I’ll do my top 20 planning on doing all of them
20: Nothing Else Matters
19: Ain’t My Bitch
18: Hardwired
17: Leper Messiah
16: Blackened
15: St. Anger
14: All Nightmare Long
13: The Thing That Should Not Be
12: Spit out The Bone
11: Ride The Lightning
10: Welcome Home Sanatarium
9: Enter Sandman
8: Where The Wild Things Are
(Underrated as hell)
7: Fade To Black
6: Damage Inc
5: For Whom The Bell Tolls
4: Master of Puppets
3: One
2: Suicide & Redemption
(Yeah, love this song. Best solo to any song ever only things holding it back from being number 1 is the main riff is annoying as hell should’ve been like 15 minutes long thought it’s already like 10 minutes long.)
1: Disposable Heroes
Very fair list! Wild Things, Nightnare and Redemption are really good
Here's mine:
30 - Escape
29 - Fuel
28 - Ride the Lightning
27 - ...And Justice for All
26 - Metal Militia
25 - The Unforgiven II
24 - 2 X 4
23 - Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth)
22 - Until it Sleeps
21 - The Unforgiven III
20 - The God that Failed
19 - Disposable Heroes
18 - Confusion
17 - Welcome Home, Sanitarium
16 - The Thing That Should Not Be
15 - Sweet Amber
14 - The Outlaw Torn
13 - Bad Seed
12 - Moth Into Flame
11 - Battery
10 - For Whom the Bell Tolls
9 - Creeping Death
8 - Enter Sandman
7 - Harvester of Sorrow
6 - Seek And Destroy
5 - The Unforgiven
4 - One
3 - Inamorata
2 - Fade to Black
1 - Blackened
FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE WHO LIKES TTTSNB
Finally someone Who likes shortest straw
Here's the reason that they didn't play Dyers Eve that much:
5 words: It's way too damn fast. Might not seem like it but try to play it for 5 minutes straight and you'll understand
I listem them from like 2013-14 and I totally agree with Your ranking, but there's more awesome songs like Metal Militria, No remose from Kill' Em All; Next is Black Album because songs from RTL to Justice are on perfect place. I love Wherever I May Roam and Of Wolf and Man, these songs are masterpieces. From Load very underrated is Wasting My Hate. St. Anger is very hated album but I listen to this album many times and I like it, my fav is Sweet Amber; this riff is soo good. DM song are very underrated like The Judas Kiss and My Apocalypse, I recomend listen to costum version of My Apocalypse in Seattle 89' cuz this is killer. From Hardwierd album my heart goes to Moth Into Flame, Halo On Fire and Split Out the Bone. And closing we have 72 Seasons album: Instantly I loved Screeming Suicide, Lux Æterna with 80' vibe, Chasing Light, Too far Gone?, Room of Mirrors where drums are killer and Inamorata
Nice list!
THIS LIST IS SUPER VALID
Hard to give only 30. I’ll give you the whole discog.
The best of the best. Isolated from the others. Just perfect:
1 Creeping Death
2 One
3 Fight Fire With Fire
4 Master of Puppets
5 Blackened
6 Ride The Lightning
7 Battery
Absolute classics, though not as good as the top 7:
8 Seek and Destroy
9 Eye of the Beholder
10 Don’t Tread on Me
11 For Whom The Bell Tolls
12 Fade To Black
13 Disposable Heroes
14 And Justice For All
15 Damage Inc
16 The Four Horsemen
17 Broken Beat And Scarred
18 The Frayed Ends of Sanity
19 The Thing That Should Not Be
20 Escape
These ones aren’t S tier but still legendary:
21 Enter Sandman
22 Spit Out The Bone
23 My Friend of Misery
24 Nothing Else Matters
25 Whiplash
26 The Unforgiven III
27 Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
28 Inamorata
29 Harvester of Sorrow
30 Dyers Eve
31 Hardwired
32 Cyanide
33 Fuel
34 Now That We’re Dead
They’re bangers, but not enough to be called legendary:
35 The Call of Ktulu
36 Cure
37 No Remorse
38 The Day That Never Comes
39 The End of the Line
40 The Unforgiven
41 2x4
42 Frantic
43 Metal Militia
44 Bad Seed
45 My Apocalypse
46 72 Seasons
47 Where The Wild Things Are
48 Lux Aeterna
49 Hit The Lights
50 Trapped Under Ice
These songs are still very good, like Metallica usually are:
51 Orion
52 The Struggle Within
53 Shoot Me Again
54 Sad But True
55 All Nightmare Long
56 Shadows Follow
57 Suicide And Redemption
58 To Live Is To Die
59 Moth Into Flame
60 Room of Mirrors
61 Sleepwalk My Life Away
62 Murder One
63 Attitude
64 That Was Just Your Life
65 Motorbreath
66 The Shortest Straw
67 If Darkness Had A Son
68 You Must Burn
69 Fixxxer
70 Leper Messiah
71 The Unnamed Feeling
I definitely like them, but most others surpass them:
72 Phantom Lord
73 ManUNkind
74 The Outlaw Torn
75 Holier Than Thou
76 Am I Savage
77 Atlas Rise
78 The Unforgiven II
79 St Anger
80 Here Comes Revenge
81 Prince Charming
These songs I can still call them good songs but I don’t feel they match the rest:
82 Halo On Fire
83 Wherever I May Roam
84 Purify
85 Devil’s Dance
86 Chasing Light
87 My World
88 All Within My Hands
89 Until It Sleeps
90 Through The Never
91 Some Kind of Monster
92 King Nothing
They’re decent, but I can’t quite call them good.:
93 Bleeding Me
94 Better Than You
95 The God That Failed
96 Poor Twisted Me
97 Dream No More
98 Too Far Gone
99 Screaming Suicide
They’re OK. I can still enjoy them for the most part but there are a few things that aren’t my taste:
100 Carpe Diem Baby
101 Wasting My Hate
102 The Judas Kiss
103 Sweet Amber
104 Thorn Within
105 Ain’t My B***h
106 Confusion
107 Crown of Barbed Wire
I don’t really enjoy these ones. I don’t dislike them enough for me to say that I hate them, though. Just not easy for me to listen to:
108 Anaesthesia (Pulling Teeth)
109 Mama Said
110 Hero of the Day
111 Low Man’s Lyric
112 Dirty Window
These are the songs that I HATE:
113 Of Wolf And Man
114 Slither
115 Ronnie
116 The Memory Remains
117 Jump In The Fire
118 Invisible Kid
119 The House Jack Built
Wow!! That must have taken a lot of time!! I made a list ranking all of their songs and you should make your own as well, it doesn't have to be a super editing masterpiece tho.. I love Jump In The Fire and like The House Jack Built but I perfectly see why you don't like them.. Maybe Jump sounds like an old annoying ACDC song and the talkbox solo is self-explainatory.
Also making this lists is about being different and sharing different opinions, otherwise it would be boring if everyone had the same opinion or taste
Glad to see The Unforgiven III in here. Good list, I like it.
Also where is Of Wolf and Man for you? It's my number 1
It's at #34 for me.
Glad you liked the list!
we have the exaclty (exeption of escape, obvislouly) top 3!
Mine:
30: Frantic
29: The Four Horsemen
28: The End of the Line
27: Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
26: The Frayed Ends Of Sanity
25: 72 Seasons
24: Shadows Follow
23: Screaming Suicide
22: The Unforgiven
21: Fade to Black
20: Moth Into Flame
19: Cyanide
18: Jump In The Fire
17: Seek & Destroy (especially from their 1990-1994 concerts with the song)
16: Fight Fire With Fire
15: Until It Sleeps
14: Lux Æterna
13: If Darkness Had A Son
12: Spit Out The Bone
11: Sad But True
10: Wherever I May Roam
9: Disposable Heroes
8: Creeping Death
7: Master of Puppets
6: All Nightmare Long
5: For Whom The Bell Tolls
4: Harvester Of Sorrow
3: Inamorata
2: Enter Sandman
1: One
1-To Live Is To Die
2-Fade to black
3-My friend of misery
4-Dyers Eve
5-The day that never comes
6-The Call of Ktulu
7-Eye of the beholder
8-Orion
9-Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
10-Blackened
11-The unforgiven
12-Harvester of Sorrow
13-Creeping Death
14-That was just your life
15-Nothing else matters
16-The four horsemen
17-One
18-And Justice For All...
19-For whom the bell tolls
20-Master of puppets
21-Damage, Inc.
22-Fight fire with fire
23-Wherever i may roam
24-Just A Bullet Away
25-Suicid & Redemption
26-The unforgiven II
27-Moth Into Flame
28-Halo On Fire
29-The unforgiven III
30-Battery
Buen video, buenas elecciones, trapped under oce y until it sleeps casi nunca aparecen en los tops de la gente. Totalmente de acuerdo en que es la mejor del RTL
Tienes pensado en hacer videos de top de las canciones mas difíciles de tocar?
No se nada de teoría musical y solo hago estos videos para compartir mi opinión e interés sobre la banda. Tienes otra idea quizas? Aun tengo q hacer el top de las infravaloradas
@@vinceyrankings canciones del st. Anger de peor a menos peor
@@Mundo-Metal ya tengo un ranking de st anger. Pero la idea me causa gracia por lo malo que es
@@vinceyrankingsQuiero decir, st La ira no era tan mala
Dude I’m glad someone else loves Escape as much as I do
Here's my top favorite Met songs (i'll go with one per album because i know i'm gonna include the whole Justice album if i don't make it like that):
12) 72 Seasons
11) Moth Into Flame
10) Iced Honey (yes, some Lulu, this is one of their best song ever in my opinion)
9) The Unforgiven III
8) Frantic
7) Carpe Diem Baby
6) Wasting My Hate
5) Wherever I May Roam ?
4) ...And Justice For All
3) Leper Messiah
2) Ride The Lightning
1) No Remorse
I'll offer just a Top 10.
1. Creeping Death.
2. Master of Puppets.
3. One.
4. That Was Just Your Life.
5. Fade to Black.
6. For Whom The Bell Tolls.
7. The Four Horsemen.
8. Moth Into Flame.
9. Blackened.
10. Seek & Destroy.
Honorable mention (cover song): Remember Tomorrow.
i have Creeping Death first… the entire song is badass, especially that bridge!
Why aren't you giving Orion some love lol?
It's in my top 40 and Ktulu is Cliff's masterpiece imo. Top 45+ are 9's/10 btw
@@vinceyrankings Both belong top 5 IMO, neither is better than the other, they do different things better than the other.
My top 20 is:
1- Orion
2- Master of puppets
3- One
4- For whom the bell tolls
5- Nothing else matters
6- Fade to black
7- Creeping death
8- Sanitarium
9- Blackened
10- Call of ktulu
11- Seek and destroy
12- The four horsemen
13- Disposable heroes
14- The things that should not be
15- Battery
16- The shortest straw
17- To live is to die
18- Ride the lightning
19- Anesthesia
20- And justice for all
Escape!! Yes! Also in my top 3
My list would be totally different than yours. Let me give it a try:
1. One
2. Fade to Black
3. The Unforgiven
4. Blackened
5. Master of puppets
6. For whom the bell tolls
7. Hero of the day
8. Wherever I may roam
9. Unforgiven 2
10. Turn the page
11. Low man's lyric
12. And Justice for all
13. Battery
14. Until it sleeps
15. Whiskey in the Jar
16. Bleeding me
17. Mama said
18. Outlaw torn
19. Unforgiven 3
20. Creeping death
Whiskey in the jar???!!😱
Sorry, I just got surprised since I seriously cannot stand that song but hey, it's ur taste. Appreciate the time u took to type all of this
@vinceyrankings that's because I always liked the original one and when Metallica sang that, I found their version even better than the original. Never expected that.
Finally someone shoes some love to hero of the day
I definitely have one of the most unusual tops in terms of a set of songs...
Let's go!
30) No Leaf Clover
29) Orion
28) Rebel of Babylon
27) Hardwired
26) Frantic
25) Bleeding Me
24) Phantom Lord
23) Hit the Lights
22) Fade to Black
21) The Call of Ktulu
20) Shoot Me Again (yes, I like this song)
19) The Unforgiven III
18) Until it Sleeps
17) Mama Said
16) The Judas Kiss
15) The Shortest Straw
14) The Struggle Within (does anyone even remember about her?)
13) The Unforgiven II
12) Fight Fire with Fire
11) St. Anger
10) Leper Messiah
9) Fuel
8) The Unforgiven
7) Damage Inc.
6) For Whom the Bell Tolls
5) One
4) Jump in The Fire (SO COME ON!)
3) No Remorse
2) Some Kind of Monster (SURPRISE!)
1) The Four Horsemen
I love a huge number of Metallica songs, but I got tired of some, but I still listen to these and enjoy them. All the songs that are in the top - I still listen to them often. YEAH!
master of puppets should have been put further. Even if it is overrated it still belongs further up, especialy since it introduced you (and me) to the band.
It still holds up tho. FTB and FWTBT kind of lost its touch for me but this, RTL, Unforgiven were too strong to still be a few of my favorites. What's your top 30?
This list is tentative so I may change things around, but here’s my top 30:
30. Sweet Amber
29. The Four Horsemen
28. Halo on Fire
27. Moth Into Flame
26. All Nightmare Long
25. Too Far Gone?
24. Creeping Death
23. To Live is to Die
22. Master of Puppets
21. Dyers Eve
20. Inamorata
19. The Unforgiven II
18. The Unforgiven III
17. Bleeding Me
16. Ride the Lightning
15. Spit Out the Bone
14. Whiplash
13. The Unforgiven
12. Damage, Inc.
11. Blackened
10. The Outlaw Torn
9. Orion
8. Suicide & Redemption
7. Fight Fire With Fire
6. Fixxxer
5. No Leaf Clover
4. Fade to Black
3. Disposable Heroes
2. One
1. Nothing Else Matters
My top not in order would be: one, sanitarium, wherever i may roam, the unforgiven, creeping death, fade to Black, moth into flame, orion, master of puppets, and justice for all, the frayed ends of sanity, inamorata, dyers eve, the outlaw torn
it pisses me off that you put escape top 3 but didn’t even put fade to black in this ENTIRE list!?
I personally love Escape cos it's full of angst and i love the bridge riff. I like FTB as well but it kind of depresses me depending on my mood.
It's not top 10 worth, top 20 at the very most, i honestly put it in in the top 40
Nice list, but no fade to black?!
I personally have it somewhere my top 50 bcs it didn't hit me as hard as the other songs even tho it is still a really good song. There's like only 20 songs in their discography I dislike, so..
@@vinceyrankings valid. Metallica is hard to rank bc they have so many great songs !
We disagree about most of the list (or at least the placement of songs on the list) except for 1 thing.
DISPOSABLE HEROES at #1.
My personal opinion….Halo on Fire has one of the coolest outros ever 🤘🏻
Where are room of mirrors and shadows follow?
Why did no one talk about Blitzkreig😭😭😭
It's a cover. Great song though.
@@metalzonemt-2 I literally just found this out like an hour ago before seeing this comment.
why does everyone forget about the lords of summer?
They should return
Always too polarized opinions towards Escape, this song have come a long way from being underrated to be considered one the very best of the band. But seriously guys, it wasnt that bad back in the day (actually I liked it) but it's still a filler song that pales within the formidable discography of Metallica.
Where’s fade to black…
I don't care what y'all will say but I really don't like any of the Unforgivens
So motorbreath,jump into the fire,escape,trapped under ice and disposable heroes are the 5 best Metallica songs?😳 pretty good list though