I didn't know that the results were obscured, I would like to add the results as follows: Baking Soda - Styrofoam - Charcoal - Cement Test 1: Top1 - Top 4 - Top 3 - Top2 Test 2: Top1 - Top 3 - Top 4 - Top2 Test 3: Top3 - Top 4 - Top 1 - Top2 I hope you enjoy watching my video! Thank you so much!
⚠️ God has said in the Quran: 🔵 { O mankind, worship your Lord, who created you and those before you, that you may become righteous - ( 2:21 ) 🔴 [He] who made for you the earth a bed [spread out] and the sky a ceiling and sent down from the sky, rain and brought forth thereby fruits as provision for you. So do not attribute to Allah equals while you know [that there is nothing similar to Him]. ( 2:22 ) 🔵 And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down upon Our Servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah the like thereof and call upon your witnesses other than Allah, if you should be truthful. ( 2:23 ) 🔴 But if you do not - and you will never be able to - then fear the Fire, whose fuel is men and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.( 2:24 ) 🔵 And give good tidings to those who believe and do righteous deeds that they will have gardens [in Paradise] beneath which rivers flow. Whenever they are provided with a provision of fruit therefrom, they will say, "This is what we were provided with before." And it is given to them in likeness. And they will have therein purified spouses, and they will abide therein eternally. ( 2:25 ) ⚠️ Quran
@@1islam1 el coran son palabras vacias y no te das cuenta de lo segado que estas busca Yeshua dijo: Yo soy el camino, y la verdad, y la vida; nadie viene al Padre, sino por mí. Juan 14:6
@@crossmaster27.. { Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God } (1 Corinthians 6:9-10)
@@crossmaster27 ⚠️ Jesus was a servant of God ⚠️ { The God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the God of our fathers, has glorified his servant Jesus.} (Acts 3:13). 📚 The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus
To be accurate, you should use EXACTLY the same amount of glue with each bonding agent. Having been a plastic modeler for 60 years, and having been using cyanoacrylate glue since it's introduction as Eastman 910 in the very late 1960's, I could have told you, baking soda (or sodium carbonate, "washing soda") would be BY FAR the superior bonding agent to ANY material bond. The Eastman Chemicals "poop sheet" on Eastman 910 (there are and entire SERIES of Eastman "900" "super-glues") plainly states that alkaline agents promote the strongest bonds. The first was made to bond the wing spars of B-52's in place! Yes, the wings of B-52's are GLUED-ON! My late Daddy machined the two plates of the wing attachments from high grade aluminum. They form a hinge that allows the wing to move over 12 feet vertically from at rest to full load in flight.
Recall test result: (1) Wood-to-metal baking soda 5.505 kg cement 4.425 kg styroform 3.2 kg charcoal 4.095 kg (2) Plastic-to-plastic: baking soda 0.785 kg cement 0.65 kg styroform 0.365 kg charcoal 0.35 kg (3) Wood-to-wood: baking soda 5.445 kg cement 6.8 kg styroform 3.16 kg charcoal 8.245 kg
There were so many UNCONTROLLED variables that the data is useless. The positioning hook of the scale was erratic, the amount of each of the powders used, the amount of the glue, the size of the surfaces, the temperatures, etc.
Interesting experiments, but there were a few things that make the results difficult to interpret. Most have to do with standardization within each experiemental condition. For example, the actual amount of glue applied and the gapping between surfaces. The most glaring though, was the inconsistent placement of wood and zip ties on the strength test. A force applied increases inproportion to the distance from the fulcrum. In effect, the further away from the fulcrum you placed the zip ties, the less measured force it would take to break the joint. I would recommend repeating these experiements, but standardizing everything.
You should've considered to include a 5th item which is just a super glue so we can differentiate how strong it is without mixing it to baking soda, Styrofoam, charcoal, and cement.
Just from my experience, it seems the baking soda is great for hard white plastic repairs. For more flexible plastic, use the Styrofoam. For black plastic, use the charcoal, but it works better when finely powdered like cigarette ash. Not sure if cement would be the best for bonding ceramic and stone, but it wouldn't surprise me. Super glue is acrilate that undergoes polymerization in the presence of water. I have seen acrylics (plexiglass) melted with acetone , which makes a hellava glue in its own right, but I have yet to see powdered acrylic and superglue done. Please make that video experiment.
you don't need any powder, just use a pencil to color black the surface then use couple of drop. that's it you are done. you need to use file on very smooth surface as you can not draw from pencil on smooth surface such as glass, use little sanding or filing then rub pencil then stick.
The experiment has three problems: 1.- Time between the glue and the experiment. For example: cement has a time to toughen. If you last 24 jours between the glue and the experiment it is better 2.- You have to take the same distance between the glue and the site of the force, as you are doing an experiment of momentum force this is very different if you are 5 cm or 6 cm from the glue 3.- The distance of the two pieces of material must be the same. Is diffenrent if it brokes in the connection of materials or if it brokes in teh middle of the glue And this experiment only is at flexion.... if you want to know the glue power you have to do it at longitudinal force.
@@rbhe357 Cement reacts with the humidity of the atmosphere. As cianocrilate is no waterproof, the cement wil be reacting days... and is going to be harder as it passes. But you have to see it, because cement with the reaction change its dimension and is possible that it makes micro-cracks that cracks the union
The measurement device should always be installed at the exact distance from the glued area at all test items. This was not the case. A small difference give already a big failure in accuracy.
There are one more mistake The charcoal is not in powder form compared to other materials Add that in your list It should be a great feedback for the experiment
You should have measured out the amount of additive/accelerant to ensure a fair comparison. On the plastic-to-plastic, you needed to make the distance from the vise jaws to the joint the same for all tests, as well as the distance from the joint to the pulling force. variations of those lengths will have a significant effect on the force applied.
For next time: 1: "Control": use pure super glue for one sample 2: Variable to Standardise: Distance between items to be glued 3: Variable to Standardise: Distance from joint at which force is applied 4: Variable to Standardise: Mass or Volume of Glue utilised 5: Variable to Standardise: Mass or Volume of non-glue component utilised In short, (i) compare all to just glue, and (ii) TRY to make sure that the non-glue component is the only thing changed.
I love the testing. I agree with everyone that a more controlled test, same amount of stuff, scale the exact same distance from the joint would make the test more accurate. But it is still interesting.
Very interesting experiments. I would like to see these experiments conducted with fibers: Glass fiber (from insulation), sawdust, 0000 steel wool, and some kind of plastic fibers.
Some people are ridiculous in these comments! LMAO! This person wasn't doing an experiment for the FBI! They were testing which of the materials would work the best with in your home when you need to make a quick repair! We aren't talking about rocket science experiments here. Some of your comments want the same amount of glue, but if one product needs more glue for a connection, then that's OK. The issue is which material will generally work the best and these tests show that. If you feel you can do better, then create your own channel and do some experiments! Otherwise, RELAX!
If hes putting in enough work to make a video , why not make it a really good one . also RELAX ! Hes not going to be carted off to FBI , just moderately grilled.
I read in a similar video that the strongest combination for super glue is baking soda. Apparently this combination was so strong, it was used for holding together parts of the wing on old war planes. When you mix super glue and baking soda, it accelerates the curing process. Chemically, the bicarbonate molecules in baking soda react with cyanoacrylate to create a reactive ion that more easily bonds with other cyanoacrylate molecules...so yes, your experiment result was accurate👍
I really like these videos 🙂 They are strangely addictive. When I tried this myself, I found that the superglue drips off the baking powder (without absorbing into it). Has anyone else had this problem?
Thanks for doing this test. For me, I think baking soda is the way to go. It's easy to find and cheap. I don't have a clue where I would find a small amount of cement so it's just as well....
I enjoyed the video, but had a few after thoughts about application. I wonder about durability under different conditions such as excessive heat, moisture or repeated cycles of extreme temperature changes. I imagine most of the above examples would work great to reattach a fallen rear view mirror on your windshield, but couldn't function on a muffler, besides the weight, it also gets exposed to the weather conditions repeated shocks from bumps. Another video on that might be interesting too.
Controlling the distance from the joint is essencial…Directly affects the momentum to which each material is exposed. Nevertheless, great experiment to have macro conclusions. Perhaps a finest one comparing bkng soda to cement.
*Since baking soda is in powder form, the particles cannot hold together and form bonds. Naturally, since the glued carbonate is hard, it breaks after a certain resistance is applied. It may be a good idea to add glass fiber powder or carbon fiber powder to the baking soda to create a bond between the baking soda particles and provide strength.💡*
Never heard of this before, but it should work! I have used flox (chopped cotton microfibers) to add more strength to bondings, with excellent results.
sodium bicarb and iso glue catalyzes like fiberglass and resin. It gets extremely hot and ever since hearing about it maybe a decade ago, it's my go-to for rock solid repairs. I don't know if any of the other tests have strong chemical reactions but the baking soda is a game changer.
Thank you for this. This is a bit helpful. However, it would be more accurate if you anchor the meter same exact point for all materials. Because even a slight difference in the anchoring of the weighing scale hook along the length of the pieces can spell a big difference (e.g. the closer to the glued joint, the harder it is to break, the farther from the joint, the easier it is to break; this is the principle of the lever). Another minor point is the amount of material used for the joints. It should be same weight in grams for all materials being compared, and exact same amount of super glue. Because for example, if you put a little bit more cement than baking soda, then obviously there will be a strength difference; same with amount of super glue.
Ive always heard that you cut the baking soda with charcoal (graphite) and apply in thin layers with the glue. Ive used this technique to mend broken plastic in laptops where the hinge for the screen tightened and broke the plastic mounts. Works amazingly well
Hey! great work, the idea is interesting, I just think you need a little break of about 24 hours before applying force to make the most of the capacity of each glue.
I think these trials/results by Gaus are interesting but there are several potential variables that need more attention IMHO 1) Interspacing Gap variability 2) Amount of bonding agent/resin applied 3) Amount of Superglue applied 4) Drying time 5) distance of applied force from the joint However that said, I didn’t realize that some of these compounds could be used the way they were. I mean you could choose iron filings for one. But the real variability might be coming from just the superglue itself. So there should be a fifth one with just the superglue and nothing else. Anyway interesting trials 👏
I think that each joint should wait at least between 8 and 24 hours for drying to have more conclusive results. It seems to me that many of the tests have not even passed half an hour after applying and that is decisive. On the channel "El Angelito" he tests a ring with cyanoacrylate and sodium bicarbonate, and with a crane he is able to lift a washing machine and then a platform with more than 200 kilos. And stretching the joint transversally is not the same as stretching it longitudinally. Good! You already have material for another video.
Seems quite a lot of time and effort went into this. The point in fixing things around the house, not landing spacecraft so... you kind of suck rooney - why piss on this, when it's helpful. I have some things to fix around the house - like a banister - brackets came out of the wall, now how do I secure that?!? This dude has some ideas, and I appreciate that.
Thanks for the video. I like styrofoam since it's not a powder, it can be controlled better. However, if you need strength, Baking Soda is best for most applications. Cement seems to good for all applications. However it's a coarse powder. Harder to sand down smooth. Of course you could be more scientific by carefully marking and applying your force at specific points. I noticed there was some variability in where you applied the load. I don't think it would change the relative rankings.
This is OK for getting a general impression, but for a proper analysis of material strength and bonding ability, you'd need to do separate shear test and tension tests that eliminated factors of inconsistency. A tension test being two surfaces glued end-to-end and pull apart at 90 degrees from the glue plane. Shear is glueing two surfaces in an overlap manner and pulling it apart along the same plane as the bonded surface.
Crabby, no good but constructive criticism is sometimes needed. And these tests have some shortcomings that need to be pointed out as the results are not reliable, when you place your leverage point (his zip tie)just anywhere you like and them try to list the results as comparable. They are not...the ties would need to be the same distance from the joint to be valid. Even then, his hand and the angle he pulls against the force gauge will be an issue also. So our guy does good tests...he just needs to adjust some of his techniques and he will have a better channel. Nothing wrong with helping people improve their videos.
Great experiment! I have used baking soda and was surprised that it was as hard as stone when dry and strong too. Unbelievable! How strong would pencil lead be?
I have been burning my eyes and gluing my fingers together with cyano and baking soda for 45 years. Sometimes I would lick the joining surface too. That helps also. Once or thrice I managed to glue a stick to my tongue. No joke.
Very nice (but not accurate) test, gave a hint of where and when to use what. Would be nice to se a test of glueing two diffenet materials together (i.e. wood to metal, plastic to metal, etc.)
The tests are not accurate in multiple ways: 1- The Grain size of charcoal does not match with the cement & baking soda! 2- The Gaps between the different test objects do not match (they are different)! 3- The distances of the applied forces to the glued joints are different!
Grain size is not that critical, he is trying to compare the different materials, so comparing Baking Soda to Cement is fine...they are two commonly available substances we can all access, and use. Charcoal...maybe not as it is variable sized and lumpy here otherwise it would be ok to test it. Of course Styrofoam is the same...as a common substance that everyone can get and many are trying/claiming to use to glue things. So his testing is valid and useful, except as you point out in item 3 his force measurements are not very accurate. Otherwise, his ideas of testing these substances is useful as there are lots of videos claiming the strength of one versus the others which is what people want to know - which is best. Looks like Baking Soda in this one.
I mostly use Baking Soda. I have fixed all my grandkids toys, but I have also fixed multiple cracks on refrigerator shelving. Large and small ones. Saved me hundreds of $$$ Works great. What is your opinion of Graphite Powered? I have used that to fix broken plastic on my trucks nerf step bars. Hardened like steel.
Good effort. Results can be skewed by so many factors mentioned in the other comments as to question the results - which i dont understand. Which is top 1, top 2, etc?
I didn't know it would hide the results, I would like to add the results as follows: Baking Soda - Styrofoam - Charcoal - Cement Test 1: Top1 - Top 4 - Top 3 - Top2 Test 2: Top1 - Top 3 - Top 4 - Top2 Test 3: Top3 - Top 4 - Top 1 - Top2
Fiberglass can be a good option, fiberglass sheets are normally used to repair rigid suitcases or bumper plastics with EPOXY, and I think that with cyanoacrylate it could work very well, the difference is the price of cyanoacrylate if you have to repair very large surfaces, but for small repairs I think it can be better than epoxy. Yes, it melts, but the glass is still present at a molecular level and after drying it acquires its maximum resistance.
a totally bogus test. First of all the tests cannot be accurately reproduced. The amount of material used at the base of each screw is not exact in each test. And the amount super glue used is different among the test subject. Thumbs down.
Hej! Tack. Kanske inte 100% vetenskapligt men mycket intressant. Försöken gav ju rätt klara resultat. Det skulle också vara bra om du gjorde samma test mellan bakpulver och natriumbikarbonat.
Should have tried out with sawdust as well. I used sawdust + superglue to stick a reverse threaded nut to it's Bakelite (or similar material) body, since I was unable to procure a replacement. It worked absolutely well, being exposed to super heated steam. Of course the joint did give up, but it did last far more than what I expected it would. Actually, the nut is still stuck to the compound that I created. The entire block became unstuck from the Bakelite body. So, metal + sawdust + superglue works well.
One thing I noticed on the two pieces of metal bars adhered together that may have been better. If you would have flipped the mounded piles of the powder on to face away from you when pulling it would have better judged the strength. Unless you were judging solely where it contacted the 90 degree face between the metal bars. It would be like using tape and expecting it to hold up with only tape on one side and pulling with the tape facing you. If that makes any sense lol. I know these arent scientific, and I really enjoy them! Or maybe flipped the bars and put the powder on both sides, which is what you would probably do in the real world assuming you could. Cool videos! Subbed
Excellente vidéo, j'ai moi même fais l'expérience avec de la limaille de fer très fine et le résultat très bon pour faire du comblage de manque sur des pièces de petites mécaniques.
I appreciate the test but another flaw, with considerable impact on the results, is the distance you placed the strength meter hook from the glued portion. You should have measured the distance to be sure there was consistant leverage applied.
I have a fog light panel cover that was destroyed and it broke the brackets holding it into the bumper so the only thing holding it in place now is super glue and baking soda and it has been 6 months now and it has not moved yet..I only put it in the two places where the bracket was so I will testify that baking soda and super glue works miracles..
Additional variables in the first test could be the differences in leverage created by the distance of the hook pulling on the nail from the point of contact with the wood and the differences in the amount of bonding agent and glue. The same applies to all of your tests, remove these factors as variables and your tests could be more accurate.
I haven't tried it on aluminum, but if you want the glue and baking soda to stick better to the aluminum surface, you have to roughen the aluminum surface.
Repeat the tests, but this time paying more attention to precise equal amounts in gr. or mg.., plus ensuring the same distance point where pulling force is applied. Then we see if same results. Great first attempt nonetheless - thanks!
Interesting. I think it should be more control . Posición of scale etc. But for me the worst is a lack a control test. Glued materials only with glue. To see and evaluate if the materials used in mix are doing better or worse. But great work
I didn't know that the results were obscured, I would like to add the results as follows:
Baking Soda - Styrofoam - Charcoal - Cement
Test 1: Top1 - Top 4 - Top 3 - Top2
Test 2: Top1 - Top 3 - Top 4 - Top2
Test 3: Top3 - Top 4 - Top 1 - Top2
I hope you enjoy watching my video!
Thank you so much!
⚠️ God has said in the Quran:
🔵 { O mankind, worship your Lord, who created you and those before you, that you may become righteous - ( 2:21 )
🔴 [He] who made for you the earth a bed [spread out] and the sky a ceiling and sent down from the sky, rain and brought forth thereby fruits as provision for you. So do not attribute to Allah equals while you know [that there is nothing similar to Him]. ( 2:22 )
🔵 And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down upon Our Servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah the like thereof and call upon your witnesses other than Allah, if you should be truthful. ( 2:23 )
🔴 But if you do not - and you will never be able to - then fear the Fire, whose fuel is men and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.( 2:24 )
🔵 And give good tidings to those who believe and do righteous deeds that they will have gardens [in Paradise] beneath which rivers flow. Whenever they are provided with a provision of fruit therefrom, they will say, "This is what we were provided with before." And it is given to them in likeness. And they will have therein purified spouses, and they will abide therein eternally. ( 2:25 )
⚠️ Quran
This is not the forum for your crap! @@1islam1
@@1islam1 el coran son palabras vacias y no te das cuenta de lo segado que estas busca Yeshua dijo: Yo soy el camino, y la verdad, y la vida; nadie viene al Padre, sino por mí. Juan 14:6
@@crossmaster27..
{ Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders
nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God } (1 Corinthians 6:9-10)
@@crossmaster27
⚠️ Jesus was a servant of God ⚠️
{ The God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the God of our fathers, has glorified his servant Jesus.} (Acts 3:13). 📚
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus
To be accurate, you should use EXACTLY the same amount of glue with each bonding agent. Having been a plastic modeler for 60 years, and having been using cyanoacrylate glue since it's introduction as Eastman 910 in the very late 1960's, I could have told you, baking soda (or sodium carbonate, "washing soda") would be BY FAR the superior bonding agent to ANY material bond. The Eastman Chemicals "poop sheet" on Eastman 910 (there are and entire SERIES of Eastman "900" "super-glues") plainly states that alkaline agents promote the strongest bonds. The first was made to bond the wing spars of B-52's in place! Yes, the wings of B-52's are GLUED-ON! My late Daddy machined the two plates of the wing attachments from high grade aluminum. They form a hinge that allows the wing to move over 12 feet vertically from at rest to full load in flight.
Baking soda, chemical name - sodium bicarbonate.
Washing soda, chemical name - sodium carbonate.
Thank you. I learn more from comments than from the video.
So what's your point? He used bicarbonate of soda for these tests not caustic soda....caustic soda is very dangerous.
Interesting information. Thank You.
@@fromtheflightdeck252
Caustic soda was never mentioned.
Recall test result:
(1) Wood-to-metal
baking soda 5.505 kg
cement 4.425 kg
styroform 3.2 kg
charcoal 4.095 kg
(2) Plastic-to-plastic:
baking soda 0.785 kg
cement 0.65 kg
styroform 0.365 kg
charcoal 0.35 kg
(3) Wood-to-wood:
baking soda 5.445 kg
cement 6.8 kg
styroform 3.16 kg
charcoal 8.245 kg
Thanks
Thanks for the experiments. Do you have any comparison with lead? 🙏
Thank you my love
Scusa la curiosità, hai provato legno legno con segatura e super colla ? Che ne pensate
i think cement is the best, because more stable than other
There were so many UNCONTROLLED variables that the data is useless. The positioning hook of the scale was erratic, the amount of each of the powders used, the amount of the glue, the size of the surfaces, the temperatures, etc.
How many hours did he let it dry?
Yea hook positioning made this data not useful it was a good try tho
same thought, best result should be hang up, and put the weight at the end, and pull it via gravity
That's how research is made now. The number of views and likes shows if the result was a success
do it urself then 🤡
Interesting experiments, but there were a few things that make the results difficult to interpret. Most have to do with standardization within each experiemental condition. For example, the actual amount of glue applied and the gapping between surfaces. The most glaring though, was the inconsistent placement of wood and zip ties on the strength test. A force applied increases inproportion to the distance from the fulcrum. In effect, the further away from the fulcrum you placed the zip ties, the less measured force it would take to break the joint. I would recommend repeating these experiements, but standardizing everything.
Crazy Glue/Baking Soda Great for Guitar Nut Filed to Low
@randyaivaz3356 Thanks for that. That'll solve a problem for me.☺️ Need to fix an aluminium nut too. Maybe cement for the colour match.🤔
In Portugal we call that physics, and is probabily on the levers chapter. Very good point indeed.
it gives me ideas; that's the main thing
You should've considered to include a 5th item which is just a super glue so we can differentiate how strong it is without mixing it to baking soda, Styrofoam, charcoal, and cement.
😂 You could do it yourself and upload the results for the TH-cam scientists to scrutinize.
Good idea
Just from my experience, it seems the baking soda is great for hard white plastic repairs. For more flexible plastic, use the Styrofoam. For black plastic, use the charcoal, but it works better when finely powdered like cigarette ash. Not sure if cement would be the best for bonding ceramic and stone, but it wouldn't surprise me. Super glue is acrilate that undergoes polymerization in the presence of water. I have seen acrylics (plexiglass) melted with acetone , which makes a hellava glue in its own right, but I have yet to see powdered acrylic and superglue done. Please make that video experiment.
Lies again? Batman Superman Big Shot
habe probiert. plexiglass und acetone, hat geklappt
Mix an alkaline material in with each of those regardless for best strength. Need to get that pH above 8 or so
you don't need any powder, just use a pencil to color black the surface then use couple of drop. that's it you are done.
you need to use file on very smooth surface as you can not draw from pencil on smooth surface such as glass, use little sanding or filing then rub pencil then stick.
So you powdered acrylic shit and than tried
La mejor opción se obtiene mezclando tres elementos:
Bicarbonato, Carbón y Cianocrilato.
Hasta dónde he probado nada la ha superado
The experiment has three problems:
1.- Time between the glue and the experiment. For example: cement has a time to toughen. If you last 24 jours between the glue and the experiment it is better
2.- You have to take the same distance between the glue and the site of the force, as you are doing an experiment of momentum force this is very different if you are 5 cm or 6 cm from the glue
3.- The distance of the two pieces of material must be the same. Is diffenrent if it brokes in the connection of materials or if it brokes in teh middle of the glue
And this experiment only is at flexion.... if you want to know the glue power you have to do it at longitudinal force.
Cement doesn't react with glue. The cement is just a filler matrix.
@@rbhe357
Cement reacts with the humidity of the atmosphere.
As cianocrilate is no waterproof, the cement wil be reacting days... and is going to be harder as it passes. But you have to see it, because cement with the reaction change its dimension and is possible that it makes micro-cracks that cracks the union
The measurement device should always be installed at the exact distance from the glued area at all test items. This was not the case. A small difference give already a big failure in accuracy.
There are one more mistake
The charcoal is not in powder form compared to other materials
Add that in your list
It should be a great feedback for the experiment
You should have measured out the amount of additive/accelerant to ensure a fair comparison. On the plastic-to-plastic, you needed to make the distance from the vise jaws to the joint the same for all tests, as well as the distance from the joint to the pulling force. variations of those lengths will have a significant effect on the force applied.
I will note this 👍👍
Cierto, además del tiempo de secado, inicia la prueba al último que le coloca el superpegamento
Dude, this experiment is to work out which dodgy repair is the strongest- it’s hardly gonna need NASA accuracy 😅
@@timjohnun4297Bueno entonces para ti es igual pegar con moco! 😂
@@GausDIY The Law of Levers! Force = pressure x distance... Thus distance must be exactly equal for all tests.
For next time:
1: "Control": use pure super glue for one sample
2: Variable to Standardise: Distance between items to be glued
3: Variable to Standardise: Distance from joint at which force is applied
4: Variable to Standardise: Mass or Volume of Glue utilised
5: Variable to Standardise: Mass or Volume of non-glue component utilised
In short, (i) compare all to just glue, and (ii) TRY to make sure that the non-glue component is the only thing changed.
I love the testing. I agree with everyone that a more controlled test, same amount of stuff, scale the exact same distance from the joint would make the test more accurate. But it is still interesting.
I agree, the leverage of distance from repair point to where force applied could make results change.
The method is not very meticulous, but the conclusion that Baking Soda is quite effective still holds, seemingly.
Exacto! El torque depende del largo de la palanca.
Very interesting experiments. I would like to see these experiments conducted with fibers: Glass fiber (from insulation), sawdust, 0000 steel wool, and some kind of plastic fibers.
Great video!
Some people are ridiculous in these comments! LMAO! This person wasn't doing an experiment for the FBI! They were testing which of the materials would work the best with in your home when you need to make a quick repair! We aren't talking about rocket science experiments here. Some of your comments want the same amount of glue, but if one product needs more glue for a connection, then that's OK. The issue is which material will generally work the best and these tests show that. If you feel you can do better, then create your own channel and do some experiments! Otherwise, RELAX!
😂😂😂😂
And why aren't you relaxed then? You just wrote half a page of garbage.
If hes putting in enough work to make a video , why not make it a really good one .
also RELAX ! Hes not going to be carted off to FBI , just moderately grilled.
I read in a similar video that the strongest combination for super glue is baking soda. Apparently this combination was so strong, it was used for holding together parts of the wing on old war planes. When you mix super glue and baking soda, it accelerates the curing process. Chemically, the bicarbonate molecules in baking soda react with cyanoacrylate to create a reactive ion that more easily bonds with other cyanoacrylate molecules...so yes, your experiment result was accurate👍
I have tried it. Proven to be true.
The pulls should have been made from exact distances. Thanks for the demos...
I think also that the baking soda was the first applied and also the last tried. It had more time to set or cure than the last one.
I really like these videos 🙂 They are strangely addictive. When I tried this myself, I found that the superglue drips off the baking powder (without absorbing into it). Has anyone else had this problem?
Glad you like them! I have used a lot of super glue and baking soda but have never had it separate from the baking powder.
Thanks for doing this test. For me, I think baking soda is the way to go. It's easy to find and cheap. I don't have a clue where I would find a small amount of cement so it's just as well....
thank you so much
I enjoyed the video, but had a few after thoughts about application. I wonder about durability under different conditions such as excessive heat, moisture or repeated cycles of extreme temperature changes. I imagine most of the above examples would work great to reattach a fallen rear view mirror on your windshield, but couldn't function on a muffler, besides the weight, it also gets exposed to the weather conditions repeated shocks from bumps. Another video on that might be interesting too.
Maybe you should try fine salt, baking soda can also be found in different granules and I think the finest is the one that achieves the best results.
Eksperimen ini sangat membantu sy untuk memilih bahan yg cocok, saat perbaikan berbagai barang👍👍👍
Controlling the distance from the joint is essencial…Directly affects the momentum to which each material is exposed. Nevertheless, great experiment to have macro conclusions. Perhaps a finest one comparing bkng soda to cement.
Mil gracias por ese experimento. Me ahorro el ensayo. Ahora tengo mejor apreciación de que utilizar en mis reparaciones.
Falto con algodón y con papel o cartón.
Great job! Now I know which to use. Just a sudden thought, how about graphite from pencils?
Yes, I will try it. thank you!
感謝你做這個實驗！個人有一些疑問想詢問你？問題一：請問木炭是市面販售木炭再加工成為木炭粉末？還是直接使用雷射印表機的補充碳粉（不是碳粉匣）是指充填碳粉匣的外售補充碳粉？問題二：我在我車子後車燈殼破裂時使用小蘇打粉加膠水，因為操作不慎導致後來粉末汙染燈殼內部，於是靈機一動（原本單純遮蓋使用）使用3M透氣紙膠帶（醫療用）加上瞬間膠水，感覺強度比單純小蘇打粉末加上膠水強，也比較好施工！
這實驗差距太小 變數極多 沒有意義
光是你怎麼固定與拉動的螺絲力矩 每次測都是差距極大
*Since baking soda is in powder form, the particles cannot hold together and form bonds. Naturally, since the glued carbonate is hard, it breaks after a certain resistance is applied. It may be a good idea to add glass fiber powder or carbon fiber powder to the baking soda to create a bond between the baking soda particles and provide strength.💡*
Never heard of this before, but it should work! I have used flox (chopped cotton microfibers) to add more strength to bondings, with excellent results.
sodium bicarb and iso glue catalyzes like fiberglass and resin. It gets extremely hot and ever since hearing about it maybe a decade ago, it's my go-to for rock solid repairs. I don't know if any of the other tests have strong chemical reactions but the baking soda is a game changer.
@@AN-kg4ei I had to look this up but..... sodium bicarbonate = baking soda.
Спасибо
Thank you for this. This is a bit helpful. However, it would be more accurate if you anchor the meter same exact point for all materials. Because even a slight difference in the anchoring of the weighing scale hook along the length of the pieces can spell a big difference (e.g. the closer to the glued joint, the harder it is to break, the farther from the joint, the easier it is to break; this is the principle of the lever). Another minor point is the amount of material used for the joints. It should be same weight in grams for all materials being compared, and exact same amount of super glue. Because for example, if you put a little bit more cement than baking soda, then obviously there will be a strength difference; same with amount of super glue.
Ive always heard that you cut the baking soda with charcoal (graphite) and apply in thin layers with the glue. Ive used this technique to mend broken plastic in laptops where the hinge for the screen tightened and broke the plastic mounts. Works amazingly well
Charcoal is not graphite. They are different allotropes of carbon. (You can get graphite from a pencil... and, yes, it's not the wooden part.)
What proportions do you use? How long does the repair last?
I don't see graphite and charcoal as being the same product.
Thank you for this test. I never knew which one to use.
you still don't. See comments above
Would using carbon black and graphite make a difference for strength ????
Hey! great work, the idea is interesting, I just think you need a little break of about 24 hours before applying force to make the most of the capacity of each glue.
Thank you
Thank you! Excelent job!!
I think these trials/results by Gaus are interesting but there are several potential variables that need more attention IMHO
1) Interspacing Gap variability
2) Amount of bonding agent/resin applied
3) Amount of Superglue applied
4) Drying time
5) distance of applied force from the joint
However that said, I didn’t realize that some of these compounds could be used the way they were. I mean you could choose iron filings for one. But the real variability might be coming from just the superglue itself. So there should be a fifth one with just the superglue and nothing else.
Anyway interesting trials 👏
I think that each joint should wait at least between 8 and 24 hours for drying to have more conclusive results. It seems to me that many of the tests have not even passed half an hour after applying and that is decisive. On the channel "El Angelito" he tests a ring with cyanoacrylate and sodium bicarbonate, and with a crane he is able to lift a washing machine and then a platform with more than 200 kilos. And stretching the joint transversally is not the same as stretching it longitudinally. Good! You already have material for another video.
thank you, I will learn and do it in another video
Excelente información Muchas gracias Lo pondré en práctica
Very imprecise methods. Just the placement of the hook on the samples can throw off the readings.
Seems quite a lot of time and effort went into this. The point in fixing things around the house, not landing spacecraft so... you kind of suck rooney - why piss on this, when it's helpful. I have some things to fix around the house - like a banister - brackets came out of the wall, now how do I secure that?!?
This dude has some ideas, and I appreciate that.
Grazie per queste prove chiarificatrici.
Thanks for the video. I like styrofoam since it's not a powder, it can be controlled better. However, if you need strength, Baking Soda is best for most applications. Cement seems to good for all applications. However it's a coarse powder. Harder to sand down smooth. Of course you could be more scientific by carefully marking and applying your force at specific points. I noticed there was some variability in where you applied the load. I don't think it would change the relative rankings.
Thank you for your comment, Have a nice day!
That is what I noticed. Especially in the last test. The Cement would have a higher scale load, but probably the same ranking for all.
@twinwankel - Since cement is coarse, I wonder if unsanded grout would be better?
This is OK for getting a general impression, but for a proper analysis of material strength and bonding ability, you'd need to do separate shear test and tension tests that eliminated factors of inconsistency. A tension test being two surfaces glued end-to-end and pull apart at 90 degrees from the glue plane. Shear is glueing two surfaces in an overlap manner and pulling it apart along the same plane as the bonded surface.
Baking soda is great, but wood knows its own. Charcoal was the strongest with wood alone. Interesting!
Thank you!
The best test,,thank you very much.
Great video! Thanks for share ❤🎉
You mean ,the glue really does the job? ☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️ 8
Yes, these materials help the glue bond more firmly.
THANK YOU Gaus DIY : Dislike crabby comments. Like educational comments that respect the producer of the video.
Crabby, no good but constructive criticism is sometimes needed. And these tests have some shortcomings that need to be pointed out as the results are not reliable, when you place your leverage point (his zip tie)just anywhere you like and them try to list the results as comparable.
They are not...the ties would need to be the same distance from the joint to be valid.
Even then, his hand and the angle he pulls against the force gauge will be an issue also. So our guy does good tests...he just needs to adjust some of his techniques and he will have a better channel. Nothing wrong with helping people improve their videos.
Great experiment!
I have used baking soda and was surprised that it was as hard as stone when dry and strong too. Unbelievable!
How strong would pencil lead be?
Thank you! Cheers! pencil is very strong
Dziękuję za test👍🇵🇱
I like working
I have been burning my eyes and gluing my fingers together with cyano and baking soda for 45 years. Sometimes I would lick the joining surface too. That helps also. Once or thrice I managed to glue a stick to my tongue. No joke.
Joe, it's you? No joke?
When you went to the hospital did the doctor say "stick your tongue out"?
This is great. Thank you. I subscribed and liked. Look forward to more.
Thank you, Have a nice day :)
Very nice (but not accurate) test, gave a hint of where and when to use what. Would be nice to se a test of glueing two diffenet materials together (i.e. wood to metal, plastic to metal, etc.)
Thank you, I will make another video that is more accurate and better ❤️❤️
Super!! Danke. Repariere gerade die Verschraubungen meiner Wohnwagenrücklichter mit deiner Empfehlung. AWESOME!
Thank Bro!
cotton works great too
Thank you for sharing your experiment, friend.
The tests are not accurate in multiple ways:
1- The Grain size of charcoal does not match with the cement & baking soda!
2- The Gaps between the different test objects do not match (they are different)!
3- The distances of the applied forces to the glued joints are different!
Grain size is not that critical, he is trying to compare the different materials, so comparing Baking Soda to Cement is fine...they are two commonly available substances we can all access, and use. Charcoal...maybe not as it is variable sized and lumpy here otherwise it would be ok to test it. Of course Styrofoam is the same...as a common substance that everyone can get and many are trying/claiming to use to glue things.
So his testing is valid and useful, except as you point out in item 3 his force measurements are not very accurate.
Otherwise, his ideas of testing these substances is useful as there are lots of videos claiming the strength of one versus the others which is what people want to know - which is best. Looks like Baking Soda in this one.
I mostly use Baking Soda. I have fixed all my grandkids toys, but I have also fixed multiple cracks on refrigerator shelving. Large and small ones. Saved me hundreds of $$$ Works great.
What is your opinion of Graphite Powered? I have used that to fix broken plastic on my trucks nerf step bars. Hardened like steel.
A dubious test for ignoring the concept of Torque.
Great video. Thanks for taking the time.
Please use annotations very at the end, because those covers finally information (8:31 min)
You can read it in comment section
Good effort. Results can be skewed by so many factors mentioned in the other comments as to question the results - which i dont understand. Which is top 1, top 2, etc?
should have added saw dust also in the test items cos saw dust also makes up a very strong bonding. Do try saw dust in your next experimet
I uses saw dust to strengthen joints on RC aircraft, it will break somewhere else than where sawdust was used.
And sand.
The closer you pull to the connection the harder it gets. The further it becomes easier. Leverage.
For proper analysis and comparison you should have a plain cyanoacrilate glue (without aditives)
Thanks for your hard work.
Thank!
Did you wait for the super glue to dry?
😂
Cool test! I know that luthiers use superglue and baking soda to repair bone and plastic on stringed instruments
Good basic test was waiting to see the results, but the stupid pop ups hid half of the results, so no wiser now
I didn't know it would hide the results, I would like to add the results as follows:
Baking Soda - Styrofoam - Charcoal - Cement
Test 1: Top1 - Top 4 - Top 3 - Top2
Test 2: Top1 - Top 3 - Top 4 - Top2
Test 3: Top3 - Top 4 - Top 1 - Top2
i am going to glue some fairing parts for my motorbike tomorow using super glue and baking soda. thanks for this vid
Thanks for a completely worthless unscientific way to waste several bottles of superglue!
Just curious... fiberglass?think the fibers may hold better. And the glass might melt?
Fiberglass can be a good option, fiberglass sheets are normally used to repair rigid suitcases or bumper plastics with EPOXY, and I think that with cyanoacrylate it could work very well, the difference is the price of cyanoacrylate if you have to repair very large surfaces, but for small repairs I think it can be better than epoxy. Yes, it melts, but the glass is still present at a molecular level and after drying it acquires its maximum resistance.
a totally bogus test. First of all the tests cannot be accurately reproduced. The amount of material used at the base of each screw is not exact in each test. And the amount super glue used is different among the test subject. Thumbs down.
Hej! Tack. Kanske inte 100% vetenskapligt men mycket intressant. Försöken gav ju rätt klara resultat. Det skulle också vara bra om du gjorde samma test mellan bakpulver och natriumbikarbonat.
can u summarize which combo to se for best results on which materials joined?
Should have tried out with sawdust as well. I used sawdust + superglue to stick a reverse threaded nut to it's Bakelite (or similar material) body, since I was unable to procure a replacement. It worked absolutely well, being exposed to super heated steam. Of course the joint did give up, but it did last far more than what I expected it would. Actually, the nut is still stuck to the compound that I created. The entire block became unstuck from the Bakelite body. So, metal + sawdust + superglue works well.
I use sawdust alot, great results, sand as well, sets like stone.
@@drewledge620 Absolutely!
One thing I noticed on the two pieces of metal bars adhered together that may have been better. If you would have flipped the mounded piles of the powder on to face away from you when pulling it would have better judged the strength. Unless you were judging solely where it contacted the 90 degree face between the metal bars. It would be like using tape and expecting it to hold up with only tape on one side and pulling with the tape facing you. If that makes any sense lol. I know these arent scientific, and I really enjoy them! Or maybe flipped the bars and put the powder on both sides, which is what you would probably do in the real world assuming you could. Cool videos! Subbed
Excellente vidéo, j'ai moi même fais l'expérience avec de la limaille de fer très fine et le résultat très bon pour faire du comblage de manque
sur des pièces de petites mécaniques.
I appreciate the test but another flaw, with considerable impact on the results, is the distance you placed the strength meter hook from the glued portion. You should have measured the distance to be sure there was consistant leverage applied.
Excellent video ❤. Cheers from Australia
Gd morning Po sir ask ko lang po gaano nmn po katagal ang epekto nyan i ilang araw,linggo,, o bwan bago po kyo mgpalit ng uling
Outstanding, thank you 🙂
I have a fog light panel cover that was destroyed and it broke the brackets holding it into the bumper so the only thing holding it in place now is super glue and baking soda and it has been 6 months now and it has not moved yet..I only put it in the two places where the bracket was so I will testify that baking soda and super glue works miracles..
Thanks for the info, very useful.
How about a mix of all of them?
That's true
Let's mix them !!
Additional variables in the first test could be the differences in leverage created by the distance of the hook pulling on the nail from the point of contact with the wood and the differences in the amount of bonding agent and glue. The same applies to all of your tests, remove these factors as variables and your tests could be more accurate.
Thank you so much for your feedback on my content.
Under UV light the baking soda is insane with crazy glue
Do each of them has given ample time to fully cure b4 the test is perform?
Not using the same amount of each substance and the same amount of glue, the test is too inaccurate to show anything.
The final results are covered by the ads for related videos… Genius!
Will backing soda and super glue work this good on aluminium And generally on metals?
I haven't tried it on aluminum, but if you want the glue and baking soda to stick better to the aluminum surface, you have to roughen the aluminum surface.
@@GausDIY Thnx mate
Repeat the tests, but this time paying more attention to precise equal amounts in gr. or mg.., plus ensuring the same distance point where pulling force is applied. Then we see if same results. Great first attempt nonetheless - thanks!
Interesting. I think it should be more control . Posición of scale etc. But for me the worst is a lack a control test. Glued materials only with glue. To see and evaluate if the materials used in mix are doing better or worse. But great work
I mix my super glue with milled carbonfiber, the result is to strong to be true 😉
Yes, It's very strong
Soft cloth without lint + Super glue also very good combination
Mix the baking soda and charcoal together and pour some glue. It is the strongest mixture in the world.
How do you know that dona video about it to proof
So many uncontrolled variables, it's insane.
Excellente vidéo. Et au moins nous avons les résultats. Merci
I usually use powdered coffee since it reacts nicely with the glue and is easily available at home
Plesae try again by placing the spring balance a measured fixed distance from the repair. Lever effect has a massive effect on the reading.
Good idea 💡. Great tests. 🎉🎉🎉🎉 Many places require this idea. Congratulations and thank you for sharing this video. ❤🎉🎉🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤❤🎉❤🎉🎉❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
Great experiment
Thanks for doing it!!
Great comments , I agree with all of them.
👍👍👍
I'm very hapy to read your comment. thank you
😊
In Baking Soda We Trust