Glock 19 vs Sig Sauer P365 X Macro, What's Better?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ย. 2024
- Today I'm once again talking about firearms. In this video I compare my experiences shooting the Glock 19 and the Sig Sauer P365 X Macro.
To sum up my talking points, I have had malfunctions with both pistols. These are man made machines and they do sometimes fail. Although in the course of owning and firing these two guns I have still determined them to be reliable. What this comparison really comes down to is a matter of preference. Do you want a dedicated concealed carry pistol with the P365 X Macro? Or do you want a versatile, do-it-all gun like the Glock 19?
I've discovered in my range sessions that while I can manipulate both weapons quickly and accurately, the Glock 19 is the better shooting gun for me. Despite having an inferior trigger, grip texture, and only iron sights, the Glock is easier to control, fire quickly, and remain accurate with. While the P365 is an innovative design that shoots well and comes optics ready from the factory, I find the gun to be significantly snappier in terms of its recoil impulse.
Let me know your thoughts in the comments below. Enjoy.
INSTAGRAM: @_worndowncrown
#gunsafety
I have multiples of both. It's pretty simple to me. The Glock 19 shots better due to its size and weight and is more reliable for a heavily used gun. The Sig is easier to carry, has better ergos and holds two extra rounds. The Sig will not be as durable and reliable over a 20K round life but is fine for a lower round count gun. The modular design doesn't do much for me as I'm going to own tons of guns regardless. I prefer the simplicity of the Glock being a Glock Armorer as I find the Sig a bit more difficult to work on. Both solid guns though.
@@dustyd6617 this guy gets it.
This is what steered me away from these slim, space-aged micro guns. I need mines to last because I never know what the future holds.
@@ResplendentRaiderif you put 40k rounds through a pistol, you can afford to get another pistol.
@@dancruze thats fair.
"A Sig is a bit more difficult to work on..." what an understatement. It takes me worlds longer to take apart the FCU to change a trigger shoe compared to the ability to completely detail strip a Glock with a 3/32 punch pin in the matter of a few minutes. It's no contest if you want to be self sufficient with your defensive pistol.
You should carry the biggest reliable gun you can conceal because big guns shoot better personally I carry a M&P Compact g19 size 90% of the time because it shoots better than my micro compact Shield Plus
Better grip, easier draw, softer shooting, faster shooting, better velocity and accuracy. I have a shield plus for athletic shorts. But I also carry a g 19 primarily. Moving up to the carry comp metal once I get another 250 through it with no issues!
My Dad used to say "A shootout is a big problem that you are not going to solve with a small gun".
That's the one I had to see every single day 4930 rounds through it I did have to send it back to get my front sight tightened up other than that absolutely flawless never had a malfunction of any kind p365 X macro non-comp
I want to academy to try the g19 gen 5 it was the perfect size for my medium size to small hands I have tried the Marco yet
here’s one way to judge handguns: visit a few ranges and rent the versions you are interested in. You’ll discover what happens when things are dirty or worn out. I rented a p365 twice and would never buy one. failure to extract at two different ranges was enough for me to avoid it. YMMV
This is what I did before actually buying my X macro. Its interesting that we arrived at different conclusions about the gun
@@WornDownCrown the one I would avoid is the original P365. I ended up with a P229 and a Glock 19. Different platforms, but both have been around a long time.
@@rjlane3475 I’ve never had any interest in the original p365
Agreed
You should carry the biggest gun you can conceal because big guns shoot better personally I carry a M&P Compact g19 size 90% of the time because it shoots better than my micro compact Shield Plus
I have shot glock 21 for duty use, glock 30s offduty, glock 40 duty use, glock 47 duty use, glock 45 offduty. Never a single malfunction with any of them. Had issues with glock 43x using shield arms magazines .
A Glock is what most people but as their first gun. Many are accustomed to the grip and mushy trigger.
Most people that haven’t tried a Glock until after owning other guns aren’t fans of Glock.
Been carrying a Glock 19 for the last 10 years. I’ve tried to replace it with a couple different newer pistols (including the Macro) but to no avail. I just don’t trust anything else with my life like I do with the Glock 19.
The proper comparison would be a G19 and a base model non-ported version of the sig 365
This p365 isn’t ported or compensated at all…
I too have the HD XR sights on my G19. Very expensive but well worth it.
Sig has a few too many issues for me to ever take the plunge and buy one, but I have shot a few and did like them to some extent.
Glock 19 ALL day LONG...... Glock is the standard by which all guns go by..........PERIOD....
I owned a West German SIG P226 in the 1980's, which really set the bar for an out of the box, reliable combat handgun. Both the P320 and P290RS where train wrecks with a multitude of failures. It seem any new SIG product launch today is a disguised opportunity for consumers to become unpaid Beta Testers. I will never, ever buy any new SIG product. That being said I have two friends that own and carry a P365 and are happy campers, while my other friends daily carry Glock and Walther firearms respectfully. Right now I'm considering switching to a FN Reflex MRD, going to a range next week to try before buying.
I keep my p365 X macro around because I trust its reliability and its performance. In my experience if it had any catatstrophic failures I’d have already turned the gun in for a refund
I’ve bought two 320’s never had a problem.
A great and informative video. I’m glad we have more innovation these days and we’re able to get such a thin pistol that still behaves like a full size pistol. With that being said I’ll still take a Glock simply because I shoot that better, but I would love to carry my dad’s XMacro if that was an option (I don’t own one).
4:12 that’s exactly what my grandparents say. They moved to Hawaii to retire and while it’s more gun restrictive and expensive than South Dakota, they love living in paradise too.
Good video overall. It all started with the 1911. ALL semiauto handguns are based to some degree off that platform. The Glock raised the bar on reliability and durability. The Sig Sauer P365 (and P320) have once again raised that bar. This time in flexibility, features, and capacity. I have a couple of Glock 19s along with Sig P320s and P365s. I shoot my Sigs FAR better than almost any Glock I've ever shot. My P320 has been Extremely reliable for me. My XMacro is my newest setup and I'm still figuring out how I want to configure it.
Marco Rubio?
Holy shit. He looks just like him! It’s prob his bro. 😂
Marco's nose points downward
@@BrandensOutdoorChannel very specific… lol
Very informative
Cheap plastic 'iron' sights ?
My current EDC and Duty gun is a Tac Ops X Macro w/ a full size EPS and FDEZ large back strap. I shoot it better (faster and more accurately) than any of my Glocks and P320s. BUT there are like 3 or 4 generations of the 17 round magazines already, and I couldn't get the X Macro to "Trust with my life" reliability until swapping all the mag springs with ISMI springs.
After about a thousand rounds without malfunction with 124gr +P and 115gr training ammo and finding about 7 magazines I can trust, it was a long road for my most current p365 x macro.
I think Sig does have "better" options, but their QC is so bad I can't recommend anything besides their tried and true 226/229s.
Glock is like In N Out burger. Super limited options, but you know what you're getting. Sig is like that hole in the wall dine in restaurant with good classic items but questionable daily specials.
I often times joke with people that if they want to get good at weapons manipulation and malfunction clearing, buy a Sig and a Glock. Sig for practice, Glock for Duty/carry.
The Glock and in n out burger analogy is so accurate 🤣
Slow fire I group the macro better slightly but at speed it’s about equal. Glock feels more durable and sturdier and the width on a pistol is more a control factor than the grip length, so I prefer that form factor than these slim line deals, whether it’s a G19,M&P or CZ P10c overall. PDP is too chunky but I love the full size versions.
Go with the Glock you can do everything with it.
Regarding your grip issue with the sig. I put a Hogue grip sleeve on my p365 Macro comp and that fixed the issue that you are talking about.
@@James-uq4wb thanks for the recommendation
I have the same variation of the 19. Glad to see I’m not the only one without M.O.S.👍Would be interested in your comparison of the 19 with the Sig 365 legion.
Glock is still better❤
Great Video
Great video Morgan, what are your thoughts on Walther’s do you have any or have you shot any?
Never shot Walthers before so I can’t say I have an opinion on them.
My name is also morgan and i’ve had a walther ppq for about 10 years that has been 100% reliable through thousands of rounds, has awesome ergos and a top shelf trigger. It’s also very well made.
I would say its any Walther product is objectively superior to any comparable glock model. They only benefit of a glock over a walther in my mind would be a better after market.
I like the macro. The g19 grip needs to be atleast a half inch longer.
@@calebclark6739 agreed, I’d love if the grip was a tad longer as well. My dominant hand kind of hangs off of it
I'm not sure why given you likely had the 19 first, why you went with the x macro in a mag ban state. Presented with the same situation where I daily carried a compact P320, the perfect complement was the P365X, something VERY concealable.
I had the X macro first actually. The Glock 19 came second.
@@WornDownCrown oh wow g19 second?! wow.
S&W MP 2.0 Compact shoot much better than Glock 19 Gen 5. Period.
The glock goes bang every time, thats all it has. The sig also goes bang every time and has better ergos and trigger.
I like the Glock trigger, and especially the reset much better.
The point about ergonomics is debatable. I find the ergonomics of the Glock to be much better than the X Macro. I’ll give it to you though, the Sig has the better trigger
Hey from the people's republic of N.J. Great post. We're stuck with 10 round mags too (for now) .
I CCW a G19 but am torn between aP365 x macro or a S&W Shield plus. Do you think the quality of the Sig justifies the cost???
@@lanced3256 yes, I absolutely do. I love my macro and would absolutely buy it again given the chance
I'm kinda over tiny guns I'll take a glock 19 over a sig .
Im not a big glock fan. Appreciate them for their history and simplicity/reliability. Glock however has gotten lazy and complacent and has been passed up by several companies who are just doing it better.
That said, i dont like sig as a company and would never own any sig newer than a p2** era gun based on principal.
What would be your pistol of choice?
@@WornDownCrownbetween the two, glock. I own a walther ppq and cz p07 and am very happy with both.
The problems with the Sig that you talked about regarding the spent case not extracting is not a magazine issue like you said, it's an extractor issue, Or could be an ammo issue if the shell casing is to soft thus causing the extractor to rip the rim of the case.
@@James-uq4wb that’s likely, when I was having those failures to extract, I was using CCI Blazer. Those issues haven’t occurred with any other brand. I do think it is mag related however because loading it to 10 plus 1 created a lot of upward tension on the slide
@@WornDownCrown The mags will break in, just keep them loaded so the spring can compress a bit.
Try a Hogue grip to “fatten” the Xmacro.
Sig is known not to torque those red dots properly. Also, if yours was zeroed its luck of the draw. They do not pre zero.
I haven’t had issues with the zero ever on mine, perhaps I did get lucky
One is reliable machine. One is a rust bucket POS. Take your pick.
glocks just don't have a good beaver tail and the slide cuts my hand up if I try to grip it properly.
I’m aware that many people have that issue, fortunately I don’t seem tk have it when I grip high but it’s definitely an issue for some. Add on one of those adjustable back straps that comes with the package
Gotta hold the gun right best gun to own Glock all the way, sig have too much defective 😅
Those who trade comfortability over liberty deserve neither.
Who willingly trades thier 2Amendment rights for "paradise"?
I have professional responsibilities in my life that brought me here, and those have nothing to do with the 2A.
Please refrain from criticizing my life choices when you don’t know anything about them.
@WornDownCrown not trying to criticize, just don't understand personally.
It wasn’t my choice to move here. I received orders.
I have a 19 and 320 prefer the 320. Why? grip angle, night sights out of the box, trigger good, prefer the serrations and have had good luck with sigs. Oh and the mags are steel.
I’ve shot the 320 AXG legion, the M18, M17, and X5 Legion, and never had issues with any of them. I think they get the job done just fine. I still have the same amount of holes in my body as I’m supposed to, but everyones experiences may vary.
What weapon light do u have on the Glock.
Streamlight TLR1 HL
"plastic iron sights" the irony lol
Did you have the made in USA or made in Italy mags? The USA ones hang up sometimes.
USA mags
Shave your head. You'll look good. I went thru that and it sucks until you get past it.
Have both, Xmacro all day
I'm glad your X Macro is working out for you so well! What's your experience with it been like?
Do you live at the gun range….😅😅😅COOL. Look at the walls!!!
F.y.i.its a XMacro without the compensator.
Both could kill HUMANS
Springfield Hellcats>>>ALL! /Thread 🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣
@@WornDownCrown 😜
Glocks are the past.
Glocks guys kill me about Glocks 40 year track record. That's true and should be celebrated but if for example a gun has a 15-20 year track record at that point does it make it any less reliable 😂😂? At that point both guns have probably experienced all conditions and you can trust them BOTH equally
Nah to many instances where sig goes off on its own🤷🏻♂️ i dont call that reliability
@@TONY4563084show me where that relates to the P365 the #1 selling pistol in the US right now. I’ll wait
I’ve had both and the Sig just shot better to me. Never had one single jam on my Macro. Had 2 on my g19c with defensive ammo.
Glad it’s working out for you man. Stay safe 🤙
Ya my 19c jammed especially with the 115 grain
For a shtf pistol give me the Glock but for edc give me the Sig all day.. Side note of course the Glock handles recoil better it's heavier. It's called physics
So u buy a glock.. U have to alter it, modify it or add accessories to it just to get it on par with modern pistols.. At that point u have paid double.. Why not just buy the Sig Xmacro, out of the box its better than the Glock u had to basically buy twice for it to be good 🤷🏻♂️
Saying "Glock is innovative" is an oxymoron
Your statement has a lot of inaccuracies.
For one thing, I bought the Sig first. When the Sig started having malfunctions I bought the Glock, and replaced the iron sights and added a light.
The Sig, with its own light and optic, is hundreds of dollars more expensive than the Glock.
The Glock on the other hand is well under 800 in total costs.
A stock Glock ran right out of the box more reliably than my SIG. again, the only thing that was modified on the gun was the sights.
Get your facts straight
@WornDownCrown my xmacro was $750, my Holosun PID was $99, my eps carry was $325
I bought a Glock19 for $650, put the same lights and red dot on it, then I had to put a trigger on it because Glock triggers are shit.. then I had to put buis because glock sights are shit.. Then I had to get it's stippled because Glock's have trash ass grips... When I was done I paid a little over 1k for the sig, when I was done with the Glock I paid over $1500..
How about u get your math straight.. Glock doesn't need yall to make up lies for them..
If you had to do all that to get your Glock to shoot well, it’s not the glock’s fault. It’s yours.
That’s easy… Glock!!!
Looks like someone disagrees 🤣
Glock more reliable then sig, sig have too much defection and watcha out sig going shoot your 🦵 😂
G19 all day but the G26/G23👑💨🦌🐗🐻 are the only two glocks you’ll ever need in life edc both(g26 flush appendix) all mags/cals are covered,just toss Mr.g19x/45/17/22 a 13/15rd mid fight last mag
🧟♂️🥷🚘🔫😒🤭
Any sig is better
Why do you say that?
Great video
Thanks!