Im a massive Pittsburgh and Fluery fan, but his peak was never that high tbh. He's a great all timer because of the longevity rather than any one point in his career being phenomenal. I'd have him more in the middle of this list
Also "ever be better" IS WAY TOO strong of a sentence. EVER is a insanely heavy word. Hockey has only been around for like a century, imagine it 500 years later
I have jake ottinger in nhl25 & hes standing on his head every game. I went from nhl19 playing on superstar & my goalie would never be above 900% to nhl25 playing on pro & being the lowest scoring team in the leauge but also letting in the least goals. Its so nice to have help on the backend & not force the team to have under 10 shots for a 50% chance to win lol
Oettinger is overrated. Saying "pay the man already" is stupid when they're obviously having a conflict about the contract, or there would be one already. And no, Fleury is not better than Quick.
Price outplayed Fleury with a sub playoff team against champion caliber VGK, he had little to no cartilage in his knees and was battling mental health issues. Price blows Shesterkin, Bobrovsky and Ullmark out of the water. (Nvm he isn't playing anymore im dumb)
#1 was Fleury 😆 🤣 😂 Seems like the two that won cups BY ACTUALLY PLAYING would be better options than a guy that won his gold Medal and the majority of his cups on the bench.... IN HIS PRIME.... and has a losing record in the finals and lost the juniors Gold Medal game he played... while on TEAM CANADA.
price is still not retired, and prime quick was also better than prime fleury. fleury has never been the league's best goalie, despite the one vezina he was gifted in vegas. vasy would also be ahead.
Fleury gotta be one of the most overrated goalies ever. Bro was great but putting him ahead of guys like Vasi & Quick is crazy. Fleury was great at times but there’s a reason the pens never won another cup until Matt Murray came around. Fleury never had a season as good as Vasi in 2021 or Quick in 2012. If we’re going off primes that alone bumps him down to 3rd and you can make pretty a good argument that Helle in 2020 was better than Fleury best years.
@@Imapioneer he's been a good to great goalie on winning teams for a long-ass time. he's never been truly elite. he's never been the league's best at any time. he's the patrick marleau of goalies.
🚨 Elevate your sports betting experience and support my brand by signing up for any sportsbook in your region right here: signupexpert.com/jimmyshow
Technically price is still on contract but thats not still playing
Yeah I was abt to say that
there is no chance in hell Prime Fleury is better than Prime vasy or quick.
Fr
I mean...2nd best gk of all time? Ehhhhh
Agreed
@@MarekCyranek-cu2gvcap
@@ninjashep5264u stupid
Add price into that no.1 spot. He's still on contract
Igor Seshterkin😂
Bro forgot demko, he was runner up to vezna last year and he got injured for the last 2 months of the season
Im a massive Pittsburgh and Fluery fan, but his peak was never that high tbh. He's a great all timer because of the longevity rather than any one point in his career being phenomenal. I'd have him more in the middle of this list
No goalie will ever be better than Jonathan quick in the 2012 playoffs. Not even a kings fan but that was fucking insane to watch
I mean, similar to 2021 Price. Put the team on their backs
Also "ever be better" IS WAY TOO strong of a sentence. EVER is a insanely heavy word. Hockey has only been around for like a century, imagine it 500 years later
@ Jesus bet you’re fun at parties brothaaaa
WHERE TF ARE PRICE AND FREDDY
not playing
Freddy sucks and price mid
@@Vicctrous 😂
NO!!! Price would be go orst he is still on the roster and is the best goalie ever even better than roy and grant fuhr
number 2 carey price don’t mess with him
Carey Price????????
It better be flurry-before
Ok good it was flurry
WHERE'S THE HECK IS JUUSE SAROS!?!?!?
Pretty much everyone here in their prime are better than Saros. If it was closer to top 15 or 20, he’d probably be here
@@patheticdawgaccording to what? Not according to skill
I have jake ottinger in nhl25 & hes standing on his head every game.
I went from nhl19 playing on superstar & my goalie would never be above 900% to nhl25 playing on pro & being the lowest scoring team in the leauge but also letting in the least goals.
Its so nice to have help on the backend & not force the team to have under 10 shots for a 50% chance to win lol
BRADEN HOLTBY
Price??
Aren't some of these in their prime now?
price is the greatest goalie of all time
I was dying for you to say Fleury at the end lol
Carey Price
Jordan Binnigton
When was Fleury ever in his prime better than any of those goalies. Vazy is going to be the greatest goalie of all time.
Buddy I'm sorry there will awalys be 3 names ahead of his Roy, Hasek and Broduer
@@storm_drex492true
@@storm_drex492 Vasy is on pace to be better. Quickest goalie of all time to get 300 wins, he beat like a 60 year old record
Oettinger is overrated. Saying "pay the man already" is stupid when they're obviously having a conflict about the contract, or there would be one already. And no, Fleury is not better than Quick.
Oettinger?
@@fnafking1987-o3t Is overrated
@@PigeonNHL he didnt say oettinger, he was not in the video.
@@fnafking1987-o3t Watch the video? Oettinger was #10
Yes he totally said to pay Oettinger already mhm
where is demko
Pekka Rinne🐐....
i said the flower at the start
fleury is the greatest on his prime
Where is Henrik Lundqvist????
Carry price?
What about Carey price? Wow
What abt varlomov
i think it goes marc,andrei,connor/igor
Price outplayed Fleury with a sub playoff team against champion caliber VGK, he had little to no cartilage in his knees and was battling mental health issues. Price blows Shesterkin, Bobrovsky and Ullmark out of the water. (Nvm he isn't playing anymore im dumb)
No price😢!!!
He didn’t consider him on this list, otherwise he would have been probably top 2 if not 1st
@ oh
Jarry over Swaymen .. markstrom over sorokin ..sway and ott still so young and not in their prime yet imo
Nah, 1. Quick 2. Vasy 3. MAF
demko would be close. personal opinion tho
And no oettinger😊
#1 was Fleury 😆 🤣 😂
Seems like the two that won cups BY ACTUALLY PLAYING would be better options than a guy that won his gold Medal and the majority of his cups on the bench.... IN HIS PRIME.... and has a losing record in the finals and lost the juniors Gold Medal game he played... while on TEAM CANADA.
add vasy 1 up bro
Bro no demko
price is still not retired, and prime quick was also better than prime fleury. fleury has never been the league's best goalie, despite the one vezina he was gifted in vegas. vasy would also be ahead.
Thatcher demko
Flames fans remembering Jake Ottenger in his prime 😰😰😰
That just brings good memories of Johnny ot goal for me
BRO WHERE THE HELL IS KING HENRIK THE BEST #30 IN ALL OF HOCKEY??
Still playing
only for current goalies. hank is retired. technically price isn't, though, so he should be here.
Price
Please never make a list again 🙏🙏
What is this list😂
Pls demko
Bro...6 or 7 of these guys ARE STILL IN THEIR PRIME. NY can't afford to pay shesty and still have a team. Quick is a bit over rated.
Fleury gotta be one of the most overrated goalies ever. Bro was great but putting him ahead of guys like Vasi & Quick is crazy. Fleury was great at times but there’s a reason the pens never won another cup until Matt Murray came around.
Fleury never had a season as good as Vasi in 2021 or Quick in 2012. If we’re going off primes that alone bumps him down to 3rd and you can make pretty a good argument that Helle in 2020 was better than Fleury best years.
How is second most in wins ever as a goalie overated?
@@Imapioneerhe was so great that multiple teams looked to replace him
@@alexthebasilisk because he was aging, but back then he was one of the greatest of all time
@@Imapioneer he's been a good to great goalie on winning teams for a long-ass time. he's never been truly elite. he's never been the league's best at any time. he's the patrick marleau of goalies.
@@Imapioneer wins is a team stat. It tells you nothing about how good a goalie was on their own.
Thank god price wasnt on this list most over rated listerine addicted bust, halak woulda won the habs a cup 😢
I'll take Dustin Wolf over all of them. Just watch.
ya ok .907 SV% and 1 career SO..real stud there lol..Devon Levi is the future not that kid
@@RoamHockey pretty good rookie numbers and he'll only get better
@@RoamHockey and it's a 921 SV%
Devon Levi has an 870 sv % lol what are you smoking?
Thatcher demko