Did you guys notice how Josh and Mr. Enter had different opinions on this episode..? Internet, its possible. It's possible to have intelligent conversations about things. It doesn't always have to boil down to name calling. It's okay for people to have varying opinions.
SBCannon I feel ya man! It's really annoying seeing people condescend to each other in comments sections or (worse yet) make entire reviews solely for the purpose of Sticking it to someone else!
SBCannon I wish Tommy Oliver understood this. But then again, he DID try to RAISE ENOUGH MONEY to support himself on opinions alone, which is never a good idea.
Wow...I never knew Mr. Enter was this funny. He doesn't really have much comedy in his solo work. Then again, Josh brings out the humor in most of the people he works with.
He's more of a straight man with more dry comedy (common among the more comically attuned Autistics, I'm one), so having a guy like Josh who's more wacky or off the wall helps best.
My guess is Josh wrote the majority of the episode. It happens sometimes with collars like this, where you can tell one reviewer or the other wrote the script.
I see it like this. Fluttershy does have negative things to say, but she never voiced them for fear of hurting her friends feeling. She has been restrained because she was shy and worried of hurting others. After IronWill’s assertiveness training, she has finally gained a freedom and power she has not had before. But the line “power corrupts” comes into play here. She is so empowered and feels so free, and able to finally release everything she held back that she is drowning in the feeling of empowerment to the point she doesn’t realize she has crossed a line. And she crossed that line when her friends confronted her about it. Before the assertive lessons, Fluttershy probably held back all those things BECAUSE they were hurtful and knew it would hurt them. But AFTER the assertive lessons, Fluttershy has become so empowered and free that she could say such things, and not feel how she hurt her friends until after she has had the chance to actually calm herself and look back on what she just did. Just like in the episode.
Speaking as someone who has actually had a supposed friend tell me that what I was passionate about doing as a career was stupid and pointless, this episode actually hit very close to home in a very bad way. Having that happen to you is immensely hurtful, and it isn't something you get past easily, especially if you're already insecure about your own work. As a result, I agree with Mr. Enter: It was over-the-top abusive behavior, and Pinkie and Rarity reacted unrealistically well to it.
Oh thank god people do hate this crossover. Josh was extremely annoying and they didn't get along OF COURSE people hated it. I just wish I could find more comments about it because it looks like the section isn't complaining about it at all. Somehow. Enter needs a non collab version of this.
I know a lot of people seem to dislike Mr. Enter, but I thought this review was awesome. Like, even if Mr. Enter wasn't as over the top as Josh, that's the point; Josh is supposed to be the wild one, and typically his collab partners will counter or highlight that. That, and Mr. Enter reminds me a lot of my friend Thomas: Logical, composed, inwardly seething with anger and contempt.
The reason I hate him is becomes he has no respect for his Fons and would block anybody who disagrees with him even if it is constrictive criticism. Plus he said trolling and cyber bullying is the same thing and he told his fans "shut the fuck up if you think otherwise" in his trolls review.
th4t 0n3 guy wh0 sp3lls h1s n4m3 w1th numb3rs™ Because people are usually dicks about the whole distinction and don't respond to his video/post's points while being so. He blocks dicks, not those who actually speak reasonably and don't insult him.
"its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict." ya you could say that about anything. what is the difference between a prankster and a terrorist its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict. what's the difference between someone who makes a bad cartoon show and a child rapist its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict but Oh wait you think that there are a difference so according to mrenter "you need to shut the fuck up"
Josh reviews an episode that causes a bunch of controversy while collabing with a reviewer who causes a bunch of controversy? I'm sure that the comments below will be nothing but calm, respectful, and reasonable. Who the hell am I kidding, time to read the shitfest.
***** You forgot the CIS... (Ironically I had college classes that were in a CIS department, although that was called "Computer Information Science" and not whatever that is on places like tumblr.)
+MrGMoney1944 It being the last Metal Gear doesn't piss me off. It's a single narrative that should have a defined beginning, middle, and end, so finally filling in this gap to close the book is a good thing. What pisses me off is Konami burning everything to the ground and saying "Fuck you, world! You're not worthy of Japan!"
The goats being Iron Will's workers may be based off of the fact there's a species of goat that in found ONLY on the island of Crete and nowhere else in the world.
You know what I like about this review? *****'s gags and TheMysteriousMrEnter's down to earth attitude. The two of you just play off each other so well.
The part that saves this episode for me is when Fluttershy looks at her reflection and admits to herself that she's becoming a monster. I relate to this episode because I've been through the same trialls in my own life; I've been pushed down and devalued by bullies for so many years of my life, when it came to relationships with friends on the internet who I thought I could trust, I started to get quite nasty and spiteful in a bid to be assertive. I did so because I felt I had to be so jaded in order to keep myself safe. I have tried to find that balance between avoiding being abused and not being an abuser back, which is more difficult than many give it credit for. Fluttershy learns from this experience. She demonstrates what I have had to go through, and in the end manages to find that balance. I will admit the pacing is an issue, but at the same time it at least makes some sense why Fluttershy realized how she went much too far.
1:55 Strange, my dad feeds our rabbits baby carrots once a day without the green part, and they have both lived passed the expected life span of normal rabbits.
RainbowCatLord I wasn't shipping them. If I had one friend and was annoyed about her having another friend, I would be pissed at someone treating my friend badly
Otaku-Taku Tetsu~ truly hes a good looking guy. its a shame he's asexual and has bit of a distaste for romance. i wish he was at least he was demisexual.
Wait you have pet rats? Me too!!! EEEEEEK So cool! Do you adopt? I'm adopting two little girls later this week ^^ But awesome review dude! Love it! I personally didn't mind this episode too much despite I hear similar reviews like this about it frequently. I guess I don't mind it and actually embrace it because it told me that the show and writers weren't afraid to take some 'risks' with the characters. I was blindsided by the change of Fluttershy and the tone of everything in the story, that it was actually a refreshing new take for me. Sure it was harsh and even tear jerking... (yes I actually cried seeing Rarity and Pinkie cry), but it still was something new. That alone I'm always happy to see.
I actually love that scene. The way they react to it is just perfect and I think the way it is build up is great. I also think the moral itself is great as the way the ponies act is very much like how people act in the real world. I think it's episodes like these that push FIM above the MLP stigma. Equestria is not just a peaceful wonderland and there will be ponies that will take advantage of your weakness and strength and aggression can still get the job done. There is a saying in Dutch that goes: "Gluttonous people own half the world" meaning that the more demanding you are the more you usually get. I think this episode demonstrated that and that kindness will often just leave you getting taken advantage of.
OMG, Josh and Mr Enter doing a collab. That's got to be the best idea ever! Great review you two. A perfect balance of the good, the bad, and the funny. The episode, I believe, has a good story but could have been executed in a much better way.
These guys got me through the early, dark days when I lost my wife and daughter to a drunk driver and helped me fight alcoholism. Almost 4 years sober. Doing right by the memory of my lady and by myself as well. If you are watching this in 2022 you are a legend and if you're suffering from depression or negative emotions, know you are never alone and positive vibes onto you!
Yay, colab with Josh and Mr Enter! :D Also I'm with Mr Enter on this one, this is my personal pick for Worst Episode though now that I've watched this review, I can definitely understand your points on it, Josh. Good work as always. :)
+Cody Hines Piccolo said that in the original Funimation dub. TFS did that quote word-for-word as satire. That's why Nail asking what he's doing is all the funnier.
To be fair of the Greeks believed that both Helio's and Apollo were capable of seeing everything that happened under the day and Artemis everything in the night
"She's unassertive, not stupid." Take it from a mega-introvert, Mr. Enter: when nerves are involved, anything that can come out wrong will come out wrong. :/
Josh and Mr. Enter are two of my most favorite youtubers, so when I saw that they were doing a review together, I practically died with excitement. And they did not disappoint! Love you guys!
***** My filming couch is still in the moving van and the only other one was in the living room which had a window behind it with positively atrocious glare. Had to make do with what I had.
Mr. Enter AND Josh in aone vid?! i think i found heaven!! also, that fanart in the endcredits was really, really sweet!! huge up's to the artists that made those pieces!
Looking at this episode as a whole, I had a sudden realisation. If you spend your life being a doormat, and then suddenly you have the courage to be assertive, that’s an entire life’s worth of anger steaming to the top with no filter for once... So even though fluttershy went over the top, it makes sense.
sigh... I know I'm doing exactly what Josh did (but decided to drop it) by addressing this.... but I thought the point of Discord turning Fluttershy just like that was to show he could just do that with all of the main 6 but that wouldn't be fun. & him doing that with Flutters was also to show that he's a sore loser, which fits his character
I never thought we'd see Josh with the Mysterious Mr.Enter: Josh is a joker who forgives errors in some places. Mr. Enter takes things more seriously. Then, again, it DOES make more sense if it's on this channel instead if FOB Equestria.
I really don't understand why there are so many people that hate this episode. Not only do I love this episode, it is one of my favorites. In fact, it's not only just that. This was my very first episode of MLPFIM. I got into the show and this wonderful fandom because of this episode. This episode made me start binging the entire series up to this episode (which was the latest one at the time). The show, the characters, the fan art, fan fiction, and reviewers like Josh and so many others that I've seen are only because of this episode. I get that not everyone can like the same thing. I know that. But everyone can always get excited with the fandom about their start to the show but I can't do that because of all the hate this episode gets. It makes me feel alone in the fandom. I guess why this episode is so important to me is because... I totally relate to this. I was quiet and reserved throughout my childhood. I tended to be a loner, had few friends, and was bullied drastically all the way until I left high school. I always just took it and never fought back or insulted anyone. I decided to be the nice guy. But... there were so many times I wanted to fight. To hurt them like they hurt me. I always thought it would make me feel good, that I would become better if I did the same things. However, I never did. Because I was better than that. I would never hurt anyone because it is wrong. And that's probably why I relate to this episode. I can see myself in what I could have been if I decided to do what everyone else did. I know for a fact I could have been just like Fluttershy in this episode if not worse if I gave up being nice and just did what my bullies did. This episode makes me feel good because seeing Fluttershy show herself to be assertive yet polite at the end, much like how I handled myself when I was bullied. I was kind, but I asserted myself properly. This episode makes me feel proud how I stayed a good person, that I didn't become like how Fluttershy did when she overdid the assertiveness. I have so much good and love in my life now but I wouldn't have had any of that if I gave into my darker feelings growing up. Like how Josh once made a Top 10 Personal Episodes list for this show, if I did it, this episode would be my number one spot. Not only did it lead me to changes and a great show and fandom, it allows me to look back at the choices I made to be good and kind and be proud of that.
Rixec2 People such as myself hate the episode because of what Fluttershy does throughout the episode and how overboard she went with her assertiveness to the point where it can be classed as bullying especially with the Pinkie Pie and Rarity Part. Granted, there are some good points in the episode but the pacing fucks it up really badly and make it seems mean spirited but after watching this episode; my hatred for it seems to be not as bad anymore. I can see how people like the episode and how some hates it while there some indifference about it. It just depends on how you look at it.
I'm gonna have to say, this is probably the single most divided comment section I've seen on a TH-cam video that wasn't directly related to politics or religion.
Josh Scorcher and Mr.Enter are collaborating?! From this day forth, Christmas is now on July 27th. Merry Christmas one and all!!! As for the episode, I have issues with some of the character's actions in the episode and believe it to be a bit too mean spirited mainly because of Fluttershy taking Iron Will's advise and abusing it. I'm just going to stop there because this is one episode I'm never plan on reviewing because of the big debate over it. Nice review you two. Mr.Enter I like your work and Josh you bring the comedy like no other. Can't wait to see more from both of you. And Mr.Enter, good luck on your 100th Atrocity.
The day silver quill collabs with mr enter is the day i can die happily think about it they're complete opposites both in terms of character and style.
Well, THIS is an awesome combination....I enjoy both your MLP reviews and Mr. Enter's Animated Atrocities, so this is a pretty awesome team-up already.
'There are three things all wise men fear: the sea in storm, a night with no moon, and the anger of a gentle man.' I suppose that's the reason why all the ponies fear aggressive-assertive Fluttershy in the cake store
Ink is either envious or really happy one of her best friends collab one of her fave reviewers but how would I know lol Gosh Josh you and Mr. Enter are so similar especially in your voices I have a hard time telling who's who amazing work your collabs out do each other every time XD
"Would you want to add more unpleasant onto the pile?" No, I want to see them be friends again. However, in this particular episode I wanted to see Fluttershy face retribution for her actions. I wanted to see her get some of the wrath that she threw her own friends thrown back at her. She only saw her reflection of her madness in a puddle, she didn't experience her own wrath and feel the pain she dealt to her friends!
8:45 My reaction when this was first uploaded. It had finally happened. My two favorite reviewers reviewing (or in Mr. Enter's case, revisiting) an episode of MLP. :D
"You insult my room? I go KABOOM!!"
That honestly had me in stitches. XD
CatMaster90001
Same
Find me a medic, fellow viewers!
My funnybone has been fractured.
Medic? I regret everything!
@@nerdyfan21 I second that, dude.
I get it.The Minotaur is part bull and she ended up being a BULLY
Lol
Yay! Someone else got the analogy!
+Morgan Sloatman Not analogy, joke.
I dunno. I thought it was BULLshit, so it kind of counts as an ANALogy.
XD
Did you guys notice how Josh and Mr. Enter had different opinions on this episode..?
Internet, its possible. It's possible to have intelligent conversations about things.
It doesn't always have to boil down to name calling.
It's okay for people to have varying opinions.
SBCannon Same for when Mr. Enter and PieGuy debated on the quality of "I'm With Stupid." They were civil about it.
SBCannon I feel ya man! It's really annoying seeing people condescend to each other in comments sections or (worse yet) make entire reviews solely for the purpose of Sticking it to someone else!
SBCannon I wish Tommy Oliver understood this. But then again, he DID try to RAISE ENOUGH MONEY to support himself on opinions alone, which is never a good idea.
andrewkful Tommy Oliver..? You mean the Original Green Ranger?
Sorry, I couldn't resist.
SBCannon that's the *cool* Tommy Oliver
"If she was a human she would be flipping someone off in the carriage" xD
I can see someone making a video
I don’t know why everyone thinks she was flipping them off. It looked more like an angry fist shake.
Two of my favorite reviewers in one video?
This makes me a rainbow shoot out of me and rocket me through the sky in pure joy.
courtney brian Just like Pinkie?
courtney brian as long as said rainbow does not make a baby unicorn.... you are in the clear
Deeviant juvygenius exactly like Pinkie and no the rainbow doesn't make a baby unicorn
Yay I'm not the only one happy that 2 of my favorite reviewers are collabing
courtney brian yep
Wow...I never knew Mr. Enter was this funny. He doesn't really have much comedy in his solo work. Then again, Josh brings out the humor in most of the people he works with.
He's more comically serious.
He's more of a straight man with more dry comedy (common among the more comically attuned Autistics, I'm one), so having a guy like Josh who's more wacky or off the wall helps best.
My guess is Josh wrote the majority of the episode. It happens sometimes with collars like this, where you can tell one reviewer or the other wrote the script.
I see it like this.
Fluttershy does have negative things to say, but she never voiced them for fear of hurting her friends feeling. She has been restrained because she was shy and worried of hurting others.
After IronWill’s assertiveness training, she has finally gained a freedom and power she has not had before. But the line “power corrupts” comes into play here.
She is so empowered and feels so free, and able to finally release everything she held back that she is drowning in the feeling of empowerment to the point she doesn’t realize she has crossed a line.
And she crossed that line when her friends confronted her about it.
Before the assertive lessons, Fluttershy probably held back all those things BECAUSE they were hurtful and knew it would hurt them.
But AFTER the assertive lessons, Fluttershy has become so empowered and free that she could say such things, and not feel how she hurt her friends until after she has had the chance to actually calm herself and look back on what she just did.
Just like in the episode.
Speaking as someone who has actually had a supposed friend tell me that what I was passionate about doing as a career was stupid and pointless, this episode actually hit very close to home in a very bad way. Having that happen to you is immensely hurtful, and it isn't something you get past easily, especially if you're already insecure about your own work. As a result, I agree with Mr. Enter: It was over-the-top abusive behavior, and Pinkie and Rarity reacted unrealistically well to it.
What did Mr Rayan say? His comment was deleted.
@@sethmoss8671 Probably dismissing LaydiNite's feelings?
Mr.Enter sounds just like Josh if Josh was always calm.
Agreed Mr Doorags from 8 years ago
5:15 "be assertive." "Beep beep." "No, not insertive." Take that Mr. Enter.
Hyperactive optimist meets jaded cynic.
Nice to see the Josh/Mr. Enter collab is just as fun as I thought it'd be.
I don't see why people hate this crossover, these guys are like the dream team of the Cartoon community for me.
probably just haters of Mr Enter, and honestly, allot of his haters are retareded idiots, or modern spongebob fans (whats the difference?)
@@ellnats As much as I like some episodes of modern Spongebob, Enter's right that the show has been having problems.
Oh thank god people do hate this crossover. Josh was extremely annoying and they didn't get along OF COURSE people hated it. I just wish I could find more comments about it because it looks like the section isn't complaining about it at all. Somehow. Enter needs a non collab version of this.
@@crystalmaiden7791Mr. enter is the asshole! Do not blame Josh!
I know a lot of people seem to dislike Mr. Enter, but I thought this review was awesome. Like, even if Mr. Enter wasn't as over the top as Josh, that's the point; Josh is supposed to be the wild one, and typically his collab partners will counter or highlight that. That, and Mr. Enter reminds me a lot of my friend Thomas: Logical, composed, inwardly seething with anger and contempt.
The reason I hate him is becomes he has no respect for his Fons and would block anybody who disagrees with him even if it is constrictive criticism. Plus he said trolling and cyber bullying is the same thing and he told his fans "shut the fuck up if you think otherwise" in his trolls review.
th4t 0n3 guy wh0 sp3lls h1s n4m3 w1th numb3rs™ Because people are usually dicks about the whole distinction and don't respond to his video/post's points while being so. He blocks dicks, not those who actually speak reasonably and don't insult him.
"its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict." ya you could say that about anything. what is the difference between a prankster and a terrorist its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict. what's the difference between someone who makes a bad cartoon show and a child rapist its the difference between a person experiencing there first high and a drug addict but Oh wait you think that there are a difference so according to mrenter "you need to shut the fuck up"
tyrant351 To me he always seemed like a more truthful American I Haye Everything.
tyrant351
Yeah I never got the Mr.Enter hate...
2 bits!
1 bit!
2 bits!
Rabbit season!
Duck season!
RABBIT SEASON!!!
I legit died there. I am now a soul... still laughing hard.
DUCK SEASON FIRE!
Josh reviews an episode that causes a bunch of controversy while collabing with a reviewer who causes a bunch of controversy? I'm sure that the comments below will be nothing but calm, respectful, and reasonable.
Who the hell am I kidding, time to read the shitfest.
***** You forgot the CIS... (Ironically I had college classes that were in a CIS department, although that was called "Computer Information Science" and not whatever that is on places like tumblr.)
Crazy Luigi Oh? The only thing I think of when talking about bad TH-cam comments is people telling others to kill themselves or something.
***** Well that's unfortunately what I see when people talk about people that are considered "scum" these days.
Crazy Luigi Hmm...
Oh well, what're you gonna do?
Crazy Luigi cis is short for cissexual, which is someone who identifies with their birth gender. It's the opposite of transsexual.
Holy shit, Joshscorcher and TheMysteriousMr.Enter in the same video, my life is complete.
Rusticabcd what's next, mrenter, voice of reason and sliver Quill
Mr Enter?! Mr Enter?! Oh buck yeah, I can't wait to see this review.
Update: I watched it three times.
Big Boss If Big Boss loves it, then I love it.
Hey Boss are you as pissed as me about the next Metal Gear game being the last because Kojima is basically getting the book.
+MrGMoney1944 It being the last Metal Gear doesn't piss me off. It's a single narrative that should have a defined beginning, middle, and end, so finally filling in this gap to close the book is a good thing. What pisses me off is Konami burning everything to the ground and saying "Fuck you, world! You're not worthy of Japan!"
+Big Boss
Yes send guys from upper management to work as janitors then wonder why everyone is calling you evil .
Joshscorcher and Mr Enter collabing?!
*Grabs Popcorn*
THIS IS GONNA BE GOOD
Alex Ramirez
And it is
Hey me too💎
This should happen more often.
The goats being Iron Will's workers may be based off of the fact there's a species of goat that in found ONLY on the island of Crete and nowhere else in the world.
Godzillawolf1 #Themoreyouknow
True...but what kid would get that?
Also Pan, who got stuck in the labyrinth.
You know what I like about this review? *****'s gags and TheMysteriousMrEnter's down to earth attitude. The two of you just play off each other so well.
The part that saves this episode for me is when Fluttershy looks at her reflection and admits to herself that she's becoming a monster. I relate to this episode because I've been through the same trialls in my own life; I've been pushed down and devalued by bullies for so many years of my life, when it came to relationships with friends on the internet who I thought I could trust, I started to get quite nasty and spiteful in a bid to be assertive. I did so because I felt I had to be so jaded in order to keep myself safe. I have tried to find that balance between avoiding being abused and not being an abuser back, which is more difficult than many give it credit for.
Fluttershy learns from this experience. She demonstrates what I have had to go through, and in the end manages to find that balance. I will admit the pacing is an issue, but at the same time it at least makes some sense why Fluttershy realized how she went much too far.
1:55 Strange, my dad feeds our rabbits baby carrots once a day without the green part, and they have both lived passed the expected life span of normal rabbits.
yes, rabbits can eat carrots but not in big loads or as a daily diet
Mr. Enter: "Fluttershy you don't need to see a self help guru, you need to see a shrink!"
That's why she's going to Dr. Wolf! :D
Whos dr wolf
Is it like a doctor whos a werewolf
Car Mikislav Dr wolf is a youtuber go check it out
@@zaithehedgewolf4587 sorry I don't trust hedgehogs
Car Mikislav harsh -n-
@@zaithehedgewolf4587 igga
"I didn't know assertive meant easily-offended"
Have you been to Tumblr?
+FC Mania
That kind of crap was going on with Tumblr two years ag--- Wait, never mind... I remember...
nowadays nothing has changed, but it's a different website with a blue icon
Or Twitter?
Or Twitter
I wonder what Discord would think of everyone's treatment of Fluttershy
He wouldn't have cared. That Fluttershy X Discord thing isn't actually gonna happen.
RainbowCatLord I wasn't shipping them. If I had one friend and was annoyed about her having another friend, I would be pissed at someone treating my friend badly
Oh
Carrying on now...
Michael Iv oh SHIT
When you have a crush on mr.enter and know he wouldn't care either way .
Otaku-Taku Tetsu~ truly hes a good looking guy. its a shame he's asexual and has bit of a distaste for romance. i wish he was at least he was demisexual.
You understand my pain...
Gotta agree he's cute. But I gotta respect his sexuality, or lack of. .
Slash pony pretty much my stance on it idk about everyone else .
Lady Moth hes a great man i have a strong respect for his critical ability.
7:11 I've always seen it as Celestia being like the Equestrian equivalent of a Pharoah. She's not ACTUALLY a God, but most ponies believe she is.
Wait you have pet rats? Me too!!! EEEEEEK So cool! Do you adopt? I'm adopting two little girls later this week ^^
But awesome review dude! Love it! I personally didn't mind this episode too much despite I hear similar reviews like this about it frequently. I guess I don't mind it and actually embrace it because it told me that the show and writers weren't afraid to take some 'risks' with the characters. I was blindsided by the change of Fluttershy and the tone of everything in the story, that it was actually a refreshing new take for me. Sure it was harsh and even tear jerking... (yes I actually cried seeing Rarity and Pinkie cry), but it still was something new. That alone I'm always happy to see.
Mice are dope! 👉😎👉
Nerdy Fan
And cute.
This is why everypony love you because your cute oh and if I ever come to your rift please keep you pet rainbow ball from eating me please
I'm very late to the party, but I have ratties too. I just adopted 2 little boys that I'm hoping to introduce to my current boys.
I actually love that scene. The way they react to it is just perfect and I think the way it is build up is great. I also think the moral itself is great as the way the ponies act is very much like how people act in the real world. I think it's episodes like these that push FIM above the MLP stigma. Equestria is not just a peaceful wonderland and there will be ponies that will take advantage of your weakness and strength and aggression can still get the job done.
There is a saying in Dutch that goes: "Gluttonous people own half the world" meaning that the more demanding you are the more you usually get. I think this episode demonstrated that and that kindness will often just leave you getting taken advantage of.
OMG, Josh and Mr Enter doing a collab. That's got to be the best idea ever! Great review you two. A perfect balance of the good, the bad, and the funny. The episode, I believe, has a good story but could have been executed in a much better way.
BlueRav3 My thoughts exactly.
These guys got me through the early, dark days when I lost my wife and daughter to a drunk driver and helped me fight alcoholism. Almost 4 years sober. Doing right by the memory of my lady and by myself as well. If you are watching this in 2022 you are a legend and if you're suffering from depression or negative emotions, know you are never alone and positive vibes onto you!
Yay, colab with Josh and Mr Enter! :D Also I'm with Mr Enter on this one, this is my personal pick for Worst Episode though now that I've watched this review, I can definitely understand your points on it, Josh. Good work as always. :)
Wow! A Collaboration between Joshscorcher AND Mr. Enter?!?! It must be my birthday! :D
11:01 YOU CAN WIN, YOU FEEL GREAT, YOU CAN DO THIS
The Desert Storm what are you doing?
The Desert Storm Hail Satan! Hail Satan!
Flame Kai'zer DBZ Abridged reference.
The Desert Storm Piccolo : Oh HA HA !
+Cody Hines Piccolo said that in the original Funimation dub. TFS did that quote word-for-word as satire. That's why Nail asking what he's doing is all the funnier.
Mr. Enter and Firebrand in the same video? Boy, I haven't seen such a good colab since Nostalgia Critic and the AVGN reviewed the 2014 TMNT movie.
Dutch_Atlantic_13 ikr
Emrald70 That's cool. Fun fact: It was MrEnter's review of the first Equestria Girls movie that got me into the fandom.
***** in actually getting engaged into the fandom. Which episodes do you start off with or avoid?
Carl Bloke Well I watched the first EG movie (loved it BTW) then I watched the series itself starting with episode one. Been hooked ever since.
***** ok thanks. I got into the show watching episodes from different seasons but I guess I'll watch it in order
"Spongebob did it better." ...I never thought I'd hear that phrase spoken. Ever.
HOLY CRAP A Mr.Enter and Joshscorcher crossover this is going to be Awesome
To be fair of the Greeks believed that both Helio's and Apollo were capable of seeing everything that happened under the day and Artemis everything in the night
"She's unassertive, not stupid."
Take it from a mega-introvert, Mr. Enter: when nerves are involved, anything that can come out wrong will come out wrong. :/
Mr. Enter brought me here, and now I have a new subscription!
Man, I am *not* used to seeing camera footage of Mr. Enter.
Josh and Mr. Enter are two of my most favorite youtubers, so when I saw that they were doing a review together, I practically died with excitement. And they did not disappoint! Love you guys!
I'm not even a brony. Mr. Enter's WTFU video brought me here.
welcome to the brony side ot the Internet.
Mark Condon
Same yet here we are! XDDDDDDDD
I have a question why did Josh green screen himself?
***** My filming couch is still in the moving van and the only other one was in the living room which had a window behind it with positively atrocious glare. Had to make do with what I had.
Ok, it was confusing me in the review but still like it.
Hey Josh! Sence you are Using the Flutty's "YEY", For Censore, Why Don't you review Sonic Rainboom?
Теодор Дочов He did. It was one of his first reviews.
OK! I Don't Remember it. What's yhe Link?
Is it in joshscorcher, or FOBEquestria?
17:28 mr.enter used common sense...
it's super effective!
Mr. Enter AND Josh in aone vid?! i think i found heaven!!
also, that fanart in the endcredits was really, really sweet!! huge up's to the artists that made those pieces!
16:46 "How did he track her down? He didn't seem to ask for her name and adress."
Maybe he did it *OFFSCREEN!* >.
in my opinion putting your hoof down is about learning to cope with annoyance and not being mean about it.
portia mccollom I think that's a good way of looking at it; I think a lot of people need to learn from it.
7:44 Iron Will seems like a really popular guy in Equestria, so I think most of the ponies probably came just to watch him.
"You's expect that kind of turnout for a concert or something."
"You's expect that kind of turnout"
"YOU'S EXPECT"
Robert Pysh I can't believed I missed that the first time. Now I can't stop laughing.
Robert Pysh HOW COULD I MISS THAT. ETERNAL SHAME ON ME.
Robert Pysh You's messin' around wit me?
;P
Looking at this episode as a whole, I had a sudden realisation. If you spend your life being a doormat, and then suddenly you have the courage to be assertive, that’s an entire life’s worth of anger steaming to the top with no filter for once... So even though fluttershy went over the top, it makes sense.
Mr.Enter and Joshscorcher together for a review? YES!!!
Mr. Enter AND Joshscorcher? Hell yeah!
I love Mr.Enter's mustache.
The instant I saw what Enter's request was in the description, I died of laughter.
A crossover with JoshScorcher and Mr. Enter? Wow, that's Awesome! Never thought that will ever happen.
i thought Mr. Enter has left the fandom... Well, back to my favorites again :)
I honestly thought she was going to say "You cut in line, I CUT YOU"
This is the best Joshscorcher video ever. And the best Mr Enter one too.
It took a few seconds to realize that was Mr Enter, then I realized putting your hoof down is his most hated episode.
1) DR HORRIBLE
2) great review
3) where have you been Mr. Enter??? I miss you so much!
sigh... I know I'm doing exactly what Josh did (but decided to drop it) by addressing this.... but I thought the point of Discord turning Fluttershy just like that was to show he could just do that with all of the main 6 but that wouldn't be fun. & him doing that with Flutters was also to show that he's a sore loser, which fits his character
I never thought we'd see Josh with the Mysterious Mr.Enter: Josh is a joker who forgives errors in some places. Mr. Enter takes things more seriously.
Then, again, it DOES make more sense if it's on this channel instead if FOB Equestria.
Finally the day where Mr. Enter and Josh collab! This is awesome!:D
A collab between Joshcorcher and TheMysteriousMrEnter? MY LIFE IS COMPLETE!
I really don't understand why there are so many people that hate this episode. Not only do I love this episode, it is one of my favorites. In fact, it's not only just that.
This was my very first episode of MLPFIM.
I got into the show and this wonderful fandom because of this episode. This episode made me start binging the entire series up to this episode (which was the latest one at the time). The show, the characters, the fan art, fan fiction, and reviewers like Josh and so many others that I've seen are only because of this episode. I get that not everyone can like the same thing. I know that. But everyone can always get excited with the fandom about their start to the show but I can't do that because of all the hate this episode gets. It makes me feel alone in the fandom.
I guess why this episode is so important to me is because... I totally relate to this. I was quiet and reserved throughout my childhood. I tended to be a loner, had few friends, and was bullied drastically all the way until I left high school. I always just took it and never fought back or insulted anyone. I decided to be the nice guy. But... there were so many times I wanted to fight. To hurt them like they hurt me.
I always thought it would make me feel good, that I would become better if I did the same things. However, I never did. Because I was better than that. I would never hurt anyone because it is wrong. And that's probably why I relate to this episode. I can see myself in what I could have been if I decided to do what everyone else did. I know for a fact I could have been just like Fluttershy in this episode if not worse if I gave up being nice and just did what my bullies did. This episode makes me feel good because seeing Fluttershy show herself to be assertive yet polite at the end, much like how I handled myself when I was bullied. I was kind, but I asserted myself properly.
This episode makes me feel proud how I stayed a good person, that I didn't become like how Fluttershy did when she overdid the assertiveness. I have so much good and love in my life now but I wouldn't have had any of that if I gave into my darker feelings growing up. Like how Josh once made a Top 10 Personal Episodes list for this show, if I did it, this episode would be my number one spot. Not only did it lead me to changes and a great show and fandom, it allows me to look back at the choices I made to be good and kind and be proud of that.
Rixec2 People such as myself hate the episode because of what Fluttershy does throughout the episode and how overboard she went with her assertiveness to the point where it can be classed as bullying especially with the Pinkie Pie and Rarity Part. Granted, there are some good points in the episode but the pacing fucks it up really badly and make it seems mean spirited but after watching this episode; my hatred for it seems to be not as bad anymore.
I can see how people like the episode and how some hates it while there some indifference about it. It just depends on how you look at it.
Rixec2 You, sir, have my personal congrats. *applause* If only other people were more like you...
Oh my god i just realized that's mr. Enter. He's adorable.
I'm gonna have to say, this is probably the single most divided comment section I've seen on a TH-cam video that wasn't directly related to politics or religion.
Why the crap was celestia watching you?I ALWAYS FEEL LIKE, CELESTIA'S WATCHING MEEEEE! AND I GOT NO PRIVACY! *somebody's watching me*
Josh Scorcher and Mr.Enter are collaborating?!
From this day forth, Christmas is now on July 27th.
Merry Christmas one and all!!!
As for the episode, I have issues with some of the character's actions in the episode and believe it to be a bit too mean spirited mainly because of Fluttershy taking Iron Will's advise and abusing it. I'm just going to stop there because this is one episode I'm never plan on reviewing because of the big debate over it.
Nice review you two. Mr.Enter I like your work and Josh you bring the comedy like no other. Can't wait to see more from both of you. And Mr.Enter, good luck on your 100th Atrocity.
***** TH-cam states 27 so I'd go with 27.
Redcord CHN Christmas in July.
The day silver quill collabs with mr enter is the day i can die happily think about it they're complete opposites both in terms of character and style.
+Redcord CHN so Christmas on my birthday YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY
+nick YAY
Ironically a few months after this Mr enter was attacked by a horse.
Matthew since when?
Carl Bloke Mr.Enter vlogs Horse
Matthew oh
Matthew Oh, the delicious irony.
You'd think it'd be a rabbit...
4:28
Looks like someone is getting a 'broner'...
*[Cricket Chirping]*
That was low of me, I completely apologize.
Josh and Mr. Enter?
**FANGASMING INTENSIFIES**
"I swear Pinkie Pie is an Eldritch Abomination."
Ok she's not THAT much of an enigma, she's not Cthulu or D-Reaper.
Well, THIS is an awesome combination....I enjoy both your MLP reviews and Mr. Enter's Animated Atrocities, so this is a pretty awesome team-up already.
Fluttershy: treat me like a pushover and you get the once over!
Scott Pilgrim: That doesn’t even rhyme!
Genius... pure genius josh. Thank you. 😂
'There are three things all wise men fear: the sea in storm, a night with no moon, and the anger of a gentle man.' I suppose that's the reason why all the ponies fear aggressive-assertive Fluttershy in the cake store
I dont eat Rabbit. But I would make... exceptions...
*edit*
what the heck is josh doing in a shack?
***** green screen, bruh
vidyogamenurd
I meant the context... bruh.
He's on the run from aggressive collab partners.
***** Oh...
Then I don't know.
bruh
GammaWALLE ... is that the real reason? Is there an overarching Fiery storyline? Why not just FIND a wooden wall and record there?
mr enter and josh work off each other
keep up the great work you both
Mr. Enter's beard and mustache make me physically ill...
+Limbo Studios Really. Because it cured my cancer.
Your pic does the same to me
That picture of a humanized Fluttershy flipping the bird that you were talking about... that actually exists.
where is the original mr. enter review
let me guess, taken down by Hasbro
Nope. I can give you a commentary that has the whole video tho.
7:55 - 8:50 BEST PART EVER! LOVE HIS REACTION
I will never be able to do a collab with Joshscorcher and MysteriousMrEnter.
Why even live?
You insult my room, I go! Ka Boooooooom! ~ Josh Scorcher 2015
It's so weird to hear MrEnter's voice coming from something xD
This was really great. I liked the more balanced and calm perspective Enter gave. Love the more dry humour.
Ink is either envious or really happy one of her best friends collab one of her fave reviewers but how would I know lol
Gosh Josh you and Mr. Enter are so similar especially in your voices I have a hard time telling who's who amazing work your collabs out do each other every time XD
Mr. Enter looks like a teddy bear. A teddy bear that'd set me on fire if I hugged him...
great review Josh
7:24 I'm just more concerned that TheMysteriousMrEnter made a joke than Celestia's stalking
"Would you want to add more unpleasant onto the pile?"
No, I want to see them be friends again. However, in this particular episode I wanted to see Fluttershy face retribution for her actions. I wanted to see her get some of the wrath that she threw her own friends thrown back at her. She only saw her reflection of her madness in a puddle, she didn't experience her own wrath and feel the pain she dealt to her friends!
10:15
if you hear that from FLuttershy , you will get back in the line too :)
Josh, what happened to your middle finger?
Jake Zero Shaver slipped out of my hands and I sliced my finger open.
***** hope it heals fast.
Ow!
He hurt it flipping the bird to many times
***** oh wow. this is why i let my beard grow out.
20:04- "You insult my room, I go KABOOM!!!"
Rabbits aren't rodents, they're lagomorphs
8:45 My reaction when this was first uploaded. It had finally happened. My two favorite reviewers reviewing (or in Mr. Enter's case, revisiting) an episode of MLP. :D
4:38 - 4:57 Hey, I found that part hilarious!
Me too
More of these two
would be awesome.
Kain Copper true
"I actually liked this episode." (Guns start firing) "OK, FINE THE EPISODE'S S***!"
I do too 😜
(BANG BANG BANG) I'M NOT DUMB!
Dragon Watcher yay you surrendered
Mr. Enter's right, you know.