Hanafi Fiqh Channel- Asalaam alykm, love your channel brother, I was just wondering about whether a person is supposed to say ameen aloud, aloud in a quiet volume or just in his mind after the imam has recited surah Al fatihah?
Salaam Alaykum Brother, Jazak Allah Khayr ! I had a question, what is the Hanafi fiqh's position on praying in the congregation in Masjid ? As far as what I know the Hanabila say that its Wajib, and I think Shafie says that its Sunnah Mu'aqqadah, I dont know about Maliki but what about the Hanafiyyah ? Jazakum allahu Khayran !
Amal Ahl Medina this the problem in all sects they are not able to search the proper as no of hanfi reject each other because they do not know which is actual hanfi fiqh Actually Islam is all about truth and truth is only one for which we have to test ourselves
@@basharatahmad3I think you are misunderstanding "truth is only one". For many issues, there are VALID differences of opinion i.e. more than one opinion is valid; this is why there were so many differences of opinion among sahabah.
@@basharatahmad3He never said that ghair muqallid is bad, he just wanted to tell that they Don't claim to follow a madhhab. In fact even those jurists who follow a madhhab; don't follow their imam always, and differ from their imam where ever they find it necessary.
OH MY GOD! Allaah will always protect his Deen in Mecca Madinah and does not need help from Group's or Movements named after Villages or Places in Far East India which is the Present Day Land of Idolatry and Statue Worship Making too.
shaykh u did not mention any hadith regarding the iqamah from kutub us sittah (6 books BUKHARI MUSLIM NASAI ABUDAWOOD TIRMIZI & IBNMAJAH ) instead u went to musannaf ibn abi shaiba's hadith which is a primary hadith book which contains 37000 hadith and many hadiths in that are munqati, mawquf marfoo & only few hadith are sahih. Please do check SAHIH AL BUKHARI HADITH 607 SAHIH MUSLIM HADITH 378B SUNAN NASAI HADITH 668 (Sahih) JAMIAT TIRMIDHI HADITH 193 (sahih) SUNAN IBN MAJAH 730 (sahih) all the above mentioned ahadith are sahih and states that the iqamah should be pronouced once, o Shaykh you u did not mention these 4 sahih hadiths and went for a daif hadith , infact Imam Abu hanifa himself tells that AUTHENTIC HADITH IS MY STANCE " but people are blindly following any thing that is directed towards Imam abu hanifa which he did not even told. Please do check above given hadiths, and check hadith jamiat tirmidhi 194 which is daif and states that the iqamah is to br pronouced twice. Please do correct me if i am wrong. JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
so let me ge this straight..... Sahaba Taba'een scholars of Ahl al hadith such as; Malik Awzai Thawri Layth Ibn Sa'ad Shafi Ibn Al Mubarak Sufyan ibn Uyaana Ahmed ibn Hanbal Bukhari Muslim Ishaaq ibn Rahuya ibn abi shayba etc etc are all wrong and the people opinions and analogy with very little hadith are correct!!!
And who told you that Ath Thawri and Ibn Al Mubarak belonged to the Ahl ul Hadith movement? BTW, this guy isn't referring to the Ahl ul Hadith movement which existed in the early history of Islam. Rather, the modern Ahl e Hadith movement.
Masha Allah
mashallah ustad
There are 20 idiots who are against of Hadiths and disliked this video. May Allah open there eyes and mind. Ameen
Ameen
Waiting for the next one!!!
Finally been waiting for this when is the next one coming??
BossHd Gamerz next week, IA.
Hanafi Fiqh Channel- Asalaam alykm, love your channel brother, I was just wondering about whether a person is supposed to say ameen aloud, aloud in a quiet volume or just in his mind after the imam has recited surah Al fatihah?
The Amin should be said softly while moving one's lips
Salaam Alaykum Brother, Jazak Allah Khayr ! I had a question, what is the Hanafi fiqh's position on praying in the congregation in Masjid ? As far as what I know the Hanabila say that its Wajib, and I think Shafie says that its Sunnah Mu'aqqadah, I dont know about Maliki but what about the Hanafiyyah ? Jazakum allahu Khayran !
Zubair Anwar its wajib
Can someone pls type the iqamah for me
Assalamu alaykum Is the full series complete ? Where do I find the full thing
I want to translate into Bengali all vdo of the Channel. And upload to my channel. Please give me permit
im super salafi!
Kamen Raida Gaimu
wow,so you must be part of the justice league!!
@@dr.snuggles8317 LOLOL
@@waqemhaq4196
:-)
Alhamdullilah you misquoting giving name gair muqalid it is unfortunate to people who fallow hadith
basharat ahmad
some people today claim to follow hadith but in reality they also follow scholars who use that "sahih hadith"for their opinion!
Amal Ahl Medina this the problem in all sects they are not able to search the proper as no of hanfi reject each other because they do not know which is actual hanfi fiqh
Actually Islam is all about truth and truth is only one for which we have to test ourselves
@@basharatahmad3I think you are misunderstanding "truth is only one". For many issues, there are VALID differences of opinion i.e. more than one opinion is valid; this is why there were so many differences of opinion among sahabah.
@@basharatahmad3He never said that ghair muqallid is bad, he just wanted to tell that they Don't claim to follow a madhhab. In fact even those jurists who follow a madhhab; don't follow their imam always, and differ from their imam where ever they find it necessary.
what is hanafi salah?
He just means the salah method which hanafi jurists have considered to be correct.
عندم يتفوق أصفير علي الكبار يحرب
OH MY GOD! Allaah will always protect his Deen in Mecca Madinah and does not need help from Group's or Movements named after Villages or Places in Far East India which is the Present Day Land of Idolatry and Statue Worship Making too.
Diwane Chootye. Learn how to pass urine first.
Huh?
shaykh u did not mention any hadith regarding the iqamah from kutub us sittah (6 books BUKHARI MUSLIM NASAI ABUDAWOOD TIRMIZI & IBNMAJAH ) instead u went to musannaf ibn abi shaiba's hadith which is a primary hadith book which contains 37000 hadith and many hadiths in that are munqati, mawquf marfoo & only few hadith are sahih. Please do check SAHIH AL BUKHARI HADITH 607
SAHIH MUSLIM HADITH 378B
SUNAN NASAI HADITH 668 (Sahih)
JAMIAT TIRMIDHI HADITH 193 (sahih)
SUNAN IBN MAJAH 730 (sahih)
all the above mentioned ahadith are sahih and states that the iqamah should be pronouced once, o Shaykh you u did not mention these 4 sahih hadiths and went for a daif hadith , infact Imam Abu hanifa himself tells that AUTHENTIC HADITH IS MY STANCE " but people are blindly following any thing that is directed towards Imam abu hanifa which he did not even told. Please do check above given hadiths, and check hadith jamiat tirmidhi 194 which is daif and states that the iqamah is to br pronouced twice. Please do correct me if i am wrong.
JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
@@AAPublicity please give me the Refrence brother.....
so let me ge this straight..... Sahaba Taba'een scholars of Ahl al hadith such as; Malik Awzai Thawri Layth Ibn Sa'ad Shafi Ibn Al Mubarak Sufyan ibn Uyaana Ahmed ibn Hanbal Bukhari Muslim Ishaaq ibn Rahuya ibn abi shayba etc etc are all wrong and the people opinions and analogy with very little hadith are correct!!!
Ath Thari and Ibn Al Mubarak would pronounce the phrases of the iqamah twice as Thirmidhi has mentions in Hadith no. 194
And who told you that Ath Thawri and Ibn Al Mubarak belonged to the Ahl ul Hadith movement?
BTW, this guy isn't referring to the Ahl ul Hadith movement which existed in the early history of Islam. Rather, the modern Ahl e Hadith movement.