“Someday my family may seek to hunt that valley. And if they do, you remember me.” James took those words to heart. The Natives gave his daughter a place to rest and his family to thrive on, it’s the least he can do.
@@TheSequimKid Fate is a interesting thing, seems to have created a bind between the Duttons and the natives. First in 1883 a Dutton daughter falls in love with a Comanche warrior that saves her and her family, then is killed by a Lakota warrior. Then a Dutton son seven generations later falls in love with a woman from another tribe and has a son. Bearing the name Dutton. Fate is interesting.
@@siksika4603 Didn't know, I'm from Mexico, here Indio = Indian but it has a bad connotation, we use indígena, I thought in English was the same. Good to know.
The fact that Elsa married a Comanche, was mortally wounded by the Lakota, and tended to by the Crow is a clear tell of how every nation was different and they deserved to be weighed based on their actions, not their skin. 1883 is one of the best shows ever made. The fact that James, a former confederate captain, not only fought alongside a freed slave, but trusted a union captain to protect his wife and son. These dynamics break all the boundaries we humans create, by having HUMAN moments that beg we settle our differences and wash off our perceived problems to face the real ones in front of us. Every single main and common character had a depth and brilliance to them. I absolutely love this show
As someone who started with 1883 and loved 1883 this flashback just warms my heart. I kinda want to watch it again but I don't know if I want to put myself through that emotional pain again
@@7amadayel3b85 1883.Unlike Yellowstone it's shorter and already finished. Only one season of 10 episodes. Keep in mind Yellowstone is very tonally different from 1883. Not bad, just different. So once you get to Yellowstone don't go expecting the same.
Best part was James giving them some of his cattle to eat for free so they wouldn't starve. Even though the Duttons have to make a living off selling their cattle. That part showed just how much James and his family liked and respected Native Americans for helping the Duttons find land and tried helping their daughter who died.
Tim McGraw makes a pretty good actor. Excellent sound quality in this scene with the sounds of cold leather as he shifts in his saddle. Excellent story here. I love the authenticity of the props and the compassion shown toward his fellow man. Kudos to Sheridan for brilliant writing.
First thing I ever saw him in was The Blind Side and was pleasantly surprised at just how good an actor he really was. When I saw he & his wife both were to star in 1883, I figured both would be amazing. The role of a Cowboy?!! McGraw must have thought this would b a piece of cake! Doesnt EVERY country singer wanna b a cowboy??? They sure convinced ME that they were the parents of Elsa Dutton alright!
@@janalalewicz7385 Have you ever seen Friday Night Lights? The movie, not the show. Tim plays the dad of the fullback, Don Billingsley. McGraw does a phenomenal job in that roll. Fantastic acting and fantastic movie. Highly recommend.
There are a few music artists who are equally strong actors and actresses. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill DEFINITELY fit into this category. I was impressed by their acting skills in 1883, and the only problem I have is that the show was a limited-run series! Give me a thumbs up if you also cried during every episode!
During the end it literally tore my heart out when Elsa died. It was only a movie but I was not ok for several days afterwards, the whole thing got to me. Best western I've ever watched, And I will never watch Disc 4 again.
It broke me too, 24 hours after watching that moving scene I'm fighting back tears even now. Sadest bit of TV I've seen for a very long time. When Elsas mum- Faith was told she had to say goodbye to her broke me too, the last time she would ever see her,and Tim protecting her - his arms wrapped around her as she took her last ride out, broke me. I couldn't stop crying during the last two episodes, and in the final episode I cried non stop.So powerful.I watched the " extras" after and Tim openly admitted he too became overwhelmed filming some scenes. God Bless 🙌
Close your eyes and just listen to the guy talking about putting his father in the tree. Such good acting. Makes you pine for a time when he could find peace.
No, no it shouldn't... You are dangerously romanticizing one of the most violent periods in American history, and probably the most violent in Native history. Their land was stolen, and he shouldn't have to ask a favor! Like if you had a single reference grounded in non fiction that idea of what their lives were actually like would change drastically.... Like this shows base are the same people who are against immigrants now because they are afraid to lose what they have, but your ancestors were immigrants who took from the people who lived here first and you are cool with it????
Haven’t seen Yellowstone yet, but wd started watching 1883 and are hooked! I’m also from Germany living here in the states so this show is so emotional to me because they have German immigrants and German actors in it. I love the connection Americans have with Germans 🇺🇸🇩🇪❤️
@@samsam18200 I haven’t seen Yellowstone yet, so we’re basically starting with 1883 and then going into Yellowstone. Does Yellowstone make more sense once viewers watch 1883? Is this why you wish you had seen 1883 first?
Sarah Hubbard You don’t have to enjoy one to enjoy the other but 1883 explains a lot of stuff. Watching Yellowstone first kind of spoils the end of 1883 actually. The flashbacks in season four tell you a lot.
I love the compassion shown for the indigenous people by the Dutton ancestry. I have to believe that even though there were many injustices served on native Americans in the westward expansion era, that there were those however few who truly sympathized and were empathetic to their plight and cause. I hope so anyway.
"The friends of the Indians" was a group that was started to try and help them. From their perspective at that time the Indians were viewed as behind the times and so they tried to bring them into the modern world of that time. This is criticized by some today but they are looking at it from a modern 21st century perspective and not a 19th century one. Today we understand and appreciate the unique culture of the native Americans and realize that things could have been different. The eastern natives had already been displaced and the war between the British and the French played a big role. Then along came the war between Britain and the USA in 1812. The fur trade also played a big role. The American civil war also caused a lot of problems for native Americans The white european settlers did not have it easy too..These things are seldom mentioned today.
@@conifergreen2 Here in the South it was mostly Scots-Irish and Germans that first "settled" the Appalachians...after the Indians of course. But the tribes in the South were known to be very friendly to the Europeans that moved into their lands....and vice-versa. "Most" of the White people that first moved into the area were poor and escaping the more populated Eastern coast. Mainly the Cherokee and Creek Indians, but also the Choctaw, Chickasaw & Seminole (a sub-tribe of the Creeks you might say). For the first few decades, they predominantly were all very friendly with new settlers...and regularly traded with each other, lived amongst each other and even inter-married quite a lot. But sadly, our government which has been on a downward slope of corruption and greed (Especially since the Civil War), stabbed these "Civilized Tribes" in the back, fought and forced the Native people to Oklahoma...which the Indian people called the Trail of Tears. The expansion of European people across the country was inevitable....the fighting between two different cultures was understandable, but the way all the Native people were betrayed SO many times was just shameful....to say the least.
I haven't reached this far into Yellowstone, but 1883 was epic! I'm still shaken by how good that was. Seeing this flashback warms my heart. I just started 1923, but I wish there was more of a backstory into building that empire and claiming all of that land.
Noone else could fill these roles, these roles were meant to be filled by everyone playing them! Just wow! Utterly beautiful and gutting episodes so far.
@@thelink6756 fits perfectly with the show! Not cringe at all and you're obviously not a fan of it if you don't like her narration. The show is built around her
I didn’t know I needed Tim McGraw and Faith Hill in a show…. You live and you learn. Loving s4 so far! I hope we get at least 2-3 more seasons with the family.
@@mikesuggs1642 1883 is a one off, so there won't be a second season, but the Dutton family saga will continue in 1932 which doesn't have an announced release date yet.
IMHO, I think this is one of the best excerpts of Yellowstone. Great acting, great words, great scene. I wonder, if you believe in these things, if this is related to how much luck the Dutton family has had and continue to have. James Dutton’s compassion to these beaten people has allowed karma to continue showering the Duttons with good luck. In other words, how you treat people is how you will be treated. Otherwise, you’ll have a date with karma, whether you want it or not. True, John Dutton has had to fight hard for his family and legacy, but nothing worth having ever comes easy or cheap. Love this show.
I think the luck aspect of the Duttons come from the fact that they were given permission to be on that land. This prequel was the best thing to happen to this series in my eyes. Taylor Sheridan is an absolute genius and hats off to him for telling this story the way it should be !
Couldn't agree more Veronica. Well said. Whether one believes in it or not, Karma IS real. You get what you give. Good or bad, what comes around goes around, sooner or later.
@@jonkent928 why don't you just put us out of curiosity and tell us, Mr Dictionary. We would love to hear what the alternate woke version is of the word karma.
but he fought for his family and his family’s legacy, just like James did. I think that’s the real appeal of the show. John ain’t doing nothing we wouldn’t do for our own families.
@@vellytyre5658 if u watched the show, youd know the duttons didnt steal any land. He was told by a native where he could to bury his daughter build a future for his family. The land was given to him.
I’m glad I started with 1883 and watched everything in technical order instead of the order they came out. It was totally by accident but I think watching it chronically makes a big difference. I wish they would’ve done more episodes of 1883 though like they’re doing with 1923. I’ve always loved flashbacks in shows as it gives story and characters more depth but seeing these flashbacks definitely hits different.
Taylor Sheridan (Travis Wheatley of Yellowstone or Charles Goodnight of 1883) sure knows how to write excellent western tv series, and it's cool how he tied both Yellowstone and 1883 stories together.
He's brilliant at other genres. He penned "Hell or High Water", "Mayor of Kingstown", "Wind River" and "Sicarrio" that I can think of off hand. I know he has more writing credits as well. He's been very busy and for a reason. He knows how to write.
I can't overlook his deep hatred for bikers. Always the antagonists, or very plain villains, like in Tulsa King. Might have something to do with how he finished up in Sons of Anarchy, and how he can't talk to Kurt Sutter.
Tim and Faiths acting sucks. They struggle to show any emotion. Faith always looks uncomfortable in her scenes like she's trying so hard to not look at the camera. All I see is Tim and Faith. They do not make their characters come to life with the emotions needed.
@@kimberly9129 you're in such a small minority of ppl that see them like that. Like seriously overwhelming majority of people myself included thought they did a good job.
I would have to say that it states 1893 flashback because the show 1883 shows how Dutton father started the ranch after the war. Then 10 yrs later(1893) is the flashback of the Dutton father meeting with the indigenous to allow him to bury their father. Just my opinion on how I read the show... BTW. I can't wait for 1883. I think these shows have been much needed to bring back the country and western feel. 👌🤠
The older boy is Spencer Dutton, John Dutton's (Costner's) great uncle. And the younger boy is John dutton the 1st, his grandfather. And James Dutton is his great grandfather. Wow
Also, in the episode 4 of season 4, James Dutton(Tim McGraw), who is John Dutton's Great Grandfather, is killed. Which means Margaret(Faith Hill) gets the Dutton land (Yellowstone).
There was a lot of John Dutton in the way Tim McGraw played his ancestor. An underplayed and quiet strength of character. If this clip is an indication of the 1893 spinoff then we are not going to be disappointed.
Only for his politics, not for his acting abilities and that's just stupid. I wonder if they do the same to the people who cook their food, dispense their medicine, fix the brakes on their cars, does emergency surgery on their kids or handles their money.
OK it's official; country music singers make damn good actors. I remember seeing Dwight Yokum in Slingblade and being amazed at his talent. Now here i get Tim McGraw making me believe I was in the year 1883. Like he made me believe I was an Odessa Permian fan in F N L...
Is this the only show/series you've ever seen ? It doesn't make it into my Top 250. i liked the show even though the script was almost unbearable as it defied logic, reason & reality ==> for a show that's supposed to be rooted in those things. I agree the cast did well considering those mis-steps ==> but BEST YOU'VE EVER SEEN ? I'm curious => did you just recently get your sight back ?
@@jeffwisener1378 => FRINGE, LOST, GOT, SOA, SUITS, Sneaky Pete, Breaking Bad, Hill Street Blues, 24, Deadwood, Godless, Prison Break, Justified, Dexter, The Walking Dead, Counterpart, Bosch, Fortitude, Rectify, The Five, Broadchurch, Twin Peaks, Journeyman, Awake, True Detective (with Matthew McConaughey, Woody Harrelson, Michelle Monaghan).......there's 25 and i didn't even break a sweat. ROTFLMAO. ENJOY ! You need another 20-25 => just let me know !
@@13kimosabi13 Lmfao. Stopped reading the list after I saw Sons of Anarchy. One of the most lame, cheese shows. It was at least watchable in the beginning... but man did it go down hill. Can't believe you put that on your list. You criticize someone that says 1883 is one of their favorites, and then stick SOA on your list. Hilarious. Mr. Inbetween, Deadwood, and The Sopranos. There's some great television. Something like SOA wouldn't even be in the same universe as these 3 shows.. and I'd 100% put 1883 above SOA as well. No question.
After watching the finale to 1883, this scene makes a whole lot more sense now. It adds to the importance of the land, the characters, and the stakes of just keeping it. But I wonder if the current generation of the Duttons know about it.
Seems like James relies heavily on his wife to keep him in check. It also seems like the Duttons attach deeply to family and grieve a lifetime over loss. It’s likely that without Margaret he’d be a much harder man. When John says the family died with his wife he means it, and the problems with their family really stem from her early departure.
Just finished watching 1883 couple of weeks ago as a repeat on the Paramount Channel. Excellent movie. Didn't know there was a 1893 I only knew of 1923 and 66 66
jeff robinson - I’m only assuming that’s why this was in the episode. At some point John is going to figure out that he can give the Ranch to Tate, and that will be how they keep it in the family. Tate being 1/2 Native American, he will share the land with his Native American family. Then no one can take it away, or sell any of it. Just my opinion…
Of course it was or they would never have shown it. Every time the show does a montage to the past it always comes back to the present and represents itself in one way or another.
After watching the show, you basically already know once he tells James his plan to bury his father by the tree his mind is already made up. First he asks you want to bury him here? And then he when the native says yes by that tree, James makes a face that says I’ve been there. And then goes over the top and helps them out more. At this point he has a huge respect for natives but also understanding of his situation.
I hate the fact he got killed off :( James Dutton is my favorite Dutton :) I'm so glad I started watching the Yellowstone Universe series in chronological order :) 1883 is the best series in my opinion, then Yellowstone and then 1923.
Lynch66 - Taylor recently bought the 6666 Ranch. It has over 142,000 acres and was listed for sale at $192.2 million dollars. Perhaps that’s why Taylor wanted to make a TV show about it…
Tim McGraw is just an amazing actor, isn't he? The way he talks, his manner and body movements are just natural. Like he is playing a role of himself. I ike Kevin Costner's patriarch role. But Tim MCgraw is just killing it. For me 1883 is better series than Yellowstone.
Hard to compare….1883 is 10 episodes with an ending Sheridan considers it a 10 hour movie….Yellowstone has been 4 whole seasons and in the middle of season 5 with ups and downs season 4 was the worst but season 2 and 3 are so good…..I prefer Yellowstone cuz of the characters not the story
We just love this series Paramount 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻…the injustice committed to the Native American Indians was so unjust…like in the beautiful book..burry my heart at wounded knee 🙏🏻
Looks like it will be a great show. I'm guessing the bones that were dug up were his. As being a farmer they should have taken the ear tag out of the calf. Didn't have them years ago.
@@andorastorm1000 of course they will call it indigenous burial ground. It's going to screw over the Duttons, but it may also stop that airport from being built permanently
@@batmansdad3195 not really. Spiritual sites can not be removed or built on top of. The field is just that a field. So Dutton gets his field back, Native Americans get at least a say on what happens, and the elite witch gets big fat zero and no runway. Lol
@@andorastorm1000 yeah they only show the one body found, we know they will take their time looking for more. Over the years that family could have kept burying their members there. The only way up here you'd be allowed to build is if the body was relocated using traditional ceremony of the indigenous peoples. Trade off would probably be they have the rights to name something and reserect some plaque staying this was treating land
@@batmansdad3195 I think it was only one body, but I think the Father will turn out to be a Chief of some Nation and that will be what makes the difference. The Father was born on that land, and Dutton (Tim Mcgraw's Dutt9n) said he can be buried but he decides where. It will be interesting for sure.
I'm glad you guys liked it, but my wife and I were disappointed by it. I thought it focused too much on the daughter and her drama - I was hoping for a bit more substance. The Yellowstone series is much better ( or at least that's what we thought)
“Someday my family may seek to hunt that valley. And if they do, you remember me.” James took those words to heart. The Natives gave his daughter a place to rest and his family to thrive on, it’s the least he can do.
And seven generations later, Tate is born.
@@TheSequimKid Fate is a interesting thing, seems to have created a bind between the Duttons and the natives. First in 1883 a Dutton daughter falls in love with a Comanche warrior that saves her and her family, then is killed by a Lakota warrior. Then a Dutton son seven generations later falls in love with a woman from another tribe and has a son. Bearing the name Dutton. Fate is interesting.
@@IStealFries kacey would be the 6th generation. tate is the 7th and the time when they will reclaim the land.
@@icer1249 And there is beauty in that circle.
Also the natives who shot her
How this scene plays out makes more sense after watching the prequel. Their respect for the Indians was gained on the journey to this land.
I was talking to my wife about this scene when I was watching 1883 also. Definitely made this make more sense..
Natives
@@scoobums13 I'm 100% 1st nation's. Niitsitapi. The only people that have an issue with the term Indian, are not native.
@@siksika4603 Didn't know, I'm from Mexico, here Indio = Indian but it has a bad connotation, we use indígena, I thought in English was the same.
Good to know.
@@siksika4603 no lol, I'd like to be known as Native. Not Indian, I'm not from India ✌️
The fact that Elsa married a Comanche, was mortally wounded by the Lakota, and tended to by the Crow is a clear tell of how every nation was different and they deserved to be weighed based on their actions, not their skin. 1883 is one of the best shows ever made.
The fact that James, a former confederate captain, not only fought alongside a freed slave, but trusted a union captain to protect his wife and son.
These dynamics break all the boundaries we humans create, by having HUMAN moments that beg we settle our differences and wash off our perceived problems to face the real ones in front of us.
Every single main and common character had a depth and brilliance to them. I absolutely love this show
As someone who started with 1883 and loved 1883 this flashback just warms my heart.
I kinda want to watch it again but I don't know if I want to put myself through that emotional pain again
what i see first ?
@@7amadayel3b85 1883.Unlike Yellowstone it's shorter and already finished. Only one season of 10 episodes.
Keep in mind Yellowstone is very tonally different from 1883. Not bad, just different. So once you get to Yellowstone don't go expecting the same.
@@theunknownuser9609 Nah, Yellowstone is terrible now and has been since the Season 2 finale. lol
@@ComedyBros5 Yeah, but I wouldn't want to like keep anyone from enjoying it.
Lighting with the Yellow Hair! Is that you? 😎
Best part was James giving them some of his cattle to eat for free so they wouldn't starve. Even though the Duttons have to make a living off selling their cattle. That part showed just how much James and his family liked and respected Native Americans for helping the Duttons find land and tried helping their daughter who died.
They traveled over his land for multiple days and didn't forage or graze or poach. That's respect. He just returned it.
Tim McGraw makes a pretty good actor. Excellent sound quality in this scene with the sounds of cold leather as he shifts in his saddle. Excellent story here. I love the authenticity of the props and the compassion shown toward his fellow man. Kudos to Sheridan for brilliant writing.
Check out 1883 they just gave him his own show
All true expect for ear tag in the heifer.
@@nmelkhunter1 Yea, I'm not even a cattleman and I noticed that wasn't a steer!
First thing I ever saw him in was The Blind Side and was pleasantly surprised at just how good an actor he really was. When I saw he & his wife both were to star in 1883, I figured both would be amazing. The role of a Cowboy?!! McGraw must have thought this would b a piece of cake! Doesnt EVERY country singer wanna b a cowboy??? They sure convinced ME that they were the parents of Elsa Dutton alright!
@@janalalewicz7385 Have you ever seen Friday Night Lights? The movie, not the show. Tim plays the dad of the fullback, Don Billingsley. McGraw does a phenomenal job in that roll. Fantastic acting and fantastic movie. Highly recommend.
Tim Mcgraw really killed this role. incredibly talented guy.
No kidding, just watched 1883 and wow
And Dutch shows up to James’s land saying “I’ve got a plan.” Arthur and John are in the back shaking their head.
Lolll stop 🤣
It's okay boah
OMG, I'm dead! LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOL, I just finished playing that game. Best video game I've EVER played. What a storyline, RIP Arthur.
You are killing me man! Jokes aside, RDR2 is my favourite game ever and this show looks like it could fill in the void that the game has left in me
There are a few music artists who are equally strong actors and actresses. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill DEFINITELY fit into this category. I was impressed by their acting skills in 1883, and the only problem I have is that the show was a limited-run series! Give me a thumbs up if you also cried during every episode!
During the end it literally tore my heart out when Elsa died.
It was only a movie but I was not ok for several days afterwards, the whole thing got to me.
Best western I've ever watched,
And I will never watch Disc 4 again.
Yes, the show was a tough [love] watch. It's also a stark reminder of how soft we've become now.
who needs a name like James Dutton when your called Tim Mcgraw! it's such a badass cowboy name! 😂👌🏻
It broke me too, 24 hours after watching that moving scene I'm fighting back tears even now. Sadest bit of TV I've seen for a very long time.
When Elsas mum- Faith was told she had to say goodbye to her broke me too, the last time she would ever see her,and Tim protecting her - his arms wrapped around her as she took her last ride out, broke me.
I couldn't stop crying during the last two episodes, and in the final episode I cried non stop.So powerful.I watched the " extras" after and Tim openly admitted he too became overwhelmed filming some scenes.
God Bless 🙌
This scene hits so hard after watching *1883*
It makes so much sense now
10 yrs earlier he was told: You are Welcome to this (Paradise?) but in 7 generations my people will take it back! Love this show!
I like to think John will give the ranch to the Indian reservation
Tate is the 7th generation, and as Monica's son, he possibly fulfills the prophecy
How prophetic
1883 is one of the best to be made loved it. The acting quality is beyond
The only thing that sucked was the loss of ennis and Elsa. I had really hoped to see something there with those two but the way it ended was damn good
@@fernandog806 I mean things like that always suck but the story would suck if they were all plot-armor superheroes. Makes it more realistic this way.
I think 1923 is better than the other two
Damn, if thats true I'm stoked. just finished 83 and it was incredible@@lolarose70
Who knew Tim McGraw would make such a badass western actor, he really has something here
Close your eyes and just listen to the guy talking about putting his father in the tree. Such good acting. Makes you pine for a time when he could find peace.
No, no it shouldn't... You are dangerously romanticizing one of the most violent periods in American history, and probably the most violent in Native history. Their land was stolen, and he shouldn't have to ask a favor! Like if you had a single reference grounded in non fiction that idea of what their lives were actually like would change drastically.... Like this shows base are the same people who are against immigrants now because they are afraid to lose what they have, but your ancestors were immigrants who took from the people who lived here first and you are cool with it????
Haven’t seen Yellowstone yet, but wd started watching 1883 and are hooked! I’m also from Germany living here in the states so this show is so emotional to me because they have German immigrants and German actors in it. I love the connection Americans have with Germans 🇺🇸🇩🇪❤️
I wish I could have watched 1883 before I watched Yellowstone.
Enjoy Yellowstone! It’s great
ausgezeihneit!
@@samsam18200 I haven’t seen Yellowstone yet, so we’re basically starting with 1883 and then going into Yellowstone. Does Yellowstone make more sense once viewers watch 1883? Is this why you wish you had seen 1883 first?
Sarah Hubbard You don’t have to enjoy one to enjoy the other but 1883 explains a lot of stuff. Watching Yellowstone first kind of spoils the end of 1883 actually. The flashbacks in season four tell you a lot.
I love the compassion shown for the indigenous people by the Dutton ancestry. I have to believe that even though there were many injustices served on native Americans in the westward expansion era, that there were those however few who truly sympathized and were empathetic to their plight and cause. I hope so anyway.
"The friends of the Indians" was a group that was started to try and help them. From their perspective at that time the Indians were viewed as behind the times and so they tried to bring them into the modern world of that time. This is criticized by some today but they are looking at it from a modern 21st century perspective and not a 19th century one. Today we understand and appreciate the unique culture of the native Americans and realize that things could have been different. The eastern natives had already been displaced and the war between the British and the French played a big role. Then along came the war between Britain and the USA in 1812. The fur trade also played a big role. The American civil war also caused a lot of problems for native Americans The white european settlers did not have it easy too..These things are seldom mentioned today.
@@conifergreen2 Here in the South it was mostly Scots-Irish and Germans that first "settled" the Appalachians...after the Indians of course. But the tribes in the South were known to be very friendly to the Europeans that moved into their lands....and vice-versa.
"Most" of the White people that first moved into the area were poor and escaping the more populated Eastern coast.
Mainly the Cherokee and Creek Indians, but also the Choctaw, Chickasaw & Seminole (a sub-tribe of the Creeks you might say).
For the first few decades, they predominantly were all very friendly with new settlers...and regularly traded with each other, lived amongst each other and even inter-married quite a lot.
But sadly, our government which has been on a downward slope of corruption and greed (Especially since the Civil War), stabbed these "Civilized Tribes" in the back, fought and forced the Native people to Oklahoma...which the Indian people called the Trail of Tears.
The expansion of European people across the country was inevitable....the fighting between two different cultures was understandable, but the way all the Native people were betrayed SO many times was just shameful....to say the least.
Probably didn’t know Natives shot his daughter with an arrow.
theres no such thing as justice....thats an illusion for the poor
I mean he just admitted he took all their land....but he did leave them a single cow. True hero of the people
1883 is the best show I've ever seen. Greetings from Hungary
And so the kind deed returns a favor over a hundred years later. Cool story line.
I haven't reached this far into Yellowstone, but 1883 was epic! I'm still shaken by how good that was. Seeing this flashback warms my heart. I just started 1923, but I wish there was more of a backstory into building that empire and claiming all of that land.
Powerful teaching moment for his children. The way he handled it with so much respect was.. awesome
Noone else could fill these roles, these roles were meant to be filled by everyone playing them! Just wow! Utterly beautiful and gutting episodes so far.
Hello ma’am, thanks so much and i really appreciate your love and support for my dad acting career...Ryland Cole Hauser...God bless
This show was the best of the franchise and Tim McGraw did a perfect job. I want to see him do more acting.
I am SO looking forward to this prequel to the great Yellowstone show.
@Yeti Manetti It premiere's this month on the 18th.
@Yeti Manetti out now
It is incredible. Better than Yellowstone.
It’s fantastic!!
1883 is lit. Everybody watch it so we can get more in the future
First 4 episodes of the 1883 series is 🔥🔥🔥🔥
are 1983 and yellowstone related?
@@raptorhacker599 yes
I could do without Elsa's constant cringe narration.
Wait until you see Episode 6 and 7! It gets even Better!!!
@@thelink6756 fits perfectly with the show! Not cringe at all and you're obviously not a fan of it if you don't like her narration. The show is built around her
Dignity on both sides. And peace. And respect.
I didn’t know I needed Tim McGraw and Faith Hill in a show…. You live and you learn.
Loving s4 so far! I hope we get at least 2-3 more seasons with the family.
Not so pretty anymore. She's like 57 and looks it. Even with plastic surgery and botox.
@@kimberly9129 lol you sound jealous Faith is bad af and looked like a snack the whole season
@@Posiviata93 you sound desperate af. Blind af too. She ruined her face with plastic surgery. Quit reaching.
Justin Timberlake will be next, just you wait and see.
I've seen this scene several times it's so real I forget they are acting. 1883 is my favorite series hope it never ends.
At the rate they are killing off the cast. They may not be anyone left for a season 2! But that was the reality of the West.
@@mikesuggs1642 there is no season 2 :(
@@mikesuggs1642 1883 is a one off, so there won't be a second season, but the Dutton family saga will continue in 1932 which doesn't have an announced release date yet.
Sorry but it’s done after one season
Tim can not act. He shows NO emotion. All I see is Tim McGraw. He needs to take that permanent smirk off his face if he wants to act.
IMHO, I think this is one of the best excerpts of Yellowstone. Great acting, great words, great scene. I wonder, if you believe in these things, if this is related to how much luck the Dutton family has had and continue to have. James Dutton’s compassion to these beaten people has allowed karma to continue showering the Duttons with good luck. In other words, how you treat people is how you will be treated. Otherwise, you’ll have a date with karma, whether you want it or not. True, John Dutton has had to fight hard for his family and legacy, but nothing worth having ever comes easy or cheap. Love this show.
I think the luck aspect of the Duttons come from the fact that they were given permission to be on that land. This prequel was the best thing to happen to this series in my eyes. Taylor Sheridan is an absolute genius and hats off to him for telling this story the way it should be !
Couldn't agree more Veronica. Well said. Whether one believes in it or not, Karma IS real. You get what you give. Good or bad, what comes around goes around, sooner or later.
I encourage you to research the word "karma". 🙏🏼 Journey well.
@@jonkent928 why don't you just put us out of curiosity and tell us, Mr Dictionary. We would love to hear what the alternate woke version is of the word karma.
@@bigeneingers good luck friend
Who knew John Dutton character would be exactly like his ancestor: wise and understanding.
but he fought for his family and his family’s legacy, just like James did. I think that’s the real appeal of the show. John ain’t doing nothing we wouldn’t do for our own families.
Best Western I have seen since Lonesome Dove!
Really love the level of respect each show the other here.
the YT man that stole their land does not deserve any respect and will never ever have it.
@@vellytyre5658 if u watched the show, youd know the duttons didnt steal any land. He was told by a native where he could to bury his daughter build a future for his family. The land was given to him.
@@vellytyre5658respect is a given when you’re on the wrong end of a barrel
@vellytyre5658 he had an agreement and he kept it. Watch 1893
I'm hooked on 1883. I saw one free episode of Yellowstone, then I found 1883. So glad I'm watching that first. It's a fantastic show.
Definitely 1883 first! Looking forward to season two in the fall!
I’m glad I started with 1883 and watched everything in technical order instead of the order they came out. It was totally by accident but I think watching it chronically makes a big difference. I wish they would’ve done more episodes of 1883 though like they’re doing with 1923. I’ve always loved flashbacks in shows as it gives story and characters more depth but seeing these flashbacks definitely hits different.
I wish 1883 hadn't ended. I can't get enough of it. But it looks like I will have to settle for 1932 and re-watching 1883 again.
I think I'm looking forward to this more than Christmas itself.
Taylor Sheridan (Travis Wheatley of Yellowstone or Charles Goodnight of 1883) sure knows how to write excellent western tv series, and it's cool how he tied both Yellowstone and 1883 stories together.
He's brilliant at other genres. He penned "Hell or High Water", "Mayor of Kingstown", "Wind River" and "Sicarrio" that I can think of off hand. I know he has more writing credits as well. He's been very busy and for a reason. He knows how to write.
@@robertvargas9693 mayor of Kingstown is pretty good. Waiting patiently for season 2
@@ferafera20 mayor of Kingstown was amazing to the wife and I, Wind River brilliant movie too, Taylor's a legend tbh
I wonder if Travis from Yellowstone is related to Charles Goodnight. Just a nice little theory I can't help but think up.
I can't overlook his deep hatred for bikers. Always the antagonists, or very plain villains, like in Tulsa King.
Might have something to do with how he finished up in Sons of Anarchy, and how he can't talk to Kurt Sutter.
I am hooked. Love this show. Faith and Tim are pretty good actors. Very authentic.
Tim and Faiths acting sucks. They struggle to show any emotion. Faith always looks uncomfortable in her scenes like she's trying so hard to not look at the camera. All I see is Tim and Faith. They do not make their characters come to life with the emotions needed.
@@kimberly9129 you're in such a small minority of ppl that see them like that. Like seriously overwhelming majority of people myself included thought they did a good job.
I loved 1883, but after the way it ended, I can’t watch any more of it. The heart and soul of the show isn’t the same. 💔
Really have to watch the prequel to understand that he's honoring his promise.
Good to know Allflex ear tags were available in 1883 for those Hereford cattle in this clip.
Yes, and a steer suddenly looks like a cow too.
Good to know they had HD cameras too capable of capturing these interactions.
@@blueberrytacos 😂😂😂
No shit
I didn't see that the first 12 times I watched it.
One of the best scenes in the whole series.
I wish all of Yellowstone was like this. 1883 was great, Yellowstone seems more like a soap opera.
I would have to say that it states 1893 flashback because the show 1883 shows how Dutton father started the ranch after the war. Then 10 yrs later(1893) is the flashback of the Dutton father meeting with the indigenous to allow him to bury their father.
Just my opinion on how I read the show...
BTW. I can't wait for 1883. I think these shows have been much needed to bring back the country and western feel. 👌🤠
The older boy is Spencer Dutton, John Dutton's (Costner's) great uncle. And the younger boy is John dutton the 1st, his grandfather. And James Dutton is his great grandfather. Wow
How do you know Spencer is his uncle? Was that name mentioned on Yellowstone before?
@@garycharboneau4219 that’s what I think too
Also, in the episode 4 of season 4, James Dutton(Tim McGraw), who is John Dutton's Great Grandfather, is killed. Which means Margaret(Faith Hill) gets the Dutton land (Yellowstone).
@@garycharboneau4219 i don't think so personally i think he lived. His wife was just really upset when he got blood on her floor. 😉
@@garycharboneau4219 we share the same theory about Elsa's son being spencer.
Hopefully this is an indication of a good show to come!
@Yeti Manetti yes I've seen them and was referring to 1883.
There was a lot of John Dutton in the way Tim McGraw played his ancestor. An underplayed and quiet strength of character. If this clip is an indication of the 1893 spinoff then we are not going to be disappointed.
Brilliant performance from the entire cast. Tim McGraw left me speechless. Hope there will be another season.
This right here just cost me the price of 1883 on dvd. Well done.
I hear ALOT of people trash Tim when he was announced but I think he’ll do great
Not Tim’s first acting gig. He was awesome in “The Shack”
Only for his politics, not for his acting abilities and that's just stupid. I wonder if they do the same to the people who cook their food, dispense their medicine, fix the brakes on their cars, does emergency surgery on their kids or handles their money.
OK it's official; country music singers make damn good actors. I remember seeing Dwight Yokum in Slingblade and being amazed at his talent. Now here i get Tim McGraw making me believe I was in the year 1883. Like he made me believe I was an Odessa Permian fan in F N L...
1883 is so much better than Yellowstone. I really hope it gets more seasons.
I thought it was 1 and done, just like 1923.
Tim McGraw seems to be a perfect fit.
Tim McGraw is an underrated actor
Why, he shows his hypocrisy by making money carrying a gun while he detests gun ownership.
@brent rogers no it doesn’t
@@drewhendley loop
Nope
The man he’s asking to bury on James’ land, is the man that told James about Paradise Valley, Montana (Yellowstone Ranch) in the last episode of 1883.
How do you know for sure? Also why does James say that he wasn’t the one who took the land?
@@MaximillianNewman because he technically did not take it… It was given to him.
@@XMarksMyHeart661 By who?
@@Anth230the United States government.
@@Anth230 by the Indian that told him about the place and to settle there.
THAT'S the kinda respect we're lacking
1883 1923, excellent writing and story telling…. The honor and the truth telling, WOW!!
From beginning to end, the best casting I’ve ever seen!!
Is this the only show/series you've ever seen ? It doesn't make it into my Top 250.
i liked the show even though the script was almost unbearable as it defied logic, reason & reality ==> for a show that's supposed to be rooted in those things. I agree the cast did well considering those mis-steps ==> but BEST YOU'VE EVER SEEN ?
I'm curious => did you just recently get your sight back ?
@@13kimosabi13 obviously you think there are much better programs. List 20, my bet is 1883 is better than 90% of your so called better shows.
@@jeffwisener1378 => FRINGE, LOST, GOT, SOA, SUITS, Sneaky Pete, Breaking Bad, Hill Street Blues, 24, Deadwood, Godless, Prison Break, Justified, Dexter, The Walking Dead, Counterpart, Bosch, Fortitude, Rectify, The Five, Broadchurch, Twin Peaks, Journeyman, Awake, True Detective (with Matthew McConaughey, Woody Harrelson, Michelle Monaghan).......there's 25 and i didn't even break a sweat.
ROTFLMAO. ENJOY ! You need another 20-25 => just let me know !
@@13kimosabi13 Good list! I need to check a few (not watched) out. Thxs.
@@13kimosabi13 Lmfao. Stopped reading the list after I saw Sons of Anarchy. One of the most lame, cheese shows.
It was at least watchable in the beginning... but man did it go down hill. Can't believe you put that on your list. You criticize someone that says 1883 is one of their favorites, and then stick SOA on your list. Hilarious.
Mr. Inbetween, Deadwood, and The Sopranos. There's some great television. Something like SOA wouldn't even be in the same universe as these 3 shows.. and I'd 100% put 1883 above SOA as well. No question.
This series and the others by Mr. Sheridan are excellent.
Thank you.
1883 was excellent. Sad ending but good.
One thing I love is indigenous people and the country!
latest episode of 1883 got me right in the feels but i knew it was coming
Makes way more sense after watching the prequel. The OG Duttons really had more respect for indigenous people more than the modern Duttons.
After watching the finale to 1883, this scene makes a whole lot more sense now. It adds to the importance of the land, the characters, and the stakes of just keeping it. But I wonder if the current generation of the Duttons know about it.
I think John does when he said something like “what an embarrassment we’ve become after all the sacrifices that were made to give us a home.”
Seems like James relies heavily on his wife to keep him in check. It also seems like the Duttons attach deeply to family and grieve a lifetime over loss. It’s likely that without Margaret he’d be a much harder man. When John says the family died with his wife he means it, and the problems with their family really stem from her early departure.
They know about it. So does Monica and her family. So do the Broken Rock people. John's grandson Tate is the Seventh Generation.
James character is easily my favorite in all the yellowstone series.
Tim Mcgraw is such a badass cowboy name anyway...guy was made for this role! 👌🏻
Just finished watching 1883 couple of weeks ago as a repeat on the Paramount Channel. Excellent movie.
Didn't know there was a 1893 I only knew of 1923 and 66 66
So are these the same bones unearthed stopping the development?
that was my thought
I hope so. It might be what stops construction for good. Wouldn't that be a twist!
jeff robinson - I’m only assuming that’s why this was in the episode. At some point John is going to figure out that he can give the Ranch to Tate, and that will be how they keep it in the family. Tate being 1/2 Native American, he will share the land with his Native American family. Then no one can take it away, or sell any of it. Just my opinion…
Of course it was or they would never have shown it. Every time the show does a montage to the past it always comes back to the present and represents itself in one way or another.
@@strumbum946 I like where you are going with this.
Just finished 1883 and loved it. Now on to 1923. Taylor Sheridan should do a series somewhere in the 1950-1980 timeframe.
After watching the show, you basically already know once he tells James his plan to bury his father by the tree his mind is already made up. First he asks you want to bury him here? And then he when the native says yes by that tree, James makes a face that says I’ve been there. And then goes over the top and helps them out more. At this point he has a huge respect for natives but also understanding of his situation.
I'm just glad I watched this whole franchise chronologically.
I hate the fact he got killed off :( James Dutton is my favorite Dutton :) I'm so glad I started watching the Yellowstone Universe series in chronological order :) 1883 is the best series in my opinion, then Yellowstone and then 1923.
This flashback is better than all of 1883
Taylor Sheridan, he will own television
Lynch66 - Taylor recently bought the 6666 Ranch. It has over 142,000 acres and was listed for sale at $192.2 million dollars. Perhaps that’s why Taylor wanted to make a TV show about it…
@@strumbum946 Yeah and you know, I have lived in Houston my whole life and never even heard of it, LOL
@@lynch6642- I'm thinking most of us outside of the ranching world never heard of it until we strated seeing the 6666 TV show being talked about.
@@lynch6642 maybe because it's in Montana
@@sandicosenza6170 6666 Ranch in in Texas
Tim McGraw is just an amazing actor, isn't he? The way he talks, his manner and body movements are just natural. Like he is playing a role of himself. I ike Kevin Costner's patriarch role. But Tim MCgraw is just killing it. For me 1883 is better series than Yellowstone.
Hard to compare….1883 is 10 episodes with an ending Sheridan considers it a 10 hour movie….Yellowstone has been 4 whole seasons and in the middle of season 5 with ups and downs season 4 was the worst but season 2 and 3 are so good…..I prefer Yellowstone cuz of the characters not the story
1883 > Yellowstone > 1923
We just love this series Paramount 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻…the injustice committed to the Native American Indians was so unjust…like in the beautiful book..burry my heart at wounded knee 🙏🏻
If there was a time to go back to such a time it is now. Living the way of the native was a hard but very honorable way of life.
This spinoff was waaaaay too short and sooooo deeep I wish we got so much more , love every second of it
This is exactly what human nature should be like
1883 was amazing!!!!
Darn good writing and acting!!!
Tim McGraw. THAT guy can act!!!
Can't wait for December 🤠
Wow that's one right man and one great Indian 👍
Kudos to Faith, Tim and the cast, love the show and authenticity they all bring to it
No disrespect, but when did Tim Mcgraw become such an amazing actor?! Hot wife, beautiful family, great singer, now Emmy worthy actor?! Not fair.
I really really miss tim mcgraw character
Yes 1883 should have focused more on him than the daughter and her drama.
James was so cool
I LOVE this serial. As a lifelong Louis L Amour fan there is nothing like a good western.
Now after watching 1883 I realize they are burying the chief who recommended the Duttons bury Elsa in the valley and start a ranch there.
Ahhhhh the promise he made the Indian man that was helping Elsa 🥲
Looks like it will be a great show. I'm guessing the bones that were dug up were his. As being a farmer they should have taken the ear tag out of the calf. Didn't have them years ago.
It will the Native American Father that died bones, it might be what saves the land. Wouldn't that be hilarious 🤣
@@andorastorm1000 of course they will call it indigenous burial ground. It's going to screw over the Duttons, but it may also stop that airport from being built permanently
@@batmansdad3195 not really. Spiritual sites can not be removed or built on top of. The field is just that a field. So Dutton gets his field back, Native Americans get at least a say on what happens, and the elite witch gets big fat zero and no runway. Lol
@@andorastorm1000 yeah they only show the one body found, we know they will take their time looking for more. Over the years that family could have kept burying their members there. The only way up here you'd be allowed to build is if the body was relocated using traditional ceremony of the indigenous peoples. Trade off would probably be they have the rights to name something and reserect some plaque staying this was treating land
@@batmansdad3195 I think it was only one body, but I think the Father will turn out to be a Chief of some Nation and that will be what makes the difference. The Father was born on that land, and Dutton (Tim Mcgraw's Dutt9n) said he can be buried but he decides where. It will be interesting for sure.
One thing I DO admire about them is their reverence and respect for the elderly. Always have.
Hello ma’am, thanks so much and i really appreciate your love and support for my dad acting career...Ryland Cole Hauser...God bless
RIP ELSA😭
1883 is a masterpiece me my fiancée loved it so much , this scene now makes much more sense !
I'm glad you guys liked it, but my wife and I were disappointed by it. I thought it focused too much on the daughter and her drama - I was hoping for a bit more substance. The Yellowstone series is much better ( or at least that's what we thought)
I wonder if he knew he was speaking to an Indian outlaw half Cherokee and Choctaw🍻
His baby was a Chippewa, all his friends call him bear claw
Lol good one
We need more of this.
I’m mad that they cut this show off I wanted to see more of it learn more of the history . It was good while it lasted
There’s more to come though. 5 more shows are planned including 1934 taking place of the son
Totally forgot about this flashback. 1883 was great. The opening narration of 1923 (Elsa again) tells you what happened to them.
Fantastic. The Indian outlaw playing a Cowboy.
Ha ha. A gun hating Indian outlaw.
After watching this clip I can appreciate 1883 a lot more
This prequel is awesome!!
In one week i look all 4 seasons great . Thank you.