The Double Life of Malay Muslims in Malaysia
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ธ.ค. 2024
- This video is a reminder to every Malay Muslim who fears Allah and the Last Day that Hak Istimewa that they're benefitting from is not aligned with Islam as it infringes on the rights of others. Islam teaches us to be just and Islam does not tolerate any form of racism. This special privilege given to the Malays is not affirmative action despite them wanting to call it that as it's not temporary. I only ask that we acknowledge that it's wrong and hate the sin because how are we going to stand in front of Allah on the Day of Judgement with a sound heart if we don't? We have to put an end to this cognitive dissonance within our own conscience.
If you enjoyed the video, then leave a like, comment and subscribe and watch my other videos to support this channel's growth.
Support my dawah efforts directly without giving a share to TH-cam.
(I don't make money from ads)
PayPal: paypal.me/fear...
Buy me a coffee: buymeacoffee.c...
#islam #allah #malaysia #melayu #malay #dawah #muslim #deen
I see a lot of people misrepresenting my views so let me clarify myself once more even though I already did in the video.
Never did I mention once in the video that I oppose safeguarding the position of the Malays and the indigenous people in Malaysia. Safeguarding their position and wellbeing is understandable within the context that is Malaysian history. My issue is that the implementation of this concept has been abused to the detriment of other races. Let me give you an example, I've seen many cases where Malays who do not deserve something, they may be rich or not qualified, yet they receive a benefit that another non-Malay who is more deserving (they may be in need or more qualified) does not get. You can complain all you want about the economy being in the hands of the minorities and keep repeating the same talking points about history but the truth is that, it's really not that important.
Let me tell you what the real issue is. The real issue is that Muslims and in this context the Malays, have abandoned the Qur'an and Sunnah as their compass in life hence why we're facing so many problems. You can tell me that Malaysia is secular and we're multiracial but that is really just beside the point. I'm not addressing the government, I'm addressing you, the people. If we start abiding by the Qur'an and Sunnah and view life through this lens and find solutions within the deen of Allah, you're telling me we won't fix all our problems? If you say no, then you have issues with your Aqeedah as a Muslim.
We shouldn't be uniting upon race or country. We should be uniting towards religion. That is the only thing that can truly unite people and that is evident in the life of the Prophet, peace be upon him. The Arabs were tribal in nature and they went to wars over one another despite being of the same race. What united them? It was Tawheed of Allah.
My main message in this video if you couldn't understand it the first time is that we Malays should go back to the Qur'an and Sunnah then we will inevitably become dominant and successful. We should be calling the other races who are Non-Muslims towards our beautiful religion and thus they will assimilate.
How much effort has been done for this? Instead, we are actively pushing people away from Islam when that should be our goal. Until we as a race realize this then we will never succeed. I'm conveying what Allah and His Messenger said and you're replying to me about history and economics? You think I don't know history? Fear Allah and start looking at this life from the lens of Islam and not your whims and desires.
Again, I'm not asking we give up this land to the non-Malays. I ask that we live by the Qur'an and Sunnah and become true representatives of Allah on this land. Allah says in the Qur'an 24:55,
"Allāh has promised those who have believed among you and done righteous deeds that He will surely grant them succession [to authority] upon the earth just as He granted it to those before them and that He will surely establish for them [therein] their religion which He has preferred for them and that He will surely substitute for them, after their fear, security, [for] they worship Me, not associating anything with Me. But whoever disbelieves after that - then those are the defiantly disobedient."
To obtain authority over this land we have to 1. Believe and 2. Do righteous deeds. Did Allah tell us to oppress, commit injustice by abusing a law to safeguard our own race which fosters a "me vs them" mentality which basically leads to racism? The solution is right in front of our eyes, but we have abandoned it. That's why you see a lot of people telling me about history which I already know of and couldn't care less of yet they don't quote what Allah or His Messenger said. That tells you all you need to know about our state as a race.
Abang, you said you are half Melayu. Siapa other half?
Assalamualaikum, if you truly want to help the ummah, then please correct me or yourself on things about your video and your views.
1. Based on the research of a Motivational Figure in 2021, roughly 80% of Muslims don't fulfil the required 17 rakaat of Fardhu Prayer. I think this number doesn't change much until now(correct me if I'm wrong). The subject of this video is inappropriate or have you addressed the root cause of this problem elsewhere?
2. I realised and admit that Bumiputera has an unfair advantage compared to non-bumiputera, but it is unreasonable for us Melayu to sacrifice for the non-Muslim like how the Ansar sacrifice their wealth for the Muhajirin. I would understand if it's the Palestinians we are talking about.
Waalaikumussalam warahmatullah
1. I have indirectly talked about this but if it needs its own video then I will make one.
2. I'm not asking to sacrifice for non-Muslims. I'm asking about being just. Justice means giving each person who has rights his rights and putting everything in its proper place. There are many Muslims among the non-Malays. Are we being just with them with the way this law is being implemented today? We're supposed to be bringing people closer to Islam not away from it and by Allah, I've never seen any non-Muslim feel attracted to Islam because of such implementation. We can safeguard the Malays no problem, but we have to be just. This concept has been used to manipulate the Malays for political gains. Why won't we wake up and realize this.
@@Lelaki-MELAYUmuka-JAPAN-TAIWAN aq melayu kacuk gak (Bapak = Pashtun, Afghan + Melayu, Emak = Melayu + Cina). Aq xtahu, but kat sekolah aq org yg muka kacuk ni auto jadi famous. Untuk aq X sebab aq time sekolah dulu gemok. So orang ejek Aq babi pink sebab kulit aq pink2 n badan gemuk. But I never di bully sebab aq nmpk lain dari muka org melayu.
Zaman sekarang ni maybe ko jadi famous kot, sebab sekarang kan zaman KPOP, banyak je pompuan melayu yg nak, melainkan ko x hensem.
Well said brothers, racism is really normal among Malay community eventhough Islam teaches about unity
I am Malaysian born Chinese. Ignore haters. Keep working hard and don't give up. As a Malaysian Chinese i feel some times its quite unfair to label all malays lazy . How about those grab riders delivering food for us despite rain or shine? Think about it.
Grab riders are doing it due to a lack of choice, what about local construction workers that have near none existent rights.
It's probably the lazy malay teachers and workers that caused us to have the belief that malays are lazy
I totally agree with you, As a full Malay, me and one of my close friend, has always talked about this issue, we both want things to change, but we lack the power to make any in a significant way. Hopefully, someone will come along who is able to make the necessary changes.
Be the change you want to see
as long as you exist, you will grow brother. I am praying for all of you, Malay or not
You don't need power brother. "I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say, “Whosoever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart - and that is the weakest of faith.” 40 hadith of An-Nawawi
As another half malay, I have to say that ethnic nationalism is the bane of the Ummah. Be it Malay, African, or Arab nationalism
This is the consequence of us adopting the western style of "nation-states"
@@user-op8fg3ny3j I think this problem predates that, otherwise the Prophet pbuh wouldn't have spoken about it
@@kaissondmitrijev1044 sure. I mean, it doesn't help the problem that Muslims divide ourselves based on our race
are u half black ? , i notice as black teen living here alot of racism in the system
@@user-op8fg3ny3j true, the entire concept of nation states is satanic
As a Singaporean Muslim (non-Malay), I get what you're saying to a certain extent. However, the reality is, the people who want to take over your country (like they did Singapore) do not subscribe to Islam and therefore also don't have the same values you're preaching here. When I go to Malaysia I enjoy the fact that it is easy to eat halal and make my prayers almost everywhere. A large portion of Malaysian tax money goes towards Islam, be it the large mosques or enforcing Islam in the country. If Malaysia falls to another race (and by that extension, religion), I can assure you that these privileges Muslims have in Malaysia will be gone in a few decades. Just look at what's happening in India to the Muslims there. You sound very young and optimistic, but unfortunately, the real world works very differently. Every country employs some form of racial discrimination (whether outwardly or in secret) to the minority or the weaker races, and this won't change just because the leaders are Muslims.
True, in case between 2 muslim of diffrent ethnic, yes.
In malaysia context is much more complicated. The question is do you trust your religion in the hand of non muslim. since malay must be muslim here, this have become a ethnic problem.
Aku pernah tersangkut isu ni dulu.. tapi bila baca sejarah sebenar negara malaysia dan pihak mana yang memerdekakan negara serta pihak mana yang sibuk mengelak persefahaman bangsa dengan mencipta aliran sekolah yang berbeza, aku paham mengapa negara ini jadi begini.. Hidup perlu jadi realist bukan idealist. Baca sejarah lebih banyak agar tidak berlaku perpecahan seperti singapura.. sejarah 13 mei.. Semakin muslim dan melayu lemah, semakin bergolak negara.. Isu ni terlalu besar dan membarah dalam negara.. Tidak cukup untuk dibincang di sini.
MashaAllah❤May Allah bless you and guide the Ummah in the right direction.Ameen
Love your video may Allah bless you ❤
JazakAllah khayr for sharing. May Allah grant us all guidance.
Reminder: Make sure to LIKE and SHARE this video to your fellow Muslim brothers and sister, this deserves more attention.
I get what you mean, but it's more complicated than that.
If between Muslims, yes the opportunity should be equal despite of race and background. That is undeniable.
The Malays are generally Muslims, and the other races are generally non Muslims. Thus this fact in itself shows that our playing field are in a different level..
Muslims naturally want to lead the country as close as the Quran and sunnah and that's fine.
However the non Muslims they don't care about the Quran and sunnah. They don't have the same vision towards the country. Their aim is to make the country secular and at par with the other western nations, and this will compromise the Islamic values that we know and love. And they don't want Islam to be part of the equation.
Black, White, Foreigner, Local, We are all Muslims.
Rohingya too
everyone, every Muslims are brothers and sisters. Its not just a Malay problem, its a problem for every Muslim! no matter what our nationality is, ethnicity, culture or race... we are all equal and should stand by each other's side. the Israel Hamas conflict... its not a war between Israel and Palestine! it should be a war between Israel and every Muslim country! it don't matter if we are not from Palestine, Palestine is also our country because it is a Muslim country and we should also go in war and help them but sadly I don't see any Muslim countries helping them... every Muslim country in this world should unite and act as one.
This is a war between JEWS and ISLAM.
may ISLAM come out unscathed and victorious, Insha-allah!
@@Alghi451 hell nauw
@@GamerManEd1yz_ yes and cope harder
Someone shared your video. I'm here for this.
Even affirmative action in this day and age is racist.
any law that favors one race over another is racist.
Its really as simple as that but some cant grasp this simple concept.
i am not from malaysia, thanks for talking about this, i will be praying for all of you, and one day i hope justice prevails, have patience
I will be the bad guy in the OP eye's and present my view.
The only reason OP can say such thing "is" because he is born Malay and speaking from a comfortable space,
as per the other redditor comment, the law is made because we have to take in all the non native into our nation just because of british wont send them back and the non native apparently had political power on a nation that is not their own, where their races doesn't even fight the war to free Malaya, heck they even support their nation and stay loyal for a very long time to it even after merdeka, (and malay is the racist apparently in the holier than thou malay eye).
Kalau bubarkan 153, OP boleh jamin ke Islam kekal harmoni? sekarang ni pun punya banyak usaha nak jatuhkan islam dan liberalkan malaysia.
And it all happened because we keep betraying each other in favor of political power! That was how we got conquered by foreign powers in the first place!
I second this thought, its nothing to do with islam, because sabah and sarawakians are still given this benefit. Its simply to protect the origins of Malaysia, mainly being Tanah Melayu and Borneo.
Its seems as its racists because the other races have been living long here, but the Law was made to protect the original race here.
If it was racist towards non muslims, then bumiputera would not also not have the benefits
setuju, sekarang ni ramai yg tak faham sejarah, tu yg membuta tuli je cakap
Aaaaa im glad i found this video, as an indonesian that lives in malaysia (my parents are both Indonesians but doesnt have an ic) i sometime do deal with ppl telling me to go back to my country and such. And not only that, its hard to get an ic nowadays especially renewing visa😅 i dont deal as much rascism i bc of the similarities of malay and indonesians ppl.
May Allah guide us all to the highest rank of jannah!!!❤
MashaAllah brother!!! As a revert and a Chinese myself who embraced Islam 3 years ago Alhamdulillah, u have spoken out what exactly I've been having in my mind.
The other thing I'm not afraid of questioning, are our political pond scums and our kuffar royals.
I hope all our local TH-cam podcasters like Kindered Stories, Syihabuddin Ahmad etc would highlight and react to this particular video.
Jazakumullahu Khair and Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi Ta'ala wabarakatuh
idk if i should consider myself a full Malay since I have Chinese blood but can't speak mandarin. I agree 100% with you. bersatupadu is senjata terkuat melayu tanpa mengira full malay or half malay
If we follow Indonesia's way, I can say that no Chinese, no Indian and definitely no indigenous people of Sabah and Sarawak would stick to their traditional names anymore! All citizens of Malaysia will be Muslims, everyone will speak the Malay language and everyone will use Arab names, albeit with Malay spelling!
Same in qatar, where I'm from, born and grew up, it's sadly in every muslim country i think, islam should be our nation, not follow the west and divide between "nationalities", yes there mught be regional names like makkah, madinah at the time of the prophet, likewise malaysia, qatar, bangladesh etc, but following the western way of creating your own "country" and being nastionalistic is nothing but the garbage ideas of the west. Me being bangladeshi I see many of my people be racist and get inti fights with pakistanis or indians even though they're muslims. I'm so happy to find a brother like you, you matched my ideas 100% i never thought I'd find someone who thinks as precisely as you, even the evidences that you gave. Muslims shouldn't have special privileges based on what "country or nationality" they're from. We're all equal, islam is our country, our nation, our brotherhood. It angers me so much whenever I see muslims from different countries waving their flags, doing national day celebrations when these were all the west's idea to divide us. If we were just like our prophet we'd still have our khalifa, and not a single muslim country especially in africa would suffer and gaza nowadays as well.
Africa suffer because of islamic militants enforcing the sharia and geno ciding the african christians. Middle east countries suffer because every islamic sects are fighting among themselves of who are the hypocrites. They even persecuting christians as halal kiling. The Indian peninsular are fill with violences after Pakistan and Bangladesh falls under islam and the Indian Christians are force to leave their villages and live like nomads out of fear from being kil by the muslims and hindus there. The western world are in chaos and crimes rising after massive muslims immigrants came into europe in the past few decades.
Islam is an agent of chaos and violence. The devil's perfect tool. I'm glad Malaysia are not under islamic sharia. We are more towrds the civil laws.
Regarding the issue of Bumiputera rights, if we want to make changes, it's not just the Malays who need to accept the change, but also the non-Bumiputera. Bumiputera rights are an example of 'positive discrimination,' meaning we have certain privileges. However, to maintain harmony in our country, we also grant rights to the non-Bumiputera, such as vernacular schools and the freedom to use their own languages as the medium of instruction in those schools.
The question is, are the non-Bumiputera willing to abolish vernacular schools in exchange for equal rights regardless of race? I've come across such discussions on social media. Bumiputera want non-Bumiputera to be fluent in the national language and to abolish vernacular schools, while non-Bumiputera want Bumiputera privileges to be abolished. But throughout the debate, neither side is willing to give up their own privileges. And that's the issue.
I appreciate your hope and desire to change the country. But can we bring all Malaysians together to compromise? That’s the real challenge. Without compromise, there’s a risk of racial conflict, as this is a significant issue. We want change, but the question remains: *Are We Ready To Compromise?*
P.S. I'm very sorry for what you've been through as someone of half-Malay. But this issue is not unique to Malays. Most people of mixed race, regardless of ethnicity or nationality, have experienced something similar. Half-Chinese individuals face the same challenges, and even in Korea, there are numerous documented cases of the harsh lives of mixed-race individuals there. I know you just want to share your experience as someone of half-Malay, but I just want to clarify that this is a broader, global issue, affecting many mixed-race individuals, regardless of their specific ethnic backgrounds or nationalities.
Thats what they dont want to mention..many of them still dont respect islam,many still dont want assimilate..still wanna be chauvanistt ,and its not malay that control economy..its the chinese..but these rich chinese dont want to heelp their ppl pon,thats why they jealous malay like to give other malays help..they think without bumi rights all will be good?nah,will be worst because the rich will be rich..see china sudahla
why must non-bumiputeras give up vernacular schools to remove bumiputera rights? I don't see the connection
@@forsens_pet simple. You take something from me, i take something away from you. That's a human nature.
This is dumb. Vernacular schools don't discriminate against who can join. In fact it exist because of the discrimination most of us face from the Malay. Religion should not be a staple of education.
And abandoning vernacular school wouldn't change how bad our education system is. Simply go watch the video from CNA. Simply put our problem stems from race, racism and how most Malays feel about Bahasa Malaysia.
And also 'positive discrimination' cannot exist. It is, in itself a hyperbole. By favouring one over the other, simply because of race is already taking opportunity from them.
@@kingkuro8317 True, I agree with everything you said. But what I’m pointing out is the harsh reality we face. To achieve equal rights, non-Bumiputera might have to give something in return for what the Malays hold most dear. It's not an ideal or fair situation, but it's what may need to be done to maintain peace and harmony. Malay is the majority, and Bumiputera rights are something they deeply protect. If we directly challenge what they value most, the risk of serious racial conflict is real. In order to reach equality, both sides might have to make difficult sacrifices. It’s a sad and harsh reality, but in the end, the goal is peace for everyone.
As a Malay Muslim I thought I was alone in thinking the same way. Glad there are other Malay Muslims who feel the same way. Love your work! 🥰
Is there truly racism in your country? Especially towards Africans . Am African planning to visit Malaysia. Will I be welcomed?
@@habeebmusa1216 Which type of African are you? Africa is kinda large. From my experience which is more Malay Muslim based, if you are more Northern African or have lighter skin complexion then you probably won't face any racism. If you are from other parts of Africa or have darker skin tone then you won't face any direct racism, but more so indirect racism. Like you will still be treated well by people but in their hearts they may feel a different way. Over here they're more racist towards South Asians.
@@orcasocute Am Nigerian. Thanks for the info bro
@@habeebmusa1216 Wc 🥰
im a half malay and i can relate to many people in the comments. my tip to every half malay, stop trying to prove yourself to them. just do you, i know it sounds cliche tapi mmg betul. ade berapa ramai orang kau nak asyik prove yourself to be a malay?? sampai khiamat tak habis. remember ; a state of being is a far more superior evidence than a performance.
as a full malay, im sorry for waht happened to you
This has been talked about and its way complicated to solve than it was said to be. The reason for the ethnic privilege heavily influenced by the journey towards the independence of Malaysia. Dissolving the Act 153 means the sacrifice made to free ourselves by colonialist will be for naught during the early days of independence. Malaysia originally is a muslim country and locals were malays at peninsular and bumiputera and sabah and sarawak too so it make sense why the rule was made to be that way. That being said other race should have some ways of obtaining the same privilige through a specific ways but we just dont have the means to make this possible at the moment due to internal crisis within our ministry and the economy of our country. The constitution of medina is made possible bcs it has less variety of race and has the means to achieve it.
I’m a Malaysian Indian currently living and working in Australia, if Malaysia can change its quota system I would love to return to my homeland and help build it into the advance country it deserves to be. I believe our generation will be the one to change these backward mindset that has plagued our great country and finally allow us to sit equal to other strong nations on a global stage. I beg the Malay people to view us Indians and Chinese as your people as we too love Malaysia and want to work together to achieve success for our people regardless of race and religion. Satu Malaysia for all her citizens
This guy is spitting Facts 💯💯💯
Assalamualaikum WBT brother, thank you for this video, thank you May Allah SWT bless speaking the truth. But be careful enemies of Islam is always watching, waiting, obverserving for a moment of weakness. May Allah SWT protect you in your journey to Justice ❤
Since we talk about Malaysia, lets discuss in our national language.
1. Bercakap ttg justice atau adil? Apa maksud adil? Adil = meletakkan sesuatu pada tempatnya (rujuk dbp). Terang2 adil bukan samarata. Tapi bg hak kepada yang berhak.
2. Nak bgtau yang Malaysia bukan negara Islam, tapi negara Muslim. Even mahkamah syariah di sini pun tak kuat nak dibandingkan dengan mahkamah lain. Jadi, tindakan kita tak menjadi gambaran negara Islam pun. Hudud pun tak jalan kat sini.
3. Kalau fikir dr sudut sisi lain, ini satu langkah utk bagi perlindungan kepada bumiputera. Sbb ni tanah asal kami. Malah, takde larangan atau sekatan pun utk kaum lain strive/berusaha gila2 kat negara ni. Bukti? Orang paling kaya kat Malaysia ni bukan Melayu pun. Jadi, apa isunya?
4. Hati2 dalam menggunakan dalil. Takut2 ter"tunggang".
1. Adil ini perkataan yang diambil dari bahasa arab dan definisi yang digunakan dalam dewan bahasa adalah berdasarkan Islam. Ia, adil tak semestinya sama rata tetapi "hak istimewa Melayu" terang-terang bukan keadilan dari segi implementasi.
2. Kenapa kita bangga bahawa Malaysia bukan gambaran Islam? Bukankah kita Muslim, umat Nabi Muhammad, ingin menjadi representasi Islam di bumi ini? Adakah kita akan disoal dalam kubur tentang kemelayuan kita atau keislaman kita? Fikir dulu.
3. Siapa yang memberi perlindungan? Siapa yang mengawal segala bende di alam semesta? Bukankah Allah? Adakah Allah memerintahkan kita untuk melindungi diri kita dan bangsa kita dengan undang2 yang menindas hak orang lain? Saya rasa tidak. Apa kena mengena jika orang paling kaya bukan orang Melayu? Jadi kalau orang paling kaya bukan Melayu ia bererti kita boleh menindas yang miskin dan selainnya? Isunya implementasi undang2 ini menindas hak orang lain. Kamu Muslim dan nak tak nak menjadi representasi Islam. Mereka berfikir ini apa yang Islam ajarkan jadi hati mereka menjauhi daripada mahu menerima Islam. Adakah ini satu bende yang bagus? Bukankah ini boleh menjadi penyebab orang tidak menerima Islam? Tidakkah kita akan disoal di akhirat?
4. Berhati-hati memberi pendapat yang tidak berdasarkan rasional atau logik. Ilmu dalam dunia ni adalah apa Allah firman dan apa Nabi bersabda. Fikir balik tujuan kehidupan kita dan kamu akan jumpa jawapan yang betul.
@@FeartheHour brother ive seen your video, it still seems to me your are still beating around the bush here. can u list what technical changes u wanna propose? be precise
Ini bukan tanah kamu, ini tanah Allah SWT. lepas kamu mati, tanah akan berpindah ke orang lain dan seterusnya sampailah kiamat. Tak da apa yang dimiliki oleh kamu hanya kerana bangsa kamu. Daripada so called melindungi kamu patut empower semua orang di Malaysia. Apa beza kamu dan Malaysian yang lain? Bangsa? Apa pentingnya bangsa kamu atau bangsa aku di muka bumi ini? Tiada kepentingannya langsung. Mementingkan bangsa adalah sikap yang bodoh, kita kena pentingkan cara2 untuk memajukan semua rakyat Malaysia bukan hanya bangsa bumiputera
@@abdulhalim-jk9lz
1. "Ini bukan tanah kamu, ini tanah Allah". Okay. Duit yg ada kat dlm acc kau, bukan duit kau. So, bg kat aku sekarang. Kau takleh nak marah sbb tu bukan duit kau pun.📏.
Ya. Mmg milik Allah, tp diamanahkan kepada?
2.Asasnya, semua orang ada hak yang sama, iaitu boleh berusaha, cari rezeki kat sini. Dan, pemimpin kita perlu lindungi anak buahnya. So, inilah caranya. Dengan "Ketuanan Melayu" yang masih terpasak ni pun, tanah2 rizab Melayu dah semakin berkurang. Just imagine kalau kita just hapuskan ketuanan ni, agak2 berapa percent lg yang tinggal? Melayu tak complain kalau kaum cina nak bg perlindungan or bantuan kepada kaumnya, Melayu tak complain kalau kaum India nak bg bantuan kepada kaumnya, kenapa kaum lain nak complain kalau Melayu nak bg bantuan n perlindungan kat kaum Melayu ni?
Bg bantuan atau jaga anak buah sendiri ni bukan racist. Racist ni ada 2 elemen - bangga dgn kaum sendiri, hina bangsa lain. Bg perlindungan dan kelebihan kepada bangsa sendiri ≠ hina bangsa lain. Ketuanan Melayu dianggap racist bg bukan Melayu. Tp bg Melayu, ini ialah perlindungan terakhir kitorg. See the difference
U think the average minority is a billionaire is it? We are all struggling like hell , u want proof? Look at singapore , equal rights everyone is thriving . Their last president was malay and she got there because she was good at her job proved herself no special privelages. That how it should be for malaysia to truly be democratic and successful as a country in this day and age
This need to receive more recognition
As black teen living here, the racism part is true, there's a lot of racism in the system(school etc) and it make it hard for foreigners living here
Agreed, with the speaker. I myself multiracial Malay (both of my parents are half malay). I really think that equity and equality will make us more successful than give us hand outs. I really wish all Malaysian people will eventually intergrate into one another. The problem today is integration, the minority don't want to integrate to the main culture. I think thats why we have problems like this, Phillipines, Thailand and Indonesia dont have this problem. Like, im kinda irritated when i need to speak english to my friends (my own countrymen) instead of Malay (national language, and being lingua Franca since forever).
Indonesia will swallowing your country and this racism system will end soon and all of you will have to speak bahasa Indonesia no matter what your race is, jaya selalu jaya
Alhamdulillah brother for having the bravery to say this, I never had problems on this issue because I'm a Malay but when I met my friends, I realised how cruel and unjust this system is. It really pains me to see people actively supporting it and 'jokingly' be racist to others even though Allah prohibits it. May Allah guide us on the right path and make this country right. Jazakallah khair
another example of using bombastic words to sound clever.
What's the solution then. It's to follow the Quran and Sunnah. Have we follow it? Have we take Quran and Sunnah as the Constitution? We colonized by British, the secular state that ironically gave Zionist the promised land because God promised them. Have to see it from bigger persepective. Its chronological we end up as today. Islam always above nationalisme, yet the native (Bumi) biased on nationalisme, and non native appose this via so called liberalisme, socialisme. I am muslim first and always choose the most islamic options. Setiap tindakan adalah niatnya. Allah Knows Best.
Bro, at 6:29, are you seriously drawing similarity between Muhajirin, the Awwaluun, the best Mu'minin, who had left all their belongings and properties for the sake of Allah with non-Muslims foreign laborers who were brought by British colonizers for their sole survivorship? Who were contempt and insecure with the natives' sense of belongings in their own homeland. The Hijrah of Muhajirin that happened after pledges by the Medina inhabitants, 2 pledges. While the Chinese and Indian laborers came because of British, not because of pledges between natives here, with them but because British colonizers needed laborers. Also, they had been lootings and arsons by these Chinese immigrants onto locals during British colonial period, knowing that they would be protected by British against Malay retaliation. That also during colonial rule, Malay educations were systematically being imposed with limited opportunity, as opposed to Chinese's and Indian's.
I AM HONESTLY CONFUSED. HOW CAN YOU DRAW SIMILARITY BETWEEN THESE TWO ENTIRELY DIFFERENT SCENARIOS? ARE YOU SURE IT IS NOT YOU WHO HAVE THE 'MENTAL DISSONANCE'?
Are you sure these people who rejected the suggestion of inclusion of Jawi curriculum in their vernacular schools because of their irrational fear of being "converted into Islam", which the objective has never been that btw, have even a little glimpse of similarity with Muhajirin?
If there had been pledges between Malays and the immigrants before their arrivals into Malaya at that time, I myself would know that there would be no Article 153 in our federal constitution. But reality has never been that. So, I am deeply unconvinced with your view on this matter, as presented in this video.
1. I really don't care whether you agree with me or not. Your opinion means nothing to me as not once have I seen you say Allah said or His Messenger said.
2. It seems you have a deep hatred towards other races. Not all are British laborers and even if so, what about their children now who are born here and their children? Are they all trying to take over your rights and land while you oppress them? How insecure can you be.
3. The comparison is not to say that these other races are the Muhajirin. It's about being unselfish and prioritizing others over ourselves. I'm not even asking for that. I'm asking for justice which clearly isn't being upheld here with the implementation of these laws. Read my pinned comment for my exact stance. Some of these so-called laborers you speak of are Muslims. Their children are Muslims. So it's fine to oppress them as well and take their rights? It's fine that they aren't given a good opportunity in life because of something that Allah chose for them? You can choose your religion, but you can't choose your race hence it means nothing.
4. Do you love pointing the finger? You're a Muslim aren't you? I really don't care whether these people want the Jawi curriculum or not. The implementation of Islam in this country isn't good anyways so of course people would be turned off by Islam. Does Islam support injustice even by an atom's weight?
At the end of the day let me say this, my stance is clear. I'm against injustice. I don't care about race, nor country. I'm against nationalism, secularism, and racism which are the foundations of this country. The cognitive dissonance is that Malays, the majority population are Muslims yet live within and support such a system. One will argue we are multiracial and it's because of historical events that led to Malaysia being the way it is but that's ultimately beside the point for me. The point is you're Muslim so act like one and make your lens Islam and not this thing you've been indoctrinated with.
@@FeartheHour
1. Likewise.
2. I was just highlighting the historical realities of British colonial administration and its impact on socio-economic disparities among different racial groups in Malaysia. The policies implemented during this period significantly favored non-Malay communities, leading to long-lasting inequalities. And yes, you right. Not all brought by British were laborers, some of them were soldiers. For instance, the Torrens system of land registration, introduced by the British, facilitated land ownership primarily for non-Malay individuals, enabling them to accumulate wealth over generations. So yeah, some colonial policies got them where they are right now, like Ng Chin Siu & Sons Rubber Estates. Also, calling me the oppressor because I favor Article 153 from Federal Constitution knowing how hundreds of years British colonial policies had ruined Malay people while the current job market favors non-Malays is funnily incoherent. I guess I just don’t have the luxury to be dismissive on this matter like you do.
3. Article 153 is ratified by Reid Commission due to lingering effect of the colonial policies while the immigrants brought to Malaysia were absorbed to be Malaysia citizens upon independence en commence. Btw, Tun Sambanthan said in Parliament, 1st June 1965, “If we look around in Asia and East Asia, particularly, you will find that my race the Indian race, is not welcomed in Ceylon, is not welcomed in Burma. Look at my brother Chinese race, in Cambodia, in all the other areas. It has been my great fortune to have born in this country. Where else can you find a more charitable, a more polite, a more decent race than Malay race? Where else can you get such politically decent treatment for any immigrant race?”. Also, if you are actually being fair and just, can you really pinpoint how much they are being “oppressed” and “taken their right”? Also, please be reminded that the New Economy Policy was becoming what it is becoming is because of the bloody attempt to undermine Malay livelihood when they “gained” power. And you ask Malay to be unselfish and prioritizing other people who undermine our own being over ourselves. Make that makes sense.
4. That’s not the point. What I’m trying to say is it’s so pretentious and out-of-place to refer to Surah Hashr ayat 8 to 9 for the people who freely being anti-Islam, who would whole-heartedly protest whenever there are policy that they think Islamic being in place, like dress code in government premises- this aims to maintain prudence, nothing Islamic. They would shout, calling the people who agree with this policy as Taliban out loud. When in actuality, the content of the Quran you referred to point to helping people who are ousted away from they place because of their steadfastness to faith, specifically the Muhajirin situation. I’m not pointing the finger, I’m pointing the actual occurrences. Please stop beating around the bush.
5. In actuality, from my POV, you are against historical context and reality on how the past is capable of influencing the current dynamic. I guess that’s why you are just being obstinate on how tangible the things really are and this idealistic behavior is not helping. While you realize that this country is founded on secularism, nationalism and racism, that helps no one when you gaslight the background history that brings us to this current affair but your own desire to feel right. Saying Malay people who happen to be majority, and also used to be imposed with marginalizing British colonial policies who then are entitled for their interests to be protected as mental dissonance is so out of place. Historical context is not indoctrination. It’s just fact.
6. Also, if you really against oppression, can you please stop withholding comments and just let them appear without your restrain.
The fact that you're accusing me of withholding comments is enough to paint the picture of this whole situation. I haven't done such a thing but yes you're quick to point the finger and be suspicious and accuse me.
You demonize and overgeneralize other races as if they're all like that. Are you telling me with 100% certainty they're all as you say they are? Allah tells us in the Qur'an to avoid suspicion. Allah tells Prophet Musa to go to Pharaoh who is the worst disbeliever to ever walk this Earth and talk to him gently. Allah tells us to call others to Islam. Yet, I don't see this as of any importance to you as all you blabber about is worldly history that won't mean anything after you die. You can call me idealistic all you like, but that's the reality. Our only purpose of existence is to worship Allah. Hopefully you're not one of those who don't even understand what worship is and will generalize it as just praying as you generalize other things. Yet, here you are bickering and fighting for something that won't bring you closer to Him nor is it fulfilling your purpose as a slave of Allah. You want to fight for this dunya then go ahead. My fight is for the Hereafter. Are there no Muslim Chinese or Muslim Indians? So it's fine right that their children despite getting good results can't get the same opportunities to further their studies like the Malays do, and Malays less deserving get it? I thought we were both Muslim? How many Malays who are so well to do yet benefit from this discrimination? I know of so many. Yet, what do you care?
Anyways, it's pointless talking to you because you don't share the same principles as I do. Not once have you based your arguments on Allah and His Messenger and it's all about history. All the people 100 years from now who have nothing to do with that history will suffer the consequences. Something they never chose for themselves. Yet they might be Muslim. But who cares right?
@@FeartheHour
My comment is really getting withholden here. This is not a blunt accusation. I was just inferred the probable cause to the fact that my comment does not appear in comment section. If that's not the case, it is just the error from my end then.
That is a widespread reality. Like the reprimand for democratizing Zakat for both muslim and non-muslim unconditionally and Jakim to be abolished. I guess you are just above into the all-encompassing abstractive view that this issue is not a problem at all. And I am just being the sordid one here. True it is not all of the people, but they are loud and influential at best. Also, nobody stops anyone from knowing Islam. It just the matter of want or not. It's hypocritical to reprimand me to keep nicety and docility when you yourself slamming Malays as a whole, as racists for consenting to Article 153, without acknowledging the historical context of how this national foundation was established in the constitution. This article not only recognizes the special position of the Malays but also the compromise that granted citizenship to all immigrants during the pre-independence period. Are you yourself really approaching this issue gently? Don't misunderstood me, I am also distraught to the fact that the qualified people from being given opportunities as they are deserved, but to negate the national framework that resulted from series of memoranda and social contract as utter racism is itself blunt ignorance and gaslighting. Afterall, exception does not make the rule. But I believe that open discussion on the concerns and fears between people involved can even possibly help bringing about the new covenant, just like the social contract. But this requires the utmost seriousness, legislative execution and dedication from all people. And I doubt that this can happen because everyone called out each other with racist slurs and stereotypes.
And just affirming about yourself to people about your resolve does not make you do things correctly, even far less capable to influence people to actually consider your POV. Even more, when you also ridicule people who have this understanding that obviously oppose to yours, that is if you intend to spark understanding on this issue in the first place. Some people feel strongly on this matter than you do because of historical grievances. Pursue the Akhirah, while painting other people in the way that make them as blunt racist is crazy. It just gives off “holier than thou” vibe.
Based on this reply, it seems like you don't understand my view at all.
I'm not against safeguarding the Malay position nor do I want the Malays not to have power. I'm against the implementation of this article as it is today. It has been abused to the detriment of other races which you yourself have acknowledged. Again, this video is meant for people to see that and acknowledge that. You also have to understand the way it's being implemented today causes Malay to consider minorities as the "other". It breeds in them to prioritize themselves over others regardless of any context and undoubtedly will lead to racism. You also have to understand that it causes the Malays to be easily manipulated. The people in power dangle this notion of rights and privileges only for their own benefit. They use it as an agenda as well to demonize others. All this for dirty politics that doesn't align with Islam. Also you said people can just learn about Islam? Yeah, they need to be enticed to learn but they aren't with the way we carry ourselves. Our character and how we treat other people are a means of da'wah as well. They think our religion is discriminatory or backwards because the people representing showcase that.
Anyways, this is the last thing I'll say to you as this is going nowhere. Whatever that you posited if it aligns with Qur'an and Sunnah with clear evidences regardless of history then I will gladly accept but if nothing is based on that and historical justifications are given yet they don't align with Islamic teachings then there is no way for me to accept that. The Malays will become successful when they go back to Qur'an and Sunnah. But when will they realize this?
Very well put brother.
As a non Malay Muslim thank you for speaking out, usually I'm unable to express how I truly feel due to the oppressive atmosphere
But I felt relieved to hear these points from a fellow Muslim, may the cognitive dissonance fade away slowly and let the rakyat truly be united under the 1st Rukun Negara Kepercayaan Kepada Tuhan
yeah… overgeneralization…
The real moment of: “awak berfikiran terbuka tak?”. good video btw.
Maybe you guys can refer to dr maza video, perlis's mufti to understand the Islamic view on this topic.
It is true that everyone is equal in islam, however don't forget what prophet said about quraish in which they should be the leader. Try to look at the hadith and the scholars discussion on it. Or you can try to find the video I mentioned above. Dont remember the title but I think he explains this in one of his lecture. Something related to Jawi, islam, melayu or zakir naik i can't remember.
The fact that he is ignoring the history says a lot about his knowledge in which the Malays are not racist as they accept all those people to live in this country. Isn't it such an ignorant ways to say that "I do not learnt and appreciate the history as I only focused on the akhirah only" like bro, learn Maqasid Syariah please, and perhaps you will understand. And please learn diplomatic ways of Islam before proceeding.
In Malaysia they give lots of respect to the Palestinians but unfortunately they are not allowed to open Bank accounts in here so far. We never know in future these laws might change.
people from Bangladesh are very hard working people but it is normal the Malays look down on them. I have seen many times the Malays go out of the way in helping the white skinned people like British, Italian, Koreans etc at the same time they look down to people from Pakistan, India,, Bangladesh etc
you need to understand the context of why malays respect them so much. even decades of oppression by zionist israel, they still preservere and chose to fight for their homeland. if they suddenly choose to emigrate to malaysia like how rohingya did, you will see a lot of malays oppose to that. heck lets be real, even liberals dont want them here. just look at siti kassim questioning why bringing them to malaysia (they were brought here to get medical treatment and then sent back, supposedly). lets be real, most of us dont want any more migration of foreigners into this country whoever they may be.
regarding 2nd point, i agree. but why? after decades of exposure to whitewashed-skincare and entertainment industry and also beauty standard that been set by western world, it isnt hard to see why. wordwide, skin whitening industry worth billions. even in india they faced the same issue. look at top celebrity in India, they are all fair skinned. some of them even went such a great length by bleaching their skin so they can be on top of the list too. so its not just a ‘malay problem’, its a worldwide problem. anyways, malays have been exposed so much that it has materialised to a point where they prefential treatment based on colours of skin. and also because south asians came here and work at low paying jobs. but i still see lots of them married malays (although that has its own controversies too) heck, even chinese have prefential treatment. lets face it, its malaysian in general not just malays.
Assalamu Alaykum brother. May Allah make me your friend in axirat. I agree with what you said
Waalaikumussalam warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
3:56 my dad said, imagine how harder your life would be without affirmative action, with a far more competitive life.
As Salamu Alaikum
take love from bangladesh. keep going and keep talking about right things brother. i really appreciate you .
jazak allahu khairan❤
Your argument suggests a lack of understanding regarding Article 153 and its historical context. Perhaps living in other countries could provide valuable insights to complement your perspective as you seem to have little to no knowledge about the outside world which is unfortunate.
It's important to approach such discussions with thorough knowledge and avoid making assumptions that might be perceived as self-serving. A more holistic Muslim perspective would consider the broader context and the positive contributions of various communities throughout the world.
The Malay community's welcoming nature toward diverse groups demonstrates their openness and inclusivity which you can see throughout the history. That is why you must not sleep during the history class to have a better understanding of this world. Your parents' interrace marriage is a testament to this acceptance and the families accept each other,. What does this means to you?
Spreading hatred is counterproductive and goes against the principles of Islam. I encourage you to explore Islamic diplomatic concepts and approach such topics with a greater depth of understanding so that you will not another mistake like this one. Grow up and be a better holistic Muslim then.
What this guy say its true.
As a non malay muslim, i dont see malays as religious at all, from little till adult, i was called many names by malays, I was told to make roti canai and nasi kandar due to my race, was called bangla due to my color, heck i remember one time i wanted to answer a history question and the lecturer told that a foreigner like me cannot answer the question(fully knowing i was a local). When i go to mosque for friday prayers, some mosque can still be heard saying "melayu Islam). Anything happens in Malaysia its always Melayu Islam and never semua muslim. The malays think they are special because of their race but no they are not special at all, they are just normal human beings with no significance, Islam brought significance to them and they attribute it to their race. Worst thing, the muslim convert preachers are also more race baiting rather than religion preaching which makes the situation worse. Back then i always try to mingle with the majority but nowadays, i just want to be left alone and sometimes prefer to mingle with the minority.I know not all of them are like this but when its a majority of them.
im a malay. am sad to hear of your bad experiences around your malay-muslim circles.
im involved with one or two NGOs for revert muslims in Klang Valley, and as per my experiences most malay Tom Dick and Harry interacted well with reverts, and even non-malay muslims in the NGO. So just curious from where do most of your bad experiences originate?
alas, i hope we both pray for the unity of the ummah, insyaAllah
@@Kampfer014 My bad experience started heavily from boarding schools onwards. (i dont wanna name them, will cause bigger issues). I felt so alone being called names and people laughing around. That one time i retorted back and got the seniors involved(of course they supported their people rather than being just) but yeah its all behind now.. but it gives a sting inside the heart you know. Everytime when i work with non muslim, i feel like would it be good if these guys are muslims instead.
@@abdulhalim-jk9lz thanks for opening up, sir. i myself hails from a boarding school of 5 years. so i hv my bit of understanding on the social scar it had left you.
Experiences may left u to be discriminating, as i cn see in your posts. am not defending my kin, but not all of us malays are so as you think, hence pls sir, make doa for us as a fellow muslim man. Good changes are coming to the ummah and i feel it. may Allah SWT grants u good life, neighboors and companions brother AbdulHalim
Thank you for sharing your experience. I too studied in a boarding school and since I'm mixed race I've seen both sides of the story. Anyways, I'd love for you to join my Telegram group so that we can have more like-minded people from Malaysia in one space. If you're interested do give me an email and may Allah bless you and reward you.
I seriously thought this would criticise (rightly) the Malays for having elements of *our* culture conflict against Islamic teachings, instead it's just another soy-infused critique of the Malays from a liberal-light perspective for not being 'socially just' enough. Pass.
I guess the brother has never heard of jizya. I guess he never heard of the caliph's right to impose restrictions on non-Muslims as he deems fit (so long as he doesnt intrude on limits the Quran and Sunnah has set) as incentives for non-Muslims to become Muslims. Did the Prophet exile all kuffar from the haram, even those already living there? Were the Muslims allowed swords and arms while kuffar are not?
Please don't say: "but you can't become Malay." Refer to what the definition of a Malay is at the very beginning of this video of this even crosses your mind.
I have and will keep criticizing the Malays for their innovations and cultural practice. You can refer to my dayooth video as one example.
Nothing you brought forward has anything to do with the issue at hand. Jizya at certain times was even lower than the Zakat. Why not give an example of these so-called restrictions. Let's see whether they go against the Qur'an or Sunnah as not all the things that the caliphs (after the first 4) did were perfect.
Injustice is injustice. This issue clearly goes against the Qur'an and Sunnah but if it fits with your whims and desires then I guess some Muslims will say otherwise.
So let's say hypothetically, a Malay who didn't get good results is picked over a non-Malay Muslim who did way better in their exams. Similarly, a rich Malay gets benefits while a non-Malay Muslim doesn't? What world do you live in that these two (which is just the tip of the iceberg) examples that are happening every day after decades of affirmation action can be considered as justice? Something must be wrong with your understanding of Qur'an and Sunnah if that's the case.
@@FeartheHour it's not about being higher or lower. It's about a contradiction to your assumption that treating everyone equally is "just". I did give examples, go read again. Let's start with the obvious one if you want to be pedantic: Was the policy instituted by the Prophet which is to remove all kuffar inhabitants from the haram lands, an injustice? See it's really convenient when you're the one defining injustice isn't it?
As for your hypothetical, it depends on the law. If the wali ul amr has such policies then it is his/their right to have so. You need to prove from the Quran and Sunnah that Islamic governments must provide equal education access to all citizens regardless of religion. Spoiler: they do not. Now, whether such a policy is actually a smart one which benefits Muslims, that is a whole other question.
Now, and this is just my suggestion, instead of living in hypotheticals how about we look at reality. Remind me again which race has the largest economic power in Malaysia?
Your examples are flawed unfortunately. Your argument is as long as the leader says so then it goes. Yeah it goes in the sense that we have to obey it but that doesn't make all of the laws right. My video isn't about the law itself. It's about the implementation of the law which many don't see anything wrong with. I also never said once that justicr means being equal. Justice means giving each person who has rights his rights and putting everything in its proper place. Just because the leader says so doesn't make it just. Are you telling me the implementation of this law fits with the description of justice I just gave you?
You're telling me to live in reality but I feel that you should look in the mirror when saying that. I know of so many people who were deprived of their rights while people who are of less deserving gets more than they deserve. Is this justice to you? Does being Malay regardless of how rich or poor you are, and just because you originate from this land means you can get benefit with no end, and others who because of something they can't choose despite being born in the same land deserve less?
Anyways, you can keep believing your beliefs. Let's cross examine the truth in the Hereafter.
Edit: I find it funny that you said it was convenient that I defined justice the way I see it. Yet, this whole concept of Malay rights and the implementation thereof is basically the convenience you speak of.
Edit 2: You said I need to prove that Islamic governments need to provide access to equal education in the Qur'an and Sunnah. That's really easy. The Qur'an and Sunnah are against injustice. As long as we determine that it's unjust then it becomes proven.
First of all, Malaysia is not an Islamic government. The whole basis is not Islamic. The constitution is not based on the Qur'an and Sunnah. Democracy is not Islamic. So, I don't know where you got this notion from.
Second, what does getting an education mean in this day and age? I feel like you didn't think this through. Depriving one of access to education means depriving them from their livelihood as today you need an education to get a job. Now, if the person being deprived is a Muslim? Is that just? Even if it's a disbeliever it's unjust. So it's fine to limit one's opportunity to get an education which ultimately limits one's ability to provide for their family? On top of that you don't give them any other benefits like you get just because you were born Malay. Now let's reverse the situation. If you were a Muslim in a non-Muslim country and they limited your access to education and thus ultimately you couldn't provide for your family just because of your religion or race, would that be just?
Wake up to reality.
@@FeartheHourbefore I respond, may I know are you Salafi or Ash'ari/Maturidi? I'm not asking to find faults, rather to better understand your worldview.
@@FeartheHour i just realised you edited your comment, and havent responded to mine. Do respond to that before any further response, kindly.
No, that's a strawman of my argument. Try steelmanning it next time, or if you dont know, ask me.
Dont mentio yourself as a "Malay Muslim." You're a MUSILIM. dont differentiate yourself with your community all because you're a different race. You're a one of us, brother
But they don't like it when he reveals that he also has the DNA of another race! Apparently, they're taught by their parents to see all non-Malays as "evil people", which causes them to prevent their siblings or even their children from marrying non-Malays even though the non-Malays are also Muslims!
The problem come from overly respecting the Quran with putting it high on wardrobe and never touch it, let alone read it and apply what written in it in daily life
May god help us, man 😢
When tou mentioned Ansari is poorer than muhajirin this totally wrong. The muhajirin had to left their belongings in mekah like abd Rahman bin auf.
I never said they were poorer than the Muhajirin. I said they were poor as well which is a fact
@@FeartheHour you are wrong if not how the Ansari can split half of their wealth.
The verse itself states that they are in need
I totally understand your reason but our country is not a "Islamic" country. As you said, we're more to a secular country than a muslim country. We're more to secular nationalist country which is predominantly Malay.
I hate to say this, but the reason is because it is deep rooted in our history too. Malays are traumatized from the horrific history of their past ancestors from the British colonialism, Japan colonialism to communist group. Hence the reason why the article was made from the constitution to protect the Malays right to self determination from outsiders who's trying to exploit our country resources and land.
Everyone knows that before Malaysia, Malays and Orang Asli were amongst the first residents of Malaysia. Many non Malays try to deny Malays indigenous claim to the land, even if that's the case then where do Malay come from if not tanah Melayu? Jawa? Indonesia? All these ethnic groups are mostly originated from Malay archipelago once upon a time ago so Malays are indeed indigenous to Malaysia by logic since we're originated from the same region, just lived separately by tribes.
The question is, if we do give those rights to non Malays, would Malaysia be an Islamic country as we should be? Will the non Malays will respect Malays and their religion? Would they recognize Islam as Malaysia official religion? Would they influx all their people from China and India to make a majority against Malay in the future? This is complex that you think it is, it's not just Malays, it's also for other non Malays to make their decision too
don't care who you are mix malay or fully malay...who are you to question about practicing article 153 perlembagaan? Hak Istimewa its not only privilege for malay its privilege for all bumiputera like a bumiputera sabah sarawak,orang asli semenanjung and siam also...this is right of bumiputera which is not only Islam are practicing by bumiputera as a religion...
what can we do? we live in a time where race, gender, looks and wealth are what determine your worth. yg berkuasa semakin berkuasa, yg lemah semakin ditindas. already lose all my hope on the world, nothing has changed. the only thing thats changing is the way they manipulate and fool us. just trusting that Allah will bring all the justices we deserve in the Hereafter
It not race superior but to protect right of natives.
Most of us fear what happen to palestine will happen in Malaysia.
Edit: I admit racist happen from time to time but i berani kata yg rasic tu B40 dan tk ikut islam. Majoriti anak muda islam tidak solat Jumaat.
bruhh hina sangat ke B40 ni tak semua macam tulah cuba banyakkan pergaulan bro
@@Thatoneguyfrommedieval Saya cakap dari pegalaman saya maaf sebab saya terlampau. Tapi ini rialiti saya nampak degan pegalam hidup saya. Saya juga tergolong B40.
Edit : Ye betul tk semua tapi biasanya yg atas dari B40 peratusan racis lebih rendah kerna lebih integriti dan moral.
(Ikut logic la. Lagi banyak populasi = banyak yg tk beradap) aku tk deny ada juga T20 yg racis cuma mereka lebih matang tk tunjuk sagat dan sembunyi buat secara diam-diam.
@@itzael7246 terima kasih kerana sudi berkongsikan realiti pengalaman dan memberi pendapat anda dengan saya mintak maaf juga jika terdapat kesalahan dari sudut saya sebagai seorang yang berstatus yang sama marilah kita membina perspektif yang positif dikalangan kita supaya menjadi contoh kepada yang lain jika terdapat banyak yang keruh pasti banyak lagi yang jernih salam damai ✌️
israel are also using the same logic to justify their genocide. They also feel like they are protecting their rights as the real natives of that land. Just something to think about. Its simply not good when a group has special rights over others. it only serves to divide the country even more.
but is it the right way to protect the right of natives? Rather than protecting why not empower all of us? Did Islam ask to protect certain right of native in the expense of others? Islam empowers all of us, Islam ask us to do good things but all i can see is they took Islam and twisted it and say that without Malay protection there would be no Islam, which is illogical.
I completely agree with this vid even if im a full malay
Melayu Mudah Lupa
Terbaik video broo 🎉
Religion and politics is a bad mix, it is not going to change anytime soon.
Make dua for me that I learn to code and make money with it and then make hijrah to Sharjah one day.
Funny and sad that as a Singaporean Malay who is also Muslim. We dont have priveleges. We have to work for it.. the opposite of Malaysia where racial bias is still lurking behind exclusivity. We have to compete with the Indians and Chinese who most of them are superior due to their competitive mindset. Back then we were lacking but we adapt with the rest and also try to be competitive, and now we’re on a good level, majority of our community are well educated, have decent jobs, doing so well financially. Although we wish for a simple life we still strive without hand holding with extra benefits like bumiputera. Yet the Malaysians dont see us as equals, they scoff at us for being “oppressed” and “not malay enough” and they think theyre superior than the puny Singaporean Malays. We’re more resilient and can do things independently without any bumiputera bullshit.. but i wont say we’re superior because we’re still human and out and foremost, Muslim.
Ur remark is packed with inferiority complex shaped by the habitual racism and stereotypes. It's funny to read what you're stating, that Indian and Chinese are superiors while also backing urself off from being associated by even remotely to the idea of "superiority" by the justification of "we're still Muslim". Also, to spit on Malaysia's Constitution Article 153 as bullshit makes that even clear.
Komunis memang semua benda share😅termasuk bini+harta benda😂
tak ada keistimewaan lansung sebagai suami🤣
The one with cognitive dissonance when it comes to socio-political landscape in Malaysia is definitely you.
Article 153 which addresses the special position of the Malays and the indigenous peoples of Malaysia (collectively referred to as "Bumiputera") in terms of affirmative action and privileges has been always part of the core Malaysia's Federation Constitution. The foundation of this Article 153 is based on Reid Commission, which was a significant body established in 1955 to draft the Constitution for the Federation of Malaya, that ultimately led to the country's independence from British colonial rule.
This commission was to gather views from various stakeholders, including political parties, community leaders, and the public, regarding the constitutional framework for Malaya. The commission's work had been crucial in addressing the aspirations of the diverse ethnic groups in Malaya, including Malays, Chinese, and Indians, and in ensuring that their rights and interests were represented in the new constitution. Therefore, Article 153, just like any provisions in the constitution, is always crafted after lengthy considerations and negotiations between various groups and parties that may be parts of Malaysia's demographics like we know today.
"Well, if it is a well-considered legislation, WHY IS IT A PREFERENTIAL MEANS FOR THE INDIGENOUS AND NATIVE DEMOGRAPHICS IN THIS COUNTRY ONLY?" Bro, read history on pre-independence time. Malays used to exclude themselves into villages from British colonial settlements because they refused to be colonizers coolies. So, British colonizers brought in Indians and Chinese people from their respective homeland who happens to be part of British colonial territories at that time to be their low-paid laborers (that is, if they were paid at all). Chinese got to live in towns under British rule, also given debt capital and lands here from British, who were the foreign colonizers, to build their livelihood here. Indians were given estates. Malays were not entitled debt capital by the British resource leeches because they were kinda rebellious against British colonial policies, and also because why would they want native people to be prosperous in their own land when they as the colonizers can keep exploiting the resources. This had been happening for hundreds of years.
In short, Article 153 is one of the CORE articles in Malaysia's Constitution due to the historical background and landscape of this country that used to marginalize native and indigenous people. So, when it is CORE, it is part of Malaysia's identity as well. Pointing this as a systemic racism is as well as pointing Malaysia is not a sovereign country with their own constitutions and background history. Also, a petty and narrow-viewed gaslighting. If there are people that impulsively with 'knee-jerk reaction' yelling at you "Go back to your country!" as you yapping on this matter as 'utter racism', please do not feel too overly offended because part of it may be true because if you are really a Malaysian, how come you do not know the causes that Article 153, a core article of Constitution of Federation of Malaysia came to be. You and I are muslims, but we are also tied to one's citizenship, and thus being imposed to the legal landscape, whether it favors us or not.
About the New Economic Policy (NEP), did you know what led to this policy that was implemented in 1971? It was the provocative riot by GERAKAN supporters, which were Chinese majority party consisted of DAP and PPP who won the general election in Kuala Lumpur in 13 May 1969. They celebrated their election victory by parading into Malay predominantly populated area, which is Kampung Baru while chanting "M@t1 Melayu!" translated into English as "D#@th to the Malays!". What was the outcome of this riot? Racial tension with widespread looting, arson, and violence reported across Kuala Lumpur that lasted for several days. By the way NEP was aligned with constitution provision which is Article 153 which was triggered by 13 May Tragedy.
But of course, Malays are racist entitled lazy bunch of freeloaders🙄
This is why johore wants to get out of malaysia😂😂😂
Says the richest person in Malaysia until top 9 is a malay bumis? The most ceos in this country is the malay bumis? Or am I sensing greediness by using religion to doubt?
And what's your point? Who cares who are the top 10 most richest people in the country. Allah didn't ask us to become the richest people, but he did tell us to be just (adil). Rizq is the hands of Allah. It's not something we can control yet we fight tooth and nail for it because of our greed. What is in our hands and control is our actions to establish justice in our dealings with others.
@@FeartheHour the thing is everyone can get rich here I have 2 friends 1 from Indonesia and 1 from Bangladesh there both rich can support their family at home even build the mosque at their hometown. Both work at low level job one as construction another as grass cutter. They are both hardworking.
From your prescription of yourself looks like either you are lazy or you just want to create stir using religion as argument. Or you feel your father should have the opportunity same as malay bumi.
@@FeartheHour I also have a story in my hometown where an Arab came and preach the religion of Islam later the people surrounding pity him and give the land for his family to live. Secretly he fled with his family and sold the land to non Muslim and this non Muslim use the land for their religion.
@@FeartheHour adil is Allah deter in the eye of human maybe is unjust but god knows. So don't be lazy, work.
I don't understand why you're telling me to work. You and I both benefit from special privileges and you're telling me to work? It can't get more ironic than that. Don't try to assume my intentions, I don't care about money or this dunya. I only care about justice which is not being implemented with this law. If you don't care about that then that's too bad. You answer for it on the Day of Judgement. We will see who was right on this issue
there's no racism in Islam:
_"All mankind is from Adam and Eve, an Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab; also a White has no superiority over a Black nor a Black has any superiority over a White except by piety and good action. Learn that every Muslim is a brother to every Muslim and that the Muslims constitute one brotherhood."_ - Prophet Muhammad ﷺ last Friday sermon / khutbah.
malaysia tidak faham bahawa apabila melaksanakan qouta ia menyebabkan orang yang tidak cekap memegang jawatan ke atas orang yang lebih mahir. Kita perlukan sistem yang lebih mengutamakan merit.
0:57 WHY ARE YOU CALLING ME OUT 😭😭😭✋✋✋
Totally agree brother the last part is so true. I reside in the neighbouring country and I believe its the same here as well.
When you critique people they get all sensitive.
Really stresses me out. Complain about their life, dengki and can't stand the success of others. Really too much greed.
Definitely not all but I totally agree with what you said here.
A Malay doesn't necessarily need to be Muslim imo. If else what do you call Malays before Islam came in Tanah Melayu? If a Malay become an atheist what race is he/she?
Pre-Islam Malays are still Malays even though their previous religion is either Buddhism or Hinduism! Even the word "Malay" itself originates from India!
a Malay by definition in our Constitution, has to be a Muslim.
no ifs no buts.
@@Model3GenerativeANdroid then answer my question. A Malay who became an atheist, what race is he/she?
@@izzdanial4323 Jahannam race
@@Model3GenerativeANdroid that's not even a valid race. See this is why you can't mix race and religion. I'm fine if the youtuber critiques the race ONLY or religion ONLY. But mixing those two and generalizing ppl isn't going to work.
It's like saying English ppl = Christians or Indian ppl = Hinduism. Nonsense logic.
Now talk about democracy in Malaysia.
(Disclaimer, my grammar sucks)
I couldn't agree more to the fact that Malays at the moment can't stop clinging to the special rights given to them, although those special rights were intended to help them get back on their feet temporarily.
From my point of experience, some Malay that quite... radical muslims i could say, argues with same verse you mentioned back there, albeit with a completely different view.
"All mankind is from Adam and Eve, an Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab; also a White has no superiority over a Black nor a Black has any superiority over a White except by piety and good action."
So, how can they have a different view? Simple, "except by piety and good action.". Some Muslims interpretate this verse to say that all race are equal BUT for those who have the same level of piety or beliefs. In simple words, a white Muslim is not superior to a black Muslim and an Arab Muslim is not superior to non-Arab Muslim. That's how some of them understand the verse.
Now why these radical Muslims Malays most of the time hold a grudge towards non-Malays? Different beliefs, they felt the fact that they're Muslims believers and they are above those are non-muslim, because what? Piety right?
Now I'm not saying that they're correct, because they forgot something that's equally important in the verse. The good action of those non-muslims. These radicals preach on how they're more pious believers but blatantly disregard the merits of other race that most of the time are non-muslims.
Another thing is most Malays are disunified in their each ideas.
Some Malays prefers they keep the special rights because they literally have, a inferiority complex. They fears that if they have the same right with other race. Other race with surpassed them because they have that "Melayu malas" mentality rooted deep inside. And have the phobia of "the royals will get dethroned of we got the same rights as others race", like how perssimistic is that?
Some other Malay especially those radical Muslims, believe that the only way to solve this crisis is making this country Malaysia as a fully islamic state. Now isn't Malaysia already a country that have Islam as national religion? Yes, but we still relied on the British ways of government, a government based on a western system. Malaysia is still a secular based nation. And you could already guess which part of our nation strongly against making our country a fully islamic state, right?
Some Malays wish to see a day where the they (bumiputera) are equal with other race in Malaysia. These are usually seen as "liberals" because they were assumed to not care about their "special position" in Malaysia.
I can say many more but you get my point, they're not unified. They have favouritism towards Malays because we can obviously assume all Malays have the same beliefs, Islam.
For me, personally what I learnt for this is, we Malays is no superior than other race/non-muslims entirely. Why? A Muslim may be pious but doesn't do more good action compared to a non-muslim. For that even if a non-muslim didn't have the same piety as a Muslim, each human have their own merits in this world.
I hoped that one day Malays will get rid of that inferiority complex towards other race and actual face head on challenges of this work equally with other race. And if perhaps Allah give a chance one day, supposely the dream of making Malaysia a fully islamic country fully based on islamic Sharia law and islamic government come true.
We can learn fom Rasullullah SAW rule over the first islamic nation. There's dhimmi kafirs living among the Muslims, they were given protection and not forced to participate in war. They're respected as an equal human being, just different beliefs.
Just so you know, Islam=Arabization.
@@Yuhanna8.23 Ummm... no? Islam and Arab are not interchangeable.
@@orcasocute What an ignorant person. Before Islam came, the Arabs are a mix of paganism and some are Christians. Arab is a race, Islam is a religion. That is a fact. There many Christians Arab today. Deal with it.
True
I’m mix Malay-Indian-Chinese is it wrong
Im totally find with other races.
Buang masa tengok video ni. Tkde pun tunjuk 'double life' mcm dlm title. Preachy betul
"Double life" yang dimaksudkan ialah "talam dua muka"! Depan baik, belakang jahat...
Fitnah akhir zaman 🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂
Aku baru tertengok video ni.. aduhai... Nanti klu ade masa aku nk tulis komen panjang sikit kat sini... Belum cukup teliti tpi dh perasan paling betul
You say you are mixed race? Are you mixed with another Malayasian ethnic group(Indian, Chinese) or non Malayasian group?
Based on the accent, I guess probably Indian
Hello what age you got married
this is much complicated then what you think. Yes, sure, with the system that are inbedded in our government influences the racism towards non-Malays, especially immigrants and their rights. But throughout the history, Malay or specifically i'd say Muslim majority race that live in this country causes lots of privileges towards the development of Islamic societies, like halal logo food, azan and etc. Malaysia unlike other countries is very diversed, not just race but religion, if we make an equalities, it'll be secular countries. Our government system also give superiority towards the tradition of this lands, u will see many immigrants like rohingya, bangladeshi and much more, doesnt even know how to speak malay, which is also one of factors for racial-hate things and dividing. even arabs doesnt speak the same arabic as the greatest human being, Prophet Muhammad (saw) but the modernised version. This is also why Allah (swt) made differences in races. so we may learn their tradition and languages. im really not believing in nationalism but, this is better than nothing, sure we can be like afghanistan, fully, islamic-sharia administration, but in diversed country? it'll be complicated.
what i cant agree with you is "if they is not islam then they are not considered as malay". how about native malay? i am a native malay and we as native malay are mostly not islam and dont have religion but our identical card preferred us as (malay). i feel like we as a native malay dipinggirkan. ouh sorry. this video tuju for your "malay people" right? so i think this video are nothing to do for us "native malay". bye.
ramai cakap hak istimewa melayu tapi tak sebut bagi habis...cakap penuh terus hak istimewa melayu bumiputera sabah dan sarawak yang dilindungi dibawah article 153 perlembagaan...bererti hak istimewa tu bukan untuk melayu saja tapi untuk semua bumiputera seperti orang asli, siam pribumi dari sabah dan sarawak...apa benda paling penting dalam hak istimewa tersebut? jawapannya adalah jual beli dan kepemilikan tanah dimana ada batasan tertentu diantara bumiputera dan bukan bumiputra...mamat youtuber ni tak faham sejarah dan tunggang islam utk pandangan dia....dia lupa bukan semua bumiputra tu orang islam...dia sebok pertikai article 153 tpi dia lupa article tu bukan hak melayu saja tapi hak seluruh bumiputra dia sedang pertikai...dia sapa?
Keep COOKING
Technically you are not a malay. You are mix that being said that does not mean your bloodline can't/wont still be malay just say if your child marries another malay than it will be diluted but percentage wise you would be more malay. None of us are truly one race only.
what about The Double Life of saudi Muslims in saudi
You ain't wrong tho...
Both can be wrong simultaneously
@@user-op8fg3ny3j i heard there is nightclub under the prince's house, is that true? I am losing all hope everyday... Even our holiest place is...
I do hate it
Video is too long, no need to define who malay people are, no need to define what cognitive dissonance is
He just wanted to make sure we wake up from our delusions!
the way you speaks does not sound like a malay. May be you is a mamak background or bangladeshi
no true Malaysian are Atheist.
Rukun Negara #1
Atheist worship themselves. So they can still be call as a true Malaysian by the 1st rukun😬
😂 what is you're credentials half Malay 🤭 penunggang kaw kaw
its not a malaysian only problem. tbh its a nationalism problem. before world war 1, the ummah was still under the ottoman empire. but post world war, people decide to segregate land according to nationals. and every country is built on their own constitution which is agreed upon the land owners (or) the land inhibitors. hak status quo orang melayu is chartered by Reid in his Reif commission (suruhanjaya Reid). Reid commission is done by 5 people, non of them were Malays!. Reid ( UK ) , Ivor Jenning ( UK ), William Mckell ( Australia ), Hakim Malik ( India ) , Hakim Halim bin Abdul Hamid ( Pakistan ). Not even one Malay Bumiputera representative in the committee. So basically it's the foreigner outside the nation that decide the future of the nation by founding it's constitution. Because they know who owned the land, and who are the inhibitors of the land. so to become malay is impossible. but marrying one will overrule the other nation's descendent.
me as malay, did not find you as a fellow malay since your accent sounds like bangla-india. but as fellow muslim, i do consider you as my brother of my own family. islam basically getting rid of gap in race and ethnicity
Many malays aren't truly malay brotheran. The malay race is mix also. A little sprinkle of indian Chinese arab Filipino thai British Dutch Portuguese
Yep...Malaydesh i assume now
Im half Malay 😂😂😂 be matured kid...u just spread fitnah... Ur sins are counting
??????