counsel has obsessive compulsive disorder, not quirky “OCD I like my things straight”, but “the entire world will end if that chair does not squeak two more times“ this disability causes her to be completely and utterly unable to focus on anything that is going on around her if one of her triggers is flipped.
Regretfully, most of the laws protecting people with disabilities get flat out ignored. Plaintiffs win less than 10% of cases filed for ADA violations. Laws mean nothing if the judicial system refuses to enforce them.
Ya but OCD isn’t a real disability in this way. (OCD is literally made up by the experiencer) If I was depressed so I showed up late to court, I couldn’t use my depression as an excuse for acting inappropriately. This isn’t the best analogy however, because depression can be neurological and biologically effective tiny you- OCD is psychological and not actually a real thing. Her reacting to these things in a court room is inappropriate. You don’t have to bend over backwards for people with disabilities, just “reasonably accommodate” To not squeak your chair in a certain way when you’re sitting in it is highly unreasonable.
Ocd is a compulsive disorder. In this particular case she hears a squeak it has to come in set of 3. She only heard 1 squeak so she cant talk until she hears 2 more. The stimulus can be anything like turning off a light switch 3 times before leaving a room. The actual number can differ from case to case bit ive seen most 3 and 7 being the magic number for most. I dated a woman once that had this and it can drive a normal peraon crazy. Waited to pick her up one day and we was already running late. When she came out she passed under a tree and a branch brushed her hair alittle. Any onlther person would of fix the messed up spot and went on. She on the other hand had to start over. She couldnd fix that spot she had to rewash her hair and then her head was cleaner thatn her body ao she had to take another shower so her head and body was the same amount of clean. It would be nothing for find her cleaning her kitchen at 3 am. Because she went for a drink and spilt alittle bit and when she wiped it up that part of the counter was cleaner than the rest so she cleaned the entire kitchen. It horrible for a person with this aswell as anyone living with them.
I have the same thing for the number 4. I once walked into a door and hit my head and I actually backed up and bonked myself again because the torture of the odd number was worse than the physical pain
Why doesn’t the law firm gift the janitor something to oil them chairs! It happened repeatedly in this episode and would have been an ongoing issue in her field! Ugh! TV!
@@gramfero 1) you are required to rise for the judge so in that case it kinda is and 2) disrupting the proceedings is considered being in contempt of court which is a charge. It's like saying it's not illegal to play music as you're waking your whole neighborhood up blasting it out of your windows. *_It infact is actually in that circumstance._*
@BR-bj9bf i want to agree, but actual OCD is more complicated. Usually there's a core fear unless she is exhibiting "just right" OCD. If it's "just right" and the squeaking was a 10 on her scale, then I can believe her reaction. We're a variably chaotic bunch. I haven't seen the rest of the show though.
@@pathoesr7872 It is that version. The episode shows that she developed her compulsions while their mother was going through a difficult court case: a sequence of three or bad things will happen.
I installed an electronic door lock so I didn't have to walk up and down the stairs to the door in the middle of the night or going around the block 3 times yo make sure the door is closed.. ocd can be for anyone and anything.. the most significant similarity I notice is a lot of people go by the 3rd power
I have OCD its the worst thing and its awful its not cute or quriky i would cry because if i didnt touch the top of things like 8 times if i didn't i would think something awful would to be me or my family istill have it not as bad i catch myself doing it then i stop myself and calm myself down
I have non physical compulsive ocd and let me tell you this is tame she may be frozen but her side is say 2 more squeaks 1000 times a min it overwhelms your mind and you cannot to absolutely anything
I was really excited for her to get her own spin-off and then just recently found out that ABC canceled that attempt and now I'm like really bummed because the good lawyer would have been a good show
@@DatasavingmodeBoth are mental disorders, just one is mostly psychological and the other is neurogical. (OCD is likely rooted in neurodivergency, but is mostly psychological)
meanwhile saul goodman against her: you said you have ocd with squeaks, but may I entertain you that what you heard was NOT a squeak? Mr Miller at the back of the court can make incredible sounds with his mouth (one could call it talking), and it was he, not the chair, that made the noise!
Good Samaritan laws don't protect from poor judgement as a medical professional. They are there to protect people acting above their level of expertise as an act of preventing or mitigating an emergency. A surgeon who doesn't act as a trained surgeon may not be protected in most states.
I agree that Dr Murphy was a Good Samaritan to save the life of the patient. However, being outside of a professional capacity when acting is irrelevant, when the trained medical professional shows up on every medical scene and *acts* in a trained, medical professional capacity. In which case, Dr. Murphy is not covered by the Good Samaritan Law, depending on what State he was in. Matters, based on the Law. Every medical person should know that and still act.
I know certain situations like this can't be helped, but i hate this scenario. Like she's cute and great at her job, but I personally don't have the patience to deal with this
Good Samaritan laws often protect medical professionals less than the general public because they can be penalized due to malpractice. In my state, a nurse risks legal repercussions for using narcan on an OD since it can be perceived as prescribing.
I made my own comment, but good Samaritan laws are not in place to protect educated people when they act incompetently. I've read disciplinary actions for medical professionals in every state. Y'all aren't half as smart as you should be for the jobs you do.
@@oedhelsetren A lot of it, I think is specialization. For example, most doctors and nurses may have training in first aid and what to do when a current patient codes, etc. but few are regularly dealing with acute scenarios unless they practice in emergency medicine or intensive care. That and being aware of how far your knowledge/capacity goes. Example, I am a trained cardiac CNA and a mental health technician. Beyond things like apply pressure to wounds, CPR, don't move broken bones... my greatest skills are the ability to recognize what to do in the case of stroke, grasp sooner when something might be a medical emergency and know faster than most when to suggest a person sees a doctor. In terms of psych skills, I may be able to de-escalate a non-acute mental health crisis, but I don't have the support and resources in daily life to deal with full blown psychosis beyond reaching out for help.
Plaintiff's counsel is a sore loser and intentionally triggered the OCD of the Respondent's counsel by making an audible squeak. She can't function again and the a catastrophe will occur if there's not another two more squeaks to make a sum of three squeaks. He intentionally interfered with opposing counsel's ability to represent her client.
So i get that lawyers have to go through years apon years of schools and exams but what do judges have to do? how does one even become a judge? it seems so arbitrary
The short of it? All judges are lawyers who must have a certain amount of experience practicing the law before qualifying for the position. There are different types of judges, usually separated by exactly how wide their jurisdiction is, as well as, in the U.S at least, whether they operate at the federal level or not and in a few cases whether the judge presides over certain types of cases. So ALL judges, big or small, must have experience and understanding of the law, and nobody who isn't a professional in law can become a judge. As for the process? I am not an expert on it, but as far as I know it varies from state to state, but generally speaking judges can be either elected or appointed, and federal judges tend to always require vetting and approval from the government. Specifically, all supreme court justices require congressional approval, but even judges appointed to lower tier courts require said certification. Does that answer your question?
Dr Murphy’s counsel has OCD and can’t continue to speak until she hears another two squeaks. Opposing counsel knows this and deliberately squeaked the chair.
Dr Murphy’s counsel has OCD and can’t continue to speak until she hears another two squeaks. Opposing counsel knows this and deliberately squeaked the chair.
I don’t know about anyone else but I personally don’t really see anything different about Dr.Murphy it seems more to me that he talks a little slow and thinks very fast he’s super smart I don’t see any difference from any of person maybe I’m not looking for the right things but I don’t see why people make autism sound so bad sometimes it can be more severe than others but sometimes like with Dr. Murphy it’s almost like a superpower
@@prissylovejoy702 no but I’m also remarking on how most of the autistic people I’ve met aren’t all that different I’m trying to make a point that autism doesn’t make you inhuman
You need to understand the context in this scene the man was driving recklessly and was injured the woman lawyer is defending the other man who saved his life and had to amputate his arm to save him but instead the one who was amputated sued him for it
@@Curly_gurlies_XO chosing between being an amputee and dead is his right. a good samarithean can t do an amputation. so in that moment he acted as an doctor which can be sued.
counsel has obsessive compulsive disorder, not quirky “OCD I like my things straight”, but “the entire world will end if that chair does not squeak two more times“ this disability causes her to be completely and utterly unable to focus on anything that is going on around her if one of her triggers is flipped.
Just great😅
And I take it the other lawyer knew this is this other lawyer to straight up ablest
That other lawyer knew he was losing that is why he went for the cheap shot 😢😢😢😢
@@starvoltnexus3139 yeah, it's so shitty
The world will end if I do not stop a Microwave before it hits 1 second
I feel like it should be against the law to use someone’s disability to try to discredit them in a situation like this
Regretfully, most of the laws protecting people with disabilities get flat out ignored. Plaintiffs win less than 10% of cases filed for ADA violations. Laws mean nothing if the judicial system refuses to enforce them.
Maybe the other lawyer wasn't aware of the disability.
@@eunickissimohe is, he gets called out on it on another occasion and claims he’ll do anything to help his client win
@@eunickissimoLaywers are aware... they deliberately choose an argument that makes their client look better, regardless of due justice.
Ya but OCD isn’t a real disability in this way. (OCD is literally made up by the experiencer)
If I was depressed so I showed up late to court, I couldn’t use my depression as an excuse for acting inappropriately. This isn’t the best analogy however, because depression can be neurological and biologically effective tiny you- OCD is psychological and not actually a real thing.
Her reacting to these things in a court room is inappropriate.
You don’t have to bend over backwards for people with disabilities, just “reasonably accommodate”
To not squeak your chair in a certain way when you’re sitting in it is highly unreasonable.
"Counsel is using a technicality" bro... all the laws are technical
All while he’s literally doing the same
Not MURPHY'S LAW!!!!
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA, OOOWNNNED!!!
🤣🤣🤣
Ocd is a compulsive disorder. In this particular case she hears a squeak it has to come in set of 3. She only heard 1 squeak so she cant talk until she hears 2 more. The stimulus can be anything like turning off a light switch 3 times before leaving a room. The actual number can differ from case to case bit ive seen most 3 and 7 being the magic number for most. I dated a woman once that had this and it can drive a normal peraon crazy. Waited to pick her up one day and we was already running late. When she came out she passed under a tree and a branch brushed her hair alittle. Any onlther person would of fix the messed up spot and went on. She on the other hand had to start over. She couldnd fix that spot she had to rewash her hair and then her head was cleaner thatn her body ao she had to take another shower so her head and body was the same amount of clean. It would be nothing for find her cleaning her kitchen at 3 am. Because she went for a drink and spilt alittle bit and when she wiped it up that part of the counter was cleaner than the rest so she cleaned the entire kitchen. It horrible for a person with this aswell as anyone living with them.
I have the same thing for the number 4. I once walked into a door and hit my head and I actually backed up and bonked myself again because the torture of the odd number was worse than the physical pain
My aunt has a similar problem. When my uncle got hurt and almost died it took her 4 hours to hurriedly get ready to leave the house
It wouldn't be complete until the number has been met.
3 is my number. It feels balanced.
OCD is a disability.
@carolynmansager6952 yes you are correct it is 100%.
Why doesn’t the law firm gift the janitor something to oil them chairs! It happened repeatedly in this episode and would have been an ongoing issue in her field! Ugh! TV!
Does the oppposing lawyer figure out her trigger and intentionally use it to mess her up?
Yup
It wasn’t even a well kept secret
How immoral and likely illegal.
@@anondabombhow is it illegal to sit in a chair?
@@gramfero 1) you are required to rise for the judge so in that case it kinda is and 2) disrupting the proceedings is considered being in contempt of court which is a charge.
It's like saying it's not illegal to play music as you're waking your whole neighborhood up blasting it out of your windows.
*_It infact is actually in that circumstance._*
Trying to have a “Cheap Win“ ! Lawyer must come back to Elementary School to learn, Good Manners and Right Conduct !!!
quite dirty of the opposition to abuse someones disability like that, but it also means its his tell when hes panicing
S6 - E16 👍👍👍You're welcome!
Thank youuuu
Does she have OCD?
Yes, she does :)
Actual OCD, not the romanticized version people claim upon themselves.
@BR-bj9bf i want to agree, but actual OCD is more complicated. Usually there's a core fear unless she is exhibiting "just right" OCD. If it's "just right" and the squeaking was a 10 on her scale, then I can believe her reaction. We're a variably chaotic bunch.
I haven't seen the rest of the show though.
@@pathoesr7872 It is that version. The episode shows that she developed her compulsions while their mother was going through a difficult court case: a sequence of three or bad things will happen.
I installed an electronic door lock so I didn't have to walk up and down the stairs to the door in the middle of the night or going around the block 3 times yo make sure the door is closed.. ocd can be for anyone and anything.. the most significant similarity I notice is a lot of people go by the 3rd power
Listen to a lot of political chants. Three syllables.
Our brains seem to like a beginning, middle, and end.
I have OCD its the worst thing and its awful its not cute or quriky i would cry because if i didnt touch the top of things like 8 times if i didn't i would think something awful would to be me or my family istill have it not as bad i catch myself doing it then i stop myself and calm myself down
My favorite part of the movie is the song. I get pumped up when the cellos get louder and faster.
I have non physical compulsive ocd and let me tell you this is tame she may be frozen but her side is say 2 more squeaks 1000 times a min it overwhelms your mind and you cannot to absolutely anything
I was really excited for her to get her own spin-off and then just recently found out that ABC canceled that attempt and now I'm like really bummed because the good lawyer would have been a good show
Dr. Shaun and his counselor are in different spots on the same spectrum.
Yup spectrum
Ocd and autism are not on the same spectrum
Nope. Ocd is a mental disorder, autism is not (it's a developmental one)
Not the same spectrum but they still share some similarities I guess
@@DatasavingmodeBoth are mental disorders, just one is mostly psychological and the other is neurogical. (OCD is likely rooted in neurodivergency, but is mostly psychological)
meanwhile saul goodman against her: you said you have ocd with squeaks, but may I entertain you that what you heard was NOT a squeak? Mr Miller at the back of the court can make incredible sounds with his mouth (one could call it talking), and it was he, not the chair, that made the noise!
lmfao!
Sheldon and his 3 knocks.
*He was not on the clock and worked independently of others, **_he was not acting in a professional capacity._*
Good Samaritan laws don't protect from poor judgement as a medical professional. They are there to protect people acting above their level of expertise as an act of preventing or mitigating an emergency. A surgeon who doesn't act as a trained surgeon may not be protected in most states.
* knock, knock, knock*
“Penny?”
*Knock, knock, knock*
“Penny?”
* knock, knock, knock*
Penny?
I agree that Dr Murphy was a Good Samaritan to save the life of the patient. However, being outside of a professional capacity when acting is irrelevant, when the trained medical professional shows up on every medical scene and *acts* in a trained, medical professional capacity. In which case, Dr. Murphy is not covered by the Good Samaritan Law, depending on what State he was in. Matters, based on the Law. Every medical person should know that and still act.
Sean would be protected under the good sameritan law.
Z
I know certain situations like this can't be helped, but i hate this scenario. Like she's cute and great at her job, but I personally don't have the patience to deal with this
Holy shit this isnt just about this short shauns actor was absolutely insane at his role
I swear he's doing it on purpose
That guy is a jerk.
Good Samaritan laws often protect medical professionals less than the general public because they can be penalized due to malpractice. In my state, a nurse risks legal repercussions for using narcan on an OD since it can be perceived as prescribing.
I made my own comment, but good Samaritan laws are not in place to protect educated people when they act incompetently. I've read disciplinary actions for medical professionals in every state. Y'all aren't half as smart as you should be for the jobs you do.
@@oedhelsetren A lot of it, I think is specialization. For example, most doctors and nurses may have training in first aid and what to do when a current patient codes, etc. but few are regularly dealing with acute scenarios unless they practice in emergency medicine or intensive care. That and being aware of how far your knowledge/capacity goes.
Example, I am a trained cardiac CNA and a mental health technician. Beyond things like apply pressure to wounds, CPR, don't move broken bones... my greatest skills are the ability to recognize what to do in the case of stroke, grasp sooner when something might be a medical emergency and know faster than most when to suggest a person sees a doctor.
In terms of psych skills, I may be able to de-escalate a non-acute mental health crisis, but I don't have the support and resources in daily life to deal with full blown psychosis beyond reaching out for help.
This is an unrealistic interpretation of ocd
Losing so he resorted to petty immature bull behavior
Holy shit those eyes
I have OCD like her and I also use the number 3 but it’s a bit more complicated for me
Which series is this?
With what I've read so far, I definitely have OCD
for those who havent seen the show whats the meaning of the squeaking chairs in the courtroom?
Plaintiff's counsel is a sore loser and intentionally triggered the OCD of the Respondent's counsel by making an audible squeak.
She can't function again and the a catastrophe will occur if there's not another two more squeaks to make a sum of three squeaks.
He intentionally interfered with opposing counsel's ability to represent her client.
So i get that lawyers have to go through years apon years of schools and exams but what do judges have to do? how does one even become a judge? it seems so arbitrary
The short of it? All judges are lawyers who must have a certain amount of experience practicing the law before qualifying for the position. There are different types of judges, usually separated by exactly how wide their jurisdiction is, as well as, in the U.S at least, whether they operate at the federal level or not and in a few cases whether the judge presides over certain types of cases. So ALL judges, big or small, must have experience and understanding of the law, and nobody who isn't a professional in law can become a judge.
As for the process? I am not an expert on it, but as far as I know it varies from state to state, but generally speaking judges can be either elected or appointed, and federal judges tend to always require vetting and approval from the government. Specifically, all supreme court justices require congressional approval, but even judges appointed to lower tier courts require said certification.
Does that answer your question?
What episode is this 😅
6-16 👍👍👍👍👍👍
Where is paragraph man
Did not know Ronnie was moonlighting as a judge.
This is not how law works
The guy looks like jerma
What movie?
The good Doctor
What's the name of the show please?
The Good Doctor.
It's a USA adaptation of a Korean procedural drama
@@TheKrispyfort Thank You So Much!
Which episode
T6 - E16 👍👍👍👍👍
Sup with the squeaks
think she has ocd
Dr Murphy’s counsel has OCD and can’t continue to speak until she hears another two squeaks. Opposing counsel knows this and deliberately squeaked the chair.
@@roseanne74 shut up dork
Does that TV show about the autistic doctor really need an OCD lawyer
Sure, why not? Surely in the span of one whole show you can understand more than one thing.
What is the name of this film?
It’s a tv show.it’s called the good doctor
@@KingMovie100 thanks ❤️
S6 - E16 You're welcome! 😂🙂
Ok i’ve seen this scene a thousand times someone pls tell how this ends
I think Shaun provides two more squeaks to free her from it and to prevent the world ending.
What is the movie
This is show it’s called the good doctor
I don't understand that "squeaks matter" Can anyone explain
Dr Murphy’s counsel has OCD and can’t continue to speak until she hears another two squeaks. Opposing counsel knows this and deliberately squeaked the chair.
I don’t know about anyone else but I personally don’t really see anything different about Dr.Murphy it seems more to me that he talks a little slow and thinks very fast he’s super smart I don’t see any difference from any of person maybe I’m not looking for the right things but I don’t see why people make autism sound so bad sometimes it can be more severe than others but sometimes like with Dr. Murphy it’s almost like a superpower
i mean he also has other social difficulties in the show (eg saying "inappropriate" things) and sensory issues and big issues with change
Damn it’s because your watching a tv scripted to present only the things they want to high light.
You think this is real life or something?
@@prissylovejoy702 no but I’m also remarking on how most of the autistic people I’ve met aren’t all that different I’m trying to make a point that autism doesn’t make you inhuman
@@KiXiLeD Who is say it does?
Such a low blow
Another sleezy lawyer tactic.. lock her up at any means possible..
You need to understand the context in this scene the man was driving recklessly and was injured the woman lawyer is defending the other man who saved his life and had to amputate his arm to save him but instead the one who was amputated sued him for it
@@Curly_gurlies_XOBro really said "lock her up" to a TV show clip.
@@nicholasgearhart7597 lmao it’s funny like it’s fake
@@Curly_gurlies_XO chosing between being an amputee and dead is his right. a good samarithean can t do an amputation. so in that moment he acted as an doctor which can be sued.
@@idahooo3253 yet he is a surgeon
The alleged judge, a man?
Which ep
S6 ep16
Whats to video you marked unavailable in the United States
That man should not be allowed in that courtroom!
I 100% guarantee you she's lying by omission
?
👾
Pin me🍅
Why in every American film or serie the judge is black?
?