Sedevacantist people all seem disagreeable and overly angry? Wow, it’s like there’s some means of grace in the world which they having willingly cut themselves off from. I wonder what that could be. Hmm.
Pope Pius VI, Auctorem fidei, Aug. 28, 1794: “47. Likewise, the proposition which teaches that it is necessary, according to the natural and divine laws, for either excommunication or for suspension, that a personal examination should precede, and that, therefore, sentences called ‘ipso facto’ have no other force than that of a serious threat without any actual effect” - false, rash, pernicious, injurious to the power of the Church, erroneous. (Denz. 1547)
@@KyleWhittington You're saying that in order to be a formal heretic one has to have a personal examination (i.e., publicly corrected or face an inquisitorial tribunal, etc.). That's false according to the quote I provided.
@@KyleWhittington So you just follow the crowds rather than the Truth. Focusing on the horizontal rather than the vertical. Exodus 23:2 "Thou shalt not follow the multitude to do evil: neither shalt thou yield in judgment, to the opinion of the most part, to stray from the truth."
@@TheRomanCatholicChurch Nah, I just have no interest with having this conversation on a topic that I don't take seriously with a faceless stranger that seemingly has no interest in my well-being. Rather, everything about your responses have just been trying to prove yourself right and me wrong. I don't take this topic seriously, and I take you even less seriously. But please, I hope you continue these ineffective tactics to try and spew your nonsense, you're only further proving my point.
I feel like you didn’t even watch the video because “recycled arguments” would probably be an upgrade from this absolute zero-effort video. I’m just not interested in neo-gnostic Protestantism.
@@KyleWhittington Lol. This isn't a parody account, it's called marketing. But it is rather annoying...the bigger sede channels don't really give me the time of day.
The issue is primarily that the post Vatican II "popes" have promulgated things that are contrary to Catholic dogma. The church cannot contradict itself, therefore, it is not the Catholic Church. This is about Catholic dogma. I'm more than willing to talk. Ill talk to my priest, one of the dozens of priests from the CMRI.
Sedevacantism makes sense. Heretics cannot be Pope, so Pope Pius XII was the last Pope. And, it certainly doesn't make sense to be a member of Newchurch (the Conciliar church), which is based on heresy, and which has different sacramental rites, liturgy, theology, etc.
@@KyleWhittingtonislam, jehovas witness, seventh day adventists and mormons are gnostic cults, sedevacantism is one of a few Catholic positions, dont call your brother a fool and especially dont bear false witness against him, whichever one of those it is youre seeking to accomplish...
@@Seethi_CCall no man on earth father for One is your Father in heaven. Youre either a Father by the power of Christ because youre baptized into and profess the One True Faith, or youre not... if you dont profess the True Faith then you arent Catholic, let alone anyones spiritual superior who is Catholic and holds in the highest regard the holy seat of the Blessed Pope Saint Peter that they would call out any heretic who would even dare touch it or even come within its vicinity, light and dark has no agreement, darkness is overtaken entirely.
“The world is so much better when the Church is alive “. As a former life long sede I can say that is Exactly right!!
Sedevacantist people all seem disagreeable and overly angry? Wow, it’s like there’s some means of grace in the world which they having willingly cut themselves off from. I wonder what that could be. Hmm.
I’ve been a sedevacantist twice in my life. Once when JPII died and once when BXVI stepped down.
I anticipate I will be one again in the next 5 years. Which is quite the serious call to pray for the Holy Father.
You couldn't do the Peanuts thing in the beginning? Wah wah wah waah waaaah. Still the mumbling and gibberish sounds were amusing.
That might have been better lol
I agree. The world is so much better when the church is alive. 🕊❤️🔥
Bro this is so true 😂 they never talk to me either
Where have you come across people who hold the sede position and won't talk to you?
Pope Pius VI, Auctorem fidei, Aug. 28, 1794:
“47. Likewise, the proposition which teaches that it is necessary, according to the natural and divine laws, for either excommunication or for suspension, that a personal examination should precede, and that, therefore, sentences called ‘ipso facto’ have no other force than that of a serious threat without any actual effect” - false, rash, pernicious, injurious to the power of the Church, erroneous. (Denz. 1547)
I’m gonna be honest, I’ve read this like 5 times over and have no idea what you’re trying to say.
@@KyleWhittington You're saying that in order to be a formal heretic one has to have a personal examination (i.e., publicly corrected or face an inquisitorial tribunal, etc.). That's false according to the quote I provided.
Yeah, I’ll be honest. I have no interest in having this conversation. I also stated that I don’t have the time or energy to take this topic seriously.
@@KyleWhittington So you just follow the crowds rather than the Truth. Focusing on the horizontal rather than the vertical.
Exodus 23:2 "Thou shalt not follow the multitude to do evil: neither shalt thou yield in judgment, to the opinion of the most part, to stray from the truth."
@@TheRomanCatholicChurch Nah, I just have no interest with having this conversation on a topic that I don't take seriously with a faceless stranger that seemingly has no interest in my well-being. Rather, everything about your responses have just been trying to prove yourself right and me wrong. I don't take this topic seriously, and I take you even less seriously. But please, I hope you continue these ineffective tactics to try and spew your nonsense, you're only further proving my point.
not a sede but this wasn't compelling.
Honestly, that’s fair
Same ol' recycled arguments that sedevacantists have already addressed.
I feel like you didn’t even watch the video because “recycled arguments” would probably be an upgrade from this absolute zero-effort video. I’m just not interested in neo-gnostic Protestantism.
Dios te de muchas Bendiciones 🙏
Gracias
😂😂😂 look free content for me. Thanks buddy!
That's all I've ever aspired to: having my content featured on parody accounts with less than 50 subscribers. I've truly arrived.
@@KyleWhittington Lol. This isn't a parody account, it's called marketing.
But it is rather annoying...the bigger sede channels don't really give me the time of day.
@@SedePicanteProbably because every sede group thinks that they are right and the other sede groups are heretics
God bless you, Kyle!
you should read my book.
Is there a place that I can purchase a physical copy?
@@KyleWhittington no. you can access it through my channel. look in the comment section of my most recent videos.
@@contrasedevacantism6811 Got it. Thanks!
There is a YT channel called TVC that explains the position.
@@littlerock5256 how ironic, I actually debated him in the comment section in one of his videos.
This is the stupidest video against sedevacantism I have seen so far 🤣🤣🤣🤣, no arguments.
And yet you still managed to prove my point.
The issue is primarily that the post Vatican II "popes" have promulgated things that are contrary to Catholic dogma. The church cannot contradict itself, therefore, it is not the Catholic Church.
This is about Catholic dogma.
I'm more than willing to talk.
Ill talk to my priest, one of the dozens of priests from the CMRI.
Sedevacantism makes sense. Heretics cannot be Pope, so Pope Pius XII was the last Pope. And, it certainly doesn't make sense to be a member of Newchurch (the Conciliar church), which is based on heresy, and which has different sacramental rites, liturgy, theology, etc.
Enjoy your gnostic cult then.
Heretics cannot be Pope
Francis is the Pope
Therefore, Francis is not a heretic
@@KyleWhittingtonislam, jehovas witness, seventh day adventists and mormons are gnostic cults, sedevacantism is one of a few Catholic positions, dont call your brother a fool and especially dont bear false witness against him, whichever one of those it is youre seeking to accomplish...
@@Seethi_CCall no man on earth father for One is your Father in heaven. Youre either a Father by the power of Christ because youre baptized into and profess the One True Faith, or youre not... if you dont profess the True Faith then you arent Catholic, let alone anyones spiritual superior who is Catholic and holds in the highest regard the holy seat of the Blessed Pope Saint Peter that they would call out any heretic who would even dare touch it or even come within its vicinity, light and dark has no agreement, darkness is overtaken entirely.
@aperson0adWell the minor premise is supported by peaceful and universal acceptance. But yeah, I don’t expect this statement to change their minds.