#1 Joe Montana | NFL Films | Top 10 Quarterbacks of All Time
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Joe Montana tops the list of Top 10 QBs of All-Time.
Subscribe to NFL Films: goo.gl/XJTggL
Start your free trial of NFL Game Pass: www.nfl.com/ga...
Check out our other channels:
NFL Network / nflnetwork
NFL / nfl
Watch NFL Now: www.nfl.com/now
Listen to NFL podcasts: www.nfl.com/pod...
Watch the NFL network: nflnonline.nfl....
Download the NFL mobile app: www.nfl.com/apps
2016 NFL Schedule: www.nfl.com/sch...
Buy tickets to watch your favorite team: www.nfl.com/tic...
Shop NFL: www.nflshop.com...
Like us on Facebook: / nflfilms
Follow us on Twitter: / nflfilms
Follow us on Instagram: / nflfilms
Montana was one if the the most efficient quarterbacks ever. I don't care if he never passed for a billion yards or anything, he was the best playoff quarterback ever. Also, have you seen the accuracy if his throws? they were on-spot. Finally, he had the best name of any quarterback. So, yeah, he was the best
Those old 49er uniforms were the bomb
Yes gotta love the wide pant stripes too!
Classic NFL uni💯
The 80s and the 75th Anniversary unis are the absolute best ever.
I'm not going to lie he was better than Brady
Henry Ha l
lol Brady is the undisputed goat now
of cheating yes.
Montana is an undefeated sb champion. Yeah he don't have 7 rings but he also doesn't have any losses.
man i wish I was alive when Montana played so I can argue about this list
If you did you'd never forget it.
To be a west coast ten year old in the 80's watching Montana bring football to life was an amazing exposure. there was only one team: 49ers.
If you wanted a dollar for every yard and touchdown thrown you'd want Brady, Brees, or Manning. But if you wanted the best chance to win, you're gonna want Montana. In a Big game, Montana was going to stay on the Bus just a little bit longer than those other guys.
I'm 41 yrs old. Seen alot of great Niner teams. But I have NEVER felt so at ease even if we were sown 14 in the 4th qtr. Some how some way he would make it happen. He never looked nervous he was silly smooth. Best post season qb ever . Who else u want under center when you gotta go 90+ doe the Super Bowl ? If you need 3 call Brady. If you need 6 call Joe. 88,89 playoffs 19tds 1int 70% 1,623 yards Dominated. He was usually on the bench in 4th qtr. Losing qbs put up lots of #'s . Joe was efficient when the NFL was for men . When the QB would get destroyed and no flag..Cool Joe the man
Man he could do everything cool joe
Butthurt Patriots fans in the comment section get over it your guy Brady cheated and lost twice to Eli Manning in the Super Bowl.
bulldogsbob yourteamcheats.com
the truth
bulldogsbob so your going to punish Brady for going to the Super Bowl more times
Jack Gordon no punish him for not showing up in the biggest of moments twice. By your logic lbj> mj because he WENT to more finals
Only one thing in that statement you said was accurate and that was the fact that he lost to Eli twice in the super bowl
They forgot to mention that he also played in an era where defenses weren't handicapped by the rules. WRs and QBs didn't have refs protecting them like now. He also played in an era that will probably go down as the greatest era for defensive players. No QBs of this era had to deal with the likes of Lawrence Taylor, Carl Banks, Wilbur Marshall, Mike Singletary, Otis Wilson, Reggie White, Sam Mills, Vaughn Johnson, Pat Swillings, Leonard Marshall, Dexter Manley. This man has to deal with three of the greatest defenses... Bears, Giants and Saints. A few of them he got knocked out of the game.
I'm a Patriots fan through and through but damnit.....Joe Cool.....you can't disregard what he did in his Time,Brady is one of the Greats but it's hard to compare The two.Different era's Different defenses.respect to both Legends
Smart statement!
That was a smart comment g
Brady cheated
@@jorgeoropeza6343 haahaa tell that to Montana and his stickrum receiver....
@@damiandavematig-a6052 you must be talking about the Raiders, 49ers best receivers in NFL History
those 378 dislikes are from patriot fans
BOOM Pro yessir
If Montana had the protection that today's QBs get he'd have even MORE records under his belt.
You say that like he has a ton of records, I can’t think of any besides 11-0 TD INT in the super bowl
@@ianmalcolm8591 he hold the superbowl records for most passes completed without an interception, he also holds the superbowl record for most passes attempted without an interception, these records will never be broken
Ehhh probably not. Players as a whole are much better athletes now than they were. He wouldn’t get away with all of the scrambling he did. Played in the perfect era for his skill set and play style
thank god, it's not Brady
JOE MONTANA NUMBER ONE YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kalvin Johnston Joe sucks Elway is Better
95% of people that say Brady is better. have never even watched a Joe Montana game.
***** Let me guess you have never seen Joe play a game either . 49ers were a very balanced team that was very hard to stop. Because you couldn't shut down the run or the pass.
Montana Beat everyone Marino, Elway etc. 4-0 and never lost a Super Bowl or needed a kicker. Oh ya he not only didn't lose he never lost twice to the same guy in a Super Bowl..... Fact 🐐
Brown he needed everyone
SuperPuggus101 Montana don’t got 6 rings and Joe monanta top receiver (jerry rice) admitted to cheating
@@bobbybetwirlin8442 Since you say Brady is the GOAT do you think New England's luck in Super Bowl XX would have been the same if Tom Brady was the Patriots' QB?
I would pay to see Tom Brady take the field against this defensive unit: m.th-cam.com/video/y3NeuBtw7Uc/w-d-xo.html
Those are facts but doesn’t tell the whole story
@@CrystalDominique Or better yet, I'd rather see Brady take on the Steel Curtain of the 1970's. He wouldn't survive that defense.
All you Patriot fans who come on here and complain that Brady is the greatest have one serious problem... you're all too young and didn't see *Montana* play. NOBODY ever played the QB position like he did. He also played in a different era... an era where QB's could get hit and did... today they would throw a flag. Nobody was better under pressure than *Montana* and I've seen some of the best clutch QB's ever... *Snake Stabler*, *Marino*, *Elway*, *Staubach*... but *Montana* just made everything look easy. He made it all look so easy... playing the most difficult position in all of sports and he made it look easy. Can't say enough about *Joe Montana*!!!
I saw Montana play and he is one of the best. That doesn't diminish Brady's accomplishments.
If you watched last year's AFCC the Broncos hit the Patriots QB 23 times. Not too shabby.
There's a massive difference between being hit today and being hit in the 80's or 90's. As far as Brady's accomplishments... he's lost two Super Bowls to a _supposedly_ weaker team. I'll never forget before the first SB against the Giants and a reporter asked Brady what he would do if the Giant D held the Pats offense to 14 points. Brady just laughed that arrogant, cocky way of his and said... "That will never happen."
Well, guess what Tom... it did happen. 14 points is all you managed to put on the board. Another difference is that in Brady's Super Bowl wins, he always relied on his kicker to make the FG to win it, whereas *Montana* drove his team 92 yards and THREW the game winning TD with :34 left. So you can say all you want about Brady and his accomplishments, but he still isn't as good as *Joe Montana* and he never will be.
Dr Death I respect your strong feelings on the subject but you seem to have a fixed mindset when it comes to the comparison.
Obviously the defense isn't allowed to hit QBs like they used to but your characterization that it is a "massive difference" is an exaggeration. Players today are bigger and faster. Defensive linemen who were considered big then are outweighed by today's players by 10-30 pounds. LT was only 235 lbs. Al Baker was 260. JJ Watt, Julius Peppers, Ndamukong Suh and others are 290+ and can fly.
Not to mention the fact that Brady has been sacked 120 times more than Montana has.
If you put something in quotes, you should be sure that it is a direct quote. Brady never said what you said he said. At least make an attempt to be accurate.
Montana & his league-best #1 offense w/ Rice, Wilson, Clark, Francis, Rathman, Craig & Co. (13-2 regular season) got shut down and lost to the 8-7 Vikings AT HOME with Joe throwing a pick-six before BEING BENCHED. Montana & Co scoring only 3 points in back-to-back one-and-dones.
Brady has more wins, more comebacks, more game-winning drives, and a higher playoff winning percentage. So for you to dismiss the comparison only belies your bias.
Plus you're completely ignoring the fact that the Niners had a Top 3 defense for 9/10 of Joe's seasons there.
In his last 3 NFCC games S.F. gave up a total of 6 points. He only needed a FG to win. Talk about playing without pressure.
First of all, Brady did say what I said he said. Secondly, I live in KC and got to experience *Montana Magic* up close and personal. I saw every game he played with the Chiefs, at Arrowhead and on the television when they were on the road. What that guy meant to his team is unparalleled. He lifted that entire team up and his first season here, pulled off two 4th quarter comebacks in the playoffs. And he did it by throwing TD's, not relying on a kicker.
Secondly, Brady has been sacked more because he's thrown like 3000 more times than *Montana* did. So 120 more sacks is minor compared to the number of attempts. But that's okay. You can believe what you want, just know that you're wrong. There will never be another QB like *Montana*, period.
Dr Death Not sure why you are taking this so personally. I don't have anything bad to say about your hero. Just spitting out facts.
Montana went to a Chief team that was coming off three straight playoff seasons so while he played well there he didn't really do anything for K.C. that Steve DeBerg and Dave Krieg didn't do.
But I'm not going to pee on your parade.
It's your past and your journey.
Hey haters.
Joe Montana beat Steve Young and that loaded 49ers team that beat the chargers in the superbowl.
and your point is?
that doesnt mean anything...
it means he was great no matter what team he played with...
Calvin Berger it means he was great on his own
Hed of beaten Dallas in the Super Bowl the year before had he not gotten injured in Buffalo..
Mark Sanchez is the best Quarter back ever.
W
Sanchez has never lost a Superbowl, Brady has lost 2, Sanchez>Brady
W
lol
Rex Grossman is
Incoming butthurt Pats "fans" saying Brady should be 1 😂😂😂 funny how most of you weren't even born when Brady took over and weren't fans when Drew Bledsoe was the starting QB
yung freshy just like 90% of the people watching this video weren't born when Montana was playing.
lmao what do you think all patriots fans are under 20?? you are so dumb
yung freshy LOOK AT STATS YOU DIPSHIT!!! if anything people who think Montana is better r clinging onto their nostalgia! Montana had the 'perfect touch's oh GET REAL.
titanbox 555 You are out of touch with reality !
acquired immunity Read the comment again loser I said "MOST OF YOU" so who you calling dumb kid?
Joe Montana was the best. But now he is #2.
Tom Brady vs Joe Montana/Steve Young
combined
career - regular season and playoffs
Wins
Tom - 238
Joe/Steve - 235
Losses
Tom - 70
Joe/Steve - 109
Win Pct
Tom - .773
Joe/Steve - .683
TD
Tom - 593
Joe/Steve - 570
INT
Tom - 205
Joe/Steve - 280
Rate
Tom - 96.6
Joe/Steve - 94.0
Can't compare 2 differnt era's when montana played you could hit the qb now with brady you can't same with Jordan and LeBron 2 differnt era's
riiight, ignorant argument...the ONLY thing Brady has on Montana is longevity..that's it and that's all....Montana played back when Defenses could play Defense...Montana competed against other Championship caliber opponents during that era..the Redskins, Giants and Bears were all contending teams with Ferocious Defenses....Montana won his 4 Super Bowls in 9 seasons..it took Brady 15 seasons to win his 4th...not even close...
@@tflo75 Montana played before there was a salary cap so the Niners could retain all those Pro-Bowlers and All-Pros and obtain high-priced free agents.
Montana is a cloe #2 but anyone who has paid attention recognizes Brady as the GOAT.
I would say that when this was posted Brady and Montana may have been tied. But there's no competition now. Brady won another MVP, went to two more SBs and won one of them since then. And threw for 505 yards in the one he lost. 5-3 > 4-0 in Super Bowls, there's really no question about it. And if you want to go by stats Brady wins in every meaningful category.
If Tom Brady was the QB you claim he is Philadelphia would have lost Super Bowl LII & NYG would have 2 Super Bowl wins.
If you study Super Bowl LII Brady had time to throw the 🏈 away before that strip sack by Brandon Graham. When you see your offensive line collapsing you throw the 🏈 away so your offense can maintain possession.
During San Francisco's game-winning drive in Super Bowl XXIII Montana had to throw the ball out of bounds on either 2nd or 3rd Down when he saw he didn't have the time to get set.
That's all Tom Brady had to do in Super Bowl LII before the strip by Brandon Graham. New England would still have 3rd and if necessary 4th Down to pick up the 1st to keep the drive alive. If New England would have had possession past the 2:00 warning in Super Bowl LII they would have won.
Tom Brady jeopardized New England's entire season by refusing to get rid of the 🏈 on 2nd Down & 2 and that's why Philadelphia won. As a QB you just don't do that when everything your entire team has worked for just to be in the Super Bowl is on the line.
Brady has rules protecting him and a radio in his helmet. Montana had no rules and no radio in his helmet. Montana had to memorize 200 plus plays and formations and hand signals.
Joe didn't have cheating scandals.
Joe was the best especially in Super Bowls. Blew out the Broncos and the Dolphins. 92 yard drive to win against Cincy. Brady wins 2 with Vinatieri kicks, another against Seattle on a stupid play call. No blowouts or dominant performances. Then Atlanta happens and he is suddenly the greatest of all time?
Game sealing drive in the 4th quarter in all 6 super bowl wins. 9 appearances. 10 straight conference chip games. How does anyone hand wave this resume?
It was the defense and kickers that won both Super Bowls against the Bengals not Montana
XVI Wersching 14 of 26 points and the defense destroyed the 3rd best offense ( 5 sacks 4 turnovers and 8 penalties ) and don't forget that goal line stance.
XXlll Cofer 8 of 20 points and the defense destroyed the #1 offense ( 5 sacks 1 turnover 7 penalties and allowed only 229 total yards to a team averaging 28 ppg ) and don't forget the 16th ranked defense couldn't hold the lead. Facts.
@@RLSmith-jt8qj He played in a weak AFC and played in an easier time for quarterbacks. Montana dominated a loaded NFC while getting mauled by hungry Bears and Giants, shot at by Cowboys and Redskins, and hit by battering Rams all the time.
@@lcrossmk8563 I've been here for the whole run my guy. The better part of 2 decades. 18 years as a starter and at the end of the biggest games in the NFL he's always there and it's only a surprise if he loses. You can take Montana. I'm not going to try and shame you for that. He's Joe cool. But I've been watching Brady dominate this sport since I was 12 years old. 9 super bowls and 6 rings later he is the new standard for which greatness will be measured. And the entire football world has known that for years now. Welcome to the 21st century
@@RLSmith-jt8qj Really? Is HE the new standard now? More like overhyped. What about Peyton Manning and Drew Brees? Tom Brady isn't the only standard, you know. Peyton Manning and Drew Brees are right up there with him. And how long have you been a Patriots fan? I'm just going to assume you're a bandwagoner who doesn't know about how the Patriots were the original whipping boys of the NFL.
He was just beautiful to watch I miss him.
Montana= never cheated.
If you're referring to Deflate-Gate, I sincerely urge you to look up the actual facts. Brady did nothing wrong.
@@efie9179 stickum was already gone by then
Christopher Terrell shut up
So the offensive line of the 49ers didn't cheat in the 80's?
Neither did Tom Brady
As a teen in the 70's, I was Dallas Cowboy & Roger Staubach fan, and to be truthful, I hated Joe Montana during the 80's, because of "the catch" against the Cowboy's in 1982. After that, one of my favorite things to do was to root against Joe Montana & the 49er's during the 80's (bad decision). But in hind sight I must admit, he is the greatest ever in the POST season (especially in Superbowls), when it really counted, and during a time when a quarterback had to throw under-pressure knowing he might get HIT savagely. In fact, that is what ended his career with the 49er's (he was never the same) and was traded to the Chiefs. I seen both Brady & Joe play. Brady is very good, but in the clutch Joe was better. If you look at Joe, most of his heroic throws are on the move and avoiding this type of pressure. He was the best at throwing on the run, and I think this separated him from the rest. Besides as Brady even admits, Joe Montana was his childhood hero and inspiration.
are you on drugs JOE MONTANA BETTER UNDER PRESSURE THEN TIM BRADY THAT IS INSANE
@@tochia5919
Sounds like you missed NFL Films Top 10 Clutch Quarterbacks of all time!
#1 JOE MONTANA
th-cam.com/video/NBr1MWg2jNE/w-d-xo.html
JOE MONTANA THE GOAT!
Goat 🐐 Brady 6 Superbowl rings more then Montana 4 Superbowl ring
Nope
You really can't say this anymore.
Joe played in real era of football . Brady played in soft lg
3:42 salty Steve young
V K also an amazing SF QB. But his BYU stint is legendary.
All these flavors and Patriots fans choose to be salty.
Salty big time ! I have a good laugh every time these kids compare Brady's stats to Montana's.LMAO
FullmetalNinja25 Hold the W
Joe Montana best QB all time
Goat 🐐 Brady 6 Superbowl rings more then Montana 4 superbowl rings
@Zach Wells
Montana lost before Superbowl Giants 49-3 beat 49ers 1986 😂
@Zach Wells
Goat 🐐 Brady 6 rings and 4 Sb Mvps surpassed Montana 4 rings and 3 Sb Mvps
@Zach Wells
Excuses 🖕
Patriots fans it's no problem. This list won't be the same after Brady retires. Any football fan knows Brady has a SOLID chance at another ring.
alienzero52 another "ring"
I think you mean ring* lmao but good try dipshit. no matter what it will be a ring, even if your dumbass says they cheat.....it is still a physical/ real ring budd however, an asterisk next to it will show that there is controversy surrounding it.
alienzero52 it won't change anything. Montana is the best of all time. never lost in Superbowl. no interception. no upset.
Dicky Putra who FUCKIN cares. Tom made it to more! should he be penalized for that? Tom has better stats, wins, everything!
Different eras in football defences were actually allowed to play defence in those days face mask hits to the knees were all allowed no such thing as roughing the passer
Joe Montana was a perfect QB he was just beautiful too watch! GOAT
Throughout his entire career, there was one secret to Joe Montana's success that very few people ever knew about. He threw properly inflated footballs...
How do you know?
What about the silicone and the stickum?
@@peterkay8997 🎯🎯
Joe Montana is THE G.O.A.T.
Never lost a Super Bowl. Never threw an INT in any Super Bowl. Argue just those two specific things, Brady fans. You can't.
Brady won 6 and played in 9...so I guess losing BEFORE you make the Superbowl is better than losing in it? LOL
bpc118 Um ok, then it’s 6 to 4 Brady?
So we gonna gloss over those 3 str8 post seasons of 1 and done. 0 tds and around 4 ints in his prime. 🤔🤔🤔
Okay... Well now its 2019. I’m 45 years old and Tom Brady has been dominating the NFL since I was 27. And he’s not even done yet... Think about that for a second.
Always nice having the best supporting cast and a QB protected era where nobody can lay a finger on you without getting flagged. QBs of the 80s took punishment so it wasnt really possible to play into your 40s.
@googly moogly - You can’t be serious. This is the age of free agency. Brady didn’t have Rice and Taylor like Montana did. Irvin and Harper like Aikman did. Harrison and Reggie Wayne like Peyton Manning did. Swann and Stallworth like Bradshaw did for their entire careers. Let me give you an update of the revolving door of midget wide receivers Brady had that couldn’t do jack sh!t when they weren’t playing with Tom Brady (since apparently you haven’t been paying attention): Troy Brown, Wes Welker, Danny Amendola, Deion Branch, David Givins, Chris Hogan, Aaron, Dobson, David Patten, Josh Gordon, Brandon Tate, Jabar Gaffney, Bethel Johnson, Malcom Mitchell, Brandon Cooks, Jordan Matthews, Amara Darboh, Reche Caldwell, Braxton Berrios, Paul Turner, Cordarrelle, Patterson, Malcolm Mitchell, Darren Andrews, Bennie Fowler, Devin Lucien, Kenny Britt, Riley McCarron, Phillip Dorset, Chad Hansen, Cody Hollister, Mathew Slater... And on and on and on. Brady had Moss for two years and they shattered every record. Besides Moss, do you see any other Hall of Famers on this list? Do you? No you don’t. You better bring it better than that @googly. I got you all day, every day. You are fighting a losing battle.
@googly moogly - Ask Peyton Manning with his multiple neck surgeries, multiple knee surgeries and broken jaw how soft the NFL is. Ask Andrew Luck. Ask Cam Newton. Ask Patrick Mahomes, Drew Brees, and Ben Roethlisburger (all on Injured Reserve right now) how soft the NFL is. Ask Aaron Rodgers with his knee and shoulder surgeries... AND BETTER YET - Ask Ray Lewis and the Ravens how soft they were. The Steelers and Eagles defenses how soft they were. Ask Brian Urlacher and the Bears. Ask the Legion of Boom in Seattle how soft they were. Dude you must me high.
Montana is the GOAT and it's not even close! Think of it like a video game, Montana won playing on hard level while Tammy Brady played on easy level. Those of us that know REAL football know that Montana is GOAT and Brady, well he is a False Prophet.
@@thegoat164 Hell yeah. Nice way to put it. Montana playing Hard Level. Brady playing Easy Level.
Brady throws great underneath ; that's it.
His championships are due to a salary cap, that does not allow teams to stack talent on defense. Montana faced defenses like the Giants, Bears, Broncos, Redskins, and raiders when they mattered. There is no pass rush anymore.
Is there a Lawrence Taylor out there? Charles Haley? Fred Dean?
Just a few good linemen that fill the gap. . . . BORING.
Yep, no Reggie White, Karl Mecklenburg, Joe Klecko, etc. - very good point.
@@Pingo21 The '85 Chicago Bears defense would put those wannabes to shame.
If Brady is truly the GOAT do you think New England's luck would have changed if Tom Brady was the Patriots' QB in Super Bowl XX?
You named montanas teammates to help your argument?
your argument kind of fails bec 49ers were able to stack a team bec of non salary cap era. montana never won a sb in salary cap era. what patriots did was unbelievable bec dynasties shouldn't be able to exist in salary cap eras. that said, dan marino is the goat in terms of pure qb play, peyton is the goat regular season qb and tom a little bit of all
Man, looking at this comments section you'd think that football didn't exist before 2001. Tom Brady was not a great QB until the 2004 season (i.e. after he had already won 2 Super Bowls) and he has had the benefit of the rules opening up the passing game so QBs can achieve numbers never seen before. There is an argument to be made that Brady is the best ever (just as there is for Manning, Montana, Unitas, etc.) but comparing Super Bowl wins or stats means very little if you don't apply some context (ex. the rules at the time, the teams the QBs played for, what the stats of an average QB looked like, etc.).
Dude.. by the time Brady goes to his 2nd super bowl the opposes players already feared him. And the legend has only grown as he has accomplished more.
Montana
Brady
Elway
Peyton
Favre
Marino
Staubach
Young
Bradshaw
Brees
IMO
Mmgen 1 love it but I don't know about manning and elway
The Panty dropper I am not a very big fan of peyton personally, but you may very well switch them
This comments section is filled with people who keep saying Brady was better but let me ask you this: Who handles Pressure Better: Brady or Montana? Brady can easily be beat based on if you can place great middle pressure on his own line like the Texans did. The team that was the best at this the 46 Bears, (1981-1986.) And Montana beat them 23-0 in the 1984 season. If Brady crumpled under the Texans offense think of the mass acted it would be to see him get sacked by Hampton, Singletary, McMichael, or to have Fridge just sit on him. Better question who faced the better competition: Montana or Brady? Montana faced hall of fame Quarterbacks: John Elway, Dan Marino, Dan Fouts, Jim Kelly etc. Brady has who other than Peyton Manning? Drew Brees could match up against Dan Fouts, Peyton Manning when he arrived with the Colts who was compared with: Dan Marino. Montana was more athletic, had more options, handled pressure better, faced and blew out better competition, and he was more accurate. 4-0 in Superbowls, against Legendary Quarterbacks; John Elway, Dan Marino, heck even Boomer Esiason was better than anyone Brady faced. Sure Montana had a stacked team but Brady for the past 5-10 Years too. He had Randy Moss as a receiver for 2 years, in 2013 he received possible the best tight end ever in Rob Gronkowski, He worked with a great wide receiver in Julian Edelman and since the arrival of Bill Belicheck they had one of the best defenses in the league since 2000. Joe Montana just based on his in game performances beats out Brady
Nice argument. After this game it's completely invalid
Marvin Listenbee thank you but look at what happened in the first half, their offense broke down completely and the only thing Brady did good was the comeback in the 4th quarter to win overtime. Brady honestly had a pretty bad performance, he threw a pick 6, missed the majority of the throws throughout the original game. Edelman was dropping passes frequently, Chris Hogan looked like the rookie he is, and Steven Gostowski (correct me if I spelled it wrong on accident) missed a 40 yard field goal. Overall it seem to me, the Falcons choked rather than the Patriots excelled.
Also I forgot to add Montana was dominant from 81' onward heck he led the Kansas City Chiefs to a championship game. Brady always played on the same team, the same coach the same System. Montana proved at 34 years old that his presence alone upped the team's ability. When Brady goes to a championship game with the Jets, Chiefs or Browns then you can say that he isn't a system QB. Also Montana didn't have Walsh his entire career, from 1889-1994. Montana didn't have Walsh but still one a Superbowl and went to the Conference championship for the NFC and AFC Titles. Also If Montana doesn't take that hit in the 1990 NFC Championship game which lead to a concussion, broken hand and broken ribs, then he leads the 49ers to 3 super bowls in a row, and probably a 5th ring. Also the 4-3 playoff record argument is bs. Montana lost in the 1993 AFC Championship game against one of the best teams of the 90s. Kelly's Bills. He got to that game with one of the worst supporting casts for a Quarterback. Even then his playoff wins and losses are larger as you have to count Conference and Championship games which places it out at 16-9 playoff record not even counting Superbowls or his time in Kansas city. Which of they were counted would make his record: 20-9 One of the most impressive Playoff records for a Quarterback. Joe Montana was dominant. and was the centerpiece of both teams he played for. Montana is just plain the best
Sorry, Sam, but 7 out of 10 people don't agree with you that Montana is better. Tom Brady is the greatest Big Game quarterback in the history of the NFL.
JTM And...he lost a again in the world's game and he did it through a both a fumble and a bad hail Mary. Montana would have done better. Brady had time and multiple opportunities and choked again
Brady's Super Bowl wins were won by Malcolm Butler's defense and Adam Vinatieri's field goals
Montana's Super Bowl wins were won by clutch and accurate passes by Montana
For the big game, Montana's my guy.
Reasons why Brady isn't number 1. Cheating scandals, having HOF players like Randy Moss, Rob Gronkowski, Wes Welker, and Adam Vinaterri on his team throughout his career, and finally having Bill Bellichick arguably the best coach of all time. Let's be honest here, put any QB in Bellichick's system and he will do good.
Soviet Turtles what about fucking jerry rice? Montana had him
yeah that's one wide receiver and he wasn't the only one that he threw to
lol Montana had what people consider the best offensive minded head coach of all time. get the fuck out.
and montana didnt have a wonderful defense did he?
Soviet Turtles you can say all the same things about Montana dumb ass
Happy this is not Brady
lol this list was before Brady won his last 3 SB. I think we know who'd be number one now.
@@ChokeslamToHell last 2
@@cobracmr4 This was posted to TH-cam before last 2, but I am pretty sure it originally aired years before it was posted.
@@cobracmr4 No, you are right. It did air in 2016. Crazy they had Montana 1 at this point still. Brady had the same number of SB titles and much more playoff success.
@@ChokeslamToHell the argument back then I feel could have gone either way.
Brady cant hold Joe's jock strap
lol ok dude
Goat 🐐 Brady 6 Superbowl rings more then Montana 4 superbowl rings 😂😂😂
Goat 🐐 Brady 4 Superbowl Mvps more then Montana 3 Superbowl Mvps 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Facts
@@darrickmanes8555 he got 5 now
He deserves it GG 😭😊
I’m a 9ers fan but I think now Brady’s better than Montana
@Oliver McCall Correct, the rest can be debated
Montana made it look easy. If he had bill Walsh for his whole career he would have won more superbowls.
Brady fans will flood all of these posts.
They are a tidal wave of insecurity.
Ikr
Tome Brady had a greater overall career BUT - if I HAVE to win a Super Bowl because my life depends on it as a coach - gimme Montana. He never lost the big game. Brady did. More than once. In fact, I'd argue that if Montana would've had the benefit of modern medicine and the "Brady rules", he would have led the Chiefs to a ring after the Niners traded him. But Brady is GREAT. The guy went from one of the best "game managers" of all time and letting Vinatieri kick them to wins - to being a badass gunslinger and setting single season records for QBs in yardage and TD passes.
If Joe Montana played in Tom Brady’s era there’s a good chance the 49ers would have never lost Joe Montana in the first place to injuries. When Joe Montana got injured in the 1990 NFC championship game to the New York Giants in today’s standards that would’ve been considered a dirty hit it would have been illegal. Which means Joe Montana probably would have won more Super Bowls. And Steve Young would’ve probably been traded to another football team.
Montana.....humble and can never go wrong with 2 min left down by 6.
Now that's the reasons why Montana is better than Brady
Goat 🐐 Brady 6 rings and 4 Sb Mvps better then Montana 4 rings only 3 Sb Mvps
Darrick Manes bruh u came here like 3 years ago😂
Undefeated in Super Bowl appearances and he had endorsements with Sega, Skechers, Papa John's pizza and Hanes underwear
1) Brady 2) Montana 3) Unitas 4) Manning 5 )Graham
I saw Montana play. Also Marino, Fouts, Bradshaw, etc. Great, great quarterbacks. I was lucky to live during their heyday. Miss them all.
You were very lucky
Brady is great no doubt about that, but the way the rules are in the NFL now you can't really say Brady is better than Montana using stats. Is Brady the greatest since his career started? Yes. Is he the greatest of all time? Not even close
David Diaz, and what's kinda interesting is that if you look at it, Montana and Walsh kinda laid the groundwork for the modern NFL
@@auxiliis8366 VERY much they did cause all plays run on timing.....in terms of passing plays the ball is coming out much quicker than it was in previous era's
11-0 / 4-0
At least joe Montana could run lmao
ATLEAST HE COULD WEAR ALL HIS RINGS IN ONE HAND.
JOE MONTANA HAD PROBABLY THE GREATEST RECEIVER OF ALL TIME PLAYING FOR HIM
Reign Of Mayfield actually he won 2 of his 4 super bowls before Rice was even drafted
Holla at me when Montana loses in the Super Bowl. Until then Brady will always be #2. Don't @ me.
Big Poppa Pump you're a troll jobber
Big Poppa Pump to an Eli Manning giants led team twice.
Brady couldn't carry Montana's JOCK STRAP FACT!
Mike Montana well he got 6 rings and if you Wiki Tom Brady it even says he’s the goat lol
@@bobbybetwirlin8442
Wiki doesn't say any such thing. It says he is considered to be ONE of the greatest QBs of all time.
Now Jerry Rice's Wiki says he is considered to be THE greatest wide receiver in NFL History.
Joe Montana was not only considered the greatest QB of all time but also the #1 Clutch QB of all time. How do you like those apples?
this is a joke brady is number 1 peyton 3 and Montana 2 and im a cowboy fan
LongSnappersLivesMatter Peyton 1
Peyton #1 for sure, better stats and he didnt always have an amazing team to support him like brady
lance allen Haha, okay.. That's a lie. Plus, Peyton got a 3 year head start before Brady. Brady is number 1 no doubt.
PSN: xOptismed Well, recently with the broncos he had a half decent defense and the best offense ever
lance allen It doesn't change the fact that he choked against the Seahawks. Not to mention he was pretty much irrelevant (carried by the defence) in the Bronco's win at Superbowl 50. Your point about no support is utter bullshit. I get it, he's a great qb, and I'm not taking that away from him; however, Peyton was not so great when the games mattered the most.
No cheating allegations, 4-0 in Super Bowls. Joe Montana is the GOAT.
JOE = PERFECTION = GOAT
How is Montana perfect? He was a Quarterback in the NFL for 16 years and he was only able to get to 4 Superbowls, that means he was only good enough to get there 25% of his career, he failed to make the appearance 12 times. Tom Brady on the other hand, has played for 20 years now and made it to the big game 9 times, that's a smoking 45% of his career and won 30% of his career.
steve Pepke Montana never loss a super bowl out of all of the Super Bowls he has played in. Brady (Worst QB) lost 3 Super Bowls, (42, 46, and 52)
@@princepond1633 - So, you somehow think it's worse for a team/players to come in as the 2nd best team in the NFL than it is the team's/players who weren't good enough to play in the Superbowl. Montana wasn't good enough to make it to the Superbowl 75% of his career and Brady wasn't good enough only 55% of his Career. Montana wasn't good enough to get to to the Superbowl 12 of his 16 years. He only didn't lose in the Superbowl more because he wasn't good enough to play in more
@@steveTGO this
Yea, yea, yea, yes. Thank you. We know it. Joe is #1.
If Brady played with Rice he would have 6 rings
Jocky Rohnson
He had moss at the tail end of his career he made moss great again...he was BAD in Oakland nd then when he left New England he was bad again
Mitchell Lee
Brady's already better and his career isn't over yet😂😂😂
More playoff wins ..better in every statistical category ...played in a more competitive league ..played against Peyton manning every year ..more Super Bowl appearances ..
take the L tbh
Julian Edelman #Minitron #11Hunnit #slotGOAT montana has 2 without rice. L
Jocky Rohnson
Wouldn't be surprised if Brady not in a New England in inform next year ...but jimmy g looks good and Brady can lead another team to a sb watch
Many endorsements and 4 Super Bowl victories made Joe Montana great! He was one of the spokepersons of the best selling Sega videogame system of all time: The 16-Bit Sega Genesis!
Yeah that game was great at that time facts
Steve Young's face at 3:41 XD
I watched that game against the Cowboys when he hit Dwight Clark for the win. This is a tough comparison a lot tougher than Jordan vs Lebron where Jordan is clearly better. Slight edge to Montana based on the higher playoff passer rating, 4/4 in super bowls, and no interceptions in super bowls.
He took a beating many times and still delivered. Watch The Catch game. Dallas pounded him and he still won. He is clearly the best.
This needs an update: Montana #2, Brady #1
can you believe that the 49ers had joe and steve in the same team at the same time, joe is #1 and steve is # 10 on this list
What's the background music?
pov: it’s 2021 and brady just came off his 7th super bowl win😦
Lol all you kids who have never seen montana play come in here and claim for a fact that brady is better smh
Overall career Brady is better. But If I'm picking one QB to play in the Super Bowl Montana is still my guy. His Super performances were flawless....Brady cannot claim that.
GG, we knew it was him or brady
1. Roger Staubach 2. Joe Montana 3. Johnny Unitas 4. Bart Starr 5. Peyton Manning 6. Terry Bradshaw
7. Roman Gabriel 8. Fran Tarkenton 9. Tom Brady 10. Len Dawson
Most yards than any player
Most touchdowns than any player
Most wins than any player
Most Super Bowl wins
Leadership, clutchnes
We all know who is #1
and who is that? because tom dont have the most yards
@@Raylen23 yes he does if you include playoffs
prior to SB 49, montana was the GOAT. once brady led the biggest comeback in the 4th quarter in SB history, he earned his place at no. 1
how if the only thing seattle had to do was run the ball
Harald Maier because nobody had ever come back from 10 down in the 4th quarter of the super bowl before. the fat that the pats made a big play on defense does nothing to taint or take away from that
Pascal if u gone make excuses fo him losing. Y u won't bring up the tuck rule? That rule changed everything. The nigga shouldn't even went to the Super Bowl that year. Charles Woodson made him fumble. Brady is a top 5 top 7 qb he's not the greatest. That goes to Peyton manning. Rings don't determine greatness
tommy 313 the tuck rule WAS ALREADY A RULE. it was used AGAINST the pats earlier that season, and led to them losing against the jets! and if rings dont determine greatness, then i can argue that dan marino is better than joe montana! you really gotta sort your shit out, man. until then, take the L.
😂 what L. U just proved my point? What other argument do u have behind rings? What I asked u and u said rings once again. U gone always lose cuz the fact is that Peyton is the best. Dan is better than joe? U say tom Brady Was unlucky with the catches and that's y he lost . But u don't bring up the miss field goals by vander when Peyton was with the colts or that nick Harper got tackled by Big Ben. Peyton manning revolutionized the game. What did Brady do? The pats have shown that they are good without him. I've never said the tuck rule wasn't in existence I said u saying a player is better than a player becuse of rings and there are many things that lead up to that. So u took the L cuz I said bring up something other then rings and what did u do? Y'all Brady fans don't want it. Manning is by far the greatest. Stop commenting cuz u gone say the same dumb arguement
I’m pretty sure that Montana lost his title as GOAT when Brady won SuperBowl 51 and 53
No. Brady practically had those gift-wrapped to him by the opposition.
Brady was #1 even before the falcons super bowl
Brady will NEVER be #1, Hell he isn't even Top 10 as he plays ARENA FOOTBALL and the Great Joe Montana played QB in the NFL.
Remember that at age 39 Tom Brady is still the best Qb in the NFL...what was Joe doing at 39?
two idiots who dont know anything.montana around this time damn near brought the chiefs to the super bowl
u think that chiefs offense was stacked with pro bowlers?all kc had was a defense until montana got there.and all the hits montana took throughout his career were starting to take its toll
Montana had to quit because he kept on getting injuries if he didn't then he would have more and he was still baller when he was on the chiefs id like to see Brady go to the browns and make them win a super bowl oh wait he can't
Dean 343 that's like saying why would joe Montana go to the chiefs after he won four with the 49ers
Dean 343 if he truly was he would be able to make the worst team in the NFL the best team like Montana did the niners
Hands down best ever QB to play the game, 89 game at Philly when sacked 6 times and ripped Philly is why henis the best QB ever.
I was at that game. He took a beating
Brady is number one, and here's why:
-Brady has been to more Super Bowls. They both have four, but since Brady has been to more, it's more impressive
-Brady's reign of dominance has lasted MUCH longer. Montana's era of dominance was from 81-90, only ten years. Brady has been nothing short of excellent for sixteen years, and him (and the Patriots) show no signs of slowing down
-Brady has more postseason wins
-If that wasn't enough, Brady leads Montana on the statistical leaderboards.
I'm not some "butthurt Pats fan", I actually argued Montana was better until Super Bowl XLIX. This isn't to hate on Joe, these are just the facts.
WOWZERZ
First Brady has been dominant more then Montana because Montana played in an era where Defenders could tombstone player without a penalty unlike like now. Also Brady has better stats because he is playing in a passing league and Montana played in a time where it was to run the ball all the time until Bill Walsh made the West Coast offense
You are missing many facts,so you need to research more cause there are many points to take in to consideration.One thing you need to learn is that stats are for losers ! Doesn't mean stats don't mean anything but stats only tell part of the story as you have to look much deeper at the situation of how those numbers came to be.Changes in the rules of the game have a huge impact on stats.Example,In 1984 Dan Marino passed for 48 TD's and was a record that stood for 20 years until major rule changes in favor of the offense changed that.Payton Manning 2004 passed for 49 TD's ,Brady 2007 passed for 50 TD's,and Payton Manning again in 2013 passed for 55 TD's.So in a very short period of time not once not twice but 3 times it was broken.Can you say easy peasy ? Drew Brees breaks Marino's passing yards record that stood for 27 years,again easy peasy.Brees breaks Johnny Unitas's record that stood for half a century by passing for a TD in 48 consecutive games,easy peasy.I could go on but I think you get the point ? So those Pats fans that want to try to use Brady's stats as an argument vs Montana you can stop right now cause it's so not working.
has it ever occurred to you that maybe the new players are just starting to surpass the old ones because theyre ACTUALLY BETTER?
Andy the Bearman How is Brady's skillset better then Montana, Elway, or Marino? How is he better?
Joe cool lost his spot for sure now.
Brady, I guess, will need to win at least one more to silence all the haters.
i wish we could have more footages of him
List is still accurate, systom brady is nowhere near montana peyton or even elway
My faith in humanity has been restored
there is a clip of montana doing a 360 and making LT miss him and grab nothing but air, i saw that clip once, but i cant find it anymore on youtube.
1. Tom Brady 5-7
2. Joe Montana 4-4
3. Terry Bradshaw 4-4
Montana is 2nd because he played longer
Justin Johnson Montana never lost a super bowl
Never threw an interception in a Super Bowl, either!
@@ericreyes9511 never been to 5 superbowls either. Hmm...
I think Montana is the number one qb In nlf history not just the super bowl records he has let's go back and see his life in the nlf and out the NFL. Before the NFL he won a national championship for NOTRE DAME IN 1977 " and he still didn't get a rookie card in the NFL when he got drafted! it came out a couple years later lol they thought he was a kicker for the 49ers and he won two super bowls with out Jerry Rice .. rerry got drafted in 1985 Montana already had two rings with out the greatest WR In the league! !!! come on should I go on ... he gets hurt almost lost his job to young and wins another superbowl in 1989 made John alway look like a fool beat some of the best qbs in his time in superbowls.
@Cesar Raudales if we go by stats then Drew Brees should be the GOAT 🐐, playoffs its Brady but Brady's stats aren't bad either and has more MVP's than Brees
Man, y'all can talk about TB12 all y'all want.
Joe Montana is the (G.Q.O.A.T)....▪
Nobody did it better under INTENSE PRESSURE AND DURESS than him!
No way Brady could have withstood the onslaughts and sack hits Montana endure during a time in the NFL when the objective was to take QB's out, LITERALLY ON A STRETCHER❗
Brady literally just played an entire season on a torn MCL 🤣
@@TKTwelve
As soft as the NFL has gotten in comparison to the way defenses played when Montana was throwing touchdowns, any one can play injured in this league the way the rules are now!
Reality ✔❗ You believe in all this TB12 Hype don't you?
He probably got that injury when he was lit up on that yacht throwing the 🏆 around.....
Can't believe everything you hear an read fella....
@@cwvos You know Montana isn’t the GOAT when the only argument in his favor is a hypothetical statement. Brady has absolutely demolished Montana’s records without unlimited cap.
Von Miller and Michael Stratham both called him tough and unyielding surprised no one went after Montana legs or knees Brady DOSENT complain to the refs or cries to the opponents by your logic manning and any QB from the 21ST century wouldn’t last long Brady also is what 6 sacks away from being the most sacked QB in history Steve won with the niners meaning the system was the biggest reason so was Craig Lott Walsh Rice
@@cwvos Brady played in the 00S for 7 years before they broke his knee and even RAY LEWIS and JAMES HARRSION have respect for him when his opponents who have sacked him hard have given him props then you are clearly wrong Brady will have 1000X more records too and Double the ring count 8TH incoming
What about now with 6 rings? That's like 2 more than Montana I think. Even Montana says Brady's the goat now
Link to where he says that or you're a lier. Montana has always been quoted that there's no greatest of all time and Otto Gram still has 7 Championships. Brady isn't even the most clutch or best of his era. That would be the Manning Bros. End of story cheatriot.
I respect joe Montana and the magic the 49ers were able to create with him. But........honestly, he wasn't even the best qb of his era, just part of the best team of his era.
andromeda gen that some bullshit
I didn’t know Tom Brady changed his name to Joe Montana.
Brady is the best-manufactured QB in the NFL his wins in the super bowl were fixed by Goodell and kraft they made him the football players he is today
@@bobcrandall7749 PURE STUPIDITY.
You can argue why Joe is better than brady but this bullshit.😂😂😂
your right Roger Goodell and Bob Kraft made Tom Brady the QB he is today
GOAT! # 1 of all time
why the fuck is Joe Montana number 1 and Brady number 2….. like I'm looking at the stats and Brady beats him in almost everything, not to mention that Montana's team is so stacked on offense and defense
Praveen Perera because they played good teams. pats division is easy as hell
Praveen Perera You have been deceived by PHONY stats.
+fake Brady made the division easy for the pats... Before it was quite hard
+Mike Montana Are you dumb?
Am I dumb ? Most certainly not ! I am educated and know the game of football very well and I don't mean in just the last 20 years either.Anyone that just looks at some stats and throws numbers at you without taking a deeper look at how those numbers came to be is the dumb one.Open your eyes and take a look around sometime OK ?
For me his still Number 1, not the lap dog Quarter Back of the NFL Executives...
Noooo Ryan Leaf is the greatest QB of all time...
Brady: 3 super bowl losses
Leaf: 0 super bowl losses
sure, lets all just pay attention to all of his losses
Last time I checked Montana never lost the big game, Brady lost 3 times. You gonna take a 100% chance to win a championship or a 70% chance to win a championship? Joe wouldn’t lose to Eli or Nick Foles that much I know.
Stop it. Brady is GOAT. Montana had the benefit of a HOF roster. Not to mention the Great "OFFENSIVE" mined coach in Bill Walsh.
LMAO! LIke brady never had a good team. Shut your mouth rn.
Gemini Man He didn't like how Montana had. He had a HOF roster due to the fact there was no salary cap or free angency. And Brady still accomplished just as much as Montana(even More) with the constant roster changes over the years.... Please kid go back to bed. Brady is GOAT
BeastMode 21 what about the greatest mind in sports belicheck? and his always great team
The Panty dropper Bill was a "DEFENSIVE" minded coach rarely touched in on offense. That was Brady's domain. You saw how 1st overall pick drew Bledsoe(who had led the pats to a superbowl) couldn't get the offense. Without Brady Bill was on the verge of being fired as he never had a winning season and started the season 0-2. Like I said Brady is GOAT
HOF roster? Other than Montana himself they only had Ronnie Lott, Fred Dean and Jerry Rice that were HOFers. He won his first two with only Lott and Dean both defensive players while he had no superstar on offense until 1985 when they got Rice. Dean left so he won his next two with Rice and Lott. Doesn't sound like a HOF roster to me
When brady gets his 5th ring he will be number 1
Joe Montana, the Qb who even Tom Brady looked up to and calls the G.O.A.T....
Stats don't support this...take away his 4 best Super Bowl seasons and his career is not great. He was clutch in 4 playoffs. Hes Eli manning times two.
DeadMoNeyProductions BP that is so dumb take away tom brady 4 super he is like below .500 in the playoffs
DeadMoNeyProductions BP then do the same with Brady and tell me he is better than peyton
Donte Underwood I say the best if he win 1 more SB or 2 more MVP Malcolm butler save his legacy
LOL !
Donte Underwood what you fail to see is that Peyton's are better than Brady's
Tom Brady is the number 1 QB! End of story!
What a DREAMER YOU ARE FOOL! Joe Montana played QB in the NFL. Brady plays Arena Football.
@@thegoat164 Bullshit Montana had Jerry Rice. Brady had multiple WR in his career except for Randy Moss and Gronk
@@AndrewWarrenPatriotsfan
The GOAT The Great Joe Montana and Brady, well he is a FRAUD! You look ridiculous in that getup!
@@AndrewWarrenPatriotsfan He had consistency in his receiving corps, namely Wes Welker, Deion Branch, and Julian Edelman. All of them were above-average in their own right,
lcrossmk8 rob gronkowski as well, also had troy brown