It doesnt but it probably has an effect on public perception which influences elections and provides scrutiny which can influence government decision making.
@@AB-J it's deliberately confrontational. Most modern legislative chambers are in amphitheatre style seating. Spreads people out, you're not staring each of your political opponents down and can actually have purposeful discussion.
Sunak and the Tories lecturing Starmer on principles and kleptocracy is quite something. Have the Tories figured out where the missing PPE billions went yet?
Specs and fashion subsidy for the future labour that were dressed worse than a dewhurst rack of lamb in case they ever got into power or perhaps funding 50 shades of grey to concoct a report that was dubious to say the least.
True but at least Rishi charismatic and funny. Labour are doing the exact same thing. They're bought and paid for.. Its just lefties are unwilling to admit that for some reason..
"We left the second lowest debt in the G7" lies, damage lies and tory statistics, they trebled the national debt and the interest costs on that £3 trillion are why borrowing is still increasing.
Covid furlough scheme, helping to fund Ukraine and also winter cost of living payments have done this. I don't see how this would be any different under any other government...
@@SirSupremmmmmmme we're not lol. We're 2nd lowest and that's not difficult with the countries that are in the G7. Our national debt as a percentage of GDP has been growing at a rate which is 4th in the G7. Things aren't looking good for us right now because of the last couple of years
@@SDDT24he didn’t. Tony Blair funded his spending increases with indirect taxes or the economy naturally doing well. The debt to gdp didn’t spike dramatically under Blair
I'd 100% rather have Rishi Sunak as British PM rather than this lying git, that we call our usless PM. Lets hope in 4yrs time the British people will see sense & vote Conservative. I sure do hope so Conservatives Forever. I felt proud to be British when we had a Conservative PM, now i feel like we're a joke to the world.
To be fair, that was a good first jab by Rishi about new employment law and STarmer firing and hiring Sue Gray as chief of staff- Starmer didn't even address his own hypocrisy.
Honestly, if they can get the rail system renationalised and get fares down and better services, that’d be a damn sight better than anything the tories did. Actually, right now I’m waiting for a train since the one I was going to get was cancelled so I have to wait an hour for the next one.
@@jablot5054 what we have found with railway franchises is that all the competition turns out to be is when the franchises are being chosen by the government, they promise more and better service for less cost to be more appealing. This is obviously impossible, and has resulted in many franchises falling through before their end date and several companies are now run by the government already. The fact that this has happened at all suggests that railway privatisation does not work without perhaps even more severe restrictions, which noone wants, and therefore nationalisation is the only realistic policy going forward.
@@jablot5054Untrue, there will be competition as there will still be open access operations alongside the nationalised operators. Alongside the mainline GBR operator there will still be Grand Central, Lumo and Hull trains.
Labour has a point. A lot of old people can afford the tax, and the more poorer pensioners are going to get the tax, so the many that are poor will get the tax, the few that are rich won’t, and can pay for it themselves.
Yeah I agree, old people don’t contribute much to society at present, like who contribute more to society a 25 year old guy or 90 year old man. It’s obvious we need to protect thr young. I would introduce an 60% tax on all pensions too
As an American, i just start rolling my eyes when i keep hearing “14 years, 22 billion”. I feel like i heard it in day one and i keep hearing it but no solutions…
Starmer set out what some of those solutions are in his response - did you not hear him? It’s been just 3 months since Labour took office for goodness sake and it’s right he keeps reminding everyone (with short memories) what mess the Tories left this country in.
Sunak is letting his hair down and relaxed as he knows his time is coming to an end, it's probably the best performance I've seen from him and even had comic timing. Obviously he is under a lot less pressure than as PM.
@@danielgreener4574 Yes that’s what I thought. It’s always easier when you’re not in the hot seat. Mind you he’s got the material. Starmer and co have been laughably incompetent in their first few months.
Leaders on both sides of the house have used the same vague avoidance technique for years. Use a few soundbites and blame everyone else. This is why people like Farage gain traction, love him or loathe him, he sounds different to that same old bluster and he stands out because of it. This country is at a very low point right now.
@@alfsmith4936 yeah feel like they should increase taxes for the companies increasing the use of self-service and AI systems, so that they either provide more jobs or pay taxes to compensate for the people who are gonna end up on unemployment benefits because there's less jobs out there
I’ve watched Pmqs degrade over the years. I wanted Starmer in but I absolutely loathe how all he does is deflect and deflect and deflect. No wonder he’s become so unpopular.
What do we get as taxpayers! Shafted every time! £22 billion pounds, black hole Immigrants free Football tickets free Clothes free Taxpayers stuffed. Talk about national security wait until it’s on your doorstep. Then it’s too late. Mr Speaker please help! 😂😂😂😂
I wish Starmer would disappear into that £22bn black hole. It sounds more and more like "The dog ate my homework" excuse except I'm more inclined to believe the dog story.
Well, it's definitely not too far off. If it's true that the Tories left debt, and spent too much, wasted too much - £22bn black hole is no bad excuse and might be true. Sir Keir makes it sound boring, but if anyone ordinarily mentioned £22bn like that, I'd be shocked. It is the kind of thing you have to say again and again because £22bn is not something you can usher away in a week unless you're Elon Musk. And even though the Government should have resou- oh wait, no they don't. So even if it becomes an excuse, it's not a bad one.
"Previous government" is surely an acceptable excuse for 12-18 months? After then, the government should have had a chance to fix a few things. The last government were still blaming the previous party after having 14 years to do things their way.
For 14 years Cameron, May, Boris, Truss and Sunak used to show & tell us about a note left by Gordon Brown saying there is no money left, you didn’t say a word but accepted the rhetoric. Now you don’t want to hear the truth about £22bn that’s two tier judgement , and is not acceptable
@@XeNeXX Ahh, ideological blindness. Gotta love it. You *know* if it was vice-versa, you'd skin Sunak for not answering the question that was asked twice.
@@Payteer Yeah, which is why I suggested the change in name. Rarely in PMQs will Qs receive any meaningful As. As you imply, the whole thing is theatre.
With Starmer never answering Sunaks question will the hold on nis and tax apply equally to employers as well as employees. And never an answer forthcoming, as he changed the subject each time we waited to hear an answer to the question. Starmers either thick, or deliberately keeps changing the subject.
Does he think no one notices the lack of an answer to a question. But this is a governing of a nation. With the leader playing childish games instead of doing business. We the public are paying these people. How can we get our representatives to work instead of play ? But why did Sunak not insist on a straight reply. By taking control of the meeting and insisting before another question is forthcoming, the question is answered.
@@lydiamond12 she's not, she's just sitting there. PMQ is not the place to jeer like you're in secondary school. You guys find any little thing and blow it out of proportion, she's just sitting there sensibly.
You could create a good drinking game out of prime ministers questions. You have a shot of vodka/whiskey every time an mp or the prime minister keir starmer says 22 billion pound black whole wich obviously doesn't exists
We could just prosecute the people who were paid £33bn for the 'track and trace' phone app and use Michelle Moan's luxury PPE yacht to patrol the channel, looking for immigrants in dinghies but it wouldn't make the Conservative party look good...
14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion Surely this excuse will expire soon, SURELY.
@adonmawson7495 how on earth is it a valid point, Labour have been in power for 3 Months, All Labour does is complain about what the Conservatives left them. It's been almost 4 months. They should get on with the 'Change' instead of complaining
@ChalkyR2D2 That's a bit like if you broke your legs and you said why can't you run a marathon already? In order to get "Change" they have to first deal with what was left to them and that obviously takes time. You say they've been in power for 3 months like it's been 3 years ffs
I’m pretty sure the last time conservatives won they didn’t go on abt what labour did and talked about what their doing and even I’m pretty sure when blair won he didn’t go on abt what the tories did and went on abt what their doing aswell im starting to think starmer just wanted to be pm to say “look at me im the pm now” and he’s even flexing that he got a huge majority bro is so self absorbed
All to do with the previous governments increase austerity measures imposed on local authorities over many many years based on wasteful policies that only benefited the Tories and their mates.
I wish PMs would actually just be straight forward about their plans. It's the same on both sides, dodging the hard questions by blathering on about unrelated "wins" and how the other side did worse
Politics Joe needs to stop being biased and accept that now that free-gear-Keir is the PM the title of the video should be “Rishi Sunak takes on Keir Starmer” and not the other way around
Watching the way they carry on in this room like a bunch of spoiled children makes the entire country sick. I’ve honestly seen more civil debates at derby matches between opposing football teams fans
Everyone, next time the press decides to rip, twist, and destroy the Prime Minister, I urge you all to consider whether it’s truly a reflection of reality! Sunak was a better option-he understands the economy. It’s a shame he isn’t in power. Labour will make you all poorer. Every time Labour has been in government, employment has been lower.
According to a recent news story from the Telegraph I think they revealed a way to cheat the system; by claiming a pension support benefit. The funny thing is that the PM & chancellor both said "those entitled to credit will still get it & not enough are claiming this right now".
Ppl need to realise. Labour n Tories are 2 peas in the same pod, going to the same destination, just using different routes........Does anyone know MPs get a £350 a week for lunch, on top of their wage. But still hitting the lil guy 1st. Ppl need to realise we are being played......Look up inheritence tax. To understand the scam of this society....... WE ALL FOOLISH ATM
6:19 Do you want to remind the house who told Mi5 not to look into Russia interference? We can’t have honest conversations with the tories as a party. The tories have let thousands die due to negligence and incompetence. Ban The Tories!
Oh cut the Russia phobia bs.. it’s wearing off. There has been no clear evidence of this but used a political tool and false narrative to mislead the public. When ever Labour or Conservative disagree with any organisation it’s Russia interference nonsense. Why do people blindly fall for this lie. The MSM cannot be relied on.. do your own research people. Just watch when Trump wins it will be Russia interference bs again.
@@delbertsingh9469 There’s Russia phobia and then there’s our former prime minister (as foreign secretary I believe) ditching his security team to party with the son of a former KGB spy with ties to putin.
@@SaintWill70 George Osborne, who was Conservative chancellor after Labour in 2010 said it was a lie in an interview 2 years ago. I didn't need to be there, it's well known. Unfortunately for the conservatives, this black hole Starmer is talking about is real, because they didn't want to reveal the shortfall before the election
@@rickmartin5288 agreed it's the politics at play. Labour are looking to brand the Tories as being a disaster for the economy and the country. They need the branding to stick and stay fresh in the mind in 5 years time. Thing is, Labour need to actually achieve change within 5 years or they'll look no better
I support the employee rights bill, but seriously can either of them have a front on front rational arguement about economics. Not just jabs at each other on a personal level.
It's maybe an unpopular decision after the past few months but I'm actually really impressed by Starmer. I mean, he's somehow managed to make me like Sunak more than him - that has to count for something, right?
Yes they would. England is not a fascist nation and the Tories can't pretend they're not trying to push the nation into it, since 2015 because what Nigel Farage does looks like fun, much to the annoyance of their traditional, sensible, conservative voters.
The Tories don't want compulsory voting. If they did, they would have brought it in, given they have been the dominant party in the UK. It's the same reason the Tories like FPTP, because it has served them well, up till now. They also brought in voter ID, which is another barrier to voting. As for Labour, they should promote PR, because it's a fairer voting system. They won't of course, now they have a huge majority.
@@chindit6784 totally agree, the tories weren’t great. But it’s pretty clear that this labour government is no longer for the working people and are completely unrecognisable to their roots from old. Kier never has any answers, just goes on about a 22bn black hole. Labour had a plan to prevent fuel price rises… fuel prices have gone up since. Labour hammered Rishi about his plans for WFA cuts and hurting pensioners, then got into power and did exactly that. Personally preparing for hikes in taxes they promised weren’t going to be increased too.
How does this format of debate help run a country? It’s like watching rivalling fans at a football game
'Tradition'.
It's all a bunch of nonsense
@@tewybaby 😂😂
I don't understand what's wrong with the format, but I agree on the fact that they are like fans of football
It doesnt but it probably has an effect on public perception which influences elections and provides scrutiny which can influence government decision making.
@@AB-J it's deliberately confrontational. Most modern legislative chambers are in amphitheatre style seating. Spreads people out, you're not staring each of your political opponents down and can actually have purposeful discussion.
It’s like a school playground
Tbf it's much more civil than it's been in the past - this is miles better than Boris v Corbyn
@@sg3215 No corbyn was the best
First time?
It's nice to see Rishi enjoying himself. It's quite easy though, isn't it, taking the piss out of a liar and a coward.
Yep, it is easy. Shame he’s got nobody to take the piss out of tho :(
Can he not have a conversation without talking about the so called 22 Billion black hole.🤣
Sunak and the Tories lecturing Starmer on principles and kleptocracy is quite something. Have the Tories figured out where the missing PPE billions went yet?
Specs and fashion subsidy for the future labour that were dressed worse than a dewhurst rack of lamb in case they ever got into power or perhaps funding 50 shades of grey to concoct a report that was dubious to say the least.
Another elephant in the room.
True but at least Rishi charismatic and funny. Labour are doing the exact same thing. They're bought and paid for.. Its just lefties are unwilling to admit that for some reason..
Have labour for a clue what they doing yet? Absolutely not apart from fucking us all over well done
Have starmer figured out where his freebie money come from
At least Starmer didn’t keep calling him prime minister.
Shouldn't the title be reversed as well? Rishi sunak should be challenging kier starmer
he did ojne actually lol - around 5:30
@lreddy101 no he didn't, that was hoyle
Our bars are really low, aren't we?
"We left the second lowest debt in the G7" lies, damage lies and tory statistics, they trebled the national debt and the interest costs on that £3 trillion are why borrowing is still increasing.
Still lowest in G7 mate, wakeup.
Covid furlough scheme, helping to fund Ukraine and also winter cost of living payments have done this. I don't see how this would be any different under any other government...
Acting like Tony Blair didn’t start the trend of borrowing at a huge scale
@@SirSupremmmmmmme we're not lol. We're 2nd lowest and that's not difficult with the countries that are in the G7. Our national debt as a percentage of GDP has been growing at a rate which is 4th in the G7. Things aren't looking good for us right now because of the last couple of years
@@SDDT24he didn’t.
Tony Blair funded his spending increases with indirect taxes or the economy naturally doing well. The debt to gdp didn’t spike dramatically under Blair
What a circus!
That's all it is. This country is screwed either way.
Westminster these days seems as scripted as the WWE. Only less entertaining.
Your first PMQ's? This is for the public record & not a parliamentary debate.
@@parker-ii7fg So true!
yeah tories cant behave well in opposition at all lol - still acting like petchulent children
I'd 100% rather have Rishi Sunak as British PM rather than this lying git, that we call our usless PM. Lets hope in 4yrs time the British people will see sense & vote Conservative. I sure do hope so Conservatives Forever. I felt proud to be British when we had a Conservative PM, now i feel like we're a joke to the world.
To be fair, that was a good first jab by Rishi about new employment law and STarmer firing and hiring Sue Gray as chief of staff-
Starmer didn't even address his own hypocrisy.
Honestly, if they can get the rail system renationalised and get fares down and better services, that’d be a damn sight better than anything the tories did. Actually, right now I’m waiting for a train since the one I was going to get was cancelled so I have to wait an hour for the next one.
Absolutely. As hopeless as I am for this government, that is smth i feel optimistic for
@@kingeddiam2543 nationalisation will just increase costs, as there will be no competition.
@@jablot5054 what we have found with railway franchises is that all the competition turns out to be is when the franchises are being chosen by the government, they promise more and better service for less cost to be more appealing. This is obviously impossible, and has resulted in many franchises falling through before their end date and several companies are now run by the government already. The fact that this has happened at all suggests that railway privatisation does not work without perhaps even more severe restrictions, which noone wants, and therefore nationalisation is the only realistic policy going forward.
@@jablot5054Untrue, there will be competition as there will still be open access operations alongside the nationalised operators. Alongside the mainline GBR operator there will still be Grand Central, Lumo and Hull trains.
@@jablot5054 There is no competition anyway.
4:42 anyone else here the speaker call rishi prime minister?
Christ, what was Starmer thinking in reverting to political babble in response to Sunak's softball bipartisan last question?
Labour has a point. A lot of old people can afford the tax, and the more poorer pensioners are going to get the tax, so the many that are poor will get the tax, the few that are rich won’t, and can pay for it themselves.
Yeah I agree, old people don’t contribute much to society at present, like who contribute more to society a 25 year old guy or 90 year old man. It’s obvious we need to protect thr young. I would introduce an 60% tax on all pensions too
@@neilp7623 🤣🤣🤣
Said a true socialist
That's not how the tax works
@@sl0w_racer yes tax people more as they age
The tories think scapping maternity pay and the minimum wage is a vote winner 😂
I think they're just desperate for the money in some pensioner's wills.
The Tories were sooooo much better than Labour!
@@JohnClem7865how so?
All bad it's a lies . They are a Mafia nothing else
Didnt see that on their manifesto
Bring back Corbyn. This ain’t labour
True
😂😂😂Absolutely Nott disaster
Who would we have rather have in now? Still Sunak or that liar Stalin?
Sunak but I’m not a Tory voter but a Labour voter.
@@jamescooper8856 I'm not a Tory voter mate, But I'd have Sunak anyday over Stalin.👍
RISHI.
As an American, i just start rolling my eyes when i keep hearing “14 years, 22 billion”. I feel like i heard it in day one and i keep hearing it but no solutions…
Starmer set out what some of those solutions are in his response - did you not hear him? It’s been just 3 months since Labour took office for goodness sake and it’s right he keeps reminding everyone (with short memories) what mess the Tories left this country in.
So... do you propose Starmer never again refers to the hole that Tories left the country in? Its important to put everything into context.
Stupid ministers wasting people money and making dramas
Starmer’s answer to everything and every criticism is “yeah but the tories”.
Sunak looked relaxed and makes a far better opposition leader than a PM.
Sunak is letting his hair down and relaxed as he knows his time is coming to an end, it's probably the best performance I've seen from him and even had comic timing. Obviously he is under a lot less pressure than as PM.
@@danielgreener4574 Yes that’s what I thought. It’s always easier when you’re not in the hot seat. Mind you he’s got the material. Starmer and co have been laughably incompetent in their first few months.
This is like deja vu.
The Speaker should be saying "Answer the question" or what is the point?
The NI and fiscal rules questions clearly landed.
Seriously……. Could you trust any of them?
Leaders on both sides of the house have used the same vague avoidance technique for years. Use a few soundbites and blame everyone else.
This is why people like Farage gain traction, love him or loathe him, he sounds different to that same old bluster and he stands out because of it. This country is at a very low point right now.
1:37 is keir saying that raising taxes caused the "$22 billion blackhole" now? ridiculous
I think he was bringing them up separately
no hw wasnt - if you paid attention he said rasing taxes would be the only other way outr of that black hole as cuts arent beneficial for anyone
@@XeNeXX He's right.. Employers need to pay more tax, to prop up the safety net for people who are replaced by self service machines and AI.
@@alfsmith4936 yeah feel like they should increase taxes for the companies increasing the use of self-service and AI systems, so that they either provide more jobs or pay taxes to compensate for the people who are gonna end up on unemployment benefits because there's less jobs out there
Such a weird and ridiculous line to take when they will obviously have to raise taxes for investment.
Carry on parliament
Nice debate. Thank you for sharing.
What a sausage!! I mean berk!
There’s no difference in the parties.
It’s the muppet show
I’ve watched Pmqs degrade over the years. I wanted Starmer in but I absolutely loathe how all he does is deflect and deflect and deflect. No wonder he’s become so unpopular.
I haven't even started yet and I just know 22 billion and 14 years will be said many many times
Starmer needs to move on from saying the tories did this and that, we know what happened, move on..
True rather them than labour
What do we get as taxpayers!
Shafted every time!
£22 billion pounds, black hole
Immigrants free
Football tickets free
Clothes free
Taxpayers stuffed.
Talk about national security wait until it’s on your doorstep.
Then it’s too late.
Mr Speaker please help! 😂😂😂😂
Starmer is a rabbit in the headlights.
☀️🐰☀️
I wish Starmer would disappear into that £22bn black hole. It sounds more and more like "The dog ate my homework" excuse except I'm more inclined to believe the dog story.
If you, by your own admission, believe "the dog ate my homework" story, haven't you then just admitted to being extremely gullible or naive?
Well, it's definitely not too far off. If it's true that the Tories left debt, and spent too much, wasted too much - £22bn black hole is no bad excuse and might be true. Sir Keir makes it sound boring, but if anyone ordinarily mentioned £22bn like that, I'd be shocked. It is the kind of thing you have to say again and again because £22bn is not something you can usher away in a week unless you're Elon Musk. And even though the Government should have resou- oh wait, no they don't. So even if it becomes an excuse, it's not a bad one.
Unlike tory BS mantra "vaccine rollout"
"Previous government" is surely an acceptable excuse for 12-18 months? After then, the government should have had a chance to fix a few things.
The last government were still blaming the previous party after having 14 years to do things their way.
For 14 years Cameron, May, Boris, Truss and Sunak used to show & tell us about a note left by Gordon Brown saying there is no money left, you didn’t say a word but accepted the rhetoric. Now you don’t want to hear the truth about £22bn that’s two tier judgement , and is not acceptable
Is this bollocks from this week? Last week? Week before last? Or next week? Pathetic
In all fairness. That was a good showing from Rishi.
You think?
He’s absolutely delusional WHY is he still here?
I don’t know why Sunak is still there either
@@neilmchardy9061He’s not scared of you racists that’s why
@@neilmchardy9061 his replacement isn't ready yet
Why do the other clowns 🤡 keep standing up 😂 like they will get a word in...😂 they all piss me off.
Remember Britain, you got fed up with the conservatives, but you voted in a muppet
I’m not a labour or torie supporter, but judging the performance of this pm, I don’t think he’ll be PM for long.
What a poor judgment!
@@RolandMat-u6y Open your eyes ffs
@@RolandMat-u6yLawyer PM or MP = not socially or business intelligent.
@@RolandMat-u6yHere we go….. is it really?
I hate the Tories, but only slightly more than this red tory labour government.
They are all nicely drunk & coked up after their free lunch today
Sunak was head and shoulders abive granny harmer here. Brilliant.
Oh so they're back after they're little summer holiday... Only 3 months
The political system in the United Kingdom is broken, this PMQs is a waste of time. No PM ever answers a question. Bring back Guy Fawkes.
I know it’s unserious and poor but rishi basically some zingers 😂😂 the Ali line was actually hilarious
Should be called Prime Minister's Evasions.
answered every proper one
@@XeNeXX Ahh, ideological blindness. Gotta love it. You *know* if it was vice-versa, you'd skin Sunak for not answering the question that was asked twice.
@@WisdomWeaverBitcoinBruv because until the budget is announced Sunak knows he won't get an answer to it. It was only political point scoring.
@@Payteer Yeah, which is why I suggested the change in name. Rarely in PMQs will Qs receive any meaningful As. As you imply, the whole thing is theatre.
@@WisdomWeaverBitcoinBruv its been obvious that PMQs are not for the PM to answer questions. It about showing their character, and their charisma.
2 multi millionaires battling it out for working ordinary people? 🤣
my thoughts exactly. i miss having an actual socialist party
They aren’t even remotely comparable. Keir Starmer is well paid but as a public servant.
@@lukemoores6763 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@SaintWill70 errr news to me.
What do you want? A homeless man as prime minister?
The whole place looks like rap battle.😂
Yeaaaeeeeaaaaah😂
Rishi is weaker in opposition that in power. I fail to see how he is in politics.
Kier is worse than rishi and rishi was one of the worst pms we’ve ever had get em all out
@@Matli1804He was not a bad Chancellor.
With Starmer never answering Sunaks question will the hold on nis and tax apply equally to employers as well as employees. And never an answer forthcoming, as he changed the subject each time we waited to hear an answer to the question. Starmers either thick, or deliberately keeps changing the subject.
Does he think no one notices the lack of an answer to a question. But this is a governing of a nation. With the leader playing childish games instead of doing business. We the public are paying these people. How can we get our representatives to work instead of play ? But why did Sunak not insist on a straight reply. By taking control of the meeting and insisting before another question is forthcoming, the question is answered.
Labour Tory same old story.
Zzzzzzzzzz
TH-cam whiner, writes like a minor.
Labour are a shit version of the tories!
Ruzzian talking points
Rayner is looking bored out of her mind. Dreaming of Ibiza.
Like you've never taken a holiday
@@HenryLobber What a silly response. PM questions time is not the place to be daydreaming.
@HenryLobber Not many are able to take heavily subsidised holidays....
@@lydiamond12 she's not, she's just sitting there. PMQ is not the place to jeer like you're in secondary school. You guys find any little thing and blow it out of proportion, she's just sitting there sensibly.
@@dabhand6796 stop spouting BS. Holidays aren't subsidised at all for MPs.
England is finished
But Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are okay?
Good.
UK government, not just England.
Houses and investment was sorted already.
Sunak doing the same thing as he did when PM - asking Starmer questions.
And Starmer yapping.
Sunak did nothing but gaslight too. That's just politicians for you
Starmer just tries to hit a few keywords every time he speaks
Starmer can't keep avoiding challenges by stating the Tories had 14 years to fix things. That won't wash forever
You could create a good drinking game out of prime ministers questions. You have a shot of vodka/whiskey every time an mp or the prime minister keir starmer says 22 billion pound black whole wich obviously doesn't exists
We could just prosecute the people who were paid £33bn for the 'track and trace' phone app and use Michelle Moan's luxury PPE yacht to patrol the channel, looking for immigrants in dinghies but it wouldn't make the Conservative party look good...
@@alfsmith4936 That I agree with.
We couldn't trust the Tories and now we can't trust Labour. We need a better system!
Vote Reform UK.
@@JupiterThunder If you've half a mind to vote Reform UK, that's more than enough.
If Reform UK is the answer you've asked completely the wrong fucking question. A party for the bigoted and I'll educated
A kangaroo court
14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion, 14 years, 22 billion
Surely this excuse will expire soon, SURELY.
Well it's a valid point, the Conservatives have done poorly during their tenure so you can't blame the guy. But he is a pleb.
@adonmawson7495 how on earth is it a valid point, Labour have been in power for 3 Months, All Labour does is complain about what the Conservatives left them. It's been almost 4 months. They should get on with the 'Change' instead of complaining
@ChalkyR2D2 That's a bit like if you broke your legs and you said why can't you run a marathon already? In order to get "Change" they have to first deal with what was left to them and that obviously takes time. You say they've been in power for 3 months like it's been 3 years ffs
I remember Johnson talking about the Labour government of the 1970's !!.
You have to remind people of the damage done in the last 14 years
I’m pretty sure the last time conservatives won they didn’t go on abt what labour did and talked about what their doing and even I’m pretty sure when blair won he didn’t go on abt what the tories did and went on abt what their doing aswell im starting to think starmer just wanted to be pm to say “look at me im the pm now” and he’s even flexing that he got a huge majority bro is so self absorbed
Bunch of clowns the parliament is
Rishi's good at asking questions in opposition
He was always good at asking questions, he was never one for answers.
How did they got there ? 😂😂😂 nobody else was interested in it ?
A serpent biting a lizard.
Can we ask kier if the mayor of London's 15.2 billion debt is included in the black hole...
All to do with the previous governments increase austerity measures imposed on local authorities over many many years based on wasteful policies that only benefited the Tories and their mates.
@@Payteer but he has a budget of 20 billion a year... So how has he racked up a debt of 15?!! And he's a labour mayor too...
I wish PMs would actually just be straight forward about their plans. It's the same on both sides, dodging the hard questions by blathering on about unrelated "wins" and how the other side did worse
@@SaintWill70 what?
Sick of the black hole by labour
Sick of the truth?
"Labour", note the capitalisation due to it being a proper noun.
It's called "an education", please feel free to try one.
1.8% of government spending.
Big whoop.
They love complaining about their black hole rather than providing solutions to fix it.
“Black hole” is complete nonsense.
Starmer will have to make tough decisions and things will probably get worse befriend they better but hes looking long term need to support him
Politics Joe needs to stop being biased and accept that now that free-gear-Keir is the PM the title of the video should be “Rishi Sunak takes on Keir Starmer” and not the other way around
Not answering questions….shouldnt be speaker “forcing” pm answering these ?
The pot and kettle paradox
1:55 love him or hate him, that Lord Alli line was COLD
Tories gonna tory
At what point do we call for their arrest for the crimes they’ve committed against the British people?
@@hazyhayley7488sadly never as they are the establishment
Vote reform!!
2 tier kier looks very uncomfortable
Why do we as brits accept these idiots running the country is the best we can have?
Yes
Watching the way they carry on in this room like a bunch of spoiled children makes the entire country sick. I’ve honestly seen more civil debates at derby matches between opposing football teams fans
Everyone, next time the press decides to rip, twist, and destroy the Prime Minister, I urge you all to consider whether it’s truly a reflection of reality! Sunak was a better option-he understands the economy. It’s a shame he isn’t in power. Labour will make you all poorer. Every time Labour has been in government, employment has been lower.
sumak - he did awfully well as a PM didnt he? marginally better than loser Truss
Don’t take these people seriously
Hard times ahead yet again for the poorest in our society.
Always the same only as good as your last vote.
starmers arguement is so annoying. He basically just says " its fine to be mediocre and not that helpful because they were worse!!! "
According to a recent news story from the Telegraph I think they revealed a way to cheat the system; by claiming a pension support benefit.
The funny thing is that the PM & chancellor both said "those entitled to credit will still get it & not enough are claiming this right now".
Vote Reform
Just answer the question ffs. Starmer is a devious liar.
Can you remember ex PM Johnson ever answering a question? Half the lies ex PM Johnson tells aren't true and the other half are just lies.
@@paulwilson7234 100% true, so why is Starmer continuing the same style of politics?
Ppl need to realise. Labour n Tories are 2 peas in the same pod, going to the same destination, just using different routes........Does anyone know MPs get a £350 a week for lunch, on top of their wage. But still hitting the lil guy 1st. Ppl need to realise we are being played......Look up inheritence tax. To understand the scam of this society....... WE ALL FOOLISH ATM
This is just two hypocrites arguing. Neither are prepared to do what is best everyone.
Kilback Mill
Constructive support in the same spirit. Double speak ahoy.
"Que?" Could you try writing that in English, old boy? I've got absolutely no idea what you're on about.
6:19 Do you want to remind the house who told Mi5 not to look into Russia interference?
We can’t have honest conversations with the tories as a party. The tories have let thousands die due to negligence and incompetence.
Ban The Tories!
Oh cut the Russia phobia bs.. it’s wearing off. There has been no clear evidence of this but used a political tool and false narrative to mislead the public. When ever Labour or Conservative disagree with any organisation it’s Russia interference nonsense. Why do people blindly fall for this lie. The MSM cannot be relied on.. do your own research people. Just watch when Trump wins it will be Russia interference bs again.
Thousands will factually die as a result of winter fuel payments being cut...
Each party worse than the other
@@delbertsingh9469 There’s Russia phobia and then there’s our former prime minister (as foreign secretary I believe) ditching his security team to party with the son of a former KGB spy with ties to putin.
Starmer really is underwhelming.
Evidently "22 million pound black hole" has just about replaced "my father was a toolmaker"in the robot's dialogue programming
Do you remember, "There was no money left" after Gordon Brown?
They still used that earlier this year and it's still false
@@SaintWill70 George Osborne, who was Conservative chancellor after Labour in 2010 said it was a lie in an interview 2 years ago.
I didn't need to be there, it's well known.
Unfortunately for the conservatives, this black hole Starmer is talking about is real, because they didn't want to reveal the shortfall before the election
@randomdaveUK 100% right, though shamefully on both parties it's just another example of how little there is to separate them
@@SaintWill70 George Osborne admitted it was a lie mate, didn't have to be there. He said so in an interview go check it out
@@rickmartin5288 agreed it's the politics at play. Labour are looking to brand the Tories as being a disaster for the economy and the country. They need the branding to stick and stay fresh in the mind in 5 years time.
Thing is, Labour need to actually achieve change within 5 years or they'll look no better
I support the employee rights bill, but seriously can either of them have a front on front rational arguement about economics.
Not just jabs at each other on a personal level.
It's maybe an unpopular decision after the past few months but I'm actually really impressed by Starmer. I mean, he's somehow managed to make me like Sunak more than him - that has to count for something, right?
Time to enact compulsory voting in the UK like Australia. This rabble would have never got in
Yes they would. England is not a fascist nation and the Tories can't pretend they're not trying to push the nation into it, since 2015 because what Nigel Farage does looks like fun, much to the annoyance of their traditional, sensible, conservative voters.
The Tories don't want compulsory voting. If they did, they would have brought it in, given they have been the dominant party in the UK. It's the same reason the Tories like FPTP, because it has served them well, up till now. They also brought in voter ID, which is another barrier to voting. As for Labour, they should promote PR, because it's a fairer voting system. They won't of course, now they have a huge majority.
Sunak is much better
How does starmer make rishi look likeable?
Did you know that the conservatives left a 22bn black hole? That’s all Starmer ever says…. “Boring… Boring…”
@@SaintWill70 ohhhh no I didn’t. I’ve got more sense than that. I knew labour getting in would be chaos. It just baffles me how people voted for them.
@@dpukkz_bbqwhat is this "chaos" exactly. Nothing we havent seen with the tories. Apart from wfa cut
@@chindit6784 totally agree, the tories weren’t great. But it’s pretty clear that this labour government is no longer for the working people and are completely unrecognisable to their roots from old.
Kier never has any answers, just goes on about a 22bn black hole.
Labour had a plan to prevent fuel price rises… fuel prices have gone up since.
Labour hammered Rishi about his plans for WFA cuts and hurting pensioners, then got into power and did exactly that.
Personally preparing for hikes in taxes they promised weren’t going to be increased too.