Without coachella, world will never seen le sserafim's 100% live performance. Even during encore and local music shows, they all lipsyncing and use backups. They never released recording behind
@@malou1969oh you’re so dramatic. Let them fall a little and gain more experience. They weren’t that bad and let them learn from mistakes. So stupid that they should “stop performing “. That’s not real life. People can improve with more experience and practice.
Like what xuimin of exo advice to new idols “ DANCING ISN’T THAT IMPORTANT. SINGING IS THE MOST IMPORTANT. IF YOU CANT SING WELL, NO MATTER HOW GOOD YOU ARE AT DANCING, YOU WON’T LOOK TALENTED”
@@ZenenraDaniya "So" if Le Sserafim had listened they would not now be facing derision and humiliation. That industry is currently tough enough without being known as the group that can't sing.
They fucked up by not adjusting the performance routine. It’s just plain dumb to go to a LIVE singing festival with the usual choreo intensive routine. Look at JHope in Lolla, he’s a great dancer but picked and chose when he would dance and go hard. Ended up being an iconic performance.
Newjeans did the same at Lolla and it worked really well - I’m surprised they didn’t adjust the songs properly for the festival setting especially since they have a lot of intense choreography.
I disagree, Ateez were able to sing and dance and they performed fine, same with txt in Lolla. So I don’t think the problem is just the dancing being hard, I think they sadly just don’t have consistency when it comes to there live vocals.
@@Mitchis_Euphoria i agree, i havent seen ateez or txt performance but i havent seen any bad commets so i assume it was good.... But what i do know is that bts has sang Dionysus, IDOL and other songs with hard choreos and have done a good Job so i dont understand wha hybe is not training LS to do good. BTS? they were trained and they modify stuff when need it and NJ also modified stuff... so why cant LS? And idk if i can even blame source bc common... they had GFriend, i ws not a fan but they were good
@@Dream-kp7bf I would say using BTS as a compare is tough. Their medleys in concert go 4 songs straight of hard high energy songs. But even then they only pick and choose spots that they do hard choreo. Gfriend never performed at a festival. I haven’t seen ateez perform but if they did good I would think they chose strategically when to dance and when to sing. Like look at JKs Times Square performance, he was awesome but totally dying after each song. He smartly placed a slow song after each fast one. You gotta be smart about this. Doing the same choreo doing back arches and crawling on the floor while supposedly singing at a festival doesn’t even fit the atmosphere. They want vocals. It’s not MNET.
If you do not have that great vocal yes don't do a performance like a dance Crew. But the reality is dancing didn't translate to a good performance cuz the reality is vocal is the most important in everything! You don't have to break the bones to have a great performance.😅
And how old is mamamoo? Look I don’t doubt they were just as good when they debuted and I’m not familiar with their music completely however I do know lesserafim and like it is said in this video they are great performers and singers. They are not the best since they are more performance based. Just look at Sakura she has 10 years of being an idol and yes she is lacking in the vocal performance however she is good at saeling an image. An idol, is much more than just a good singer. I’m sure mamamoo is both good performers and singers but that is an exception to the rule. Just look at ATEEZ they also performed and their stage was t even critiqued as much as lesserafim.
Exo jumped around, danced, ran across the stage, even danced in water and still sounded great. Ateez’s Coachella performance was so good. They danced hard with the wind hitting them and out of breath and their vocals were still good. If you’re going to perform at one of the biggest music festivals you better be really good. You’re not only performing for your fans but for people who enjoy music. Rosie from Black Pink crawled on the floor between the members legs and vocals were still great. Beyoncé dances and runs around and still perfection
@@liekhan9woah bp, exo, Beyonce flop?????!!!!! Are you newbie? 🤣🤣 Meanwhile Sakura who 3x debut but still not improves. Come on men 3x and 11 years and still singing like a newbies
I think what makes their performance quite bad is because they don't have solid vocals to begin with and they added a very demanding choreography on top of it.. If they have Beyonce level vocals that's when they could add those demanding choreography... They should have stick to the vocal training before they add those fancy choreo..
thats wht im saying after watching so many of their encores u can tell they arent vocally strong so instead of giving better vocal training they are givin g them such difficult choreo like HYBE is doing the same with ILLIT their vocals arent also that good
True, it’s obvious that these girls aren’t very secure in their vocal abilities even without the dancing. So for them to have an even higher demanding choreo, doesn’t solve any problem for them. The company should start focusing on making these girls be more confident in their vocal abilities first.
Indeed. They are singers, not dancers. So, they should tone down their choreo and focus more on singing. They should've put it on their priority list. Their performance is not that disastrous but it is bad. Hybe should really invest on their vocal lessons. It is not just Le Sserafim who we're criticized and trended on wrong way bcoz of their vocals. It is already numerous Hybe groups.
That one! It kinda became an industry wide problem as the generations continued. It’s completely normal to not sing stable while crawling bending backwards doing backflips and all that jazz, but even without that they just decent singers not extremely bad, but also not as good as we are used to from earlier generations. People used to eat Taemin alive for his lacking vocally and I’m convinced that nowadays he can’t easily keep up with the newer idols even outsing many of them. It’s just that vocal lessons don’t seem to be that important anymore. It makes sense with the shift in the industry but what we have then are idols straining their vocals, not having fully control over their singing and hurting themselves constantly. This performance just shows the bigger problem we have on hand and they shouldn’t get dragged like that. It’s something we see a lot with later 4th gen and 5th groups but especially in HYBE girl groups. New Jeans gets the same flag and even ILLIT they not even a month old and people are bashing them for that
HYBE is just a factory that keeps cloning out new versions of New Jeans at this point, they don’t care about the artists and what actually suits their voices and their skill level… 🫠
What’s crazy to me is if you compare them to Ateez who had choreo that was more difficult and were running all over the stage. The vocals were still stable. The performance aspect overall was phenomenal. So I have to wonder what’s going on at Hype that these girls weren’t prepared enough. And I hate to see people giving them excuses. “Oh they were tired”, “oh the wind and dust.” BlackPink didn’t have those issues. Aespa didn’t have those issues. Even tho I’d say Aespa was placed on the Coachella stage too early in their career. Either way, I hope this provides a wake up call for the girls and the company.
They can't compare because Ateez actually had Backtracks and back vocals for all the singers even some times for the rapers and that's fine and smart, because they would sound exactly like this without them, but they actually do smarter, they sound good because they know how to play with the back vocals, it's not a real live, like le sserafim but it's effective. And I'm not saying that they can't sing or nothing like that they can and really good, but with that choreos they need to have that live recording moments, because it's imposible in any other way.
@sicatsz yes, he sings espectacular, but when he sings high notes he is not dancing for a reason, and even in that he has backing vocals, if you heard with attention you could notice that, and for the other members there are times that even don't sings certain phrases in the Coachella live, but it's because they're dancing, and that's reasonable for everything that i say previously.
@@camiloeduardchubrown8156they have backtracks, but they were singing live and ppl who have ears can easily point that out. They know when to go all out in dancing and when to kinda lie low to focus on singing. But u really cannot compare cuz ateez has been singing live since they were rookies and they are literally the sons of immortal songs which only allowed live stages. They were practicing their vocals for their whole carreer, not only dance and performance, unlike what most of 4th gen kpop are doing rn.
them fans be like "she's getting better in singing" like brooo is your standards that low, they better stay in the studio and not sing live cause people have expectations, that'll be a waste of moneyyyy 👁️👄👁️
Y’all sound so fuckin dumb saying shit like this 😂😂 they were invited to Coachella and they’re only gonna get more successful and the crowd enjoyed it. That is literally ALL that matters, y’all criticism is literally WORTHLESS they are growing as a group AS WE SPEAK. And this coming from someone who doesn’t even care for kpop I just happened to come across this.
agree!! the agency is so messed up, how can they give a hard choreo for the girls if they can't even keep up with the vocals. they need to practice harder for the vocals or give them simpler choreo so they can be more stable in singing live.
nah the girls are at fault, how is hybes fault that they cant sing, the so called opera singer couldnt hit a singke note and lets not forget the iconic "vICtOry"
@kkurakisseverybody bro shut up voices on kpop are very different and yunjin voice is the most avg kpop voice she was literally struggling thru the whole performance, even sakura was more stable then her,
They did some rushed vocal lessons prior to coachella but you can not suddenly make people improve their breathing and singing technique cause they're not talented geniuses who improve leaps and bounds in just a short time. I don't know how they handle their breaks, maybe they just chill instead of making efforts to improve their singing. I do know Sakura has improved a bit but she's into crocheting more than singing, or she already hit her limits in her vocal talents.
fans always defend with "it's normal to bad at live singing because their choreo is hard" is ridiculous. y'all should check SNSD's debut with INTO THE NEW WORLD IN 2007. They had an intense choreo but they sang the song live so well. NMIXX also had a hard choreo but they can sing live. stop normalized this. idols have to sing is a bare minimum skill they should have.
@@PikaChu-uz4su if you insist lol check them out, they sing live when they are still a rookie with such a choreo. th-cam.com/video/T28Av5QZtUc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=_dh-yeERK7UVwP4v
those who are making excuses are not helping these girls actually. They need to know the truth and accepts criticism and realize it for their own improvements.
@@PikaChu-uz4suokay how about ateez then? They dance so hard and yet still manage to get a stable voice. Stop defending ur idol and stop being denial. UR IDOL HAVE A TERRIBLE VOICE
@@PikaChu-uz4su i mean.. does it even matter when they came from a generation where lipsync wasn't that popular yet. you can watch their you think performance as a better example.
They did much better week end 2. But what you see or heard online is really true that Week end 1 about their vocals was super unstable and their voice cracked on quite a few part. So its really true they struggled 100% on weekend 1. If you watch and compare you will know. Week end 2 was fire for sure though. They took all that hate and criticism on their vocals for week 1 and stepped up for weekend 2 . Their choreography intensively is a lot less energetic compare to week 1 probably most likely to focus more on their vocals. They was super crazy and energetic on week end 1 and that might cause them to be unstable. If you want to watch the HD quality, You can still watch it on coachella youtube channel sahara stage just rewind it back until sunday mid night its all gone. I really think cause its their first coachella they gone a bit over the top on their dancing so it backfired on their vocals on weekend 1 haha
For a new group to be able to dance for 40 minutes while singing at that and keeping up the energy I commend them last time i saw that bts had to lay on the floor for 2 minutes k pop ain’t easy
Im sorry, its not kpop😂 but hybe .. if you follow from first generation until now its really different, their senior know how to sing live because in tv show they have to sing live no matter what..and this new generation can lipsing all the time😂
Pop and choreos aren't for live ??? I've watched BLACKPINK and aespa and they served...aespa really needs to be appreciated they're just 1 yr & 4 months that time despite being nervous their vocals are soo good.
Right, the hate aespa got for their coachelle performance was absolutely overblown and undeserved. Stable and strong vocals and it was their first performance in front of a live crowd. They were clearly not very comfortable yet but their live execution was good. Aespa's strength is def their vocals and technical skills rather than stage presence and hype, but they can still crush their own songs and they did grow in that area a lot since. As a disclaimer, Im not particularly a fan of BP but I def think that BP has notably better stage presence than aespa, however that doesnt make aespa's performance a bad one. And BP themselves can also crush their own songs live, which is what is setting these groups apart from LSF imo.
@@geniusss4 did you even read their post? No one said BP didnt sing. Even LSF sang the first weekend. But opening your mouth and producing a sound doesnt necessarily make you a good singer. (to clarify, I am NOT saying BP are bad singers at all. Just pointing out how youre saying nothing new)
You know it's bad when Entire Korea had "Blackpink Coachella" Trending Instead of Them ......Just go to Blackpink's Coachella performance once and there are 1000s of comments sayings that they went there to Cleanse there ears after this Mess .......hybe really set them up .
@@strawkittyxoxo Yeah BABYMONSTER will absolutely do well with their singing too if they perform in Coachella because they were trained for years. I mean I don't blame LE SSERAFIM because it's not their fault that they sang bad but the blame should all go to Hybe because they didn't prepare them well for Coachella, shame on HYBE! And please don't hate LE SSERAFIM, just send them love and support
@@MadaraxUchiha I mean its kinda girls fault too, u can't say tht they didn't train them sakura has been in the industry for almost 11 years and yunjin was an opera singer, they have more experience then some 3rd gen idols..
@@strawkittyxoxou are so deluded in ur little bubble. nobody tryna be the next bp🤡and babymonster aint eating nobody up with their trash reject bp songs
i would have agreed with what you guys’ opinions if i didn’t see le sserafim straining and having no technique in singing even when staying completely still. so no its not just a choreography problem
I feel like this group also has no "i recently debuted" excuse. How long have they been on already? Like almost 3 years. And I think even at debut, you need to have a cretain skill level to debut ( which is also fkd now in kpop ). Look at Ateez's mama 2019 performance, they were a one year old rookie group and that performance was live as fk and stable. Jongho was even singing a song in female key and didnt miss a note. And there are more examples of actually good live groups. Svt, mamamoo, gidle, bts. This group and many others really have no excuse to suck. I am sorry for the bad words, but really in the nicest way possible I hope the standards goes higher.
girls' generation's debut song says it all. there are group of people who are trained and capable of doing this crazy continuous dance and singing along. just because some ppl can't doesn't mean it's impossible to do.
I THINK THE BIG 3 (SM , JYP AND YG ) ARTIST ARE WELL TRAINED AND CAN SING LIVE WHILE DANCING THEY ALSO MATCH THE CHOREO IN ORDER FOR THE ARTIST TO SING IT BETTER DURING LIVE ..
Come out of your big 3 bubble, there are many artists from smaller labels who can sing & dance at the same time. Prime example is ATEEZ, nobody touch them when it comes to live performances, dance, singing, facial expressions, stage presence, they're a power pack combo.
For the standards you mentioned, I feel like they're totally realistic because all we want is stable live VOCALS. They could literally cut their choreo in half and no one would care as long as they sound half decent. They're SINGERS for God's sake! We've seen this being done in previous generations with Shinee, 2NE1, TVXQ, EXO, Seventeen, & Mamamoo, so why exactly shouldn't we expect the same live experience from newer groups? Hoping to get your money's worth in a concert and not have your ears bleed and face cringe shouldn't be unrealistic for concrt-goers, especially since these idols supposedly "train" for years to perfect the art of singing and dancing at the same time. There are so many groups who sing while running to become more stable so I don't see why these groups should get a pass for slacking. Other groups are working just as hard if not harder. Anyways, those were my two cents, don't be too bothered by it
Hate to break it to you, but the kpop industry prioritizes catchy songs, choreos, visuals, fits, and fan service. We are seeing more hope with NMixx(greatest girl group past or present when performing live sing and dancing stably), KOL, ZB1, VVUP, UNIS, Triple S, StayC, etc. so that’s a good sign. Previous generations had much less groups and you don’t see the bad ones that couldn’t sing since there were fewer popular ones like Shinee and TvXQ who could perform live stably. The reality is those older gens had terrible groups that people didn’t pay attention to. Older gens might have performed more lives with little back tracks, but there were also many bad live performances too along with bad groups in non big 3
@@inquisitvem6723 bad groups didn't survive in gen 1 and gen 2, only the top groups get recognized. that's what you call quality management which is apparently inexistent in today's kpop fandoms.
@@lulukeran2020 like i said, there were many bad groups in early gens whether they were weeded out is irrelevant. Point was early Gen was no better. Also, even if a group had vocal talent like KISS & CRY , they couldn’t tackle what the big 3 had which was $ and leverage on music shows. It was hard for any non big 3 group to survive even if they were talented. BTS fortunately found another way. BTS had experienced it first hand being discriminated on music and variety shows to promote themselves and took the bold move of using any avenue social media as much as they could to get their name out there. It turned out to be a shrewd move that changed the industry which is how all groups use these days with their own vlogs and doing skits writhing their company. They broke the mold of control by big 3. Even to this day, you don’t see BTS on many variety shows out there because they do mostly in house. What they did was show proof that you didn’t need big 3 money to promote. Nowdays the money is too good to pass up, so companies crank out groups left and right. Still, it’s always never been vocals as #1 priority as a whole.
We all know that no performance is perfect but there is a certain expectation and standard to be met especially at COACHELLA. Just take a look at Blackpink’s Coachella performance. They managed to dance and sing at the same time and people LOVED it so much with all the stage presence they are giving. They are the GOLD standard.
@@dangzitspro Edit: Sorry for the word vomit lol Objectively speaking, yes they were able to perform while singing and dancing, but the only groups I can think of that blackpink was better than is Aespa & Le Sserafim. The likes of Ateez, 2NE1, The Rose, Epik High and other K-soloists gave a better performance in my opinion. Just being able to hit the notes 70% of the time does not make someone "The GOLD" standard. For instance, if u look at the kpop acts in the industry rn, u'd be able to realize just how high the standard some groups have set in terms of vocals, stage presence, and choreography as well as performances. My vocal trinity consists of EXO, MAMAMOO, and BTOB, where all the members, at the least, are proficient vocalists and have an understanding of technique (meaning they can hold a note for more than 5 seconds), which is more than what some of the newer groups' main vocalists can do. Seventeen, Mamamoo, Got7 and MonstaX along with NMixx, 2PM, TVXQ and SNSD are all beasts on stage. If u ever saw them perform, u'd realize just how limited ur idea of a good performance is. Plus, Blackpink has never really stood out among their peers when performing at festivals where other idol groups were present as well, and only go viral for shows where they were either the only K-act performing or among K-indie artists, which prevents the audience from making any type of comparisons and an overall better opinion of them (not saying they aren't good, but they're not all what their fans hype them to be - I've seen WAY better in kpop)
That’s why I think yg and sm have the best singers. This is why their training is so hard especially yg. Look at Baby monster,they can absolutely sing, and yg made sure of that with their monthly evaluations. Even JYP is hard on his vocalists, it might come out as mean but this is what he’s trying to avoid. Also the fact that hybe choreos are not the easiest doesn’t help them catch a breath. ATP most K-pop companies are just debuting dancers and idols who have the looks not actual singers, which is what the music is actually about.
Everyone always says hybe has bad vocals when singing live. Hybe is not just one company, but there is an agency within it. Not all the artists/idols there sing badly, maybe I think their girl groups are the ones who lack vocals. Just complain to their agency Soumu, Ador, and Belift, don't let all the artists in the hype get involved. They are one company but their agency system is different and the way they manage their artists is also different.
@@rinaervinajuliyanti9585 well yeah but the groups that have good vocals are the ones they debuted earlier, which is the boy groups but imo I think they rushed to debut their newer groups, they have really good and catchy songs but they just debuted looks/visuals tbh
That's why Blackpink did a special simplified choreo for the performances. YG managers were always the best in terms of live performance. Why such a huge company as Hybe can't understand the simple things 🤔
I don't think it's about simple or hard Choreo . Lsf can't sing properly while even standing . I have seen those encores .......As for Blackpink.....no doubt that they r Really good stage commanders and performers . Even while Dancing their vocals are really stable .
@@Xoxo78941 ofc it is? Also bps songs r always in the same pattern rap, bridge, chorus and again rap, bridge, dance break ( no singing buncha ratatatat and dumdum). Which is how each member can focus in jst one thing, rose and jisoo jst sing bridges while Jenni and Lisa raps, their chorus r mostly edms, now serrafims each song have a very very different vibe, each requiring constant singing, and don't forget the choreos, y can't u view it that way? I'd say it's the company's fault, bps songs r loud, which is why they sound good even when they yell in their rap parts, serrafim don't have typical kpop rap they barely honestly, and their choruses always have lyrics, also different song patterns. Yea the encore was bad, but now they sound much better even with energetic dancing, idk yall here jst to hate not to criticise
@@nazunaw Blackpink's Song This ....Blackpink's song that ....yet no kpop idols can sing and perform them except few . And my point still stands that lsf Can't sing even while standing. So i don't know what nonsense u r yapping abt lmao.
I think its too soon for them to perform in coachella, it must be overwhelming for them. Yes they had a huge impact in music industry but if their die hard fans would just reason out that it is because of their choreography, i think its not. When they say that bp can perform well bcoz bp has an easy choreo, i would definitely disagree. BP performed their songs well and also if others can see, BP even come up with a choreo in every song they performed and also they improve rheir choreo in their last coachella performance.
@@Xoxo78941 y'all barely read anything and say yapping lmao. Ok listen here kindergartener, All I'm saying is bp's song pattern are always same, EDM choruses and dance break with dumdumdum. Bp's management team did a good job in showcasing the girls visual and charisma in Coachella. Serrafim known for its hard choreo, and every song had a different vibe to it, right? difficult dances, melodious tones, lows and high notes. Serrafims songs are also much clamer than of Bp's loud songs and rap. Which is prolly why they didn't skip dancing. Yea Sakura sounded bad on encore but let's talk abt the improvement!! Sakura in Coachella is serving with her energetic dance plus better vocals than standing still in encore. It can be seen that they worked hard for it. Raw vocals with no backtrack, singing and dancing for whole 40mins.
tbh I don't think the expectations were high, we just wanted the bare minimum,i.e. stable vocals, which kpop groups have been able to accomplish before while singing live while dancing, with no backtrack (eg: ateez,mamamoo, aespa,nct,nmixx, to name a few.) No one expects them to sound like taeyeon or wendy. Two things could've been done here,1)sing with a back track, or 2) tone down the choreo, and neither was done. I'm really not sure what hybe was thinking. They have great songs but they were not ready for Coachella.
@@KpopNiDontStop The best thing they said was about backtracks. Thats why performances vs encores differ vastly. Its too unrealistic to be dancing and singing at the same time.
K-pop stans confuse me. On one hand you have people defending terrible encores where they’re standing still and on the other hand they lose their minds when the vocals aren’t there during a performance that’s completely live. I was honestly expecting this to be a whole lot worse, at least the energy was there. And I think you’re right, fans are so used to convincing themselves that lip syncing is a live vocal that this is a shock to the system
Chaewon and yunjin (she only was shaky at the beginning maybe due to nerves or excitement, but she did well afterwards, and she does kno how to sing usually, so let's not lump everybody together and exaggerate like that)
@@MidnightxCrow Honestly I was shocked when I found out yunjin is the main vocalist, cause how can you sound so shaky and off pitch throughout the performances. I've followed them for a while now and am always left disappointed by their vocals. Chaewon seems to be the only one carrying the vocals in the group.
@@MidnightxCrowI checked their uni fes performances back when they were just debuted and I thought yunjin sounds bad live. Like she screamed maybe to be heard clearer but it just sounds out of tune for me. Boy i was surprised when I found out she’s the main vocalist
@@MidnightxCrowyunjin at times was just screaming. I get it she was hyped but even in the smart line “lesserafim to victory” which is not hard to sing, she sounded so off key. Girl can sing I mean she was an opera singer but I definitely think lesserafim songs don’t do her justice
I agree with the fact that the bar is especially high for Coachella but…. that’s because the other groups that came before set that bar. Blackpink came in and absolutely killed it. Ateez dominated it. 2NE1 literally brought it and set it on fire 🔥 And Ik there were mixed opinions on Aespa but regardless of personal opinions if they were ready or not Aespa still danced AND sung beautifully simultaneously. The fact is Le Ssarifim seems to have been the only one having this hard of a time with doing both. The bar was set high because the artist before them have gone above and beyond expectations. I don’t thinks it’s exactly logical to blame “ the bar” as you put it when only one group hasn’t been able to even hit close to the expectation.
they had everything going for them, their energy, charm and presence was through the roof, they really looked like they were having fun and the band was the cherry on top. However, I think it would be much better if the choreography was simplified for this stage especially because there was little backtrack for them and they couldn't rely on it to regulate their own breathing...
i love LSF too but die hard stans need to face reality... vocally they really not up to par, even when u say they dancing and singing at the same time is hard, they should be trained for that cuz that's their job. u are a top idol group in the kpop industry with international audience, if you wanna be up there on a coachella stage with some of the biggest names in teh world u need to get better than this. i blame HYBE for this. a company that is slowly losing its soul, they knew the stage is a live band to begin with but still threw the girls under the bus even tho they know they not quite ready yet.
I stan the new Group UNIS recently, they really devoured the stages they went to. And i just recently known that some were not a trainee or no long trainee days except that some of them are in the entertainment indistry but not kpop tho.. just wow they can deliver
@@saksa-k985 Wow, you got me there. UNIS was the reasons my standard changed in kpop. They only have 2 months to prepare for debut but they already have 5 songs with choreos. And they can deliver. Visuals are really balanced and diverse.They have their own colours (Colors of eight, reference from dopamine chorus) Plus they can sing live which is the core of being an idol. I'm not flaming any group. Its just that this one is a fresh breathe of air.
I don't stan either group but Ateez is literally performing next to them and they don't have those same 'issues' with their vocals?? If you talk about choreo then Ateez's is even more tiring than lssf's and they were singing stable even after drinking alcohol. I think the hate people are giving lssf is wrong but you can't say that they aren't truly lacking in the vocal department. Yes, lssf is more of a 'performer' group like Itzy than a 'singer' group like Aespa, but they should at least have decently stable singing like Itzy. Criticize them for their weak vocals all you want, at least they can sing live pretty similar to the studio version every single time.
But broo This is the thing about obessession fans are talking about . I feel like people are sooo busy in hating le Sserafim that they forgot about Ateez only which is not suppose to happen.
@kkurakisseverybody lsf has two of their members who debuted in the same time as atz, also when atz did their first world tour in 2019, literally 4 months old rookies, they were already singing live and stable and for several stops too. There's literally no excuse for them, unless they weren't getting vocal lessons the same way on how they get dance lessons (this is one is on hybe/source). I do not condone the hate, but the constructive criticisms are, in fact, valid.
@kkurakisseverybody Fine, then let's not bring up Ateez. Aespa is also a girl group with similar physiques as Lssf. They performed Black Mamba as one of the first songs, where the choreo requires them to drop to the ground in the chorus, which is just as hard as Antifragile's choreo, also one of the first songs performed. You can't defend their difference in live vocals with the boy group excuse. Honestly, I'm not expecting lssf to have the SM level of vocals, but look at Itzy. They got bashed for their vocals too, but at least they can replicate it live.
@kkurakisseverybodyBffr my dude. They all had to work hard to make their debut ( normally ). Idols are supposed to be average at the very least or above average vocally in order to debut. Lsf are not rookies anymore but how is it that newer group from the BIG3 already surpassed them in any domain ??
I think the hate really stemmed from the encores at music shows in Korea. That started it all. Then suddenly they went to Coachella where they need to sing live and dance and the standards for the performers are different from Korea. Wale and Efra was right with stating it was the management's fault for not preparing the girls' set better with adjusting the choreo, when not to dance and just sing. So sad for the hate they are getting when it's ultimately the management's fault.
I don't know if you guys know, but shinee sing and dance at the same time and they good. Why? Because they train together running and singing, so when they dance they know how to breathe
@@clockon9929where did you get that information from? According to google it’s the exact opposite. Y’all shouldn’t make up sex/gender based things as an excuse.
No.....bc it gives fans the excuse that they were dancing, thats why their vocals weren't good....lmao. Like the girls weren't criticized a month ago for their music show encore where they were just STANDING there. They can't sing, dancing or not.
Y’all this type of live singing for coachella was done wayy better by Ateez in 2024 and Aespa ate with their live and of course BlackPink. It wasn’t 100% perfect but they were great enough but LeSserafim is obviously lower calibre literally only Chaewon was carrying the vocals and she wasn’t perfect but still I think the standard is her but Yujin who is also a main vocal was so bad. We all have been saying Hybe doesn’t focus on their vocals they don’t do well even in the encores.
I totally agree.They are beasts performing live on stage. Their performance at AAA awards show and their live performance in Wish bus 107.5 radio attests to their vocals…
and they are POP even BINI is POP it's just the yare more working harder than these people who have silver spoon on their mouths because they have BIG AGENCY backing them up
I was there. They were real bad. They danced well but their vocals were not good. Out of tune, lack of stability…I think they need more vocal training. Comparing this to BP’s 2019 Sahara performance, there’s a huge gap. You guys are too nice. You should revisit Blackpink’s performance from 2019 under the same conditions. I was also at BP’s 2019 Coachella performance and they killed it which is why BP became more popular in the west and got more followers. 👀
@@Diwwiyat Yes there was a very subtle splitting but their vocals carried through very loudly and were stable. BP was ready for their performance with plenty of training and experiences throughout the years…
YG built BP (and now BM) to tour, HYBE builds girl groups for the studio. YG spends years identifying and then training their idols. HYBE throws together their groups quickly with virtually no training whatsoever. Saturday night's result was a foregone conclusion the moment LSF was announced in Jan. BTW, I have a recording of BP's 2019 performance which I regularly listen to to this day. An example of how to do it right.
We all know that no performance is perfect but there is a certain expectation and standard to be met especially at COACHELLA. Just take a look at Blackpink’s Coachella performance. They managed to dance and sing at the same time and people LOVED it so much with all the stage presence they are giving. They are the GOLD standard.
They did much better week end 2. But what you see or heard online is really true that Week end 1 about their vocals was super unstable and their voice cracked on quite a few part. So its really true they struggled 100% on weekend 1. If you watch and compare you will know. Week end 2 was fire for sure though. They took all that hate and criticism on their vocals for week 1 and stepped up for weekend 2 . Their choreography intensively is a lot less energetic compare to week 1 probably most likely to focus more on their vocals. They was super crazy and energetic on week end 1 and that might cause them to be unstable. If you want to watch the HD quality, You can still watch it on coachella youtube channel sahara stage just rewind it back until sunday mid night its all gone. I really think cause its their first coachella they gone a bit over the top on their dancing so it backfired on their vocals on weekend 1 haha
They shouldn't have sent them. Especially when people all around the world are watching them with hawk eyes for any mistake from their side. At this point they are getting bullied in the name of criticism.
@@aeondale011 ofcourse they can't. Besides the lineup was announced before this whole scandal. It's just, it's bad. The hate is so bad. It's no longer criticism. It's bullying. The points are all valid yes. But the amount of hate?? Nah. Nobody deserves that.
@@MidnightxCrow I know dude. But looking at the hate they are getting I wish they didn't go. Though I know it's not possible. They improved. But haters be damned
What I saw in tiktok, and I think is also the reason for the criticism, they didn’t sing well even without dancing. But I also think is HYBE’s fault, they are focusing too much in the coreography and they forget all of the other aspects. Also the thing is that Illit didn’t do well in singing live, so that made it worse. Plus Babymonster did really well singing so they are comparing all of them. Really liked your review. I think is easy to hate but explaining like you did is what matters.
Not HYBEs fault dmbarse lol...how is it the agencys fault that the girls dont work hard? Its up to lessarfim to train and practice their vocals. Look at Bp, lazy work ethic and their lazy performances and poor lives were shown on their stages
@@TheTruthX7 tru... leaving on stage in the middle of the performances is very unprofessional too. they are seniors they should set good example to rookies
You will not wish to say that they are just impossible to dance and sing to hard choreos after watching TREASURE, BM, AESPA etc. They are also 4th and 5th gen but slays. I don't wanna compare to be honest. no hate but they train well in every aspect. Do you think someone can sing and dance all of a sudden. It takes time and effort but in Le serrafim's case, I don't think they have a good understanding of what practice and learning can do. Their instructors might be spoon feeding them just to hit the point and that's not gonna work. The band was set loud in order not to make a huge deal on their vocals but it is really visible that they did not do well. Their vocals were not only unstable in smart but also in other songs every single time and the adlibs were the worst of all. But, i do appreciate the effort.
i know its Far for PPOP for now, But i would want to see a PPOP Group to perform on Coachella~ BINI or SB19? i know Ppop is not that big like Kpop. but i know Ppop Would do Great With Live performance~
@@heavensky8706 yup! You r right. If us Filipino just unite, and appreciate more our local artist. We have the talent and all~ our artist just need more support.
I have always loved LE SSERAFIM and I love them still but it’s just a shame that they’re not able to keep up vocally. In terms of stage presence, they’ve got it in the bag. They should’ve gone to Coachella further in their career when the vocals have been more practiced and improved. It was too soon, vocally but performance wise they were ready (stage presence, choreo etc.)
@@chady1229 that’s literally what I said: they were ready performance wise, just not vocally. And it wasn’t as disastrous as people made it out to be but it wasn’t at the level it should’ve been
Completely agree with your point about unrealistic expectations in kpop- doing physically demanding/jumpy choreo will make vocals suffer because physics. And if the idols don't dance as well, they're "lazy" all of a sudden. Aka they just can't win. The only way this is going to get better is if the industry changes.
So as a person Who is very new to Kpop - I watched Lsf performance at coachella And since Blackpink was trending on X so i watched Blackpink's 2019 Performance of coachella also .........all i can say is....... There is a Reason why Blackpink is at the Top . I personally found Earth and sky difference not even in Vocals but also stage presence ........especially that Jennie Girl ......She's so fire and captivating omg . I think Lsf should really focus on singing more than dancing. Cause as a spectator I think Singing is more important than dancing. The girls are Very good Dancers i must say tho.
We want (G)I-DLE in Coachella! I think they can do well singing live and dancing at the same time 😁 I also think that you'll have a different opinion on this matter when it comes to (G)I-DLE 😎
so now our "a singer should be able to sing her own song" standard is unrealistic?? we don't ask them to be ariana or beyonce, we just want them to practice more in vocal department so they could sing their song.
I understand some of the criticism but they blatant hate that they received is not okay and should not be tolerated. I respect your opinions and criticisms thank you for sharing this video
Literally the hate is so forced. It’s okay to point out that they need more vocal training but they’ve mainly received hate, I can’t go to any LSF related post without someone in the comments mentioning their singing although it has no correlation to the post.
Completely agree, sadly, having a balanced viewpoint and looking at the overall picture is vanishingly rare on the internet these days 😂😂 glad this video at least was sensible. There was room for improvement in their vocals and I think their management could have done a lot more in terms of changing the choreo to support their vocals and adding more production. But I really don't think it was the dumpster fire that everyone is saying it was- I really enjoyed it overall!
You two are so completely sensible and realistic in your approach to this issue. Thank you for seeing both the positives and the negatives, as well as what could be expected onstage and what could never happen. The band was fantastic. The dancing was well done and some of the vocals were memorable. I think there were nerves at the beginning (Antifragile) but they worked through them alright and then it was just about endurance as they supported each other through the performance. I am looking forward to seeing Ateez this next weekend as I couldn’t see them Friday. Aside from a more staggered choreography that helps the performers deal with strong parts, Ateez is also 8 members vs. 5. That means more spread in line distribution and those extra seconds can mean a lot in regaining one’s composure. I would also say that I felt there were technical glitches song to song as the soundboard didn’t seem to activate microphones back to the same levels throughout the performance. This was probably not helped as they switched from handheld to headset partway through the performance but that seemed to be planned. With all that being said, and with all the complaints and finger pointing online, every comment I have seen from those who attended in person was that they put on a great show and the crowd was engaged. I think they can only do better this next weekend and should be able to walk away from Coachella with their heads held high. ❤ Thanks for a great reaction & evaluation
I am sorry. This is why I have to, have to, have to appreciate artist like beyonce. Beyonce did a damn hour and a half show at Coachella. Where she dances intensely and had vocal stabiliy right through, so stop making excuses. She has been doing that for 20 years. People need to start taking the art more serious. I petition for beyonce to give kpop some advice. I was utterly disappointed in this performance. Sigh!!!
i think hybe or especially sourcemusic should consider again about the realistic choreo. they still can have a good stage presence without running out of breath 💗 love the girls
totally agree with this is more of a company problem. specially their music producers too. The way they made some of their songs made it sound to not be sung live. I was watching that Perfect Night part and boy, I realized it's not meant to be performed live. I wish HYBE stop making these kind of music with too much vocal adjustments
Agree, I like both lsrf and ive and I think Starship, a medium-sized company, produce better songs that suits their idols better than Hybe, one of the biggest company in SK. Like are LSRF’s producers didn’t take into consideration about the member’s vocal range when they made songs? I mean sakura isn’t the singer of the century but she sounds decent when singing high pitched songs (like the songs Imase produced). I just think hybe needs to hire better producers tbh
@@SirBobM good for you. i dont like listening to songs that i cant distinguish which one of the singers are singing or whether if it's a robot or a person who is singing because of the huge amount of vocal adjustments
Easy listening song is good when U have headphones n in car but doesn't suitable on stage..when they trying to change instruments they look like trying to catch breath with live band..
@@blacksheep1069 totally agree. there are songs that are suited for own enjoyment, for headphones, car, phone speaker, and Perfect Night was that song. I didnt enjoy that live Perfect Night they did
Last time i seen a long k pop performance it was twice and bts sana fainted and members of bts had to lay down on stage for minutes k pop is really hard i would love to see the improvement of le serafim
Ateez showed how it’s done at Coachella. There’s actually groups that can dance hard choreography and still be stable live. Even after an hour. It is very possible, not everyone can be talented and work hard enough to achieve it though. My standards are high thanks to Ateez and Dreamcatcher. It can be done so I think what you’re saying is just an excuse tbh
People who defend them saying that they were doing so much and it was difficult to sing etc. Ateez did a lot too and somehow performed vocally way better. That means the girls were not prepared vocally for coachella and/or just lacked vocal performance.
i agree with you on this. but, we also have to keep in mind that the girls have only been a group for 2 years. Ateez has been a group since 2018, of course they're gonna perform better, that's a given.
@@vaehvebut sakura and chaewon also first debuted in 2018. And i sakura case even longer. Plus, Yunjin was in produce 48 which started before ateez debut. Only Kazuha and Eunchae didnt have experience, but at the same time, to be an idol, you need to go through a training period. So they should be ready the moment they debut. And even then, they have the easiest part of their songs. So really, no excuse here.
@KingKikikoi ateez vocal is only stable when they're standing still Like jongho have to stand still to hit his note Le Sserafim are literally jumping non stop so its mostly the choreo problem
hybe needs to stop making songs for virality and actually make songs that their artist can sign. I think this also come from acquiring demos and releasing them instead of them making their owns songs. Like their songs are not in their range at all. They should have adjusted their choreos and I feel like their band should have pulled back at times and vice versa, sometimes it was too overpowering or underwhelming. It’s also unfortunate that people thinks it’s okay for artists to to not be able to deliver vocally, in my opinion singing should always the number one priority and dancing second. It unfortunate that certain companies think otherwise.
Thank you for this reaction and for being so honest and fair. I respect you guys a lot. Also, thank you for not bashing the girls bc even if some of the criticism is valid, the unimaginable hate train the girls have been facing is too much and just mean and vile. There is too much hate in this world. We can express criticism and still remain respectful.
I feel soo bad for them imagine seeing your video somewhere and the comment section filled with how bad you are 😢 we should hype them up and cheer them to become greater❤
Its just that we can't control other people. It must be owerwhelming for them to perform in a new environment. I wish they could find hope in this circumstances and will continue performing while improving themselves.
This is what I’m saying! I totally agree with you. These girls are actually admirable for singing live the entire time🫡. The vocals are not perfect but it is raw and only natural as they’re losing steam while dancing 😊
yeah but a 17 year old should still as well as the rest be able to take criticism not hate ofc but actual critique and realize that hybe needs to quit producing visuyally appealing idols who only focus on dance and do it like jyp yg where theyre all rounders baemon do everything and are balanced nmixx as well. hybe hasnt produced really talented idols since newjeans and other than them u have to go to txt
Nothing to do with hybe dmbarse😂its the girls responsibility to work hard and practice vocals....look at bp. Bp have lazy work ethic and it showed on stage....jisoo and jennie the prime examples
I see where your coming from but aespa, atteez, blackpink as kpop groups who also performed at coschella they all did so well with live vocals and dancing and being stable.
The thing is we as stans aren’t often that delusional to assume that the vocals gonna sound like the recording, in general but especially while dancing that intensely. It’s as you said humanly impossible so you often have grace for that. That’s why fans of the newer generation don’t care much about live vocals while performances anymore, it’s the trade off you get for these intense dance performances. What happens here is that many didn’t expect them to be perfect, but they even underperformed vocally while the bar was already in hell. With all the love I have for them (they became one of my favorite groups the last couple of years) they seemed to have given up at some point and just gave us speech singing or rough notes. Lesserafim never had a strong vocal line like that and what kinda fuels the comments is that there isn’t much improvement despite being nearly 3 years in the industry. To be fair many idols stay stagnant in their abilities once they debut and if the hate train doesn’t hit them, but it’s a constant critism for them and I think much of the bitterness lies there.
yes like nobody expected them to sound perfect but for them to do even worse I was shocked! I expected them to adjust the chorus and performance to fit the Coachella stage but it’s unfortunate that singing is not held to the importance it should when it comes to certain groups
They should debut as dancers not singers.. they look like reciting a poem.. they sounds like an elementary student.. sometimes child singing is better than them
Looking at the comments and they totally don't understand the video hdjdjd i agree with all that they say, But the BIG PROBLEM HERE is that they throw le sserafim without ANY back vocal for like the 99% of the show, they could be done that and it would have been fine, like ateez, they have their back track and vocals for the singers and it's good, or for the main vocal he sings when he need, no dance and sing, it's just a completely honest movement from them (HYBE) or just a stupid desicion, because let me tell you 99% of kpop groups sound like this without all the support they have with Backtrack and back vocals
yeah but nobody sings live without a backtrack if ur a kpop group thats not the issue here in kpop u need bavk tracks or else it sounds horrible look at ateez bpink coachella they go hard on choreo in certain sections and ease up in others its a live performing skill to psce urself ur not meant to sing live 100 percent as fans we dont expect it either but in the parts that ur supposed to hit live if ur not doing that thats a skill issue and hybe a training and management issue cuz listen to bpink u could hear they were on the edge while singing but they still hit the notes 85 90 percent perfect throughout the whole set thats good training ssera have horrible training and i think the girls themselves need to try harder cuz standing still in a encore sounding that bad is unacceptable same with illit if ur gonna be a kpop idol u need to put in the work cuz its a tough job with yes unneccesary hate but also valid criticism if ur not performing up to par and hybe is just content with producing lack of talent newjeans is the only successful and talented group to come from there recently really since txt im not hating i understand they might hae had less backtravk and thats a hybe issue they have to have that if theyre gonna keep the same choreo but also in general they dont have a single vocal powerhouse or real talent eunchae was badly trained kazuha wasnt trained at all sakura should be good by now but her japanese training completely ruined her voice from akb or hkt whatever days and their horrible training but still she was in izone and ssera she should have improved like she did her dancing yunjin hasnt sounded good since debut era for some reason she makes no sense she was good but now did she stop training i know exo members for example went and asked for more vocal training years into debut even though theyre vocal kings they still wanna improve chaewon is just badly trained as well plus i feel shes trying to imitate western voices too much and it doesent suit her tone at all hybe doesent give them parts that optimize their voices aswell
@@chady1229 that is debatable, I hope I misunderstood you but you sound like sooo angry for some reason hdjs and, there is no comparison in this live performance with any other, not almost close, and yes they have to be quiet or stay still when they have to sing, but they didn't, they try to sing and dance almost all the time, and when they already want to sing without dancing they had breathing problems, but that's different from being a bad Singer, they can sing, they always have space to be better? yes, nobody deny that, and that's it's part of the growing process, but be a singer it's different from singing and dancing with that type of choreo at the same time, because it's physically impossible, and again it's shocking how the industry brainwashed people thinking that it was "really" bad, because almost 99% have never heard what an artist actually sounds like singing and dancing LIVE, because k-pop has always lied about "live performance" in shows or awards ceremonies and people really think that is a live performance. This is how a person sings and dances these choreos without any backtrack, and that's for any K-pop group there, almost 99% , we share some opinions, but the point of view it's different.
They overestimated lsfm and thought they would answer the critics by singing live without backtracks. It's ridiculous that hybe is so blinded by popularity that they aren't ready to take criticism. I predict that they gonna be the same even after 5yrs of debut
Thank you for expressing the realistic nature of live performances (especially at an outdoor festival) and the unrealistic expectations music shows and other heavily produced video content have caused. The girls did incredible and are undoubtedly talented. They will improve accordingly as they do more live performances, like many other groups have done before them.
@@FlorenceDoit000 As a fan following from the beginning, I could see how hard they worked and they put on a great performance for the crowd. Was it perfect? No. But people are greatly exaggerating saying it was terrible. Anyone can see they performed their butts off and had a lot of fun. You and others don’t have to be so hateful about it.
lol only low level and expendable employees in the real world gets a pass like this. Nevermind doctors or pilots, even plumbers can't afford to fk up this much on their jobs. But it's not the idols fault that their HYBE served underprepared and undercooked meals. They chose to be the McDonald's of the industry to make as much money as possible so here we are.
@@yukikteez8036 They are no less deserving than others and Coachella specially invited them. This group is less than 2 years old and this is their first major festival, performing for 40 minutes straight with a 2 minute break. Give them some grace. The adrenaline alone must have been so overwhelming. Haters really wanna nitpick everything to lift up their fave, saying it was a horrible set when it wasn’t. No one improves overnight and I’ve been watching the kpop industry for so long to know it takes time for groups to hone their live performances. They did a great job for weekend 1 and they will surely take valid critiques into account for weekend 2.
2nd gen Kpop groups are pretty great in performing in front of and engaging large crowds. Handheld mics with minimal to no vocal backing were common in the past. YGE groups gets flak for iffy or simplistic choreos, but their perfs still work and translate much better with a large crowd. Seems like it's part of their training.
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D5 | Summer | วันอาทิตย์ จะขิตหรือจะรอด!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-4JLNwQRK-Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Without coachella, world will never seen le sserafim's 100% live performance. Even during encore and local music shows, they all lipsyncing and use backups. They never released recording behind
Yap. rely on backtacking only. Stop doing live performances please, please,please!!!
Not just lesserafim but all kpop idols except in encores.
@@malou1969oh you’re so dramatic. Let them fall a little and gain more experience. They weren’t that bad and let them learn from mistakes. So stupid that they should “stop performing “. That’s not real life. People can improve with more experience and practice.
Like what xuimin of exo advice to new idols “ DANCING ISN’T THAT IMPORTANT. SINGING IS THE MOST IMPORTANT. IF YOU CANT SING WELL, NO MATTER HOW GOOD YOU ARE AT DANCING, YOU WON’T LOOK TALENTED”
But he nowhere we can see. So?
He had his time to shine and now is enjoying his life and money@@ZenenraDaniya
@@ZenenraDaniya a newbie in kpop industry has been detected 🤣
Lol do you even know who is he or which grp he is from💀@@ZenenraDaniya
@@ZenenraDaniya "So" if Le Sserafim had listened they would not now be facing derision and humiliation. That industry is currently tough enough without being known as the group that can't sing.
Fans defending artists that can't perform live are having the hardest time to swallow the truth right now. Stan talent, stan performers.
then,Stan LAPILLUS😂❤
then stan NMIXX
It's so hard defending them but they def need vocal training, esp the younger ones and yunjin 😢😢😢😢
Stan SB19
You want to see good performances? do invite
SB19 next year in that coachella.
THEY WERE NOT READY FOR COACHELLA..... IT'S A FACT
Say it loudly
u must be deaf 13:15
yes
As a fearnot, truth really hurts 😢
They fucked up by not adjusting the performance routine. It’s just plain dumb to go to a LIVE singing festival with the usual choreo intensive routine. Look at JHope in Lolla, he’s a great dancer but picked and chose when he would dance and go hard. Ended up being an iconic performance.
Newjeans did the same at Lolla and it worked really well - I’m surprised they didn’t adjust the songs properly for the festival setting especially since they have a lot of intense choreography.
I disagree, Ateez were able to sing and dance and they performed fine, same with txt in Lolla. So I don’t think the problem is just the dancing being hard, I think they sadly just don’t have consistency when it comes to there live vocals.
@@Mitchis_Euphoria i agree, i havent seen ateez or txt performance but i havent seen any bad commets so i assume it was good.... But what i do know is that bts has sang Dionysus, IDOL and other songs with hard choreos and have done a good Job so i dont understand wha hybe is not training LS to do good. BTS? they were trained and they modify stuff when need it and NJ also modified stuff... so why cant LS? And idk if i can even blame source bc common... they had GFriend, i ws not a fan but they were good
@@Dream-kp7bf I would say using BTS as a compare is tough. Their medleys in concert go 4 songs straight of hard high energy songs. But even then they only pick and choose spots that they do hard choreo. Gfriend never performed at a festival. I haven’t seen ateez perform but if they did good I would think they chose strategically when to dance and when to sing. Like look at JKs Times Square performance, he was awesome but totally dying after each song. He smartly placed a slow song after each fast one. You gotta be smart about this.
Doing the same choreo doing back arches and crawling on the floor while supposedly singing at a festival doesn’t even fit the atmosphere. They want vocals. It’s not MNET.
If you do not have that great vocal yes don't do a performance like a dance Crew. But the reality is dancing didn't translate to a good performance cuz the reality is vocal is the most important in everything! You don't have to break the bones to have a great performance.😅
Put Mamamoo up on the Coachella stage! They'll show you how to dance and sing live!
This what I say.... My ear is bleeding... It's disappointing
@@devilsabelbel9268 than don't listen lmao
And how old is mamamoo? Look I don’t doubt they were just as good when they debuted and I’m not familiar with their music completely however I do know lesserafim and like it is said in this video they are great performers and singers. They are not the best since they are more performance based. Just look at Sakura she has 10 years of being an idol and yes she is lacking in the vocal performance however she is good at saeling an image. An idol, is much more than just a good singer. I’m sure mamamoo is both good performers and singers but that is an exception to the rule. Just look at ATEEZ they also performed and their stage was t even critiqued as much as lesserafim.
That's what i'm thinking!!
Because they don’t have that hard choreos to do while singing like le sserafim does.
All the hate that aespa rookies got at Coachella, when there performences were amazing, all of them sound perfectly clear! 😭
Aespa was lacking in stage present at that time
@@nagisashiota6731 Their new album with Drama would kill it at Coachella. Aespa was a year too early
@@talonvo215 That's right. They can do better now
their 1st live audiences were the coachella after being virtually promoted, so yeah, a very early mistake
@@FolderName92 plus they were only given mics and a screen. no background dancers and had bare minimum set production. sm set them up
Exo jumped around, danced, ran across the stage, even danced in water and still sounded great. Ateez’s Coachella performance was so good. They danced hard with the wind hitting them and out of breath and their vocals were still good. If you’re going to perform at one of the biggest music festivals you better be really good. You’re not only performing for your fans but for people who enjoy music. Rosie from Black Pink crawled on the floor between the members legs and vocals were still great. Beyoncé dances and runs around and still perfection
Imagine.. Doin all that stuff but goes flopping hard
@@liekhan9calling exo, blackpink, Beyonce flop?? Ohh this must be yellow building stan
Blackpink not singing live
@@liekhan9woah bp, exo, Beyonce flop?????!!!!! Are you newbie? 🤣🤣
Meanwhile Sakura who 3x debut but still not improves. Come on men 3x and 11 years and still singing like a newbies
@@stephanies5389 only one flopped, exo
I think what makes their performance quite bad is because they don't have solid vocals to begin with and they added a very demanding choreography on top of it.. If they have Beyonce level vocals that's when they could add those demanding choreography... They should have stick to the vocal training before they add those fancy choreo..
thats wht im saying after watching so many of their encores u can tell they arent vocally strong so instead of giving better vocal training they are givin g them such difficult choreo like HYBE is doing the same with ILLIT their vocals arent also that good
True, it’s obvious that these girls aren’t very secure in their vocal abilities even without the dancing. So for them to have an even higher demanding choreo, doesn’t solve any problem for them. The company should start focusing on making these girls be more confident in their vocal abilities first.
Indeed. They are singers, not dancers. So, they should tone down their choreo and focus more on singing. They should've put it on their priority list. Their performance is not that disastrous but it is bad. Hybe should really invest on their vocal lessons. It is not just Le Sserafim who we're criticized and trended on wrong way bcoz of their vocals. It is already numerous Hybe groups.
That one! It kinda became an industry wide problem as the generations continued. It’s completely normal to not sing stable while crawling bending backwards doing backflips and all that jazz, but even without that they just decent singers not extremely bad, but also not as good as we are used to from earlier generations. People used to eat Taemin alive for his lacking vocally and I’m convinced that nowadays he can’t easily keep up with the newer idols even outsing many of them. It’s just that vocal lessons don’t seem to be that important anymore. It makes sense with the shift in the industry but what we have then are idols straining their vocals, not having fully control over their singing and hurting themselves constantly. This performance just shows the bigger problem we have on hand and they shouldn’t get dragged like that. It’s something we see a lot with later 4th gen and 5th groups but especially in HYBE girl groups. New Jeans gets the same flag and even ILLIT they not even a month old and people are bashing them for that
HYBE is just a factory that keeps cloning out new versions of New Jeans at this point, they don’t care about the artists and what actually suits their voices and their skill level… 🫠
Problem with HYBE GGs they need vocal training - LSF, ILLIT and NewJeans. There I said it
I agree.
Hybe is deaf man
Yeah I think the girl groups do but the boy groups are really good with vocals
More like they need better balanced choreos that don't cause them to go out of breath when singing.
Newjeans have decent vocals
What’s crazy to me is if you compare them to Ateez who had choreo that was more difficult and were running all over the stage. The vocals were still stable. The performance aspect overall was phenomenal. So I have to wonder what’s going on at Hype that these girls weren’t prepared enough. And I hate to see people giving them excuses. “Oh they were tired”, “oh the wind and dust.” BlackPink didn’t have those issues. Aespa didn’t have those issues. Even tho I’d say Aespa was placed on the Coachella stage too early in their career. Either way, I hope this provides a wake up call for the girls and the company.
They can't compare because Ateez actually had Backtracks and back vocals for all the singers even some times for the rapers and that's fine and smart, because they would sound exactly like this without them, but they actually do smarter, they sound good because they know how to play with the back vocals, it's not a real live, like le sserafim but it's effective.
And I'm not saying that they can't sing or nothing like that they can and really good, but with that choreos they need to have that live recording moments, because it's imposible in any other way.
@@camiloeduardchubrown8156did you hear jongho? come on.
@sicatsz yes, he sings espectacular, but when he sings high notes he is not dancing for a reason, and even in that he has backing vocals, if you heard with attention you could notice that, and for the other members there are times that even don't sings certain phrases in the Coachella live, but it's because they're dancing, and that's reasonable for everything that i say previously.
@@camiloeduardchubrown8156 even with dancing he’s still stable. It’s not excuse 🤷🏾♀️
@@camiloeduardchubrown8156they have backtracks, but they were singing live and ppl who have ears can easily point that out. They know when to go all out in dancing and when to kinda lie low to focus on singing. But u really cannot compare cuz ateez has been singing live since they were rookies and they are literally the sons of immortal songs which only allowed live stages. They were practicing their vocals for their whole carreer, not only dance and performance, unlike what most of 4th gen kpop are doing rn.
them fans be like "she's getting better in singing" like brooo is your standards that low, they better stay in the studio and not sing live cause people have expectations, that'll be a waste of moneyyyy 👁️👄👁️
People who were there and paid money for it enjoyed it, the only ones hating ,are jobless people like you.
Fr
In short, they are not vocally ready for Coachella, this is Hybe's wrong management. Poor girls.
Y’all sound so fuckin dumb saying shit like this 😂😂 they were invited to Coachella and they’re only gonna get more successful and the crowd enjoyed it. That is literally ALL that matters, y’all criticism is literally WORTHLESS they are growing as a group AS WE SPEAK. And this coming from someone who doesn’t even care for kpop I just happened to come across this.
agree!! the agency is so messed up, how can they give a hard choreo for the girls if they can't even keep up with the vocals. they need to practice harder for the vocals or give them simpler choreo so they can be more stable in singing live.
nah the girls are at fault, how is hybes fault that they cant sing, the so called opera singer couldnt hit a singke note and lets not forget the iconic "vICtOry"
@kkurakisseverybody bro shut up voices on kpop are very different and yunjin voice is the most avg kpop voice she was literally struggling thru the whole performance, even sakura was more stable then her,
They did some rushed vocal lessons prior to coachella but you can not suddenly make people improve their breathing and singing technique cause they're not talented geniuses who improve leaps and bounds in just a short time. I don't know how they handle their breaks, maybe they just chill instead of making efforts to improve their singing. I do know Sakura has improved a bit but she's into crocheting more than singing, or she already hit her limits in her vocal talents.
fans always defend with "it's normal to bad at live singing because their choreo is hard" is ridiculous. y'all should check SNSD's debut with INTO THE NEW WORLD IN 2007. They had an intense choreo but they sang the song live so well. NMIXX also had a hard choreo but they can sing live. stop normalized this. idols have to sing is a bare minimum skill they should have.
Was SNSD crawling on the ground or doing back bends while singing ITNW? Because i don’t remember them doing that 🤔
@@PikaChu-uz4su if you insist lol check them out, they sing live when they are still a rookie with such a choreo.
th-cam.com/video/T28Av5QZtUc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=_dh-yeERK7UVwP4v
those who are making excuses are not helping these girls actually. They need to know the truth and accepts criticism and realize it for their own improvements.
@@PikaChu-uz4suokay how about ateez then? They dance so hard and yet still manage to get a stable voice. Stop defending ur idol and stop being denial. UR IDOL HAVE A TERRIBLE VOICE
@@PikaChu-uz4su i mean.. does it even matter when they came from a generation where lipsync wasn't that popular yet. you can watch their you think performance as a better example.
Bro blackpink when they preformed for coachella it was clearly live and it was AMAZING
Exactly!
@@xox95that’s a matter of opinion. But I will say one that is not a popular one.
@@Blinky423 bp gets dragged every single day. and im glad🤗 armys really doing a blessing fr
@@xox95 AT least she sounds better than sakura 😂😂. Stage presence is way better and stronger plus u could hear her voice clearly.
@@caratsarecarating shes called stiffsoo for a reason 😘
It's not only about the voices being stable or them being tired, it's off pitch, there's no musicality, the tone...
They did much better week end 2. But what you see or heard online is really true that Week end 1 about their vocals was super unstable and their voice cracked on quite a few part. So its really true they struggled 100% on weekend 1. If you watch and compare you will know. Week end 2 was fire for sure though. They took all that hate and criticism on their vocals for week 1 and stepped up for weekend 2 . Their choreography intensively is a lot less energetic compare to week 1 probably most likely to focus more on their vocals. They was super crazy and energetic on week end 1 and that might cause them to be unstable. If you want to watch the HD quality, You can still watch it on coachella youtube channel sahara stage just rewind it back until sunday mid night its all gone. I really think cause its their first coachella they gone a bit over the top on their dancing so it backfired on their vocals on weekend 1 haha
ateez did so good they danced and sang amazing live please react to them
I realized that they no longer react to Ateez. 😢
@@amargaridinha2787do you know why?
@@amargaridinha2787maybe next video.
DAMN YES PLEASEE 😢❤
at least they're stable. The high note was really good even when I only saw a snippet.
HYBE is DEAD WRONGGGGG, these girls were not vocally ready at ALL
threw them out to the wolves completely unprepared
i kinda agreee with this.... they should've started in small stages first since they need more experience. but hybe put them in a big stage in a snap
For a new group to be able to dance for 40 minutes while singing at that and keeping up the energy I commend them last time i saw that bts had to lay on the floor for 2 minutes k pop ain’t easy
@@theboyinthedark6521 they aren’t a new group
@@moonlightbae_ 2022 I consider newer a newer group able to give a 40 minute performance pretty interesting not too many times i see such a long
For me, Kpop has to stop debuting people for beauty, and value talent.
Yeah
PREACH
Im sorry, its not kpop😂 but hybe .. if you follow from first generation until now its really different, their senior know how to sing live because in tv show they have to sing live no matter what..and this new generation can lipsing all the time😂
There's so many pretty people and have talents also 🤷
Pop and choreos aren't for live ??? I've watched BLACKPINK and aespa and they served...aespa really needs to be appreciated they're just 1 yr & 4 months that time despite being nervous their vocals are soo good.
Right, the hate aespa got for their coachelle performance was absolutely overblown and undeserved. Stable and strong vocals and it was their first performance in front of a live crowd. They were clearly not very comfortable yet but their live execution was good. Aespa's strength is def their vocals and technical skills rather than stage presence and hype, but they can still crush their own songs and they did grow in that area a lot since.
As a disclaimer, Im not particularly a fan of BP but I def think that BP has notably better stage presence than aespa, however that doesnt make aespa's performance a bad one. And BP themselves can also crush their own songs live, which is what is setting these groups apart from LSF imo.
Blackpink's performance what truly absymal imo
Blackpink sang half of it except Rose, are you kidding? And aespa was so boring:d
@@geniusss4 did you even read their post? No one said BP didnt sing. Even LSF sang the first weekend. But opening your mouth and producing a sound doesnt necessarily make you a good singer. (to clarify, I am NOT saying BP are bad singers at all. Just pointing out how youre saying nothing new)
@@KY-jd1nl I'm saying blackpink didn't sing half of the song? I say they made a full pb??
You know it's bad when Entire Korea had "Blackpink Coachella" Trending Instead of Them ......Just go to Blackpink's Coachella performance once and there are 1000s of comments sayings that they went there to Cleanse there ears after this Mess .......hybe really set them up .
I feel bad for them. 😢
suits hybe right for trynna recreate the next bp, even ygs new group BABYMONSTER can eat up evey girl group present in hybe
@@strawkittyxoxo
Yeah BABYMONSTER will absolutely do well with their singing too if they perform in Coachella because they were trained for years. I mean I don't blame LE SSERAFIM because it's not their fault that they sang bad but the blame should all go to Hybe because they didn't prepare them well for Coachella, shame on HYBE!
And please don't hate LE SSERAFIM, just send them love and support
@@MadaraxUchiha I mean its kinda girls fault too, u can't say tht they didn't train them sakura has been in the industry for almost 11 years and yunjin was an opera singer, they have more experience then some 3rd gen idols..
@@strawkittyxoxou are so deluded in ur little bubble. nobody tryna be the next bp🤡and babymonster aint eating nobody up with their trash reject bp songs
i would have agreed with what you guys’ opinions if i didn’t see le sserafim straining and having no technique in singing even when staying completely still. so no its not just a choreography problem
They need more trainings. maybe voice lessons?
I feel like this group also has no "i recently debuted" excuse. How long have they been on already? Like almost 3 years. And I think even at debut, you need to have a cretain skill level to debut ( which is also fkd now in kpop ). Look at Ateez's mama 2019 performance, they were a one year old rookie group and that performance was live as fk and stable. Jongho was even singing a song in female key and didnt miss a note. And there are more examples of actually good live groups. Svt, mamamoo, gidle, bts. This group and many others really have no excuse to suck. I am sorry for the bad words, but really in the nicest way possible I hope the standards goes higher.
girls' generation's debut song says it all. there are group of people who are trained and capable of doing this crazy continuous dance and singing along. just because some ppl can't doesn't mean it's impossible to do.
I THINK THE BIG 3 (SM , JYP AND YG ) ARTIST ARE WELL TRAINED AND CAN SING LIVE WHILE DANCING THEY ALSO MATCH THE CHOREO IN ORDER FOR THE ARTIST TO SING IT BETTER DURING LIVE ..
there is a reason why they r the big 3.they know how to train their idols and make sure no one can point fingers at them
Come out of your big 3 bubble, there are many artists from smaller labels who can sing & dance at the same time. Prime example is ATEEZ, nobody touch them when it comes to live performances, dance, singing, facial expressions, stage presence, they're a power pack combo.
You should react to Ateez in coachella. They literally ate the performance. They were vocally so stable and their energy was on another level
Ateez Kiss of life infinite stayc Billie weeekly purple kiss Jungkook j hope many other they aren't from big 3 but can perform live well
yeah, nmixx, babymonster, aespa are crazyyy. especially nmixx with bone cracking choreography 😂
that never happens with XG, I’ve seen their documentary, they trained to perform live, every group is good in the studio but not all are good live
Most of their 88rising performances were lip syncing,
They have the ability but they mostly stopped singing live while dancing after Mascara era.
For the standards you mentioned, I feel like they're totally realistic because all we want is stable live VOCALS. They could literally cut their choreo in half and no one would care as long as they sound half decent. They're SINGERS for God's sake! We've seen this being done in previous generations with Shinee, 2NE1, TVXQ, EXO, Seventeen, & Mamamoo, so why exactly shouldn't we expect the same live experience from newer groups? Hoping to get your money's worth in a concert and not have your ears bleed and face cringe shouldn't be unrealistic for concrt-goers, especially since these idols supposedly "train" for years to perfect the art of singing and dancing at the same time. There are so many groups who sing while running to become more stable so I don't see why these groups should get a pass for slacking. Other groups are working just as hard if not harder. Anyways, those were my two cents, don't be too bothered by it
Hate to break it to you, but the kpop industry prioritizes catchy songs, choreos, visuals, fits, and fan service. We are seeing more hope with NMixx(greatest girl group past or present when performing live sing and dancing stably), KOL, ZB1, VVUP, UNIS, Triple S, StayC, etc. so that’s a good sign. Previous generations had much less groups and you don’t see the bad ones that couldn’t sing since there were fewer popular ones like Shinee and TvXQ who could perform live stably. The reality is those older gens had terrible groups that people didn’t pay attention to. Older gens might have performed more lives with little back tracks, but there were also many bad live performances too along with bad groups in non big 3
@@inquisitvem6723 bad groups didn't survive in gen 1 and gen 2, only the top groups get recognized. that's what you call quality management which is apparently inexistent in today's kpop fandoms.
@@lulukeran2020 like i said, there were many bad groups in early gens whether they were weeded out is irrelevant. Point was early Gen was no better. Also, even if a group had vocal talent like KISS & CRY , they couldn’t tackle what the big 3 had which was $ and leverage on music shows. It was hard for any non big 3 group to survive even if they were talented. BTS fortunately found another way. BTS had experienced it first hand being discriminated on music and variety shows to promote themselves and took the bold move of using any avenue social media as much as they could to get their name out there. It turned out to be a shrewd move that changed the industry which is how all groups use these days with their own vlogs and doing skits writhing their company. They broke the mold of control by big 3. Even to this day, you don’t see BTS on many variety shows out there because they do mostly in house. What they did was show proof that you didn’t need big 3 money to promote. Nowdays the money is too good to pass up, so companies crank out groups left and right. Still, it’s always never been vocals as #1 priority as a whole.
We all know that no performance is perfect but there is a certain expectation and standard to be met especially at COACHELLA. Just take a look at Blackpink’s Coachella performance. They managed to dance and sing at the same time and people LOVED it so much with all the stage presence they are giving. They are the GOLD standard.
@@dangzitspro
Edit: Sorry for the word vomit lol
Objectively speaking, yes they were able to perform while singing and dancing, but the only groups I can think of that blackpink was better than is Aespa & Le Sserafim. The likes of Ateez, 2NE1, The Rose, Epik High and other K-soloists gave a better performance in my opinion.
Just being able to hit the notes 70% of the time does not make someone "The GOLD" standard. For instance, if u look at the kpop acts in the industry rn, u'd be able to realize just how high the standard some groups have set in terms of vocals, stage presence, and choreography as well as performances. My vocal trinity consists of EXO, MAMAMOO, and BTOB, where all the members, at the least, are proficient vocalists and have an understanding of technique (meaning they can hold a note for more than 5 seconds), which is more than what some of the newer groups' main vocalists can do. Seventeen, Mamamoo, Got7 and MonstaX along with NMixx, 2PM, TVXQ and SNSD are all beasts on stage. If u ever saw them perform, u'd realize just how limited ur idea of a good performance is. Plus, Blackpink has never really stood out among their peers when performing at festivals where other idol groups were present as well, and only go viral for shows where they were either the only K-act performing or among K-indie artists, which prevents the audience from making any type of comparisons and an overall better opinion of them (not saying they aren't good, but they're not all what their fans hype them to be - I've seen WAY better in kpop)
That’s why I think yg and sm have the best singers. This is why their training is so hard especially yg. Look at Baby monster,they can absolutely sing, and yg made sure of that with their monthly evaluations. Even JYP is hard on his vocalists, it might come out as mean but this is what he’s trying to avoid. Also the fact that hybe choreos are not the easiest doesn’t help them catch a breath. ATP most K-pop companies are just debuting dancers and idols who have the looks not actual singers, which is what the music is actually about.
Hype without BTS are just NOTHING
Everyone always says hybe has bad vocals when singing live. Hybe is not just one company, but there is an agency within it.
Not all the artists/idols there sing badly, maybe I think their girl groups are the ones who lack vocals. Just complain to their agency Soumu, Ador, and Belift, don't let all the artists in the hype get involved. They are one company but their agency system is different and the way they manage their artists is also different.
@@rubyjacob7005right
@@rinaervinajuliyanti9585 well yeah but the groups that have good vocals are the ones they debuted earlier, which is the boy groups but imo I think they rushed to debut their newer groups, they have really good and catchy songs but they just debuted looks/visuals tbh
But blackpink not that good tbh
That's why Blackpink did a special simplified choreo for the performances. YG managers were always the best in terms of live performance. Why such a huge company as Hybe can't understand the simple things 🤔
I don't think it's about simple or hard Choreo . Lsf can't sing properly while even standing . I have seen those encores .......As for Blackpink.....no doubt that they r Really good stage commanders and performers . Even while Dancing their vocals are really stable .
@@Xoxo78941 ofc it is? Also bps songs r always in the same pattern rap, bridge, chorus and again rap, bridge, dance break ( no singing buncha ratatatat and dumdum). Which is how each member can focus in jst one thing, rose and jisoo jst sing bridges while Jenni and Lisa raps, their chorus r mostly edms, now serrafims each song have a very very different vibe, each requiring constant singing, and don't forget the choreos, y can't u view it that way? I'd say it's the company's fault, bps songs r loud, which is why they sound good even when they yell in their rap parts, serrafim don't have typical kpop rap they barely honestly, and their choruses always have lyrics, also different song patterns.
Yea the encore was bad, but now they sound much better even with energetic dancing, idk yall here jst to hate not to criticise
@@nazunaw Blackpink's Song This ....Blackpink's song that ....yet no kpop idols can sing and perform them except few .
And my point still stands that lsf Can't sing even while standing. So i don't know what nonsense u r yapping abt lmao.
I think its too soon for them to perform in coachella, it must be overwhelming for them. Yes they had a huge impact in music industry but if their die hard fans would just reason out that it is because of their choreography, i think its not.
When they say that bp can perform well bcoz bp has an easy choreo, i would definitely disagree. BP performed their songs well and also if others can see, BP even come up with a choreo in every song they performed and also they improve rheir choreo in their last coachella performance.
@@Xoxo78941 y'all barely read anything and say yapping lmao.
Ok listen here kindergartener,
All I'm saying is bp's song pattern are always same, EDM choruses and dance break with dumdumdum.
Bp's management team did a good job in showcasing the girls visual and charisma in Coachella.
Serrafim known for its hard choreo, and every song had a different vibe to it, right?
difficult dances, melodious tones, lows and high notes.
Serrafims songs are also much clamer than of Bp's loud songs and rap. Which is prolly why they didn't skip dancing.
Yea Sakura sounded bad on encore but let's talk abt the improvement!! Sakura in Coachella is serving with her energetic dance plus better vocals than standing still in encore. It can be seen that they worked hard for it. Raw vocals with no backtrack, singing and dancing for whole 40mins.
Should react ateez at Coachella
Amazing vocals and performance
Yes would love that
Yess
tbh I don't think the expectations were high, we just wanted the bare minimum,i.e. stable vocals, which kpop groups have been able to accomplish before while singing live while dancing, with no backtrack (eg: ateez,mamamoo, aespa,nct,nmixx, to name a few.) No one expects them to sound like taeyeon or wendy. Two things could've been done here,1)sing with a back track, or 2) tone down the choreo, and neither was done. I'm really not sure what hybe was thinking. They have great songs but they were not ready for Coachella.
This is the most realistic take and I thank you for that.
Right ? I'm reading these comments and I swear everyone was watching like a different video , they guys very fair and accurate with their assessment
fr some comments on others vids r jst pure jealousy hate, disgusting ppl
Fr ??? I was getting tired of all the dumb reviews claiming it was some legendary shit 😂
Yeah I agree with them as an entire performance it was great despite all the negativity from people that were not there.
@@KpopNiDontStop The best thing they said was about backtracks. Thats why performances vs encores differ vastly. Its too unrealistic to be dancing and singing at the same time.
K-pop stans confuse me. On one hand you have people defending terrible encores where they’re standing still and on the other hand they lose their minds when the vocals aren’t there during a performance that’s completely live. I was honestly expecting this to be a whole lot worse, at least the energy was there. And I think you’re right, fans are so used to convincing themselves that lip syncing is a live vocal that this is a shock to the system
Kpop fans are hypocrisy in person.
Kpop fans are hypocrisy in person.
Love is blind
@@muhammadnazmi1195lmaooo 😭
i mean i think the poeple defending the encores are not the same people who are criticising the vocals at coachella?
Vocally I'd say Chaewon is the only one who did well.
Chaewon and yunjin (she only was shaky at the beginning maybe due to nerves or excitement, but she did well afterwards, and she does kno how to sing usually, so let's not lump everybody together and exaggerate like that)
@@MidnightxCrow Honestly I was shocked when I found out yunjin is the main vocalist, cause how can you sound so shaky and off pitch throughout the performances. I've followed them for a while now and am always left disappointed by their vocals. Chaewon seems to be the only one carrying the vocals in the group.
@@MidnightxCrowI checked their uni fes performances back when they were just debuted and I thought yunjin sounds bad live. Like she screamed maybe to be heard clearer but it just sounds out of tune for me. Boy i was surprised when I found out she’s the main vocalist
@@tash_scshe had some issue with her legato and stamina
@@MidnightxCrowyunjin at times was just screaming. I get it she was hyped but even in the smart line “lesserafim to victory” which is not hard to sing, she sounded so off key. Girl can sing I mean she was an opera singer but I definitely think lesserafim songs don’t do her justice
I agree with the fact that the bar is especially high for Coachella but…. that’s because the other groups that came before set that bar. Blackpink came in and absolutely killed it. Ateez dominated it. 2NE1 literally brought it and set it on fire 🔥 And Ik there were mixed opinions on Aespa but regardless of personal opinions if they were ready or not Aespa still danced AND sung beautifully simultaneously. The fact is Le Ssarifim seems to have been the only one having this hard of a time with doing both. The bar was set high because the artist before them have gone above and beyond expectations.
I don’t thinks it’s exactly logical to blame “ the bar” as you put it when only one group hasn’t been able to even hit close to the expectation.
they had everything going for them, their energy, charm and presence was through the roof, they really looked like they were having fun and the band was the cherry on top. However, I think it would be much better if the choreography was simplified for this stage especially because there was little backtrack for them and they couldn't rely on it to regulate their own breathing...
it was already simplified. The parts where they sing usually involve little movements.
i love LSF too but die hard stans need to face reality... vocally they really not up to par, even when u say they dancing and singing at the same time is hard, they should be trained for that cuz that's their job. u are a top idol group in the kpop industry with international audience, if you wanna be up there on a coachella stage with some of the biggest names in teh world u need to get better than this. i blame HYBE for this. a company that is slowly losing its soul, they knew the stage is a live band to begin with but still threw the girls under the bus even tho they know they not quite ready yet.
I was also a fan, but man. It all changed when I discovered a new group that can sing live and you can easily determine which voice is which.
I stan the new Group UNIS recently, they really devoured the stages they went to. And i just recently known that some were not a trainee or no long trainee days except that some of them are in the entertainment indistry but not kpop tho.. just wow they can deliver
@@saksa-k985 Wow, you got me there. UNIS was the reasons my standard changed in kpop. They only have 2 months to prepare for debut but they already have 5 songs with choreos. And they can deliver.
Visuals are really balanced and diverse.They have their own colours (Colors of eight, reference from dopamine chorus)
Plus they can sing live which is the core of being an idol.
I'm not flaming any group. Its just that this one is a fresh breathe of air.
@@kurtlugay8195i feel you bro👊 UNIS is OT8❤
Did you ever there at cochella? Because the local praised them
I don't stan either group but Ateez is literally performing next to them and they don't have those same 'issues' with their vocals?? If you talk about choreo then Ateez's is even more tiring than lssf's and they were singing stable even after drinking alcohol. I think the hate people are giving lssf is wrong but you can't say that they aren't truly lacking in the vocal department.
Yes, lssf is more of a 'performer' group like Itzy than a 'singer' group like Aespa, but they should at least have decently stable singing like Itzy. Criticize them for their weak vocals all you want, at least they can sing live pretty similar to the studio version every single time.
But broo
This is the thing about obessession fans are talking about . I feel like people are sooo busy in hating le Sserafim that they forgot about Ateez only which is not suppose to happen.
@@skyfever994exactly why focus on negative things, ateez did amazing but no one is talking about that.
@kkurakisseverybody lsf has two of their members who debuted in the same time as atz, also when atz did their first world tour in 2019, literally 4 months old rookies, they were already singing live and stable and for several stops too. There's literally no excuse for them, unless they weren't getting vocal lessons the same way on how they get dance lessons (this is one is on hybe/source). I do not condone the hate, but the constructive criticisms are, in fact, valid.
@kkurakisseverybody Fine, then let's not bring up Ateez. Aespa is also a girl group with similar physiques as Lssf. They performed Black Mamba as one of the first songs, where the choreo requires them to drop to the ground in the chorus, which is just as hard as Antifragile's choreo, also one of the first songs performed. You can't defend their difference in live vocals with the boy group excuse. Honestly, I'm not expecting lssf to have the SM level of vocals, but look at Itzy. They got bashed for their vocals too, but at least they can replicate it live.
@kkurakisseverybodyBffr my dude. They all had to work hard to make their debut ( normally ). Idols are supposed to be average at the very least or above average vocally in order to debut. Lsf are not rookies anymore but how is it that newer group from the BIG3 already surpassed them in any domain ??
Simple words to say..when you are a singer you must have a good voice quality live or lipsync..The Word SINGER😂
I think the hate really stemmed from the encores at music shows in Korea. That started it all. Then suddenly they went to Coachella where they need to sing live and dance and the standards for the performers are different from Korea. Wale and Efra was right with stating it was the management's fault for not preparing the girls' set better with adjusting the choreo, when not to dance and just sing. So sad for the hate they are getting when it's ultimately the management's fault.
ateez coachella too please!! dont forget guerilla
No thanks
Yeeesss Ateez serving those vocalsss wow!! 🔥🔥
@@liekhan9no one ask u stfu
I don't know if you guys know, but shinee sing and dance at the same time and they good. Why? Because they train together running and singing, so when they dance they know how to breathe
@@clockon9929where did you get that information from? According to google it’s the exact opposite. Y’all shouldn’t make up sex/gender based things as an excuse.
stans always making shit up for an excuse.
@@chesiresaysboy groups do have more stamina, but there's still no excuse for le sserafim to sound so bad live
@@jasm-uk7ml SAYS WHO? not science. So tell me where you’re getting that info from.
@chesiresays men literally have more muscles and energy than women, let's not be stupid and ignore reality and science
but they still found it hard to sing "Easy" in an encore (while standing mind you) so it's definitely a skill issue
Tottaly agree...the choreography IT SHOULD'VE BEEN as easily as possible in order to aloud em to stand out vocally.
No.....bc it gives fans the excuse that they were dancing, thats why their vocals weren't good....lmao. Like the girls weren't criticized a month ago for their music show encore where they were just STANDING there. They can't sing, dancing or not.
Y’all this type of live singing for coachella was done wayy better by Ateez in 2024 and Aespa ate with their live and of course BlackPink. It wasn’t 100% perfect but they were great enough but LeSserafim is obviously lower calibre literally only Chaewon was carrying the vocals and she wasn’t perfect but still I think the standard is her but Yujin who is also a main vocal was so bad. We all have been saying Hybe doesn’t focus on their vocals they don’t do well even in the encores.
HOPE PPOP GROUP PERFORM IN COACHELLA LIKE SB19 🇵🇭
That's what I'm wishing for!!! SB19 needs to be at the Coachella....
I totally agree.They are beasts performing live on stage. Their performance at AAA awards show and their live performance in Wish bus 107.5 radio attests to their vocals…
True
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💞
and they are POP even BINI is POP it's just the yare more working harder than these people who have silver spoon on their mouths because they have BIG AGENCY backing them up
I was there. They were real bad. They danced well but their vocals were not good. Out of tune, lack of stability…I think they need more vocal training. Comparing this to BP’s 2019 Sahara performance, there’s a huge gap. You guys are too nice. You should revisit Blackpink’s performance from 2019 under the same conditions. I was also at BP’s 2019 Coachella performance and they killed it which is why BP became more popular in the west and got more followers. 👀
BLACKPINK had a backing track, subtle but still
@@Diwwiyat Yes there was a very subtle splitting but their vocals carried through very loudly and were stable. BP was ready for their performance with plenty of training and experiences throughout the years…
YG built BP (and now BM) to tour, HYBE builds girl groups for the studio. YG spends years identifying and then training their idols. HYBE throws together their groups quickly with virtually no training whatsoever. Saturday night's result was a foregone conclusion the moment LSF was announced in Jan. BTW, I have a recording of BP's 2019 performance which I regularly listen to to this day. An example of how to do it right.
We all know that no performance is perfect but there is a certain expectation and standard to be met especially at COACHELLA. Just take a look at Blackpink’s Coachella performance. They managed to dance and sing at the same time and people LOVED it so much with all the stage presence they are giving. They are the GOLD standard.
They did much better week end 2. But what you see or heard online is really true that Week end 1 about their vocals was super unstable and their voice cracked on quite a few part. So its really true they struggled 100% on weekend 1. If you watch and compare you will know. Week end 2 was fire for sure though. They took all that hate and criticism on their vocals for week 1 and stepped up for weekend 2 . Their choreography intensively is a lot less energetic compare to week 1 probably most likely to focus more on their vocals. They was super crazy and energetic on week end 1 and that might cause them to be unstable. If you want to watch the HD quality, You can still watch it on coachella youtube channel sahara stage just rewind it back until sunday mid night its all gone. I really think cause its their first coachella they gone a bit over the top on their dancing so it backfired on their vocals on weekend 1 haha
THEY JUST CAN SCREAM
They shouldn't have sent them. Especially when people all around the world are watching them with hawk eyes for any mistake from their side. At this point they are getting bullied in the name of criticism.
coachella invited them, would they take that down? 😅
@@aeondale011 ofcourse they can't. Besides the lineup was announced before this whole scandal. It's just, it's bad. The hate is so bad. It's no longer criticism. It's bullying. The points are all valid yes. But the amount of hate?? Nah. Nobody deserves that.
@@aeondale011they invited big bang before they invited BP and they refused. They can certainly do that as well
They were invited, do you not understand?
@@MidnightxCrow I know dude. But looking at the hate they are getting I wish they didn't go. Though I know it's not possible. They improved. But haters be damned
How about ATEEZ? Did u guys skip them 😞
Just check them out and commenting them
they both tried to defend 😂😂😂😂
I’m sorry but why does this feels like another Inkigayo performance added with some shouting🤧😭😭😭
Beauty privilege is real
What I saw in tiktok, and I think is also the reason for the criticism, they didn’t sing well even without dancing. But I also think is HYBE’s fault, they are focusing too much in the coreography and they forget all of the other aspects. Also the thing is that Illit didn’t do well in singing live, so that made it worse. Plus Babymonster did really well singing so they are comparing all of them.
Really liked your review. I think is easy to hate but explaining like you did is what matters.
Not HYBEs fault dmbarse lol...how is it the agencys fault that the girls dont work hard? Its up to lessarfim to train and practice their vocals. Look at Bp, lazy work ethic and their lazy performances and poor lives were shown on their stages
@@TheTruthX7 tru... leaving on stage in the middle of the performances is very unprofessional too. they are seniors they should set good example to rookies
So Ateez Coachella reaction next orr..??
Yeah ateez did great.
Absolutely!
You will not wish to say that they are just impossible to dance and sing to hard choreos after watching TREASURE, BM, AESPA etc. They are also 4th and 5th gen but slays. I don't wanna compare to be honest. no hate but they train well in every aspect. Do you think someone can sing and dance all of a sudden. It takes time and effort but in Le serrafim's case, I don't think they have a good understanding of what practice and learning can do. Their instructors might be spoon feeding them just to hit the point and that's not gonna work. The band was set loud in order not to make a huge deal on their vocals but it is really visible that they did not do well. Their vocals were not only unstable in smart but also in other songs every single time and the adlibs were the worst of all. But, i do appreciate the effort.
they both tried to defend
Thank you so much for this video!! People need to hear this.
i know its Far for PPOP for now, But i would want to see a PPOP Group to perform on Coachella~ BINI or SB19? i know Ppop is not that big like Kpop. but i know Ppop Would do Great With Live performance~
Actually, we can make that possible if Filipinos unite to support ppop
@@heavensky8706 yup! You r right. If us Filipino just unite, and appreciate more our local artist. We have the talent and all~ our artist just need more support.
Even a rookie group in PH can sing live. And some don't even train 3-5 years.
Up
Ppop is absolutely 💯 Amazing. Filipino’s are born with a microphone 🎙️. 💙💙💙 I’m not Asian and I even know they are Live Monsters.
I have always loved LE SSERAFIM and I love them still but it’s just a shame that they’re not able to keep up vocally. In terms of stage presence, they’ve got it in the bag. They should’ve gone to Coachella further in their career when the vocals have been more practiced and improved. It was too soon, vocally but performance wise they were ready (stage presence, choreo etc.)
i disagree they were ready performance wise their screaming and constant cursing made me cringe so hard
@@chady1229 that’s literally what I said: they were ready performance wise, just not vocally. And it wasn’t as disastrous as people made it out to be but it wasn’t at the level it should’ve been
Lowkey, I want to hear SB19 on a coachella even if its only like 2-3 songs😂
Completely agree with your point about unrealistic expectations in kpop- doing physically demanding/jumpy choreo will make vocals suffer because physics. And if the idols don't dance as well, they're "lazy" all of a sudden. Aka they just can't win. The only way this is going to get better is if the industry changes.
So as a person Who is very new to Kpop - I watched Lsf performance at coachella And since Blackpink was trending on X so i watched Blackpink's 2019 Performance of coachella also .........all i can say is....... There is a Reason why Blackpink is at the Top . I personally found Earth and sky difference not even in Vocals but also stage presence ........especially that Jennie Girl ......She's so fire and captivating omg .
I think Lsf should really focus on singing more than dancing. Cause as a spectator I think Singing is more important than dancing. The girls are Very good Dancers i must say tho.
To be honest coachella blackpink it's better ❤
I agree with you
thank you so much guys for reacting and telling your opinion abt this issue !!! ❤❤
We want (G)I-DLE in Coachella!
I think they can do well singing live and dancing at the same time 😁
I also think that you'll have a different opinion on this matter when it comes to (G)I-DLE 😎
Can we Got ateez Coachella too
Ateez at Coachella please. Thank you🥰🤗✌️🙏💜💜💜
XG needs to perform at Coachella.. huge stage and crowds is their ballpark..
Yes please! I want to hear girl gang ant coachella😢
Totally agree 👍💯
so now our "a singer should be able to sing her own song" standard is unrealistic?? we don't ask them to be ariana or beyonce, we just want them to practice more in vocal department so they could sing their song.
I understand some of the criticism but they blatant hate that they received is not okay and should not be tolerated. I respect your opinions and criticisms thank you for sharing this video
Literally the hate is so forced. It’s okay to point out that they need more vocal training but they’ve mainly received hate, I can’t go to any LSF related post without someone in the comments mentioning their singing although it has no correlation to the post.
Yeah I feel sorry for them. Criticism is okay but not that much of hate.
@@chesiresays 너 이런 하찮은 일을 하고 있구나 ㅋㅋㅋ 아이돌처럼 행동하는 jpop 사람들의 용기가 정말 웃기네요. 외모만으로 대한민국을 진짜로 만들어보세요! 나는 그들이 개선되기를 바랍니다
@@chesiresaysIt’s crazy how they trying so hard to convince us they can’t sing. I am not falling for that anymore
Completely agree, sadly, having a balanced viewpoint and looking at the overall picture is vanishingly rare on the internet these days 😂😂 glad this video at least was sensible. There was room for improvement in their vocals and I think their management could have done a lot more in terms of changing the choreo to support their vocals and adding more production. But I really don't think it was the dumpster fire that everyone is saying it was- I really enjoyed it overall!
Plz watch ATEEZ Coachella performance, they're the best ❤
You two are so completely sensible and realistic in your approach to this issue. Thank you for seeing both the positives and the negatives, as well as what could be expected onstage and what could never happen.
The band was fantastic. The dancing was well done and some of the vocals were memorable. I think there were nerves at the beginning (Antifragile) but they worked through them alright and then it was just about endurance as they supported each other through the performance.
I am looking forward to seeing Ateez this next weekend as I couldn’t see them Friday. Aside from a more staggered choreography that helps the performers deal with strong parts, Ateez is also 8 members vs. 5. That means more spread in line distribution and those extra seconds can mean a lot in regaining one’s composure. I would also say that I felt there were technical glitches song to song as the soundboard didn’t seem to activate microphones back to the same levels throughout the performance. This was probably not helped as they switched from handheld to headset partway through the performance but that seemed to be planned.
With all that being said, and with all the complaints and finger pointing online, every comment I have seen from those who attended in person was that they put on a great show and the crowd was engaged. I think they can only do better this next weekend and should be able to walk away from Coachella with their heads held high. ❤
Thanks for a great reaction & evaluation
I am sorry. This is why I have to, have to, have to appreciate artist like beyonce. Beyonce did a damn hour and a half show at Coachella. Where she dances intensely and had vocal stabiliy right through, so stop making excuses. She has been doing that for 20 years. People need to start taking the art more serious. I petition for beyonce to give kpop some advice. I was utterly disappointed in this performance. Sigh!!!
i think hybe or especially sourcemusic should consider again about the realistic choreo. they still can have a good stage presence without running out of breath 💗 love the girls
true. i feel like source music too lazy to examine what suitable choreo for their voice to make it not too running out breath.
totally agree with this is more of a company problem. specially their music producers too. The way they made some of their songs made it sound to not be sung live. I was watching that Perfect Night part and boy, I realized it's not meant to be performed live. I wish HYBE stop making these kind of music with too much vocal adjustments
I rather listen to a bop song than a boring one and I think less choreography with more vocal training will fix that eventually!
Agree, I like both lsrf and ive and I think Starship, a medium-sized company, produce better songs that suits their idols better than Hybe, one of the biggest company in SK. Like are LSRF’s producers didn’t take into consideration about the member’s vocal range when they made songs? I mean sakura isn’t the singer of the century but she sounds decent when singing high pitched songs (like the songs Imase produced). I just think hybe needs to hire better producers tbh
@@SirBobM good for you. i dont like listening to songs that i cant distinguish which one of the singers are singing or whether if it's a robot or a person who is singing because of the huge amount of vocal adjustments
Easy listening song is good when U have headphones n in car but doesn't suitable on stage..when they trying to change instruments they look like trying to catch breath with live band..
@@blacksheep1069 totally agree. there are songs that are suited for own enjoyment, for headphones, car, phone speaker, and Perfect Night was that song. I didnt enjoy that live Perfect Night they did
it's not impossible to singing and dancing live. many idols have proven it. it's just them need to get more vocal training
they both tried to defend 😂😂😂
Last time i seen a long k pop performance it was twice and bts sana fainted and members of bts had to lay down on stage for minutes k pop is really hard i would love to see the improvement of le serafim
Ateez showed how it’s done at Coachella. There’s actually groups that can dance hard choreography and still be stable live. Even after an hour. It is very possible, not everyone can be talented and work hard enough to achieve it though. My standards are high thanks to Ateez and Dreamcatcher. It can be done so I think what you’re saying is just an excuse tbh
@winter0146 they are known to not lip sync, that’s why they won immortal songs several times
People who defend them saying that they were doing so much and it was difficult to sing etc. Ateez did a lot too and somehow performed vocally way better. That means the girls were not prepared vocally for coachella and/or just lacked vocal performance.
Exactly and because their bad singing got soo much attention so no one's talking about ateez
i agree with you on this. but, we also have to keep in mind that the girls have only been a group for 2 years. Ateez has been a group since 2018, of course they're gonna perform better, that's a given.
@@aaradhya4242 Ateez isn’t getting much attention because they’re guys. It’s easy more fun to bully women so LSFM will be the headline :)
@@vaehvebut sakura and chaewon also first debuted in 2018. And i sakura case even longer. Plus, Yunjin was in produce 48 which started before ateez debut. Only Kazuha and Eunchae didnt have experience, but at the same time, to be an idol, you need to go through a training period. So they should be ready the moment they debut. And even then, they have the easiest part of their songs. So really, no excuse here.
@KingKikikoi ateez vocal is only stable when they're standing still
Like jongho have to stand still to hit his note
Le Sserafim are literally jumping non stop so its mostly the choreo problem
Guys please react to Ateez coachella performance 2024
hybe needs to stop making songs for virality and actually make songs that their artist can sign. I think this also come from acquiring demos and releasing them instead of them making their owns songs. Like their songs are not in their range at all. They should have adjusted their choreos and I feel like their band should have pulled back at times and vice versa, sometimes it was too overpowering or underwhelming. It’s also unfortunate that people thinks it’s okay for artists to to not be able to deliver vocally, in my opinion singing should always the number one priority and dancing second. It unfortunate that certain companies think otherwise.
I wish ITZY could perform in Coachella. They can sing live and have such a strong stage presence plus the hard choreos! Perfect for Coachella stage
있지는 보컬이 없습니다 소리만 낸다고 해서 라이브를 잘하는게 아닙니다
Thank you for this reaction and for being so honest and fair. I respect you guys a lot. Also, thank you for not bashing the girls bc even if some of the criticism is valid, the unimaginable hate train the girls have been facing is too much and just mean and vile. There is too much hate in this world. We can express criticism and still remain respectful.
I feel soo bad for them imagine seeing your video somewhere and the comment section filled with how bad you are 😢 we should hype them up and cheer them to become greater❤
but its true they need to hear it hybe clearly doesent care enough to train them properly no hate but they need to be able to be criticized
@@chady1229 have u read the comments from knetz? They are really rudd and cyberbullying them,especially eunchae.
Its just that we can't control other people. It must be owerwhelming for them to perform in a new environment.
I wish they could find hope in this circumstances and will continue performing while improving themselves.
@@chady1229Yes death threats and r*pe threats are such criticism, especially to a 17 years old.
this video makes me want to binge your reactions. you have very fair takes.
This is what I’m saying! I totally agree with you. These girls are actually admirable for singing live the entire time🫡. The vocals are not perfect but it is raw and only natural as they’re losing steam while dancing 😊
Listen to “the Rose”🌹😍
Ateez💯
hybe and management problem exactly! also i feel so bad for Eunchae she shouldnt be dealing with this tremendous amount of hate at a young age
yeah but a 17 year old should still as well as the rest be able to take criticism not hate ofc but actual critique and realize that hybe needs to quit producing visuyally appealing idols who only focus on dance and do it like jyp yg where theyre all rounders baemon do everything and are balanced nmixx as well. hybe hasnt produced really talented idols since newjeans and other than them u have to go to txt
if you want to play logic here then she wouldn't be debuting at such a young age. She needs to be in school rn
Nothing to do with hybe dmbarse😂its the girls responsibility to work hard and practice vocals....look at bp. Bp have lazy work ethic and it showed on stage....jisoo and jennie the prime examples
@@TheTruthX7hater ass ,why did u bring blackpink here ? Ik ur lazier
I see where your coming from but aespa, atteez, blackpink as kpop groups who also performed at coschella they all did so well with live vocals and dancing and being stable.
now why are y'all not boycotting starbucks
Yawn
ATEEZ perf will🔥stable vocal while dancing👏
My ATINY EGO is rising like stick exchange graph
The thing is we as stans aren’t often that delusional to assume that the vocals gonna sound like the recording, in general but especially while dancing that intensely. It’s as you said humanly impossible so you often have grace for that. That’s why fans of the newer generation don’t care much about live vocals while performances anymore, it’s the trade off you get for these intense dance performances. What happens here is that many didn’t expect them to be perfect, but they even underperformed vocally while the bar was already in hell. With all the love I have for them (they became one of my favorite groups the last couple of years) they seemed to have given up at some point and just gave us speech singing or rough notes. Lesserafim never had a strong vocal line like that and what kinda fuels the comments is that there isn’t much improvement despite being nearly 3 years in the industry. To be fair many idols stay stagnant in their abilities once they debut and if the hate train doesn’t hit them, but it’s a constant critism for them and I think much of the bitterness lies there.
Hybe prioritize their rookies groups on performance than vocals but they get better eventually in all aspects like their other successful top idols!
yes like nobody expected them to sound perfect but for them to do even worse I was shocked! I expected them to adjust the chorus and performance to fit the Coachella stage but it’s unfortunate that singing is not held to the importance it should when it comes to certain groups
JUST ACCEPT THAT THEY NEED VOCAL TRAINING.. PEOPLE PAY TO SEE THEIR TALENT. PEOPLE DONT NEED DANCERS ONLY BUT ALSO LIVE VOCALS NOT EDITED
They should debut as dancers not singers.. they look like reciting a poem.. they sounds like an elementary student.. sometimes child singing is better than them
Great video, just subscribed. We love our Le Sserafim girls!!
from what i hear the best way to go about training for live vocals for a live performance is singing while full on sprinting on the treadmills
Please do react to ateez's performance at coachella too!
I know a group that have performed live multiple times. And hope someday, they be able to perform in Coachella.
Looking at the comments and they totally don't understand the video hdjdjd i agree with all that they say, But the BIG PROBLEM HERE is that they throw le sserafim without ANY back vocal for like the 99% of the show, they could be done that and it would have been fine, like ateez, they have their back track and vocals for the singers and it's good, or for the main vocal he sings when he need, no dance and sing, it's just a completely honest movement from them (HYBE) or just a stupid desicion, because let me tell you 99% of kpop groups sound like this without all the support they have with Backtrack and back vocals
yeah but nobody sings live without a backtrack if ur a kpop group thats not the issue here in kpop u need bavk tracks or else it sounds horrible look at ateez bpink coachella they go hard on choreo in certain sections and ease up in others its a live performing skill to psce urself ur not meant to sing live 100 percent as fans we dont expect it either but in the parts that ur supposed to hit live if ur not doing that thats a skill issue and hybe a training and management issue cuz listen to bpink u could hear they were on the edge while singing but they still hit the notes 85 90 percent perfect throughout the whole set thats good training ssera have horrible training and i think the girls themselves need to try harder cuz standing still in a encore sounding that bad is unacceptable same with illit if ur gonna be a kpop idol u need to put in the work cuz its a tough job with yes unneccesary hate but also valid criticism if ur not performing up to par and hybe is just content with producing lack of talent newjeans is the only successful and talented group to come from there recently really since txt im not hating i understand they might hae had less backtravk and thats a hybe issue they have to have that if theyre gonna keep the same choreo but also in general they dont have a single vocal powerhouse or real talent eunchae was badly trained kazuha wasnt trained at all sakura should be good by now but her japanese training completely ruined her voice from akb or hkt whatever days and their horrible training but still she was in izone and ssera she should have improved like she did her dancing yunjin hasnt sounded good since debut era for some reason she makes no sense she was good but now did she stop training i know exo members for example went and asked for more vocal training years into debut even though theyre vocal kings they still wanna improve chaewon is just badly trained as well plus i feel shes trying to imitate western voices too much and it doesent suit her tone at all hybe doesent give them parts that optimize their voices aswell
@@chady1229 that is debatable, I hope I misunderstood you but you sound like sooo angry for some reason hdjs and, there is no comparison in this live performance with any other, not almost close, and yes they have to be quiet or stay still when they have to sing, but they didn't, they try to sing and dance almost all the time, and when they already want to sing without dancing they had breathing problems, but that's different from being a bad Singer, they can sing, they always have space to be better? yes, nobody deny that, and that's it's part of the growing process, but be a singer it's different from singing and dancing with that type of choreo at the same time, because it's physically impossible, and again it's shocking how the industry brainwashed people thinking that it was "really" bad, because almost 99% have never heard what an artist actually sounds like singing and dancing LIVE, because k-pop has always lied about "live performance" in shows or awards ceremonies and people really think that is a live performance. This is how a person sings and dances these choreos without any backtrack, and that's for any K-pop group there, almost 99% , we share some opinions, but the point of view it's different.
They overestimated lsfm and thought they would answer the critics by singing live without backtracks. It's ridiculous that hybe is so blinded by popularity that they aren't ready to take criticism. I predict that they gonna be the same even after 5yrs of debut
This problem happen because they almost all this time lipsync so they as performance who sing and dance dont know their mistake and shortcomings
Oh, i know groups who can sing live and sound good WITHOUT backtracks.
The way HYBE disbanded gfriend and mistreated fromis, it's like they hate ggs with good vocals. 💀
i think they just want popularity, everything does not matter to them
i don’t think you even watched the video they definitely were messing up towards their end
Thank you for expressing the realistic nature of live performances (especially at an outdoor festival) and the unrealistic expectations music shows and other heavily produced video content have caused.
The girls did incredible and are undoubtedly talented. They will improve accordingly as they do more live performances, like many other groups have done before them.
They were not incredible during coachella ... as you said they WILL IMPROVE but wasn't incredible. Periodt.
@@FlorenceDoit000 As a fan following from the beginning, I could see how hard they worked and they put on a great performance for the crowd. Was it perfect? No. But people are greatly exaggerating saying it was terrible. Anyone can see they performed their butts off and had a lot of fun. You and others don’t have to be so hateful about it.
So why they don't know thier limits and go after thier improvement ? I hate when non deserved take opportunity
lol only low level and expendable employees in the real world gets a pass like this. Nevermind doctors or pilots, even plumbers can't afford to fk up this much on their jobs. But it's not the idols fault that their HYBE served underprepared and undercooked meals. They chose to be the McDonald's of the industry to make as much money as possible so here we are.
@@yukikteez8036 They are no less deserving than others and Coachella specially invited them. This group is less than 2 years old and this is their first major festival, performing for 40 minutes straight with a 2 minute break. Give them some grace. The adrenaline alone must have been so overwhelming. Haters really wanna nitpick everything to lift up their fave, saying it was a horrible set when it wasn’t.
No one improves overnight and I’ve been watching the kpop industry for so long to know it takes time for groups to hone their live performances. They did a great job for weekend 1 and they will surely take valid critiques into account for weekend 2.
The problem is Blackpink start, and then all of group and company want to do that also
2nd gen Kpop groups are pretty great in performing in front of and engaging large crowds. Handheld mics with minimal to no vocal backing were common in the past.
YGE groups gets flak for iffy or simplistic choreos, but their perfs still work and translate much better with a large crowd. Seems like it's part of their training.
I love how you react truthfully.