⏳ TIME IS ; not on your side girl you lost a good thing and I don't even feel sorry for you you deserve to lose him cuz he didn't deserve you I think you're evil cruel manipulative vindictive and I think you had it in for Johnny Johnny is so cool down to earth he's beautiful person inside and out his smile his laughter everything about him is beautiful and I bet you don't like that do you go find yourself a low life just like you cuz you will never make movies you'll never be in pictures you're a nobody you're nothing you're just an evil evil b**** and he didn't deserve you not for a day a minute never Johnny was he's just too good for you you you deserve everything you get good life good luck finding love the world is on to you if I was in front of your face I'd beat you down you know that girl I would kick your freaking ass for what you have done to Johnny Johnny is a good man the world loves him the world stands behind him everybody sees right through you why don't you go crawl under a rock go hide somewhere I would never want to show my face especially and around Hollywood and you don't you don't even think you done nothing wrong you've done everything wrong is why you lost the man that loved you the man that would have seen you would have carried you through life he deserves to be loved he deserves to have a good woman a good beautiful woman not a ugly skeleton evil devil woman like you God have mercy on your soul
This woman is insane. Insane. I'm disgusted by the media giving her, the ABUSER, a platform to continue her defamation! If Johnny had lost this case, there's NO WAY they'd invite him on to tell tall tales. This woman, & Smollet, have single handedly made things so much worse for ACTUAL victims.
Amber is only being held to account bc Johnny Depp is a famous guy. What i take away from all of this is that very attractive women have the unchallenged privilege of being exactly like this if they choose; complete w/their own narrative of victimization which they can nowadays project daily on social media to thousands of white knight replies.
Imagine being JD and having to sit there for weeks listening all her bs knowing she is mirroring things that she actually did it against you. It's sickening.
Yes, at the 12 minute mark when Amber is parroting back about seeing eyes go black and he wasn't there anymore - that describes the berserk out of control violence mode that a BPD gets into where their eyes do dilate black & their face drains and they are incoherent and violently insane attacking non-stop like in a zombie movie. JD must have described the horror of seeing Amber get like that and not knowing what was attacking him or how to stop her as it was like she wasn't there and instead he was fighting a demon.
Her only real emotion is embarrassment, that’s why she claims it as the worst thing ever, over bottle r@93 and meat grinder beat with heavy rings abuse and being a hostage for days.
As an abuse survivor, I find it fascinating her motions are always the aggressive motion rather than receptive passive victim action as she recounts the interactions of supposed assaults. Another is the fact she never recounts how it FELT. She never states how her body felt but focuses on how she thought. When your getting assaulted you are not thinking, your feeling....
She's very aggressive when she speaks. If this is how she is in front of the world, imagine what she's like behind closed doors. Imagine how bad she treated the maid that found her pooh she left in the bed. I heard she was screaming at her and said hello to everyone except that one maid. Then took her in the other room and yelled. If she's this aggressive and destructive when she knows the world is watching just shows what she's like. The turd is a complete psychotic LIAR
I’m an empathetic person but not once did I believe in her acting. My sorrow is that she is obviously a damaged person and, as they so often do, is taking (or trying to take) others down with her into the abyss. She must’ve watched way too many old films to think that that kind of acting works in 21st century 🤦🏼♀️ Please Johnny Depp take a stand for all the voiceless victims of abuse, whether male or female ❤
Me too. It all seemed so obvious that she is a mess mentally, her storytelling bad acting of a made up story, that she believed she could convince the jury because she believes she's a good actor. This mother's heart saw thru it all and had empathy for her. Johnny is a Saint
I never blieved her acting since she first time appeared with those bruises there was something what didnt fit me all in that time Now i know what.And I think I am not alone
@@MoparMomma I don’t think he’s a saint and he is also damaged, but I love that for once the victim was believed (surely a very rare thing with narcissists being cunningly manipulative, dishonest and a master/mistress of smear campaigns, gaslighting, cruelty, abuse, inconsistency and inflicting isolation), had the good sense not to engage or enter into her dramas, and will hopefully have a voice and his life back. I’m so glad the world saw through the lies and dramas and had his back. I hope he heals well and surfaces up to a more joyful future 🍀🍀🍀
I'm generally not into the celebrity scene, but this trial captivated me. It's such a great study on pathological personality. It had real-life high drama and an Insider view into celebrity life. I support Johnny and think what he did is important for all men hiding behind domestic abuse. Thanks for continuing to analyze Ambers's behavior. You guys are the best.
I totally agree! I would just add, for him (career and perceived manliness) to admit to being abused is a huge step forward for BOYS & men who need support. I also feel it was time to stop the "Believe ALL women, regardless" narrative. That narrative has given opportunity to vindictive women to ruin the lives of many men and their families. ... No investigation/interrogation of either party? Accused = Guilty is wrong!
YES, Greg, Amber does so much detailing and non-denials, she is lying. And Chase is right she is malingering, reversing her and Johnny's roles in every incidence of violence. TRUE, Mark, there's zero evidence of truth in her testimony. And where's the evidence she was injured by broken glass? That's because there is none. She couldn't "see him" because she's in a rage! The fake crying is so bad, ugh! Listen to Incredibly Average's Australian tapes of what occurred, it's really telling. Scott is correct, her body language does not show fear about the incident only that she isn't being believed.
@@eva-jwatts7604 I truly believe Johnny put up with it for 2 reasons (a few more, also but not relevant to what I'm going to say). #1. Being a man versus a woman I think he felt that no matter how hard she hit him she couldn't do the damage the stronger sex can do to the weaker sex. #2. His mother was abusive so he was conditioned to abusive women. I feel so badly for him because he (and everyone else) deserves to be treated so much better than this.
I’m in line with you in terms of celebrity things. I think what captivated people was that money and fame doesn’t mean life is better- it just hides a lot of dysfunctional relationships and Amber’s lies are so bad it was really unreal to watch. I’m glad Johnny went for this battle and won. It clearly was hard to see him reveal his life to the world.
The moment she lost all credibility: Camille: “he hit you repeatedly?” Amber: “yes.” Camille: “was he wearing rings?” Amber: “he always wears rings.” Camille: “so this picture shows you after he repeatedly hit you in the face with rings on?” Amber: “... what was the question?”
She's disgusting, and a horrible actor. How dare she use faked DV and faked PTSD. She makes a mockery of every man, woman and child who really struggle. How dare she so obviously and cavalierly do a bump of whatever she was snorting in front of cameras in a court of law. She should have been called on it. AH demonstrates how she believes she's so brilliant and above us mere "randos" that she can manipulate every and all situations.
to me it is when she is asked about the pictures in the backless dress and she says "I assume you have it". that was clearly her knowing she was fucked.
I believe when she was fake sobbing at that one point, she said "I don't want to do this" and "I can't" because she's waiting for someone to say "Miss Heard do you need a moment?" because she can't figure out what to say next, she got lost in her lines and she needs a minute to remember what to say. She disgusts me.
It's because she truly is narcissistic! They lie even when they KNOW the person KNOWS they are telling lies! It's the first thing they think of - to LIE! They double down of the lies by "remembering" little bits here and there to try and paint a picture that would be more believable. I had a family member who would do this from the time they were a small child! And this trait was carried over even when dealing with other close family members and people she claimed were best friends! It's that they can NEVER admit guilt of fault and simply MUST put that on someone else, and it doesn't matter who gets nailed with it as long as they can "believe" they come off as being innocent! In my opinion it's another sign of mental illness or personality disorder.
I was in an extremely abusive relationship at the age of 18. I got my jaw broken in 7 places... 5 broken ribs... broken collar bone... and more. To this day, if I talk about this... I cry and shake uncontrollably. AH is not believable in any form.
She’s only person I’ve ever heard of being beaten as bad as she claimed, stepping on as much glass as she’s described and “getting rocked in the nose” yet had/have no marks to show for it. Guess she’s got the same abilities as wolverine
As a retired psych RN, I'm amazed that I felt absolutely. NO. Empathetic response to her testimony. I've HEARD many terrible stories from abused women and this is phony all the way!! And her presentation of clothing and hair is to make herself look like " poor PITIFUL me!"
Clothing and hair look more military like or like uniforms that representatives of a totalitarian state or institution would wear. It does not say "poor me" AT ALL. But the EXACT opposite. A lawyer said that AH wore all the wrong clothes. The outfits and often the hair are masculine but she should have looked female, delicate and thus, vulnerable to present herself as the victim she claims she is.
Most JD supporters said that they felt uncomfortable watching Amber 'cry'. They attributed their feelings of discomfort to her lying. We are engrained from birth to feel uncomfortable watching another person in pain. Make your miinds up JD supporters. Are you supposed to feel uncomfortable or nothing? In reality its all very subjective. Behavioral analysis is easy under standard conditions but here we have celebrity using drugs and live TV. This will make behavioral analysis extremely complicated. It means nothing if you feel nothing
@Anne Smith No it's the same video they previously posted except in these edited ones they've added the side bar for video reference, showing us what they're talking about rather than us having to remember how she looked at a specific moment or what she said. I like it!
I remember one time when my ex was black-out drunk and hit me twice in the face with no rings on. My face was almost unrecognizable. Broke both cheekbones. I had 2 black eyes for weeks. My eyes were swollen shut damn near for 2 days. I wish I could honestly say that was the first or last time it happened. To this day I cannot stand the smell of alcohol on a man's breath. She does not represent me.
I think her "breakdown" scene with the dry sobbing was intended to get a compassionate intervention from the judge. When that doesn't happen, she pours it on thicker and even says at one point "I don't wanna do this!" Idk if the judge was being extra careful not to prejudice the jury or if she was just caught up in the cringe like the rest of us, but props to her for not taking that bait!
I actually can't get enough of these analyses if Amber Heard. My ex husband was very much like her and I hope to avoid getting close to another narcissist ever again
I'll go out on a limb, too. I don't believe she was ever trapped in a room or trying to get past him. I believe she is transferring his situations to her own.
absolutely agree! she took his story and made it her own. just like she did with Kate James story (the ra*e allegation. Ms. James stated this in the U.K. trial, and was not believed). Ms. heard is absolutely shameless in her accusations against Mr. Depp. it's appalling that she can sit there and take his story and turn it into her own. however, it's classic narcissistic behavior. I grew up with a narcissistic sibling and witnessed this kind behavior first hand. it's quite disturbing to witness
According to AH, he bashed her head against a marble countertop, threw her into furniture causing it to break, punched her, choked her, dragged her through broken glass, and violated her with a broken liquor bottle. As a survivor of a violent partner, how TF did ALL OF THAT happen but somehow she DIDN’T need medical attention? 🧐
As a DV survivor with PTSD it sickens me to see Amber Heard feigning symptoms of having PTSD..the audio recordings prove she didn't fear Johnny who she claims was abusing her..let me tell you, I did everything I could not to say or do anything to agitate my exhusband because I feared what he'd do to me..the abuse I endured for 7 yrs was extremely violent.. Her inability to recount the sequence of the incident as it happened is her way of giving herself an out for perjury.. Amber's story jumps around and doesn't make sense. Her phony emotional acting is way over the top and not at all believable..
I feel the same about her testimony and the interview she did. The audio recordings expose her for what she really was like. I made myself as small and as quiet as possible with my ex. And I can remember everything he did to me 18yrs later. I cannot express just how disgusting she is.
I agree. It’s not only evident to me in the audio recordings, but also in the known circumstances surrounding their relationship. JD moved multiple members of AH’s friends and/or family into his penthouses so they’d be around for her. I’m not saying it never happens, but I’ve personally never seen a man as controlling and violent as she claims JD was, allow their partner to have such a large and easily accessible support system at their beckon call, and I’ve been dealing w DV survivors for years in my profession. Clearly AH is a very demanding person, in both her relationships and her friendships. Anybody who’s ever been around an abusive or controlling person knows that abusers tend to isolate their partner and keep them on a short leash. When I heard her testimony that she text her friend Rocky to come over during an alleged violent attack (JD’s team alleges Rocky was already hiding in their penthouse, which I tend to believe since it’s supported by other testimony) and Rocky ran and got her key and let herself into their penthouse to allegedly run to AH’s side to protect her, it seemed to be in direct contrast to her claim of him being “controlling”. It’s very hard for me to believe that a man who allows his wife’s friends to have unlimited access into their personal life, is violent and controlling. Imagine a man who regularly and violently attacks his wife allowing her friends to bust in anytime and stand between them. I just can’t see that happening. I think she’s lying about 95% of what she claimed, but that’s jmo.
Exactly. Me too. I did everything I could to make my husband happy... ESPECIALLY when he was angry and violent.... even while panicking on the inside, on the outside I would be very calm and be nice to him and try to help him feel understood and cared about, to calm him down. I would never EVER deride him like we hear Amber doing on the recordings. Oh my God, even if I had had that kind of nastiness in me to begin with, I never would have shown it to him, as I would have been WAY too afraid. And to this day, although I have rarely talked about it... I feel shame, and am very subdued and simply sad, when I describe it, not over the top dramatic like that, EVER. I would be embarrassed to do that, and yes, I have PTSD.
I'm also a DV survivor. I'm so insulted by how she's acting.. I can't take it anymore... I rarely speak about my experience, but I've had to since this trial.. She makes me so angry. Hope you are doing well. Ty for speaking out, it's nice to know I'm not alone.
My partner wasn't physical and I still don't talk about it like this. No hysterics, definitely actual tears. Isolation is one of the primary aspects of an abusive relationship. I keep hearing about all of her friends all around them, living there, traveling with them. The biggest thing discrediting her, for me, were the recordings. She sounds exactly, exactly, like an abuser.. My abuser. It's terrifying. The one where she laughs maniacally pushing him to go like a "all men do". It scared me to death. Others she's talking in circles, every point he makes she discounts, every time he addresses a point she raises, she dismisses it. Around and around until nothing makes sense. We're responsible for our actions, including sobriety, but I'm not surprised he didn't stay sober. I bet his depression was off the charts. And she claims responsibility for none of it, not one thing. She scares the sh!t out of me. I think she's an example of how escalation doesn't stop on it's own. I believe she would have killed him.
When she starts in on the “really trying to cry” part, I’ve never been so uncomfortable watching something in my life. Everyone in that room HAD to feel how theatric that was and it must have been so uncomfortable for that jury. Secondly, a lot of the time the Judge will step in and ask the witness if they need a break when they start getting upset, but this judge doesn’t say a word. Just let’s her dig her own grave, and that speaks to how the judge was feeling in that moment as well.
Agreed, the part about the judge not stopping to give her a break is a really big deal. I’m not sure how many people caught that but it really struck me.
Omg right? It’s so obvious. Doesn’t take a behavioral expert to even see it. I literally have second hand embarrassment listening to her. It’s to off!!!
We are wired as human beings to feel deeply uncomfortable when we see someone experiencing real torture or genuinely in deep plight. This is definitely not your average drama experience. Behavioral so-called experts can BS us all they want. But our gut instincts are wired from birth to read genuine body language deep inside. That's why so many people feel uncomfortable watching this . She may not satisfy the so-called behaviour anal-ists. But consider that Amber's crying makes us uneasy because deep down our guts are telling us we need to be uncomfortable, concerned, worried, whatever. This is not faking. Your baby sixth sense and guts indirectly admitted it .
Attorney Benjamin Chew is a solid litigator. I realize he looks like an affable person. Fluent in Spanish he has represented many foreign governments in court. He has argued cases in the European Court of Human Rights and the international Criminal Court. He is not to be messed with and should be respected for his participation in this case.
It’s so uncomfortable to watch her awful acting, I can only imagine how difficult it was in person for the jury. I can almost bet she watched hours of actual victims of DV testifying in court….and this was her best attempt at emulating that. She’s insane.
She is just bloody terrible to watch. I know pain and I know others that do. That is not what broken looks like when being confronted about suffering. Thats someone that does not know it, trying to display it. Now she may just find out what living with some kind of mental torment is like.
"It’s so uncomfortable to watch her awful acting," I love it, I watch these videos every few days for a good laugh. That part where she goes "Ive never been so scared in my life!" I crack up every time. Comedy gold! :)
Also, she is so much more "upset" SIX years after this supposed attack than she was during the deposition she made at the time, when she was rolling her eyes, smirking and eating cookies the whole time.
When I watched this live, I felt extremely uncomfortable and when they panned over to Johnny, I got really upset for him because I knew in my gut that he was innocent. It just hit me like a ton of bricks that she created a monstrous story and that it was all a lie. I couldn’t stop thinking about it the rest of the day. I was genuinely upset for him because I just knew it was all fake
Imagine how much more palpable this would have been in the court room. It's obvious the people still supporting AH didn't watch any of the trial in any length.
I felt the same. it was so hard to watch, particularly when she was telling Rhianna's story and I almost expected her to be calling him Chris. The only time I've seen anything like this in real life was with children, and you know in your gut that you're being lied to be the trouble maker. Maybe his acting experience pages off for him in court because he stayed quite composed despite the fact that he was obviously perturbed. I'm happy for him though...had he not sat through this he wouldn't have been vindicated.
Since birth we are wired to read body language and feel uneasy when we see someone cry. Even the youngest child even a dog will respond to a crying individual. Your baby gut sense is making you uneasy so that you will respond. Our own feelings of unease will be relieved when we say "there there, pat on the shoulder, or give a hug. It's all basic instincts
What is so ironic about this trial is how easily Heard could have gotten away with it all, even at this stage, if it weren't for the very same personality disorders that caused her to ruin her marriage and engage in this hoax to begin with. She could have sold the world a tale of an imperfect victim engaged in mutual abuse and the jury would probably have believed it enough to accept Depp was hitting her. Instead she tried to present the image of a perfect victim, a saint and a martyr, who suffered literally unbelievable levels of one-sided and unprovoked violence. Not only was her story implausible and her performance poor, her extremely over-the-top descriptions of violence created a new problem regarding her total lack of evidence. If anything, what evidence was shown created endless discrepancies with her tales of broken noses and getting endlessly punched in the face by a fist bedecked in rings. Heard blew up her marriage, but she also blew up her exit route with her hyperbolic and histrionic performances.
So well said!!!! If only she could have held back and made the violence stories at least fit the photos and admitted to also using drugs and alcohol, she might have been more convincing. Instead, she tries to convince us that she’s this perfect, innocent girl from a little town near Texas, who fell in love, was brutally beaten but prevailed with the help of Amica cream, make up, ice and her super human healing abilities… And of course, she over-estimated her acting abilities…
I could not agree more. I have been saying this from the beginning of the trial. It sounds crazy to call Johnny "lucky", but he actually IS lucky that Amber Turd is so fvcking crazy because had she been less crazy and more thoughtful about her ABUSE HOAX, she not only would've gotten away with it initially, but she'd still be getting away with it to this day and Depp's life and career would be OVER for good. Had Amber Turd simply said something like "Johnny was a jealous drunk and occasionally he would go out with friends and get high and drunk, then he'd come home in a jealous rage over an actor I was working with on a movie or an old friend I talked to and he would start slapping me around and belittling me and my acting career". THAT LEVEL OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE STILL WOULD'VE ENDED JOHNNY'S HOLLYWOOD CAREER! PERIOD! Not only that, but that level of violence IS ACTUALLY BELIEVABLE based on her pictures. Even if the pictures are Photoshopped and even if the marks on her face are totally fake and were created BY Amber Turd with her "bruise kit". There wouldn't really be any way to PROVE that they were faked, and the red marks and bruises would at least be consistent with a drunken Depp smacking Amber around in a jealous rage. But she is SO INSANE that she just couldn't help herself. She desperately wanted to have a "survivor story" that involved harrowing levels of violence and seckshual assault. She desperately wanted that level of fame and notoriety for herself, and she desperately wanted to DESTROY Johnny Depp's life and career. So she fabricated these truly insane lies that involved savage beatings where she is claiming that Depp basically came within a millimeter of caving her skull in and killing her, in addition to violent seckshual assaults and R4PES with foreign objects. She even said MULTIPLE TIMES during her performance on the stand that she thought she was GOING TO DIE at the hands of Depp!!! Then she puts up a picture of a little redness on her cheek and claims the picture was taken after one of these BRUTAL beatings. LMFAO! It's actually really scary to think about how this could've ended for Depp had Amber Turd been even slightly sane. The same level of insanity that ruined Depp's life and career is the same level of insanity that saved him. And that is exactly why Depp fought to have this trial televised. Because he KNEW that Amber Turd's lies would be immediately evident to the entire world if we were able to see her full testimony ourselves without it first being DELIBERATELY EDITED by the propagandist mainstream media to make AMBER TURD look like the victim. Amber's craziness coupled with this trial being televised are what saved Depp's career and probably his life as well. I can certainly see Depp ODing (either accidentally or deliberately) or taking a lethal cocktail of drugs and alcohol at the same time had Amber Turd actually been successful in ending Depp's acting and music careers and destroying his good name and reputation publicly. Scary to think about.
What I love about the BP is that you guys explain why I feel weird about people who are being deceptive. I can’t identify these things specifically, but I just know in my gut that something is off. With Amber, my jaw was on the floor, it was such obvious acting. I can’t believe she thought this would fool anyone. It’s like a bad after-school special. That girl needs help.
Ya know, when she was "crying hysterically" and stammering around and at a loss for words, I'm thinking she had reached the point where she was hoping against hope that the judge would intercede and ask her if she needed a break (poor thing), thus giving her the chance to regroup and have a chance to reorganize her story.
and that time i was thinking maybe the judge was allowing her to have that "meltdown" so that the jury can really see through her lies... that's why the Judge never called a break.
Yeah, I think the judge was so fed up with their shenanigans in her courtroom (the fake Gina post, passing notes, b$tching about everything, objecting to their own questions, obviously lying), she was ready to let the client fry herself.
That's exactly what my thoughts were at the time watching it live. She was hoping the judge would stop everything and would say "the witness needs a break... Get her a tissue"🤣 When that didn't happen, she became even more awkward, and she twisted, pretended to cry, and used that poor wasted tissue, trying to rub her non existent tears from her face. 😂
You guys make me feel so validated for how I felt about her during this horrible display of ridiculous!!! Thank you Greg for mentioning the menthol on her tissue, I said that's what she was doing all along because the way she used that tissue was just odd!!! It's so hard to watch over again, her performance is laughable!!
If you go watch the interview of Rhiannia after Chris brown beat her…she steals her exact words, it will blow your mind. It’s just like I believe she used the movie Gone Girl as her playbook.
The way she changed her emotions so very quickly when someone says "objection". It's as if she's making a movie and someone shouts "cut". Depp's lawyers said it was the performance of her life. It may of been, but it wasn't a very good one.
I know what you mean. It's the lack of authenticity. She is using all the right words, but her whole delivery is inconsistent with someone who has actually been through the kind of abuse she is talking about. If she had been sent flying across a glass covered floor, beaten senseless over and over again by a strong man wearing large, heavy rings and then had her head bounced off a solid wooden bar repeatedly, she would at very least have needed hospital treatment for all the cuts and broken bones she would have had. She is describing a "movie fight", like when Rocky gets beaten all around the ring but keeps getting back up. In reality he wouldn't have survived. Same here. If her description was true, she'd have the visible scars to prove it.
Amber stole the story from someone else's experience. She got that "his eyes were black...I couldn't see him " thing from Rhianna talking about her experience where she actually had a beat up face and canceled shows and sought medical attention and the police report. Amber had and did none of these.
There is a Clip I watched of AH and Johnny where Johnny is taking a nap and AH is watching a movie with exact see scrip as what she said through out the trial. It was rehearsed and planned for a long time. Fake
The part about panicking helped explain why I simultaneously did not feel even the slightest temptation to be moved, and why I also sensed something more than acting was going on. I never thought before now that "I don't want to do this" might mean "I'm in way too deep now." Also, I LOVE the editing. The simultaneous voices is just cool.
@@plutoxn It's like a toddler getting themselves all worked up: first comes the "dry crying" and the yelling and then they get themselves worked up enough that the 'real" crying" comes along.
I was very conflicted, because I instantaneously knew Heard's body language exuded "I'm in way too deep... Am I going to get caught?" However, I washed myself of biasness and wanted to hear what Amber had to say. So, I then viewed her testimony trying to seek the truth, which was extremely difficult, because she constantly mixed her truths with lies. I didn't know what to believe, but I did know she was lying a lot. So, I tried imagining Heard was telling the truth. Then I noticed after the 10 day court break, Amber's whole demeanor changed, and I instantaneously knew she lied about almost everything. Especially, the abuse.
@Mary Russell THANK GOD the court didn't fall for her fakery; it would have gone badly for Johnny if they had! No doubt these are the methods she has used all her life to manipulate people and it's obvious they have worked, else she wouldn't be using them NOW. I was happy the judge was a WOMAN; a MAN might well have fallen for her nonsense! . Johnny's legal team was superb; Amber's team was a farce, except for Rottenborn, and I got the impression all along he was doing his job and nothing more, defending the FRAUD that was Amber! The fact that he immediately bowed out of the case once the verdict was spoken and was never heard[sic] from again spoke VOLUMES. Elaine, not so much! I had a strong suspicion she had "hot pants" for Amber, hence her ongoing "public defense"of her! Wonder if she herself called a halt or somebody else woke her up to what she was doing ! LOL!
I’m a DV survivor and I can still tell you who, what, when and where. It leaves an indelible mark on you. I had to file a restraining order and there was no way in hell I would go to him and ask for a hug. I thought she has PTSD. People with that would never go to the abuser and ask for a hug. To me, this is just to try and bring him back in.
I thought he showed enormous restraint. He was thoughtful, hesitant and very funny at times on the stand. Anguish and sadness and disappointment in a failed relationship and an enormous betrayal came over strongly. I loved it when he asked Mr Rottenborn 'is that the document I've already signed three times?' And the mega pint did me in.
No. He’s thinking, “I loved her. I would have died for her.” Then, like he said on one of the recordings, he realizes THAT woman he loved & would have died for didn’t exist. Lastly, he realizes what he held in his arms & cherished is the creature on the stand filled with duplicity, hatred, deceit & malevolence.
I always thought that when all this dramatic crying was taking place that the judge would have asked if she needed a minute…. I can only conclude that even the judge didn’t even believe her ❤️❤️❤️you guys
I think that's what she'd been hoping for, to buy herself time remembering what to say. But no one was buying it. I'm a very empathic person, if someone is upset or even says something sad I mirror that sadness and often endnup crying with them. I've heard others who are the same say this same thing...she didn't elicite an empathetic response in me, ididn't get upset or sad. I got angry, indignant, frustrated (all on Johnny's behalf and that she was clearly concocting this story), and I even heavily cringed. It was terrible acting, made worse by the lack of tears and ridiculousness of what she said (he wasn't there, it wasn't him anymore... too many horror films or was she having some kind of hallucination/psychotic moment?)
I thought the same thing...even the judge doesn't believe her!! AND her own attorney was hoping that maybe just maybe Amber would be able to produce some tears this time!
It really is spooky seeing how she remembers everything JD did but when it comes to recalling her/their own actions, it's blurry. They makes me believe even more so that she was abusive.
Exactly what I was thinking like is she serious? Difference between both Johnny would own up to his mistakes while she's still in denial like if she has taken notes on what they call "plead the 5th" problem is that she doesn't know how to use that word properly
Absolutely right! She was remembering what she did to him, I bet. He was the victim. That statement of the thrown bottle whizzing near her head? That's what SHE did to HIM. If one follows the encounters she's had with other people: punching her girlfriend in the arm in an airline building where the police caught her and filed a report, punching Elon in the face after which those bruises were visible in some pictures online, and beating up her own sister, etc. Also she was arrested around the age of 15 of driving with a friend in a car. The car crashed and her friend died. She was arrested for that so the police must have found she did something unlawful, perhaps drinking or drugs?
I don't think that what she claims to remember about "what he did" is actually true. I think his running away from confrontations is true. But the rest of what she's accusing him of is not true because that is not in his nature. All his previous lovers and those who know him well have sworn in court that Mr. Depp has never and would never do those things. She has to make him look like the bad guy and that she is the victim, when actually it is exactly in reverse. She is the evil one and he is the victim. Apparently she fed him drugs just as it was reported recently that she did to her "friends" like Cara De LaVigne, and the young girls she groomed to attend sex parties and service the guys. She apparently has in the past beaten up her own sister, punched Elon Musk - a former lover, hit her other former lover (an actor from Mexico), her "friends," etc. She is a grave danger to others and the authorities need to act on this.
Every time I watch her I imagine the incredible amount of damage she is describing like when she supposedly received a broken nose and tells the jury the reason why her nose isn’t swollen or discolored it “usually with that kind of injury the damage isn’t that bad and for me it wasn’t bad at all!” What? A broken nose is a lot of damage. Rings would burst the skin on her face leaving a ton of swelling and bruising none of which could be covered up with a “bruise kit”
As someone who has had his nose broken for him on a couple different occasions and had my face struck, it’s absolutely surreal that she would make these outlandish claims of brutal alleged violence. It doesn’t take a full power strike to give you a serious black eye. I’ve had plenty. They hurt, they’re apparent, and they take a while to go down. I have never taken a hit from a person wearing rings like Johnny’s. But as you say, if any of her nonsense was true, she would have been lacerated, swollen, and bloodied. No amount of makeup or ice would be able to hide it. She would have required medical attention. Her teeth would have likely been broken. Her facial bones would have been broken. Women’s skulls are actually different than men’s. They are less likely to take damage without serious consequences. I have a hard time believing Amber has experienced a fist to the face. Ever. I don’t believe she has ever experienced injuries caused broken glass. It’s super easy to get deeeeep cuts with even an accidental exposure to shards of glass. If her bare back had fallen on it, she would have required medical attention and would likely have visible scars, even after it healed. She wouldn’t be wearing a backless dress. Maybe never again. She is despicable.
@@yakhooves Ikr. She keeps forgetting about the whole Scarring thing an how Bruises change Color over time. Oh of course She's like Wolverine from the X-Men so she doesn't seem to have the problems us mere mortals have 🤦♀️
She's just talking rubbish. I fainted once and hit my nose on a hard floor. For weeks and weeks, my eyes and nose were puffy and bruised. Not even if her nose wasn't broken, but she'd been hit
This analysis is so great because most of us watching could sense that she was lying, that something wasn't right and its great to be validated here. I appreciated Chase just calling it as it is "this is deception", there's no getting around that.
this trial, particularly amber's testimony is a great real life study on narcissistic personality and good for behavioral students to criticize and analyze
Camille was so calm, cool and collected. I am extremely impressed at her professionalism at handling a Mid-Range Cluster B Narcissist and not allowing that narcissist to get her off track or pull her into the narrative the narcissist wanted to go. Camille is a Queen👸🏽. One of the best lawyers I have seen in a very long time.
I thought if JD had a guy instead of Camille it would have fallen flat and failed, no matter how good he could have been, by appearing bullying and mean. She was perfect for the job she had to do: prove A a liar. But, I'm not familiar with your description of A and those terms, but I can recognize an egomaniacal, man-hating sociopath. Is that what you're saying I think? Great comment, tho. 🙂
@@lauroandrea3241 Wrong. So sad you can't spot a narcissist; means you are one or you are being used by one. She is VERY much a Mid-Range Cluster B Narcissist in addition to being a Psychopath and diagnosed with BOTH Borderline Personality Disorder AND Histrionic Personality Disorder (last two are by Dr. Shannon Curry). Just because it did not come up in the courtroom does not mean she doesn't have that particular personality disorder. Look up the definition of a Mid-range Cluster B Narcissist (also HG Tudor is an ULTRA narcissist and has done an extensive breakdown of why she is also a narcissist) If you want to see that, his youtube channel is HG Tudor or you can google his name online. There are also other channels like: The Behavioral Arts (he also has a psychology degree) and The Body Language guy that have all concluded the same thing. HOWEVER you need 5 of these 9 traits to be diagnosed as a Narcissist (the severity of each determines what range narcissist you are) and she fits ALL 9: 1.Have a grandiose sense of self-importance. 2. Preoccupied by fantasies such as those of unlimited success, brilliance, beauty, power, or ideal love. 3. Believe they are special or unique and can only be understood by and associate with people of a certain standing. 4. Require excessive admiration. 5. Have a sense of entitlement. 6. Manipulates others to achieve their own gains. 7. Lacks empathy. 8. Often envious of others or believes others are envious of them. 9. Display arrogant and haughty behaviors or attitudes. AND look up the definition of a Psychopath...she literally fits EVERY single symptom listed in the dictionary: Glibness/superficial charm Grandiose sense of self-worth Need for stimulation/proneness to boredom Pathological lying Conning/manipulative Lack of remorse or guilt Shallow affect (i.e., reduced emotional responses) Callous/lack of empathy Parasitic lifestyle Poor behavioral controls Promiscuous sexual behavior Early behavioral problems Lack of realistic, long-term goals Impulsivity Irresponsibility Failure to accept responsibility for one's own actions Many short-term marital relationships Juvenile delinquency (there is a mug shot to prove jail time as a youth)
@@lauroandrea3241 They often go hand in hand, we have one in our family, my doctor told me BPD with narcissism, she just happens to have histrionics with it. 🙄💯🙃🐨🦘
On the recordings, she sounds so loud, aggressive, in control and ready to strike, for that reason, it's hard for me to believe that she's being dragged around, scared feeling hopeless and defenceless. I can smell her BS*. What a disgusting human being, she is so malicious.
I went into watching the trial having not seen any Amber videos before, so i had no baseline, also I had been biased by the media's reporting against JD. So i was curious. Once Amber actually took the stand, I couldn't believe what she was saying, it was like watching someone lie to me, someone gas lighting me..something I have experienced enough over a period of time to immunize me to it. It appeared that she had reversed roles with JH in the attacks. No wonder they didnt want this broadcast, because seeing IS believing, and seeing Amber made me believe JD was the true victim here. Being a parent of 3 adult children also plays into this for me. Parents have to sort through accusations, fights, lies, etc., to get to the truth when dealing with kids, and this reminded me of certains times I sat patiently listening to one of my kids lying about something that happened, amazed at the preposterous tale he spun. It would have been easier to believe he had been abducted by aliens. My kids eventually concluded, "you can't lie to dad, he just seems to know, he's a mind reader" I wasnt a mind reader, they were just bad liars. Amber is a bad liar. Just let her talk.
This is exactly how I felt. I knew nothing until the trial and I am not a fan of either one. I do know what is to experience DV. AH was so unbelievable. I felt very sorry for JD. I am glad this opened up the topic of DV and the stigma male endure as suspected abusers. Anyone can be a victim. She needs help and I hope she gets it, at least for her little girl's sake.
@@pelipequi1493 I also felt sorry for him thinking about the gaslighting he probably had to endure with the "Monster". The guy is broken and has demons and characters and she brought them out in this relationship. She was trying to convince him that he was doing horrible things when he was blacked out and he, someone who is already fearing this .
I am a survivor of dv and I agree with all of you. As I watched I felt sick, angry and somewhat embarrassed for her because she sounds so ridiculous. I'm angry, offended and disgusted she's using the pain of experiences victims have gone through to suit her selfish needs. I was able to relate with Johnny's testimony which helped me to brlieve him, understand him, how he felt, what he went through, the confusion he felt and why he didn't get out of the situation even though he had enough money to go. He's human too. I'm really glad I found your channel. It helped me to understand some things I was feeling. I keep thinking of something new to say. I'm also disgusted with her lawyers. Do they really believe her? They can't be that naive. I'm also surprised she didn't do more to hurt Johnny. He's lucky to have gotten out alive. Thank God!
Same here. I've been in a few abusive relationships in my lifetime. You don't act like her and if you cry, it's very hard to go back to not crying. And it's the survivor who won't look at you if they have PTSD. She stares him down the way abusers do.
She almost always smiled when referring to hurting JD. That quick little smile was her way of reliving her hurting him and the joy she got from it is undeniable.
@@lyricessence Thanks. That smile is fleeting. I can see why people may have missed it. I am headed to TBA to see what they say. I, also, am glad you caught it. (Some people doubted my observation) In my mind, this makes her serial killer potential rank very high. I have given thought to the idea she would be capable of torturing JD's dog as a proxy of torturing him. It is clear she wants to torture JD emotionally and physically. And she aint done. Yet.
@@uselesscause3178 I agree too. There are an awful lot of people who see this charade from a very different viewpoint & will be convinced that she couldn't possibly lie so confidently. Those people have never lived with a narcissist. I sometimes watch these videos, several times over. Mostly because I can hardly believe the absolute NERVE she has, to sit there in front of the whole court, PLUS millions watching on tv & try & ACT her way out of it. KNOWING that these lies have destroyed another person's life! I know that if I were in court, guilty like she is, I would crumble immediately under cross examination. You have to have an obscene amount of arrogance, to stick your nose in the air & wade through the lies, without ever once looking embarrassed or ashamed. But I do love to watch Camille, slap her down & make her shut her mouth. You can see that Heard HATES it & that she despises Camille. A young woman, telling her to be quiet! How dare she. You just know that in everyday life, if anybody told her to shut her mouth, she'd be out there, fists ablazing. This has probably been the only time in her life when she has had to obey, sometimes. She clearly pushes it even with Camille, continuing to talk when she's been told to stop. But it's worth watching, just to see Camille laugh at her nonsense.
Believe me true DV survivors like myself know how sympathetic you guys all are regarding DV. I never believed her testimony, it was pathetic. SHE is the ONLY person who has offended true DV survivors. Thank You, guys, for these AMAZING evaluations…I am certainly not an expert and your explanations have explained precisely why I felt “so off” while watching her. Complete deception.
Everyone knows now that Amber cheated on Depp with Elon, and others,So if he's the father of her child... He needs to think about the welfare of the child. She's An abuser, and A liar, she's pathetic.
When someone is upset and crying people usually feel upset for them. But, this is a load of ridiculous hog wash. I can not feel any sympathy for her I just want to shout SHUT UP IT IS EMBARRASSING! Basically this is all lies.
Poor Jonny.... this woman should be punished, not only because of what she tried to do to JD but because of how she plays on something that is real to millions of real victims. Its horriffic
I can tell you the instant I knew she was lying. She said broken liquor bottles were on the floor, she was slipping on the glass and alcohol and she never mentioned how bad the alcohol hurt getting into cuts on her feet. Alcohol burns like hell in any open wound.
I felt absolutely nothing towards/for Amber when she was testifying except anger. I endured 18 yrs of IPV and none of her stories touched me or made me feel grief or sadness towards her. She lied amd lied and lied.
Your history of IPV gives you disadvantage in judgement between couples. There will be some kind of bias which depends on who you believe is the perpetrator and who you perceive the victim. Subjective.
@@Goodzillla1066 for someone who's trying to make people feel bad for amber heard's account of ipv you sure have no issue shooting down other people's account of ipv by saying their judgment is disadvantaged, their experience makes them biased and SUBJECTIVE? Obviously everyone's life experience molds their beliefs, who are you to start discounting that? Disgusting, it's clear a majority of people side with depp, you may side with heard but what gave you the right to discount the feelings of other ipv victims other than heard?
@@Goodzillla1066 You are wrong what happens is we survivors recognise the behaviours of the abuser. They are ALL very similar it's why we comment we SEE it. 💯👍🙃🐨🦘
I love Ben's reaction during the pledged/donated issue, he is absolutely astounded lol and poor johnny isn't the least bit surprised. I believe at some point it even looks like he says "I told you" or something along those lines to Ben. Everyone is legitimately shocked she has the audacity to insist or maintain the things she does but he knows who she is and how far she will go.
This women is a train wreck The fact that she's still out spending money as if she's a millionaire.She openliy breaks the law & abuses people with no consequeses .
Mark Bowden always steals my breath when I see that surfer energy hair, classy intelect and dynamic personality mash up. All four of you gentlemen are a priceless resource of knowledge, so no shade implied. I just find it impossible to look away when Mark is in motion.
It is such an odd experience watching her testimony. You normally would feel sorry for someone who is describing DV, but you end up laughing at the AH with the bad, overacting and feeling icky for giving her this attention while she tells her lies. You also feel I am witnessing a crazy person with my own eyes.
Mark seems unaware that Ben Chew is one of the most lauded and brilliant trial attorneys around. He led the entire legal team for Johnny and hand picked the best counsel from four of Brown Rudnick's offices around the United States to argue this case. Mark, meet Ben, you'd really like him.
I'm generally very empathetic and when I hear true victims of crime (family of missing/murdered people), I choke and it has a powerful effect. Without having any training in body language, I have to say watching Amber Heard breaking down and sobbing, describing the assaults on her I felt nothing - except maybe the mild amusement of watching a bad actress in a B movie. Nothing.
Im the same but watching Amber i feel disgust and a deep sense of injustice. Something deep in the gut. I don't want to say a reaction to evil, maybe to lies designed to destroy an innocent person, with a manipulation and disrespect of what truth even is, it feels very sinister and I feel horror and hostility and disbelief too.
@@loislewis5229 I actually said that to my hubby, IF I was on jury duty (which is unlikely) since I am in Australia 🇦🇺 I said I would have laughed, or the very least a stifled giggle 😃 glad I'm not the only one, I'm not trying to be disrespectful to JD It's just that she was that bad!! 👍💯🙃🐨🦘
It's crazy how a good actor in a movie can draw me into to empathize with them & bring me to tears but she makes me feel like I am watching someone drunk at a funeral making an ass of themselves that all I want to do is look away in embarrassment and disgust.
What I find fascinating is through all the violence she claims she went through. Feet arms legs in glass never did she get medical treatment? And she heals so fast almost like she has super hero powers where she heals after such traumatic treatment.
I’m an enormous empath and cry at commercials. Her gross performance evokes disgust from me and embarrassment for her. A manipulative entitled liar who thinks she can outsmart the world. Lock her up!!
I’m like you and she leaves me cold and repulsed. There is no real emotion in her other that when she talks about “people don’t like me” because she has to have everyone worship at her feet. Repulsive.
In Johnny's place, I don't know if I could have held a straight face with some of her bad acting. I think I would have been unconsciously making faces and smirking, especially at this story.
The line. "I couldn't see his eyes, they were black I couldn't see him." Was actually the EXACT verbiage and hand motions that Rihanna used when describing when CB beat her. Compare the two, Riri is where she got that monolog almost word for word when she's doing that fake crying
She’s done her research. The problem is that she’s literally doing a class project in school and instead of doing her own work, she’s plagiarized the entire thing. She’s taken what she’s seen from TH-cam videos and elsewhere of other, real victims’ depositions and copied and pasted, claiming it as her own. Not just Rihanna’s (poor girl) but Johnny Depp’s too. It’s like watching a horror movie. And not horror porn like Saw, this is Silence of the Lambs stuff. Not that she eats people literally but figuratively and she’s trying to mimic behaviours and mind control people and doing a really bad job. This isn’t even bad soap opera acting. My mom was abused and when she would even reference it, there were snorts, sniffs, tears everywhere, her face was just a mess, her eyes were red and she was covered in tears and snot. Amber leaves the stand way too put together for someone recounting physical violence by a partner. Oh yeah, Ms Fenty also had unmistakable bruising on her face, like you’d see if you were hit hard.
Lets be clear here: when she went on the Dutch talkshow, she said she “DONATED” all of the money. “Every penny…. I wanted nothing” So she knew she was lying, it’s not a confusion about the words pledge and donate.
Ffs, and what if she eventually pays the remaining amount? Does that suddenly convert her from a filthy liar to a truther? Y'all contradicting yourselves, She can't suddenly be a liar and suddenly be truther because of the last penny. Good grief 😡
@@Goodzillla1066 no. If she’d said I will pay it all then she wouldn’t have been lying, unless of course she never pays it. What made her a lier is that she said she had paid. Past tense.
@@Lovelee123 Oh so now we have the GRAMMAR police accusing her of lying? 🚨 🚨 You will find more filthy *grammar liars* around you every day, friends, family, at work, at school, certainly government. Go pick on those *grammar liars* if you really want to live up to that principle and not be a double standard hypocrite. Go ahead shout at them "Lier Lier" (sic) but fix your own grammer (sic) and spelling first
Exactly, she is describing everything only changes the victim and the perpetrator, a disgusting human being. even tough she will keep future sugardaddies, will get millions of dollars for her book which will be called “if a was the real abuser, how would I have abused jD”, similar to OJ Simpson disgusting book, at the end she will die alone , her daughter at the age of 12, will abandoned her, as she will read through the coral media durignher mothers trial and appeal. amber will have a couple years of money.making possibilities, afterwards she will wither away lonely and isolated from her family and friends, pure disgust if I look at her
The secondhand embarrassment I'm getting from her (fake) breakdown is unimaginable. Imagine being one of the jury, AH pointing that comically exaggerated frowning emoji at them, like a child throwing a temper tantrum for not getting their way. Idk, I feel like people would be more likely to avoid eye contact, hide their face due to shame, for appearing weak in front of an audience, during a flashback?
I'm just appalled that someone would lie about such a serious thing. What kind of person does that? I grow so tired of the awful things people do to each other in this world I appreciate the analysis you guys provide. Fantastically informative. Thankyou
As someone with BPD I think a lot of people miss this one thing. There had to be something small to make her believe something big. Maybe Johnny accidentally grabbed her bare leg. Not even with a bottle. Just grabbed. Or He brushed he leg with a cup. Something like that could truly make someone with BPD start to make a lie based in “truth”. Or whatever she thinks is true from he POv. I truly do not believe she knows she’s lying anymore. I think she truly believe me this happened because she just made a false reality out of her feelings.
Her behavior was… and is…criminal abuse. She can no longer punch him but continued to abuse him with her Op-Ed. She abused him from the stand for three weeks, and still persists retelling her lies in public! I wonder if even criminal charges would shut her up?
I know, why do people go out of their way to hurt and in this case also lie about something that can hurt others, especially someone that they claimed to 💕. Someone who has been truly abused really doesn't want to share this kind of information with anyone. Don't understand why she would want to live in a home 🏠 penthouse owned by JD if she was so horrified by him
Incredible editing on this one guys. You are really stepping it up in the cutaways with the visual moments syncing up with exactly what the person is saying and describing. Sometimes in the past it could be difficult to line up precisely those moments but you've really just unlocked the right recipe for it. Excellent work.
I STILL find myself pouring over these for hours.. but the new edits help me discern the actual gestures so much better… it’s helped me cut the hours back… ( but I’m not letting anybody know this , all my people know I am busy and out of circulation from 1pm Thurs onward!!!
Exactly what Scott said: Back when I watched her testimony I had to laugh at the most dramatic part and back then I felt really bad about that, but it was my intuition. It felt so unbelievable and totally ridiculous. Now that Scott explained it's normal to giggle at that part I feel a bit better. It was in fact unbelievable and totally ridiculous.
I think everyone--especially the media--needs to be asking Chase's question: "What kind of person would be comfortable doing all of this?" Thanks for this. Just found you by listening to this morning's live with Incredibly Average's first installment of her full deposition on the divorce case (from the chat recommendations). Subbed.
If there were "several" incidents in that month where he beat her in the face while wearing rings, she would have witnesses and pictures showing the damage that would have lasted for a month+
Normally I get upset watching someone crying and relating some kind of trauma, no matter who they are or what their experience has been but, weirdly, she just left me completely cold.
I know right it's like something in me just feels horrible for them even if it's something on T.V.! Yet with Her I just was almost getting a lil agitated. That's Definitely not like Me all.
I was revolted at this utterly disgusting and pathetic attempt at manipulation and deception. She's simply put an empty husk trying to pass for a human.
I just cannot imagine how shocking it would be to JD hearing these lies coming from her mouth. I would personally have a hard time listening to this if this were me. Kudos to him for keeping his focus on writing on his notepad with his head down. How shameful her lies are. Very unnerving to see someone this deceptive. I would be terrified to be in a relationship with someone like this. Thank goodness he got out.
I had to listen to my narcissistic mother do the same thing. I thought similar- even if Johnny could restrain his body listening to all those lies its harder to control your face- open mouth suprize at the chutzpah or anger and disgust at the injustice of it all showing in the mouth. Its hard to repress when they are spontaneous reactions at what Heard is saying. He must have had some very strong coaching from his counsel.
I almost think he already knew mostly what she was going to say because, aside from the outright fabrications, the story told was what happened just with the roles reversed. He lived with it for 4-6 years. The shock of the lies had long since worn off.
@@KlockoFett maybe, some of it seemed on the fly new lies. Like, just now making up as she went along. Absolutely terrible no matter which way you look at it.
It must have been so hard hard for him to hear this crap. And not be able to say anything. As for me when I watched this I was yelling at the screen. With disgust for her such a liar. None of this felt real. I know abuse as many of us do.
@Christina Forsythe I absolutely adore it when mark goes off on his tangents… I love his interpretations along with his accessing his classical knowledge about words, and theatre arts and the human condition…all four of these men bring unique gifts to the table .. and I especially love Marks sense of humour!!
I have to disagree on Mark! He’s hilarious and feels like he would be the most fun to hang out with. They all are entertaining but he reminds me of the guy who wore the vests in “ Four Weddings And A Funeral”😂💗
This testimony is the most unbelievable nonsense I have ever heard. I watched a lot of this trial but I am glad I missed this part. Thank you, guys, for your analysis. This woman is evil.
The ' I didn't see him it wasn't johhny' was completely stolen from Rihanna's genuine description of the abuse by Chris Brown. interesting that neither council nor judge ever asks if she needs a break - they knew it was all bull💩
Amber never realised that repeating back her testimony about the abuse was actually a trap. She always answered as if repeating her claims was helpful to her
It was the glass scene that did it for me. I stepped on one small piece of glass once and it gouged a big hole in my foot. I had 8 stitches it hurt like hell. She would have had to go to hospital and have glass removed from her feet if what happened to her actually happened
16:28 'A survivor would break eye contact when telling their story.' -Greg. I agree. I also feel that the last thing a survivor would do is stare-down the jury.
I've only ever told my husband about previous abuse and I couldn't even look at him when I told him then I said I don't want to discuss it further just needed him to know.
From 12:52 - 13:40 it is just ridiculous. I could not have been on the jury. At this point I would have had to raise my hand and tell the judge, "your honor, if you can make her stop, we can give our verdict right now."
Why didn't she just LEAVE? Did she really want his money that badly. She's vile lying gold digger. Just go away. You're a crap actress, fairly attractive so she'll pull another chump, until she attempts to knock him about lol 😆
Credit to Johnny for sitting there calmly listening, lie after lie after hideous lie, this woman is either the ultimate evil representation of a woman or she's insane.....
I’m generally an empathetic person! I tend to see the good in most people. But watching her try and destroy another persons life with these lies, she deserves everything she has coming to her!
I really feel like when she was acting dramatic & the fake tears etc, she was hoping for the judge to intervene & give her a break. There were various pauses & then she restarted the emotions & her testimony. So glad the judge didn’t.
Penny was justing chewing the popcorn watching that big acting roll Amber did on the stand. Penny didn't want to pause that show for no intermission break.
Elaine probably coached her on that. It's true that judges often do that. It was done to me when I got on the stand and I was ok at first but when things got difficult I couldn't continue without a break. I fought hard to stay focused and honest but when the trauma started peeking through the carefully crafted exterior I had created for the world there was no way to stop the tears, the fear, the anxiety. If you are a survivor of DV and/or SA, just because you can move forward in your life doesn't mean that trauma will completely heal.
@@Kepi_Kei First I want to say I am so sorry you went through the trauma you did. I agree with you wholeheartedly on your assessment of her testimony of the trauma she went through. True victims can see through her theatrics. It is a crime or should be, that she used true victims for financial gain!
Love, love, love this new format! Makes it so much easier to see the body language as you’re talking about it. You guys are awesome, just love your different takes. Top quality! Love this channel!
I am a survivor of both childhood and domestic abuse and have been diagnosed with CPTSD. I still remember exactly what happened during the last incident with my exhusband although the amount of time is distorted. I know where I was and where he was during the entire thing despite the fact that I was having trauma responses in that moment. It's been over 12 years and I still cry everytime I try to express the emotions that I was feeling while it was happening. Her behavior is just like my mother and hearing the audio was bone chilling because I heard her voice. It actually made me nauseous.
I'm a survivor as well. I find it amazing the amount of times she has no clear memory of ANY of her "alleged " abuse. I can clearly recall mine in excruciating detail. Especially the sequence. AH is not a real victim.
I'm now in my late 70s, and my radar is still not good. I need to ask someone to help me decide if a new person is "safe" or not. I'm so accustomed to surprising my internal voice, it's virtually silent. Keep on working at it, and try to believe your first doubts instead of questioning them.
I’m not a body language expert… And it took me no time at all to see she’s lying! And badly lol. So bizarre to hear someone speaking that weird tense about something that supposedly gave you the highest level of PTSD one can have
"I looked in his eyes and it was just black" - with the benefit of hindsight and analysis, we now know that she actually *stole* this description, almost word for word, from an interview that Rihanna gave after her assault. The reason she flounders is because she can't remember what her next line is - she cusses herself for it, then tries to buy time. Interesting to note that the judge, who has a duty of care, doesn't suggest a break - clearly she wasn't buying the act either. xx
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE: th-cam.com/users/thebehaviorpanel
MERCH STORE: thebehaviorpanel.myspreadshop.com/
FACEBOOK GROUP: facebook.com/groups/thebehaviorpanelists
⏳ TIME IS ; not on your side girl you lost a good thing and I don't even feel sorry for you you deserve to lose him cuz he didn't deserve you I think you're evil cruel manipulative vindictive and I think you had it in for Johnny Johnny is so cool down to earth he's beautiful person inside and out his smile his laughter everything about him is beautiful and I bet you don't like that do you go find yourself a low life just like you cuz you will never make movies you'll never be in pictures you're a nobody you're nothing you're just an evil evil b**** and he didn't deserve you not for a day a minute never Johnny was he's just too good for you you you deserve everything you get good life good luck finding love the world is on to you if I was in front of your face I'd beat you down you know that girl I would kick your freaking ass for what you have done to Johnny Johnny is a good man the world loves him the world stands behind him everybody sees right through you why don't you go crawl under a rock go hide somewhere I would never want to show my face especially and around Hollywood and you don't you don't even think you done nothing wrong you've done everything wrong is why you lost the man that loved you the man that would have seen you would have carried you through life he deserves to be loved he deserves to have a good woman a good beautiful woman not a ugly skeleton evil devil woman like you God have mercy on your soul
No
P
¹q
Question: can you evaluate someone with Oculopharangeal muscular dystrophy?
This woman is insane. Insane. I'm disgusted by the media giving her, the ABUSER, a platform to continue her defamation! If Johnny had lost this case, there's NO WAY they'd invite him on to tell tall tales. This woman, & Smollet, have single handedly made things so much worse for ACTUAL victims.
I'm so glad you have all confirmed that the jury did their job without question correctly in this case.
Shes the lowest of the low
It’s terrifying how insane she is , she needs real help
Amber is only being held to account bc Johnny Depp is a famous guy. What i take away from all of this is that very attractive women have the unchallenged privilege of being exactly like this if they choose; complete w/their own narrative of victimization which they can nowadays project daily on social media to thousands of white knight replies.
Same here
Imagine being JD and having to sit there for weeks listening all her bs knowing she is mirroring things that she actually did it against you. It's sickening.
This trial has taught me a lot about keeping your composure! Something I am terrible at! But if Johnny can stay chill(ish) then I know it’s possible!
I think so too. I think she's explaining what he experienced.
He's probably just relieved that security are present this time.
Yes, at the 12 minute mark when Amber is parroting back about seeing eyes go black and he wasn't there anymore - that describes the berserk out of control violence mode that a BPD gets into where their eyes do dilate black & their face drains and they are incoherent and violently insane attacking non-stop like in a zombie movie. JD must have described the horror of seeing Amber get like that and not knowing what was attacking him or how to stop her as it was like she wasn't there and instead he was fighting a demon.
@@alysgrant6732 I thought so too, as she rattles off the different scenes.
It's like watching an alien attemp to fake human emotions without ever experiencing any.
She is a pretend person. Very sad😪
Well put! Soooo bizarre.
Her only real emotion is embarrassment, that’s why she claims it as the worst thing ever, over bottle r@93 and meat grinder beat with heavy rings abuse and being a hostage for days.
🤣🤣🤣so true
I truly feel sorry for her. She’s in a prison of her own making.
As an abuse survivor, I find it fascinating her motions are always the aggressive motion rather than receptive passive victim action as she recounts the interactions of supposed assaults. Another is the fact she never recounts how it FELT. She never states how her body felt but focuses on how she thought. When your getting assaulted you are not thinking, your feeling....
Exactly. Her body language is aggressive and dominant. Depp was the opposite.
So true
that's actually a really good catch 😮
She's very aggressive when she speaks. If this is how she is in front of the world, imagine what she's like behind closed doors. Imagine how bad she treated the maid that found her pooh she left in the bed. I heard she was screaming at her and said hello to everyone except that one maid. Then took her in the other room and yelled. If she's this aggressive and destructive when she knows the world is watching just shows what she's like. The turd is a complete psychotic LIAR
@@izzeypally It's a good catch because it's lived experiences
I’m an empathetic person but not once did I believe in her acting. My sorrow is that she is obviously a damaged person and, as they so often do, is taking (or trying to take) others down with her into the abyss. She must’ve watched way too many old films to think that that kind of acting works in 21st century 🤦🏼♀️ Please Johnny Depp take a stand for all the voiceless victims of abuse, whether male or female ❤
Me too.
It all seemed so obvious that she is a mess mentally, her storytelling bad acting of a made up story, that she believed she could convince the jury because she believes she's a good actor.
This mother's heart saw thru it all and had empathy for her.
Johnny is a Saint
@Robin Justice 💜
@Robin Justice Me three. I am very empathetic. But AH was just as phoney as can be. Give her an F+++ on her acting. Hugs to you Robin.
I never blieved her acting since she first time appeared with those bruises there was something what didnt fit me all in that time Now i know what.And I think I am not alone
@@MoparMomma I don’t think he’s a saint and he is also damaged, but I love that for once the victim was believed (surely a very rare thing with narcissists being cunningly manipulative, dishonest and a master/mistress of smear campaigns, gaslighting, cruelty, abuse, inconsistency and inflicting isolation), had the good sense not to engage or enter into her dramas, and will hopefully have a voice and his life back. I’m so glad the world saw through the lies and dramas and had his back. I hope he heals well and surfaces up to a more joyful future 🍀🍀🍀
I'm generally not into the celebrity scene, but this trial captivated me. It's such a great study on pathological personality. It had real-life high drama and an Insider view into celebrity life. I support Johnny and think what he did is important for all men hiding behind domestic abuse. Thanks for continuing to analyze Ambers's behavior. You guys are the best.
YESSSSSSS GREAT STUDY ON PATHOLOGICAL BEHAVIOR !!!!!!!!!
I totally agree! I would just add, for him (career and perceived manliness) to admit to being abused is a huge step forward for BOYS & men who need support. I also feel it was time to stop the "Believe ALL women, regardless" narrative. That narrative has given opportunity to vindictive women to ruin the lives of many men and their families. ... No investigation/interrogation of either party? Accused = Guilty is wrong!
YES, Greg, Amber does so much detailing and non-denials, she is lying. And Chase is right she is malingering, reversing her and Johnny's roles in every incidence of violence. TRUE, Mark, there's zero evidence of truth in her testimony. And where's the evidence she was injured by broken glass? That's because there is none. She couldn't "see him" because she's in a rage! The fake crying is so bad, ugh! Listen to Incredibly Average's Australian tapes of what occurred, it's really telling. Scott is correct, her body language does not show fear about the incident only that she isn't being believed.
@@eva-jwatts7604 I truly believe Johnny put up with it for 2 reasons (a few more, also but not relevant to what I'm going to say). #1. Being a man versus a woman I think he felt that no matter how hard she hit him she couldn't do the damage the stronger sex can do to the weaker sex. #2. His mother was abusive so he was conditioned to abusive women. I feel so badly for him because he (and everyone else) deserves to be treated so much better than this.
I’m in line with you in terms of celebrity things. I think what captivated people was that money and fame doesn’t mean life is better- it just hides a lot of dysfunctional relationships and Amber’s lies are so bad it was really unreal to watch. I’m glad Johnny went for this battle and won. It clearly was hard to see him reveal his life to the world.
The moment she lost all credibility:
Camille: “he hit you repeatedly?”
Amber: “yes.”
Camille: “was he wearing rings?”
Amber: “he always wears rings.”
Camille: “so this picture shows you after he repeatedly hit you in the face with rings on?”
Amber: “... what was the question?”
🤣🤣
She's disgusting, and a horrible actor. How dare she use faked DV and faked PTSD. She makes a mockery of every man, woman and child who really struggle. How dare she so obviously and cavalierly do a bump of whatever she was snorting in front of cameras in a court of law. She should have been called on it. AH demonstrates how she believes she's so brilliant and above us mere "randos" that she can manipulate every and all situations.
to me it is when she is asked about the pictures in the backless dress and she says "I assume you have it". that was clearly her knowing she was fucked.
😁
👍spot on
I’m a woman and psychologist. I’ve been around a while. Age 78. Mother of four. I find it impossible to believe this woman.
I believe when she was fake sobbing at that one point, she said "I don't want to do this" and "I can't" because she's waiting for someone to say "Miss Heard do you need a moment?" because she can't figure out what to say next, she got lost in her lines and she needs a minute to remember what to say. She disgusts me.
And notice how no-one, not the Judge or her own legal team, asked her if she needed to take a moment - everyone knew she was lying…
And meanwhile, she reportedly has decided to appeal and has a book deal.
No one felt her distress because it was obviously fake
@@amiblueful disgusting isn't it?
Yep and then after faffing about she goes back to the last line she said....back on script
Lying as much as Amber does must be absolutely exhausting, Its exhausting just watching her lie.
I think she believes most of her allegations, which is even more disturbing in some ways.
She's used to it.
It's because she truly is narcissistic! They lie even when they KNOW the person KNOWS they are telling lies! It's the first thing they think of - to LIE! They double down of the lies by "remembering" little bits here and there to try and paint a picture that would be more believable. I had a family member who would do this from the time they were a small child! And this trait was carried over even when dealing with other close family members and people she claimed were best friends! It's that they can NEVER admit guilt of fault and simply MUST put that on someone else, and it doesn't matter who gets nailed with it as long as they can "believe" they come off as being innocent! In my opinion it's another sign of mental illness or personality disorder.
A.H. is one sick person!
How does she have any friends or supporters?
I was in an extremely abusive relationship at the age of 18. I got my jaw broken in 7 places... 5 broken ribs... broken collar bone... and more. To this day, if I talk about this... I cry and shake uncontrollably. AH is not believable in any form.
I am so sorry that happened to you. I think Amber has triggered a lot of DV survivors and she has outraged them.
Sorry that happened to you dear.
She’s only person I’ve ever heard of being beaten as bad as she claimed, stepping on as much glass as she’s described and “getting rocked in the nose” yet had/have no marks to show for it. Guess she’s got the same abilities as wolverine
That sweet sweet magical Amica cream 😂
And no need to get er treatment?
😂😂😂
LOL
Especially if you are being beaten with a fist full of chunky, huge rings! Not ONE MARK?!?!?!?!?
As a retired psych RN, I'm amazed that I felt absolutely. NO. Empathetic response to her testimony. I've HEARD many terrible stories from abused women and this is phony all the way!! And her presentation of clothing and hair is to make herself look like " poor PITIFUL me!"
Right? All it did was make me extremely uncomfortable but I didn't believe any of it.
I have never seen someone wipe their eyebrows instead of their eyes if they are supposed to be crying.
Clothing and hair look more military like or like uniforms that representatives of a totalitarian state or institution would wear. It does not say "poor me" AT ALL. But the EXACT opposite.
A lawyer said that AH wore all the wrong clothes. The outfits and often the hair are masculine but she should have looked female, delicate and thus, vulnerable to present herself as the victim she claims she is.
Most JD supporters said that they felt uncomfortable watching Amber 'cry'. They attributed their feelings of discomfort to her lying. We are engrained from birth to feel uncomfortable watching another person in pain. Make your miinds up JD supporters. Are you supposed to feel uncomfortable or nothing? In reality its all very subjective. Behavioral analysis is easy under standard conditions but here we have celebrity using drugs and live TV. This will make behavioral analysis extremely complicated. It means nothing if you feel nothing
And then immediately in the NBC interview looks different 🤦♀️
Camille was 'snarky' while she was questioning amber on purpose! She knew it would get under amber's skin and fluster her. Which it did 😊
I loved watching Camille go after her.
Good job Camille you’re a wahine toa ❤
ME TOO!!!😅
I love how Chase & Mark just gets straight to the point and says it's deception!! Well done guys. 👏👏
No tears no snot no Jodi Foster.
street scam artist level to be exact.
It is, what it is.
@@annesmith372 That's okay, I think they remain consistent and I get to see more of these men.
@Anne Smith No it's the same video they previously posted except in these edited ones they've added the side bar for video reference, showing us what they're talking about rather than us having to remember how she looked at a specific moment or what she said. I like it!
I remember one time when my ex was black-out drunk and hit me twice in the face with no rings on. My face was almost unrecognizable. Broke both cheekbones. I had 2 black eyes for weeks. My eyes were swollen shut damn near for 2 days. I wish I could honestly say that was the first or last time it happened. To this day I cannot stand the smell of alcohol on a man's breath. She does not represent me.
I think her "breakdown" scene with the dry sobbing was intended to get a compassionate intervention from the judge. When that doesn't happen, she pours it on thicker and even says at one point "I don't wanna do this!" Idk if the judge was being extra careful not to prejudice the jury or if she was just caught up in the cringe like the rest of us, but props to her for not taking that bait!
I almost wished the judge stopped her so I didn't have to hear anymore of the bull. It's stinking in here and my eyes are watering 🤣
YES! Hard agree. She really thought someone was gonna rescue her. 🤣
@@aliciagamble833 waiting for the director to yell CUUUUTT !!!!!!!
@@aliciagamble833 exactly this! Great awareness guys! I also caught the I don’t even want to do this. She’s insufferable
It proves that her lawyers know it's all lies because they would have asked for a break if it was genuine.
I actually can't get enough of these analyses if Amber Heard. My ex husband was very much like her and I hope to avoid getting close to another narcissist ever again
I agree ❤️
There are a lot of other good videos about narcissists as well. I did a lot of research before leaving my POS. I love these peeps too.
Psychology is so fascinating. She is quite the representation of so many things.
Don't we all sister!
I DONT WANT TO HEAR YOU OUT!! No yaah i do ... i just like shouting cos it makes me feel p0owerfulled. ;)
I'll go out on a limb, too. I don't believe she was ever trapped in a room or trying to get past him. I believe she is transferring his situations to her own.
She’s literally describing what she did to him including “he threw a bottle at me”
Exactly. This was his rendition of what happened.
absolutely agree! she took his story and made it her own. just like she did with Kate James story (the ra*e allegation. Ms. James stated this in the U.K. trial, and was not believed). Ms. heard is absolutely shameless in her accusations against Mr. Depp. it's appalling that she can sit there and take his story and turn it into her own. however, it's classic narcissistic behavior. I grew up with a narcissistic sibling and witnessed this kind behavior first hand. it's quite disturbing to witness
lol, have no fear @Claudia, it's the Brooklyn Bridge ur strolling on 🌉, not a limb
That’s what I thought also!
According to AH, he bashed her head against a marble countertop, threw her into furniture causing it to break, punched her, choked her, dragged her through broken glass, and violated her with a broken liquor bottle.
As a survivor of a violent partner, how TF did ALL OF THAT happen but somehow she DIDN’T need medical attention? 🧐
I'm surprised he didn't also set her on fire and she didn't seek medical treatment. Her life is a poorly written fantasy movie.
@@ashleemorgan708😳😂😂😂😂
And also how could he do all
Of this with his cut finger
Not just didn't need medical attention, but nobody saw any injuries and she had a doctor and nurse show up and didn't need or as for help.
She didn't even need a bandaid.
As a DV survivor with PTSD it sickens me to see Amber Heard feigning symptoms of having PTSD..the audio recordings prove she didn't fear Johnny who she claims was abusing her..let me tell you, I did everything I could not to say or do anything to agitate my exhusband because I feared what he'd do to me..the abuse I endured for 7 yrs was extremely violent..
Her inability to recount the sequence of the incident as it happened is her way of giving herself an out for perjury..
Amber's story jumps around and doesn't make sense.
Her phony emotional acting is way over the top and not at all believable..
I feel the same about her testimony and the interview she did. The audio recordings expose her for what she really was like. I made myself as small and as quiet as possible with my ex. And I can remember everything he did to me 18yrs later.
I cannot express just how disgusting she is.
I agree. It’s not only evident to me in the audio recordings, but also in the known circumstances surrounding their relationship. JD moved multiple members of AH’s friends and/or family into his penthouses so they’d be around for her. I’m not saying it never happens, but I’ve personally never seen a man as controlling and violent as she claims JD was, allow their partner to have such a large and easily accessible support system at their beckon call, and I’ve been dealing w DV survivors for years in my profession. Clearly AH is a very demanding person, in both her relationships and her friendships. Anybody who’s ever been around an abusive or controlling person knows that abusers tend to isolate their partner and keep them on a short leash. When I heard her testimony that she text her friend Rocky to come over during an alleged violent attack (JD’s team alleges Rocky was already hiding in their penthouse, which I tend to believe since it’s supported by other testimony) and Rocky ran and got her key and let herself into their penthouse to allegedly run to AH’s side to protect her, it seemed to be in direct contrast to her claim of him being “controlling”. It’s very hard for me to believe that a man who allows his wife’s friends to have unlimited access into their personal life, is violent and controlling. Imagine a man who regularly and violently attacks his wife allowing her friends to bust in anytime and stand between them. I just can’t see that happening. I think she’s lying about 95% of what she claimed, but that’s jmo.
Exactly. Me too. I did everything I could to make my husband happy... ESPECIALLY when he was angry and violent.... even while panicking on the inside, on the outside I would be very calm and be nice to him and try to help him feel understood and cared about, to calm him down.
I would never EVER deride him like we hear Amber doing on the recordings. Oh my God, even if I had had that kind of nastiness in me to begin with, I never would have shown it to him, as I would have been WAY too afraid.
And to this day, although I have rarely talked about it... I feel shame, and am very subdued and simply sad, when I describe it, not over the top dramatic like that, EVER. I would be embarrassed to do that,
and yes, I have PTSD.
I'm also a DV survivor. I'm so insulted by how she's acting.. I can't take it anymore... I rarely speak about my experience, but I've had to since this trial.. She makes me so angry.
Hope you are doing well. Ty for speaking out, it's nice to know I'm not alone.
My partner wasn't physical and I still don't talk about it like this. No hysterics, definitely actual tears. Isolation is one of the primary aspects of an abusive relationship. I keep hearing about all of her friends all around them, living there, traveling with them. The biggest thing discrediting her, for me, were the recordings. She sounds exactly, exactly, like an abuser.. My abuser. It's terrifying. The one where she laughs maniacally pushing him to go like a "all men do". It scared me to death. Others she's talking in circles, every point he makes she discounts, every time he addresses a point she raises, she dismisses it. Around and around until nothing makes sense. We're responsible for our actions, including sobriety, but I'm not surprised he didn't stay sober. I bet his depression was off the charts. And she claims responsibility for none of it, not one thing. She scares the sh!t out of me. I think she's an example of how escalation doesn't stop on it's own. I believe she would have killed him.
When she starts in on the “really trying to cry” part, I’ve never been so uncomfortable watching something in my life. Everyone in that room HAD to feel how theatric that was and it must have been so uncomfortable for that jury. Secondly, a lot of the time the Judge will step in and ask the witness if they need a break when they start getting upset, but this judge doesn’t say a word. Just let’s her dig her own grave, and that speaks to how the judge was feeling in that moment as well.
Good point, that didn't occur to me. The judge probably didn't detect real distress ... which tells us she was acting.
If this was the performance of her lifetime, she is a horrible actress. No wonder she has not had much of an acting career.
Agreed, the part about the judge not stopping to give her a break is a really big deal. I’m not sure how many people caught that but it really struck me.
Omg right? It’s so obvious. Doesn’t take a behavioral expert to even see it. I literally have second hand embarrassment listening to her. It’s to off!!!
We are wired as human beings to feel deeply uncomfortable when we see someone experiencing real torture or genuinely in deep plight. This is definitely not your average drama experience. Behavioral so-called experts can BS us all they want. But our gut instincts are wired from birth to read genuine body language deep inside. That's why so many people feel uncomfortable watching this . She may not satisfy the so-called behaviour anal-ists. But consider that Amber's crying makes us uneasy because deep down our guts are telling us we need to be uncomfortable, concerned, worried, whatever. This is not faking. Your baby sixth sense and guts indirectly admitted it .
Attorney Benjamin Chew is a solid litigator. I realize he looks like an affable person. Fluent in Spanish he has represented many foreign governments in court. He has argued cases in the European Court of Human Rights and the international Criminal Court. He is not to be messed with and should be respected for his participation in this case.
He certainly is!
Certainly a lot more than JD’s side kick! What is wrong with Mark today?
Yes, I looked him up on LinkedIn and his qualifications are impeccable.
That’s interesting - JD’s lawyers were so much more likeable than AH’s that’s for sure!
Yup he is amazing!! He’s the one that made sure this all ran smoothly, if it wasn’t for Chew this trial could have easily went in the other direction
It’s so uncomfortable to watch her awful acting, I can only imagine how difficult it was in person for the jury.
I can almost bet she watched hours of actual victims of DV testifying in court….and this was her best attempt at emulating that. She’s insane.
What an insult to those women.
So true
Agree she studied many victims. Her words were too stock in describing the blackness of the abyss
She is just bloody terrible to watch. I know pain and I know others that do. That is not what broken looks like when being confronted about suffering. Thats someone that does not know it, trying to display it. Now she may just find out what living with some kind of mental torment is like.
"It’s so uncomfortable to watch her awful acting,"
I love it, I watch these videos every few days for a good laugh. That part where she goes "Ive never been so scared in my life!" I crack up every time. Comedy gold! :)
She sobbed more on that stand than i have in my whole 46yrs of life, yet amazingly never shed a single tear.
And I don't know about anyone else but my eyes aren't the only things that leak, I would've had snot as well.
Also, she is so much more "upset" SIX years after this supposed attack than she was during the deposition she made at the time, when she was rolling her eyes, smirking and eating cookies the whole time.
When I watched this live, I felt extremely uncomfortable and when they panned over to Johnny, I got really upset for him because I knew in my gut that he was innocent. It just hit me like a ton of bricks that she created a monstrous story and that it was all a lie. I couldn’t stop thinking about it the rest of the day. I was genuinely upset for him because I just knew it was all fake
Imagine how much more palpable this would have been in the court room. It's obvious the people still supporting AH didn't watch any of the trial in any length.
I felt the same. it was so hard to watch, particularly when she was telling Rhianna's story and I almost expected her to be calling him Chris. The only time I've seen anything like this in real life was with children, and you know in your gut that you're being lied to be the trouble maker.
Maybe his acting experience pages off for him in court because he stayed quite composed despite the fact that he was obviously perturbed. I'm happy for him though...had he not sat through this he wouldn't have been vindicated.
Since birth we are wired to read body language and feel uneasy when we see someone cry. Even the youngest child even a dog will respond to a crying individual. Your baby gut sense is making you uneasy so that you will respond. Our own feelings of unease will be relieved when we say "there there, pat on the shoulder, or give a hug. It's all basic instincts
I felt the same….just imagine how he must’ve felt
To me-Amber ring TRUE - to me, Depp liar.
What is so ironic about this trial is how easily Heard could have gotten away with it all, even at this stage, if it weren't for the very same personality disorders that caused her to ruin her marriage and engage in this hoax to begin with.
She could have sold the world a tale of an imperfect victim engaged in mutual abuse and the jury would probably have believed it enough to accept Depp was hitting her.
Instead she tried to present the image of a perfect victim, a saint and a martyr, who suffered literally unbelievable levels of one-sided and unprovoked violence. Not only was her story implausible and her performance poor, her extremely over-the-top descriptions of violence created a new problem regarding her total lack of evidence. If anything, what evidence was shown created endless discrepancies with her tales of broken noses and getting endlessly punched in the face by a fist bedecked in rings.
Heard blew up her marriage, but she also blew up her exit route with her hyperbolic and histrionic performances.
This is a perfect assessment. What got her into this mess... was the same modus operandi she used to get out.
Messy in.... Messy out. Kudos !!
So well said!!!! If only she could have held back and made the violence stories at least fit the photos and admitted to also using drugs and alcohol, she might have been more convincing. Instead, she tries to convince us that she’s this perfect, innocent girl from a little town near Texas, who fell in love, was brutally beaten but prevailed with the help of Amica cream, make up, ice and her super human healing abilities… And of course, she over-estimated her acting abilities…
@@TheSuzberry that would explain the upswept hair styles !!
I could not agree more. I have been saying this from the beginning of the trial. It sounds crazy to call Johnny "lucky", but he actually IS lucky that Amber Turd is so fvcking crazy because had she been less crazy and more thoughtful about her ABUSE HOAX, she not only would've gotten away with it initially, but she'd still be getting away with it to this day and Depp's life and career would be OVER for good.
Had Amber Turd simply said something like "Johnny was a jealous drunk and occasionally he would go out with friends and get high and drunk, then he'd come home in a jealous rage over an actor I was working with on a movie or an old friend I talked to and he would start slapping me around and belittling me and my acting career". THAT LEVEL OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE STILL WOULD'VE ENDED JOHNNY'S HOLLYWOOD CAREER! PERIOD! Not only that, but that level of violence IS ACTUALLY BELIEVABLE based on her pictures. Even if the pictures are Photoshopped and even if the marks on her face are totally fake and were created BY Amber Turd with her "bruise kit". There wouldn't really be any way to PROVE that they were faked, and the red marks and bruises would at least be consistent with a drunken Depp smacking Amber around in a jealous rage.
But she is SO INSANE that she just couldn't help herself. She desperately wanted to have a "survivor story" that involved harrowing levels of violence and seckshual assault. She desperately wanted that level of fame and notoriety for herself, and she desperately wanted to DESTROY Johnny Depp's life and career. So she fabricated these truly insane lies that involved savage beatings where she is claiming that Depp basically came within a millimeter of caving her skull in and killing her, in addition to violent seckshual assaults and R4PES with foreign objects. She even said MULTIPLE TIMES during her performance on the stand that she thought she was GOING TO DIE at the hands of Depp!!! Then she puts up a picture of a little redness on her cheek and claims the picture was taken after one of these BRUTAL beatings. LMFAO!
It's actually really scary to think about how this could've ended for Depp had Amber Turd been even slightly sane. The same level of insanity that ruined Depp's life and career is the same level of insanity that saved him. And that is exactly why Depp fought to have this trial televised. Because he KNEW that Amber Turd's lies would be immediately evident to the entire world if we were able to see her full testimony ourselves without it first being DELIBERATELY EDITED by the propagandist mainstream media to make AMBER TURD look like the victim.
Amber's craziness coupled with this trial being televised are what saved Depp's career and probably his life as well. I can certainly see Depp ODing (either accidentally or deliberately) or taking a lethal cocktail of drugs and alcohol at the same time had Amber Turd actually been successful in ending Depp's acting and music careers and destroying his good name and reputation publicly. Scary to think about.
Spot on
What I love about the BP is that you guys explain why I feel weird about people who are being deceptive.
I can’t identify these things specifically, but I just know in my gut that something is off.
With Amber, my jaw was on the floor, it was such obvious acting. I can’t believe she thought this would fool anyone. It’s like a bad after-school special.
That girl needs help.
She’s such an awful actress! It’s a wonder that she ever got a job at all! It’s just so fake!
Very bad acting...
Ya know, when she was "crying hysterically" and stammering around and at a loss for words, I'm thinking she had reached the point where she was hoping against hope that the judge would intercede and ask her if she needed a break (poor thing), thus giving her the chance to regroup and have a chance to reorganize her story.
I was thinking that as well.
and that time i was thinking maybe the judge was allowing her to have that "meltdown" so that the jury can really see through her lies... that's why the Judge never called a break.
Yeah, I think the judge was so fed up with their shenanigans in her courtroom (the fake Gina post, passing notes, b$tching about everything, objecting to their own questions, obviously lying), she was ready to let the client fry herself.
That's exactly what my thoughts were at the time watching it live. She was hoping the judge would stop everything and would say "the witness needs a break... Get her a tissue"🤣 When that didn't happen, she became even more awkward, and she twisted, pretended to cry, and used that poor wasted tissue, trying to rub her non existent tears from her face. 😂
200% agree with this 😅
You guys make me feel so validated for how I felt about her during this horrible display of ridiculous!!! Thank you Greg for mentioning the menthol on her tissue, I said that's what she was doing all along because the way she used that tissue was just odd!!! It's so hard to watch over again, her performance is laughable!!
But still....no tears. Right?
Glad she did take the stand. She would of fooled us all again.
@@TheSuzberry after johnny took the stand, she was going to take it, its just who she is
If you go watch the interview of Rhiannia after Chris brown beat her…she steals her exact words, it will blow your mind. It’s just like I believe she used the movie Gone Girl as her playbook.
Ditto. LOL I watched the trial during our RV trip. Husband drove, I watched on my cell. Jaw dropping reaction during her testimonies. 😲
The way she changed her emotions so very quickly when someone says "objection". It's as if she's making a movie and someone shouts "cut".
Depp's lawyers said it was the performance of her life. It may of been, but it wasn't a very good one.
AGREE, reminds me of film before talking movies, an over acted melodrama with over dramatic acting.🙄🙃🐨🦘💯
She’s so disgusting that she could lie about this man so badly and manipulative doesn’t care about anyone but herself. She makes me sick!!!!
Typically I can sympathize with any kind of sad story. But only when it’s authentic. Her “breaking down” is NOT authentic feeling AT ALL for me.
It’s other peoples stories.
The “it wasn’t him anymore” part she got that from Rihanna (the singer) who actually was assaulted.
I know what you mean. It's the lack of authenticity. She is using all the right words, but her whole delivery is inconsistent with someone who has actually been through the kind of abuse she is talking about. If she had been sent flying across a glass covered floor, beaten senseless over and over again by a strong man wearing large, heavy rings and then had her head bounced off a solid wooden bar repeatedly, she would at very least have needed hospital treatment for all the cuts and broken bones she would have had. She is describing a "movie fight", like when Rocky gets beaten all around the ring but keeps getting back up. In reality he wouldn't have survived. Same here. If her description was true, she'd have the visible scars to prove it.
@@philgallagher1 Die Hard 4! 😂 must see it.. 😂
Amber stole the story from someone else's experience. She got that "his eyes were black...I couldn't see him " thing from Rhianna talking about her experience where she actually had a beat up face and canceled shows and sought medical attention and the police report. Amber had and did none of these.
There is a Clip I watched of AH and Johnny where Johnny is taking a nap and AH is watching a movie with exact see scrip as what she said through out the trial. It was rehearsed and planned for a long time. Fake
And her assistant. She stole her story
The part about panicking helped explain why I simultaneously did not feel even the slightest temptation to be moved, and why I also sensed something more than acting was going on. I never thought before now that "I don't want to do this" might mean "I'm in way too deep now."
Also, I LOVE the editing. The simultaneous voices is just cool.
The editing is insanely good!
@@plutoxn It's like a toddler getting themselves all worked up: first comes the "dry crying" and the yelling and then they get themselves worked up enough that the 'real" crying" comes along.
I was very conflicted, because I instantaneously knew Heard's body language exuded "I'm in way too deep... Am I going to get caught?" However, I washed myself of biasness and wanted to hear what Amber had to say. So, I then viewed her testimony trying to seek the truth, which was extremely difficult, because she constantly mixed her truths with lies. I didn't know what to believe, but I did know she was lying a lot. So, I tried imagining Heard was telling the truth. Then I noticed after the 10 day court break, Amber's whole demeanor changed, and I instantaneously knew she lied about almost everything. Especially, the abuse.
@Mary Russell THANK GOD the court didn't fall for her fakery; it would have gone badly for Johnny if they had! No doubt these are the methods she has used all her life to manipulate people and it's obvious they have worked, else she wouldn't be using them NOW. I was happy the judge was a WOMAN; a MAN might well have fallen for her nonsense!
. Johnny's legal team was superb; Amber's team was a farce, except for Rottenborn, and I got the impression all along he was doing his job and nothing more, defending the FRAUD that was Amber! The fact that he immediately bowed out of the case once the verdict was spoken and was never heard[sic] from again spoke VOLUMES. Elaine, not so much! I had a strong suspicion she had "hot pants" for Amber, hence her ongoing "public defense"of her! Wonder if she herself called a halt or somebody else woke her up to what she was doing ! LOL!
I’m a DV survivor and I can still tell you who, what, when and where. It leaves an indelible mark on you. I had to file a restraining order and there was no way in hell I would go to him and ask for a hug. I thought she has PTSD. People with that would never go to the abuser and ask for a hug. To me, this is just to try and bring him back in.
Yeah, so she could use him some more and get more $ out of him.
Poor Johnny, he is sitting there thinking, "I can't believe she is telling these lies!!!"
I thought he showed enormous restraint. He was thoughtful, hesitant and very funny at times on the stand. Anguish and sadness and disappointment in a failed relationship and an enormous betrayal came over strongly. I loved it when he asked Mr Rottenborn 'is that the document I've already signed three times?' And the mega pint did me in.
No. He’s thinking, “I loved her. I would have died for her.”
Then, like he said on one of the recordings, he realizes THAT woman he loved & would have died for didn’t exist.
Lastly, he realizes what he held in his arms & cherished is the creature on the stand filled with duplicity, hatred, deceit & malevolence.
This is rhiannas story. She is a pathetic evil witch. But not one picture not one photoWhere are the tears
@@margomeave9064 I believe exactly the same as you 👍
I always thought that when all this dramatic crying was taking place that the judge would have asked if she needed a minute…. I can only conclude that even the judge didn’t even believe her ❤️❤️❤️you guys
Judge Penny is a great one. 💕
Yea I found that odd that no one asked if she needed a minute
I think that's what she'd been hoping for, to buy herself time remembering what to say. But no one was buying it. I'm a very empathic person, if someone is upset or even says something sad I mirror that sadness and often endnup crying with them. I've heard others who are the same say this same thing...she didn't elicite an empathetic response in me, ididn't get upset or sad. I got angry, indignant, frustrated (all on Johnny's behalf and that she was clearly concocting this story), and I even heavily cringed. It was terrible acting, made worse by the lack of tears and ridiculousness of what she said (he wasn't there, it wasn't him anymore... too many horror films or was she having some kind of hallucination/psychotic moment?)
@@MelissaCast I didn't find it odd because I knew that no one was believing her bs. The judge isn't dumb.
I thought the same thing...even the judge doesn't believe her!! AND her own attorney was hoping that maybe just maybe Amber would be able to produce some tears this time!
It really is spooky seeing how she remembers everything JD did but when it comes to recalling her/their own actions, it's blurry. They makes me believe even more so that she was abusive.
Exactly what I was thinking like is she serious? Difference between both Johnny would own up to his mistakes while she's still in denial like if she has taken notes on what they call "plead the 5th" problem is that she doesn't know how to use that word properly
Fatal Attraction in real life.
Absolutely right! She was remembering what she did to him, I bet. He was the victim. That statement of the thrown bottle whizzing near her head? That's what SHE did to HIM. If one follows the encounters she's had with other people: punching her girlfriend in the arm in an airline building where the police caught her and filed a report, punching Elon in the face after which those bruises were visible in some pictures online, and beating up her own sister, etc. Also she was arrested around the age of 15 of driving with a friend in a car. The car crashed and her friend died. She was arrested for that so the police must have found she did something unlawful, perhaps drinking or drugs?
I don't think that what she claims to remember about "what he did" is actually true. I think his running away from confrontations is true. But the rest of what she's accusing him of is not true because that is not in his nature. All his previous lovers and those who know him well have sworn in court that Mr. Depp has never and would never do those things.
She has to make him look like the bad guy and that she is the victim, when actually it is exactly in reverse. She is the evil one and he is the victim. Apparently she fed him drugs just as it was reported recently that she did to her "friends" like Cara De LaVigne, and the young girls she groomed to attend sex parties and service the guys. She apparently has in the past beaten up her own sister, punched Elon Musk - a former lover, hit her other former lover (an actor from Mexico), her "friends," etc. She is a grave danger to others and the authorities need to act on this.
Because she was recalling her own actions and projected it onto JD.
Every time I watch her I imagine the incredible amount of damage she is describing like when she supposedly received a broken nose and tells the jury the reason why her nose isn’t swollen or discolored it “usually with that kind of injury the damage isn’t that bad and for me it wasn’t bad at all!” What? A broken nose is a lot of damage. Rings would burst the skin on her face leaving a ton of swelling and bruising none of which could be covered up with a “bruise kit”
As someone who has had his nose broken for him on a couple different occasions and had my face struck, it’s absolutely surreal that she would make these outlandish claims of brutal alleged violence. It doesn’t take a full power strike to give you a serious black eye. I’ve had plenty. They hurt, they’re apparent, and they take a while to go down.
I have never taken a hit from a person wearing rings like Johnny’s. But as you say, if any of her nonsense was true, she would have been lacerated, swollen, and bloodied. No amount of makeup or ice would be able to hide it. She would have required medical attention. Her teeth would have likely been broken. Her facial bones would have been broken. Women’s skulls are actually different than men’s. They are less likely to take damage without serious consequences.
I have a hard time believing Amber has experienced a fist to the face. Ever. I don’t believe she has ever experienced injuries caused broken glass. It’s super easy to get deeeeep cuts with even an accidental exposure to shards of glass. If her bare back had fallen on it, she would have required medical attention and would likely have visible scars, even after it healed. She wouldn’t be wearing a backless dress. Maybe never again.
She is despicable.
Mini-T?! "YOU NAILED IT!!!" 😉👍
@@yakhooves Ikr. She keeps forgetting about the whole Scarring thing an how Bruises change Color over time. Oh of course She's like Wolverine from the X-Men so she doesn't seem to have the problems us mere mortals have 🤦♀️
She's just talking rubbish. I fainted once and hit my nose on a hard floor. For weeks and weeks, my eyes and nose were puffy and bruised. Not even if her nose wasn't broken, but she'd been hit
I’ve broken my nose twice. I can say, no amount of makeup was going to cover up the swelling and my two black eyes.
This analysis is so great because most of us watching could sense that she was lying, that something wasn't right and its great to be validated here. I appreciated Chase just calling it as it is "this is deception", there's no getting around that.
Once a lier always a lier that's what muma told me ,so right I've never lied again since I was 9 I'm 60 now god bless her 🙏
this trial, particularly amber's testimony is a great real life study on narcissistic personality and good for behavioral students to criticize and analyze
@@margota8342 does she know shes lying?
Camille was so calm, cool and collected. I am extremely impressed at her professionalism at handling a Mid-Range Cluster B Narcissist and not allowing that narcissist to get her off track or pull her into the narrative the narcissist wanted to go. Camille is a Queen👸🏽. One of the best lawyers I have seen in a very long time.
I thought if JD had a guy instead of Camille it would have fallen flat and failed, no matter how good he could have been, by appearing bullying and mean. She was perfect for the job she had to do: prove A a liar. But, I'm not familiar with your description of A and those terms, but I can recognize an egomaniacal, man-hating sociopath. Is that what you're saying I think? Great comment, tho. 🙂
💩 uncomfortable with her tactics and brought out her crazy
She's not a narc. She's a borderline.
@@lauroandrea3241 Wrong. So sad you can't spot a narcissist; means you are one or you are being used by one. She is VERY much a Mid-Range Cluster B Narcissist in addition to being a Psychopath and diagnosed with BOTH Borderline Personality Disorder AND Histrionic Personality Disorder (last two are by Dr. Shannon Curry). Just because it did not come up in the courtroom does not mean she doesn't have that particular personality disorder.
Look up the definition of a Mid-range Cluster B Narcissist (also HG Tudor is an ULTRA narcissist and has done an extensive breakdown of why she is also a narcissist) If you want to see that, his youtube channel is HG Tudor or you can google his name online. There are also other channels like: The Behavioral Arts (he also has a psychology degree) and The Body Language guy that have all concluded the same thing.
HOWEVER you need 5 of these 9 traits to be diagnosed as a Narcissist (the severity of each determines what range narcissist you are) and she fits ALL 9:
1.Have a grandiose sense of self-importance.
2. Preoccupied by fantasies such as those of unlimited success, brilliance, beauty, power, or ideal love.
3. Believe they are special or unique and can only be understood by and associate with people of a certain standing.
4. Require excessive admiration.
5. Have a sense of entitlement.
6. Manipulates others to achieve their own gains.
7. Lacks empathy.
8. Often envious of others or believes others are envious of them.
9. Display arrogant and haughty behaviors or attitudes.
AND look up the definition of a Psychopath...she literally fits EVERY single symptom listed in the dictionary: Glibness/superficial charm
Grandiose sense of self-worth
Need for stimulation/proneness to boredom
Pathological lying
Conning/manipulative
Lack of remorse or guilt
Shallow affect (i.e., reduced emotional responses)
Callous/lack of empathy
Parasitic lifestyle
Poor behavioral controls
Promiscuous sexual behavior
Early behavioral problems
Lack of realistic, long-term goals
Impulsivity
Irresponsibility
Failure to accept responsibility for one's own actions
Many short-term marital relationships
Juvenile delinquency (there is a mug shot to prove jail time as a youth)
@@lauroandrea3241 They often go hand in hand, we have one in our family, my doctor told me BPD with narcissism, she just happens to have histrionics with it. 🙄💯🙃🐨🦘
It’s always been extremely uncomfortable for me to see someone lying. I can hardly hold eye contact with a person when I see them being untruthful.
I get embarrassed for them.
Exactly
@Konstantin Dahlin how interesting!
On the recordings, she sounds so loud, aggressive, in control and ready to strike, for that reason, it's hard for me to believe that she's being dragged around, scared feeling hopeless and defenceless. I can smell her BS*. What a disgusting human being, she is so malicious.
I went into watching the trial having not seen any Amber videos before, so i had no baseline, also I had been biased by the media's reporting against JD. So i was curious. Once Amber actually took the stand, I couldn't believe what she was saying, it was like watching someone lie to me, someone gas lighting me..something I have experienced enough over a period of time to immunize me to it. It appeared that she had reversed roles with JH in the attacks. No wonder they didnt want this broadcast, because seeing IS believing, and seeing Amber made me believe JD was the true victim here. Being a parent of 3 adult children also plays into this for me. Parents have to sort through accusations, fights, lies, etc., to get to the truth when dealing with kids, and this reminded me of certains times I sat patiently listening to one of my kids lying about something that happened, amazed at the preposterous tale he spun. It would have been easier to believe he had been abducted by aliens. My kids eventually concluded, "you can't lie to dad, he just seems to know, he's a mind reader"
I wasnt a mind reader, they were just bad liars.
Amber is a bad liar.
Just let her talk.
This comment is the winner of the day for me!
Yep. The more she talks the deeper the hole she digs.
This is exactly how I felt. I knew nothing until the trial and I am not a fan of either one. I do know what is to experience DV. AH was so unbelievable. I felt very sorry for JD. I am glad this opened up the topic of DV and the stigma male endure as suspected abusers. Anyone can be a victim. She needs help and I hope she gets it, at least for her little girl's sake.
Totally agree.
@@pelipequi1493 I also felt sorry for him thinking about the gaslighting he probably had to endure with the "Monster".
The guy is broken and has demons and characters and she brought them out in this relationship. She was trying to convince him that he was doing horrible things when he was blacked out and he, someone who is already fearing this
.
It's fascinating to watch an habitual liar get called out in real time and see the lengths she's willing to go to continue the lies.
Who believes her
@@ivanboyraz2936
I can only hear crickets.
It's insane that she has any supporters.
"in real time" I see what you did there 😆
@@ivanboyraz2936 I don't!
You have to be a sick pathological liar with no remorse or conscience to do something like this.
Yes🐒
BINGO! 👿👎😡😳🙄🐨🦘🇦🇺
No more calls we have a winner!!...She absolutely is! 💯
She is a psychopath.
I am a survivor of dv and I agree with all of you. As I watched I felt sick, angry and somewhat embarrassed for her because she sounds so ridiculous. I'm angry, offended and disgusted she's using the pain of experiences victims have gone through to suit her selfish needs. I was able to relate with Johnny's testimony which helped me to brlieve him, understand him, how he felt, what he went through, the confusion he felt and why he didn't get out of the situation even though he had enough money to go. He's human too. I'm really glad I found your channel. It helped me to understand some things I was feeling.
I keep thinking of something new to say. I'm also disgusted with her lawyers. Do they really believe her? They can't be that naive. I'm also surprised she didn't do more to hurt Johnny. He's lucky to have gotten out alive. Thank God!
Same here. I've been in a few abusive relationships in my lifetime. You don't act like her and if you cry, it's very hard to go back to not crying. And it's the survivor who won't look at you if they have PTSD. She stares him down the way abusers do.
@@TheNiteSkye VERY well said. Thank you.
She almost always smiled when referring to hurting JD. That quick little smile was her way of reliving her hurting him and the joy she got from it is undeniable.
Glad to see you caught this too. It's touched on by The Behavioral Arts but for those who have intimately known psychopaths, it leaps out.
@@lyricessence Thanks. That smile is fleeting. I can see why people may have missed it. I am headed to TBA to see what they say. I, also, am glad you caught it. (Some people doubted my observation)
In my mind, this makes her serial killer potential rank very high. I have given thought to the idea she would be capable of torturing JD's dog as a proxy of torturing him. It is clear she wants to torture JD emotionally and physically. And she aint done. Yet.
@@uselesscause3178 I concur on all points.
@@uselesscause3178 I agree too. There are an awful lot of people who see this charade from a very different viewpoint & will be convinced that she couldn't possibly lie so confidently. Those people have never lived with a narcissist. I sometimes watch these videos, several times over. Mostly because I can hardly believe the absolute NERVE she has, to sit there in front of the whole court, PLUS millions watching on tv & try & ACT her way out of it. KNOWING that these lies have destroyed another person's life! I know that if I were in court, guilty like she is, I would crumble immediately under cross examination. You have to have an obscene amount of arrogance, to stick your nose in the air & wade through the lies, without ever once looking embarrassed or ashamed. But I do love to watch Camille, slap her down & make her shut her mouth. You can see that Heard HATES it & that she despises Camille. A young woman, telling her to be quiet! How dare she. You just know that in everyday life, if anybody told her to shut her mouth, she'd be out there, fists ablazing. This has probably been the only time in her life when she has had to obey, sometimes. She clearly pushes it even with Camille, continuing to talk when she's been told to stop. But it's worth watching, just to see Camille laugh at her nonsense.
Believe me true DV survivors like myself know how sympathetic you guys all are regarding DV. I never believed her testimony, it was pathetic. SHE is the ONLY person who has offended true DV survivors. Thank You, guys, for these AMAZING evaluations…I am certainly not an expert and your explanations have explained precisely why I felt “so off” while watching her. Complete deception.
Everyone knows now that Amber cheated on Depp with Elon, and others,So if he's the father of her child... He needs to think about the welfare of the child. She's An abuser, and A liar, she's pathetic.
When someone is upset and crying people usually feel upset for them. But, this is a load of ridiculous hog wash. I can not feel any sympathy for her I just want to shout SHUT UP IT IS EMBARRASSING! Basically this is all lies.
Poor Jonny.... this woman should be punished, not only because of what she tried to do to JD but because of how she plays on something that is real to millions of real victims. Its horriffic
I can tell you the instant I knew she was lying. She said broken liquor bottles were on the floor, she was slipping on the glass and alcohol and she never mentioned how bad the alcohol hurt getting into cuts on her feet. Alcohol burns like hell in any open wound.
as many people have speculated she's wolverine - and can heal spontaneously
great point about the alcohol in a wound
It burns soooooo bad!
@@shannonEGBOK plus, stepping on glass pretty much shuts you down add the burning alcohol to that and how did she not need medical care?
...and there would have been blood all over the floors if she was walking around with cuts to the soles of her feet!!! Not just in the immediate area!
I felt absolutely nothing towards/for Amber when she was testifying except anger. I endured 18 yrs of IPV and none of her stories touched me or made me feel grief or sadness towards her. She lied amd lied and lied.
I felt more emotion from a law and order svu scene than hers.
Your history of IPV gives you disadvantage in judgement between couples. There will be some kind of bias which depends on who you believe is the perpetrator and who you perceive the victim. Subjective.
@@Goodzillla1066 for someone who's trying to make people feel bad for amber heard's account of ipv you sure have no issue shooting down other people's account of ipv by saying their judgment is disadvantaged, their experience makes them biased and SUBJECTIVE? Obviously everyone's life experience molds their beliefs, who are you to start discounting that? Disgusting, it's clear a majority of people side with depp, you may side with heard but what gave you the right to discount the feelings of other ipv victims other than heard?
@@awesum7944 where is your reply? It got deleted
@@Goodzillla1066 You are wrong what happens is we survivors recognise the behaviours of the abuser. They are ALL very similar it's why we comment we SEE it. 💯👍🙃🐨🦘
Five more lies? I'm sure it's pretty safe to say that at least ninety percent of everything that came out of her mouth was a lie.
I love Ben's reaction during the pledged/donated issue, he is absolutely astounded lol and poor johnny isn't the least bit surprised. I believe at some point it even looks like he says "I told you" or something along those lines to Ben. Everyone is legitimately shocked she has the audacity to insist or maintain the things she does but he knows who she is and how far she will go.
This women is a train wreck The fact that she's still out spending money as if she's a millionaire.She openliy breaks the law & abuses people with no consequeses .
Mark Bowden always steals my breath when I see that surfer energy hair, classy intelect and dynamic personality mash up. All four of you gentlemen are a priceless resource of knowledge, so no shade implied. I just find it impossible to look away when Mark is in motion.
100% agreed, and I’d love to be there in Vegas!
Chase for me. He's a cutie xxx
One time he mentioned he was dyslexic & at that moment I became one of his top fans!
What a brilliant mind.
🤣You said it SO well!
I loveeeeee Mark! Wish there were more of him so I can bring that energy home with me!
It is such an odd experience watching her testimony. You normally would feel sorry for someone who is describing DV, but you end up laughing at the AH with the bad, overacting and feeling icky for giving her this attention while she tells her lies. You also feel I am witnessing a crazy person with my own eyes.
Mark seems unaware that Ben Chew is one of the most lauded and brilliant trial attorneys around. He led the entire legal team for Johnny and hand picked the best counsel from four of Brown Rudnick's offices around the United States to argue this case. Mark, meet Ben, you'd really like him.
Yes that’s true about Ben being the best attorney…and hand picked the other great attorneys! All respect and admiration to Ben Chew!
@Christina Forsythe I think yes, hugely.
She’s fascinating to watch as she thinks she’s outsmarting the attorney with her BS… also the gawking at the jury is just plain creepy
I'm generally very empathetic and when I hear true victims of crime (family of missing/murdered people), I choke and it has a powerful effect. Without having any training in body language, I have to say watching Amber Heard breaking down and sobbing, describing the assaults on her I felt nothing - except maybe the mild amusement of watching a bad actress in a B movie. Nothing.
Im the same but watching Amber i feel disgust and a deep sense of injustice. Something deep in the gut. I don't want to say a reaction to evil, maybe to lies designed to destroy an innocent person, with a manipulation and disrespect of what truth even is, it feels very sinister and I feel horror and hostility and disbelief too.
I Dislike this inhumane Turd but I outright LOL @ her ridiculous over acted crying, it was almost comical, like 👍 hard to believe AT ALL, 😂 🙄🙃🐨🦘
Her acting was so bad, I started to giggle just like Scott mentioned. If I had been on the jury, I wouldn’t have been able to keep a straight face.
@@loislewis5229 I actually said that to my hubby, IF I was on jury duty (which is unlikely) since I am in Australia 🇦🇺 I said I would have laughed, or the very least a stifled giggle 😃 glad I'm not the only one, I'm not trying to be disrespectful to JD It's just that she was that bad!! 👍💯🙃🐨🦘
Same here. After listening to her for a while I just felt annoyed.
It's crazy how a good actor in a movie can draw me into to empathize with them & bring me to tears but she makes me feel like I am watching someone drunk at a funeral making an ass of themselves that all I want to do is look away in embarrassment and disgust.
Agree .
I felt so embarrassed for her..oh my God..that was some really bad acting..
It infuriates me that people still side with her and that she's being further enabled and given platforms to spew her lies.
From 31.40 shows her insanity perfectly. Pure evil.
What I find fascinating is through all the violence she claims she went through. Feet arms legs in glass never did she get medical treatment? And she heals so fast almost like she has super hero powers where she heals after such traumatic treatment.
I’m an enormous empath and cry at commercials. Her gross performance evokes disgust from me and embarrassment for her. A manipulative entitled liar who thinks she can outsmart the world. Lock her up!!
I’m like you and she leaves me cold and repulsed. There is no real emotion in her other that when she talks about “people don’t like me” because she has to have everyone worship at her feet. Repulsive.
Jup said something along the same line. Just thinking about the train station scene in Hatchi makes me more sad than her theatrics
The sheer amount of self control Johnny had to have had to sit there and hear these horrific lies is outstanding. I just can’t. So ridiculous.
I hope someone points him towards this channel and he sees some of the panel’s analysis!
I can't imagine the amount of restraint johnny had to have while listening to her LIE, over and over again
I was waiting for him to yell out "you're a f*cking liar!"
In Johnny's place, I don't know if I could have held a straight face with some of her bad acting. I think I would have been unconsciously making faces and smirking, especially at this story.
I would flip a table if I were him.
Johnny's restraint since the trial has also been amazing.
Yes it’s amazing! Just be careful. She is so manipulative!!! Xx
The line. "I couldn't see his eyes, they were black I couldn't see him." Was actually the EXACT verbiage and hand motions that Rihanna used when describing when CB beat her. Compare the two, Riri is where she got that monolog almost word for word when she's doing that fake crying
Yes! Exactly!
Psychopath!
Btw, Bill Burr was actually close to the truth.
Came here to say same thing
She’s done her research. The problem is that she’s literally doing a class project in school and instead of doing her own work, she’s plagiarized the entire thing. She’s taken what she’s seen from TH-cam videos and elsewhere of other, real victims’ depositions and copied and pasted, claiming it as her own. Not just Rihanna’s (poor girl) but Johnny Depp’s too. It’s like watching a horror movie. And not horror porn like Saw, this is Silence of the Lambs stuff. Not that she eats people literally but figuratively and she’s trying to mimic behaviours and mind control people and doing a really bad job. This isn’t even bad soap opera acting. My mom was abused and when she would even reference it, there were snorts, sniffs, tears everywhere, her face was just a mess, her eyes were red and she was covered in tears and snot. Amber leaves the stand way too put together for someone recounting physical violence by a partner. Oh yeah, Ms Fenty also had unmistakable bruising on her face, like you’d see if you were hit hard.
Lets be clear here: when she went on the Dutch talkshow, she said she “DONATED” all of the money. “Every penny…. I wanted nothing”
So she knew she was lying, it’s not a confusion about the words pledge and donate.
Yes. She really looked like she swallowed the canary when the interviewer first asked her about it.
..Meanwhile the money was sitting in her bank account growing interest.
Ffs, and what if she eventually pays the remaining amount? Does that suddenly convert her from a filthy liar to a truther? Y'all contradicting yourselves, She can't suddenly be a liar and suddenly be truther because of the last penny. Good grief 😡
@@Goodzillla1066 no. If she’d said I will pay it all then she wouldn’t have been lying, unless of course she never pays it. What made her a lier is that she said she had paid. Past tense.
@@Lovelee123 Oh so now we have the GRAMMAR police accusing her of lying? 🚨 🚨 You will find more filthy *grammar liars* around you every day, friends, family, at work, at school, certainly government. Go pick on those *grammar liars* if you really want to live up to that principle and not be a double standard hypocrite. Go ahead shout at them "Lier Lier" (sic) but fix your own grammer (sic) and spelling first
Her description of the bottles flying by her head and crashing behind her is the same words Depp used.
Yeah she’s pulling a Hillary and using the oppositions words as her own. These Borderlines are so transparent.
Exactly, she is describing everything only changes the victim and the perpetrator, a disgusting human being. even tough she will keep future sugardaddies, will get millions of dollars for her book which will be called “if a was the real abuser, how would I have abused jD”, similar to OJ Simpson disgusting book, at the end she will die alone , her daughter at the age of 12, will abandoned her, as she will read through the coral media durignher mothers trial and appeal. amber will have a couple years of money.making possibilities, afterwards she will wither away lonely and isolated from her family and friends, pure disgust if I look at her
She’s such a bad liar, that the judge never bothered to ask her if she needed some time to compose herself. Terrible acting and so pathetic.
Thought the same, and was gonna say it but saw your comment.
The secondhand embarrassment I'm getting from her (fake) breakdown is unimaginable. Imagine being one of the jury, AH pointing that comically exaggerated frowning emoji at them, like a child throwing a temper tantrum for not getting their way. Idk, I feel like people would be more likely to avoid eye contact, hide their face due to shame, for appearing weak in front of an audience, during a flashback?
I'm just appalled that someone would lie about such a serious thing. What kind of person does that?
I grow so tired of the awful things people do to each other in this world
I appreciate the analysis you guys provide. Fantastically informative. Thankyou
As someone with BPD I think a lot of people miss this one thing. There had to be something small to make her believe something big. Maybe Johnny accidentally grabbed her bare leg. Not even with a bottle. Just grabbed. Or He brushed he leg with a cup. Something like that could truly make someone with BPD start to make a lie based in “truth”. Or whatever she thinks is true from he POv.
I truly do not believe she knows she’s lying anymore. I think she truly believe me this happened because she just made a false reality out of her feelings.
Her behavior was… and is…criminal abuse. She can no longer punch him but continued to abuse him with her Op-Ed. She abused him from the stand for three weeks, and still persists retelling her lies in public! I wonder if even criminal charges would shut her up?
@@overtlygrrl4850 if she really believed that happened to her, she wouldn't have to fake her emotions.
I know, why do people go out of their way to hurt and in this case also lie about something that can hurt others, especially someone that they claimed to 💕. Someone who has been truly abused really doesn't want to share this kind of information with anyone. Don't understand why she would want to live in a home 🏠 penthouse owned by JD if she was so horrified by him
someone who wants money, fame, and people to feel sorry for them. sadly
Incredible editing on this one guys. You are really stepping it up in the cutaways with the visual moments syncing up with exactly what the person is saying and describing. Sometimes in the past it could be difficult to line up precisely those moments but you've really just unlocked the right recipe for it. Excellent work.
Agree.
I hope they continue with this format.
I noticed this too! The last few video edits are really great. The content is always fascinating too
Same!
I know it's extra work but the context is soo so so good
I STILL find myself pouring over these for hours.. but the new edits help me discern the actual gestures so much better… it’s helped me cut the hours back… ( but I’m not letting anybody know this , all my people know I am busy and out of circulation from 1pm Thurs onward!!!
Exactly what Scott said: Back when I watched her testimony I had to laugh at the most dramatic part and back then I felt really bad about that, but it was my intuition. It felt so unbelievable and totally ridiculous. Now that Scott explained it's normal to giggle at that part I feel a bit better. It was in fact unbelievable and totally ridiculous.
I think everyone--especially the media--needs to be asking Chase's question: "What kind of person would be comfortable doing all of this?" Thanks for this. Just found you by listening to this morning's live with Incredibly Average's first installment of her full deposition on the divorce case (from the chat recommendations). Subbed.
What?
If there were "several" incidents in that month where he beat her in the face while wearing rings, she would have witnesses and pictures showing the damage that would have lasted for a month+
Chris Brown landed several punches on Rihanna without rings, and we can see what her face looked like after that.
Normally I get upset watching someone crying and relating some kind of trauma, no matter who they are or what their experience has been but, weirdly, she just left me completely cold.
I know right it's like something in me just feels horrible for them even if it's something on T.V.! Yet with Her I just was almost getting a lil agitated. That's Definitely not like Me all.
I was revolted at this utterly disgusting and pathetic attempt at manipulation and deception. She's simply put an empty husk trying to pass for a human.
Same, with her I was feeling nothing.
I just cannot imagine how shocking it would be to JD hearing these lies coming from her mouth. I would personally have a hard time listening to this if this were me. Kudos to him for keeping his focus on writing on his notepad with his head down.
How shameful her lies are. Very unnerving to see someone this deceptive.
I would be terrified to be in a relationship with someone like this. Thank goodness he got out.
I had to listen to my narcissistic mother do the same thing. I thought similar- even if Johnny could restrain his body listening to all those lies its harder to control your face- open mouth suprize at the chutzpah or anger and disgust at the injustice of it all showing in the mouth. Its hard to repress when they are spontaneous reactions at what Heard is saying. He must have had some very strong coaching from his counsel.
I almost think he already knew mostly what she was going to say because, aside from the outright fabrications, the story told was what happened just with the roles reversed. He lived with it for 4-6 years. The shock of the lies had long since worn off.
@@KlockoFett maybe, some of it seemed on the fly new lies. Like, just now making up as she went along.
Absolutely terrible no matter which way you look at it.
It must have been so hard hard for him to hear this crap. And not be able to say anything. As for me when I watched this I was yelling at the screen. With disgust for her such a liar. None of this felt real. I know abuse as many of us do.
Yeah what was up with that notepad anyway. Was he drawing cartoons? He should sell them on eBay.
I'm so glad Johnny Depp was found innocent!!
He's reputation has been fully restored and he deserves an apology from Disney!
These four men have very different , and unique personalities, yet brought together, makes for a very entertaining and educational program.
I feel the same 😍😍😍😍
Wonderful isn't it !!!
@@harlcc261
Yes
@Christina Forsythe I absolutely adore it when mark goes off on his tangents… I love his interpretations along with his accessing his classical knowledge about words, and theatre arts and the human condition…all four of these men bring unique gifts to the table .. and I especially love Marks sense of humour!!
I have to disagree on Mark! He’s hilarious and feels like he would be the most fun to hang out with. They all are entertaining but he reminds me of the guy who wore the vests in “ Four Weddings And A Funeral”😂💗
This testimony is the most unbelievable nonsense I have ever heard. I watched a lot of this trial but I am glad I missed this part. Thank you, guys, for your analysis. This woman is evil.
The ways she kept answering the questions while purposefully looking at the jury was so disingenuous.
It's just so bizarre to watch. The jury is not talking to you or asking a question so why are you answering a question while staring at the jury?
@@LKCLifer Interestingly, one of the jurors who was interviewed afterward said that it made them very uncomfortable.
she looks like she's glitching out
Poor Johnny, how he must have suffered at her hands thank you jury for seeing through her lies. My heart is breaking for Johnny 😭
The ' I didn't see him it wasn't johhny' was completely stolen from Rihanna's genuine description of the abuse by Chris Brown.
interesting that neither council nor judge ever asks if she needs a break - they knew it was all bull💩
“Just tell the truth”- something her lawyer couldn’t tell her to do. That’s the bull’s eye that she clearly avoided.
Amber never realised that repeating back her testimony about the abuse was actually a trap. She always answered as if repeating her claims was helpful to her
It was the glass scene that did it for me. I stepped on one small piece of glass once and it gouged a big hole in my foot. I had 8 stitches it hurt like hell. She would have had to go to hospital and have glass removed from her feet if what happened to her actually happened
16:28 'A survivor would break eye contact when telling their story.' -Greg. I agree. I also feel that the last thing a survivor would do is stare-down the jury.
I've only ever told my husband about previous abuse and I couldn't even look at him when I told him then I said I don't want to discuss it further just needed him to know.
Who does that anyway!??! Like she wanted to charm the jury and it wasn't working she switched...
From 12:52 - 13:40 it is just ridiculous. I could not have been on the jury. At this point I would have had to raise my hand and tell the judge, "your honor, if you can make her stop, we can give our verdict right now."
Well she just won worst actress everi love Ben
😂 responding to Kevin Ashley
Amen! The fact that she just ripped off Rihanna’s very words when Rihanna had the everlivin HELL beat out of her? So offensive and INFURIATING!
Why didn't she just LEAVE? Did she really want his money that badly. She's vile lying gold digger. Just go away. You're a crap actress, fairly attractive so she'll pull another chump, until she attempts to knock him about lol 😆
I laughed my head off. So TRUE. I would have done the same myself.
Credit to Johnny for sitting there calmly listening, lie after lie after hideous lie, this woman is either the ultimate evil representation of a woman or she's insane.....
I vote for the later
Insane
Johnny knows not giving her attention not looking at her will piss her off more,
👏👏👏 yes, credit to Johnny 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙🫂
Both.
I would like to see a few episodes focused on Rocky Pennington deposition in the Heard trial. VERY interesting questions were asked by Heard council.
I’m generally an empathetic person! I tend to see the good in most people. But watching her try and destroy another persons life with these lies, she deserves everything she has coming to her!
I really feel like when she was acting dramatic & the fake tears etc, she was hoping for the judge to intervene & give her a break. There were various pauses & then she restarted the emotions & her testimony. So glad the judge didn’t.
she couldn't even squeeze out a tear
Penny was justing chewing the popcorn watching that big acting roll Amber did on the stand. Penny didn't want to pause that show for no intermission break.
Elaine probably coached her on that. It's true that judges often do that. It was done to me when I got on the stand and I was ok at first but when things got difficult I couldn't continue without a break. I fought hard to stay focused and honest but when the trauma started peeking through the carefully crafted exterior I had created for the world there was no way to stop the tears, the fear, the anxiety. If you are a survivor of DV and/or SA, just because you can move forward in your life doesn't mean that trauma will completely heal.
@@Kepi_Kei First I want to say I am so sorry you went through the trauma you did. I agree with you wholeheartedly on your assessment of her testimony of the trauma she went through. True victims can see through her theatrics. It is a crime or should be, that she used true victims for financial gain!
Love, love, love this new format! Makes it so much easier to see the body language as you’re talking about it. You guys are awesome, just love your different takes. Top quality! Love this channel!
I am a survivor of both childhood and domestic abuse and have been diagnosed with CPTSD. I still remember exactly what happened during the last incident with my exhusband although the amount of time is distorted. I know where I was and where he was during the entire thing despite the fact that I was having trauma responses in that moment. It's been over 12 years and I still cry everytime I try to express the emotions that I was feeling while it was happening. Her behavior is just like my mother and hearing the audio was bone chilling because I heard her voice. It actually made me nauseous.
I'm learning a lot I'm a dv sv survivor. So I have this small ability to detect bs. . . thank you gentleman . y'all are amazing at your job . 🙏💪
I think we domestic abuse survivors, have a huge eye and ear for BS!
I'm a survivor as well.
I find it amazing the amount of times she has no clear memory of ANY of her "alleged " abuse.
I can clearly recall mine in excruciating detail. Especially the sequence.
AH is not a real victim.
I'm now in my late 70s, and my radar is still not good. I need to ask someone to help me decide if a new person is "safe" or not. I'm so accustomed to surprising my internal voice, it's virtually silent. Keep on working at it, and try to believe your first doubts instead of questioning them.
I’m not a body language expert… And it took me no time at all to see she’s lying! And badly lol. So bizarre to hear someone speaking that weird tense about something that supposedly gave you the highest level of PTSD one can have
I can’t understand how anyone does believe her. Not for a second. It’s like she’s beaming her testimony from another galaxy. She’s a loon.
"I looked in his eyes and it was just black" - with the benefit of hindsight and analysis, we now know that she actually *stole* this description, almost word for word, from an interview that Rihanna gave after her assault. The reason she flounders is because she can't remember what her next line is - she cusses herself for it, then tries to buy time. Interesting to note that the judge, who has a duty of care, doesn't suggest a break - clearly she wasn't buying the act either. xx
So true. She repeated that one line about seeing “black” three or four times. Way too similar to Rihanna’s interview.
Wow I didn't know this! Amber Turd truly is a complete parasite living off of and aggrandizing herself through other peoples' real pain. Despicable!!
Yup, almost word for word what Rihanna said