Putin's air defence failures mount while Iran could create more problems for his regime | Frontline
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 เม.ย. 2024
- Putin will be nervous about close ally Iran backing proxies and militant groups abroad while at home the Kremlin struggles to find an answer to low coast Ukrainian drone strikes.
Speaking to Kate Gerbeau and James Hanson this week's Frontline experts outline Ukraine's strategies and the threats to Putin's regime:
Michael Clarke, Defence Analyst
Roger Boyes, The Times Diplomatic Editor
Justin Bronk, RUSI Senior Research Fellow on Airpower and Tech
John Foreman, Former Defence Attaché Moscow and Kyiv
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
![ตรงที่เดิม - ฝน พรสุดา [ต้นฉบับ :เบส ขวางหวัน]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c5YnbGEztI8/mqdefault.jpg)
My best wishes to Ukraine! And let of ALL of Europe to support Ukraine with or without US support!!
I’m embarrassed by my s**t government 😞
Why does Europe has to rely on US support? The war is on their neck of the woods. The aggressor is one of them. The victim is one of them.
With allies like the Yanks, who needs enemies?
@@gerryhouska2859shut up Ivan. USA is a great ally.
If you cared about ukraine you would have had them surrender years ago
It is always good to listen to Professor Clarke. He always talks sense. From Australia.
He seemed a bit dotty, actually.
he tells you what you want to hear, nothing more.
do you even know who stephan bandera was??
You mean nonsense
Love Professor Clarke. The Russian trolls hate him.
Endless violence masquerading as "sense." smfh
Professor Micheal Clarke is the best. Thank you.
What like Russia running out of missiles in March 2022
@@pauldean8638they had to go cap in hand to Rocket Boy and the mullahs
@Hakam-dr4fland what are you? A lying troll? Or as good as TASS, your state press agency?
@@davidbrancaleone3039 what makes them a Russian just by a comment . Am British and one of the oldest family’s ever recorded and I’d say the same as hakam . Clarke is an idiot who hasn’t got a clue , he’s a paid propagandist as he don’t come on for free.
@@MeM_UK that’s funny as no other country’s missiles used in the conflict . So come on name me a missile fired by Russia that’s not Russian , let’s see what other nonsense you going to spew
First guest with Kate was great, should have been more of him
He's my favorite. That's Professor Michael Clark.
There was, yesterday!
It would help if some of your guest speakers could string a sentence together coherently,unfortunately your second guest totally drove me to distraction and I had to switch off,🥱
Prof Clarke ❤
I have been listening to Micheal Clarke and his anaylsis of the recent attacks. Very objective indeed. Fully support his anaylsis.
It's just a little salty
Ukraine has not much time left to surrender before there is nothing left to surrender!
a fools support , rest assured
Roger Boyes, while being careful certainly, does not come across as being adequately articulate for this kind of interview.
He definitely works better behind the desk than being behind the microphone
articulation is the ability to express ideas effectively. His over use of filler words may be distracting for some but what's important is the ideas and insights he expresses
@@larrysteinke1839 He does not articulate them effectively and therefore does not convey his ideas and insights effectively. He gives the impression that he is a bumbling idiot. ‘Bumbling’ he certainly does. Why make excuses for him? His ideas are probably best expressed by others more adeptly, fluent and quick thinking. He may be very good at his job but he is hopeless in an interview.
@@hedydd2 I..... 'uhm'...... totally...... 'uhm' ......agree with you....... 'uuhm......you know'......'uhm'...about Roger...'uhm'...Boyes.
I really felt uncomfortable when he made analogies about tentacles
Mam or madam Kate Gerbeau and mr James Hanson are brilliant commentators, They're asking the objective questions to the political and military analysts regarding on these conflicts in Ukraine and Middle East, very impressive video, thank you so much Times Radio actors..
Sir it was 1987 that the 19 year old German teenager landed in Red square and not 1972.
Yep, chums, Mathias Rust , a short-sighted 19 y.old German. During the Gorbachiovian years of perestroika /restructuring. Greetings from Lietuva Lithuania.
@alfonsasgrinevicius7477 I remember I was about 8 years old. 45 now. Wow, quite story.
@@user-dq4jk2dd3d you are Certainly Right.
I wonder where Mathias is right now, if anyone knows??
Russia seems to do nothing very well at all.
Says someone who knows absolutely nothing about Russia, and hasn't learnt a single thing over the last two years.
Doing everything badly, but in large numbers. Can't win wars with just numbers in the modern era.
@billbellell9462 They won WWII for us, what more do you want????
ruzzia is very good at infecting western social media with lying propaganda.
Russia has an excellent supply of gangsters and trolls🎉🎉🎉
The threat to Europe of a Soviet invasion has never been greater as we teeter upon a precipice, yet our brave defenders in Ukraine are having to ration shells and pull back. How insane is that?
Soviet? What Soviet? Stop drinking cool aid. NATO was romancing Ukraine - it crossed a red line - Russia invaded after years of warning it to stop. Now nigh on 700K Ukrainians are dead - and even if "SOMEHOW" we could "MIRACULOUSLY" supply what's left of their pulverised forces with unlimited munitions - LOL - they would still never have a scintilla of a chance to repel the Russians militarily. There is no defeating a nuclear power - you have to pass M.A.D and that is the bottom line.
ruzzia can barely move in Ukraine. It's not going to invade Europe any time soon.
@@percyfaith11 You seem to lack the understanding of war of attrition. Ya, The west like the cold war says Russia was a joke until contract time comes up for weapon porjects budgets and purchases. Then Russia like the USSR was the bigest threat of all and we need to double our Defence budget. Russia is grinding Ukraine into the ground and we are back to the Cold war. EU wanted to move into eastern europe in Russias expanding NATO. Sort of like what they promissed not to do. Surprise here we are.
Russia couldn't invade a candy store never mind Europe
@@dean-gm1lg Acccording to who? Same leaders who went up against 3rd world forces, pulled out Afghanistan. how we do in viet Nam. In reality we have idea how the full war is going since the news shows all proganda clips given from Ukraine give us more money Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
It’s so sad we can’t help Ukraine with the same air defence that Israel have, there must be something that would work to stop the Russian bombs
Ukraine and Israel are geographically speaking a different world. Israel has a very limited amount of territory relative to Ukraine. Israel can much more easily cove their entire territory with a fairly localized air defense. Ukraine has a much larger territory to protect with population centers very distant from each other.
Yes there is something we can do, the same thing we could have done thirty years ago when we made the same promise to Russia - Neutrality for Ukraine with respect to NATO.
We can but there are western countries which seem reluctant to send their equipment!
@@MrMielten No we can't. The west can 'see the bottom of the barrel' when it comes to armoury - as stated by NATO Admiral Rob Bauer six months ago.
Israel won't share the tech with anyone
Ukraine will fight. Give them weapons. EU has depended too long on Uncle Sam.
uncle sam prefers poo-tin rubles now.
Republicans love their Swiss numbered bank accounts🎉🎉🎉
I'm amazed that Ukraine won't reach out to Asian countries for weapons, especially artillery...truly amazed. Poland is much better shape for having done it.
EU, what a joke they are..
Most of their soldiers are dead....dead cant fight.
Sneaky, got me in with the first guy and then hit me with the umm, aahh guy
Excellent
... Thank you!
That's my girl. She is the best in the west. You go Kate.
Kate is excellent. Very professional & shows respect for her guests by looking immaculate and lets them finish everything they want to say without chipping in.
Is it me, or are The Times regurgitating quite a bit of content. I listened to Michael Clarke saying a lot of this in another clip last week.
He did...all of the analysts do this though, it's not the Times necessarily, the people they are speaking to have talking points, and BOTH the analysts and the new outlets are regurgitating content, even like this compilation here...until several days pass and new events have influenced what they say.
I personally have not heard of Clarke's similar comments so far, but that's because I only see him once every other week at best, i don't follow him as closely as Gen. Ben Hodges and others.
You are correct. They are spamming old content every few days; slicing and rearranging stories and repackaging them with new titles and intros.
They all do it . That’s why it’s advisable to read and watch a diverse source of news sources .
They are Bagdad Bob.
They spout a lot of nonsense, it's frankly embarrassing..
Someone needs to give the second speaker a jumpstart before the mikes are turned on.
Mathias Rust: flew in 1987
Thank you for this interview with Michael Clarke. It's always interesting to hear his analysis of the situation in Ukraine.
Roger needs to speed up his talking. Get on with it Roger that was a painful listen.
😂
Play at +25% speed, fixes it for me............... Oh make that +50 or 75%!!
Yes a bit painful but worth putting up with. His analysis was quite good.
Let's be clear, "We do not encourage" is not the same as "We are against". Read between the lines whether the USA is truly bothered or not! Deniable vagueness works wonderfully at times!
You're a wise and knowledgeable lady 👍
@@Ultranationalist987 She just knows how to read, fact some seem to miss. or are able to read words but miss it's interpretation completely
@@Maddog-xc2zv either that or she just watched jake broes last update ..
@@colinobrien3806 I usually tend to give more credit to people's own intelligence when comparing to "parrot" other you tuber words. And I do have a lot of respect for Jake Broe, which I also follow on a regular basis; but still have no proof to underscore the words written by the lady. As I stated, without still having watched such video, it's more a matter of being able to read and interpret texts rather then echoing others, no matter the competence they may carry. Cheers.
It would have been better if America said nothing at all on the subject,considering their hands are tied by trump and co,this negative narrative which was repeated Gen Austin just gives Russia more encouragement to keep the war going,hoping the US will give up on support for UKR!
Looking forward to peace one day 🕊️
Please... someone who can complete a cogent thought!
Man, this guy can’t find his words. 😅
Doesn’t it make you sad that so much energy and resources are going into the war machine?
Yes!
Depends on what side you are on. If you are a company making money, they are loving it.
Adress your question to putin
I have the utmost respect for Michael Clark, but it seems to me that Mathis Rust flew a Cessna into Red Sqare in May of 1987 & NOT IN 1972!!!!!!! 😇
Two years continuous fight and spending billions in arms have dented in economy of both countries
Thanks for the video.
Can't we all just get along?
Mathias Rust flew into Red Square on the 28th of May 1987 not 1972.
🇺🇦❤🇺🇦❤🇺🇦❤
Ukraine needs more help to defend democracy!
Spot on ..the truth ...wake up people
...
Thanks to you all for your wise words. I hope the weak-kneed politicians are listening!
"The slow blade penetrates the shield" - in this case the blade is an RC Cessna and the shield is Russian air defences.
1987, Mathias was born in 1968. :)
A difficult watch...after Prof Clarke. Interesting all the same....
I switched off at octipus
Octopus mate. As in 8. Like the number of arms/legs it has.
Bring back the Swordfish
Sopwith
SLAVA UKRAINE
Excellent interview, too bad you won't fix the volume. It is most unprofessional.
This guy is great to listen to
Victory. VICTORY ! Well said Sir !
I think Rust was 1987 not 1972.
And you are correct.
20:52 Justin Bronk on speed filtering by radar Doppler gate, GPS jamming EW electronic warfare versus inertia guiding… striking at a deep target over long distance can be easier than highly defended close targets.
Counter UAV technology will not be difficult when the UAV threat increases
Is nice to see a rehash of older videos. To me that means only one thing a slow new day, because the alternative is unthinkable. Thanks.
Glory to Ukraine. God Bless Ukraine and her people. 🇺🇦🇺🇸
Similar incident happened in Washington; some years ago, when a US citizen glided into the WH area.
It's becoming more and more hard to justify both wars😂😂 and the lies starts to be hard to hide from our side.
Reduce the petro out put.
Interesting ❤
Reminds me of the Simpsons episode where grand-pa had stolen the Wight Flyer out of the museum. Attack plans were scrambled ...but they couldn't engage the bogey... they just kept screaming past grand-pa doing about 10 miles hour😂
Cut to the chase and hear it As it Is!.. 52:00
What is 61 billion going to do that 300 billion plus didn't do for Ukraine ?
Create more jobs in the US, that's what.
Spit it out Rodger!!!
Just imagine having Putin and Khomaniac around for tea.
I love this guy!
Too much hesitation in the guest, irritating
Circulation.......Circulation.......
Japan has it's own issues with Russia.
Stalin seized a group of islands in the Northern waters of Japanese territory in the closing days of WWII.
Japan has been trying diplomatically to secure their return from Putin with no success.
The Soviets and Japanese Armies did clash in the Mongolian region of China early in the WWII era but had ceased hostilities. Then Stalin jumped on the victory over Japan bandwagon as an Allied power and steadfastly refused to leave.
Japan sees a Russian defeat in Ukraine as possibly serving their interests against Russia.
You do know that Japan only surrendered to tge west cause they were scared of Russia.
It had nothing to do with the bombs that were dropped.
Very true and if anything pops off with NATO or the United States and Russia, Japan must take advantage of the opportunity and get back it's illegally seized Northern territories , and join the coalition against Russia
Japan is really one of the only countries in the world that has already defeated the Russian navy a hundred years ago
Um, ah, ah, ah, um..........,.. ah, um....., is distracting and hard to follow
That's it going to stop watching this channel as the start of any video is used as some sort of clickbait and it's getting irritating
33:10 This man speaks the truth.
Mathias Rust flew to Red Square 1987....
Most of us in the US call Japan, Taiwan, Australia, South Korea and New Zealand "The West" also
Same thing happened where A guy landed in DC.
More exactly, on the White House lawn.
Thanks. Ow, Ya. I forgot he landed that close. They did freak out though. Little craft can fly under the radar and embarise the best security.
@@Knox122771 I understand a war of attrition just fine. I understand how the West broke the Soviet Union financially and technologically in the Cold War. With proper support Ukr can win a war of attrition with the orcs.
@@percyfaith11 I do not know what war you are watching. Stick with the call of duty clips on CNN. Ukraine not doing so great in the real one.
@@Knox122771 like ruzzia is?😆
t..t..t..t..t..t..today junior! Dayum killin me
Ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh
Has anyone wondered why relations are deteriorating between Russia and Iran.
The words people say and what others hear can be totally different ends of the spektrum.
"Peace talks" can be heard as a good thing, the peaceful ending or it can also be heard as surrender and defeat. Can you guess what Ukraine hears?
If Hamas was an Iranian proxy, then why are they mainly funded by Qatar?
Because Iran is under sanctions... they use Qatar.
Hamas is a problem no matter who funds them. Their status as Iran's proxy matters very little.
Money laundry run by fundamentalists who blame Jews for everything. Look at photos from Innocents Abroad: Arabs under the Ottmans were literally dirt poor. After 1500 deep ocean shipping made the Silk Road pointless.
This is a game. They all are working for the same entity. It is beyond most people's understanding.
And Iran will turn on russia
Whatever the opposite of articulate, clear, and engaging may be.. the second guy has it in spades. He is a zero. Get rid of that sloth.
Mr. Rust landed on red square on 28 May 1987 - not 1972 (he was 4 at that time).
If it is in Japan's interest to support Ukraine, how much more so Taiwan's?
Why isn't Taiwan doing more to support the good guys in this war?
I wonder how many kids gor booted out of old squeakies classroom for falling asleep. He needs some speed
Face the truth: "Do a deal“ with Russia, really means capitulation to Russia. Do not mislead or sugar coat what "Doing a Deal With Russia" really means for Ukraine.
Time to bring back some of the old anti-aircraft systems to bring down the drones? Do the Russians not have the old ZSU systems in storage?
And how good are the Uk's air defences? Do we have the capability? Do we have air defence missiles?
Projection TV
Refining capability restored. This is not classified. Ffs do better
American aid is about to be approved. Speaker Johnson put country before his job. Very impressive.
Im glad he did that too, but it isn’t really impressive given that he hasn’t been able to perform the most basic of governance since taking the position, and he cost so many Ukrainian lives with the 7 month delay. Previous to becoming speaker, he voted no on aid to Ukraine, and then waited while Ukrainians paid with their lives, because the former president told him to. I’m still very glad it got done and hope that he will continue to work in a bipartisan way to make some other progress. Too bad repubs voted down, for example, the toughest legislation on the brdr in modern history because the former president told them not to. Check it out. It was written by one of the most conservative republicans in Congress. Half of republicans voted no on aid to Ukraine, so I will vote for all democrats, who are united on this issue.
The problem is that they are adapting to current times even though it might take them some time to get there
Damn they butchered the description 🤣
Repeat same msg for what?
The time is ripe that britain that used to be great once upon a time get back it' s historic land that rightfully belongs to it, Crimea.
Poor sound quality 😢
Those light aircraft are probably not discovered, because the russian radar filters out targets moving slowly. It might be the range gauge that can't believe it is the same radar target because it hasn't moved enough since the last sweep. Secondly they are probably under the radar horisont for much of the distance. Under 1500-2000 feet they can't see it 50 miles away. There is a minimum angle for traditional radar to avoid getting radar returns from buildings and trees.
I find that interesting since the US picks up ballons that fly slow, and track air traffic of small private planes like the Cessna. I'm sure Russians can to....I think you're right about the height/distance factor though
This women i enjoy her journalism professionality
the question with European commitments continue to be, when do they deliver?
Supporting Ukraine is a priority .
Any politician that decides otherwise will lose votes.
No one voluntarily votes for Putin.
I hope you are right
you❤❤❤
Shame on all you rich countries
Watching that sesna like drone flying into an oil redinery in Russia is almost comical.
That's what the pilot's last words were.
Surprised they didn't try and blame it on Bin Laden 😂
Rodger, for heavens sake, get back on your oxygen!!
Then retire, for good.
So when was Irans air space infringed?
Are we prepared in the WEST??
Clarke obviously still knows very little about Ukraine even after studying 2 years of it. Support for Zelensky is still there and will remain to be despite the propaganda disseminated in the west! Don't be ridiculous!
Diverting attention from the failures of the counteroffensive. Media war is very detached from the reality war on the ground.
You really shouldn't criticize Russian media they get paid in rubles
If Israel decide to take out Iran’s drone factories then Putin might have a few headaches
Like 2006
Must be a good video if so many russian bots have commented already! 😊
botEm ukraine -- you're covered -- "It may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal." Henry Kissinger
No, must be okay if the Langley Liars come crawling out to comment.
@@robertatkins9419 Langley Liars? Kissinger is on record as having said that!!
@@boota1979 Thanks, I didn't know that.
@Hakam-dr4fl And lies and lies, even when they come with a fake made-up name tag.
The fact that Putin is blowing up key infrastructure in Ukraine with huge FAB1500 gps glide bombs shows just how hopeless the Russian Army are, there is no way that Putin doesn't want to inherit a well working Ukraine, if Ukraine surrender, he will rebuild all of this key infrastructure, this could be half a trillion dollar alone, but trying to do it without working power stations, water works and other civil engineering is really not in Putin's interest. I could have just said Putin is really struggling, like verge of losing struggling
Gaza is not a proxy war with Iran, although they may paint it that way for convenience. Israel has coveted Palestinian territory since its creation. Israeli policy is Imperialistic, always has been, though backed by religious rather materialistic desires
A problem for Putin is that 'Mascarova', had a mirror image. Although if he is Count Putinulah then he really shouldn't have any reflection at all.
Oh dear 'shhh' enough said eh??? don't have to tell him anything eh?