So do I. I think bannacafalata may be my favourite character too because while it may be a bit rushed to fit the runtime, the strength to accept who and what you are is a rare gift and it is nice to see someone self actualise like that.
I wasn't. If he had stuck to the actual flaws of the episode, and with this one there are many, I would have been fine. Instead, the jokes were flimsy and could be (and often were) explained only a few minutes later in the episode. So yeah, as much as I am a fan of Sins, this one was badly done and not up to their usual standard. They had so much to work with in this glorious mess of an episode, and instead went for cheap and easy, and wrong.
@@ms_scribbles I kinda took it as there arent enough legitimate sins in Doctor Who to fill a 14 minute video so some had to be stretched a bit. Theres literally not enough to criticise about this show because it's perfect (just kidding but you get my point)
As a fan of Doctor Who and CinemaSins I'm happy this is literally just a guy making up random s*** about TV shows the entertainment this is about a serious as your average episode of something like Family Guy
“But doesn’t this mean you could just stall the robot by asking it pointless questions?” “Information override: Compute to the last digit the value of pi. Okay, just do that to every robot you meet. Off you go.”
Because an arrogant prick who knows half of these sins could be easily explained but Jesus to be deliberately ignorant and therefore loses any entertainment value
@@joegreenhalgh6902 Fun fact: the speech stated that the Doctor would save Earth, which is what he did. If you wanted to see Earth nuked by the ship, watch the episode "Turn Left" which shows you what happens when the Doctor isn't around to stop the ship from nuking the Earth. (Side Note: "Voyage of the Damned" stated the ship would wipe out all life on Earth, "Turn Left" shows us the ship only wiping out South England, soooooooooooo I'll let you off if you wanted to sin that fact)
The biggest sin of all is that Doctor Who only gets 1 video a year made about it, whilst the likes of Friends and The Mandalorian are covered episode by episode.
Pretty much. I wonder how they'll do the End Of Time in a couple of years since it was a two parter, one episode on Christmas Day and the other was on New Year's Day.
Let's hope they make plenty of jokes about how that piece of crap Moffat turned the First Doctor into a raging misogynist for no reason. The First Doctor was slightly a product of the times, but for FFS, Moffat took it way too far and insulted not only women, but the memories of everyone who worked on the show in the Hartnell years who would have never let the sexist jokes to get THAT bad, including the WOMAN who would have NEVER let such lines be in the show. The only time he mentioned someone deserving a "jolly good smacked bottom" was his GRANDDAUGHTER, not some random woman he's only just met. Ugh. F*ck Moffat. F*ck him with a rusty butterknife.
Allonsy, Alonzo is one of my favourite parts of the entire show there is nothing more David Tennant than that bit especially because he gets so hyped about it. Peak Tennant's Doctor
Americans just think their culture is more important so they call anything outside of their own country "discount", when honestly, them saying "discount" is a discount version of british "btec" and also America is discount England had to be said
"Sooo, who's idea was it to propel a massive ship with a nuclear bomb?" A nuclear reactor / similar fusion device? Well ... NASA, almost every modern scientist, and most people who know about modern power generation - That's who :p
Except New Zealand almost a war with france over the fact the french government commissioned a hit on a boat named the rainbow warrior which was a greenpeace vessel the hit was executed and a bomb was planted on the boat by french operatives and it blew killing a civilian and creating massive hostility towards france from new Zealand for a long time
NASA had never flown a fusion device. Or a nuclear reactor. RTGs, yes, but there is no bomb potential there. That said, any energy source is, at minimum, hazardous. More often, it has explosive potential. The bigger the engine, the bigger the risk. Your car is full of gasoline, unless it's electric, in which case, different-but-similar kinds of risks. Etc. It's the nature of storing energy.
@@bobbyfeet2240 they didn't say they actually flew them, but just that they've all proposed such things. They wanted to build some in the '70s to go to Mars etc, but then Nixon cut the budget and redirected to the Space Shuttle.
Top 5 "Pandorica Opens" when he's talking to the fleets "The Doctor Falls" when talking to the master and missy "The Rings of Ahkaten" towards the star The epic speech in "The Zygon Inversion" And doesn't most of "Heaven Sent" count?
"If you know the Doctor's history with angels." Did you just sin continuity...? Because Blink was literally four episodes before this. I don't know if it's Aaron's delivery or if TV Sins is just worse at this sort of thing than the mothership, but honestly it takes a whole lot of the fun out of the videos for me when they do shit like this. They have two options: "This episode isn't a standalone *ding*" or "This episode has nothing to do with the ones around it *ding*."
Everything wrong with "Everything Wrong With Doctor Who "Voyage of the Damned""... Bill and Ted's Phone box was inspired by the TARDIS, not the other way around. {DING} Not a single sin taken off for all the awesome parts of this episode. {DING} Discount "Cinema Sins" narrator. {DING} {DING} {DING} {DING} {DING} Happy New Year!
"And the reporter, please don't forget him... can we see some of his unnecessary backstory please?" Well, Nicholas Witchell is an actual reporter in real life, so we kind of know his backstory already... What's that? Americans don't? Oh no! Anyway...
TV Sins: How can they know about the Titanic but this guy doesn't know who Santa is? Episode: He faked his Earth knowledge. TV Sins: How dare you give me backstory!
Sinning things like the lack of life preservers, when that is clearly the point because everyone is supposed to die on this journey, or the professor not knowing about Santa, when we later find out he has no qualifications and is making it all up, is just lazy!
The sin for life preservers was about the life preserver that fell into the Tardis at the beginning of the episode, and then no life preservers were ever shown again after that.
@@andrewe2057 except he says it again when the ship explodes, saying that oh now nothing can save them, which was the point! And also the original one about having the life preserver despite it being a space ship was obviously a decorative choice!
I know I’m coming late to the party, I promise I have noticed it before, but I gotta give you props for the “Sinsung” at the bottom of the screen. It’s subtle but I dig it!
Discount Bill and Ted? The TARDIS? A machine introduced to the world in 1963, and you call it out for RIPPING ON BILL AND TED?????? *Uber-Who Nerd is angry*
here's another well actually moment: Earth's atmosphere actually extends very far into space. There is no specific line that marks space and not space. The ISS is still in Earth's atmosphere and is constantly being slightly slowed down due to atmospheric drag. So, if the meteors are moving at a high enough speed and the Titanic is close enough to Earth (it's not clearly defined) the meteors could have fiery trails
Yep, the queen being a fan of the Doctor is historically accurate. In fact, the only BBC controller who never received a knighthood was the one responsible for killing classic Who. Lizzy be petty when you mess with her Time Lord. Also, Michael Grade was legitimately a jerk.
9:41 _"This is where the kitchen staff were murdered earlier, so there are far too few _*_carcasses_*_ in this room."_ Except, carcass refers to the remains of an animal, specifically the remains of a meat animal after being dressed and prepared for butchering. The word you were looking for is *corpses.* Cheers!
Plus the fact it's a gigantic ship in space with thousands of guests, did he not think to realise there may be more than one single tiny kitchen on the entire ship?
He has sinned the “obvious” lack of life preservers on the outside of the ship, but does no one see the decorative life preserver in the ballroom at 1:27?
They are from the same family tree branch. Well adjusted siblings . Now you want bitter family members the phone booth that use to help superman change absolutely hates these guys. (its' like the Drunk uncle that use to be the high school football star that just didn't go anywhere with his life. )
Attacking Doctor Who like some sort of swine. 90% of the sins are answered in the episode, such as the reason why they were wrong about the 'great god santa' being that the character didn't go to a proper university. Also sinning characterisation. Oh and don't forget sinning WILFRED MOTT
If you can’t stand your shows/series being sinned, don’t watch the episode. You know it’s going to be sinned enough to get it to ~15min for the ad revenue. AND, they are going to sin things obvious to show lovers, so they make comments and leave likes/dislikes. Specifically for the increased viewer interaction numbers which advertisers, and the TH-cam recommendation algorithm love.
and sinning "unnecessary" backstory like Donna's dad which gets revealed later in the series. You can't just say "satire" when your points are straight up incorrect smh!
I love all the Sins channels but TVSins always feels like it's scrapping the bottom of the barrel for jokes. Yeah I know it's supposed to be for satire and giggles but it gets to a point where the satire isn't even funny to begin with and just sounds like nitpicking for the sake of padding the sin count and the run time of the video. (feel free to come with your pitchforks and torches because I don't get it or because i'm a hater)
You forgot to sin how £1 million is apparently worth 50 million credits on Sto, meaning 5000 credit phone bill that is roughly equal to the price of 2 first class tickets on The Titanic and would have taken Foon and Morvin 20 years to pay off is only £100.
Aw, skipped over the best part of this episode, the part where the rich douche guy says, "who put you in charge, and who the hell are you anyway?" Then the Doctor gives his "I'm the Doctor" line. That made this episode for me.
11:10. This is ALSO explained in like 30 seconds. The Host respond to him because now that Capricorn is dead. Their protocols that followed him are deleted and they reset to follow the the next person in command and the host have registered the fact that's the Doctor.
I appreciate that you guys like a good simple action romp, but I love this era of doctor who because everyone has a story, yeah some are more interesting than others but everybody is a person with a story
You say “no one cares why they know robotics, we don’t need an explanation” but a few Christmas specials later there’s a planet where fish swim through the air, and people lost their minds that there was no explanation for how it works (even though “alien planet in a science fiction program” should have been sufficient)
Voyage of the Damned? More like Voyage of the Damned Good looking! Look, it's Dr Who, I've got nothing. Even if I watched Dr Who, I'd probably still have nothing. Hell, I'd know I'd have nothing if I did that.
Information; there is a protocol called seaspeak where specific words and phrases are used for clarity. The first word is e.g. Question, Request, Warning, Information etc. Most verbal communication at sea is in English so having a limited, vocabulary and syntax reduces the chance of errors.
1:29 There's a life preserver right there. They're just used as decoration on the ship, which is why there's none on the outside of the ship because that would be stupid.
4:07 It's based on the movie The Poseidon Adventure, not the actual Titanic disaster. Also, the sinking of the Titanic was over a century ago. If you mean by having a lighthearted 9/11 movie in say 2101 as "a few years", then sure.
10:00 Funny, dear. It was supposed to be funny. Nobody in their right mind expected that part to be the exciting bit. Maybe wait another line of dialogue before judging.
The Doctor being wary of the angel robots might be a reference not to the Weeping Angels, but the androids from the Fourth Doctor episode The Robots of Death, which feature very similar looking robots that also chant "kill, kill, kill"
The thing about Russel T Davies' era as showrunner was that he was obsessed with giving everyone backstory. Like EVERYONE. Luckily it all got sorted when Moffat took over and only 1/5 non-main characters got any level of backstory. But then Chibbers buggered it all up.
And that's why the RTD episodes are brilliant episodes with so many recognisable and memorable characters whose death made you sad and Moffats episodes and characters were all mostly forgettable, pointless and had no weight to them at all. Chibnall brought the show back to how good it used to be before Moffat buggered it up.
You ever watch something and then later that night stumble across a channel that recaps that EXACT show on the EXACT episode that you just HAPPENED to watch out of the WHOLE series? Yeah. You know where I'm GOING with this.
Yes exactly! I feel like you can tell when they genuinely dislike something because the tone of the sins is totally different. I know these are satire but this one seemed kinda brutal compared to other recent videos
If you had someone on the ship saying you don't need a shield , then you do, then you don't, then you do again, and making everyone stop working on the ship even though the ship has a 99% chance of surviving the meteors, then you have a pandemic reference.
Here are all the audio outtake clips at the end: 1 (13:02): The Fifth Element (Gaumont Film Company, 1997) 2 (13:16): Max Headroom: 20 Minutes into the Future (Channel 4, 4th April 1985) 3 (13:18): SpongeBob SquarePants, "Pickles" (season 1, episode 6B; Nickelodeon, 21st August 1999) 4 (13:28): Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (DreamWorks Pictures, 2004) 5 (13:29): Super Mario Galaxy 64 (Nintendo, 1996) 6 (13:36): Ex Machina (A24, 2014) 7 (13:42): Toy Story 2 (Walt Disney Pictures, 199) 8 (13:43): Monty Python and the Holy Grail (EMI Films, 1975) 9 (13:47): The Lonely Island's "Cool Guys Don't Look at Explosions" (MTV, 31st May 2009) 10 (13:55): The Emperor's New Groove (Walt Disney Pictures, 2000) 11 (14:05): Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (DreamWorks Pictures, 2004) 12 (14:14): Toy Story (Walt Disney Pictures, 1995)
Okay... the sin about Bannakaffalatta "knowing he could do this the whole time but waiting until now"... using his remaining energy reserves to knock out the angels literally killed bannakaffalatta. He died moments later. Of course that would be a last resort.
8:11. Yes he knew he could do it. But it drains his battery til it's completely depleted. That's why he doesn't do it. Another thing you clearly weren't paying a blind bit of attention to
Lol I just rewatched the entire series after I got my mom into dr who during quarantine and you would be SHOCKED how many unintentional references there are to the pandemic
This was my first Dr. Who Christmas special back two years ago and as a new Whovian (modern Who was what I binged in 2020~) and a self-proclaimed expert on the Titanic, I adore this special. It holds a very special place in my heart, and I do feel like some of the jokes were not funny here. Oh well~ Still a fun video.
You sin the fact that the people on the ship don’t know enough about Earth but know enough about the ship to build a replica but then don’t know it’s history - except that’s the point. Max is the only other person who knows and he did it as a sick joke. He’s the one who decided on the name and the design not the people on the ship. It also kinda explains how the ship would act as a nuclear bomb but tbh large objects falling from space would also cause a large amount of damage anyway. Also you sin the fact the Doctor doesn’t use the questions to perpetually stall and then sin the part where it’s explained there’s a limit. Also I imagine he did think of his EMP blast earlier but - for obvious reasons - didn’t want to literally kill himself unless he had to (the fact the device can be recharged doesn’t necessarily mean it’ll resurrect the dead partially organic being). I don’t know if the scene was meant t be slightly comedic (if not then that’s a sin) but it did seem obvious to me that Max did not take Astrid’s Damn Big Hero moment with the forklift seriously coz he knew his machine was clearly too grounded to be pushed (he only panicked once he was being lifted).
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
It's just for jokes, don't get mad. It's just for jokes, don't get mad. It's just for jokes, don't...
Too fucking late.
..... AAAAAAARRRRRRGHHHHHHHHH!
get mad for not praising Bernard Cribbins!
Too fucking late................................................
"Discount bill and ted phone thing" dont get mad....F*ck
I don't know if i'm thrilled or terrified. i love doctor who and this special.
One of my favourite Doctor Who episodes ever.
Same lol
Agreed. Bannakafalatta - Cyborg!
So do I. I think bannacafalata may be my favourite character too because while it may be a bit rushed to fit the runtime, the strength to accept who and what you are is a rare gift and it is nice to see someone self actualise like that.
As a Brit, I'm Angry,
As a Fan of Doctor Who, I'm Angry
As a Fan of Sins, I'm Happy.
I Feel... Conflicted.
Me too. I was so conflicted watching this episode.
I wasn't. If he had stuck to the actual flaws of the episode, and with this one there are many, I would have been fine. Instead, the jokes were flimsy and could be (and often were) explained only a few minutes later in the episode. So yeah, as much as I am a fan of Sins, this one was badly done and not up to their usual standard. They had so much to work with in this glorious mess of an episode, and instead went for cheap and easy, and wrong.
@@ms_scribbles I kinda took it as there arent enough legitimate sins in Doctor Who to fill a 14 minute video so some had to be stretched a bit. Theres literally not enough to criticise about this show because it's perfect (just kidding but you get my point)
As a fan of Doctor Who and CinemaSins I'm happy this is literally just a guy making up random s*** about TV shows the entertainment this is about a serious as your average episode of something like Family Guy
"Blink and you'll miss it" good one
He sinned the reference to the angles then made a reference to the angles lol
@@Jonathan-vf7wg idk it’s a little obtuse to me
@@twistedspike69 🤣🤣🤣
@@twistedspike69 lolll
“But doesn’t this mean you could just stall the robot by asking it pointless questions?”
“Information override: Compute to the last digit the value of pi. Okay, just do that to every robot you meet. Off you go.”
You didn’t remove a sin for the Doctor’s speech?! That’s a sin!!!
Because an arrogant prick who knows half of these sins could be easily explained but Jesus to be deliberately ignorant and therefore loses any entertainment value
Because it's a lie, it didn't kill everyone on earth.
@@joegreenhalgh6902 Fun fact: the speech stated that the Doctor would save Earth, which is what he did. If you wanted to see Earth nuked by the ship, watch the episode "Turn Left" which shows you what happens when the Doctor isn't around to stop the ship from nuking the Earth. (Side Note: "Voyage of the Damned" stated the ship would wipe out all life on Earth, "Turn Left" shows us the ship only wiping out South England, soooooooooooo I'll let you off if you wanted to sin that fact)
@@TwilightZebby I have, it doesn't kill all 6 billion people on earth.
@@TwilightZebby I didn't read your full comment lol, that was indeed my sin lol
4:50 Dude, the TARDIS predates Bill and Ted by 25 years. If anything, Bill and Ted are the knockoff.
At this rate, we'll get to Twice Upon a Time in about 10 years...
That will break the sin counter.
The biggest sin of all is that Doctor Who only gets 1 video a year made about it, whilst the likes of Friends and The Mandalorian are covered episode by episode.
Pretty much. I wonder how they'll do the End Of Time in a couple of years since it was a two parter, one episode on Christmas Day and the other was on New Year's Day.
Let's hope they make plenty of jokes about how that piece of crap Moffat turned the First Doctor into a raging misogynist for no reason. The First Doctor was slightly a product of the times, but for FFS, Moffat took it way too far and insulted not only women, but the memories of everyone who worked on the show in the Hartnell years who would have never let the sexist jokes to get THAT bad, including the WOMAN who would have NEVER let such lines be in the show. The only time he mentioned someone deserving a "jolly good smacked bottom" was his GRANDDAUGHTER, not some random woman he's only just met. Ugh. F*ck Moffat. F*ck him with a rusty butterknife.
@@ms_scribbles okay but hes a better writer than RTD
Not removing a sin for the doctor's speech. Aaaaand for Alons y, Alonzo!
Allonsy, Alonzo is one of my favourite parts of the entire show there is nothing more David Tennant than that bit especially because he gets so hyped about it. Peak Tennant's Doctor
4:52 It's not a discount version of something if the so called "discount" came first
Any NuWho stuff gets treated as newer by Americans anyway
@@Whiteythereaper That's a sin on the Americans that. 😂😂😂
While I agree Doctor Who is the name brand and Bill & Ted the discount, this is not necessarily true:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrox
Americans just think their culture is more important so they call anything outside of their own country "discount", when honestly, them saying "discount" is a discount version of british "btec" and also America is discount England had to be said
"Sooo, who's idea was it to propel a massive ship with a nuclear bomb?"
A nuclear reactor / similar fusion device? Well ... NASA, almost every modern scientist, and most people who know about modern power generation - That's who :p
Except New Zealand almost a war with france over the fact the french government commissioned a hit on a boat named the rainbow warrior which was a greenpeace vessel the hit was executed and a bomb was planted on the boat by french operatives and it blew killing a civilian and creating massive hostility towards france from new Zealand for a long time
And the argument nz doesn't know enough is false because ernest rutherford the man who split the atom was from new Zealand and proud
NASA had never flown a fusion device. Or a nuclear reactor. RTGs, yes, but there is no bomb potential there.
That said, any energy source is, at minimum, hazardous. More often, it has explosive potential. The bigger the engine, the bigger the risk. Your car is full of gasoline, unless it's electric, in which case, different-but-similar kinds of risks. Etc. It's the nature of storing energy.
@@bobbyfeet2240 Fission*
@@bobbyfeet2240 they didn't say they actually flew them, but just that they've all proposed such things. They wanted to build some in the '70s to go to Mars etc, but then Nixon cut the budget and redirected to the Space Shuttle.
This episode has one of the best speeches by The Doctor
Definitely of Tennant's doctor, out of every doctor it's a bit hard to pick.
Top 5
"Pandorica Opens" when he's talking to the fleets
"The Doctor Falls" when talking to the master and missy
"The Rings of Ahkaten" towards the star
The epic speech in "The Zygon Inversion"
And doesn't most of "Heaven Sent" count?
"If you know the Doctor's history with angels." Did you just sin continuity...? Because Blink was literally four episodes before this. I don't know if it's Aaron's delivery or if TV Sins is just worse at this sort of thing than the mothership, but honestly it takes a whole lot of the fun out of the videos for me when they do shit like this. They have two options: "This episode isn't a standalone *ding*" or "This episode has nothing to do with the ones around it *ding*."
You're just now figuring out that most of the sins completely disregard context, or are utterly arbitrary?
Dude Doctor Who was in the 60s, the first Bill and Ted movie wasn't even a twinkle in the writers nutsack!
smh ignorant writer lol
They are SO good at trolling.
Absolutely!!! Someone gets it.
THAT'S THE JOKE
@@ScottKorin Joke or not. It's an insult to pop culture.
YOU LEAVE THE 10TH DOCTOR ALONE! He's 903 years old. He can do whatever he wants.
What's that? A giant boat? With people on it? Without masks? KISSING? BREATHING UNCLEAN AIR?
How do u know the air is unclean
Everything wrong with "Everything Wrong With Doctor Who "Voyage of the Damned""... Bill and Ted's Phone box was inspired by the TARDIS, not the other way around. {DING} Not a single sin taken off for all the awesome parts of this episode. {DING}
Discount "Cinema Sins" narrator. {DING} {DING} {DING} {DING} {DING}
Happy New Year!
Hes not really a discount Cinema sins narrortor , this channel is owned by cinema sins
@@titaniumwolf8756 No shit, Chet. It's a joke.
"And the reporter, please don't forget him... can we see some of his unnecessary backstory please?"
Well, Nicholas Witchell is an actual reporter in real life, so we kind of know his backstory already... What's that? Americans don't? Oh no! Anyway...
TV Sins: How can they know about the Titanic but this guy doesn't know who Santa is?
Episode: He faked his Earth knowledge.
TV Sins: How dare you give me backstory!
Sinning things like the lack of life preservers, when that is clearly the point because everyone is supposed to die on this journey, or the professor not knowing about Santa, when we later find out he has no qualifications and is making it all up, is just lazy!
The sin for life preservers was about the life preserver that fell into the Tardis at the beginning of the episode, and then no life preservers were ever shown again after that.
@@andrewe2057 except he says it again when the ship explodes, saying that oh now nothing can save them, which was the point! And also the original one about having the life preserver despite it being a space ship was obviously a decorative choice!
Plus its the Titanic.
I know I’m coming late to the party, I promise I have noticed it before, but I gotta give you props for the “Sinsung” at the bottom of the screen. It’s subtle but I dig it!
I somehow have never noticed this, even though I've seen nearly every single TV sins video. 🤦
Thanks for pointing that out!
Did you really just call the TARDIS a bill and ted knockoff?
Discount Bill and Ted? The TARDIS? A machine introduced to the world in 1963, and you call it out for RIPPING ON BILL AND TED?????? *Uber-Who Nerd is angry*
here's another well actually moment: Earth's atmosphere actually extends very far into space. There is no specific line that marks space and not space. The ISS is still in Earth's atmosphere and is constantly being slightly slowed down due to atmospheric drag. So, if the meteors are moving at a high enough speed and the Titanic is close enough to Earth (it's not clearly defined) the meteors could have fiery trails
Haha what’s wrong with backstory and character development 😂
Yep, the queen being a fan of the Doctor is historically accurate. In fact, the only BBC controller who never received a knighthood was the one responsible for killing classic Who. Lizzy be petty when you mess with her Time Lord.
Also, Michael Grade was legitimately a jerk.
How can they skip my favorite Doctor Who line ever?
Doctor Who: "You should see me in the morning."
Kiley:"Ok"
9:41 _"This is where the kitchen staff were murdered earlier, so there are far too few _*_carcasses_*_ in this room."_ Except, carcass refers to the remains of an animal, specifically the remains of a meat animal after being dressed and prepared for butchering. The word you were looking for is *corpses.* Cheers!
Plus the fact it's a gigantic ship in space with thousands of guests, did he not think to realise there may be more than one single tiny kitchen on the entire ship?
I knew there'd be a ton of people complaining about the Bill and Ted line. xD
So did we. :)
@@TVSins Satan is proud of you
It's kind of depressing how many people don't get that the "mistake" was intentional.
@@TVSins that's what makes you so great. Epic Sin Trolls.
@@TVSins Ooooh, you bastards. lol
He has sinned the “obvious” lack of life preservers on the outside of the ship, but does no one see the decorative life preserver in the ballroom at 1:27?
Sinning the greatest description of Christmas ever... "then they invade Turkey and eat their flesh"
Anyone miss when sins used to be like actual valid sins and not just jokes?
Valid Sins on this channel:- Yes
Valid Sins for the episode:- Nope.
Those 15 minutes of run time for ad revenue ain't gonna fill themselves right?
@Manek Iridius Seriously. If anything, they've added _more_ legit criticisms as the channels' have grown.
4:52 discount Bill and Ted phone booth? the TARDIS is older than Bill and Ted's booth, shame on you
They are from the same family tree branch. Well adjusted siblings . Now you want bitter family members the phone booth that use to help superman change absolutely hates these guys. (its' like the Drunk uncle that use to be the high school football star that just didn't go anywhere with his life. )
That was in fact the joke, yes;).
Attacking Doctor Who like some sort of swine. 90% of the sins are answered in the episode, such as the reason why they were wrong about the 'great god santa' being that the character didn't go to a proper university. Also sinning characterisation. Oh and don't forget sinning WILFRED MOTT
its satire my guy
satire does not defend being straight up wrong, especially as it isn't even funny
@@iseetreesofgreen3367 it's bad satire my guy
If you can’t stand your shows/series being sinned, don’t watch the episode. You know it’s going to be sinned enough to get it to ~15min for the ad revenue.
AND, they are going to sin things obvious to show lovers, so they make comments and leave likes/dislikes. Specifically for the increased viewer interaction numbers which advertisers, and the TH-cam recommendation algorithm love.
and sinning "unnecessary" backstory like Donna's dad which gets revealed later in the series. You can't just say "satire" when your points are straight up incorrect smh!
Okay now do the weeping angel episodes. Those scared the crap out of me.
I love all the Sins channels but TVSins always feels like it's scrapping the bottom of the barrel for jokes. Yeah I know it's supposed to be for satire and giggles but it gets to a point where the satire isn't even funny to begin with and just sounds like nitpicking for the sake of padding the sin count and the run time of the video.
(feel free to come with your pitchforks and torches because I don't get it or because i'm a hater)
I will say that Jeremy from CinemaSins does sometimes sound amused when he's poking holes in a movie, TVSins kind of just likes tearing things apart.
Completely agree. Cinemassins is great, I can never get through an entire one of these. It’s grating.
The sins don't even make sense here. It's just useless complaining with no real insight
Totally agree, this guy is so awful I can barely even get through the videos
This is the greatest tv ever made, there’s nothing wrong with it
"Discount bill and Ted phone booth" bud you got that backwards
Audio Outtake should have included Yoda: "When 900 years old you reach, look as good you will not!"
THIS is quality programming. Pls do a spread of Dr’s!
5:27 Seriously? You didn't remove a sin for this moment? It's definitely one of Tennant's top moments on the show.
6:44 i gotta appreciate the d&d reference! well done
You forgot to sin how £1 million is apparently worth 50 million credits on Sto, meaning 5000 credit phone bill that is roughly equal to the price of 2 first class tickets on The Titanic and would have taken Foon and Morvin 20 years to pay off is only £100.
I’m pretty sure it’s more difficult to bring a person back from the dead with a teleport than to, you know, teleport someone.
Aw, skipped over the best part of this episode, the part where the rich douche guy says, "who put you in charge, and who the hell are you anyway?" Then the Doctor gives his "I'm the Doctor" line. That made this episode for me.
They confused Santa Claus with Krampus. No biggie
I love David Tennant as Dr Who. These shows are precious to me, I was apprehensive about watching this ... so glad I did. Brilliantly hilarious 😆
I love Doctor Who and this episode but I honestly didn't notice there were no life preserves outside til you pointed it out.
11:10. This is ALSO explained in like 30 seconds. The Host respond to him because now that Capricorn is dead. Their protocols that followed him are deleted and they reset to follow the the next person in command and the host have registered the fact that's the Doctor.
You didn't even bring up Alonsy Arlonso
Don’t you ruin Ten for me like this!!
I'm surprised the Doctor hasn't appeared into the CinemaSins studio and use the Sonic Screwdriver to remove the sins.
technically every moment of the day is 'past midnight until exactly midnight in one's own time zone.
I appreciate that you guys like a good simple action romp, but I love this era of doctor who because everyone has a story, yeah some are more interesting than others but everybody is a person with a story
You say “no one cares why they know robotics, we don’t need an explanation” but a few Christmas specials later there’s a planet where fish swim through the air, and people lost their minds that there was no explanation for how it works (even though “alien planet in a science fiction program” should have been sufficient)
Back story for the reporter - his name is Nicholas Witchell, he's the BBC's royal correspondent and Prince Charles said that he can't bear him
Totally love the fact that you do a doctor who special every year
Please do Everything Wrong With Ducktales (2017) "The Shadow War"
Voyage of the Damned? More like Voyage of the Damned Good looking!
Look, it's Dr Who, I've got nothing.
Even if I watched Dr Who, I'd probably still have nothing. Hell, I'd know I'd have nothing if I did that.
2:45 And a deep mighty voice, 'least that is what I've come to understand.
Information; there is a protocol called seaspeak where specific words and phrases are used for clarity. The first word is e.g. Question, Request, Warning, Information etc. Most verbal communication at sea is in English so having a limited, vocabulary and syntax reduces the chance of errors.
Don't you f**king DARE call the TARDIS a "discount Bill and Ted phone booth thing." Don't you DARE!!!
This is probably my second favorite Christmas special, second to A Christmas Carol.
Cant believe you sinned the part after astrix dies and theres explosions behind the doctor and he is all cool and calm. That was epic
"Still more historically accurate than The Crown though." I nearly spat out my drink.
"Reliance on its history" when talking about the weeping angels that literally originated in the tenant erae
No sin removed for Russel Tovey? WHY NOT he’s the best!
1:29 There's a life preserver right there. They're just used as decoration on the ship, which is why there's none on the outside of the ship because that would be stupid.
2:54 That's the point. He SHOULD know who Santa was, but he faked his credentials to get the job. They explain this later in the episode.
4:07 It's based on the movie The Poseidon Adventure, not the actual Titanic disaster. Also, the sinking of the Titanic was over a century ago. If you mean by having a lighthearted 9/11 movie in say 2101 as "a few years", then sure.
10:00 Funny, dear. It was supposed to be funny. Nobody in their right mind expected that part to be the exciting bit. Maybe wait another line of dialogue before judging.
12:15 I mean...would YOU turn her down? 🤣
And yes, I ignored the "discount Bill & Ted's phonebox" comment because that was was so transparently a troll.
If they are restoring spell slots on a short rest, that must mean the Doctor is a warlock. I would have said he‘s a wizard, tbh.
Nah, Ten is definitely an artificer~
The deciding who lives and who dies and that would make them a monster thing is foreshadowing the Timelord Victorious.
I audibly screamed "Yes!" When this released
those meteors have flaming tails because they're part of a distant planet the doctor blew when the wannabe galactic conquerers irked him
The Doctor being wary of the angel robots might be a reference not to the Weeping Angels, but the androids from the Fourth Doctor episode The Robots of Death, which feature very similar looking robots that also chant "kill, kill, kill"
The thing about Russel T Davies' era as showrunner was that he was obsessed with giving everyone backstory. Like EVERYONE. Luckily it all got sorted when Moffat took over and only 1/5 non-main characters got any level of backstory. But then Chibbers buggered it all up.
And that's why the RTD episodes are brilliant episodes with so many recognisable and memorable characters whose death made you sad and Moffats episodes and characters were all mostly forgettable, pointless and had no weight to them at all. Chibnall brought the show back to how good it used to be before Moffat buggered it up.
Wait what do you mean discount Bill and Ted phone booth? I'm pretty sure its the other way around
The "sad old man" played "Richard Bucket" in my favorite British series of all time "Keeping up Appearances"
You ever watch something and then later that night stumble across a channel that recaps that EXACT show on the EXACT episode that you just HAPPENED to watch out of the WHOLE series? Yeah. You know where I'm GOING with this.
So long as you're doing sci-fi Christmas-y TV episodes, I humbly request TNG's "Tapestry".
Ok usually these are in good fun but it feels like this guy doesn’t even like the show.
Hi, welcome to Cinema Sins are you new here?
Yes exactly! I feel like you can tell when they genuinely dislike something because the tone of the sins is totally different. I know these are satire but this one seemed kinda brutal compared to other recent videos
Only a fan would reference the episode Blink and the catchphrase "Allons-y".
Bashing on my favorite Doctor Who Christmas special? Okay
If you had someone on the ship saying you don't need a shield , then you do, then you don't, then you do again, and making everyone stop working on the ship even though the ship has a 99% chance of surviving the meteors, then you have a pandemic reference.
Sins involving d&d AND BattleBots? I'm lovin it.
It feels like logic is overshadowed by charisma of the doctor
Please do what's wrong with the present Doctor, it will blow your mind.
Fun Fact: The reporter at 3:00 is Nicholas Witchell, the actual Royal Correspondent for BBC News.
Here are all the audio outtake clips at the end:
1 (13:02): The Fifth Element (Gaumont Film Company, 1997)
2 (13:16): Max Headroom: 20 Minutes into the Future (Channel 4, 4th April 1985)
3 (13:18): SpongeBob SquarePants, "Pickles" (season 1, episode 6B; Nickelodeon, 21st August 1999)
4 (13:28): Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (DreamWorks Pictures, 2004)
5 (13:29): Super Mario Galaxy 64 (Nintendo, 1996)
6 (13:36): Ex Machina (A24, 2014)
7 (13:42): Toy Story 2 (Walt Disney Pictures, 199)
8 (13:43): Monty Python and the Holy Grail (EMI Films, 1975)
9 (13:47): The Lonely Island's "Cool Guys Don't Look at Explosions" (MTV, 31st May 2009)
10 (13:55): The Emperor's New Groove (Walt Disney Pictures, 2000)
11 (14:05): Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (DreamWorks Pictures, 2004)
12 (14:14): Toy Story (Walt Disney Pictures, 1995)
Discount Bill & Ted Phone-box???.
No no NO. Bill & Ted is a discount version of THIS time travelling blue box.
The TARDIS is the original.
It was a troll, dear. Calm down.
Okay... the sin about Bannakaffalatta "knowing he could do this the whole time but waiting until now"... using his remaining energy reserves to knock out the angels literally killed bannakaffalatta. He died moments later. Of course that would be a last resort.
"Discount bill and ted?" Ummm... anyone wanna tell them that bill and Ted based their time machine off doctor who?
I love when Doctor Who gets sinned. Cuz I love Doctor Who, Sins are a great recap
These outtakes were legendary 😂
I actually think introducing Wilf here is awesome because by the time we see him again the true fans are like “hey it’s that guy, cool!”
8:11. Yes he knew he could do it. But it drains his battery til it's completely depleted. That's why he doesn't do it. Another thing you clearly weren't paying a blind bit of attention to
Lol I just rewatched the entire series after I got my mom into dr who during quarantine and you would be SHOCKED how many unintentional references there are to the pandemic
This was my first Dr. Who Christmas special back two years ago and as a new Whovian (modern Who was what I binged in 2020~) and a self-proclaimed expert on the Titanic, I adore this special. It holds a very special place in my heart, and I do feel like some of the jokes were not funny here. Oh well~ Still a fun video.
I have been hoping more episodes of Doctor Who would be sinned. Love the show, but I'm always curious what might be wrong in the episodes
I wanna see some of the later Capaldi episodes or even some of Jodie's, the ones that genuinely suffer very weak writing
My new year starts with a TV Sins video?? BEST YEAR EVER!!! What?? You say there's a new Cinema Sins video as well???
you have gone after my second favourite show how dare you but still love the sins
You sin the fact that the people on the ship don’t know enough about Earth but know enough about the ship to build a replica but then don’t know it’s history - except that’s the point. Max is the only other person who knows and he did it as a sick joke. He’s the one who decided on the name and the design not the people on the ship. It also kinda explains how the ship would act as a nuclear bomb but tbh large objects falling from space would also cause a large amount of damage anyway.
Also you sin the fact the Doctor doesn’t use the questions to perpetually stall and then sin the part where it’s explained there’s a limit.
Also I imagine he did think of his EMP blast earlier but - for obvious reasons - didn’t want to literally kill himself unless he had to (the fact the device can be recharged doesn’t necessarily mean it’ll resurrect the dead partially organic being).
I don’t know if the scene was meant t be slightly comedic (if not then that’s a sin) but it did seem obvious to me that Max did not take Astrid’s Damn Big Hero moment with the forklift seriously coz he knew his machine was clearly too grounded to be pushed (he only panicked once he was being lifted).
3:55 if we can barely see windows, a dark coloured life belt isn’t going to be seen from space. Also they are for show, they aren’t practical.