Fadhlina Sidek: Malay Parents Send Children To Vernacular Schools Because... | In The Studio
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ม.ค. 2024
- What do you think of vernacular schools?
Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek joins Inside Story to tell us her stance on the establishment of vernacular schools, and the future of education in Malaysia.
_____
What to watch next? ⤵️
▶️ H.E. Walid Abu Ali: Israel’s Occupation of Palestine Must End | In The Studio
• H.E. Walid Abu Ali: Is...
▶️ Jangan Menyesal Lepas Beli Rumah | Net Balance & Chill S2 EP3 | Insomniacks, Natasha, Ceddy
• Jangan Menyesal Lepas ...
▶️ Mahkamah lepaskan Zahid, tetapi....
• Mahkamah lepaskan Zahi...
▶️ Cerita Dia Camni: Risiko Vape Tinggi??
• Risiko Vape Tinggi??
▶️ Seminit: Paris Syndrome Tu Apa?
• Paris Syndrome Tu Apa?...
▶️ Ekceli: iPhone Atau Android Lagi Best?
• iPhone Atau Android La...
▶️ Cerita Dia Camni: Company Untung Sebab Cuti Period
• Company Untung Sebab C...
▶️ Tan Sri Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah: My Humble Beginnings Gave Me An Advantage | In The Studio
• Tan Sri Dr Noor Hisham...
▶️ Apa Guna Ambil Takaful Kalau Tak Claim? | Net Balance & Chill S2 EP4 | Ceddy, Dayah Bakar, Dayana
• Apa Guna Ambil Takaful...
_____
Follow us!
Twitter: / bfmradio
Instagram: / bfmradio
TikTok: / bfmradio
Facebook: / bfmradio
LinkedIn: / bfmmedia
We r in big trouble with a minister who can't communicate
can see she suffocate trying to say her life from laywer to education minister in 360degree, can say it just a diff "ball game"
Maybe she should attend public speaking class. Severely lack of vocabs. Can see that she thinks in Malay first and then process into english
Which is better? In Malaysia Nation, People can speak English not too influent rather than people who live in Malaysia cannot speak well Bahasa Malaysia?
@@zildjanzildjan1473 this obsession of English fluency in a country where the primary language is Bahasa 😂. I have no words for these people
yer kak english penting, medium for knowledge, then if dahmaju until technology kita pegang mcm korea ke taiwan punya semiconductor industry org pasti dtg belajar bahasa jugak@@halimaziz
Honestly Malaysia needs a competent Education Minister with politics out of the education system.
The only competent madanon minister is that 1 veteran politician from johore. He has some intelligence. The rest are just like their leader. That is why RM is going down faster thay the gravity, foreign investors are running away, prices and tax are skyrocketing, and what do they do? Balas dendam sama dia org punya nemesis instead of putting 200% effort to improve.
@@pakatxdeharapan1793 I couldnt have said it any better myself. PMX political vendetta is rhethorically waste of time , to cover up his own inept with inapt shitshow administrating cabinet. " GST 6 % tidak dibuat" But LVGT, HVGT skyrocketing to 10%. PMX a paradoxical man defines himself a true meaning of DICTATOR.
Tidak mungkin menyediakan sekolah bahasa dan sekolah kepada semua orang yang menyusup ke negara ini. Anda boleh melihat mereka di pusat tahanan. Jika tidak, anda perlu pergi ke India. Ada sekolah
Terpaksa pergi ke endiyan bangla agensi pengambilan untuk menyelesaikan masalah bahasa. Kalau bahasa tamil, kena keluar dari sini pula.
Well said! Beyond that. Malaysia needs a better, no an exemplary ONE school system for ALL.
We need a new education minister. She is beating round the bush. Not sure what she stands for.
It's her first rodeo... say let her complete 5 years first.
I would nominate Nik Nazmi to replace her anytime of the day
Absolutely. Always talking about her children rather than focussing an appropriate answer to queries raised,actually and actually.
You are not the only one making this adverse comment.
I think there has been too many Education Ministers rocking the boat introducing their own revolutionary _great ideas_ with the whole system stumbling from one thing to another achieving nothing as quality and standards falls gradually but consistently. There is no magic bullet. We need to put in the hard work, not concentrating on flashy panaceas that never pan out. The Malaysian Education System has been focussed too much on short term goals, and not long term multi-decade hard work. I am not sure all the red tape and reporting pushed on to the teachers are helping. SRJK (C)s are outperforming SRKs. Why? I doubt it is because they have a million KPIs.
On and on and on...just answer the damn question. No need for the long winded side stories. Cant even understand what you're blabbering about.
spot on
She even said her six year old kid is her mentor.
many things to hide : normal for them to changed goalposts as they like -- no brainer Going Nowhere what system ???😢
Omg.She doesnt know what she is talking about
Very true
She really don't know and what is education is about
She's taking about bullshit..😆😆🤭
She thinks shes a genius N feels contented with herself. Bla bla bla all the way...
but she is PH minister, how dare you !!!
she is not able to express herself too well , first time listening to her converse in english
Just like Halimah Ali of PAS. No difference
After this we will vote for PAS MP as a education minister...cannot give a chance to chinese MP 😅
Yes, a bit pretentious... can't finish watching the video. Tried watching for 5 mins, erm she didn't really answer to the interviewer...
Find it hard to understand what she was communicating.
Put aside her fluency in english, but im impressed that she can talk for 1 hour without any content or point..it's all just "i think..i hope..maybe.."
Malaysian schools don't train you to speak.
she just survive with a bit accent sound intellectual,😂😂😂, incompetent, replicate a lot our pmx,maybe her party doctrine, talk like planta but incompetent on doing job,tin kosong covered with reformasi cover ,
@@jack19677???? English class teaches that, I can confirm as a Malaysian student idiot, ever heard of speaking exercises we have during English?
It's perplexing how she managed to become both a lawyer and minister of education, considering her difficulties with mastering English.
Just wondering how?
That's the Malaysian standard of education for you.
We are brought up by Umno rule and she is the perfect example of the lacking... She knew it and will like to change it..
@@xzdrtxyzxvn7:21
I would care less on whatever she said during this interview...i want to see results...education should be the basis for unity..language should be the basis for unity...Sila Pastikan Bahasa Melayu di martabatkan
Full Stop
What is your definition of unity? How does education and language contribute to unity?
Agree 💯
@@ptaeiy Especially language. Thailand has had 2 ethnic Chinese prime minister whose voter base was in the RURAL areas. You can imagine their mastery of the language. Rishi Sunak's parents are India born. The mayor of London is Pakistani. Nikki Haley's parents are Punjab, India born. The previous defense minister of Canada was a traditional Sikh. That's unity.
@@SukhdevSingh-ge5rj So what would you like to see happen to better unite us Malaysians?
I am sorry but it was agonising listening to her. She mangled words and couldn't string together a proper sentence.
Yeah haha. she looks very nervous and trying her best to construct a sentence in English and she constantly repeats her answers 😆. Anwar is a HUGE disappointment we have to wait unfortunately for another 3.5 years to kick this monkey out from power .
Dont know what the hell she's talking bout
Agreed.
I am sure Fadlina Sidek is a wonderful person a very down to earth person.
But we need a more skillful , communicative and intellectual Minister of Education.
The problems are the quality of teachers who can't grasp English proficiency and insufficient focus on STEM in educational systems.
Yes, whenever I place my orders or purchases in English, the cafe staff or shop staff struggle to express themselves. Bus drivers struggle to advise the correct fares in English.
You hit the nail on its head.
You must understand that teachers are trained according to their major subjects but they are given other subjects to teach to occupy the vacancy of the schools. Teachers are trained to be all rounders when they are in the field though not all are superb. The Education Minister needs to do a thorough check on the ratios of the intake of the trainee teachers based on each critical subjects so that there will be no excess of other subjects in the later year.
@@yeohlaykimkpm-guru8965Yup, totally agreed with you Madame. Because a lot of peoples out there doesn't know about this. They only know to condemn everything without knowing the real facts
Oh my goodness, gracious moi! Fadlina is herself in dire need to improve her spoken EL espc her grammar. Better proficiency level speaking English. A legal eagle should excel in expressing herself. Yet could discern her struggling to make some points across. Yes, it's great her 6 yo daughter "always told her".... a good heart is important. Undeniably, she has a precocious child. Lucky her. But several instances before completing something, she cuts-off herself, sentences left hanging jumping into something else! Is she nervous and uncomfortable? I daren't comment on the proficiency of the two hosts lest it might diminish her as the honourable minister guest on BFM! I beg your ....my impudence or is it ...my prudence?! Moi is baffled.
The bottom line is that ..... this lady is not fluent in English, struggling to speak and having difficulty finding the correct words to express herself. when replying to the interviewer. BTW, the interviewer speaks excellent English.
No different from Halimah Ali of PAS
Take my challange to see the DJ speak Malay in their slot...😅😅😅 What a shame...
I find her fairly fluent, though she struggled a little bit when expressing herself at the beginning part.
@@tengfs Why? She was Education Minister too?
@@ptaeiy nope, but I expect an education minister to speak better English
Please please bring back MORALS & CIVICS as compulsory subject. Look at half of the youth today...most drug addicts. We have no proper subject in schools to really mold students with responsibility, respect and civic mindedness.
Bring back and make it more about treating people well rather than remembering which principle or what trait it is called.
Setuju sekarang ramai budak-budak X ada rasa hormat kepada guru dan org tua
Trust me, these subjects doesn't help.
@@henryyeoh8610 the program that was launch some 15years ago..semi national service where school leavers go to a camp to learn survival course , teamwork, motivation also was a big fail nationwide.
Morality and civic-mindedness are responsibilities of the parents. Whether your child become a pharmacist or a drug addict is solely on you, and not on the teachers. Do not leave your responsibilites over your child's moral compass at the teachers' feet.
Religion and politics should steer clear of schools... Period
What is she babbling? Her English 😑
Read from a prepared text if she is not coherent in English.
Malay must be lead to come out of comfort zone and becomes more progressive.
The protectism policies in the past decades has trully deprived Malay from all the possibilities.
We must admit Malaysia had gradually depleted of reserve, natural wealth of the country had been robbed from governance that divide and rule. The wealth cannot provide securities to Malay anymore.
Malaysia will not survive if the mentality of majority Malaysian continue to be regressive and mislead. Malay must be aware and be open minded toward progressiveness.
Well said. Gov policies made Malay weaker in fact.
The rich Malay politicians have used this to their advantage for so long ... Keep the rural Malays stupid, uneducated, insecure, fearful of their rights being taken away... then they win their votes and continue to govern the country.
Current policies make them poorer and degrading
If the education minister speaks like any folk in the street, you really cannot expect much from Malaysia’s education system beside craps
I always believe that Malaysia must be merit and values based to grow but at the same time, you can say have some form of affirmative action based on need. A good example, is education. For all courses, 80% of the places must be based on merit/values, the 20% can be given based on needs, regardless of race. That's the way.
I say it should be 99% base on merit/values, affirmative action only harm ppl competitive nature.
@@blurdreamer I disagree. I think a bit of affirmative action like 20% is fine especially in an emerging country like Malaysia where it's not yet fully developed, but, must be done on 100% racial blind basis among Malaysians.
@blurdreamer I disagree. I think a bit of affirmative action like 20% is fine especially in an emerging country like Malaysia where it's not yet fully developed, but, must be done on 100% racial blind basis among Malaysians.
Another skeptic racist bigoted ideology
It will be good if Sarawak Sabah Johor manage their state schools.International schools in Malaysia are considered the best in Asia.
This Minister is just following the book..has no opinions or ideas of education..gosh communication 😢...wrong choice ! GOD SAVES OUR EDUCATION 😊
It’s painful to listen to this Education Minister who doesn’t do her homework before going on air.
Not impressive when answering direct questions from journalists. One excuse for the poor showing was that we were affected by COVID. However, other countries were also affected. So what's the real weakness,actually if I may borrow this word so commonly used in the conversation..
She much better than previous education minister.
@@mariambintijaafar8323 this is fact
No lah, if speak in her mother tongue, no problem lah....😊
9 @@user-uw1br3cr8d
Being a mother of 6 does NOT qualify or solidify your position as an Education Minister. Trust me! You will NOT last long in politics! Or in your Minister position. 😂😂😂
To be fair to her, she did imply that being a mother of 6 makes her better equipped to be a Minister of Education. It is just coincidental.
Changes should be implemented incrementally.
1. Revise the syllabus to ensure one common syllabus for all though medium of instruction can be different
2. Remove redundancies in all levels within the profession: simplify and optimise all activities and resources
3. Reforms all teacher training colleges. Ensure only the best can become teachers. Hiring based on merits.
4. Teachers can be fired based on behaviour and performance.
5. Students must meet expectations before moving to next level. Remove auto promotion system to next level if students fail in assessment.
The best students would prefer to venture into engineering, medicine etc to receive better income.
What about meritocracy? Are merits not included in education? How is it that top scorers are rejected into local universities?
This is the burning question left unanswered.
meritocracy? does🙄 it even exist, eat yourself huh😂
I’m a bumiputra from Sarawak and I support any move in opening UITM to non-Malay. Come on lah high time education is done based on merit.
Please answer this nagging issue. PM Annuar slammed a young Indian girl for raising this inconvenient question in a Public Q&A session. Pity the girl who was shocked.So was the audience and the many thousands watching it..
@@user-uw1br3cr8dwhy u wanna question the perlembagaan u want the whole malay people attack anuar n cause kegawatan darurat in de country?? U think its easier to abolish this
She is rather sympathetic and a likable person but I have doubts about the huge work in front of her.... and she still has got some improvements on her English too.
Got to brush up.
She's more of a housewife than a minister
The government should split out the budget for education to ensure the public understands how much is paid to TEACHERS, and how much is paid to the Education Department staff. I think it will be eye opening.
That is not yet counting the amount in corruption.
National School = Religious School, full with Al-Azhar no where to go Ustaz Ustazah graduates. Please consider hiring local STEM graduates who are currently unemployed as temporary substitute teachers.
I agreed with yr statement
How shocking
Are you sure??they can teach subject not related to their expertise meh??my school smk I never see al Azhar graduate there😅
Vernacular schools are successful as they have multi racial teachers.All students are the same they love caring teachers.
You are the example that the vernacular school didnt give a good example for children and parent...Why compare with other? Is it school at orang asli didnt good for them?? What a shame for vernacular people
What are you really want to spill out from your word Anne?
Sekolah kebangsaan sudah gagal total sekolah kebangsaan cuma lahirkan murid yang nakal
Nothing to do with multiracial. It's the amount of homework. Chinese school has a lot of homework of course better lah.
Multiracial teacher? Hahahaha
Primary School - Focus on foundation, which is reading, writing and maths
Secondary School - Focus on knowledge, which is to grow the knowledge base
College/Pre-university - Focus on understanding the knowledge, which is to how the knowledge works
University - Focus on applying the knowledge, which is to apply the knowledge in our lives
Masters - Focus on questioning the knowledge, which is to question the knowledge we have acquired
Doctorate - Focus on creating new knowledge, which is to create new understanding
Look aside whatever little shortcomings/mis-steps of her/the ministry as you can feel she is genuinely concerned and taking action to improve the education n welfare in schools of our children. I think that is the most important thing is to work together with her/the ministry/school, and not against her/anyone for the betterment of the country and our future generation. Remember it is easier to criticize from the outside, especially when one doesn't have all the facts and is not involved in the implementation and the problem solving. Contribute with your time and effort and not just verbally (esp. when it is negative). Anyone can highlight a problem, but do also think of the solution and implement it to truly see if it works
From my opinion i believe the ministry of education of Malaysia should solve the problem of school congestion and look to maybe to work with the private companies to build way more numbers of school with greater facilities.
Hi minister of education. Im so sorry, I cant really understand what you are talking about. Although I appreciate your effort of trying to convey the message across but please improve your vocabs and grammar. The 2 radio hosts can speak way better!
Horrible minister
To be able to address focusing in STEM, most importantly, should start teaching Math and Science in English in all secondary schools, not selected DLP school only. Students need to be able to express themselves in English in order to have competency globally.
Still no idea what she is talking about 😮😢😅 carilah yg lebih Layak!
Vernacular schools still maintain the standard of yesteryear but not the national schools.
180 degrees, not 360 - 360 you end up where you started
Ini lah standard of our education minister
I cringe when I hear her mispronounce vernacular…
Sigh
Sad everything was just right going well with the system until the brilliant leaders came came with ideas to suit their ego.
The people were blending well no suspicion among the communities. Both English and Bahasa is important for survival and integration. Along the way the beautiful Bahasa Melayu has been destroyed completely. Instead of maintaining the Bahasa Melayu they took a short cut mixing with English and made a mockery out of it. We don't have to follow any neighbouring . Chinese don't do that.
Indians don't do that.
The English don't do that but we did it easy way out.
The Minister is unable to freely speak her mind so as not to offend the majority. Its a situation we are facing.
What ever it is we cannot teach hatred and suspicion to the young ones it will snow ball. It has already snow balled you see on the road and every where. We are stuck now the nation will suffer.
I am seventy years old now it's heart breaking. Hoping things will change for the better.
No offence and bless you.
@@sachi330 You are indeed correct. We took the easy way out. There should have been only ONE school system that binds us well and unified us in spirit and love of country and countrymen.
Instead they build disparate vernacular school system that ultimately caused us to be wary and suspicious of one another. That segregates us instead of integrating us. We are forever doomed less we ALL come together under ONE school system.
Amusing. I almost fell from my chair listening to this show.
Pls train lots and lots of english speaking teachers in maths and science. Currently Elite and rich Malays and Non Malay, predominantly send their kids to english speaking private school. If you are serious in reducing the gap of Elite and Non Elite, pls don't deprive the sub urban and kampung kids from English.
YB, you mentioned quality of Education. What and How are you going to address it?
In Malaysia, it is unfortunate that education tends to get mixed up with politic.... Sorry to mention this, because if people of certain community mentioned something unfavorable about Malaysia education, some people could feel offended and they take it quiet personally....
Kenapa banyak orang komen pasal Inggeris dia tak bagus?
Inggeris dia fasih.
❤ ade mucuk , bokali
Her english is such impostor... Bad..
You have lost the plot, Education minister.
Was the minister herself a failure to the education her parent gave her.
Based on her opinion above my answer is
YES.
😂😂😂Joker
The hosts need to make sure that the minister does not digress.
Disappointed with the minister.
No calibre. 😢😢😢
There is a simple reason why Singapore is always TOP. If you study into their education policy your answers are there.
This is a tongue-tied, fumbling lawyer. Highly unusual. 😂
Happy to know that our country has place a very high priority on education.
I don’t hear any passion in her voice when discussing education in the country… 😅
Very halfhearted and lackadaisical
Dear minister , at this stage ,it is better late than never to impliment English as medium of instruction like our PM or old parents' school days experienced. The trend to speak English in school days was very common. Hence , Maths & Science be taught in English should be a better choice. By doing so, pupils will be versed with their oral English speaking capability, just like parents who were educated in the 60 &70s. This will help pupils to have the confidence to speak English among themselves. Later, when they come out to work & might face foreigners or even some Singaporeans , they have the confidence to speak English (Good English involves Pronunciation , tenses, grammar , construction of sentences). Wonder Fool !
Our previous education Minister (Radzi Jiddin) successfully put Malaysia as the worst performing ASEAN country in recent 2022 PISA assessment... Her turn is due Next year in 2025... Right when PMX got his turn chairing ASEAN... Good Luck to her...
I am not her greatest fan, but you can't just pin everything on her. Malaysian educational system is in such a shamble not of her doing. It will take a lot of efforts over many years to set it right. However, I don't see that she has a vision on what is needed to make it right. The fault lies with PMX for making such a weak choice for the Ed. Minister post. It just go to show PMX apparent low emphasis on the educational problems in Malaysia.
Tarik balik (7x)
Good that bfm put your programs onto you tube
Sebagai bekas guru , saya sedih sikap menteri ni.Sepatutnya tugasnya untuk berfikir menarik pelajar ke aliran Perdana , Matlamat Dasar Pelajaran Kebangsan.yang diimpikan Menteri n kjaan dulu lepas merdeka.Perpaduan melalui sek kebangsan. tapi sebaliknya.Apa punyai bingai menteri.Sbb parti PKR kecil. Jadi ikut saje cakap DAP
She is a good person.... but the job is obviously toooooo big for her to handle.
What's the criteria in selecting Ministers to important cabinet posts? For instance, if a guy is a qualified engineer, he will more useful in the Ministry of Works.If he is put to some other ministry not relevant to his educational background, he will be a misfit. Just like putting square pegs into round holes. This is an example of utilising human resources appropriately. In a football, the coach would want to put the best strikers to score goals for the team.Just an analogy..
Best of Malaysia education system was with Tan Sri Khir Johari as a Minister. Firstly have a multi racial teachers situation and English language teaching situation.
Could you elaborate more on why Tan Sri was the best education minister?
It was fairly at good level then compared to Asean countries.We had good teachers from India and Peace Corp teachers at that time.
Fluency in English is a given now, it's no big deal. Now, also must know Chinese.
You want fluency, but commenting in Manglish! I hardly understand what are you trying to say!
@@mystictraveller7031 Maybe you're a foreigner, that's why.
the second part of the conversation between both of them ways better and informatic than 1st part with edu minister...
No difference.Wondering what was her message.A lot of story telling about her kids.
Well said. Keep up the good work. 👍
Where are your children educated, gomen school or private school?
6 children? She has dutifully been following her leaders call for her people to have large families for reasons best known to Malaysians generally.
If the minister can complete her 1 term consider lucky already. She is lost in the middle of nowhere
So disappointed, firstly shes not fluent as a minister let alone minister of edu, secondly se was struggling to recall the 5 principals of the edu blueprint- disastrous! They should give in n start referencing countries which are far more advanced- estonian, singaporean edu are some eg. Very disappointed. Getting equity in stem, swan ( student with additional needs) , access etc.
Malu lah!
Menteri ada baca surah Al-Kafirun dekat rumah tak? Sampaikan perkataan Kafir pun nak diharamkan dekat rumah.
Pakai je bahasa pengantaraan melayu atau english. Ni pakai bahasa mandarin, pastu bile keluar tak reti bahasa kebangsaan, pastu deme kawan ngn puak2 deme la. Makin takda kesatuan.
Options for different pathways for higher education will be the best option. However the cut off point of SPM level should be the baseline for all other progression in education.
She is really a woman of widom but her open support for vernacular school system will definately enrage Atuk Mahathir. Everything will go haywire when he becomes PM in 2045.
Pasar Malam English
Dear PMX, please replace this education minister immediately before it's too late, she is trying to portray that she can do the job but it is obvious she's not ready or qualified. 'Are you happy now?' What a silly unprofessional remark, embarrassing. Her English delivery and communication is below par. A hard listen.
Agreed. Thousands watched the interview and were disappointed at the level of expression in communication, using English. Might as well switch to Bahasa Kebangsaan for ease of understanding by the audience.
Why not the government introduce charter schools,it has an amazing system and promises way better facilities in our education systems.
😂😂😂
Unity in education system with 10% quota... In public university 😂😂😂
Almost 100% teachers are now melayu 🤔🤔🤔
That's suppose to reflect unity???
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
That is why all races must come together and work as a unity goverment ,if we let the opposition influence to much the current government will also have no choice and nationalisme will spread even more which will lead to a collapse of our country
Useless Education minister
From the way she speaks and carries herself, she should remain a clerk forever
it is mainly because other races can learn Mandarin language continuously for a few years. It is a value added to them. However, it is not in SK. That is why, SK need to implement largely on studying other main languages. To make that subjects a compulsory for student to learn from std 1 to 6.
Why not just have only ONE school where ALL the Malaysian languages are taught to ALL? Let the malay, indian, chinese kids grow/learn/compete/fight together? Find out what is best from the SKs and the SRJKs and use that to build an exemplary school system that benefits ALL.
@@ptaeiy then you have to amend a national constitution. Do you think can get 2/3 in Parliament?
@@vzavna5617 Nothing is impossible. If we presented concrete evidences of the dire need for the change. We should lay bare for all to see the positive impacts this much needed change to our school system will have to the betterment of all involved. We should also present to our audience the full unimaginable future disintegration of our much cherished pluralistic society if we failed to act in time.
So the question become, who is our target audience? Definitely not the bickering politicians and their cohorts. Instead we should seek the advice of academicians, socio-economics experts and other relevant stakeholders to present a case to the nation, to the people. This is the only way I see that we might be able to get this done. There should be ongoing tireless active discourses of this issue at community levels so that enough pressure will be exerted on the politicians to take action. Are you up for it?
btw. You are very keen to realize that knowing more languages is an asset. Beyond that, I am afraid that the current disparate schooling system is actually causing the malays much harm. SK is in a rut, while others are reaching, or even at world class levels. They are building modern world class srjkc/sjkc with world class teaching staffs in newly minted townships that are quite out of reach for most malays. Imagine the total growing disparity between races will only get wider.
@@vzavna5617 Need to work at it. Vernacular must be abolished.
Some people like to complain of the dual law systems in the country, Shari'a and Civil. What about the dual education system, SPM and UEC. UEC must be abolished.
Jangan perasan, jika begini pendapat yg kau beri pasal sekolah vernacular... nampak gaya Malaysia perlukan menteri pendidikan yg baru.
Last minister's contribution was black shoes. You will be remembered for 2 days only school uniform, 2 days sports attire (now we need to buy more) and 1 day curriculum uniform (buy and buy). Cosmetics, without benchmarking how we are compared to our neighbours. Memalukan!
Mazlee's contribution is much more, but of course...people only remember him for black shoes.
Most people misunderstood Mazlee. He did a lot but didn't show it. After he left, he admitted his biggest mistake: He didn't have a PR team.
Please read Mr Mazlee's book
Dr Mazlee is quite competent. I don’t think the black shoe policy is a great , but it's still necessary. Compared with the previous so called Menteri Kanan, dr Mazlee is better. As for the current one, we should give her more time.
Fluency in English is a given now, it's no big deal. Now, also must know Chinese.
Pls revise your Education System .As Dr Tun M suggested in his days , 1) Maths & Science be taught in English 2) pls have at least two periods in a week for pupils to learn " Oral English". The former PM ,Tun Dr. M & Datuk Sri Anwar both had been taught in this way (during Colonial Days) . The std of English of young Malaysians lie on your hands. Kindly guide them through the proper channel. Terima Kasih. Wonder Fool !
Sorry POMI but if you want Malaysian to be better to be good in English, you need to request the MOE to give more training and chance to English teachers. It is their job. Not science teachers, not mathematics teacher and non-english teachers. Help our English teacher to play their part and other subjects teachers will also can focus on their main subject.
And Malaysian has thier own official language. Thus their malay is good enough to actually proud to be Malaysian!?!?!?! Thus their chinese, indian and thier native languuage far much better??
Do not see the problems on their surface. Think deeper and go to the roots of the problem.
As I am one of PPSMI generation, I can assurely inform you that my english is good due to my English teacher is fantastic. marvelous! May Allah bless our teachers.
Got to look into the root cause to identify the problems of declining standards. The selection of English teachers must be stringent to achieve better quality of language teaching. Many parents have observed this weakness.
Vernacular schools are a great SUCCESS in Malaysia.
So what do you want? Being a candidate becoming PRU then be a Education Minister...Less talk more action..could u?
Only to the select few. Smashing success indeed.
I would not make such statement without empirical data.
This is not true though. If you had taught in vernacular schools (SJKC), you would have seen that the so-called drilling-based success cannot be translated into problem-solving skills in real life. The school culture is mostly about asking for exam tips but not focusing on learning basic literacy skills. I'm not denying the efforts put in by SJKC, I'm saying that perhaps SK and SJKC are not much different in terms of performance. So it's a good idea for Malay parents to send your kids to SJKC if you want your kids to learn Mandarin and immerse them in Chinese culture. However, if you send your kids to SJKC in the hope of seeking a high-quality international-school-like education, you might be disappointed. 😂
@@chngdexter2008 agreed. Both schools have pros and cons. But I would still say its a positive for Malays to go to Chinese schools stream for gaining an extra language and Chinese to SK gaining excess to the culture of the majority community . Esp those from the lower income group.both groups would gain positives from both SRJK and SK. But quality of students coming out from those two streams is somewhat the same. International schools can be slighly better and all rounded but still it lacks hacks on local culture and way too expensive with mediocre result
Just follow S'pore with with the same culture as M'sian, for sure the education will improve drastically without wasting another 20 years and still the same. THIS IS A FACT.
Do you think Malays willing accept the Singapore System most of them mix politics n Religion with everything even on education.
Move there better.
Our education system teaches only one thing. Everybody knows this...
It is not how good you are...
It is what race you are that determines whether you get accepted into institution of higher learning.
Why do people choose Vernacular schools??
All parents want a better future for their children.
It is not we are not loyal but are treated as second class citizen.
We want a better life for our children.
V can mix with only one group and don't have to mix with others.
Then can join the private sector for employment then discriminate against the rest.
People choose vernacular school so that they don't have to mix with other races. Vernacular schools should be abolished.
the issues are not difficult: update the curriculum and benchmark against international standards, build proper schools, have proficient teachers, ensure proper funding of ALL schools
Simply the standard of education in government schools is appalling?????
This lady minister no doubt a bit temperamental but looks very determined and try to be fair from education point of view. Give her some time definitely she will improve the whole system. She is like Rafidah Aziz. Pray God will give her the strength to overcome the obstacles.
far cry from the quality of Fahmi Fadzil's answer, why is she given such important and highly watched portfolio is beyond me. she should be Deputy at most.
really a greenhorn
For me, she's not even worth a deputy position.
Where is the Deputy Minister? Just because cannot speak Malay well?? I like to speak/interview in malay...😅😅😅
@@zildjanzildjan1473 you ask the Minister lor why Deputy is not interviewed instead of her, and I doubt she cannot speak Malay, all MPs and Ministers can speak Malay, if you want Malay interview just go Keluar Sekejap and TIBER and request them to interview
@zildjanzildjan1473
I've trouble understanding your English. Kalau Inggeris tak bagus, pakailah B.Melayu.
@@3mKay I doubt that very much. There are lots of MPs copmparable to her poor command of English in their poor spoken command of Bahasa Malaysia. To be called a Malaysian they should be fluent without pelat.
But but but I have senior in local university who was attempting his calculus 2 for the 3rd time... That was his 10th semester trying hard to graduate in bachelor of education degree (minor in maths)...not sure he manage to graduate or not...
This malady of venicular education will definitely drag the separation and disintegration of ethnic polarisation into more devastating for future malaysia
Quality is very important.what Really dissapointed me after knowing one of iium lecture a women called profesor "S" famous for his "katurah" thing .tell unlogic and silly fact about the malay land history and people on his YT.,. Also, who gives Profesor title ???KkM please take a look and take action. Must Monitor all the quality ..
Go and prove her wrong
Firstly, I would say thank you Dr Sidek for helping more people to understand the role of vernacular schools. Sad to see people who complain about vernacular schools without truly knowing what is being taught there. Other than discipline, the first thing I learnt that Malaysia is our home and a very close second thing is we live in a multi-racial country, so we must learn to tolerate. So thank you.
Pertama sekali, saya ingin mengucapkan banyak terima kasih kepada Dr Sidek kerana keterangan beliau telah membantu lebih ramai orang memahami peranan sekolah vernakular. Amat sedih melihat orang yang merungut tentang sekolah vernakular tanpa benar-benar mengetahui apa yang diajar di sana. Selain daripada disiplin, antara perkara pertama yang saya pelajari ialah Malaysia adalah kampung kita semua. Yang kedua ialah Malaysia adalah negara berbilang kaum dan kita harus bertolak ansur kepada semua kaum. Jadi banyak terima kasih atas keterangan beliau.
Tolerating is not the same thing as integration and unity. Tolerate infer a degree of self importance over others. It infer an involuntary act.
The main role of vernacular schools to my mind is in the creation of different ethnic-based communities. It's promoting segregation and shunning natural integration of Malaysian people.
@@ptaeiy Agree to disagree on your point. I didn't go to non-vernacular schools so I cannot comment. However feedback from my colleagues who went to those schools, they were segregated and encouraged to leave the school. It was an eye-opener for me but I remain steadfast that it is probably a small portion of the student population that are like that. So whilst I understand it may seem that vernacular schools might have a degree of self-importance. That self-importance is built upon the identity of being a Malaysian. That self-importance is built on the identity that as Malaysians, we live in a multi-racial society and that we must not speak ill, do-ill and wish ill of other fellow Malaysians. Maybe it's good to reference how Malaysian societies are built around the world. How many of them open halal restaurants because they went through vernacular school and were taught of the self-importance being a Malaysian overseas. I even chose to have a halal wedding banquet because of my education as it was not how I was taught.
@@ennyong1985 Ok I see your point of view. Very much shielded, I would say, but honest and commendable nevertheless. I have nothing against vernacular school system in their methodology. I have issue with the existence of disparate schools for different ethnicities that cannot but promote segregation and inequitable educational experiences for our kids. ALL of our kids should go to ONE school under ONE atap, so that they can learn/compete/fight/emphatize/know one another, together.
I would not try and say that your friends' unfortunate experiences were rare and far between, but that is what comes from all these years of our disparate school systems promoting ill-feelings and distrust. I would wager that your friends' bad experiences were either in their mid-primary or even secondary school years. I betcha if you put a group of malays, chinese and indians toddlers together and all throughout their school years, you will see a different result. I have more to say, but I'll await your response to this.
@@ptaeiy Whilst I hate the "very much shielded' comment. Here's our agreement point - I very much agree that all children should go through ONE school system under ONE atap. Although the minister has shared the increase of other races going into Chinese schools, Chinese vernacular schools must be doing something right.
But on the flip side, I strongly believe in educating kids, the burden does not solely lie on the teachers' shoulders. Family plays a very large role as their contact hours with the children will always be far more than teachers. So in my opinion, whilst ONE school system ONE language under ONE atap is much preferred, it is paramount that some families work on disseminating the right Malaysian values.
And not all vernacular schools are set up the same way. I've had friends who shared that whilst they studied in SRJK and SMJK, the medium of education was Malay (and English in English). Only difference was Mandarin and Tamil were compulsory subjects, depending on their race. But that's also a form of segregation.
@@ennyong1985For some reason my long reply to you is not being disp;ayed. here
Senang cakap. I'm for whatever best from all 3 schools systems incorporated into this ONE school under One atap proposal. If nothing from the SK is any good, so be it, tendang masuk tong sampah. No religious teachings during normal school hours. History of religion is made an elective. Make BM and English as compulsory subjects, and Tamil, Mandarin, French etc as electives. Let the kids learn/compete with each other under one attap since kindergartens. In 20 years you will start to see the change in society. In 40 years you would see a more pronounced change that we can ALL be proud of as Malaysian. It is that simple if the rakyat wants it and make the govt do it.
p/s: It looks like MrBoLiao98 can't take the heat and deleted his thread despite you offering him help.
I know education is a pressing matter, and we all have our aspirations for how we want each new generation of younglings to develop.. I believe the voices about what we want from the current education minister is loud and strong, and will continue to be that way as long as many of those who care continue to care.
That being said, let's not kid ourselves. We preach about leaders being better than mere bosses, but have we stopped to think - if she was the employee and our country the business model.. are we acting as a boss or a leader? It's obvious she has shortcomings, as any person would. I really do look forward to, if at all, us being able to contribute our strengths with hopes to better our education here. That, rather than yell into the voids of the interwebs or anywhere about the disdains we have. If you want to blame anything more on the pandemic, this would be it in my opinion. Seriously, during the pandemic was a terrible time, but everyone suddenly being masters of complaining was what drove me the most insane.
Feel so sorry for her to hear and see how she present... Her staff should helped her. How can you compare something in 2018 when now is 2024. she is not addressing the real education issues. Education for all children was implemented by xMOE Dr Mazlee Malik. Then it was removed . Now stateless children are finding it difficult to register back in schools because of some napoleons. You spoke well on Vernacular schools to be recognized but yet there are fanatics are still fighting to remove vernacular schools from High court to Appeal and Federal? The madani govt have yet to put this down.
How many/proportion students in the class compare to Kebangsaan one?
Tq. to the Madani government for giving us the Vernacular school. ❤
Vernacular schools further segregrates our young generations.. why uphold such colonial divide and conquer policy? We've reached independence for half a decade, yet we chain ourselves... Reformation of education is needed
Agree 💯 i say no to Vernacular school
Basmi kan je srjk smjk uec
Don't religious schools, MARA colleges & UiTM also segregate our younger generation?
@@lionelproctor82 religious schools only for muslim
you want to enter religious schools kah
if you to enter religious schools
masok islam lah
mara colleges and uitm only for sekolah kebangsaan pupils only
@@LODEH08532 You pretty much proved my point, which is that agama schools segregate Muslims ☪️ students from other students ✝️ ☸️ 🕉 , while UiTM & MRSMs segregate Bumiputera students from non-Bumiputera students.
Teaching is dedication creative intelligent and Smart responsible teachers.
If M’sia is truly a multiracial country, then its education policy should be reverted to multilingual and diversity. Uniformity in education is not necessarily the best policy for unity, harmony and integration. Diversity in education reflects the essence of multiracial M’sian society. Sarawak is the best example of diversity in education and racial unity. The key to unity is respect, respect and respect!
In Sarawak in the60' the pupil in primary six can speak in English much better than form5. Nowadays form 5 leavers just cannot speak english properly.
Education Ministers MUST go round and give SURPRISE CHECKING TO THE SCHOOLS AND SIT IN THE CLASS, later give their comments. Many rich parents send their children to "HOME SCHOOL". The poor who can't afford ....said: It is no use to complain. ....to who????
Example, in medical sector, the cardiothoric specialisation of doctors, only malay doctors are allowed to venture into this specialisation...due to halalisation of the medical sector!! Again religion is messing and intefering the medical sector in malaysia.
We must have 1) a TEAM qualified Education Ministers who can spot on what need to change and upgrade. Vernacular School is NOT important(Sorry Fadhlina is beating around the bush. Not sharp enough to see to the needs of the Schools 2) up grade the Principals and see that Teachers who are committed and dedicated Teachers. Students will follow what the teachers teach. 3)No AUTOMATIC PROMOTION FOR ALL STUDENTS WHEN THEY DON'T PASS THEIR EXAMS.
It is nice to continue with comfortable system that with no competition at all and continue to enforce over the spilt milk as well as denying the nation as OK. SMiLE 😀