‘Election Commission Image Damaged in Last Decade, Has to Prove Its Credibility by its Performance’
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 มี.ค. 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
In two separate interviews to discuss the Election Commission, at a time when it has been reduced to a one man Commission and the Prime Minister has the power to overrule Opposition concerns whilst appointing two new Election Commissioners, two former Chief Election Commissioners have expressed concern about the public image and impression of the Election Commission.
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
![พรากรัก - เต้ย อภิวัฒน์ [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ShT2ltn8GBE/mqdefault.jpg)
Qureshi always sits on the fence even when it comes to persecution of Muslims. Most retired public servants are on government pension. Thapar won't get much out of them. Overruling the supreme court directive on selection of ECs by the government is the single biggest anti constitutional act among many others in the last ten years. It's like Rohit Sharma selecting the three umpires before a cricket match and instructing them what to do. Look at the ads put out by BJP to promote Modi by using Indian Army and children. The CEC is already in deep slumber except to warn one person Rahul Gandhi not to say PANAUTI. Wonderful election commission.
👍👍👍
Everyone should have come to the streets when the bill is passed
Sir we want PM from south india
Qureshi is quite clearly a fence-sitter ..
I agree to all of that & the fact that the collegium to select CEC should be non-partisan, but where was this concern all these years when this mechanism did not even exist at all & CEC was basically directly chosen by the PM?
good Journalism
I appreciate you
Mr. Qureshi forgets the fact that Mr. Modi is not democratic like earlier PMs.
🎉 Rightly said brother
Congress bhakts.
@@AjayKumar-re2zpsecular bhakts
Modi was PM in 2019 when the old system was followed. So he was democratic then but not now?
சிறப்பான வாழ்த்துக்குரிய தகவல்கள். தாய் நாட்டைக் காப்பாற்ற வேண்டியது நமது பொறுப்பு. மீண்டும் மோடி வேண்டாம் மோடி.
Very nice and useful discussion of general public.
I don't understand. I work in an office. If I need to resign, I need to replace, give knowledge transfer, serve a notice period, and what not. But a person in the top position in election commission can simply decide not to go to work from today, and the whole country can suffer, and yet we never made any rule about such resignations. I don't know if I'm more important than the CEC....
No, employment under govt is contract based. Either give three months notice or pay three month’s salary and leave at it. That is all. It is equally applicable to the employer and employee. If there is a disciplinary proceedings against a servant or the govt. wants to remove him unreasonably, this rule will not be applicable.
In a country where the holder of the highest executive position in the Government is not mandatorily required to hold any specific educational qualifications, it is not surprising that the rules you rightly mentioned regarding resignations of senior Government functionaries do not exist.
Very correct. Normally everyone knows one month notice is required before one to resign or to remove!!! Big game is under the carpet.
Ridiculous but true
Because they loss faith
Thanks!
Thanks
As for Wes Bengal, I can say that time and again the EC has failed to discharge it's responsibilities with utmost sincerity and integrity. Before every election, they make a lot of noise. However, on election days, CAPF personnel remain largely ineffective.
Who told you that ?? Capf was very effective in 2021 bidhansabha election in Bengal .
I'm from coochbehar I know what the condition is here .
During election goons threatened not to go to booth but I never seen those things during loksabha and bidhansabha .
The countrymen by and large would be happy if the credibility of E.C is restored as was that of under T.N.Seshan.
What a joke!
Very good analysis. Thanq.
Good decision sc tq
Thanks our leader image is shining in all events. All institutions image are blurred & made the institutions authorities as Obidient servants of the leader.
GREAT IMPARTIAL CHANNEL SALUTES BRAVE HEARTS IF INDIA.
Great 👍journalism 👏👍
data entry operator works for Indian multinational company needs to serve 60 to 90 days notice period. But resigning from the most critical post that decide the fate of billions of Indian is damn easy 🤓🤓
Govt itself has made it easy. Earlier no govt official ( including judges ) could take any job / assignment for two years after leaving the office
Thanks Karan bringing relevant topic for discussion
Honble SC should intervene and stop govt going 'my way high way "by viswaguru.Theneed of the hour is a "Mr.Seshan"!
He begins by saying all is well on autopilot...then sums up by crashing the same
Great interview. It’s need of hour.
Its a super channel sir god bless u
Wow as usual the only one person has been the up holder of the demolishing pillar which has been questioned ❤ karran thapar
He is blowing hot and cold in the same breath 😂
Great people who report truth
I found the lineup of questions and their order quite appealing, especially given their versatility for accommodating multiple guests on the show without requiring adjustments. To sum up, it's evident that the independence of the Election Commission is in question, highlighting the need for specific actions to preserve it. The outcry against EVMs calls for widespread support to uphold democratic principles.
@Karan Thapar loved your work
💯%✔️
Mr qurashi u are always as per your soul. Always great to listen you.
MR.QURESHY ,is not Frank and forthright and having been ex-shouldexpress his views freely and frankly !what does he lose but will gain and save democracy !
सलाम थापर साहाब.
Salute ❤❤❤. Even an owl is sufficient , what is need of 3. Integrity is an important element rather than number.
Qureshi has answered very diplomatically not taking direct confrontation with the Government
Karan knows how to put words in people's mouths, I enjoy it!👍
Good 👍
Whether 1 or 10 all fish are suppose to be from the samepond so nothing is going to change
Smart Tv
Shameless people we have in this country including educated and responsible officers of administrative machinery. Whatever feelings people may have but responsible people should not side with anti social elements who value castes and classes of society. It is very disturbing to see responsible officers and lawyers challenging the constitutional rights of the people. This should be changed. Jai Hind.
No democracy in Modi India
Why so ? There was democracy during congress rule ?
Why revenge? Talk about current situation.
@@vvk594My father was alcoholic so I'll also remain alcoholic so that my future kid will also become like me. Y'all see democracy through lens of different parties not what it means for the general citizens
@@Unity_first1 , India has no true leader,Under this govt, oneday, India will be broken apiece
@vvk594 yes there was freedom speech in congress rule we could criticism the congress rule but doesent happens now.
Have arna goosewamy, anand sanginadhan and liedheepak as 3 new election commissioners.😅
Don't give the idead
Forgot Anil Maasi
If you receive a cheque how long do you keep it with you before en cash it? It can not be more than one week.
So, if one party has purchased some amount of bond in some specific date it needs to be checked which political party has en cashed the same amount or similar amount within one week.
All three of the options as the question asked for.
👌👌👌
❤❤❤
Ur one of the toughest journalist 😂😂I remember ur video conversation with our Indian pm
Good truth is truth god with truth
🙏👍🏻
One program with two different CEC!!! Great
Crucial point is that 2024 poll should be held by ballot papers only . Civil society, Sensitive Citizens, lawyers forum and all public should come on road to strongly protest and exerts pressure to EC that conduct 2024 poll by ballots only not by doubtfull EVM ( manipulated EVM ) as Election is people's events in which public choose his service Provider, EC is simply an agency to conduct free and fare poll, so EC should not admant to use EVM in 2024 in poll.??🤔
Once a bureaucrat,always a bureaucract.Neither yes nor no or maybe I don't know....
If not now, never.
Hello Mr reporter no one can supercede Mr TN seshan former the best CEC of this beloved india.
Mr Thapar, with every interview that you bring, I face the dilemma -- Whether to miss it perilously, or to get my head bludgeoned with a theater of rigor and repetitions.
Being on probation and worrying for promotion is some thing not expected from persons occupying or going to occupy. . Perhaps the issue who holds hand
Need of the hour is Seshan only ex EC chief who is remembered as excellent. No other ex EC chief finds mention in this regard. Neither of these ex EC are remembered for good work
I support
As an Indian citizen I have no faith in Election commission of INDIA
🎉🎉🎉
Academy /education system creditablety is down by the some political leaders in the labour surplus democracies nation of the world??????
It seems that some important decisions are required to be taken by the CEC. As only two ECs were there, it might have been difficult to take had Mr. Goel not resigned. After abrupt resignation of Mr. Goel it will now be smooth sailing for CEC.
What about E V M rigging through software from B J P Chairman s........
you can go shouting in the street pavli, he is not my PM.
Quraishi was good. More details on how and why Lavasa was hounded
👍
Its my opinion that there should be law that the who win the election in a perticular party ticket can not join the other party before completing the five years.
I think it is covered under defection law even now also. A person elected through certain party cannot abruptly join another.
Karan ,What is the Color Of ECI is Clear Day By Days !
Badly damaged specially when a former EC says that still the EVM is stand alone after induction of vvpat 😂
Up to 1991 one man election commissioner.For TN seasion,three members election commission.That doesn't mean TN Seasion wrong.
Pls let the audience know on why dads nerve broke in 1962 sino india war?
Great step Karan. Let me write something for you on CEC.
इस संवाद ने कई प्रश्नों पर बेबाक चर्चा की है। कमीशन पर भरोसा नहीं रह गया हैं।
Karan - Most people believe that Election commission is partisan. It has one rule for opposition and another for ruling party . Election commission closes its eyes on the blatant flouting of Model code of conduct and that's the sad reality . The integrity of the commission has a question mark ❓
I expect they appeared on condition that they would not discuss the complete blindness and partiality towards a party by the CEC and immediate action on mc violations by another party. Karan would definitely have liked to ask them instance wise.
Very perceptive observation!
In an autocracy, all these things dont matter. It people who have guts to save the nation who will stand out!
What about appointment of Navin Chawla during your favourite s government
CJI will not get rajya sabha seat now😊
What is the problem with Mr Thapar ?? Earlier for nearly 70 years in tjhe congress regime, President appoints based on recommendation of PM/ committee. One should have confidence on the integrity of PM / committee
Earlier system of appointing CEC was,is and will be absolutely perfect and highly democratic.
ECs like Peri Sastri and TN Seshan are most unlikely to come again. Under the present regime only yes ECs are permitted.
Honourable SC must oversee the smooth conduct of Election
Well done CJI..!!
During congress and coalition governments ec image was not damaged
Very daring and honest journalist 😮
Custodian is hearing but not acting
Thapar is never daring when questioning any party other than the BJP. Then he becomes their biggest defender.
Still billions in india speaks truth. Thanks to both ex ECs
Wire ..
No one is able to prove anything ...
Perception and frustration of individuals ..
Irrelevant
Mirror mirror on the Wall
Putin Xi Kim n Namo
Who’s the most undemocratic
Of them all…?
Public unrest is important for the some political leaders in the democracies nation of the world?????
BJP has controlled ECI, SBI, CBI ED Jjdiciary in India during BJP rule our democracy was tjreat❤
EC not bothered to prove anything. Not led by such persons
Thank you Karan Sir. Both viewpoints expressed by the CEC's demonstrate a fair and impartial perspective.
Now Gujarat mafia will have its own Election Commission 😮
Pm singlehandedly decided cec up to thus year. So Guharat mafia couldn't choose before?
Leader of oppositi9n may not be aware of the meeting or he may not attend
So basically credibility of election commission wasn't damaged when M.S Gill , The former Election commissioner retired on 13th june 2001 and nominated him in a Rajya sabha and then continue to be in cabinet from 2009-11 as Minister of youth and sports affairs .. Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai 😂😂😂😂
Karan why don't you cover ladakh issues?
Election Commissioner has purchased 60 lakhs EVM machines.
We are using 40 lakhs EVM machines.
Where these 20 lakhs EVM machines Gone or Missing.
Opposition asked EC for Details. He is Salient.
Opposition asked Modi ji in Parliament. He is also Salient. No Answer.
Election Commissioner might have kept a BJP CHIP inside the EVM machines..
He is Sold Out to BJP Party..
Krishna Morty is a better in analysing ! Thapar is a mischief maker !
The nation is watching how the government does not want the CJI on the selection committee. The government has definitely motives behind its actions. You can't rely on such a motivated lot
Only Karan Thapar image is damaged.and his narratives have met with stiff resistance by public at large.
No power what they do.
I think no TH-camr should invite Mr Quraishi on discussion regarding electioneering in India. His views are supportive to ill motives of BJP’s Govt by and large.
T N Sheshan says i bite polititian in my morning breakfast. After him, no CEC was competent. Mere seniority and IAS post makes no any difference.
Supreme Court should take steps immediately to quash all cases taken by ED during modi goverments time.
Dissolve these instructions which are unconstitutional and SC should conduct ballot voting by monitoring the process of election only way to save democracy.. Chandigarh is latest example of the current situation.
Why should the government sulk to include the CJI in the selection committee?