Just based off the way player overall ratings have worked in the past for every football game. Travis will be over a 95. He will have a 90+ in every skill category both offensive and defensive.
Looking at it that way I agree but from this perspective I looked at solely power rankings. I probably should have considered your approach for him at least.
@alanamaya1669 congrats you are the winner of the giveaway. Since I really do not want to dox anyone I will need a venmo, paypal or cashapp to transfer you the giveaway winnings.
I'd be a bit surprised if both Quinshon Judkins or Emeka Egbuka aren't 95+ Overalls, if not both. I would also bet that Omarion Hampton and Travis Hunter are 95+ Overalls (Especially Travis Hunter.) I also think Ewers is a lock to be a 95+ Overall
I considered most of them but after seeing how many players were at 95+ they have been stingy in the past, not to say that doesn't change. Also Hampton was a lock for me but I somehow glossed over him when recording... and Egbuka was a big surprise to me as well but looking at the power rankings he didn't make the cut.
I tossed that idea around but looking at any power rankings he was rarely a top 5 at either position and he was never ranked in the top 25 in totality. Had to cut some people out but maybe I am wrong about that one!
I think you miss one kid.. The RB for the North Carolina Tar Hills Omarion Hampton #28... this kid as a True Freshman ran for 1905yds & 21 TD That's better in yards then Ollie Gordon II and tied in TDs with 21.. I think he will be up there.. the kid is explosive and with every touch could take it to the house!!! Remind me of a Penn state's #26 S. Barkley... ijs .. check out his Highlights and stats.. @cswee123
You are 100% correct I had him in my list and completely missed him when recording. Wow I cannot believe it... well he was in the 98 overall group if it makes you feel any better lol
I wanted to put him up there badly, but (at least in the last 4 games) there hasn't been a HB that high and there were only ever two 99's. Also not being in the SEC or B10 I think may have hurt him indirectly.
Mason Graham DT for Michigan will be a 95 or 96. The other Wolverine DT Kenneth Grant will be only a few points behind that. I understand if Donovan Edwards is a 93-94 based on last year, but i think he's going to surprise people if the new o-line gels right away. He's one of those backs who I think gets better when they get in a rhythm and he'll be the #1 guy this year.
I went back and forth on that, but I was too unsure how they would handle the two way part. As a CB he is 95+ but as a WR I see it holding him back so if they average it I think it goes below 95.
Haven't seen that yet (I am no expert btw) when I was looking at different ranking. I could have read it incorrectly but regardless he is still a great player both ways!
Valid point, down the road I will consider that. The videos I thought separated themselves well enough but I did notice a few instances where the green of the field blended in too well. Thanks for the input.
Thank you! I tried to be as unbiased it helps when I am a UK alum and fan since we don't really have top players lol. But I would hope so, kinda similar to baseball with Ohtani it is the hot thing right now. I was curious how they would handle two way players, in NCAA 14 they could play positions but if they were not in their main one their awareness suffered a lot.
I could’ve made a case for either but after looking at the numbers from previous games the list was too small. Also neither of those guys are looked at as a top 2-3 player at their position right now
@cswee123 Let it be known. I respect your opinion, but I just can't see it. Travis is arguably the best all-around athlete in college football and plays 2 way!?!?! Quinn is a 3-year starter that's improved each year and has the numbers to prove it... There's no way EA has them both under a 95...
Valid points, someone pointed out the rating of Hunter and he will likely be 90+ in most categories so just by that he will more than likely end up >95. And I agree with that. But Quinn was on the edge, I tried to keep my personal views out of it and go off the rankings mostly.
Did I miss him or is Mason Graham really not on list? He is the best interior lineman in nation, top 2 DL like Will is considered CB, won award last year for it and considered a possible top 5-pick in next years nfl draft
Not on the list, we based of power rankings and the places we looks he was good. We also grouped all DL together and from what I could tell he was the third as a whole. Not perfect but tried to have it be "data" driven rather than my own opinion.
@@Ish393 yeah just looked at it. Missed a few but out of the 19 I selected (I have 18 in the video since I forgot to put in Hampton) I got 13/19. Pretty good I do believe! Definitely didn’t get the order right and missed Graham. But all in all good attempt
I agree, the B10 and SEC will probably have ~80% of the top 200 players. Especially since they want to make it feel more realistic you can't have 90's all over the place
Idk much about college football at least I terms of the players but I’m extremely excited, also your commentary is top notch and makes the video interesting to listen to and watch.
Just based off the way player overall ratings have worked in the past for every football game. Travis will be over a 95. He will have a 90+ in every skill category both offensive and defensive.
Looking at it that way I agree but from this perspective I looked at solely power rankings. I probably should have considered your approach for him at least.
I think Travis hunter might be the highest rated player
I could see it but man I would be surprised
Its got to be Travis hunter due to him being a WR and CB🤷🏽and also haveing amazing height lights.
I don't disagree 100% but just how the rankings fell after looking at all the pre season power rankings. I am excited to see!
@alanamaya1669 congrats you are the winner of the giveaway. Since I really do not want to dox anyone I will need a venmo, paypal or cashapp to transfer you the giveaway winnings.
I'd be a bit surprised if both Quinshon Judkins or Emeka Egbuka aren't 95+ Overalls, if not both. I would also bet that Omarion Hampton and Travis Hunter are 95+ Overalls (Especially Travis Hunter.) I also think Ewers is a lock to be a 95+ Overall
I considered most of them but after seeing how many players were at 95+ they have been stingy in the past, not to say that doesn't change. Also Hampton was a lock for me but I somehow glossed over him when recording... and Egbuka was a big surprise to me as well but looking at the power rankings he didn't make the cut.
I honestly can’t wait for this game
Me either!
Travis definitely should be above 97
I tossed that idea around but looking at any power rankings he was rarely a top 5 at either position and he was never ranked in the top 25 in totality. Had to cut some people out but maybe I am wrong about that one!
I NEED THE GAME
I hope they do it justice!
Jalen Milroe def 97+ lock because he brought a decent team to an amazing team and a very deserved win against Georgia
I would have agreed but he did get benched last year... he is still a top 5 QB but I don't think the ratings team would be as high on him.
@@cswee123 Most Heisman votes for any returning player.
C Beck
GA QB
I think you miss one kid.. The RB for the North Carolina Tar Hills Omarion Hampton #28... this kid as a True Freshman ran for 1905yds & 21 TD That's better in yards then Ollie Gordon II and tied in TDs with 21.. I think he will be up there.. the kid is explosive and with every touch could take it to the house!!! Remind me of a Penn state's #26 S. Barkley... ijs .. check out his Highlights and stats.. @cswee123
You are 100% correct I had him in my list and completely missed him when recording. Wow I cannot believe it... well he was in the 98 overall group if it makes you feel any better lol
i would like to see Jalen millroe i think it being his 3rd year he will be the scariest QB this year might not be the best
If he can improve from last year I think he could be the best QB in the draft but that is still to be seen.
I think hunter is a 96
I can see that, if I extended the list to 20 he would have been on it.
Ollie Gordon will be a 99, I think he might be the only one.
I wanted to put him up there badly, but (at least in the last 4 games) there hasn't been a HB that high and there were only ever two 99's. Also not being in the SEC or B10 I think may have hurt him indirectly.
w video
Appreciate it!
Mason Graham DT for Michigan will be a 95 or 96. The other Wolverine DT Kenneth Grant will be only a few points behind that. I understand if Donovan Edwards is a 93-94 based on last year, but i think he's going to surprise people if the new o-line gels right away. He's one of those backs who I think gets better when they get in a rhythm and he'll be the #1 guy this year.
I agree with that 100%, I just think from a paper ratings stand point Michigan lost a lot and that may have hurt Edwards indirectly.
I think travis hunter will be te highest overall even if he doesnt deserve it
I went back and forth on that, but I was too unsure how they would handle the two way part. As a CB he is 95+ but as a WR I see it holding him back so if they average it I think it goes below 95.
NFL scouts are saying he is a better receiver than corner back
Haven't seen that yet (I am no expert btw) when I was looking at different ranking. I could have read it incorrectly but regardless he is still a great player both ways!
Carson beck is overrated af tbh.
Probably but he did pass for almost 4K yards last year. Playing with all 4-5 stars helps a lot so I gave him the benefit.
Do we have to say something nice about the game to get a copy?
Nope, just need a comment to enter the drawing.
№12
You didn’t say what position or schools they are from. You also showed pic of them with the busy Gameplay video behind. Clean it up please
Valid point, down the road I will consider that. The videos I thought separated themselves well enough but I did notice a few instances where the green of the field blended in too well. Thanks for the input.
Thank you for not making any of the cover athletes a 95+. They are all overrated and the whole Colorado team is overrated.
I think Hunter will be close! But with him being a two-way player I don’t think they would give him the bump.
The Don is about to show you what's up
I don't mind missing a few. I think if I hot 50%+ it was a good prediction. I think the last group is all but guaranteed to be a top 10 player though.
Shut up
Your underrated bro 🔥
Appreciate it man!
Pretty good non biased ratings do you think there will be two way players in dynasty recruiting
Thank you! I tried to be as unbiased it helps when I am a UK alum and fan since we don't really have top players lol. But I would hope so, kinda similar to baseball with Ohtani it is the hot thing right now. I was curious how they would handle two way players, in NCAA 14 they could play positions but if they were not in their main one their awareness suffered a lot.
7:15 500 hours played per game? Daaaamn
I'm so excited for College Football 25, & I'll probably gonna be saving up some money for that.
I cannot wait either!
You lost all credibility for me when you excluded the cover athletes... There is no way Quinn or Travis is not a 95...
I could’ve made a case for either but after looking at the numbers from previous games the list was too small. Also neither of those guys are looked at as a top 2-3 player at their position right now
@cswee123 Let it be known. I respect your opinion, but I just can't see it. Travis is arguably the best all-around athlete in college football and plays 2 way!?!?! Quinn is a 3-year starter that's improved each year and has the numbers to prove it... There's no way EA has them both under a 95...
Valid points, someone pointed out the rating of Hunter and he will likely be 90+ in most categories so just by that he will more than likely end up >95. And I agree with that. But Quinn was on the edge, I tried to keep my personal views out of it and go off the rankings mostly.
Did I miss him or is Mason Graham really not on list? He is the best interior lineman in nation, top 2 DL like Will is considered CB, won award last year for it and considered a possible top 5-pick in next years nfl draft
Not on the list, we based of power rankings and the places we looks he was good. We also grouped all DL together and from what I could tell he was the third as a whole. Not perfect but tried to have it be "data" driven rather than my own opinion.
@@cswee123 Fair. Looks like Ea more so agreed with Graham being there. Tied for best Dl in game and 2nd best overall at 95.
@@Ish393 yeah just looked at it. Missed a few but out of the 19 I selected (I have 18 in the video since I forgot to put in Hampton) I got 13/19. Pretty good I do believe! Definitely didn’t get the order right and missed Graham. But all in all good attempt
I think the big ten will have a lot of top players it is going to be a stacked conference this season
I agree, the B10 and SEC will probably have ~80% of the top 200 players. Especially since they want to make it feel more realistic you can't have 90's all over the place
@cswee123 yes those 2 conferences are going to be rough to beat
I remember when Wyoming had a 99 over receiver. forgot who it was
Not sure who that would be but if you find out let me know!
@@cswee123 just looked it up. Looking at time frame I’m thinking it’s Jovon Bouknight
Jabber
Idk much about college football at least I terms of the players but I’m extremely excited, also your commentary is top notch and makes the video interesting to listen to and watch.
I appreciate the kind words. It means a lot, thank you! Glad you are excited so am I.