29:49 Zeddy's golden heart corrected Rarran for no reason, correct play was to ignore mumbling unless directly asked and Rarran would go on an adventure looking for a minion.
Zeddy, your Canadian was showing cause you kept correcting Rarran when you didn't have to. You could have let him off, but you didn't. Such a far cry from the "toxic" gamer you were. Good vibes and wholesome friendships are more your speed now. Haha!
At first I was thinking being able to search through the library would ruin the spirit of the game, then I saw Zeddy's first card and said 'yep okay I get why'
@@ZakadingNo it would still be one question. If you ask, “standard or wild?” and are given an answer, you only need one question, and if you ask, “Is it standard?” And you are given an answer yes, you know it is standard. Or if you are given an answer no, you know it is wild.
As previously said, not how binary questions work. Rarran even stops Zeddy from asking a non binary question. Only non binary question that would be bad is "is it carx X or card Y" since if it was X and they wpuld of asked Y first, then they saved a question
Zeddy: Is it from before Ashes of Outland? Rarran: Yes Is it from Naxx? Is it from GvG? Is it from Grand Tournament? Is it from Blackrock? Is it from LoE? Is it from Old Gods? Is it from Karazhan? Is it from Gadgetzan? Is it from Un'Goro? Is it from Frozen Throne? Is it from Kobolds? Is it from Witchwood? Is it from Boomsday? Is it from Rastakhan? Is it from RoS? Is it from Uldum?
It's pretty easy to translate to just Yes or No questions. For example: Asking 'Standard or Wild?' could either be asked as 'Is it a Standard Card?' or 'Is it a Wild Card?' Similarly, 'Before or after Demon Hunter?' could either be asked as 'Is it before Demon Hunter?' or 'Is it after Demon Hunter?' I don't think it is breaking the rules to ask questions that only have two options as that is functionally the same as Yes/No questions.
@@JustAHearthstoneNoob I was going to make that distinction because I knew one single person was going to say that exact thing, so fine, yes, they are technically spells
This is a fun series. Yeah the questions were weird: but a lot are fine to ask. Like, "is it 6 or higher" is still a yes or no question. Same with "Is it a minion or a spell". That HAS a yes/no answer.
This was a ton of fun! I can think of so many interesting questions that could drastically reduce the pool once expansion, class and minion/spell are locked down. "Does it depict a playable race in World of Warcraft?" comes to mind as a possibility.
Oooh I like this as an alternate Do You Know Hearthstone type quiz. I have one suggestion that may or may not be too restrictive: only one question of a 'type' e.g. only one question for mana brackets, 1 for expansion, 1 for class (can still ask after neutral/class), etc, just to force some unique questions like 'textless' or 'does it do damage' instead of being a speedrun to narrow down mana cost/class/expansion and then seeing the stupidest card available.
I thought Zeddy was gonna get serious and pop off on the 3rd round. But by the time the point was awarded, I half-expected him to start asking about the shaman's star sign with how many questions were asked lol
Rarran, I stopped playing hearthstone a long time ago but I came across your channel a few months ago and your content is so amazing, I don’t plan on going but to HS but I love watching your videos. Keep up the incredible work!
i think what this game might need is like. have the person with the card give a few little details or hints to start just to give the guessing player a little direction. could result in some fun mindgames too. but i really like this i think it's a great format
I love this duo! Discovered Zeddy's channel through yours! You two are my favorite HS content creators together with Voxy! Also, great show! Love to see more!
I think you guys should continue this and work your way up to facing off against a Hearthstone Designer. Like that would be the final boss in the series and whoever wins that round gets a prize!
Nice format. A question counter would be nice if it isn't too much effort in post. Also it would be nice to see how many questions it took the first person in order to find the card while the second is playing. Thanks for the Hearthstone contet @Rarran
Love the game. I suggest you try bending it to be like "Guess that Pokemon!" where you show a shadow outline of a minion's art and then do the "Guess Who" game. Trump would be a good guest with his long running knowledge
If you ever do something like this again, might I suggest one thing: Give points based on the difference in guess count. So that 21 to 12 guess round would be worth a big 9 points.
So a quick thing on the OR questions cause i saw you guys talk about it. Technically an Or question is still yes or no. Basically the way it logically breaks down is if i ask an OR question and the answer is yes any one of those things listed in the question is true. In the case of the final question where he asks "is it X or Y card." If the answer to that question is Yes then he still has to ask another question but its 50/50.
I wish you could get Ben Brode on for one of these kinds of videos, whether its this or DYKHS, It'd be a ton of fun to see our good old friend Benny Boy.
Since you can look the library you don’t have to pick un obscure card … it’s just a matter of asking the right questions . Without looking , some of the cards would be impossible though
I would love to see more. My thoughts though would to maybe stick to hard yes or no questions though. The point of this is asking the right questions and there is too much room for invalidating a round when you use binary question outside the yes or no. My other thought is if it would be fun to have the card hidden from the TH-cam crowd until the answer was given. I have no idea if it would be more exciting to follow how close/far off someone is or if you left in the dark along with the guesser
Theres a type of question that can make things easier, lets say theres a subset of 10, you can ask whether if the card is between 3-6 or the other two extremes
Rarran: "Okay, so the card is not in the twist format, that means it came out before Demon Hunter came out" If Zeddy picked a neutral card, you would have be ROYALLY screwed there, buddy.
Everyone bringing up the immediate "starts using non yes or no questions" aren't realizing that asking "Is it a minion or a spell" gets the same result as asking "Is it a minion" or "is it a spell" separately. If Zeddy picks a minion and Rarran asks if it is a spell, the answer would be no. This would mean it is a minion. It's a binary question with an implicit "yes or no" outcome. Same goes for "wild or standard" or "was it before or after x expansion". (Admittedly I forgot about locations/hero cards/weapons yanno as I think about it the minion/spell one really isn't a binary one huh, but the other points still stand honestly)
i realised the most difficult guesses would be core sets at specific years, year of the hydra had the explorers and lets say you choosen elise, you can say yes if they ask league of explorers or core set
Very fun, but I think the game would be better if it wasn't easy to reliably guess by doing binary search over the classes and mana cost. It's more interesting when the card is guessed based on something other than the obvious numeric values.
![[Live] : ONE 169 วันนี้!! "อนาโตลี vs อูมาร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IK3YZVWuFJg/mqdefault.jpg)
Yeah I said the intro wrong in hindsight, but the questions were still more or less “yes or no” questions
Also I’ll be doing this more based on the video feedback
Im a couple of beers deep and I didnt understand the intro xD but we are cool man.
Binary questions is the term you are looking for I believe. Would love to see more of this, great vid.
"Only yes/no questions"
"Is it Standard or Wild?"
👏
Binary-only questions limitation is a good way to keep it consistent.
And this was really fun to watch, even if slightly clumsy :)
29:49 Zeddy's golden heart corrected Rarran for no reason, correct play was to ignore mumbling unless directly asked and Rarran would go on an adventure looking for a minion.
he could've won if he cheated peepoEvil :D
I honestly think that was Rarran's intent which is pretty dirty lmao
@@sunnysangha2097it’s not cheating to let the opponent confuse themself with bad questions
Literally 2 rounds were given because he clarified when he didn't need to XD
Zeddy IMMEDIATELY trolling is very on brand
This was super fun, and now you know what Nordrassil Druid is!
You're too nice to Rarran 😂
Zeddy, your Canadian was showing cause you kept correcting Rarran when you didn't have to. You could have let him off, but you didn't. Such a far cry from the "toxic" gamer you were. Good vibes and wholesome friendships are more your speed now. Haha!
At first I was thinking being able to search through the library would ruin the spirit of the game, then I saw Zeddy's first card and said 'yep okay I get why'
I imagine it kind of like a game of Ghess who
This game would actually be impossible if you couldn’t go through the collection
"only yes or no questions"
Immediately starts asking non yes or no questions
They were binary questions though, I think they could all be converted to yes or no questions.
@@benbooth2783 They would end up being twice as many questions, however.
@@ZakadingNo it would still be one question. If you ask, “standard or wild?” and are given an answer, you only need one question, and if you ask, “Is it standard?” And you are given an answer yes, you know it is standard. Or if you are given an answer no, you know it is wild.
As previously said, not how binary questions work. Rarran even stops Zeddy from asking a non binary question.
Only non binary question that would be bad is "is it carx X or card Y" since if it was X and they wpuld of asked Y first, then they saved a question
@@somewhatfunnyguyy You are correct
Zeddy: Is it from before Ashes of Outland?
Rarran: Yes
Is it from Naxx?
Is it from GvG?
Is it from Grand Tournament?
Is it from Blackrock?
Is it from LoE?
Is it from Old Gods?
Is it from Karazhan?
Is it from Gadgetzan?
Is it from Un'Goro?
Is it from Frozen Throne?
Is it from Kobolds?
Is it from Witchwood?
Is it from Boomsday?
Is it from Rastakhan?
Is it from RoS?
Is it from Uldum?
It's pretty easy to translate to just Yes or No questions.
For example:
Asking 'Standard or Wild?' could either be asked as 'Is it a Standard Card?' or 'Is it a Wild Card?'
Similarly, 'Before or after Demon Hunter?' could either be asked as 'Is it before Demon Hunter?' or 'Is it after Demon Hunter?'
I don't think it is breaking the rules to ask questions that only have two options as that is functionally the same as Yes/No questions.
Shout out to Zeddy for throwing the game entirely constantly, gotta give Rarran a win from time to time.
Rarran staring at 3 mana minions trying to find an even minion gave me brain damage.
I think Rarran forgot weapons, heroes, quests, and locations exist given he thinks 'is it a minion or a spell' is a yes or no question
Quests are spells
@@JustAHearthstoneNoob I was going to make that distinction because I knew one single person was going to say that exact thing, so fine, yes, they are technically spells
Yh zeddy was way to nice, should have let rarran go down the minion route
Well, it IS yes or no...this is why you don't ask compound questions, because the answer to "Is it a minion or a spell?" is "Yes."
It is still a yes/no question. If a card is a minion or a spell, the answer is yes. If it is a hero, quest or location, the answer is no.
>Click the video
>yes or no question
>first question isnt a yes or no question
>leaves
You are neurodivergent
Also, I feel like, if you know it's a class card, a good followup to "does it have keywords" is "is it a class-specific keyword"
This is a fun series. Yeah the questions were weird: but a lot are fine to ask. Like, "is it 6 or higher" is still a yes or no question. Same with "Is it a minion or a spell". That HAS a yes/no answer.
"Is it a minion or a spell?"
"Yes."
Minion/spell is a problem if they picked a weapon or location tho
This is a fun update to the whole "Do you know hearthstone format" Great video
This was a ton of fun! I can think of so many interesting questions that could drastically reduce the pool once expansion, class and minion/spell are locked down. "Does it depict a playable race in World of Warcraft?" comes to mind as a possibility.
Creative but not very Hearthstony
My two favourite HS creators making videos together :)))
Youre both awesome
Keep up the great content
We all apreciate you guys
Oooh I like this as an alternate Do You Know Hearthstone type quiz. I have one suggestion that may or may not be too restrictive: only one question of a 'type' e.g. only one question for mana brackets, 1 for expansion, 1 for class (can still ask after neutral/class), etc, just to force some unique questions like 'textless' or 'does it do damage' instead of being a speedrun to narrow down mana cost/class/expansion and then seeing the stupidest card available.
I thought Zeddy was gonna get serious and pop off on the 3rd round. But by the time the point was awarded, I half-expected him to start asking about the shaman's star sign with how many questions were asked lol
Rarran, I stopped playing hearthstone a long time ago but I came across your channel a few months ago and your content is so amazing, I don’t plan on going but to HS but I love watching your videos. Keep up the incredible work!
Rarran: "Only yes or no questions"
Also Rarran on his VERY FIRST question: "Is it a standard or wild card?"
That is essentially a yes or no question
Still a binary question
The correct answer to this question is "Yes".
@@oren000 wild
Also Rarran: "Is it a spell or a minion?" (1:25)
Says only yes or no questions, but immediately breaks the rule
This is super fun and would love to see more of this, but please add a question counter!! That would make it much more exciting to watch.
I like to imagine each of them clacking little plastic pictures of the cards down with each question.
Awesome to see my two favorite HS content creators making a video together!!! Hope to see more of this kind of content!
This was super fun to watch!
This reminds me a lot of guess who. Just imagined seeing target dummy as ome of the cards you got to flip down 😂
Your Zeddy crossovers are really funny, excellent vid, I completely forgot Vanessa Vancleef existed ngl
"Can only ask yes or no questions"
First question: "Is this wild or standard?"
Hmm...
LETS GOOOO this is the creator combo i waited for
this was a FANTASTIC GAME!! I DEMAND MORE IMMEDIATELY
I loved seeing Zeddy in this, and the premise is great. One of my favorite videos in a while
This was fun to watch, good job to you and Zeddy!
i think what this game might need is like. have the person with the card give a few little details or hints to start just to give the guessing player a little direction. could result in some fun mindgames too. but i really like this i think it's a great format
The man never stops cooking, sick idea. Also Zeddy, Pog
Two of the best Hearthstone content creators lets go
I love this duo! Discovered Zeddy's channel through yours! You two are my favorite HS content creators together with Voxy! Also, great show! Love to see more!
I think you guys should continue this and work your way up to facing off against a Hearthstone Designer. Like that would be the final boss in the series and whoever wins that round gets a prize!
"We can only ask yes or no questions."
Proceeds to ask tons of non yes or no questions.
love zeddy content with rarran
if this happens again, a question counter would be fun
Great video, really liked the concept. Before i knew it i had watched a 30 minute video.
This was very fun to watch, cool concept!
This game was fun, it would be nice to see you going against one of the devs
Standard > Spell > Minion > Cost
Only recently started watching/playing hearthstone, I really appreciate you for getting me into this game! Great content also :)
this one was my favorite mini-game so far, really nice video!
loved it, Rarran and Zeddy such a comedy duo
Gg guys, great to see you doing content together.
Zeddy is sounding more like Gabe Newell as he ages.
1:18 Zeddy doing the El Risitas Laugh
Rest Well King
Nice format. A question counter would be nice if it isn't too much effort in post. Also it would be nice to see how many questions it took the first person in order to find the card while the second is playing. Thanks for the Hearthstone contet @Rarran
That was fun to watch!
Really nice video, would enjoy more
Rarran with zeddy is perfect
Very fun, but Zeddy helped you so much when he didn't need to. Very hard challenge to get these cards in as few questions as possible
Rarran is so good at this game his mouth doesnt even need to mobe to laugh 30:56
Love the game. I suggest you try bending it to be like "Guess that Pokemon!" where you show a shadow outline of a minion's art and then do the "Guess Who" game. Trump would be a good guest with his long running knowledge
“Is it a minion or a spell?”
“Yes.”
If you ever do something like this again, might I suggest one thing: Give points based on the difference in guess count. So that 21 to 12 guess round would be worth a big 9 points.
Woo Zeddy is a great guest!
@Rarran more of that format please :)
So a quick thing on the OR questions cause i saw you guys talk about it. Technically an Or question is still yes or no. Basically the way it logically breaks down is if i ask an OR question and the answer is yes any one of those things listed in the question is true. In the case of the final question where he asks "is it X or Y card." If the answer to that question is Yes then he still has to ask another question but its 50/50.
Love the sweater Rarren, NS represent!
"Is it a minion or spell?"
"Minion"
Weird yes/no answer
I wish you could get Ben Brode on for one of these kinds of videos, whether its this or DYKHS, It'd be a ton of fun to see our good old friend Benny Boy.
"Standard or Wild" is such a trash first question, but you just kept going for it because it is just feels natural 😂
this is a really good idea
Rarran sitting on 13k dust makes me sad lol
Zeddy picking neutral cards over and over when it limits the card pool so much
I would have gone with one of those event cards like old ETC or that guy who summons a awesome invention.
Since you can look the library you don’t have to pick un obscure card … it’s just a matter of asking the right questions . Without looking , some of the cards would be impossible though
Rarran: U can only ask Yes or No questions
Also Rarran: Is It A MiNiOn Or A SpELlL ?
Can answer still yes or no. If it's a weapon, it's a no.
Today in Hearthstone we will learn binary search!
I would love to see more. My thoughts though would to maybe stick to hard yes or no questions though. The point of this is asking the right questions and there is too much room for invalidating a round when you use binary question outside the yes or no.
My other thought is if it would be fun to have the card hidden from the TH-cam crowd until the answer was given. I have no idea if it would be more exciting to follow how close/far off someone is or if you left in the dark along with the guesser
I see how it is... Rarran had to get the Sig Tony to make a vid with Zeddy KEKW
Theres a type of question that can make things easier, lets say theres a subset of 10, you can ask whether if the card is between 3-6 or the other two extremes
rarran’s method to cut down the amount of options is way worse than zeddy’s
I enjoy these even more than DYK Hearthstone
Your face when writing LMAFO be like 30:56
This was fun
Love this series!!!
Rarran: "Okay, so the card is not in the twist format, that means it came out before Demon Hunter came out"
If Zeddy picked a neutral card, you would have be ROYALLY screwed there, buddy.
Honestly interesting and fun
best way to screw someone up is to pick a location. Not technically a spell, minion or weapon.
you can add "|" between keywords on the search bar to narrow it even further. For instance Legendary | Spell
Everyone bringing up the immediate "starts using non yes or no questions" aren't realizing that asking "Is it a minion or a spell" gets the same result as asking "Is it a minion" or "is it a spell" separately. If Zeddy picks a minion and Rarran asks if it is a spell, the answer would be no. This would mean it is a minion. It's a binary question with an implicit "yes or no" outcome. Same goes for "wild or standard" or "was it before or after x expansion". (Admittedly I forgot about locations/hero cards/weapons yanno as I think about it the minion/spell one really isn't a binary one huh, but the other points still stand honestly)
Is it a minion or a spell can still be answered yes/no, cause if the card is a weapon for example, the answer is no, they just pepegad a bit
oh man if only you picked Prison of Yogg saron right after Zeddy picked it
You should alternate guesses like in "guess who?" and see who gets it first
this was fire
This was great
You should do this with other content creators, this is awesome!
i realised the most difficult guesses would be core sets at specific years, year of the hydra had the explorers and lets say you choosen elise, you can say yes if they ask league of explorers or core set
An interesting twist would be if only the NO's are counted. This may add to the tension quite a bit in how to ask your the questions. :D
Nordrassil Druid was so fucking evil, I never saw that card, I belive it never was in rotation for standard...
Is there hs timeline for everything what they changed in gamemodes? bcs i realised i have no idea when devs made changes like making core set
A good card to choose would be Worthless imp the 1/1 token you get from Sense Demons if you don’t have 2 demons in your deck to draw.
They only allowed craftable cards
Next time you do this, you should ask "Was this card considered 'good'"?
Very fun, but I think the game would be better if it wasn't easy to reliably guess by doing binary search over the classes and mana cost. It's more interesting when the card is guessed based on something other than the obvious numeric values.
That was great lol