Had he known what power he had, he'd have double or nothing'd the entire mansion instead of the bombs to enter. They would have had 3 mansions, because it was a nat 20.
The fact that they came to basically the same conclusion twice in the goblin puzzle and still struggled both times to execute it is the epitome of dnd. Players can be the smartest people in the world but when playing dnd, they lose all but one braincell and it's just great to watch.
I thought I was about to see a video about traitor without a traitor. Instead, I saw the greatest video about gambling of the history of this platform.
Tell Noah to make a new npc "living rock" looks like a normal rock but if anyone tries to interact with it then it's wakes up and looks like a mossy rock/turtle
I love the idea of Skip being double voted out because of double or nothing, and in the next video he appears as a 5th guest, and gets instantly voted out
I did something similar for a dnd one shot. Everyone rolled a d20, and anyone who got above a 15 would be the killer. No one rolled more then a 15, so I just had the inciting ‘murder’ really be an accident, and all following murders were either accidents or caused by the paranoia of the players
@@pieklik3133 They didn’t, after a while they all got into a fight because all of them suspected each other. Two of the 3 PCs died, and the third one failed a dex save, which sent her over a third story staircase to her death. Then I revealed that there was no killer, and how all the NPCs died of accidents. Then I got called an asshole for an hour while I laughed. Also, the inciting death of the host was from a heart attack. A big part of the one shot was the players trying to figure out how the killer killed the host without leaving a mark on the body (I am an asshole).
I always love the point in the recording where Noah gets fed up of how off the rails everything gets. The silent seething rage at how things have utterly spiraled into madness gives me a giggle every single time. Along with the awful rolls that make things so much worse to the point where he's like "yeah a 6 will hit" Love it.
ngl Branzy was so fire. "Branzy if you kill our healer-" "Like he's healing ANYTHING! Don't act like he's useful so far! He's moving rocks, he's a geologist at best!" Edit: 1.5k likes!?!? I think this is my first time with a popular comment.
I'm an English teacher and I once did this with my students before teaching The Crucible. Basically, I told them that they were villagers and they had to vote off the witches, and then at the end I revealed that there had never been any witches.
That is a fantastic teaching method. Damn I wish we did that. (But actually I'm pretty sure we did something similar when taught about the red scare, where some of the class were labeled communists, though I'm pretty sure there were people who got that role so it's not exactly the same, but what is similar is how the people who got accused were mostly not communist's)
I find it really funny that the second Noah said that there wasn't a traitor they all immediately went that it makes sense because they know him well enough to know that's what he'd pull lol
I think the goblin puzzle was supposed to be a simple obstacle, but it took so long to solve because they simply failed to comprehend the simple puzzle.
@@luciuseclipse I disagree. I think the goblin puzzle was supposed to be a simple obstacle, but they struggled to understand the mechanics for a long time so Noah decided to end the game.
2:43 Idea: tell them there's a "Traitor shop" and that items purchased will be placed for the traitor to "find". Now every time someone finds something they're suspicious
Failboat using his insider knowledge, taking screenshots, pushing rocks, grabbing flamingos. It’s so funny how paranoid and unhinged repeat players slowly become the more they’re subjected to Noah’s schemes and just how much you notice it when they play with new players Just the sheer differences between veteran Magic The Noah video participants versus the -fresh meat- I mean, new players
@@RedHorseArcherThey need to put the same people in both games and then vote on which was worse. At least Noah doesn't take 8 hours. Also need to put eachother in games.
@@sweatynoob1402 Yeah, his new 'contestants' (aka victims) have no idea what makes it so good, or how Cannon Dwarf (when they show up again) is something from the deepest pits of hell.
It is so painful. I made a small labirynth once. 4 months later my players found an exit and it was the best day of my life. Describing the same room at least 5 times each session redefined torture for me. I swore I ll never do a puzzle requiering more than pressing two visible buttons at the same time ever again
I gave a players a puzzle one time at their request. It was a room an enemy had just run into but no enemy was in the room when they entered. After searching the room the first time they found writing on a door with no handle or lock and a mirror opposite the writing. I gave them the writing on a sheet of paper. For over an hour they were yelling at each other and me over what they found to be an impossible puzzle. It was just mirror writing that had to be read aloud to open the door. Last puzzle I ever gave players.
gonna be honest the puzzle here was really well made actually, doesn't spell things out and lets the players figure it out, while giving a subtle hint on how to do it AND they're kind of just fighting shit the whole time it's awesome
Eh this type of puzzle is always more of a pain than it is actually fun to solve though especially with common it is. Its probably the most common type of puzzle in games and is never enjoyable. It is only really entertaining here for how much suffering it causes due to the sheer chaos of everyone's actions
I want to think Noah prerecorded a bunch of wheel spins, and that every single wheel was rigged from the start. He made jay roll low, skip fails only the important double or nothings, branzy roll super high, and fail was already throwing
Way to high effort for someone who would create this game to be played seriously, no chance Noah would do that when he just wants to see the chaos his pawns get into on their own accord.
You want to think or you do? Imagine him having a thousand videos open ready to play to show the players the rolls and he has to keep track of it 😂 sounds like a nightmare
My favorite part. 49:01 Noah: “any specific word you’d like to or two words you’d like to add on to that?” Branzy: “Pretty Please.” Noah: “…Any others?” Skip: “No no, Branzy. Look at your sheet. LOOK AT YOUR SHEET!” Branzy: “Oh my sheet, of course, sneak attack..”
He didn't overestimate their intelligence. It's just that any form of D&D puzzles seems to make even the smartest people perform as if they've never had a shred of situational awareness in their life and that's just the curse of TTRPGs (I've been playing for 5ish years now). It's funny as hell tho.
No it’s because the game would end in under 3 minutes. Nick will be blaming everybody, Vern will be a rage mess, Brent is Brent, and Sophist would 100% be acting suspicious as fuck ON PURPOSE, DOESN’T MATTER HE AIN’T THE IMPOSTER, HE WILL.
fun fact: the double or nothing odds were not 50 / 50. The odds of winning were actually 11/20 (or 55%) while the odds of losing were 9/20 (or 45%). This is because the numbers 1-9 were losing (9 numbers) while numbers 10 - 20 were winning (11 numbers)
Yeah, that was kinda funny. In terms of gambling, that makes it a +EV strategy. That is to say, it'd be one that beats the house with a sufficiently large number of games. What's even funnier is how poorly his rolls went when it mattered.
@pleinairr there wouldn't be a sufficiently large number within any 1 video though, and the consequences are so much harsher than potential rewards outside of healing. doubled bombs means nothing on walls as its still just roll decent to break through, the ending loot being nothing'd means you have to find a new ending, thrown knife damage doesn't seem to scale 1:1 with quantity. if all of these things did genuinely double the reward when winning the 55/45, then you would be right in it being a +EV strategy.
"The traitor knows where the treasure is and the traitor can rig the rolls on the spinning wheel." It's Noah. Noah is the traitor. He has been all along.
“since this is your first time being enraged, you’ll just flail around” does this imply that these are the same entities as the ones from the board games? the lore is wild
@@Victorsandergamer wrote that late at night but basically i think i meant like these people from the rpg's retain their memories from past adventures and board games and vice versa
@AceRubo i think that's true bc some special things about players like thunder spell or the CPR frog or that guy (i forgot the name) what is a half horse and half human or DFD
This is literally a big dilemma in the field of Game Theory and deciding how to resolve situations like this, where one party believes the other turned on them when it never happened, is a big factor in avoiding nuclear war and encouraging disarmament in the real world.
the best bit about the knife borrowing at 1:01:36 is that instead of double or nothing-ing, they could have just offered two knifes out of their infinite knives
@@damianblick4679 I'm so used to the playstyle of throwing 100 knives each turn from these videos I forgot throwing one at a time is just as effective lol
If the party crashers had been this videos *guests* they would 100% have voted someone out within 15 minutes and likely sabotage the survivors. These guys were clearly happy to just let each other cook, no matter how sus.
I love the idea that there’re a group of thieves plan to rob a mansion’s vault but end up delete it to thin air and all the treasure they got is 1 coin under the rock outside the mansion😭
Skip upon learning what his powers are: "Huh, I suppose that's a neat trick to use with responsibility." Skip by the end of it: _sees any object_ "... I can double you."
Atheist games in "Blood on the Clocktower" (there is no demon/werewolf, you must execute the narrator instead. If you are wrong and a demon DOES exist, good guys auto-lose) do tend to produce a lot of paranoia.
*Interesting idea:* Noah, that idea of someone rigging a wheel is actually very interesting, you could do a video in which there is indeed a *traitor* , and that *traitor* can simply decide how much he rolled on the wheel, while other players roll normally, I think the easiest way to do this is just by not actually showing to the players their actual rolls and Noah just declare it, but during the *traitor* rolls he is typing just to Noah the roll he wants, the time it takes for the traitor to type could raise suspicions, but if Noah is secretly rolling for the other players that would also take time and make it fair again. That game would generate so much paranoia and chaos. I leave to someone else to comment what that game could be about or its goal...
@@BreakyOnline I don't think it would take too much effort, Noah did some things similar before, he already rolls wheels, he already hid the screen for the players, when the players were "blind", this time he would just need to hide the wheel not the gameboard, and texting just a simple number to him would not take long, I can see it happening easily
I laughed so hard just because of skip's double or nothing and this is the funniest video I have seen. Surely a second part can be made as the castle is probably not fully explored. Will love to see it
i wouldnt keep my hopes up, he rarely uses the same concept twice. just ignore his "players are blind," "bad trivia," "players change the rules," and so on.
We need more of this, I love Magic the Noah gaslighting content, seeing the players believe in something and then those beliefs getting crushed is always entertaining
You know what’s a great idea. Everything is mimics even the players weapons and bags. Only at the end is that revealed. But in the beginning only a few show themselves like one tree on the top left or a chest/house and slowly increasing as the go to the right until the whole map is a mimic and the ground is too. Then the players find out there weapons are mimics. And it would be really funny if you made their profiles slightly off by just a bit like redrawn or something and reveal they are mimics of themselves
I’ve done this before myself in Mafia, it’s great. Players accuse each other and get confused, sometimes two people will rip each other apart thinking the other is the mafia, detectives get befuddled if they make it to the end. Keeping the dead quiet is always the hardest part!
I think why the "nobody is a tratior" thing didn't really work was because it was so chaotic nobody had time to think about who it could be and everybody played so chaotically you couldn't deduce anything. In the Getaway they had more time to think about who it was so it increased the tension. Though I don't know if this was the intended result.
yeah true, I think the inverse concept people are suggesting of them all being traitors would work a lot better since there would be the intents of malice and active sabotaging
Next time add a traitor to a co-op game, tell everyone else who the traitor is and the traitor that they have to win alone, but everyone wins by helping the traitor win without the traitor realizing
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 ธันวาคม 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dNTiBBthKgQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Telling the players the traitor can rig the rolls on the wheel is diabolical, lol.
Honestly, it makes an "all traitor" game sound genuinely interesting.
All players are rigging their votes to "seem" random
How would one rig a roll on a wheel of names?
yea the best part of that clause is that it would be impossible to do with the program he is using to do rolls lol
@@komaragiri9525 you could prerecord results and play the clip of a certain number
@addchannelname2052 Noah could have a video clip of every wheel space and play the clip that ends on the space the traitor wants.
The moment Skip realized the potential of "double or nothing", that mansion metaphorically went up in flames
Literally, however, large swaths of it vanished into the backrooms, to never be seen again
Had he known what power he had, he'd have double or nothing'd the entire mansion instead of the bombs to enter. They would have had 3 mansions, because it was a nat 20.
should've doubled or nothinged the entire mansion
With how much of its contents were destroyed, flames would be merciful.
"I used to be called the Juice box"
- breaks into the mansion with a bomb
- deletes its residents all life savings
-refuses to elaborate
-obtains vaporeon
-leaves
- in the process of all that skip had the worst luck ever
Failboat: "hands up! this is a robbery!"
skip: "i would like to double the robbery"
(robbery ends)
Also
-Goes in and deletes every vault except the one with puzzle
-Leave
@@JeffTheModderwhy….
*in the distance a copy pasta starts playing*
The fact that they came to basically the same conclusion twice in the goblin puzzle and still struggled both times to execute it is the epitome of dnd. Players can be the smartest people in the world but when playing dnd, they lose all but one braincell and it's just great to watch.
lmao yea it's awesome to watch
Four brains are worse than one! 😂
I thought I was about to see a video about traitor without a traitor. Instead, I saw the greatest video about gambling of the history of this platform.
id argue noah's 32 youtuber gameshow is an even greater video about gambling, but that's just me.
@@exepire7877 that video is also about how conniving spiff is
i think the scavenger hunt won that title now
Next time, make everyone the traitor
Genious
you’re a genius
Watch The Getaway for that, great series but Wendover has already done the concept
so pretty much all of the dnd videos
No thats the generic thing that everyone does though isnt it
I love how it took under 5 seconds for everyone to immediately accept "oh yeah no traitor mhmm yep that makes sense"
It's because there was no information game shenanigans. It was literally just a normal game, but maybe someone's evil.
its magic the noah
If you guys watch one part of this video please watch 59:55
Also the whole video
Will do
7th like
rock pushing skills were indeed useful, that coin was the ultimate win lol
Tell Noah to make a new npc "living rock" looks like a normal rock but if anyone tries to interact with it then it's wakes up and looks like a mossy rock/turtle
good ADCIXE
I love the idea of Skip being double voted out because of double or nothing, and in the next video he appears as a 5th guest, and gets instantly voted out
"has it seen us" followed by him rotating the creature 80 degrees to the right to directly face them was way funnier to me than it should have been
I did something similar for a dnd one shot.
Everyone rolled a d20, and anyone who got above a 15 would be the killer. No one rolled more then a 15, so I just had the inciting ‘murder’ really be an accident, and all following murders were either accidents or caused by the paranoia of the players
some people just wanna watch the world burn
That’s a really fun idea, i might try to do something like that myself
How long took them to figure it out?
@@pieklik3133
They didn’t, after a while they all got into a fight because all of them suspected each other. Two of the 3 PCs died, and the third one failed a dex save, which sent her over a third story staircase to her death.
Then I revealed that there was no killer, and how all the NPCs died of accidents. Then I got called an asshole for an hour while I laughed.
Also, the inciting death of the host was from a heart attack. A big part of the one shot was the players trying to figure out how the killer killed the host without leaving a mark on the body (I am an asshole).
@@thebaldcat6708you are evil. Be my DM
"I dont trust him"-Skip after strapping branzy to a bomb
I like how that was easily the most traitor move but everyone kinda just brushed it off and were suspicious of the bad double or nothing rolls.
@@roboozYea lol
@@roboozcuz he kept rigging the rolls
It's incredible that at some point they realized that the true power of “double or nothing” is not duplicating things, but yes taking them to nothing
E
LETS GO GAMBLING
@@turbo8584 aw dang it!
99% of people who DIDNT win big had this mindset
double or nothing the wall
0:10 I love that you put eyes on Branzy because his logo disk thingy has none
With out eyes you will be trauma traize
lol
“Deal”
“Right… what do you mean deal?!”
It was my favorite moment
Fail: “I’d like to push that rock”
Noah: “We are actually going in turn order, failboat it’s your turn”
Fail: “ok, I’d like to push that rock”
He does that more often than you might think
In before someone say _"We watched the video"_ on the party.
thanks for the subtitles i guess?
this guys so good at writing what people said, he should get an award
@@Anoverlyinterestedfish this guy's so good at being sarcastic, he should get an award
I love how every Noah video eventually becomes a PSA against gambling
or, depending on how you watch it, an ad for gambling
I double or nothing this comment!
@@lego_minifig I love how every Noah video eventually becomes a PSA against gambling
@@EEEEEEEEEEEELDDDGyou're amazing XD
@@lego_minifig you rolled a 1
I always love the point in the recording where Noah gets fed up of how off the rails everything gets. The silent seething rage at how things have utterly spiraled into madness gives me a giggle every single time. Along with the awful rolls that make things so much worse to the point where he's like "yeah a 6 will hit" Love it.
Well,they are goblins
The AI video is the best example of this, bro was praying for them to beat cannondwarf
Sophist: "I cast thunder spell!"
Failboat: _"I PUSH THE ROCKS!"_
Skip: "DOUBLE OR NOTHING"
ngl Branzy was so fire.
"Branzy if you kill our healer-"
"Like he's healing ANYTHING! Don't act like he's useful so far! He's moving rocks, he's a geologist at best!"
Edit: 1.5k likes!?!? I think this is my first time with a popular comment.
Branzy is always a good guy for comedy, and he does redstone so he actually pretty smart
He's used to clown at this point. I feel like he has a leg up here
I'm an English teacher and I once did this with my students before teaching The Crucible. Basically, I told them that they were villagers and they had to vote off the witches, and then at the end I revealed that there had never been any witches.
Oooh, that's a good way to do that, damn.
That is a fantastic teaching method. Damn I wish we did that. (But actually I'm pretty sure we did something similar when taught about the red scare, where some of the class were labeled communists, though I'm pretty sure there were people who got that role so it's not exactly the same, but what is similar is how the people who got accused were mostly not communist's)
So like the real witch hunts
@@pedrolmlkzknow you get it
my teacher did this too lol
Once again, gambling is proven to be the main antagonist of a magic the noah video
As always
Protagonist
Gambling is not a protagonist
It's the love interest
I love how Failboat has been pavlovian conditioned to look for coins
And grabbing flamingos
It's more Skinner's conditioning, as it's done with rewards🤔
And turn himself into a horse when given the opportunity.
Cant belive that there was no shop i love watching failboat think of the most random places to find coins
@@withedoter6277 pavlov's dog was given treats when a bell was rung, then later when he'd ring the bell the dog's mouth would water. soo
I find it really funny that the second Noah said that there wasn't a traitor they all immediately went that it makes sense because they know him well enough to know that's what he'd pull lol
80% of rock pushers stop before they find the second coin
I like to think the goblin puzzle was supposed to be a simple obstacle, but it took so long to solve that Noah decided to make it the endpoint
I think the goblin puzzle was supposed to be a simple obstacle, but it took so long to solve because they simply failed to comprehend the simple puzzle.
@@luciuseclipse What a completely original theory!
(I'm going along with the joke dw.)
I felt real pain every time i saw a path to solving it
WE NEED A PART 2!
@@luciuseclipse I disagree. I think the goblin puzzle was supposed to be a simple obstacle, but they struggled to understand the mechanics for a long time so Noah decided to end the game.
2:43 Idea: tell them there's a "Traitor shop" and that items purchased will be placed for the traitor to "find". Now every time someone finds something they're suspicious
E
evil
thats just evil
other members of the party could grab it tho
@@kaiotrem358you’re not very smart are you? There’s no actual traitor shop and there isn’t a traitor either
Failboat using his insider knowledge, taking screenshots, pushing rocks, grabbing flamingos.
It’s so funny how paranoid and unhinged repeat players slowly become the more they’re subjected to Noah’s schemes and just how much you notice it when they play with new players
Just the sheer differences between veteran Magic The Noah video participants versus the -fresh meat- I mean, new players
Players is a weird way of writing victims
@@eatingyoshi4403 Vell, Noah so far just has players. But Valefisk... Let's just say he went further than Noah on the same path.
One does not go through two videos involving “Smallfrog horse tongue CPR” and come out of it the same man as he was going in.
Well the Flamingo was a win con
@@RedHorseArcherThey need to put the same people in both games and then vote on which was worse. At least Noah doesn't take 8 hours.
Also need to put eachother in games.
Who won:
Sophist
"I CAST THUNDERSPELL!"
Vs
Skip
"Double or nothing"
Put them on a team with at least 4 other people (so they can be the minority by at least 1/3) and watch to see if they’ll team up or compete.
I would love to see a landmine hidden under a rock. "Maybe a coin is under here?" *dies*
I love that failboat immediately went for the flamingo and the others are just confused
It’s funny because failboat has been in a lot of magic the Noah recordings and in those flamingos are usually the goal
@sweatynoob1402 exactly
@@sweatynoob1402 Yeah, his new 'contestants' (aka victims) have no idea what makes it so good, or how Cannon Dwarf (when they show up again) is something from the deepest pits of hell.
1:16:37 The DM when they give the party a simple puzzle and it takes them 3 hours to solve it
This part is starting to drive me insane🥲 they were so close
It is so painful. I made a small labirynth once. 4 months later my players found an exit and it was the best day of my life. Describing the same room at least 5 times each session redefined torture for me. I swore I ll never do a puzzle requiering more than pressing two visible buttons at the same time ever again
Yea its so fucking annoying they literally where so close and the fucked it up
The way I am gaslit into not understanding this puzzle now is wild lmao
I gave a players a puzzle one time at their request. It was a room an enemy had just run into but no enemy was in the room when they entered. After searching the room the first time they found writing on a door with no handle or lock and a mirror opposite the writing. I gave them the writing on a sheet of paper.
For over an hour they were yelling at each other and me over what they found to be an impossible puzzle.
It was just mirror writing that had to be read aloud to open the door. Last puzzle I ever gave players.
oh now we're talking
Fr
9:28
I just remembered among us and now ima watch all your videos again, you and kimi were the best imposters
5up please be in one of these rah
Hi 5up
Nothing has made me laugh quite like Skip fumbling all the Double or Nothing rolls, making everyone think he's the traitor.
gonna be honest the puzzle here was really well made actually, doesn't spell things out and lets the players figure it out, while giving a subtle hint on how to do it
AND they're kind of just fighting shit the whole time it's awesome
Eh this type of puzzle is always more of a pain than it is actually fun to solve though especially with common it is. Its probably the most common type of puzzle in games and is never enjoyable. It is only really entertaining here for how much suffering it causes due to the sheer chaos of everyone's actions
Failboat: pushing rocks
Jay: trying to get things done
Branzy: Actually getting things done
Skip: DOUBLE OR NOTHING
Telling them that the traitor can rig rolls is such an ingenious way to organically make them doubt each other.
I want to think Noah prerecorded a bunch of wheel spins, and that every single wheel was rigged from the start. He made jay roll low, skip fails only the important double or nothings, branzy roll super high, and fail was already throwing
Dont fuckin give him any idea-, wait no actually this is brilliant if youre psychopath
Way to high effort for someone who would create this game to be played seriously, no chance Noah would do that when he just wants to see the chaos his pawns get into on their own accord.
Awesome pfp my guy. Techno never dies!
@@VaporeonEnjoyer1he would do this since it's funny someday
You want to think or you do? Imagine him having a thousand videos open ready to play to show the players the rolls and he has to keep track of it 😂 sounds like a nightmare
Sounds like noah is panicking a little at 58:40 😂
I love those moments when the gameshow gets derailed TOO much
My favorite part. 49:01
Noah: “any specific word you’d like to or two words you’d like to add on to that?”
Branzy: “Pretty Please.”
Noah: “…Any others?”
Skip: “No no, Branzy. Look at your sheet. LOOK AT YOUR SHEET!”
Branzy: “Oh my sheet, of course, sneak attack..”
The fact that They were on the last room for 30 minutes (1/3 of the video) shows that noah overestimated their intelligence
To be fair to them, even without the confusion, the room would have taken a long time, like 15-20 min, because of the amount of turn required
@ true
@@kentlab3850 Also cause Noah bungled the rules at the start which threw everyone off.
He didn't overestimate their intelligence. It's just that any form of D&D puzzles seems to make even the smartest people perform as if they've never had a shred of situational awareness in their life and that's just the curse of TTRPGs (I've been playing for 5ish years now). It's funny as hell tho.
@@kommanderkermit4874 yeah, that clearly didn't help
They should've known Noah wouldn’t put the effort into creating a riggable wheel that looks just like the non-rigged wheel found in his other videos
No, the wheel was always rigged
i'd like to think he prerecorded a bunch a wheels (maybe 3-5 of each number) and rigged everyone's wheel, and he framed basically everyone
@@knight764 people would see the progress bar on the video pop up when he unpauses it, they'd need a special sneaky video player that had zero UI
@@Kekatronic you can just make them gifs
Yeah just use gyazo or just convert mp4s into gifs ⁰@@lasiace
I feel like the sole reason that the Party Crashers weren't picked for this video is because they would be at each others throats in under 3 minutes.
no they would just kick out Sophist in the first nanosecond and then be confused why the game hasn't finished
Sophist would absolutely act as suspicious as possible on purpose just to fuck with them
No it’s because the game would end in under 3 minutes. Nick will be blaming everybody, Vern will be a rage mess, Brent is Brent, and Sophist would 100% be acting suspicious as fuck ON PURPOSE, DOESN’T MATTER HE AIN’T THE IMPOSTER, HE WILL.
fun fact: the double or nothing odds were not 50 / 50. The odds of winning were actually 11/20 (or 55%) while the odds of losing were 9/20 (or 45%). This is because the numbers 1-9 were losing (9 numbers) while numbers 10 - 20 were winning (11 numbers)
Yeah, that was kinda funny. In terms of gambling, that makes it a +EV strategy. That is to say, it'd be one that beats the house with a sufficiently large number of games. What's even funnier is how poorly his rolls went when it mattered.
@pleinairr there wouldn't be a sufficiently large number within any 1 video though, and the consequences are so much harsher than potential rewards outside of healing.
doubled bombs means nothing on walls as its still just roll decent to break through,
the ending loot being nothing'd means you have to find a new ending,
thrown knife damage doesn't seem to scale 1:1 with quantity.
if all of these things did genuinely double the reward when winning the 55/45, then you would be right in it being a +EV strategy.
"Noah doesn't like it when we go out of the slides"
Noah: "it makes me angry."
Horrifying exchange
0:30
“One of you is a taitor”
Those darn traitorous potatoes.
Yeah Its Noah XD
I hate it when my taitors betray me!
What’s taitors precious
Potatoes at the meeting: "Guys, I think there's a pasta among us."
"The traitor knows where the treasure is and the traitor can rig the rolls on the spinning wheel."
It's Noah. Noah is the traitor. He has been all along.
i love how there was clearly a game plan but they did everything but that.
E
would you like to double or nothing what you stated here
Double or nothing the mansion.
its a magic the noah video, isnt that what always happens?
they never even went through the front door
49:11 As assassin "Pretty please"
I dont know why this makes me laugh so long ahahahahah
I really love how the "enraged" sprite hasnt ever changed since it was introduced
“since this is your first time being enraged, you’ll just flail around”
does this imply that these are the same entities as the ones from the board games? the lore is wild
? :o i don't get whatchu mean but i'm intrigued!
@@Victorsandergamer wrote that late at night but basically i think i meant like these people from the rpg's retain their memories from past adventures and board games and vice versa
@@AceRuboI guess since they're real people the lore comnects through all games
@@AceRubo WRITERS, DO YOUR WORK
@AceRubo i think that's true bc some special things about players like thunder spell or the CPR frog or that guy (i forgot the name) what is a half horse and half human or DFD
43:58 its "shia-kazing", a spongebob reference where plankton tried to do magic, yelled "shia-kazing", clapped his hands together, and blew up
I thought of that as soon as i heard it
Skip saying double or nothing has the same vibes as Sophist yelling thunderspell
Fr
Now imagine
Double or nothing on Thunder spell
Noah: I'm never making a puzzle again
Also Noah: Makes a game, which is inherently a puzzle
Me: Checkmate, Noah. You now have to make a puzzle again.
17:28 some inexplicable force is getting rid of the rocks infront of us
This is literally a big dilemma in the field of Game Theory and deciding how to resolve situations like this, where one party believes the other turned on them when it never happened, is a big factor in avoiding nuclear war and encouraging disarmament in the real world.
Why don’t we simply double or nothing all the nuclear bombs to stop nuclear war from ever-happening?
Why don't we simply double or nothing all the nuclear bombs to have a bunch more nukes and have everyone like us?
@@someguy4096 Unfortunately that's when the big rollls come in
Soviet Union: I’d like to double it
@@zamalamahama4894Fun fact: The Cuban missle crisis was a retaliation to Nuclear missles being placed on the Soviet border
1:25:30
Honestly that’s a perfect ending. Everyone has exactly 1 person who thinks they’re the traitor
E
Actually, you're right
That was beautiful and the lie worked as intended
the best bit about the knife borrowing at 1:01:36 is that instead of double or nothing-ing, they could have just offered two knifes out of their infinite knives
He has only 78 left not infinite
@@damianblick4679 we both know he ain't using half of that... lest skip nothinged all of them
*Double or nothing the two knives*
@@damianblick4679 I'm so used to the playstyle of throwing 100 knives each turn from these videos I forgot throwing one at a time is just as effective lol
Branzy: I mean, how many times can you double and it go wrong in a row?
DougDoug literally 2 videos later: Watch me.
Branzy, and Skip are some of my favourite people on TH-cam, and Failboat is my favourite character in the games of Magic The Noah.
I love how Failboat just spent ages looking for a coin even though Noah told him there were none
Yeah, but why would you trust Noah
I mean, it worked out
@@tomduckworth6430 never trust Noah
@tomduckworth6430 never trust Noah
Nah "Double or Nothing Jay's lips" is crazy work
If the party crashers had been this videos *guests* they would 100% have voted someone out within 15 minutes and likely sabotage the survivors. These guys were clearly happy to just let each other cook, no matter how sus.
Wdym party crashers
@@Drunken_catSophist, Nick, Vernias and Brent. Their joined channel is called Party Crashers.
@@DarthMolgy Ahh okay mb
1:12:27 there's a reference to Nick here I think with the subtitles lol
@@ReignyRain AHAH i didn't see this in my first watch-through! good catch!
The fact rhese guys are all close friends makes this 10x better
Dan: ROCKS!
Skip: DOUBLE OR NOTHING
Branzy: hits 20s all the time
Jay: actually playing the game
There was always a traitor, we never saw him do, I wish it was sophist
I cast Thunderspell
Yayayaya
Noah was the traitor
Skip is definitely the sophist of this group
OF COURSE HE CASTED THUNDERSPELL ON THEM IT WAS SO OBVIOUS
Double or nothing is the new THUNDERSPELL
I love the idea that there’re a group of thieves plan to rob a mansion’s vault but end up delete it to thin air and all the treasure they got is 1 coin under the rock outside the mansion😭
yknow, after seeing failboat on exploding tnt like 10 years ago, its crazy seeing him here and nobody even knowing where he's from
Right?
Skip upon learning what his powers are: "Huh, I suppose that's a neat trick to use with responsibility."
Skip by the end of it: _sees any object_ "... I can double you."
“Congratulations you’ve won the lottery!”
“…”
“…”
“…Double or nothing”
How many levels of deception does a social deduction game have where no one is evil?
either none or 2*n
@@bruhzzer Awww you didn't say the line
Atheist games in "Blood on the Clocktower" (there is no demon/werewolf, you must execute the narrator instead. If you are wrong and a demon DOES exist, good guys auto-lose) do tend to produce a lot of paranoia.
*Interesting idea:* Noah,
that idea of someone rigging a wheel is actually very interesting, you could do a video in which there is indeed a *traitor* , and that *traitor* can simply decide how much he rolled on the wheel, while other players roll normally, I think the easiest way to do this is just by not actually showing to the players their actual rolls and Noah just declare it, but during the *traitor* rolls he is typing just to Noah the roll he wants, the time it takes for the traitor to type could raise suspicions, but if Noah is secretly rolling for the other players that would also take time and make it fair again. That game would generate so much paranoia and chaos. I leave to someone else to comment what that game could be about or its goal...
yeah that would be interesting
Too much effort, also its not your turn, you lose a heart
@@BreakyOnline I don't think it would take too much effort, Noah did some things similar before, he already rolls wheels, he already hid the screen for the players, when the players were "blind", this time he would just need to hide the wheel not the gameboard, and texting just a simple number to him would not take long, I can see it happening easily
this is magical, they remind me of TAZ podcast in season 1 where they all still sucked at D&D but roleplayed it so well it worked
I'm a simple person. I see branzy in the thumbnail and I know the chaos approaches.
the doubling and nothing'ing the knife on the ground was so funny
one third of the entire video being spent on a single puzzle checks out
I laughed so hard just because of skip's double or nothing and this is the funniest video I have seen. Surely a second part can be made as the castle is probably not fully explored. Will love to see it
The failhorse frog tongue cpr videos were really hilarious, but this is definitely in my top 5 at least…
i wouldnt keep my hopes up, he rarely uses the same concept twice. just ignore his "players are blind," "bad trivia," "players change the rules," and so on.
They spent a solid 25 minutes before they even entered the mansion 💀💀
They should've known right from the beginning that there was no traitor, because you literally cannot rig the randomizer wheel Noah uses
the whole double or nothing ability was the best thing you could've given them holy
I like how Noah vaguely said the traitor can rig the rolls, but nobody stopped to think about the fact that there is no way to do that discreetly.
Sure there is, just have a wheel prerecorded for every result and spin that tab instead when requested
the fact that the last half an hour was just the goblin puzzle lol
Skip's perspective is titled 'I ruined a Magic The Noah Video', which made me chuckle because like, how does one ruin a Magic The Noah video?
Its very simple how one ruins a Noah video, Gambling addiction.
skip becomes evie
evie:loves thunder spell
skip:love making objects duplicate or be obliterated
We need more of this, I love Magic the Noah gaslighting content, seeing the players believe in something and then those beliefs getting crushed is always entertaining
lol evil... pls do more @MagicTheNoah!
but fr his videos remind me of DNSL i love this type of content
I love that it took 0 seconds for everyone to against each other
E
@@EEEEEEEEshut up
@@EEEEEEEE Will this guy shut up...? I swear, I see this bot everywhere, and it gets on my nerves...
@WPS007 E
"I'm never making another puzzle again" ~ Said by every DM at least once in their career
Skip: I DOUBLE OR NOTHING EVERY ENEMY😂😂😂
Can't do it on the living, only the Inanimate objects can be gambled
He can’t double enemies or teammates
The moment I saw a puzzle with THIS GROUP, I knew they were not getting past this
You know what’s a great idea. Everything is mimics even the players weapons and bags. Only at the end is that revealed. But in the beginning only a few show themselves like one tree on the top left or a chest/house and slowly increasing as the go to the right until the whole map is a mimic and the ground is too. Then the players find out there weapons are mimics. And it would be really funny if you made their profiles slightly off by just a bit like redrawn or something and reveal they are mimics of themselves
Make the players Noah drawings and just say it's a raise in the budget
@ that’s the best idea ever
and if anyone tries to get a mimic detector noah just denies it
This would be good revenge for the mimic detector
@ yeah perfect!
Noah's videos are quickly becoming movies and I am for it
Them doing the goblin puzzle hurt to watch. Loved the video, please make more.
I’ve done this before myself in Mafia, it’s great. Players accuse each other and get confused, sometimes two people will rip each other apart thinking the other is the mafia, detectives get befuddled if they make it to the end. Keeping the dead quiet is always the hardest part!
This channel brings like every TH-camr I went through a phase of loving
I think why the "nobody is a tratior" thing didn't really work was because it was so chaotic nobody had time to think about who it could be and everybody played so chaotically you couldn't deduce anything. In the Getaway they had more time to think about who it was so it increased the tension. Though I don't know if this was the intended result.
I feel like either way it was crazy fun tho, also most of his videos are chaos, and thats what I enjoy about watching him.
yeah true, I think the inverse concept people are suggesting of them all being traitors would work a lot better since there would be the intents of malice and active sabotaging
Next time add a traitor to a co-op game, tell everyone else who the traitor is and the traitor that they have to win alone, but everyone wins by helping the traitor win without the traitor realizing
what are you even saying? lol
Traitor thinks they’re being sneaky but everyone knows and is trying to help them
4:18 Someone saying "woah, scamming" and "logan paul reference" on the top of the screen is crazy
Noah starts to die inside watching them trying to solve the puzzle and conclude not making anymore puzzles is genuinely funny lmao.
Hahahahaha I didn't think you could top Cannondwarf but damn it Noah you proved me wrong. That goblin puzzle was especially painful to watch.