I’ve played with blue like 5 times and they are like that every single time. Non stop whining and complaining and then saying hypocritical stuff to everyone else 😂 Absolute last name I want to see when I load up a game.
I don’t even play catan but sometimes for some reason I just love to listen to this guy talk about catan. Even though I don’t know what’s even going on half the time 😂
Big mistake @21:00. You said it yourself, you shouldn’t be buying any more devs after pulling the second VP. Settling for 9 on the wheat port is the right play. Sure, a knight unblocks your 10 wheat, but it’s far too slow given orange’s position.
Man thats a rough start, the gang robbing took its toll 4 sure. Its rough when you have a decent set up, but everyone over values it as an amazing GOD Tier set up. Especially when someone elses setup is either just as good or better.
@@JohnSmithEx he wasnt even on an amazing setup. he would have gotten that amazing setup if he got his village up before the gang rob. thats the main problem
@@mauer1How about not starting with a setup that will soon be amazing, unless you are gang robbed? Choosing such a setup is like begging to be gang robbed.
@@JohnSmithEx what I am saying. He relied on the table to either understand that black might be a bigger villain or to not be able to rob him before he gets everything. Risks he doesn't need to get into if he is the better player. And if he isn't, he should get better instead of having to rely on such risks. Beeing in the position to kill black off himself sounds much better when black is a secret killer.
Really don’t understand why he pulled… and twice which is (basically) a city and i’m sure he could’ve settled through that with all the wood and brick he got
@@yorai26 I said it's not impossible with his setup, he has the cards in hand one way or another. Never commented on whether it's a good decision. Also if he has 10 cards in hand he can almost definitely do a 3:1 somewhere for the last ore instead of 2 devs And finally if you're worried about monos and 7 outs, you should be equally worried about pulling only knight from the deck(dyl said he knew there were a lot of knights left in deck, his words not mine). He didn't really have many winning draws from the deck, mono could be worthless, yop would be bad if he drew it as the second dev (cuz he burned all his city resources). Really was only a hunt for the vp(s)
Why are you always throwing the winchance away by pulling TWICE while being at 8 points that makes no sense and you said it yourself the deck is full of knights and even if you pull year of plenty it only gives you 2 free cards you already have in your hand. And this time and a few games before it 100% would have won you the game if you just settled. Your greed for devs is ruining your climb.
Rage babies who can't read the board are the absolute bane of online Catan. I mean, I guess if you're a skilled manipulator you could actually weaponize their ignorance, but it feels too much like being a con-man.
So you would prefer to be matched against stronger opponents who are better at reading the board? In that case not only you would lose more frequently, but also you wouldn't have the excuse that you lost because your opponents played badly. "Oh, no, I lost because my opponent made a mistake!" What a pathetic excuse for a loss!
@@JohnSmithEx You absolutely can lose in Catan from opponents making mistakes. Their lack of reading the board with an added bonus of emotional play REALLY makes the game hard, especially since he was the one that boned blue at the start. Overall, I would much rather play a solid player than an emotional one because it makes the game far more enjoyable, just like how playing against the family member that ragequits all the time is no fun
@@notmewastakenI agree that you can lose from mistakes made by opponents. My point is that you can also win from such mistakes. Sometimes you'll be the lucky beneficiary of an opponent's mistake, and sometimes someone else will. It's a matter of luck, just like the dev cards and the dice. But statistically the farthest from infallible your opponents are, the largest your winning percentage is going to be. Now whether you find it more enjoyable to lose playing against solid players, than to win playing against emotional players, is totally subjective, and I am not judging you for your preference.
Hey Dylighted, I was Orange in this game. Good game. I appreciate you did not enjoy the attention from the robber this game, but it made sense to rile up people against you. ;-) You also predicted it though. The disconnect was unfortunate, but good to see it extended the game and added a twist to the video!
I think you can still point 5 9 10 point left, if black plows you by taking 6 4 11 he leaves the 3 9 11 or 6 3 11 open for you and the whole middle of the board
@@catanace1741he could’ve done it the other way around too, ie play an agro knight after he settles to try to get an ore or wheat. Either way he really had to play that knight there
A database of emotional players is a great idea. Also, we need a "wall of shame" for players that actively sabotage and cheat games, since Colonist NEVER takes action against them. It's the anonymous factor that makes people so freely toxic. 95% of what happens online would never happen in an in person game.
@@JohnSmithEx Knowing someone plays emotionally rather than logically helps IMMENSELY with game theory. It's somewhat difficult to predict what someone playing logically might do, as there might be many different moves (and levels of intelligence TO those moves) that might benefit their game. BUT, someone who plays emotionally is easy to predict. Their underdeveloped Pre-Frontal Cortex makes their actions almost robotic. The hard part is knowing whether someone is that way or not until it's too late. Having a database where you can quickly C+F their username would be immensely helpful.
@@Drillbitaylerusually the signs of an emotional player appear quite early in the game, for example in the chat, in the road placements or in the early gameplay. And these signs are more fresh and reliable, than an entry in a database that was entered months earlier by a stranger. So this hypothetical database could only give you an early warning of what might be revealed during the game anyway. What would you do with this early warning? Would you avoid for example cutting-off an emotional player, like Dylan did to Blue at 4:01 in this game? Conversely would you cut-off Blue if you knew for sure that Blue is a solid coldblooded player who never reacts emotionally?
rank 70 and ppl steal rage stealing you cuz 8-4 plow... i think so catan needs in additional rule - after 4(or 5) in a row steals you can use free knight (which is not count as a used knight but just for free) or somethin like that for balance or some, or maybe after 4 steals at x-first moves knight just goes on random spot on the map...
1:28 "This 5-9-10 is also decent. [...] that's pretty ugly! [...] ah, this is pretty ugly, ha ha!" -- Dylan mocking Orange for their ugly setup. Hindsight 20/20. 🙂
You're way too obsessed with devs and it drives you to low EV plays, I think it is a hangup from when you played almost exclusively OWS. Need to be more flexible in playstyle and win condition.
Dylan wants to climb the ladder and get the "notgoodenuf" account to #1. To do this he must play to his strengths. Playing unfamiliar road setups won't cut it.
Brother, he already had a road setup, but porting everything for ores then popping when he already said there was a high concentration of knights is a low EV play. Sometimes getting the easy settle and saving for the city is a better play. @@JohnSmithEx
@@DrOmegaBattleSphere starting with a road setup was Dylan's critical mistake in this game. After that, playing suboptimally was to be expected. After seeing his setup, I was pretty sure that he will lose horribly and unspectacularly. Btw no offense, but I am not your brother. I am also not a fan of Dandy Drew, which might explain why I dislike being called "brother".
@@JohnSmithEx All men are brothers, this is inescapable. Defaulting to OWS every game will never make you a really top player. Sometimes the position and board just doesn't allow it.
@@DrOmegaBattleSphereaccording to Wikipedia, brother is a man or boy who shares one or more parents with another. I.e. a male sibling. So unless we have the same mother or father, we are not brothers. We might be, who knows, but the chances are extremely slim. Considering that I was raised by a married couple along with my two sisters, calling me a brother questions indirectly the ethics of either my mother, or yours. Being a good road player requires mental abilities that Dylan just don't have. Abilities like spatial awareness, exhaustive path finding and fast counting. His other talents largely compensate for this inability, but yes becoming #1 without mastering road play should be extremely difficult.
4:01 "Let's do the 8-4. The problem with the 8-4 makes me look so scary." -- Not only it makes you look scary, it makes you actually scary. I mean, it makes the average player scary. Your opponent didn't know that they are playing against Dylighted, who is so bad at road-play. 🙂
Rough table. Maybe blue & black were acting childish purposefully to try and put everyone else on tilt? So much easier to get that kinda read in person.
I wish these people who hate playing Catan would stop playing Catan 😂 If you couldn’t win I’m glad it was orange I could not have witnessed these crybabies taking a win lol
Misplay in the last round. He could have ported 2 wheat for an ore and pulled for the win. Shame. He didn't even see it post game. That's why he isn't #1 yet. He has a lot to learn.
He didn’t have enough wheat to port and buy a dev after he settled, he only had two and he needed 3. Now he could’ve and should’ve played an agro knight to try to steal a wheat or ore in order to pop
Blue: "Worst type of player, revenge loser"
Didn't he..? Start the game saying he was going to target you the entire game for cutting him off?
I was looking for this comment 😂😂
Man, I bet blue watched this is felt embarrassed lol
Oh man I've played Samkoz a few times before, he's exactly like this in every game lol
Blue dares to say "revenge loser" at the end after being a crybaby about the plow at the beginning...
I’ve played with blue like 5 times and they are like that every single time. Non stop whining and complaining and then saying hypocritical stuff to everyone else 😂 Absolute last name I want to see when I load up a game.
I don’t even play catan but sometimes for some reason I just love to listen to this guy talk about catan. Even though I don’t know what’s even going on half the time 😂
Same
These opponents are insane. “Never really. Production too strong.” while everyone else already has a settlement and Blues a card away from the city…
How do you explain this? What triggered their insanity? Maybe the mysterious "notgoodenuf" nickname played a role?
Big mistake @21:00. You said it yourself, you shouldn’t be buying any more devs after pulling the second VP. Settling for 9 on the wheat port is the right play. Sure, a knight unblocks your 10 wheat, but it’s far too slow given orange’s position.
Man thats a rough start, the gang robbing took its toll 4 sure. Its rough when you have a decent set up, but everyone over values it as an amazing GOD Tier set up. Especially when someone elses setup is either just as good or better.
How about not starting with an amazing setup, and let someone else be the target of the robber?
@@dk0932??
@@JohnSmithEx
he wasnt even on an amazing setup.
he would have gotten that amazing setup if he got his village up before the gang rob.
thats the main problem
@@mauer1How about not starting with a setup that will soon be amazing, unless you are gang robbed? Choosing such a setup is like begging to be gang robbed.
@@JohnSmithEx what I am saying.
He relied on the table to either understand that black might be a bigger villain or to not be able to rob him before he gets everything.
Risks he doesn't need to get into if he is the better player.
And if he isn't, he should get better instead of having to rely on such risks.
Beeing in the position to kill black off himself sounds much better when black is a secret killer.
If you would’ve just built the settle for 9 instead of pulling for knights I think you would have won.
Really don’t understand why he pulled… and twice which is (basically) a city and i’m sure he could’ve settled through that with all the wood and brick he got
He would need to find the 10th point, and a city with his setup is basically impossible
@@Drengen10 2 devs is almost a city's worth, just needs a 3:1
@@zwxyer he can't just pass with 8-10 cards and hold for the city. He wanted to port and hold but was afraid from a mono
@@yorai26 I said it's not impossible with his setup, he has the cards in hand one way or another. Never commented on whether it's a good decision.
Also if he has 10 cards in hand he can almost definitely do a 3:1 somewhere for the last ore instead of 2 devs
And finally if you're worried about monos and 7 outs, you should be equally worried about pulling only knight from the deck(dyl said he knew there were a lot of knights left in deck, his words not mine). He didn't really have many winning draws from the deck, mono could be worthless, yop would be bad if he drew it as the second dev (cuz he burned all his city resources). Really was only a hunt for the vp(s)
Holy shit these dudes were so toxic
And that's why I wish Colonist had a blocking option
Whom would you block?
@@JohnSmithExblack I presume
@@psyche1182I would block notgoodenuf for having a silly username. 🙂
emotional players are the worst but black was so funny
I hoped for a national analysis video but i guess he already summed it
@@Peter-q1p7tdandy is releasing a video on some of the boards next week, hopefully he talks about the semi and the final as well
Why are you always throwing the winchance away by pulling TWICE while being at 8 points that makes no sense and you said it yourself the deck is full of knights and even if you pull year of plenty it only gives you 2 free cards you already have in your hand. And this time and a few games before it 100% would have won you the game if you just settled. Your greed for devs is ruining your climb.
Rage babies who can't read the board are the absolute bane of online Catan. I mean, I guess if you're a skilled manipulator you could actually weaponize their ignorance, but it feels too much like being a con-man.
So you would prefer to be matched against stronger opponents who are better at reading the board? In that case not only you would lose more frequently, but also you wouldn't have the excuse that you lost because your opponents played badly. "Oh, no, I lost because my opponent made a mistake!" What a pathetic excuse for a loss!
@@JohnSmithEx You absolutely can lose in Catan from opponents making mistakes. Their lack of reading the board with an added bonus of emotional play REALLY makes the game hard, especially since he was the one that boned blue at the start. Overall, I would much rather play a solid player than an emotional one because it makes the game far more enjoyable, just like how playing against the family member that ragequits all the time is no fun
@@notmewastakenI agree that you can lose from mistakes made by opponents. My point is that you can also win from such mistakes. Sometimes you'll be the lucky beneficiary of an opponent's mistake, and sometimes someone else will. It's a matter of luck, just like the dev cards and the dice. But statistically the farthest from infallible your opponents are, the largest your winning percentage is going to be.
Now whether you find it more enjoyable to lose playing against solid players, than to win playing against emotional players, is totally subjective, and I am not judging you for your preference.
I love this overlay, maybe colonist should get back to it, trade offers makes sense here.
Like for spoiler shield 🛡
Just an oof game 😭😂 but definitely agro knight at the end for a pull chance no?
Yeah both orange and blue were agreeing at the beginning to rob you, wild game overall
I mean it was a good decision by them, feel like dylighted always undershows his position
i have no idea whats happening or whats being explained and why, but i am invested
4-6-11 would’ve been much stronger than 8-4 plow on blue. Early game was a struggle because you kept getting solo blocked
He got solo blocked because blue was the one rolling the 7s
Hey Dylighted, I was Orange in this game. Good game. I appreciate you did not enjoy the attention from the robber this game, but it made sense to rile up people against you. ;-) You also predicted it though.
The disconnect was unfortunate, but good to see it extended the game and added a twist to the video!
I think you can still point 5 9 10 point left, if black plows you by taking 6 4 11 he leaves the 3 9 11 or 6 3 11 open for you and the whole middle of the board
You had the wheat port! You could have still ported for an ore without even needing to play an aggressive knight on the last turn!
he had one sheep and 2 wheat. he could not have ported without having 3 wheats. so needed to play the knight. But he had some questionable plays ngl.
@@nandgate69 he could dev first, and then if he got a vp, he could use the knight to try and hunt for the last card to settle.
@@catanace1741he could’ve done it the other way around too, ie play an agro knight after he settles to try to get an ore or wheat. Either way he really had to play that knight there
"knew you'd do that"
so you have... chosen death? 🤨
A database of emotional players is a great idea. Also, we need a "wall of shame" for players that actively sabotage and cheat games, since Colonist NEVER takes action against them. It's the anonymous factor that makes people so freely toxic. 95% of what happens online would never happen in an in person game.
How would you utilize a database of emotional players to your advantage?
@@JohnSmithEx Knowing someone plays emotionally rather than logically helps IMMENSELY with game theory. It's somewhat difficult to predict what someone playing logically might do, as there might be many different moves (and levels of intelligence TO those moves) that might benefit their game. BUT, someone who plays emotionally is easy to predict. Their underdeveloped Pre-Frontal Cortex makes their actions almost robotic. The hard part is knowing whether someone is that way or not until it's too late. Having a database where you can quickly C+F their username would be immensely helpful.
@@Drillbitaylerusually the signs of an emotional player appear quite early in the game, for example in the chat, in the road placements or in the early gameplay. And these signs are more fresh and reliable, than an entry in a database that was entered months earlier by a stranger. So this hypothetical database could only give you an early warning of what might be revealed during the game anyway. What would you do with this early warning? Would you avoid for example cutting-off an emotional player, like Dylan did to Blue at 4:01 in this game? Conversely would you cut-off Blue if you knew for sure that Blue is a solid coldblooded player who never reacts emotionally?
rank 70 and ppl steal rage stealing you cuz 8-4 plow... i think so catan needs in additional rule - after 4(or 5) in a row steals you can use free knight (which is not count as a used knight but just for free) or somethin like that for balance or some, or maybe after 4 steals at x-first moves knight just goes on random spot on the map...
if you suspect black beeing the secret killer, why not just get rid of him yourself?
1:28 "This 5-9-10 is also decent. [...] that's pretty ugly! [...] ah, this is pretty ugly, ha ha!" -- Dylan mocking Orange for their ugly setup. Hindsight 20/20. 🙂
You're way too obsessed with devs and it drives you to low EV plays, I think it is a hangup from when you played almost exclusively OWS. Need to be more flexible in playstyle and win condition.
Dylan wants to climb the ladder and get the "notgoodenuf" account to #1. To do this he must play to his strengths. Playing unfamiliar road setups won't cut it.
Brother, he already had a road setup, but porting everything for ores then popping when he already said there was a high concentration of knights is a low EV play. Sometimes getting the easy settle and saving for the city is a better play. @@JohnSmithEx
@@DrOmegaBattleSphere starting with a road setup was Dylan's critical mistake in this game. After that, playing suboptimally was to be expected. After seeing his setup, I was pretty sure that he will lose horribly and unspectacularly.
Btw no offense, but I am not your brother. I am also not a fan of Dandy Drew, which might explain why I dislike being called "brother".
@@JohnSmithEx All men are brothers, this is inescapable.
Defaulting to OWS every game will never make you a really top player. Sometimes the position and board just doesn't allow it.
@@DrOmegaBattleSphereaccording to Wikipedia, brother is a man or boy who shares one or more parents with another. I.e. a male sibling. So unless we have the same mother or father, we are not brothers. We might be, who knows, but the chances are extremely slim. Considering that I was raised by a married couple along with my two sisters, calling me a brother questions indirectly the ethics of either my mother, or yours.
Being a good road player requires mental abilities that Dylan just don't have. Abilities like spatial awareness, exhaustive path finding and fast counting. His other talents largely compensate for this inability, but yes becoming #1 without mastering road play should be extremely difficult.
Blue and black remind me of Phil Hellmuth. But not as good as he is.
4:01 "Let's do the 8-4. The problem with the 8-4 makes me look so scary." -- Not only it makes you look scary, it makes you actually scary. I mean, it makes the average player scary. Your opponent didn't know that they are playing against Dylighted, who is so bad at road-play. 🙂
blue is that you?
@@klauspeters8487 fascinating. I can see a world where I was Blue.
Rough table. Maybe blue & black were acting childish purposefully to try and put everyone else on tilt? So much easier to get that kinda read in person.
Spoilers
Spoiler Blocking Comment
Trying one more time..... with multiple accounts =P
Sooo many long ads !!!! Jaysus this is ridiculous
Lost to bot idk that rank 1 goal is going down the toilet 🤣🤣
I wish these people who hate playing Catan would stop playing Catan 😂 If you couldn’t win I’m glad it was orange I could not have witnessed these crybabies taking a win lol
Responding first?
Misplay in the last round. He could have ported 2 wheat for an ore and pulled for the win. Shame. He didn't even see it post game. That's why he isn't #1 yet. He has a lot to learn.
He didn’t have enough wheat to port and buy a dev after he settled, he only had two and he needed 3. Now he could’ve and should’ve played an agro knight to try to steal a wheat or ore in order to pop