Thank you Mr Roy , I was 7 years old boy at the time . 1950 riot was horrendous. Shortly afterwards on 13 th of March we all left our ancestral home and left East Pakistan . No one talk about that exodus. My father’s friend with his whole were slaughter over Bhoirob bridge and thrown in the river. Very traumatic memory
My mother’s side was from Pabna’ Sirajgunge ( were landed gentry ) and my father’s side was from Dhaka Manickgunge. 2 of my “mashi” maternal aunts ( my late mother ‘s first paternal cousin sisters ) were raped and forcibly converted to Sunni Islam and forced into marriage with Bengali Muslims while the extended family members were escaping the barbaric Anti Hindu pogroms being perpetrated by the Pakistani Khan Sena and Bengali speaking Jamaat affiliated Muslims during 1971 ! 3 years later both of them committed suicide ! Many of them escaped the Anti Hindu riots / pogroms - wisely during 1947-50 but some of them stayed back with inane illusions like the famous Dalit Bengali Hindu politician Jogen Mondol and his ilk did during 1947-50 ; and had to pay horrendous price like I stated !
I am a Bangladeshi hindu writing from Sylhet, Bangladesh. I am greatful to to listen something special from such a wise person , its seems like Roy sir is speaking on behalf of Bangladeshi hindus. Nobody could so open like him,Bangladeshi muslim mind getting darker each day. This is the responsiblity to take necessary action from humanitarian point of view. whatever happens in Bangladesh hindus must be safe & sound & establish DHARMA. No matter what,India and Indian's hindus are our last hope
Does Hindu in Bangladesh has less rights in Bangladesh than Muslims...!!!!!!! During the student protest why no one attacked Hindus but why they attacked later after the victory over dictator??? What makes you feel that whatever happened to the Hindus in Bangladesh was only to target because of their Minor identity....????
@@krishnabhan6098 Main reasons - 1. A lot of hindus taking refuge in India during our liberation war didn’t returned. You will get the numbers if you check your national database. 2. Birth rate among muslims are almost double(if not more) in the sub-continent than that of the Hindus. Other reasons - * Hindus like to settle in India because most of the spiritual sites of their religion is there. * Hindus are easily given citizenship in India. They like to migrate as it is economically prosperous than Bangladesh.
@@KolipokiMB then stay strong based on knowledge of Geeta, nurture strength, analyse personality of Shri Krishna, and build a powerful fort. Cooperate and make a tough link. Learn from Israelis, how to counter decisively
As long as Indian media and their experts are in turmoil Bangladesh is in right position 😅 does India really support the people of Bangladesh or Hasina or any specific community ???
That is quite vissible. Looting , dacuti, labour strike, price rise, no police , mass resignation of professors. It is very easy to blame india and ignore own problem.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990who got caught they were Awami League party people. They tried to show that this govt is a failure and indian media shows it Hasina still gave her terror attack in Bangladesh.
@@Mehdi-JonyBangladeshi youth thinks that they gained freedom from Hasina madame's dictatorship.But the religious fanatics used this revolution as an excuse to morph this youth movement into a zombie apocalypse...constant chaos,burning of minorities houses and smashing of Hindu temples,beating up of college students,smashing the statues of freedom fighters,economic collapse,feeble military and para military security.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 , you are explaining something in a wrong way , no one is blaming you for Bangldesh problems right now.. but India's involvement with Hasina's bad deeds are proven truth... you might want to deny that but Hasina's shelter in India proves a lot.. Modi does not want his involvement to be revealed in the world , he might try to send Hasina somewhere far and in worst case Hasina might loose her life. modi at any cost would bury the secrets with her...
Because they have gone insane as Bangladeshi youth has come to understand India's heinous conspiracy.they exploited us with the help of Awami league for years.They have hostile relation with all their neighbours.we were the only one left that also slipped.so they have gone mad😂😂😂😂
@@gulapiokram3613 a further study required. Islam practised by Pakistan consider Bangladeshis of lower standards, while Bangladeshis try to appease them!!!
@@FDTLSM-sr1iy sorry, its the other way round. It seems you have stolen the words of Hinduism. Muslims, after facing severe reverts in stealing property and women of Hindus, have resorted now to steal knowledge and stamp in their name, how shameful!!
CAA requirements must be changed to allow minorities of Bangladesh. 2014 cutoff date does not work for Hindus, who would wish to migrate due to inhumane treatments of them.
Please save bangladeshi Hindus 🙏,We Hindus are under a lot of pressure, soon after the journalists leave, they start again, they told us that we should not tell there was any attack, we can't say anything more.😢, please request your govt not to issue any type of Visa towards Bangladeshi Muslim, it will be a life saving help 😢🙏 We Bangladeshi Hindus are not even equal to animals, No one cares, we are kafer, মালাউনের বাচ্ছা, মালু, so on😢
@@banjaminparker2034 banduk kahase milenge? Hamare pas ab na rahe ghar , na rahe Naukri, na janeka koi thikana, un logone socha mar pitke vaga denge to India dur honge, Bahut taklif me Hun, aplogo ko andaja nehi 😔
To all the Bangladeshi radical muslims why don't u make ur constitution SECULAR as it was to prove ur point that hindus r respected in ur ISLAMIC REPUBLIC!
@@wahidmurad9589 our constitution is secular. You bozo. That's why EDUCATION is important. In india muslims % is going High it's not like your country where the minorities % is going low year after year. Real bozoo
@@vish3161 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Do paysa ka pepsi, godi media propagndusts are sexy..... What a country!!! Hoe come an nation can this much ignorant!!! #Rendi_propaganda
@noneoftheabove666 Terrible English 😮😮😮😮. Our 1st language is Bangla. So, It's okay to do any mistake when it comes to communicate in others language. Your PM Modi also doesn’t have enough knowledge of English. Language is a medium of communication. When you don't have any logical argument you talk about irrelevant issues. You are also the supporters of Godi media.
@arindambaisya 🇧🇩 If India thinks Bangladesh is on the wrong way, that means we are on the right path (2). We know the history of how India got control of Sikkim. Do not try to fool Bangladeshi people.
Bengali hindus is the most persecuted community in subcontinent whether by bangladeahi jihadi population or by Pakistan army during Bangladesh liberation war. Hindus were 1/4 of east bengal population before partitions but now they are less then 8% of population of Bangladesh.
Give me a Data, how many houses of Hindus in Bangladesh were bulldozed in last 15 years? Man we don"t need to learn Harmony from India. You are always welcome to visit BD and take a look on the people of Hindus here. Don't be fooled by your GODI Media, Instead of these trash-talk show, have a look on any ground report of current situation, youll surely get another view.
@@taketrick2725The houses of Hindus were no bulldozed but burnt and vandalized ......and whose houses are bulldozed in India ??? Only those who have criminal antecedents .So ,that's the difference .
Deep Halder seems to have an unhealthy obsession with Bangladesh's politics rather than working towards improving his his home country of India, which is riddled with unemployment, a virulent caste system, a lack of toilets and sanitation, poverty, a lack of security for women, and an overall legacy of underdevelopment. Most educated Indians that I observe here in the US will leave India and never look back, and it seems the rest like him try to instigate communal tension in their neighboring countries.
He's a reporter focused on Bangladesh, not that he's obsessed with your craphole country. Major publications have correspondents that focus on regions and Bangladesh is one of his areas
Actually he was not comfortable in the entire interview. He realized it early and was looking quite perturbed, uneasy when he interviewed him. Print should have some common sense not to deploy people who had been associated with BJP ( even if they tell the real story) for the interview.They should have made an interview for the Qadri who heads that Nizam-e- something on his views on Hindus. Always get information from horses mouth and verify the horse action.
He is a journalist and he has every right to get on with topics he is passionate about. There is no paucity of journalists in India who can talk about internal issues. Perhaps, people like you who downplay hindu genocide to please your sickular friends, must get over the unhealthy obsession of equalizing everything to uphold the theory of sickularism.
@@rajchakraborty6320 he actually has written a book on Marijappi massacre and he talked about it in pondy lit festival . He was very comfortable in his skin. Here I think he was under watch or pressure and is visible. You can check the pondy lit festival, deep and kanchan gupta have a discussion about Bangladeshi Hindus. Definitely the Print ecosystem is to be blamed. Understand if someone gets paid although you are ideologically poles apart you may actually end up working up for the opposite cause or direction
Tathagat ji, also mention that, the firm belief of Bengalis, which method of Independence they would follow, Netaji's or Gandhi's. This clarity was terribly missing. They were a confused lot, and there was no visionary leader, except Shayama da, who at the end was left alone.
@@racer2123-dx6fv Indian Muslims are hundred times safer than Bangladeshi Muslims. A large number of Bangladeshi Muslims migrate illegally from Bangladesh. So don't say anything without knowing. Muslims are the second-largest religious group in India, and their population has been growing steadily for several decades. According to the 2011 census, Muslims made up 14.2% of India's population, up from 10.6% in 1951. 😂😂😂You lied and you are not ashamed to call yourself a Muslim. Does the Qur'an teach this? 😂😂
@@racer2123-dx6fv Indian Muslims are hundred times safer than Bangladeshi Muslims. A large number of Bangladeshi Muslims migrate illegally from Bangladesh. So don't say anything without knowing. Muslims are the second-largest religious group in India, and their population has been growing steadily for several decades. According to the 2011 census, Muslims made up 14.2% of India's population, up from 10.6% in 1951. Why does their population grow if they are not protected? If you worry too much, take them.
India is not criticizing Bangladesh. An Indian news channel has posted an interview of a subject matter expert of Bangladesh. You are taking offense to it because he's speaking the truth. You do not want to admit that you converted to a violent religion that converts people to their religion by hook or by crook.
Well it's doesn't matter its not about right or wrong... But Both India and Bangladesh should co-operate eachother and exchange territories Parts of India which wants to follow Sharia law should join Bangladesh and part Bangladesh which want to follow Hinduism should merge with India In this way we can maintain peace & harmony in the region
🇧🇩 Even the Hindus in Bangladesh know who are with them. Hindu students killed by Hasina- no reaction from India. Hindu supporter of Hasina robbed- huge reaction
It doesn't really matters who is in power ..a Muslim dominated country can't tolerate any non-muslims ..Anyone can can research it in pakistan, bangladesh, morocco, nigeria, Syria, libia, Iraq ,turkey where there non muslims either got butchered or forced to convert or have to fled from these islamic nations.....whereas populations of muslims increased in non muslim countries like India, Britian, France...islamic ideology either butcher other faiths or make them convert whoever in government
@qofsalt8478 🇧🇩Indian media did not see them as students at all. Not a single word for the killing of 700+ students. But when protestors attacked houses of the dictators' supporters, your media classified those as attack on minorities. But those Hindus were supporter of Sheikh Hasina as like many muslim supporters houses were attacked.
@@Anwarhossain-ib3quso if you are a supporter you ll be attacked? So why were temples attacked? were these temples awami league supporters ? And if that is rational mosques of awami league supporters should have been torched....so whatever logic you bangladeshis give your hypocrisy will be exposed.Rahul anando was a supporter of your movement why was his house burnt down.
Tathagata roy is living legend of hindu rights.. If u watch his social media videos and write up of last 20 years, it's truth and reality 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Hindus of East Bengal has always been prosecuted since 1947 and certainly after 1971.. Mr Roy is correct, funny that Hindu bengalis never talk about it. West Bengal govt. is always talking about appeasement just for political benefits. Thank you Mr. Roy.
Wow before when I used to think about communal mindset in the subcontinent I only often wondered about Pakistan and India every now and then as well but largely had good thoughts about the communal harmony in India but the way the Indian media has been ever since August 5th bringing a communal angle to the issue in Bangladesh, gotta admit Indian urban class seems to only pretend that they’re secular but they have deep rooted communal mentality ingrained in them. These guys are still talking about their own propaganda when there has been other Indian journalists who’ve visited Bangladesh and did some ground reporting and found out the actual truth. While these guys are sitting their asses in their studios and homes and still pushing this narrative.
@@shubhrobose6078🇧🇩 after every country getting independence, only minorities are suffering are from India. Research your history, your riots, govt involvement ets
@@racer2123-dx6fv Ohhh I really didn't know INDIA is not secular but a Hindu country..... Thank you Bhai you have in depth Knowledge regarding My Country 😂
@@shubhrobose6078 😂😂look up,gujrat,Assam I mean All bjp states.😂😂BJP cannot do anything of Bangladesh, Because they already make lot of anti Muslim laws.
@@racer2123-dx6fv I Am A Proud Indian buddy and i stay in Gujarat.... I really would like you to visit Gujarat and then honestly justify what you say ..... Ignorance will not take you anywhere....
@@racer2123-dx6fv There are many Bangladeshi specially muslims here in Gujarat and they claim they are living in a better condition here and this is fact my Brother....
The jammat and Pakistan elements have taken centre stage . Dr Yunus has only face value in this aftermath . .is it becoming east pakistan in the making? That is very sad .
I live near Chuknagar. Yes! It is true that their was mass killing. But will you say all of they are hindu? So far to my knowledge they are all Bengali. Their are hindu and Muslim cristhian as well.
I think the mentality of this BJP person is the root of all problems in the Hindu-Muslim turmoil in this subcontinent. The problem should be solved mutually by integrity between the two communities. You've to acknowledge that there might be some bad person in Islam who controls a significant mass of the Muslim community in Bangladesh by propagating violence, but you can't blame the whole religion for that "minor" issue. After the government collapse mostly muslims were attacked and looted by the infiltrators. The peaceful community named "Ahmadi Muslims" was largely attacked in comparison to the Hindu community in proportion. So don't judge the whole situation from the perspective of religious scripture. Rather, you should blame some bad persons intended to implement their political intention by using the name of "Islam". So in the end, I would suggest the BJP person study Islam from the perspective of that particular incident, compared to the situation of the then Arabiya in 560A.D and the situation of Prophet Muhammad (Sa.) rather than blaming the innocent Muslims for their religious belief.
*The U.K's famous islamist like Zakir Nayak is Anjem Chowdhury - Pakistani origin. *33 crores isn't 330 million Gods.Sanskrit word "Koti" have another meaning "types". After the particular 33 koti Devta verse of Vedas subsequent verse talk about names of 33 types Devta. *My grandparents are victim of 1971 Hindu genocide.They told me how members of their family were killed & R......🥹.They come to India as a refugee.
Nehru and Gandhi were Bengalis and Netajhi Subhas Chandra Bose was a traitor to Hindus indeed because he included many Muslims in INA, in important positions in his administration and adopted the electrifying slogan 'Jay Hind' invented by a Muslim 😂😂😂😂
Mr.Roy is absolutely wrong in saying that violence following the uprisal on Bangladesh was targetted towards Hindus. He has no idea of the background and the reason for the revolution that happened leading to the ouster of Sheikh Hasina. The publc anger was against all that had to do with the Awami League regime which forcefully ruled the country for over 15 years by manipulating elections in its favour. In the process both Muslim and Hindus were victims of mob wrath.The violence was not basically against Hindus alone. Mr. Roy raised the issue of exodus of Hindus from East Pakistan and subsequently Bangladesh. He appears to be oblivious of the mass exodus of Muslims from India who were compelled to migrate to East Pakistan and present Bangladesh since 1947 .Their traumatic experience remained largely undocumented! Muslims in India were persecuted prior to 1947 and are still being mistreated during BJP rule. The Babri Masjid demolition episode and lynching of Muslims by Hindu bigots at different times are well known facts but overlooked. One should be aware of history when making sweeping and one sided remarks casting aspersions on Bangladeshi Muslims. Such biased discussion gives impression of communal feeling on the part of Mr. Roy.
And how many Indian Muslims are running to Bangladesh or Pakistan to "escape" the BJP regime? Which rights are Indian Muslims being denied? Could you please list them? Asking for Uniform Civil Code in a secular country isn't denying Muslim rights. Fast-tracking Indian citizenship for non-Muslim refugees from Bangladesh and Pakistan, where Islam is a state religion, is not denying Muslim rights. Modifying the Waqf Act to allow court intervention is not denying Muslim rights. And all minorities in India, including Muslims would rather stay in India or move to Pakistan and Bangladesh. This cannot be said for both Hindu and non-Hindu minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
Muslim population living in Israel as citizens has a positive population growth rate. Whereas Hindu population living in Bangladesh has a steep negetive population growth rate. Their numbers have declined from 22% in 1971 to 7.8% today ! And no world media speak up about this silent genocide of Hindus happening in Bangladesh. Compare to this, in West Bengal, the bordering State of India, the Muslim population has grown there from 8% to 33% now over the similar time period. One can imagine the terrible ground realities for Hindus in Bangladesh❗️
Sir, the Nobel Laureate got the peace award for moneylending a profession of hindu banias. Now running a nation under Army's control is a tall order. And yet he can not be denied an opportunity to try his hand despite his old age.
this is completely wrong. Tell me how many Hindus died after August 05. there were over a dozen Hindu students died during the protest, killed by Hasinsa goons, police, and other state-sponsored apparatus. A list is in preparation- you all will see. Hindus in Bangladesh cannot conveniently take their communal outfit as and when needed and required. Hasina's police IGP grabbed marginalised land and properties during his tenure in Gopalganj. Translate this and listen to this hindu leader of Bangladesh: th-cam.com/video/VDnkfMJ44dc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=lpI0GZRG1dGUWSso
The present Govt of Bangladesh is very radicalised...The matter must be taken in FATF and all the International foram ...with all footage of attacks on Hindu and other minorities....and comments of all the threat given to India a sovereign country....
The place where I live in Kolkata has multiple camp area all around, the land was allocated to the East Pakistan Hindu refugees which cannot be sold. They had nothing when they came 😢 most would have left their old back or had their women raped or killed. Don't think we have forgotten. We now know what is written in the book, it is now all available on the internet with translation.
Not opting to call Mahatma as such diminishes the speaker, not Gandhiji. Royji is entitled to his views. Like any great person, Gandhiji also made mistakes. With the wisdom of hindsight, it is so easy to pass judgment. At the time of Noakhali, peace between the communities was the highest priority. It is true and nauseating to find Islamic fundamentalism hijacking the movement in B'Desh. It would be sheer naivete to expect wisdom and statesmanship from the likes of Tathagata Roy. Jay Ravi, Canada
😂! Before you speak, please learn the history. No, it is not merely the wisdom of hindsight; even during his time, people in Bengal did not hold Gandhi in high regard. Gandhi was often perceived as pompous and primarily concerned with his own image, rather than the welfare of the people of Bengal."
33:37 Noakhali actually proved that Gandhi was ineffective on the face of muslim led pogroms,because his camping in noakhali had no effect on the one sided pogrom which ensued despite gandhi and his goat instead was stolen,killed and eaten and the head was given back as a gift to Gandhi.He was only effective in pacifying hindus...during great calcutta killings which in anyway was not started by hindus..in any case....pacifist as they already are.
Having connections in Bangladesh and currently dealing with bangladeshis...whatever tathagata is saying is 100% true since it is coming from a bjp leader who was a first generation refugee it is more authentic.
No do nt blame the indian bengali hindus..they were busy finding their foothold in an alien land.Moreover Bidhan chandra roy and its police had barred survivors from bangladesh from talking to the media it happened to one of my relatives who were respectable doctors.They whitewished all news coming from bangladesh. It started with the congress and continued in the cpm regime and now it is coming to the fore because of social media.
Arguing with What’s app university students was the biggest mistake of my life.After all these people elected a chapri tea seller as Their prime minister 😂
@@skyplay01 the guy didn’t even comment on your religion. It shows the level of ignorance of a lot of Indians when you attack a person's religious beliefs.
Very unfortunate to see an educated person like Mr Roy loosing his centricity. So biased in his views especially comments on Mahatma Gandhi. Totally waste of time listening to a stooge of safron brigade. Sorry for the harsh statements. Request to Dr Roy, drop the RSS specs and bring back centricity. Stop giving polarising statements.
The comment about Gandhiji is his intentionally distorted opinion. The issue of persecution can very well be presented without opining about one of the greatest leaders the world has ever seen. I would love to see him talking about Shyamaprasad Mukherjee's association with Muslim League and him colluding wirh the british intelligence against Quit India movement.
1975( After killing Bangabandhu, they started looting hindu), 1991 ( Babri Mosque vandalism time in India, they had burned a lots of Mondir in Bangladesh including Dhaleshwari Temple), 2001 after election. Afterwards Nasirnagar, Hathajari, Narayanganj, Sylhet, Jessore, Satkhira, Thakurgaon, Golapganj, Rangpur, Pachgar, Kummila etc.
The largest Islamist party in Bangladesh Jaamat never won 20 out of 350 seats in Assembly election & these deluded guys are saying vast majority of Bangladesh is extremist like RSS or BJP? We Bangladeshi never destroyed a Temple & built a Mosque in It's place
Entire subcontinent is filled with mosque built over demolished Temple's , Islam's holiest place kaba it's is the worship place of non believers but captured by Muslims which they contemplated throughout the world.
Go & ask ISCON temple authorities in Bangladesh or try to read news or even search in YT. Lying non stop doesnt mean its the truth. e.g. there was attempt to place a holy book during a Hindu festival to attempt to attack them & it was all over BD news. Also FYI Hindu's of BD were protesting in Dhaka on 9 Aug 2024 against repeated attacks- what you are good is only at lying
Like RSS...how may temples have been attacked in bangladesh in last 50 years vs mosques attacked than in bengal or total India ...your media statistics says more than 3000 in bangladesh.
Go & ask ISCON temple authorities in Bangladesh or try to read news or even search in YT. Lying non stop doesnt mean its the truth. e.g. there was attempt to place a holy book during a Hindu festival to attempt to attack them & it was all over BD news. Also FYI Hindu's of BD were protesting in Dhaka on 9 Aug 2024 against repeated attacks- what you are good is only at lying
After the Liberation of India and Pakistan in1947, the intellectual elite Muslims had to leave India and migrate to Pakistan . Similarly the elite hindus had to leave Pakistan and migrate to India.
@@neelakantpatel ask yourself why ?? Its a common practice of India now getting involved in other neighboring countries internal affairs and sadlybut trie most of them are completely false and fabricated.....
Unlike Bangladesh which is ISLAMIC country India has a SECULAR constitution. Hindus in Bangladesh r second class citizens by the constitution itself forget how they r being treated by Muslims. To deny the attacks on hindus u urself r proving the point. Bigotry in Islam is nothing new.
Muslim population living in Israel as citizens has a positive population growth rate. Whereas Hindu population living in Bangladesh has a steep negetive population growth rate. Their numbers have declined from 22% in 1971 to 7.8% today ! And no world media speak up about this silent genocide of Hindus happening in Bangladesh. Compare to this, in West Bengal, the bordering State of India, the Muslim population has grown there from 8% to 33% now over the similar time period❗️
A good one. Unless one talks to learned ones like Tathagata Roy, perspectives will remain blinded. The question is how to navigate in this complex landscape. CAA is good but it is for politics. The former governor's idea of leaning hard on BD to ensure the safety of Hindus is good. But how does one do it? It leaves the scope of misinterpretations. Someone might say, that unless BD provides safety to Hindus in BD, India cannot guarantee the security of Muslims in India (that is what is happening now) and initiate a process of coercion. An idea like this can be misinterpreted and misused by those who want to use it for their self-interest. I wish the former Governor made some good workable recommendations. I don't have any answer.
We will cry about the innocent Hindus in Bangladesh whose 200 temples are burned to ground since the coup and bangladesh will pay afterwards. Pakistan has been paying the price so did Maldives and now it seem it Bangladesh turn.
Hindus in Bangladesh are safe but if they feel any danger exchange of Hindu Muslim of Indo Bangla be accorded or Modiji converse with Dr. Younus sb for friendly relationship as was in Hasinaji's government as happy survival of Bangladesh is impossible because of its geographical condition. Starving Pakistan can't help Bangladesh from any corner because of its own extreme poverty and political instabilities.
Print two favourite targets Punjab and Bengal.. and It knows why India cannot be India without considering complex history of these 2 states which have connections beyond borders 😂
Dr zakir Naik is a true Muslim and a good human being. He didn't do anything wrong. He was preaching Islam in a peaceful way withoout any force or violence and converted thousands if Hindus towards the only truth. The Hard-line Hindu politicians didnt like that their flocks were getting converted, so they instigated against him on the banner of terrorism when there was absolutely nothing like that. Muslim ruled Indian subcontinent for eight hundred years there were no problems then. Hindus and Muslims were living together. problems started when the British colonial powers came and started to rule India. After they left, devided the country, starved millions of people to death and looted its wealth.After that the problems remained between Hindus and Muslims ever since. Devide and conquer strategies prevailed. Its a sad situation.
@@abhirupsen1747refugees? Bangladesh doesn’t recognise any refugees. You are talking about hindus then why don’t you take them in ? Why let them back inside to Bangladesh?
Absolutely true in some years what you said will be a reality in Bangladesh seeing what is going on in BD😂.... Our Indian Machine is already Oiled.... Waiting eagerly to see the condition of the Machine called Bangladesh
Mr. Roy, as long as you move along with your propaganda machines, you will lose further grounds in Bangladesh. The Gen Z of Bangladesh are much more informative, decisive and audacious on slapping the face of the liars and big brothers.
Bihar is not a probince of Bangladesh.Then how the term has been used since 1971 till date.May be helped to understand the historical impact of this terminology.?
Actually Deep Halder was not comfortable in the entire interview. He realized it early and was looking quite perturbed, uneasy when he interviewed him. Print should have some common sense not to deploy people who had been associated with BJP ( even if they tell the real story) for the interview.They should have made an interview for the Qadri who heads that Nizam-e- something on his views on Hindus. Always get information from horses mouth and verify the horse action.
![[ ออกกอง ] วัยหนุ่ม 2544 โลกหลังลูกกรง..ทัวร์กองถ่ายหนังใน "คุกของจริง" | JUSTดูIT.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vB--aOkZCpw/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you Mr Roy , I was 7 years old boy at the time . 1950 riot was horrendous. Shortly afterwards on 13 th of March we all left our ancestral home and left East Pakistan . No one talk about that exodus. My father’s friend with his whole were slaughter over Bhoirob bridge and thrown in the river. Very traumatic memory
My mother’s side was from Pabna’ Sirajgunge ( were landed gentry ) and my father’s side was from Dhaka Manickgunge. 2 of my “mashi” maternal aunts ( my late mother ‘s first paternal cousin sisters ) were raped and forcibly converted to Sunni Islam and forced into marriage with Bengali Muslims while the extended family members were escaping the barbaric Anti Hindu pogroms being perpetrated by the Pakistani Khan Sena and Bengali speaking Jamaat affiliated Muslims during 1971 ! 3 years later both of them committed suicide ! Many of them escaped the Anti Hindu riots / pogroms - wisely during 1947-50 but some of them stayed back with inane illusions like the famous Dalit Bengali Hindu politician Jogen Mondol and his ilk did during 1947-50 ; and had to pay horrendous price like I stated !
The silence of the “liberals” of the west is deafening
I am a Bangladeshi hindu writing from Sylhet, Bangladesh.
I am greatful to to listen something special from such a wise person , its seems like Roy sir is speaking on behalf of Bangladeshi hindus.
Nobody could so open like him,Bangladeshi muslim mind getting darker each day.
This is the responsiblity to take necessary action from humanitarian point of view. whatever happens in Bangladesh hindus must be safe & sound & establish DHARMA.
No matter what,India and Indian's hindus are our last hope
Does Hindu in Bangladesh has less rights in Bangladesh than Muslims...!!!!!!! During the student protest why no one attacked Hindus but why they attacked later after the victory over dictator??? What makes you feel that whatever happened to the Hindus in Bangladesh was only to target because of their Minor identity....????
@@rashed-ulanwar3521Why hindu population reduced so much.Whereas minority percentage in India growing.Data tells you all
sure, we believe you user-bd6fw6gf4q 🤣 you Indian bots are so hilarious
Indian BOT spotted😂😂😂...We aren’t fool..bitch
@@krishnabhan6098
Main reasons -
1. A lot of hindus taking refuge in India during our liberation war didn’t returned. You will get the numbers if you check your national database.
2. Birth rate among muslims are almost double(if not more) in the sub-continent than that of the Hindus.
Other reasons -
* Hindus like to settle in India because most of the spiritual sites of their religion is there.
* Hindus are easily given citizenship in India. They like to migrate as it is economically prosperous than Bangladesh.
I am Bangladeshi. What Roy is saying is very true.
@@KolipokiMB then stay strong based on knowledge of Geeta, nurture strength, analyse personality of Shri Krishna, and build a powerful fort. Cooperate and make a tough link. Learn from Israelis, how to counter decisively
Don't publish your name, use aliases
@@Sujit-ee8cs a well wisher. And in a way, the situation of Bangladesh is reflected.
Print had the guts to do this interview 😄. Surprising
these lindus trying to create a communal war in bd
Muslim attack's hindu Awami BNP or jamat they all are same.
As long as Indian media and their experts are in turmoil Bangladesh is in right position 😅 does India really support the people of Bangladesh or Hasina or any specific community ???
That is quite vissible.
Looting , dacuti, labour strike, price rise, no police , mass resignation of professors.
It is very easy to blame india and ignore own problem.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990who got caught they were Awami League party people. They tried to show that this govt is a failure and indian media shows it Hasina still gave her terror attack in Bangladesh.
@@Mehdi-JonyBangladeshi youth thinks that they gained freedom from Hasina madame's dictatorship.But the religious fanatics used this revolution as an excuse to morph this youth movement into a zombie apocalypse...constant chaos,burning of minorities houses and smashing of Hindu temples,beating up of college students,smashing the statues of freedom fighters,economic collapse,feeble military and para military security.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 , you are explaining something in a wrong way , no one is blaming you for Bangldesh problems right now.. but India's involvement with Hasina's bad deeds are proven truth... you might want to deny that but Hasina's shelter in India proves a lot.. Modi does not want his involvement to be revealed in the world , he might try to send Hasina somewhere far and in worst case Hasina might loose her life. modi at any cost would bury the secrets with her...
Because they have gone insane as Bangladeshi youth has come to understand India's heinous conspiracy.they exploited us with the help of Awami league for years.They have hostile relation with all their neighbours.we were the only one left that also slipped.so they have gone mad😂😂😂😂
Islam is not a religion but a military doctrine.
@@madeformind7393 evilish of course
Right.Particularly the Islam practiced by the Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims.
@@gulapiokram3613 a further study required. Islam practised by Pakistan consider Bangladeshis of lower standards, while Bangladeshis try to appease them!!!
That's right. Islam is not a religion but a complete way of life. Hinduism is a misnomer.
@@FDTLSM-sr1iy sorry, its the other way round. It seems you have stolen the words of Hinduism. Muslims, after facing severe reverts in stealing property and women of Hindus, have resorted now to steal knowledge and stamp in their name, how shameful!!
CAA requirements must be changed to allow minorities of Bangladesh. 2014 cutoff date does not work for Hindus, who would wish to migrate due to inhumane treatments of them.
Please save bangladeshi Hindus 🙏,We Hindus are under a lot of pressure, soon after the journalists leave, they start again, they told us that we should not tell there was any attack, we can't say anything more.😢, please request your govt not to issue any type of Visa towards Bangladeshi Muslim, it will be a life saving help 😢🙏
We Bangladeshi Hindus are not even equal to animals, No one cares, we are kafer, মালাউনের বাচ্ছা, মালু, so on😢
Banduk uthaoge kisi ko kahi Jane ki koi jarurat nahi north Bangladesh me hindudesh banana chahiye.
@@banjaminparker2034 banduk kahase milenge? Hamare pas ab na rahe ghar , na rahe Naukri, na janeka koi thikana, un logone socha mar pitke vaga denge to India dur honge, Bahut taklif me Hun, aplogo ko andaja nehi 😔
Muslim attack's hindu Awami BNP or jamat don't matter they all are same.
@@banjaminparker2034Muslim Bangladesh jindabad ❤️🇧🇩
To all the Bangladeshi radical muslims why don't u make ur constitution SECULAR as it was to prove ur point that hindus r respected in ur ISLAMIC REPUBLIC!
To all the Indian radical Hindus why don't u make ur constitution SECULAR as it was to prove ur point that Musilms r respected in ur Hindu REPUBLIC!
@@wahidmurad9589it is already secular you f00lllll
@@wahidmurad9589 our constitution is secular. You bozo. That's why EDUCATION is important.
In india muslims % is going High it's not like your country where the minorities % is going low year after year. Real bozoo
😂😂😂 indian constitution is already secular
@@wahidmurad9589 that's why EDUCATION is important.
So many indignant comments by Bangladeshis on this page is an indicator that Tatagatha is spot on about Islam and Bangladesh ..
They come in groups.
They comment on literally all Indian videos about Bangladesh.
It is very easy to spot them because of their terrible English 😅
😂😂chapri, Talk about RSS radical hindu group 😂😂😂Assam Muslim situation.
You will torture Muslim, and want we will treat hindu well? 😂
@@ThePolymerisst ha ha.
@@vish3161 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Do paysa ka pepsi, godi media propagndusts are sexy.....
What a country!!! Hoe come an nation can this much ignorant!!!
#Rendi_propaganda
@noneoftheabove666
Terrible English 😮😮😮😮.
Our 1st language is Bangla. So, It's okay to do any mistake when it comes to communicate in others language. Your PM Modi also doesn’t have enough knowledge of English. Language is a medium of communication. When you don't have any logical argument you talk about irrelevant issues. You are also the supporters of Godi media.
Bangladesh is soon going to be a hot bed for militancy and the next failed state in South Asia. It's really unfortunate.
How?? Bangladesh will be the next big thing
Oil your own machine.. You failed to catch the one culprit for the rape case and here you are hammering your head about our country.
how is that your concern ?
As long as you guys think Bangladesh is in wrong way,we feel relieved that we are on right way.Thank you for your this consideration.
@arindambaisya 🇧🇩 If India thinks Bangladesh is on the wrong way, that means we are on the right path (2).
We know the history of how India got control of Sikkim. Do not try to fool Bangladeshi people.
#saveBangladeshindus remember no mosque has been attacked in Bangladesh and 200 temples are burned.
And it is proved that awami league and Hindus attacked temple to make news
🇧🇩Who told you 200 temples were burnt?
@@Anwarhossain-ib3qu they Don't need proof😂, Don't argue with these idiotic WhatsApp uni Lindus😆
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Next jokes
@@sadmanwasi7297 you dumbos are coming in every Indian videos to comment your stinky arguments ...and then have guts to call us to ignore ...lol
Bengali hindus is the most persecuted community in subcontinent whether by bangladeahi jihadi population or by Pakistan army during Bangladesh liberation war. Hindus were 1/4 of east bengal population before partitions but now they are less then 8% of population of Bangladesh.
An extremist Indian lecturing about minority. See your face in the mirror 😂
Its due to economics, nothing to do with persecution
Give me a Data, how many houses of Hindus in Bangladesh were bulldozed in last 15 years? Man we don"t need to learn Harmony from India. You are always welcome to visit BD and take a look on the people of Hindus here. Don't be fooled by your GODI Media, Instead of these trash-talk show, have a look on any ground report of current situation, youll surely get another view.
Edit : Indian muslims are the most persecuted community in subcontinent .
@@taketrick2725The houses of Hindus were no bulldozed but burnt and vandalized ......and whose houses are bulldozed in India ??? Only those who have criminal antecedents .So ,that's the difference .
Absolutely brave narration by Tathagat roy.
These silly statements cannot hide real Islam bro #Exmuslim
Absolutely a narration to be repaid by BJP government , for spreading hatrait..
Deep Halder seems to have an unhealthy obsession with Bangladesh's politics rather than working towards improving his his home country of India, which is riddled with unemployment, a virulent caste system, a lack of toilets and sanitation, poverty, a lack of security for women, and an overall legacy of underdevelopment. Most educated Indians that I observe here in the US will leave India and never look back, and it seems the rest like him try to instigate communal tension in their neighboring countries.
He's a reporter focused on Bangladesh, not that he's obsessed with your craphole country. Major publications have correspondents that focus on regions and Bangladesh is one of his areas
Actually he was not comfortable in the entire interview. He realized it early and was looking quite perturbed, uneasy when he interviewed him. Print should have some common sense not to deploy people who had been associated with BJP ( even if they tell the real story) for the interview.They should have made an interview for the Qadri who heads that Nizam-e- something on his views on Hindus. Always get information from horses mouth and verify the horse action.
He is a journalist and he has every right to get on with topics he is passionate about. There is no paucity of journalists in India who can talk about internal issues. Perhaps, people like you who downplay hindu genocide to please your sickular friends, must get over the unhealthy obsession of equalizing everything to uphold the theory of sickularism.
@@rajchakraborty6320 he actually has written a book on Marijappi massacre and he talked about it in pondy lit festival . He was very comfortable in his skin. Here I think he was under watch or pressure and is visible. You can check the pondy lit festival, deep and kanchan gupta have a discussion about Bangladeshi Hindus. Definitely the Print ecosystem is to be blamed. Understand if someone gets paid although you are ideologically poles apart you may actually end up working up for the opposite cause or direction
Tathagat ji, also mention that, the firm belief of Bengalis, which method of Independence they would follow, Netaji's or Gandhi's. This clarity was terribly missing. They were a confused lot, and there was no visionary leader, except Shayama da, who at the end was left alone.
Sir, you lied nicely. You will get good position in BJP next election.
Can you point lies ?
He didn’t lie . He is right
He is a liar..but bangladesh fuck raw and india
😂😂Why he avoid maharastra train case?If hindutba party is fine for india,then why not islamic party in bangladesh?@@bramhanandamarathe7277
What was the lie
Remove the entry date restriction on CAA. Make India "a natural home for Hindus"
All eyes on Bangladeshi Hindus
th-cam.com/video/6zgkIiucGPI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=pd9IZKdlwDsCGQys
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Save indian Muslim 😂😂.
@@racer2123-dx6fv Indian Muslims are hundred times safer than Bangladeshi Muslims. A large number of Bangladeshi Muslims migrate illegally from Bangladesh. So don't say anything without knowing.
Muslims are the second-largest religious group in India, and their population has been growing steadily for several decades. According to the 2011 census, Muslims made up 14.2% of India's population, up from 10.6% in 1951.
😂😂😂You lied and you are not ashamed to call yourself a Muslim. Does the Qur'an teach this? 😂😂
@@racer2123-dx6fv Indian Muslims are hundred times safer than Bangladeshi Muslims. A large number of Bangladeshi Muslims migrate illegally from Bangladesh. So don't say anything without knowing.
Muslims are the second-largest religious group in India, and their population has been growing steadily for several decades. According to the 2011 census, Muslims made up 14.2% of India's population, up from 10.6% in 1951.
Why does their population grow if they are not protected? If you worry too much, take them.
Very precious information given by you sir 🙏. Congratulations
When India is criticizing Bangladesh,Bangldesh is in right directions.
India is not criticizing Bangladesh. An Indian news channel has posted an interview of a subject matter expert of Bangladesh. You are taking offense to it because he's speaking the truth. You do not want to admit that you converted to a violent religion that converts people to their religion by hook or by crook.
@@VijayKumar-dn4pz 🤣🤣🤣🤣 You are so funny 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lindu attack muslim @@VijayKumar-dn4pz
Well it's doesn't matter its not about right or wrong...
But Both India and Bangladesh should co-operate eachother and exchange territories
Parts of India which wants to follow Sharia law should join Bangladesh and part Bangladesh which want to follow Hinduism should merge with India
In this way we can maintain peace & harmony in the region
What is the direction?
🇧🇩 Even the Hindus in Bangladesh know who are with them.
Hindu students killed by Hasina- no reaction from India.
Hindu supporter of Hasina robbed- huge reaction
HAHAHA.... India saw those student as protestors not as hindus. But Extremist muslim saw them as Hindus rather than as bangladeshi...
It doesn't really matters who is in power ..a Muslim dominated country can't tolerate any non-muslims ..Anyone can can research it in pakistan, bangladesh, morocco, nigeria, Syria, libia, Iraq ,turkey where there non muslims either got butchered or forced to convert or have to fled from these islamic nations.....whereas populations of muslims increased in non muslim countries like India, Britian, France...islamic ideology either butcher other faiths or make them convert whoever in government
@qofsalt8478 🇧🇩Indian media did not see them as students at all. Not a single word for the killing of 700+ students. But when protestors attacked houses of the dictators' supporters, your media classified those as attack on minorities. But those Hindus were supporter of Sheikh Hasina as like many muslim supporters houses were attacked.
@@qofsalt8478 we know who the real extremists are! Trying to start a communal violence
@@Anwarhossain-ib3quso if you are a supporter you ll be attacked? So why were temples attacked? were these temples awami league supporters ? And if that is rational mosques of awami league supporters should have been torched....so whatever logic you bangladeshis give your hypocrisy will be exposed.Rahul anando was a supporter of your movement why was his house burnt down.
Tathagata roy is living legend of hindu rights.. If u watch his social media videos and write up of last 20 years, it's truth and reality 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Bangladesh is rapidly becoming banglastan which is concerning for neighbors
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Do paysa ka pepsi, godi media propagndusts are sexy.....
What a country!!! Hoe come an nation can this much ignorant!!!
#Rendi_propaganda
😂😂😂rendia,Think about your RSS,Shiv sena,Bajrnaghi dal.Hijab ban,Madrasah ban in up.
@@racer2123-dx6fvbanning madrasa means better education for Muslims student madarsa are global hubs of radicalization.
Hindus of East Bengal has always been prosecuted since 1947 and certainly after 1971.. Mr Roy is correct, funny that Hindu bengalis never talk about it. West Bengal govt. is always talking about appeasement just for political benefits. Thank you Mr. Roy.
I'm a Bangladeshi Hindu. This info of Tathagata roy is a propaganda
U r a fake profile of mulla
When will us Hindus react.
Staying peaceful will make it worst.
1000 plus years we have learnt nothing.
Wow... So much open space given for open minded discussion... 👍
Wow before when I used to think about communal mindset in the subcontinent I only often wondered about Pakistan and India every now and then as well but largely had good thoughts about the communal harmony in India but the way the Indian media has been ever since August 5th bringing a communal angle to the issue in Bangladesh, gotta admit Indian urban class seems to only pretend that they’re secular but they have deep rooted communal mentality ingrained in them. These guys are still talking about their own propaganda when there has been other Indian journalists who’ve visited Bangladesh and did some ground reporting and found out the actual truth. While these guys are sitting their asses in their studios and homes and still pushing this narrative.
So basically any criticism of Islam is communal ?
Im sure you have no idea about what is happening with the minorities since ages in Pakistan and Bangladesh
@@vish3161absolutely this is what a section of the world society think this way 😂
@@vish3161Use some of your brian dear friend he was clearly talking about the situation of Bangladesh.
Wash your eyes and read again mate.
@@shubhrobose6078🇧🇩 after every country getting independence, only minorities are suffering are from India. Research your history, your riots, govt involvement ets
Absolutely agree with you sir , by no mean Mohandas Gandhi is a candidate for being called MAHATMA.....
😂😂hindutva is ok in india,but our Islamic party should not allow in Bangladesh 😂😂why chapri rendian? 😂
@@racer2123-dx6fv Ohhh I really didn't know INDIA is not secular but a Hindu country..... Thank you Bhai you have in depth Knowledge regarding My Country 😂
@@shubhrobose6078 😂😂look up,gujrat,Assam I mean All bjp states.😂😂BJP cannot do anything of Bangladesh, Because they already make lot of anti Muslim laws.
@@racer2123-dx6fv I Am A Proud Indian buddy and i stay in Gujarat.... I really would like you to visit Gujarat and then honestly justify what you say ..... Ignorance will not take you anywhere....
@@racer2123-dx6fv There are many Bangladeshi specially muslims here in Gujarat and they claim they are living in a better condition here and this is fact my Brother....
Thanks for speaking the truth about Bangladesh hindus, really appreciate it from all the Bangladeshi hindus.
The jammat and Pakistan elements have taken centre stage . Dr Yunus has only face value in this aftermath . .is it becoming east pakistan in the making? That is very sad .
🇧🇩 People of Bangladesh can choose Jamat as their leader. Bangladesh is a sovereign country, it is not an Indian state.
Do paysa ka pepsi, godi media propagndusts are sexy....😂😂😂😂
Hindooo😂.
It was always east pakistan. Bangladeshis were main leaders of Muslim league
Cry more 😂
Paje*et
Tathagata babu as usual erudite and full of facts.👍
I live near Chuknagar. Yes! It is true that their was mass killing. But will you say all of they are hindu? So far to my knowledge they are all Bengali. Their are hindu and Muslim cristhian as well.
Without LIES ISLAM DIES
You fear Islam so much???😂😂😂😂remember Islam doesn't teach us to disrespect any other religion.that's the difference.
👌👍🙏😂😂😂
Is that all you can say. It makes no sense at all. Are you a Hindu or what?
I think the mentality of this BJP person is the root of all problems in the Hindu-Muslim turmoil in this subcontinent. The problem should be solved mutually by integrity between the two communities. You've to acknowledge that there might be some bad person in Islam who controls a significant mass of the Muslim community in Bangladesh by propagating violence, but you can't blame the whole religion for that "minor" issue. After the government collapse mostly muslims were attacked and looted by the infiltrators. The peaceful community named "Ahmadi Muslims" was largely attacked in comparison to the Hindu community in proportion. So don't judge the whole situation from the perspective of religious scripture. Rather, you should blame some bad persons intended to implement their political intention by using the name of "Islam".
So in the end, I would suggest the BJP person study Islam from the perspective of that particular incident, compared to the situation of the then Arabiya in 560A.D and the situation of Prophet Muhammad (Sa.) rather than blaming the innocent Muslims for their religious belief.
Right, you are..... There were 80-100 houses of Ahmadi Muslims which were burnt and looted by the infiltrators....
जब बांग्लादेश बना तब ही हिंदू देश बना देना चाहिए था !!
In your dreams 😂😂😂😂😂
Stop getting carried away by media talking about rape cases in India and keep fighting to help Hindus in Bangladesh!!!!!!!
*The U.K's famous islamist like Zakir Nayak is Anjem Chowdhury - Pakistani origin.
*33 crores isn't 330 million Gods.Sanskrit word "Koti" have another meaning "types".
After the particular 33 koti Devta verse of Vedas subsequent verse talk about names of 33 types Devta.
*My grandparents are victim of 1971 Hindu genocide.They told me how members of their family were killed & R......🥹.They come to India as a refugee.
People like you need to speak up, including to the international media. Tell the story of the persecution and slaughter of Bengali Hindus.
Get out of India . Bangladeshi go back to Bangladesh
Stop imitating the verbal ways of the West.
The DNA of not identifying the true goes on in East. Earlier it was Jinnah, now it is Jamat.
That's where Hindus make mistakes
Blaming to one Individual
All this happening because of Islam
We can see results all over the world
Nehru and Gandhi were Bengalis and Netajhi Subhas Chandra Bose was a traitor to Hindus indeed because he included many Muslims in INA, in important positions in his administration and adopted the electrifying slogan 'Jay Hind' invented by a Muslim 😂😂😂😂
@@artlover648 how a nuisance like you enters this discussion.
@@artlover648 you seem to inherit a Pakistani DNA. Correct it in next birth by taking birth in Hindu Bengali family in India!!!
Muslim attack's hindu Awami BNP or jamat no matter they all are same.
Mr.Roy is absolutely wrong in saying that violence following the uprisal on Bangladesh was targetted towards Hindus. He has no idea of the background and the reason for the revolution that happened leading to the ouster of Sheikh Hasina. The publc anger was against all that had to do with the Awami League regime which forcefully ruled the country for over 15 years by manipulating elections in its favour. In the process both Muslim and Hindus were victims of mob wrath.The violence was not basically against Hindus alone. Mr. Roy raised the issue of exodus of Hindus from East Pakistan and subsequently Bangladesh. He appears to be oblivious of the mass exodus of Muslims from India who were compelled to migrate to East Pakistan and present Bangladesh since 1947 .Their traumatic experience remained largely undocumented! Muslims in India were persecuted prior to 1947 and are still being mistreated during BJP rule. The Babri Masjid demolition episode and lynching of Muslims by Hindu bigots at different times are well known facts but overlooked. One should be aware of history when making sweeping and one sided remarks casting aspersions on Bangladeshi Muslims. Such biased discussion gives impression of communal feeling on the part of Mr. Roy.
Its a shame that a man of his position failed to understand Bangladesh.
There's not much to understand about a country born on the basis of religious bigotry.
Don't try to hide the real Islam bro #ExMuslim
@@skyplay01ex hindu jindabad
he understands everything he is linduvta propaganda
He is right
For once The Print has interviewed the right person.
Shame on scholars like you. Expert in fabrication.
It's not fabrication it's the nature of Islam please don't try to hide #ExMuslim
Explain more on fabrication..
Bangladeshi Hindu population has been decreased from 13% to 6% since independence of Bangladesh.
utter nonsence
by the way i am a hindu too
Well said by Thatagat Roy even the awarness among WB hindus are very minimum.
What a irony BJP RSS talking about minority rights 😂😂😂
Bangladeshis should not even speak of minorities after you did this for years
And how many Indian Muslims are running to Bangladesh or Pakistan to "escape" the BJP regime? Which rights are Indian Muslims being denied? Could you please list them? Asking for Uniform Civil Code in a secular country isn't denying Muslim rights. Fast-tracking Indian citizenship for non-Muslim refugees from Bangladesh and Pakistan, where Islam is a state religion, is not denying Muslim rights. Modifying the Waqf Act to allow court intervention is not denying Muslim rights. And all minorities in India, including Muslims would rather stay in India or move to Pakistan and Bangladesh. This cannot be said for both Hindu and non-Hindu minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
Minorities in India are safe. They even have good position.
ThePrint, ur content is so clean
Give human rights for Muslims and others in India
Muslim population living in Israel as citizens has a positive population growth rate. Whereas Hindu population living in Bangladesh has a steep negetive population growth rate. Their numbers have declined from 22% in 1971 to 7.8% today ! And no world media speak up about this silent genocide of Hindus happening in Bangladesh. Compare to this, in West Bengal, the bordering State of India, the Muslim population has grown there from 8% to 33% now over the similar time period. One can imagine the terrible ground realities for Hindus in Bangladesh❗️
He is spreading propaganda
Your statement can't hide real Islam bro 😂 #ExMuslim
@@skyplay01 as if we care about piss lover lindus?
Which part you think is propoganda ?
Sir, the Nobel Laureate got the peace award for moneylending a profession of hindu banias.
Now running a nation under Army's
control is a tall order.
And yet he can not be denied an
opportunity to try his hand despite his old age.
this is completely wrong. Tell me how many Hindus died after August 05. there were over a dozen Hindu students died during the protest, killed by Hasinsa goons, police, and other state-sponsored apparatus. A list is in preparation- you all will see. Hindus in Bangladesh cannot conveniently take their communal outfit as and when needed and required. Hasina's police IGP grabbed marginalised land and properties during his tenure in Gopalganj. Translate this and listen to this hindu leader of Bangladesh: th-cam.com/video/VDnkfMJ44dc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=lpI0GZRG1dGUWSso
The present Govt of Bangladesh is very radicalised...The matter must be taken in FATF and all the International foram ...with all footage of attacks on Hindu and other minorities....and comments of all the threat given to India a sovereign country....
The place where I live in Kolkata has multiple camp area all around, the land was allocated to the East Pakistan Hindu refugees which cannot be sold. They had nothing when they came 😢 most would have left their old back or had their women raped or killed.
Don't think we have forgotten.
We now know what is written in the book, it is now all available on the internet with translation.
@@sushilupadhyay3340definitely not radicalised as much as India is
@@sushilupadhyay3340radical than rss bjp?
200 temples has been burned and zero mosque since the coup. Islamist has taken over Bangladesh.
Even released terrorist.
Not opting to call Mahatma as such diminishes the speaker, not Gandhiji. Royji is entitled to his views. Like any great person, Gandhiji also made mistakes. With the wisdom of hindsight, it is so easy to pass judgment. At the time of Noakhali, peace between the communities was the highest priority. It is true and nauseating to find Islamic fundamentalism hijacking the movement in B'Desh. It would be sheer naivete to expect wisdom and statesmanship from the likes of Tathagata Roy. Jay Ravi, Canada
😂! Before you speak, please learn the history. No, it is not merely the wisdom of hindsight; even during his time, people in Bengal did not hold Gandhi in high regard. Gandhi was often perceived as pompous and primarily concerned with his own image, rather than the welfare of the people of Bengal."
33:37 Noakhali actually proved that Gandhi was ineffective on the face of muslim led pogroms,because his camping in noakhali had no effect on the one sided pogrom which ensued despite gandhi and his goat instead was stolen,killed and eaten and the head was given back as a gift to Gandhi.He was only effective in pacifying hindus...during great calcutta killings which in anyway was not started by hindus..in any case....pacifist as they already are.
Having connections in Bangladesh and currently dealing with bangladeshis...whatever tathagata is saying is 100% true since it is coming from a bjp leader who was a first generation refugee it is more authentic.
Tell me one thing that qualifies for Mahatma??
@@parthamukherjee277excellent observation. Noakhali was horrific
No do nt blame the indian bengali hindus..they were busy finding their foothold in an alien land.Moreover Bidhan chandra roy and its police had barred survivors from bangladesh from talking to the media it happened to one of my relatives who were respectable doctors.They whitewished all news coming from bangladesh. It started with the congress and continued in the cpm regime and now it is coming to the fore because of social media.
Have some shame hizra..
Punjabi took r3venge why did not you??
Arguing with What’s app university students was the biggest mistake of my life.After all these people elected a chapri tea seller as Their prime minister 😂
That's called democracy, a phenomenon of which Islamist chuds like you are not aware of...
These silly jokes can't hide the nature of Islam #ExMuslim
@@skyplay01 the guy didn’t even comment on your religion. It shows the level of ignorance of a lot of Indians when you attack a person's religious beliefs.
a killer of gujrattttttttt, talking bed about muslims during election lecture
@@gphgrid8250killer of Gujarat? What would happen to Hindus in Bangladesh if they burned a train as in Godhra, killing pilgrims? I think we all know
The solution of every problem comes to the point that India wants Hasina back in power of Bangladesh 😂😂
The Print also became GODI??? If you love Hasina so much, make her PM of India.
Cry me a river! Truth hurts..
Low IQ Jihadi… they are talking about Hindu oppression by Bangladeshi Jihadis. You converts are way worse than Arabs …
Hasina will next PM of India 😂😂
Yes no more chai wala hasina will bring Indians to toilet from rail line 😂
🇧🇩 Print is corrupted. Its a Godi
At last there should be a separation of state and church in Bangladesh.
Very unfortunate to see an educated person like Mr Roy loosing his centricity. So biased in his views especially comments on Mahatma Gandhi. Totally waste of time listening to a stooge of safron brigade. Sorry for the harsh statements. Request to Dr Roy, drop the RSS specs and bring back centricity. Stop giving polarising statements.
Nothing he has said is irrational or wrong.
The comment about Gandhiji is his intentionally distorted opinion. The issue of persecution can very well be presented without opining about one of the greatest leaders the world has ever seen. I would love to see him talking about Shyamaprasad Mukherjee's association with Muslim League and him colluding wirh the british intelligence against Quit India movement.
He is entitled to his opinion.
@@NoName-ox7dz Absolutely, he is but so do I. Hence the post.
As long as Indian media and their experts are in turmoil Bangladesh is in right position
1975( After killing Bangabandhu, they started looting hindu), 1991 ( Babri Mosque vandalism time in India, they had burned a lots of Mondir in Bangladesh including Dhaleshwari Temple), 2001 after election.
Afterwards Nasirnagar, Hathajari, Narayanganj, Sylhet, Jessore, Satkhira, Thakurgaon, Golapganj, Rangpur, Pachgar, Kummila etc.
The largest Islamist party in Bangladesh Jaamat never won 20 out of 350 seats in Assembly election & these deluded guys are saying vast majority of Bangladesh is extremist like RSS or BJP? We Bangladeshi never destroyed a Temple & built a Mosque in It's place
But you still see hindu as kaafir
Entire subcontinent is filled with mosque built over demolished Temple's , Islam's holiest place kaba it's is the worship place of non believers but captured by Muslims which they contemplated throughout the world.
Go & ask ISCON temple authorities in Bangladesh or try to read news or even search in YT. Lying non stop doesnt mean its the truth. e.g. there was attempt to place a holy book during a Hindu festival to attempt to attack them & it was all over BD news. Also FYI Hindu's of BD were protesting in Dhaka on 9 Aug 2024 against repeated attacks- what you are good is only at lying
Like RSS...how may temples have been attacked in bangladesh in last 50 years vs mosques attacked than in bengal or total India ...your media statistics says more than 3000 in bangladesh.
Go & ask ISCON temple authorities in Bangladesh or try to read news or even search in YT. Lying non stop doesnt mean its the truth. e.g. there was attempt to place a holy book during a Hindu festival to attempt to attack them & it was all over BD news. Also FYI Hindu's of BD were protesting in Dhaka on 9 Aug 2024 against repeated attacks- what you are good is only at lying
After the Liberation of India and Pakistan in1947, the intellectual elite Muslims had to leave India and migrate to Pakistan . Similarly the elite hindus had to leave Pakistan and migrate to India.
Our misfortune, complete exchange of population not carried out in 1947
Protect Muslim and respect Muslim in india
We, bangladeshi people can maintain our harmony. Don't think much about our affairs...
Why worry about Indian affairs though? As strange as it gets!!
@@neelakantpatel ask yourself why ??
Its a common practice of India now getting involved in other neighboring countries internal affairs and sadlybut trie most of them are completely false and fabricated.....
Unlike Bangladesh which is ISLAMIC country India has a SECULAR constitution. Hindus in Bangladesh r second class citizens by the constitution itself forget how they r being treated by Muslims. To deny the attacks on hindus u urself r proving the point. Bigotry in Islam is nothing new.
@@Vnvcbn some of them brother. Overall we don't have any specific communal ideology.
How many muslim left India till now 🙄🙄
Muslim population living in Israel as citizens has a positive population growth rate. Whereas Hindu population living in Bangladesh has a steep negetive population growth rate. Their numbers have declined from 22% in 1971 to 7.8% today ! And no world media speak up about this silent genocide of Hindus happening in Bangladesh. Compare to this, in West Bengal, the bordering State of India, the Muslim population has grown there from 8% to 33% now over the similar time period❗️
If BJP can be in power in India why Jamar can not rule Bangladesh if people of Bangladesh vote them .
Modi does not radicalize people who are not educated😆
Nobody is telling they can't rule Bangladesh. Only thing is we should recognise for what they are.
@@neelakantpatelWhat they are?
@@tapaschatterjee7993🇧🇩 We can clearly see to whom Mr educated Modi is radicalising.
Desert cult followers can convert everything to desert as long as they keep off from our Hindu Brothers and Sisters
A good one. Unless one talks to learned ones like Tathagata Roy, perspectives will remain blinded. The question is how to navigate in this complex landscape. CAA is good but it is for politics.
The former governor's idea of leaning hard on BD to ensure the safety of Hindus is good. But how does one do it? It leaves the scope of misinterpretations. Someone might say, that unless BD provides safety to Hindus in BD, India cannot guarantee the security of Muslims in India (that is what is happening now) and initiate a process of coercion.
An idea like this can be misinterpreted and misused by those who want to use it for their self-interest. I wish the former Governor made some good workable recommendations. I don't have any answer.
The print pls stop this bull shit.
Truth hurt huh.
You are a Bangladeshi. No wonder you want to hide it.
You are foreigner Arab go back to arab
Don’t cry anymore as you like hasina so much make her as prime minister of India, kick out the chai wala
We will cry about the innocent Hindus in Bangladesh whose 200 temples are burned to ground since the coup and bangladesh will pay afterwards.
Pakistan has been paying the price so did Maldives and now it seem it Bangladesh turn.
Seems like you are a person with BRAIN🤣
Desert cult followers should stay away from such discussion
@@sudipbhattacharjee9have you take Cow Pi*s shot today??? Seems you are not.
Soon your madrasa graduate students will roam around the world with a begging bowl like your ummah brother Pakistan.
25:28 You're absolutely correct.
Please save us - the Bangladeshi Hindus
Sir is known well about Bangladesh and I am 1oo percent agree
Great one👏
Well spoken Sir.
The Pint should take interview from Taslima Nasrin.
Both of you are amazing
Excellent work Deep
Hindus in Bangladesh are safe but if they feel any danger exchange of Hindu Muslim of Indo Bangla be accorded or Modiji converse with Dr. Younus sb for friendly relationship as was in Hasinaji's government as happy survival of Bangladesh is impossible because of its geographical condition. Starving Pakistan can't help Bangladesh from any corner because of its own extreme poverty and political instabilities.
Why don't you talk about all the people who were killed by the hasina regime?
You're welcome to visit Bangladesh to have fair isea about Bangladeshi Hindu.
I am asking The Print to go to Bangladesh and ask Hindus community what is going on there.
Kind of same thing as putting HAMAS in charge of Gaza 🥲
Tathagatha Roy is known for doing straight hard talk.
The Quranic Ayat dont talk about killing raping or torturing peaceful Hindus.
Print two favourite targets Punjab and Bengal.. and It knows why India cannot be India without considering complex history of these 2 states which have connections beyond borders 😂
Dr zakir Naik is a true Muslim and a good human being. He didn't do anything wrong. He was preaching Islam in a peaceful way withoout any force or violence and converted thousands if Hindus towards the only truth. The Hard-line Hindu politicians didnt like that their flocks were getting converted, so they instigated against him on the banner of terrorism when there was absolutely nothing like that. Muslim ruled Indian subcontinent for eight hundred years there were no problems then. Hindus and Muslims were living together. problems started when the British colonial powers came and started to rule India. After they left, devided the country, starved millions of people to death and looted its wealth.After that the problems remained between Hindus and Muslims ever since. Devide and conquer strategies prevailed. Its a sad situation.
Please upload Full episode without editing.. We need full video for knowing history...
Not as a muslim but as a human being i can confirm all he is saying is truth.
Why Indians talking about Bangladesh? You oil your own machine. We are all Bangladeshi there is no minority
Please take back all the refugees back. We will stop talking
Yes we know that's what your final objective is, half of the work was done in 71 and other half has been happening since than.
@@abhirupsen1747refugees? Bangladesh doesn’t recognise any refugees. You are talking about hindus then why don’t you take them in ? Why let them back inside to Bangladesh?
@@abhirupsen1747who will go to a shitty, literally, country like india.
Absolutely true in some years what you said will be a reality in Bangladesh seeing what is going on in BD😂....
Our Indian Machine is already Oiled....
Waiting eagerly to see the condition of the Machine called Bangladesh
Mr. Roy, as long as you move along with your propaganda machines, you will lose further grounds in Bangladesh. The Gen Z of Bangladesh are much more informative, decisive and audacious on slapping the face of the liars and big brothers.
India with 4 trillion economy don’t give fu*k your Gen Z.
Bihar is not a probince of Bangladesh.Then how the term has been used since 1971 till date.May be helped to understand the historical impact of this terminology.?
Actually Deep Halder was not comfortable in the entire interview. He realized it early and was looking quite perturbed, uneasy when he interviewed him. Print should have some common sense not to deploy people who had been associated with BJP ( even if they tell the real story) for the interview.They should have made an interview for the Qadri who heads that Nizam-e- something on his views on Hindus. Always get information from horses mouth and verify the horse action.
We sit and discuss.. Sufferers are sufferring. Unfortunate.
Save minority in India.You need not to worry about others.
We should take very stringent action by starting NRC by sidelining macu-secu & mafia tmc.
Shocking
Yes, you can't compare 2 religion. But the outcome is same. People are getting hurt for religion.