I feel Dayne Zorko has been robbed. He should have been the best at 15 but to not even put him on honourable mentions. I know he hasn’t been the best this year but you put Clayton Oliver at the best number 13 saying someone that had a better year but cause of previous years Clayton was better unfair. That’s disrespect not only has Dayne been deserving of a honourable mention but should have been the best even this year. And other years he has made all Australian and a 5 time winner of the Brisbane lions BF. That’s pure disrespect man. But I love your work and keep it up this is just my opinion.
I respect you opinion man and glad you enjoy my stuff, but for the best player at number 15 it’s hard to go past Sam Taylor. He’s pretty much the comps best key defender, also won the b&f in 2022. My selections were based off a balance between the best current players & overall success/ability, so I’m not going with players past their prime (i.e Fyfe, Zorko). Oliver is in his prime at the moment and even though last year he was riddled with injury, he’s off the back of 2 consecutive coaches MVP awards & is ability wise still one of the games best mids.
Zac Bailey doesn’t get enough recognition. Might also add that he also loves coming in clutch (2021 Goal After Siren, assist in match winner in Elim final, crisp goal to put Lions in front in Granny). The more said about him, the better.
Yes but I also stated that I would factor in their career success and also their overall ability to get a balanced list, therefore picking clarry was the obvious choice.
@@Yitzzz Fair point, but Oliver is a multiple AA recipient and has won 2 AFL CA MVP awards. Also considering he was imo the best player in the comp last year and overall he’s one of the games best midfielders. So it’s hard to override a player like clarry. That was my thought process behind it.
Gotta say Joe Daniher a little bit robbed for Number 3. Leading goalkicker for a grand final side who has greatly improved his skill in the past 12 months. No heat on Serong though, bloke is great.
Surely cooper Sharman over Reilly O’Brien, yes may not have played as much as him yet but look at his influence he has had when he has played, could’ve at least got a honourable mention
1 Steven May 2 Jordan De Goey 3 Caleb Serong 4 Marcus Bontempelli 5 Christian Petracca 6 James Sicily 7 Zach Merrett 8 Andrew Brayshaw 9 Lachie Neale 10 Scott Pendlebury 11 Max Gawn 12 Jordan Dawson 13 Taylor Walker 14 Callum Mills 15 Sam Taylor 16 Oliver Wines 17 Daniel Rioli 18 Sam Walsh 19 Rowan Marshall 20 Nick Larkey 21 Tom Liberatore 22 Josh Kelly 23 Charlie Cameron 24 Nic Newman 25 Jack Crisp 26 Tom Hawkins 27 Mason Redman 28 Jarrod Witts 29 Shai Bolton 30 Charlie Curnow 31 Harris Andrews 32 Darcy Fogarty 33 Zac Bailey 34 Ben King 35 Nick Daicos 36 Kysaiah Pickett 37 Tom Barrass 38 Jeremy Howe 39 Connor Idun 40 Jack Payne 41 Brody Mihocek 42 Adam Saad 43 Reilly O’Brien 44 Tom Stewart 45 Brad Close 46 Mark Blicavs 47 Anthony Caminiti 48 Mark Keane 49 Jai Culley 50 Ben Brown
Harris got crazy robbed of AA, was easily top 2 best key defenders, he was way more consistant than Moore who fell off heaps in the later bits of the season. They really hate putting Lions players in the AA team it seems
Did consider Fyfe, but the criteria for the sections was picking the best current player, which would obviously be Merrett. If I were picking it on a career wise basis then yeah would be hard to go past Fyfe.
Travis Boak didnt even get an honourable mention??
Wouldn’t be in the mix really for one of the best current players in the no 1 guernsey.
@@RilesMacca he wears 10
For 1 I think trealor should’ve at least got a hounerable mention
You forgot bobby hill😢.
I feel Dayne Zorko has been robbed. He should have been the best at 15 but to not even put him on honourable mentions. I know he hasn’t been the best this year but you put Clayton Oliver at the best number 13 saying someone that had a better year but cause of previous years Clayton was better unfair. That’s disrespect not only has Dayne been deserving of a honourable mention but should have been the best even this year. And other years he has made all Australian and a 5 time winner of the Brisbane lions BF. That’s pure disrespect man. But I love your work and keep it up this is just my opinion.
I respect you opinion man and glad you enjoy my stuff, but for the best player at number 15 it’s hard to go past Sam Taylor. He’s pretty much the comps best key defender, also won the b&f in 2022. My selections were based off a balance between the best current players & overall success/ability, so I’m not going with players past their prime (i.e Fyfe, Zorko). Oliver is in his prime at the moment and even though last year he was riddled with injury, he’s off the back of 2 consecutive coaches MVP awards & is ability wise still one of the games best mids.
Warner over Steven May
You should run AFL Photoshop tutorials as instructions videos like graphic designer?
Sounds like a cool idea, I have just learnt myself however over the years.
Neale over Butters?
Tough one to split, Butters better this year I'd say but overall has to be Neale.
Come on at least put luke breust for number 22
Zac Bailey doesn’t get enough recognition. Might also add that he also loves coming in clutch (2021 Goal After Siren, assist in match winner in Elim final, crisp goal to put Lions in front in Granny). The more said about him, the better.
Why is clayton oliver above walker? You said is was on the 2023 season which walker did way better than oliver,
Yes but I also stated that I would factor in their career success and also their overall ability to get a balanced list, therefore picking clarry was the obvious choice.
@@RilesMaccanah, walkers better
@@RilesMaccathat doesn’t make sense. Walker is the crows leading goal kicker all time. How can that blemish his record?
@@Yitzzz Fair point, but Oliver is a multiple AA recipient and has won 2 AFL CA MVP awards. Also considering he was imo the best player in the comp last year and overall he’s one of the games best midfielders. So it’s hard to override a player like clarry. That was my thought process behind it.
What about Blake ???
darcy fogarty for 32 stiff, especially to not even get an honorable mention
Yeah I had Fogarty considered, didn’t worry too much about the honourable mentions just threw in players that popped out.
Fogarty still isn’t consistent enough. He really needs to step up to cover Tex’s inevitable tailing off …
Damn disrespect to Jack Henry and Zach Guthrie
Add Gryan Miers to that too. The bloke was being compared to Lionel Messi for crying out loud!
Both quite underrated players, especially Zach Guthire thought his year was pretty good.
@RilesMacca yeah I was surprised when you had paddy mccartin ahead of him despite (sadly) only playing 3 gamss
Gotta say Joe Daniher a little bit robbed for Number 3. Leading goalkicker for a grand final side who has greatly improved his skill in the past 12 months. No heat on Serong though, bloke is great.
How is it not, How is it not
10:27 not much competition is CRAZY considering Murphy should be AA
He's a solid player but there's a bit of a gulf in comparison with Witts given he's the number 1 hit out ruckman in the comp.
rankine got the famous number 23 for the crows now
I think jai newcombe is stiff to not even get a mention for number 3, yes a bit biased as a hawks supporter but the blokes an absolute gun no regrets.
connor rozee now wears number 1 btw
Yes he does but for the 2023 season he was in 20
Surley Bayley fritsch ahead of Harris andrews
Extremely creative video and good opinions
38 Howe and Cumberland
Gryan Miers robbed of no.32
I love how you name all the players, except for number 4 which is simply “The Bont.” The guy is becoming a legend before our eyes.
Nic Martin in 37 for sure 100%
Same with jye Menzie
Steele Sidebottom not getting a mention is a bit stiff, other than that fantastic list and another ripper, creative video! Love your work!
Steele Sidebottom
Surely cooper Sharman over Reilly O’Brien, yes may not have played as much as him yet but look at his influence he has had when he has played, could’ve at least got a honourable mention
No north 😢
josh Kelly over Sidebottom, idk about that and not even in the honourable mentions.
1 Steven May
2 Jordan De Goey
3 Caleb Serong
4 Marcus Bontempelli
5 Christian Petracca
6 James Sicily
7 Zach Merrett
8 Andrew Brayshaw
9 Lachie Neale
10 Scott Pendlebury
11 Max Gawn
12 Jordan Dawson
13 Taylor Walker
14 Callum Mills
15 Sam Taylor
16 Oliver Wines
17 Daniel Rioli
18 Sam Walsh
19 Rowan Marshall
20 Nick Larkey
21 Tom Liberatore
22 Josh Kelly
23 Charlie Cameron
24 Nic Newman
25 Jack Crisp
26 Tom Hawkins
27 Mason Redman
28 Jarrod Witts
29 Shai Bolton
30 Charlie Curnow
31 Harris Andrews
32 Darcy Fogarty
33 Zac Bailey
34 Ben King
35 Nick Daicos
36 Kysaiah Pickett
37 Tom Barrass
38 Jeremy Howe
39 Connor Idun
40 Jack Payne
41 Brody Mihocek
42 Adam Saad
43 Reilly O’Brien
44 Tom Stewart
45 Brad Close
46 Mark Blicavs
47 Anthony Caminiti
48 Mark Keane
49 Jai Culley
50 Ben Brown
1 connor rozee
Connor was wearing 20
Brown?
Bro no way. 2hrs ago AFL facebook page uploaded a video of the best player of each number
finally some connor idun appreciation
What happened to liam jones for jursey 19
Didn’t really consider him too much, I guess you can put him in over Gunston.
How tf can you take the bont and mihocek over the goat Judd McVee
Harris got crazy robbed of AA, was easily top 2 best key defenders, he was way more consistant than Moore who fell off heaps in the later bits of the season. They really hate putting Lions players in the AA team it seems
Glad I unsubbed. Woefully inconsistent with your choices 😒
Fair enough mate, what ones you disagree with?
Haha someone getting butt hurt over your opinion soft as butter
Nick Murray Slander vid #3924
44 is tim english
Number 22 i would put luke breust
What did u make this vid on?
I use Adobe illustrator for my graphics
How is Mills better then Taranto?
zak butters for 9
How did you put merrett above freaking JOSH DAICOS, and Kelly above rankine
Both Merret and Kelly are better than daicos and rankine
Watch Rankines highlights not many small forwards kicks the goals like he does however Kelly still in front of Rankine at this stage
Neale didn’t even win the brisbane b&f, Harris Andrews did
Zach Merrett over Nathan Fyfe? And nat Fyfe not even given an honorable mention? Duel Brownlow.....
Did consider Fyfe, but the criteria for the sections was picking the best current player, which would obviously be Merrett. If I were picking it on a career wise basis then yeah would be hard to go past Fyfe.
#22 Lizard Blakey should have got an honorable mention, and he’ll soon surpass Kelly …
he did
How do you have Toby Bedford above Jordan Ridley 😂
That was my mistake, I had Ridley on my list forgot to copy him over onto the graphic. Comparison wise I’d have him over Bedford for sure.
butters should have been 9, AA rover, COaches mvp, most corageous and won his clubs B and f
How about Toby Green? He so pivotal to GWS’s success especially as skipper. I’m thinking WTF?!
Hard to go past the bont from his season in 2023, both terrific players no doubt.