Gamegenic Stronghold 200 vs Ultimate Guard Twin Flip N Tray | Deck Box Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- Today we compare 2 deck boxes for storing 200+ cards. Both include an additional token and dice tray as well. Which box is the one for you? Check out the video! Let me know below which is your preferred choice for storage!
The token/dice tray can hold 20 unsleeved tokens and still perfectly fit exactly 12 dice on top. Awesome product review I have the stronghold it's a quality box, no complaints.
(Edit) I don't advise getting the white colour it gets dirty very quickly
Yeah, good call - i avoid the white colors on deck boxes as i find they get dirty even if i am careful with them.
Yea, I got a white sidekick and like, within a week of living in my backpack it was “worn out” on the edges of the lid. Though personally that isn’t a complete deal breaker, at least how mine discolored.
Both deck boxes practically the same but i use the ultimate guard one since its cheaper than the stronghold at my local card shop.
Great video im considering both so this video was perfect for me.
Thanks Neil! Honestly, you can’t go wrong with either one!
Very informal thanks for that!
Glad it was helpful!
Don't get me wrong your video is good, but you are reviewing "premium" deck boxes and you are not trying to fit real 100 double-sleeved card deck. I have Ultimate guard and I am having issues to fit the deck in the tray (using Dragon shield matte + KMC perfect size). That means you definitely will not be able to fit Dragon shield combo with Perfect size Sealable. I think this is vital information for many people out there who are looking to buy such expensive box. (They are probably not buying such box for deck not worth to double sleeve.)
Also, players who double sleeve their decks and/or constantly changing and experimenting with the decks, may look for other uses of dice trays, such as if you can fit sleeved cards or tokens the tray. And again UG just barely cannot fit the sleeved card in the dice tray. (If you don't want to see the ugly side of one sided tokens, great way is to sleeve them too.)
That is actually why I am here, to find out if Gamegenic can do better than this. Based on the specs the trays are little bit bigger than Ultimate guard's. It might not seem as a huge difference, but maybe it is, but we will never know from this review.
TLDR: missing Double-sleeved deck test with non/sealable perfect size inners + additional tokens; missing fitting sleeved cards in dice tray;
The Watchtower 100+ also doesnt fit a double sleeved edh deck with dragon shield sleeves as the outer.
I will be getting one of the strongholds in the mail and use the same type of double sleeveing I'll let you know if my commander deck fits double sleeved.
@@xXCigarXx thanks, but no need to, I already have both.
@@GiliacHeskel in that case do they fit a double sleeved deck with dragonshield resealables?
@@xXCigarXx You will not be able to fit double sleeved deck with Sealable inners into Ultimate guard. It is barely able to hold double sleeved deck with regular inners.
Gamegenic stronghold XL (exclusive version designed for thicker sleeves) will hold no problem double sleeved deck with any inner sleeves.
I am not 100% sure about non-exclusive version of Gamegenic boxes and Thicker inner sleeves, I have only the XL version.
I suggest you to check videos from Tolarian Community College for more details.
th-cam.com/video/yw6mLWnJ2WI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/E_FHG6bXpws/w-d-xo.html
Hey man, do you always use Katana sleeves? Wondering how will these hold up if I use Dragon Shield sleeves. Heard they are thicker so less cards can fit inside.
I got a flip n tray and it doesn't fit 100 dragon shield double sleeved card with resealable perfect fit inner sleeve so i'ts a big no go if you're using this high quality protection.
Fits perfectly fine for me double sleeved too. Make sure there's no air in your sleeves. Very common when double sleeving
@@ninomusician I did some testing since then and i think that it's because i'm using resealable perfect fit inner sleeve. Since there is another layer in the card compared to other kind of inner sleeve, it might cause it to be a bit too wide for ultimate guard product.
@@luciechariot6805 this could definitely be it
just asking if you already found a deckbox that fits with the resealable perfect fit inner sleeve(dragon shield thindra)?
@@jcblaza The Ultra Pro Satin Tower does a fantastic job for this with a bit of room left. As for double (or more) deck boxes, i'm pretty sure that the Gamegenic line would work since they are wider but i haven't tested it yet nor found a review specificly about it online.
I just need something that can hold a triple sleeved commander deck
Ty for this
Doed any of theese fit a mini snap holder?
can it fit toplouder?????
No it cant, i have one and dont fit
i like how you just review these deck boxes but dont post links
@@BrokeAssCollectorany idiot who recommends a deck box would post links to the item. Otherwise you wouldnt do the review. “Let me just make a review items i want to recommend but make you look up the items.” Lol
Wouldnt**