ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Indian Archaeologist on Harappa, Burial sites, And Animal Attacks | Dostcast 111 w/ Disha Ahluwalia
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ส.ค. 2024
- Disha Ahluwalia is a field archaeologist and the founder of Confessions of an Archaeologist-an archaeology communications handle. In this podcast, Vinamre and Disha talk about Indian history, the Harappan civilization, Archaeology in India, handling dead skeletons, finding chariots in India, usage of archaeological tools, DNA sampling, Sherd analysis, Discovery+ documentary and her expedition at Rakhigarhi.
Article on the findings at Rakhigarhi: www.livehistoryindia.com/stor...
Follow Confessions of an Archaeologist on-
Twitter: / coa_archaeology
Instagram: / confessionsofanarchaeo...
Follow Disha Ahluwalia on-
Twitter: / ahluwaliadisha
Timestamps-
0:00 Intro
0:53 Sun exposure, physical activity, and tool usage in Archaeology
5:30 What is the process?
6:49 How do archaeologists do peer-review?
7:45 What is a field season?
8:48 Archaeological license and malpractice
9:55 Archaeology in India
13:03 Shocking findings in Archaeology
15:17 Harappan Civilization
22:27 Who helps you?
24:55 Archaeology is hard
29:06 Ancestral wisdom in modern times
32:00 Writing reports and papers
35:03 Archaeological consultant
36:16 Coolest thing you've discovered
39:08 Hierarchy in Harappa?
41:45 Non-harappans & their burials
45:11 What caused harappans to be urban?
51:16 Security in the city
52:30 Pottery
54:50 How hard is it to be objective?
55:48 Sherd and analysis
58:58 How hard is it to explain your job?
59:43 Animal Attacks
1:03:32 Trench Transportation
1:04:27 How many people work in an excavation?
1:06:58 India's significance in global archaeology
1:12:50 Visiting sites
1:14:38 Colosseum tour
1:16:09 How did you get into archaeology?
1:17:39 When can you touch objects?
1:19:44 DNA sampling
1:21:41 Re-burying, Chariots, and Weapons
1:28:10 Discovery+ documentary
1:31:02 Conclusion
Join our community- / discord
Listen to the audio version of the full podcasts at -
Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/70vrbHe...
Google Podcast - podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
Apple Podcast - podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast...
==
This is the official channel for Dostcast, a podcast by Vinamre Kasanaa.
Connect with me
Instagram: / vinamrekasanaa
Twitter: / vinamrekasanaa
Dostcast on Instagram: / dostcast
Dostcast on Facebook: / dostcast
Dostcast on Snapchat: / dostcast
==
Contact Us
For business inquiries: dostcast@egiplay.com
For collaborations: vinamre@dostcast.com
==
I'm proud to announce that my new course 'Art of Reading and Writing Effectively' is now available to purchase on Skill91.com.
With this course you will be getting:
🔥 Unlimited Access to 25+ Video Modules on Reading, Idea Generation, Online Writing Tools, and How to Write Like A Pro
🔥 15+ Writing Templates To Deliver Effective Writing
🔥 Tried-And-Tested Editing Masterclass
🔥 7 Day Writing Challenge To Help You Publish Your Work
🔥 Taught In Hinglish
🔥 Certificate of Completion
You Will Learn:
✅ How To Make Reading & Writing Easy
✅ How To Never Run Out Of Ideas
✅ Myths About Grammar & Vocabulary
✅ The Right Way To Read
✅ How To Build Your Note-Taking System
✅ How To Get Over Your Fears
✅ How To Remember What You Read
✅ How To Consume High-Quality Information
✅ The Art of Curation
✅ Writing Through Prompts
✅ How To Build A Daily Reading Routine
✅ How To Build A Daily Writing Routine
✅ The Art of Journaling
✅ Free-writing
✅ How To Use Writing Templates
✅ How To Observe The World
✅ How To Write And Edit Your First Draft
✅ 7 Day Writing Challenge
✨ Start learning here: www.skill91.com/s/store/cours... ✨
==
#Dostcast #india #archaeology
![บุษบา - วงชานเมือง [LiveCoverVertion] Original : เมนทอล](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Dm81sKcd9rs/mqdefault.jpg)
There are so many foreign archaeological podcasts.. so happy to finally listen to an indian archaeologist.
Brilliant! Lets get more archaeologists in India!
and dig more craves :D let the dead be dead!! , just kidding :D
And historians too who are non biased
Keep left librandus out of archeology they have already suppressed our history almost 100%.
Archaelogy is open in India , so much work needs to be done , India I am sure has a dense and overlapping periods that need to be explored that would be so educational and bring a perspective to our history. Unfortunately it cannot be done by individuals but needs to be supported. But Great job has been done by Ms Ahluwalia Ji, You are a true daughter of India. Please continue to educate. thank you.
Was listening this on Spotify and I can't ignore that how sweet her voice is! Lovely podcast, and also vinamre with his scorpio jokes 🤣
Are bhai bhai bhai bhai...
Are bhai samee 😂🐒
In early 2022, my wife and I visited Lothal, an important Harrapan site just outside of Ahmedabad. It was truly mindblowing. It was incredible to see upfront the seals, especially the famous unicorn seal which we have only seen in pictures. What was really incredible was the amount of items that were on display in the museum. It was obvious that these were extensive settlements with incredible technology. For example, Lothal was a port city with a dry dock technology which is still in use today. There was also a factory for making ceramic beads of extremely small size. I really hope that the link between this civilization and the present can be ultimately found. Anyway, based on this visit, we have decided to visit the other sites such as Dholavira and Rakhighari. Would definitely urge all Indians to visit at least one of the Harapaan sites. Hope more Disha's get excited about this important work to rediscover our past.
Kudos to the host for bringing up an exciting but not so popular field of archaeology and to the guest for giving a fresh face to our archaic ISI deptt. and covering the topic very well and openly. 👌👏👍
I am happy ki Indian history pe baatein ho rhi h aur Indian history ke baare me jaanna kitna jaruri... Its great that vinamre is giving that history in the form of content... which is great.
It’s funny but i’ve had a similar conversation with Disha when i think she told me she was doing her thesis.
When you and the host were discussing i was in my head reliving the insta chat her and me had had.
Good job though Disha i still yet to have to visit the sites you mentioned few years ago!
Hope you reach greater heights!
Love and light ✨
Love the podcast.... keep bringing more archaeologist and historians.
In India we give more importance and celebrate historians over archeologist .Like Romila Thapar had given over Dr BB lal
It’s like celebrating cricket commentator over cricket player
Romila Thapar is shitt and the reason behind our youth's ignorance towards the real history of our land,She isn't a Historian,she's a distorian
@Swami Vivekanand x BTS💜 in india. That's it
Lol cuz Romila Thapar is a historian she had to gather information from all archeological sites and have to give a conclusive remark about the society and culture by interpreting the findings.... your comment doesn't make sense...it's like why giving recognition to the monument maker while it was built by labourers 🤦🏻♂️ besides each and every archeologists are acknowledged it's not that everybody knows Romila Thapar and the archeologists are unknown.. LoL it shows you never read any history book...where each and every archeologists has been acknowledged as a source..
@@akhilnarayan5392 Romila Thapar is a shitt,a distorian who has destroyed our history, minds of our civilization for sake of some personal Benefits
Romila thapar is a propaganda and biggest lier .... she ain't a historian but a paid stooge
Praveen Mohan's yt channel is single handedly promoting Indian history on social media. ASI must support him or do similar work. #DOSTCAT please invite Praveen Mohan
Agree with you
@ABHRA TALUKDER So a/c to u Elon Musk would be a Zakir Naik too? Bro the thing is he was forced to do what he does, if ASI would have documented the things he is doing with all the assumptions and facts there would be no Praveen bt most of his videos make sense so please untill and unless there is a better alternative atleast let him documents all the things.
I used to never LISTEN any podcasts! Yours is the only one I make sure to always give it a listen everytime you upload. Amazing ! Dostcast to the 🌕
Indian archaeological sites have a lot more to discover. I appreciate hardworking archaeologists like herself!
Impressed by interests shown by young Indians in archeology
It's nice to see, you are getting proper historians and archeologists unlike other channels where people are talking about history without proper education in the field.
Loved this podcast ,... Thanks for getting this all together...people need to have collection of these kinda podcasts 🌪️
Great conversation, Disha ji explained so many interesting g things about her job and discoveries… This is a fascinating topic and hopefully we will find out more in the coming years👍
Brilliant, u are in search of real heros..most underrated channel..ol the best
What an amazing talk, Vinamre! Thank you.. looking forward to more such interesting talks
I’ve seen ‘Academia’ closely, it works on ‘funding & ecosystem’. If there is “funding” for something they’ll find ways to prove it right, by citing each other. Second, when it aids “ideology” of the ‘ecosystem’.
That circular citations(citation loop) has been quite prevalent since the communist take over of academia 70s in india , and Vikram spamath was attacked by the ecosystem for the same reason.. their arguments didn't stand in court because it was later found the arguments they were forming was basically citing each other's work .. again and again ... And the original source was one of their claims and the original claim also had no actual proof 🤦♂️
This has been happening a lot ..
Calling it ecosystem is a bit misleading. these are colonial networks/colonial collaboration networks.
That is a great conversation. Learned a lot about Archelogy and how Archelogist works in extreme conditions.
Bring more peeps like this.
Words I learned from this episode:
Tanning
Anthropogenic
Extrapolate
conjecture
repercussion
camouflage
Good job🤌🏼
Shard
Scorpio
In ancient times ,few intellectuals met each other and talked and gained and spread knowledge amongst others ,i think these podcasts are reviving the periods again
Thanks to daughters like Disha we are very hopeful for the future of our civilization.
Loved this podcast. We need such kind of raw content more now than ever about our history and heritage.
Cudoos to you for bringing these amazing archiologist ..plz bring more of them and ask them to tell ancient stories .
Kudos
Bhai, I was waiting for this podcast❤️
Bhaisaaaab I’m so glad I’ve been watching Vinamre since his Shaatir days
5th day into this podcast couldn't finish it just because falling asleep because of her voice...so soothing
Bravo Dishaji. You are doing what I always wanted to do. I am a physician.
We can't learn much until we find a bilingual script like the Rosetta stone.
Not necessary . If we have enough symbols and use machine learning, we can get some useful insights. Specially if we get longer scripts..
Disha is so refreshing to hear , thanks for this keep going strong
I am studying to be an archaeologist and was in the midst of a study slump and this video popped up on my feed, feeling rejuvenated! Lucky to have chosen this field!
I jus love it when she smiles or laugh 😂❤️
Please keep bringing more of these science and art people like biologist, microbiologist, anthropologists etc
This podcast has broadened my understanding the significance and scale of Harappa Civilization. I really appreciate.
I am mesmerized with her. Fascinating subject, fascinating cuteness and fascinating voice. 😛
Love the podcast ❤️
Commenting because i loved the conversation and want it to reach more people.
I beg to differ regarding stupas, that it started with Buddha and pillar inscription started from Ashoka.
As when you read Tripitak, the only authentic source of Buddhism, Gautama asked Ananda to build stupa on his name after he dies like ancient kings used to build theirs. Suggesting it is a earlier practice.
Then for Ashoka pillar, when you go thru all inscription, in it it is written that some inscription were carved all earlier standing pillars. Suggesting, it is an early practice.
love the conversation❤❤
Very excited for this
Fascinating talk 🙌 Thank you Dishaji. Wish I were in your team. Always aspired to work in Archealogy.
I don't want this to end!!
In North we use big blue boulders (neela patther) then carve them to be rectangle and stack them and use a mud mixture to seal all the holes and to cover it and on roof we lay big tree trunks and you can do a whole wooden sealing or use wooden trunks as a support and use stone slabs
1:16:36 Padathe hai bhai, I remember one incident where instead of crude tools used by ancient humans, I wrote cruel tools and lost a mark or something, that incident is one of my core memories now F. So yea they do teach mostly 5th or 6th grade.
Even in class 12 we have evolution.
@@sillymoose9647 hmm, Ig Science stream students wouldn't be learning those stuff if it's in Social Sciene. And if it is in Science stream, at least people who don't take Biology would have completely forgotten it lol.
@ABHRA TALUKDER ye bhi theek hai. Anyway, it's more in Sociology, other fields do need Science, like at least for History, Literature (not writing books, but analysis of languages and stuff).
Probably Sociology is like that coz there's no responsibility on what they say, write or express.
Very knowledgeable podcast!!
her smile is so cute😍😍
And left thirsty for much more... I wish that the discussion was more and more elementary, creating content that can attract more and more common people. That could be a small but effective help towards making more people take up archaeology. What a day of work looks like; interesting human stories from their work; growth of the individual (intellectual/emotional/...); etc. could generate a bit more romanticisation and hopefully attract people with that.
I too thought the same.
Very informative podcast, thank you!
I agree, The best podcast in Bharat.
Disha's voice is so sweet🌹
Hands down the best podcast in india
Great conversation.
She is soo sweet spoken n well knowledged👌👌👌
Just brilliant. Thanks to Disha ma'am for such an amazing podcast. It was certainly an enriching to hear from horse mouth.
Aaj toh bohot excited ho rha huu ptani kyu🙂
nice pod ,,, would love to see ASI view on AIT and latest DNA findings in new sites
She is a rock star and the host is a genius .
Getting So many career options by watching different podcasts.
Kindly bring more archaeologists on the show
Disha is a superstar!
Disha ahluwalia please open a youtube channel if possible, the information you give is so good
When kasanaa said "poora zamin hi utha ke le gye " bhai same bat mere bhi man me chali 😂
Lov u bhai for this initiative. Or logon ko lao bhai bs self proclaimed historian ko mat lana 😅😅
Bahut zyada acha episode bawa!
I remember Abhijit Iyer Mitra bashing Indian Subcontinent for not having grand monuments (in Charvaka podcast) and how felt the Indic people lacked vision and scale.
I want to see how Disha and Abhijit would have a discussion on it with 01:06:58 as reference.
Abhijit Iyer Mitra is no expert in anything other than maybe defence systems. Even within defence system, his expertise is very limited that he lets on. He's a social media commentator at best.
Wow! Being civil servant aspirant, your each and every word is so enlightening. Jo NCERTs nahi smjha paayi unhe baaton baaton-2 me hi explain kr diya. Beutiful mind.
Love this girl for real knowledge. Not superficial barbie doll.
I loved this one.
P.S.- I also hate monitor lizards more than spiders. So relatable in that way :)
Most of the archeologists are from delhi thats something amazing
Feels Intresting....
During reburying it's the structure/trench that gets covered but all the findings are always taken back to the department for research. Sinauli is an exciting find and throws up so many avenues for study. The title of this video though is misleading. No secrets revealed here.
I like the indians who explore non conventional career options other than engineering 😀.....kudos to her 👏
Very interesting
Plz invite Dr Niraj Rai. One of topmost archaeologist of country. 👍
Niraj rai works on dna and genetics , not archaeology.
bhai anchor tu thoda research kar liya kar terms ko . but i appreciate disha to explain everything in layman terms. i have met so many so callled liberal indian people discarding the chariot finding and calling it a cart. i hope government/private donors funds ASI and archeology departments of universities to excavate more.
Anyone can suggest some good books to read about the Indus valley civilisation?
This was a rare topic to touch and was a good listen. Keep up the work man. 👍🏼
Check Abhijeet Chawda's podcast,this man is an encyclopaedia for the lesser known global history and Indian civilization country
@@karanasthana1582 thanks for the recommend bro. Have heard him, although I'm looking to gain some info from the archaeologist and historians from the field. :)
@@dirtonmyshoes i am not into the technical stuff but Praveen Mohan is someone I can recommend, although I feel he deliberately sensationalise stuff but his intent his good
The Indus civilization: A contemporary perspective by Gregory L Possehl. You can read any of his works. He was one of the major excavators in Indus valley sites in Pakistan, Gujarat, Rajasthan from 1964 until his death in 2011.
Informative
Harappan civilization is the first chapter of class 12 history Cbse. Now we read about the variations and the uniqueness of urban towns as well as the small towns! Knowledge about the civilization is way more now but obviously due to the disability to descifer the script it makes us history students a bit lagged!
Please Make another Podcast with Disha Ahluwalia and Anica Mann and also with other archeologists too
1:20:40 it is the mastoid process of temporal bone*'
however the PETROUS part of temporal bone cannot be felt superficially and it lodges the INNER EAR(the cochlea and vestibular apparatus)
Is topic pe Movie banani chahiye.. Lara croft of India.. running away from snakes,lizards...at same time working hard in not favorable environment.trying to figure out the circle ⭕
Bro can you please put small pictures. Of tools and maps in your videos
ya he can keep a tv or screen, like Joe to watch, react to things on podcast
You should give some glimpse of podcast in the beginning of the video
Awsome podcast bro
Y bro
@@mixedbyhals1329 nothing bro 😄
@@shaktiman7858 i see what you did there
In the Keezhadi excavations in Tamilnadu, I believe a number of symbols found in the Harappan site were also found in Keezhadi. Is there any connection between these two civilisations?
Same people.
Indeed she is beauty with brain
Her smile is beautiful when she was talking about potters design
Her smile when she was talking about snakes... Kind of fan moment...
@@asancheti1841 . cringe
Without sounding sexist, would u have asked such trivial questions like how do you work in hot sun while digging, and getting a tan, if you were interviewing a guy, one shouldn't waste time on such mundane discussion when you have such an informed guest and try to extract as much information as possible, but then can't blame the host, one who is not even aware what carbon dating is, how do can anyone expect such a person to ask relevant questions to an archeologist
@Abhinav u need not be an expert to know these basic things, all you need is a formal education
@@jibibabu9179 I would love to listen you asking relevant questions to the host, So where's the link to your podcast? 🙂
@@jibibabu9179 that is just elitist.
@@1OxP The least one can do is read through wikipedia to get schooled in the field rather than asking such unintelligent questions, as for my podcast will share a link with you for sure once it is up and to enlighten yourself with the information on this topic you need not invest one hr of your time on this video and but rather browse through more informative videos which are in abundance in this platform
Bhai kuch jyada hi nahi soch rhe ho 😂
Vinamra has a good voice
Always to the 🌙
1:16:36 class 12th biology evolution and it's very detail from carbon dating to evolution of plant and animals and humans , also connection link
can't stop staring at the velvet underground poster
invite Mr. Nilesh Oak ji
yessss, m surprised more people haven't discovered him yet
Voice of mam 😍😍😍
We need more cute archaeologists like Disha :D. Very happy to see the younger generation is still interested in ancient history.
When will we decide the texts and scripts is what I am waiting for
She is Lara Croft of India :D
Being an academic, Disha should have used "Indian Sub-continent" rather than "South Asia". Otherwise, the discussion was fascinating and informative.
I believe 'Indian subcontinent' is a geographic term while 'South Asia' is a political term.
So when you're discussing countries you use 'South Asia', and when describing the tectonic plate, for example, you use 'Indian subcontinent'.
Doesn't make any difference
It's same thing
@@FirstLast-vr5gh wrong it's indian sub continent because not necessary to use political term as it is not political topic.
Just to please some leftist or western mindset.
@@girijasankar1800 allah means god or bhagwan, will anyone use allah to refer to their god or bhagwan? Don't be stupid and comment
21:30
NICE
If Prakhar appreciates and Tells you To look at some stuff, it must be something,which it is!!!
never knew feminine udbhav is an archaeologist