"This Should Not Happen In A Muslim Country" Malaysia Top Court Faces Backlash For Sharia Law Ruling
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 มิ.ย. 2024
- Malaysia's top court Friday struck down over a dozen Shariah state laws, saying they encroached on federal authority.
Many Muslims denounced the decision, and said they feared it would undermine religious courts in Malaysia.
In an 8-1 ruling, the nine-member Federal Court panel invalidated 16 laws made by the opposition-run Kelantan state government, which imposed punishments for offenses from sodomy, sexual harassment, incest, and cross-dressing to giving false evidence.
#malaysia #kelantan #kualalumpur #sharialaw #worldnews
n18oc_world n18oc_crux
0:00 INTRODUCTION
2:55 MALAYSIAN FEDERAL COURT VS KELANTAN STATE GOVT
5:16 “I'M DOING THIS NOT FOR MYSELF, I DO THIS FOR ALL”
CRUX is your daily video news guide to the big events that are shaping our world. We track news, geopolitics, diplomacy and defence strategies and explain how they shape national policies. Crux makes sense of global developments, and analyses their impact on daily lives.
Follow CRUX on Telegram: bit.ly/3fnlLua
Follow CRUX on Instagram (@crux.india): bit.ly/3qSFx1K
Follow CRUX on Facebook: bit.ly/2Lte7iF
#GetCloserToTheNews with latest headlines on politics, sports and entertainment on news18.com bit.ly/2Y4QccL
Also watch:
Crux Decode: bit.ly/3MjzIoG
Crux+ : bit.ly/35mm97B
Crux Most Watched: bit.ly/3KhJ8iX
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.76[2/2] เดินมาสิบกว่าป่า วันนี้รู้แล้วว่าโจโฉกลัวอะไร!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/R7Yor-t2Au0/mqdefault.jpg)
When they are in Minorities they want a Secular country,
When they are in Majority they want a Islamic Nation, Good Descision by the Court.
Totally argree.
Malaysia is Islamic country they have more morale and secular to fellow religions , Malaysia is not like India they didn't destroy any chriches or mandirs to build masjid they ddisnt any state sponsored terrorism on minorities they didn't built anti hindu ir anti chritians organization to attack them where in india indian ruling government do this and do appeasing politics. Malaysian government never killed any non muslimsband bulldozed they house and properties , malasians government never arrest any non muslims because they are non muslims whereas in india there thousands of such cases are there. Malaysian muslims never bombed any non muslims property or prayer place with support of government or with collective organised way but india it happens.
U r very much to put ur nose or others state affairs without knowing facts but don't have any guts to speak against ur own government which acting like aparthied state. And openly support and give them make anti muslim program and spread Islamophobia through media and its anti muslim organization
Well said
absolutely, agree
Thank God we have federal court judges who have not been brainwashed by religion
not yet !!!!
Why thank GOD if what GOD says just fall in deaf ears...???????
@@shyltearmagoch6973 😂😂😂😂
**looks at profile picture**
_ironic..._
Too bad the Supreme Court itself can be bribed
Same issue in India, we want Uniform Civil code for all citizen. Religion is a private matter. Dont mix it with the laws of the nation
That's way you government killed muslims .also terrorism
th-cam.com/users/shortsYHmDTw814wM?si=v_J_GMlT6heVkeLF
This is 21st century and people still can't separate state from religion.... what a disgrace to humanity as a whole.
Still in 18th century😂
Which is the majority of ISLAMIST countries in the Middle East
@@jovpal5685Pakistan is also the biggest offender
@@notusneo again ISLAM is the biggest crap to ever be made
Only atheists want a state - religion separation
Malaysian Constitution is supreme over Islamic/ Shariah laws. That's what the federal court is saying.
In Islam, no law is above Islamic law. So how is Islam the official religion yet still secular?
That's how a democratic country should function, religion should be an individual freedom and not the basis for basic constitution
@@carmalmartin4658 interesting. The bill of rights are known as God given rights.
Since when is it supreme? 1950?
@@nicholasholloway8743but sharia is oppressive couldn't it be from God 😅😅😅
I myself is Malay Muslim and I'm tired of hearing people say "we cannot practice Islam fully if there is no sharia law". If you go and live in Germany or Norway or Russia, you can still practice your religion without any problems lol. Clearly these people never travel outside of their country. I don't like closed-minded extreme conservative people🤮
Are u a muslim by name or like a real muslim?
The foreign countries have a lot of hurdles, France has banned home schooling and other western countries have banned segregation in schools. There are a lot of issues other issues that are actually significant. The basic idea is quite simple to understand, step by step, inch by inch, Islam must be erased from the society. It all starts from the top. European countries are already in process of banning Imams from abroad and home train the Imams with state sanctioned cirriculum. It might take 50 years or 100 years, but that is the ultimate aim and objective.
It is only a matter of time before western countries succeed in making Muslim governments pass law where a girl can have sex with anyone including other girls and not have to marry and the same will apply to boys. The national TV will be controlled so as to not issue programs that are considered Islamic and so on. It is in motion gradually all over the Muslim world.
Shut up Atheist.. You aren't Muslim by any chance
Yeah, those Muslims Immigrants makes more harm than good went they lived in western countries
I agree with you my friend. I am Canadian and we have an open border policy and we have even built mosques for Muslims to worship. The government even lets you have a religious exemption for your occupation so that you can maintain your Namaz on time
Leaving Islam and becoming atheist was one of the best decisions of my life
Joining Islam and having discipline in life was the best decision I did
@@avusookay6743 having a 5 time namaz along with having a purpose in life helps me move forward in life.
@ammeo welcome to humanity ❤
@@sesha03 thnx
@@drakensingh9856 islam f@cked all rules and curse to whole world
Separation of Church and state, ALWAYS. In this case it is separation of mosque and state.
if you are a Christian then understand that you have rejected the laws of your god in place for man made laws. Christians are becoming really stupid thinking they are better than the rulings of god
No the people don’t want this so we cannot accept this
The separation of Church and State is Judeao-Christian inspired. Most Western countries follow Jesus's principle - love your neighbour as yourself. Most of the laws in the West are based on this axiom.
No, no separation of church and state
Malaysia is a secular state with Islam as the official religion. So these idiots that keep spinning that Malaysia is an islamic country have no respect for the Federal Constitution.
They are not in the least oppressive. Its how its interpreted, perceived and practiced. Nothing in Islam is repressive or degrading. It's propaganda since the early 80's by a certain other group elsewhere in the world that started it, now a full time lobby job. If you haven't researched it, you cant judge it.
@@user-gh2kq6is1rkeep peddling your propaganda
@@user-gh2kq6is1r Not repressive or oppressive ??? Ok, certainly coercive especially for some who have absolutely no freedom in choosing what they should believe in.
@@bluemarlin2u We ALL have choice. But if ever you were to read the Quran, there is nothing, absolutely nothing that you're forced to do. Its a guide for the best way to live. Life on Earth is temporary, short and like any instructions book, or leaflet, we can also learn how to live our best life. Look at our world, its one huge mess. We need to learn more. Its the Christian western world always at war and looting.
Totally morally bankrupt, yet they point fingers, looking fir a scapegoat. Humans are self destructive. We are nature/spiritual beings on a human journey, not vice versa.
@@bluemarlin2uif ure not muslim why u cared? If u care go study facts
Wonder will the protesters will agree that Sabah which is a Christian majority state to enact Christian based laws?
If Sabah so wishes
Sabah is Hella Muslim majority state tho.... With almost 70% Muslims with all its head minister always muslims
It should anyway... But stay inline with Federal Constitution supreme Laws.. not dangering any other faith in the State .
What makes you so sure it's not already. Of course, the natives too want their own....😂
What Christian based law? Give an example.
Those are evil laws. Well-done judges for standing up for humans
True! Very inhuman law!
God bless those brave Judges
As a Muslim I agree. Those are laws made to suppress women especially
How can u still be a Muslim and believe that? @@IamDanish99
It's Democracy
Malaysia is a federation comprised of Malaya, Sabah & Sarawak. Though Islam is the religion of the federation, the country is secular in nature as it places the Federal Constitution as its highest law. All communities accepted this when Malaya gained its independence in 1957 and when Malaysia was formed in 1963. Unfortunately some politicians are riding on this issue to garner votes from conservative Muslims.
Especially the corrupt politicians
Sarawak is a state with Christian majority, yet no protest to enact christian based laws. Seems obvious Christians are of higher moral grounds with greater respect for the beloved Malaysia.
@cmoma.
Hanya fasal agama.
Nanti sama2 rakyat dlm negara, negeri akan salam faham dan bermusuhan.
Siapa untung.
Setan yang untung.
Sarawak is an Asian heaven.
Sarawak will be under siege in no time.
Sarawak and Sabah should join and form their own country.
@@earlysda Sarawak tidak akan gabung dengan Sabah sekiranya mahu berpisah dengan Semenanjung Malaysia, kerana Sabah ada terlalu banyak buaya Padang Pasir. Selain buaya yang buas, ada banyak masalah seperti tuntutan sultan Sulu, Philipine, kumpulan bersenjata dari kepulauan laut Sulu. Mungkin akan digasak oleh negara Cina. Masa depan Sabah macam Syria.
This was not about 'Islamic Laws'. It was about the Constitution. If those so-called 'Muslim Politicians' really wanted to enforce 'Islamic Laws' what they should have done was to amend the Constitution. Why they did not ? They wanted to politicise the issues. They wanted to create a situation where Islam as a Religion is under attack. Those politicians wanted to be a hero. In order to be a hero you need a villain. Now they have a villain, the Court. This is a time to spin and spin.
to amend the Constitution is for the federal politicians, not the States..
for so many years the state of kelantan called the federal government to amend the Constitution to allocate for the installment of Syariah Law for the whole country!
when the call was not heeded the state of kelantan had no choice but to at least establish syariah law for the State of Kelantan!
now it seems instead of supporting Kelantan, the small step taken by Kelantan lawmakers faces total destruction by the federal government & fellow muslims like yourself..how unfortunate & may Allah forgive us, you & me. aamiin
@@a_min60if shari'a law is passed how about the non muslim should they follow it?
@@justrawr6856Eventually it will be enforced to non-Muslims as well. The Indonesian province of Acheh uses the Shariah Law as well as Indonesian legal system to administer the province. Shariah law is supposed to be only used on Muslim offenders but there are cases where non-Muslims are punished according to Shariah Law. Several men are caned publicly for gambling, but they are not Muslims. An elderly Christian woman is also caned publicly for selling alcohol.
@@justrawr6856Initially they will say that it will not apply to non Muslims but step by step they will enforce it upon non Muslims. That's their strategy to establish the caliphate.
Politicians will kill this country. Tunku abdul rahman never thought PAS would exist after merdeka
Islam tends to eliminate opponents, so I fear for the lives of these two women. You don't tend to see the same modus operandi from Christians.
because christians are hypocrites and Muslims are peaceful ❤
They already did that in Middle Ages Europe. Now it is Islam's turn. Every religion has its high and low points in history. Karl Marx was right
@@farouqomaro598 I think we both know that Karl Marx wasn't "right", even Noam Chomsky concedes that.
Wow! I am amazed by the comments posted here by the people of Malaysia. Immense respect for them.
There is no place Sharia in the modern world. It must go.
One Law for all citizens
Hormatilah kedaulatan undang-undang negara sendiri. Undang-undang negara Arab Saudi khas untuk Padang Pasir Arab sahaja.
They are so barbaric
Bro, one law for all citizens is actually Islamic law.
@@sheffieldgeek what is federal constitution my friend, islamic law belong to Padang Pasir Arab.
@@sheffieldgeekgeek, so you think it is fine to impose Islamic laws on everybody?
One can be religious, whether it is Muslim, Christian, Hindus or Buddhist, but one should NOT be a fanatic in their religion and impose their believes, practice & their religious laws on others.
Who are you to say your God is true & my God is not?
You have your ‘Holy’ book & I have mine.
p.s. Oops! Talking religions is like ‘throwing the rock into the volcano’ 🙏
True. But after 911 , the extremists are still strong.
Islam is no better then any othe fantasy religion. So you think some prophet ascend to 7th heaven riding a winged donkey with female human head?
Like you didn't know the one particular religion flock how they behaving 😂
I agree
tanchye, There is only one true God. His name is Jesus, and he created this world and everything in it by speaking it into existence in 6 days, then rested the 7th.
He never forces the conscience.
Well done ladies!! Congratulations on your success in the courts! You have no doubt helped so many people.
Why emphisise ladies? Also you knowthat the laws struck doesn't mean those offences are now legal they are to be dealt with in federal corts rather than state ones
the sooner you dump sharia laws, the better
Religion and government should always be separate. If someone wants to participate in religious practices, let them. If someone wants to impose those practices on others, that cannot be allowed.
And that is where you run into a death trap with muslim families..!
And thats how you get overthrown, state religions protect the government in these places of the world
unless if it is a cult that harms human beings (like human sacrifices, gaslighting, or promotes discrmination)
then those kinds of religions should be banned
@@mistergrindr3634 True. Religions requiring killing the ”non-believers” should be banned.
@@mistergrindr3634 any belief system that infringes on human rights cannot be allowed to govern. If people want to voluntarily participate, that is up to them except when it involves manipulation, mental, or physical abuse, especially of others. It’s a slippery slope when you ban beliefs, but I agree those practices must be prosecuted according to secular law. If you have a parallel system, like Sharia courts, then prosecute in accordance with those laws as well. That said, the secular law prevails when it comes to punishments like imprisonment, torture, and the death penalty.
as so many leaders have said before " islam cannot coexist in a democratic country as it cannot separate state and mosque - this is why islamic societies struggle with heterogenous ideas and herd mentatity approaches to socio economic issues
Yes it's cause in Islam the religion permeates through every aspect of life and government. Outlines how literally almost everything should be. Christianity does not control everything to that extent which is why it's so compatible with secular society and democracy. It allows culture to be preserved while still worshipping the same God as other believers around the globe.
@@andrewsantillan6020 as a Christian I agree we do separate state and church which is why liberty is a much bigger trend in Christian dominated countries but if Islamic countries do this separation straight away it won't work because then the constitutional laws would be directly taken from religious law book and I m referring to the hadeef which is another discussion anyways... The solution is to always put religious courts at a permanent disposition by making it less than the official judiciary of that country... However any challenges to sharia means putting secular law above religious law which will threaten the effect of the religious law. Islam as a spiritual belief is way to barbaric and the actions of Isis are just an eye opener to the actual rules and regulations to be followed by the quran... The West must not entertain a cultural hug with such countries and vice versa!
@@danCK1990 Christian worship their desires as God whereas muslims worship God only.Thats why every religion is jealous on muslims trying to follow their religion
Thats because most of you have come to the uk for a western way of life @@momytik
There is no such thing as "mosque and state" in Islam. There has never been any thing like pope or clergy that has authority or power in Muslim societies. How come you do not understand so basic?
Many shariah laws violate basic human rights anyone who is in favor of shariah law should be put on a watch list.
I’m in favour of Shariah law 😊
@@bobbobby3085 Then live in cave
@@maxpro6379 Why?
@@bobbobby3085 coz people like you are disgrace in this modern world who think 1400 years old Stone Age rule still good for this mankind
@@bobbobby3085.Why ? Because Shariah laws are very effective in jungles, but those are totally useless in human society. This is why a cave is the best place to practice the great Shariah laws.
People should be able to believe in what they like. But not force it on others or kill others over them. I am glad Malaysia is moving forward to be free from the shackles of religious repression. As an Englishman i love and respect Malaysia and its good people. Who deserve freedom and the best life can be afforded to them. Its a nice feeling being free and changing laws if they are antiquated or ridiculous.
You know this ruling does not mean Sharia law is gone? You do realise in Islam that you cannot force religion on others? You do realise you are completely and utterly wrong?
Oh yes it does look at history .@@bobbobby3085
Sane normal people should rule a country .Not religious gangsters .@@bobbobby3085
You dont know what your talking about .You sound like a college student who has not learnt much about the world. I have and your talking out of your backside little man.@by3085
Even Malaysia is not free from Jihadist ideology...
Same people creating problems every where
Lol Malaysia is a conservative muslim country. It will NEVER be free from jihadists.
The majority have no real idea about their religion. I lived there for 15 years. Their so called leader(s) are using a religion to bully the Chinese & Indians. Funnily it has created a vacuum; both legal & illegal immigrants from Bangladesh & Rakhine have flooded the country using the religion as a pass. Their method gonna blow up big time lol
You have no idea
I have a better solution, might as well merge Perlis, Kedah, Terengganu and Kelantan into some kind of New Federation of Caliphates and secede them from Malaysia so that they can build a nation based on whatever syariah law they want, then they will be dubbed the “Afghanistan or Pakistan of Southeast Asia”. Don’t involve the whole Malaysia, we are a multi racial and multi religious country with different beliefs and cultures. Those Malaysians especially the fundamentalist minded Muslims whom don’t like the idea of multicultural or a multireligious identity can move to the newly Islamic Republic of Kelantan or whatever you want to call it.
Same book different people
In Australia , we had traditional Aboriginal tribal laws, where if convicted by elders, the accused can receive punishment such as spearing into the back of your legs. I'm glad the federal government has intervened to make this illegal!
UN should declare shariya law as inhuman and cruelty.
UN should declare shariya law is the only solution for world peace and prosperity,Do you know shariya law first read then comment ok
By an 8-1 majority, the Federal Court ruled on Friday that the Kelantan state government did not have the power to enact the laws, on offences from sodomy to sexual harassment, possession of false information, intoxication and scale measurements, because they were already covered in civil law and were the responsibility of the federal parliament.
Religion is personal and free, not interfering with how others live their lives or how government control how your life. Thats no longer religion. People who attempt that should have the religion removed from their ID. Thats not religion, thats shameful political doctrine with a hue of shameful terrorism.
Other than sexual harrassment, the government should not have laws concerning those things anyway. "Possessing false information" is outlawing any opinion you do not agree with essentially. I will keep my freedom of speech thankyou. 🙂
@@AliciaGuitarit's actually "giving false evidence" not "possession of false information".
Unless Islam is removed from Malaysia, the country of Malaysia is doomed.
thank you for this summary😊😊
Democracy when its convenient, but no democracy when you dont like something.
Who said anything about no democracy??? Do people like you have their ears in their asshole or something ??
That's the business of politics
Always the case! Just look at our Democrats 😢
Islam is problem for the world.
@@ThomasRogan-gc5pi You mean the Republicans who want a Christo-fascist state run by the "right" sect of Christianity. You're delusional my friend.
Muslims on other land
We want to preach our religion peacefully we have right to preach
Muslim in islamic land
You cant preach you religion in Muslim countries
💯💯
Protect other religious people in your country from this evil religion and its laws...🙏
“Courts have ruled that 16 sharia laws are barbaric and primitive”
What are those laws ya?
Its funny to see Islamphobe comment here😂. U assume islam is bad, but u are forgot and blind for ur own country with ur horrible "modern laws". When compare to islamic law u can see how islamic law is heavenly and protect humanity from falsehood and sinful. Example qatar with islamic law, u can see the qatar for a year!!! only have 1 or 2 cases!!of crime Compare to other country with their "modern law" with so much criminal cases per year. U can even sleep outside with ur gold in qatar and no one gonna steal it!!
@@radishwhite7834 Some of those being not allowing necrophilia, riba in business and sex before marriage. Now, who's fuck up?
@@sandcrakes the last one being illegal before is so stupid lmao. People have been having sex long before any religion existed, who are you to impose religious ideals on nature😂
If sharia enacted in the constitution. Peaceful progressive Indonesia will perhaps another Pakistan besides Egypt.
What those protesters do not seem to understand is that the ruling does not in any way undermine Islamic legal system nor the official religion of the country.
It merely corrected where Kelantanese state stepped beyond established boundaries.
I have a better solution, might as well merge Perlis, Kedah, Terengganu and Kelantan into some kind of New Federation of Caliphates and secede them from Malaysia so that they can build a nation based on whatever syariah law they want, then they will be dubbed the “Afghanistan or Pakistan of Southeast Asia”. Don’t involve the whole Malaysia, we are a multi racial and multi religious country with different beliefs and cultures. Those Malaysians especially the fundamentalist minded Muslims whom don’t like the idea of multicultural or a multireligious identity can move to the newly Islamic Republic of Kelantan or whatever you want to call it.
Those people are lacking a lot in the upstairs department.
1@@cjshow-zp6nh
Brainwashed
@@cjshow-zp6nh Oh no please....These people are dangerous and scary to live with. Its best that they be relocated somewhere in the remote like an island or what away from the civilization.
Why can't these individuals do the same when even the UK's King distances himself from politics?
Chad Malaysian Court 🗿
*Religion should not impede a fair legal system.*
the religion is more fair than your legal system. but you do not want to even look into it because of your stupidity and you think you know everything
How does this impede secular laws?
Implementing religious laws is BY DEFINITION impeding on secular laws!@@bobbobby3085
@@bobbobby3085it may have the possibility to impead secular law, by overruling particular secular laws deemed vital into protecting the rights and duties of its citizens...
For instance, protecting murder from being criminalised under certain conditions which Islam may or may not condone as just...
Reconfiguring marriage customs the way Islam would dictate as best policy...
Redirecting taxpayer money towards whatever Islam considers worthy...
Changing education requirements and expectations and freedoms to whatever Islam dictates as a proper education...
Altering the rights and responsibilities of men and women, as such, to whatever Islam considers just and proper...
There are many things to consider in elevating any religious group to a predominant power...
There are many cases studies of various cults and cult leaders to demonstrate how pathological it can get...
@@Ockerby If you would actually look into what this ruling actually means it was just a matter of federal vs states jurisdiction
All the matters you listed were not affected by this ruling the laws which were declared unconstitutional did not include education, marriage etc
Having an 'official state religion ' is where your problem started
You would rather be under atheism ? You must be out here transitioning to the other sex while giving yourself 20 pronouns 🤣🤣
So true it's where every problem starts for a democratic country
Don't mix religion and politics
unfortunately Islam is political by it's very nature - unlike almost all major religions who only prescribe general guiding principles Islam expects that you live your entire life day in day out according to sharia law, and that also means de facto enforcement is deemed necessary
the most infamous one to be example is Israel lol
See how they want secularism and tolerance and acceptance in all other countries except in Islamic countries. Being hypocrites and touting victimhood is their trademark.
Bravo for bringing Malaysia from the C7th into the C21st. It's a wonderful country with fantastic people.
A win for humanity, logism and science. What a day!
And for porn
No way bro really thinks that 😂 this is an issue of states right it does not mean Sharia will be gone at all remember Malaysia is a Muslim country you’d realise this if you actually used some of that reason and logic you so love 💀
@@bobbobby3085 Slowly the world is turning atheistic. Soon people will leave religion.
@@ku5285 Ok and? 💀 You sound like some cult leader rn 😂 The vast majority of people are still religious and in most parts of the world religion isnt declining remember theres other places outsidethe west 🤣
@@bobbobby3085 Welp if the punishment for leaving religion is a death penalty, then obviously nobody will leave💀.
Imagine being so insecure abt a religion, that you k!ll them for leaving 😂😂.
All major developed countries are turning atheistic, 3rd world countries too are following.
Women demanding Sharia law in this 21 century😢 i have no words to say.... its sick😷🤒🤢
They hate themselves
Chickens supporting KFC😂🤣
they are religious fanatic people, they don't have concern for other women s
They are affected by virus
I was just saying shameful. They love being whipped.
Indian court should learn from it as well. India need Uniform civil code
Exactly
India need shariya law for peace and prosperity in the country
@@mdtahir3502 chitiya 😅🤣🤣...the world will be peaceful without anything related to a specific cult of a religion
@@mdtahir3502then why their is no peace in Islamic countries. IND is a Hindu rastra. ban Islamic terrorism and Sharia law
Congratulations malaysia for such dare devil announcement, hope malaysia will become secular soon
Desert cult is dangerous
0nly denger0us for k*fir
No... Idiots are dangerous... And I think one of them is here which I am replying to...
May The True God overthrow it forever.feel sorry for its brainwashed victims...
Lund pujaris are not allowed here....😂
are you a cow worshipper
Why are there even "religious courts" in the first place?
Religious courts are not legally binding. They are between consenting parties who wants to resolve an issue without the intervention of the state judicial system. This exists for Jews (and maybe other religions) around the globe as well.
google? don't have it in your country?
@@user-sd7ce4pd5s Of course you miss my point.
@@SockieTheSockPuppet there was no point in the first place
@user-sd7ce4pd5s Yes, there was. Little scary how obvious it is and you still don't see it.
thank god our Federal Court still above the islamic court.
Don't mix religion with politics. No other religion is superior than the other. It is between you and your God.
Religion has to be an entirely private matter. I would react very angrily if anybody would try to convert me. My wife, a devout Christian, knows that, although she doesn't fully understand my animistic belief, which has no clergy, no books and no specific places of worship. I leave her totally alone with her belief, and we have the understanding that she leaves me totally alone with mine. And we are married for more than 27 years.
Secularism is trash. Islam is political and counters man-made ideologies such as democracy and communism.
That's the problem of islam.
@@wernerschneider4460how it should be, for EVERYONE. Congratulations on your successful marriage.
The religion that God has revealed, is true and superior to all other philosophies.
It is strange that people are against a religion consdering itself superior but yet consider the western secular system to be superior. What a contradiction.
All countries that want to keep their identities must speak against a hateful ideology.
If they want these laws move to a country that has them.
Well said!!
Like Sudan and Pakistan. Problem is they also don't want to stay in these places which their faith has already totally messed up. They migrate as refugees!
Malay identity is islam
For context, the issue isn't even being anti shariah or anything, the issue is that there were already federal laws dealing with the specific issues mentioned which had more severe punishments than the shariah enactments made state level. Due to this, 16 out of 18 of the the state level enactments became null. Almost all the issues in question are still punishable, not legalised.
You made an important point when you noted that the punishment meted out by Sharia law is generally not as harsh as federal law in Malaysia. Because of Sharia, muslim men can get away with lenient or nonexistent punishment for crimes like rape, domestic violence, honor killings, and such. This change is a really big deal, especially for women!
Thanks for the clarification
Very bold step by Supreme Court of Malaysia. Where sharia starts, humanity and freedom dies.
Only in "Hislam."
"A REAL Muslim believes..."
That when God said there was to be no compulsion in religion, he meant every last aspect of religion.
If I commit a crime against you, you have every right to seek recompense.
But if I commit a Sin against God...
God does not need your help.
Average bbc/fox news watcher
@@BilalKhan-cq6mnhe is a hindu. A hindu will always hate Islam as their idols are thrown by muslims
They really think defending human rights against imposing extremist religious ideology is “challenging” and “discriminating” against muslims… Each person should individually pursue their religion in their own and not impose it to others, a thing extremist muslims do not understand it seems.
And thats why religion and State must be separate. You can freely practice religion without it dictating your country's laws
Agree
Agree, but many muslims do not understand that.
hence forth, it says in the quran to dominate over the world and use Sharia to you country to "honor" allah
Then after you capture them, it says in the Quran to kill them except the women and make these women your slaves
WATCH APOSTATE PROPHET AND DAVID WOOD
Muslim politicians trying to paint who's the enemy of islam, only for them to make an enemy out of each other
Tell that to Vatican city
@@drakensingh9856 The Vatican doesnt persecute other religions present within or adjacent their country
It's high time for the supreme federal court to take action against all these bogus state legislations for good
Saman Terengganu sekali la Ah Cong.
The two women are role models for women all over the world. Stop being brainwashed by religions which opress women and girls.
The ruling this time was 8-1. Muslim countries do not become more tolerant over time. The case will come up again in the future. There will be a new judge, and the ruling will be 7-2 in favor of freedom. A couple years later the court will need to decide again, but the ruling will be a narrow 5-4. It's only a question of time. Eventually Malaysia will sadly careen into a pit of religious authoritarianism.
@@harrisiskandar8356 on the way nanti, wahai pentaksub ajaran PPA
@@DemPilafian it dosen't matter, some jurisdiction matters needed to cleared for good because this has been pending for a long time
"Sharia law' aka barbarism. Yeah, pretty good to have government to decide all nationals face the same laws and independent of their religion.
Good Show. Never let your country be dictated by one religious group control.
They should be more worried about corruption, fitnah, lying etc.....
And child marriage
@@keangwooichoo6138 and LGBTQ gabage ideologi
Cost of living... Increase... Politicians politicking... People's are suffering... Islam is way of life... Every aspect of living... Not just worshipping...how to manage the country... Even How you go to toilet... Can any religion show how to spit... Islam shows... So make research and study about Islam before you are dead...
also child marriage, mutah (legal prostitution) and permission to have secret wives.
Also HOMO sex miniac .
Good to see malysia moving forward from ancient to 21st , ai stage. Keep stiving
The world would be a much better place without this so called law.
What's the Mosque name in the thumbnail? it has Iranic and Indian design ❤
Kelantan legislature had overstepped its authority by passing state law that infringe upon an individual liberty and rights under protection by Federal law.
I have a better solution, might as well merge Perlis, Kedah, Terengganu and Kelantan into some kind of New Federation of Caliphates and secede them from Malaysia so that they can build a nation based on whatever syariah law they want, then they will be dubbed the “Afghanistan or Pakistan of Southeast Asia”. Don’t involve the whole Malaysia, we are a multi racial and multi religious country with different beliefs and cultures. Those Malaysians especially the fundamentalist minded Muslims whom don’t like the idea of multicultural or a multireligious identity can move to the newly Islamic Republic of Kelantan or whatever you want to call it.
@@cjshow-zp6nhnot gonna happen. keep dreaming DAP. u can't rule Malaysia.
@@cjshow-zp6nh The fundamentalist whom don’t like the idea of multicultural or a multireligious identity can move to Afghanistan , Iran or Yemen, but they want to stay here, they must adhere to Malaysian Constitution and accept Malaysian Jurisprudence without exception. Your suggestion requires the consent of all 4 Malay sultans owners of those states, not whatever people.
@@FoodRoo 🥱 mat jenin, they already ruling your economy. One more step to rule..
@@glurppuffloid9796 To understand this problem of Malayisa’s religious division we need to look back at history of how Malaysia became radicalised, This all this started after the Iranian Revolution in 1979 which the secular system was abandoned in favour of the fundamentalist Islamic governance led by Imam Khomeini all because they want to depose the secular but autocratic Shah monarchy whom was viewed as the agent of the Zionist west by the radicals under the slogan “Islam is the solution”.
This move then spillover into other Islamic countries including Malaysia which some of our major Malay Islamic parties adopted this motto and this causes a political competition between UMNO and PAS during the 1980s to see who can out”Islam” each other to see who is more “Islam” and this is how we got into this mess today.
Not only that, Some of our ulamas whom have studied in countries like Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan where Islamic fundamentalism is rampant even in some institutions, brought back the radical form of Islam back into Malaysia and this adds more salt to the wound.
Our country is secular. Period
It was before it got invaded by islam .. now just word secular left
Bruh don’t you know your own history islam spread to malaysia through trade.
@@kamroneshkqobilov1040 Most Indians have this impression that Islam came through war and conquest everywhere. They don't know, for instance, that the southern state of Kerala is very similar to Indonesia in the sense that Islam spread peacefully through trade and cultural exchange.
@@MostLucid Thanks for telling me the two exceptions in the entire world.
@@MostLucid In Kerala also Islamic extremists tried to establish an Islamic state in the 1920s. But it was put down by the British who were ruling India at that time.
what were the 16 Sharia State Laws?
Not every Malaysian is Muslim. The law must apply equally to all.
Not a Muslim country. But a country with majority Muslims & Islam is official religion
If idiot dont comment.. Malaysia is muslim country and member of Organisation of Islamic Countries.. also halal hub world, islamic finance best in world, and friendly muslim tourism..
Only over 60% are Muslims, the rest are non muslims.
Not Muslim country? So, funny. 😂
It is a muslim-majority country because majority are Malays who are automatically muslims according to the Constitution. But it is NOT ISLAMIC (theocratic).
@@honeyho9890 and that doesn't mean anything at all...
Malaysia is by constitution. No constitution, no Malaysia.
We don't need then
Malaysia is a Muslim major country so it belongs to Muslim
Nobody needs ur logic
@@Noname-zs2tb Say what you want. The Federal Constitution still remains as the supreme law of Malaysia, super seceding the Sharia state laws. That’s the fact you need to accept. Kau gi lah baca balik tentang Perlembagaan. Malaysia belongs to all Malaysians, regardless of race or religion. 2024 dah ni pakcik oi. Palahotak kau tu jgn hapak sgt lah.
Federal
They fear it would undermine religious courts? Good! Courts have to be neutral in any way not driven by religion.
Finally, a victory for those who want freedom in Malaysia!
It is about conflict between federal laws and state laws. That is all that there is to it. If you still want them, go change the federal laws, with 2/3 votes in parliament.
I pray for the safety and well being of the malay lady lawyer who challenged the kelantan state law. May God always protect her and her family from her own kind who has gone to Satan and threatened her life.
👍 me too
Do you think God prefer her to live under His law or the human's law? If want protection from Him, shouldnt we live under his rule? If she wants to live under human rule than ask human to protect her la.
@user-nq1sk3kl4b humans twist your God's law. Did you meet God and clarified those laws yourself? Or you just follow what others wrote?
May Gd protect her against the minions of Allah(aka Satan). 1 John 2:22 - Such is the Antichrist(Satan), he denies the Father(Gd) and the Son(Jesus).
@@user-nq1sk3kl4b But Allah is not god. Allah is Satan. Only Satan will have a prophet that violates Gd's 10 Commandments and still dare to shamelessly call himself a holy prophet.
Laws and governments should be secular, you cannot let religious dogma be laws, will you also allow laws of Zues or Thor also be legal laws?
So sad to see this unique people stripped of their ancestral religion and culture, seeing them brainwashed by an Judeo-Arabic religion. I hope they can reclaim the way of their ancestors!
Greetings from Sweden!✋🏻💙💛🇸🇪
💯💯
The protestor might want to read the judgment. This has nothing to do with Islamic laws but has everything to do with the jurisdiction that the state legislature has over the subject matters that it can or cannot make laws for. Malaysia is a Muslim majority nation and not an Islamic theocratic state.
They won't, because they are brainwashed by PAS and their rational is hijacked by their anger and fear and whatever the PAS brainwashed them.
an example of a country that only prioritizes a certain religion but when it comes to other religious beliefs it will close itself off and not care is truly ironic and hypocritical
But everywhere else they will cry minority and victim card
Insecurity rules..
As if other countries don't do the same
Some judges in India are guilty of appeasing the Modi Government with its majoritarian Hindu ideology@@aenirrinea523
@@aenirrinea523 only islamic countries do that, no other countries do the same.
Let me tell you an anecdote about Sabah based on Philippine history, cause I'm Pinoy.
Once upon a time Sabah used to be a Philippine territory. We'll it was going to be by the 1960s or 70s something. Why? Let's just say that the president of that time (Google it, it's interesting between the global POV and the Pinoy POV) requested it be settled, cause that's how territory-making worked, old school style or something.
But then came along the president's infamous "opponent": his very own bestie. Yes. Just a jealous one, cause the girl who the guy ditched ends up becoming the president's girlboss goddess of a wife.
Another to consider is that bestie was like in his head to the president "that was supposed to me bro!" cause guy actually liked power, covering it by being righteous and heroic and sht.
Which was why bestie met with the homies who haven't moved on from WW2 and said "if this means war it means war".
So they blew things up around the country.
Now here's the interesting part. Bestie made a deal with terrorists from Malaysia. He was like "I receive= gang gang; you receive= Sabah".
And because the new jaundice government of 1986 didn't give a fck about Sabah, hence it's free real estate for Malaysia who were probably like "I see this as an absolute win".
Bravo Malaysia !❤
Respect!
No
As an ex Muslim Malaysian, this is good news. Its a sign that Malaysia is becoming educated and modern.
Oh like some civilised country that bombing other countries? Sure dude. Religion or not, education always there
Oh like some civilised country that bombing other countries? Sure dude. Religion or not, education always there
May you find your way back. But still, its up Allah whether you are worthy or not
@@user-nq1sk3kl4b Nope, it's up to him to choose. Religion is a personal matter in almost every prosperous secular democratic country with freedom of/from religion.
The government should be protecting everyone's rights to practice religion but there are no favoured state religion, all are equal regardless of race or gender.
@@Pr0fane26a secular country/law is even more intolerant of religious icons be it Hinduism, Sikhsm, Christianity or Islam.
There us a reason why there is a seperation of religion and state. Too much fanaticism impedes development.
You said it 100%
And that seperation has led to kids being able to take drugs to change their gender
@@ren.8137 That is what they call the pursuit of happiness.The fundamental rights of citizens.
@@Laser593 Pursuit of happiness? There are many things that will make you feels happy, physically and mentally. If taking drugs is fun then this country and its future generation are doomed. People are encouraging something so out of place it is a miracle that God didn't burn this world yet.
@@syahmellow5114 You can pursuit happiness as long as you don't break the laws of the land. Plain and simple.
People don't know exactly what sharia is. They think it's Islamic Law and that's why all these confusion. Basically a tribal law where a group of people fallows. It it's not the law for the whole community due to other tribal existence. When a solution aren't in tribal affairs than they go outside of the tribe. Now combined tribes are formed in one, so sharia is not acceptable.
Good!! May it fade away into obscurity where sharia law belongs ❤
Why do you think this way?
@@bobbobby3085 it is a pox to logic, individual freedom, women's rights, and progressive society.
@@TheDrackOfSpades It isn’t any of that you have just listed don’t know where you get such outdated ideas from but ok 🤷♂️
@@bobbobby3085 what does sharia law say if you want to walk your town topless as a women... tell me.
@@TheDrackOfSpades It says it’s sinful and that such a women and all the men who ogle her are sinful but that matter is between her and God on the day of judgement and all the authorities can do is tell her to cover up and maybe possibly impose a fine. It must be noted that such a similar action is illegal in most of the world and can be punished by fines and prison time in most western countries
Hidup Malaysia! A Malaysia for ALL Malaysians!
Respect to the brave Mother - daughter duo... These ugly laws have no place in modern society...
says a person who follows a stone age religion and also has never read his own religious scriptures nor does he have any intention to follow it.
This is an islamic country .. if you don't like it then go travel to australia like sajat and apply citizen ship there .. we do not need traitor in our country.
@@zorton7461 have you read yours?? I have read so many because we don't have "single book" we have libraries...😇
1 idiot gave a single book to his community which has so many flaws, & now it became cult that is causing harm to society.. when those cult people were living in caves...We had whole civilisation which has given so many things to this world, so please don't teach who is following barbaric cult... even stone age people had good morals than them.. they never married to their own sister, like this cult do...
@@ThePhiloSpheresgo back Palestine if you want shariah laws 😊
@@forytube4998 why Malaysia is same islamic as palestine or any other islamic country. by the way Palestine is not waiting for you with garlands
Also a good way to get your products banned from export.
Thank goodness!!!!!!
The crimes those laws are concerned with are still illegal what happened was not the dismantling of islamic law but just a jurisdiction dispute between the state and federal government
Malaysia is a secular state, not a muslim state
who said malaysia is secular ? syariah law still exist in malaysia and islam as official religion. anwar also said malaysia is not secular
Not a secular state nor an Islamic state.
@@aqildarwisy-np3ds The Federal Constitution already guarantees "freedom of religion" which by definition means a secular state. Islam is the official religion but it is not above the Federal Constitution, which also then confirms that it is not a Muslim state.
Did everybody forget the basics of common law or the history of Malaysia's formation?
@nicholasj5798 Many idiots think muslim majority population = Islamic country 😂
@@aqildarwisy-np3ds dude... We are neither secular or islamic... According to the Court...
Puan Nik Elin should be our next Prime Minister ! She is a women of calibre and courage ! We neen women like her to save Malaysia from becoming a TALIBAN STATE ! We pray for Pn Nik Elina's safety !
😂😂😂
Yup, until MYR slide further to myr10 to usd1...😅
Count my support in for this wonderful woman Pn Nik Elin. Will not forget this adorable name till the rest of my life.
Naaah Sharia laws are fairer and provides better protection to society against the immoral liberal values imported from the West
If Dr m can, why not her
Only if we Indians could learn from fellow democracy.
Either read the news or display in bold letters with time for people to read.
Malaysia has a written Federal Constitution since independence in 1957 the King or Yang di Pertuan Agong, the Federal Government and Constituent States must not place themselves above the law.
Think rationally. If a law is unconstitutional , the court has no choice but to say so.
Please respect the court and judges.
@@hotpot4170 yes.. That's why they struck down those 16 laws...
Bila agama islam d lecehkan d permalukan d negara agama resminya agama islam.dan hanya berlaku zaman Anuar Ibrahim ..
@@starcaptain6159 diamlah..
Most MPs swear on the Contitution but DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING.Maybe they should be more Educated on the Supreme Law of the Land.
Again, a bad education system has stifled and enslaved brains. Religious leaders like this!
Good for you guys !!
There is a big difference between religious decree and national law. It is important to keep church (of whatever type) separate from state.
Malaysia is a secular country (not a theocratic country !) having islam as the official religion with federal constitutional laws as its highest supreme order.
This is the actual constitution but extremist from kelantan led by pas party is spreading hatred towards concerts and towards non muslims
Islam as official religion but cannot enact islamic law. Your logic is worse than a 4 year old's logic
@@keangwooichoo6138dap Communist want communist village being got UNESCO recognize 🤣
Secular country with Islam as official religion?...that sound so Dumb....how a secular State mentioned about religion in it constitution and having Muslim King as head of state make Malaysia secular country ??😂... Malaysia is purely Islamic country you just refuse to accept it...💁
@@ayahpinkofficial2769 orang melayu masuk komunis juga, ramai tinggal di China tak balik bonggok.
Muslim Countries are different from the west, so the ideas many people expose here will not necessarily apply to Muslim Countries. The problem with Malaysia and every other Muslim Country is that Islam is a System that includes rules for Social, State, Political, Justice, Behaviour and Existencial norms, more than any other Religion. Their justice system relies mostly on the words of the Prophet than in actual facts. And that was reflected in the decision. That guy is one of the reasons that I will never visit Malaysia again, or any other Muslim country due to their retrograde and unfair laws. Look at Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, etc, and see the denigrating laws and conditions those countries have, I know coz I lamentably been there........
Religion should never be involved in the legal system. Anybody that thinks it should has a primitive mind. Religion is for your heart and your home not for Law. This primitive mindset should not be tolerated anywhere.
I have lived in several SE Asian countries, including Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, the Philippines, and Vietnam, also having traveled through Laos, Cambodia and many others. In my view, Malaysia has the most potential to develop into a very strong regional economy and become a significant international player. This recent court decision just further confirms that Malaysia is on the right path of development. It's as if Singapore had a child with a very bright future! 🙏
A country like Malaysia which doesn't allow its citizens to marry whom they want to marry, except they convert to another religion, is not the place where I want to live in. In the Philippines, the state doesn't care about religion, when two people fall in love and want to get married. My wife and I have totally different religions and neither her family, not any officials nor she herself cared about it. And I don't care about it either.
That joke right.
@@wernerschneider4460 I believe divorced isn't allowed in Philippines for their citizens, and its due to religious (Catholicism) interference with the state? That is one thing that had made me really uncomfortable with Philippines as there's no separation of religion from government.
@@wernerschneider4460yes that’s one thing that made me not date or marry a Malay. True love does not involve conversion and religion. Nor does it involve the family members .
Oh. Wouldnt it be Indonesia who has the potential? They have an enormous land mass and population to be mobilized to what their direction is. Also, they have vast amounts of natural resources. And Indonesia still shares the same Malacca Straits. They have more potential imo. Just my opinion tho
Very peaceful..
Yeah like some civilised countries that love bombing other countries abd call them terrorist
Of course its peaceful. If we compare with hindus where they dont care about the environment, or buddhist where its all about money, or christians where theres a lot of crime in majority christian people, muslim still way better
Very peaceful indeed 🤣
😂😂😂
By a person who haven't go to Malaysia or 1 single Islamic country
One time Malaysians are all Buddhist, Hindhus, they were converted to Islam so may be a Islamic country present because of Islam population secondry but first which religion was there must not forget reality.Born to a mother she is real mother may be you got 2nd mother it will not be equal to first.
How about then majority Christian Sarawak to pass its own State laws based on Christianity beliefs system? 😊
Cuz shariah is worse
u can have u own laws applied for ur own people...we muslim don't even care just as this sharia don't apply to u christian so wht's ur excuse u want to invol urself in smthing tht dont have any relation with u??
Lunatic islamists are worst than christian people
Sharia doesn`t apply to non muslims , so what is your point anyways?
Shariah law apply to islamian najib and cronies?
A great decision by Highest Court of the land should be respected by all.
Tolerance is the willingness to forgive before an offense is made..