The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict explained on a map
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2024
- NEW VERSION ! More detailed and updated. Let’s retrace the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, from the Ancient History of the Jews, until today.
#Israel #Palestine #Israeli-Palestinian conflict #History #Summary #Explanation #Understand #Geo History
--------
Support the channel on Patreon: / geohistory
--------
English translation & voiceover: Matthew Bates www.epicvoiceover.com/
--------
Original French version: • Tout comprendre sur le...
Russian version: • Конфликт Израиля и Пал...
Arabic version: Coming soon
Spanish version: Coming soon
Portuguese version (Brazil): • COMPREENDA TODO O CONF...
Japanese version: • イスラエル・パレスチナ問題
Korean version: Coming soon
German version: • Die Geschichte von Pal...
--------
Musics (TH-cam Audio library)
Dark Zephyr - Audio Hertz
--------
Software: Adobe After Effects
--------
Chapters
00:00 A Brief Ancient History of the Jews
04:33 The Pogroms in Russia
06:06 Birth of the Zionist movement
08:00 Fall of the Ottoman Empire
09:38 The British Mandate for Palestine
10:58 The Great Arab Revolt
12:38 World War II
14:05 The UN Partition Plan for Palestine
15:45 The Civil War in Mandatory Palestine
17:32 The First Arab-Israeli War
19:40 The Suez Crisis
21:12 The Palestinian resistance
23:13 The Yom Kippur War
24:42 Attempts at Peace
26:29 The Second Intifada
28:21 The Gaza Strip
30:25 Israel-Hamas war
31:50 Which Future?
![เกิดใหม่ทั้งทีก็เป็นสไลม์ไปซะแล้ว ซีซั่น 3 - ตอนที่ 57 [ซับไทย]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pNhft3YZFRE/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm back! Sorry for the long delay. Due to the sensitivity of this topic, I spent more time on research. Also, the video is longer than usual, which means more editing work. I hope this video helps you to understand better this complex and controversial topic! Stay respectful in your comments, please. See you soon!
Glad you're back
Every video has amazing quality, take your time. 🙂
Hopefully blud doesnt get cancelled after the vid 🙏🙏
The Palestine Hotel (Arabic: فندق فلسطين), often referred to simply as The Palestine, is a 16-story hotel in Baghdad, Iraq located on Firdos Square near from Saadon, across from the Ishtar Hotel. It has long been favoured by journalists and media personnel. The hotel overlooks the Tigris on its eastern bank and is located several hundred metres south of the Baghdad Hotel.
History
Good luck, my friend.
Important to note: the Phillistines were Greek people, not the present day Palestinians who are arabs.
Are Palestinians really Arabs. Because I’ve done some research and it turns out Palestinians are more Levant than Arab.
@@KeViN-De-Belgium Palestinians are genetically very close to Jews and other Middle East populations, including Turks (Anatolians), Lebanese, Egyptians, Armenians, and Iranians.
@@KeViN-De-BelgiumLevant is more or less used to describe multiple countries put together through language and culture, similar to how Polynesia is not a county but has countries within them.
I am Palestinian and I am sure that we are Arabs. Palestinians have multiple origins, for example, my family's origin dates back to sudi arabia, my neighbor's origin dates back to Albania, and my other neighbor's origin dates back to the Greeks. We are a diverse people, now we are Arab and we speak Arabic، This is the case with the Israeli people as well
@@Rashed.m2005 i'm screen-shoting this comment
you just disproved the palestinian claim and proved the israeli side
who came to the land from all around the world, yet we sing the same songs, tell the same stories and can basically read texts from 3000 years ago.
no symmetry to speak of buddy.
and now, let's tell you why jerusalem is holy for muslims
seems that a prophecy came about exactly when the temple mound was conquered (700 years after the ch1ldmolester's demise)
making up a story about a dream he had where he flew on a donkey who's hoof touched the roof of the temple..
bruh.. islame just makes stuff uo as they go..
just like palestine.. you are no different then your arab friends all around, stop making israel a lame place like you make EVERY place.
99% of the comments about how bad the comment section is gonna be lol
and because of that there won't be any terrible comments
Clap your hands everyone, we have a real orignial thinker here.
1% being about geohistory coming back
Don't mind if i FREE PALESTINE?
This is what it call: you focus on who said it instead of focusing of what he actually said
This video doesn’t mention Egypt was offered Gaza back with the Sinai Peninsula and they didn’t want it.
Who offered it? what's your source?
@@user-ck6dy9tf2cbruh he’s right it should be common knowledge
@@ScythPlayz Well, he has to say who offered and what's his source, if it's that common.
@@user-ck6dy9tf2c @ScythPlayz
It's the Camp David Accords my friend. In 67 Israel also took the entire Sinai Peninsula which was part of Egypt. In 1978, as part of the Camp David accords, Israel agreed to give back the Sinai Peninsula and tried to make it a package deal including Gaza. Egypt refused the offer, saying Gaza was never part of Egypt.
They were not offered Gaza, and Gaza was never theirs to take in the first place. Gaza is a part of Palestine, and the Zionists just need to fucking leave and stop their genocide and illegal occupation.
And yet another point that is missing is that when Israel made peace with Jordan and Egypt, they refused to take West Bank and Gaza respectively under their control even though they used to occupy these territories before.
Precisely because it was occupation….
@@christopherkucia1071 Jordan literally annexed the entirety of the West Bank, and gave out Jordanian citizenship to all the arabs there. The occupation argument might fly for Gaza which wasn't officially made an Egyptian territory during this war but definitely not for the West Bank.
@@thesunisup_ i would say the west bank is more over given for palestinians to make their own land rather than just be part of israel this is complicated enough but to give perspective the arab nations would had suceeded if it wasn't for israelites to protest for independence and fight for their country as a nation ive seen mutliple videos before the war showing palestinians throwing rocks at israelites for entering the temple of jerusalem because according to the palestinians its their mosque which was built by the Umayyad caliphate who invaded israel and built the al aqsa mosque for their convenience
That's the most ignorant bullshit I've ever read. How much did the Jews pay you to make such an absurd claim with zero evidence to support it?
I have Jordanian and Egyptian friends who say that their respective countries can't stand Palestinians because all they do is cause problems and they align with Iran and Hamas.
This is going to be a very civil and respectful comment section
You should do stand-up comedy 😂
Palestine is not free
The Palestine Hotel (Arabic: فندق فلسطين), often referred to simply as The Palestine, is a 16-story hotel in Baghdad, Iraq located on Firdos Square near from Saadon, across from the Ishtar Hotel. It has long been favoured by journalists and media personnel. The hotel overlooks the Tigris on its eastern bank and is located several hundred metres south of the Baghdad Hotel.
History
Ancient Egypt was a civilization of ancient Northeast Africa. It was concentrated along the lower reaches of the Nile River, situated in the place that is now the country Egypt. Ancient Egyptian civilization followed prehistoric Egypt and coalesced around 3100 BC (according to conventional Egyptian chronology)[1] with the political unification of Upper and Lower Egypt under Menes (often identified with Narmer).[2] The history of ancient Egypt unfolded as a series of stable kingdoms interspersed by periods of relative instability known as “Intermediate Periods.” The various kingdoms fall into one of three categories: the Old Kingdom of the Early Bronze Age, the Middle Kingdom of the Middle Bronze Age, or the New Kingdom of the Late Bronze Age.
The Gulf War was an armed conflict between Iraq and a 42-country coalition led by the United States. The coalition's efforts against Iraq were carried out in two key phases: Operation Desert Shield, which marked the military buildup from August 1990 to January 1991; and Operation Desert Storm, which began with the aerial bombing campaign against Iraq on 17 January 1991 and came to a close with the American-led liberation of Kuwait on 28 February 1991.
Man was missing for half a year now i get it he was cooking
And he delivered
You should really be careful with the 'cooking' metaphor given the subject matter
Definitely cooking some BS
Cookin in the kitchen making stir fry
@@jimmysaber according to you
It’s really funny that people say that this is Pro Israel and others that its Pro Palestinian 🤣
Probably means it's neither
It's pro facts so people don't like that they're not matching with the lies they're fed on tiktok so clearly the video is wrong!
agreed this was vry unbiased but i thibnk there was some mis information
I’d say it’s pro-history
That seems neutral to me.
15:56 it's incorrect to use this flag while representing Palestinians before the creation of Israel this flag was only adopted in 1964
Correct! As indeed is the name Palestinians to describe the Muslim Arabs living in the territories!
Actually it's not incorrect but it's the other way around, he talks about and shows the Arab Revolt flag (or flag of Heetzaz). At that time, it did not represent Palestinians but Arab nationalism and pan-arabism. It was later adapted by the PLO.
@@brianbeagArabs have forgotten that they used the hate the name Palestine once because it means invader in Jewish. I wonder why!
And Israel's flag, the seal of solomon or star of remphan want used until 1948
True, but the only official flag for the region at the time was the Union Jack, he needs a flag to represent the Palestinian Arabs, what else should he use?
Egypt: Palestinians are our brothers in language & faith.
Also Egypt: co-blockades.
Egypt hates the Muslim Brotherhood
The thing is, as soon as Egypt accepts them, they will never be able to return to their homes again. Eliminating the hope for a Palestinian state.
Egypt is controlled by z10n1sts (sisi’s government)
@@hassanmady7763 same as how the Palestinians in Lebanon,Syria and Jordan are yet to return. People blame the Palestinian diasporas for Black September and the ignition of Lebanese civil war but forget the root cause, Al-Nakba and expulsion of the Palestinians.
@@johnxina5126 they intend to forget. To suit their narrative
Love that this channel isn't afraid to just state facts as they are with a simple animation that's easy to follow.
Facts are just evil for the fundamentalists.
Facts are not 100% concrete like a forbidden knowledge that people are afraid to talk about. No, one MUST research sources with different biases to come out with facts through the huge cloud of information
It may sound pedantic but it gives him more credit rather than just, "Facts!!!!" because the video will always inadvertently come out biased in one aspect or another
@@tonybehaviour9945 will people please stop with the. “He missed this in x years” because of course that’s like saying oh you need to get every s single minor detail like this guy breathed at this time on this day at this second etc.
When it comes to history what really is a fact? It's not like natural science, once people are involved nothing is a rigorous fact
@@bian7744 the most accurate account of anything, is to be taken as fact. so a pro palestinian says: someone killed an innocent child, a pro israeli says: someone killed a child in self defense, then a non biased source says: someone killed a child who threw a rock at him, which could be seen as self defense, but could be argued upon if the force was necessary
2 important things to mention: Palestinians aren't Philistines, while the Philistines were a Greek tribe the Palestinians are Arabs aka originated in Saudi Arabia.
Secondly, the name Palestine was originally Philistia and it was given to the land of Israel after the defeating of the Bar Kohkva revolt in the 2nd century as a way to mock the Jews as the name Philistia as you might have already guessed is derived from the Philistines who were one of the biblical enemies of the Israelites (Jews). At the time of the Ottoman empire the land wasn't called "Palestine" but it was ruled under the governing of the Egyptian region of the Ottoman empire, after the Brits conquered the land of Israel they called both Jordan and Israel "the British mandate of Palestine (or Palestina) א"י, א"י means the land of Israel (ארץ ישראל in Hebrew).
Thank you for a great video!
Arabs originated from Yemen not Saudi , Also Arabic ethnicities moved to Palestine 6000 years ago , the tribes of Canaan are Yemeni tribes
@@lastbruh62 I meant from the Arabian peninsula.
Secondly, there isn't a single historian who really thinks that "Palestinians" are a Canaanite tribe, and no, the Canaanites were not Yemeni tribes but were diverse, being sourced from Egypt, Transjordan, Iraq, Turkey, Syria, Greece and more...
Arabs were not in Palestine 300 years or less, they were there since 3000 years, not only Arabs but Armenians and Assyrians and many other ethnicities , all of them called themselves Palestinians
Incorrect, Palestinians are a combination of local levantine people, Greeks, and some Arabs, their language changed ocer hundreds of years after Arab muslim conquest of the region, they are largely not from the Arabian peninsula.
@@user-lr9ru6qj2d If you have a single source that these people called themselves Palestinians before the Roman conquest then I would like to see it.
Yoseph Hadad, an israeli arab activist shared that when israel came to be according to his grandmother who was actually there at the time, anyone who was in israeli designated territory could choose to stay right where they are and become israeli citizens, some chose to do so (and the fact is theres 2mil arabs in israel atm, full rights and no apartheid bs) and some hated the fact there would be a state for jews and chose war from the very beginning, and when given the choice (many times mind you) to make a Palestinian official state, they declined, not because they didnt want a state, but because they didnt want Israel to be. Otherwise they might as well would have made a state while it was Jordanian occupation, or Egyptian.
Don't you see how zionist settlers treat the Arabs who stayed even today? they keep bothering and threatening them under the IDF protection, and they do their best to kick them out of their land
Yosef hadad 😂😂😂
2milion arabs full rights ? They can live where ever they want ?😂
Another account of the events state that the arabs living in israel at that time were also partly influenced to leave by arab leaders who promised them that they will get to return once they "rid the place of jews" - something which unfortunately did not happen because the arabs lost the war against israel. So in any way you look at it, the palestinians being displaced is largely their own doing. Play stupid games, win stupid prices.
You really choose that propagandist lol?
Slight correction. The northern kingdom of Israel was conquered by the Assyrians. Only later did the southern kingdom of Judah get conquered by Babylonia. So they were not conquered at the same time and not by the same people. Other than that a very objective and unbiased video.
I wouldn't have called the muslim caliphate tolerant mind.
@@nah88Muslims were pretty tolerant for their time. They had heavy taxes, but they wouldn’t have outright genocides. Compared to Europe, the local Jewish population had it decent under the Muslims.
What is the kingdom of David and Solomon?
I have never heard that phrase in my life.
It's also biblically and historically inaccurate, as David was not even the second king of Isreal.
And he wasn't even it's 10th leader
Who cares its *don't justify invading Palestine*
@@SCOTLANDforEVER12976 it is no justification i just tell what jewish tradition is
small correction, around 800K jews were exiled from arab countries (Yemen, Iraq, Syria, Egypt...), 200k more than the arab refugees.
When?
@@RP3X7in the 50's
Only in Egypt and Jordan they were expelled in the classical sense, amounting to about 100,000 Jews. Most Arab nations in fact banned the Jews from leaving to not strengthen Israel, they may have faced discrimination, but they were not exiles. In some countries, like Algeria and Yemen, they left mainly because of the wars there, which had nothing to do with Israel. In other countries they eventually left when the Israelis negotiated an end to the travel bans or left illegally with the assistance of the Mossad.
@@smittywerbenjaggermanjense672 sounds like exile with extra steps to me. You can also say that out of the 600k Arabs leaving Israel, most left not out of fear but because they were promised to get back once the Arabs countries will finish with the jews.
yea and when did that happen? and how many Palestinians were exiled when Israel took control?
If you’re gonna pick a side, do it based on facts. I truly don’t care what side you fall on. Just form your alliance based on truth.
STOP REFERRING TO THE ZIONIST OCCUPATION OF PALESTINE AS A CONFLICT
Soooo.... You're literally saying support Palestine, because Israel doesn't do "facts". Zionism is all about lies and propaganda. Oh, and raping babies.
Allied with the truth, I like it!
the facts point towards being pro israel, but if you are a leftist, "fact" isn't a word in your dictionary
In a recent genetic study jews from several diaspora were examined. The research was done to learn how to treat diseases that are characteristics of a certain ethnic group in israel. For the purpose of the study people were selected whose both parents are from the same country. Ashkenazi jews, jews from marocco, jews from irak and Iran, and jews from italy and Yemen participated in the study. The result of the study showed that all the participants in the study are third cousins from the father side. That means a genetic match of 2%, between two complete strangers there is genetic match of 0.2%. between two brothers for example there is a genetic match of 50%. The study shows that Ashkenazi jews and jews from marocco and jews from irak and Iran and jews from italy and from Yemen they all share a common ancestor from the father's side.
Yeah so? Why is DNA testing prohibited in israel btw
Many people do dna test in israel. Who tell you that nonsense.
Jews don’t have a common Y-dna ( thus Jews don’t have a common ancestor ) , , in fact most Europeans have a common ancestor , but Jews don’t have a common ( what an irony ) in fact Jews are like Christians and Muslims they are made up of very diverse people from different origins , the key difference is Jews forget there original origins , but thankfully Y-dna inform us they don’t have a common paternal ancestor .
Exactely!! Besides, converters during history are also jews period!
@@theoutsider078because of the ultra-orthodox. They don’t like the DNA stuff.
Anyways, several Jews live in the US and they do DNA tests all the time.
as an Israeli who went to public school, the Idea that Israel only teaches bible stories as history is ridiculous, we had bible class and history class and they were totally separate.
Which history do they use when claiming historical right to property?
@@seanphlegming7679 can you tell me if there has been a palestinian state before the modern one
@@seanphlegming7679
1. both the bible and general history agree about the existence of ancient Israel / Judea and that Jews as a religion and ethnicity came from there.
2. historical connection to the land isn't the only thing to legitimize Israel it's just the one everybody focuses on.
to be honest, as a child in Israel I didn't even considered for a brief moment that the stories we've been reading about in Bible class are a real world events, it was like a fantasy book for me.
only when I grew up I understood which stories go hand in hand with real world well-documented events and archeological findings and which stories stay as "fantasy".
most Israelis don't use the Bible for any reasoning, there's enough evidence of the two kingdoms and the two temples even without the Bible scripture.
כן אההה? לראות אנשים שמאמינים שאנחנו לומדים את התנך כהיסטוריה מצחיקה אותי
everyone's talking about the argument in the comment section but I don't see one
It's literally the same situation whenever there's a video about the balkans. Everyone's really looking to just say something
Well, sometimes it's happen in the "newest comment" option really,
But yet again, sometimes
It's like trying to normalize nazi germany
Same I hate when that happens
I found 5
People saying that this is “pro-israel” or “pro-Palestinian” just proves the fact how neutral this video is
bro believes the people are neutral lol
@@morke_ The uploader. Not the people.
@@stick8982 so the uploader is not a human being?
@@stick8982 There is no neutrality in the political field, in history, it's a battle of narratives supporting sides, neutrality doesn't exist in any sense.
@@stick8982 there is no neutrality in the political field, in history, it's a battle of narratives supporting sides, neutrality doesn't exist in any sense.
19:00 since you didnt say so i felt obligated, they were told to leave because the arab told them they will win the war.
And the 150:000 didnt left at all.
I say this to people all the time, israelis didn't kick out the majority of the arabs that lived there. The surrounding arab countries told them they would win the war and told them to leave their homes because they were gonna win in 2 weeks.
Therefore the civilians in Gaza should be confident that if they leave to Egypt during the current conflict that they will be allowed back to their homes when it's over? Israeli's can't be trusted, that's the only constant in their 76 year history
According to Wikipedia it was a mix of both, with the main cause expulsion by Israël
@@kasperkappe9066
1. Send me( in the original language you read about it)
2.Wikipedia is a non academic source where everyone can write whatever they want. thats why Wikipedia itself have different explanations(not exactly the right word) for the same subject when you choose different languages.
3. Try using google scholar with academic approval tick on, or i can just send you my source(based)
@@kasperkappe9066 "according to wikipedia" - the site where everyone can write whatever they want and changes it defnition of a subject based on the place where your ip is currently is.
try google scholar with academic paper "tick" on.
24 hours later: this video has been age restricted/demonetized for violating TH-cam guidelines
Has it?
@@MrSupernova111 not yet (hopefully, it doesn’t happen)
We better hope not. It's better than most midia nonsense.
@@L.internet8 which is why youtube may seek to diminish it's propagation in the first place, they propel the narrative of the mass-media whilst filtering anything that risks scrutinizing said narrative.
4 hr left
You left out the 1949 Lausanne conference-it's not true that Israel refused to allow refugees to return. Rather, they wanted formal peace from the Arab states and recognition of their borders based on the 1949 armistice. In return, Israel offered to either annex Gaza and grant citizenship to all its inhabitants or to compensate all refugees for their displacement as well as accepting 100,000 refugees into Israel. The Arab states refused.
Any sources so I can back up the claim, as most media is very biased and can be untrue. He might've left it out as its on a biased network or there is no proof of it.
So you're in favour of Ukraine negotiating ceding territory to Russia then for peace?
thats a very kind offer From Isreal to give ciitizenship to the local population ... I wish putin learn from that
@@user-op8fg3ny3jwhat does this have to do with Ukraine? It’s an entirely different matter.
@@RNKel1 it shows your only interested in peace when it benefits you
It's a surprisingly neutral representation of the conflict. Both sides will not be happy about it.
You call this Zionist propaganda neutral? Fuck, you're getting paid by them too, eh?
No word on the jewish refugees from arab countries?
Some were native tribes, and some are migrants. Unless you're talking about during world war where in some arab countries Jews were blocked to leave (some reasoned so the Jews wouldn't be hunted), 2 countries reported to have kicked them out (I have no idea why), and some countries willingly helped them survive the anti-jewish movement and the Holocaust (like Morocco, during 19XXs)
if he mentioned it he probably should mention that you guys stole babies from the Yemeni jews because they were too "impure" and less Jewish or not the type of Jewish u want
@@hyumiliatedbs3355 Native tribes? That sounds as true as Jesus being a palestinian...
@@david-segal yea? Israeli is a tribe, that is how it works around the middle east, naming one of your greatest ancestors as your group and making it your tribe
Key word: countries. You were not a country yet when you decided you can kick locals out.
10:45 the flag introduced in this part was yet to be invented in 1936. This is the PLO flag created in 1964. But so far that’s the only inaccurate thing Iv’e noticed. Really factual and accurate!
The entire framing of the video is pro Palestinian.
The Palestinians are framed at any possible intersection as infentile and lacking agency and responsibility.
Kingdom of Hejaz?
Not a palestinian flag, but it was created before 64
that was the flag of the arab revolt with the color order switched, used since the late 1910s and by the Palestine Arab Congress in the 30s. So no, it's not inaccurate
Exactly! I pointed this out too! Using this fake flag is misleading at best
The flag is from 1925, it predates the Israeli one by a decade.
I love how there is absolutely 0 bias in this video. This is how history should be taught.
It is already bias when they start with thousands of years ago nunsense.
Not 0 but pretty little
I take it back there is a lot of important information left out to promote a certain view, its quite biased
@@einhalbesbrot yo im no expert would you mind telling me how/why coz i support palestine fully but know nothing about what actually happened there
@@mr.fariednasab2161 im not gonna write an essay. It begins with the name origin of palestine which is misrepresented here, made to look like it was jewish before ever being calles palestine. Also the history after 1946 is quite inaccurate (to not say wrong), its made to look like muslims started civil unrest by attacking jewish villages and "besieging" jerusalem (which by that point was clearly under the rulings of UN and british mandate, muslims were not allowed to express there religion there, which is unlawfull), it was not stated thar those actions came as a reaction to muslims being violently pushed out of their living quarters and homes.
Thanks for uploading again @GeoHistory!
Besides all the heavy topics you post I really enjoy your content it’s very helpful during my history classes ❤
99% of the comments are about how bad the comment section is going to be while 1% of them are actually related to the topic.
Nahh, the other 1% is this comment 😂
You know the 99% includes you right?
50% "comment section will be bad"
30% "people are saying comment section will be bad instead of comment section being bad"
20% actually related to the video
Now the ones at the top are talking about how all the other comments are talking about how bad the comments will be.
@@mrjimmbo then u are also saying bad jaidofnwoekidd
This is probably the most informative video i'll see on the topic. You did too good for the comment section to be bad.
I'm sorry how we in Russia treated Jews!
Your comment is so complex when delved into before I begin, I am not saying what happened to the Jews was not terrible. Politically Russia supports Palestine the enemy of Israel due to being an enemy of USA. Both Israel and Russia are invading foreign countries and support neither.
You didn't do it yesterday, yet you yourself did nothing you don't represent you country
as a jew i tell you as i would germans. you are not responsible for the sins of your forefathers. the only responsibility descendants of anyone bears is learning from the past and not repeating said sins.
Genocide supporter
You are absolutely not to blame, however your words means a lot.
Just for context - the offical flag of the Houthis, displayed at 33:25, reads "Allah is the Greatest, Death to America, Death to Israel, A Curse Upon the Jews, Victory to Islam"
Based
@@engloulevent what about that is based, is it were 350million people die?
@@engloulevent How is that based thats evil
@@englouleventhow is that based.... They are calling for the genocide of millions of mostly innocent people
@andrewpritt8739 and @engloulevent please don't fight
Video:is about Israel and Palestine
*Sighs, opens the comments section*
ikr thats what i was thinking!
No matter how much research you do, there’s always gonna be that same group of people that’s like where’s this where’s that
I haven't seen many videos that talk about the conflict in such an unbiased manner. Good job
Agreed, although I’m curious on the historical sources. I’ve seen many conflicting sources supporting or dismissing the Bible’s timelines.
Even though a disagree with some points as a pro palastinan
I can see he tried very hard to get as many facts right and he deserves respect for that
Tf do u mean unbiased? Thats not possible. This is a part of history that only has 1 way of speaking about it, ex: if someone was to make a vid on the ww2 german society or colonialism, would you comment wow what an unbiased vid? What does it mean to be unbiased when talking about colonialism?
@@aniemgamaou6591 what does it means to be unbiased when talking about colonialism?
Maybe by stating the facts as they happened pertaining to colonialism? Saying colonialism is bad would show bias, which is probably what you were hoping for.
@@abd1x7And as a Jew I similarly disagree with certain things but there was definitely an excellent effort to get as many facts right as possible
I'm amazed that you left the Comments section open for this video but from the looks of things everybody is staying chilled and respectful at the moment. Hope it stays that way. 🙏
(P.S. Thanks for all the work you do with putting these videos together. Would still love to see your take on the colonisation of New Zealand, particularly the land wars between the native Maori tribes vs the British & colonial forces.)
the beat dropped harder than my grandma down the stairs
This channel is a masterclass in fair, unbiased analysis of history. Good work!
Oh boy I'm sure these comments are gonna be very civil
@@Mikhail-zk3gr You're better at yapping bullshit.
civil like WAR
saying the muslim colonizers "tollerated" jews is like saying white people in the south tolerated black people in Jim Crow America
also, didn't mention al-Husseini ended up siding with the nazis, lived in nazi germany doing propaganda work for them, and had significant support in Palestine, egypt, Iraq etc
Jews were living and moving to those countries to live under Muslim ruler , with many fleeing Europe for a reason
@@syed269correct
True
If you want to judge people or have an opinion in history, you should base them on that time's standards, not today's.
If you take that into consideration, yes, they tolerated them a lot more than other countries
@@ilyesbouzidi7837 this is just pathetic apologist nonsense
they weren't "tolerated", they were brutally oppressed. Jim-Crow style. And people treated the same were also oppressed
the Pact of Umar required jewish orphans to be forcibly taken from their community and raised Muslim at the threat of death
this is not "tolerated"
they had to always give way to any Muslim. dress differently so they were immediately recognisable as jews. live in smaller houses than the smallest Muslim house. worship in basements. and the jizya tax is essentially the same thing as mafia-style extortion
the word "tolerated" gives the impression they were left alone and not persecuted. This is simply a lie
awesome information. People need to know the history before commenting on the conflict. context is everything.
So ive read comments that this video is bias towards Palestine and comments that its bias towards Israel.
I would take that as a compliment
56% of the population has been convinced by TikTok that America bad, so anything America likes or supports is bad.
is being bias stating facts?
jews want to be victims so badly, they spread propaganda that are treated as facts
I mean at it’s better to offend everyone then just one group 😅
I think it depends on the amount of information someone knows. Those who are in favor of Palestine knows more information that favors the Palestinian narrative. Those who are in favor of Israel knows more information that favors the Israeli narrative. The video missed out many of the things from both sides. If the video fails to mention what they already know, it means the video is biased against their position.
That's what I realized after watching the video. I know some pro-Palestine info and plenty of pro-Israel info that were not mentioned. I have a pro-Israel bias because I hate Islam and Marxist Communism and that's why I know more information that favors the Israeli narrative than the Palestinian narrative.
A well made video and for the most part, balanced, compared to a lot of other channels.
32:05 you failed to mention the special refugee status that is passed down. No other refugees have this privilege, inflating that number.
Israel does not allow them back, nor recognizes that there were Palestinians past or future on the land it colonized and homes it stole.
Well they are still refugees. If Jews from around the world can simply demand to return in a country only because of their belief or because their ancestors from hundreds of years ago once lived in this land, then people of Palestinian descent should also be allowed to return in the land where their grandparents and great-grandparents once lived and where they were expelled from in the last 80 years.
It should be one rule for all and not only some people benefitting because of their belief, that's literally what an Austrian painter did, classified one group as better and superior than others and look what happened.
It is not true. every refugee is the same.
@@firstnamelastname6976
I am too lazy to type it all out, but here is a what another person wrote which is pretty on point.
“There are two UN refugee agencies: UNHCR and UNRWA. Roughly speaking, the UNHCR oversees ALL refugee resettlement globally while the UNRWA was founded specifically to handle the Palestinian refugees. Over time, they have developed slightly different missions, methods, and operating definitions. The UNHCR only considers those who flee conflict or persecution to be refugees and works to assist resettlement into new communities. The UNRWA - again, remember they only work with Palestinians - considers that refugee status to continue down through the generations until the conflict is resolved and works to aid Palestinians where they are until that point, not resettle.
From there, reasonable people could debate which approach is better or more effective at helping people fleeing conflict or persecution. The UNRWA's approach has unnecessarily perpetuated the Palestinian-Israeli conflict by keeping alive the possibility of return to a land they no longer inhabit and have not lived on in their lifetimes or, in some cases, their parent's lifetimes. No other refugee group is allowed this fiction. The UNHCR has assisted others in building new lives elsewhere in diaspora. For this reason and a host of others, the UNRWA should be disbanded and the care and aid of the Palestinian refugees passed to the UNHCR. The Gaza residents who have been displaced by this current war are refugees, but from today's conflict not 1948. They deserve help and aid in both survival and resettlement (should they choose it).”
Also keep in mind, some Arab countries don’t even allow Palestinians to achieve citizenship.
@firstnamelastname6976 No, it is true. It’s why there’s two UN refugee organizations: one for >95% of refugees, and one for Palestinians.
A Vietnamese refugee who comes to America and has kids does not give birth to refugees, she gives birth to Americans. Meanwhile, there are hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who are the children, grandchildren, even great-grandchildren of those expelled to Gaza and the West Bank during the Nakba who were born refugees and whose future children will also be born refugees.
Such a lot of information - will need to rewatch a couple of times - Great Job!
This video combines handy graphics with a level of detail and complexity that is often overlooked in most brief summaries of the conflict. Well done. Perhaps the best introduction to the subject I’ve seen.
As a Canadian wasp, I think I should chime in here with facts I made up.
Awesome summary, doc!
Massacre of Granada in Al-Andalus killed 4.000 Jews in one day (which is 3000 Jews more than in the entirety of the Portuguese inquisition, which killed 1100).
Massacre of Fez (1033 AD) killed 6000 Jews in one day, which is way more than the Jews that died in the entire history of the Spanish Inquisition.
Don’t forget the great number of massacres against the Jews in the Islamic world (occurred until 20th century) and that the muslims expelled the Jews from Medina. This video is romanticizing the muslims.
Medina was a place the Arab Jews created. It had an old name starting with a Y. Mohammed killed most and took their gold and women.
Maybe the jews should have never came to this region in the first place
Great comment! You get a gold star 🌟! 😉
So , the Jews broke 4 peace treaties in a row in Medina , Muslims in the 4 times asked the Jews to bring the ones that broke the peace treaties to get punished , Jews refused ... Waged war against the Muslims , lost badly and instead of killing them Muslims expelled them , like Bano Quraidha , Muslims trusted that the pegans won't be able to attack them from the South because of the Bano Quraidha's fortress , but Bano Quraidha betrayed Muhammed and attacked with Pegans , Muslims ended up beating both the Pegans and Jews miserably .
Don't cry when it's almost every time was the Jews that started these wars , a Jew will always tell you how much they suffer but never will tell you why
Did you ever wonder why?
From Egypt, I can say that this video is one of the most honest and not biased toward any of the conflicting parties. ❤
All I've learned is today is just another page in the book. We're just here now but who knows how long it will go.
My favorite history channel when it comes to war is back!
I have yet to watch the video, but I expect no sugarcoating like the videos before.
It's a miracle that Israel become a state in this region and managing to keep the economic and quality of living in western standards. Why neighboring countries like Lebanon, Syria and Jordan stay have such big difference in the economic aspect ?
The neighboring countries were colonized for a couple decades, while israel was founded by rich jews from around the globe, especially usa
Other countries don't get billions of dollars worth of free aid
@@rarespetric5973 Arab countries can’t stop crying about colonization, instead they keep ruining their countries, not making any social or economic process. There are many examples of colonized countries being rich and prosperous, it’s no excuse.
@@pribyvate the free aid came as of recent, during the current genocide. The money covers food and repairs but wont save an entire economy. Billions of dollars is nothing for a country. Gdps often have tens of billions. Also palestine didnt receive billions, just millions.
@@rarespetric5973
Boo hoo... All of these countries are failing because they are ruled by terrorists. Simple. They keep attacking other countries instead of caring for their own people and country.
for some reason it seems that many of the comment sections here seems to be respectful to each other
🙏
I can kind of see a parallel between the traditional story and the historical evidence-based story. The traditional story posits that Jews were evacuated from Egyptian control in Egypt and fled across the Sinai peninsula before settling in modern day Israel, whereas historical evidence like the video says points more towards the Egyptian I guess empire extending past modern day Israel and then receding after being harassed by the Hittites. The traditional account could be partially technically true if they were already in the area that would become Israel, but under Egyptian occupation, so they were technically in Egypt, and if the Egyptians left their land that would be equivalent to them leaving the Egyptians' land.
No evidence.
Learned a lot here, well done.
Imagine a video about the conflict in Cyprus starting with "Zeus fucked a bull, and then the titans besieged mount Olympus..."
LMAOOO this shit caught me offguard
☠️☠️☠️☠️
Israel Palestine comments went From arguments to literal jokes 😂
Me: “I’m sorry, but what does the 1529 Siege of Vienna have to do with your occupation of Cyprus?”
Erdoğan: “We get there when we get there!”
Except that it is a bad analogy. Historians have yet to catch up on the Biblical narrative due to the lack of archaeological findings, but over time, when new discoveries were made, historians slowly RELUCTANTLY concede to the Biblical narrative.
For example, historians denied the existence of the Hittites even though it is in the Bible, but today, they accept it as historical.
@@retrictumrectus1010the field of archaeology was invented in order to validate the biblical narrative. Really the bias has always been in favor of the Bible until archaeologists failed to find evidence to support the exodus and the world flood. The later parts of the Old Testament are generally regarded as historical, save some embellishments, so I’m not sure what you mean about historians denying the existence of the Hittites due to them being mentioned in the Bible, because as far as I know historians weren’t reluctantly conceding to the biblical narrative but rather using it as a starting point and believing its claims when they could find evidence to support them
I’m still as confused as I was before I watched the video…
its okay if you have a learning disability. I feel you .
this video should be shown to any politician who speaks on this topic but doesnt know anything about it
A very detailed video regarding the confluct.
However, when addressing the refugee issue, you forgot to mention that by UN definition a refugee status is only available for the first generation and their decendents must be intergrated into their host countries. The fact that Arab countries are unwilling to intergrate the Palestinians and keep naming their towns of residence 'refugee camps' tells you all you need to know for how the conflict is kept alive.
Also, Jews weren't just expelled from Iraq and Yemen, but from the entire middle east.
The only country that didn't give ids to muslim palestinians is Lebanon due to political and religious reasons, all the christian palestinians in lebanon have lebanese ids, as a policy from the country to increase the christian population (same for armenians). But the palestinians are also refusing to fully integrate to the country that is hosting them to prevent losing their identity and in hopes of returning back home one day.
Its hilarious how "centrists" shift blame from the illegal state of Israel to the Arab countries just because they won't get physically involved in an issue that israel itself created and facilitated, this video didn't even talk about the zionist nazi connection
And I thought Palestine was the evil emperor in Star Wars.
Hamas is. Palastine isn't.
@@relo999
Palestine doesn't exist.
But yeah... Hamas is evil.
Did we watch the same video? It's crazy how brainwashed you are
Hamas just hides between Palestinians
If Israel attack: it would be called genocide
If Israel don't attack: Hamas would irritate Israel
and Hamas is teaching young children to be the new Hamas
In case anyone doesn't get this reference, the main antagonist of the Star Wars Movies is "Emperor Palpatine".
finally a short video about the history of the conflict that actually is not biased
that's a great video
Well explained, and thorough.
Thank you for the well researched, balanced explanation of the history. Well done.
Fantastic video. Thanks for the slice of history.
Why are Palestinians the only group in history that passes down refugee status over multiple generations... you dont see any polish refugees still kicking around from WW2, they moved elsewhere and moved on. However, Palestinians in Gaza are refugees because their great grandparents lived in now Israel 80 years ago... it doesn't make any sense.
Other notable things, you refer to the area as Palestine well before there was ever a group of people who called themselves palestinians. It also feels a tad unfair to call out certain israeli extremist actions in detail, while glossing over the countless Palestinan attacks during the Intifada's in a breif sentence.
The area was called Palestina since Roman times, but the Palestinians were considered to be the jews. Only in the 1960 the arabs started calling themselves Palestinians. But i think it's fine to call the region this, as long as it's clear that you refer to the region, and not to the imagined Palestinian state.
This isn't true. A son of a Kurd is a Kurd. He doesn't become "Norwegian" by moving to Norway.
@@tmpqtyutmpqty4733 no but if the son of a Kurd is adopted by a Norwegian he becomes a Norwegian , so your wrong
the video is unfair in the way it only mentions so called Israeli extremist actions = Dir Yasin was in response of an Arab attack on a Jewish convoy of doctors and nurses that killed many , likewise the murder of those Arabs in Hebron was in response to the murder of a Jewish baby girl .
@@tmpqtyutmpqty4733 someone of Kurdish heritage born in Norway is Norwegian… a child born to Syrian refugees in Canada is Canadian.
Palestinians were displaced 70 years ago and they’re still refugees. That’s unprecedented. If they just accepted the existence of Israel they would’ve had a Palestinian state in 1948 but they wanted it all, from the river to the sea as they say.
First vid from this channel ive watched and very good objective explanation and maps really help. I think some more info regarding what was happening in the area between the romans and the ottomans could have been given though(i.e. the expansion of islam and arab people into the region, then the various powers that changed over until eventually the ottomans got established). Also maybe a few loaded terms that could have been cut for more specific examples(references to terrorist attacks by both sides, were these bombs, suicide bombs, rockets, shootings, infrastructure sabatoge i generally know at esch stage but itd be good to get really hardcore indisputable if you are a bit more specific.
Your best video yet ❤
Great job Geo History! This can't have been an easy one
I wanted to ask kindly if there are certain words not allowed in this commentsection (blacklisted) as my comments keep getting deleted.
Are they manual edits or am i not allowed to use certain words?
This was really well researched! Very fair and balanced too.
Fantastic work!
Honey,wake up Geo History has uploaded
Rick was right, this is such a complicated topic.
IM A PICKKE MORTY
It's not
What the fuck is complicated about not stealing land
@@Soap010 Well, the US took over 50% of Mexico, so it must be really complicated.
@@610Hobbies the whole of us land was stolen genius It just was like a million years ago
Amazing video, and very unbiased too 👏
19:30 you’re missing the other countries the ancient Jews came from (Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Yemen) and the reason they left. It wasn’t just persecution, it was exile under the threat of death.
Great video!
Great video! Not many are able to present the basic facts on that level of neutrality. Thank you!
This video contains numerous lies and inaccuracies:
The territory was never referred to as Palestine by the Ottomans; it was called South Syria.
The Palestinian flag was only invented in the 1960s.
No mention is made of the Husseini family's affiliation with Hitler.
There is no mention of the numerous massacres of Jews by Arabs under the British mandate.
No mention of the persecution of Jews in Arab states other than Iraq and Yemen and their ethnic cleansing.
The terrorists who killed the Olympians are referred to as a commando squad?
The video downplays the raids and massacres of Jews by Arabs during the War of Independence but emphasizes the Deir Yassin incident.
It fails to mention Arafat's KGB connection.
There is no mention that Israel and the international community left civilian infrastructure in Gaza for the Palestinians to use, but the video stresses the destruction after Hamas attacks.
Palestinians are casually referred to as refugees three generations after the war. Are the Germans expelled from Czechia and France after WWII still considered refugees?
There is no mention of Hamas being an Iranian proxy organization spreading radical Islam and aiming to commit genocide against all Jews.
This video is, at best, a very mediocre historical account and, in fact, extremely biased and full of lies.
the fact that you're the first one in the 100s long comments list to mention such a big list of innacuracies, says that either you searched so well that you found info that they didn't see, or that most of these innacuracies weren't mentioned for a good reason
@@hothdog How about addressing my comments instead of making general statements? Which one of my comments is not accurate? And if they are accurate, what is the "good reason" to leave them out?
The deir yassin massacre is frequently exagerrated by pro palestinian factions to bolster their argument that jews persecuted arabs and drove them out. When in fact it was the arab leaders themselves who manipulated the story by exagerrating the deaths and used this to scare the arabs into leaving israel, and also by promising them they would be able to return once the arab league gets rid of the jews in israel during the war, which ironically they lost.
This. This is exactly the comment I was looking for.
Not a single mention of Jewish massacres by Arabs that started as early as 1919.
No mention of all the peace treaties offered to Arabs that were continually rejected time after time only to bring more bloodshed.
I was thinking it was an objective video at first, but realized it was heavily biased towards Arabs in this case.
And I’m not saying the Jews were perfect along the way but come on now you can’t leave THAT MUCH crucial information out when trying to objectively deliver the conflict.
I could literally point out 10 more inaccuracies in a heartbeat, if there is any half-brain pro Palestinian around here that is up for the challenge.
This is an excellent video and it summarizes the facts without bias, congrats to the creators.
as a jew calling the first aliyah the old yishuv is stupid, the old yishuv is the jews that were there before 1881 not after
🤣🤣But you won't last long
@@MermaidMonarchist could you clarify
@@bomoose You still think that the world will just let Israel create Greater Israel
He said exactly that in the video. He referred to the 'Old Yishuv' as the areas where mainly Sephardic Jews had remained after the suppression by the Romans. The 'new Yishuv' is where mainly Ashkenazi Jews migrated to after 1881. 4:33
@@MermaidMonarchistfunny boy
israel:*exists for 1 day*
arab league:and i took that personally
I don't know where are you from but I'm sure your people will be angry to when some other people steal your home and tell you we used to live here 5000 years ago
Exist for 1 day forgetting their 1 day existence was built upon mass murderer, rape, and ethnic cleansing.
Perhaps you wanna read the tantoura documentary that was published by Israeli themselves.
@@mohamedsenousy4705 While having the skin tone, accents, and culture of Europeans.
Israel attacked across the UN partition line months before the Arab states intervened. They had already wiped hundreds of Arab villages off the map by the time they officially declared independence. Look up Plan Dalet.
@@mohamedsenousy4705 well it wasnt "stolen" and nobody was thrown out, before they attacked, and if they just had agreed to a two state solution, perhaps the situation would have been different.
Thank you for explaining that... I never understood it before 🙏
Explains agreat deal
There is little to no evidence of the Kazar theory
ONe of the most neutral video on the topic, amazing, great job!
Great video. Although I would have like to see a bit more coverage of the northern Israelis who were conquered by the Assyrians a couple hundred years before the the southern Israelis were conquered and taken to Babylon. The southern were returned to Israel when the the Persians conquered the Babylonians, but the northern Israelis; the 10 "lost tribes of Israel", were scattered throughout Mesopotamia and were not returned
Thank you for this video
Thank you for this outstanding summary.
Well Done ! IMO this is a Great video Effort.
Cool vid bro
Thank you, learnt so much from this video
Fun fact, Spharadi means Spanish in hebrew, so Spanish Jews
Good explanation!
I found the video very interesting to watch.
You forgot to talk about how Arabs got the Levant
They used force like Christians did, yet for some reason you don't call people to talk about the legality of Europe or America.
keep it at making shorts
@@tmpqtyutmpqty4733 Oh the IRONY
why is that relevant to this video? What is wrong with you?
Thank you for stating the history and plainly as possible. No spin, just facts as best as your research is and clear maps. I’m sure there will be disputes about some facts but all in all you did an amazing job and I learned a lot more than I knew.
The 11th commandment says: fight with random ppl in yt comment section with a bad arguments and do mothing to resolve the problems
You’re wrong
yes this is what god taught us
@@kennypowers17 he's joking
Resolve the problem?
We have no power
@@PLC_Mapping lol so was I!!! I was starting a fight in the comment section 😂
Geo History is the best!
no way a fellow gd player????
shocker
hi gd players
At Western Propaganda. He skipped the International Law violations of the 👃 and their soon indictment at the ICJ, led by South Africa.
@@timmy-wj2hc I can't believe my nose committed international law violations and got indicted at the ICJ, led by South Africa.
This video is lacking a lot of information. But at least y’all tried
Such as?
Great presentation. Thank you.
So you made this again? Nice
I believe the first one was focused on Arab conflict overall.
Yeah first one was focused after the ottoman collapse