2 Kings chapter 17 if you want a better explanation of the samaritans, the modern day samaritans abandoned their idolatry but they consider the Bible to be a “propaganda piece” against them and they believe that they’re the real Israelites and not the Jews, their population only has a few hundred left and they have their own edited version of the Torah and their own high priest, they also get along pretty well now with both the Jews and the Palestinians, the chief Rabbi of Jerusalem at one point declared them as a sect of Judaism to protect them and the Palestinians see them as “arab Jews” and they have both Israel and Palestinian citizenship
Hey, I'm a Samaritan. Thank you for the video, I'm not sure if I agree about the origins of the Samaritans though... as modern dna and archeological findings debunked some things you mentioned like the original place of temple.
So do you consider yourself the same as a jews when in come to the patrillinial line because you guys and jews are the same genetically on the male line
Thank you SO much for this video! I’ve heard about the enmity between the Jews and the Samaritans, but I never fully understood it. This video clarified the reasons very well! I appreciate your work!
Confidently incorrect. There is zero evidence of foreign influence on the Samaritan Pentateuch. They just have disagreements about sacred locations and don’t observe books written after the Pentateuch
Your information was excellent! I'm searching videos to explain the meaning of Jesus parable of the good Samaritan. There seems to be various ideas of the true meaning!? Thank you for this very good explanation of the hatred between the 2 groups.
Thank you for the comprehensive history of the Jewish-Samaritan relationship. About to read John 4 with my daughter and was so happy to find this video. A noticed a pattern every time He spoke with a non-Jew how direct He was in revealing Himself to them (Samaritan woman at the well), yet would not directly reveal Himself to the Pharisees. Thank you and Samuel Abraham Perez for my discovering you. Love your content. God bless your ministry ✝️
It's the religious and ethnic equivalent of the uncanny valley. Someone who is almost exactly (but not quite) the same as you provokes a stronger reaction than someone who is more different. It's because the Samaritans were so similar to the ancient Jews that those differences really stood out. So they badmouthed each other instead of focusing on the similarities... and getting along.
You're absolutely correct on how the Samaritan people did mix their religious practices with worshipping YHWH and wrongly worshipping false gods of the land. Quote: Samaritans. "The only place in the O.T. where these are mentioned gives their origin, and the mixed character of their worship. The king of Assyria had peopled the cities by colonists from the East, they were then in Jehovah's land, but they did not fear Him, therefore He sent lions among them. On the king of Assyria being informed of this, a priest who had been carried away from Samaria was sent thither, to teach them how they should fear the God of that land. The result was that they feared Jehovah, and served their own gods! 2 Kings 17:24-41."
The simple answer to the question is...because the new testament writers made it sound like they did. In each other's writings there are major disagreements and some cultural tension, but nothing to the level that the christian authors made up
This is so incomplete. You’re not asking the Samaritans (who still exist btw) for their side of the story. The one that holds up better than the anti-Samaritan slander you’re repeating.
And I'm not even understand why. Jews and Samaritans helped each other in the last 1,000 years and have no problems with each other anymore. The situation is even funny because we both consider each other as "branch" from our "true" religion, therefore saying that we are indeed brothers by blood.
I think it's complicated because their Priest's (royals) were exiled. After exile they would have destroyed all stories related to them, to cover up the fact that they were not loyal to the blood-line who served them faithfully. Their descendants would have remained which you likely associate with the Samaritans of today who preserved the old law. What happened to those Priest's is anyone's guess. I think they were probably ambushed once they left the city so that their bodies could be discarded. Those Egyptians were not mixed as the Tribe of Dan on the matriarchal side, they would have likely for this reason posed a threat to Judah's ambition to lessen the influence of divine wisdom and to change the law. It is no coincidence that their tribe migrates into that area around the same time that Egypt's older Dynasties were killed and their ancient system discarded in favor for tyranny (a demo of cracy). I would wager once they helped in diplomacy to win others who were of the old ways they were maybe killed. Either way what I am fairly sure occurred soon after is that some new leader of the raiders decided to replace them with a bunch of wolves who then replicated their work to generate more coin. Military men don't usually have faith in what they cannot comprehend which a seer did as back then they had no brain scans to prove they had significantly more taste. Literal narrow mindedness and poor taste. So they often killed these other entities to drag everything into a simulated version which garners far greater profit; at the cost of such utter dominance and a complete eradication of it's original source until everything sacred related to the relationship between angels and man is destroyed and nobody knows who they are anymore as they are surrounded by surrogates and cyborgs. At this point stories and media becomes mostly worthless and hollow. Welcome to the 21st century.
Hello, please explain how they can tell the difference between an Israelite and a Hamite when people living at the time couldn't even tell the difference. And when the inhabitants of the land, the Canaanites, saw the mourning in the floor of Atad, they said, This is a grievous mourning to the Egyptians: wherefore the name of it was called Abelmizraim, which is beyond Jordan." - Genesis 50:11 (in reference to all of Israel's appearance when mourning Jacob's death) "And they said, An Egyptian delivered us out of the hand of the shepherds, and also drew water enough for us, and watered the flock." - Exodus 2:19 (in reference to Moses' appearance) "Art not thou that Egyptian, which before these days madest an uproar, and leddest out into the wilderness four thousand men that were murderers?" - Acts 21:38 (in reference to Paul's appearance) How did they go into Egypt(AFRICA) with 70 souls and come out hundreds of years later as a mixed multitude and look European?
There are Israelis of Libyan, Egyptian, Iraqi, Syrian, descent. Not all israelíes are Germany. Please explain to me why your kind are obsessed with wanting to be Hebrews-Israelites?
@@emfegmfeg7100 Likely because the HIbiru were associated with the Hill Country Canaanites who were more aggressive. They posed more of a threat to Judah, so I would wager in todays political circles it is equally more favorable to be from their blood for the same reason it was back when the north fell to bolster Judah's merchants: mostly for fact that those who are more dangerous are more so flattered until they become subjugated by those who do the flattering. As the other four tribes who were not hill country were associated with Seafarers from the very ancient tribe of Dan and what I assume to be various mixes of these cultures, I assume the Hibiru were those who took on more duties related to raiding and fighting.
Completely messed up ... Sanaritans are ethno-religious group in what was known as palestine. They claimed to be amongst the remnants of the 12 tribes of biblical israel 🇮🇱 (not to be confused with the modern state of israel {zionism}). Samaritans have their own version of torah which they claimed to be more purer & is free from distortion.. they claimed that the Mount Gerizem in westbank of occupied Palestinian territory to be the true Temple of God. They speak & write a older version of Hebrew language... they speak Aramaic (language of Jesus' time) in some of their religious services and they speak Levantine Arabic as their daily language. It is wrong to paint them in negatives 🎞 & glorify the jews because both are remnants of tha 12 tribes of Biblical israel. The Samaritans foremost teaching like Judaism is the belief in God as the One & only Divine being. (Absolute monotheism) and they have their own set of laws.
Great video, was looking for an explanation like this for years and you hit the bullseye. Having maps with the sea in perspective helps enormously also. So, what happened the Samaritans eventually? Ancestors of today's Lebanese Christians?
Many of the Samaritans followed Jesus and thus were "converted". Many were killed, just as the Jews were in the times following Jesus. The surviving Samaritans still exist, although are very few of them left. They seem to produce many sons, but not daughters, and it is said that in the small population of about 800, there are 9 more men per 1 woman. 10 to 1. It's all a very interesting history. I will always believe what the scripture says, but to add context to that, when we research history, we need to listen to both sides of every story. History is written by the victors.
I'm trying to piece together the whole twelve sections of Israel for the twelve tribes and Levite cities in the twelve sections for the Levites and how that fits into this.
John 4 also shows where that Christ did not refute the Samaritan woman when she claimed Jacob as their forefather. He revealed Himself as the Messiah in Samaria first and on that day, he planted the seeds for the Samaritan conversion to Christianity. This conversion continued in the Book of Acts. So the real question is not why do the Jews hate the Christians of Samaria, but why do Evangelical Christians hate the Samaritans? Christ did not side with the Jews against the Samaritans, so why do Protestants condone the occupation of Samaria.?
What is the difference between a Samaritan and a Jew? The Samaritan woman asked Jesus in John 4:12 "are You greater than *our father Jacob*, who gave us the well, and drank from it himself, as well as his sons and his livestock?” If Jacob was a Jew and He's the Samaritans' father why aren't they considered Jews?
Wow. I was about to do a study on John chapter 4, I had to search the truth about their relation. I had just read the book of Ezra, Nehemiah, Haggai and Zechariah the whole story of the way they treated and related to each other lie there. In John chapter 4 we see Jesus restoring that relationship between brothers.
2000 years of removal of the people from the land and sending them by force by the romans, basically ethnic cleansing of all the jews from the land and killing more than a million and a half of them, couple of hundreds of years after, the romans (Byzantines) killed about a million of the Samaritans, so after that there were almost no jews or Israelites in the land, mostly couple of thousands, most of the population were Christians (about 2 million Christians), Israel of today is basically returning home after the ethnic cleansing of the romans
We cannot give presumptive authority to the masoretic text, which is what Jews and Christians use. It’s a one-sided document, told from the perspective of the Jews. It’s a myth that there was never any copyist errors. The Jews hated their siblings. The Samaritans are, in fact, true Israelites. DNA studies prove this. They only follow the written Torah. The Jews follow the oral Torah, plus the written Torah. Deuteronomy 4:2 & 12:32 tell us that it is a sin to add or take away from the law of Moses. It is a sin and called rebellion to teach others not to follow it. There are blessings for obeying and curses for disobeying. For good reason, the Samaritans don’t believe that the Tanakh is inspired. They call it “Ezra’s Torah.” The Samaritan Pentateuch predates the Masoretic text. No place in Torah is Jerusalem mentioned. There is good reason to believe that Mount Gerizim is the chosen place, not Jerusalem. Temples made with hewn stones is a sin. There is no need for a temple in either Samaria nor Jerusalem. The prophecy for Abraham’s descendants to become a “multitude of nations” will be fulfilled through the northern kingdom, Samaria, and Ephraim. Jacob prophesied and passed this blessing on to Ephraim. See Genesis 48:19. Father is going to restore Israel and bring us back to the promised land, the land of our fathers. It is His promise. His word stands forever. He will bring us back to the land when we turn back to His Torah. His Torah is a lamp to our feet and a light to our path and it defines righteousness. It is not to hard to obey it if we circumcise our hearts. Shalom! 😃
The people with the closest link to the original tribes of Israel are what you call Palestinian and became Christian and then Muslim. The people with the most distant genetic links to the Tribes of Israel are paradoxically the people called Jews today. What you have are distant relatives who settled in Europe two thousand years ago, who have beef that is redundant after two thousand years in the place and for the people. You may as well argue over which royal family has a right to rule Europe. Europeans don't care.
@@salmaalmeahlky126 no, more like according to the history books. The romans called it Judea and Samaria too, before they conquered it completely and renamed it palestine. There are even roman coins saying "Judea has been conquered". Look it up. The name palestine is nothing but a degrading name to insult the jews.
you do a good job of telling Judah's side of the story, however, you are missing a huge part of the story by ignoring the Samaritan account of history. Keep in mind that the Babylonian Talmud is the version of the Talmud that was altered by generations of exposure to Babylonian beliefs.... One could say that it wasn't the "Samaritans" that brought foreign influences to the Torah, but rather the Jews returning from exile. One could examine the evidence for oneself, especially since the Babylonian Talmud seems to endorse some forms of necromancy.
There is a huge component of this that every one is missing. Genesis 48: 19 correctly translated states that Ephraim will become the fullness of the gentiles. Ephraim aka the northern kingdom, shall become the fullness of the gentiles. Can you see where this is leading? You won’t like it, you won’t want to accept it but, the Samaritans were, are, direct descendants of the ten tribes, and therefore, descendants of the 12 tribes, the fathers people. Regardless of personal feelings or the nitpicking of mother’s vs father’s DNA. The life is in the blood, and they have the blood. Furthermore, now, the world, through centuries of migration and marriage, and growing populations, are also descendants of his people.
If they were Israelites, mixed or not, even not Israelite at all- if they chose to be Torah observant and believe in a messiah to come(?) then they should have been considered Israelites. Ruth and many others were not DNA Jews and were adopted into the faith/Converted.
More false information about the samaritans... Samaritan information not from a samaritan...what a joke. Im know going to learn about baking from a motor mechanic. samaritans a pure jews with an uncorrupted torah.
Last time I checked Samaritans didn't identify as Jews, but just as "Israelites". They're Israelites just like the Jews but they don't identify as Jews cause you know... they're Samaritans not Jews. Do your research, I did mine. They asked the same question to an actual samaritan man, and his response was "We're not Jews but we too are Israelites" . And btw I too believe their Torah is uncorrupted .
The Samaritans (or Isrealites as they call themselves) have a long standing tradition of not intermixing. Do you have any record of them intermixing? Meanwhile, the Jews allow intermixing. as long as the new spouse "comverts" to Judeism.
They are confusing the Shomrim of Nablus and Holon (who are descendants of Leví and Yosef) with another group called samaritans in the Book of Kings. These are two different nations. In fact the ones called people of samaria are from 5 nations. They are called samaritans because the land of Samaria. The Shomrim are called by this name because they are keepers of the Torah. They followed Rabbinical Orthodox prejudices and misinterpretations. Nevertheless, Chabad Hasidut considers the Shomrim to be keepers of an ancient form of Hebrew and descendants of ancient Israel.
I have a HEBREW / GREEK study Bible published by AMG, it footnotes 2 Kings 17.41 and says these people “became known as the Samaratins”. And points out that they worshipped other gods, alongside worship of the TRUE god. (Verse 31 mentions child sacrifice within this context ) V. 29 in King James actually uses the word SAMARATINS. MIXING worship of FALSE gods into their worship of the TRUE god is definitely wrong! 17.33-4 shows a progression of mixing the two, but leads to ONLY worshiping the FALSE god. Lesson DON’T TOLERATE IDOLS IN OUR LIFE!
Your timeline needs to be revised. The Samaritan civilization was dying about the same time the Jewish religion formed. This was like 2000 years before christ. The Hindu religion also started in the same area as the Jewish they split, and Hindus moved to where India is now. Also, as the samaritans were around 2000 years before the Jewish, you should say the Jews refused to worship the many samaritan gods.
Here's a timeline of the major events in the history of the Sumerians, Jews, Hindus, and Christians: Sumerians: 4000 BCE: The Sumerians settle in Mesopotamia and begin to develop their civilization. 3500 BCE: Sumerians develop a system of writing using cuneiform script. 2334 BCE: Sargon of Akkad, a Semitic ruler, conquers Sumer and establishes the Akkadian Empire. 2112 BCE: The Ur III dynasty, the last Sumerian dynasty, comes to an end after being conquered by the Elamites. Jews: 2000 BCE: Abraham, the father of Judaism, is born. 1250 BCE: Moses leads the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt and receives the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai. 1000 BCE: King David establishes Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. 586 BCE: The Babylonians destroy the First Temple in Jerusalem and exile the Jews to Babylon. 516 BCE: The Second Temple is built in Jerusalem after the Jews are allowed to return from exile in Babylon. Hindus: 2500 BCE: The Indus Valley Civilization emerges in the Indian subcontinent. 1500 BCE: The Vedas, the oldest scriptures of Hinduism, are composed. 322-185 BCE: The Maurya Empire is established by Chandragupta Maurya, which leads to the spread of Buddhism in India. 600-1100 CE: The Golden Age of Hinduism, marked by the rise of classical Sanskrit literature, art, and architecture. 1947 CE: India gains independence from British rule, and the country is divided into India and Pakistan. Christians: 4 BCE: Jesus Christ is born in Bethlehem. 30 CE: Jesus is crucified and resurrected. 313 CE: The Edict of Milan is issued, granting religious toleration to Christianity in the Roman Empire. 1054 CE: The Great Schism occurs, splitting the Christian Church into the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church. 1517 CE: Martin Luther nails his 95 Theses to the door of a church in Wittenberg, sparking the Protestant Reformation.
we to this day hear the jewish media refer to people that rescue people as "good samaritans" its actually an insult, btw i have jewish blood. i know what we run lol
Shalmanezer, king of Assyria carried away Israel to Assyria because they had been rejected by God for their unrepentant idolatry practices And Kings 17, and relocated 5 different tribes of Assyrians with 5 different idolatry practices in Samaria. 2 kings 17:24-41. This is the reason why Jews do not have anything to do with the Samaritans of their day, because they believed that they were strangers living in the promised land. The Samaritan woman at the well who was met by Jesus Christ because of her faith in the God of the Jews. She had allied herself, like Ruth, to Jacob, by saying "our father Jacob...Our fathers worshipped..." John 4:1-26. She, in her quest for the True God, went through all the 5 gods of Assyria, and now found about the God of Israel. Just then, she met Jesus who then told her the good news of salvation by faith in the One that God has sent to restore Israel. Because of her faith in Him, she not only got saved, but became the evangelist to proclaim this good news to all Samaritans. The idols and gods are likened to having a marital relationship, thus, she had been with 5 husbands and now even the 6th wasn't what she was looking for. This meant that the mystery which was hidden right from the beginning- Jews and Gentiles would be saved, was fulfilled. Jesus was indeed sent only to the lost sheep of Israel, but He also ministered to anyone who would simply have the faith of Abraham and believe God through Christ Jesus, who was sent to seek and save lost Israel. The Samaritan woman was one of the 3 gentiles ministered to by Jesus Christ for their faith in Him: The Roman Centurion, the Samaritan woman at the well and the Canaanite woman. He didn't acknowledge the Greek gentiles when they came to seek Him because He had to pay the wages for their sins before they could finally be included in salvation work of Jesus Christ by grace, through faith in His sacrificial death, burial and resurrection John 12:32. Finally, by the Holy Spirit, Philip was sent to include Jew Proselytes, through the Ethiopian Eunuch, then the Apostle Paul was sent to the rest of the world.
After the kingdom divided the( 1 kings 12) north king jeroboam created his own religion by building two shrines with golden calves on high places. He chose his own time to offer sacrifices. He appointed priests that were not Levites. All of these things are abomination. Later, when the north was plundered. Only the poorest of the poor were left behind in the north. The rest of the Israelites were exiled…Diaspora. So yes some, a few poor were left in the north and mixed with heathen nations. I believe these poor people were the Samaritans. That’s why the Jews despised them. Because they followed Jeroboams sinful ways. But somehow to this day they do follow Torah. I don’t know what feasts they follow. They are literally brothers. They need to reconcile. The Jew is not reconciling with anyone in this world as I am aware of.
Absolutely misinformed video. Samaritans were Canaanites and had been native to that land. Also, they were not settled by Assyrians, wrong. Also, Jews saw them as inferior and that was just like how Azis view Jews. So ,that's karma.
I am an Arab and the samiratans are the true Jews and children of Israel . And we Muslims Respect them so much because they believe in our prophet Mohammed and they respect because he is mentioned in their scripture .
What do you lying? Or speaking while not knowing? The Samiratans don't believe in Mohammad. Their no mentions of Muhammad in the Torah(in Samaritan's Torah too) and also the Samiratans refuse to believe that there were any other prophets beside Moses. To them only and only Moses was a prophet.
The ten tribes of Israel are Samaria and populated Europe and the Americas and the remnant remained Samaria and Palestine Israel was never Jewish The first Jews were the captivity of The house of Judah which became Babylonian Talmudic Judaism(not of God) end eventually lynched The Messiah
Thus the whole 12 tribes of Abraham was expunged from the Promised Land for not following the commandment of God. In the Lost years of Jesus some scholars tells of the young Jesus traveling in the East, curing and preaching up to Tibet before going back to Istael. As Yahusha said, God is spirit and should be worship with all their spirit, mind , heart and mind. No matter who they are and what they done not only on holy mountain and temples. That is what we are doing right now, worshipping God where we are. Now I understand fully thanks to you the gap between the Jews and Samaritans.
"They wern't going to follow the law of Moses any more" A hardcore Moses religion that rejects everyone else isn't going to follow the law of Moses any more? You really need to consider your sources. 1/10 for effort.
Brings new light to the "Good Samaritan" story
Brilliant, just brilliant! What a condensed delivery of context behind the Jews and Samaritans. Thank you so much
2 Kings chapter 17 if you want a better explanation of the samaritans, the modern day samaritans abandoned their idolatry but they consider the Bible to be a “propaganda piece” against them and they believe that they’re the real Israelites and not the Jews, their population only has a few hundred left and they have their own edited version of the Torah and their own high priest, they also get along pretty well now with both the Jews and the Palestinians, the chief Rabbi of Jerusalem at one point declared them as a sect of Judaism to protect them and the Palestinians see them as “arab Jews” and they have both Israel and Palestinian citizenship
Hey, I'm a Samaritan. Thank you for the video, I'm not sure if I agree about the origins of the Samaritans though... as modern dna and archeological findings debunked some things you mentioned like the original place of temple.
Hey Abood, can you give me some more details? What is your understanding of the origins of the Samaritans?
@@2BeLikeChrist hes right, the samaritans and modern day jews have identical patrilenial (male line) dna although are different in the female line
So do you consider yourself the same as a jews when in come to the patrillinial line because you guys and jews are the same genetically on the male line
@@edgargarred4319 we believe we are part of what remained from the tribe of Levi and Joseph
@@AboodCohen but you guys do share the male lineage with the jews, it would make you jewish
This is an excellent and concise summary of the Jews and the Samaritans! Thank You!
Hey, Dr! Thanks. I'm glad you found it helpful.
Thank you for this bro! 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
thanks this was amazing
God bless you Brother
You're absolutely brilliant. God bless u brother.
Wow! Loved this! Thank you 🙏
You're welcome!
Ha
Very good explanation. Help me a lot with my study
Glad it was benefitial
This was really great, thank you!
Thank you! i'm so grateful that you finally answered that question.
Masterful teacher. Just discovered your video's. Great job.
Thank you SO much for this video! I’ve heard about the enmity between the Jews and the Samaritans, but I never fully understood it. This video clarified the reasons very well! I appreciate your work!
Thank u that put everything into perspective...
Great info
Really helpful.
Helps a lot, thanks so much.
Confidently incorrect. There is zero evidence of foreign influence on the Samaritan Pentateuch. They just have disagreements about sacred locations and don’t observe books written after the Pentateuch
Thanks, brother God bless you and your efforts you are putting into His Kingdom. God be with you and your family.
You're welcome Immanuel Victor, thank you for the encouragement :)
Hh
Your information was excellent! I'm searching videos to explain the meaning of Jesus parable of the good Samaritan. There seems to be various ideas of the true meaning!? Thank you for this very good explanation of the hatred between the 2 groups.
great stuff
This was truly informative..... Thank you..
Always wanted to know as a kid.now in my sixties. Excellent info.thanks a lot
Thank you so much for this very clear explanation.
Thanks so much
Insightful ❤
Thank you for the comprehensive history of the Jewish-Samaritan relationship. About to read John 4 with my daughter and was so happy to find this video. A noticed a pattern every time He spoke with a non-Jew how direct He was in revealing Himself to them (Samaritan woman at the well), yet would not directly reveal Himself to the Pharisees. Thank you and Samuel Abraham Perez for my discovering you. Love your content. God bless your ministry ✝️
Maybe he knew the Pharisees were to smart for him.
You does'nt know who is this Samaritan?
Should be (do not know !)@@robertocabuyoc2819
It's the religious and ethnic equivalent of the uncanny valley. Someone who is almost exactly (but not quite) the same as you provokes a stronger reaction than someone who is more different. It's because the Samaritans were so similar to the ancient Jews that those differences really stood out. So they badmouthed each other instead of focusing on the similarities... and getting along.
You're absolutely correct on how the Samaritan people did mix their religious practices with worshipping YHWH and wrongly worshipping false gods of the land.
Quote:
Samaritans.
"The only place in the O.T. where these are mentioned gives their origin, and the mixed character of their worship. The king of Assyria had peopled the cities by colonists from the East, they were then in Jehovah's land, but they did not fear Him, therefore He sent lions among them. On the king of Assyria being informed of this, a priest who had been carried away from Samaria was sent thither, to teach them how they should fear the God of that land. The result was that they feared Jehovah, and served their own gods! 2 Kings 17:24-41."
The simple answer to the question is...because the new testament writers made it sound like they did. In each other's writings there are major disagreements and some cultural tension, but nothing to the level that the christian authors made up
I love this teaching..
Hi, where do you get your info for reason number 4 about the priest of Judah whose grandson married a samaritan?
@ibrahimkayanja5606
Nehemiah 13:27-31
Oh my thank you sooo much! Finally Got the answer I needed 🙏❤️
Is that a Cyrillic letter on your shirt? ;)
Ч?
This is so incomplete. You’re not asking the Samaritans (who still exist btw) for their side of the story. The one that holds up better than the anti-Samaritan slander you’re repeating.
And I'm not even understand why. Jews and Samaritans helped each other in the last 1,000 years and have no problems with each other anymore. The situation is even funny because we both consider each other as "branch" from our "true" religion, therefore saying that we are indeed brothers by blood.
I think it's complicated because their Priest's (royals) were exiled. After exile they would have destroyed all stories related to them, to cover up the fact that they were not loyal to the blood-line who served them faithfully. Their descendants would have remained which you likely associate with the Samaritans of today who preserved the old law. What happened to those Priest's is anyone's guess. I think they were probably ambushed once they left the city so that their bodies could be discarded. Those Egyptians were not mixed as the Tribe of Dan on the matriarchal side, they would have likely for this reason posed a threat to Judah's ambition to lessen the influence of divine wisdom and to change the law. It is no coincidence that their tribe migrates into that area around the same time that Egypt's older Dynasties were killed and their ancient system discarded in favor for tyranny (a demo of cracy). I would wager once they helped in diplomacy to win others who were of the old ways they were maybe killed. Either way what I am fairly sure occurred soon after is that some new leader of the raiders decided to replace them with a bunch of wolves who then replicated their work to generate more coin. Military men don't usually have faith in what they cannot comprehend which a seer did as back then they had no brain scans to prove they had significantly more taste. Literal narrow mindedness and poor taste. So they often killed these other entities to drag everything into a simulated version which garners far greater profit; at the cost of such utter dominance and a complete eradication of it's original source until everything sacred related to the relationship between angels and man is destroyed and nobody knows who they are anymore as they are surrounded by surrogates and cyborgs. At this point stories and media becomes mostly worthless and hollow. Welcome to the 21st century.
Thank you.
Thanks. That's what I call a summary.
Thank you
Very nice and informative.
Very informative!!!
Hello, please explain how they can tell the difference between an Israelite and a Hamite when people living at the time couldn't even tell the difference.
And when the inhabitants of the land, the Canaanites, saw the mourning in the floor of Atad, they said, This is a grievous mourning to the Egyptians: wherefore the name of it was called Abelmizraim, which is beyond Jordan." - Genesis 50:11 (in reference to all of Israel's appearance when mourning Jacob's death)
"And they said, An Egyptian delivered us out of the hand of the shepherds, and also drew water enough for us, and watered the flock." - Exodus 2:19 (in reference to Moses' appearance)
"Art not thou that Egyptian, which before these days madest an uproar, and leddest out into the wilderness four thousand men that were murderers?" - Acts 21:38 (in reference to Paul's appearance)
How did they go into Egypt(AFRICA) with 70 souls and come out hundreds of years later as a mixed multitude and look European?
There are Israelis of Libyan, Egyptian, Iraqi, Syrian, descent. Not all israelíes are Germany. Please explain to me why your kind are obsessed with wanting to be Hebrews-Israelites?
@@emfegmfeg7100 Likely because the HIbiru were associated with the Hill Country Canaanites who were more aggressive. They posed more of a threat to Judah, so I would wager in todays political circles it is equally more favorable to be from their blood for the same reason it was back when the north fell to bolster Judah's merchants: mostly for fact that those who are more dangerous are more so flattered until they become subjugated by those who do the flattering. As the other four tribes who were not hill country were associated with Seafarers from the very ancient tribe of Dan and what I assume to be various mixes of these cultures, I assume the Hibiru were those who took on more duties related to raiding and fighting.
Completely messed up ...
Sanaritans are ethno-religious group
in what was known as palestine. They claimed to be amongst the remnants of the 12 tribes of biblical israel 🇮🇱 (not to be confused with the modern state of israel {zionism}). Samaritans have their own version of torah which they claimed to be more purer & is free from distortion.. they claimed that the Mount Gerizem in westbank of occupied Palestinian territory to be the true Temple of God. They speak & write a older version of Hebrew language... they speak Aramaic (language of Jesus' time) in some of their religious services and they speak Levantine Arabic as their daily language. It is wrong to paint them in negatives 🎞 & glorify the jews because both are remnants of tha 12 tribes of Biblical israel.
The Samaritans foremost teaching like Judaism is the belief in God as the One & only Divine being. (Absolute monotheism) and they have their own set of laws.
Lies
Theres no such thing as palestine
Great video, was looking for an explanation like this for years and you hit the bullseye. Having maps with the sea in perspective helps enormously also. So, what happened the Samaritans eventually? Ancestors of today's Lebanese Christians?
Many of the Samaritans followed Jesus and thus were "converted". Many were killed, just as the Jews were in the times following Jesus. The surviving Samaritans still exist, although are very few of them left. They seem to produce many sons, but not daughters, and it is said that in the small population of about 800, there are 9 more men per 1 woman. 10 to 1. It's all a very interesting history. I will always believe what the scripture says, but to add context to that, when we research history, we need to listen to both sides of every story. History is written by the victors.
Finally got and understood
Thank you for that information.
I'm trying to piece together the whole twelve sections of Israel for the twelve tribes and Levite cities in the twelve sections for the Levites and how that fits into this.
How did they know who was or wasn't a Samaritan or Jew? Was there a physiological difference in appearance? Was it the way they dressed?
Thank you so very much!!! Continue doing what you're doing!!
Thank you this has been super helpful!
John 4 also shows where that Christ did not refute the Samaritan woman when she claimed Jacob as their forefather. He revealed Himself as the Messiah in Samaria first and on that day, he planted the seeds for the Samaritan conversion to Christianity. This conversion continued in the Book of Acts.
So the real question is not why do the Jews hate the Christians of Samaria, but why do Evangelical Christians hate the Samaritans? Christ did not side with the Jews against the Samaritans, so why do Protestants condone the occupation of Samaria.?
Thank youu 😄
What is the difference between a Samaritan and a Jew? The Samaritan woman asked Jesus in John 4:12
"are You greater than *our father Jacob*, who gave us the well, and drank from it himself, as well as his sons and his livestock?”
If Jacob was a Jew and He's the Samaritans' father why aren't they considered Jews?
Wow. I was about to do a study on John chapter 4, I had to search the truth about their relation. I had just read the book of Ezra, Nehemiah, Haggai and Zechariah the whole story of the way they treated and related to each other lie there.
In John chapter 4 we see Jesus restoring that relationship between brothers.
Makes much more sense now.
Did you study the full history of Samaritan you discused who are they.
Love it!!!
wait so why wasn't israel around before 1948?
2000 years of removal of the people from the land and sending them by force by the romans, basically ethnic cleansing of all the jews from the land and killing more than a million and a half of them, couple of hundreds of years after, the romans (Byzantines) killed about a million of the Samaritans, so after that there were almost no jews or Israelites in the land, mostly couple of thousands, most of the population were Christians (about 2 million Christians), Israel of today is basically returning home after the ethnic cleansing of the romans
If you help me understand much better, thank you so much!
The Samaritans say otherwise they say they are monotheists and follow Moses. Moreover, genetic studies show they are identical to Jews.
Is there another ethnicity in conflict over land and religion as long as the Jews are or have been? Just genuinely curious.
We cannot give presumptive authority to the masoretic text, which is what Jews and Christians use. It’s a one-sided document, told from the perspective of the Jews. It’s a myth that there was never any copyist errors. The Jews hated their siblings. The Samaritans are, in fact, true Israelites. DNA studies prove this. They only follow the written Torah. The Jews follow the oral Torah, plus the written Torah. Deuteronomy 4:2 & 12:32 tell us that it is a sin to add or take away from the law of Moses. It is a sin and called rebellion to teach others not to follow it. There are blessings for obeying and curses for disobeying. For good reason, the Samaritans don’t believe that the Tanakh is inspired. They call it “Ezra’s Torah.” The Samaritan Pentateuch predates the Masoretic text. No place in Torah is Jerusalem mentioned. There is good reason to believe that Mount Gerizim is the chosen place, not Jerusalem. Temples made with hewn stones is a sin. There is no need for a temple in either Samaria nor Jerusalem. The prophecy for Abraham’s descendants to become a “multitude of nations” will be fulfilled through the northern kingdom, Samaria, and Ephraim. Jacob prophesied and passed this blessing on to Ephraim. See Genesis 48:19. Father is going to restore Israel and bring us back to the promised land, the land of our fathers. It is His promise. His word stands forever. He will bring us back to the land when we turn back to His Torah. His Torah is a lamp to our feet and a light to our path and it defines righteousness. It is not to hard to obey it if we circumcise our hearts. Shalom! 😃
Very very useful information brother, I am so amazed by the information. God bless you man
Their true name is “shomranim”, which is guardians or protectors in Hebrew
They’re called shomronim because they lived in the shomron. Like yehudim from Yehuda.
So what other Gods the Samaritans have other than Moses' God?
The people with the closest link to the original tribes of Israel are what you call Palestinian and became Christian and then Muslim. The people with the most distant genetic links to the Tribes of Israel are paradoxically the people called Jews today. What you have are distant relatives who settled in Europe two thousand years ago, who have beef that is redundant after two thousand years in the place and for the people. You may as well argue over which royal family has a right to rule Europe. Europeans don't care.
This was very enlightening for a Muslim Arab like myself.. i always thought they were just the Native Jews of Palestine. Good job explaining it :)
Hay Ahmed, I’m glad it was helpful and thank you 😊
Back then it wasn't called Palestine. But Judea and Samaria.
@@yurichtube1162 in the book of fairytales and according to the guy in the sky
@@salmaalmeahlky126 no, more like according to the history books. The romans called it Judea and Samaria too, before they conquered it completely and renamed it palestine. There are even roman coins saying "Judea has been conquered". Look it up. The name palestine is nothing but a degrading name to insult the jews.
@@yurichtube1162 Palestinians are samaritans who converted to Islam
Thanks guys, really appreciate what yall are doing.
You're welcome, David! Hope you have a great day!
you do a good job of telling Judah's side of the story, however, you are missing a huge part of the story by ignoring the Samaritan account of history. Keep in mind that the Babylonian Talmud is the version of the Talmud that was altered by generations of exposure to Babylonian beliefs.... One could say that it wasn't the "Samaritans" that brought foreign influences to the Torah, but rather the Jews returning from exile. One could examine the evidence for oneself, especially since the Babylonian Talmud seems to endorse some forms of necromancy.
What paganism is in the talmud? And where?
Very helpful video! Thank you very much! God bless you.
John 4:3-42
Samaritans and jews dealing with issue till Esau join ishmail and joined the chat in israel while palestine is cheering lol
this is the jewish and christian narrative not the samaritan narrative which have the older version of the torah.
There is a huge component of this that every one is missing. Genesis 48: 19 correctly translated states that Ephraim will become the fullness of the gentiles. Ephraim aka the northern kingdom, shall become the fullness of the gentiles. Can you see where this is leading? You won’t like it, you won’t want to accept it but, the Samaritans were, are, direct descendants of the ten tribes, and therefore, descendants of the 12 tribes, the fathers people. Regardless of personal feelings or the nitpicking of mother’s vs father’s DNA. The life is in the blood, and they have the blood. Furthermore, now, the world, through centuries of migration and marriage, and growing populations, are also descendants of his people.
Were Samaritans part of the covenant with Jacob?
Anyone who follows the law of God is part of the covenant. No one is perfect unless they follow the covenant of God regardless to who......
If they were Israelites, mixed or not, even not Israelite at all- if they chose to be Torah observant and believe in a messiah to come(?) then they should have been considered Israelites. Ruth and many others were not DNA Jews and were adopted into the faith/Converted.
@@Musick79 but they hold different beliefs. They’re heretics.
Gos bless You 🫶
More false information about the samaritans... Samaritan information not from a samaritan...what a joke. Im know going to learn about baking from a motor mechanic. samaritans a pure jews with an uncorrupted torah.
Last time I checked Samaritans didn't identify as Jews, but just as "Israelites". They're Israelites just like the Jews but they don't identify as Jews cause you know... they're Samaritans not Jews. Do your research, I did mine. They asked the same question to an actual samaritan man, and his response was "We're not Jews but we too are Israelites" . And btw I too believe their Torah is uncorrupted .
@@Goldenskies__ Correct
The Samaritans (or Isrealites as they call themselves) have a long standing tradition of not intermixing.
Do you have any record of them intermixing?
Meanwhile, the Jews allow intermixing. as long as the new spouse "comverts" to Judeism.
Maybe that why they only have 200 members! They recent allow the men to marry foreign women lol
Ohhh i get it now😅 That is why they hate each other. History is not really my thing when i read it alone. I need a teacher to explain it.
I used to hate history when I was younger. I think I only learned to like it when I realized how much it helped me understand the Bible.
I feel the same way, thank you for explaining the story.
They are confusing the Shomrim of Nablus and Holon (who are descendants of Leví and Yosef) with another group called samaritans in the Book of Kings. These are two different nations. In fact the ones called people of samaria are from 5 nations. They are called samaritans because the land of Samaria. The Shomrim are called by this name because they are keepers of the Torah. They followed Rabbinical Orthodox prejudices and misinterpretations. Nevertheless, Chabad Hasidut considers the Shomrim to be keepers of an ancient form of Hebrew and descendants of ancient Israel.
I have a HEBREW / GREEK study Bible published by AMG, it footnotes 2 Kings 17.41 and says these people “became known as the Samaratins”. And points out that they worshipped other gods, alongside worship of the TRUE god. (Verse 31 mentions child sacrifice within this context )
V. 29 in King James actually uses the word SAMARATINS.
MIXING worship of FALSE gods into their worship of the TRUE god is definitely wrong!
17.33-4 shows a progression of mixing the two, but leads to ONLY worshiping the FALSE god.
Lesson DON’T TOLERATE IDOLS IN OUR LIFE!
Your timeline needs to be revised. The Samaritan civilization was dying about the same time the Jewish religion formed. This was like 2000 years before christ. The Hindu religion also started in the same area as the Jewish they split, and Hindus moved to where India is now. Also, as the samaritans were around 2000 years before the Jewish, you should say the Jews refused to worship the many samaritan gods.
They had s competing Temple simultaneous to the one in Judea.
Now i understand it much better. Thank you for this video ♥️
No, you don't. You're much better off learning from credible sources, instead of religiously motivated sources.
Here's a timeline of the major events in the history of the Sumerians, Jews, Hindus, and Christians:
Sumerians:
4000 BCE: The Sumerians settle in Mesopotamia and begin to develop their civilization.
3500 BCE: Sumerians develop a system of writing using cuneiform script.
2334 BCE: Sargon of Akkad, a Semitic ruler, conquers Sumer and establishes the Akkadian Empire.
2112 BCE: The Ur III dynasty, the last Sumerian dynasty, comes to an end after being conquered by the Elamites.
Jews:
2000 BCE: Abraham, the father of Judaism, is born.
1250 BCE: Moses leads the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt and receives the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai.
1000 BCE: King David establishes Jerusalem as the capital of Israel.
586 BCE: The Babylonians destroy the First Temple in Jerusalem and exile the Jews to Babylon.
516 BCE: The Second Temple is built in Jerusalem after the Jews are allowed to return from exile in Babylon.
Hindus:
2500 BCE: The Indus Valley Civilization emerges in the Indian subcontinent.
1500 BCE: The Vedas, the oldest scriptures of Hinduism, are composed.
322-185 BCE: The Maurya Empire is established by Chandragupta Maurya, which leads to the spread of Buddhism in India.
600-1100 CE: The Golden Age of Hinduism, marked by the rise of classical Sanskrit literature, art, and architecture.
1947 CE: India gains independence from British rule, and the country is divided into India and Pakistan.
Christians:
4 BCE: Jesus Christ is born in Bethlehem.
30 CE: Jesus is crucified and resurrected.
313 CE: The Edict of Milan is issued, granting religious toleration to Christianity in the Roman Empire.
1054 CE: The Great Schism occurs, splitting the Christian Church into the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church.
1517 CE: Martin Luther nails his 95 Theses to the door of a church in Wittenberg, sparking the Protestant Reformation.
And to think Sunnis and Shias were bad apples with each other
Cypress native, the aethernet is made of us.
we to this day hear the jewish media refer to people that rescue people as "good samaritans" its actually an insult, btw i have jewish blood. i know what we run lol
Shalmanezer, king of Assyria carried away Israel to Assyria because they had been rejected by God for their unrepentant idolatry practices And Kings 17, and relocated 5 different tribes of Assyrians with 5 different idolatry practices in Samaria. 2 kings 17:24-41.
This is the reason why Jews do not have anything to do with the Samaritans of their day, because they believed that they were strangers living in the promised land.
The Samaritan woman at the well who was met by Jesus Christ because of her faith in the God of the Jews. She had allied herself, like Ruth, to Jacob, by saying "our father Jacob...Our fathers worshipped..." John 4:1-26.
She, in her quest for the True God, went through all the 5 gods of Assyria, and now found about the God of Israel.
Just then, she met Jesus who then told her the good news of salvation by faith in the One that God has sent to restore Israel.
Because of her faith in Him, she not only got saved, but became the evangelist to proclaim this good news to all Samaritans.
The idols and gods are likened to having a marital relationship, thus, she had been with 5 husbands and now even the 6th wasn't what she was looking for.
This meant that the mystery which was hidden right from the beginning- Jews and Gentiles would be saved, was fulfilled.
Jesus was indeed sent only to the lost sheep of Israel, but He also ministered to anyone who would simply have the faith of Abraham and believe God through Christ Jesus, who was sent to seek and save lost Israel.
The Samaritan woman was one of the 3 gentiles ministered to by Jesus Christ for their faith in Him:
The Roman Centurion, the Samaritan woman at the well and the Canaanite woman.
He didn't acknowledge the Greek gentiles when they came to seek Him because He had to pay the wages for their sins before they could finally be included in salvation work of Jesus Christ by grace, through faith in His sacrificial death, burial and resurrection John 12:32.
Finally, by the Holy Spirit, Philip was sent to include Jew Proselytes, through the Ethiopian Eunuch, then the Apostle Paul was sent to the rest of the world.
After the kingdom divided the( 1 kings 12) north king jeroboam created his own religion by building two shrines with golden calves on high places. He chose his own time to offer sacrifices. He appointed priests that were not Levites. All of these things are abomination. Later, when the north was plundered. Only the poorest of the poor were left behind in the north. The rest of the Israelites were exiled…Diaspora. So yes some, a few poor were left in the north and mixed with heathen nations. I believe these poor people were the Samaritans. That’s why the Jews despised them. Because they followed Jeroboams sinful ways. But somehow to this day they do follow Torah. I don’t know what feasts they follow. They are literally brothers. They need to reconcile. The Jew is not reconciling with anyone in this world as I am aware of.
Thank you Jesus! God bless you!
But is not Jesus called a Samaritan in the Bible by the Jews? John 8:48
Absolutely misinformed video.
Samaritans were Canaanites and had been native to that land.
Also, they were not settled by Assyrians, wrong.
Also, Jews saw them as inferior and that was just like how Azis view Jews. So ,that's karma.
I am an Arab and the samiratans are the true Jews and children of Israel . And we Muslims Respect them so much because they believe in our prophet Mohammed and they respect because he is mentioned in their scripture .
What do you lying? Or speaking while not knowing? The Samiratans don't believe in Mohammad. Their no mentions of Muhammad in the Torah(in Samaritan's Torah too) and also the Samiratans refuse to believe that there were any other prophets beside Moses. To them only and only Moses was a prophet.
😂😂😂
Why muslilm claim every aspect of history but not belongs with it topic. Im head are shake it to the left and shake it to right😂😂😂😂😂😂
The ten tribes of Israel are Samaria and populated Europe and the Americas and the remnant remained Samaria and Palestine
Israel was never Jewish
The first Jews were the captivity of The house of Judah which became Babylonian Talmudic Judaism(not of God) end eventually lynched The Messiah
Thus the whole 12 tribes of Abraham was expunged from the Promised Land for not following the commandment of God. In the Lost years of Jesus some scholars tells of the young Jesus traveling in the East, curing and preaching up to Tibet before going back to Istael. As Yahusha said, God is spirit and should be worship with all their spirit, mind , heart and mind. No matter who they are and what they done not only on holy mountain and temples. That is what we are doing right now, worshipping God where we are. Now I understand fully thanks to you the gap between the Jews and Samaritans.
13 tribes - Khazars
Samaritan are true jewish. His not zionist
bad info you are , they worship the one true god and they follow the torah mister , i lived in nablus scheme and they do worship the one holy god
"They wern't going to follow the law of Moses any more"
A hardcore Moses religion that rejects everyone else isn't going to follow the law of Moses any more? You really need to consider your sources.
1/10 for effort.