@@MichelleLeah The moment she started with that ok ok ok, Mathis would’ve dismissed her case for contempt and verbally destroyed her. Millian was way too nice here
She was yelling at her tho..She's the judge but that's a grown woman...Now, when Judge Milian lowered her tone which in my opinion was her own self-checking, then the defendant should've started being compliant.
It's interesting that you're thinking of her kids' behavior rather than how miserable they must be living with her. No child is "bad". Only bad parents.
@@lacymacdougall9660 the mother’s behavior is a direct result of their parents’ behavior as you yourself pointed out. The kids are already representative of the mom’s behavior.
What about the judges kids🤔🤔 wonder what type of sociopaths they’ll turn into. People who think they can talk down/belittle others always raise angels right 🤷🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
I can’t believe the judge didn’t agree with the harassment claim. That lady harassed the judge, you know she’s doing it to the plaintiff. Hell, I feel harassed just watching the B.
BS RULING!! Ppl who call CPS as a way to punish someone they're mad at should absolutely have to pay a huge fine for harassment! She should have gotten every penny of that 3 grand!
That poor plaintiff looked terrified this entire case. No wonder she had to sue for $60. She didn't want confrontation with a woman who acts like that!
The defendant's entrance says all,I needed to see. This is a case of narcissistic behavior. The defendant's behavior is definitely arrogant and thinks,she is entitled.
I think the defendant’s defiance in a courtroom showed her bullying behavior and I have no doubt that she’s harassed the plaintiff. I also believe she called to report bad parenting against the plaintiff. That’s harassment. She should’ve received damages.
Well, it must have been a good idea this time, because she sided with her on the harassment part, so she didn't have to pay up. It was a horrible decision though.
Judge or not, respect is respect. You can be stern while being respectful towards the litigants. That judge set the tone for the disrespect she received.
Judge Mathis would’ve NEVAAAAAH let this defendant get away with this!!! The time she said “You don’t have to yell at me” she would’ve been out the door for contempt, plaintiff awarded $3000. Period.
The plaintiff absolutely proved and deserved the $3,000. These shows get rich off these people's stories but rarely pay them anything. I can't see how Judge Marilyn can warrant paying her husband and Harvey.
I think she decided that awarding her this high fee would cause her living situation more turmoil than help. She probably surmised that the defendant was suing more based off principle than for the money.
I hate to bring up the competition but judge Judy would have nailed her for ABUSING the legal system... in this case contacting CPS- a clear-cut example of this
The defendant yelling at the judge and the judge let her carry on with the case instead of granting the plaintiff All that she was suing for? All I can say is WOW
You & me both! The first time she had to keep asking her if she understood her. I would have tossed her out then, I'm the damn judge! She waited waaaay to late to give her the boot! She LOOKS tough with her kids, her "man", the person at McDonald's, at Rite Aid. She's just rude AF.
@@destina3898 and they keep saying JJ or JM would not have taken it, but what they don't get is JJ and JM wait for a reason to yell or belittle someone. JM be on 10 from the beginning sometimes....I love her, but she was doing too much during this case.
Clearly there was harassment evidence, and with Judge Mathis, the defendant would have been thrown out for contempt and the plaintiff awarded whatever she was asking for. The judge was very patient with this defendant
Was she??? She went in as soon as the case started. First going off on the defendant and the plaintiff hadn’t even said a word before she went off on her for “raising her hands” too much? If someone talked to you like that would you be all calm about it just because she had on “a black robe”. I’m the most calm and patient person too and I would’ve probably had an attitude as well. I’m sorry I usually agree with the judge based on her verdicts and sometimes when she goes off on people I also agree but she was acting like her day was f’d up from the jump. This was rude and shows her level of superiority really goes to her head. Just because you have that robe doesn’t mean people have to be meek and mild and take your ish.
@Marilyn Willett you don’t have to tell me what I know. I know how to treat people and I know how I am to be treated. In no court of law will anyone talk to me like that and expect to get a respectful response. Women like me?? You don’t know me to say such a thing. Based off of that alone I should throw that back at you and say “women like you can dish it but can’t take it”. All I’m saying is that the judge came off very disrespectful from the jump and for every action there is a reaction. The young lady reacted to her inappropriately based upon the judges disposition. Before she even did it to the defendant she was already yelling at the plaintiff. Sometimes I understand the “aggressiveness” but sometimes it’s simply uncalled for. PERIOD! Thats my opinion and I’m sticking with it. Like yours it don’t mean SHIT!
@@sheisme2 that's the difference between Millian and Mathis. Judge Mathis rules sometimes based on emotion but Millian still tries to be fair with the ruling.
@@TUN3MODE nah the judge was unfair with this one the plaintiff should’ve gotten all the money i hate she only got $60 that made me mad i think Peoples court is a bit more stricter than Judge Mathis i think JM can do more because it’s his own practice Judge Milan is just a employee judge for the People’s court she don’t have as much power as Judge Mathis or Judge Judy
This is why I do not get close to neighbors. Don’t come to my house, don’t ask me for nothing, don’t speak to me- nothing. Ppl are crazy these days, it’s not Mr. Rogers’ neighborhood like it was when our parents were growing up. The defendant I bet she looks a mess under that bang. She is such a turn off. I bet she’s a terrible mother because her actions told her whole story. The plaintiff really turned me off by reiterating how her underage daughter persuaded her to let the crazy lady hold the speaker . How do you just throw your child under the bus like that when you are the parent -what you say goes, it’s not the little girl’s fault. This case was crazy.
You right. Some folks move to where I live. One neighbor kept asking for quarters to wash her laundry. I kept catching her going to store buying snacks and not washing the clothes. I told her don't ever ask me for any quarters again and she never paid back the ones she took over a few months. Other neighbors come asking for toilet paper and expected me to buy them groceries. Every time I went by their apt to my own. They thought my sacks were for them. I got tired of it. I live on a fixed income and have many disabilities. Then had the nerve to ask could they come over and visit. I said I don't go into anybody apt and nobody coming into mine. I didn't even like mgt coming in or maintenance because they steal and stuff still don't get fixed.
She is craaaaazy disrespectful! The bailiff kept moving closer and closer, because he knew this nut might be dangerous! That 12-year-old is very mature. The mom looks terrified!
That defendant does have not just a few but many screws loose. She thinks she is cute, she walked in a courtroom dressed and acting like she was coming to a VH1 reality show audition.
Catfish, Bangfish.. Mess.. She still has the speakers- she started that nonsense about stolen speakers to cover, hoping she would set up a justification for not paying.
After that scene with the defendant the judge should’ve given the plaintiff every single penny she asked for and the defendant should’ve been found guilty and held responsible for her disrespectfulness in court. Act a fool means you should get treated as one. Period!!
Aww man that woman is out of control, attitude should play in small claims cases especially when ur the defendant 🤦🏻♀️ she disrespected the hell out of the judge
@@lucabrasi2561 The judge has the right to have an attitude. It's her court. She can be as big of a bitch as she wants, and the litigants just have to suck it up. Too bad so sad.
The defendant is SO arrogant, probably used to getting what she wants by flaunting her goods. That ain't gonna work in court, sis. The judge should have dismissed her after she kept arguing that first time.
If the defendant couldn't even contain herself in a courtroom then I could only imagine what her personal relationships are like. It's a sure fire way to end up dying alone because nobody in their right mind wants to deal with anyone who's that self absorbed and combative.
Wow! I couldn’t bare to hear that mouth breather trying to be all sassy during this case, I can’t imagine the horrors her neighbors, friends, coworkers, and every human being around her have to deal with every day.
@@34stzoo Exactly what I was thinking. Screw Nicki Minaj, I wanna be mistaken for JJ. That woman is a boss and her earnings (due to her brains) show it!
She said she didnt ask her to buy them, she wanted to go buy them herself... but before that she said she told the plaintiff that she could go with her to buy them or give the money to go buy them.. 🤔
My exact thoughts it’s apart of the manipulation to get something for nothing🤨🤨 Twisted thinking..It’s just that simple … 💵 +🦵🏾+🚙+🏬 + 📢 +😃+💃🏾 There should only be 2 people involved when making a purchase You and the merchant..
When you are disrespectful to the judge that is contempt and there is a price for that, it doesnt matter how right or wrong your case is you still blew it and you should pay .
Unfortunately, due to this being a TV show she can't legally hold someone in contempt. She explained it in one of those post-interviews with her husband. I wish she could.
@@brettsfav4 He's not a real judge anymore. None of them are real judges anymore. You have to renew your license to practice law (Judge Mathis let his license go a long time ago), but JJ, Judge Mathis, Judge Millian, etc all retired from actually being a judge to be TV mediators. The money was better. lol But yeah, anyone can be TV mediators (judges)... literally, anyone (even children, the uneducated, etc) can be TV judges.
@@jenerin905 She can't hold anyone for contempt, but she has the ability to reward or punish someone who is contemptuous. It's a mediator show, where she has the ability to make any decision she wants. For some reason, she doesn't punish people like the defendant like she should.
I think Judge Milan was WRONG here, she started that attitude and then wanted her to calm down. She disrespected her many times and was yelling at her and continued even when she INITIALLY remained calm.
Thank you!! I am sitting here thinking the same. She calmly asked for judge to not yell at her and Milan got louder?? And then repeated the same question condescendingly when the lady answered multiple times
I don't think it's right for the Judge to yell at anyone, have respect and you'll get respect. She raised her hand to speak and Milian yelled at her, uncalled for. These judges think they're Gods. I do think the plaintiff should have gotten the money for harassment, especially if she had evidence. I wonder why she didn't give it to her smh.
You don't raise your hand in court and posture your head like you'rea little primadonna. Milian grills everyone. Don't come on the show if you don't like that about her. The defendant is a complete loser and needs to seek help. Her ego is far too fragile.
@@coffeepandacat like I said, have respect and you'll get respect. Just because she grills everyone does that make it right?? Noooo. It's rude and unprofessional, she's a hothead just like the defendant and that day she met her match😊😊
@@coffeepandacat no she said put her hand down. She did. Then she started barking and being condescending like she always does. It would have been worth to 60 dollars to tell that rude judge to kiss my ass. She is boisterous and obnoxious to everybody. People don't have to accept abuse from her crabby ass.
@@coffeepandacat also raising her hand was the respectful way of asking permission to speak. All the judge had to do was say wait. You can raise your hand in court. Posture your head like a prima donna? Smh you sound ignorant.
The defendant thought she was going to get scouted for some kind of ratchet reality tv show. I’m sad she wasn’t thrown out of courtroom much earlier. I also don’t get why the plaintiff didn’t get her harassment! The judge saw the defendant’s behavior first hand.
Plaintiff and her daughter are both so pretty, gorgeous skin. And for 12 her daughter is very well spoken she acted better then the grown ass defendant
@Marilyn Willett since when does complimenting others skin tone make that person “self conscious”? You’re acting as if she said her skin tone was the *only beautiful skin tone in the world.* let people compliment others .. yall have no reason being so hateful.
Most of the comments are about the defendant but The judge started off on 1000. Why was it ok for her to be yelling and raising her voice like that to both the plaintiff and defendant but when she gets that same energy “she is ratchet and acting like she’s in the street”??? That’s crazy. The plaintiff raising her hand 20 times or what ever should not be annoying to a judge. Yeah she thinks she’s better because she is the judge. Period!!! That wasn’t right and I don’t see how anyone could think that’s fair. It’s quite demeaning and belittling regardless of how the defendant looks and acts after the fact.
I was hoping someone else saw that too! I can understand the judge trying to maintain control, but there isn't any reason to be disrespectful. I think that she took one look at the defendant and felt like she could speak to her any kind of way. I felt like she was over the top with her.
@@ellehinkins623 thank you!!! I absolutely agree with you. I was shocked at how hard she was going. She came off so aggressive and dismissive. I guess most people forgot about the beginning and just Harped on the girl when she actually started being rude back but I remember specifically in the case the girl saying “I haven’t even said anything and can you please stop yelling at me”. You act like that with a person you already assume to be ratchet then don’t be surprised when her true colors show lol
I haven’t finished the whole thing so idk if she gets really disrespectful but in the beginning she was only asking JM to not yell at her which I think is definitely reasonable, no adult wants to be talked down on.
I just I mentioned something similar in my comment , The Judge was yelling her to put her hand down . She never said a word the only thing she said was can you stop yelling at me . Then the Judge ask to her to yelling DO YOU UNDERSTAND ME she didn't want to reply because the judge was yelling . Then the Judge said she can yell because she has on a robe . Who disrespecting Who ? The Judge start off wrong only because her hand was up to get the Judge attention . The Judge was embarrassed but her because she asked her to stop yelling on T.V. See people can't stand when you stand up for yourself ! Now they call it disrespect ( SMH )
Whewwwww, I haven't seen a nastier defendant. Edit: The plaintiff should've gotten compensated for the harassment. Shiiiiiiiiiiit I felt harassed just from watching her behavior. I can't imagine living next to ole girl. I wonder how Judge Mathis or Judge Judy would've handled her🤔
When the plaintiff wasn't explaining clearly why she gave the defendant the speakers, I was thinking it was clear after hearing JM talk to her. She is extremely forceful, disrespectful. and entitled. Yeah, the plaintiff deserved to be compensated for harassment.
The defendant is so rude, nasty and disrespectful. The judge should've thrown her out much earlier. I've worked with people like the defendant. All they do is lie and create problems. I can't stand people like the defendant.
Less than half way through the defendant talking and I think to myself, “she’s Nikki Minaj from Wish” when she said they made fun of her for exactly that, I cracked up. 😅
When the defendant said congratulations it reminded me of when Joseline told Nina Parker congratulations when she said she has a degree in journalism 😂😂😂
I would've gave that lady what she asked for because being a bully and being loud scared this lady I can tell that poor lady ain't no hood chick like her smh
A false CPS case definitely warrants harassment. How do you ask her if she can relocate and state “we have to have peace where we live for our kids” Give her the 3k so she can afford to relocate. The defendant is at shit crazy.
I knew the defendant was crazy immediately I saw her walk into the court room smiling like an idiot...if I were the judge I will make her pay every penny even for harassment. What nansense.
Probably one of the rudest defendants I have seen! I expected her to be kicked out much sooner she acted like she was ready to fight the judge. I wouldn’t want her as a neighbor either. This is why I can’t be friendly with neighbors much because you don’t know what type of foolishness they may be on and like the judge says I have to have peace where I lay.
She didn't award the 3k for the plaintiffs safety. That's why she asked would she be able to move before saying it (and note the sad look the judge had on her face, her whole tone changed at that point). That 3k would've ruined the plaintiffs life with that crazy defendant constantly harassing and maybe even turning violent on her.
The defendant walked in like she thought she was a model walking down a runway. She clearly thinks she's hot stuff and above everyone else. She needs to get over herself.
Wow...I had to rewind to see what you mean, but wow, this defendant definitely came to get her moment on TV. But she acted such a fool, I don't know what she thought she was accomplishing!
Oh gosh..I had the same thoughts...she was beaming away with no remorse. I had jealous nasty bully neighbors who did not want me to work and live in peace. More I ignored them more provoking they resorted to...what were they teaching their own children?!
12:58 This crap I don't understand? I always refer back to the case where a limousine driver showed up late to take a couple to a ferry so they can attend the wedding reception. Outside of the Bride setting everything up not giving enough time to take into account any mishap before the ferry departed. The limousine company refund all their money and tried to make things right with the couple, owning up to everything! The Bride decided to sue for 5K for emotional distress for ruining their wedding reception. The Judge awarded 5K for emotional distress and breach of contract! I was like WTF! The company screwed up and tried to make things right. It wasn't a malicious act and they owned up to it. But for someone calling CPS on you to get back at you doesn't warrant or reach the level of emotional distress and harassment in her book? I wish could meet her in person and ask, why?
I think in this case, the judge wasn't able to get down to the facts of what happened. The whole explanation of my daughter convinced me was kind of sketchy. So yes the defendant is out of line but who's to say the plaintiff also isn't antagonistic to a degree but just knows how to comport herself in a courtroom.
@@christianfernandez91 I was thinking the same thing. The plaintiff looks like the stereotypical "quiet, causes no trouble with anybody" in front of authority figures but behind closed doors she raises hell
In the limo case, you're talking about a couple who pays a premium (wedding services pay extra just when the word wedding is used for premium service) for a once in a lifetime (hopefully) event. They were cut hours short for their event and the other things they paid for weren't up to the standard they paid for due to them being late... Because of the limo company. I do agree though that a harassment settlement was absolutely needed in this case, but the plaintiff needed to keep better records of it. Dates CPS showed up, any inconveniences due to that, anytime the defendant was loud and unruly, and so on. Just the defendant's attitude in court should have proven how hard it is to live around her.
I agree with JM. The plaintiff caused way too much trouble by agreeing to give the defendant the speakers. Plus, the defendant was way out of line. “You’re not gonna keep yelling at me”?! Oh yeah, ✌🏽defendant.
The defendant should have been dismissed since 14:47. I absolutely believe the plaintiff about the harassment and she should have been granted that $3000 as well. When they get back home I’m sure she’s going to have an even harder time living around her.
She does it and its not okay. She puts people down and that's not okay. If she keeps it up, she may want to consider a security detail. Most people aren't okay with being denigrated on national television.
Actually, I'm surprised Judge Milian yelled at her. She is usually respectful. I'm not giving her excuses, but I guess she was in a mood. The meanest Judge on TV is still Judge Judy. She always have an attitude and yells all the time. She is always snotty to people whether they're polite or not. If she catches someone in a lie, she gets really pissed. She doesn't care what others think. I guess that's why people love Judge Judy. I still watch her lol.
The defendant walks in like 'All Hail The Queen!', someone thinks highly of themselves! She lied on at least two fronts, that she could ever have respect for anyone, and that anyone could be her friend ... like cozying up to a viper!!
The defendant got lucky Judge Milian was lenient with her behavior. Over talking, she swore("grown ass woman"),...... she definitely came in on a high horse.
A judge sets the tone in the courtroom. Milian makes a practice of mishandling and berating/yelling right out of the gate. These are adults. Your degree and position do not give you the right to disrespect litigants just as my teaching degree doesn’t justify me mishandling students. Do better, Judge, and better will be reciprocated. I applaud the defendant for demanding she be dealt with, with dignity.
To an egomaniac they think they're the one's that are never wrong. Her attitude sucks and I believe she did try to rip off that girl. her attitude says it all
@@janetcupp467 Oh I don't doubt that at ALL. Egomaniacs always think they can treat people how they want and get away with it. Well, (to misquote the kids today) she fooled around and found out!
If I was the judge, I would’ve dismissed the defendant a long time ago. Contempt. Simple as that. She’s beyond disrespectful.
Judge Mathis would have definitely kicked her out and the plaintiff would have won.
Yes. The defendant was so rude. All she succeeded in doing is making herself look like an idiot.
@@MichelleLeah The moment she started with that ok ok ok, Mathis would’ve dismissed her case for contempt and verbally destroyed her. Millian was way too nice here
Oh yes definitely
She was yelling at her tho..She's the judge but that's a grown woman...Now, when Judge Milian lowered her tone which in my opinion was her own self-checking, then the defendant should've started being compliant.
If this is how she acts in court, I can only imagine how bad her kids are thanks to her . Smh
It's interesting that you're thinking of her kids' behavior rather than how miserable they must be living with her. No child is "bad". Only bad parents.
@@lacymacdougall9660 the mother’s behavior is a direct result of their parents’ behavior as you yourself pointed out. The kids are already representative of the mom’s behavior.
Yes exactly.
What about the judges kids🤔🤔 wonder what type of sociopaths they’ll turn into. People who think they can talk down/belittle others always raise angels right 🤷🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
@Marilyn Willett super fan 🤣😂🤣 you have no clue what’s going on in her home with her children.
I can’t believe the judge didn’t agree with the harassment claim. That lady harassed the judge, you know she’s doing it to the plaintiff. Hell, I feel harassed just watching the B.
💯😆
Facts 💀🤣😭
Truth!!! Lol
My thoughts exactly, especially after she acknowledged the false allegations to CPS
I would have given her $6000 for harassment. That defendant was an obnoxious Cardi B wannabe. And a very poor wannabe at that.
BS RULING!! Ppl who call CPS as a way to punish someone they're mad at should absolutely have to pay a huge fine for harassment! She should have gotten every penny of that 3 grand!
Can you imagine the defendant acting like that in front of judge Judy? She would eat her up!
That would have been fun to watch 😂😂😂
I've seen worse on Judy's show, but this particular Defendant could probably get her to say something she'd regret.
Judge Judy would make her feel so small lol
Or Judge Milian now... this was in 2015... lol
She would have been ruled against and thrown out. I don’t know what judge Milan was thinking this episode
That poor plaintiff looked terrified this entire case. No wonder she had to sue for $60. She didn't want confrontation with a woman who acts like that!
Judge mathis would gave the plantiff 3000 just cause of the defendant attitude
That's what I said if u want harassment, u better go to Judge Mathis. Milian never gives anyone harassment.
Lol facts
AND he would've kept the defendant there to hear that ruling!
And would've match their sassyness
She definitely should have went to Mathis! Ain’t no way she shouldn’t have gotten something for harassment.. Wow! 😞
The defendant's entrance says all,I needed to see. This is a case of narcissistic behavior.
The defendant's behavior is definitely arrogant and thinks,she is entitled.
I'm surprised the judge let the defendant go on for that long, I was expecting her to toss her out sooner
Let the clown dance around a bit for the show lol
@@prockjohn Lol! So true...
Yea, that was painful to watch. I felt disrespected on her behalf!
The judge says that she gives them more leeway cuz its arbitration. She says shes more strict in real court
No, the case would've ended too quickly, depriving us of the entertainment factor...
I think the defendant’s defiance in a courtroom showed her bullying behavior and I have no doubt that she’s harassed the plaintiff. I also believe she called to report bad parenting against the plaintiff. That’s harassment. She should’ve received damages.
I don't think harassing the judge when you're being sued for harassment is a good idea.
Well, it must have been a good idea this time, because she sided with her on the harassment part, so she didn't have to pay up. It was a horrible decision though.
😂😂😂 right
Truth!
she yelled at her and talked to her crazy so she did the same
Didn't seem to make a difference. Strangely...
LMAOOOO the walk in… whatever the plaintiff said the defendant did… she did it 😅
The defendant needs some serious therapy and counseling for her behavior. Never disrespect the judge.
She needs some home training! Shameful behavior!
Therapy yes....a kick in the arse.....multiple times
@@judyhall3373 Why does the date matter?
Terrible
Judge or not, respect is respect. You can be stern while being respectful towards the litigants. That judge set the tone for the disrespect she received.
Judge Mathis would’ve NEVAAAAAH let this defendant get away with this!!! The time she said “You don’t have to yell at me” she would’ve been out the door for contempt, plaintiff awarded $3000. Period.
Yes, he would have yelled that so quick and not even heard the rest of the case of had the plaintiff provide any evidence. Milian too soft.
@@strike8490 😂 exactly!!
Defendant thought it was an audition and all she did was make herself look ratchet
DEFINITELY HAS NOOOOOOOOOO CLASS!!
She was there for her 15mins of fame🤣😖 cringe worthy...
Happy she was on tv
Beyond ratchet
Exactly
The defendant was rude and nasty. I wish she was able to charge her with contempt of court
I’m extremely dissatisfied with the verdict. If anyone deserved compensation for emotional distress the plaintiff did. Outrageous!
exactly
The plaintiff absolutely proved and deserved the $3,000. These shows get rich off these people's stories but rarely pay them anything. I can't see how Judge Marilyn can warrant paying her husband and Harvey.
I think she decided that awarding her this high fee would cause her living situation more turmoil than help. She probably surmised that the defendant was suing more based off principle than for the money.
Disrespectful Defendant.
I hate to bring up the competition but judge Judy would have nailed her for ABUSING the legal system... in this case contacting CPS- a clear-cut example of this
What a lovely young woman the daughter is. You can tell she is being raised with care and love.
The defendant yelling at the judge and the judge let her carry on with the case instead of granting the plaintiff All that she was suing for? All I can say is WOW
You & me both! The first time she had to keep asking her if she understood her. I would have tossed her out then, I'm the damn judge! She waited waaaay to late to give her the boot!
She LOOKS tough with her kids, her "man", the person at McDonald's, at Rite Aid. She's just rude AF.
I'm actually glad the defendant stuck up for herself that crazy judge be yelling for no reason!! And it makes me mad
@@destina3898 and they keep saying JJ or JM would not have taken it, but what they don't get is JJ and JM wait for a reason to yell or belittle someone. JM be on 10 from the beginning sometimes....I love her, but she was doing too much during this case.
Um that's not how the law works. That's called abuse of power which no fair minded judge should do.
Right any other person she throws them out.
Harvey said " i gotta tell you the defendant is such an idiot"😂😂😂😂😅
Clearly there was harassment evidence, and with Judge Mathis, the defendant would have been thrown out for contempt and the plaintiff awarded whatever she was asking for. The judge was very patient with this defendant
Was she??? She went in as soon as the case started. First going off on the defendant and the plaintiff hadn’t even said a word before she went off on her for “raising her hands” too much? If someone talked to you like that would you be all calm about it just because she had on “a black robe”. I’m the most calm and patient person too and I would’ve probably had an attitude as well. I’m sorry I usually agree with the judge based on her verdicts and sometimes when she goes off on people I also agree but she was acting like her day was f’d up from the jump. This was rude and shows her level of superiority really goes to her head. Just because you have that robe doesn’t mean people have to be meek and mild and take your ish.
Amen 🙏
It's not a real court. It's an arbitration. There can't be contempt technically.
@Roi Samagoue there is a video with the judge and her husband talking about not being able to charge anyone for contempt.
@Marilyn Willett you don’t have to tell me what I know. I know how to treat people and I know how I am to be treated. In no court of law will anyone talk to me like that and expect to get a respectful response.
Women like me?? You don’t know me to say such a thing. Based off of that alone I should throw that back at you and say “women like you can dish it but can’t take it”.
All I’m saying is that the judge came off very disrespectful from the jump and for every action there is a reaction. The young lady reacted to her inappropriately based upon the judges disposition. Before she even did it to the defendant she was already yelling at the plaintiff. Sometimes I understand the “aggressiveness” but sometimes it’s simply uncalled for. PERIOD! Thats my opinion and I’m sticking with it. Like yours it don’t mean SHIT!
The defendant is so trifling.
I am surprised Judge didn't put the defendant out of the courtroom.
Defendant walked in with the creepiest smile on her face. Oh yeah, she crazy.
I googled her name. Looks like she owns a housekeeping company and an actress.
Yesssss ..very creepy with attitude too
Walking in like she’s somebody 😂😂 wait I’ll retract that she is somebody in her world 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Right!
A character 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. She was ready for her moment.
This young bird is crazy lol 🙄😂😂 sis just stop it. This is why I stay to myself. People are crazy 😧
The defendant I so lucky that JM doesn't have the ability to hold her contempt of court because it's a show. She's straight disrespectful
You can dismiss the case in the plaintiffs favor though!
@@sheisme2 that case would’ve been dismissed the first time the defendant yelled at the judge.
@@sheisme2 that's the difference between Millian and Mathis. Judge Mathis rules sometimes based on emotion but Millian still tries to be fair with the ruling.
@@TUN3MODE nah the judge was unfair with this one the plaintiff should’ve gotten all the money i hate she only got $60 that made me mad i think Peoples court is a bit more stricter than Judge Mathis i think JM can do more because it’s his own practice Judge Milan is just a employee judge for the People’s court she don’t have as much power as Judge Mathis or Judge Judy
@@TUN3MODE I think for the most part she's fair but there's some cases where I'm just like REALLY!! You don't make sense lol
Judge Milian should have kicked her out a long time ago!! She has some patience!!💙🤞🏻
Defendant embarrassed herself. Poor children 😢.
💯🥴
Absolutely
poor anyone that gotta be round her.....yikes
People like her have no shame
Trash
Hide your lying eyes with your fringe, defendant is creepy. The ignorance of the defendant making fun of the judge, OH DAMN!
This is why I do not get close to neighbors. Don’t come to my house, don’t ask me for nothing, don’t speak to me- nothing. Ppl are crazy these days, it’s not Mr. Rogers’ neighborhood like it was when our parents were growing up.
The defendant I bet she looks a mess under that bang. She is such a turn off. I bet she’s a terrible mother because her actions told her whole story.
The plaintiff really turned me off by reiterating how her underage daughter persuaded her to let the crazy lady hold the speaker . How do you just throw your child under the bus like that when you are the parent -what you say goes, it’s not the little girl’s fault. This case was crazy.
100%
You right. Some folks move to where I live. One neighbor kept asking for quarters to wash her laundry. I kept catching her going to store buying snacks and not washing the clothes. I told her don't ever ask me for any quarters again and she never paid back the ones she took over a few months.
Other neighbors come asking for toilet paper and expected me to buy them groceries. Every time I went by their apt to my own. They thought my sacks were for them. I got tired of it. I live on a fixed income and have many disabilities. Then had the nerve to ask could they come over and visit. I said I don't go into anybody apt and nobody coming into mine. I didn't even like mgt coming in or maintenance because they steal and stuff still don't get fixed.
Me either. I go from home to my car, car to home. I don’t want any convo, no favors and I’m not giving any.
She is craaaaazy disrespectful! The bailiff kept moving closer and closer, because he knew this nut might be dangerous!
That 12-year-old is very mature. The mom looks terrified!
I wish Judge Mathis would of took this case. He would of put her out!!
That defendant does have not just a few but many screws loose. She thinks she is cute, she walked in a courtroom dressed and acting like she was coming to a VH1 reality show audition.
Walking like she was on the red carpet. ☺
Yessssss!!!!!!
that is exactly why , this just a show . she would go to jail for 93 days if she act like this in a real court .
Googled: looks like she's had acting gigs.
Loose? I think they're missing
Catfish, Bangfish.. Mess.. She still has the speakers- she started that nonsense about stolen speakers to cover, hoping she would set up a justification for not paying.
After that scene with the defendant the judge should’ve given the plaintiff every single penny she asked for and the defendant should’ve been found guilty and held responsible for her disrespectfulness in court. Act a fool means you should get treated as one. Period!!
Judge Mathis would have done just that. Contempt.
Contempt of court is what the charge is.
@veldatingling5841 how do you know
Damn mad respect for the judge for not trying to yell over the defendant, just immediately dismissed her.
she was probably having a bad day. normally, she does not put up with nonsense
Aww man that woman is out of control, attitude should play in small claims cases especially when ur the defendant 🤦🏻♀️ she disrespected the hell out of the judge
JM is a boss bish and shut that attitude down 🤣
Douglas was ready to kick her out
The judge had a attitude 1st, with both women,
I know her babies daddies RAN away, I feel sorry for her kids.
@@lucabrasi2561 The judge has the right to have an attitude. It's her court. She can be as big of a bitch as she wants, and the litigants just have to suck it up. Too bad so sad.
The Judge was yelling at her first !!! People in authority don't have to yell just because they feel that they have power over others .
Agreed!
Lol, welcome to court
Based on your name, I see why you would agree 🤦🏽♀️
Don’t be in front of a judge and you won’t have that problem. Also she does have power over every single person that comes in front of her
The defendant's understanding of court room proceedings is zero.
The defendant is SO arrogant, probably used to getting what she wants by flaunting her goods.
That ain't gonna work in court, sis.
The judge should have dismissed her after she kept arguing that first time.
I can't believe she didn't get dismissed immediately talking back to the judge
If the defendant couldn't even contain herself in a courtroom then I could only imagine what her personal relationships are like. It's a sure fire way to end up dying alone because nobody in their right mind wants to deal with anyone who's that self absorbed and combative.
I can't even make it through this case...I hate ppl like this, act crazy then start yelling at the judge 🙄
Lmaoooo where did the defendant think she was at? Never seen someone so blatantly disrespect a judge 🤦🏾♀️
I'm mind blown
The judge let her smh 🤦♀️
Only on judge brown
Good for her. Only you 🐑 thinks it’s ok to let somebody belittle you just cause they wear a robe smh
Hoochie mother and a neighborhood rat 🐁
Wow! I couldn’t bare to hear that mouth breather trying to be all sassy during this case, I can’t imagine the horrors her neighbors, friends, coworkers, and every human being around her have to deal with every day.
That was super awkward watching the defendant walk in and did all that extra stuff 😳
Yeah she is using the wig to cover her bad eye
Yeah like I was embarrassed for her
@@dr.a2160 me too
She thinks she's Nicki Minaj, lol!!
Right. She's used to bullying people. One of these days where gonna run into the wrong one.
“PUT YOUR HAND DOWN! “ 😭 *defendants soul leaves body* lol judge Milian mastered the art of putting fear in people.
Let's keep it real... Byrd would be escorting her out of the courtroom as soon as she started disrespecting Judy!
Judge Judy is a disrespectful little person.
@@nBasedAce Yeah, but she gets paid too.
@@34stzoo Exactly what I was thinking. Screw Nicki Minaj, I wanna be mistaken for JJ. That woman is a boss and her earnings (due to her brains) show it!
@@nBasedAce and so is this bx5ch of a judge
Judge Joe Brown would've humiliated her to tears.
How you fly but can't afford to buy a speaker.....all she gonna do is put it next to her air mattress
She said she didnt ask her to buy them, she wanted to go buy them herself... but before that she said she told the plaintiff that she could go with her to buy them or give the money to go buy them.. 🤔
My exact thoughts it’s apart of the manipulation to get something for nothing🤨🤨 Twisted thinking..It’s just that simple … 💵 +🦵🏾+🚙+🏬 + 📢 +😃+💃🏾 There should only be 2 people involved when making a purchase You and the merchant..
THANK YOU!!! That frustrated me.
I love how Harvey called the defendant an idiot 😂 she was!!
I would have loved to see judge Judy deal with the defendant.
Yikes! This was cringe beyond measure!! The disrespect was through the roof!! Her poor children.
When you are disrespectful to the judge that is contempt and there is a price for that, it doesnt matter how right or wrong your case is you still blew it and you should pay .
Unfortunately, due to this being a TV show she can't legally hold someone in contempt. She explained it in one of those post-interviews with her husband. I wish she could.
@@jenerin905 Yes she can. Judge Mathis does it and it is a REAL court that just happens to be televised.
@@brettsfav4 she explained it was the deal the production company made when People's court was produced many moons ago...
@@brettsfav4 He's not a real judge anymore. None of them are real judges anymore. You have to renew your license to practice law (Judge Mathis let his license go a long time ago), but JJ, Judge Mathis, Judge Millian, etc all retired from actually being a judge to be TV mediators. The money was better. lol But yeah, anyone can be TV mediators (judges)... literally, anyone (even children, the uneducated, etc) can be TV judges.
@@jenerin905 She can't hold anyone for contempt, but she has the ability to reward or punish someone who is contemptuous. It's a mediator show, where she has the ability to make any decision she wants. For some reason, she doesn't punish people like the defendant like she should.
Where’s Judge Mathis when we need him? SMH
She called cps on the plaintiff and she didn't get anything for that? That's ridiculous she should of went to JJ
Please do not walk into court think you are cute! Trust me we all do not! That smile cut off when the judge corrected you too! 🤣🤣
The defendant won't make it far in life with an attitude like that.
She can talk to everyone, respect. You always listen.
I love watching the audience look them up and down when they walk in…
Now I’m watching them 😭
😂😂😂😂
Well they are paid actors, for real.
Lol the lady right behind the defendant cracked me up. She was like um ok... haha
I've seen the Asian woman in pink before and she has the most interesting reactions
I think Judge Milan was WRONG here, she started that attitude and then wanted her to calm down. She disrespected her many times and was yelling at her and continued even when she INITIALLY remained calm.
Thank you!! I am sitting here thinking the same. She calmly asked for judge to not yell at her and Milan got louder?? And then repeated the same question condescendingly when the lady answered multiple times
Yea. I'm surprised more people haven't gotten loud with her. She loud talks people often.
I don't think it's right for the Judge to yell at anyone, have respect and you'll get respect. She raised her hand to speak and Milian yelled at her, uncalled for. These judges think they're Gods.
I do think the plaintiff should have gotten the money for harassment, especially if she had evidence. I wonder why she didn't give it to her smh.
You don't raise your hand in court and posture your head like you'rea little primadonna. Milian grills everyone. Don't come on the show if you don't like that about her. The defendant is a complete loser and needs to seek help. Her ego is far too fragile.
@@coffeepandacat like I said, have respect and you'll get respect.
Just because she grills everyone does that make it right?? Noooo. It's rude and unprofessional, she's a hothead just like the defendant and that day she met her match😊😊
@@coffeepandacat no she said put her hand down. She did. Then she started barking and being condescending like she always does. It would have been worth to 60 dollars to tell that rude judge to kiss my ass. She is boisterous and obnoxious to everybody. People don't have to accept abuse from her crabby ass.
@@coffeepandacat also raising her hand was the respectful way of asking permission to speak. All the judge had to do was say wait. You can raise your hand in court. Posture your head like a prima donna? Smh you sound ignorant.
Defendant--- 0:35 walks in prancing and smiling
Me in my head --defendant lost already 😂😂😂 smh
The defendant thought she was going to get scouted for some kind of ratchet reality tv show. I’m sad she wasn’t thrown out of courtroom much earlier. I also don’t get why the plaintiff didn’t get her harassment! The judge saw the defendant’s behavior first hand.
The JUDGE really has to learn not to yell at people she does that alot smh
Plaintiff and her daughter are both so pretty, gorgeous skin. And for 12 her daughter is very well spoken she acted better then the grown ass defendant
The defendant is pretty too
What does the skin....(got to do with anything!). 🤦♀️
@@elainevankat5353 some people have really nice skin. I agree, I thought the plaintiff and daughter’s skin were fantastic!
@@elainevankat5353 why are you feeling offended lmfao if you wanted a compliment too just say that
@Marilyn Willett since when does complimenting others skin tone make that person “self conscious”? You’re acting as if she said her skin tone was the *only beautiful skin tone in the world.* let people compliment others .. yall have no reason being so hateful.
Most of the comments are about the defendant but The judge started off on 1000. Why was it ok for her to be yelling and raising her voice like that to both the plaintiff and defendant but when she gets that same energy “she is ratchet and acting like she’s in the street”??? That’s crazy. The plaintiff raising her hand 20 times or what ever should not be annoying to a judge. Yeah she thinks she’s better because she is the judge. Period!!! That wasn’t right and I don’t see how anyone could think that’s fair. It’s quite demeaning and belittling regardless of how the defendant looks and acts after the fact.
I was hoping someone else saw that too! I can understand the judge trying to maintain control, but there isn't any reason to be disrespectful. I think that she took one look at the defendant and felt like she could speak to her any kind of way. I felt like she was over the top with her.
@@ellehinkins623 thank you!!! I absolutely agree with you. I was shocked at how hard she was going. She came off so aggressive and dismissive. I guess most people forgot about the beginning and just Harped on the girl when she actually started being rude back but I remember specifically in the case the girl saying “I haven’t even said anything and can you please stop yelling at me”. You act like that with a person you already assume to be ratchet then don’t be surprised when her true colors show lol
I haven’t finished the whole thing so idk if she gets really disrespectful but in the beginning she was only asking JM to not yell at her which I think is definitely reasonable, no adult wants to be talked down on.
I just I mentioned something similar in my comment , The Judge was yelling her to put her hand down . She never said a word the only thing she said was can you stop yelling at me . Then the Judge ask to her to yelling DO YOU UNDERSTAND ME she didn't want to reply because the judge was yelling . Then the Judge said she can yell because she has on a robe . Who disrespecting Who ? The Judge start off wrong only because her hand was up to get the Judge attention . The Judge was embarrassed but her because she asked her to stop yelling on T.V. See people can't stand when you stand up for yourself ! Now they call it disrespect ( SMH )
@@royalcrown7000 exactly!
Whewwwww, I haven't seen a nastier defendant.
Edit: The plaintiff should've gotten compensated for the harassment. Shiiiiiiiiiiit I felt harassed just from watching her behavior. I can't imagine living next to ole girl. I wonder how Judge Mathis or Judge Judy would've handled her🤔
When the plaintiff wasn't explaining clearly why she gave the defendant the speakers, I was thinking it was clear after hearing JM talk to her. She is extremely forceful, disrespectful. and entitled. Yeah, the plaintiff deserved to be compensated for harassment.
Judge Mathis would entertain it
Judge Judy would of kicked her out
Judge Judy would have called her r@tched and kicked her out lol
she would’ve left wigless 😂
The defendant is so rude, nasty and disrespectful. The judge should've thrown her out much earlier. I've worked with people like the defendant. All they do is lie and create problems. I can't stand people like the defendant.
I’m willing to bet the farm she’s lost a few cases as well as friends and husbands. I hope her kids don’t get abused by her as well.
The plantif did say she didn't like how the crazy woman treated her own kids. So I'm sure they catch a lot more abuse than other people in her life.
She needs some serious help!
Less than half way through the defendant talking and I think to myself, “she’s Nikki Minaj from Wish” when she said they made fun of her for exactly that, I cracked up. 😅
When the defendant said congratulations it reminded me of when Joseline told Nina Parker congratulations when she said she has a degree in journalism 😂😂😂
😂😂
I’m not Mimi the Maid, Stebie. You gonna respect the Puerto Rican Princess! 🤣
How random to see a reference to Love and Hip Hop Atlanta listed here.
People like the defendant I seriously run away from all about self and egotistical
I would've gave that lady what she asked for because being a bully and being loud scared this lady I can tell that poor lady ain't no hood chick like her smh
The fact she didn’t give her the
harassment after the way she acted in court is crazy
The Judge is one of a kind bc none of the other judges on TV would allow it
The defendant waddled in there like she was auditioning for miss black hoochie koochie. She needs to get over herself.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😫
A false CPS case definitely warrants harassment. How do you ask her if she can relocate and state “we have to have peace where we live for our kids”
Give her the 3k so she can afford to relocate. The defendant is at shit crazy.
I totally see the “tryin’ to be like Nicki Minaj”.
Exactly.
I think a blind man could see it tbh
I knew the defendant was crazy immediately I saw her walk into the court room smiling like an idiot...if I were the judge I will make her pay every penny even for harassment. What nansense.
The defendant is beyond ratchet; she needs to be on a Desperate Housewives show!
More like Ghetto Single Mothers show
@@elizabethg0809 when did they mention she was a single mother?
@@elizabethg0809 racist much
@@elizabethg0809 exactly 9 times out of 10 she’s never been married as ignorant as she is
@@dawniipoo322 You must not live in the States, because "Ghetto" isn't exclusive to only Black People. LOL
This woman is horrible. The judge should’ve kicked her out and awarded that lady everything she asked for
Probably one of the rudest defendants I have seen! I expected her to be kicked out much sooner she acted like she was ready to fight the judge. I wouldn’t want her as a neighbor either. This is why I can’t be friendly with neighbors much because you don’t know what type of foolishness they may be on and like the judge says I have to have peace where I lay.
She didn't award the 3k for the plaintiffs safety. That's why she asked would she be able to move before saying it (and note the sad look the judge had on her face, her whole tone changed at that point). That 3k would've ruined the plaintiffs life with that crazy defendant constantly harassing and maybe even turning violent on her.
The defendant walked in like she thought she was a model walking down a runway. She clearly thinks she's hot stuff and above everyone else. She needs to get over herself.
Wow...I had to rewind to see what you mean, but wow, this defendant definitely came to get her moment on TV. But she acted such a fool, I don't know what she thought she was accomplishing!
Yes,she obviously thinks highly of herself 😱 Ma'am, Nicki Minaj You Are NOT!!!
Just goes to prove that beauty is only skin deep, she is one ugly human on the inside.
And no, I didn't find her all that attractive.
Oh gosh..I had the same thoughts...she was beaming away with no remorse. I had jealous nasty bully neighbors who did not want me to work and live in peace. More I ignored them more provoking they resorted to...what were they teaching their own children?!
She reminds me of one of those pom pom dogs where their hair covers their eyes lol
pups dying of laughter everytime they panned over to the Defendent just to see and empty box as if they were expecting her to interrupt!!! 😂
She lucky she wasnt on JUDGE MATHIS. He would have went clean TF OFF n called her a CRACKHEAD. Claim DISMISSED for PERJURY……
Lmfao !! Definitely crackhead for acting like that 😭 he don’t play
The defendant thinks she should never be told "no."
12:58 This crap I don't understand? I always refer back to the case where a limousine driver showed up late to take a couple to a ferry so they can attend the wedding reception. Outside of the Bride setting everything up not giving enough time to take into account any mishap before the ferry departed. The limousine company refund all their money and tried to make things right with the couple, owning up to everything! The Bride decided to sue for 5K for emotional distress for ruining their wedding reception. The Judge awarded 5K for emotional distress and breach of contract! I was like WTF! The company screwed up and tried to make things right. It wasn't a malicious act and they owned up to it. But for someone calling CPS on you to get back at you doesn't warrant or reach the level of emotional distress and harassment in her book? I wish could meet her in person and ask, why?
100% agree
I agree with this. Defendant was way out of line.
I think in this case, the judge wasn't able to get down to the facts of what happened. The whole explanation of my daughter convinced me was kind of sketchy. So yes the defendant is out of line but who's to say the plaintiff also isn't antagonistic to a degree but just knows how to comport herself in a courtroom.
@@christianfernandez91 I was thinking the same thing. The plaintiff looks like the stereotypical "quiet, causes no trouble with anybody" in front of authority figures but behind closed doors she raises hell
In the limo case, you're talking about a couple who pays a premium (wedding services pay extra just when the word wedding is used for premium service) for a once in a lifetime (hopefully) event. They were cut hours short for their event and the other things they paid for weren't up to the standard they paid for due to them being late... Because of the limo company.
I do agree though that a harassment settlement was absolutely needed in this case, but the plaintiff needed to keep better records of it. Dates CPS showed up, any inconveniences due to that, anytime the defendant was loud and unruly, and so on. Just the defendant's attitude in court should have proven how hard it is to live around her.
You can tell that the defendant comes from a place where you don't talk like that without risking an ass beating.
I agree with JM. The plaintiff caused way too much trouble by agreeing to give the defendant the speakers. Plus, the defendant was way out of line. “You’re not gonna keep yelling at me”?! Oh yeah, ✌🏽defendant.
I truly believe the plaintiff is afraid of the defendant.
The defendant should have been dismissed since 14:47. I absolutely believe the plaintiff about the harassment and she should have been granted that $3000 as well. When they get back home I’m sure she’s going to have an even harder time living around her.
A judge can’t yell and attempt to belittle grown adults and expect them not to feel offended.
Thank you ... Thank you .. thank you ... Finally a comment that makes good sense
She does it and its not okay. She puts people down and that's not okay. If she keeps it up, she may want to consider a security detail. Most people aren't okay with being denigrated on national television.
Actually, I'm surprised Judge Milian yelled at her. She is usually respectful. I'm not giving her excuses, but I guess she was in a mood. The meanest Judge on TV is still Judge Judy. She always have an attitude and yells all the time. She is always snotty to people whether they're polite or not. If she catches someone in a lie, she gets really pissed. She doesn't care what others think. I guess that's why people love Judge Judy. I still watch her lol.
The defendant’s attitude was gross to begin with
The defendant is the pure and complete definition of what getto is
I think "Ratchet" is more appropriate, because you can be Ghetto but still Respectful at the same time.
you got to spell it correctly first for me to take you seriously...she is not ghetto, she just gave JM the same energy she gave her.
Nah that ain’t ghetto, that bih a demon!!! Straight demonic
@@saraijuelz1564 you sound ridiculous right now! Man change now!
Wearing a wig like Nicky Minaj does not mean you look like Nicky. , her friends were gassing her up 😂😂😂😂😂
Wow i can’t even deal with this broad . The plaintiff clearly felt threatened by this chic that’s why she gave her the speaker.
Also, based on the defendant’s nasty attitude, she definitely deserves the harassment. I believe she bullies that lady at this point 😩
The defendant walks in like 'All Hail The Queen!', someone thinks highly of themselves!
She lied on at least two fronts, that she could ever have respect for anyone, and that anyone could be her friend ... like cozying up to a viper!!
The defendant got lucky Judge Milian was lenient with her behavior. Over talking, she swore("grown ass woman"),...... she definitely came in on a high horse.
Smack talking like that rages me!!!! Who raised that woman to be so nasty
A judge sets the tone in the courtroom. Milian makes a practice of mishandling and berating/yelling right out of the gate. These are adults. Your degree and position do not give you the right to disrespect litigants just as my teaching degree doesn’t justify me mishandling students. Do better, Judge, and better will be reciprocated. I applaud the defendant for demanding she be dealt with, with dignity.
The lady in the black dress makes the rules. I thought everybody knew that?
To an egomaniac they think they're the one's that are never wrong. Her attitude sucks and I believe she did try to rip off that girl. her attitude says it all
Not if you never finished the 3rd Grade.
@@janetcupp467 Oh I don't doubt that at ALL. Egomaniacs always think they can treat people how they want and get away with it. Well, (to misquote the kids today) she fooled around and found out!
Defendant upon entering the courtroom:😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈