Pre-recorded Anthony over his casket: "So that was my life. Didja love it? Didja hate it? What wouldja rate it? Deadthony Stifftano, mortality, forever."
I can’t believe Weezer was above Weezer. Along with that, Weezer was much better than Weezer! I also think that Weezer should have been below Weezer, it just doesn’t stand up to Weezer.
Weezer was better than Weezer. Both are great albums, but Weezer just wins it by an inch. Weezer was okay, Weezer is underrated, and Weezer is probably one of the worst Weezer album Weezer has made.
The best review of Weezer's Black Album that I ever read went like this: "I think somewhere around the 47th straight time that I stick my finger into a running blender and it clips a fingertip off, I shouldn't be allowed to be mad at the blender anymore. All it's doing is existing and here I am, trying to jam my finger into it"
@@ralphenstein9105 If you're careful you can make sure you only cut about 1/5 of your finger off at a time. That way you can do it over and over again.
@@user-ln5yo4ir9v I'm confused I listen to Death Grips, I like the group, but I've never heard of the fake fans. It makes sense they would exist just statistically but I don't really know what you are referring to or implying.
drakethepoet yeah there’s a meme about Anthony being a racist and the humour comes from everyone knowing he’s not and that he’s a good guy. The joke’s kind of overused by now though
As someone who is not a regular viewer of this channel and not into the TH-cam music review community, this comment section confuses me profusely but I guess keep at it, my guys
Most of these aren’t even albums by Weezer (most of these aren’t even ACTUAL albums), and Blue isn’t even made in 1971. And Raditude #1??? ARE YOU SERIOUS?!?!?
Weezer feels like a kid who has good friends but isn’t popular so he keeps pushing his old friends away to become friends with the cool kids but ends up being left out every time.
@@sirsquilliam0 More like the dude who started out as rad and being a rebel, to trying to be cool 10 years after their success later. But they can be good sometimes.
pinkerton was basically the album that resulted after river’s original sophomore album concept, “songs from the black hole” was abandoned. it was supposed to be a space-themed rock opera, but was scrapped after bassist matt sharp released his “return of the rentals” album which stole/borrowed/shared(?) the album’s intended moog/synth-heavy aesthetic. so instead rivers wrote the raw and stripped down pinkerton, in some cases reworking material originally intended for SFTBH. most of the demos of SFTBH have since been released and fans have been able to reconstruct what would’ve been. the album was more musically light-hearted and would’ve had a cleaner production quality, plus a gimmicky, yet creative concept that would have lent itself well to promotion and cheeky music videos. had that album been released instead of pinkerton i think the band’s popularity from the blue album would have continued to grow instead of falling off a cliff, and the trajectory of their career would’ve been drastically different. i can’t help but imagine THAT alternate history.
@@hullabaloobird I kept reading SFTBH as Soundtracks For The Blind and now I can’t help but imagine Weezer releasing Blue to critical and commercial acclaim, and then releasing SFTB instead of pinkerton, it getting the exact same treatment as pinkerton did, and the rest of their albums being the same funny thought
It's really a shame the reaction to Pinkerton was bad initially, imagine where they'd be now if it had been well received? I would love to have seen Weezer go full gritty emo. Imagine a full album of stuff like their cover of Velouria - could have been awesome.
The poor reception of Pinkerton is ultimately what made Weezer over correct with their blandest album "green" where the only song i give a shit about is "island in the sun". It's a shame cause i do think Pinkerton was their best album imo and it be cool to see them continue with that sound but sadly things did not turn out that way.
I like Pinkerton alot but after a while you really want to turn on something else, I honestly would love if Weezer went in the Everything will be Alright in the End, Blue Album White Album direction, those albums to me are great to listen to and I honestly never get me bored as I would with Pinkerton sometimes
My personal top 5 Weezer songs: 1) Smells like teen spirit - NirWeezer 2) Teenage Dirtbag - Weezer Weezer 3) Burn The House Down - AWeezerR 4) Stressed Out - Twenty One Weezer’s 5) Pumped Up Kicks - Foster The Weezer
Shame with the Black Album. They should have gone full on black metal or at least something like Motörhead but with Rivers not trying too hard and not taking himself seriously.
Right? I feel like Rivers has his bag by now, if us fans aren’t going to ever be satisfied by anything but Blue Album 2 they should totally just be going nuts
Much as I adore Buddy Holly, My Name is Jonas is one hell of an opening track. It's the "still making noise, making noise" bit that gets me every time.
@@conansmith5164 we all will. We're all slowly dying. Life is a lie. Thanksgiving was about killing Indians. We're all just waiting for our inevitable death. Also pinkertons better then blue album.
I think he will put it 4th in between EWBAITE and White. In the review he said it was at least as good as the white album so he may possibly put it 3rd.
Yeah Blue is one of those rare moments in rock where the first album is perfect and instantly classic. Every song on that album holds up to this day. Every one. And that in itself is rare. They've been chasing that perfection ever since. Do a Jimmy Eat World best to worst.
Blue is the 2nd album I ever owned, the 1st being Primus - Tales from the Punchbowl. I still consider it flawless, the buildup towards the end of Only in Dreams still gives me goosebumps.
He did Angel and The One so dirty. Also he put green way too high, especially for someone who criticizes them for being too bland. Nice to see White and Hurley get some love though.
Definitely, AaTO is one of my favorite Weezer songs. Really nice to see EWBAITE and White where they are though. Your hunger games video you just released was absolutely hilarious though btw lol.
Angel and the One is kinda boring. Also green is very enjoyable for it's short length, Glorious Day and Island in the Sun are some of my favorite songs from the 2000s
Worst to Best: The Strokes Jay-Z The Beatles The Roots John Coltrane (pretty ambitious) System of a Down Arcade Fire Also: Mastadon RHCP Stevie Wonder (again ambitious) Interpol A Tribe Called Quest
Contrary to Anthony’s opinion I actually love the album cover. I thought it was hilarious when it came out. But, I bet anyone who didn’t watch LOST didn’t appreciate it on the same level
@@tylerhathaway9525 I've watched lost, but the cover really makes my will to listen to the album fade. It's almost like weezer tried too hard to look funny and goofy and quirky and chose to use the most stupid Hurley picture they could as the cover for the album.
And I bet Anthony's will get more views within one day. It makes me a little sad as much as I love Melon that the moment he releases anything, whether it be a review, worst to best, track review, etc, it immediately puts a massive shadow over the backs of anyone else doing the same thing.
@@lvndrr_dashboard yeah I'm not big on artv just saying. :) I've personally dealt with a lot of view struggle when I put out a review that Anthony's done / going to do. Nothing wrong with that, though!
@@TheMetalTempestYT Anthony is the most popular music reviewer on the site for a reason, if someone else doesn't get as much attention for a similar video it's not Anthony's fault 😂
13: Pacific Daydream 12: Make Believe 11: Raditude 10: Black 9: Teal 8: Red 7: Hurley 6: Green 5: Maladroit 4: Everything Will Be Alright in The End 3: White 2: Pinkerton 1: Blue
I don't know Fantwan... spending 20 minutes to push your Rivers is Kurt theory? Then giving the top spot to "In Utero" when "Nevermind" is clearly the better Weezer album... And giving TPAB #3? You dropped the ball on this one :(
Now that I think about it even Pinkerton was greeted with disappointment by fans. So literally every album Rivers came out with after Blue has been greeted with a negative reaction with the exception of maybe White and EWBAITE. So I can see why he’d want to rebel against his own audience. They were dead wrong about Pinkerton so maybe he thought we were dead wrong about all the other records.
I’d say there was a SHARP withdrawal of vulnerability after the backlash to Pinkerton. Coupled with a defensiveness and imo a certain blindness. The podcast Bandsplain does a great Weezer episode that goes into this
My opinion: 1. The Black Album 2. The Blueprint 3. In My Lifetime, Vol. 1 4. Roc La Familia: The Dynasty 5. Reasonable Doubt 6. 4:44 7. Watch the Throne 8. Collision Course 9. Vol 2... Hard Knock Life 10. The Blueprint 2 11. Vol 3: The Life and Times of S. Carter I haven’t heard the others
Taha Kamran Kanye only produced like 3 songs on the Blueprint and the best songs on the Black Album aren’t even Kanye produced. Kanye did not carry the Blueprint or Black Album.
So... I met my wife at a Weezer concert between Pinkerton and the green album. I’ve always felt like they were a special band because of that... but Make Believe was the last album I bought. I did go back and listen to some of their stuff last year, but the only things that stood out to me were the parts you talked about on Everything Will Be Alright in the End. I’ve made peace with the fact that I am a cliche and continue to listen to the first two albums and various tracks off of other albums.
I've decided over the last couple weeks of listening to both Hurley & Raditude a lot that Raditude is decidedly better than Hurley, and in fact Raditude's positives are so high that it must be purchased. (If You're Wondering if I Want You To) I Want You To alone was a high spot for Weezer's entire discography, but then after listening to the album for the first time in many years, I almost picked up on both I Don't Want To Let You Go, and Put Me Back Together and now I'm embarrassed I didn't pick them out the first time I listened to the album. I Don't Want To Let You Go is now one of my very favorite Weezer songs ever. To be fair, I don't like songs like Girl Got Hot, I'm Your Daddy, and Can't Stop Partying, they represent the lowest common denominator of Weezer songs, just like most drug-related songs from other albums like Hash Pipe, Dope Nose, (the exception being White's Do You Want To Get High? which is amazing) and others as well as Beverly Hills. But like I said before, the high points of the album make it decidedly better than Hurley or the Black album IMO. For me the list looks something like: 1: Blue/OK Human 3: White 4: Pinkerton ... ... Last: Black (Would have been Hurley if Black had included what was supposed to be their lead single for the album, Midnight (Cardigan Disaster))
Almost every single song on green has the EXACT same formula. The song starts with the a guitar solo that is playing the lyrics to the bridge. Then verse chorus verse chorus bridge, guitar solo that is playing the lyrics to the verse, chorus, ends on a verse
I felt the mixing in Pinkerton was way better. It doesnt feel "rough" to me and it has a lot more dynamic moments to me than in Blue, IE Across The Sea. Only in dreams is like a preview into whats to come with Pinkerton.
The main difference to me is the drum sound. The drums on Blue sound great, but a little dry and polite. On the other hand the drums on Pinkerton hit you like a fucking brick wall of intensity
the really fantastic songs on daydream, teal, and black give me hope that rivers and the gang can put out another perfect album that appreciates their early successes but also fleshes out their current pop trajectory. it might not happen until 2025 but you best believe i’ll still be around to appreciate it.
Pre-recorded Anthony over his casket: "So that was my life. Didja love it? Didja hate it? What wouldja rate it? Deadthony Stifftano, mortality, forever."
LMAO
You're the best you're the best, what should I reincarnate as next
Melon: Trans-
Melon's ghost: ition!
@@harrylane4 damn you beat me to it!
Dies : Tran
Heaven: sition
I can’t believe Weezer was above Weezer. Along with that, Weezer was much better than Weezer! I also think that Weezer should have been below Weezer, it just doesn’t stand up to Weezer.
you smoking bruh, weezer is great, weezer is hella overrated
Nah Weezer beats Weezer by milessssss
Dude ya forgot Weezer
Your all forgetting the underrated classic weezer
Weezer was better than Weezer. Both are great albums, but Weezer just wins it by an inch. Weezer was okay, Weezer is underrated, and Weezer is probably one of the worst Weezer album Weezer has made.
SPOILER: FULL LIST
1. Raditude
2. Make Believe
3. Weezer (The Pink Abum)
4. The Bends
5. DAMN.
6. New Calassic
7. Raditude
8. Pacific Daydreaming
9. Lil Pump Mixtape
10. Weezer
11. Weezer
12. Raditude Deluxe
13. MBDTF
14. Pinkerton
Should’ve put me at six and DAMN. At 7
Raditude Deluxe 🤣
bro ¤_¤ I'm dying lmao
@@MyBeautifulDarkTwistedFantasy6 Hi My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
@@NMY399 Bring down the government, they don’t, they don’t speak for us…
I did not expect you to give all their albums a 10
Ethan TPAB
Anthony told me to my face that Blue is a 10, not that it's an """"official"""" 10 tho
Bet you didn’t expect him to give your profile pic a 6 either :(
overrated comment
lol it's funny cos he didn't
The best review of Weezer's Black Album that I ever read went like this:
"I think somewhere around the 47th straight time that I stick my finger into a running blender and it clips a fingertip off, I shouldn't be allowed to be mad at the blender anymore. All it's doing is existing and here I am, trying to jam my finger into it"
Surely, you can't do that more than 10 times, can you?
@@ralphenstein9105 If you're careful you can make sure you only cut about 1/5 of your finger off at a time. That way you can do it over and over again.
@@Peter-sn2wg ok thanks ive been doing it wrong
Is the album the blender or the finger?
@@ballsackdave3897 the album is how many times you've done it, weezer is the blender, and you are the finger.
yes Anthony we know "Beverly Hills" is the best Weezer song, you didn't need to repeat it 4 tmes.
It's a banger tho
Kek Jong un your joking right
that's where I want to bey
I like it ngl
Its a meh of a song
Why is melon talking about raditude, classic week isnt for months
*Ratitude
Bro idfk maybe he forgot how to read a calendar
I had the same question
He was wondering if we wanted him to, and was pretty sure we said, “We want you to.”
...what
Weezer has a more BDSM relationship with their fans than Death Grips.
station27000 its the opposite of death grips, we let DG fuck us up, but weezer lets the fans fuck them up
@@deathhzrd Death grips probably hate their fucking retarded fake "fans"
What is a death grip
@@smlfan0072 it's a
@@user-ln5yo4ir9v I'm confused I listen to Death Grips, I like the group, but I've never heard of the fake fans. It makes sense they would exist just statistically but I don't really know what you are referring to or implying.
*Weezer Songs Worst to Best*
1. Teenage Dirtbag
The More You Know C’mon man... Teenage Dirtbag was written by the band Ween.
FamousByFriday k
No it was written by tom waits
this comment is killing me because i used to think Teenage Dirtbag was made by weezer lmao
Wheatus is terrible but... C'mon that song slaps
My mom's boyfriends worst to best melonnn!!!
Bro Jared from Subway is #1 for sure, he always brought those kids over to play with you.
5. Dylan
4. Cole
3.Devon
2. Tyrone
1.Muhammad
not to be racist, but 1-Your Uncle
you know he’d put himself first, classic melon move
not to be racist, but I’m sure Father’s Day is the most confusing holiday to you
I know Rivers is asthmatic but you don't have to call the band weezer
Yeah the true name is weerez
zerwee
Idon'tevenknow Do you watch Billy Cobb?
@@Mr__Joe ye
Cool. Me too
“I didn’t like the black album because I don’t like black people” isn’t a review Anthony
Isn’t he married to a black woman?
drakethepoet yeah there’s a meme about Anthony being a racist and the humour comes from everyone knowing he’s not and that he’s a good guy. The joke’s kind of overused by now though
@@gavinj1456 oh. Ok. did not know.
@@gavinj1456 the joke should’ve ended when media outlets tried to actually call him alt right
@@murdock9916 that didn’t really happen much, especially because he’s a very leftist youtuber
As someone who is not a regular viewer of this channel and not into the TH-cam music review community, this comment section confuses me profusely but I guess keep at it, my guys
It is a mix of the most immature and mature people out there, and is amazing.
Cool comment but when you said we need to round up all the melons and put them in camps I thought that may have been crossing the line a tad.
Cory Thompson Sir that was absolutely unacceptable! 😡
Cory Thompson oh Cory how could I stay mad at you 😍☺️
To be honest this was my exact reaction upon entering the r/weezer community
Can't wait to get the "Best of Weezer" box set where it's just 13 copies of the Blue Album.
I also read The Hard Times
Alex Metcalf how many times did he say “this is the worst song in their discography” 2? 3? 4? LUL
They can call it “The Gold Album”
mmm nice stolen joke
Nah it’s just the box
Literally everyone: BEATLES BEST TO WORST
fantano: aight I heard weezer
You heard Beatles when everyone really saying Pink Floyd
@@AWMK101 pink floyd is a real weird way to spell david bowie
FlaviusBelisarius Hey I’d love either!
are you sure they're not saying Queen?
Digression Media Sadly no... as much great music as queen has, the majority of their discography is pretty bad tbh
If you want to destroy my flannel
Hold this meme as I walk away
Hold this melon
If you want to destroy my street cred/ post this meme as I mock a gay
I'm glad to see that raditude is your favorite weezer record
I agree with the list, but you didn't have to knock Pinkerton down a spot just because Pink Triangle is about gay people.
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
I'm glad someone made that song though cause it really resonates with some people, like me.
@@DanteToska Palutena Reflect/Up Smash=BOSS!
@@yellowwwig9631 a TH-cam classic B)
Where is this joke from lmao
Raditude at number 1 is the best plot twist I've ever seen
Vinicius Castro number 1...twice...cuz it’s an 11
Here's the list
13. Pacific Daydream (2017)
12. Make Believe (2005)
11. Blue (1971)
10. Dookie (1994)
9. Songs From the Forthcoming "Maladriot" (2002)
8. Annoying Orange - Wazzup 3: Bonzai Tree (2010)
7. Hurley (2010)
6. Cars 2 Soundtrack (2011)
5. Christmas CD (2000)
4. Christmas with Weezer (2008)
3. Pinkerton (1996)
2. Lil' Weezer & Friends [The Green Mixtape] (2009)
1. Raditude (2009)
jrctennis23 Ratitude is a personal favorite of mine!!!!!
Most of these aren’t even albums by Weezer (most of these aren’t even ACTUAL albums), and Blue isn’t even made in 1971. And Raditude #1??? ARE YOU SERIOUS?!?!?
free memes he’s having some fun. 🙄 you should try it
you forgot DAMN.
free memes r/whoosh
Here’s my ranking of all of weezer’s weezer albums
7. Weezer
6. Weezer
5. Weezer
4. Weezer
3. Weezer
2. Weezer
1. Weezer
How the fuck is Weezer better than Weezer, Weezer had so many good tracks but Weezer was way more hit or miss
Fuck you , if you can’t understand why the master piece weezer shouldn’t be above “weezer” than you don’t deserve ears
Insightful.
What?? I never heard of Weezer
1.Pinkerton
Anthony, I was surprised to see the Teal album at number one! Your logic behind it really convinced me that this is indeed the best album of all time!
Are you colourblind?
What drugs?
I mean, every song on it is a classic so there you go
Look...
@@g-wiz154 its a joke LOL
Anthony this is clickbait. You ranked every bit of music ever except for Weezer.
Weezer feels like a kid who has good friends but isn’t popular so he keeps pushing his old friends away to become friends with the cool kids but ends up being left out every time.
@@sirsquilliam0 More like the dude who started out as rad and being a rebel, to trying to be cool 10 years after their success later. But they can be good sometimes.
It's so accurate because what you mentioned is a movie cliché... And that's what Weezer's music is now, a cliché
Dang this is to relatable
do u watch that one tf2 youtuber who had a wind waker pfp who had that one song off pinkerton his name was smth like funky or funke
hey nice pfp lollol
My grandmother called she wants her shirt back
my grandmother is dead
CHEERIO KING sorry to hear that.
Her curtains actually
@@yungctrlfreakhaha
I can only imagine if Pinkerton got a better reception would it have changed how Weezer make music today
Like think about that
pinkerton was basically the album that resulted after river’s original sophomore album concept, “songs from the black hole” was abandoned. it was supposed to be a space-themed rock opera, but was scrapped after bassist matt sharp released his “return of the rentals” album which stole/borrowed/shared(?) the album’s intended moog/synth-heavy aesthetic. so instead rivers wrote the raw and stripped down pinkerton, in some cases reworking material originally intended for SFTBH. most of the demos of SFTBH have since been released and fans have been able to reconstruct what would’ve been. the album was more musically light-hearted and would’ve had a cleaner production quality, plus a gimmicky, yet creative concept that would have lent itself well to promotion and cheeky music videos. had that album been released instead of pinkerton i think the band’s popularity from the blue album would have continued to grow instead of falling off a cliff, and the trajectory of their career would’ve been drastically different. i can’t help but imagine THAT alternate history.
I wish I could visit that alternate universe just to take a look (and a listen) and see how things went
Can I live in the world where pinkerton was considered the amazing album it was immediately?
@@hullabaloobird I kept reading SFTBH as Soundtracks For The Blind and now I can’t help but imagine Weezer releasing Blue to critical and commercial acclaim, and then releasing SFTB instead of pinkerton, it getting the exact same treatment as pinkerton did, and the rest of their albums being the same
funny thought
There’s not many guys that can pull off a shirt like that. You can’t either, but I applaud you for trying.
HAHAHAHHAHAHA NOOOOOO
This is genuinely such a good insult I am definitely going to remember to use this eventually
he could pull it off if he wasn’t so fucking pale
This comment needs more likes 💀😭
Anthony looks surprisingly good in it
I can agree with most of the rankings but I don’t think you were very subtle placing the Black album at #13 and the White album at #1 melon.
Francisthony Galtontano
It's really a shame the reaction to Pinkerton was bad initially, imagine where they'd be now if it had been well received? I would love to have seen Weezer go full gritty emo. Imagine a full album of stuff like their cover of Velouria - could have been awesome.
The poor reception of Pinkerton is ultimately what made Weezer over correct with their blandest album "green" where the only song i give a shit about is "island in the sun". It's a shame cause i do think Pinkerton was their best album imo and it be cool to see them continue with that sound but sadly things did not turn out that way.
This idiot would have said Pinkerton was garbage too back then. Close minded critics. I always knew it was their best.
I like Pinkerton alot but after a while you really want to turn on something else, I honestly would love if Weezer went in the Everything will be Alright in the End, Blue Album White Album direction, those albums to me are great to listen to and I honestly never get me bored as I would with Pinkerton sometimes
@@nopenope4183 green was good
Teague Ricks I agree
The quality of Weezer albums seems to weirdly mirror the trajectory of happiness in my life
I feel bad for your mental health.
good 2016?
followed by an immediate dip?
Not sure I like the idea of a human in the Raditude phase of life. Sounds insane
I've been in a Raditude phase. Not fun. Maladroit phase is the best
My personal top 5 Weezer songs:
1) Smells like teen spirit - NirWeezer
2) Teenage Dirtbag - Weezer Weezer
3) Burn The House Down - AWeezerR
4) Stressed Out - Twenty One Weezer’s
5) Pumped Up Kicks - Foster The Weezer
"Foster the Weez"
Don't forget "Basket case" by Green Weezer, and "Here Comes The Sun" by The Weasels.
and also "creep" by Weeziohead.
*Tweetus
you forgot "everlong" by the Foo Weezers
Weezer is like the Sonic the Hedgehog of the music world
White is like Sonic Generations
What would Sonic 06 be?
@@derekrequiem4359 Raditude
@@moralambiguo3708 Why does everyone always ignore Put Me Back Together and Let It All Hang Out? Those songs are quite underrated.
Shadow the Hedgehog is Raditude
Runs out of colors :
Weezer : oh no
"Fuck it, we are going with numbers now
Weezer: The 14th album"
no wonder the cover art for latest Weezer tracks (which reeks of "graphics design is my passion" meme so badly) is titled "Van Weezer" lol
@@lnlonelyness6021 the singles slap don’t @ me
@@tpags7398 well yeah they do, like I said it's like Hurley: decent to good tracks, fucking atrocious cover art
@@lnlonelyness6021 I’d argue the songs are too tier weezer
Shame with the Black Album. They should have gone full on black metal or at least something like Motörhead but with Rivers not trying too hard and not taking himself seriously.
dÆdrÆm scrÆm - full-on black metal would’ve been amazing
At their level of success, it seems like they would be more comfortable taking risks in music genres.
dÆdrÆm scrÆm - or just keep making pop/rock and making millions of dollars.
Right? I feel like Rivers has his bag by now, if us fans aren’t going to ever be satisfied by anything but Blue Album 2 they should totally just be going nuts
LordLucario99 EXACTLY! They should be doing polka albums by now! 😄
Looking at that album cover, I totally forgot that melon was the 5th member of weezer.
Their best album is definitely their crossover with Ween, "Weener."
I’m wheezing right now thinking about your big strong hands on my body!!!😫😫😫
Dude 😂😂😂
*thicc vegan hands
Damn, that sounds HOT!
Heheheheheheheheh, wEeZiNg
Now THAT is HOT!
Much as I adore Buddy Holly, My Name is Jonas is one hell of an opening track. It's the "still making noise, making noise" bit that gets me every time.
tell me what to do, now the tank is dry. now this wheel is flat, A N D Y O U K N O W W H A T E L S E ? ! ? !
My Name is Jonas is probably one of the best opening tracks ever.
BigBird Music IN THE MAIL TODAY
I fucking love my name is Jonas. It's fantastic.
why did I just watch a guy say "I love raditute" for 31 minutes
Raditoot
Im weezing because of my smoking addiction. Rate that antonio
LOL
I'm koffing bc of all of the second hand smoke, please stop for your own good
Light 5
@@conansmith5164 we all will. We're all slowly dying. Life is a lie. Thanksgiving was about killing Indians. We're all just waiting for our inevitable death. Also pinkertons better then blue album.
Why the hell is the Black album last while the White album is the best?
What are you trying to insinuate here?
Black album sucks, that's why. It's boring and mundane. White has a concept, really great songs and awesome production.
@@jones1749 r/woooosh
I love when people get all “ACksHUaLlyYYyy” on meme comments lol I swear to god no one is more annoying than 90s alt rock band fanboys
@@skypie3000 r/woooosh
Ellis Frank Gee thanks Ellis, now we know guys.
It's great to see that your favorite Weezer album is Pacific Daydream too!
how u gonna mention blue album and not bring up The World Has Turned And Left Me Here
with ease
@@loopskratch6065 whaddya mean thas a great song
Everytime the bassline starts I can hear Kim Deal singing Gigantic
One of the weaker track on Blue imo
Or Holiday
Pink Floyd Worst to Best Melonhead!!
I'd definitely would be interested in watching that
Glitzy Guy piper is just sgt. peppers but they took more LSD
Beat me to it, make it happen!
My Top 5 would be..
1. Wish You Were Here
2. Animals
3. The Dark Side of the Moon
4. The Wall
5. Meddle
Yesss please fuck
Anthony is so behind the times, he hasn’t even included OK Human on this list!!!
Yes I was very dissapointed
He's letting it sink, when he's ready to rank it he'll update this video
I think he will put it 4th in between EWBAITE and White. In the review he said it was at least as good as the white album so he may possibly put it 3rd.
YOU IDIOT CHECK THE UPLOAD DATE
@@marek419 it was a joke.
Yeah Blue is one of those rare moments in rock where the first album is perfect and instantly classic. Every song on that album holds up to this day. Every one. And that in itself is rare. They've been chasing that perfection ever since.
Do a Jimmy Eat World best to worst.
Definetely Maybe.
Definitely maybe
In The Court Of The Crimson King
100% true
Take This To Your Grave
My Weezer ranking:
5. Everything Now
4. Refelktor
3. Neon Bible
2. Funeral
1. The Suburbs
Nice arcade.fire album ranking
This made me laugh harder than it should have.
the suburbs < neon bible > funeral > reflektor > everything now
Melon Bible Melon Bible not much chance for survival if the Melon Bible is right
@@musicman6555 lmao hahahah
"there's nothing stopping the band from writing another my name is jonas, but they most likely never will put out another only in dreams"
Exactly.
He said “WORSThony BESTtano here,” but the words on screen said “BESThony WORSTano.”
wow youre so smart bravo
He might be planning to do another worst to best later on in the year and wants to do another intro for that one
How bout that "as" he corrected in post.
You have the eyes of an eagle...
*ding*
HE ACTUALLY DID IT! THE ABSOLUTE MAD LAD
Blue is the 2nd album I ever owned, the 1st being Primus - Tales from the Punchbowl. I still consider it flawless, the buildup towards the end of Only in Dreams still gives me goosebumps.
Here’s Melons ranking
13. Pacific Daydream
12. Make Believe
11. Ratitude
10. Weezer (Black Album)
9. Weezer (Teal Album)
8. Weezer(Red Album)
7. Hurley
6. Weezer (Green Album)
5. Maladroit
4. Everything will be alright in the end
3. Weezer (White Album)
2. Pinkerton
1. Weezer (Blue Album)
beeneylord you lied to me
Thx for saving me a half hr
He forgot the Christmas ep and death to false metal
@@emeraldpotato3050 No he didn't. He even said he was only including studio albums
aka the wrong one
Pixies worst to best would be awesome
Bossanova number one or we riot.
Oh dude easy peasy
Bossanova
Trompe le monde
Surfer Rosa
Doolittle
Come on Pilgrim
Headcarrier
Indy Cindy
Calling it now
@@mrxmenguy no Doolittle is by far the best
Bossanova is Antny's favourite, I'm pretty sure he's said it before
Palms especially since they’re now touring with Weezer again.
I ironically like Beverly Hills. That’s the first song that introduced me to Weezer.
big same
Yep me too
i UNironically like beverly hills. it's catchy af i don't have any history with it
He did Angel and The One so dirty. Also he put green way too high, especially for someone who criticizes them for being too bland. Nice to see White and Hurley get some love though.
Definitely, AaTO is one of my favorite Weezer songs. Really nice to see EWBAITE and White where they are though. Your hunger games video you just released was absolutely hilarious though btw lol.
Angel and the One is kinda boring.
Also green is very enjoyable for it's short length, Glorious Day and Island in the Sun are some of my favorite songs from the 2000s
Lol I watched your Weezer worst to best last week, and I was thinking about the whole time I watched this
Billy Cobb should put the zerwee album in third.
Angel and the one is pretentious trash
Hurley has the best weezer album cover, what are you on, melon
Excuse me the best weezer album cover is Corey in the house
Hurley is the best album cover of all time
Worst to Best:
The Strokes
Jay-Z
The Beatles
The Roots
John Coltrane (pretty ambitious)
System of a Down
Arcade Fire
Also:
Mastadon
RHCP
Stevie Wonder (again ambitious)
Interpol
A Tribe Called Quest
Mine for Strokes
1. Is this it?
2. Room on Fire
3. Angles
4. Comedown Machine
5. First Impressions of Earth
Spam singles is this it album is honestly the best
@@NotYourNachoes420 yes
5. Everything Now
4. Reflektor
3. Neon Bible
2. The Suburbs
1. Funeral
(maybe switch 4 and 3)
Spam singles really wish they release something new
I know Raditude is rad but did you really have to give it the top five spots?
Idgaf if people call me pretentious I still find "Only in Dreams" to be utterly incredible.
Yeah I hate it but I don’t see what’s pretentious about liking it
@@oakoe188 Why do you hate it? Personally I love it and it's probably one of my favorite tracks they've released.
@@_d.b.cooper it’s just too slow and the chorus drives me insane
@@_d.b.cooper the baseline is great though
@@oakoe188 Yeah I can see that, it does kinda drag, but that baseline is the best part of the song
Anthony, you have my N-word pass to explain how you would have renamed the Black Album.
Nevin Alexis ahaha wtf?
He'd name it Nevin.
@@ChrisPBacon-xn9up Nevin album. Rolls off the tongue.
OMG 😱 that was the most beautiful part of the video 😭! Anthony 🍈 has earned my respect 🙂! As gay/lesbian/trans woman 💁♀️🏳️🌈 Anthony 🍈 is my hero 😭😭!
@@Mr__Joe
Angelic 2 The Core isn’t the best Weezer album silly melon.
Me: *never heard a Weezer song or knew they existed*
Also me: yeah fuck that album
Have you checked them out yet? They experiment with their music every album and it's pretty nice.
I understand never having listened to weezer but how could you have never heard of them?
@@mxrefxs I'm not in an environment where their music would be played by for instance, a car passing.
It's mostly Hispanic music and rap.
@@sin21ful nice
@@sin21ful I pray for a reality where I don't know Weezer exist
What about Christmas with Weezer?! that album rocked Melon!
Hurley's album artwork is actually symbolic of there being a little bit of Hurley in all of us.
Contrary to Anthony’s opinion I actually love the album cover. I thought it was hilarious when it came out. But, I bet anyone who didn’t watch LOST didn’t appreciate it on the same level
the real Hurley was the friends we made along the way
@@tylerhathaway9525 I've watched lost, but the cover really makes my will to listen to the album fade. It's almost like weezer tried too hard to look funny and goofy and quirky and chose to use the most stupid Hurley picture they could as the cover for the album.
Worst to best of David Bowie challenge: make a vid that is under 30 min
Diek Lachst Speedrun
I was with you until you said the White Album was better than any music any black artist has made simply because "white is right", Melon. Not cool.
NerdSpartanPerson it’s ca lord a
Joke
Ever heard of that ?
@@killerfoxraspberryplays8903 r/woooosh
@@killerfoxraspberryplays8903 Fuck off
@@ballguy1527 You FUCK OFF
@@suleymantekingurmen7643 YOU FUCK OFF
"Something /scorchingly/ honest about the way Rivers sings"
I see what you did there. Ay caramba!
Anthony you can't just sing Teenage Dirtbag by Weetus for 30 minutes l was promised Weezer worst to best. I cry Anthony
Here before a Weezer Las Vegas residency.
Mark my words people.
ARTV: I did my Weezer Ranked, First
Fantano: Hold my Vegan Burger
Weezer: Worst To Best
And I bet Anthony's will get more views within one day. It makes me a little sad as much as I love Melon that the moment he releases anything, whether it be a review, worst to best, track review, etc, it immediately puts a massive shadow over the backs of anyone else doing the same thing.
@@TheMetalTempestYT he put pinkerton as number one, so its a list i automatically cannot respect
but artv sucks
@@lvndrr_dashboard yeah I'm not big on artv just saying. :) I've personally dealt with a lot of view struggle when I put out a review that Anthony's done / going to do. Nothing wrong with that, though!
@@TheMetalTempestYT Anthony is the most popular music reviewer on the site for a reason, if someone else doesn't get as much attention for a similar video it's not Anthony's fault 😂
Anthony loves Pork and Beans despite being vegan
Yeah, & Rivers Cuomo is a longtime vegetarian
Hurley is definetly their best cover and title
_4 8 15 16 23 42_
Nice lost reference lol
lost reference good job
LOST
13: Pacific Daydream
12: Make Believe
11: Raditude
10: Black
9: Teal
8: Red
7: Hurley
6: Green
5: Maladroit
4: Everything Will Be Alright in The End
3: White
2: Pinkerton
1: Blue
1. Blue
2. Blue
3. Blue.
4. Blue
5.
6.
7.
8. 9 through 13
How is this video longer than the Green Album?
I don't know Fantwan... spending 20 minutes to push your Rivers is Kurt theory? Then giving the top spot to "In Utero" when "Nevermind" is clearly the better Weezer album... And giving TPAB #3? You dropped the ball on this one :(
Everything Will be Alright in the End is such a great album
Sonny Etchell couldn’t agree more. It’s THE comeback album of our decade IMHO
Name a band who made such an impactful comeback album in recent years....I can’t even think of one
Honestly yeah
Feels like it got overshadowed by how good White was (though I like ewbaite more) and BAD Pacific Daydream was
Yo Melon why isn’t the Zerwee EP included in this ?
How do you know about that
@@channelrashaadytplaysttvyo462 because it's amazing
Kek Jong un it’s pretty mediocre at best
Luke yeah the guy that made zerwee has much better stuff. His name is billy Cobb look him up he has some great stuff.
I believe this list only features full length albums
Why did you put Raditude as the best weezer album Antknee?
I came here to say this exact thing
MaddoMeep He must had thought it was so...
“RAD”
Better question: why was Kids see ghosts here? It's not even a Weezer album
these comments have gotten obnoxious
I can't believe you just listed all of the Weezer albums in a pile marked as "Worst", surprisingly insightful Anthony
Now that I think about it even Pinkerton was greeted with disappointment by fans.
So literally every album Rivers came out with after Blue has been greeted with a negative reaction with the exception of maybe White and EWBAITE. So I can see why he’d want to rebel against his own audience.
They were dead wrong about Pinkerton so maybe he thought we were dead wrong about all the other records.
I’d say there was a SHARP withdrawal of vulnerability after the backlash to Pinkerton. Coupled with a defensiveness and imo a certain blindness. The podcast Bandsplain does a great Weezer episode that goes into this
@@tylerhathaway9525
Awesome. Always lookin for new podcasts. Thanks!
Jay Z Best to Worst. Very curious about your ranking of 444 amongst his classics.
The Blueprint is the best
Blueprint or Reasonable Doubt number 1
Kanye carried Blueprint and The Black Album
My opinion:
1. The Black Album
2. The Blueprint
3. In My Lifetime, Vol. 1
4. Roc La Familia: The Dynasty
5. Reasonable Doubt
6. 4:44
7. Watch the Throne
8. Collision Course
9. Vol 2... Hard Knock Life
10. The Blueprint 2
11. Vol 3: The Life and Times of S. Carter
I haven’t heard the others
Taha Kamran Kanye only produced like 3 songs on the Blueprint and the best songs on the Black Album aren’t even Kanye produced. Kanye did not carry the Blueprint or Black Album.
> asked about doing a beatles worst to best, "that would be so many albums tho"
> does a 30 min wtb on the albums of weezer
mfw
13. The
12. Most
11. Inconsistent
10. Band
9. Ever
8. But
7. Has
6. Two
5. Absolutely
4. Brilliant
3. Albums
2. Pinkerton
1. Blue
And White
13*
i didn't even know weezer had that many records
Everyone:
Pink Floyd best to worst
Beatles best to worst
Melon:
Weezer best to worst
It will be a coincidence that in the only 2 albums where MATT SHARP played are the best?
You didn't need to go so far as to say the White album, despite being recent, was one of the best just for being white...
The top 6 is accurate af
Except for pinkerton. That's number 1 Mr. Weezethony Ertano.
goth
and EWBAITE is better than White but yeah
Pinkerton is too sad to be number 1
Blue is perfect
@@charleston5012 no that was unlistenably bad
So... I met my wife at a Weezer concert between Pinkerton and the green album. I’ve always felt like they were a special band because of that... but Make Believe was the last album I bought. I did go back and listen to some of their stuff last year, but the only things that stood out to me were the parts you talked about on Everything Will Be Alright in the End. I’ve made peace with the fact that I am a cliche and continue to listen to the first two albums and various tracks off of other albums.
Man, I wish I could meet a girl at a Weezer concert
@@LegendryHeropon man i wish weezer was real. Man i wish woman were real. Man i wish
@@grandcross4290 weeze
@@grandcross4290 is that your real name, or are you just a big fan of Castlevania?
@@LegendryHeropon lol I've never played castlevanina, sorry to disappoint. i got it from a concert tour a band went on lol.
I am so glad the White Album got the third spot. Love that album
Yeah, and the Black Album got tenth. Talk about Anthony the White Supremacist 😍😍😍
1. Blue Album
2. Pinkerton
3....
.....
13. Raditude
Swap Pinkerton and blue album and I agree mr Juansi
Why does everyone hate raditude?
@@theps4guylol608 cuz its bad
I've decided over the last couple weeks of listening to both Hurley & Raditude a lot that Raditude is decidedly better than Hurley, and in fact Raditude's positives are so high that it must be purchased. (If You're Wondering if I Want You To) I Want You To alone was a high spot for Weezer's entire discography, but then after listening to the album for the first time in many years, I almost picked up on both I Don't Want To Let You Go, and Put Me Back Together and now I'm embarrassed I didn't pick them out the first time I listened to the album. I Don't Want To Let You Go is now one of my very favorite Weezer songs ever.
To be fair, I don't like songs like Girl Got Hot, I'm Your Daddy, and Can't Stop Partying, they represent the lowest common denominator of Weezer songs, just like most drug-related songs from other albums like Hash Pipe, Dope Nose, (the exception being White's Do You Want To Get High? which is amazing) and others as well as Beverly Hills. But like I said before, the high points of the album make it decidedly better than Hurley or the Black album IMO.
For me the list looks something like:
1: Blue/OK Human
3: White
4: Pinkerton
...
...
Last: Black (Would have been Hurley if Black had included what was supposed to be their lead single for the album, Midnight (Cardigan Disaster))
Almost every single song on green has the EXACT same formula. The song starts with the a guitar solo that is playing the lyrics to the bridge. Then verse chorus verse chorus bridge, guitar solo that is playing the lyrics to the verse, chorus, ends on a verse
0:20-0:24 Did you seriously call Yes an alternative rock band? WTF?
I mean it kinda is
Yes
well in the 80s they kinda were tbh
He needs to do Yes worst to best
Not gonna lie, I really like Feels like Summer, but I get why you wouldn’t as a Weezer fan. I really like when they perform it live too
I felt the mixing in Pinkerton was way better. It doesnt feel "rough" to me and it has a lot more dynamic moments to me than in Blue, IE Across The Sea. Only in dreams is like a preview into whats to come with Pinkerton.
The main difference to me is the drum sound. The drums on Blue sound great, but a little dry and polite. On the other hand the drums on Pinkerton hit you like a fucking brick wall of intensity
Suggestions for future Worst to Best:
The Beatles
Kate Bush
Animal Collective
The Cure
THE CURE WOULD BE BOMB
the really fantastic songs on daydream, teal, and black give me hope that rivers and the gang can put out another perfect album that appreciates their early successes but also fleshes out their current pop trajectory. it might not happen until 2025 but you best believe i’ll still be around to appreciate it.
This comment aged like a fine wine. Ok human is fantastic and probably the best we will get for a minute
ANTHONY FANTANO
HAS JOINED WEEZER
You should do:
Kate Bush
The Cure
Echo & the Bunnymen
Wire
Roxy Music
The Velvet Underground or Lou Reed
Tom Waits
New Order
Kate bush please
ben folds
@naenaesan OH SHIT. thank you :) love that album and music video. and Danny Brown
@@mrtesticles889 Hounds of Love is the best
@@thegroove14 Im gunna have to disagree and say The Dreaming is better but regardless both are damn near perfect.