Why Pearl is the most Complex Steven Universe Character

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มิ.ย. 2024
  • Pearl is a very interesting and complicated Steven Universe character with lots of nuisance and things to analyses about her. Characters featured in this episode are rose quartz, garnet, its over isnt it. This is a pearl video essay about pearl and pink diamond.
    tags (ignore)
    #stevenuniverse
    #pearl
    #videoessay
    this is NOT Steven Universe is Garbage and Here's Why or The Evolution of Pearl or I Wanted To Hate Steven Universe or Adventure Time

ความคิดเห็น • 456

  • @ceciliacordon770
    @ceciliacordon770 ปีที่แล้ว +2573

    I don't think those are tears of guilt at the end of Rose's Scabbard. Pearl is so codependent that even after Rose is long gone, she still views her self worth through Rose. I think Steven confirming Pearl's worth, existence and experiences as valid allows Pearl the release of a lot of repressed emotions about Rose and the codependency she had for her. But, there is not enough critical discourse around Steven Universe and it's my main special interest so please make more.

    • @stanqifrey1575
      @stanqifrey1575 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +32

      felt that bestie

    • @chane11ee7
      @chane11ee7 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +22

      I agree I thought that way too when I watched the show

    • @lulusugarlife
      @lulusugarlife 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

      This

    • @ACagedBird364
      @ACagedBird364 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

      Also she started doing this with Garnet as well

    • @frozenyogurth
      @frozenyogurth 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +14

      Feel you on the discourse part.
      Regarding Pearl's tears, I honestly think it's a mix of both. I think you're spot on regarding her realeasing repressed emotions in that scene. For one she feels validated by Steven but also realizes just how unfair she is being to him, because it's not his fault Rose is gone and she's aware that she's compairing Steven to Rose. But at the same times she feels good about the validation because in some capacity she still sees Steven as Rose. I think in that moment she also internalizes that Steven and Rose are different people. Also think that these were tears of Love for Steven. I think in that moment she realized how much she matters to Steven, and despite Rose not being here anymore she now has Steven, who adores her as well, but in a differnt way.

  • @lavaman9910
    @lavaman9910  ปีที่แล้ว +1891

    CORRECTION:
    - rose didn't create the zoo, she asked the diamonds if she could preserve life on earth and they created the zoo
    - rose didn't randomly attack bismuth. bismuth attacked her first, which makes roses events much less shitty

    • @canislupus9208
      @canislupus9208 ปีที่แล้ว +37

      Wait sorry, where were we told the latter bit? I know that Rose realized Bismuth wasn't going to let up on the idea of Shattering, but I don't remember Bismuth being the first to fight her about it lol; only the post-flashback tussle with Steven

    • @Tuskbumper
      @Tuskbumper ปีที่แล้ว +239

      I feel like Rose isn't even really a bad person overall. Not only is her story told backwards but you can chalk up the Spinel thing to her not having experienced much in terms of development past the tantrums. It feels like a thing a diamond WOULD do, and it's extremely lax compared to destroying planets with life on them.

    • @seok-jin514
      @seok-jin514 ปีที่แล้ว +18

      @@Tuskbumper 100% agree

    • @20000dino
      @20000dino ปีที่แล้ว +53

      @@Tuskbumper The show pretty much just starts using her as an escape goat for all the atrocities caused by the other Diamonds from Season 4 onwards (which is when the show started getting really terrible imo).
      How interesting would it have been if the show actually stuck to its initial attempt of portraying Rose as a nuanced character (instead of villainizing her at every chance they got, from a certain point onwards).

    • @XohjaiSbarkeater
      @XohjaiSbarkeater ปีที่แล้ว +16

      ​@@Tuskbumper spinel is enough for me to not like her.

  • @CoachingForCreators
    @CoachingForCreators 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +824

    Seeing Pearl sabotage the tower just to fuse gave so much insight into her character. I hurt for her but the storytelling is brilliant.

    • @xTwilightWolvesx
      @xTwilightWolvesx 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +60

      During Pearl’s early days, she fused with Pink Diamond. It makes sense that she longs for that connection again. She shouldn’t have done what she did to Garnet, but it makes more sense with that context.

    • @boomgirlbucko
      @boomgirlbucko หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      ​@@xTwilightWolvesx It's just Rose now

  • @TragicSun
    @TragicSun ปีที่แล้ว +1077

    Ironically, it was Pearl in her most naive self who told Pink Diamond that freedom WAS possible right when she needed it most. While Pink was feeling trapped, Pearl was proposing ideas for her, ideas that went absurdly against Homeworld yet Pink started to believe.
    It is important to mention that Rebecca stated in an interview that Pink Diamond and Rose were separated people in Pearl's mind, she believed in Rose's new identity, and how at the end of the day Pink had granted her freedom. But her choice, Pearl’s proud way of "rebelling", as an individual, was to follow the person she loved…The fantasy both Pearl and Rose created, and the one both struggled.

    At the same time the moment Pearl "shattered" Pink Diamond was inherently catastrophic for her. Not only because the ugliest phase of the war began, but because Pearl "murdered" the person she was literally made for. It went against every part of her programming, her instincts, and it probably hurt psychologically way more than she was willing to admit. Pearl's feelings of guilt are often overlooked "why did I do it?" In the end everything resulted in the war, corruption and destruction of gems… Feeling responsible while lying to everyone, left simply unable to communicate and properly deal with her own emotions, and not knowing how to ended up with Pearl having a huge mental fog. Disguising her own chaos with a need of control.
    There’s an interesting post in the SU subreddit called “A theory on ways Pearls functioning(with images)” and speculates on how important the perception of visual forms are for gems.

  • @liz5054
    @liz5054 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +281

    I think that ‘A single pale rose’ was such an important episode not only because Steven learned the truth about Rose, but because Pearl wanted something that was intrinsically opposite of what Pink wanted, and Pearl chose to do it anyway. It was incredibly difficult for her to do, but the fact that Pearl chose to disobey Pink’s final order because SHE wanted to (“I’ve wanted to tell you for so long”) was the final domino preventing her from moving on.
    I think after that episode Pearl does still grieve Rose, but it’s in a more healthy way. It’s grief, but with room to move on and grow as a person. It’s no longer all-consuming.

    • @NotWhatIamMadeFor
      @NotWhatIamMadeFor 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

      Amethyst too, don't forget that she is also tragic. Amethyst hides her feelings of insecurity behind being brash and using humor. But, she knows she was created to fight a war she really had nothing to do with and the only reason they didn't want her is that she was considered defective because she wasn't born big and strong like the other Amathysts. She is dealing with the fact that if she wasn't "defective" she would have been fighting on the other side of a war. She was only created to destroy and fight. Yet she was so weak she wasn't born on time and when she was born she had already been abandoned and alone. It stayed in her mind that she wasn't really the big and strong gem she should be and that makes her feel so insecure that she feels she has to hide her insecurities when, in fact her "defectiveness" ended up making her our "Amethyst" instead of a regular noncapatslized amathyst "drones"

    • @SourWine789
      @SourWine789 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      ​@NotWhatIamMadeFor yeah! I'm glad Amythest realized that everyone likes her the way she is and that if she was as "big and strong" like the others then she would not have been Amythest at all

  • @shovknight3008
    @shovknight3008 ปีที่แล้ว +594

    Pearl probably has one or the saddest backstories in the whole show. Her story of sacrificing everything to be with rose only to be upstaged by Greg and still being forced to keep roses most important secret puts her up there with spinel and lapis for me.

  • @mertensiam3384
    @mertensiam3384 ปีที่แล้ว +429

    Rose didn't make the Zoo, the Diamonds did when she asked them to stop the colonization because she didn't want to kill the humans
    Rose didn't attack Bismuth, Bismuth attacked Rose when she didn't agree
    Pearl WAS free. She didn't want to. It was her choice to stay

    • @Crisis121
      @Crisis121 ปีที่แล้ว +38

      "Pearl WAS free. She didn't want to. It was her choice to stay"
      This seems a little bit naive. The gem rebellion was Pearl's idea, and once Rose committed to it, there was no path back for Pearl. If Pearl defected from the Crystal Gems then she would have been killed, or worse. She was not equipped to live independently or with the humans. Her only real choice was to fight for the Crystal Gems. Rose knew this and felt guilty about it, you can tell from the exchange between Pearl and holo-Rose.
      True freedom for Pearl would mean dismantling the Diamond Authority, which is not something that Rose was able to do for Pearl, but ultimately Steven succeeded at doing.

  • @feartheb33k33p3r
    @feartheb33k33p3r 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +45

    pearl is a representation of the psychological damage you get from fumbling a BBW only to see her have kids with a soundcloud rapper

    • @CodgerGunslinger
      @CodgerGunslinger 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Real.... happened to my friend Hava,, he's ok now

    • @thehawk8332
      @thehawk8332 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Real
      Except Greg is a hell of a catch anyway.

  • @nilsc9783
    @nilsc9783 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +55

    The thing with Rose is that, during her lifetime she was one of the 4 most powerful entities in the universe. All the relationships she had, with anybody, were asymmetric. This is what her conflict with Spinelle shows: that if someone has the power to ask an annoying underling to stop moving for all eternity, and enough privilege to then forget about the matter, they will use it. The mere existence of the diamonds is a bad thing, even when they're personally nice.

    • @PS-dm1dq
      @PS-dm1dq 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +13

      Very good point! While the effect of her choices had devastating consequences, Pink D didn't ask to be in the position of having so much power over others, especially so much emotional dependency from Spinel and Pearl

    • @shadenox8164
      @shadenox8164 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

      To clear up one thing though only Pearls are compelled to obey orders from diamonds. Pink likely assumed Spinel would just get bored and stop.

  • @amelka_sto_
    @amelka_sto_ 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +153

    The human zoo was created by other diamonds NOT Pink. Pink wanted to convince Blue and Yellow to stop the colony since she cared for humans who lived there so the diamonds created zoo for her so she can keep few humans safe and continue the colony

    • @itsherry5217
      @itsherry5217 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      Exactly !! I wanted to say that !

    • @nasta1exe
      @nasta1exe หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      plus for spinel, she probably knew she was about to go to war and i wouldn't bring this joyful fella into a war personnally. plus, after the war all the portals and all ways for her to contact spinel were destroyed on earth. she had no way of coming back to her.

    • @ZOMBOZ0ISBACK
      @ZOMBOZ0ISBACK 14 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@nasta1exeshe was literally shown to be annoyed with spinel before she left her there, don’t make excuses for lying and abandoning someone.

    • @nasta1exe
      @nasta1exe 13 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@ZOMBOZ0ISBACK just bc she was slightly annoyed with her doesn't mean she abandoned her willingly? she still liked spinel, but spinel was litterally the embodiement of what the other diamonds limited Pink to be : a child needing toys to play with and nothing more. If I was Pink I probably would have mixed feelings about Spinel too.

    • @ZOMBOZ0ISBACK
      @ZOMBOZ0ISBACK 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@nasta1exe “she didn’t abandon her willingly” yes bc she definitely didn’t abandon spinel on her own free will 😍
      Just stop the convo, ur logic isn’t logical

  • @lordbritish5285
    @lordbritish5285 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +133

    i think she didnt love him when he was born, but she grew to love him. loving him in a way she had to learn because she only knew romantic love for rose, so she had to learn familial love

  • @awefawn7793
    @awefawn7793 ปีที่แล้ว +267

    forever my favorite character. Lapis, Blue Diamond, and Peridot after her in no particular order, but Pearl will always be #1 for me.

    • @LourdesSavage
      @LourdesSavage ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Pearl’s *obsession* cough devotion makes me sad. Why she’s at the bottom of my stack rank. Living for someone else is low vibes. If her devotion only comes from her feelings of worthlessness and longing, it’s not a strength and it’s proven to be a weakness in the show. Pearl is a baddie by her own right and her worst moments come because of her obsession. Stephen looks HARROWED when she tries to inflict her ideology on Connie.
      PERIDOT FOR LYFE.

    • @fulanodetal3000
      @fulanodetal3000 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      oh nice list. im a lapis defender 4lyfe tbh. so many people hate her or call her "mutually abusive" with jasper and it's so frustrating.

    • @sqkoi
      @sqkoi 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      so glad blue diamond is on there! shes such a sweet character and tbh the best mother figure-like character in the series

    • @amazinggraciegurl
      @amazinggraciegurl 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      ​​​​​@@sqkoiOh plsss 🙄 Blue Diamond literally mentally and physically tortured her actual child (solitary confinement is a torture method). Not only was she imprisoning Pink for long lengths of time in a pitch dark room, but she'd go into the room to continually ab*se her in other ways. Constantly gaslighting her (claiming it's Pink's behavior that's getting her tortured, making herself out to be the victim). And literally blasting Pink with her powers so hard that she gets slammed into the walls. That scene where Steven's in Pink's pov in the prison chamber not ringing a bell to you? How is any of that motherly? Having a soft voice doesn't make somebody motherly. She, Yellow, and White are the reasons Pink felt so unloved that she didn't think the other Diamonds would care if she disappeared. And let's not even go into all the genocide that Blue was partially behind. Istg, I will never understand why people think Blue is so sweet. She's one of the cruellest characters. Trying to change after eons of being a genocide-loving ab*ser does not make her a nice person. She's got a very long way to go before she can be considered sweet or motherly. Do I think she's capable of change? Yes. Do I think she's the best motherly figure on the show? Hard no. She literally put her own kid through hell and back. I'm not even going to respond to anything you say back because I literally can't emotionally handle people who excuse abu*er's actions.

    • @sqkoi
      @sqkoi 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@amazinggraciegurl ok

  • @martaaranda8664
    @martaaranda8664 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +31

    We have to remember we see rose’s character development in reverse because it is from Stevens perspective and as a child he only grows to learn of these things.

  • @lulub517
    @lulub517 ปีที่แล้ว +172

    Rewatching season one makes it so much more impactful and painful to see her anxious and flighty personality begin and her complete dedication to Rose throughout the series explaining why she is so dedicated and thinks so little of herself.
    Plus her singing voice is just unmatched and unbeatable imo.

  • @lillyvalley7362
    @lillyvalley7362 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +112

    I think Rose is an excellently complex character, as well as pearl. And their entire relationship as well as their backstory. It's such an interesting dynamic. Rose, despite being an alien, is incredibly human in her flaws, her decisions and even in her selfishness. I've often wondered if she bubble bismuth because she regretted leaving spinel in that garden which was a horrible action, but it does make you think about it. If it affected how she handled the interaction with the breaking point in that moment. she was also incredibly human to act thinking only of yourself, just to avoid embarrassment. Maybe that's why she didn't tell the other gems, maybe she wanted to keep having them look at her as this goddess, because it made her feel better to think of herself as this literally changed being to separate herself from her previous existence . Where is she did horrible things, because that's what she knew in her culture. you could argue it makes her a victim as well (being a victim doesn't absolve you of bad behavior). Growing up in a dictatorship. She's a very complex character. She's not good or bad. And pearl is another victim in a long line of the terrible actions of the diamonds. these characters can be simply categorized as good or bad. Just like humans, they are a collection of actions and experiences, and its how we learn from them that define our character. And I think for a kid show, the fact that all of these characters can be analyzed in such a uniquely human way despite being aliens, is very cool. It's not the best show to ever exist on television, but I think it's a wonderful addition to the world of animation, and pave the way for a lot of other excellent shows. Steven universe has a special place in my heart I growing up i always felt like an alien watching people and mimicking them to pass as human when in reality, I never understood them.. My mask was flawless until I couldn't keep it up anymore. And that was right around when Steven universe came out, in my 20s and it helped me a lot. I saw some of my self and Rose not only because I am a giant woman but because I had created a façade that wasn't me. I felt like I wasn't a real person and I felt myself asking myself all the time is this not how it works? I probably wouldn't have had the introspection to get help and realize that I'm autistic and that it's OK to be me and that there are people out there who find tall women very beautiful. It was nice to see your character like that even if she wasn't perfect.., people wanna talk about bad characters, but I think it's important to remember that you can't always put someone in the box of good and evil and that sometimes even 'bad' characters in shows that may be a little corny can have a good effect on people. I really liked your video by the way I thought it was very well worded. Keep up the great work.

    • @somerandomperson1662
      @somerandomperson1662 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      i just read all that

    • @amazinggraciegurl
      @amazinggraciegurl 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      I definitely agree that Rose is an incredibly complex character, and I love that you've been inspired by her. 💖 I enjoyed reading your comment. I also can totally relate to putting up a facade to appear more "normal." One thing though that I'd like to amicably bring up: Rose actually was a huge victim. It's not arguable, it's indisputable. One of the hugest victims on the show. The other Diamonds literally tortured her (solitary confinement is a torture method). They put her through so much physical and emotional anguish that she literally thought they wouldn't care if she disappeared. Hence the fake shattering. I'd also say that she was a lot more good than bad. She made some mistakes, but not as many as people make it out to be. She left Spinel because the other Diamonds literally gave her Spinel as a toy to play with. How could Pink then see Spinel as anything other than a toy when she had no other frame of reference for what Spinel is? Pink's entire character is based off the life and growth of a human. The youngest we see Pink is when she was a child, hence the other Diamonds giving her "toys" like Spinel and sending her off to the Garden to play so they could work without being distracted. Pink leaving Spinel symbolizes a child leaving behind a toy they've grown tired of. Rebecca actually said this and was inspired to create Spinel by a memory of herself leaving behind a toy when she was a kid. That scene that so many see as Pink being a terrible person is her being a naive child who simply couldn't know any better due to her environment and upbringing. Pink exploring Earth with Pearl, realizing how messed up the other Diamonds' actions are, and rebelling marks her adolescence. This is also when she poofed and hid Bismuth, which was due to being threatened by Bismuth, not due to any kind of despicable agenda that fans love to make up. One thing that comes to my mind is how many Gems Rose must've seen the other Diamonds shatter. Other than feeling threatened by the fact that she's Pink Diamond and Bismuth was out to kill anybody outside of the Rebellion (Pink Diamond would've been her main target), Rose could very well be triggered by even the thought of shattering. It annoys me that all the blame is on Rose here when Bismuth was the one who wanted to stoop to murdering Gems that were brainwashed by the Diamond authority. Rose would know about that brainwashing better than anybody, as she was literally raised by them. The Rose we see after the war is her as an adult. As you said, she's such an amazingly complex character and the fact that people just write her off as a villain breaks my heart. Even Rebecca has talked smack about her, which makes zero sense to me. Why create such a nuanced character and give them so many layers if you're just going to end up scapegoating them? 😕 Anyways, I'm always glad to see people who don't bash Rose for a living. 😆🩷

    • @ACagedBird364
      @ACagedBird364 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      All I wanna do
      Is see you turn into
      A giant woman A GIANT WOMAN

  • @Peridot5xg
    @Peridot5xg ปีที่แล้ว +180

    *["Pearlhaps" one of the most well developed gems! Her story is just so full of layers...]*

    • @hnfiiinc5993
      @hnfiiinc5993 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +8

      She had one of the biggest character arcs that I did not expect - even from the pilot.
      She went from the well-mannered co-parent to an internally suffering war veteran with closure issues fast.

    • @alexandrite9685
      @alexandrite9685 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      Hmmm, layers, like the layers of her memories inside of her gem?

  • @citrinethecorgi
    @citrinethecorgi 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +38

    Dude i cannot watch that scene from rose's scabbard without tearing up. it is such a powerful and impactful scene and the first time we truly see pearl's walls down and her past with rose.

  • @selfgaming1456
    @selfgaming1456 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +97

    I would have LOVED some sort of scene in Future where she had to choose between Rose and Steven and she made the choice to fight to get Steven. Like some gem manipulated her mind to think that she could give up Steven and get Rose back and she snapped NEVER

    • @j.jaylee.h
      @j.jaylee.h 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +16

      THAT WOULD'VE BEEN SICK

    • @eg-draw
      @eg-draw 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

      She literally was silently fighing between those two the whole show

    • @Sire-Swagg
      @Sire-Swagg 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Idk I feel like it would kinda go against the finale in season 5, cause isn’t that exactly what white did

    • @shadenox8164
      @shadenox8164 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I feel like we already knew that by that point personally.

  • @DaedricThot
    @DaedricThot ปีที่แล้ว +59

    Pearl is my favorite character in SU, she went through so much and still doesn’t get as much attention like the other gems. She’s amazing.

  • @Platina-ti8hr
    @Platina-ti8hr 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +8

    Pink didnt make the human zoo. Blue and Yellow did after Pink told them she wanted to keep the life on earth. The other diamonds misunderstood her and created the human zoo as a supposed gift.

  • @hanakodoritoss
    @hanakodoritoss ปีที่แล้ว +77

    Pearl is my favorite character. Her development was so stunning, her character is so unique.

  • @saiyurico2682
    @saiyurico2682 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +24

    while there was some mistakes you made, overall it's a topic I love to see discussed. Pearl's character was so intriguing because it was heavily involved in the mystery of the show. I also love the noticable arc of her character such as her finally feeling comfortable to shapeshift, take a small bite of food and enjoy human culture etc by the end of the show. It shows such incredible growth from her servitude to true freedom from all internal struggle of truly belonging to no one.

  • @avii8742
    @avii8742 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    i don’t pink diamond is a bad character, they need to make a mini series about the life of pink diamond. we already know that everything was told backwards but I think it’ll bring justice to her character.

  • @ajyechani3399
    @ajyechani3399 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    This is just a thought, but when Pearl was rejuvenated, before she appears again, her clam asks if the master of that pearl wanted customization, and when Greg didn't, the shell said that the settings will be default, showing us Pearl.
    This is just a thought which may add to how sad it is for Pearl. We all know that pearls are customized to match their master, but Pearl isn't, making me think that because Pink Diamond's pearl was broken, White decided to keep it, and brought Pink a new Pearl, but Pink didn't customize her. It made me think that maybe Pink loved Volleyball more than Pearl.

    • @shadenox8164
      @shadenox8164 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I mean to begin with? Probably. She had a connection with Volleyball and Pearl was meant to be her replacement.

  • @tomatoheadfd
    @tomatoheadfd ปีที่แล้ว +31

    I agree with the tittle of this video.

  • @avej99
    @avej99 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

    My god, pearl’s character hits soo different in the early episodes upon a rewatch of the series. So many interactions are given deep layers

  • @nikeee318
    @nikeee318 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    1. in one of the episodes pearl sais that blue and yellow built the zoo and in a previous one that they wanted to save them but couldn't after the war
    2. roze didn't 'kill' bismuth because bismuth disagreed with her but because she was dangerous. If bismuth were to use the breaking point she could've attracted the attention of yellow and blue causing them to send all of homeworld to the war on earth, possibly shattering every gem in the rebelion, get roze/pink locked away and pearl bubbled or even shattered.
    roze did many things that harmed the people around her, but it's important to remember she an immortal being that suffered at the hands of THE most abusive, toxic and disfunctional family in the entire univers. yes she's dons bad things, but she isn't horrible.
    I think it's the writers fault for vilainising her (especially in future), because we forget how caring pink/roze was at the end of the day.

  • @gottastoppo
    @gottastoppo 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    I was so happy for how much Pearl has changed in the final, she became so nice and calm, for the most part, and opened up to people. That was really satisfying to see for me, because Pearl was and still is my favorite Steven Universe character.

  • @impsallad9544
    @impsallad9544 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    Loving the character studies, please keep ‘em coming!

  • @rraygun
    @rraygun ปีที่แล้ว +4

    just finished binging all of your content! your complex understanding and analytical approach to these shows is amazing, it’s almost like experiencing these moments for the first time. Keep up the great work!! :]

  • @Em-Theassiate8888-mp3uf
    @Em-Theassiate8888-mp3uf 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    One note: Rose did not setup the zoo - that was her sisters, the other Diamonds set up a zoo for her when she told them she wanted to save the biological life from the gems invasion. The other diamonds set up the zoo to try to preserve some life, imagining that Rose just wanted to keep the life as a 'record', like how we save things in museums.

  • @lurkleaf
    @lurkleaf 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I randomly saw the lemongrab thumbnail and put it on to sleep but then ended up staying up because I was so interested. really great content

  • @kurikiarizeth2990
    @kurikiarizeth2990 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Another incredible video. Your analysis and voice as well as topic choices are awesome. It seems like you put a bunch of work into thinking it through and as someone who is trying to write a story myself, videos like this are great perspective. Glad I found your channel 💫

  • @luand.757
    @luand.757 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Just love this video, i was searching for an interesting steven universe video to watch, cause i got really into su vibes and randomly found a video about my favorite charcter and just love it, keep going lavaman, hugs from brazil

  • @aerrrrrr
    @aerrrrrr 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    having watched rgu (which i believe was one of the heaviest inspirations for pearl and pink) really gave so much more nuance to understanding pearls character now, and i think the parallels are just so interesting between them and utena/anthy

  • @tuumef1799
    @tuumef1799 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    This was a neatly done exploration of Pearl's behavior. Thanks for the video.

  • @leftotd
    @leftotd ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I really enjoyed watching this, makes me want to rewatch the show, thank you lavaman

  • @davidkristensen1188
    @davidkristensen1188 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    I hope you have a series of all of the characters in Steven Universe and end them all with " and that's why x is the most complex charecter in Steven Universe." Great essay very well edited thank you

  • @dudeelame
    @dudeelame 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I love your videos, man! You really catch a lot of hidden beauty in the storytelling of these shows.

  • @angierivas7171
    @angierivas7171 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    in the span of an hour, you have become my new favorite TH-camr. plss keep making videos, they are amazing!!

  • @Reginald293
    @Reginald293 ปีที่แล้ว

    Dude, these videos are awesome!! Can't wait for any new videos you have brewing!

  • @ninomaeputanginanis-kfp
    @ninomaeputanginanis-kfp ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Awesome video! So much thought has obviously been put into it. And I think you really captured the beauty and nuance of Steven Universe, a show that I really loved. I Hope you make more videos like this maybe on Adventure Time characters cause they're also pretty fun and complex. How about Princess Bubblegum or Marceline or Ice King?

  • @CorruptedProgram
    @CorruptedProgram 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Imagine having a crush on someone and been with them for thousand of year only for them to fall in love with someone else for one year its not rose fault she can chose who ever she love and I don't think pearl tell rose how she feel all those time anyway but still it hurt alot

  • @paloma4444
    @paloma4444 ปีที่แล้ว +157

    Five points I feel are relevant
    1) Rose never "chose" Greg over Pearl. Most likely, she was never even aware Pearl was jealous
    2) Rose did not build the human zoo. The Diamonds did.
    3) BISMUTH was the one who tried to kill Rose for disagreeing. Not the other way around
    4) Pearl WAS free. If she had wanted to stay in Homeworld Rose would have found a way to let her. Look at other Pearls and you'll see they aren't attached to their Diamonds like that. Pearl just loves Rose, so she has no reason TO wanna ditch her
    5) Pink and Rose being very different identities is crucial to Pearls character. Because she ONLY loves Rose, not Pink as a Diamond.

    • @tomatoheadfd
      @tomatoheadfd ปีที่แล้ว +8

      I agree with you.

    • @lavaman9910
      @lavaman9910  ปีที่แล้ว +44

      My 2 cents on this
      1. Regardless of whether Greg was jealous she did chose him over pearl
      2. Just ur right I fucked up on this one lol
      3. Is this true? I know its implied but just because she tried to kill Steven doesn't mean she tied to kill rose (maybe i missed the subtext tho lol)
      4. My arguement was that pearl was never free because she had no other actual option as her world only existed in the context of rose. Like she 'could' have stayed at homeworld but she had never even spent a day without rose and she was deff dependent of her. Like basically a slave loving her master she was created to serve feels very different from pearl just randomly being in love
      5. I mean you're right pearl only loved rose when she was in rose form but rose is still the same person as pink (maybe you could elaborate more on how this is relevant)
      Overall good points!

    • @paloma4444
      @paloma4444 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      @@lavaman9910 1 - nope. She didn't choose Greg she loved them both. She didn't even know they were treating it as a competition
      3 - yes, Bis attacked Rose. Not the other way around
      4- Pearl was free. She stayed with Rose becaude it was by any measure the better option. None of the other pearls are attached to their Diamonds. It is not because she is a Pearl.

    • @chessguy-hq3zr
      @chessguy-hq3zr ปีที่แล้ว +20

      ​@@paloma4444 i think the idea is that pearl didn't have a choice because without rose she saw herself as nothing (because she was made to be roses slave)

    • @paloma4444
      @paloma4444 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@chessguy-hq3zr That is not how choices work dude. That is like saying 'I didn't have a choice but marry my wife because without her my life is so much sadder'

  • @guized7475
    @guized7475 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    dang I thought this was a channel with an hundred+ videos but was instead an welcome edition to an content creator that'll do that in the near future, gonna be a treat indeed which is keep up the great work, have fun while doing so and of course do it at your own pace cause honestly videos like this just makes me want to see the world in different lenses while of course getting ideas and other stuff for writing I suppose you could say.

  • @h.thomasseckinger3509
    @h.thomasseckinger3509 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I like these. I can't tell if it's helping my creative writing in terms of character writing but I like to think that it's helping to look at characters differently as I get older.

  • @sprout3579
    @sprout3579 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    i love watching character analysis videos, and i was so surprised to see your channel was new since i loved your videos so much. im excited for new content from you !!

  • @sethklaassen2532
    @sethklaassen2532 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    when steven says "well I think your pretty great" it reminds me of stevens video that rose left for him "every time you love being yourself thats me loving you" kinda implying that because he thinks shes pretty great rose must have too

  • @templarstealth4712
    @templarstealth4712 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Bro this long form stuff is amazing keep it up

  • @eastward98
    @eastward98 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I've listened to all your videos in one go (as I've been organising) and I thought they were all really interesting! You've got a good thing going on here. Looking forward to any more (if you feel like it) 👌

  • @onceortwiceooh
    @onceortwiceooh ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Great video, hope to see more from you on Steven Universe!

  • @luyandalungile5778
    @luyandalungile5778 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I’m totally inlove with the narrators voice ✨😩

  • @Leo-vc4hz
    @Leo-vc4hz หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Where have you gone bro? Just binge watched every one of your videos and I love your content and takes. You have genuine talent and I would love to see more content from you

  • @Volgotha
    @Volgotha 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I think Pink Diamond was always jist "Playing the Part" because thats what she was taught to donby Blue and Yellow, until Greg makes her snap out out of itnin that scene before they "fuse", and thats why Rose fell for him, because she was being genuine for the first time.

  • @yeet-wg8ee
    @yeet-wg8ee 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    i love the way u explain and analyze the characters, just discovered ur channel and i already love ur content and videos

  • @husk5373
    @husk5373 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Keep making videos playa, all of these are gold

  • @Blitz_Noodler03
    @Blitz_Noodler03 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    You should make more videos! I love your content and you have something really special!

  • @bigape6012
    @bigape6012 ปีที่แล้ว

    Man these videos are sick keep it up I will be watching all your videos from now on

  • @meltymooncakes
    @meltymooncakes 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    you are such an underrated channel!!! keep it up! i love this stuff

  • @summerraylene
    @summerraylene 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    All of your videos are so gold ✨

  • @annepandesal
    @annepandesal 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    i always thought of the tears as relief or a for reprieve. that there is someone who thinks shes great and loves her for her.
    also hey youre the one that made the lemongrab video, i really enjoyed it. this videos is cool i should really try to to back to steven universe

  • @rizwanzaman1793
    @rizwanzaman1793 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I am so glad I watched through Steven Universe these past few months. This show has definitely grown on me, I love it and the characters.

  • @lila7477
    @lila7477 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    An important distinction is the fact that Pearl did not know a Pink Diamond that was “bratty” and did the things that we now know she did. Pearl was her second pearl. She never knew her to be unkind as Volleyball would have been her pearl at the time, so she has an inherently different perspective of Pink Diamond.

  • @istolekookiesbananamilk1509
    @istolekookiesbananamilk1509 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I loovvveee your videos! I love your words. It just makes sense. I"ve seen it before and I've felt the feelings but never described it. You just did it for me. You're cool

  • @crissy4445
    @crissy4445 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Just found your channel and its very insightful! Please keep making videos, I hope to be watching more for a long time 😊😊

  • @jahiisjackson6299
    @jahiisjackson6299 ปีที่แล้ว

    i found this channel through the lemon grab video and i absolutely love it.

  • @Eminem2k15
    @Eminem2k15 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I'm so happy that i found this channel

  • @Computo3000
    @Computo3000 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    These videos are all great, keep it up!

  • @Adrian_1114
    @Adrian_1114 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Man I just found your channel by random and gosh dang this is some great video analysis! Kinda makes me want to rewatch AD so thanks for that I guess.

  • @idkeh
    @idkeh ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Love this, your channel is pretty good

  • @johnlemonlime
    @johnlemonlime ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I love your takes

  • @IronpenWorldbuilding
    @IronpenWorldbuilding ปีที่แล้ว

    This TH-cam channel is awesome, glad to be here at 7.83k subs and I hope you many more

  • @hanananah
    @hanananah 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    There are characters that are literally multiple people but bird mom is still more complex because she's got so many issues 😂

  • @D.H.critters
    @D.H.critters ปีที่แล้ว

    I love how you are surprised, at the end of the videos, that someone would watch them until the end haha 😊 that's cute! Your videos are really nice to watch 🙂

  • @Interlude0fTati
    @Interlude0fTati ปีที่แล้ว

    Love the videos looking forward to your next upload

  • @tyrannosauruswrex123
    @tyrannosauruswrex123 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Pink diamond didn't create the zoo. That was blue diamond, after pink requested for humans to be preserved

  • @sierraa.bryant9322
    @sierraa.bryant9322 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    WOOOO! 4500th like!
    This is an AMAZING video that showcases exactly why Pearl will always be my favorite. I relate to her and honestly love her too to an insane degree. She is amazing

  • @katlehohlahane7758
    @katlehohlahane7758 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Best Videos man😃
    I wish i had found your channel later WHEN it had more videos to watch.
    Wonderful content

  • @cobii5174
    @cobii5174 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    just watched all ur vids man hope u keep these up

  • @KoreijiProductions
    @KoreijiProductions 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Hey I stumbled on your channel and really enjoyed your videos, I really find your insightfull commentary on these characters interesting and entertaining. I hope there will be more of them in the future.
    But I understand if you don't have the time anymore, lost interest or moved on to different things.
    Just know your videos had impact on me and I hope things are going great for you.

  • @alexreign1433
    @alexreign1433 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hi I just want to let you know that you are an amazing TH-camr and I love how eloquent your videos are. Please make more

  • @Idkanymorelol.
    @Idkanymorelol. ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Honestly we don’t need reasons why she’s the most complex character

  • @B00Radl33
    @B00Radl33 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    You make some incredible points and I love this conversation. But I want to make some points.
    1- the show spends a lot of time showing us how codependent Pearl is, by showing what happened after her partner died. Ruby is just as bad, maybe worse when forced away from Sapphire.
    But Garnet's purpose is to show power in healthy relationships.
    2- Rose Quartz is a hero, who made impossible choices, and took impossible chances for her friends. She gambled everything and lost.
    Pink Diamond was a bratty teenager. Who Pearl barely even met.
    And Bismuth wanted to murder Rose's mother and sisters. If someone ever shows you the gun they are going to use to kill your family members, it is no longer a disagreement. Even if they are your friend, even if they don't know you are related. Even if your siblings are involved in a war.
    Bismuth deserved better, but Rose was emotionally justified.

  • @maya.valverde8969
    @maya.valverde8969 ปีที่แล้ว

    make more of these pls these are my two fav shows

  • @ashantiwood3635
    @ashantiwood3635 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I actually agree pearl is a very fascinating character. Steven universe actually had me questioning some parts myself. I actually hated pearls character but then I realized I didn't like her character because pearl and I have damn near mirror traits. I had a relationship where I felt exactly like pearl to the point were it became obsessive but since are relationship ended prematurely and down right horrible. All these years I still have may questions. Could we have been happy together? Was the relationship wrong? Was it all my fault? Was I just a stupid little girl? Was everyone right about us about me? Etc. It messed me up so bad that my life ment literally nothing to me for over a decade. When I started watching Steven universe pearl character really hit me, it's had to validate yourself when you live for another person you forget that you matter especially when Noone there to tell you matter. Pearl character really hit me after she sang its over isn't it." You won and she choose you and she loved you now she gone. It's over isn't it why can't I move on. Now that I'm an adult I can tell myself yes that happen to me but that not all of me. And that I'm something.

  • @Devilcakes
    @Devilcakes 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    5:35 okay. So I just wanted to add in, Pink Pearl, now Volleyball, is shown to still have feelings for Pink diamond in the epilogue. It might be something baked into the pearls to prevent their willing defection from the authorities.

  • @Dfclt
    @Dfclt 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    damn it would be cool to see you cover more characters from different universes and not only adventure time

  • @First_Grafter
    @First_Grafter ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I completely watched Steven Universe start to finish multiple times and I never knew this
    Or this deeply
    Good video ❤

  • @alohaalonie3414
    @alohaalonie3414 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    CORRECTION:
    1. Pink diamond tried convincing the other Diamonds to stop the Earth colonization because she cared so much about humans. The Diamonds didn't want to so blue took some humans and made the zoo for pink. (THAT SHE DID NOT ASK FOR.)
    2. Bissmuth attack her first after Rose rejected her weapon, which rose didn't;t like because it shatters gems. (AKA kills them, bubbling doesn't kill them)
    3. Her leaving Spinel as she starting to mature and prove herself to the diamonds is equivalent to us when we stopped playing with toys. Spinel was a toy so I don't think she fully understood that spinel had more emotion considering she was always happy. bringing her or giving her to the diamonds would've been worse, bubbling was the good thing that couldve happened then.

  • @Angela-ie6ql
    @Angela-ie6ql 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I'm loving this videos❤

  • @jacobmartinez8865
    @jacobmartinez8865 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    She bubbled bismuth for a reason, bismuth wanted to shatter the diamonds (and Maybe other gems)

    • @justprixy5469
      @justprixy5469 ปีที่แล้ว

      Bismuth also wanted to shatter rose as roses self defense she had to bubble bismuth and my theory is that rose doesnt want the crystal gems to know that she bubbled bismuth because maybe she the crystal gems think her as a bad person or smt

  • @KydroxHD
    @KydroxHD ปีที่แล้ว

    I just found this channel. This is some good shit. Your lemongrab video hooked me, and this one reeled me in! Ez sub. Do a character analysis of Lapis next :)

  • @SilvaSnakeStudios
    @SilvaSnakeStudios 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    I think pearl definitely clings to what’s ever left , she is the lore basically , I don’t think those are tears of guilt , those are tears of genuine sadness , pearl did get married to bismuth after the show tho 😳 , but pearl makes me cry sometimes she is probably one of the most traumatized gem ( I don’t class Steven as a gem besties fight me I dare you 😘😘 ) pearl lost someone so important to her , pearl is so sad 😞
    Lol i have some headcanons for you
    Lesbian ( canon )
    Depressed (canon)
    Adhd & ocd ( canon? )
    And now some au’s
    Vicious pearl
    Teacher pearl
    Crazy pearl
    Paranoid pearl (ik she’s paranoid but still)
    Drunk pearl ☺️
    Lol have an amazing day remeber you are worth it you aren’t too skinny you aren’t to fat you aren’t boring you aren’t mean you aren’t bad
    Omg wait pearl isn’t annoying weird mother figure 🙃
    !!!

  • @user-wy6ln7uf9f
    @user-wy6ln7uf9f 13 วันที่ผ่านมา

    i believe pearl has bpd. she does risky life-threatening things like walking on the edge of the penthouse in the “mr.greg” episode, drives a car really fast, always shifts in the way how she percepts herself. pink/rose quartz is obviously her fp, she can’t imagine living without her even after she’s gone. the emptiness, the gimmick of the discipline to make her escape from the reality and so on… i, as a bdp person myself, can relate to her. she’s not doing sh, i wonder if it’s related to the gem nature, but all other things are possible depicting bpd…

  • @P1p3r_i_Guess
    @P1p3r_i_Guess หลายเดือนก่อน

    6:59 “we all did what we had to during the war”

  • @red_light_3937
    @red_light_3937 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I love my waves of feelings I’ve always had for Pearl. I’ve loved her, I’ve been disappointed by what I thought was bad writing for her, I’ve felt deep sorrow & sympathy for her, I’ve felt pride in her, and now that the show is over I just live Pearls character & think she’s my favorite!

  • @TheHuntrees007
    @TheHuntrees007 ปีที่แล้ว

    Bangin'. You make me want to watch this show. Dang!

  • @GabibelleDuSwag
    @GabibelleDuSwag ปีที่แล้ว +4

    so so good video thank you!

  • @Zamu273
    @Zamu273 17 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    Wonder where you went.. holding out for more vids

  • @TomTom-vl9sb
    @TomTom-vl9sb ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I would love to see you cover infinity train!