I was actually in Nutty Putty caves a week to the day before John died. I was there for an after-school trip with some other, outdoorsy friends and a teacher. This event hits really close to home because I actually got stuck in the same tube John did a week later. Honestly, the only reason I walked away is because I decided to go down feet-first in my first attempt instead of head-first like John did. I had gotten as far down as I could and looking down awkwardly between my feet, I thought I could see the tunnel flatten out, and then open up into a larger chamber, so I decided to climb back up the pipe, flip around, and go down head first. As I started to move up, however, I hit my helmet on the ceiling, which dislodged my helmet-clipped light, and sent it clattering down the tube beneath my feet. From where I was positioned in my "chimney wedge" (for non climbers/spelunkers, it just means you have one foot pushed against the rock in front of you, and the other knelt under your but, with that foot wedged on the rock behind you, letting you rest your arms for a bit, and have them both free. Imagine the pose a hurdler makes right as they're jumping, with one leg forward and one tucked underneath and you have roughly the right idea in mind, though the tube was way too narrow to let you stretch your legs all the way like that), I looked down and could see that the light was facing away from me at an angle, and only a tiny bit of light was reflecting back. I scootched down just a bit, and with the light sitting where it had fallen, I could see that what I thought was an opening to a larger cavern was just a trick of the shadows, and the tube narrowed down into virtually nothing. My light started flickering, and a little bit later went out. I started freaking out, hyperventilating a bit (big no no), realizing I was alone, in the pitch dark, and I hadn't told my buddy I would be exploring this section of the cave. I could literally feel the walls of the cave closing around me, but know now it was just my chest getting larger and larger as I kept sucking down air. It took me a minute, but I paused, forced myself to calm down, and think through the situation. Panic is your number one enemy in these scenarios and will kill you faster than just about anything, by making you do something dumb, like climbing up enough to get space, flip around, go down head first, and try and find my headlamp in the dark --which I was considering in my panic. I forced myself to breathe slowly, and assess my situation. Was I hurt? No. Was I lost? Not necessarily; there was a fairly few number of turn offs between me and a main section of the cave. I could probably make it if I took it slow, even in the pitch black. What tools did I have? Helmet good, shoes still tied --and then I remembered, I had a back up light. It was some dinky little dollar-store light, but I had tested the batteries before, and knew it worked. I'd thrown it in my cargo pocket almost as an afterthought and forgotten it. But there it was. So I climbed back up using my back-up flashlight held between my teeth so I had my hands free, made it back to the group, explained what had happened, and told my buddy sorry for losing his headlight. He laughed and, I'll never forget, said, "It's fine. Not worth risking your life for." Fast forward a week to the following Friday, and my teacher (the same one who had organized the trip for us the week prior) pulls me aside after school, and asks if I can stay late for something urgent. I phone my mom right there at his desk, confirm, and then ask him what's going on. What he does next is really weird. He pulls up some really detailed maps of the Nutty Putty cave system, and lays out a bunch of photos on his desk of different passages, turns, etc. all in a random order. He then asks me to show him EXACTLY where I had gotten stuck the week before, using the maps and by arranging the pictures before he can tell me anything else. I do, and he then asks if I remembered him saying he was friends with several members of the cave search and rescue team for Utah. I confirm, and he tells me that the same friend that helped him get the permit for our go-through the week prior had just called and told him a spelunker had just gotten stuck, and it was serious. He said he needed me to confirm the spot I had gotten stuck in was the same one as John was, before he could (legally) show me/tell me anything else, because it was technically a 'crime scene' type situation. I don't remember the exact words he used for that, but basically, somewhere between HIPPA and "Someone might die soon" there's some laws that say search and rescue personnel can't just be sharing live info on the recovery efforts willy nilly. But, since I had verified that I had been in the exact spot John was now in... well, congratulations. I'd just been drafted into the search and rescue effort (in a tiny way). He put me on the phone with some people then, and they asked me questions about that section of the cave. There was only one map that had that section even partially mapped, so they asked about if I remembered seeing any side tunnels, and about what colors the soil and rock were, if I remembered any striations/layers in the rock down that section of the tube, and a bunch of other stuff that they were using to try and get a better assessment of what equipment might/might not work. He then showed me some of the pictures of the actual scene. They obviously had some people down there who could see the rocks for themselves and were way more expert than me, but I think they were mostly interested in what I had seen at the very bottom of the crevice, and if I had seen any openings down there, since Johns body was now blocking them from being able to see down that part themselves. I told them everything I could, and they thanked me, and I left. I think they had me call my mom right before I left too, and ask her permission to give my number to the Search and Rescue team in case they had any more questions (they had asked her for permission for my general involvement when I called her and asked her to pick me up later after school). Anyway, after that I left. That weekend, my teacher called me to thank me, and let me know that John had passed. It's.... sobering, to be honest. I see videos on the Nutty Putty caves accident pop up on horror channels every year or so, and I always mark them to watch later, but... I need to gear myself up for them because it all feels so... personal. It's like watching yourself dodge a bullet over, and over again, and then see someone else get hit by it. I honestly think I've probably got some level of survivor's guilt from it, wondering "what if I had dropped a big rock down the hole when I was done, to make it clear that you couldn't go down" or "what if I had just gone headfirst after my headlamp, and John was alive and well with his wife, child, and family today?" Maybe John would be sitting at his computer right now, typing up his memories about how he was scheduled to go to Nutty Putty caves just a week after it closed because a spelunker died there. Obviously, there's no point feeling guilty over it. But I'll never lose the sense of connection to John and his story. In a way, I feel like I've gotta live both of our lives for us, since through pure chance, I was spared, and he was taken by the same pit in Nutty Putty. RIP John. And to all his friends and family, live well in his memory.
Damn, this is a long post. I still can't figure out how the 6'0 tall, 200 pounds Jones was able to squeeze half of his body through such a tight hole. That makes no sense. Once his arms entered the hole, he should have been stuck right then and there.
There is absolutely no reason to do this. Your life is more important than some personal glory or thrill seeking. Don't do what that fool did by risking yourself. Life is short and I'd think you unlike him it seems, would not want to create such trauma upon family and friends as he and others liem him have to theirs.
I’ve been considering how to respond to some of the folks taking offense to this story in the comments, specifically because it is partially based around a horrific, real tragedy. First off, I do understand where you are coming from; it was a concern I initially had when the story idea came to me more than a year before I wrote it. Here are a few points I’d like to make that ultimately led me to decide to go forward with it. 1) The story is meant as an allegory for grief and/or ptsd. Jasper Grant is a fictional stand-in for the rescuers who tried and failed to save John Jones. I hope their experiences are nothing like what Jasper went through, but it was something that struck me as extremely emotionally compelling that should be explored. 2) John Jones is not the “villain” of this piece (the way I intended it). The voices/specter Jasper experiences are either a) in his head, manifestations of his misplaced guilt (as Dr. Feagles suggests) or b) a malevolent entity that initially trapped John and has assumed his form to better torment Jasper whom it has parasitically glommed onto, feeding on negative emotions like fear and sadness 3) Lastly, though the story idea made me uncomfortable, I decided that this is a work of fiction and a creepypasta at that. If the story makes people come out of it feeling uncomfortable or disturbed, well, my job as the author is accomplished. Sorry if it ended up not being to your liking, but I nevertheless appreciate everyone who listened and commented.
My good dude, ad a writer, you should know 'I see where you're coming from BUT - two paragraphs worth of unneeded explanation - Sorry you didn't like it," is an inadequate apology to the persons offended that a piece of fiction, a work of art - which means the goal doesn't matter, the interpretation does - was based on a legitimate tragedy. Were the living family consulted? The use of a deceased persons as a prop is in poor taste, regardless. Sorry if that's not to your liking.
I have to agree with Ozzi. Normally I'm all for artists and authors free expression but this wades into legal waters. You can't just throw a real person into your story as a prop. Public figures are fair game for parody or satire. John Jones is not a public figure. He's a victim of a tragedy. This would not qualify as fair use and it's rather poor taste. To speak plainly, his family could sue you. Even though John is dead his family still has what is called the, "Right of Publicity." This is why you typically don't see professional writers doing shit like this, it's more trouble than it's worth. It would have taken you no effort to create a fictional character to haunt Jasper. You used John because it gives your story more impact than it would have had otherwise. Which is sad because this is a good story, without the skeevy use of a dead kid as a prop.
Saw this story uploaded by CGS Creepy Ghost Stories yesterday but I thought it sounded too funny so I never gave it a listen. But now that you post it i feel like I have to listen I never miss out on your videos 😎
Whew.... Heavy stuff.. what an incredible story. And your VOICE, the way you can capture the spirit and draw emotions of each character. I forget that it's not like.. a full cast! You, Sir, are an Artist.
The story of John Jones and Nutty Putty cave is indeed true folks. A sad story indeed and a terrible way to die. And sad for his would be rescuers who I guess always asked themselves many questions.
I dont know which is worse the true story of this cave or the fictional one but the out come is still the same. Death. Great story and narration as always.
Great pick of a story! Thanks. And thanks for the link to the text. As always, it's great to read along as you narrate. Your voice brings so much depth to the story.
This story disturbed me so deeply, and this is one of those "Draw your own conclusion" endings. I have an intense fear of closed spaces, and this story is just a hard one for me to get through. As always Big Guy GREAT JOB!! God Bless you and your family.
This was an incredible story that you narrated very well. I was surprised to find out it was true. It was very suspenseful and tragic though. Thank you. Have a great day 💖 🌟
No disrespect to Skott, the story was beautifully narrated. Although this story is incredibly well written, I struggle with the depiction of John turning into a ghostly figure seeking revenge. I do not think John would have put any blame onto his rescuer's (to be honest that is nonsensical). John made the decision to go spelunking in Nutty Putty, the people who attempted his rescue put their own lives at risk and sat with him while he passed away. I can't help feeling this depiction is disrespectful to the people that suffered this real tragedy. Maybe I am being overly sensitive. I don't know...
Dang it, I just listened to CGS's version yesterday. It's an awesome story regardless, and I give you a like and comment for the algorithm anyways. Hope you're doing well Skott.
This is such a sad, yet horrific story. It's stuck with me since I 1st heard it! The movie that was done based on this event was really good, but it definitely showcased how traumatic it must've been for his fiance & brother. I cried through 90% of it!! Not sure I can handle listening to it again, but because I love Nature's Temper narrations so much, I'm gonna try....😕
This is a great story, I enjoyed immensely!!! I love your voice and narration 💙💙💙 Thank you for all the time and work you put into your vids!!! I appreciate you so much 💙🤗💙 Take care, stay safe and God bless you ❤️
Good story, but I'm definitely not good with turning the actual victim of a tragedy into a villain. Seems disrespectful to his family considering how recently this happened.
@@Raging_unicorn I'm sorry, but John's family and the people who worked the attempted rescue are alive and may come across this. It doesn't matter if it was 20 years ago. John wasn't a bad man and he sure as heck would not be seeking revenge and taunting the people who tried to get him out.
@@NaturesTemper I had a feeling you weren't aware. Accident happened on 24th November 2009. John Edward Jones. Really awful event. His body was never recovered, so the Cave was sealed and serves as a memorial to him.
As an amateur caver, the Nutty Putty incident is a real life horror and cautionary tale. This makes it SOOOO much worse! It never dawned on me that it is perfect circumstances to make an angry ghost!
Wait.... isn't this based off a true story? I recall seeing another video like this that did say a young man died upside down in a cave out in the midwest, and i believe it was the nutty putty cave too, as dumb as the name sounds...
utah, that was a cave that no one should have gone in, very small tight and cramped spaces. it was named after the clay that was found inside much of it
@@no_mnom except in those movies the producers have permission of the deceased personals family to make it. No one asked John’s family I’d it was okay to demonize him for this creepypasta.
All john wanted was a little company. Great narration and great story. To all of the people outraged by the use of a true event, remember this john chose to risk his life In that cave and became a cautionary tale amongst the caving community because of it. I always feel worse for the failed rescuers in these scenarios, they try their hardest but are still unable to save the person who has trapped themselves.
@@aerynstormcrow I totally understand this. It's very well written and Skott is the best. I just wish the author had changed some details. I do not think for a second that John would have proportioned any blame to the people who worked tirelessly to rescue him.
@@felineexceptional oh yeah the story is great. But leave John out of it, ya know? Choose a different cave name and a different ghost name. People might know who’s being referenced, but it’s not blatantly disrespectful that way. Also, whoever wrote it really opened themselves up for a lawsuit. Just a bad idea all around. But yeah, really good story otherwise.
@@aerynstormcrow Oh gosh, I hadn't thought about lawsuits... Yeah, most writers would have changed victim names and/or location names to prevent them being sued and put in the usual Fiction Disclaimer.. Not sure if that would be a road that the family would go down, but I would guarantee that the production company who made the movie and the rights would. Like you, my first thoughts were with Johns relatives, friends and the rescuers. It may have been almost 13 years ago, but I'm sure it hurts just the same as if it were yesterday.
Wow i'm always the last 🤣What is Ghosts of Nutty Putty🤣🤣sorry but i must laugh i'm very sorry ,nur i'm so happy to listen to your wonderful voice and story we have 8pm i sit at the sofa relax and listen to your story after i heard Amanda Jane also a wonderful artistbut then i'm at once here my friend 😘😁❤🖤🖐‼
Isn't this kinda in bad taste? There's lots of caving stories but to spin a dude that died just a few years ago into the story just seems kinda... euch. I could understand if this was actually telling John's story but instead it's spun into this fuckin' ghost story. It just seems kinda skeevy. The writer is just using this dead kid to give their story more oomph. They could have easily made up a dead caver to be the ghost haunting Jasper. Not to mention, the legality of putting a real person into your story is a bit iffy. Dunno if this qualifies as, "fair use." Lmao. Which btw, no shade on Naturestemper. He's just narrating and doing it well at that.
This is NOT okay! A real man (John Jones) lost his life in that cave and someone decided to fictionalize it into a creepypasta?! Absolutely not okay!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 85 | คู่เอก "ยอดเหล็กเพชร vs ผึ้งหลวง"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Qq_19bnnxEo/mqdefault.jpg)
I was actually in Nutty Putty caves a week to the day before John died.
I was there for an after-school trip with some other, outdoorsy friends and a teacher. This event hits really close to home because I actually got stuck in the same tube John did a week later. Honestly, the only reason I walked away is because I decided to go down feet-first in my first attempt instead of head-first like John did. I had gotten as far down as I could and looking down awkwardly between my feet, I thought I could see the tunnel flatten out, and then open up into a larger chamber, so I decided to climb back up the pipe, flip around, and go down head first.
As I started to move up, however, I hit my helmet on the ceiling, which dislodged my helmet-clipped light, and sent it clattering down the tube beneath my feet. From where I was positioned in my "chimney wedge" (for non climbers/spelunkers, it just means you have one foot pushed against the rock in front of you, and the other knelt under your but, with that foot wedged on the rock behind you, letting you rest your arms for a bit, and have them both free. Imagine the pose a hurdler makes right as they're jumping, with one leg forward and one tucked underneath and you have roughly the right idea in mind, though the tube was way too narrow to let you stretch your legs all the way like that), I looked down and could see that the light was facing away from me at an angle, and only a tiny bit of light was reflecting back. I scootched down just a bit, and with the light sitting where it had fallen, I could see that what I thought was an opening to a larger cavern was just a trick of the shadows, and the tube narrowed down into virtually nothing. My light started flickering, and a little bit later went out.
I started freaking out, hyperventilating a bit (big no no), realizing I was alone, in the pitch dark, and I hadn't told my buddy I would be exploring this section of the cave. I could literally feel the walls of the cave closing around me, but know now it was just my chest getting larger and larger as I kept sucking down air. It took me a minute, but I paused, forced myself to calm down, and think through the situation. Panic is your number one enemy in these scenarios and will kill you faster than just about anything, by making you do something dumb, like climbing up enough to get space, flip around, go down head first, and try and find my headlamp in the dark --which I was considering in my panic.
I forced myself to breathe slowly, and assess my situation. Was I hurt? No. Was I lost? Not necessarily; there was a fairly few number of turn offs between me and a main section of the cave. I could probably make it if I took it slow, even in the pitch black. What tools did I have? Helmet good, shoes still tied --and then I remembered, I had a back up light. It was some dinky little dollar-store light, but I had tested the batteries before, and knew it worked. I'd thrown it in my cargo pocket almost as an afterthought and forgotten it. But there it was.
So I climbed back up using my back-up flashlight held between my teeth so I had my hands free, made it back to the group, explained what had happened, and told my buddy sorry for losing his headlight. He laughed and, I'll never forget, said, "It's fine. Not worth risking your life for."
Fast forward a week to the following Friday, and my teacher (the same one who had organized the trip for us the week prior) pulls me aside after school, and asks if I can stay late for something urgent. I phone my mom right there at his desk, confirm, and then ask him what's going on.
What he does next is really weird. He pulls up some really detailed maps of the Nutty Putty cave system, and lays out a bunch of photos on his desk of different passages, turns, etc. all in a random order.
He then asks me to show him EXACTLY where I had gotten stuck the week before, using the maps and by arranging the pictures before he can tell me anything else. I do, and he then asks if I remembered him saying he was friends with several members of the cave search and rescue team for Utah. I confirm, and he tells me that the same friend that helped him get the permit for our go-through the week prior had just called and told him a spelunker had just gotten stuck, and it was serious.
He said he needed me to confirm the spot I had gotten stuck in was the same one as John was, before he could (legally) show me/tell me anything else, because it was technically a 'crime scene' type situation. I don't remember the exact words he used for that, but basically, somewhere between HIPPA and "Someone might die soon" there's some laws that say search and rescue personnel can't just be sharing live info on the recovery efforts willy nilly. But, since I had verified that I had been in the exact spot John was now in... well, congratulations. I'd just been drafted into the search and rescue effort (in a tiny way).
He put me on the phone with some people then, and they asked me questions about that section of the cave. There was only one map that had that section even partially mapped, so they asked about if I remembered seeing any side tunnels, and about what colors the soil and rock were, if I remembered any striations/layers in the rock down that section of the tube, and a bunch of other stuff that they were using to try and get a better assessment of what equipment might/might not work.
He then showed me some of the pictures of the actual scene. They obviously had some people down there who could see the rocks for themselves and were way more expert than me, but I think they were mostly interested in what I had seen at the very bottom of the crevice, and if I had seen any openings down there, since Johns body was now blocking them from being able to see down that part themselves.
I told them everything I could, and they thanked me, and I left. I think they had me call my mom right before I left too, and ask her permission to give my number to the Search and Rescue team in case they had any more questions (they had asked her for permission for my general involvement when I called her and asked her to pick me up later after school). Anyway, after that I left.
That weekend, my teacher called me to thank me, and let me know that John had passed.
It's.... sobering, to be honest. I see videos on the Nutty Putty caves accident pop up on horror channels every year or so, and I always mark them to watch later, but... I need to gear myself up for them because it all feels so... personal. It's like watching yourself dodge a bullet over, and over again, and then see someone else get hit by it. I honestly think I've probably got some level of survivor's guilt from it, wondering "what if I had dropped a big rock down the hole when I was done, to make it clear that you couldn't go down" or "what if I had just gone headfirst after my headlamp, and John was alive and well with his wife, child, and family today?"
Maybe John would be sitting at his computer right now, typing up his memories about how he was scheduled to go to Nutty Putty caves just a week after it closed because a spelunker died there.
Obviously, there's no point feeling guilty over it. But I'll never lose the sense of connection to John and his story. In a way, I feel like I've gotta live both of our lives for us, since through pure chance, I was spared, and he was taken by the same pit in Nutty Putty.
RIP John. And to all his friends and family, live well in his memory.
@Watch And Shoot i think some entity is tricking or luring people into that same spot
@@cutedpanda00 chill bro lol
Damn, this is a long post. I still can't figure out how the 6'0 tall, 200 pounds Jones was able to squeeze half of his body through such a tight hole. That makes no sense. Once his arms entered the hole, he should have been stuck right then and there.
Amazing story man. Glad you're ok and thanks for sharing
There is absolutely no reason to do this. Your life is more important than some personal glory or thrill seeking. Don't do what that fool did by risking yourself. Life is short and I'd think you unlike him it seems, would not want to create such trauma upon family and friends as he and others liem him have to theirs.
I’ve been considering how to respond to some of the folks taking offense to this story in the comments, specifically because it is partially based around a horrific, real tragedy. First off, I do understand where you are coming from; it was a concern I initially had when the story idea came to me more than a year before I wrote it. Here are a few points I’d like to make that ultimately led me to decide to go forward with it. 1) The story is meant as an allegory for grief and/or ptsd. Jasper Grant is a fictional stand-in for the rescuers who tried and failed to save John Jones. I hope their experiences are nothing like what Jasper went through, but it was something that struck me as extremely emotionally compelling that should be explored. 2) John Jones is not the “villain” of this piece (the way I intended it). The voices/specter Jasper experiences are either a) in his head, manifestations of his misplaced guilt (as Dr. Feagles suggests) or b) a malevolent entity that initially trapped John and has assumed his form to better torment Jasper whom it has parasitically glommed onto, feeding on negative emotions like fear and sadness 3) Lastly, though the story idea made me uncomfortable, I decided that this is a work of fiction and a creepypasta at that. If the story makes people come out of it feeling uncomfortable or disturbed, well, my job as the author is accomplished. Sorry if it ended up not being to your liking, but I nevertheless appreciate everyone who listened and commented.
My good dude, ad a writer, you should know 'I see where you're coming from BUT - two paragraphs worth of unneeded explanation - Sorry you didn't like it," is an inadequate apology to the persons offended that a piece of fiction, a work of art - which means the goal doesn't matter, the interpretation does - was based on a legitimate tragedy. Were the living family consulted? The use of a deceased persons as a prop is in poor taste, regardless. Sorry if that's not to your liking.
Ignore the snowflakes man. The story is good. Hollywood does it all the time yet when the average joe does it it’s wrong.🤨
Loved your story. I know that voice in your head that puts you down and criticising you no matter what you do.
I have to agree with Ozzi. Normally I'm all for artists and authors free expression but this wades into legal waters.
You can't just throw a real person into your story as a prop. Public figures are fair game for parody or satire. John Jones is not a public figure. He's a victim of a tragedy. This would not qualify as fair use and it's rather poor taste. To speak plainly, his family could sue you. Even though John is dead his family still has what is called the, "Right of Publicity." This is why you typically don't see professional writers doing shit like this, it's more trouble than it's worth.
It would have taken you no effort to create a fictional character to haunt Jasper.
You used John because it gives your story more impact than it would have had otherwise.
Which is sad because this is a good story, without the skeevy use of a dead kid as a prop.
Keep doing you're thing I think you did a awesome job.
Saw this story uploaded by CGS Creepy Ghost Stories yesterday but I thought it sounded too funny so I never gave it a listen. But now that you post it i feel like I have to listen I never miss out on your videos 😎
Nutty putty is true horror honestly but there have been worse caving incidents.
I swear the extreme cavers are insane
@@no_mnom Oh dang this is new to me ive never heard about the caving accident before. Cavers are crazy to do what they do.
Whew.... Heavy stuff.. what an incredible story. And your VOICE, the way you can capture the spirit and draw emotions of each character. I forget that it's not like.. a full cast! You, Sir, are an Artist.
The story of John Jones and Nutty Putty cave is indeed true folks. A sad story indeed and a terrible way to die. And sad for his would be rescuers who I guess always asked themselves many questions.
This has to be one of the most horrifying ways to die. Ive seen numerous docos on it. Thank you so much for this.
I dont know which is worse the true story of this cave or the fictional one but the out come is still the same. Death. Great story and narration as always.
Great pick of a story! Thanks. And thanks for the link to the text. As always, it's great to read along as you narrate. Your voice brings so much depth to the story.
It’s a fictionalized account of John Jones’ death. It’s not okay that this exists.
Excellent Storytelling Nature's Temper! 🤗 This Author always writes such Great Stories! Thanks Skott! 🤷♀️✌💜👻🐶😻🐢🐾🍄💋👀🙏
You’re a great narrator!!! Fantastic voice and story telling, sound and style.
This story disturbed me so deeply, and this is one of those "Draw your own conclusion" endings. I have an intense fear of closed spaces, and this story is just a hard one for me to get through. As always Big Guy GREAT JOB!! God Bless you and your family.
SUCH A GOOD STORY! Your narration of this is awesome
This was an incredible story that you narrated very well. I was surprised to find out it was true. It was very suspenseful and tragic though. Thank you. Have a great day 💖 🌟
No disrespect to Skott, the story was beautifully narrated. Although this story is incredibly well written, I struggle with the depiction of John turning into a ghostly figure seeking revenge. I do not think John would have put any blame onto his rescuer's (to be honest that is nonsensical). John made the decision to go spelunking in Nutty Putty, the people who attempted his rescue put their own lives at risk and sat with him while he passed away. I can't help feeling this depiction is disrespectful to the people that suffered this real tragedy. Maybe I am being overly sensitive. I don't know...
You can stop being dramatic now
@@jebuschrist9161 Right back at ya.
@@felineexceptional I don’t think you understand what being dramatic is. Your name must be Karen.
@@jebuschrist9161 Ok Hun.
@feline exceptional As someone who has spelunked in Nutty Putty, I completely agree. No shade on Skott, but this story is in bad taste.
That was AWESOME!! ❤️❤️❤️
Dang it, I just listened to CGS's version yesterday. It's an awesome story regardless, and I give you a like and comment for the algorithm anyways. Hope you're doing well Skott.
Oh that was in my state. So very sad.
This is such a sad, yet horrific story. It's stuck with me since I 1st heard it! The movie that was done based on this event was really good, but it definitely showcased how traumatic it must've been for his fiance & brother. I cried through 90% of it!! Not sure I can handle listening to it again, but because I love Nature's Temper narrations so much, I'm gonna try....😕
Can already tell this is going to be awesome!
Awesome work!!!
This is a great story, I enjoyed immensely!!! I love your voice and narration 💙💙💙 Thank you for all the time and work you put into your vids!!! I appreciate you so much 💙🤗💙
Take care, stay safe and God bless you ❤️
Mr Ballen has a episode about nutty putty cave.
Same incident/story
I love Ballen's channel
This is a true story. The guy died and they sealed him on the cave. Nobody can go back in now.
Brutal story.
I.absolutely hatw the concept of cavIng it screams for a darwin award and these stoeies.always twist my stomach, so un that sense great job,,
What a title. If it were by anyone but SS I would've assumed it were a parody and left it for a later date but curiosity got the better of me.
My ultimate nightmare! 😱😱😱
Good story, but I'm definitely not good with turning the actual victim of a tragedy into a villain. Seems disrespectful to his family considering how recently this happened.
It was over a decade ago, it wasn't recent at all.
@@Raging_unicorn I'm sorry, but John's family and the people who worked the attempted rescue are alive and may come across this. It doesn't matter if it was 20 years ago. John wasn't a bad man and he sure as heck would not be seeking revenge and taunting the people who tried to get him out.
Very much in agreement.
Oh wow I actually had no idea this was based on an actual event
@@NaturesTemper I had a feeling you weren't aware. Accident happened on 24th November 2009. John Edward Jones. Really awful event. His body was never recovered, so the Cave was sealed and serves as a memorial to him.
As an amateur caver, the Nutty Putty incident is a real life horror and cautionary tale. This makes it SOOOO much worse! It never dawned on me that it is perfect circumstances to make an angry ghost!
Wait.... isn't this based off a true story? I recall seeing another video like this that did say a young man died upside down in a cave out in the midwest, and i believe it was the nutty putty cave too, as dumb as the name sounds...
Yes it is.
It's based off the incident I assume like those "based on a real story" movies
utah, that was a cave that no one should have gone in, very small tight and cramped spaces. it was named after the clay that was found inside much of it
@@no_mnom except in those movies the producers have permission of the deceased personals family to make it. No one asked John’s family I’d it was okay to demonize him for this creepypasta.
@@aerynstormcrow why are you going out of your way to make problems?
The true story was horrific. It amazes me that these idiots even THINK to wriggle into such situations, but what a terrible way to die.
All john wanted was a little company. Great narration and great story. To all of the people outraged by the use of a true event, remember this john chose to risk his life In that cave and became a cautionary tale amongst the caving community because of it. I always feel worse for the failed rescuers in these scenarios, they try their hardest but are still unable to save the person who has trapped themselves.
I think there is entity on that cave that luring people into that spot where jhon dies
John's a real ghosthole.
From the title i was expecting a ghost to jump out of a plastic egg.
Temper i fucken love you
Damn it can’t end like that!
Man, that was terrible! I had been hoping for a happy ending, and then this!
Well that cut off abruptly
Them: What cute Nickname did you give your Girlfriend?
Me: *the Title*
My fat ass read the title as "Ghosts of nutty buddy"...
Daughter of the man who died in real life would be about 13 now. Hopefully she didn't listen to this.
♥️
Oh no 😢 depression and suicide are in the works!! How unlucky can one man get????
Well this is nightmare fuel.
Stay out of caves people 🙂
It’s a fictionalized account of a recent true story. Personally I find it really disrespectful to the real John.
@@aerynstormcrow I totally understand this. It's very well written and Skott is the best. I just wish the author had changed some details. I do not think for a second that John would have proportioned any blame to the people who worked tirelessly to rescue him.
@@felineexceptional oh yeah the story is great. But leave John out of it, ya know? Choose a different cave name and a different ghost name. People might know who’s being referenced, but it’s not blatantly disrespectful that way. Also, whoever wrote it really opened themselves up for a lawsuit. Just a bad idea all around. But yeah, really good story otherwise.
@@aerynstormcrow Oh gosh, I hadn't thought about lawsuits... Yeah, most writers would have changed victim names and/or location names to prevent them being sued and put in the usual Fiction Disclaimer.. Not sure if that would be a road that the family would go down, but I would guarantee that the production company who made the movie and the rights would. Like you, my first thoughts were with Johns relatives, friends and the rescuers. It may have been almost 13 years ago, but I'm sure it hurts just the same as if it were yesterday.
mary kapusta..just read this story but she was half in a bottle of gin. your'e a better reader
Whos mary kapusta?
Yeah. And what kind of gin?
#82-✅👍🏻
Scott...creepy G just did this story yesterday
Ok
Wow i'm always the last 🤣What is Ghosts of Nutty Putty🤣🤣sorry but i must laugh i'm very sorry ,nur i'm so happy to listen to your wonderful voice and story we have 8pm i sit at the sofa relax and listen to your story after i heard Amanda Jane also a wonderful artistbut then i'm at once here my friend 😘😁❤🖤🖐‼
Nutty Putty cave, named for the soft clay inside, is now the sealed tomb of John Jones.
@@corlenajames1381 Thanks so much for the info i found the name so funny.Nowi learned something new
Isn't this kinda in bad taste? There's lots of caving stories but to spin a dude that died just a few years ago into the story just seems kinda... euch.
I could understand if this was actually telling John's story but instead it's spun into this fuckin' ghost story.
It just seems kinda skeevy. The writer is just using this dead kid to give their story more oomph. They could have easily made up a dead caver to be the ghost haunting Jasper.
Not to mention, the legality of putting a real person into your story is a bit iffy. Dunno if this qualifies as, "fair use." Lmao.
Which btw, no shade on Naturestemper. He's just narrating and doing it well at that.
This is NOT okay! A real man (John Jones) lost his life in that cave and someone decided to fictionalize it into a creepypasta?! Absolutely not okay!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬
I'm first
Great narration but bad story.
It's a true story.. Nutty Putty cave is his tomb
@@paladln13 the caver story itself is awesome. The horror story, not so much
Sorry but I can't stop laughing at the name Nutty Putty.
You know what happened at Nutty Putty cave?