Lessons from the Golden Era of Andalusia | Al Jazeera World
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2018
- Saadane Benbabaali is an Algerian academic whose ancestors came from what is now the southern Spanish region of Andalusia. He has retired from teaching literature and Arabic at Paris University III. But for 15 years, Benbabaali has led groups of students on annual trips to Andalusia to share his passion and knowledge about the region and its rich history.
He believes that the period of Arab Muslim rule over the Iberian peninsula was arguably the only time in European history when Muslims, Jews and Christians lived relatively peacefully together, producing a common culture and harmonious society.
He also thinks that the period and place have powerful lessons for what he sees as today's fractured world.
"There were beautiful periods of co-existence in Andalusia. So why not today? We need to cultivate the spirit of optimism in people ... Today, the difference is that everyone thinks they own the truth and will confront others. They're even prepared to kill for this," Benbabaali says.
In 711, Muslim forces entered the Iberian peninsula from North Africa. They eventually occupied most of present-day Portugal, Spain and parts of southern France, which became known as al-Andalus as it joined the expanding Umayyad Empire
During the Islamic 'golden age' between the 8th and 14th century, al-Andalus became a hub for social and cultural exchange, while the arts, science, architecture, agriculture, medicine and mathemathics flourished.
Many attribute these achievements to religious tolerance and collaboration between Muslims, Christians and Jews, which is why that period of history is also sometimes referred to as La Convivencia, or co-existence.
The era also produced some of the most significant scholars, poets, musicians, philosophers, historians and thinkers of the medieval age - such as Ibn Arabi, Ibn Rushd (also known as Averroes), al-Zarqali (Arzachel in Latin), al-Zahrawi (Abulcasis in Latin) and Ibn Firnas, among others.
"Today we need all those [Andalusian] philosophers, thinkers and Sufis, who like Ibn Arabi made love the basis of human relationships," says Benbabaali.
The retired university teacher subscribes to a school of thought that considers Andalusia's golden age to have been a beacon of enlightenment for Europe and the lands around the Mediterranean Sea.
"Andalusia is a world that belongs to the past but this past had a reputation and an impact on the people who experienced it and left behind a culture, music and ideas that still exist today," says Benbabaali.
The 'Reconquista' of al-Andalus
As time passed, however, internal conflict resulted in the emergence of competing city-states and led to a gradual weakening of central power and influence.
Muslim rule over al-Andalus came to an end in 1492 with the conclusion of the "Reconquista," a centuries-long campaign by Christian states aimed at recapturing the territories that had previously been taken by Muslim forces.
Queen Isabella I of Castille and King Ferdinand II of Aragon initiated the Spanish Inquisition, aimed at re-establishing Catholic orthodoxy across their kingdoms. After royal decrees in 1492 and 1502, Jews and Muslims were ordered to convert to Christianity or leave Spain.
An era of tolerance, peace and co-existence had come to an end - and even the descendants of those Muslims who did convert to Christianity, known as "Moriscos", were expelled from the country by King Philip in 1609.
But, for some, the golden age of Islam still remains in the collective Muslim memory.
A video of Mouaz al-Nass, a young Syrian Islamic musician, went viral after he gave the adhan [the Muslim call to prayer] in Spain's Alhambra Palace, which was built by the Muslim rulers of Granada in the 1330s. It's believed to have been be the first adhan heard there for 500 years and has been viewed over a million times on social media. Nass reportedly said he felt the walls of the palace missed 'hearing the call to Allah'.
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
More from Al Jazeera World on:
TH-cam - aje.io/aljazeeraworldYT
Facebook - / aljazeeraworld
Twitter - / aljazeera_world
Visit our website - www.aljazeera.com/aljazeeraworld
Subscribe to AJE on TH-cam - aje.io/YTsubscribe
#AlJazeeraWorld #Andalusia #AlJazeeraEnglish - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
I was born in the capital of the actual Andalusia, Seville, and I totally think it's a blessing. I have so much pride in my heritage. Thank you for the documentary!!
Can we keep in touch?
I m Pakistani but I love the history of the Andalusia when I read I feel myself in that era, it's my wish to see Andalusia granada
Therese & Coco say it clear the Hagia Sophia grand MOSQUE 🕌
Your a beautiful lady Cristina
@@theresecoco1887 trash & caca stfu
Thank you, Aljazeera you're already saved an epic history!
Nope .they put romantic ideas for you to eat up and feal good about your intolerante religion.we still have stories about how peacefull it was.we dont forget and dont eat your lies
Turkey invided Roman Empire and took all the Christian churches that where in Greek territory. This must be known. Also you should beg pardon for invading Spain in the year 711. What do you say aboput it? You know I´m saying the truth.
@@pepeluis6923 and who exactly did the empire belong to and how exactly it came into being....dont tire yourself for someone from the history.
@@pedroismaelo There is nothing romantic you don't know the history behind you are lead by emotions and hate.
Read history from Memoinod the Jewish rabbi from Al Andalus.
@@realitytube6290 i dont have to read Foreigners history.we have our history of centuries of islam invasion.the real history written by the people, the woman kidnapings the slavery the taxations,the hate towards others.f of with your taqya or your islam bias
So much Spanish blood was shed before they regained freedom
What a documentary you make always inspiring
جميل و جميل جدا !!
Muchísimas gracias por ese documento. Me encanta y mucho !!
Very very proud of you all, you have made my day happier
I enjoyed your documentary. Thank you!
By seeing this it left a great impact on my soul of humanity
Madina úl zahra was beautiful lasted only less then 100 year.
I really enjoyed the ANDULUSIA REGION IT WAS BEAUTIFUL.
Yes Spain is beautiful. Beautiful language, churches, sea, wine, ancient history,
Very beautiful documentary thanks for all of you
amazing work. plausible in every aspect.
Thanks a million to Aljazeera.
Respect from Bangladesh to the honorable faculty member, all the learners as well as other people who involved in exploring the knowledge regarding the golden history of Andalusia...
May Almighty Allah keep you on way to real success in both life...
The History of Andalus belongs to Spaniards
16:42. The "excuse" is that the Islamic conquests brought 700 years of religious conflict to Iberia and the Spanish were tired of it. The expulsion of the Moors put an end to it.
Friendly reminder that the the vast majority of the massacres of that time were by christians living in al andalus
yes, after 700 years. for reference, America existed for about 200.
@@G73ServerRappel amical si les musulmans ne seraient pas venu OCCUPÉ L'HISPANIA CHRÉTIENNE RIEN NE SERAIT ARRIVÉ
What about the Visitgoths? Why does everyone forget about them and pretends that they never existed?
Because it would offend Al-Jazeera
They were absorbed by the dominant moorish culture
@@asheru9254 You mean like the Amazigh?
@@gordh3081 No. The Moorish Islamic culture that dominated the Iberian peninsular.
@@asheru9254 the one run by Arabs and Berbers you mean
This video is more of a history of a one teacher rather than the history of Andulusia let a lone the lessons we need to obtain from it. 🙃
Underneath the Alhambra there are rooms without doors and windows where Christian slaves were let down by ropes from a hole in the ceiling. Traditional Islam
😬
beautifully put together report 👍👍💎
Only it dealt with Arabs, not with Spanish people
“Relatively peaceful co-existence”
Antarctica is relatively warm compared to the depths of space
@juanancriadillas Agreed. Spain is a nice country whose culture and cuisine are rich and diverse and does not need to be under the immoral yoke of Islam.
@juanancriadillas They always lie. Islam is a creed of war and destruction ultimately but as history has shown we must be vigilant and united against a threat looking to become strong enough to do this. Thanks for highlighting the terrible past events. I am from the UK but visited Barcelona once with my family and was captivated by it's beauty today.
@juanancriadillas Agreed. They scream that awful adhan as a cry of conquest (as TRT crow about) and yes: They do have that Gang Mentality
@@abel7459 And?
find it the Mother of Ironies that
Immediately the ummah forsake that desolate primitive desert 🏜️ for the Greek Persian inspired city of Damascus, then bhagdad then constantinople today istanbul
Why is it these golden age or alleged great Islamic center of learnings never took place in Mecca Medina ?
Basically standing on the shoulders of the disbeliver giant
Amazing
Andalusia did not exist in the Middle Ages and is a modern region of Spain, it has nothing to do with Al Andalus which is the name that the Arabs gave to the Iberian Peninsula. Do not confuse Andalusia with Al Andalus, it has nothing to do with it. They can continue dreaming but Andalusians (not to be confused with andalusí) do not feel any affinity with the Arab or Muslim world, we are a modern Spanish and European region.
Al Jazeera's documentary is always well researched.
Music and drinking 🍷 wine and women dancing 💃 was the reason in the end for the fall of the caliphate in the Al Andalus.
Cet pluto l'armée Chrétienne qui ont foutu DEHORS vos ancêtres voleurs des terres CHRÉTIENNES EUROPÉENNE ☪️🧹🧹
best Channel
So we have Frenchie yearning for the past in Spain. What a touchy feely romanticized revisionist documentary. You would think that if the Spaniards had coexisted under Islamic rule it would have lasted.
It lasted close to 800 years you moron.
@@xj5634 no it didnt. They were at each other throats for 800 yesrs. And bt the way 800 years only in Granada, about 5% of Iberia
@@xj5634 no it didn't last as a place of coexistence for 800 years
Amazing indeed 🥀🥀🥀🥀 Thank you 😢😢😢🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏
Thanks so much for posting!
Granada/ Alhambra, Sévilla/ Giralda y Alcazar, Cordoba/ Mezquita y Madinat az-Zahra: merveilles de la culture ibéro-arabo-bérbère!
Museums apart from the beautiful Cathedral
4 old buildings. Used as museums for tourists. Spain washed out Arabic, Arab customs and ideology, Arabs.
There is nothing Arabic in Andalusia apart from a couple of monuments
@@jmcr1963 same happened in Istanbul. Nothing byzantine apart ftom the Haghia Sophia and perhaps some ruins.
de qu'elle culture arabo berbère il y a en Espagne ???
Ne raconté pas des idioties Al Andalus est mort depuis près de 9 siècles , et la culture Espagnole est Occidental
Andalus did indeed have a happy ending. The Spaniards reclaimed their country. It is indeed a happy place sunshine, sea, guitar music, the Spanish language, the Pueblos Blancos, amazing Serrano ham on crusty bread, red Andalucian wine, sherry, large areas of wild erness....
Happy ending? Andalusia is one of the poorest regions in Spain and with the highests rates of unemployment. Spanish landlords ("terratenientes") have been exploiting this land and its people for centuries. I'm sorry, but as Andalusian myself I cannot consider it a happy ending. It's kind of a bittersweet outcome.
@@ecarmona_ so, what to do go back under Islamic tyranny
@ Blackbird Flying, however, it's still better than Morocco and other Northern African states. Indeed, Spain being the promised land for these people.
@@ecarmona_ so you would rather be like Morrocco? Andalusians don't risk their lives to reach Morrocan shores. The opposite, yes. If Andalucia has a huge unemployement, well centuries of islam have got its toll, my friend.
@@alfredoarroyo9201 @MrPinoCavallo @SIR Lord Henry mortimer That's not what I was implying. You need to read more history and less xenophobic right-wing pamphlets. The latifundia have played a crucial role in the current poverty in Andalusia and they started with the wrongly named "Reconquista".
Andalusia is a colony within Spain: we are cheap labour for the big Spanish companies, the autonomous community that has the highest rate of latifundia, unemployment and poverty, our resources are extracted by Spanish companies that pay taxes in Madrid, not Andalusia, our way of speaking and our customs are constantly mocked and stereotyped by the Spanish (and sometimes even claimed as mainly Spanish when they think our cultural elements are worth it, e.g. flamenco, the Andalusian copla or the Andalusian horse).
So please, stop saying that xenophobic bullshit about Morocco and the "islamic tyranny". Morocco has nothing to do in this matter and I am not going to talk about their situation there. Nor does the Islam of the Middle Ages in al-Andalus have anything to do with the situation of Islamic countries today.
You should stop talking nonsense if you don't know what it's like to live in Andalusia and listen to the people who do live here.
Islamic heritage n attractive culture in Al Andalus is so great n tres magnifique. Warmest greeting n Salam from 232 Indonesian muslim. Its awakened my beautiful memory when I was in Cordova, Alhambra n Toledo. Islam is the greatest
find it the Mother of Ironies that
Immediately the ummah forsake that desolate primitive desert 🏜️ for the Greek Persian inspired city of Damascus, then bhagdad then constantinople today istanbul
Why is it these golden age or alleged great Islamic center of learnings never took place in Mecca Medina ?
Basically standing on the shoulders of the disbeliver giant
@Kris Nestor
Pope Calixtus III, April 1455 promises and vows to the Holy Trinity,
Father, Son, and Holy Ghost,
to exalt the true Faith and to extirpate the diabolical sect of the reprobate and faithless Mohammed in the East. For there the light of Faith is almost completely extinguished.
to reconquer Constantinople, from Mahomet II, the son of the devil and the enemy of our Crucified Redeemer. Further, I vow to deliver the Christians held in slavery, by the followers of Mohammads
The History of the Popes from the Close of the Middle Ages, Volume II (1891), p. 346
You don't know a thing mate.
Spain not al andalus
Martyrs of Córdoba,Sacks of Córdoba (1009-13),1066 Granada massacre,The Day of the Ditch
Make a documentary about this
What?
The man's ancestors didn't come from Spain. They were from North Africa and they invaded Spain
Conquered
Funny u say that...
Berbers
Game changer you must have had a difficult childhood
Nice, Al Andalusia.💚
Al Andalus was bad for Europe
@@sirlordhenrymortimer6620 lol
@@abuqadr629 rip your logic
Saying al-Andalusia is insulting history, al-Andalus is not Andalusia
@geriondetartesos3949 Al Andalous c'était un pays de voleurs venu d'Afrique que les Hispaniques CHRÉTIENS n'ont jamais reconnu , cet pourquoi ils n'ont JAMAIS cessé de leurs faire la guerre a ces voleurs 781 annes . Et l'andalusie n'existe pas a cette époque mais L'HISPANIA
Beautiful
Ohh tariq bin ziads Spain.....
Spain is nonomuslim western European first world democracy they have no intrest in islam today,king felipes and cuca gamarra Spain.Lord Jesus belongs there
Is there any way to get a recording of Clelia Bergerot's beautiful Andalusian Music shown on 5:17?
The lesson should be that invasion creates a reaction, a Reconquista. This collective experience should have taken place in Saudi Arabia not in Spain
That song they were playing around the 15:30 mark sound like "Adelita" from Mexico.
Literally stop calling it the golden era when my people were enslaved
Lol rubbish
Yeah :/
Literally, a golden era
👏👏🫶👍🙌🙌
Tal cual🌹❤️
😍
In this video at 4 minutes played an Arabic song with female voice. Can anyone share me thats lyrics or song?
اغنية عجبت منك ومني في تقرير بصوت من غناها
InshaAllah I will vistit Alandalus. This region fascinates me. 🇧🇪♥️🇪🇸☪️🇸🇦
Make sure you use the word "Spain" . You might end up in Afghanistan
Spain*
Al-Andalus doesn’t exist anymore. You’d be visiting the modern region called Andalucía mainly. There are historic sites in Extremadura, Murcia, Castilla etc to see as well
Don't come you are not welcome
I don't get it why putting Saudi Flag? The only countries concerned by myslim Spain are Portugal Spain Morocco and West Algeria. Stop appropriating our history please
Teach multiculturalism to your Muslim brothers
Have you learned it???? Seems not from your genocidal friends in Delhi
@@atruenut Hindus have been practicing tolerance and multiculturalism for thousands of years. But everyone's patience has limits.
@@gordh3081 But the Hindus persecuted the Buddhists & the Hindus of lower cast were oppressed. To be honest,most of the people in South Asia are extremely emotional & they react violently when their emotions are attacked & it is applicable in case of religion, cricket or other sports , philosophy, language, rituals or culture.
The only country that still practise caste system among themselves
andalus...oh andalus..you are my dream!!
Yes especially Marbella
Please make video about ottomon rule of europa
Alhambra is truly a wonder - the most amazing palace ever!!! Granada was amazing, too.
Yes marvelous celebration every second January. Very near the Alhambra you can get amazing jamón iberico and red wine
Visiting Alhambra was one of the most amazing places in Spain and, surprisingly, I wore an Arizona hat and someone from nearby was also there and greeted us, too. I certain I'll return there perhaps in a year or two - have a close friend in Spain.
Anyone know the name of this tour?
I'd like a word with the person who came up with the title, please.
👍
27:43 I see Jon Snow!
😆
I want to learn Andulisia more😥
There is no country called Andalusia mate
@@marioformosa4259 🥵 Autonomous Community all have they're own history and Culture and about Andalusia he Meant he want to learn about the Golden era of Spainish Knowledge when Europe was in dark age
@@masfiqratul7559 dark age did not exist FYI. There was a christian revival of the culture in Europe coming from Ireland. Yes perhaps knowledge was lost about many things but it was not like they describe in movies all cold, poverty, diseases,etc.
By the way islamic conquest did not happen by handing out flowers. It happened by killing.
@@jgappy5643 I always tell these Abdul’s and the Arabized people that before al andalus it was called Hispania
@@masfiqratul7559 U r right, this is called Ranesa in Europe !!!
Thanks, Al-Jazeera for the Islamic golden age series, continue it... The westerns have already minded and I've seen many of them doing their 'own version' of Islamic Golden Age and Islamic culture and history and thus misleading few and leading the Islamophobes...
[no offence, comments unnecessary]
Lol.stop eating this b.s.there was never a golden age.your religion is to mutch intolerante to have Peace today imagine centuries ago.the amount of lstories we have in litle villages from centuries ago really dont agree with this b.s.piece.
@juanancriadillas what are you saying idiot brainwashed lol what spain it is andalusia you destroyed them kill aztecs incas and moors it was capital of science
@juanancriadillas sooo...what happen to your country who slayed hundreds of thousands of native american and south east asian?! Any words for them?!
I gonna tell you the Islamic Golden Age in the Iberian Peninsula: Massive religious and political repression of the native people, 3 time for taxes and no political security at all, no rights to worship or build a Church and slave trade particularly of the people of the North of the Peninsula in the souk of Cordoba. Notable reasons to become Islamophobic. Take my comment from the North of the Peninsula.
@@Jawadkhaann golden age,lol.bunch of liars.
The only reason they leaved peacefully was the fact that Islam was the main ruler of that era , Under Islamic law .
@@Holyproperty ISIS destroyed !!! New Zealand rises !!! Europe will answer the call
Sofia Cathedral in Istambul is a Christian Cathedral. When are you going to give us back that Cahedral?
@Sadaqat Ali that's big time lie. No proove to claim! Even turks can't claim let alone you muslin from south asia.
@@girdharsingh4287 It was bought by Sultan Mehmed the conquerer.
@@mariyabiswas3391 where is your evidence of that
How about the grand mezquita?
@@girdharsingh4287Giridhar from India,Mind your own business,why do you Hindus wade into affairs not of your concern
They believe that they made a documentary on andalusia but nobody spoke Spanish.
Joydeep De Andalusia was using Arabic language in the period they talking about
Well, Joydeep De you just exposed your American ignorance - read a book and educate yourself. The language of Andalusia was Arabic!
Are you just a silly fool? The Teacher/professor spent his career teaching in Paris and the majority of people on this tour are French. Furthermore, are you saying that a documentary about Andulusia cannot be made in any language other than Arabic or Spanish? Please wake up!
You seem to have some real anger issues.
Could you do a sound research on Islam without knowing Arabic? To understand the timeless Andalucia, I think it is important to know that culture in its entirety. Andalucia was a beautiful mix of three cultures. Only looking through the angel of Islam is seemingly ignorant. How do you think of Andalucia without embracing flamenco, without Lorca? This documentary seems to be biased towards only one aspect of Andalucia and therefore reflects a poor quality of these people. Andalucia demands more rigorous efforts.
The prosperity of this world depends on the peaceful co-existence of different region followers as they lived about 700 years in Andalusia. The researchers should forward their research findings for making this World the most beautiful and peacful in future. The Muslim, The Jews and many Christian do worship of only one God, the creator of all creation. Thus no enmity among followers of Sacred Books given by God.
Peacefully to include massacres, destruction, enslavement.
No enmity to other humans whatsoever. We should not judge other men religion,whatever his religion is. God is the only one who judges. We must be careful not thinking we are able to do this better then God. But yes, we should learn to coexist. I think the beautiful society that emerges from this is nothing ever seen in human history.
Peaceful?, It was a 700 years near constant fighting..
@@pragueexpat5106les musulmans parle to ut le temps du paradis Al Andalus, mais bizarrement ils oublient que leurs venu ont apporté a L'Hispania Chrétienne 783 année de Guerre .
Les Chrétiens n'ont jamais reconnu Al Andalus pays de Voleurs venu d'Afrique.
Haaa HYPOCRESIE quand tu nous tiens ....
His ancestors came from North Africa who later invaded Spain
The last part had me dying.
The golden era of Andalusia is now...
and when they conquered all the world and Seville became the centre of the world....the overhyping of the Moorish occupation is nonsense.
Liar
Ignorance
Western idiocracy - what a shame you people know nothing about that history …even in the museums you cannot find any history about the Islamic times that were more then 600 years …
Read "The Myth of an Andalusian Paradise."
Can anyone please tell me the sufi song sang at 3:52-4:06 timeline of this video?
عجبت منك و مني يا منية المتمني ادنيتني منك حتى. ظننت انك مني وغبت في الوجد حتى افنيتني بك عني. يا نعمتي في حياتي. وراحتي بعد دفني. مالي بغيرك انس. اذ كنت خوفي وامني يا من رياض معاني وقد حوت كل فن وان تمنت شيئا. فأنت كل التمني
@@benabdullah6249 can you give me the link of this song?
@@benabdullah6249 hi Ben....
Rim Banna ,Astonished by you and me on TH-cam I believe
Like the documentary of aljazeera about crusades there is a need to make documentary on Muslim rise n fall in Spain.
No need. It has already been forgotten, not being relevant to Spanish people
Now its a concrete jungle, rip my beauty
I'm frm Malaysia - & Andalucia has been one of my fascinations - & for many Arabs that ancestors were from the part of the region, they should always be proud
The region is morocco
Berbers not arabs
Spain is not Araby
Proud of the slave center of Europe
@@onewildandcrazyguy9213 stfu
min. 42:++: "...the conquest of Al Andalus was complete by 1492. ...exile and Jews were expelled. The grand era of tolerance, peace, and coexistence had come to a painful end."
Only a pea-brained idiot would believe that the miraculous Reconquista took place if things were good.
Beautiful. Europe without Islam historic effect would've been dark frozen swamp.
Yeah, all those aqueducts, or the Greek medicine or arches that the Arabs copied were just waiting for the arabs to be invented out of the mass of pagan semitic peoples before... already... inventing... all of that...
Yes, without Greek and Roman effort, the arabs would still be worshipping fire.
It's not that hard, especially since there was European civilisations before there were even arabs, just like there were jews before there was islam.
@@Oscuros Civilization nor science began with Greeks and how does that help your demographic decline in 2019.
@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed keep lying to yourself
@Martin Woo I'm talking demographics you're pushing conspiracy theories and fear pandering
@@Oscuros Civilization & Science started from Mesopotamia (Iraq) & Egypt.
Sufism is the other name of ignorance which have nothing to do with Islam or practical life. Islam is very simple covering all the aspects of life of which worshipping Allah and serving humanity are top.
My mother took a dna test and Andalusia came up as one of her top results.
They actually said "Andalusia"?
@@giltedged7529 yes. Why?
@@michellebadillo7574 Because there is no distinct Andalusian
i’m melayu but i love spain history😁
Yes especially Las Navas de Tolosa
@@marioformosa4259 2:60
@@marioformosa4259 Tú no eres español.
@@torrezno1990 Los españoles no son árabes ni quieren serlo
@@torrezno1990y usted es Espanol ??
Myths console in times of dissolution
Andalusia was born in 1970 as an Autonomous Community, here we speak of Al-Andalus, not Andalusia because Andalusia and Al-Andalus are completely different things, At no time during the reconquest did the border between Christianity and Islam coincide with the borders of the current
the first time the term Andalusia is heard is in the fifteenth century
@@samuelcumbrerarodriguez3958 no, these lands were called Al-Andalus, and after the reconquest they were baptized as Castilla la Nuevisima or New Castilla, the term Andalusia is created by Blash Infante in the 20th century
@@geriondetartesos3949 There is no country called Al-Andalus
@@geriondetartesos3949Les Hispanic Chrétiens qui ce sont Battus contre l'ocupant musulman pendant 783 annes de guerre n'ont jamais reconnu Al Andalus
Depuis les ROMAINS c'etai L'Hispania et maintenant cet l'Espagne CHRÉTIENNE
@@geriondetartesos3949ces terres appelés Al Andalus n'ont jamais existé aux yeux des Hispanic Chrétiens . C'était toujours L'HISPANIA CHRÉTIENNE avec la naissance des Royaumes Ibériques comme le Portugal , Castille , Aragon
MASHA ALLAH
salutation to all the moors
A bit of a myth the andalusian paradise. Christains were still 2nd class
If one is to understand the south of the United States before 1866 one would have to spend a great deal of time focusing in on slavery. If one wants to understand Andalusian Spain one will have to spend a great deal of time focusing in on slavery in Islamic spain. Slavery was a huge part of Islamic Spain's history. Cordoba was the slave capital of Europe for a while. Most of the slaves were northern European and Eastern European Christians as well as sub-Saharan Africans many of whom were castrated. Funny how this part of Andalusian Spain is either almost always ignored or glossed over
It should be better than forced to convert, killed or expelled like what the Spanish Inquisition did.
Over night, the most tolerant nation had become the most intolerant according to one historian.
@@anaskpalmalaki8804 sure. Whenever anybody says something about Islamic Spain that isn't extremely complimentary people always say Europe is worse Europe is worse Europe is worse. Yes we get that. But that's no excuse for romanticizing Islamic Spain. When you say the most tolerant Nation are you talking about Islamic Spain. I don't know where you get that from. And there is a period of time where Jews were fleeing Islamic Spain to Catholic Spain and Catholic Spain was far more tolerant than Islamic Spain
@@anaskpalmalaki8804 who was the most tolerant Nation.
@@anaskpalmalaki8804 that historian is a fool.
Alhamdulillah love to you. I'm proud of our heritage. May Allah bless us to regain our heritages including great mosque of Cordova and Alhambra. Thank you
Peaceful lecturer of a peaceful religion having a peaceful aspirations.
Ton héritage??, tu fume quoi 😂 ce qui se trouve en Espagne est au espagnols et sûrement Au musulmans venu d'Afrique ou d'ailleurs
A lot angry right wingers in the comments, but your hate can't change the fact that spain/Portugal was under Muslim rule for over 800 years.
You are right
But as per my knowledge it's 700 years peaceful and beautiful rule in Spain and Portugal.800 years is also right.
@@kw6570 go back to your muslim country
@Cromwellian Protectorate Republican i correct you 10000 years really . you are a big liar it s time to go bed
@Cromwellian Protectorate Republican rule collonialism like did in asia africa australia
That was Al Andalus then, but now it belongs to the Spaniards and Portuguese. The Moors, mainly Berbers, have conquered it and nothing from Islam gives the Muslim the right to conquer and unite someone else's land.
Islam disappeared in all countries where Islam was spread with conquest and war. Look at the countries conquered by the Ottomans. What is left of Islam? Look at the countries conquered by the Moors: Spain, Portugal, Malta, Sicily and Sardinia.
there are 57 muslim nations three continets
The Islamic culture with its rich architectural beauty makes me proud. It's not the end because of the Christian & Jew oppression, but one day the Islamic culture & heritage will be regained but not to worry, that time we will welcome & respect the other religions as our Islam that wouldn't teach us to hate others but to live in together with tranquillity.
@Lars Nielsen we never think of bombing somewhere & grab this place & we personally I don't want any more war.The world & the innocent people suffered & still suffering a lot & nuclear war......no way.Anyway,In Islam,it's forbidden to curse anyone but could I wish u!!
No harm in dreaming. Such a primitive , desert ideology
Sure charla hebdo is one of that example.
He is algerian so amazigh, simple as that 🤷🏻♂️
Lol not everyone in Algeria is Berber there are Arabs too.
Qthetar the big majority are arabised berbers, not arab of blood. Various scientific studies have proven that
@Hamza being black doesn’t mean anything. An arab can marry black and his blood won’t change just the color.
So logically most morriscos have amazigh ancestry rather arab!?
10% of Spaniards have arab ancestry.
🇲🇦🇲🇦🇪🇸🇪🇸
🇲🇦🚽☪️🧹🧹🧹🧹🧹🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦✝️🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦
Stop trying to steal our history and culture. Al Andalus will always be the land of my ancestors. Arabic and northern African people were a minority and most of the population were Spanish Latin people converted to Islam in order to not to pay the jizya. Later on their descendants converted back to Christianity. And that is the Spanish people today. A mixture of everything in the Mediterranean sea. You are welcome to visit or to stay, but don't even think about recreating a Muslim Spain. We're already sick of religions. We are a democratic non confessional state and Al Andalus is my history, not some guy's from Africa or Asia.
Mon ami tu as raison de dire que Al Andalus fait partie de notre histoire Ibérique.
Mais je tiens à corrigé une petite chose.
L'ocupation musulmane a imposé par l'épée Al andalus pays imaginaire qui a déclenché une Guerre de 781 annes entre les autochtones Chrétiens et musulman . Nos ancêtres chrétiens Hispanic ils ont jamais reconnu Al Andalus cet pourquoi en 1236 Al Andalus fût détruit et en 1492 c'était enfin fini . l'Espagne et le Portugal ces les enfants de L'HISPANIA IBÉRIQUE CHRÉTIENNE
SALUDOS DE STRASBOURG COMPADRE .☪️💩🧹
✝️🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦✝️
Some incongruity in the editing in regards to chronology in this documentary, like...showing shots of Granada while talking about Cordoba! Has anyone else caught this?
Where r the Rafdis and Ajami Mini Rafdis particularly Pakistanis who always bark against Ummayds?
Ok
very informative regarding golden era of Muslim Spain..
You mean 800 years of us being slaves and raped?
@EuropaNostra Muslim spain is called Muslim spain.
@@danielhernandez-vo9zc bullshit
One side of the story how about the brutal part?
@@francismuiruri9064 If there are a period of time where the Christians experience some sort of Violence as you claim to be when is it if i may ask?
Spain is a happy land, Muslim countries beyond the Mediterranean, miserable. There was no Golden Age . If there was one, it certainly didn't reach North Africa
back then islamic world was a superpower
@@hussainashraf5179 nonsenses it always a miserable culture
It was not a golden age because Jews and Christians were considered second class citizens in Al Andulus. They were Dhimmis in a land that was theirs. The Moors were the invaders and they were driven back whence they came.
Reconquesta saved Spain from barbarian desert cult
Aljazeera forget to mention Roman Catholic heritage before the Islamic Spain
Andalucia is not the land of Saadane's ancestors. If he is Algerian, his land is Algeria. Otherwise, his ancestors would have invaded and occupied Andalucia for centuries, but that was not their land.
You have no idea of how arab kept their nasab and lineage up to thousand year
In west, most people are born out of wedlock.. You need to do dna testing to determine your parents
@@asmrnaturecat984 I know perfectly well who my parents are, thanks. And I am very proud of them. None of them are either Algerians. There are studies that demonstrate that people from Iberia share around 10% of DNA with people from North Africa (berebers, btw, not Arabs. With Arabas basically we share close to 0%) and people from North Africa share about the same of iberian DNA. That is not strange since until the invasion of Arabs, the North and South sides of the Mediterranean were the same political entity for hundred of years, until the Arab armies forever split this wonderful cohabitation
@@alfredoarroyo9201Vérifié vos sources.
Le nord ouest de l'Espagne est de 11% et le reste de 4%. Viva Santiago Matamoros.
Mío cid is coming 😂
Help me 🙏
I'm from Huelva near Seville
Et moi de Badajoz ......près de Séville 🤣
Myth and fantasy like an islamic Avalon.
The Moors & Berbers left such a rich culture influence to Spaniards & Portuguese. You would think they would embrace that instead of ignoring it.
Arabs not berber
Who’s ignoring it? The Romans also left a deep impression on Iberia, just as they did in North Africa, in fact deeper than the Moors as our laws are based on Roman law. If you visit Spain you will find that we are proud of our long history and try to preserve all vestiges of our varied past.
@@meadc6754 proud of your blood thirsty ignorant hysterical Isabella and her husband who believed they were pardoned before starting the massacre? Surely you gotta acknowledge their atrocities not only to the people but also distraction of the most tolerant and advanced society exist at the time?
🤡🤡🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Horrible!
اسلامی حکومت کے وقت اسپین بھوت ھی بہتر اور خوبصورت تھا
In Sha Allah Al-Andalus will Return To it’s Original Islamic Country For islam in Spain Are Growing Religion Fast Even in North America and South Latin America islam is Growing Fast
Keep on dreaming. You lot can’t even protect your Palestinian brothers from the slow genocide being inflicted on them. Saudi Arabia, birthplace of your prophet, is an ally of Israel as is Egypt and now Morocco. Hypocrites is what you are.
Spain was never originally Islamic. Before the Muslim invasions we were already Christians that’s why the push to get the moors out of Spain was considered a holy war,
@@meadc6754 we protected spain against the viking the 2 sons of ragnar
@@rayrussoEspèce d'arriérés vos ancêtres ont apporté a mon pays 781 annes de guerre , tu comprend l'abruti, ils ont fait de l'esclavagisme sexuelle etc etc
À Quand les excuses bande de 🖕💩☪️🚽🧹🧹
سينطلق البربر من الجزائر والمغرب لتناطح
للتذكير في ذاك الوقت لم تكن القوميات المسلمين حكمو وسادو بتاعونهم وتعاونو بتركهم للقوميات كان العربي لايعرف ان البربري بربري والعكس صحيح
ارتقووو لستم من حررا الاندلس
لا احد يعرف جده كيف كان هل كان صالح ام خائن
الجزائر عربية
حديث:
"لا فرق بين أعجمي وعربي إلا بالتقوى،"
I find it the Mother of Ironies that
Immediately the ummah forsake that desolate primitive desert 🏜️ for the Greek Persian inspired city of Damascus, then bhagdad then constantinople today istanbul
Why is it these golden age or alleged great Islamic center of learnings never took place in Mecca Medina ?
Basically standing on the shoulders of the disbeliver giant
Please watch Christian Prince :V
*DEUS VULT* !!!!