Which RC Radio - Transmitter comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2020
- Which RC Radio - Transmitter comparison
FlySky Palladin PL-18 - bit.ly/32wwslE
Flysky FS-i6
Radiomaster TX16S - bit.ly/38SmBaY
Taranis X9D+
Taranis Q X7 - bit.ly/3iQgI2m
Taranis X Lite
Tafanis X9 Lite
Like, Subscribe & Ding the 🔔 - bit.ly/ANsubscribe
🎥 Video Recording Gear 🎤
In the Field
► Onboard camera Mobius C2 - bit.ly/2RLNLLg
► Hatcam Firefly 8S 90º with external mic - bit.ly/2DwAP2V
► External Microphone - bit.ly/30SwvDB
In the Workshop
► Wide workbench cam - GoPro HERO7 Black and Firefly 8S 170º - bit.ly/FF8S170
► Close up workbench cam - Panasonic Lumix LX10 1080 50fps
► Audio recording - Rode smartLav+ mic in Samsung A8 - bit.ly/2ZK6GGy
► Video Editing in Final Cut Pro X on 27" iMac
► All the Action cameras I have reviewed - newtonairlines.blogspot.com/20...
🔎 More information 🔍
► Newton Airlines Uncut - bit.ly/NewtonAirlinesUncut
► Newton Airlines blog - newtonairlines.blogspot.com.au
► Links for my build materials - newtonairlines.blogspot.com/20...
► Andrew Newton TH-cam - / andrewnewtonaustralia
► My portal - anewton.net
► iNav Basics and FAQs - newtonairlines.blogspot.com/s...
► All my iNav CLI Dump files - bit.ly/2t2OPz7
►My FPV gear - newtonairlines.blogspot.com.a...
►Favourite iNav gear
Matek F405 Wing FCB - bit.ly/2SI3bAv
iNav GPS - bit.ly/2ERre6w
Beitian BN-880 GPS - bit.ly/2K7hdHc
► Depron Armin Wing build - • Depron wing build
► Skyshark P4X spars - www.kitesandfunthings.com/Pro...
► Knauf XPS Hot Wire Foam panels - www.bunnings.com.au/our-range...
► GBC EZLOAD laminating film (May be discontinued) - shop.quadient.com.au/products...
► Alternative 75 micron laminating film (not tried by me) - www.boundtoimpress.com.au/sho...
► Depron and foam board - My 6mm and 3mm depron came from www.tradewarehouse.com.au But from 2020 it seems they no longer sell proper depron. I have not found another supplier yet.
👌🏽Support this channel 👌🏽
This is a fun hobby for me, not a money making venture.
I don't have a Patreon account, and choose the minimum possible advertising option.
However if you would like to support this channel here are some options
►Direct donations to Paypal.Me - paypal.me/apnewton
►Affiliate links - BANGGOOD RC - bit.ly/2R7LMgg
If you use the affiliate link to make a purchase I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
👀 No single review will tell the whole story. Be clever, watch other reviews and shop around before making any purchase.
#AndrewNewton #transmittercomparision #bestrcradio
Thank you! Very good review! I bought the FlySky FS-i6 five years ago for my first radio. I planned on upgrading if I stayed with the RC hobby. Installed the 10 channel firmware and haven't bought another radio. I can't find a compelling reason to spend more money yet. This little FS-i6 flies all 20 of the airplanes in my hanger. I'll come back and watch this again if I ever change my mind.
went to several radios, ended up going back to my FlySky i10, just love the simple functions
this video is stellar! thank you so much. just getting in to the hobby and am doing my research. thank you for being to the point and fluffless. Thanks for including so much detail. iv been looking at a lot of reviews for transmitters and you hit a lot of points that nobody else touched on, and you were specific about it! great video. thanks a bunch!
You're very welcome!
Nice comparison ...
I was waiting for this video...
Great review. very informative
Great review Andrew! I use a hitec flash 8 myself and it does the job well. Dead easy to use
Your rc radio collection so cool sir, love it
Could have done with this a week ago :) Just pulled the trigger on the Paladin after being so impressed with my FS-I6 and the range and reliability I get from it . Also I found it very easy and intuitive to use, so I hope the Paladin is similar.
Glider setup video with the PL18 coming soon.
Hi Andrew. Now you've done a comparison of radios, it's time to compare receivers. I currently fly Spektrum (DX9) but now I'm getting into flight-controllers, I'm encountering two problems with that radio: One, I'm running short of channels to utilise the programmable features on the FC and two, I can't find any inexpensive DSMX receivers (or Spektrum models for that matter) that have a serial output. (SRXL, in Spektrumese.) Cheers!
range test is the most important thing in my opinion!
Yes, of course including that it performs the servo commands!
Thanks for sharing your opinion
Great info on radios
For me FlySky is my fpv and flight controller radio.FlySky also has a wide range of very affordable and long-range receivers. Spectrum is for my warbirds and line-of-sight flying. Easy to set up and voice can be applied to all the switches. My open text radio got corrupted firmware and is a paperweight that I've never managed to fix.
Another excellent review covering an almost impossible subject area [to cover in 20 minutes at least]. Having the TX16s, X9D+,Jumpert16 and Dx6 as my main radios I have settles into using my radiomaster as my current daily driver. It seems to do the trick for me.
Again great video.
Thanks Jason, hard to go past the TX16s if you're buying one now.
Nice radio video, I have the 9XD and like it.
Wow, how do you remember all the details from all those radios! 😮
Good information, thanks Andrew. 👍
Ha, it wasn't easy. Lots of pauses edited out.
It really is a shame that FlySky has made toy looking transmitters in the past. The protocol has always been superior to FrSky. For 35 USD you get a transmitter capable of 4Km range and Crossfire level latency right out of the box. You don't have to worry about inverted/non-inverted with iBus. With custom firmware you have 10 channels, complete telemetry, and many additional settings on a transmitter that kids, and small adults, can handle easily. I have a Q X7 now as my main controller, but for those of us who grew up with cheap FlySky, we scratch our heads when the FrSky fanboys talk about failsafe. What is this failsafe you speak of?!? LOL
Couldn't agree more. I started out with the Flysky fs-i6, then got an i6x..for the money there is nothing on the planet that can beat it..Fact! its got the lowest latency going and is cheap as hell. I still use mine in both various quads and wings. Yes the quality is not up there with the big boys...but? Can anyone match it for its functions vs price? No they cant.
My Flysky i6x is my go to at the moment. Its cheap, I did an antenna mod and it now has two three position switches (I fried my first I6x trying out Li Po's lol). I'm waiting on my signal booster to arrive for more range but for the type of flying I do its perfect. Maybe I'll get Jumper once the finances stabilize. LOL GREAT VIDEO!
Good one mate.
Totally agree with your choice on Qx7 jog wheel..it just feels right and works great. I only use a Qx7 and Fs-i6x
Totally agree!
I am a pinch flyer for helis. I got my first OpenTx radio few months ago X9 lite. It took me about 2 days to learn it coming from Spektrum and Futaba. Ergonomically had to get use to the gimbals spacing ( space between the gimbals sticks) being much narrower. I am thinking of getting either X9D or the QX7 for wider gimbal space. Don't have any examples to try out in person.
I originally started out with a Flysky fs-i6x..absolutely amazing, still use it. And iv only just finished mastering the Taranis Qx7, which with crossfire im happy with. Do we really need to be buying the newest radios that come out..Honestly? Or am i missing something?
Been using Frsky X9d since they arrived in the UK, think it was 2013. Now Opentx is vastly different from then, still love it. My regular flier is an X10 but also bought a Radiomaster T16s. Agree with all your findings. Good review. 👍
Good to hear
I’m a big fan of the QX7 maybe because it was first OpenTX radio, been using mine for over 3 years and still love it. FrSky has annoyed me with the whole ACCESS debacle and R9 issues but it’s been a workhorse for over 3 years and I still love it.
OpenTX has a ton of features but there’s plenty of tutorials online for setting up the things we generally want to do with our planes and mini quads, it can be daunting though I agree.
Speaking of the OpenTX steep learning curve, how about some Newton Airlines OpenTX Tips & Tricks? I find I do initial model setup on the computer and then making some additional programming, like Expo, on the radio itself. I then keep all my models in a handy folder. It also makes swapping different models in and out of the radio if wanted. Great video!
Big playlist of my OTX videos th-cam.com/play/PLC8MdCMvxwBh_Pkp1EkLilgWcK8CQINd9.html
Nice radio review Andrew! 🖐️🤠 So far I believe the RadioMaster is doing good. I wouldn't mind the Flysky's newest Palladin, I have the Flysky FSi6 radio. I never owned the Frysky series, but like you said, it's a well built radio, which I wouldn't mind having. I currently own the flysky FSi6, the very first Jumper T8SG, Jumper T16 pro v2, Jumper TX T8SG, and the Jumper T8sg plus v2 thats not working (stuck in USB mode).Thanks for sharing!
Ha, good collection
A lot of this is "Greek" to me, but it definitely will point me in in the right direction. Thanx ! - Robert
You're a mindreader!
10 channel firmware update on the flysky i6x , works perfect for me , simple to program , light weight , portable and cheap can't beat it in my opinion
Nice comparison Andrew! I only have a PL18 and a DX6i, so not much to compare, but you are spot on with the quality of the PL18. Its a very nice radio, but as you say the FW is still a work in progress and the latest release hasn’t helped. It does have the FlySky assistant software to backup and restore models, but no configuration. Have a great day 😁
They are considering SD card option, more models and different voice. Good improvements if they eventuate
you can rabbit on all you like I always learn something from your vids....love your work.
Haha, thanks
2019 versions of the Taranis X9D have vertical scroll wheel for menu navigation. Im using the X9D+ SE and chose it over the qx7 on ergonomics and the ability to use high power TBS Crossfire modules without modification. I'd be interested to see your review of the Team Blacksheep Tango 2.
Unlikely to test any TBS gear, I have no need for long range
I wouldnt disagree with anything you have said at all Andrew. I only own a X9D+ as well as an old Spektrum DX7 but have had a play/feel of all the others bar the Palladin.
I am going to be getting a TX16S to replace my old DX7 though.. mainly for its outstanding value and being multi protocol. My X9D+ may or may not be retired to spare duties. I'll have to wait and see how well the TX16S performs over the long term to see if it earns it..
Grear video to give newcommers plenty of food for thought.
which rc radio + receiver would you recommend for the Freewing AL37? I do not want to spend more than something like 300-350$
Radiomaster TX16 with FrSKY X8R receiver would be my choice
Good stuff Andrew,
I went for the Paladin - going from FrSky 2.4Ghz module in a Turnigy Er9X - skipping the QX7 and straight to the big gun...Haven't flown with it yet - got it a bit over a week ago - Using it to fly Xplane at the moment during Lockdown :)
However - a lot of programming I have done with it for a new Fixed wing UAV I am building I think I have everything 100% as I like it via iNav and Matek F765.
I initially programmed the side sliders for the Camera gimbal, but find that the detent is not fluid enough, so programmed a set of Logic Conditions within iNav to enable that when one of the Switches is flicked it changes the Left stick for Pitch and Yaw into a Gimbal control - making super smooth operation. Still yet to test it in flight, but should be very quick and easy to flick back to Flight controls if needed, the Side slider is still enabled as general manual control, Also hoping that when in a Navigation pattern it will maintain flight regardless of the Logic conditions.
Something from my perspective - for those forgoing the Paladin due to not having Open Firmware - is that if you are using a Fully programmable flight controller, the OS of the Remote is potentially almost irrelevant for a lot of operations and features, for instance I found that no matter what the setup is on the Paladin, 99% of the work is done by the Flight Controller anyway, including the Mixing, Logic Conditions, etc. So really all I have essentially done is pass ALL the switches, knobs, gimbals down from the Transmitter to the Receiver via Sbus, and got the FC to do the rest.
SO where Transmitter OS' would come more into play I think would be maybe for PID and tuning once everything is already programmed, as well is if NOT using a Flight Controller on a Fixed wing, or maybe wanting certain channels to go Direct to a Servo or Relay and not via the Flight Controller (maybe for failsafe or emergency parachute if FC was on the fritz! ) This of course may be quite different for a lot of people...
Very good points. Just about any radio is OK for FCB
I love my DX8, but when I need sbus, I use my X9D plus.
Q X7 was mi first radio and Ibreally love it. But with all the crap FrSky is doing I'm probably going to get a Radiomaster soon
Congrads on getting to 50K subscribers ! - Robert
Thank you so much 😀
@@AndrewNewton How many SUBSCRIBERS do you need to get a Wall Plaque ?
Looking at the Detrum RC system
They are sending the Blitz radio to me for review soon
Having dunked a DX8 in salt water, I now use the FS-i6 for RC sailing; cheap and has all the features I need. I fly planes with a DX9; expensive but defines quality. I fly quads with a TX16S with the TBS Micro TX in the back. If I started today I would buy the TX16S for all flying; great value for $$$.
Yes, hard to go past the TX16S
Good Day Andrew, Hope you are doing well. Have you done any testing on connecting the Radiomaster TX16S. wireless setup for trainer and connecting to a Flysky FSI6X as the student?
No. Would need the specific Flysky cable
@@AndrewNewton I was under the impression if the Radiomaster radio had a Frsky DJT external module you could connect wirelessly but perhaps that is not a option. Have a safe day.
You forgot to look at the T18. A clear winner as far as I'm concerned. Much nicer design than the TX16S. Getting excellent range with the internal module and pcb antenna. Replaces my T16 and 9XR Pro. Well satisfied with it.
Coming soon
Do you think T18 is worth the upgrade over T16 with internal module, USB C charging, and hall gimbals?
@@MikeMPharmaCyclist yes too many problems with that USB charging..Get the T18 and add BobAZ's 21700 5000mah battery and charger. You wont regret it. Love mine and am getting excellent range with the internal module and pcb antenna.
@@52griz interesting, I'll definitely consider that. I've been loving my T16 so far.
Thx for the video. How difficult is it to set up a basic 4 or 5 channel airplane with open tx? I thought I saw that it has some sort of wizard that makes it simple. I'm just flying basic planes.
I have attempted to make that video a few times and scrapped it. I'll try again soon. Yes there is a wizard to help.
Yes Andrew, I would have to agree about the Screens and Navigation.
I find the Taranis QX7 so much easier and quicker, and really why do you need colour when the only time that I really look at the screen is to select what Model I am flying.
Love "Companion" as you know, I think the word "Nerd" was used.
Put a pair of M7 Hall effect gimbals on it (plus your Hack) and it is the elite Transmitter...And for the Rich folk The FrSky Horus!!
Cheers
Nice comparison.Have you done,or who would you recommend for an up to date tutorial on OpenTX,and OpenTX companion.I purchased an X9+ACCST version just before the ACCESS protocol came out.Most tutorials I've seen are years old,and I'm a little anxious of conflict between the two protocols.Thanks in advance.
Check out Painless360's channel for ALL things OpenTX. Also in this case old videos are not necessarily bad, if they predate ACCESS, which everybody should just avoid.
@@cruisingaltitude5284 Thanks for the reply.i've been suscribed to Painless 360 for awhile,just sorting it out is a little intimidating.Came from Spektrum,which seems simpler,maybe less full featured
@@dcsmith5839 I got a DX6 last year for some HH RTF models and was shocked to find those don't even send RSSI. But on the hand you're certainly right, it was very easy to edit when coming from OpenTX. In any case, the programming of models didn't change at all with ACCESS protocol, it was just an attempt by FrSky to make people replace all their receivers.
I own the jumper t8sg, jumper t16 pro, flysky i6, jumper t18 pro, and the radiomaster tx16s! Out of them all...... I choose the radiomaster over all the others by far!!! I'm just going to sell the rest.
I use the T8SG+ and like it's size and weight. Why do you prefer the TX16S?
You can use a multi protocol module with the flysky i6, it uses ppm from the trainer port.
The paladins physical features and o.s are very very similar to the flysky i10, a very easy radio to setup using the colour touchscreen and graphical interface, just hope they release more firmware updates for the paladin than they did for the i10 as the stopped as soon as they fixed known bugs and went interested in further development which is a shame because the i10 spanks all other flysky radios with the exception of the paladin but could have been even better than it was
For me the flysky is a win win radio, im still on the fsai6 but do have an FSi6x waiting to go into service, i dont need huge range and they just work, though i may do the 2nd 3 pos switch mod on the i6X
i've had both the i6 and i6x
i prefer the i6, because you can flash flyplus firmware to it
sadly mine is dead
Andrew, I noticed you didn't mention the Spektrum brand radios, is it because you don't own one or don't recommend the investment in one? I know the Protocol is DSM/DSMX. Just thought to ask. I own a Jumper T16 Pro but OpenTX can be rough at times for me. Still learning it but I'm really looking towards simplicity of my plane and drones.
Just that I don't have one. Hold my flying buddies swear by Spectrum.
QX7's (Dial) is my favourite aswell, 👍 Maybe a slightly improved QX7 with additonal Dials (X9D) and internal Multiprotocolmodule (16S) would be my choice in the future.
Oh yes that would suit me too.
Ordered t16s but processing time on bg today is a joke
What is the best high end radio for RC glider?
Tandem X20 is quite good, but I still prefer the Taranis QX7
@@AndrewNewton taranis qx7 or x9 lite s?
Great Video Andrew, will the TBS module fit the X Lite ?
I guess yes, cause I had a multiprotocol module in the bay but not a tbs crossfire.
check frsky website . I had sold all my frsky stuff
Dont know sorry
Great review andrew.. between X9d plus Se and tx16s which one will you go for?
I would choose the X9D+ SE. Dont need multi protocol and not so keen on the colour version of OTX
Flysky FSTH9x or Taranis Q7? Is fsth9x good?
I started with the original 9X. Taranis Q X7 is a step up if you can afford it.
I've had a different experience with radio's, my first was a hk 6ch one model Tx, it was ultra reliable but my model numbers increased past 6 and it became a hassle re maidening each plane, so I went for a Turnigy 9x, another great radio again I ran out of model numbers, so I got a 9xr which held 30 model memory with a flysky module in it excellent Tx, Then I bought a 9xr-pro and put the same flysky module in it, it was great also with vocalising models as you select them, when the qx-7 came out the 60 model memory got me hooked! so I purchased the qx-7 which I currently use, it has hall gimbals fitted because my aileron stick was getting sloppy?? I've since added a 4 in 1 module to the Taranis qx-7 which is my daily, the 9xr-pro is another Tx I really liked I updated it's firmware to the same as the qx-7 with 60 model memory but rarely use it now, unnoteworthy Tx's I've had a Walkera (heli's) and a IrangeX multi protocol (feels like a toy) not recommended ..
my list: HK tx, Turnigy 9x, Turnigy 9xr, Turnigy 9xr-pro, Taranis QX-7 as my current tx,
Great vid as always Andrew,
My history with transmitters is almost identical, but I had a 2ch 72MHz Futaba first.
if you flash flyplus firmware to the fsi6, you get 14ch and more settings
@@allenmoore9848 github.com/qba667/FlySkyI6/releases/tag/1.7.6
there are plenty tutorials on youtube on how to do the flashing
@@allenmoore9848 I used the 10 channel mod for my Flysky i6 - refer to the Bojangles mod video here >>> www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwif1q_Gp_7qAhWPyTgGHZgNA2gQwqsBMAB6BAgIEAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DOKkZpP55p9g&usg=AOvVaw02wj2J0QetrHFrF5vBUvzy
If you do upgrade to 10 ch or 14 ch you'll need the USB cable to connect the Tx to your PC >>> www.banggood.com/FlySky-Data-Cable-USB-Download-Line-For-FS-i6-FS-T6-Transmitter-Firmware-Update-p-982289.html?cur_warehouse=CN&rmmds=buy
One thing to keep in mind is there are a few mod code options out there, the bojangles one is probably the most common imo. I avoided going to 14 channels on my i6 cause to really use 14 channels you really should add the additional Tx switch (there is another mod on bojangles code site for this) but you will find you'll have to use combinations of switches and knob positions to effectively use all the available channels, which you program into the i6 radio. Keeping things down to 10 channels kept thing simple and really if you need more than 10 channels then having a better radio with dedicated switches is probably a better approach unless youre good at setting up switch combos you can remember.
@@allenmoore9848 good luck :)
i liked this more than what is on the i6x
I use only Spektrum, I think the best consumer radio
Spektrum builds solid radios for hardware. Their protocol and programming is limited.
@@zmanphx I agree. The 'canned' mixes are good for noobs but their limiting factor as well.
Best maybe if you're not into anything detailed or interesting but just basic RC. If you want to make unique builds and really understand what you're doing and get the most out of the hobby, there are far cheaper and more capable options than anything from Spektrum. I have a Spektrum DX6i from 6 years ago, a great radio for its time but competition has destroyed Spektrum in the current market.
you can replace the switches in the Taranis with Horus Switches. Much better quality.
Yes I must do that, thanks
My local model shop is convinced these new Chinese open OS radios are not the best of choices - how come you haven't added Spektrum, Futaba, Radiolink, Hitec, Multiplex etc to your comparison?
If you want to buy them and send to me I will redo the video
@@AndrewNewton please I need it
👍👀🇭🇷
The granddaddy is the Horus mate.
Just picked up a horus x12s second hand for an absolute bargain, flashed with Open tx So far I'm finding it a breeze. Challenge, but a breeze huge leep from a Futaba FF7 on 45mhz. Lol
Russ Cole you are going to love it.
@@MrVasmikey yup, I think so. Building a self drawn F111C so need alot of mixing, spoilers to alevators, to wing swing to brakes. Lol lots of fun. Lol
😝 you’ve got too many 😝
Taranis Q X7 works not very good with lua scripts. For example, crossfire script.
Dá pra usar o TBS Crossfire sem mod. th-cam.com/video/OiRJ2783Yt8/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=CaveiraFPV
@@alessandrojh4593 , thank you! I have error (this is weird): github.com/opentx/opentx/issues/7739
@@user-bv2kv8hx5d Hello friend, I do not know how to solve the problem, if I find something I give a return. you got to see this post is old but maybe I can get some information to help.
quadcopterforum.com/threads/fixed-sd-error-expected-ver-2-2v001.15433/
Spektrum is the most user friendly and feel better than all of these radios in my opinion of course. Would have liked to see it on the bench as part of your option. These radios all require upgrades and programming to get the most out of them. Again this is my opinion and doesn't matter. ;)
Lol, you call yourself Mr FPV....and you want a Spectrum radio.....?...lol.... hilarious.
EnglishTurbines it is his opinion and he is actually right! Quality-wise and in terms of user-friendlynes spectrum is on another level compared to flysky and frsky.
@@EnglishTurbines you must be just a drone pilot to make a comment like that. I fly fpv on everything and as I said it's my opinion Spektrum is hands down the best user friendly radio and feels better than any of these radios in my "option". For drones they maybe better for some people because of the receivers being smaller for a little longer than Spektrum had available but that's changed as well. I own each one of these radios and more so I've had a chance to compare them and again in my opinion Spektrum is much better all around. You have your opinion which is fine if you don't agree with mine but maybe you should try each and form one apples to apples before saying anything about mine.
@@michaelrodgers9829 You and Tom Tiny here are both hilarious....Show me your Spectrum out at 6kms on 2.4g....Like my Taranis does...For real long range, I use my UHF module ..You boys have no idea, seriously...lol.
@@EnglishTurbines anyone can add long range modules and do the same and enjoy it more. You are the funny one. LMAO you can keep on making you comments I personally know Spektrum is a all around better radio in my opinion which after all is the only one that matters to me. Happy flying!