MUTA | Full Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2024
- The concept of Muta is a highly debated topic in Islamic jurisprudence and public discourse. Between accusations of abuse and misuse, the topic has received a lot of attention. So what is Muta marriage, does Islam allow it and how is it applied within society? Watch this documentary to find out more about temporary Marriage in Shia Islam.
Click Here to subscribe & keep updated with all our latest videos:
www.youtube.co...
Be a part of the Ahlulbayt TV mission:
ahlulbayt.tv/s...
Follow Ahlulbayt TV on social media:
Facebook - / ahlulbayt
Twitter - / ahlulbayttv
Instagram - / ahlulbayttv
Telegram - t.me/AhlulbaytTV
Snapchat - / ahlulbayttv
Website: www.Ahlulbayt.tv/
Ahlulbayt: Documentaries -
/ ahlulbayttvdocs
Ahlulbayt: Reborn -
/ ahlulbayttvreborn
Children's ABTV (CABTV) -
/ childrensabtv
Ahlulbayt: General Q&A -
/ ahlulbayttvqanda
![Temporary Marriage [Summary] Sayed Jawad Qazwini](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qHQdBLP7BVo/mqdefault.jpg)
![ผัวเถื่อน - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P08ORRVDGl8/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for beautifully explaining prostitution.
Im a sunni muslim woman and i laughed out loud when i listened to these woman jusitify, promote and encourage their own prostitution and the prostitution of other woman while using Allahs name and the quran. dispicable.
You shouldn't laugh, Allah made it halal in the Quran. Only in later hadiths after the Umar's daughter got passed around by the whole community do you see the abrogation of mutah. @@whyamionhere
You see it prostitution.
But it is not.
In today's era you call it live-in relationships.
But islam made it a legal contract with set boundaries to protect interests of both parties.
And the foremost thing required fpr this relationship is fulfilling pre-requisite terms and conditions.
If woman is unmarried ,then consent of guardian of both boy and girl.
If woman is married, then it is impermissible.
If woman is widowed then her consent is required , which is valid after waiting period is over.
This temporary marriage system helps us to protect marriage system.
There is a lot of Difference between prostitution and mutah
Prostitution is way of finding physical pleasure.
Mutah is way of finding spiritual, emotional, mental peace without getting into physical relationship.
God made man and woman as a partner to each other so that one supports other one in hardships and share happiness with one another.
In prostitution, if a child is born , then it has no future.
But in mutah , if a child is born , then that child enjoys all rights which a child from permanent marriage enjoys.
Mutah helps us to stay away from sinful acts. It helps to find company in legal ways and find peace in life.
After all human being is a social animal. We can't live alone at all times. We need some one to share our thoughts and feelings with.
Jesus says till death do you part. Allah allows temporary marriage. The excuses muslim make for this is unreal. Leave islam ☪️ .
Temporary marriage is an open door to all kinds of abuse.
In Iraq, even in the Shiite holy cities, the clerics do make this kind of marriage with young girls from poor backgrounds. It is simply disgusting.
Right!
This is prostitution in the name of Islam.
reporting this narration, ‘Abbas al Qummi writes that those angels also:
ولعنت می کند اجتناب کنندہ ازاں را
Invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who abstains from Mut’ah until the Day of Qiyamah.
Ya agreed 💯
By that logic, even normal marriage is an open door to all kinds of abuse. Women get abused in permanent marriages too all the time.
If you love temporary marriage truthfully, then give your sister to me for some days and nights
My sister did temporary marriage with her now-permanent husband and then their mutual love flourished into permanent marriage. Now they have children and love each other a lot.
Yeah, and thousands other women left used as a bin where men dropped their sperm in...
This tells us like how many day "what I can do in a mutah marriage,I can't do with my regular wife". Tells us the mad passion that kept them together
so you want the same for your daughters and hers now?
Ur sis was a dapperz mate this is pure kufr
Can her husband do mutah with other women?!
Know each other? A 9 year old girl and a 49 year old man? That is unequal manipulation known to the world as Grooming.
I see the devil’s work all over this nonsense!
Aisha was rather 20 years old, not 9.
@@shukran3907she was 52 when the marriage was completed don’t talk nonsense, the evidence is all over the place
Shia. Say not more.
@shukran3907 hes not talking about Aisha who was not 9. Hes talking about iran who just legalised aged 9.
I am a shia Muslim and I completely disagree with this practice. I tried too hard to understand but just cannot make any sense out of it. Mutah appears to be a platform to promote women abuse. In the end he says don't blame Mutah if a guy breaks a girl's heart or vice versa. Blame the person. How is it possible that a man and a woman are involved in a temporary marriage and spend days and nights together with physical intimacy - basically sharing your soul with each other and then not fall in love?? Will it not lead to a heartbreak after the contract is over?? Would you marry a girl who has had Mutah relationships in the past??
Why encourage such a practice that can lead to disaster in so many ways??
Muta is haram and a bad practice, it should not be held accountability, it should be vanished. by any means necessary. Engaging with such act and conduct. it is mesmerizing, according to my own perspectives and opinion this should not be by default. why should any girl feel in a certain way, this causes break ups, sorrow and vulnerable. why should any cheap man use this ideology just to fulfil his desire upon a temporary moment of time. no girl is cheap, neither dumb nor prostitution.
"Muta is considered haram and condemned as a harmful practice by many. It should not be condoned or tolerated, but rather abolished through any necessary means. Engaging in such conduct is deeply troubling, and in my view, it should not be normalized.
Why should any woman be subjected to feelings of vulnerability and exploitation? This practice often leads to heartbreak, sorrow, and leaves individuals feeling exploited. It's unacceptable for anyone to manipulate this ideology solely for their temporary desires. No woman deserves to be treated as cheap, foolish, or as a means for gratification.
In summary, muta undermines the dignity and respect of individuals involved and should be actively discouraged and eliminated from societal norms."
Does that capture the essence of your sentiment
Shia mazhab ke badi badi mayaanaz kutub ke hawaalon se Mutah karna behad zaroori aur bahut bada nek kaam hai. Kaun Shia hazraat apni behan-betiyaan Nikah ke bajaay 1 din ka Mutah mein dena chahte hain woh humse raabta karen😂
Thats prostitution
This is something that can easily get out of hand and also be abused…
yes . How is this different from prostitution
@@shahzansadick1248 They give a thorough explanation on how it's not prostitution and even bring sources from the Quran and sunnah of permissibility. Did you watch the video?
@@ibnbasraaIt's fancy prostitution. A contract for sex is prostitution. Even if there's no money involve
@@shahzansadick1248 mutah is prostitution 100%
From the beginning men used God to justify the unjustifiable
This is the best explanation for everything
They are claiming adultery was permissible by a new name of muta'a 🤦only twelver Shias are in support of muta'a
@@rizwanuzzamanjyoti what's a Muta'a
@@Buzz054 among twelver Shia, they can get married for a fixed time like they will get divorced in 1 year and the man will pay the women for that period of time. That is a form of prostitution according to us. Even other branches of Shias like ismaili and zaidi Shias consider it as a form of prostitution
All marriages arguably are a form of contract. Offer, accept, and value. Do you, I do, and commitments.
I can tell you been in muta
There's only two types . Mutaa and Jon mutaa. Not the men and men,dog and snake,woman and woman
@@TheOrganics01 If someone was birthed as a result of Mutah, that's perfectly legal, valid and according to the soul of Allah's word in Quran. Now I reckon you want to hurl me that "insult" also?
But not for 2 hours for sex. Its haram.
Prostitution and Mutah
Private - Check
Money paid to woman - Check
Temporary - Check
Mutah just guarantees issues regarding to pregnancy but that doesn't mean this isn't prostitution.
What about Misyar?
@@mohammadshahidhusaini3122 same thing
😂😂😂😂😂😂 if a woman actively seeks mutua for $$$ like as a full time job or something then yes this is prostitution yes… but that’s NOT how you are supposed to use mutua …. You have no effing idea how real prostitution and human trafficking/exploitation works … stop exaggerating please
-misguided by hazrat umer
@@zeldatanit4346 this is not allowed in our religion please stop this bullshit.
Be honest with yourself ask would islam really allow this act. Would you allow you sister or daughter to do this. This is a disgusting act that was done by pagans. The prophet SAW prohibited it in a authentic hadith.
Allah in the Quran made it halal. After the sahaba had their daughters do mutah too much they changed it. If mutah was so wrong why would Allah tell the man to make sure to pay the woman. Allah encourages the payment for boom boom. This is why the Quran isn't the right book, only the Torah.
Abu Bakr's daughter Asma bint Abu Bakr practised Mutah...
A 9 year old WOUld not have had children your Mutah should have a minimum age of 18.
The problem with this practice is that a woman who goes through multiple temporary marriages will always be seen as used goods!!! Whereas, a man won’t be seen that way.
The problems of most of these practices in Islam is that they are favoured heavily towards a man.
There is no benefits to the woman in this, there is only pain, trauma, risk of pregnancy, shame, and being used as a human glory hole. for what? To help a useless man that cannot be a man and fullfill the rights of a woman? Like ok so you cannot have the rights of a man fullfilled it's very simple.
Cause men and women have different attributes my friend
@@Crime_paysIf it weren’t for the hardness of their hearts, this would never happen.
@@yvettep1093 what
So if she's a virgin, you gotta make sure that she is not taken advantage of. However, if she is not a virgin anymore (divorced, widowed etc.) she does not have to be protected as much? Imagine if she is a single mother, does she not need even MORE protection, because she is taking care of her kids all by herself? And kids born out of Mut'a have little chances of growing up in a traditional family. This creates broken homes and broken existences!
Islam protects the rights of all women, there is no first class or second class of women. Mut'a serves the man's interests; where is the gain for a woman? It's a degradation for her to not be a valued enough to be a permanent wife, but "only" good enough for temporary marriage. It is demeaning and in a roundabout way prostitution, because why would a woman consent to this, if not for the money? It is exploiting someone who needs to do this to make a living. The explanation of which Ayah supposedly justifies Mut'a sounds weak to me and too much room for human interpretation.
Why did allah and muhammad permit it before
Way to make a leap to try and make a point that you can’t prove anyway. Nobody said that non-virgin women were second class. You’re assuming this based on your own prejudice against the concept.
There’s guardianship approval is required because it’s within the legal framework of Islam. Widowed/Non divorced women are given more freedom because of them having experience with what sort of commitment it takes to be married, temporary or permanent. Stop projecting your opinions in an attempt to make a point that has no logical ground.
THERE R DIFFERENT OPINIONS OF SCHOLARS ! DIDNT U HEAR THAT ! ITS DEPENDS ON THE SCHOLAR U FOLLOW
@@Akhbari-14125 ...ok? How is that relevant to the discussion here?
Sunnis usually make divorcees 2nd or 3rd or 4th wives, you will very rarely see a man marrying a first wife and putting all his energy in a divorcee. Second of all where does it say that Mut'ah does not protect the wife? When you are in a Mut'ah marriage it is the husbands obligation to provide and protect her temporary wife during the time period she is with her. 2nd wife, 3rd wife, 4th wife or Mut'ah partner whether you like it or not a divorcee with kids will have troubles becoming first and only wife to a single man. Some women may prefer to be in a Mut'ah contract with one man than being a 3rd wife.
I have no problems with the concept of mut'ah marriage. Every marriage is temporary because life is temporary. But i see a lot of problems with any kind of marriage without witnesses. If that happens...who can prove that the actual marriage took place? It could be the word of the man against the word of the woman. What if she says that he didn't give her a dowry? What if she says that he forced her to have sexual intercourse without consent? How to know who is telling the truth??? This seems quite absurd.
Mutah needs wali (guardian) from the women side..
Right??
@@studentforever7466 Only if she is a virgin the wali is needed. So the problem continues. But even when there is a wali, what if the wali and the woman lie about the whole thing??? Who defends the right of the husband? What if the woman gives birth to a child and says that the father is the "husband", lying, bringing a false "waly"?? How can you prove that the "ceremony" even took place?? She can atributte the child to any man just bringing a friend or familly as a "wali" Don't you see the madness of this stuff??
As i said before, a marriage without witnesses looks like pure fornication. They can even conceal the whole thing and that would be halaal?.If they have a child who defends the right of the child? Listen to the conditions mentioned in these videos. No wali (except with virgins) or witnesses. Sunni conditions look quite better and logical, imho.
@@joserivas1257 same can said about permanent marriage if you dont hold a ceremony and do it without involving many people.
problem can be solved by doing temporary marriage the way you do permanent marriage. hold a ceremony and invite people or at least involve your family while doing temporary marriage. the problem you are referring to can pop up in many Islamic matters like buying stuff or taking loan. any person later can say that i have not received the payment while the person is actually lying. the problem u have specifically mentioned is due to the fact that society prevails mutah as an act of taboo.
@@AwaisAli-rg4qt what you are saying is nonsense. In every culture witnesses and a written contract are necessary to prove that a marriage took place. It's not needed many people involved. Regarding financial transactions the Quran is clear about writing down contracts, debts. Etc. You are just trying to defend something secret and deceitful because you are an imami shi'a. Other shi'a sects think differently. I don't care about the "mut'ah" nature of a marriage. I don't care if that is taboo or not. I just care about the truth. I already said what i had to say. Salaam
But the biggest draw back is you cannot tell your family that I am married and the society does not expect
If you're fam is non-shia then i understand but if they are shias and claim to follow Ahlulbayt a.s then they should have no problems.
So basically we are here legalising prostitution…pay and enjoy and move on ….that’s the same what happen in red light areas ..pay and enjoy for particular time … this cannot be Islam
It is ISLAM....Ex muslim Sahil and Adam seeker
So now you're anti-Islamic and anti-Quran. What you said in your comment is also true for Nikah if we want to look at this from a negative mindset. There's never any guarantee that Nikah will be permanent, divorces happen, people move on, marry again. And let's not forget that in Nikah there's also a "wage" (Dowry) and in case of divorce, the consolatory wage and alimony.
So you see my friend, if you want to call Mutah as "legalizing prostitution", then Nikah won't escape from this label either. But the real question is, why objecting to something that's clearly stated as a law in Quran? Why nullifying something that Prophet (saww) has kept as legit and valid and only the 2nd Kalifa nullified it based on his own preference.
Lastly, "that’s the same what happen in red light areas"… no, that's called "prostitution".
The fact of the matter is that zina is widespread in Sunni circles because there is no muta. And Muta is abused in shia circles, because there is a flawed understanding of its wisdom.
How many of you are watching because of Foodie Beauty's new arc 🙌
I might just be thinking of marrying a sunni guy as I know that if he's pious, at least he wouldn't have previously been in a relationship before.
@@Akhbari-14125 dude, chillout, I know Sunnis, and tbh some of them are actually more open-minded than we would think
@@aminawadood9621 alright 👍🏻 may Allah s.w.t bless u and what's better for u should happen .
You really wanna marry a dude who praises the killers of Zahra (as) and ahlulbayt (as) ?
If you're a shia, I wouldn't recommend it. There are usually a lot of complications in shia sunni marriages, especially if both are pious. Also when children are involved in the mix it becomes much more difficult. My advice is to find a pious shia muslim.
So stupid of you to even think all Shias do it or have done it.
as Muslims, we must obey the laws mentioned in the Quran. There is a concept of monogamy in the Quran, and the rest of the concepts are just made by the people in different periods of time which have nothing to do with the Quranic laws. Temporary marriages or pleasure marriages are just showing the sexual frustration of the people, which is unlawful, inhuman, and unethical.
You agree it is a marriage but then go on to say it is out of frustration it is done? How about a normal marriage? Can i not have the same intention when i marry (non-mutah). Explain.
There r many documentries on muta ...Iraq n iran running Shia brothels ....and the beneficiaries r the clerics and men ....victims r the Shia women.
I dont know y this woman Fatima promoting the muta..?
Sexual frustration? You're either a woman or a man with low testosterone if you believe sexual frustration is what you described.
It is a basic part of the human physiology and when it is not quenched, it wither gets worse and you fornicate, masturbate to adult content (especially today) or practice deviant acts. This is a band aid solution that the two caliphs practiced and all muslims at the time of the Prophet UNTIL Umar (ra) forbid it.
@@gr3en_jamfatima295 Exactly
How many of your mothers have done Muta ?
As many as your mothers breastfeed other men 😂
The fish stinks from its head.
On the prophets sawa deathbed omar said “hasbouna kitabo Allah” and later on he forbids something from kitaba Allah, what a hypocracy.
With all do respect what the sunni’s are doing when explaining the text is exactly what the christians are doing when explaining the trinity or divinity of jesus as. There are explicit text’s, yet they beat around the bush with implicit text. May Allah swt guide is all to the truth inshâ Allah
He forbids from fhe book of Allah? Dalil?
@@TheOrganics01
4:24
What gives omar the right to forbid what allah made lawfull?
@@redman4419 dalil
@@redman4419 if it's halal then how come some of the so called shia do it only ?
@@TheOrganics01 surah a nissa brother.
because, the sunnis dont follow the prophet and his household asws. They follow the highjacked version of the sahaba :)
And among His Signs is this, that He created for you mates from among yourselves, that you may dwell in tranquility with them, and He has put love and mercy between your (hearts)"
Ofcourse the original arabic Aya is far more eloquent. How can one find tranquility with someone if he/she is just using her/him for MUTAA= pleasure?
How can one find tranquility if he is doing something in the dark?
There is more to marriage than the physical part.
Surah Nisa: يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ اتَّقُوا رَبَّكُمُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكُم مِّن نَّفْسٍ وَاحِدَةٍ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًا كَثِيرًا وَنِسَاءً ۚ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّـهَ الَّذِي تَسَاءَلُونَ بِهِ وَالْأَرْحَامَ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّـهَ كَانَ عَلَيْكُمْ رَقِيبًا ﴿1﴾
Ahmedselah That's right!
@@kabdul9208 that's about children u fool
Absolutely correct. Its haram
Shia twisting the Quran. Does not state in the Quran mutah is not allowed.
Guys are you hearing what you are talking? Wonderful blessing huh!
Seriously brother....im flabbergasted at what I hear here
@@abbasabdeali3239 people are blinded by religion. Truly speaking a holy God will not allow this kind of prostitution at any point of time.
The one who ask men to control lust is God or the one who legalize uncontrolled lust is God? They are disgracing God. They are creating a false image of God. Idolators.
Hope at any point of time God didn't allowed this prostitution.
@@SAGKavin im a Shia bohra Muslim and never have i heard of such a degrading thing like temporary marriage...for us one marriage is all that's needed for deen nd duniya
@@abbasabdeali3239 it's from Quran, that's what they said. Quran 4:24. I read it, as well as commentary. I don't know why damned Google suggested it to me. Spoiled my mood. Made me so angry.
@@SAGKavin you don't sound like a you're a muslim....
Hes twisting the Quran. The dowry is not anything to do with temporary marriage 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Comprehensively explained. Didn't know much of this information. Jazakallah Kheir.
Hi
Now Encourage your sisters n daughters to do Muta...will u
Yes, I will
@@fahmytwalib291
Masha Allah ...u r the first person who admit that ull persuade them to do muta u r a real Shia ...others r shivering in thier pants to talk about this
Maula Ali lived in fear and humiliation all his life according to the Shia
What about normal muslims, who is neither sunni or shia. Where do we stand. Let just follow the qur'an and sunnah. It was accepted once but The prophet forbbiden it later.
So basically, its a 'marriage' meant to assuage a man's sexual urge
This is the nature of the man. This is the way he was created, who are we to judge what Allah has ordained?
So you'd rather have millions of people jack off their phones like the majority of the west do? GTFO here
@@Fizafeez
I totally understand, it's vital to satisfy man's needs, ya, that makes sense
@@truthbomb2184
Majority of those in the west have a different name for it, they pay 'working ladies' an agreed amount for an agreed duration to help them assuage the natural primal needs they were born with
@@yajujmajuj1739 not all. Guess you haven't stepped outside your home to get an idea of most people's circumstances.
Allah has then made it forbidden on the 7th year of Hijra. the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1406)
Alhamdulillah for the many blessings. 🌹🙏
Thank you & May Allah bless you
alhamdu li shaytan
*Mutah is not forbidden. Its been abused which is why it needs more agency and discretion these days.*
But it's not valid and haraam nevermore being forbidden
so do you pimp out your sister?
IT IS FORBIDDEN. ALLAH HAS MADE IT FORBIDDEN.
WHAT YOU ARE DOING IS ZINA
Allah has then made it forbidden on the 7th year of Hijra. the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1406)
Indeed it is a prostitution in the name of Islam
reporting this narration, ‘Abbas al Qummi writes that those angels also:
ولعنت می کند اجتناب کنندہ ازاں را
Invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who abstains from Mut’ah until the Day of Qiyamah.
lol how did people already dislike the video without watching it😂
maybe they are jealous
people? yk exactly who those "people" who shall not be named are lol.
@@Agent.313 they thought it was based on mutah Beal former outlaw 2pacs group
Why they are disliking justifying legalized brothel? Any way in heaven all get prostitutes like a pimp house in las-vagas right?
They don't know how best Islam is to satisfy our lust.
Haters hate.
@@SAGKavin bro u know ur crazy right ?
18:00 that is not how Muslims pray,that's a different religion.
Dude, this is called 'dua' or supplication. We do it after prayer (or anytime)
It's totally not relevant anymore. If you wanna go far from home for doing business abroad, just bring your wife or do video call or buy ticket to back home at weekend. There are many alternative to keep you connecting with your wife in this modern era. Why all that thinking are only focus about man necessity? How about the temporer woman future? The wife feeling at home? It's so sick to see how selfish the shia muslim scholars above.
They are pure falsehood misusing the Quran for their desires, Alhamduli'Laah in the sunnah we don't have such weird practices, the prophet said to us in the hadith to take care of our women, not only use them for sex but really love them ❤
Same as multiple marragies in islam...like 3 or 4 wives is legal in islam....I would like to say that temporary marraiges is not very common in shias...
I don't call myself Shi'a nor sunni because that's how my dad raised me but I know about muta and I tell people about it and how it is a good thing. Then they get mad at me and everyone gangs up on me but I show them unarguable truth.
Bhia can u find someone for me
Me apki behn k sth muta krna chata hn q k yh aik achi chez hai ❤ 💙
@@abuzar560 tera kul q aqal ne hai
@@Giggidyflanders plz show me unarguable truth
It was allowed then but was banned stop letting your desires control you to change what your religion said.
Nobody has no right to ban anything in Quran
These hypocrites who call them selves muslims while doing takfir on others havent even watched the documentery and they start commenting filth. Shows really about how they have been raised
-misguided by hazrat umer
A woman or man should declare at his/her marriage that how many muttas, he or she has done before. Hiding your mutta from society and from life partner is wrong.
Surah Nisa: يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ اتَّقُوا رَبَّكُمُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكُم مِّن نَّفْسٍ وَاحِدَةٍ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًا كَثِيرًا وَنِسَاءً ۚ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّـهَ الَّذِي تَسَاءَلُونَ بِهِ وَالْأَرْحَامَ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّـهَ كَانَ عَلَيْكُمْ رَقِيبًا ﴿1﴾
i'm a 45 year old male... Anyone's sister looking for a mutah marriage??
There has to be a halal way of getting to know a person before you feel comfortable for a full permanent commitment to one another. That’s why the two consenting adults can make a time frame and stick by what works for both to make that decision. I feel like it allows them the opportunity to avoid divorce as much as possible. There are ground rules that need to be honoured. Allah sees everything. The point is that it was permitted by the Holy Prophet by the authority of Allah SWT and no man after him can make it haram or forbid it.
Masha’Allah ❤️
Who will take care of the child secondly whom will this child inherit
in other words Legal Prostitution.
This is NOT Islam...
Sister this Shia religion is not Islam
They don't follow Quran and Sunnah of prophet Muhammad
You should watch it and maybe learn that it was something that the Prophet enacted and was performed in his lifetime and that of the 1st caliph
Why dont you say this comment on the millions of muslims who smoke, drink alcohol etc???!! People like you only know how to attack the muslims who follow ahlulbait. Such hypocrisy is within you
@@thefoodshaikh811 I'm you know prophet Muhammad practice this so shia holds his sunnah. Clearly you haven't still learnt history of mutah.
good jazakallah🌹👏
I thought this was a great documentary and and very well explained. The only issue was the girl looking at pictures of herself on her phone, that made me feel awkward.
Ppl who defending Muta ..they must ensure ..that they.ll Encourage every Girl n boy to do Muta...n they may ask to thier parents how many times they did in thier primenof youth.....
Hazrati Ali (ra) (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) forbade mut’ah marriage and the meat of domestic donkeys at the time of Khaybar. According to another report, he forbade mut’ah marriage at the time of Khaybar and he forbade the meat of tame donkeys. (Narrated by al-Bukhari, 3979; Muslim, 1407)
Is it for a suuni man allowed in Iran to make mutah marriage to a Shia woman in Iran?
Hmmmmmm.... interesting subject topic. Thanks for uploading thus documentary.
There is absolutely no where in the Holy Quran where this is permitted or allowed or even mentioned.. in every religion you will find many different manipulations.. creating rules and regulations that don’t exist.. simply be honest with yourself as a human being.. having intimate relationships is a human need but don’t deform an entire religion and make it appear as a hypocritical faith when it’s true essence can simply be found in the Quran..
Do your own research and create the effort you need to understand that Islam is a faith and it depends solely on individual comprehension, keeping in mind that we are imperfect humans that have feelings and emotions and are definitely not expected to act perfectly all the time, as long as you truly try your best that is all that matters to the one God that created us all
Abdool, who told you it's not in the Quran?
Quran 4:24
"So for whatever you enjoy [of marriage] from them, give them their due compensation as an obligation. And there is no blame upon you for what you mutually agree to beyond the obligation. Indeed, Allah is ever Knowing and Wise." It clears says PAY them for their time and nothing else! 🤣🤣
Abdool, it also says in this hadith that Ibn Abbas (cousin of the prophet) also practiced muttah
"...There were two mut’ahs at the time of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): one of them was the mut`ah of Hajj (i.e., tannaffit`) and the other was mut`ah with women." - Musnad Ahmad 369
Shia religion is not Islam because they don't follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah of the prophet Muhammad
@@thefoodshaikh811 We dont follow the hypocrites. Just because someone was a companion of the Holy Prophet (PBUHH), does not mean they were righteous. I hope you know you'll be accountable for takfiring the whole Shias
@@thefoodshaikh811 We don't need certificates from you . If you think praising the enemies of our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and his progeny is SUNNAH, then I feel sorry for you.
the Hadith is clear "O people, I had permitted you Mutah before, [but now] whoever of you has any part in it currently must part with her, and do not take back anything which you may have given them, as Allah Exalted and Majestic has forbidden it until the day of resurrection.” [Muslim, Abu Dawood, Ibn Majah, Nasa`i, and Darimi], end of story.
How come omar can band Allah's words?
What about Christians and Jews
Because for Bakris (sunnis), Umar is their prophet.
Temporary or pleasure marriage is a pleasure for a man but a disaster for a woman. please ask those woman victims. they will tell you their stories with tears. please respect women as you respect men. Men and women have equal rights according to the Quran not according to your self-made so-called Shariah. In other words, you are legalizing prostitution under the cover of religion. Because a woman when she gets married 4 or five times with different people ultimately will become a prostitute. Quran e Kareem has nothing to do with these kinds of nonsense activities. Quran says. LAQAD KARAMNA BANI ADAMA. means every human being is equally respectable. so don't make fun of Quranic laws please for God's sake.
Mutah is in the Quran. But sunnis say it was changed in the hadiths afterward.
@@seektruth581 can you please give the Quranic reference regarding muta? Thank you
muta and misyar marriage both forbidden in Islam
-misguided by hazrat umer
Allhumdulilah there are men with sense still. The end of days are here. The day of judgement approaches .
I reverted from suni to shia sect... And i did mutta marriage..i felt nothing but only purity and piety in such marriage Alhumdulilah
Where are you from?
You mean you changed to shia so you could sleep around
@@dijacharoliya1964 The woman he raped was vulnerable and probably very poor, otherwise she would not have done what she did - he is a low life, i hope he caught something...and I hope his wife divorces him...
This is how Sunni converts to Shia....bcoz Shia offer is very lucrative....
@@imranali-fy6if because sunnis fail to see the difference between zina(aldultery) and marriage. Even your Maliki scholar (shiekh azraq) wrote a book in agreenment to muta'h, and Ibn Taymiyyah grandfather allowed it.
This documentary is trying to make Muta civilised, acceptable, respectable and legal. The whole style of the documentary and how both the presenter and the person being interviewed is very similar to a regular and familiar documentaries.However they present the documentary in an historical context and attempt to academize it giving it a sense of 'fact' trying to disguise it as something it is not, respectability and ethical. However no attempt can disguise that it is about religionising prostitution. All marriages are contracts, but Muta like prostitution have something very much in commom which regular marriages do not have, and that is the 'time or temporary' nature of the contract and that it is a contract where the main purpose of Muta is 'sexual pleasure'. The presenter sounds like 'Ragu' who reads channel 4 news and presents many other documentaries. He is far too intelligent to think this Muta is actually 'a marriage' and not prostitution, but on second thoughts he is a muslim after all.
Regular marriage contract because of its very nature does not have a 'time or temporary clause because it is not temporary, this contract is not temporary legally. To suggest that Muta is actually 'a marriage' is ridiculous which is what this documentary is proporting. Prostitution by any other name wheather it be Muta or some other name is still prosititution. It is prostitution masquaranding as marriage, by its very nature of being temporary as with any prostitute on the street corner or a high class prostitute or escort exclusive or not it is still prostitution. The contract sets out the parameters of the ' marriage contract' the time period of temporary - from what date to what date and its ending or disolution of the contract. It could be for a few hours , a day, weeks, months or years and money is exchanged accordingly to how much its worth. That is exactley what normal prostitutes contract is, with tge exception tgey don't call it marriagem which is more truthful and not hypocritical like muta. Prostitution via Muta is still prostitution, that is what it is prostitution, no matter how you cut the cake. Marriage or no marriage in any society except shia muslims where any temporary marriage arrangement between a man and a woman is prostitution by another name in other societies it is still called prostitution. Prostitution by any other name is still prostitution.
-misguided by hazrat umer
- thinks marriage is unethical
- don’t believe in Quran because hazrat umer said so.
Shia Islam must set minimum age boundaries to protect its holiness
As a convert to is lam so I'm muslim neither Sunni or Shia or whatever lable.
I'm just the folower of the Rasul so I have no issues with it .
It was legit then and now .
Allah swt s teaching is for all times .
if you accept Abu Bakr as the caliph after the holy prophet, that makes you a sunni. If you take Imam Ali as your leader after the holy Prophet, then you're a shia.
I accept Allah swt as my God and Rasulallah as my prophet .
In my opinion the labels are man-made with all respect due ,each to their own
@@rubenk1414 search up the event of ghadeer, and I would be happy to have a proper academic discussion with you on anything. Also, the Prophet himself said "my ummah will be divided in 73 sects..."
@rubenk1414 RASULALLAH just means messenger of God 😂😂😂😂
This is Haram. This is Zinaa!
The sahabhas did it when they went to war . ABU bakr daughter was given in mutah marriage . Sunni.books.
Are you saying the prophet allowed Zina?
-misguided by hazmat umer
4:24 ?
@@burman3789 definitely, this shit isn't allowed anywhere in the Quran.
Lies lies lies in sunni islam This is forbidden. Read hadith:
It was narrated from al-Rabee’ ibn Sabrah al-Juhani that his father told him that he was with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allaah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.”
Narrated by Muslim, 1406.
Nobody cares about your Bakri Islam created by terrorists Abu Bakr (la) and Umar (la).
-misguided by hazrat umer
@Tony DC Allah did forbid it. you need to follow the Quran and Sunnah if you want to be a Muslim. rejecting either makes you a kafir
@Tony DC Allah has then made it forbidden on the 7th year of Hijra. the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1406)
It is paid Sex in the name of Islam
reporting this narration, ‘Abbas al Qummi writes that those angels also:
ولعنت می کند اجتناب کنندہ ازاں را
Invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who abstains from Mut’ah until the Day of Qiyamah.
I myself have seen so many marriages breaking and man going out for sex or love but here why only women's are on a target mens are also should be
YOU ARE WILLING TO DO ZINAA BUT NOT MUT'AH...THE HYPOCRISIES OF SOME SECTS
Bigot
What i wanna know is how some of the young ladies feel about this? if you guys ever thought about it and if theres another prespective outside of what they listed in the video?
It is a valid and moral option for all Muslims. It's in the Quran that means it is allowed until we meet our partners in paradise. Any Muslim who claims muttah marriage is not allowed or not moral is basically saying and believing that they are better smarter and have better morals than Allah Almighty himself. That's ridiculous and not only egocentric but those people are hypocrites. Muttah marriage is an option for Muslims to avoid Zina and other sexually immoral behavior. Muttah marriage is private and Muslims have no right to judge other Muslims marriages. Muttah marriage was never abrogated because it's in the Quran. Muttah marriage was good enough for Muhammad's people but not us? That's also a ridiculous and hypocritical argument. It's lawful marriage for all times.
@@melodymitchell7313 Where is it in the Qur'an?
@geranienbaum why do you go about every comment fighting against mutah? How about I replied to every Sunni that one of your favourite people got Angry against Prophet Muhammad when he was on his deathbed??
@geranienbaum you tell me another solution for people who are not yet mentally/financially ready for marriage??
@geranienbaum are you a Christian? Then maybe you can focus more on your religion and not interfere. Like, for serious, how would you feel If I taught you something about your religion?
Thank you for the documentary, very much needed.
Can we have any reference to the said communities, policies and guidelines?
Live discussions based on this topic, and on this documentary in particular, can be helpful.
I started a room here:
PS: if it goes astray I will just leave the floor :)
Thanks.
The link keeps on being removed automatically;
To join the clubhouse room you can find me there and connect.
Hope to have some fruitful discussions.
He had No Authority whatsoever to abrogate what the Prophet allowed
Mutuah is nor marriage it is Haram. Stop trying to justify mutuah.
Thank You
As a Twelver Shia, I except Mutha. However, I think there is too much focus on young people in our communities. I consider them to be fully grown adults and not teenagers. Mutha is a wonderful gift for people of all ages. I am in the third category as a mature person with no marriage or relationship experience. My reasons are related to Asperger's Syndrome. It just means that I think a little differently than the conventional society. Society is based on human capital, created to produce a massive power system that drives the economy, etc. As an Asperger, I think a little differently, because my mind processes sensory information unlike most people in society like differently wired brains or computer software systems. For this reason, I have struggled to fit into society or find a marriage partner or make friends all my life but with mutha my life is looking sweet and rosy. Nice documentary. I thought the ending was sweet and melancholic.
Which female will accept to such a thing, I wonder? I guess muta is like the slaves of yesterday
Imagine using your condition as a way to escuse adultery.
what's an assburger? does it taste really bad?
@@sofiblinka2300 What is the result if you commit adultery? Even if you are not a Muslim. Surprisingly, some Christians practiced fornication in churches. Do you think fornication is good for you?
It's prostitution. You people are disgusting.
How is this shia Teacher recording to the Sahaba but they hate the Sahaba and make Takfir on them?????
Shouldn't there be some kind of organization/association which helps the youth (especially teenagers) with Mutah?
Like the group should help the youth be free of Vices like Pornography & Masturbation and help them with Mutah, doing things like match-making, convincing both pairs of parents, providing Sex-Ed, teaching about current issues such as LGBTQ and there's so much more....
I just feel that someone should take up leadership and do something about this opportunity. It would literally benefit thousands of Muslims around the world.
If you feel that someone should take or do something about this opportunity is your own daughter or sister. You will definitely be admired by men in this world and also get a great reward of Paradise from your Lord in the hereafter. 😆
@geranienbaum he didn’t say that
@geranienbaum lol I mean, our Imams definitely won't take responsibility as they themselves would probably be too busy "doing the deed"... smh
@@aminawadood9621 imams ?
@@excelsior31107 bro consent is important if ur heart doesn't accept it WHO CARES
Mutah marriage have been forbidden by the prophet Muhammad S.A.W permanently. Only the Shia law permit this marriage.
best doc on this subject. thanks
nice sharing
Its in quran thats perfect
This is a wonderful documentary 👏 ❤. It's brought up many issues we need to discuss in our communities. Hopefully it guide both Muslims and non Muslims. As I've learned time and time again, with our Sunni brothers and sisters theirs no reasoning with them on certain issues. I've learned to agree to disagree. And focus more on what we have in common. Salaam alaykum to you all. May Allah and blessed prophet Muhammad pbuh and his Ahlulbayt guide us..
None can guide except for Allah SWT. Allah SWT is the Creator and the only Master for whom it is just a matter of saying “Be” and it becomes. Prophet Muhammad PBUH, the Ahlul Bait and the companions are the Creation of Allah SWT. Therefore they cannot do anything for you.
Can I have your sister for one hour let me know
Will u Encourage your sisters n daughters to do Muta ...?
This is prostitution in the name of Islam
This is paid Sex
Period.
Do you realise how many women's lives these "temporary marriages" ruin? Men prey on vulnerable women...they prey on children...pedo use it in order to rape children...
Is their a club or a masjid were you can register for mutah marriage. Am interested.
Club ?
-misguided by hazrat umer
Sahih Muslim 1406 d
Sabra al-Juhani reported on the authority of his father that while he was with Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) he said:
O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection. So he who has any (woman with this type of marriage contract) he should let her off, and do not take back anything you have given to them (as dower).
Totally prohibited 🚫❌
I wonder how women back then were able to prove their innocence of zinah if they were to get pregnant. Also how any woman was able to prove that the kids belonged to a particular guy if the Mutah marriage was done in secrecy and if the guy denied it? Granted there are DNA tests now, but how degrading for the women. I think something went terribly wrong in translation, because anything that can cause such severe harm is haram.
My sunni friends slerp with there girlfriends its better to do this and then convert this in a real marriege when you Both understand each other and when not there is nothing to worry about simply find someone else
There is a justification for everything in Islam, I mean everything.
Surah Nisa: يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ اتَّقُوا رَبَّكُمُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكُم مِّن نَّفْسٍ وَاحِدَةٍ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًا كَثِيرًا وَنِسَاءً ۚ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّـهَ الَّذِي تَسَاءَلُونَ بِهِ وَالْأَرْحَامَ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّـهَ كَانَ عَلَيْكُمْ رَقِيبًا ﴿1﴾
Shias are just the 20% of muslims. Sunni Muslims does not accept this aberrration
It's called prostitution ya'll
The last day of my life I consider myself as a Muslim.
Goodbye 😔
Why?
These are shia, not Muslims, don't be fooled. May Allah guide you
Nspcc ❤🎉❤
❤onethingulovedroyalitymuslimchristisnjewishrabbibudfhistfaithhindufaithwasmarriagepermanentweddinglaws❤
.
ويجوز للرجل أن يتزوج دميته إذا كان سعيداً. لأن الزواج أكثر فائدة من العزوبة. الشريعة تجيز ذلك لأن الإسلام ليس عبئا على المؤمن أن يتبعه.
It is permissible a man to marry his doll if he is happy. since marriage is more beneficial than celibacy. Sharia Law allows it Because Islam is not a burden for a believer to follow.
----- (Kitab Ulama Qiyas , Volume 1, Page 91 )
Thank you for update & clarifications
Hi
Asalaamualaikum my respected brother and sister i am not in a mutah marriage but married as christian and then married as Muslim to the same person but it is about five year now I have no one to take care of me , i am asking for a devoice and I have been denied i am sixty and he is forty five .i am asking the shia scholars to ask him please to mollify the marriage and give me a devoice i am weary of beging i am from st Vincent and I don't have no one to put my problem to, please help me in Shaa Allah.
How is it going so far my aunty?
The arduous struggle known as the Great War, or the epic Malhama Al Kubra, which has plagued
humanity, will eventually draw to a close, paving the way for Mahdi and his dedicated followers to
establish the tenets of Islam across the globe. Muhammad Qasim is Mahdi
Hi guys is there website for people just for mutah marraige in UK . No shia or sunni just muslim
Salam.. Iam a wife my husband is very good we also bless of finance. I want my husband to bring other woman in our life and to make it legal we enter mutaah. My husband just told me...we do but no real marriage and i not ask morethan anything. He dont like to invest for any emotional connection or anything
6:151 THEE BOOK of THEE GOD says Say: "Come, I will rehearse what Allah hath (really) prohibited you from": Join not anything as equal with Him; be good to your parents; kill not your children( literally and psychology}on a plea of want;- We provide sustenance for you and for them;- come not nigh to shameful deeds. Whether open or secret; take not life, which Allah hath made sacred, except by way of justice and law: thus doth He command you, that ye may learn wisdom.
there will be severe punishement fore thos doing this ...in HELL burning the skin but THEE GOD will heal {regenerate fast dna} the burning body that fast that the pain wil exsist fore how long only THEE GOD knows.
This is not religion of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ
-misguided by hazmat umer
Man at 7.50 hes not saying peace be upon him he says it half way like hes not sincere to his loyalty .
من تمتع كان درجة كدرجة الحسين (عليه السلام) ومن تمتع مرتين فدرجة كدرجة الحسن (عليه السلام) من تمتع ثلث مرات كان درجة كدرحة على بن ابى طالب (عليه السلام) ومن تمتع اربع مرات فدرجة كدرجتى
Whoever performs Mut’ah once will attain the status of Hussain. Whoever performs it twice will attain the status of Hassan. Whoever performs it thrice will attain the status of ‘Ali radiya Llahu ‘anhu and whoever will perform it four times will attain my status (i.e. of Rasulullah salla Llahu ‘alayhi wa sallam).
Man la yadhuruhul faqih. Wasail u shia
Thank you for sharing! I find the Quran the most powerful though, since Allah himself in the Quran says to pay the woman her wage. If Allah didn't want it he will never encourage it.
@@seektruth581
Waaaaat......?
U mean pay her wage as sex worker ....?
U meant to say ...Quran promoting prostitution (astaghfirullah)
@@seektruth581
Where is that pay wage to women ....present ur proof if u really truthful
@@imranali-fy6if Quran 4:24 says to pay her for mutah. All Sunni and Shia scholars agree this specific ayah is talking about mutah marriage. Look at the different translations in your language.
@@seektruth581
This how shia distort the Quran ...that verse for war captive women ...there is no word muta and vage ....ur Taqayya n kitman wont work here.
Can a man who’s already married do mutah
lol what ? 😂
According to them yes