introduction - identifying gaps, setting the stage for those not familiar with condition/med, etc methods - in/ex criteria, trial design, endpoints results - the results, are they applicable to your patients? discussion - limitations, comparing with other studies nothing against your video (which was very informative), but i feel like the whole paper should be read. there's no real way to read it fast. there's no part of the paper that should be skipped (maybe statistical analysis can be breezed over, but some might want to know the number of participants needed to power the study to make the results legit). i read papers for fun just to see what's going on, but i'd imagine for researchers it's hard to read these papers fast and effectively bc you just have the read the whole darn thing :T props to those doing reviews and stuff, it's challenging :(
THat's what I used to think too, that I have to read every single paper in detail. But it really depends on the goal of why you read the paper. Reading a paper could be just for interest, to do preliminary lit search, screening etc. Researchers will do a deep dive when they are preparing for journal clubs or when preparing arguments for their paper.
OMG, your channel is so far the best channel i have found for medical research, ALL OF YOUR VIDEOS ARE SOOO HELPFULLLL and they are spot on!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you so much for postiiiing
Thank you Dr. Jia, I have been doing research if cholesterol should be a big concern on a keto diet, due to it being key preventing my illnesses and came across possible bigger problems like Iron overload my reference ranges being taken lightly such as my ferritin being close to over due to seeing a youtuber "Frank Tufano" explaining his iron overload personal research (since we have similar diets) how it is a reliable indicator for Iron overload and inflammation. Some recommended reducing it up to 90% by donating blood.
Hi Dr. Jia, thanks for the video. Would love to have another video on how to do a critical appraisal of a research paper. I find it difficult to make a discretion because the papers are written by experts, so my strategy so far has been to take the findings as true if it is published in the top 5-10 journals or if the author has good repute. (SIdenote: I'm not in the medical field - this strategy of reading research paper would have gotten me out of practice 🙂 ) Looking forward to more contents.
Hi Diwash Dahal. Your strategy on choosing paper is spot on, and a great way to start. That is because, the peer review process for high impact journal is rigorous and the papers typically get assessed by many research experts/in-hour statisticians. Yes, I will do a future video on critical appraisal. We do deep dives on papers when we do journal clubs.
@@PublishedMD Hi Dr. Jia, I'm not sure if it is already somewhere on your channel (will try to find it sometime), but if it's not, would it be possible to make a video on how to go about comprehending research papers with a demo. With demo I mean showing the process of navigating through an actual paper, taking notes, making assumptions, marking questions for future explorations etc. I understand it's a non linear, and non standardized process; (also not sure what the implications are to have somebody's paper demonstrated on TH-cam). It would be very helpful to see somebody providing an actual walk through of the paper reading process (of course only if this request is reasonable). Thanks for your response.
@@diwashdahal6847 No, I currently do not have a full demo on how to read a research paper. That is a great idea. I already have a few videos lined up, but will put this idea in my content bucket. Thanks!
MED, as researcher, not as clinician 4:22 Strat 1: Inquiry Based Reading 1. Ask Question 2. Find Answer 3. Interpret Author's Intents, can you trust it ?
I just found your channel and this is the first video that I watched, and I want to say that the video was really helpful and I really hope to get better in research so that I can elevate my career in the future. so, thank you for your work and I really hope that all the people looking to improve in research see your videos
@@PublishedMD I'm at the beginning of my journey. I just finished a research course and did my first porject as a training project and it took a lot of time, with all the circumstances that I've been through from exams and sudying. So, I need all the help that I can get. Thank you so much for helping
I recommend going to pubmed or google scholar. Usually there will be a button that says "read full article". There are some articles that require you to pay. If that is the case, you might want get access through your university/medical institution.
Could you assist me in writing a proposal I would pay you for your time
Thank you for posting this! This was very helpful!
Thanks for watching. If you have any questions, feel free to ask me here. I will answer it.
introduction - identifying gaps, setting the stage for those not familiar with condition/med, etc
methods - in/ex criteria, trial design, endpoints
results - the results, are they applicable to your patients?
discussion - limitations, comparing with other studies
nothing against your video (which was very informative), but i feel like the whole paper should be read. there's no real way to read it fast. there's no part of the paper that should be skipped (maybe statistical analysis can be breezed over, but some might want to know the number of participants needed to power the study to make the results legit). i read papers for fun just to see what's going on, but i'd imagine for researchers it's hard to read these papers fast and effectively bc you just have the read the whole darn thing :T
props to those doing reviews and stuff, it's challenging :(
THat's what I used to think too, that I have to read every single paper in detail. But it really depends on the goal of why you read the paper. Reading a paper could be just for interest, to do preliminary lit search, screening etc. Researchers will do a deep dive when they are preparing for journal clubs or when preparing arguments for their paper.
OMG, your channel is so far the best channel i have found for medical research, ALL OF YOUR VIDEOS ARE SOOO HELPFULLLL and they are spot on!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you so much for postiiiing
Thank you Dr. Jia, I have been doing research if cholesterol should be a big concern on a keto diet, due to it being key preventing my illnesses and came across possible bigger problems like Iron overload my reference ranges being taken lightly such as my ferritin being close to over due to seeing a youtuber "Frank Tufano" explaining his iron overload personal research (since we have similar diets) how it is a reliable indicator for Iron overload and inflammation. Some recommended reducing it up to 90% by donating blood.
Hi Dr. Jia, thanks for the video. Would love to have another video on how to do a critical appraisal of a research paper. I find it difficult to make a discretion because the papers are written by experts, so my strategy so far has been to take the findings as true if it is published in the top 5-10 journals or if the author has good repute. (SIdenote: I'm not in the medical field - this strategy of reading research paper would have gotten me out of practice 🙂 ) Looking forward to more contents.
@PublishedMD
Hi Diwash Dahal. Your strategy on choosing paper is spot on, and a great way to start. That is because, the peer review process for high impact journal is rigorous and the papers typically get assessed by many research experts/in-hour statisticians. Yes, I will do a future video on critical appraisal. We do deep dives on papers when we do journal clubs.
@@PublishedMD Hi Dr. Jia, I'm not sure if it is already somewhere on your channel (will try to find it sometime), but if it's not, would it be possible to make a video on how to go about comprehending research papers with a demo. With demo I mean showing the process of navigating through an actual paper, taking notes, making assumptions, marking questions for future explorations etc. I understand it's a non linear, and non standardized process; (also not sure what the implications are to have somebody's paper demonstrated on TH-cam). It would be very helpful to see somebody providing an actual walk through of the paper reading process (of course only if this request is reasonable). Thanks for your response.
@@diwashdahal6847 No, I currently do not have a full demo on how to read a research paper. That is a great idea. I already have a few videos lined up, but will put this idea in my content bucket. Thanks!
Thanks
Best webpages to study new infection and researches
How to write a good case series? thank you
very helpful and simplified to the max , well done
Thank you for your kind word!
MED, as researcher, not as clinician
4:22 Strat 1: Inquiry Based Reading
1. Ask Question
2. Find Answer
3. Interpret Author's Intents, can you trust it ?
Thanks!
I just found your channel and this is the first video that I watched, and I want to say that the video was really helpful and I really hope to get better in research so that I can elevate my career in the future. so, thank you for your work and I really hope that all the people looking to improve in research see your videos
THanks! What stage of the research process are you at? I will make videos suitable for you.
@@PublishedMD I'm at the beginning of my journey. I just finished a research course and did my first porject as a training project and it took a lot of time, with all the circumstances that I've been through from exams and sudying. So, I need all the help that I can get.
Thank you so much for helping
All you're doing is giving the structure of the paper
Too much information in one video thank you doctor 🙏
YES YES AND YES! If you could kindly do a comprehensive critical appraisal of a journal article please!
Will do.
Thank you for the very useful viedo.
How can I understand statistics in medical paper . Many thanks
I will consider creating more videos on statistics in the future. Thanks!
Thanks!
Thanks for watching! Let me know if there are any topics you would like me to cover. I will try my best.
hello,thanks for the video, one question where should i go to read complete medical research papers?
I recommend going to pubmed or google scholar. Usually there will be a button that says "read full article". There are some articles that require you to pay. If that is the case, you might want get access through your university/medical institution.
@@PublishedMD ok got it, thanks for the info, wish u the best:)
It was really good and helpful thanks
Thanks so much for watching!
Thanks for the info
Any time!