Culdee being on the msr? I’ve actually love that idea a lot really not the first time I’ve seen it (though they had to degauged , also poor smudger, I really loved his friendship with Lily so much, he may have been used in the war (I believe) but he just wanted to do his best.
I like It the friendship of Lily and Smudger I hope those two reunite In the next episode can you make a episode of Smudger be found and take him to the Skarloey Railway?
In my headcanon, the mountain engines only have one face, not two, although their faces are located on their cabs since they already have their coaches looking upward, technically making them cab-forwards.
Wow I really like the mix with Stanley and smudger! Instead of just choosing one or the other, their like a hybrid of a American steam engine and a British one, well done mate! You’ve gotten a new sub my good lad!
I find it quite interesting how most if not all people voicing Smudger/Stanley always give him that "Wild West Cowboy" accent instead of just a normal American one...
gives Him a good vocal identity. Skarloey and the gang are pure welsh, Thomas is the most british person you know and Smudger has an old western accent.
Not sure if being a museum piece is a better fate than scrap for Lily. Sure, she's alive, but from the looks of it she doesn't get do anything or be useful. No different than being on a scrapyard siding.
I prefer Adam over Lilly and Colin. He's just more interesting. Also, Culdee being on the MSR just doesn't work, because of the gauging. The Mountain engines run on a slightly wider gauge than the Narrow Gauge engines because of the rack rail in the middle.
Will there be a episode a where smudger be find and recovered? if so that be great to see have him come to the Skarloey Railway and have a reunion and apologize to Stewart, Falcon and Duke and maybe even have a reunion with lily.
1: there were no fitting albert or other models 2: the culdee fell railway doesn't exist in this series, so I might as well use Culdee elsewhere 3: Culdee is Narrow gauge after a peek at His wiki page 4: the Mid Sodor existed from 1872 - 1947. Culdee was on the island in 1900
![[Sodor Island Stories No.13] Oliver's Find](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxR-F_F2t8U/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Sodor Island Stories No.13] Oliver's Find](/img/tr.png)
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.83[1/2] เปิดแคมป์หลอนต้อนรับ 2 ตัวพ่อแห่งวงการผี!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2uPuHYHgwiI/mqdefault.jpg)
Leave questions about the series, the channel or really anything under THIS post!
👇👇👇👇
Will Smudger ever be found? I would love a redemption arc, and judging by others' comments, they may want that too.
Where is the Culdee model from? It looks nice but Ive checked all the sites in the desc but cant find it
Will we see a few stories about 'Smudger's' brothers from America during the war? 🇺🇸
@@thehedgebot99mph90 is smudger still behind in the old mid sodor sheds
@thehedgebot99mph90 I wonder smudger is now
Culdee being on the msr? I’ve actually love that idea a lot really not the first time I’ve seen it (though they had to degauged , also poor smudger, I really loved his friendship with Lily so much, he may have been used in the war (I believe) but he just wanted to do his best.
I like It the friendship of Lily and Smudger I hope those two reunite In the next episode can you make a episode of Smudger be found and take him to the Skarloey Railway?
I like the idea of the mountain engines faces being separated entities but how can they be on narrow gauge tracks instead of mountain tracks?
the culdee fell doesn't exist in this world. Culdee is instead just another narrow gauge engine
In my headcanon, the mountain engines only have one face, not two, although their faces are located on their cabs since they already have their coaches looking upward, technically making them cab-forwards.
Hopefully smudger will be found
I hardly doubt that
@@laurahossack9953 One can hope though, I surely do.
We need more smudger stuff,aye
Wow I really like the mix with Stanley and smudger! Instead of just choosing one or the other, their like a hybrid of a American steam engine and a British one, well done mate! You’ve gotten a new sub my good lad!
I wanna see him get rescued and Lilly get put back into service
I find it quite interesting how most if not all people voicing Smudger/Stanley always give him that "Wild West Cowboy" accent instead of just a normal American one...
gives Him a good vocal identity. Skarloey and the gang are pure welsh, Thomas is the most british person you know and Smudger has an old western accent.
Even though considering where hus basis was built, it'd be more accurate to give Smudger/Stanley a Philadelphia accent.
Time for a Smudger Rescue!!!!
now can we have a story about smudger being found and put back into service. it would be a great second part
Huh, interesting to have the faces on the rear of CFR engines be named.
A love it man 😊😊❤❤❤
Not sure if being a museum piece is a better fate than scrap for Lily. Sure, she's alive, but from the looks of it she doesn't get do anything or be useful. No different than being on a scrapyard siding.
In fact, I think scrap might be a better fate.
I prefer Adam over Lilly and Colin. He's just more interesting.
Also, Culdee being on the MSR just doesn't work, because of the gauging. The Mountain engines run on a slightly wider gauge than the Narrow Gauge engines because of the rack rail in the middle.
pilot thomas: Why did it Time travel to These moment 10:12
what's the music you used in the end where smudger can be seen getting annoyed at the owl?
Will there be a episode a where smudger be find and recovered? if so that be great to see have him come to the Skarloey Railway and have a reunion and apologize to Stewart, Falcon and Duke and maybe even have a reunion with lily.
7:46 ok how did he just come off the rails 😂😂😂
Save our boy
Smudger sounds like Duncan
Were Lily and John in the books? Never read them and listened on YT yet so not sure…think Culdee was in a magazine
And Classic Smudger lol
Isnt culdee a different gauge than the msr locos?
Surprisingly He is narrow guaged
1 nitpick I have, how does Culdee being in the msr make any sense?
1: there were no fitting albert or other models
2: the culdee fell railway doesn't exist in this series, so I might as well use Culdee elsewhere
3: Culdee is Narrow gauge after a peek at His wiki page
4: the Mid Sodor existed from 1872 - 1947. Culdee was on the island in 1900
7:50 Skil issue 💀💀
Hello ❤😊
It's funny how Fell is an Ass in more ways than one
y doesn't Smudger look like himself?