Fascinating - the history covered, the extremely interesting discussion on the interplay between personal politics and art, the discussion on Karachi; this was FANTASTIC. Thank you for this to all parties involved.
I dream of a day when Indian and Pakistani left can merge all the progressive forces of the subcontinent together and defeat the communal forces which are rising. We are the only hope in these hopeless times. Red salute to my dear comrades across the border. This is a long fight and we have to ramp up our struggle
@@ThePakistanExperience dekhiye leadership ke touch ka to pata nahi. Par hum aam log to hai touch mai. Aur is tarah ke platform se hamaare rishte aur acche hote hai 😊
CPI was pro british who supported communal Muslim league and opposed freedom struggle too. There slogan was "Ye azadi jhoothi hai" and second was "Le ke rahege Pakistan , Dena hoga Pakistan" .. Command of India's Communist Party was in hand of British Communist leaders. Percy E. Gladigs, Philip Sprat, George Elison, Bronjamin Francis Brodley, Hrew Jalester Hutchinson, S. Sakalathwala and Rajni Pamadut etc. were such a British Communist leader who worked for the communist party of India. Of these Although Saktalwala was Parsi, he was in the UK for a long time and for a few years, there were also members of the Lower House of the British Parliament (House of Commons). Rajni Pamdutt was originally Bengali but was going to Britain and was one of the founding members of the British Communist Party in 1920. The Communist Party of India was not Indian than its herriad and is not. It was ridiculous that it was a "Communist Party of India" not a Indian Communist Party. This is applicable above the Marxist Communist Party and other communist groups. In this way India's Communist movement has not been born abroad, but the formulas of its adherence, promotion, development and direction have also been abroad. CPI not only opposed Gandhi but quit India movement too. Now CPI is known as the biggest islamic fundamental force in India.
@@ThePakistanExperience This is easier said than done. Attempts to do this will be branded treasonous. There is still scope of class struggle in India (whether right or wrong) but communists are rapidly losing political support in India.
And I sincerely hope that communist are rooted from all political systems just like all bad ideas. Left also has its own idea of Ummah. It’s failed system. We need solution driven politics. Not ideologues.
Such a great conversation. Great to here Kamran Sir's take on Pakistani History. The portion you guys did on Karachi was really really great. Would love to hear a longer discussion about it :)
What an insightful Podcast I'm forever grateful to you Shehzad bhaw for such educational Pods and what an unpretentious Person Sir Kamran asdar is. He has done so much for the leftist literature of Pakistan still the way he puts himself in such a simple manner is commendable
Yaar Shehzad. This is the 255th time you have misquoted Jaun Elia. He never said UP k launday. He said Aligarh k launday as in Aligarh Muslim University k launday referring to the alumni of AMU who later became part of the Muslim elite in entire India not just UP. It changes the entire meaning of what he said when you say UP k launday
CPI was pro british who supported communal Muslim league and opposed freedom struggle too. Their slogan was "Ye azadi jhoothi hai" and second was "Le ke rahege Pakistan , Dena hoga Pakistan" .. Command of India's Communist Party was in hand of British Communist leaders. Percy E. Gladigs, Philip Sprat, George Elison, Bronjamin Francis Brodley, Hrew Jalester Hutchinson, S. Sakalathwala and Rajni Pamadut etc. were such a British Communist leader who worked for the communist party of India. Of these Although Saktalwala was Parsi, he was in the UK for a long time and for a few years, there were also members of the Lower House of the British Parliament (House of Commons). Rajni Pamdutt was originally Bengali but was going to Britain and was one of the founding members of the British Communist Party in 1920. The Communist Party of India was not Indian than its herriad and is not. It was ridiculous that it was a "Communist Party of India" not a Indian Communist Party. This is applicable above the Marxist Communist Party and other communist groups. In this way India's Communist movement has not been born abroad, but the formulas of its adherence, promotion, development and direction have also been abroad. CPI not only opposed Gandhi but quit India movement too. Now CPI is known as the biggest islamic fundamental force in India.
Bro ,,you gotta bring Abhijit Iyer Mitra. The guy is very funny plus very good traveller(not tourist) . Left hates him, right doen't like him, he criticises everyone but always comes with solution..
Fascinating - the history covered, the extremely interesting discussion on the interplay between personal politics and art, the discussion on Karachi; this was FANTASTIC. Thank you for this to all parties involved.
I dream of a day when Indian and Pakistani left can merge all the progressive forces of the subcontinent together and defeat the communal forces which are rising. We are the only hope in these hopeless times. Red salute to my dear comrades across the border. This is a long fight and we have to ramp up our struggle
@@ThePakistanExperience dekhiye leadership ke touch ka to pata nahi. Par hum aam log to hai touch mai. Aur is tarah ke platform se hamaare rishte aur acche hote hai 😊
😆😆😆
CPI was pro british who supported communal Muslim league and opposed freedom struggle too. There slogan was "Ye azadi jhoothi hai" and second was "Le ke rahege Pakistan , Dena hoga Pakistan" ..
Command of India's Communist Party was in hand of British Communist leaders. Percy E. Gladigs, Philip Sprat, George Elison, Bronjamin Francis Brodley, Hrew Jalester Hutchinson, S. Sakalathwala and Rajni Pamadut etc. were such a British Communist leader who worked for the communist party of India. Of these Although Saktalwala was Parsi, he was in the UK for a long time and for a few years, there were also members of the Lower House of the British Parliament (House of Commons). Rajni Pamdutt was originally Bengali but was going to Britain and was one of the founding members of the British Communist Party in 1920. The Communist Party of India was not Indian than its herriad and is not.
It was ridiculous that it was a "Communist Party of India" not a Indian Communist Party. This is applicable above the Marxist Communist Party and other communist groups. In this way India's Communist movement has not been born abroad, but the formulas of its adherence, promotion, development and direction have also been abroad.
CPI not only opposed Gandhi but quit India movement too.
Now CPI is known as the biggest islamic fundamental force in India.
@@ThePakistanExperience This is easier said than done. Attempts to do this will be branded treasonous. There is still scope of class struggle in India (whether right or wrong) but communists are rapidly losing political support in India.
And I sincerely hope that communist are rooted from all political systems just like all bad ideas. Left also has its own idea of Ummah. It’s failed system. We need solution driven politics. Not ideologues.
Taimur Episodes.... And this one With Kamran Asdar saab...
These episodes are going into my archive...
Excellent conversation
Shehzad trying to work through all your podcasts. This was your most sympathetic guest so far.
Jazakallah, Dr Kamran for a very insightful talk.
Awesome...
Such a great conversation. Great to here Kamran Sir's take on Pakistani History. The portion you guys did on Karachi was really really great. Would love to hear a longer discussion about it :)
first! love u kamran sahab!
Love you sir
What an insightful Podcast I'm forever grateful to you Shehzad bhaw for such educational Pods and what an unpretentious Person Sir Kamran asdar is. He has done so much for the leftist literature of Pakistan still the way he puts himself in such a simple manner is commendable
Awsm podcast!!!
Yaar Shehzad. This is the 255th time you have misquoted Jaun Elia. He never said UP k launday. He said Aligarh k launday as in Aligarh Muslim University k launday referring to the alumni of AMU who later became part of the Muslim elite in entire India not just UP. It changes the entire meaning of what he said when you say UP k launday
@@ThePakistanExperience 🙂
Please invite Amar Jaleel Sahab on extremism and Karachi history.
Maza aagya yar
Wonderful and informative discussion. I would like to hear more from the learned professor.
CPI was pro british who supported communal Muslim league and opposed freedom struggle too. Their slogan was "Ye azadi jhoothi hai" and second was "Le ke rahege Pakistan , Dena hoga Pakistan" ..
Command of India's Communist Party was in hand of British Communist leaders. Percy E. Gladigs, Philip Sprat, George Elison, Bronjamin Francis Brodley, Hrew Jalester Hutchinson, S. Sakalathwala and Rajni Pamadut etc. were such a British Communist leader who worked for the communist party of India. Of these Although Saktalwala was Parsi, he was in the UK for a long time and for a few years, there were also members of the Lower House of the British Parliament (House of Commons). Rajni Pamdutt was originally Bengali but was going to Britain and was one of the founding members of the British Communist Party in 1920. The Communist Party of India was not Indian than its herriad and is not.
It was ridiculous that it was a "Communist Party of India" not a Indian Communist Party. This is applicable above the Marxist Communist Party and other communist groups. In this way India's Communist movement has not been born abroad, but the formulas of its adherence, promotion, development and direction have also been abroad.
CPI not only opposed Gandhi but quit India movement too.
Now CPI is known as the biggest islamic fundamental force in India.
Bro please bring AIM (abhijit iyer mitra) , he is a defence economist.
I find both of you very amazing 🙂🙏.
The amount of 'bunyadi taur pe's in this conversation is astronomical.
It was a very knowledgeable session! keep up the good work !!!
Brother would like to know your desire and motivation, I am very inspired by your continuous strive.
Hahaha...lol
I am first time listening CPI was banned because of Bhagat Singh.
😆😆😆
The question is when he joined CPI ?
😆😆😆
Bro ,,you gotta bring Abhijit Iyer Mitra.
The guy is very funny plus very good traveller(not tourist) .
Left hates him, right doen't like him, he criticises everyone but always comes with solution..
Sir right wing walo ko bhi bulaye pls, Advaita kala (writer of movie kahaani) inko bula skte hain.
@@ThePakistanExperience ❤️❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience 'her' she is a woman.
More fun will be abhijit iyer mitra..
Kushal mehra too
Bakchodiya episode kab aye ga yarrr
Bakchodiya? Kay hai ?